Professional Documents
Culture Documents
A forward is an agreement between two counterparties - a buyer and seller. The buyer agrees
to buy an underlying asset from the other party (the seller). The delivery of the asset occurs at
a later time, but the price is determined at the time of purchase. Key features of forward
contracts are:
Highly customized - Counterparties can determine and define the terms and features
to fit their specific needs, including when delivery will take place and the exact
identity of the underlying asset.
All parties are exposed to counterparty default risk - This is the risk that the other
party may not make the required delivery or payment.
Transactions take place in large, private and largely unregulated markets consisting of
banks, investment banks, government and corporations.
Underlying assets can be a stocks, bonds, foreign currencies, commodities or some
combination thereof. The underlying asset could even be interest rates.
They tend to be held to maturity and have little or no market liquidity.
Any commitment between two parties to trade an asset in the future is a forward
contract.
The long position holder is the buyer of the contract and the short position holder is
the seller of the contract.
The long position will take the delivery of the asset and pay the seller of the asset the
contract value, while the seller is obligated to deliver the asset versus the cash value
of the contract at the origination date of this transaction.
When it comes to default, both parties are at risk because typically no cash is
exchanged at the beginning of the transaction. However, some transactions do require
that one or both sides put up some form of collateral to protect them from the
defaulted party.
Procedures for Settling a Forward Contract at Expiration
A forward contact at expiration can be settled in one of two ways:
1. Physical Delivery - Refers to an option or futures contract that requires the actual
underlying asset to be delivered on the specified delivery date, rather than being
traded out with offsetting contracts. Most derivatives are not actually exercised, but
are traded out before their delivery dates. However, physical delivery still occurs with
some trades: it is most common with commodities, but can also occur with other
financial instruments. Settlement by physical delivery is carried out by clearing
brokers or their agents. Promptly after the last day of trading, the regulated exchange's
clearing organization will report a purchase and sale of the underlying asset at the
previous day's settlement price (also referred to as the "invoice price"). Traders who
hold a short position in a physically settled security futures contract to expiration are
required to make delivery of the underlying asset. Those who already own the assets
may tender them to the appropriate clearing organization. Traders who do not own
assets are obligated to purchase them at the current price.
Exchanges specify the conditions of delivery for the contracts they cover. Acceptable
locations for delivery (in the case of commodities or energies) and requirements as to
the quality, grade or nature of the underlying asset to be delivered are regulated by the
exchanges. For example, only certain Treasury bonds may be delivered under the
Chicago Board of Trade's Treasury bond future. Only certain growths of coffee may
be delivered under the Coffee, Sugar and Cocoa Exchange's coffee future. In many
commodity or energy markets, parties want to settle futures by delivery, but exchange
rules are too restrictive for their needs. For example, the New York Mercantile
Exchange requires that natural gas be delivered only at the Henry Hub in Louisiana, a
location that may not be convenient for all futures traders.
2. Cash Settlement - Refers to an option or futures contract that requires the
counterparties to the contract to net out the cash difference in the value of their
positions. The appropriate party receives the cash difference.In the case of cash
settlement, no actual assets are delivered at the expiration of a futures contract.
Instead, traders must settle any open positions by making or receiving a cash payment
based on the difference between the final settlement price and the previous day's
settlement price. Under normal circumstances, the final settlement price for a cashsettled contract will reflect the opening price for the underlying asset. Once this
payment is made, neither the buyer nor the seller of the futures contract has any
further obligations on the contract.
Example: Settling a Forward Contract
Let's return to our sailboat example from the first part of this section. Assume that at the end
of 12 months you are a bit ambivalent about sailing. In this case, you could settle your
forward contract with John in one of two ways:
1. Physical Delivery - John delivers that sailboat to you and you pay him $150,000, as
agreed.
2. Cash Settlement - John sends you a check for $15,000 (The difference between your
contract's purchase price of $150,000 and the sail boat's current market value of
$165,000).
The same options are available if the current market price is lower than the forward contract's
settlement price. If John's sailboat decreases in value to $135,000, you could simply pay John
$15,000 to settle the contract, or you could pay him $150,000 and take physical possession of
the boat. (You would still suffer a $15,000 loss when you sold the boat for the current price
of $135,000.)
increased from the future price at which he is obliged to sell his tomatoes. McDonald's has
profited by $0.50 per bushel.
On the day the price change occurs, the farmer's account is debited $2.5 million ($0.50 per
bushel x 5 million bushels) and McDonald's is credited the same amount. Because the market
moves daily, futures positions are settled daily as well. Gains and losses from each day's
trading are deducted or credited to each party's account. At the expiration of a futures
contract, the spot and futures prices normally converge.
Most transactions in the futures market are settled in cash, and the actual physical commodity
is bought or sold in the cash market. For example, let's suppose that at the expiration date in
December there is a blight that decimates the tomato crop and the spot price rises to $5.50 a
bushel. McDonald's has a gain of $2 per bushel on its futures contract but it still has to buy
tomatoes. The company's $10 million gain ($2 per bushel x 5 million bushels) will be offset
against the higher cost of tomatoes on the spot market. Likewise, the farmer's loss of $10
million is offset against the higher price for which he can now sell his tomatoes.
Difference between Future and Forward Contracts:
Fundamentally, forward and futures contracts have the same function: both types of contracts allow
people to buy or sell a specific type of asset at a specific time at a given price.
However, it is in the specific details that these contracts differ. First of all, futures contracts are
exchange-traded and, therefore, are standardized contracts. Forward contracts, on the other hand,
are private agreements between two parties and are not as rigid in their stated terms and
conditions. Because forward contracts are private agreements, there is always a chance that a party
may default on its side of the agreement. Futures contracts have clearing houses that guarantee the
transactions, which drastically lowers the probability of default to almost never.
Secondly, the specific details concerning settlement and delivery are quite distinct. For forward
contracts, settlement of the contract occurs at the end of the contract. Futures contracts are
marked-to-market daily, which means that daily changes are settled day by day until the end of the
contract. Furthermore, settlement for futures contracts can occur over a range of dates. Forward
contracts, on the other hand, only possess one settlement date.
Lastly, because futures contracts are quite frequently employed by speculators, who bet on the
direction in which an asset's price will move, they are usually closed out prior to maturity and
delivery usually never happens. On the other hand, forward contracts are mostly used by hedgers
that want to eliminate the volatility of an asset's price, and delivery of the asset or cash settlement
will usually take place.
asset but OTC-traded options have a huge variety of underlying assets (bonds, currencies,
commodities, swaps, or baskets of assets).
There are two main types of options: calls and puts:
Call options provide the holder the right (but not the obligation) to purchase an
underlying asset at a specified price (the strike price), for a certain period of time. If
the stock fails to meet the strike price before the expiration date, the option expires
and becomes worthless. Investors buy calls when they think the share price of the
underlying security will rise or sell a call if they think it will fall. Selling an option is
also referred to as ''writing'' an option.
Put options give the holder the right to sell an underlying asset at a specified price (the
strike price). The seller (or writer) of the put option is obligated to buy the stock at the
strike price. Put options can be exercised at any time before the option expires.
Investors buy puts if they think the share price of the underlying stock will fall, or sell
one if they think it will rise. Put buyers - those who hold a "long" - put are either
speculative buyers looking for leverage or "insurance" buyers who want to protect
their long positions in a stock for the period of time covered by the option. Put sellers
hold a "short" expecting the market to move upward (or at least stay stable) A worstcase scenario for a put seller is a downward market turn. The maximum profit is
limited to the put premium received and is achieved when the price of the underlyer is
at or above the option's strike price at expiration. The maximum loss is unlimited for
an uncovered put writer.
To obtain these rights, the buyer must pay an option premium (price). This is the amount of
cash the buyer pays the seller to obtain the right that the option is granting them. The
premium is paid when the contract is initiated.
Defaults on options work the same way as they do with forward contracts. Defaults on
over-the counter option transactions are based on counterparties, while exchangetraded options use a clearing house.
Derivatives - Swaps
A swap is one of the most simple and successful forms of OTC-traded derivatives. It is a
cash-settled contract between two parties to exchange (or "swap") cash flow streams. As long
as the present value of the streams is equal, swaps can entail almost any type of future cash
flow. They are most often used to change the character of an asset or liability without actually
having to liquidate that asset or liability. For example, an investor holding common stock can
exchange the returns from that investment for lower risk fixed income cash flows - without
having to liquidate his equity position.
The difference between a forward contract and a swap is that a swap involves a series of
payments in the future, whereas a forward has a single future payment.
Japanese yen for British pound sterling, while others are quite complex incorporating
multiple currencies, interest rates, commodities and options. Both types are flexible in terms
of specifications such as pricing or evaluation benchmarks, timing or contractual horizons,
settlement procedures, resets, and other variables.
Generally, swaps are used for risk management by institutions such as banks, brokers, dealers
and corporations. Some qualified individuals may also be suitable users of these basic
derivatives products. The following lists highlight common swaps transactions.
Swap Characteristics
4. The last way to terminate a contract is to use a swaption. A swaption works like an
option by giving the owner the right to enter into another swap at terms that are set in
advance. By executing the swaption, the party can offset its current swap as explained
in the first way to terminate a contract.
first year, and 9% at the end of the second year. If payments are in arrears, which of the
following characterizes the net cash flow to be received by the fixed-rate payer?
A. $100,000 at the end of year two.
B. $100,000 at the end of year three.
C. $200,000 at the end of year two.
D. $200,000 at the end of year three.
A. The correct answer is "C". What's important to remember is that the payments are in
arrears, so the end-of-year payments depend on the interest rate at the beginning of the year
(or prior year end). The payment at the end of year two is based on the 12% interest rate at
the end of year one. If the floating rate is higher than the fixed rate, the fixed rate payer
receives the interest rate differential times the principal amount ($10,000 x (0.12-0.10) =
$200,000).
Calculate the Payments on an Interest Rate Swap
Consider the following example:
Notional amount = $1 million, payments are made semiannually. The corporation will pay a
floating rate of three-month LIBOR, which is at 3% and will receive a fixed payment of
3.5%.
Answer:
Floating rate payment is $1 million(.03)(180/365) = $14,790
Fixed payment is $1 million(.035)(180/365) = $17,225
The corporation will receive a net payment of $2,435.
Equity Swaps
An equity swap is an agreement between counterparties to exchange a set of payments,
determined by a stock or index return, with another set of payments (usually an interestbearing (fixed or floating rate) instrument, but they can also be the return on another stock or
index). Equity swaps are used to substitute for a direct transaction in stock. The two cash
flows are usually referred to as "legs". As with interest rate swaps, the difference in the
payment streams is netted.
Equity swaps have many applications. For example, a portfolio manager with XYZ Fund can
swap the fund's returns for the returns of the S&P 500 (capital gains, dividends and income
distributions.) They most often occur when a manager of a fixed income portfolio wants the
portfolio to have exposure to the equity markets either as a hedge or a position. The portfolio
manager would enter into a swap in which he would receive the return of the S&P 500 and
pay the counterparty a fixed rate generated form his portfolio. The payment the manager
receives will be equal to the amount he is receiving in fixed-income payments, so the
manager's net exposure is solely to the S&P 500. These types of swaps are usually
inexpensive and require little in term of administration.
For individuals, equity swaps offer some tax advantages. The owner of $1 million worth of
XYZ stock watches his stock value increase by 25% over 12 months. He wants to take some
of the profit but does not want to actually sell his shares. In this case, he can enter into an
equity swap in which he pays a counterparty (perhaps his brokerage) the total return he
receives from his XYZ shares annually for the next three years. In return, he'll take the threemonth LIBOR rate. In this scenario, the owner of XYZ does not have to report any capital
gains on his stock and retains ownership of those stocks as well.
A total return equity swaps includes capital gains and dividends paid on the
underlying stock or stock index. No principal is exchanged and payments are set off
by a notional amount.
The net payment the fund must make at the end of the first six months is $22,687.50
(47,619.04 - 24,931.51).