Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Needs
Assessment
Nutrition
Status
and
Healthy
Pregnancies
in
Detroit
Mary
Connolly
University
of
Michigan
School
of
Public
Health
Connolly
Introduction
Internationally
the
United
States
ranks
poorly
among
its
industrialized
international
counterparts
in
maternal
and
child
health
ranking
126th
in
maternal
mortality
rate
and
167th
in
infant
mortality
rates
according
the
to
the
CIA
World
Factbook.1
This
issue
is
due
in
part
to
a
multitude
of
national
health
crises
many
stemming
from
poor
nutrition
before,
during
and
after
pregnancy
including:
gestational
diabetes,
anemia,
hypertension,
obesity,
weight
gain
and
inadequate
infant
feeding
methods.2This
national
crisis
disproportionally
affects
women
of
minority
and
low-income
groups
of
which
are
in
high
population
within
city
centers
like
Detroit.
Within
the
city
of
Detroit
the
overall
infant
mortality
rate
is
alarmingly
higher
than
the
national
average
at
13.3
deaths
per
1000
births.3
Detroits
maternal
mortality
rate,
keeping
with
the
trend
is
exceedingly
high
at
an
average
of
six
pregnancy-associated
deaths
per
year.4
Conditions
that
can
contribute
to
these
rates
are
gestational
diabetes,
obesity
and
hypertension.
Sadly
all
of
these
conditions
often
can
be
prevented
and
treated
with
nutritional
intervention.
In
this
assessment
we
will
look
at
pregnancy
nutrition
status
in
relation
to
maternal
and
infant
health
outcomes
within
the
city
of
Detroit.
This
will
identify
the
potential
need
for
more
nutritional
resources
to
help
support
healthy
pregnancies
in
Detroit.
Just
within
the
state
of
Michigan
infant
mortality
rates
are
at
6.9
deaths
per
1000
births
compared
to
the
national
average
of
6
with
a
glaring
race
disparity
of
13.1
deaths
in
black
infants
compared
to
5.7
of
white
infants
in
2013.5
In
addition
to
infant
mortality
Michigan
has
the
8th
highest
pregnancy
related
maternal
mortality
rates
within
the
country.6
Nutritionally,
pregnant
women
in
Michigan
experience
higher
percentages
of
excessive
weight
gain
during
pregnancy,
higher
rates
of
anemia,
and
slightly
higher
rates
of
obesity.7
While
nutrition
is
only
a
small
way
to
combat
maternal
and
child
death
it
can
greatly
improve
quality
of
life
and
reduce
risk
of
mother
and
child
developing
chronic
diseases,
especially
in
Detroit
where
there
is
so
many
other
environmental
hazards
threatening
pregnancy
health
every
day.
Most
of
these
risks
are
solely
due
to
city
infrastructure
like
lack
of
sidewalks,
exposure
to
industry
pollutants,
social
stress,
and
inadequate
healthcare
services.
In
conjunction
with
environmental
stressors
Detroits
population
is
also
largely
comprised
of
minority
populations,
many
of
which
have
greater
risks
of
developing
harmful
conditions
during
pregnancy
from
exposure
to
more
stressors.
Michigan
Department
of
Community
Health
reported
that
in
2008
black
women
were
exposed
to
3
or
more
stressors
more
often
than
white
women.
Education
also
played
a
major
role
in
exposures
to
stressor
for
pregnant
women
in
Michigan
65.6%
of
women
who
did
not
finish
high
school
were
exposed
to
three
or
more
life
stressors.
All
these
stressors
are
often
out
of
womens
control,
but
maintaining
a
healthy
diet
is
within
their
control
if
given
the
proper
resources.
Proper
prenatal
nutrition
not
only
lowers
the
risk
of
maternal
complications
during
pregnancy,
it
can
help
to
support
a
healthy
weight
for
the
child
which
lower
its
risk
for
chronic
diseases
and
obesity
later
in
life.
By
assessing
the
prevalence
of
healthy
pregnancies
in
Detroit
important
information
on
what
nutritional
support
may
be
needed
for
women
in
Detroit
to
have
access
to
all
the
tools
to
maintain
a
healthy
and
full
term
pregnancy.
Connolly
Demographics
Detroit
spans
across
138.75
square
miles
and
houses
680,250
residents
and
has
seen
a
rapid
decrease
in
the
population
since
its
population
peak
in
the
1950s
as
illustrated
in
Figure
1.
Connolly
Figure
2
taken
from:
http://milmi.org/admin/uploadedPublications/2343_Detroit_City_Demographic_and_Lab
or_Mkt_Profile.pdf
Figure
3
taken
from:
http://milmi.org/admin/uploadedPublications/2343_Detroit_City_Demographic_and_Lab
or_Mkt_Profile.pdf
Among
Detroits
population
21.4%
of
the
population
25
years
and
older
have
not
achieved
a
high
school
diploma,
32%
have
a
high
school
education,
33.5%
have
some
college,
7.6%
have
a
bachelors
degree
and
only
5.4%
have
a
post
graduate
degree.
The
combined
population
of
people
that
do
not
have
higher
than
a
high
school
diploma
in
Detroit
is
higher
than
the
state
proportion
at
53.4%
2015
Federal
compared
to
40.3%
.10
The
dropout
rate
for
Persons
in
Poverty
Level
threshold
household
100%
FPL
black
males
is
especially
high
with
only
a
54.6%
1
$11,770
graduation
rate
compared
to
the
69.8%
rate
of
black
girls.
11
More
than
50%
of
the
working
2
15,930
population
in
Detroit
holds
an
associates
degree
3
20,090
or
less,
Figure
3
contains
the
entire
breakdown
4
24,250
as
of
2011.
Pre-term
births
are
less
prevalent
in
women
with
higher
education
levels,
but
as
of
5
28,410
2009
29
%
of
heads
of
household
in
Detroit
did
6
32,570
not
hold
high
school
diplomas.12
The
most
commonly
used
language
in
the
home
is
English,
7
36,730
but
11%
of
children
and
6%
of
adults
speak
8
40,890
Spanish
at
home
in
the
Detroit-Warren-
Dearborn
area
which
is
double
the
statewide
rates.
The
dominating
industry
of
both
residents
and
commuters
in
Detroit
is
health
care
and
social
assistance
followed
by
manufacturing
and
retail.
The
majority
of
the
citys
working
residents
are
black
(77%),
however,
the
majority
of
commuters
(55.8%)
are
Connolly
white.
There
is
also
a
significant
gender
gap
in
the
workforce
in
Detroit
with
women
making
up
the
majority
of
the
resident
workforce
(58%).13
It
is
important
to
note
that
the
majority
of
the
jobs
in
Detroit
are
concentrated
in
the
midtown
region,
but
the
city
workforce
residence
is
spread
throughout
the
entire
span
of
the
city.
Unemployment
rate
was
at
14.9%
in
2014,
more
than
double
the
Michigan
average
of
7.2%
and
the
national
average
of
6.1%.
Detroit
also
had
a
poverty
level
that
was
over
two
times
the
state
national
average
at
39.3%
of
the
population
live
compared
to
16.8%,
figure
4
breaks
down
the
federal
guidelines
used
to
determine
poverty
level.
The
median
household
income
in
Detroit
from
2009-2013
was
$26,325,
a
little
more
than
half
of
the
statewide
average
of
$48,411
and
the
national
average
of
$53,046.14
The
average
persons
per
household
in
Detroit
were
2.7
in
2014,
which
is
only
slightly
higher
than
the
state
average
of
2.53.
Of
those
households,
unmarried
women
ran
43%,
which
is
more
than
double
Michigans
rate
at
17%.
The
percent
of
married
couples
in
Detroit
households
is
27%,
about
half
the
rate
in
Michigan
at
59%.
Health
Statistic
Data
The
leading
cause
of
mortality
in
Detroit
in
2013
was
heart
disease,
followed
by
cancer
and
accidents
as
shown
in
figure
5.
This
reflects
the
causes
of
mortality
in
the
entire
state
of
Michigan
closely
as
shown
in
figure
6.
For
individuals
under
the
age
of
25
the
leading
cause
of
death
shifts
to
unintentional
injuries
accounting
for
19%
of
deaths
in
Detroits
population
under
25.
After
25
the
leading
cause
of
death
stays
consistent
to
heart
disease.15
Split
between
men
and
women
Detroit
mortality
rates
in
2013
were
fairly
even,
with
the
exception
of
men
accounting
for
66.1%
of
unintentional
injuries,
84.2%
of
suicides
and
women
accounting
for
69%
of
deaths
from
Alzheimers
disease
as
shown
in
figure
8.
Wayne
County
(including
Detroit)
in
2013
ranked
last
in
the
community
health
rankings
report
in
both
health
outcomes
and
health
factors.
Health
outcomes
were
measured
according
to
mortality
and
morbidity
data
and
health
factors
was
determined
based
on
a
multitude
of
factors
including
tobacco
use,
diet
and
exercise,
alcohol
use,
and
sexual
activity.16
Connolly
Figure
5
taken
from:
http://www.mdch.state.mi.us/pha/osr/chi/deaths/frame.asp?Topic=7&Mode=1
Figure
6
taken
from:
http://www.mdch.state.mi.us/pha/osr/chi/deaths/frame.asp?Topic=7&Mode=1
Connolly
Infant
mortality
rate
in
Detroit
was
13.3
deaths
per
1000
births
in
2013,
more
than
double
the
state
and
national
average.
There
is
a
clear
racial
disparity
in
the
state
of
Michigan
in
infant
mortality,
the
adjusted
rate
for
white
people
in
Michigan
is
5.7
and
for
black
people
the
rate
is
13.1.17
Figure
9
illustrates
these
rates
in
comparison
to
the
national
averages
over
the
past
20
years.
According
to
the
Healthy
Michigan
Low
birth
weight
is
the
leading
cause
of
infant
mortality
for
both
black
and
white
infants
in
Michigan,
it
affects
black
infants
much
more
than
white
infants.
Low
birth
weight
is
defined
as
any
live
birth
resulting
in
an
infant
weighing
less
than
2500
grams.
During
the
past
decade,
black
infants
have
been
four
to
five
times
more
likely
to
die
of
this
condition
than
white
infants.
Live
births
to
black
mothers
in
2001
had
the
highest
proportion
of
LBW,
14.2%,
compared
to
white
(6.7%),
American
Indian
(8.3%),
and
Asian
mothers
(7.7%)
respectively.
Mothers
with
inadequate
prenatal
care
had
13.7%
incidence
of
LBW
in
2001
while
those
with
adequate
care
had
7.2%.18
Table
10
shows
the
percent
of
low
birth
weight
babies
by
race
from
2010-2012.
Connolly
Figure
9
adapted
from:
"Number
and
Rate
of
Infant
Deaths
by
Race,
Michigan
and
US."
Number
and
Rate
of
Infant
Deaths
by
Race,
Michigan
and
US.
Accessed
November
7,
2015.
http://www.mdch.state.mi.us/pha/osr/InDxMain/infdx.ASP.
Figure
10
taken
from:
http://datadrivendetroit.org/birthrate/moms-place-and-low-
birth-weight-part-1-detroit/
In
Detroit
the
rate
of
children
born
to
teen
mothers
was
36
for
every
1000.
19
Children
with
teen
parents
face
an
increase
risk
of
preterm
birth
and
fetal
distress.
Over
100,000
people
in
Detroit
remain
uninsured
and
in
Wayne
county
7.9%
of
pregnant
women
never
receive
medical
care
during
pregnancy.
Detroit
has
the
second
highest
prevalence
of
obesity
in
the
state
of
Michigan
at
38.1%
and
in
2008
black
females
had
the
highest
obesity
rates
out
of
any
race
and
sex
group
in
the
state.
In
2008
obese
individuals
had
the
highest
rates
of
asthma,
angina,
stroke,
diabetes,
and
inadequate
sleep.
Obesity
is
linked
to
greater
ricks
in
complications
during
pregnancy
including
preeclampsia,
gestational
diabetes,
stillbirth
and
cesarean
delivery.
20
PRAMS
2001-2005
data
found
that
women
28%
of
women
at
obesity
status
had
cesarean
deliveries
compared
to
the
17.5%
at
healthy
weights.21
Obesity
is
caused
by
factors
including
nutritional
status,
physical
exercise
habits,
and
genetics.
Only
19.5%
of
Michigan
residents
met
the
aerobic
and
muscle-strengthening
guidelines
set
by
the
CDC
and
24.4%
do
not
engage
in
any
kind
of
leisure
time
physical
activity.
According
to
Michigan
PRAMMS
2008
18.3%
of
women
who
were
uninsured
were
also
obese,
the
numbers
were
not
available
for
cross
sectional
link
age,
obesity
status,
and
insurance
coverage.
Michigans
rate
of
gestational
diabetes
was
6.9%
in
2012-2014,
gestational
diabetes
is
often
found
at
about
24
weeks
of
pregnancy
and
is
more
prevalent
in
women
of
color.
Gestational
diabetes
increases
the
infants
risk
of
becoming
overweight
or
obese
during
childhood
and
adolescence.
Women
with
gestational
diabetes
have
an
increased
risk
of
having
a
cesarean,
preeclampsia,
and
development
of
permanent
type
2
diabetes.
GDM
can
be
diagnosed
with
an
oral
glucose
tolerance
test
(OGTT).
GDM
is
diagnosed
if
two
or
more
plasma
glucose
levels
meet
or
exceed
the
following
thresholds:
fasting
glucose
concentration
of
95
mg/dl,
1-hour
glucose
concentration
of
180
mg/dl,
2-hour
glucose
concentration
of
155
mg/dl,
or
3-hour
glucose
concentration
of
140
mg/dl.22
Detroit
women
had
10%
incidence
of
hypertension
during
pregnancy,
this
is
in
line
with
the
state
average
of
10.1%.23
Hypertensions
is
especially
dangerous
because
it
puts
the
expecting
mother
at
risk
of
preeclampsia,
or
high
blood
pressure
during
pregnancy
Connolly
which
can
lead
to
preterm
delivery,
maternal
stroke
and
death.
Hypertension
can
increase
maternal
risk
of
developing
gestational
diabetes.24
Nutrition
Assessment
Data
According
to
Michigan
WIC
Pregnancy
Nutrition
Surveillance
15.9%
of
women
took
a
multivitamin
daily
before
pregnancy,
but
during
pregnancy
83.8%
of
women
added
taking
a
multivitamin
to
their
daily
regimen.
Compliance
with
a
routine
of
multivitamin
consumption
during
pregnancy
can
help
reduce
infant
birth
defects,
maternal
anemia,
and
provide
diet
in
nutrients
that
are
harder
to
adequately
consume
with
diet
alone
like
folic
acid,
calcium,
and
iron.
Most
prenatal
vitamins
contain
essential
nutrients
that
may
be
missing
from
an
expecting
mothers
diet
like
folic
acid,
calcium,
iron,
iodine,
vitamin
B6
and
omega
3
fatty
acids.
According
to
the
National
Health
and
Nutrition
Survey
(NHANES)
the
median
for
all
pregnancies
in
2005-2010
was
less
than
adequate
in
iodine
concentrations
(>129
g/L).25
Statewide
Michigans
prevalence
of
anemia
was
high
in
2014
at
10.1%
in
the
first
trimester,
15.4%
in
the
second,
39.6%
in
the
third,
and
28.7%
postpartum.
Inadequate
intakes
of
iron
can
lead
to
fatigue,
infection,
preterm
birth,
and
low
birth
weight.
Figure
11taken
from:
http://www.mdch.state.mi.us/pha/osr/natality/tab1.2.asp
According
to
the
Michigan
Department
of
Community
Health
(figure
11)
only
17.4%
of
women
age
18-24
self
reported
adequate
fruit
and
vegetable
consumption
in
2008
this
age
group
makes
up
for
about
24%
of
Michigan
women
who
gave
birth
in
2013.26
In
Detroit
18.3%
of
the
adult
population
consumed
5
or
more
servings
of
vegetables
a
day,
which
is
higher
than
the
state
average
of
16.6%.
In
Michigan
women
had
higher
rates
of
fruit
and
vegetable
consumption
at
19.7%
of
the
population
consuming
5
or
more
servings
per
day.
27
A
larger
portion
of
the
statewide
population
ate
less
than
one
Connolly
fruit
(37.7%)
and
less
than
one
vegetable
(24.8%)
in
2013.
In
2005
80%
of
Michigan
adults
visited
a
fast
food
establishment
at
least
once
a
month
and
28%
went
two
or
more
times
a
week.28
This
lack
of
adequate
consumption
may
be
due
to
built
environment.
Of
Detroits
food
retailers
only
8%
can
be
considered
mainstream
grocery
retailers,
the
other
92%
is
comprised
of
liquor
stores,
pharmacies,
gas
stations,
dollars
stores
and
other
convenience
stores.
These
liquor
and
party
stores
accounts
for
the
greatest
number
of
food
stamp
retailers
in
Detroit,
figure
12
illustrates
the
entire
spread
of
food
stamp
retailers
in
Detroit
and
figure
13
shows
the
geographic
distance
of
Detroit
neighborhoods
from
full
service
supermarkets.29
Figures
12
and
13
taken
from:
"Detroit
Food
Desert
Report."
2007.
Accessed
November
8,
2015.30
Detroit
has
a
poor
walk
score
of
52
(100
being
the
best)
meaning
that
most
amenities
are
not
accessible
by
foot.
30
This
includes
grocery
stores
and
healthcare
clinic
where
many
women
receive
their
pregnancy
check
ups.
10
Connolly
Community
Assets
and
Existing
Services
Despite
Detroits
lack
of
environmental
and
built
resources
there
is
a
robust
network
of
resources
for
expecting
mothers.
There
is
two
WIC
(Women
Infants
and
Children)
offices
in
Detroit
which
offers
supplemental
nutrition
for
women,
infants
and
children
five
years
and
younger.
WIC
also
offers
nutrition
education
on
topics
like
breast-
feeding,
infant
and
toddler
feeding,
prenatal
weight
gain
and
anemia
and
iron
deficiency.
High-risk
patients
are
offered
individualized
counseling
and
WIC
participants
are
provided
health
care
referrals
and
connections
to
social
services
if
needed.
WIC
participants
have
improved
dietary
intake,
lower
incidence
of
low
birth
weight
babies,
and
lower
infant
mortality
than
other
Medicaid
beneficiaries.31
Medicaid
is
also
available
to
Detroit
mothers
in
need
of
insurance
after
becoming
pregnant.
Medicaid
for
pregnant
women
is
available
for
the
duration
of
their
pregnancy
and
two
months
after
their
delivery.32
Access
to
regular
doctors
visits
is
vital
to
a
healthy
pregnancy
so
doctors
can
assess
risk
factors
early
and
make
the
necessary
steps
to
curb
the
risk
of
mothers
developing
conditions
like
GDM
and
hypertension.
In
addition
to
government
resources
there
are
many
community-based
ventures
like
the
Women
Inspired
Neighborhood
center
(WIN).
WIN
offers
comprehensive
support
and
resources
to
expecting
mothers
that
extends
beyond
just
food
resources
and
gives
mothers
access
to
community
support
they
may
not
have
received
otherwise.
WIN
has
an
abundance
of
online
resources
detailing
basic
physical
exercises
during
pregnancy,
healthy
eating
guidelines,
and
advice
on
how
to
navigate
financing
healthcare
during
pregnancy.
WIN
also
offers
help
in
creating
a
supportive
community
that
can
allow
women
the
resources
and
flexibility
to
commit
to
healthy
lifestyle
choices
during
pregnancy.33Women
who
already
have
children
can
also
attend
meetings
like
Parent
Anonymous
Support
Group
through
Detroit
Parent
Network,
which
provides
a
safe
space
for
women
to
talk
to
others
about
their
concerns
and
free
childcare
during
each
event.34
Focus:
Hope
in
Detroit
also
offers
Doula
support
and
breastfeeding
counseling
which
can
also
help
lead
to
the
success
of
a
pregnancy
as
well
as
food
supplies
for
both
women
and
children
under
the
age
of
six.35
For
emergency
food
support
GLEANERS
food
bank
can
and
332
other
food
pantries
are
available
for
pregnant
Detroiters.36Health
Emergency
Lifelines
Programs
(HELP)
is
also
available
for
women
in
need
of
food
vouchers
and
dietary
supplements,
especially
expectant
mothers
who
are
HIV
positive.37
The
Community
Health
and
Social
Services
Center
also
provides
prenatal
care
for
expectant
mothers
including
physical
exams,
weight
checks,
blood
pressure,
laboratory
screening,
and
fetal
assessment.
First
time
moms
in
this
program
can
be
eligible
to
Doula
services
up
to
six
months
post
partum.38
Besides
supportive
resources
Detroit
there
are
food
distribution
options.
Six
of
Detroits
farmers
markets
accept
SNAP,
WIC,
and
participate
in
double
up
food
bucks
a
Michigan
program
that
rewards
bridge
card
holders
for
buying
Michigan
local
produce
by
matching
what
the
person
spends
up
to
$20,
so
the
card
holder
gets
up
to
$20
more
groceries.
The
participating
farmers
markets
are:
Eastern
Market,
Northwest
Detroit
Farmers
Market,
Sowing
Seeds
Growing
Futures
Farmers
Market,
Wayne
State
University
Farmers
Market,
Oakland
Avenue
Farmers
Market,
and
Islandview
Farmers
Market.39
Local
urban
garden
networks
supply
many
of
these
markets
like
Feedom
Freedom
and
11
Connolly
Keep
Growing
Detroit
that
supply
community
members
with
tools
to
produce
their
own
food
instead
of
relying
on
the
unpredictable
cooperate
food
system
in
Detroit.40
Discussion
There
is
no
specific
measurement
of
a
healthy
pregnancy,
but
through
study
of
maternal
and
child
mortality,
nutrition
assessments,
and
access
to
healthcare
it
can
be
reasonably
concluded
that
Detroit
is
rating
poorly
in
prenatal
care.
Detroit
is
a
unique
city
with
a
tumultuous
history
of
racial
tensions
and
economic
hardships.
The
city
itself
is
in
disrepair
with
over
forty
square
miles
of
vacant
land,
which
is
enough
to
fit
the
entire
city
of
San
Francisco.41
It
has
the
third
highest
arson
rate
in
the
country
at
136
arsons
per
100,000
people
and
14,500
violent
crimes
committed
in
2013.42
43
Detroit
is
highly
segregated
between
blacks
(the
majority)
and
whites
rating
a
dissimilarity
index
of
73.5
with
0
indicating
complete
integration
and
100
indicating
complete
separation.44
Since
1990
Detroit
has
lost
over
67%
of
its
primary
care
physicians
due
to
suburbanization
and
economic
hardship,
but
maintains
the
highest
chronic
disease
rates
in
the
metro
area.45
Figure
14
highlights
the
disparities
in
chronic
disease
prevalence
in
2010.
Figure
14
taken
from:
https://www.henryford.com/documents/CommunityHealth/2013%20HFHS%20CHNA_Fi
nal.pdf
Detroit
had
the
highest
rats
of
arthritis
and
cardiovascular
disease
out
of
any
other
county.
Cardiovascular
disease
can
be
combatted
with
exercise
and
healthy
diet;
unfortunately
with
Detroits
high
crime
rate
and
lack
of
community
spaces
there
are
not
many
options
for
outdoor
physical
activity.
In
2013
the
city
closed
over
50
parks
leaving
them
to
dangerous
disrepair
and
chose
only
19
premier
parks
to
continue
maintenance
on.
This
means
that
in
2013
there
was
one
park
for
every
12,280
residents.46
Despite
the
decreasing
rates
of
outdoor
recreational
space
Detroit
has
a
booming
urban
farming
and
gardening
movement
that
has
led
to
the
development
of
over
1,300
gardens
in
Detroit.
Community
members
and
local
nonprofits
that
seek
to
bring
food
security
to
Detroit
through
local
food
production
support
these
gardens.
These
12
Connolly
movements
are
gaining
important
public
recognition
on
the
food
security
issue
in
Detroit,
but
there
is
some
concern
over
the
safety
of
these
urban
farms.
Many
of
these
gardens
sit
on
vacant
land
that
used
to
have
a
home
or
other
building
structure
that
has
since
been
torn
down.
These
previous
structures
could
have
left
behind
toxic
chemicals
and
metals
like
lead
and
arsenic
in
the
soil
that
is
now
being
used
to
provide
communities
that
already
have
higher
rates
of
chronic
diseases
with
food.47
What
does
all
this
have
to
do
with
healthy
pregnancies?
Studies
done
in
2014
showed
that
African
American
women
with
high
stress
often
have
worse
birth
outcomes.
The
sources
of
stress
were
racial
discrimination,
neighborhood,
job
or
financial,
and
the
woman's
network
(family
members,
friends).48
Chronic
stress
can
lead
to
excessive
production
of
cortisol,
epinephrine
and
norepinephrine,
which
could
cause
preterm
labor
and
compromised
immune
response.49
Figure
15
shows
the
number
of
hardships
during
pregnancy
broken
down
by
percent
federal
poverty
level.
Figure
15
taken
from:
http://www.unnaturalcauses.org/assets/uploads/file/Braveman_NIH_Summit_12-12-
08.pdf
Addressing
these
issues
in
conjunction
with
healthy
pregnancies
is
key
to
creating
recommendations
that
include
holistic
care
plans
for
pregnant
women.
Nutrition
in
any
situation
is
just
the
tip
of
the
iceberg
with
health
comes;
it
is
rarely
the
sole
cause
of
a
health
issue
with
exception
to
cases
of
vitamin
deficiency.
Recommendations
These
findings
suggest
several
key
factors
in
improving
the
nutritional
health
of
pregnant
women
in
Detroit.
There
are
many
steps
that
need
to
be
taken
to
create
observable
change
in
the
community,
though
as
stated
earlier
nutrition
is
just
a
small
part
of
the
infant
mortality
crisis
in
Detroit.
First
based
on
the
findings
more
than
just
high
risk
13
Connolly
women
need
nutritional
counseling
with
a
goal
of
increasing
maternal
consumption
of
fruits
and
vegetables.
Through
cooperation
with
Detroit
public
schools
nutrition
education
needs
to
begin
in
the
classroom
not
just
through
provision
of
healthy
food
services
but
also
through
classroom
instruction
on
healthy
diets.
Through
participation
in
cooking,
growing
and
consumption
of
food
children
can
learn
early
the
power
food
has
on
quality
of
life.
This
is
a
long
term
goal
with
the
hope
that
eventually
Detroits
population
may
be
equip
with
the
tools
to
maintain
healthy
prenatal
nutrition
care
on
their
own.
More
immediately
expectant
mothers
need
to
be
provided
with
personalized
nutrition
counseling
as
early
as
their
first
check
up
to
ensure
optimal
prenatal
nutritional
health
through
to
help
prevent
GDM,
hypertension
and
fetal
abnormalities
so
nutrition
can
act
as
a
preventative
health
measure,
instead
of
a
way
to
curb
a
developed
condition
like
gestational
diabetes.
Continuing
to
support
local
groups
like
WIN
could
help
improve
not
only
the
health
status
of
pregnant
women,
but
also
all
women.
This
is
in
mind
city
support
of
programs
like
Keep
Growing
Detroit,
Detroit
Food
Justice
Task
Force
and
Detroit
Food
Policy
council
will
equip
community
members
with
the
tools
to
support
healthy
households.
These
organizations
support
nutrition
education,
participation
in
urban
agriculture
and
teach
value
skills
like
cooking
and
food
preservation
that
can
help
mothers
and
fathers
provide
balanced
meals
to
their
children.
Nutrition
education
is
vital
to
the
continued
care
of
a
pregnancy,
but
what
is
most
vital
is
that
women
have
access
to
the
resources
needed.
It
is
recommended
that
the
city
do
a
full
assessment
on
public
transportation
efficiency
and
that
local
NGOs
work
with
partners
to
provide
rides
to
women
around
the
community
to
their
doctors
and
grocery
store
of
choice.
These
non-profits
also
need
to
address
the
issue
of
childcare,
as
43
percent
of
the
households
in
Detroit
are
single
mother
homes.
Mothers
need
to
be
allowed
childcare
on
days
she
had
appointments
and
they
cannot
always
rely
on
the
thinly
spread
community.
The
city
also
needs
to
address
the
issue
of
food
insecurity,
it
has
already
been
identified
that
persons
of
color
living
below
the
poverty
line
are
the
most
vulnerable
to
changes
in
food
availability.
Now
that
the
individuals
in
needs
have
been
identified
providing
food
resources
like
food
pantries
and
soup
kitchens
can
allow
some
in
this
group,
including
mothers,
maintain
a
healthy
lifestyle.
Most
people
signed
up
for
SNAP
benefits
are
within
1
mile
of
a
SNAP
office,
further
outreach
to
people
farther
from
these
offices
need
to
be
made.
Another
huge
issue
in
Detroit
pregnancies
is
the
prevalence
of
overweight
and
obese
women
who
have
an
increased
risk
of
complications
during
pregnancy.
Aside
from
changes
in
built
environment
community
groups
and
support
are
needed
to
begin
to
combat
these
rates.
Group
doctors
visits
and
meetings
are
a
good
way
to
encourage
positive
social
pressure
on
women
to
maintain
a
healthy
pregnancy.
Better
compliance
with
prenatal
vitamins
is
also
needed
considering
the
rate
of
anemia
and
iodine
deficiency
in
Michigan
mothers.
Offering
free
and
readily
available
prenatal
vitamins
could
help
with
compliance
as
well
as
access
to
resources
for
many
Detroit
women.
The
most
effective
plan
from
supporting
nutritionally
healthy
pregnancies
would
be
for
Detroits
Department
of
Community
Health
to
conduct
a
comprehensive
community
nutrition
study.
With
the
data
available
right
now
we
know
that
nutrition
status
might
play
a
role
in
perinatal
health
and
development
of
conditions
like
gestational
diabetes,
but
14
Connolly
there
is
no
hard
data
to
back
up
these
claims.
Modeling
an
initiative
like
Ypsilantis
Health
Improvement
Plan
(HIP)
to
conduct
phone
surveys
to
understand
Detroits
unique
health
culture
would
be
a
good
start
followed
by
more
comprehensive
testing
for
nutritional
biomarkers
in
Detroits
population.
There
is
a
clear
and
observable
disparity
between
birth
outcomes
of
black
women,
which
make
up
the
majority
of
the
population
in
Detroit,
but
there
is
no
clear
evidence
that
there
is
one
identifiable
cause
such
as
inadequate
nutrition.
Latina
and
Hispanic
populations
have
relatively
good
with
outcome
despite
poverty
status
it
is
only
when
you
look
at
the
US
born
black
population
that
there
is
clearly
unfavorable
outcomes.
Better
access
to
nutrition
is
not
going
to
be
the
answer
to
lower
maternal
and
infant
mortality
rates
in
Detroit,
but
obtaining
more
comprehensive
data
on
the
average
diet
and
deficiencies
of
Detroits
population
may
give
us
important
incites
to
the
social
and
physical
causes
of
poor
pregnancy
outcomes,
particularly
that
of
the
black
community.
15
Connolly
Appendix
Predominant
Race
by
2010
Census
Tracks
Taken
from
:
http://www.newdetroit.org/docs/press/MetropolitanDetroit_RaceEquity_Report_NewDet
roit.pdf
16
Connolly
Proximity
to
Food
Pantry
among
Michigan
Low
Income
Households
Taken
from:
http://www.irp.wisc.edu/publications/focus/pdfs/foc321b.pdf
17
Connolly
References:
1
"COUNTRY
COMPARISON
::
INFANT
MORTALITY
RATE."
Central
Intelligence
Agency.
Accessed
November
3,
2015.
https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world-
factbook/rankorder/2091rank.html.
2
"Pregnancy
Complications."
Centers
for
Disease
Control
and
Prevention.
September
29,
2015.
Accessed
November
4,
2015.
http://www.cdc.gov/reproductivehealth/maternalinfanthealth/pregcomplications.htm.
3
"Number
of
Infant
Deaths
for
Selected
Cities
of
Residence."
Michigan
Department
of
Community
Health.
Accessed
November
3,
2015.
http://www.mdch.state.mi.us/pha/osr/InDxMain/Tab4.asp.
4
"Detroit
Has
Highest
Maternal
Mortality
Rate
-
Birth
Injury
Guide."
Birth
Injury
Guide.
August
22,
2014.
Accessed
November
5,
2015.
http://www.birthinjuryguide.org/2014/08/detroit-highest-maternal-mortality-rate/.
5
"Number
and
Rate
of
Infant
Deaths
by
Race,
Michigan
and
US."
Number
and
Rate
of
Infant
Deaths
by
Race,
Michigan
and
US.
Accessed
November
3,
2015.
http://www.mdch.state.mi.us/pha/osr/InDxMain/infdx.ASP.
6http://www.michigan.gov/documents/mdch/2013Status_of_Michigan_Maternal_Mortalit
y_445366_7.pdf
7
"2014
Pregnancy
Nutriton
Surveillance-
Michigan."
Michigan
Department
of
Community
Health.
May
12,
2015.
Accessed
November
5,
2015.
http://www.michigan.gov/documents/mdch/MI_PNSS_2014_State_495462_7.pdf.
8
"Detroit,
MI
Population
and
Races."
-
USA.com.
Accessed
November
5,
2015.
http://www.usa.com/detroit-mi-population-and-races.htm.
9
"Your
Geography
Selections-
Detroit."
American
FactFinder.
Accessed
November
5,
2015.
http://factfinder.census.gov/faces/tableservices/jsf/pages/productview.xhtml?src=CF.
10http://milmi.org/admin/uploadedPublications/2343_Detroit_City_Demographic_and_La
bor_Mkt_Profile.pdf
11
Data
Driven
Detroit.
Accessed
November
5,
2015.
http://datadrivendetroit.org/web_ftp/Project_Docs/DETKidsDrft_FINAL.pdf.
12
Tsoi-A-Fatt,
Rhonda.
"Keeping
Youth
Connected:
Focus
on
Detroit."
July
1,
2009.
Accessed
November
6,
2015.
http://www.clasp.org/resources-and-
publications/files/Detroit-Profile.pdf.
13
"City
Demographic
Labor
and
Market
Profile."
April
1,
2015.
Accessed
November
5,
2015.
http://milmi.org/admin/uploadedPublications/2343_Detroit_City_Demographic_and_Lab
or_Mkt_Profile.pdf.
14
"USA
QuickFacts
from
the
US
Census
Bureau."
USA
QuickFacts
from
the
US
Census
Bureau.
Accessed
November
6,
2015.
http://quickfacts.census.gov/qfd/states/00000.html.
15
"Community
Health
Information--Mortality."
Community
Health
Information--Mortality.
Accessed
November
6,
2015.
http://www.mdch.state.mi.us/pha/osr/chi/deaths/frame.asp?Topic=6.
16
http://www.countyhealthrankings.org/sites/default/files/states/CHR2013_MI_0.pdf
18
Connolly
17
"Number
and
Rate
of
Infant
Deaths
by
Race,
Michigan
and
US."
Number
and
Rate
of
Infant
Deaths
by
Race,
Michigan
and
US.
Accessed
November
7,
2015.
http://www.mdch.state.mi.us/pha/osr/InDxMain/infdx.ASP.
18
https://www.michigan.gov/documents/Healthy_Michigan_2010_1_88117_7.pdf
19
"Keeping
Youth
Connected:
Focus
on
Detroit."
July
1,
2009.
Accessed
November
8,
2015.
http://www.clasp.org/resources-and-publications/files/Detroit-Profile.pdf.
20"Pregnancy
Complications."
Centers
for
Disease
Control
and
Prevention.
September
29,
2015.
Accessed
November
4,
2015.
http://www.cdc.gov/reproductivehealth/maternalinfanthealth/pregcomplications.htm.
21
"Body
Mass
Index
and
Mode
of
Delivery."
Accessed
November
9,
2015.
http://www.michigan.gov/documents/mdch/ObesityJuly07Final_206632_7.pdf.
22
"Clinical
Diabetes."
Gestational
Diabetes
Mellitus.
Accessed
November
9,
2015.
http://clinical.diabetesjournals.org/content/23/1/17.full.
24
"Pregnancy
Complications."
Centers
for
Disease
Control
and
Prevention.
September
29,
2015.
Accessed
November
8,
2015.
http://www.cdc.gov/reproductivehealth/maternalinfanthealth/pregcomplications.htm.
25
Caldwell,
Kathleen.
"Iodine
Status
in
Pregnant
Women
in
the
National
Childrens
Study
and
in
U.S.
Women
(1544
Years),
National
Health
and
Nutrition
Examination
Survey
20052010."
November
8,
2013.
Accessed
November
8,
2015.
http://health.gov/dietaryguidelines/dga2015/comments/uploads/CID54_Reference_4.pd
f.
26
http://www.mdch.state.mi.us/pha/osr/natality/tab1.2.asp
27
"Fruit
and
Vegetable
Consumption
Among
Michigan
Adults
(2013)."
Accessed
November
8,
2015.
http://www.countyhealthrankings.org/sites/default/files/states/CHR2013_MI_0.pdf.
28
Centers
for
Disease
Control
and
Prevention.
Accessed
November
8,
2015.
http://www.cdc.gov/pcd/issues/2011/jul/10_0186.htm.
29
"Detroit
Food
Desert
Report."
2007.
Accessed
November
8,
2015.
http://www.uconnruddcenter.org/resources/upload/docs/what/policy/DetroitFoodDese
rtReport.pdf.
30
"Cities
in
Michigan."
Walk
Score.
Accessed
November
8,
2015.
https://www.walkscore.com/MI/.
31
"You
Are
HereMDHHS
Assistance
Programs
Women,
Infants
&
Children
About
WIC."
MDHHS.
Accessed
November
9,
2015.
http://www.michigan.gov/mdhhs/0,5885,7-339-
71547_4910_6329-12669--,00.html.
32
"You
Are
HereMDHHS
Assistance
Programs
Medicaid."
MDHHS.
Accessed
November
9,
2015.
http://www.michigan.gov/mdhhs/0,5885,7-339-71547_4860-35199--,00.html.
33
"WIN
Network
|
Paying
for
Doctor's
Visits."
WIN
Network
Paying
for
Doctors
Visits
Comments.
Accessed
November
9,
2015.
http://www.winnetworkdetroit.org/article/paying-for-doctors-visits/.
34
http://www.detroitparentnetwork.org/content/trainings
35
FOCUS:HOPE-
Doulas
and
Breastfeeding
Services.
Accessed
November
8,
2015.
http://www.focushope.edu/page.aspx?content_id=457&content_type=level3.
19
Connolly
36
http://www.irp.wisc.edu/publications/focus/pdfs/foc321b.pdf
37
http://www.yellowpages.com/detroit-mi/mip/health-emergency-lifeline-programs-
262886
38
"Prenatal
Care."
Prenatal
Care.
Accessed
November
9,
2015.
39
"Find
a
Farmers
Market
-
Michigan
Farmers
Market
Association
(MIFMA)."
Michigan
Farmers
Market
Association
MIFMA.
Accessed
November
9,
2015.
http://mifma.org/find-
a-farmers-market/?county=&city=Detroit&day=.
40
https://feedomfreedom.wordpress.com/about/
41
"Detroit
Has
Tons
of
Vacant
Land.
But
Forty
Square
Miles?"
Detroit
Has
Tons
of
Vacant
Land.
But
Forty
Square
Miles?
April
18,
2012.
Accessed
November
9,
2015.
42
Abbey-Lambertz,
Kate.
"Detroit's
Staggering
Murder
And
Violent
Crime
Rate
Are
'A
Public
Health
Issue'"
The
Huffington
Post.
November
14,
2014.
Accessed
November
9,
2015.
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2014/11/14/detroit-highest-murder-rate-violent-
crime_n_6144460.html.
43
Gridley@mlive.com,
Gary.
"A
Look
at
10
Cities
with
Highest
Arson
Rates
in
the
Country."
March
25,
2013.
Accessed
November
9,
2015.
http://www.mlive.com/news/flint/index.ssf/2013/03/burning_flint_10_cities_with_t_1.ht
ml.
44
Cruz,
John.
"Metro
Detroit's
Foreign
Born
Population."
Global
Detroit.
March
3,
2014.
Accessed
November
9,
2015.
http://www.globaldetroit.com/wp-
content/uploads/2014/10/Global_Detroit_MetoDetroitForeignbornmar2014full.pdf.
45
"Next
Health
Crisis:
Family
Doc
Shortage."
The
Detroit
News.
Accessed
November
9,
2015.
http://www.detroitnews.com/article/20090831/LIFESTYLE03/908310357.
46
Abbey-Lambertz,
Kate.
"Which
Detroit
Parks
Are
Closing:
City
Closing
50
Recreation
Areas
(MAP)."
The
Huffington
Post.
February
1,
2013.
Accessed
November
9,
2015.
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/02/01/which-detroit-parks-closing-
map_n_2599919.html.
47
Gabriel,
Larry.
"Detroit
Food
System
Annual
Report."
2013.
Accessed
November
9,
2015.
http://detroitfoodpolicycouncil.net/sites/default/files/pdfs/2011
2012
Annual
Food
Report.pdf.
48
Giurgescu,
Carmen,
Karen
Kavanaugh,
Kathleen
Norr,
Barbara
Dancy,
Naomi
Twigg,
Barbara
McFarlin,
Christopher
Engeland,
Mary
Hennessy,
and
Rosemary
White-Traut.
"Stressors,
Resources,
and
Stress
Responses
in
Pregnant
African
American
Women:
A
Mixed-Methods
Pilot
Study."
The
Journal
of
Perinatal
&
Neonatal
Nursing.
Accessed
November
9,
2015.
49
Braveman,
Paula.
"THE
UNSOLVED
MYSTERY
OF
RACIAL
DISPARITIES
IN
BIRTH
OUTCOMES:
IS
RACISM-RELATED
STRESS
A
MISSING
PART
OF
THE
PUZZLE?"
December
16,
2008.
Accessed
November
9,
2015.
http://www.unnaturalcauses.org/assets/uploads/file/Braveman_NIH_Summit_12-12-
08.pdf.
20