Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Dermatology 2007;215:284294
DOI: 10.1159/000107621
Abstract
Background: Skin aging has long been considered only as a
cosmetic problem. With the increase in lifespan, we are now
more often experiencing a further dimension of skin aging,
which is no longer only cosmetic, but also functional, in the
sense that the skin has lost its protective mechanical function. Dermatoporosis is the name proposed to capture, in a
holistic approach, all the aspects of this chronic cutaneous
insufficiency/fragility syndrome. Observations: In this paper, we review the clinical aspects of dermatoporosis, its histological features and the current understanding of its etiological factors. The clinical manifestations of dermatoporosis comprise (i) morphological markers of fragility rather
trivial such as senile purpura, stellate pseudoscars and skin
atrophy, and (ii) functional expression of skin fragility resulting
from minor traumas such as frequent skin laceration, delayed wound healing, nonhealing atrophic ulcers and subcutaneous bleeding with the formation of dissecting hematomas leading to large zones of necrosis. Dissecting hematomas bear significant morbidity needing hospitalization and
urgent surgical procedures. Molecular mechanisms implying hyaluronate-CD44 pathways in the control and maintenance of epithelial growth and the viscoelastic properties of
the extracellular matrix offer new opportunities for preventive intervention. Conclusion: We propose to group the different manifestations and implications of this syndrome un-
Introduction
Skin aging should not be considered as only a cosmetic issue. With extreme aging, the loss of extracellular matrix (ECM) and its major component hyaluronate (HA),
which stabilizes the intercellular structures by forming a
viscoelastic network in which collagen and elastin fibers
are embedded, induces a loss of the skins mechanical
functions. In fact, HA, just as in the joints, provides a
cushion effect to the skin structures including the epidermis. The solidity of the skin is provided by the ECM, and
the loss of HA and consequently of this viscoelastic buffering system would contribute to easy tearing resulting
in skin lacerations.
With the increase in the number of elderly individuals,
this functional rather than cosmetic dimension of skin
aging has been realized. The loss of the protective mechanical function of the skin results in extreme fragility
leading to complications such as lacerations, nonhealing
Grkan Kaya, MD, PhD
Department of Dermatology, University of Geneva
24, rue Micheli-du-Crest
CH1211 Geneva 4 (Switzerland)
Tel. +41 22 372 75 14, Fax +41 22 372 94 77, E-Mail gkaya@hcuge.ch
Downloaded by:
University of Iowa Libraries
128.255.6.125 - 6/10/2015 9:14:38 PM
Key Words
Skin aging Dermatoporosis Hyaluronate CD44
Senile Purpura
Senile purpura is localized mainly to extremities and
results from repetitive spontaneous or minimal traumaassociated dermal bleedings without any coagulation disorders. Its frequency is around 10% in an elderly population between 70 and 90 years with a female predominance, and it is associated, in 90% of the cases, with
pseudoscars (see below) [3]. These purpuric plaques disappear by leaving a deep brownish pigmentation corresponding to hemosiderin pigment (fig. 3A). Vitamin C
deficiency may also lead to dermal hematomas which are
also frequent in these patients, and a substitution therapy
should be considered. Histologically the senile purpura is
characterized by extravasation of red blood cells into the
dermis which are often found in a perivascular location.
The skin usually shows thinning of the epidermis and
dermis, marked solar elastosis and atrophy of collagen
bundles (fig. 3B).
Stellate Pseudoscar
Stellate pseudoscar is a spontaneous dermal laceration
displaying a stellar aspect [4]. The stellate pseudoscar is
encountered in 2040% of the elderly population between 70 and 90 years, and it is more frequent in females
[3]. These lesions are mainly seen on the back of the hands
and forearms and are accompanied by a senile purpura
in 3050% of the patients [3]. Clinically the pseudoscars
appear as whitish lesions. Initially 5 forms have been proposed [4]. In fact, there are 3 main types of pseudoscars:
star-shaped (fig. 4A), linear (fig. 4B) or plaque-type
(fig. 4C). These lesions are seen essentially after 60 years
of age, and become particularly frequent after 70 years.
Histologically the pseudoscar corresponds to a compact
hypocellular band of collagen under an atrophic epidermis which contains decreased amounts of elastic fibers
and mucin (fig. 4D, E, F; data not shown).
Functional Expression of Skin Fragility
They represent an emerging syndrome in the growing
population of elderly persons.
Dissecting Hematoma of the Skin
This important complication is due to mechanical fragility of the aged skin, occurs predominantly in the lower
extremities of elderly patients suffering from dermatoporosis and results in long and costly hospital stays (fig. 5D).
Dissecting hematoma is seen in elderly populations (between 70 and 99 years) with severe dermatoporosis (in
96% of the patients), showing a female predisposition
(M/F ratio: 1/5) [Kaya et al., submitted].
Dermatology 2007;215:284294
285
Downloaded by:
University of Iowa Libraries
128.255.6.125 - 6/10/2015 9:14:38 PM
porosis. Forearm skin of a dermatoporosis patient shows important atrophy, senile purpura and numerous pseudoscars (A) when
compared with the skin of a younger individual (B). Echographic
analysis of the skin of a primary dermatoporosis patient performed using a skin ultrasound system (Episcan; Longport Inc.,
Glen Mills, Pa., USA) displays a significant skin atrophy (average
of 3 measurements between the top level of epidermis and dermal-
286
Dermatology 2007;215:284294
Kaya/Saurat
Downloaded by:
University of Iowa Libraries
128.255.6.125 - 6/10/2015 9:14:38 PM
Dermatology 2007;215:284294
287
Downloaded by:
University of Iowa Libraries
128.255.6.125 - 6/10/2015 9:14:38 PM
Fig. 2. Dermal collagen, elastic fiber and mucin content in dermatoporosis. Dermatoporotic skin shows a decrease in red-stained collagen (A), black/brown-stained elastic fiber (C) and blue-stained mucin (E) content
compared to normal skin (B, D, F). Note the presence of elastic fibers in normal skin (D, arrows) which are replaced by a heavy elastotic material in dermatoporosis (C , arrows). A , B Sirius red. C , D van Gieson elastin.
E , F Colloidal iron. Original magnification !10.
Fig. 3. Clinical and histological characteristics of senile purpura. The forearm skin of a patient with dermatoporosis shows multiple noninflammatory purpuric lesions of red-black color of different sizes (A) which are
Fig. 4. Clinical and histological characteristics of pseudoscar. Pseudoscars correspond clinically to whitish linear (A), star-shaped (B) or plaque-type (C) papular lesions. Histologically the center of the lesion is formed by a
hypocellular band of collagen under an atrophic epidermis (D, E). This collagen band shows decreased amounts
of elastic fibers (F). D Hematoxylin-eosin. Original magnification !2.5. E Sirius red. Original magnification
!10. F van Gieson elastin. Original magnification !10.
288
Dermatology 2007;215:284294
Downloaded by:
University of Iowa Libraries
128.255.6.125 - 6/10/2015 9:14:38 PM
Fig. 5. Clinical staging of dermatoporosis. Stage I is characterized by extreme skin atrophy, senile purpura and
pseudoscars (A); stage II shows localized skin lacerations (B); in stage III these lacerations are more numerous
and larger (C), and in stage IV dissecting hematomas are formed (D).
Dissecting hematomas of the skin may occur in patients with anticoagulation or topical or systemic corticosteroid therapy. Corticosteroids are known to cause
skin atrophy [6], and protective measures for the lower
extremities should be taken in these patients.
Delayed Wound Healing
Chronic posttraumatic wounds are a very important
problem in the elderly, and the exact mechanism for the
delay in wound healing is not completely understood
despite the molecular analysis of some genes thought to
play a role in chronic wounds [7]. A decrease in the proliferative capacity of keratinocytes and fibroblasts,
abundant production of matrix metalloproteinases
(MMPs) and secretion of cytokines which inhibit the
dedifferentiation of keratinocytes lead to tissue destruction.
Primary Dermatoporosis
This is the most commonly seen type of dermatoporosis and results from chronological aging and long-term
and unprotected sun exposure (see below). In osteoporosis, heritability studies have shown evidence of significant genetic effects on key determinants of osteoporotic
fracture risk, including peak bone mass, muscle strength,
bone turnover markers and body mass index [8]. We currently do not know the genes implicated in primary dermatoporosis. However, we think that, as in osteoporosis,
genetic factors play a significant role in the regulation
and loss of ECM components, in the viscoelastic properties of the skin (see below) and therefore in susceptibility
to dermatoporosis.
Dermatology 2007;215:284294
289
Downloaded by:
University of Iowa Libraries
128.255.6.125 - 6/10/2015 9:14:38 PM
ECM Modifications
The clinical manifestations of skin aging have been
associated with modifications in the ECM. These modifications can be the consequence of direct damage as provoked by aging-related genomic instability, by ultraviolet
irradiation, by nonenzymatic glycation of structural proteins and also by the inflammatory response to environmental factors or by endogenous stressors [9, 10].
290
Dermatology 2007;215:284294
Skin
Senile
Pseudo- Skin
Dissecting
atrophy purpura scar
laceration hematoma
Stage I
Stage II
Stage III
Stage IV
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
++
++
It has been shown that during chronological skin aging MMPs 1, 2 and 3 were upregulated and tissue inhibitor of MMPs 1 was downregulated [11]. This imbalance
results in the degradation of dermal collagen, elastic fibers and other components of the ECM.
Alterations in Skin Viscoelasticity
Viscoelasticity, also known as anelasticity, describes
materials that exhibit both viscous and elastic characteristics. Viscous materials, like honey, resist shear flow and
strain linearly with time when a stress is applied. Elastic
materials strain instantaneously when stretched and just
as quickly return to their original state once the stress is
removed. Whereas elasticity is usually the result of bond
stretching along crystallographic planes in an ordered
solid, viscoelasticity is the result of the diffusion of atoms
or molecules inside an amorphous material [12].
The dermis is composed of a 3-dimensional network
of collagen and elastic fibers. The ECM of the skin contains two major glycosaminoglycans, dermatan sulfate
and HA (see below) [13]. Dermatan sulfate is tightly
bound to the collagen fiber network, and HA occupies
the space between the fibers. Collagen and elastic fibers
constitute the elastic, the HA forms the viscous compartment of the skin. It has been demonstrated that HA reduces the frictional wear between the collagen fibers [14,
15].
The mechanical response of skin to applied loads involves both a viscous component associated with energy
dissipation and an elastic component associated with energy storage [16, 17]. Dissipation of loads applied to the
Kaya/Saurat
Downloaded by:
University of Iowa Libraries
128.255.6.125 - 6/10/2015 9:14:38 PM
UV-Mediated Effects
Skin aging due to UV irradiation is called photoaging.
In recent years, the exposure of human skin to environmental and artificial UV irradiation has increased dramatically. UVB directly interacts with the DNA of skin
cells. The deleterious effects of UVA are principally due
to the formation of oxygen free radicals, which results in
alterations in nuclear and mitochondrial DNA, but also
in the activation of MMPs [25].
The clinical presentation corresponds to elastosis localized predominantly in the superficial dermis resulting
from the degradation of collagen and elastic fibers by
MMPs. However, a defective synthesis of collagen and
elastic fibers by fibroblasts also contributes to this process [26, 27].
We have recently shown that UVA or UVB irradiation
significantly decreased the content of HA and the expression of its receptor CD44 (see below) in the epidermis of
hairless mice [28].
Dermatoporosis: Features, Mechanisms,
Prevention and Potential Treatments
291
Downloaded by:
University of Iowa Libraries
128.255.6.125 - 6/10/2015 9:14:38 PM
Fig. 6. CD44 and HA content of dermatoporotic skin. Forearm biopsy specimens of dermatoporosis patients
show a decrease in CD44 (A) and HA (C) amounts in the epidermis and also in the dermis. Note the expression
of CD44 mainly by keratinocytes and the epidermal and superficial dermal presence of HA in normal skin (B,
D). A , B Mouse anti-human CD44 antibodies (Bender MedSystems; 2.5 g/ml). C , D Biotinylated HA binding
292
Dermatology 2007;215:284294
topical application of retinaldehyde upregulated the expression of CD44 and HA synthases in mouse skin [42].
Topical application of retinaldehyde and HAFi increased the levels of these molecules in the skin of dermatoporosis patients and corrected the skin atrophy by
showing a synergistic effect at both molecular and clinical levels [Kaya et al., manuscript in preparation].
These observations suggest that the defects in the interaction of CD44 and HA play an important role in dermatoporosis and should be considered as a new target for
the development of novel therapeutic strategies for cutaneous pathologies characterized by skin atrophy and
ECM modifications.
Kaya/Saurat
Downloaded by:
University of Iowa Libraries
128.255.6.125 - 6/10/2015 9:14:38 PM
Prevention and therapy of dermatoporosis imply longterm measures because any significant benefit cannot be
obtained within less than several months of intervention,
and any reversal might be maintained only with continuous use of the program.
Due to the harmful and accelerating effects of UV irradiation in dermatoporosis mentioned above, sun exposure should be minimized and protective measures
should be taken.
Emollients can be used for the epidermal barrier disturbance secondary to prolonged topical corticosteroid
application.
References
Dermatology 2007;215:284294
293
Downloaded by:
University of Iowa Libraries
128.255.6.125 - 6/10/2015 9:14:38 PM
294
Dermatology 2007;215:284294
40 Tammi R, Ripellino JA, Margolis RU, Maibach HI, Tammi M: Hyaluronate accumulation in human epidermis treated with retinoic acid in skin organ culture. J Invest
Dermatol 1989;92:326332.
41 Lundin A, Berne B, Michaelsson G: Topical
retinoic acid treatment of photoaged skin: its
effects on hyaluronan distribution in epidermis and on hyaluronan and retinoic acid in
suction blister fluid. Acta Derm Venereol
1992;72: 423427.
42 Kaya G, Grand D, Hotz R, Augsburger E,
Carraux P, Didierjean L, Saurat JH: Upregulation of CD44 and hyaluronate synthases by
topical retinoids in mouse skin. J Invest Dermatol 2005;124:284287.
Kaya/Saurat
Downloaded by:
University of Iowa Libraries
128.255.6.125 - 6/10/2015 9:14:38 PM