2nd Quarter 2015 Issue 32 An | Publication
YUE
Making
CEO on UMC OeN
ager)
Co) Elec)Reo
the cashless way.
erewere Oma BUM Nit
eee ay 04 African Banker's World 46 Development
Ete Round-up ofthe last quarter i the Asian I nt
fpromaussanvr AMrors barddng cle Bank take attent ?
steteea net 16 New Appointments Markets
vera onsen Who has moved where 51 Power
eta ; 34 Ther
icin ADB: The next president? 61 Special re a
dover 21 Meet the candidates wy i larke
Sep Kat 62 BRVM
sez rrveerusnanen aa sna, Niger x
sori 23 4 Turisia
Herren fee Mane Ni Rena 24 journra, Cha Technology
‘aie 25 Cristina Duarte, Cabo Verd 66 Thepower of the
spins 26 Samura Kamara, Sierr 68 le Pay late to partyin South A
pm uanccn 27 7 kala, Zimbabwe 70 Prepaid cards for the unbanked
28 Su
29° Biran Experts
1 73 ?
30 Remittances 76
Early-morning call 78
80
34 Event: 82
: Awarding Africa’ top bankers
von In Conversation
ato Ic Paton 86
oe Sola Haram 88
90Abraaj closes
$990m PE fund
DUpaI-BASED ABRAAT HAS
closed a sggom investment
fund, the latest sign of robust
private equity appetite for
‘African businesses,
“The Abraaj Africa III Fund,
the company’s third Africa
dedicated fand, will target
tothe
continent's emerging urban
‘middie class, including those
dealing in consumer goods
and financial services
“The fund will concentrate
‘on investments in the
established markets of Nigeria,
Ghana, Cate d'Ivoire, South
Africa and Kenya,
‘The fund proved popular
among European and North
‘American investors, who
accounted for 64% of the
capital committed: 74% of
the capital was provided by
institutional investors, pension
fundsand sovereign wealth
funds, according to Abra.
“The strong demand
for this new fund reflects
increasing investor
‘s8abn was invested
in private equity funds in
Africa last year, popular with
investors looking for exposure
toemerging African businesses.
$8.1bn
appreciation for the powerful
growth story unfolding across
‘Africa. It isa story driven
by rapid urbanisation and
favourable demographics that
are fuelling consumption
across multiple sectors from
an expanding, young middle
class,” said chief executive
‘Arif Naqvi. Private equity
firms area popular vehicle for
international investors looking
for exposure to emerging
‘African businesses. s81bn
vwas invested by such funds in
‘Africa last year, according to
the African Private Equity and
Venture Capital Association
Africa Finance Corporation
Eurobond oversubscribed
Infrastructure investment
institution Africa Finance
Corporation (AFC) has raised
‘$75min its frst Eurobond issue.
The five-year bond, the frst in
aplanned series of issues, was
six times oversubscribed to the
tune of $4.7bn. The funds wil
be used for "general corporate
and financing purposes” and
to repay an existing facility
according to AFC.
[AFC holds investments in 22,
African countries, amounting to
a$2.4bn balance sheet.
The popularity ofthe bond
revealsa strong demand among
investors for exposure to much
needed infrastructure projects
‘actoss the continent. The World
ABC holds investments
in 22 African countries,
‘amounting oa s2.4bn
balance sheet
$2.4bn
Bank estimates that Arica has
infrastructure funding needs of
$93bn annually until 2020,
Despite the availabilty of
capital, many investors shy away
from the dificult and costly
intial phase of development,
meaning that there are not
‘enough projects in which capital
can be deployed.Equatorial Guinea
signs China deals
Chinese companies have
signed araft of commercial
deals with Equatorial Guinea,
ina sign of Beijing's continued
interestin closer ties with
African extractors,
‘The tiny West African state,
‘one ofthe region's largest oil
producers, signed agreements
with Chinese firms in the areas
of energy, construction and
industry,
Projects agreed at
theinvestment forum in
Dalian, China, included
Chinese participation in the
construction of a petroleum
hub at Luba, an industrial city
at Mini, and a hydroelectric
plant on the Wele River.
Reuters reported that
Industrial and Commercial
Bank of China, a state-
owned lender, signed a $2bn
infrastructure deal to provide
support tothe Equato-Guinean
and Chinese companies in the
country following a state visit
to China by President Teodoro
Obiang (above).
World
Bank writes
down
Chad's
debt
Tae WoRLD BANK AND IMF
have agreed to write down
siabn of Chad's debt
A joint statement
from the multilateral
institutions praised Chad
for implementing poverty
reduction efforts and
economic management
policies that are a pre
condition for unlocking debt
relief. ibn of that relief is
expected to be covered by
multilateral creditors, with the
remainder covered by bilateral
and commercial lenders.
The statement said that
Chad had successfully
fulfilled 11 of the 15 conditions
necessary to complete the
Heavily indebted Poor
Countries Initiative, including
the successful implementation
fora year of a poverty
reduction strategy paper: That
allows a country to participate
in the Multilateral Debt Relief
Initiative
“Reaching the HIPC
completion point represents
an important achievement and
milestone for Chad. It reflects
the significant improvement
in economic management in
recent years. ait will also help
Chad allocate more resources
for poverty reduction and
the promotion of economic
growth,” said Mauricio
Villafuerta, the country’s IME
mission chieforld: West
African B
IME approves $918m loan for
underperforming Ghana
THE INTERNATIONAL ofsheddingits reputation _while protecting social essential to address Ghana's
Monetary Fund has approved for economic competence, security spending. Aninitial macroeconomic imbalances
agoi8mloantoGhanato leading to IMF eritcism that tranche of sn4.8m willbe and enhance investor
help the country overcome its an unsustainable public debt immediatey availabe. confidence in view of
economic woes load, wide fiscal andexternal The IMF waseritical of downside risks,” said Min
The three-year imbalances, and poor policy the government’sefforts to Zhu, IMF deputy managing
programme will support _choices have put the country’s restore economic stability, director.
President Mahama's medium. medium-term prospectsat arguing that “policy “Zina said that the country
term plans to get the economy risk. slippages” had undermined will need to clean up its
back on track aftr it The programme is the fiscal consolidation efforts public sector payroll, improve
expanded by only 4%in 2014 designed to kick-start growth since 2033 hiring and strengthen
= its slowest pace in 20 years. by restoring the country’s “Forceful and sustained expenditure controls in order
After decades ofgrowih, debt sustainability and implementation ofthe to begin to restore fiscal
Ghana has looked in danger macroeconomic stability programme will be credibilityWorld Bank supports
Ebola-stricken countries
‘The World Bank will give $650m Leone, Their economies have
‘of additional support ta the West — languished since the crisis led
‘African countries struggling to tothe closing of borders and
recover from the Ebolacrisis. paralysed trade and investment.
The new funds will beused The World Bank estimates
tosstrengthen healthcare, that the three countries have
agriculture and educationin _osta total of $2.2bn in GDP
Guinea, Liberia and Sierra over the course of the year,
with the disease’s economic
tall exacerbated by adecline
in global iron ore prices and
the collapse of Sierra Leone's
mining industry
The latest tranche of funding
takes the World Bank's total
Ebola fight back commitments
Above: Liberia's
President Ellen Johnson
Sirleaf talks to reporters.
to $L.62bn sincetthe start of
the crisis.
The funds vill also be
used to establish a regional
disease surveillance system to
help monitor future illnesses
‘or contain them before they
develop into pandemics.
Cote dIvoire launches
Islamic bond
(Core D'Ivorne HAS two phases of sasom and will
set up a $500m Islamic finance new projects between
bond programme to help aors and 2020.
the country fund new Islamic finance has gained
development projects traction in world markets but
‘The sukuk, which was set remains a relative rarity in
up with the support of the Africa
Islamic Development Baal ‘According to the IMB, the
privatearm, willlaunch in market for Islamic financial
assets has grown at an average
rate of 16% a year since 2006,
expanding from its traditional
base in the Gulf to established
financial markets
Khaled Al Aboodim,
chief executive of the
Islamic Corporation for the
Development of the Private
Sector, said that the bank
hoped to extend the concept
in Cote C'Wvoire
‘Our ultimate goal is
to develop the Shariah-
compliant capital market
in Cote d'Ivoire to enable
narrowing the financing gap
for developmental projects.”South Africa and China in
currency swap agreement
Sours Arnica’ Reserve
Bank has signed a three-year
curreney swap agreement with
its Chinese counterpart, as the
BRICS nations look to build
con existing financial ties
“The maximum s478bn
facility, arranged with the
People’s Bank of China,
is designed to allow the
central banks to exchang
local currencies as a means
of encouraging trade and
investment
The currency swap, which,
will also be used to relieve
short-term balance of payment
pressures, follows a 2013 deal
Anglo-American
eyes platinum IPOs
Global miner Anglo-American
is exploring potential IPOs for
some ofits troubled South
African platinum mines,
according toits chief executive,
Mark Cutifan told Anglo’s
‘annual general meeting that
the company favours a public
offering for the struggling
‘mines, butis also in negotiations
regarding a potential trade sale
and may explore other options.
“The restructure of our
platinum business is ongoing
and the operations that are
producing today are, infact,
doing well relative tothe
platinum price. We have made
a decision with respect to the
platinum assets we wll develop
for the long term and those we
willdivest as they do not fit our
th
Bank access to China's
onshore bond market.
South Africa has made
concerted efforts to forge
links with China, including
joining the Betjing-led Asian
Infrastructure Investment
capital criteria,” he sai.
Anglo's South African
platinum mines have struggled
Lnder the dual pressure of
low international prices and
protracted labour disputes.
Subsidiary Anglo- American
Platinum suffered four months
of trike action last year after
members ofthe Association of
Mineworkers and Construction
Bank as a founding member
in April
That builds on South
Africa’ status as founding
member of the New
Development Bank,
for which it will host an
African investment office and
invest s1obn,
Union demanded new pay deals.
Minershave grown more
strident in their pay demands
following a split in the union
movement and the dectine ofthe
government-aligned National
Union of Mineworkers. Cutifani
said the strikes were responsible
for 11% of a 25% decrease in
earnings before interest and
taxes at Anglo American,THE BANK WHICH INTEGRATES
Sole een O as lead) otAfrican Banker's World: South
South Africa
toughens
money-
laundering
regulations
South Africa is toughening its
financial regulations in abd to
crack down on money laundering
and terrorism financing.
The new rules are designed
to bring South Africa in tine with
UN Security Council standards on
asset freezes, and will also extend
the supervisory powers of the
‘country's Financial Intelligence
Cenire to allow it to take a closer
JSE achieves record trading
‘Tus Jouanxesaunc Stock owned Merafe Resources after _ trusts also benefited from lookat suspicious transactions.
Exchange surpassed its all itannounced to shareholders investor interest, with 25m The Financial Intelligence
time daily trading record by that Royal Bafokeng, shares traded on the day Centre Amendment Bill 2015,
volume in April, buoyed by Resources had sold its 28.68% Leanne Parson s, which is currently undergoing
strong activity in the mining, stake tocommodities giant _ director of the JSE’s equity public consultation, is designed
insurance and property Glencore. 725m shares in ‘market, called the record an | to give financial institutions more
sectors. Merafe, representing 71% of “encouraging milestone.” flexibility in how they verify their
The bourse recorded the day's activity, were traded “In comparison to the clients’ identities,
1,025mm trades on 28" April, its prior totheannouncement, corresponding period in The bill, which will lso abolish
strongest figures since the July according to the exchange. 2014, the daily average the existing Counter Money
togg listing of Old Mutual saw Activity was further volume traded on the JSE Laundering Advisory Council
1or8m shares change hands. buoyed by trading in thellife has inereased 15% to 281m is beingintroduced to close
“The day's activity was insurance sector, with Old shares, further illustrating the | regulatory gaps in South Africa's
dominated by the trade in Mutual accounting fora growth inmarket sentiment | existing regime. Itis expected to
mining shates, driven by third of the sim sector shares led by resource stocks,” she be submitted to the cabinet by
investor interest in black: tuaded. Realestate investment said, June.
Standard Bank signs on with Korean partner
uth Africa's Standard with commercial lender Woori from $24.3matthestart of the African bank like Standard
Bank has signed a Bank ina bid to comer the millennium to $287m in 2010, Bank ill enable Woori Bank to
business cooperation market for business banking according tothe bank Bilateral __ extend its banking relationship
‘agreement witha South services among South Korean trade increased from $6bnin _with key Korean cients toits
Korean counterpartasbilateral companies operating and invest. 2000 to $25bn in 2011. hnon-presence countries,” said
trade between the countries ing on the continent. ‘Woori Bank has no Standard Bank's global head
booms, The Johannesburg South Korea's foreign direct presencein Africa and therefore of financialinstitutions, Robert
headquartered bank has joined investment in Africa ballooned a partnership with a strong Cleasby.EAS eau MN ee Ce)
Cease
Deer
QUR Re UR IN
ore
LeaDeRs
TRADE
eee coy
ae Nielesy
Pa
ER en ete oe Rea t cab}
eee ae ey cet cn ne
Pee poer erage sone ee Ea cote
Moving Forward”1 FRICAM BANKER 2ND QUARTER 2005
African Banker's World: North
OCP raises $1bn bond issue
MOROCCAN FERTILISER miner launched a second debt phosphate assets in Morocco, raising money on international
producer OCP managed to _offeringto funda doubling of appointed Morgan Stanley and capital markets, according to
raise sibn offunds with its mining capacity and a tripling Barclaysas joint book-runners the firm. Itaunched its first
latest bond issue asit targets of fertiliser capacity by 2025, on the offering ‘global bond in April 2014
an expansion. according to a statement from The firmis moving away The sibn issue has been
“The Casablanca. the firm. froma financing model based priced with a0 year
headquartered phosphate ‘OCP, which owns, on bank debt in favour of ‘maturity anda 45% coupon.
Arab Monetary Fund signs World Bank deal
The Arab Monetary Fundis to collaborate onhelping countries ofthe regional financial sector, Middle East and North Africa
work with the World Bank and develop theirbond markets, especially nthe areas of access The IMF has suggested that
itsprivate sector arm the IMF stock exchanges andIslamic_—_tofinance forsmall businesses, the spreadof Islamic finance
omprojects to boost financial financing systems Islamic finance, and housing - could help to boost financial
market development in North “Through this MoU we will nance,” said Mouayed Makhniouf, inclusion in North Africa, where
Africa and the Middle East. continue to partner and provide International Finance Corpora- large percentages ofthe popula
The institutions will assistance for thedevelopment tion regional director for the tion donothave bank accounts.Priel oseNero a |PCCM Ete
looks to
Rwanda in
$22.5m deal
Teachers’ bank looks to IPO
The Tanzania Teachers’ remaining 80% available tothe nian shillings ($0.25) per share. The establishment of the
when it lists in June. teachers and workers with ‘Teachers re aspiringto development.~ 10000000
2012
African Guarantee Fund established amongst
the Economic Development Stakcholders
2014
‘Supported 1000 SMEs.
240 jobs cated.
2017 Plan
Support 7,00 Stes
Help create 170,000 obs
2019 Plan
Support 000 SMEs
Help create 253,000 obs.
Africa’s growth is our growth.
Africa stands as the world’s fastest growing economy and for us to be a part of this
growth we are working with financial institutions across the continent to support
the remarkable efforts of SMEs and help grow the brands of Africa's tomorrow.
C4,
== AFR(CANFONS
‘G6 coun he Govern of Deca ough Dana he Gover. pa eau esd nthe ncaa Development BarkNew Appointments
JANUARY
Unity Bank
‘Thomas A. Ftuh and Alhaji
Aminu Babangida were
ited as Chairman and
e Chairman respectively
of Nigeria’s Unity Bank.
Babingidais the co-founder
and Chief Executive Officer
(of Phoenix Energy. Etuh has
‘worked for over 20 yearsin
both the public and private
sector. He was appointed
Pioneer Vice Chairman of the
Board of Directors in 2014
Development
Bank of Malawi
Former Malawi Finance
Minister Friday Jumbe wa
appointed CEO of the newly
established state-owned ban
Development Bank of Mala
(DBM). Jumbeis an economist
with management and finance
experience, previously CEO
of Admare and Admare
Investment Holdings.
FEBRUARY
Barclays Africa Group
Barclays Africa Group
appointed four new employees
from Deutsche Bank to its
Africa trade team in Nigeria,
based in Lagos.
Leading the group is
Charles Weller, managing
director, Atrica Trade, with
Oladapo Adeighe, Balogun
Olusola and Dape Oluwole.
Waller previously worked as
Deutsche's Nigeria country
head
Central Bank of Angola
Gualberto Lima Campos were
appointed Angola's deputy frepevlopmen Bank of alan
central bank governors ben Naidoo epaty Governor,
Camposhas held series of SaetAtiean Reserve San and
‘ohmitangueya, Governor,
government positions, recently central bank of ambabwe.
as deputy minister for public
investment, while Van-Dunem
dhas been with the central bank
for 16 years,
Standard Chartered
Standard Chartered has
hised high-profile former
JPMorgan investment banker
Bill Winters as its new chiet
executive, replacing Peter
Sands. He will be based in
London.
Bank of Zambia
Dr Denny Kalyalya was
appointed Governor of the
Bank of Zambia, He had
been Deputy Governor ~
Operations and also served at
the World Bank as Alternate
and later as Executive Director
of the first group for Africa.
MARCH
FirstRand
Johan Burger will take over
as chief executive of South
‘Africa's FirstRand group from
30" September, replacing
ve Nxasana, who is retiring
afier nine years. Burger has
been chief financial officer
since 2002 and was appointed
deputy chief
-cutive in 2013
Central Bank of Kenya
Kenya's Central Bank
governor Njuguna Ndung'u
stepped down in March after
eight years,
His successor will be
announced in May ~ the
first time the governor will
be chosen through open
competition
Shortlisted candidates are
Doctors Haron Sirima, Patrick
Ngugi Njoroge, Edward
Sambili, Peninah Wanjira
Kariuki and Geotirey Ngungi
“Mavai, Selection forthe posts
of chairperson and deputy
governor is also taking place,
African Bank
Louis von Zeuner has been
appointed as Chairmai
‘designate of African Bank's
Good Bank in South Arica
Von Zeuner has worked
closely with the Curator on
‘African Bank since August
2014. He retired from Absa
Group as Deputy Group Chief
Executive in December 2012.
Mizuho Bank
Japan’s Mizuho Bank has
appointed Moses Singo to
head it Johannesburg office as
senior director - global trade
finance, sub-Saharan Africa
Singo joins from Rand
Merchant Bank, where he was
head of trade finance, sales
for Africa and India. (
interview on page 18).
Reserve Bank of
imbabwe
Economist John Mangudya
will take over as Governor of
the Reserve Bank of Zimbabwe
fora five-year term, He is the
former CRO of the state-linked
bank CBZ Holdings.
South African
Reserve Bank
Kuben Naidoo was appointed
Deputy Governor of the South
African Reserve Bank for five
years with effect from 1" April
He has been an advisor to the
Governor and a member of the
Monetary Policy Committee.
APRIL
BADEA
“The Mauritanian Minister
‘of Economic Affairs and
Development, Sidi Ould Tah
was elected on the 7" April
as General Director of the
‘Arab Bank for Economie
Development in Africa
(BADEA), replacing thewwwsoprabanking.com WW f « inNew Appointments
Algerian Abdel Aziz Khelef.
He will take office on
30 June.
Rand Merchant Bank
James Formby was appointed
as Rand Merchant Bank's
new CEO, taking over on
¥ October. Until then he
will operate as RMB deputy
chief executive for a smooth
succession, He has been at
RMB since 1997.
Old Mutual
Old Mutual ple appointed
Bruce Hemphill as Group
Chief Executive, as part of
a succession plan, taking
‘over most likely during Qs
2015. He will be an Executive
Director and based in
London, He is currently
Chief Executive of Wealth,
Insurance and Non-Bank
Financial Services at Standard
Bank Group.
Parting Africa’s sea of trade
‘ses Singo has joined
the Johannesburg
Representative
Oltice of Japan's
Mizuho Bank as Senior
Director ~ Global Trade
Finance, Sub-Saharan A‘rica,
Headquartered in Tokyo,
Mizuho is one of the world’s
biggest banks. Singo joins
from Rand Merchant Bank,
‘Trade and Working Capital,
where he was previously Head
of trade finance, sales for
Africa and India.
Mizuho opened their
Johannesburg office 18
months ago. In 2013,
Mizuho Corporate Bank in
Tokyo signed a cooperation
agreement with South
‘Arica’s Department of Trade
and Industry to promate
and develop economic and
industrial cooperation
between the two countries
Japan is now the most active
‘Asian finance sponsor in
Alrica, according to global law
firm Linklaters, responsible
for $354bn last year alone, and
is South Africa’ third-largest
export destination and fifth-
largest source of imports. In
South Africa’ President
Zama said, whilst in Tokyo,
that there were 110 Japanese
companies currently doing
in South Africa.
wannesburg, Singo
is responsible forall trade
products, including Mizuho's
ECA business in sub-Saharan
Africa, and its relationships
with maltilaterals such as
MIGA (the Multilateral
Investment Guarantee
Agency). He will be looking
at letters of credit guarantees,
‘commodity finance, FI
relationships and E
financing, mostly for essential
infrastructure projects, such
as electricity, water and
sanitation, rail and roads, port
infrastructure,
in experienced trade
finance banker, he says "A
lot of banks in Africa say
they need to go to trade
finance, especially short
tenor so that funding
isnot tied up for too
long. African banks
are not naturally dollar
banks, they don't
necessarily have dollar
deposits. I's important
for them to make sure
that whatever USD
they have, they use it
efficiently,
“Pma strong believer in
trade finance and I believe
it should be good business
for banks into Africa”
TTve met Japanese
companies since starting
at Mizuho. They are, of
course, looking for projects,
trading and investment
‘opportunities in Africa. Lean
see that they do have interest
and are considering how
they should be going about
their investments. They like
South Africa because they
have representatives and
subsidiaries here and they
‘want to use itas a launching
pad into sub-Saharan Africa
So of course that’s very
interesting for the rest of
Arica,
“Pima strong believer in
trade finance and I believe it
should be good business for
‘banks into Africa. African
economies are generally
driven by trade ~ trade
from Asia, Europe and
the Americas into
Arica, and also intra
‘African trade. Ifyou
look at commodity
prices now, they are
low, but one can
assume that its a cycle
and that pricing will
improve. I'm optimistic
about trade finance inPOWERING AFRICA'S FUTURE
AFC, LEAD PROJECT DEVELOPER, INVESTOR AND FINANCIER
Arica Finance Corporation (AFC) is the leod sponsor, developer ond finencier for the Kpone
Independent Power Plant, Transmission Substction ond Fuel Supply asses in Tema, Ghana.
(Cenpower Generation Compony Limited fa Special Purpose Vehicle created to develop the power plan’)
is AFC's latest involvement in diving innovation and bridging the access to power gap across Afica,
The pojedl -a350MW power generation plontiogether with exacuation ond fvel supply inasruciure,
is being developed, consinicted and financed primerily by lrican sponsors, shareholders, cantractors
fond lenders - making it the fist ofits kind in Sub-Scharan Aftica, It is also the fre private sector
‘greenfield IPP to utiize project finance in Ghone.
‘AFC, asthe mandated lead arranger also coordinated finence from a consortium of nine private sector
local and intematianal commercial banks, developrent finance insitutions, institutional and export
creditogencies
When operational, the plant willimprove Ghana's security of electric
dependable installed generation capacity by eround 13%.
supply, increasing the country’s
AFC....Transformational investments in Power...building the New Africa
www.africafc.org
Oil
Project Finance Interntinel Alrkan
‘highly Commended Aico
Infect Proje inneTheNewYorkForum
ene AFRICA
INVEST IN THE ENERGY CONTINENT
Ourevite
ACALL TO ACTION
ee eee a ly
eee te ele eee et eae en Cy
rest of the world, Africa's leading entrepreneurs and media
ee ee ee ea ere eet
Ce Om tears a
PN ee oc
ee eee tee ae tere
Bean nee ene yee
Se aoe me ee ee en ee Cd
will focus on the energy that comes from Africa's human 5
Cet ey i
See eid me
research and develooment, and sectors Ike agriculture and t Chines
Deen cece!
eect a 8 erro
Ea ee eee ed B ow
Se ee
Pete ire Re
Se cere este Rasa
NYFA: the only pan-African economic forum to be held in Africa in 2015Peo Bctrst ed
Pecnetn onnai
Nene esc oes
Cremer
Pours creat
pee ere Se
‘Under Kaberuka’s leadership,
Pree Rees
Btn peers eee
influential development institution
Punter eames tents
eee cuca
Peete cece ts
transparency in the running of the
Peter renee)
TET DISTT TT aera
eo eerie!
Renee een ete]
See nue aes
Pere meee eesti
Seen ee cea
reer cere enn
array of development and financial
Peg Ene eee)
eer Prsteestls
eas ‘ eae eo
; the eight individuals that are in the
ae a eee en
a candidates the same set of questions
pine c slbout what the future of AADB would
Pecnie) Pavan ea setProfiles: African Development Bank
Akinwumi Adesina of Nigeria is more of an agricultural development
specialist than a financier. His vision is based on continuing
decentralisation and increasing support for private initiatives
Interview with Maureen Grisot.
Akinwumi Adesina
Minister of Agriculture and
Rural Development, Nigeria
Ifappointed, what would be your frst
‘action as president?
Twould ensure that the AfDB sup-
ports inclusive growth so the lives of
the greatest number are improved
To this end, the institution should
focus on sectors that have the great-
est impact such as infrastructure and
agriculture. [twill also be essential to
convince the private sector to invest
‘more on the continent. This isthe Key
to creating jobs.
Why would you make a good
president?
lived and worked ins African coun-
tries, so I know the continent well.
stayed for 10 years in Francophone
countries and shall be a bridge be-
tween these countries and English-
speaking Africa, Finance is not the
only skill needed to meet the impor-
tant challenges. Throughout my ca-
reer, I gained experience in the much
broader field of development. In Nige
ria, [have reached millions through
projects. worked atthe community
level and Iam able to connect the
‘macro and micro levels essential for
achieving inclusive growth.
What needs to be changed in the way
the APDB operates frit to help Africa
really take off?
We must first become interested in
the structure ofthe Bank, so that it
can meetallits mandates more effee-
tively It must have an impact in the
country, and I willensure it deepens
decentralisation. African countri
can address several other sources of
funding. But the Bank must remain
their first choice. I want to improve
operational efficiency and reduce the
time between the selection of projects
and their implementation.
‘AfDB must also rebuild integrity,
transparency and accountability. |
am also known for being a cham-
pion of the fight against corruption
all throughout my career. In Nigeria,
in three months, I helped to end cor
ruption that had lasted 4o years, and I
want to make AfDB the African bank
with integrity.
Can you give a concrete example
“Iwould
ensure that
the AIDB
supports
inclusive
growth so
the lives of
the greatest
number are
improved”
of something AfDB does that other
development banks do not?
{ADB has done a lot for infrastrue-
ture on the continent. It takes about
saabn per year to cover the deficit of
infrastructure financing in Africa.
ADB has attracted funding in th
sector, including creating the initia
tive Africa so.
‘The Bank has done alot of workin
the electricity industry and supported
renewable energy while promoting
regional integration,
‘The Bank's strategy for 2013-2022 has
been adopted. In this context, how
can the new president pursue his or
her own ideas and priovities?
My ideas are perfectly consistent with
this strategy. want to promote inchi-
sive growth by developing the private
sector, stimulating regional integra
tion, by infrastructuze construction
and ensuring good governance. These
ae the AED priorities.
‘The decentralisation strategy has
been criticised for being expensive
‘and ineficient. Do you intend to
continue it?
“The quality of AFDB projects can
be improved only ifit is close to its
customers. Agriculture in Nigeria
isa success because the Ministry of
Agriculture is decentralised in the
country’s 36 states. Today we have
the best performance in this sector,
so deeply believe in decentralisation.Tunisia’s former Finance Minister, Jaloul Ayed, asserts that it is his
banking experience which allowed him to gain a clear understanding of
Africa's full potential. He calls for an AfDB closer to its markets.
Interview with Joan Tilouine.
Jaloul Ayed
Former Minister of Finance,
Tunisia
IFappointed, what would be your first
action as president?
Twould request a general assessment
‘of the Bank, with particular emphasis
‘on human resources. An institution
depends above all on the qualities of
its staff. [will meet with key leaders
and executives and listen to their
motivations and needs. Itis also im:
portant to assess efficiency and risk
the implementation of sustainable
development.
The Bank's strategy for 2013-2022 has
bbeen adopted. In this context, how
can the new president pursue his or
hher own ideas and priorities?
agree with this strategy. I do not
intend to turn it upside down but
meet the Bank's objectives includ
ing operational objectives. will add
a few small touches that I consider
‘important, firstly, with regard tothe
reform of the financial system, be-
cause only a strong financial system
can support a strong economy. We
also need to conduct studies in the
field of culture. 1 would like to put
Why would you make a good
president?
My passion for Africa and experi-
‘ence. When I led the second-largest
Moroccan banking group, Imanaged.
the acquisition of Bank of Africa and
created subsidiaries in more than 20 culture at the heart of development
African countries. My profile stands ——"_ opportunities to come to us. Under because lam convinced that it has a
oot from others. 'm nota pure prod- “I would ry leadership, the AfDR would be positive impact,
uct of the administration, even if! request a more involved in business circuits
‘was finance minister after the 20n general ‘while retaining its original vocation The decentralisation strategy has
revolution in Tunisia. havea wealth assessment _as a development bank been criticised for being expensive
cof experience in the private sector of the and inefficient. Do you intend to
and international finance. Bank,with Can you give a concrete example continue it?
particular of something AFDB does that other Lam for efficient decentralisation
What needs to be changed inthe way emphasis development banks do not? along with empowerment. Pm not
the AfDB operatesforittohelp Africa omhuman It is a development bank and as_very focused on representative of-
really take off? resources” such has played a crucial role in in- _fices because I am not convinced of
Thave a vision in order for uso seize frastructure. There are two major their efficiency. In contrast, proxim-
the extraordinary transformation of development banks involved in Af- ity seems most eficient, Proximity is
the continent, I think the AfDB is rica: the AMDB and the World Bank. crucial inorder to be more proactive
at the heart of this change and can The pan-African institution plays and pro-business. But it has a cost;
play an even greater role. would like a crucial role in providing techni- and it must be studied. I would start
the ADB to he more proactive and calassistance and intervenes to help with where there is the greatest need,
‘pro-business. I want us to seek out and assist member states in develop- that s to say, in fragile countries that
‘opportunities and not just wait for ing good strategies and reforms for we need to help.Profiles: African Development Bank
Following his time at the AfDB, Kordjé Bedoumra intends
to improve operational efficiency and pursue both short:
and long-term policies. Interview with
Hichem Ben Yaiche.
Kordjé Bedoumra
Minister of Finance and Budget,
Chad
‘appointed, what would be your first
faction as president?
You have to rapidly evaluate the situ-
ation. As know the AfDB well, this
shouldn't be difficult. Action needs
tobe taken to mobilise and motivate
the teams. I would review the organi
sational structure, focus on priorities,
simplify procedures, optimise the
budget and work to ensure effective
decentralisation. I would devise a
‘roadmap’ to strengthen the Bank's
capacity to work towards this vision.
Why would you make a good
president?
In addition to my record, Ihave had
years of varied experience at the
Bank and the Chadian government.
[As Secretary-General of the A{DB,
you are involved in all strategie and
Political discussions in talks be-
tween country representatives and
you help build consensus. My whole
career has given me unique learning
opportunities, which have equipped
ime to conduct discussions and man-
age strategic problems at the very
highest level
What needs to be changed in the way
the ADB operates frit to help Africa
really take off?
Helping Africa to takeoffs primarily
the job of African countries them-
selves and their leaders. Africa will
not take off just because of assistance.
Each country, using its vision and
mobilising its population, will ensure
f
its own development, but the ALDB
provides financial and technical sup.
port to key elements of this.
Can you give a concrete example
of something AfDB does that other
development banks do not?
For a long time, the AfDB has been
an institution which has taken charge
of regional projects and developed
instruments dedicated to financing
them. Today, many projects have
been realised, It’s an area in which
the ADB has become a leader and
“Action needs
tobe taken to
mobilise and
motivate the
teams”
Which they need to maintain and de-
velop. Integration is the basi for the
development and emergence of the
‘continent,
‘The Bank’s strategy for 2013-2022 has
been adopted. In this context, how
can the new president pursue his or
hier own ideas and priorities?
‘There shouldn't heany major contra
dictions. The 10-year strategy marks
‘out several major priority sectors.
What suggest isto develop my vision
around this 10-year strategy whilst
reorienting t to ensure we carry out
strategic objectives which I consider
to be an urgent response to current
issues
‘The decentralisation strategy has been
criticised for being expensive and inef-
ficient. Do you intend to continue it?
“There is an ongoing debate between
decentralisation and financial con:
trol. These offices area requirement
of the countries which insisted on
the Bank having more of a presence
in their area. The principle of hav-
ing a presence in the countries is im
portant and should be maintained,
alongside other institutions. However,
‘we need to analyse the effectiveness
of this decentralisation with regard
to costs, With modern information
systems and strengthened control
mechanisms, we should be able to
‘ensure a better delegation of authority
ata reduced cost and to the benefit of
‘African counties.RICAN BANNER 20D QUARTER 2015 26
Whatever improvements need to be made, the AfDB
should have one mission: to serve Africa, according to
Cristina Duarte, Minister of Finance and Planning for
Cabo Verde. Interview with Hichem Ben Yaiche.
Cristina Duarte
Minister of Finance and Planning,
Cabo Verde
If appointed, what would be your
Jirst action as president?
“The AfDB is a complex organisa-
tion in that itis both a development
and investment bank. The president
primary concern is to mobilise the
‘organisation as it is around a single
‘objective and vision. To do this, it
necessary to listen to all of AfDB's
stakeholders, in particular the Bank's
staff. One must prioritise the crea
tion of an environment of dialogue,
internal analysis and collaboration.
Can you give a concrete example
of something ADB does that other
development banks do not?
‘AFDB has played a catalyst role, It
has added an African perspective to
Africa's development.
By prioritising this perspective,
the ADBis increasingly contributing
toa sense of ownership on the part
of African governments, but also.on
the part of African societies.
‘The Bank's strategy for 2013-2022
hhas been adopted. In this context,
how can the new president pursue
his or her own ideas and priorities?
Thave been governor of the AfDB
since 2006, I was involved in this
strategy and approved it. This means
that for the next president, the road-
‘map isa good starting point. "There is
no need to put another on the table.
It is more a question of seeing
how quickly we can transfer this
strategy, which has already been
prepared, into a plan of action.
Why would you make a good
president?
‘As Finance Minister, | worked in a
firm manner, but at the same time in
participatory one. I practised with
conviction, mobilising and motivat-
ing the entire team of the Ministry.
had the opportunity to exercise this
authority in dialogue with all, but
‘while maintaining a focus on vision.
What needs to be changed in the
way the AfDB operates forit to help “One must
Africa really take off? prioritise the ‘he decentralisation strategy has
“Africa has already taken olf. So itis creation of an been criticised for being expensive
rather a question of sustaining mo. environment and inefficient. Do you intend to
‘mentum. Africa got the bal rolling of dialogue, continue it?
trough a combination of external internal ‘The next president should initiate
and internal factors. African govern- analysis an evaluation of this process not in
‘ments are adopting good governance and collab- order to eliminate it but improve it
practices. The primary responsibility oration” and make it more efficent, to turn
for Africa’ take-off, and the sustain: it into an instrument that allows
ability ofthis take-off lies primarily us to do more with fewer resources
with Africans, particularly demo- so as to consolidate the Bank’s sus-
cratically elected governments. tainabilityProfiles: African Development Bank
‘With broad experience in a number of financial institutions, Sierra
Leon
ADB works for Africa. Interview by Daniela Severino.
Samura Kamara
Minister of Foreign Affairs and
International Cooperation, Sierra Leone
appointed, what would be your first
action as president?
The Bank is not a learning curve for
our president. Time is not on our
side. Africa is on the surge, on the
move. So the very first thing you
want (0 do is engage the executive
board of directors. We have a 0-year
strategy. Unfortunately it started in
2013, and just about the time when
‘weare implementing it, the president
is going. So youhave to put that into
perspective, and the board of execu-
tive directors should help you do th
Why would you make a good
president?
T think I have a clear mix of skills,
and experience in general economic
‘management. Its not about me com-
ing in as specialist in one small area
I've been policy leader in the broad
aspects of policy development in
Sierra Leone. In may engagement with
the international community, I've
learnt lot, ! know the views. Ican
deal with the IMF, the World Bank
and Arab funding agencies.
What needs to be changed in the way
the AfDB operates fort tohelp Africa
really take off?
The 10-year strategy is good, but we
need to put it into context. The AfDB
can havea general view but you have
to bevvery specific. snot one size fits
all, And thats why L wil focus on the
country offices and regional offices,
give them more power, strengthen
them allow them to develop their
outreach,
Can you give a concrete example
of something AfDB does that other
development banks do not?
In the case of Sierra Leone, more
recently the AFDB has done well in
terms of infrastructure development.
‘here was a time when we were get
ting resources from the World Bank,
's Samura Kamara believes he is the right person to ensure the
“The very
first thing
‘you want to
do is engage
the executive
board of
directors”
‘ther bilaterals, but as the ‘gas pro.
_geessed, alot of them withdrew from
infrastructure. The AIDB stayed on,
which is very good for Africa. The
only unfortunate thing is it doesn't
have enough resources
‘The Bank's strategy for 2013-2022 has
been adopted. In this context, how
can the new president pursue his or
her own ideas and priorities?
When I read the document, I de not
see the final details ofa strategy, be-
cause a strategy lays a framework.
You now need to do an activity pro-
file, look at costing and resources.
‘The ADB must strengthen its know!-
edge of Africa, its communications
network. You have a lot of geopo-
litical associations, China-Africa,
Korea-Africa, laly-Africa, There are
‘opportunities in this, but they have
not moved forward,
‘The decentralisation strategy has
been criticised for being expensive
and inefficient. Do you intend to
continueit?
Inour post-conflict construction, we
found out that Sierra Leone was with-
‘out local government for 30 years.
And we thought that was a source for
conflict because you are marginalis
ing rural communities. We started
decentralisation, and we benefited.
In the context of the A{DB, that is
‘one good window if the Bank wants
to make a serious impact.AFBICAN BANKER 2NO QUARTER 2018 27
With plenty of experience working at the ADB, Zimbabwe's Thomas
Sakala believes he is well suited to keep the Bank's programmes and
strategies on the right track. Interview by Hichem Ben Yaiche.
Thomas Zondo Sakala
Former Vice president
of AfDB, Zimbabwe
fappointed, what would be your frst
action as president?
T would ensure that every member
of staff understands my vision and
what Lexpect in order to promote the
transformation of the Bank and the
continent Building a winning team is
‘paramount. This might require some
‘organisational fine-Funing and com
nication to both internal and ex
ternal stakeholders. Iwill meet senior
‘management and Board members to
share my vision and get their views
Why would you make a good
president?
Firstly, my long experience at the
Bank working in a numberof differ
ent Key areas and reforms that have
placed the Bank where it is today.
Secondly, my extensive knowledge
of African countries, economies and
leaders. Thirdly, my strong belief that
‘Africa has the capacity to do more for
itself. Fourthly, my familiarity with
the international development land:
scape. These attributes give me the
right profile to build on Kaberuka’s
successes. Above all, Iwill ensure
‘a smooth transition whilst quickly
scaling up on existing momentum.
What needs to be changed in the way
the ADB operates for itt help Africa
really take off?
First and foremost, it isthe respon:
sibility of each country to chart and
implement its own development path.
“Iwould
ensure that
every member
of staff
understands
my vision”
X
X
‘The Bank must build trust and pro-
vvide advice. The Bank must be alert
to what is working and not, and be
prepared to change long-held views.
‘The Bank must be ready to embrace
anew role asthe bridge between old
development banks and the emerging
players such the BRICS. To underpin
this, the Bank must be passionate,
innovative and risk-taking.
Can you give a concrete example
of something AfDB does that other
development banks do not?
T'll give you three quick examples:
1) timely and accelerated responses
during the 2008/09 financial crisis; 2)
partnerships with the AU on the Su-
dan/South Sudan question; setting
up the Africa 50 Fund in response to
the infrastructure financing gap.
‘Ihe Bank's strategy for 2013-2022 has
been adopted. In this context, how
can the new president pursue his or
hher own ideas and priorities?
The strategy charts a credible road-
map for the Bank in its quest to be at
the centre of Africa’ transformation
agenda and I was part of the team
that crafted it. The strategy foresaw
the need for periodic reviews, the
first of which will likely take place in
2016. This willbe an appropriate time
to strengthen alignment with the AU
Agenda 2063 and the post-2015 Sus-
tainable Development Goals. There
will also bea need to reflect on lessons
from the Ebola epidemic.
However, I still expect that in-
frastructure, regional integration
and private sector development will
continue to be the core operational
priority areas, whilst gender equality,
fragility and food security will remain
areas of special attention.
‘The decentralisation strategy has
been criticised for being expensive
and inefficient. Do you intend to
continue i?
Decentralisation is costly but neces-
sary. The challenge is alveays to strive
for a cost effective and efficient bal-
ance. Lam also aware that we have
failed in adequately reporting and
measuring our successes and sys~
tematically building on them. A com-
prehensive review of the programme
started under my watch. I will build
on this work and introduce additional
ideas I might have.Profiles: African Development Bank
Having overseen Ethiopia's strong growth into one of
Africa's leading economies, its finance minister, Sufian
Ahmed, believes the AfDB will be safe in his experienced
hands. Interview by Alexa Dalby.
Sufian Ahmed
Minister of Finance and Economic
Development, Ethiopia
appointed, what would be your fist
action as president?
‘The first decision {would make would
be to review the effectiveness of the
regional offices of the Bank. These
offices have been established to
speed up the implementation of the
operation in the member countries.
Untortunately either some of them
are not properly empowered or have
insuficient manpower, with the result
that implementation isnot as quick as
itshould be.
Why would you make a good
president?
I will bring my track record to the
Bank. My achievements speak for
themselves. T have been finance
minister for Ethiopia for almost two
decades. Over that time, Ethiopia
has changed from a country that
‘was associated with starvation and
poverty to one ofthe fastest-growing
economies in Africa. We are talking
about inclusive, sustainable economic
growth, investmentin infrastructure,
in modernisation of agriculture and
social development. With me, the
Bank will be in safe hands. I have
known AfDB and I have been work-
ing with all muhtlateral financial in-
stitutions for the last 20 years.
What needs o be changed in the way
the AfDB operates fort to help Africa
really take off?
The Bank really should be focused
where it makes a real difference. It
should be focused on effective im-
plementation, Most of the time we
dont lack ideas and projects. We have
the right strategies and goals. What
is missing is to convert vision into
reality and make projects a reality. I
think the Bank should focus on ad-
vising the member countries on the
right projects and the adequate means
toexecute them speedily and within
budget.
Can you give a concrete example
of something AfDB does that other
development banks do not?
From mylong experience with AfDB,
Tcan say that the Bank is a trusted
adviser to member countries. As a
pan-African institution, the AfDB
brings something very special which
is missing from other multilateral
financial institutions. Afzican coun-
tries trust the AEDB. This isa very
“The first
decision 1
would make
‘would be to
review the
effectiveness
ofthe
regional
offices of the
Bank”
‘unique asset the Bank has which no
‘other financial institutions can pro-
vide, Its in its DNA.
‘The Bank’ srategy for 2013-2022 has
been adopted. inthis context, how
can the new president pursue is or
hher own ideas anc priorities?
‘The Bank's strategy for these 1 years
isa general one For the elected next
president, itis reallya matter of em
phasis and reprioctising the goals in
the Bank's strategies. don't see any
serious problem in reconciling my
priorities with the AIDB strategies
Itisa matter of prioritising and em
phassing some ofthe goals.
‘The decentralisation strategy has
been criticised for being expensive
and inefficient. Do you intend to
continue it?
dont agree with the criticism, pro
vviding the strategy is properly imple
mented, The decentralised decision:
making is very important from my
‘experience here in my country, as well
‘as from my working relationship with
the Bank. But these regional offices’
decision-making processes should
be fully empowered. If not, they will
be inefficient. They should be fully
accountable, These are the two main
things ~ full empowerment and ac-
countability, With both, the regional
offices can bean important part ofthe
decision-making process of the Bank
as well as efficient and cost effectiveRICAN BANKER eR 2015 29
With a wealth of experience in African development institutions, Mali’s
Birama Boubacar Sidibé intends to make the AfDB more efficient in
its decentralised organisation and expand its business operations.
Interview with Hichem Ben Yaiche.
Birama Boubacar Sidibé
Vice president of the Islamic Bank
of Development, Mali
Ifappointed, what would be your first
action as president?
T would immediately convene a
meeting with the board of directors
to hear their views and share my
vision. Then I would meet the Bank’s
employees in order to reassure and
‘mobilise them around the business
plan described in my vision. The
first effective measure is to ensure
the continuity of business operations,
especially as we will be entering the
4° quarter, where efforts should focus
‘on achieving the year's objectives and
preparing accounts.
‘The first effective measure
Why would you make a good isto ensure the continuity of
president? business operations, especially
Firstly, my over three decades as we will be entering the
experience in development finance 4th quarter”
institutions, including 23 years at
the ADB. This experience is rich
and varied in terms of results and add to its traditional roe of sovereign
positions, as wel as the credibility 1 lender, catalyst and provider of high-
acquired. As proof ofthis, n regional quality, value-added services as
member countries sponsored my well as arranger of mega-projects in
application. Secondly, Lhave clearly partnership with the private sector,
expressed my vision of my plan as investors and relevant states.
‘well as the means and solutions to
‘operationalise and adapt it. Can you give a concrete example
of something AfDB does that other
What needs to be changed in the way development banks do not?
the AfDB operates frit to help Africa It teamed up with the AU and the
really take off? Economic Commission for Africa
While keeping the strategic source (ECA) and helped builda vision and
‘of the 2063 agenda, its essential to economic agenda for the continent,
adapt the AfDB's approach in order approved by African leaders: Africa
to maximise profits. The ADB should is fully im control of ts destiny for the
first time in 50 years of independence,
‘The Bank's strategy for 2013-2022 has
been adopted. In this context, how
can the new president pursue his or
her own ideas and priovities?
The 10-year strategy is the result
of extensive consultation with all
stakeholders. It has been approved
by all management structures within
the Bank. This strategy should
therefore guide my actions. However,
the 10-year horizon cals for it to be
adjusted, adapted and reassessed if
necessary in the form of three-year
rolling plan. It will need to adapt to
economic conditions as well as the
global environment and development
challenges faced by African countries.
The decentralisation strategy has
been criticised for being expensive
and inefficient. Do you intend to
continue
Yes. The objectives of efficiency
and local services that are expected
are commendable. But as with
everything, the results are more
important. Then comes the question
of the means of our ambitions and
capacity of generating revenue
to cover the operating costs. It is,
my understanding that the Banks
management have engaged in a
reflection based on these issues. If
elected, T intend to continue this,
reflection and take any corrective
actions that may be necessary.20 AFRICAN BANKER 2ND QUARTER 2
Finance: Remittances
Ahmed Ismail hopes that mobile technology will help.
to crack open Western Union and MoneyGram’s near-
monopoly on the remittance business.
Early-morning call
ckphoneshavealays he ——
a fundamental part of the “The weakest
remittance process, Ahmed part in the
Ismail (ight) says with awry remittance
laugh; when they ring early in the chain is the
‘morning, it tends to be costly physical
“Usually you get a call at 6am or agent, where
7am, and you'll agree to send $400 someone goes
because you're half asleep,” says toa corner
Ismail, sofily-spoken Somalilander, shop with
during an interview in his West some cash”
London office.
For the tens of millions of
Africans living in the diaspora,
remittances provide a social and
economic link to their countries of
origin. International money transfer
isa ss8obn industry. Remittances
contribute over s30bn to African
economies; in some countries, they
represent more than 20% of GDP.
And yet Africans pay more than
anyone else to sen money home, in
part, erties say, due to its domination
by just two global players ~ Western
Union and MoneyGram.
Ismail is CEO of WorldRemit,
a relative upstart in the money
transfer business intent on breaking
their hold and taking advantage of
the explosion in mobile technology
that has revolutionised how Africans
spend, store and transmit money.
Ismail’s hometown of Hargeisa
was effectively built on remittances,
growing from a village to a city on
the back of money transfers from
migrants in booming Gulf states in
the 1970s and 19805.
“The way it used to work was that
a trader would travel to the Gulf,
collect money from migrants, use that‘money to buy goods, go back to their
country, sll the goods and give the
‘money to the recipients,” he recalls.
‘Over the next few decades, the
money flowing back grew enormously.
According to World Bank estimates,
remittances to sub-Saharan Africa
rose from less than s93m in 1970 to
almost szobn in 2010.
As the flow of money grew, so too
did the industry around it. Through
the 1980s and 1990s, structural
adjustment dismantled capital
controls across much of Africa,
and pushed the liberalisation of the
banking sector.
Western Union and MoneyGram
raced to take advantage as markets
‘opened up ~ ofen by signing exchusive
agreements with the dominant local
financial institutions. Today, two-
thirds of global remittance trafic goes
through those two companies.
‘They abolished one type of
monopolies, which were the state-
‘owned banks, but they opened up
to another kind of monopoly” says
Ismail.
Last year a reportby the Overseas
Development Initiative (ODI), a UK
think-tank, revealed that the African
diaspora pays an average S12 in fees
and charges to send 8200 home. Based
fon the discrepancies between Africa
and the global average of around s8
this amounts to a si.abn ‘super tax
‘on the continent, the report said. The
think-tank estimated that s586m of
the total was associated with foreign
currency charges levied by Western
Union and MoneyGram,
“Exclusivity agreements between.
[money transfer operators), their
agents and banks restrict competition
and drive up prices, as do African
financial regulations favouring
banks over other remittance payment
“options,” said the report.
‘This ‘super tax’ matters.
Remittances are an important support
for many African economies, and
unique in that money tends to flow
to low-income households to be used
for consumption, investment and
to pay out-of-pocket expenses such
as healthcare costs. In 2014, around
Mobile money
Registered and active mobile money
accounts in sub-Saharan africa
‘Above: Making
femitonces faster
{transfer isgood
e1om
42am
sam
485m
8am
146.0
sg3bn was transferred into sub-
Saharan African economies, more
than all aid from the Organisation
of Economie Cooperation and
Development countries combined,
and is times that invested by private
equity companies that year
Regulation
Despite the growth of the industry,
informality and fragmentation
continued in the ay" century until
post-9/11 regulations drove many
small operators to the wall, Anti-
money laundering (AML) and ‘know-
your-customer (KYC) rules created
amajor burden.
For money transfer businesses
dealing principally in small cash
transactions, the restrictions add
enormous complexity and cost. Inan
environment of growing risk version
The Importance of remittances
emitances asa percentage of GO,
selected african counties
in the banking industry, several
cut off money transfer operators as
they tried to limit their exposure to
reputational damage and regulatory
action,
In 2013, Barclays announced it
‘would shut down the bank accounts
of the Somali money transfer firm
Dahabshiil; and in February, the
last US bank that specialised in
money transfers, Merchants Bank
of California, announced it would
close the accounts of all its Somali-
American money transfer businesses.
‘After 9/1, [smail worked with
the United Nations’ remittance
programme in the Middle East
and Fast Africa, helping smaller
companies to cope with the sudden
tightening of regulations. Itwas there
he realised the twin challenges of
compliance and cost representedFinance: Remittances
an opportunity to crack open the
‘market, while the expansion of mobile
telephony and banking created the
‘means to do it
“What we are trying to do now
is to provide a service to match the
instant flow of communication,”
Ismail says. “People are chatting for
free cross-border. We're trying to
provide service that allows people
to move money seamlessly across
borders,
Currently, around 95% of
remittances are cash-in, cash-out,
with physical agents at either end
for senders and recipients. Only 5%
‘occur online. African economies ran
largely on cash, and the penetration
0% in
the majority ofthe countries south of
the Sahara. Cash transactions havea
Jot more friction ~ handling, moving
and paying in cash adds cost and risk
es, recipients and the money
“The weakest part in the
remittance chain is the physical agent,
where someone goes to a corner
shop with some cash, and they are
providing money transfer as a side
business. They're not particularly
interested in compliance,” Ismail says.
“The challenge [money transfer
firms] face is that the guy in the
comer shop is not your stalf member.
‘They don't care aboot the compliance
stuff, all they care about is paying
their rent at the end of the month
They cut corners”
Because of the risks attached
to the cash remittance business,
Ismail says that he has sympathy for
banks that have severed ties with the
industry.
“Unfortunately in our industry
wwe have a lot of players who are
ining a large network of
physical locations that are giving a
bad image tothe rest of the industry”
he says. “Banks are starting to realise
that in this day and age, somebody
taking a lot of cash to a physical
location isa very risky business.”
‘On the send side, WorldRemit
is 190% cashless ~ senders can use
their debit or credit cards, or transfer
Cost of sending $200
Source: World Bank
Middle East &North Afric) LT — $8.6
East Asia & Pacific $8.1
Hoek $6.2
Latin America & Caribbean a $60
suns! $59
Sub-Sah:
Above: customers
fervice outlet in
Gating, Walrad
Inward
flows of
remittances
to sub-
Saharan
Africa
Soe: Worl Bark
20 Ai TT $11.5
directly from their bank accounts.
The bigger gamble for the
‘company was on the receive side,
‘where it lacks the huge agent networks
ofits larger competitors
“When we launched and said we
‘won't operate cash pickup in Nigeria,
competitors. thought that wouldn't
work,” Ismail says, "We can instantly
«credit money to any bank account in
Nigeria... We don't have cash pickup
in Nigeria, but we are doing a large
volume”
‘When it began, cash pick-up wes
100% of World Remit’s business; today
itis only 30% Ismail thinks that could
fall even further, even as the overall
business grows.
“The company allows recipients
to receive money direct to their
bank accounts, but it is in mobile
‘money that Ismail sees the greatest
potential already WorldRemit sends
more money to mobile wallets than
Western Union or MoneyGram
More than half ofits transfers into
Africa are received as mobile money
‘orairtime top-up,
'M-Pesa has more agents in Kenya
than the entire Western Union agent
network in Africa,” Ismail says.
“Those mobile operators are making
big difference in terms of how people
receive their money.”
Noteveryoneisconvinced thatthe
‘mobile revolution will fandamentally
change the cost structures of the
remittance business, however
“If the question is ‘do mobile
wallets lower the cost ofremittances?,
the way it could conceivably do itis
by mobile wallet operators expecting
less revere share from operators like
usto terminate transfer on & mobile
wallet than into cash,” says Alex
Hoffman, executive vice president
for business development in Africa
for MoneyGram.
“Maybe you could make an
argument that their costs are lower
because it’s electronic rather than
having a cash payout. But...in our
discussions with mobile operators,
we don’t observe that they are
demanding less revenue share than
their competitor banks.
“Our cost structure of sending to
mobile wallet is about the same as
sending to a cash payout. Therefore
it’s not driving down the cost of
remittances.”
Around 90% of MoneyGram’s
business is still cash transfer, but
Hoffman envisages the growth of
“self-service channels”, includingmobile wallets, kiosks ad ak ——
accounts. The company asset tselta “Something
target of making s-20% of itsevenue that has been
through these channels by 2037. a major asset
While cost is important to for Western
customers, Hoffman says the money Union, half
transfer business is complex, and a million
requires the reputation and scale locations,
larger operators like MoneyGram is now.
have-regardlessof thechannel. becoming
“Moving money is ot as simple a major
as itmay sound...There is alot of liability”
regulation involved, there’ a lat of
risk management, there area lot of
systems and processes and people and
tools that you have to put in place,”
Hofiman says.
“We know how to move money
safely and legally around the word.
‘Whether it’s cash or self-service
doesn't matter”
‘Western Union did not return
requests for comment.
‘At WorldRemit, Ismail says he
hhas been able to bring fees down 20.
30% when sending money to most
countries, and more for some. The
company offers minimum fees of
€0.95 (61.02) when sending money
from Europe; Western Union and
MoneyGram, minimum fe
typically $5 or above,
Ismail is quietly evangelical about
the potential of mobile money for
economic development. It allows
individuals in rural areas to receive
money without the cost of travelling
to cities; empowers women by
handing them control over finances
and brings informal businesses into
the formal sector.
He believes the structures
that allowed the big incumbents
to dominate the markets will be
fan anchor on their growth as the
industry shifts beneath them, adding
cost and complexity.
“Something that has been a
major asset for Western Union, half
a million locations, isnow becoming
a major lability,” he says. “These are
the legacy issues that we don't have.”
Hisbeliefhas been backed by real
smoney. In March 2oug, venture capital
firm Accel Partners invested $4om in
series A funding; in February this
‘Technology Crossover Ventures
'V) led a Sioom series B. The
company has expanded from 40
people in early 014 to more than 50,
and will be moving headquarters to
‘more upmarket premises in Central
London.
“We see huge opportunity in this
space,” Ismail says. “The industry is
rapidly shifting to online. Its 5% fof
‘volumes]. Over the next 10 years we
think 50% will move online. We think
we will see seismic transformation
in the way that people will receive
money.
Peter Gu
secure
more
se) Ee
ulid new revenue steamer your business with the Axis vdeo
Surveillance solution, With the conversion from analog to digital
Tis OPOFLURIY Is erasing. What's more you already have the
felationships and Krowledge to capitalize on it
Secure ap opportunity at www.axis.com/companion
Introducing the Axis video
surveillance solution
AXIS a
COMMUNICATIONSEvents: African Banker Awards
: Pe : Cenc
nk Limited (aur
Mastercard fix)
MasterCard and Steward Bank
‘UBA Kenya Bank Limited (Kenya)
ed
‘Banco Comercial ede Investimentos
(Mozambique)
Ecobank Transnational
Nedbank (Suh
Awarding Africa’s Sire bni
Top Bankers
‘The Federal Democratic Republic of
Ethiopia debut Slbn [organ Che
'$500m 3.903% Sukuk Bond
Stondard Bank Group Lined
Largest telecom fnancing
inAfricain2014
Standard Chartered Bonk
n every region of Africa this atwy-thends, gowammmmrmmm
year, Banks have been making Skbatnethe Sno ‘Sept Petroleum Development Company
Tepiuous maovatonsand aides . eee Fin capt toned
“These impressive performances langue larecalne au Commerce 865m Financing Package forthe
are reflected in the wide range of Extoieur von Etvoptan tativay Corporation
hominees forthe upcoming Aitican May imaaPaaa Grats
Haner Sarde me
“Innovation is key, financial dao Tesla Meclorths Hokegs Leted ZAR 2\Aba
inclusion is key, and deals ae key to ($2.0) Siondard Sek ep Lat
the continent’ transformation, Banks = a
atPO Sant an
cem fully engaged in all three,” said a
seem fully engaged in all tres ai Standard Chartered Book Aeulson of CHC Holings
. - 4 Ere lermes 0
Omar Ben Yedder. —£ -—
‘The expert judging panel of Segun Agbaje Mancging Direcor/Chief inholf 880
binkets ag bunts odes wh Shuntoporcra ‘Mesandr Forbes §950m ating and
will pick the winners have a very faces eGuEen $830m PO fandom ark
difficult task on their hands, The CHO nine Comercale de estienos
‘wards will be hosted by African bert Eien Gr Canpower Kone PP
Banker magazine a the Annwal Teno ‘Searinane Copeation
Neale Arn Deemer rhe Assog FN Capit Ll
ik (AIDB) on 27" Mayin Abigin, Mian Dir Coopentn Rant ACME ER Cail Lied —_
Cote d'Ivoire. The awards, which are Development Bank Bank pl {ate Turkana Wind Project in Kenya
held ander the high patronage ofthe Tag Himsa readin cocaine NS
[AIDB and hosted by the Professional pr ral er 2H sat
‘Association of Banks and Financial LL
Institutions of Cate d'Ivoire (APBEF- ‘Gampagide Penaeciive Avian " ai
Ino of ie doe APB EM connivance en ea
Banque AMantiqu, Corns Bank, GT ==
lity Bank
Bank, Ecobank and Nedbank. ECAis, tere Fieldstone Africa
Sopra Banking Software and Travelex Feniston Ntmwta erence ‘Nedbank Lined
arg also supporting the Awards. The (Moroco} and Merchant Bank
ala Dinner and Awards presentation eS ——_
will take place at the Sofitel Abidjan Se ae
Ivoire Hotel. ‘Trust Merchant Bank (co ‘Standard BankTELECOM
Connectivity without borders
Africa’s super-fast fibre network
Seed
— 2 eer esr ere
Liquic
Building Africa’s digital future
www.liquidtelecom.comin Conversation: Mohamed El Kettani, CEO, Attijariwafa Bank
Attijariwafa Bank has expanded from its home in Morocco to many other countries in Africa.
CEO Mohamed El Kettani explains how and why it has been making these ambitious strides,
Conquering Africa,
one country at a time
What are the keys to the success of
Attijariwafa Bank in Africa?
One of the key factors in the first
stage of expansion into Francophone
‘Africa isthe fact that we have built
an integrated banking and finance
group, which has already established
firm foundations in Morocco itselé
‘An international strategy can only be
successful if it hasa strong position
in its domestic market. This is the
case with Attijariwafa Bank.
We are the oldest Moroccan
bank, founded in 904. The merger in
22003 of the Banque Commerciale du
Maroc, the leading private bank, and
Wafabank resulted in the creation of
Attijariwafe Bank. We feel that we
have been enriched by the addition
of the personnel from both banks.
We had the choice of either
restructuring, as international banks
do, and offering compensation to
some personnel, or capitalising on
existing skills. It was thus that we
initiated an ambitious development
programme in Morocco eight years
ago 50 that we could be involved in
increasing access to banking in our
country. We subsequently extended
our network by adopting our frst
roadmap with the acquisition of
banks on the African continent,
Did you maximise the opportunities
in your domestic market before
turning your attention towards
Africa?
‘Absolu
ly. Teams were mobilised
to manage this merger, which (ok —
two years. We ended up with a
market share of between 26% and
40% in a sector that has 16 banks
‘We exceeded the critical size needed
before we could consider expanding
internationally. Fortified by this
strong position and our human
capital, we sought out considerable
growth. Given our cultural and
historical proximity, Francophone
Arica has been the most obvious
market
‘The African market, particularly
this area, is not easy. How di
you go about ensuring a secure
‘environment?
‘We capitalised on the experience and
model that enabled our success in
Morocco, This is because in spite of
their differences, African countries
have a common denominator, not
least when it comes to sociocultural
sensitivity and the nature and
structure ofthe country’s economic
fabric. Also, we are operating in
an environment which has been
strongly shaped by fomnly capitalism,
In Morocco, Attijariwafa
Bank has developed products
and services for SMEs [small and
medium enterprises] and ways of
approaching customers, particularly
microbusinesses, operating in the
informal sector.
We have therefore developed
risk evaluation strategies and
rating tools for SMEs and scoring
“Ifwe have
this strength,
it’s because
wearea
Moroccan
bankand
therefore
African”
tools for microbusinesses. We are
now duplicating these models but
adapting them to the context and
reality of each country. It is this
which enables us to gain market
shares. We have invested in Central
and West African countries, wher
access to banking is between 2%
and 10%. Asa result, there is plenty
stil to do to provide solutions and
democratise access to banking
products, particularly forthe middle
classes, microbusinesses and SMES.
‘These groups have been ignored by
international banks operating on
the African continent. Why?
Because they have not developed
the strategies they need for a better
understanding of the market and
to make the necessary changes to
procedures, methods of analysis,
appropriate supervision and
monitoring tools. If we have this
strength, it's because we are a
Moroccan bank and therefore
African,
Your strength is also that you adapt
to the realities of each country. How
did you adopt the culture of these
countries and capitalise on your
proximity?
‘At the start, people believed that we
would take'a populist line, enticing
them with promises: ‘When were in
Tunisia, wel be Tunisian, when we're
in Congo, we'll be Congolese, when
were in Senegal, welll be Senegalese.”Interview:Mohamed El Kettani, CEO, Attijariwafa Bank
The strategy devised by Attijariwafa
Bank shows that our plan will
never be centred on Morocco. Our
objective isto be a leading bank in
each country.
In what way?
Aitijariwafa does not just want to
open a little bank. We want to be
‘one of the leaders, at the front of the
pack and have a coherent strategy
that supports the social and eco-
nomic development of the country
in which we're operating, Our vi
sion is structured around the idea
that each branch becomes the focus
of the other branches. The men and
‘women who work at the heart of our
institution are the best equipped to
understand the potential synergies
that could be developed with other
For example, Senegal and Cote
Ivoire were keen to develop syner:
gies with Mali, Burkina Faso, Niger,
‘Togo or Benin..So, yes, we operate
using the principle of regional in-
tegration,
“This is because what counts in
cour strategies is to be highly active
in developing products and services
across all customer segments on a
national scale, serving households,
the middle classes, affluent, wealthy
people, SMEs and microbusinesses
as well as large company groupsand
governments. At the same time, we
Want to continue to consolidate intra-
‘African trade and co-investments
This turned into the idea that we had
rears ago of organising the Africa
Development Forum,
How is your strategy being rolled out
is the rest ofthe continent?
Before initiating our African strategy,
we took a scientific look at it. The
first thing we did was study the po-
tential of each country. In each case,
‘weasked ourselves: Can we genuinely
bring added value to the country’s
banking systemt Ts the country stable
‘enough for us to beable to implement
our development model?
‘Once this was complete, we car
ried out some research. As [stid, our
“Attijariwafa
does not just
want to open
alittle bank.
We want to
be one of the
leaders, at the
front of the
pack’
objective is to have some ‘targets?
which occupy a relatively comtort
able position in their natural market
This meant spotting banks to buy, as,
there are always opportunities for
the transfer of banking assets in the
African market. [fnot, we would
rather grow a bank from the ground
up. If we purchase a bank, we im
plement a two-year transformation
project to bring the purchased bank
Up (o the standards of the Group.
We are very demanding on this
point in terms of governance, over
hauling processes and procedures
and changing information systems.
‘We have a global information
system that we implement in all our
branches. By sharing information, we
are able to publish our consolidated
‘accounts. This information system
allows us to control all ofour banks?
accounting.
We pursue a policy which relies
‘on human capital, with professional
development occurring through four
academies, the first in Casablanca,
the second in Tunisia, where access to
banking has already been developed
‘ona par with Morocco and where
we have a large workforce. For West
Africa, we have an academy in Da.
kar and in May 2014, we founded
the fourth academy in Douala to en.
‘courage professional development in
Central Africa,
The first phase of our continental
‘expansion isto establish in all Fran-
‘cophone African countries, We have
yet to expand into Algeria, Chad and
the Central African Republic. There
are eight countries in West Africa
and six in Central Africa, That makes
19 countries including those in the
Maghreb, We have a representative
ollice in Libya. We are waiting until
the situation in this country stabi:
lises. We are now starting a second
stage of expansion beyond Franco.
phone borders.
Approaching this other part of the
‘continent will required a ‘cultural
revolution’.
Yes, acultural and mental revolution,
Our creed is Give mea woman or a
rman and will give you a project’ Itis
the teams who carry out the projects
Without them, we would never be
able to focus on development.
In order to start this second part
of our roadmap, we had to focus on
‘our workforce in order to enter new
‘countries whose cultures are different
from those in Francophone Africa.
‘What makes our model special is
that we have trust in the skills of the
local workforce. Out af 5700 people
working in our African branches, in
13 countries, there are only 23 Mo-
roceans. Moreover, the latter will
‘gradually make way for local skills,
This expansion will require
significant capital. Where wil this
‘come from?
Equity and resources are rare. You
have to apportion them with great
care and protect them. ‘This is our
‘group strategy. We have a policy of
allocating resources and equity coun-
try by country and asset by asset. InMorocco, we are fortunate that our
regulator, the Central Bank, adopted
the Basel I requirements, then Basel
Mand will shortly be adopting Basel
Is the Moroccan banking sector
complies with the strictest interna
tional requirements and this is why
the bank's growth is based on such
strong foundations
The firs stage, the 13 countries in
which we ae investing, was entirely
self financed thanks to generated
cash flow. We only had to carry out
‘one capital increase of abn dirhams
(204m), restricted to group employ
ces, Employees thus became share-
holders of 8 ofthe hank’s capital. It
is one of the highest levels in Africa
‘out ofall the companies listed on the
stock exchange
‘We are listed on the Casablanca
stock exchange and Atiijariwata
shares are very popular with in
vestors. Ifwe carry out large-seale
projects, we can turn tothe financial
market to raise capital
itehelSapin (i
Dresents Mohamed
Eixettan' of
‘Atjarivata Bank
suit the Legion
‘tHonnesr.
Senegal, Céte d'Ivoire, Gabon and
others have plans regarding the
emergence of their countries. Are
‘you involved in these major projects?
In West Africa today, Attijariwafa
Bank is by far the leading banking
provider in CFA francs. When you
are that size, it is vital that you are
involved in financing projects aimed
at developing the countries in this
region
So you're transforming savings into
investments.
rst ofall, we are the leading facilta
tor of treasury bonds. We have a posi-
tions leader in facilitating finance
for the governments of this region.
Beyond financing economic opera.
tors and households, we finance gov-
ernment projects, specifically within
the framework of PPP concessions or
finance projects. This is why we are
involved in financing power plantsin
Senegal, Cote d'Ivoire and Mali, We
are helping to finance airport expan
sionslike the one at Bamako. We are
currently appointed by Céte d’ivoi
toadvise on and secure finance for a
1gookm networkof motorways. We
are actively involved in supporting
the development of these countries,
You operate in banking, insurance,
consumer credit and business bank-
ing. Does this not result in a lack of
{focus and cohesion?
There is no lack of focus from the
customer's point of view. Beyond
financing their cash needs and in-
vestment projects, a customer of-
ten needs advice. In order to retain
each customer and create a lasting
relationship, an integrated banking
group needs to offer a whole range
af services. There's no lack of focus
Quite the opposite. We are de-
veloping the cohesion between our
divisions and synergies follow on
from this; it’s this way of building
an integrated banking and finance
group that has been shown to be suc-
cessful in Morocco and that we are
in the process of implementing in the
countries in which we are operating.
It seems that the forum you are
organising is becoming very inluen-
tial aswell as building acculture that
crosses banking, finance and even
We first had this idea about the
Africa Development Forum five years
ago. It was inspired by a discussion
with King Mohamed VI. He has re-
peatedly challenged the Moroccan
private sector, calling upon it to get
involved in Africa. His principles
have been shaped by a belief in South-
South cooperation. He has come back
to the issue several times, Based on
these political messages regarding the
Moroccan private sector, we seized
the opportunity to launch ou inter
national strategies. A private group
like ours needed to set an example
We told ourselves that we had a role
to play and set out to conquer the
African market. We then asked our
selves how to strengthen South-South
cooperation.
‘We looked at the issue from all
angles andlistened to our customers.
They said:' We have issues with con.
nectivity and air transport; we don't
know what’s happening where you
are in Morocco. We said to ourselves:
“Here's an opportunity to ereate a
platform where, over two days, peo-
ple can come together in a specific
location, somewhere we can organise
discussion between economic and
political players to manage South-
South integration ina practical way
This is why we created the Africa
Development Forum,
When you look at the banking map
of Morocco, there is wide range of
competitors. Do they overlap at all
or does each player stay within their
own domain?
Isincerely weleome the development
work that our colleagues, the BMCE
Group and the BCP Group ete., are
doing in Africa. We have great re-
spect for each other. However, when
i comes to business, the gloves are
off. I can assure you that each one
defends their interest... in the best
interest of all African stakeholders
Competition is alive and wel.CCS MOUs a ee Cn EEpubic investments were not the [Highly-Indebted Poor Countires] _ price inthe $70 range.
only growth drivers and that the initiative, who benefited from that __Rotich is also optimistic about
‘growth was broad, with areas such relief, [But] for Kenya we were not developments since the adoption
as financial serviees and construction beneficiaries of debt relief. We've been of Kenya's new constitution, which
contributing too. Despite a dip in paying our debtsand we'vemanaged devolved a lot of power to local
tourism, which in 2013 contributed debt so we know what space and governments, a move that has
12% to GDP, growth prospects in 2015, capacities we have” caused some friction. In the port of
are also expected to be high, possibly Mombasa, forexample, there istalk of
reaching 6% or more depending on International markets anew shipping levy tobe introduced
the effects ofthe fallin oil prices. Rotich thinks that Kenya going toby local government, a policy which
Rotich hints that the government international markets was positive has come under some criticism.
might come back to market. Despite for Africa more broadly too inthat it __Rotich, however, is sees such
fearsatthe end of 208 and early 2014 familiarised international investors disagreements as part of the learning
that the end of Quantitative Easing with African risk and will make curve, “For the three years that we
in the US would lead to investors them more comfortable in the future. have managed devolution we are on
moving back to US treasuries, “International investors} now have the whole comfortable with the pace
European Quantitative Easing as abetter understanding of Africa “There will be challenges which we are
‘ell as investors exiting Russia meant and I think this gave an opportunity addressing, particularly in financial
that there was still healthy appetite for them to actually diversify their _management. We are building the
for African sovereign debt last year. portfolios, capacity of the counties to earn how
‘This meant that when Kenya went “We will continue to be active in to improve their fiseal management
to market they managed to do at so the market. We evaluate our needs, “With regards the issues of
at competitive rates: when it tapped and as we also have a really vibrant taxation I think the constitution
the market for the further $7som, domestic financial market, we'll be and the laws are clear who should
for example, it did so at a highly balancing our borrowing looking tax what. We are working on a
competitive 575%. both domestically and externally. framework of improving the business
“Looking again at what is We will also be looking at Diaspora environment. Itneeds to be designed
‘happening on the global economy, bonds. We are looking at a range of to enstre that you don't chase away
‘what I see is another year at least products. We need visibility outside investors in your county. We are
of sustained low interest rates, so and it will encourage our corporates working with them to build their
‘our medium term outlook has not in Kenya to access the international capacity to understand how they
changed and, from that perspective, capital markets and invest, so we need to manage the resources that
we see ourselves continuing to are looking at it not just for raising are available, both for what they can
participate in the international proceeds for infrastructure ut other raise on their own and what they get
‘capital market and see how we can benchmark bonds for our corporate trom the central council office, We are
benefit from the conditions that there —\_ sector in Kenya and also visibility also going to come up with a model
are now,” says Rotich. In response outside” Rotich is confident with the of fiscal legislation that governs what
to those who worry that African -—===—Ssmanagement of African economies you should tax and what you should
sovereigns are piling up toomuch despite some numbers from theIMF not tax.” On the theme of taxes, the
debt through such strategies, Rotich pointing to high debt; average debt government has also been criticised
insists: “Iwould understand the ===) —_to GDP is 35%, a 1o-year high. But _forarecently introduced capital gains
criticism] froma point of view of -—-—=»—=——_—Rotich believes this money is being tax But Rotich maintains that Kenya's
countries which are having debis === put togooduse suchasinfrastructure capital gains tax of just 5% is one of
constrained, especially countries. _—=»—=——_—tohelpexpand productive capability the most competitive in the world,
thatare coming out fromthe HIPC and open up economies. although he admits that there needs
Regarding oil, Kenya is a net tobe more clarity around the details
importer, at there are big exploration ofits application. Rotich is confident
projects under way. Rotich says that this tax will not dampen activity in
thefall in the price of oil was positive the capital markets. In April, Kenya
for the country and for its balance an MoU with the Qatar Financial
of payments. At the same time, he is Centre to create a financial hub for
not worried that the fallin oil prices the region, and for Rotich, thisis just
will reduce investments in the the start of much more activity, for
oil sector and says that companies Kenya, East Africa, and the continent
Which are exploringhada breakeven as a whole. CNAwards: 2" Africa Urban Infrastructure Forum and African Mayor Awards
The continent's most transformative mayors and policymakers
gathered in Angola to discuss the importance of moving Africa's
urban development in the right direction.
Shining a spotlight
on Africa’s cities
articipants and panellists
from over 20 nations
gathered at the 2"! Africa
Urban Infrastructure and
Investment Forum held in Luanda,
‘Angola, in Apri
“The consensils was that successful
urban development in Africa needs
planning and requires sound vision
and strong political will. Throughout
the two days of discussions, a number
of recurrent themes came up, not least
the need to engage the private sector
tohelp develop Africa cities. Private
public partnerships at all levels are
needed, it was agreed, including in
both central and local government
Planningalso needs to focus on social
inclusion as well asan understanding
of African culture. Otherwise, what
could appear a master plan on paper
‘may become an expansive shum down
theline,
‘Opening the Forum, Angola's
Vice President Manuel Domingos
Vicente said that 75% of Angola's
population now lives in urban areas.
Ina keynote address, Pedro Pires,
former President of Cape Verde,
reiterated the need to address the
causes of urban migration.
Jean-Pierre Elong Mbassi,
Secretary-General of UCLG-A, the
global network of cities, local and
regional governments, stressed the
urgent need for urban infrastructure
investment plans, with an emphasis
oon financing,
Aisa Kacyira, UN Assistant
Secretary-General and Deputy
Executive Director for UN-Habitat,
commented that the Forum was
Cimento)
eon)
‘cera = Ghana $200,000
Shortlisted: Cup Tov, South Africa and Da
(emo)
Tanzania $100,000
‘Shortlisted: Ana, ha
Kinondoni
id Ric, Gl
Snr)
Praia ~ Cape Verde $50,000
essential in moving Africa towards to
the development and empowerment
oflocal economies.
Forum organiser and publisher
of African Business magazine, Omar
Ben Yedder, commented, “Many
important issues were raised and
there were many take-homes for
participants. We need to look fr local
solutions to local problems.
“For example, as one of the
speakers clearly put it, how can we
discuss affordable housing when
70% of the inputs for these houses
ar Senegal
nd, and Bagong, Cameroon
‘Above: Celebrating
the winners of the
large dey award,
Accra, whose
‘mayor Is Alfred
‘ke Vanderoulle
(Genrded, centre.
are imported. Too often, we are
importing solutions which do not
take into consideration our needs
nor the organisational structure of
‘our cities”
Key areas which were discussed
included the critical isue of financing
as well as the conditions needed to
‘mobilise the private sector and create
the right incentives for investors
Quick decision making, stability in
terms of the political and regulatory
‘environment were all cited as basic
requirements from an external
investor's perspective. Clarifying
property rights was identified as an
important issue which needed to be
addressed urgently,
{In conjunetion with the Forun
‘African Business magazine presented
the first ever‘José Eduardo dos Santos
African Mayor Awards’. These
awards acknowledge the leadership
and contribution made by mayors of
large, medium and small cities and
celebrate achievements and excellence
in urban development in Africa
“The winners will receive prize
money totalling $350,000 for specific
initiatives (see box, let, for details)
Speaking at the ceremony, Ben
Yedder said, “The winners tonight
are being led by individuals who are
showing essential leadership qualities
as they help build cities that work
‘And we will need more exemplary
leadership, good governance and
innovative thinking whilst paying
close attention to our culture and way
of living when dreaming the cities
of tomorrow. Our leaders need to be
lose to the people, and our winners
are demonstrating these qualities.”
‘The winners were selected
‘unanimously by the judging panel of
Jean-Pierre Elong Mbassi, UCLG-A;
‘Tokunbo Omisore, President of
the Africa Union of Architects;
Aisa Kirabo Kacyira, Assistant
Seeretary-General and Deputy
Executive Director for UN-Habitat;
‘Victor Leonel Miguel, Chairman
of the Angolan Architects Union;
and Gaetan Siew, Chair of the
Construction Industry Sector of
Mauritius.By funding the Thika Project, we're helpii
a community.The Loukil Group introduce
its UADH automobile pole
on to the stock exchange
aS
—-~U A DH
UNIVERSAL AUTO DISTRIBUTORS HOLDING
With the AMS and Gif Filter, already on the stock exchange, the Loukil Group is to
introduce a third asset, the UADH (Universal Auto Distributors Holding) which is the
holding company of its automobile affiliates. It has obtained the consent of the
board of directors of the Stock Exchange for admission to the Main Market of the
Stock Exchange for the 30 800 000 shares which constitute the current capital of the
UADH company, as well as the 6 153 847 new shares to be issued within the
framework of the increase in capital, ie a total of 36 953 847 shares with a 1 Dinar
par value each. The overall offer covers 12 307 694 shares, representing 33.31% of
the share capital after the increase.
The introducing broker is Attijari Intermediation and the evaluation was done by
Attijari Finances Tunisie. UADH will be the first new stock to be introduced on the
stock exchange since the beginning of the year.
Emanating from the Loukil Group, the UADH, created in 2013 within the framework
of a legal restructuring, is part of the group's new strategic vision whereby the diffe-
rent activities are being organized on the basis of the different business linesThe UADH automobile pole has been prioritized and is expected to develop sustaina-
bly and has 8 branches either directly or indirectly which represent 4 brand names,
ASS
CITROEN osauromosics mazDa
+ Citroen and DS: AURES Auto and AURES Gros.
+ Mazda : ECONOMIC Auto and MAZDA Details.
+ Renault Trucks and TCM : LVI and TRUCKS Gros.
+ GIF Filter: GIF Filter and GIF Distribution.
"UADH is the
1* integrated
automobile
operator in
Tunisia"
«First integrated automobile operator in Tunisia, UADH, declared Bassem Loukil the
CEO, under its great pole has five leading international and most prestigious brand
names in the automobile, industrial vehicles and filters sector. The group's synergy
enhances the performance of each brand as well as the good image it acquired and
provides overall support at all levels for each branch. Gaining the confidence of
great international brand names, by complying with the required standards, being
successful in the filter industry and earning the support of its clientele is for UADH a
challenge which is taken up daily. We have our skilled teams who work on the basis
of the values of excellence for which our group is renowned».
wore adh.tr
FluadnDevelopment: AMI
Africa is under-represented in the new AlIB, but that doesn't
necessarily mean it will be neglected.
Will the Asian Infrastructure
Investment Bank take attention
away from Africa?
Viet states such as Kazakhstan
and Kyrgyzstan, the Asian In-
frastructure Investment Bank (AIIB)
has attracted diverse members. But
among the 57 founding members an-
nounced in April, only two are from
Africa. With just South Africa and
Egypt being named as members of,
what's been touted as China’ rival to
the World Bank, there are fears that
‘Africa could be overlooked in China’s
latest push for multilateral influence.
“I think African governments
and the private sector should be
raising the flag and saying “how nice
that Asiais getting this, but how will
wwe benefit?” says Professor Stephany
Griffith-Jones, Financial Markets
Program Director at Columbia
University’s Initiative for Policy
Dialogue. “Africa needs to say “don't
forget about us, because we have
the biggest needs and also a lot of,
pportunities.”
The AILB will have initial capital
of $sobn and authorised capital of
sioobn. The Asian Development
Bank estimates thatthe region needs
to plug an $8 trillion infrastructure
gap from 2010 to 2020, Meanwhile,
the World Bank estimates that Africa
has similarly towering needs of $93
billion annually until 2020.
With such fierce competition for
funds, a solely Asia-focused bank
right be expected to divert attention
away from Africa’ infrastructure
concerns and the existing institutions
that serve them, However, Hongying
Wang, senior fellow at the Centre
for International Governance
Innovation (CIGD), says that the
founding of the AIIB is more likely
tobea spur for greater infrastructure
investment among rival banks than
a source of competition.
“Ina way I don't think it's a zero
sum game, that ifit is going to the
IIB, it’s not going to other banks,
she says. “It's very possible that these
banks, if structured and governed
well, will attract money that may not
have gone to infrastructure at all”
Wang says that despite an initial
focus on Asia, China is likely to
expand the bank's remit a move
that could benefit Africa.
“I think it’s been clear from
the beginning that the Chinese
government really want to make
this as multilateral and multi-
continental as possible. In the long
run, this could be China's effort to
have a kind of global reach, I don't
see this as anything that would come
atthe expense of China's relationship
with Africa.”
That is certainly the hope of
African Development Bank president
Donald Kaberuka, who told Reuters
that he hoped the bank would
take a “broader view of funding
infrastructure in Africa” and would
expand its mandate to other parts
of the world
After global rush to membership
that took both Beijing and its
rivals by surprise earlier this year,
Kaberucka was joined by World Bank
president Jim Yong Kim in offering
a cautious hand of friendship to the
new institution. Kim pledged to work
with the AIIB to improve governance
and environmental standards ~ a
pointed reference to US criticisms
that the bank will lack the safeguards
‘of Bretton Woods institutions.
‘As well as altering China's
relationship with the existing
Western-backed development
institutions, it remains to be seen
how the AIIB will work alongside
Chinese-backed institutions such
as the New Development Bank ~
commonly known as the BRICS
Bank - an institution which features
a prominent role for South Africa
‘As well as matching the initial
‘iobn investment of the other four
‘members, South Africa will host the
New Development Bank’s African
regional centre.
“I think all the enthusiasm and.
focusison the AIIB, but think they
will run in parallel,” says Griffith-
Jones, “Because it’s in the long-term
“Idon't
see this as
anything that
‘would come
atthe expense
‘of China’s
relationship
with Africa”
Right Africa under
She Al may
Invrastructure
Investment.interests of China, Brazil and Indi, I
‘would have thought that they would
find a mechanism either through the
learly the BRICS bank
jor Africa, But
abit ofa delay in terms
AILBor mo
0 leverage fundin
of policymakers’ attention.
CIGI's Wang
two institutions could work hand
in-hand too, with the AITB focusing
on China’s Silk Road ambitions in
Asia and the New Development Bank
working primarily in the Global
South,
Given its role in both institutions
and the absence of fellow sub-
Saharan African nations, South
Africa may be expected by some to
assume the mantle of ‘voice of the
believes that the
Mamphela Ramphele, a forme
managing director of the World
Bank, thinks that the country would
be better off re-evaluating its own.
motivations for joining, and says that
African counties need to re-think
their role in international forums
whether Western- backed or Chinese
“South Africa has done the right
thing I guess by joining, but did they
ask themselves what is it we want to
get out of this programme? Because
il seems to me well, China is setting
ap this, we want to be friends with
China therefore we join. If that’s the
reason then we're in trouble. But if
they've gotten into the ATIB with a
strategic approach to development
that this bank will add to, then we
have a different ball game’
For Ramphele, regardless of
China’ intentions, Africa will need
to engage with the AILB with far
more strategic purpose than it has
with development instituti
date~ starting with sending the most
to
competent people asthe continent's
representatives, “We need to sit down
and decide for ourselves what itis
we'd like to accomplish by being
part of international development
sid finance or the IMF or whatever
entity ~ right now we are only there
because those institutions are there,
she says.Sponsored Profile
Verifone is a leading brand in electronic point-of-sale terminal technologies
and has the African markets firmly in its sights in order to further deepen its
global reach. Talking with Ozgiir Ozvardar, general manager of
Middle East and North Africa (MENA) for Verifone, Stephen Williams.
learned more about Verifone’s objectives in the region.
Bringing payment
technologies to Africa
hile Africa fs still
very much a cash
based economy,
that is changing, and
changing fast with the increasing
use of debit cards as a safe
alternative to paper money. But
{as noted by Ozgir Ozvardar
Verifone's general manager for the
MENA region (which also neludes
territeries in South Attica), many
ATM transactions in Africa are
made by cardholders to withdraw
ther salaries
Nevertheless, he says, when
you consider the huge growth in
payment systems in Africa, these
are exciting times for the industry.
‘Consumers in Africa are eager
for new technologies that make
therr lives easier,” Ozvardar says,
“and they adapt easily to change
and new ways of doing business
That's why Verifone, as a global
leader in payment sen
technologies, offers our clients the
best solutions to fulfll their needs
‘Our prime focus is offering
multiple solutions to both banking
and non-banking customers,
Included among these offerings
are Our new voucher solutions,
as well as bill payment, tax
collection, government subsidies
programme solutions, and so
fon. I would say that our business
in Africa is comprised of 60%
banking and 40% non-banking
customers"
The statistic might come as
something of a surprise as one
might think that, as a supplier
of payment terminal solutions,
Verifone’s business growth within
Africa reflects growth in the
continent's retail sector.
But Ozvardar daes not
completely hold with that
analysis, “We are undertaking
many government projects, and
we are handing bill payments
and subsidy programm
Banks are offering our terminal
solutions not only to ther large
retailer customers, but also to
ther customers in the hospitality
industry as well as merchants
of all sizes in a variety of other
industries. So | believe that our
growth is reflective of other
sectors and not simply limited to
the retail spa
However, Africa already
has many sophisticated mobile
applications, and that raises the
‘question, “what does Verifone
bring to the continent that s truly
movative?”
Responding to this question,
Ozvardar explans, "We offer a
mobile money transfer service
that consumers can use with
their emart phones as well as
older devices, and we are also
working with Airtel, one of our
newest partners in Africa. This is
lust one example of the innovation
we bring to this region, which is
applicable to numerous market
segments. This is a fast-moving
market and we intend to stay
at the leading edge of the
imovations that are powering it”
Yet itis undoubtedly true that
mobile money has been around
for a number of years, bul Verifone
brings somethng to the ndusty n
ierms of a huge network
"Across the world we currently
have more than 27m installed
terminals,” Ozvarder ponnts out
‘Through our vast global footprint,
mobile phone companies and
application developers have the
abilty to efficiently penetrate
markets on a large scale.
“For example, i you develop
‘a mobile app and want itto be
accepted in Alrica or in any other
market for that matter, come to us
and we can make it happen. By
supporting the app with Verifone’s
terminals, the app can be
accepted and brought to market
very quickly. This makes it much
easier for mobile companies to
roll out a service, to go live and
foreach customers ina veryhort time.” With the Verifone
and recognised around the
world for its highly reliable, secure
and user-friendly solutions ~not
to mention its global footprint
ints - itis hardly
ing that the company h
en involved with the innovative
fagramme in Nigeria that issues
a MasterCard-branded electronic
card, which doubles as a ratio
Jentity card,
The national
n Nigeria s a pro}
losely involved with. Ma
is supplying the cards and we
are providing the technology. our
terminals incorporate biometric
readers that check fingerprint
je capture
rely decrypted
an Identity
Management Commission
Meanwhile, in Egypt, Veritone’s
sortable d
ored electronic paym
system. The system facil
the state-sp
Egypt's entre retall gasoline and
etroleum market to an el
ayment system
‘The development of an
electronic payment sy:
tended to help the country
regulat istibution and
onsumption of petroleum
‘oducts and reduce smuggling
‘smartcard-based system
ensures thal Egypt's Petroleum
and Finance Ministries can contol
value of gasoline
tems that
by Veritone
n governments
to collect income tax some are
beng rolled out m Nigeria for the
federal government
mote and more of
Atrica’s economies are being
digitised and automated, there is
a justifiable worry about payment
data breaches and oyberer
When African
Ozvardar what Ver
cer asked
ifone was dong
threats, he
fold the magazine: “As a global
leader of payment systems, our
ninals must comply with t
latest security standar
certified as doing so.
is in Vetilone’s DNA ar
absolute priority
‘And Ozvardar sees the
payment industry evolving over the
next five Fs to become
draws atiention to Apple's iPhone
6. and the Apple Pay app that, as
it begins to be used by more and
more consumers, will vansform
the industry
¥%
the future of payments sysiems
's decade will be the most
dynami¢ and important in the
history of payments, with the
convergence of electronic
payments, digtal comm
Credit slip analytics and
along with contextual n
digital advertising, coup.
‘al media," he aver
will see mere mobilly in
ing, and
Many 0
the benefits of shopping nine
reality in brick
ight future In fact,
his year, Veri
Unveiled a marke
nto sale) system
ung Galaxy Tab
Alive tablet with -rich screen
for comfortable viewing. It en:
lers to deliver value-add
argeted marketing
January
fone and Samsung
advertising
is new offering will also
support Verifone’s Secure
Commerce Architecture (SC
solution, which elimina
ter payment data
ted point of
of cone
the merchant's integr
2 (POS) system,
to the merchant ssor. By
decoupling payment data from
the IPOS, SCA eliminates the
potential for payment data to be
cal, further evidenc
‘mportance when it
comes to payments and sec
Stephen W
urilySponsored Profile
Dr Samura Kamara, Minister of Foreign Affairs and International
Cooperation for the Republic of Sierra Leone
Strengthening Africa’s Resourcefulness
and Creating Unity of Purpose
Yu
+ Samura Kamara i Siera
Leone's Miniter of Foreign
Allis & rcernaonal
Cooperation Hei also
a candidate forthe presidency
dafthe Aican Develeomert Sank
(ADB) He racertly decuszad
‘sion for bath Aiea and the Bank
vat Stephen Wiams
‘As a former Minster of
Finance, the Governor ofthe
Gentral Bank, and now in hie
current capacity as Foreign
Minister, Dr Kamara has played
‘major role inte revtalsation
of eth Sierra Leone's domestic
‘economy and ts commercial
relations withthe region, continent
‘and beyond. He led his country
bback Fem evil nar and through
the tecery Ebola crisis —bath
care challenges requiring
fengoged and sophisioaed
international eaorcination
“belive the Prien
‘demande eameane who not only
hat a deco understanding of
the compiextiae of finance and
‘e0oncmice, but algo wile a
ppowertl voices forthe needs af all
Aicans en the intemenional stage.”
DeKamara soid. "Through his
‘achievements, President Kaberuka
showed us how the AIDE'S veice
ean be used elect postive
cchanga, and | bevel vill Eng
‘imiar earsmitment of inalact,
passion and uly tothe job”
Dr SamuraKamara's passion
for development is clear from the
moment he begins to desenibe
hie career: “Since Ifinchec
Uuniverey, my ile has been epent
desing wth dvelopment
My thesis was on the monstary
Unification of Wet Attica We have
not succeeded yet, but I belive
that one way to puch forward
Atican developmertis through
monetary integration
Dr Kemarahae a weak of
experience in various government
postions, including as Central
Bank Governor, elemete exeoutve
deste for Aiea athe IMF and
Minister of Finanes andl Eecnamic
Developmert belare becoming his
country's Minister of Foreign Afi
and Intemational Caopertion,
Minister of Finance, he chaved
the Ainean Caueus constituency
‘meetings two yearsin a row and
(tided negotiations tha resulta
In nea geting athird char onthe
World Bank Execute Boord and a
Second Alternate Chairin the ME
Execute.
Thvoughout hs 26-yex career,
Dr Kamara has eolaberated and)
negatited with qlcbal leaders
to solve some of Sierra Leone's
and Africas biggest development
and recource mabaication
challenges and is among the most
experienced candidates to lead
‘he Afican Development Bank
When it camesta hie vision
forthe Bank, Dr Kamara believes
itmmust cortinue to focus an the
kay piles et forth in the “Ten Yaar
Strategy’ advanced by curent
ADB President Donald Kaberuks,
while decertralsing and bolstering
the institution’ leadership role on
the continent He recently wrote
There are four key areas
within [te Ten Year Stategy?
where I believe the Bank chouls
focus ita efforts: fighting inequalty,
sion and ingecurty,
deepening mnfastusture
evelopment and Atican
tegration: prometing private
‘sector development and economic
divereticaion and promoting
green growth and sustaining
iveihoode
Through decontalcaion,
the Banke able to work with te
ppariner to produce higher quality
projects with beter project d
‘and supervision that can b¢
implemented a much shorter
time fama. Decantalition
‘also brings about a number of
benefits for the ncividua regione
‘sit allows for greater capacty
bauileing and provides many mere
oppertunties infield ofioes*
‘Ae bath a former boars
member and client ofthe Bani
De Kamara has the unique
perepeative of both serung
the interests ofthe Banks
haldare and mobilising ite
resources for natione emerging
‘tom cont. This has given him
both unique grasp on the Ba
mechanisms and procedure,
and ae the key archtect of Sierra
Leone's historic and unearaieled
‘economic recovery - ara hand
Understanding of hw t can
help solve many ofthe problems
‘Ariean nations face today. He led
the develonmant of hie nation's
interim Poverty Recuction Strategy
(-PRSP), which helped Siera
Leone recover fram tha brink of
war eeonomic eatastraphe,
‘and subsequent iniaives
fecusing on tha "software" of post
‘conflict developers, intuding
basic education andheathoare
facilities, accountable economic
ard political governance, andthe
Greation of new social safety neta
Most recerty. Or Kamara
helped devise and complete
Sterta Leone’ latest post-war
recovery plan, the "Agenda
for Prospeniy in 2018. Inthis
rnstance Kemara focused on
the hardware" of economic
development, ntancfyng work
fon the construction of roads andl
energy facltes and creating
inoentive for foreign direct
svostmant in mining, fishing,
agribusiness and real setate
velopment, posing the way fo
the next decade af growth
Kamara views the biggest
chalenge to atvacting invars
invootment to be balancing fi
baley incentives withthe need to
(generate reverues rom taxation
Simicaly, Kamara thinks that
forthe AIDBto address emerging
challengesin Afiea, addtional
revources must be mobliged within
and outside the continent. He also
cautions that abalance neede
tobe found: "Tobe effective, the
AIDE needs to mantain a cuture
hy iplned and reepects the
ict rak-managoment peace
required ofa mar financial
“Yel, atthe came time we
needio create a dynamio, open
environment that gves the ADB's
stall the freedom to innovate
adopt and develop new ideas t0
addeess chronic and emerang
challenges in Aca
In thi regard, Kamara
belive thatthe ADB precidont
make a dilerenee through
uty among the Bank's vanous
constituencies and developing
culture within the Bank thet both
applies financial est pr
and encourages new and creative
“Ihave seen the Bank's ability
tomake a profound difarencein
the ives of people in Siera Leone
and aoraee the continent. Believe
& must cortinue toplay a cartal
olen advancing the commen
objectives ofthe African people.”up Africa’
infrastructure
The au's
Ling Ae seca
ike a pipe dream today, but
the building ofa ral ink from Kenya's
port of Mombasa to the apital Nairobi,
EEOMEBETEY, Is under way, and grand visions for the
Wwatertoler. future arein rich supply.Markets: Infrastructure
Across the continent, African
governmentsareattempting to rewrite
their geography with ambitious
infrastructure projects in road, rail,
ports, power, telecommunications
and water ~ initiatives intended to
underpin rapid growth, transform
regional and national economies, and
‘open up new investment prospects.
‘One ofthese visions is the Africa
Express Rail, which was outlined
in an Agenda 2063 “email from the
future” presented by Nkosazana
Dlamini Zuma, Chairof the African
Union (AU) Commission, in January
2014. “The African Express Rail now
connectsall the capitals ofour former
states,” read the fictitious future
email. “It is not only a high-speed
train, with adjacent highways, but
also contains pipelines for gas, oil
and water, as well as ICT broadband
cables.”
Four months late, a similarly lofty
ambition was promoted at the AU
headquarters by China's Premier Li
Keqiang, a man Chinese media have
dubbed the “high-speed rail super-
salesman”. Backed by an extra siabn
in funding, this Chinese-supported
vision of broad infrastructural
construction followed s20bn in loans
promised by President Xi Jinping in
March 2013,
Indeed, China could be a crucial
partner in Africa's ambitions. China
built its own 12,000 kilometre high-
speed rail network in
and, as with the Chin:
Nairobi-Mombasa railway, Chinese
companies are secking to engage in
similar projects around the world,
including in Angola, Ethiopia,
Nigeria, Kenya and Zimbabwe.
‘The AU’s Programme for
Infrastructure Development in
Africa (PIDA) meanwhile has alist
of s priority infrastructure projects
needed by 2040. Altogether, the
proposals would cost over s360bn,
with s68bn to be spent by 2020,
covering sectors from energy,
transport and water to ICT.
‘The World Bank estimates that
improving infrastructure could boost
economic growth across Africa by
‘yus president
Power africa
{nltiative which
bangs $zbn of
commitments by
2% each year, while PIDA estimates
an African regional transport
integration network could bring
si7abn of efficiency gains while
boosting trade hetween African
countries. Transport costs for Asian
firms are estimated to be 70% less
than their African counterparts,
while the costs of expensive and often
interrupted power make it harder for
African businesses to compete with
‘more efficient pasts of the world.
Finding funding
Finding funding fo big infrastructure
deals can be tricky, but there are
various potential sources of financing,
depending on the political, regulatory
and economic landscapes. Overall
though, domestic financing (usually
governments) typically pays for up to
50% of the projects, share expected
to rise as tax collection increases.
Multilaterals such as the World
Bank and the African Development
Bank (AfDB) also play a key role
among a plethora of multi-partner
nitiatives. The AU invested s1.sbn
in infrastructure projects in 2013,
while its Africaso fund aims to
raise siobn in equity funding. The
G8 countries, South Africa, the
European Commission and regional
development banks have also joined
the multilateras inthe Infrastructure
Consortium for Africa (ICA), which
recently published its 2013 annual
report, putting infrastructure
financing commitments at $25 3bn.
‘This includes US President Barack
Obama's Power Africa initiative,
which brings s7bn of commitments
from US government agencies. China,
India, European countries and the
Arab co-ordination group of funds
and institutions contributed ssabn of
funding commitments in 2013,
‘Africa's infrastructure projects
receive significant private sector
funding too, which totalled s8.6bn in
2013 according to the ICA, pushed up
by programmes such as South Africa's
Renewable Energy Independent
Power Producer Programme and
large Nigerian ports, ParticipantsLeft: Laying infrastructure - Workers
assemble pipelines near Abidjan.
include investment banks and
specialised institutions. Forinstance,
‘Qala Holdings says it has invested
sz4am in refurbishing the Rift Valley
Railways in Kenya. Actis, meanwhile,
is a leader in power investments,
having brought Ugandan power firm
Umeme to the securities exchange
in 2012, while its Globeleq power
company operates over ,000MW
‘of power facilities in five countries.
Several governments and parastatals
have also issued infrastructure bonds.
Kenya, for example, has raised over
stbn in bonds for roads, energy and
irrigation, and the Kenya Electricity
Generating Company has announced
plans to raise $5.bn through a mix
‘of debt and equity. South African
National Roads Agency (Sanral)
and power utility Eskom are also
well known in bond markets, and
other parastatals, such as Namibia's
Nampower, ate following their lead
Roads to trouble
Africa's infrastructure projects
have several funding routes, but
there are also many challenges.
According to ICA's latest annual
report, disbursements in 2013 were
sut.gbn, down 11% on the previous
year. According to the group, “ICA
members identified the enabling
envionment as the biggest challenge
in project preparation, including
ensuring the right attitudes, policies
and practices with stakeholders.”
‘Other key bottlenecks are the high-
risk early development stage and
project preparation,
‘Mark Ford, managing director
of consultancy Cross-border
Stages of an
infrastructure project
‘Usually the test step In an infrastructure project comes
when government planners recognise the need fr future
Infrastructural needs. The government then decides whether to
build and finance the proect itself or bring in private partners
for any oral of designing, financing bllding and operation.
Different stages of the project have diferent risk profiles and
attract diferent kinds of private investors. The construction
‘hase, for example, is typically higher risk and may be
Appropriate for an investment bank, although global tightening
‘nbanks’ capital and other controls ae causing some to pull
‘back, with specialist funds and financiers stepping into fill
the gap.
Well-structured infrastructure projects can offer along and
planned ifetime, steady and distributable cash flows, inflation-
adjusted rtumn or rising coupons and dividends, and fortunes
lncorrlatedto those of world equity markets.
Different investors have different ideas ofthe isk and
‘duration they want for thelr Investments Private Investors such
as rich individuals usually want thelr money back in ive to seven
years while earning high returns similar to those on private
‘equity. Development finance institutions tend to want to ext
theirinvestments in 10-15 years, while governments, pension
and insurance funds canbe the most pation, walting 20:30
Years forrturns.
When the same project sponsor builds and runs the whole
project, they are ncontvised to construct in away that
‘minimises later running costs. Typically, aftr a predefined
contract period, such as 30 yeas, project ownership and
‘operation couldrevert to government.
‘ne key eriterion for success is that investors trust thatthe
project's parameters, contracts and user fee agreements wil not
‘change during the feof the contract. Governments sometimes
‘offer to mitigate the risks, for Instance guaranteeing revenues
{usage is lower than forecast. Governments attempt to create
investor riendly structures, ineluding agreeing contracts under
International jurisdictions and offering regulation to ensure al
partis stick to the original contract terms. The World Bank's
‘Muttilateral Investment Guarantee Agency (MIGA) can help,
can the presence of the Arican Development Bank.
However when a projects too investor-friendly and costs the
sponsoring government inflated sums or allows user fees trrise
"apaly with te improvement Inservice, taxpayers and users
‘may protest. This eat Toad to lost revenues of a contract belng
deemed irregular and canceled.
Cross-border projects are usually significantly more
complicated than those within a single country.
IOAN BANKER 2ND QUARTER 2015 $3
Information which works with
ICA, says: “It seems that the public
and private sectors share similar
frustrations when it comes to project
preparation, a process which may eat
Lup 715% of total project costs”
Other frustrations are
more political and regard how
infrastructure ought to be delivered
and sustained. Safe and affordable
water, for example, is recognised
as a national and international
human right but the poorest are
often in remote areas and the
most expensive to reach. Poor
governance in many countries may
also interrupt privatisation and the
cultivation of partnerships with other
organisations
‘Challenges can further arise over
public private partnershipsand how
projects should be paid for. One issue
is that populations do not always
agree with paying to use services
they think should be covered by their
taxes. For example, South Africa's
Johannesburg-Pretoria and other toll
roads were held up by protests for
‘months before going livin December
208
"Amidst these opportunities and
challenges, it seems that ensuring
‘Africa gets the infrastructure it needs
largely depends on effective project
planning, management, and stable
politics. Learning from experience,
keeping project structures simple and
government policies standardised
can help speed up the roll out, as can
keeping costs down.
If Africa can get this right, the
‘underpinnings for continued growth,
trade and connectivity may be closer
than they seem.
Tom MinneyMarkets: Insurance
Takaful operators are eyeing the continent with great
hope, but there are challenges along the way
The rise of Islamic
insurance
lowly but surely, Islamic in-
surance ~ known as takaful
= has been growing across
Africa in recent years. Based
con centuries-old systems of coopera
tively paying into a fund that is then
paid out in ease of emergency, takaful
companies are gradually expanding
around the continent. North Africa
tends to lead the market, though
“ther countries and regions are fol-
lowing in its wake.
‘The rise of takaful in Africa
follows a rise in Islamic insurance
globally. As a report compiled by
Ernst & Young reveals: “With the
continued buoyancy in the estimated
s2 trillion global Islamic finance
markets the global takaful market is
estimated to continue its double-digit
growth momentum of about 14%
in 2014. By 2017, the global takaful
industry may reach over s20bn”
‘African insurance companies
have understandably been keen to
get a piece of this action.
“We sce almost a new takaful
operator being established in Africa
each month and are monitoring the
situation closely in Morocco, Tunisia,
Kenya, Nigeria and South Africa,”
says Mahomed Akoob, Managing
Director of Hannover Retakaftl, a
subsidiary of the German reinsurer,
Hannover RE
“In respect of takaful, we have
seen a gradual increase in the gross
contribution income in Africa since
22009 to date Sudan leads the African
region with a gross contribution
Income of $363,4m in 2010 followed
by Egypt with gross contribution
income of $58.9m in the same year.
However other countries such as
Kenya, Nigeria and Tunisia have also
entered the takaful industry.”
‘Akoob suggests that the likes
of Nigeria, South Africa, Kenya,
Ethiopia, Egypt and Algeria hold
‘out the most promise given the siz
of their economies
However, for all the opportunity
and potential, the takaful industry in
‘Africa is Faced with many challenges
going forwards. On the regulatory
iront, the absence of frameworks
and inconsistency of regulation isa
major issue.
‘Additionally, new solvency
requirements for insurance firms
under the Basel III Concordat and its
attendant increased capital adequacy
ratios could impact the industry.
Many african markets may also
be affected by commodity price
volatility and political uncertainty
‘And the nascent takaful industry is
additionally faced with a shortage of
Shariah-compliant investment asset
classes, a relative ack of innovation
and a current shortage of expertise.
‘Akoob also warns that it may
take some time for larger groups of
people in Airica to learn about and
turn to Islamic insurance. “Is [the
takaful industry in Africal growing?
Yes, but don't expect Muslims (or
those interested in ethical finance) to
come running once takaful operators
start offering Shariah-compliant
solutions,” he warns. “Awareness
must be created and benefits of
these solutions must be explained
progressively.”
An unsure future
Despite various challenges, many
expect the takafal sector to continue
to grow significantly in Africa over
the next decade.
Part of this, however, may rest
con how governments and regulators
position themselves in order to
encourage further development of
this sector,
‘Akoob believes that to help
foster the growth of takaful in their
countries, governments will have to,
amongst other things, streamline
authorisation processes in order to
attract new market entrants
Governments may also need
to work closely with the insurance
industry to ensure consumers are
able to access insurance products
easily and have suicient information
to make the right choices to match
their needs.
Ultimately, Akoob insists thatthe
contribution of Islamic insurance
to the development of investment,
economic growth, personal insurance
and the pension fund industry in
Alrica should not be understated.
“Lwould say that takaful would
supplement the system of social
protection.
“The industry would contribute
to the modernisation of financial
markets in Africa and facilitate
firms’ access to capital. Insura
‘would also raise stable consumption
throughout the consumers life. And
‘more importantly, the insurance/
takaful industry will create jobs in
Africa.”
Mushtak Parker
“Twould say
that takaful
would
supplement
thesystem
of social
protection”
y /
Richt: Kenran
herders examine
ash vouchers from
Fakatul insurance
trie, a
Fecelving th
payouts from
Fistrance scheme.Rather than compete at
home, some East African
insurance companies are
looking to new frontiers,
East Africa’s
insurers look
south
Experiencing rapid risen take-up of
insurance, optimism in Kenya's insurance
sectors riding hig. In 2013, Kenyan
insurers reportedly recorded a 20%
increase in gross written premiums to reach
$1.1bn, and progress since then s beloved
to have been just as strong.
Howover. these Impressive results
conceal anundereutrent of movement as
the sector reposition itself for greater
competition, Some insurers seeking out
funds for expansion and there have been
numerous mergers and acquisitions. But
‘Some lesser known insuranee companies
have opted to look instead to frontier
markets in southern Aiea. Kenya's Real
Insurance and Mayfair Insurance set
upoicesin Mozambique and Zambia
respectively in 2010, while Phoenix
Assurance has entered Zambia, Botswana,
Mozambique and Namibia, wth plans for
‘Swasilnd in the pipaine
"East African companies have always
focused in thelr nelghbourhood, few
have gone beyond Rwanda,” says Group
Managing Director at Phoenix Assurance
Group (Africa), Suresh Kumar. "in the
southern Africa region, the business culture
is very iferent, Each country has its own
pecullarties but the insurance bnowledge
[high espectalyn Botswana, Namibiaand
Mozambique. And the kind of activity is
unbelievable.” Mozambique for instance, Is
said tobe on the cusp of an infrastructural
boom, which Kumar beleves wil position
Mozambique a the sta of Phooniss
southern Africa operations. Meanie,
the insurance companys decision to
enter southern Affican i also informed by
Impressive oll and gas discoveries inthe
region. As one of the frst East African
companies to enter the kes of Botswana,
Namibia and Swaziland, Phoonlx hopes
tocaptaleeon rst mover advantages
Phoenix is much smaller than the
behemoths of southern Afican insurance
industry such as Sanlam and Hollard, but
Kumar sees tis asa positive. "When you
ate big ship, takes time to tur around
Whereas a small boat ean turn around much
he says.Billions are being raised by companies across Africa as.
investors queue up to get in on the action,
Private equity
firms awash
from IPO flood
w _frica-focused entrepreneurs
are raising hundreds of
La) millions of dollars to seize
EP investment opportunities
through a rush of listings on secur
ties exchanges. Across the continent
and internationally, leading private
equity firms are playing a starring
role in Africa’s soaring growth and
are helping to bring promising firms
to market in initial public offers
(IPOs) of shares. Eager investors
‘meanwhile are queuing up to get a
piece of the action.
On 3" April, for example,
emerging markets private equity
specialist Actis announced it had sold
i's Edita Food Industries
oversubscribed offer of
pptian Exchange
(and global depository receipts in
London). Acts sad it had invested
stoam for a 30% stake in June 2013.
The IPO market capitalisation of
s8gom thus represented a healthy
profit
‘Actis Director Sherif Ellcholy said:
“Since we invested, the business has
launched its new headquarters and
logistics hub, increased production
capacity with a major investment in
anew factory, and...the management
have brought corporate governance
standards up to international levels
The strong interest received for the
PO signals significant appetite from
both Egyptian and international
institutional investors.”
Next in line for a similar fate
ina heavi
could be Egypt's medical laboratory
services firm, Integrated Diagnostic
Holdings, which in April 2015
announced that it was pushing ahead
with a London Stock Exchange IPO
and listing in May, with a dua-listing
on the Egyptian Exchange set to
follow. The offer is likely to consist
of 50% of the shares, valuing the
company at some $600m,
‘Medical laboratory services firm.
Integrated Diagnostics Holdings
(IDE) is planning to sell part ofits
holdings too. The company offers
genetic tests, diabetes diagnosis and
basic radiology, and by September
2014, had 283 laboratories in Egypt
Jordan and Sudan, performing tests
for 4.1m patients. Actis had also
bought 21% of the company last
December from Abraa. The IPO was
planned for January or February this
year but was pushed back
‘Across Africa, total of suabn was
raised through 24 IPOs and further
offers of shares in 2014, according to
IPO Watch Africa 2014, publication
put together by accountancy and
consulting firm PwC. It says the total
raised in 2014 was equivalent to the
combined total for 2012 and 208.
IPOs accounted for $1.7bn of this
money raised, up from so.8bn in
2013, Listings on the Johannesburg
Stock Exchange accounted for 44%
oftotal PO capital, and South Africa
contributed 87% ofthe sogbn raised
through further offers
There is little sign of the tide
1Posaccou
Torsi:fon of ths
money ralsed up
from $0.8bn In
1.7bnturning in coming months, although
the first quarter of 2015 saw some
drags amidst political uncertain
Nigeria's elections, and currency
volatility asa result of commodity
fluctuations
Law firm Baker & McKenzie
forecasts 30 IPOs for African
domiciled companies in 2015. South
Africa, Nigeria and Kenya are likely
to be key markets, while other hot
spots could include Mauritius as a
popular offshore listing location,
Morocco and Tunisia. After afew
years of turbulence, Egypt’ returned
stability is also reassuring investors
(see table),
Key sectors to be targeted are
forecast to be financials, real estate,
energy and power. Baker & MeKenzie
expects six cross-border listings
and for African businesses to raise
capital through listings in London
and Frankfurt. A announcement by
East Africa's regulators that they will
finish harmonising regulations by
June 2015 means cross border listings
will get easier in four securities
exchanges
Koen Vanhaerents, global
head of capital markets at Baker &
MeKenzie, says: “While there have
been several false dawns for capital
economies and making predictions
4s notoriously difficult, we do see a
more sustainable trend developing
There are sound footings based on a
zange of factors, including improved
corporate yovernanee, belter market
regulation and of course reasonable
économie growth in many countries.
‘One pul factor for the increasing
tide of IPOs on Africa exchanges is
domestic institutional investment
giants who are growing fast and
thirsty for investments. Pension funds
in South Africa control s32abn in
assets under management and the
next nine countries add another
457bn (figure at December 2013).
In countries such as Nigeria, local
pension funds are growing at 30%
a year, fuelled by recent regulatory
reforms, and reached sasbn in
December 2013. Ghana's pension
industry ose 400% from 2008 0 2083
to reach s2.6bn, Economist Charles
Robertson of Renaissance Capital
says pension funds inthe six largest
sub-Saharan African markets will
grow to s6aabn in assets by 2020 and
{0 $73 trillion by 2050.
Rising deals
Private equity has been driving much
ofthe investment action into African
businessesin recent years and is also
wel placed to make the most of the
new trend towards IPOs, Exits using
the securities exchanges picked up in
2014 and the trend could continue in
coming months.
In June 2014, Actis announced
ithad sold nearly 46% of Uganda's
electricity company Umeme for s9sm
after an oversubscribed institutional
offer with Investec Asset Management
and the Ugandan National Social
Security Fund as major buyers,
followed by a public offer. It had
previously listed Umeme on the
Uganda Securities Exchange in 2012
in an oversubscribed IPO, followed
by listing on the Nairobi bourse.
The following month, Actis saidMarkets: Private Equity
that the private equity consortium
investors it led, including Ethos,
had partially divested a stake in
South Africa's diversified financial
services group Alexander Forbes
through an oversubscribed offer on
the Johannesburg Stock Exchange,
valued at s803m.
Emerging Capital Partners (ECP)
sold out of Tunisia’ Societé d’Articles
Hygiéniques in private placement
and a heavily oversubscribed IPO
in January 2014, which valued the
company at $164m, giving ECP
a cash multiple of 2.4 times. The
Bourse de Tunis also scored a heavily
oversubscribed IPO for industrial
paper company Sotipapier in March
2014 after Swicorp's Intaj II Fund
brought it to market in an offer which
valued it at $76m. The International
Financial Corporation sold its 195%
stake in Madison Financial Services
PLC through an IPO on the Lusaka
Stock Exchange, followed by listing
in September. Development Partners
International (DPI) used introduction
tolist HomeChoice International on
the JSE in December.
Hurley Doddy, co-CEO of ECP,
told African Banker: “Certainly,
growth of local fund managers
‘means there is more demand to buy
something and more fand managers
are looking for investments.” He
believes that as private equity
portfolio companies become more
pan-African in focus, there is scope
for more regional exchanges as well
as offshore listings. Depending on
the company, he said he will look at
regional exchanges such as Abidjan-
based Bourse Regionale de Valeur
‘Mobileres (BRVM) as well as dual-
listings on local and international
exchanges.
Nabil Triki, Managing Director
in charge of Swicorp’s private equity,
said: “This demonstrates the positive
impact that private equity can have
on companies in the region, to
ensure both the development and
the sustainability of such companies,
and to positively contribute to local
economies’ capital markets.”
Tom ttinney
“Growth of
local fund
managers
means there is
more demand
tobuy
something
and more
fund
managers are
looking for
investments”
Financials, 20%
neve
Real Estate, 15%
Industrials, 10%
oJ—~
Consumer staples, 8%
Upcoming
IPOs for 2015
and beyond
‘Total Maroc s reported tobe preparing
tooffer upto 15% of ts shares through
niPO on the Bourse de Casablanca
Valued t around $80m after Saudi
[Mabia's zahid Group bought 30%.
‘ine government i ald fo be planning
{oprivatise 10% of port operator Marsa
‘Maroc through an Po this yea
‘sn arch the Ghana Alternative
Exchange (GAX) saw Intravenous
Infustons Limited suspend its 1PO after
sponsoring broker Frst atlantic
Brokers Lt, reportedly falled to provide ‘
{he minimuin 269s payment guarantee
onthe $4.8 offer.
‘Samba Foods announced a §0.65m
Ipoon the caxin February, but no
Updates were forthcoming” Agricutural
Development Bank was reported tobe
Planeigeltzmuchedlayed $52:1m 0
forbowofthesharesonthechane
ck Exchange, having galned approval
from the secu ile and Exchange
‘commission In March,
a
AC Asset Management offered shares» Australlan-owned iron-ore explorer
thuptoSominabatancedfundin irenklggetfesaures stated trading
February. ‘Sn London's iM market n February
STranscorp Hotel isted in January after after alsing Sta.5m in ashare ofer.
nly sas of ts shares were subscribed.” exploration targets are across West
{'thibo in ate 2014 ‘Aen with an ints focus on two
Prospectsin Gabon.
ecacish op Pos ae
Indieties by iimatea po was ceayed Severs
Po Value fimes ast Year unsteadying Investor
fence, but In February uinster
inane and Economie Development
Kenneth uatambo sald was stil
Scheduled forthe first alt of 2015.
* Bourse Regionale des Valeur
inobillres, covering ight West African
‘countries, announced ft had identified
‘around 106 small to medium-sized
‘Compantes that could qualify tost
‘onthe third tier.
59 & Power, 19%
Telecos, 89% =
Healthcare, 59% Iilyy
Retall,3%6
High Technology, 2%
Product
8 Services, 296
Baker Mekensieielsedad see ran teh og
Ialathc tedster hn bo Pod
surar acne
Beene Bi Aner
ies reputed nigra
pores nsdn a Fed ace
Weld fpersin what
HANEA teat abo
ditwouapeed osc beeen
sya eee
an Rab Baz anol
see
a
« State-owned uganda Electric
Generation company Limited could ist
Sn the Uganda SecrlesEictangs in
the next two years to rise ibn to boost
jower-generating capacity to S6SMW.
yom 30m.
«Transport company Uda is amon
Several companies that say they would
iiketonst
«Finance Bank of Zambla says its
close to complying with Lusaka Stock
Exchange listing requirements after an
10 has been flagged up since 2013.
aunlecape, seated private equity
fund Brat snapped up 80% of Virgin
Active alt cba far ibn after the
Shareholder private equlty group CVC
Barner aioanced plane fal he
Company on J3E by May. Virgin rout
waite 20% wlth alt buying
Ur the company owned by Viren
sndsiseby Veen
Other potential stings include White
iver eboutces, wnichtsays wi itn
Sohannesburg.ahd London ar Hong Kong.
and Sygnia muit-management compan.JOB VACANCY
1. ony mormon lb a
mio reneues Renght step ison vacancy noice
COT Mir t tPA ly ——
ET Uae
available at
your fingertips
ibe to
for)Markets:ADCM Summit
AFRICAN BANKER 28D QUARTER 2015 61
Policymakers, opinion leaders and investors gathered in
Washington to discuss the vast opportunities arising from
African markets and what can be done to seize them.
Soaring investor funds
seek faster capital
markets growth
he opportunity is there but
itis not being tapped. That is
the message which came out
of the African Debt and Capi-
tal Markets Summit, which was held
in Washington DC during the World
Bank and IMF spring meetings.
Emerging market bonds, and
in particular African sovereign
Eurobonds, have been making
headlines over the past year,
especially as yields of European and
US treasuries have been at all-time
lows. Last year, some sigbn wasraised
by African corporates and sovereigns
including a debut bond for both.
Ethiopia (subn) and Kenya ($2.7sbn).
Yet with falling commodity and
oil prices, Giulia Pellegrini from JP
Morgan raised a few red flags in terms
of the headwinds some economiesin
Africa would have to face if they were
to keep their debt at sustainable eves.
‘The programme in Washington
also focused on more general issues
relating to African capital markets
and what needs to be done to
make them more appealing both
to corporates and more open to
domestic and international investors.
Nialé Kaba, Minister in charge
of Economy and Finance in Cote
Ivoire, told a session on capital
markets how eight West African
countries work together to drive
the growth of the regional exchange
Bourse Régionale des Valeurs
Mobiligres (BRVM), However, she
admitted that regulation would
need to be adopted and reviewed
as it was too restrictive, especially
for corporates, small and medium
enterprises and investors, to
participate in the exchange.
Set up in 1996, the exchange
only has 39 stocks listed although
itis seeking to increase this number
as well as tapping into international
capital (see p64).
Ngozi Okonjo-Iweala, outgoing
Minister of Finance and Economy
for Nigeria, painted a positive story
‘of her country. She said that she was
leaving behind a solid economy, that
Nigeria's economy was “vigorous
and resilient’, and that the transition
‘would be smooth,
The reality, however, is that
and Economy for
Nigeria patmed a
positive peture,
capital markets remain largely illiquid
and do not represent the economy in
any meaningful way, and worryingly
do not offer a viable route to raise new
capital. This in turn makes it harder
to mobilise domestic eapital to fund
public and private sector projects and
ideas.
Domestic institutional investors,
including pension funds, have over
$379bn in assets under management,
and sovereign wealth funds created in
1s countries represent another sisgbn,
but these are part of buy-sce growth,
Not much of this is ultimately
being invested in dynamic capital
markets, other than in safe high
Yielding treasury bonds. Jaloul Ayed,
former Finance Minister of Tunisia,
said thatthe greatest opportunity in
Arica today is convergence between
pension funds and private equity.
Pioneer private-equity investor
Hurley Doddy of Emerging Capital
Partners noted how fast the market
is developing with several funds
achieving closes of around sibn in
recent months
David Ashiagbor of the African
Development Bank's Making Finance
Work for Africa (MFw4A) added
that governments are keen to build
environments where private capital
can fund development and growth.
‘The African Debt & Capital
Markets Summit, organised by
IC Events, this publisher's sister
company, was held for the first time
in Washington DC.
By coinciding with the World
Bank and International Monetary
Fund spring meetings this year it
offered more chances for ministers
and policymakers to interact with
ey market participants.
Attendees included most top
banks working in Africa, key
institutional investors, exchanges,
private equity leaders, analysts,
policymakers and opinion-leaders
Key sponsors were the International
Finance Corporation (IFC),Standard
Bank Group and ‘Thomson Reuters,
and other backers such as Nigeria’,
FMDQ market and Fairfax Africa
Fund. Tom ttinneyEssen)
BUR ocie sitet nelelN cM Seg -so1(cle Beh eller (ol (mela
opportunities could help unlock a more vibrant future.
BRVM seeks distinctive
future in exchange battle
ee
i hing eight countries, a
harmonised regulatory
Roeerretnta
pegged to the euro, the West Afri-
Fer eee Cae)
Peres een tien tg
child for the continent's much-her-
alded regional integration projects
But despite the supportiveattitude
CeCe eRe!
they will come” approach to market
Pree ts
Ripert
Pee eee nr eae
Peterman eetnaty
Abidjan, the Bourse Régional des
Sree eey
Cee ee cteros
Perr nent
EE en
St eese tae
that newly established companies and
Seon eer erties)
can go very quickly to the process of
Tec ent)
Lenetrtnte te eens
conan)
Peat
arene eT ar]
Peenne erect trates
Praises arn
Pecans eee)
that it could capitalise further on a
new wave of African IPO activity
Deke TEL)
initial public offerings and fallow-on
Ere eee earn’
Peter eee et eg
een tenia
Pee eee ater eats
own market capitalisation double
eo
diversifying
Sed
ioe
pies
ed
local
eed
Pear
pens
Parents
ree
pens
Pea
reas
Ps eee TY
Amenounve believes that the key
fornia
BRVM region lies with risk-taking
Renee eeenn etd
en nace kn
region to develop local firms. KPMG
Pe ems
Soe eres
arte tn eet tes rats
Petar eum tag
‘goods, financial services and other
eee ets
Pte rece b aera
Sean e eorc
Cage eens
Peering een tts
Pasig ce sen Vis
een aod
Posner ra erent
ORS
ose ee ete Ec
them to come to the stock exchan
itean bea big opportunity for us
mom!
in a region where large companies
ceva eee tg
rence res ee erenetr sd
Src centers ca)
‘when it comes to funding longer-
fonsmeen gers tt
regional authorities will have to look
yeaa gira
Pee ean
Pee ntecctiss
Ronn ae anus
about how we can force’ some ofthe
big companies to come to the market
~ companies like banks, insurance
ee een as
Pacem cere
but give them very good incentives toreg ec eee
Daven iets tmnac)
eC
Senegalese telecoms firm Sonatel,
ene!
ecco Rese th ae acne
eed
is constantly making the case to
governments and regulators for
improved terms for listed firms.
pieces
because our partners don't like
government to give tax incentives
to big companies that are important
contributors to the fiscal budget.
ener s
Pee O ne enn eed
Cees
rates ets
RO ee aR
pecan eta
ea eee cas
Re ake
ene Conn!
Peta anne
Pence ees eres rete
firms on the advantages of seeking,
erent eats
caer es ett
chief executive claims that 50% of
een ere Cag
eng ete cen
Pree ee enc
Peerneiecs enn!
ee oer!
Creer ecrcee Tate sg
Pea a oad
Seer erea tance ene ts
ee cece
Ponca
erga ee secttag
Precast etd
Union regulator Conseil Régional de
Peete eee eens
Pees aye es
in the region can play a key role in
pin ieee
preteen
every year and as a result financial
Dn a Ona e
financing for states. The capacity of
eI eee oss
Peni een eer
peodenao meee tater
investments at an international level
from institutional investors that have
eee ues Seg
example, pension funds,” he told
Eero
Retna eee tots
Rec n aaa er eee Ces
preenrer seme nts
ecco nCmuunctas
Cra aeeete Raers
Perna eta
tee intas
infrastructure investment.
OC eee
investors base, that is absolutely
essential. The local debt market is
Pores cn een ea tts
a pure strategy of buy and hold. We
can't really blame them for this,
eee or eee ucruecd
ee eet
eee ue
have greater presence on our market,
money managers, pension funds ~
epee eu carn and
Sacer rer n ny
eats
irre cre
Pe eee Aan!
Amenounve is secking to convince
the regulator to make it easier for
states and companies to avoid having
to put guarantees in place before
ieee eet reaty
that the regulator should play the role
Diem ets eats
Serene?
Pree teen yng acs
nso ees
only regulators, but also business-
Eres
Cee Rem nny
ootnna renee
Pa eer Re Cres
pOernnreetea ts tt
ese nents
PIN vete ent teeters
ticular reveals both the limits
Crenct ste he eienc
role it hopes to forge in an already
crowded marketplace
Sane
Pees cme tatty
the frontier, or to the pre-frontier
‘market. We consider our market a
pre-frontier market, before going toa
frontier market and then an emerging
ea PerriAfrican
velopment
Supporting SMEs to drive Africa’s growth
s the African Development Bank (AfDB)
athe Ain Delores Henk (AID)
for the 2035 Annual Meeting, the institution
is readying itself to elect a new president as
the 1-year tenure of Donald Kaberuka draws
toa close
"Among the many hallmarks of the AfDBVs activities
cover the last decade have been efforts to stimulate job
creation, particularly for women and youth, with support
boeing given to Africa’ SMEs.
‘A programme launched in January last year isa case
in point. An agreement was reached to provide two sov-
ereign-guaranteed multi-tranche lines of credit (LoCs),
of respectively ss00m to the Bank of Industry (BOD, and
cof s2o0m tothe Nigerian Export-Import Bank (NEXIM)
“The programme's objective i to support the mod-
ernisation and expansion of export-oriented small- and
‘medium-sized enterprises (MES).
‘OL isthe leading catalyst for industrial development
resources in Nigeria as well as being one of the oldest
development finance institutions in Africa. It was estab-
lished in 1964 and reorganised in 200
Thine wth ts mandsteto nance industrial develop-
‘ment projects, BOI provides term finance and advisory
services primarily to indigenous SMEs, to which it de-
votes at least 85% ofits resources
‘Nigerian Export-Import Bank (NEXIM) isthe na~
tional export credit agency of Nigeria. Itwas established
in 991 with a mandate to provide export credit, guaran-
tees, insurance and advisory service to export-oriented
companies, particularly SMEs in the non-oil sector.
“The LoC’s will allow the two institutions to assist
Nigerian SMEs to be more competitive, to scale up their
gperations and ultimately ereate more employment
LoCs included a technical assistance package to
strengthen the institutional capacity of both BO! and
NEXIM, a elas ther Scie, vege th
‘Ultimately, this integrated financing package that
the AIDR has fnded has supported Niger's efforts to
diversify its economy aviay from a reliance on hydro-
carbon revenues,
“The LoCs addresses the severe challenges that Nigeria's
‘SMEs face in accessing finance in the country, enabling
export-oriented SMEs to grow, to become more competi-
tive, and ensuvea sustainable growth in employment.
‘And the AfDB has also supported SMEs in other re-
gions of the continent. The bank approved a sam line of.
Credit to one of Mozambique’s fasiest growing financial
instttins through its private sector window to Mora
“Mora Banco is actively presenti across Mozambique
corporate, SME an teal banking services.
‘This sym LOC will support SME sub-projects includ-
‘The Bank’s
SME
Programme
will offer
longer-term
resources to
thousands of
African SMEs,
with the aim
of creating
jobs and
contributing
to inclusive
growth on
the continent.
ing manufacturing, commerce/trade, services, tour-
ism, construction, agriculture and transport. Economic
benefits are likely to accrue to 70 SMEs to be financed
adding an add
urban areas.
In addition, the project will induce technology and
skills transfers, It is also anticipated that government
revenue lines though the gowth of alealde
income and! corporation taxes
Tn fact, Moza Banco is part the AfDB's Africa SME
Programme to develop and expand its SME financing
activities and provide medium- to long-term financing
‘options to local SMEs in Mozambique
Meanie n July 20, the APDB launched a fou
ar, 125m funding programme (including a $308,
Fechnicalasistanc package funded bythe Find for AF
rican Private Sector Assistance) termed the Africa Small
and Medium Enterprises (SME) Programme
"The Fund for Atrican Private Sector Assistance lev-
rages on the ADB's triple A rating, in as much as the
tating empowers t to co-fund the initiative, tothe tune of
'10.6m, in. a milateral agreement withthe government
‘of lapan (443m); the government of Austria (€1m), and
Development Bank of Austria €im). The AFDB Africa
‘SME core programme aims to support micro, small and
‘medium enterprises (MSMES) in Aftica with the neces
sary longer-term finance (and a technical assistance
packages) to mest the challenges faced by around 25
nancial initations nd their SME cents arose Afi
“The SME programme has already approved the first
two ofthe snail nsittion that il benefit fom
the programme's funding and technical assistance in
Tanzaniaand Zambia.In Tanzania, the DCB Commercial
Bank plc isa community bank that has been granted a
‘ssm LOC to uplift the standard of living of low-income
ople by providing loans to disadvantaged Tanzanians
trho cannor access financial services throagh normal
banking channels.
‘A 315m LoC hasalso been extended to CETZAM in
Zambia, a registered depost-taking micro-financing
institution that lends to Zambia's micro and small entre-
eneurs. CETZAM will also receive technical assistance
from the Fund for African Private Sector Assistance.
‘A €25m LoC was also extended last year to Fidelis
nance, a leader in the leasing mazket in Burkina Faso
witha strong focus on SMEs.
‘Throughout its on-going selection process - and
‘working parallel to the AfDB's other general support
programmes - the APDB' SME Programme will oer
longer-term resources to thousands of African SMEs,
including youth and women, contributing to job crea.
tion, poverty reduction an ineluive growth on the
continent,
al 400 new employees in rural and
5
5Sixyears ago, when the AfDB president, Donald Kaberuka,
‘addressed a SADC international conference on poverty
and development, he commented: “We will eliminate
Poverty onl if our economies can grow sustainably over
Several years. To maintain that path Its Imperative
to steadlly continue to reduce the costs and the risks
of doing business, both political and economic, while
expanding the size and diversity of our markets, The
‘ADB willbe earmarking about §1.7bn for regional
Infrastructure.”
He was later to confirm, “we are adopting new
polices to better support the middle income countries
regarding infrastructure financing and non-sovereign
activities, we are particularly keen to contribute to
resolving the energy crisis
President Kaberuka was relterating what many
economists have been saying for many years ~ that the
lack of adequate infrastructure is key cause of poverty.
In this sense, the lack of infrastructure can be defined as
meaning a lack of affordable, sustainable energy, such
as electricity, as well as the transport infrastructure that
‘can underpin trade.
‘The ATDB, among the Key sectors inits poverty
reduction strategy, has kdentified the electricity sub
sector for attention. For example, given the lawrate
“Sip
of electrification in the country, Tanzania is faced with
situation where it must increase its investments to
‘scale up electricity services in the rural areas, andithas
Included rural electrification as one ofits main pillars of
development.
Earlier this year, the ADB approved the Kenya-
‘Tanzania interconnection project that will involve the
construction of a tatal of more than 500km of 400K
high voltage alternative current (HVAC) transmission
lines in a double circuit from Isinya Substation in Kenya
‘to Singida Substation in Tanzania. 93.1 km ofthe line Is in
Kenya and 414.5 km are in Tanzania.
The transfer capacity ofthe interconnector is
designed for 2,400 MW. The associated substation works
includes the extension ofthe existing Isinya (Kenya)
and Iringa (Tanzania) substations to include 400KV
transformers, and the construction of anew 400kV
substation In Arusha, Tanzania
The project helps strengthen the regional Integration
of the East African Community and will play an important
role in encouraging Tanzania's agro-processing and
industrialisation, thereby contributing te poverty
reduction.
‘Similar projects across the continent in ereating