Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Course Sponsor
Jay R. Smith Mfg.
2781 G
Gunter
t P
Park
kD
Drive
i E
Montgomery, AL 36109
Phone: 334-277-8520
Fax: 334-272-7396
E-mail
salesengineering@jrsmith.com
Web
www.jrsmith.com
Course Number
JRS22A
Pl
Please
note:
t you will
ill need
d to
t complete
l t the
th conclusion
l i
quiz
i online
li
att
ronblank.com to receive credit
This program is registered with the AIA/CES for continuing professional education.
As such, it does not include content that may be deemed or construed to be an
approval or endorsement by the AIA or Ron Blank & Associates, Inc. of any
material of construction or any method or manner of handling, using, distributing, or
dealing in any material or product
product.
Copyright
py g Materials
This presentation is protected by U.S. and International
copyright laws. Reproduction, distribution, display
and use of the presentation without written
permission of
Ron Blank & Associates, Inc. 2008
and
Jay R. Smith Mfg. Co. 2008
is prohibited.
Learning
g Objectives
j
At the conclusion of this course,, the design
g professional
p
will be able to :
Describe the basic principles of a siphonic roof drainage systems
List the benefits of siphonic roof drainage and how the system selfselfprimes
Compare and contrast the differences between traditional drainage
and engineered
g
siphonic
p
roof drainage
g
Explain several myths and misconceptions as related to
roofing/drainage
Reference the codes and standards relating
g to siphonic
p
systems
y
Explain the role of the Licensure as it relates to health, safety, and
welfare
Name and understand the components
p
of a siphonic
p
roof drain
Learning
g Objectives
j
At the conclusion of this course,, the design
g professional
p
will be able to :
Illustrate how a siphonic system works with different roof designs and
as a controlled flow system
Site case studies and installation examples where a siphonic system
benefited the owner
Describe
D
ib h
how a siphonic
i h i system
t
can help
h l reduce
d
costs
t d
during
i hi
historic
t i
renovation projects
Incorporate a siphonic design into a building to help acquire LEED
points:: (1) for the use of recycled material (cast iron), (2) by reducing
points
site preparation (less buried pipe), (3) by using a siphonic system in
conjunction with rainwater harvesting to reduce water use and
iimprove stormwater
t
t managementt on site,
it and
d (4) under
d th
the
Innovation and Design concepts by combining the concepts of
several LEED categories
Introduction
Siphonic
p
roof drainage
g is one of the newest technologies
g
to be
introduced into the American design field. Siphonic roof drainage
requires a certain level of technical analysis similar to engineered
automatic sprinkler systems and other mechanical systems. This
course provides training to the experienced design professional
f
to
impart the necessary knowledge for the understanding of siphonic
roof drainage operation and application.
Horizontal
H
i
t l Piping
Pi i saves
space within the building
The Concept
p
In a siphonic
p
roof drainage
g system,
y
siphonic
p
roof drains engage
g g a
specially engineered and tested roof drain baffle. This baffle allows
and sustains negative atmospheric pressure in the connected
piping and inhibits the admission of air into the piping system hence
sustaining full
full--bore flow and higher flow volumes and velocities.
The hydraulic balance in a siphonic roof drainage system is
achieved by a design professional employing hydraulic calculations
to ensure that the piping system fills up automatically in cases of
moderate to heavy precipitation. The resulting fullfull-bore or siphonic
action allows for
f the installation off horizontal, i.e. level, drainage
manifold piping serving multiple roof drains.
Siphonic
S
p o c roof
oo drainage
d a age systems
sys e s a
are
e po
powered
e ed by a
and
dd
discharged
sc a ged to
o
grade by means of a vertical stack into the point of discharge
through the influence of gravity making them true gravity systems.
Outline
A Brief Overview
A Brief Overview
The Siphonic
p
Principle
p
The p
principle
p of the siphon
p
has been recognized
g
for ages.
g
A siphon
p
is
created by a tube or other type of conduit filled with the fluid to be
siphoned, thereby creating a continuous and closed path.
In any siphon, the discharge end of the conduit must be lower than
th llevell off th
the
the flfluid
id iin th
the source reservoir.
i At
Atmospheric
h i pressure att
the reservoir surface becomes the driving force pushing the fluid
through the tube to the lower point of discharge.
Siphonic Action
The Siphonic
p
Principle
p
Most examples
p
of siphons
p
include an inverted U shape,
p , this
configuration is necessary to lift the fluid out of the source reservoir
that cannot be tipped, much like a cars gas tank. However, the actual
path of the siphon tube is irrelevant to the fluids ability to flow.
Overview of Siphonic
p
Drainage
g
Closed Outlets.
Overview of Siphonic
p
Drainage
g
Piping
p gp
primes and operates
p
100%
% full ((i.e. fullfull-bore flow).
)
Water is drawn through the outlets and piping faster than gravity
channel flow alone due to negative pressure.
Lower material expenditures due to smaller pipe diameters
diameters.
Pipe inverts leaving the building are at a minimum, making deep
trenching on the site beyond the building unnecessary.
Thi is
This
i an advantage
d
t
when
h developing
d
l i LEED certified
tifi d projects.
j t
Benefits of Siphonic
p
Design
g
The major
j benefit of siphonic
p
roof drainage
g is the reduction in p
pipe
p
diameter to achieve the same volumetric flow of water off of a roof.
This is achieved by exploiting the kinds of flow patterns and behaviors
of the flow of water through
g p
pipes
p that result in p
pressure fluctuations
and priming to a full bore condition. These behaviors are systematically
avoided and prevented in the design of traditional sanitary drainage
and roof drainage systems.
Ideal siphonic drainage applications include factories, warehouses,
airports, convention centers, stadiums and bigbig-box retail.
Warehouse application
A Siphonic
p
System
y
A Siphonic System
The Self
Self--Priming
g Process in a Siphonic
p
System
y
Priming
g first occurs at the smaller diameter branch sections that
connect each roof drain to the main horizontal carrier pipe or manifold.
At this point, each siphonic roof drain acts independently as a miniminisiphonic system. As water accumulates in the manifold, air is purged
out off the
h point
i off discharge
di h
until
il the
h manifold
if ld and
d stack
k is
i 95%
9 % to 100%
full of water. The system is then completely siphonic and under
predominantly negative pressure.
Showing
Sho ing the flow
flo as pipe primes
Wavy flow (Pattern 1) is seen during rainfall events far below the
piping systems ability to prime. Light showers will typically produce
this flow condition until rainfall intensity increases to a point where
branch pipes can fully prime.
As the pipe continues to prime, the higher flow velocity of the water
captures and emulsifies the remaining air and a frothy bubble flow
forms (Pattern 4).
The frothy flow condition becomes gradually clearer until all of the
remaining air is purged out of the point of discharge. This is the fullfull-bore
flow (Pattern 5) created by siphonic action.
action
It is rare that a rainfall event will occur at the exact design intensity (Id)
for any
an sustained
s stained period
period. Therefore,
Therefore a system
s stem will
ill typically
t picall experience
e perience
flow Patterns 3 to 5 during heavy rainfall. During light rainfall events,
Patterns 1 and 2 may develop.
A Traditional System
A traditional rainwater p
piping
p g system
y
is sized and p
pitched to be at
atmospheric pressure throughout. Since pressure is constant from inlet to
outlet, the only thing inducing flow is the pipe pitch.
A Siphonic
p
System
y
Si h i systems
Siphonic
t
d
do nott require
i any special
i l iinstallation
t ll ti kit or
procedure. The pipe materials and fittings used with siphonic roof drains
are the same as those required for traditional drainage systems.
With a flat
flat, level design
design, long horizontal runs above overhead
ceilings are possible, as shown in illustration 4.
This reduces the amount of buried pipe and the associated costs
with
ith ttrenching,
hi
bedding,
b ddi
and
d backfilling
b kfilli within
ithi th
the b
buildings
ildi ffootprint.
t i t
Siphonic systems are designed to operate under subsubatmospheric pressure when primed full. The horizontal piping
in the system can have higher velocities. This means
rainwater is moved off
ff off the rooff faster
f
during the heavy
storms. During light rainfall events, the piping still drains but in
the traditional open channel flow mode.
Siphonic roof drainage systems are more efficient in the use
of materials since smaller pipe diameters can be specified to
handle a wide range of rainfall events.
Myths
y
and Misconceptions
p
Myth 1: Siphonic systems drain water off of the roof faster than traditional
piping.
Reality: Although higher operating velocities are achieved, the drainage
capacity is a function of pipe size. They can drain as quickly or as slowly as
desired. Siphonic roof drainage is very good for controlled flow
requirements.
Myth 2: Siphonic systems have to be engineered by the manufacturer or
supplier
li off th
the pipe
i and
dd
drains.
i
Reality: A majority of the siphonic systems installed in the U.S. to date have
been engineered by independent consulting engineers.
Myth 3: The pipe and fittings are available only from foreign proprietary
sources.
Reality:
y Pipe
p and fittings
g used for siphonic
p
roof drainage
g systems
y
in the
United States are the same as those used for traditional plumbing systems.
There are no special manufacturers, materials or installers needed for
siphonic roof drainage systems.
Myths
y
and Misconceptions
p
Myth 4: There is standing water on the roof at all times in order to maintain
a siphonic operation, even while not raining (i.e.,
(
the pipe is always full).
f )
Reality: When it is not raining, the roof and piping are dry. When it rains, a
layer of water develops on the roof, but in the same way as with traditional
atmospheric systems. Actually, this layer of water is typically less for
siphonic systems.
Myth 5: Water builds up on the roof until a critical level is reached and then
th drains
the
d i open up tto siphon
i h th
the water
t off.
ff
Reality: Water build
build--up on a flat roof or in gutters is not any different than
traditional systems. Transition from partly full to full bore is a smooth
transition. This property is a tested parameter for siphonic drains (15
second rule). Also, the drains are fixed and without moveable parts.
Myth 6: There must be valves, utility connections or mechanical controls to
make
k the
th siphon
i h work.
k
Reality: There are no valves, controls, regulators or moving parts of any
kind. The system consists only of drains and piping. Siphonic systems prime
y
action.
due to natural hydraulic
State Regulations
g
for Licensure
Background:
g
Licensure of engineers and professionals at design firms is
regulated at the State level. Originally, past engineering disasters
prompted a few States to adopt laws regulating the practice of
engineering.
i
i
Th
The purpose off such
h llaws iis tto protect
t t th
the h
health,
lth
safety and welfare of the public. Licensed design professionals are
required to abide by a strict code of ethics to ensure adherence to
public safety.
Professional Firms:
Most professional design firms have a Certificate of Authorization or
equivalent permit that demonstrates they are qualified to perform
engineering designs.
If your company wishes to engage in a contract with a firm offering
to design siphonic roof drainage systems it is recommended that
you obtain that companys Certificate of Authorization or permit.
This is particularly important if a roof drain product manufacturer or
sales representative offers to design siphonic systems as they may
not be able to certify the design.
Siphonic
p
Roof Drains
Siphonic Roof Drains
Drain Body
Flashing Ring
Ai B
Air
Baffle
ffl
Dome Strainer (Leaf Guard)
Governing Standard
Components
p
of a Siphonic
p
Roof Drain
Siphonic
p
roof drains are actually
y very
y simple
p devices. They
y include all
of the familiar components common to traditional roof drains. This
figure shows a cutcut-away of a typical siphonic roof drain with all its
required components.
Components
p
and Function
Baffle
Plate
Fins
Plate
l
Ring
Components
p
and Function
The drain body provides a means of mounting the fixture to a roof deck
system. It also provides a spigot outlet connection for the attachment of
drainage pipe below the roof deck surface.
Th llower surface
The
f
off the
th flashing
fl hi ring
i has
h ab
beveled
l d surface
f
tto mate
t
with the outer top surface of the drain body. The inner rim has a
depression on the upper surface that receives the base of the air baffle.
Flat Roofs
Gutters
Design Flexibility
Recommended Discharge Designs
Flat Roofs
A Siphonic roof drain system and drain are ideal for flat
flat roof
construction.
The placement of the roof drains on flat roofs is normally dictated by
structural
t t l and
d rooff design
d i criteria.
it i Th
The pitch
it h off th
the steel
t ld
deck
k or th
the
maximum thickness of tapered insulation usually establishes the
maximum spacing between roof drains. These conditions are normally
determined by the structural engineer, architect and/or plumbing
engineer prior to the plumbing and drainage design being started.
Flat Roofs
Siphonic roof drainage systems do not present any other special needs
for roof drain placement, so the architect or engineer may locate the
roof drains per traditional standard practice.
Gutters
Design
g Flexibility
y
Recommended Discharge
g Design
g
Th connecting
The
ti manhole
h l should
h ld b
be ventilated
til t d b
by some means.
This can be accomplished by installing an open grate instead of a
sealed manhole, or use a perforated manhole cover. When this is
not possible, a vent pipe can be extended from the manhole and
terminated above grade. This ventilation will prevent the possibility
of pressure fluctuations in the storm sewer system.
y
Installations
Case Study 1, IKEA Store in
Paramus,, NJ
Case Study 2, IKEA store in
Atlanta, Georgia
Savings Example Vertical Stack
Savings Example Horizontal
Piping
Case Study
y-1
Case Study
y 1 cont...
Case Study
y-2
Atlanta, Georgia
Case Study
y 2 cont...
Atlanta, Georgia
The implementation
p
of siphonic
p
roof drainage
g
Made it possible to drain the roof to the rear of the building where storm
drainage piping could be installed below the delivery access road and
off the site towards the retention pond.
Height (feet) 35
Savings
g Example
p -1
Example 1:
A vertical stack of a traditional roof drain system
y
is
designed to drain 63,940 square feet of roof surface at a
rainfall intensity of 3.25 inches per hour. According to IPC
2000, the required pipe diameter is 12 inches. At this
flow the pipe would be about 25 percent full and would
flow,
achieve a terminal velocity of 24 feet per second. Cast
iron pipe for this stack size would cost about $1,488.00
per 10 foot section.
p
An existing siphonic system design covering the same
roof area and rainfall intensity has a calculated stack
diameter of 8 inches. The design velocity is 14 feet per
second
d and
d th
the pipe
i iis 100 percentt full.
f ll C
Castt iiron pipe
i ffor
this stack size costs about $627.00 per 10 foot section.
Thats a sa
savings
ings of $861
$861.00
00 per ten foot section for
this part of the system or almost 58 percent less than
a traditional design.
Based on R.
R S.
S Means Construction Cost Data 2005
2005. These cost
calculations are examples from real world applications; your cost
may be different. These costs are given for illustration only.
Savings
g Example
p -2
Example 2:
A horizontal segment
g
of a traditional roof drain system
y
is designed
g
to drain
15,685 square feet of roof surface at a rainfall intensity of 3.25 inches per hour.
At a pitch of 1/8 per foot (about 1 percent), the required pipe diameter is 10
inches (IPC 2000, Table 1106.3). At this design flow, the pipe would be 52
percent full and have a velocity of 4.0 feet per second. Cast iron pipe with
hangers every 5 feet on center and a 1 inch fiberglass insulation cover and
couplings every 10 feet would cost about $1,057.00 per ten foot section. If
installed below grade, the cost is about the same if insulation cover is replaced
with the cost of trenching and backfill
backfill.
An existing siphonic system design covering the same roof area and rainfall
intensity has a calculated pipe manifold of 6 inches. Even without pitch, the
design velocity is 6.1 feet per second and 100 percent full. Cast iron pipe this
size with hangers every 5 feet on center and a 1 inch fiberglass insulation cover
and couplings every 10 feet would cost about $515.00 per ten foot section.
Thats
at s a sa
savings
gs o
of $5
$542.00
00 pe
per te
ten foot
oot
section in this part of the system or about
51% less than a traditional design.
Function
F
ti off Pipe
Pi Sizing
Si i
Roof Deck
Allowance by Code
Allowance by
y Code
Siphonic roof drainage tends to fall under this category. Since it can
essentially guarantee a limited discharge through pipe sizing
sizing, it poses
a more attractive solution to systems with flow control weirs at the roof
drains.
Disney C
Di
Case St
Study
d
What is LEED
How can siphonic drainage
systems help in achieving a LEED
certified project
Rainwater Harvesting
Historic Renovation
Historic Renovation
Siphonic Roof Drain
Historical Building Retrofit Application
Problem
Th Architects
The
A hit t contacted
t t d a local
l
l manufacturing
f t i representative
t ti for
f
insight on using siphonic roof drains on the job.
The local ordinance required that the exterior of the 100 year old
building not be changed and that all overflow drainage be piped into
the city storm drainage system. Additionally, the job required a quick
and viable roof drainage solution.
Historic Renovation
Solution
The Siphonic Roof Drain was selected and used because the
overflow can be controlled to a specific point on the building. In the
original design there were no overflows in place so the siphonic
drains were the perfect solution to their problem.
The manufacturing representative showed the architect how the
siphonic action of the roof drains allow the piping system to be run
horizontal. This piping design enabled the overflows to be
evacuated on the side of the building.
The vertical
ertical stack
stack, once it reached the gro
ground,
nd was
as piped to a
vented manhole where water was discharged into the storm system.
This solution satisfied both the architect and the city of Pasadena.
Th Disney
The
Di
Pasadena
P
d
project
j t was a success with
ith th
the client,
li t th
the
architect, and the city officials; all were pleased that the siphonic
roof drain was able to solve their design problems.
LEED
LEED
LEED p
points are not given
g
to individual products,
p
, but to an aggregate
gg g
of the building system that saves water, energy, and contributes to a
healthy indoor environment.
Rainwater Harvesting
g
A siphonic
p
roof drainage
g system
y
is one of the most effective
technologies offered for capturing rainwater from a building roof top
to aid in implementing rainwater harvesting.
R i
Rainwater
t H
Harvesting
ti
Rainwater Harvesting
g
In a siphonic system, several roof
drain outlets can be connected to a
single vertical discharge pipe.
Fewer discharge points and no
requirement
q
for pitch
p
in the piping
pp g
means the rainwater can be easily
routed horizontally below the roof
t a storage
to
t
tank
t k or cistern.
i t
Rainwater Harvesting
g
The stored rainwater is now available for use in non
non--potable applications
such as toilets and urinal flushing, mechanical systems, custodial uses, and
for site irrigation.
One of the major benefits of designing a building with siphonic roof
drainage and rainwater harvesting systems is reduced overall construction
and facility operation costs.
Additional benefits include reduced discharge of rainwater to lakes,
streams, rivers and sanitary systems, and decreased dependence on
municipal water supplies.
Summary
y
Summary
Conclusion
C
l i
Objectives Review
Conclusion
Conclusion
Learning siphonic roof drainage design tends to open our eyes
t issues
to
i
nott commonly
l considered
id
d in
i rooff drainage
d i
design
d i in
i
general.
Course Summary
y
The design professional will now be able to:
Describe the basic principles of a siphonic roof drainage systems
List the benefits of siphonic roof drainage and how the system self
self--primes
Compare and contrast the differences between traditional drainage and
engineered siphonic roof drainage
Explain several myths and misconceptions as related to roofing/drainage
Reference the codes and standards relating to siphonic systems
Explain
p
the role of the Licensure as it relates to health, safety,
y and welfare
Name and understand the components of a siphonic roof drain
Course Summary
y
The design
g professional
p
will now be able to:
Illustrate how a siphonic system works with different roof designs and
as a controlled flow systems
Site case studies and installation examples where a siphonic system
benefited the owner
Describe how a siphonic system can help reduce costs during historic
renovation projects
Incorporate a siphonic design into a building to help acquire LEED
points:: (1) for the use of recycled material (cast iron), (2) by reducing
points
site
it preparation
ti (l
(less b
buried
i d pipe),
i ) (3) b
by using
i a siphonic
i h i system
t
in
i
conjunction with rainwater harvesting to reduce water use and
improve stormwater management on site, and (4) under the
Innovation
Innovation and Design
Design concepts by combining the concepts of
several LEED categories.
categories.
Course Sponsor
Jay R. Smith Mfg.
2781 G
Gunter
t P
Park
kD
Drive
i E
Montgomery, AL 36109
Phone: 334-277-8520
Fax: 334-272-7396
E-mail
salesengineering@jrsmith.com
Web
www.jrsmith.com
Course Number
JRS22A
Pl
Please
note:
t you will
ill need
d to
t complete
l t the
th conclusion
l i
quiz
i online
li
att
ronblank.com to receive credit