You are on page 1of 144

2016-2017

: MA(Cantab.), Barrister (Middle Temple),

C:\Users\kioannides\OneDrive - Hadjianastassiou, Ioannides LLC\Nomiko Symvoulio\Lectures\Lectures 2015-16\Cyprus Company Law Lecture Notes 2016-17.docx
Last Printed 08/12/2016 14:41:00

1 ............................................................................................. 1

1.1 ........................................................................................................ 1
1.2 .......................................................................................... 2
1.3 ...................................................................................... 3
1.4 ...................................................................................... 3
1.4.1 .......................................................................................... 3
1.4.2 .......................................................................................... 3
1.4.3 v.
......................................................................................................... 4
1.4.4 Societas Europaea ........................................................................................... 5
1.4.5 ..................................................... 5
1.5 ..................................................... 8

2 ............................................................................................. 12

2.1 ...................................................................................................... 12
2.2 ........................................................................................ 12
2.3 ......................................................................................... 13
2.3.1 ...................................................................................... 14
2.3.2 .......................................................................................................... 18
2.3.3 .................................................................................... 19
2.3.4 ............................................................................ 19
2.3.5 ......................................................................... 20
2.3.6 ...................................................................................... 20
2.4 ................................................................................................. 21
2.5 ........ 22
2.6 ....................................................................... 23
2.7 ............................................................................................. 23
2.7.1 ................. 23
2.7.2 ......................... 24
2.8 .................................................................................... 24
2.9 ................................................................................ 24

3 ............................................ 31

3.1 ............................................................. 31
3.2 ................................................................................. 33
3.2.1 .................................................................................. 34
3.2.2 ................................................................................ 35
3.3 .................................................................................... 40
3.4 .................................................................................................... 40
3.5 ......................................................................................... 40
3.6 .............................................................................. 41
3.7 .......................................................................................... 41

i
4 .................................................................. 42

4.1 .......................................................................................... 42
4.1.1 ............................................................................. 42
4.1.2 ...................................................................... 43
4.1.3 ................................................................... 43
4.2 .................................................................................... 45
4.3 ............................................................................ 47
4.4
. ........................................................................................................... 48

5 .............................................. 49

5.1 ................................... 49
5.1.1 ............................................................................................. 49
5.1.2 (ultra vires) ........................................................... 49
5.1.3 ultra vires ............................................................ 51
5.2 .............................................. 52
5.2.1 ............................................................... 52
5.2.2 ................................................................................. 53
5.2.3 ...................................................................................... 54
5.3 ........................................................................................... 54
5.3.1 .......................................................................................................... 55
5.3.2 .......................................................... 55
5.3.3 ............................................................................................. 55
5.3.4 ...................................................................................... 57
5.4 ......................................................... 62
5.5 ......................................................................................... 63

6 .................................................................. 65

6.1 ...................................................................................................... 65
6.1.1 .......................................................................................................... 65
6.1.2 - ............................................................... 65
6.1.3 - ....................................................... 66
6.1.4 ....................................................................................................... 66
6.1.5 ........................................................................................ 66
6.2 ........................................................................................ 67
6.2.1 .......................................................................................................... 67
6.2.2 ......................................................... 67
6.3 ............................................................................... 68
6.3.1 .................................................................................. 68
6.3.2 ................................................................. 69
6.3.3 .................................................................................................. 69
6.3.4 ...................................................................................................... 69
6.4 ....................................................................................................... 69
6.4.1 .......................................................................................................... 69
6.4.2 .......................................................................................................... 71
6.4.3 ............................................................................................. 71

ii
6.4.4 . .......................................................................................... 72
6.4.5 ...................................................................................... 73
6.4.6 ............................................................................................... 73
6.4.7 .............................................................................................. 73

7 ................................................................... 75

7.1 ...................................................................................................... 75
7.2 .................................................................................... 75
7.3 ....................................................................... 76
7.4 ................................................ 76
7.5 ........................................................... 77
7.6 . 77
7.7 ........................................................................................ 79

8 .................................................................... 82

8.1 ...................................................................................................... 82
8.2 ....................................................................................... 82
8.3 ............................................ 83
8.3.1 ................................................................................ 83
8.3.2 ............................................................................... 83
8.4 ................................................................................. 84
8.5 ................................................................................. 85

9 : ............................................................ 87

9.1 ...................................................................................................... 87
9.2 .. 88
9.3 .................................................................................... 88
9.3.1 .................................................................................... 89
9.3.2 ......................................................................................... 89
9.3.3 ..................................................................................... 90
9.3.4 ........................................................................................ 90
9.4 ..................................................................................... 91
9.4.1 ...................................................................................... 92
9.4.2 .................................................................................................... 92
9.4.3 ........................................................................................................ 92
9.4.4 ................................................... 93

10 : .............................. 94

10.1 ........................................................................................... 94
10.2 ............................................................................................. 95
10.3 ....................................................................................... 96
10.3.1 ......................................................................................... 97
10.3.2 ............................................................................... 97
10.3.3 ............................................................. 98

iii
10.3.4 ......................................................................... 99
10.3.5 ......................................................... 100
10.4 .............................................................. 101
10.4.1 ......................................................................... 101
10.4.2 ...................................................................................................... 101
10.4.3 ................................................................................. 101
10.4.4 ..................................................................... 102
10.4.5 ............................................................................................. 103
10.4.6 .................................................................................................... 103
10.5 ................................................................................................. 104
10.5.1 ........................................................................................................ 104
10.5.2 ..................................................................................... 104
10.5.3 .................................................................................... 104
10.5.4 ........................................................................................ 105

11 : ........ 107

11.1 .................................................................................................... 107


11.2 ........................................................ 107
11.3 ..................................................................................... 110
11.3.1 ............................................... 110
11.3.2
.......................................................................................... 110
11.3.3 , ,

................................................... 111

12 ............................................................... 114

12.1 .................................................................................................... 114


12.2 Foss v. Harbottle .................................................... 115
12.2.1 .................................................................................................. 115
12.2.2 ............................................................................... 115
12.2.3 ............................................................................................. 120
12.3 ................................................................................ 122
12.3.1 ............................................................................................. 123
12.3.2 ................................................................................................... 124

13 .......................................... 126

13.1 .................................................................................................... 126


13.2 ..................................................................... 127
13.2.1 ................................................................................ 127
13.2.2 ......................................................................................................... 128
13.2.3 ...................................................................... 128
13.2.4 ........................................................................................... 129
13.2.5 ....................................................................................................... 129
13.2.6 .................................................................................................... 130
13.2.7 ................................................... 130

iv
13.2.8 ..................................................................................................... 133
13.3 .................................................................................... 133
13.3.1 ....................................................................................................... 133
13.3.2 ...................................................... 133
13.3.3 ................................................................................ 134
13.3.4 ................................................................... 134
13.3.5 ..................................................................................... 135
13.4 ................................................ 135
13.5 ........................................................................................... 136

v
1

1.1


1, 30/9/2012 253.441 .

2007-2008, 2007 29.016,
1998
2004. 2009 2012 18.229
. 2013 2014 11.000

.

, . 113 ,
Companies Act 1948,
.
1960,
40 , .


1948 ,

,

.


1991
()
2001. ,
1
: (www.mcit.gov.cy/mcit/drcor),
5/10/2008

2016 Kypros Ioannides

1
2000 Introduction to Cyprus Law by
& ( , Markus Zalewski).

1.2

. 113
1 .
, ,

.

,
.
, 2000
, . 113 2
.


(. 113)

.

() . ..
.
. 113.

() . 116 (
) .

() (
) .
..
.

1
. 113, 2
2
. 2()/2000

2016 Kypros Ioannides

. 113
--. --.
. 1
:

; --,
. . : . - .
(.. - , - ). ( --)
,
.

( --)
.

1.3



.
. ,
. . 113,
.

1.4

. 113, :
:



,

, , .2

1
..., 1998
2
. 113, 3(1)

2016 Kypros Ioannides

3
1.4.1

H "

()
() ,
,



()
.1


,
7 2,
3.

,
4.


,
5.

6,
.

1.4.2

. 113
7.
1
. 113, 29(1)
2
. 113, 30(1)
3
. 113, 32, 211() 213(1)()(i)
4
. 113, 30(2)
5
. 113, 29. ,
.
6
. 1.4.3
7
. 113, 2

2016 Kypros Ioannides

3
,
,

.

1.4.3 v.

, . 113
,
.

. 113
,
1.

( )
.

,


(.. 1.000 1.000
1 ).

,
()
. (
) (
)
.

.
1
. 113, 3(2)()

2016 Kypros Ioannides

. 113


1


.
.
.
.

.

1.4.4 Societas Europaea

Societas Europaea ( SE)



1 () . 2157/2001 8
2001 (SE),
SE 2.

1.4.5

(-)
:

1
. 113, 3(2)()
2
. 113, 2, . 0

2016 Kypros Ioannides

5

/
1 2
503
- (

)
25.6294 -
5 6

7 8
(
)


9

11
10






12

13


1
. 113, 3(1)
2
. 113, 3(1) 29
3
. 113, 29(1)()
4
15,000, . 113, 4
5
. 113, 81
6
. 113, 81, 29(1)()
7
. 113, 56(1)
8
. 113, 56(2)
9
. 113, 29(1)(). .

.
10
" " , , ,

, . 113, 2
11
. 113, 29(1)()
12
. 113, 47
13
. 113, 59

2016 Kypros Ioannides

6

25% -


1

2










3

, 4


5


6

7 8


9 -



1
. 113, 60
2
. 113, 60
3
. 113, 69
4
. 113, 169-169
5
. 113, 169
6
. 113, 201-201
7
. 113, 170
8
. 113, 170
9
. 113, 4(5)()

2016 Kypros Ioannides

7



: -
()
()

, 1



() 3
()

2)


1-3
-

4

1.5 5


, ,
.
.

, ,

1
. 113, 175
2
. 113, 104(3)()
3
. 113, 17 104
4
. 113, 124
5
: , (www.mcit.gov.cy)
(www.mcit.gov.cy/mcit/drcor),
5/10/2008

2016 Kypros Ioannides

8
( ), ,

, , ,
, ,
, ,
, ..


20
.

1942
1945 , ,

.

1960
.


,


. .

1967
.


,
.


1990
.

,
, , ,
, .,
.

2016 Kypros Ioannides

9
, ,

, ,
.

3 :

) , ) , )
.

() , ,
, ,
. ,
,
.

()

.
.

2015 1

.

()
, ,
.

1 (
) 2015 (.65()/2015)

2016 Kypros Ioannides

10
.

1:




/






(,

,
,


)




( &
)


2016 Kypros Ioannides

11
2

2.1


.
, ,
, . 113.
.
, ,

, ,
,
.
.

2.2


.
.


1 , . 113
2. ,
73.


3:

() 4,
() 5,
1
R. v. Registrar of Companies ex.p. Attorney General (1991) BCLC 476; R. v. Registrar of
Companies, ex p Bowen [1914] 3 KB 1161
2
. 113, 3(1)
3
. 113, 3(1)
4
. 113, 14
5
. 113, 14

2016 Kypros Ioannides

12
() ( 1)1.

2.


3.
.

.

. ( 1)
4.

2.3


5:

() .
() .
() .
()

()

(
).


1
. 113, 17(2)
2
( ) 2006.
, 102,52
0,6% .
3
(. 2), 11 (5), . 113, 17(2)
4
. 113, 17(2)
5
. 113, 4

2016 Kypros Ioannides

13
1, 2
3.

2.3.1





() 4 Limited
ltd
() 5 Public Company Limited
Public Company Ltd
Public Co. Limited
Public Co. Ltd
. . Plc
. . Public Limited
Public Ltd
() SE SE

6
() .... LLC
7



,
, 8.


9 . ""
1
. 113,
2
. 113,
3
. 113,
4
. 113, 4(1)()(i)
5
. 113, 4(1)()(ii)
6
. 113, 4(1)()(iii)
7
, . 2, 6(6)
8
. 4
9
. 113, 18

2016 Kypros Ioannides

14
.
.
1 .
(. 116) .
113
2 .
. 116
.

.
. 1133

4.
,
,
,

,
,
( )
5.

"" (striking or overbearing)
6.


.

, 7.

1
JMC Polytrade v. (1992) 3 294
2
The Cyprus Supply Company v. (1993) 4 3071
3
. 113, 19(2)
4
Deloitte Haskins & Sells Associates Ltd, Deloitte Haskins & Sells v. (1997)
4 1209
5
. 113, 19(2)
6
Entechno Development v. Republic (1986) 3 C.L.R. 2613, Epsilon Electromechanical Limited v.
(1992) 4 A.A.. 723, Deloitte Haskins & Sells Associates Ltd,
Deloitte Haskins & Sells v. (1997) 4 1209
7
. v. (1992) 4 3943

2016 Kypros Ioannides

15


,
( .. 1 2
)
3.
,
4.


, ,
Companies Act 1948 Board of Trade 5

.
2015
:

- :

i.
.
ii.

.
iii. 18
113.
iv.

.
v. .

1
JMC POLYTRADE . (1989) 3 92 (
)
2
Fashion House v. Republic (1973) 3 C.L.R. 23
3
JMC POLYTRADE . (1989) 3 92 (
), Entechno Development v. Republic (1986) 3 C.L.R. 2613
4
JMC POLYTRADE . (1989) 3 92 (
)
5
Fashion House v. Republic (1973) 3 C.L.R. 23

2016 Kypros Ioannides

16
.
vi.
,
.
vii.


.

() .
,
.

()
,

.

()


, .

()
: ,
, , , , EURO,
INTERNATIONAL.

()
, , .

() /

.

() '
: , , , Trust,
Insurance, Broker.

() .

()

2016 Kypros Ioannides

17


.



.

, ,
1 (
) 2.
, 3.

. 113

4.

2.3.2


5. 6.


7.

,
8.

,

.

1
www.mcit.gov.cy/mcit/drcor
2

3

4
v. (2001) 4 810,
v. . 1058/99 22/5/2001 (-)
5
. 113, 4(1)()
6 . 113, 3(1)
7 . v. . (2006) 1 873.
8
. 5

2016 Kypros Ioannides

18
,
,
,
,
:

() ,

() ,

, ,
,
.

2.3.3


1.




,
, ,

,

2.

2.3.4



3.
1
. 113, 4(2)
2
. 113, 4(3)
3
. 113, 4(4)()

2016 Kypros Ioannides

19
..
.1

, o ,

2,
3.

200,000
,
.

( )
4.

,
25.629 5 .
, ,


6 .
.

2.3.5



7.

2.3.6


( )
1
. 113, ,
2
. 113, (4)(4)()
3
. 113, (4)(4)()
4
. 6.
5
15,000, . 113, 4(1)
6
. 113, 4(2) 104(3)()
7
. 113, 5

2016 Kypros Ioannides

20
1.

2.4


2.

3. "" 4

, ,

( ) ,
.

,
, 5.

,
( )
6.

.113
7.

,

.1138. ,

,
9.

10:
1
(. 2), 11 (5)
2
. 113, 8
3
. 113, 21
4
. 113, 2
5
. 113, 8
6
. 113, 8
7
. 113, 10(2)
8
. 113, 10(1)
9
. 113, 10(2)
10
. 113, 11

2016 Kypros Ioannides

21
() ,
()

.

10 ,
.

,
1:

() ,
() 50 (
),
()
,
() .

() ,
,
2,
() ,
3.

2.5



. 113, , 4.

1
. 113, 29
2
. 113, 4(5)()
3
. 113, 4(5)()
4
. 113, 13
3
. 113, (4)(4)()
4
. 113, (4)(4)()

2016 Kypros Ioannides

22










,


,

2.6

. 113 1 , ,
,
.113 .


1.

.

2.7

2.7.1


,
,
1
. 113, 17(2)

2016 Kypros Ioannides

23
1.

2.

2.7.2



3,
2 . ,
3 .

2.8


.
,

. 113,

3.

2.9


4 .
. 113
,
5.
.

6
1
. 113, 102(1)
2
. 113, 192
3
1977 2010, 9
4
. 113, 17(2)
5
. 113, 15(1)
6
. 113, 15(2), v. Vineyard View Tourist Enterprises Ltd (1998)
1 300

2016 Kypros Ioannides

24

1.

1
. 113, 17(1)

2016 Kypros Ioannides

25


________________________________________________________________
1,
:


2 ( )
3 ( / )

:
5 ( /
)


89()/2015 12.

,
:

1-

: 1
2
3 (89()/2015).

1 :

>

>

>
>
>
> ,

2016 Kypros Ioannides

26

>

():
> (. )
> 2 ( ) (.
)
> 3 ( ) (.
)

> 5 (
)
>

89()/2015
12

>
>
.

> /

2
:

>
>
(
)
>
> ( -
)
> (
)

2016 Kypros Ioannides

27
>

>
.

> /

3
:
>
> (.
)
>

>
().
.
>
, ,

>
>
(
)
>
>

> :
>
>
.

>
.

2016 Kypros Ioannides

28
> /



. :

> , . :

(
Ltd Limited )
>

> .
: 89()/2015 [.4(1)()],


.
>
>

> , ,
, ,

>
>

>

>
1
> ,
,

>

>

2016 Kypros Ioannides

29

>
(. , , )
>

>

> ( ).
>

> &

>

> ,
>

5 -

(
1,2, 3 ).

:
>
> ,
> ( )
>

>
>
.

2016 Kypros Ioannides

30
3
1.

.

3.1


,
2.
.
Salomon v. Salomon3.

,

.
.

,
4. ,
:

We think that it is necessary to state that since the decision in Salmon &
Co. v. Salomon [1897] A.C. 22, it has been said time and again that a
1
. 113, 15(2), v. Vineyard View Tourist Enterprises Ltd (1998)
1 300
2
Michaelides v. Gavrielides (1980) 1 C.L.R. 244
3
Salomon v. Salomon (1897) A.C. 22
4
Michaelides v. Gavrielides (1980) 1 C.L.R. 244, Bank of Cyprus (Holdings) v. Republic (1983) 3
C.L.R. 636, Bank of Cyprus (Holdings) v. Republic (1985) 3 C.L.R. 1883, N.M. Michaelides v. Michael
James Hickman (1988) 1 CLR 98, Metro Shipping & Travel Limited v. Global Cruises S.A. (1989) 1
CLR 182, v. The Dolphin Insurance Company Limited (1990) 1 351,
v. Yellow Rose Shipping Company Limited (1995) 1 1002,
v. Vineyard View Tourist Enterprises Ltd (1998) 1 300, v. (1998)
1 867, 1. 2. v.
Nicantony Trading Co (1998) 1 1653, . .. v.
(1998) 1 2296, (1)
, (2)Eurolife Ltd, (3) , (4) cisco Ltd, (5)
(.2)
Certiorari (2005) 1 1178, Pashkovskiy v. Pashkovskayia . 8/2009 30/3/2011,
.. v. .. . 319/2008, 7/7/2014.

2016 Kypros Ioannides

31
company and the individual or individuals forming a company were separate
legal entities, however complete the control might be by one or more of those
individuals over the company. That is the whole principle of the formation of
a limited liability company, and it would be contrary to the scheme of the
Company Acts to depart from that principle. 1 :

Salomon v. Salomon,

,
.

.

( ),
,
2.

A registered Company is a legal entity distinct from its members. As such it


enjoys rights and is subject to duties which are not the same as those
enjoyed or borne by its members; it has as it is frequently put a legal
personality of its own.3 :
. ,


, .

, , .
.
,
,
.

.
. ,
, , .



,
1
Michaelides v. Gavrielides (1980) 1 C.L.R. 244
2
v. (1998) 1 867
3
Michael James Hickman (1988) 1 CLR 98

2016 Kypros Ioannides

32
. ,
,

. 1


, :




2

3
,
,
-
4

, 5
,
,
9(2)
.

3.2


, .

,

.

1
Lindos Constructions Limited v. (1993) 1 17
2
Michaelides v. Gavrielides (1980) 1 C.L.R. 244
3
v. Yellow Rose Shipping Company Limited (1995) 1 1002
4
v. Vineyard View Tourist Enterprises Ltd (1998) 1 300
5
. .. v. (1998) 1 2296

2016 Kypros Ioannides

33
3.2.1


. ,
.
.

1 :

(7) 6
.
7

.




2

()

. 113 ()

,
, ,

() , ,
.
1133
4

, 5.

1
. 113, 32
2
. 113, 311
3
. 113, 103(4), Multi Klima Maliotis Engineering Ltd v. ,
483/97 484/97, 18/02/2000 (-)
4
2002, 33(2)
5
. 113, 141

2016 Kypros Ioannides

34
3.2.2


,
,
1. , , ,

2.

,
. ( )
.


"
"3.

v. 4
.
.
.

,
11 . ,
. 11
.
,
.
1
Salomon v.
Salomon,
,
.

( ) Michaelides v. Gavrielides (1980) 1 C.L.R. 244,
250, Michaelides, Salomon,
( ) Bank of
Cyprus (Holdings) v. Republic (1983) 3 C.L.R. 636, 648
2
Michaelides v. Gavrielides, ,
. ,
Michaelides,
Salomon ( ) Bank of Cyprus (Holdings) v. Republic (1985) 3
C.L.R. 1883, 1889
3
v. (1989) 1 504
4
v. (1989) 1 504

2016 Kypros Ioannides

35
, , 11
. ,

, 104
. , .

(1)

, .
,
, .

(2)
,
, ,
,
.

(3)
(1) .
11 .

1

Salomon ().
.
.
, , Bank of Cyprus
(Holdings).

2 :

(Salomon v. Salomon & Co , 66 L.J. Ch. 35).

, .

1
v. Galatariotis Brothers Ltd .. (1995) 1
11Multi Klima Maliotis Engineering Ltd v. ,
483/97 484/97, 18/02/2000 (-)
2
Multi Klima Maliotis Engineering Ltd v. , 483/97
484/97, 18/02/2000 (-)

2016 Kypros Ioannides

36
1,

.

,
,

2
3,
4. ,


. v. Ellinas Finance Public
Company Limited5, :

Brenda Hannigan: Company Law, 2003,


. 74-82,

.
Salomon v. Salomon & Co Ltd (1897) A.C. 22, ,
, Adams v. Cape
Industries plc (1990) BCLC 479,
,

. Salomon
in group structures, ( Ord v. Belhaven Pubs Ltd (1998) 2
BCLC 447). Re: Southard Ltd (1979) 3 All E.R. 556,

,
Pennington: The Principles of
Company Law . 27 32,
, ,
.

, Prest v. Petrodel Resources Ltd & Ors 6 ,



.
1
Exalco S.A. . .. (2007) 1B 991
2
Creasey v. Breachwood Motors Ltd [1992] BCC 638
3
DHN Food Distributors Ltd v. Tower Hamlets London Borough Council [1976] 3 All ER 462
4
Adams v. Cape Industries plc [1990] Ch 433,
5
v. Ellinas Finance Public Company Limited . . 209/2009, 20/3/2013
6
Prest v. Petrodel Resources Ltd & Ord [2013] UKSC 34

2016 Kypros Ioannides

37

, ( )
( ) ,
.


.

VTB Capital plc v Nutritek International Corporation & others1,





,
.

2
,
,
.


,
3



4.

5.
1
VTB Capital plc v Nutritek International Corporation & others [2013] UKSC 5
2
v. Zako Estates Limited (1989) 1 490
3
v. (1989) 1 504
4
v.
(1996) 3 517 (
).
5
.
(1994) 4 770. :


.

2016 Kypros Ioannides

38

1.

,
2.

( ) 3.


4.

,
. . [. Gower's
Principles of Modern Company Law . 130). Smith Stone Knight Ltd v. Lord Mayor
[1939] 4 All E. R. 116],
, : (1)
; (2)
; (3) ; (4)

; (5)
; (6) ;
Bank of Cyprus v. Republic ()
Bank of Cyprus (Holdings) v. The Republic (1985) 3 C.L.R. 1883,
.
1
.. v.
(1993) 4 2677
2
Netcom Limited v. ,
. 984/2003, 08/07/2005 (-).

,
,
.
3
Bank of Cyprus (Holdings) v. Republic (1985) 3 C.L.R. 1883 . Stereo Development Co.
Limited v. (1998) 4 651
,
,
33(1)
1978-1998 :

, , ,

..
4
Camrex (Realisations) Limited v. Freewind Shipping Company Ltd (1986) 1 CLR 420, Avraam K.
Prousi v. Redundant Employees Fund (1988) 1 CLR 363

2016 Kypros Ioannides

39
:


1
,

2.

3.3


.

(
)3, .
.

3.4

4 . H

(trustee) 5.

3.5


.
,
mens rea6.
1
Othon Galanos Tax Free Shops Ltd v. (1990) 3 ... 2234,

2
.. v. Polly-Frocks Ltd (2000) 1 398
3
. 113, 3(2)
4
. 113, 16. . ( ) , .
218. . () , . 109
5 Salomon v. Salomon (1897) A.C. 22, v. Investylia Public Co Limited
(2008) 1 1117
6
Tesco Supermarkets Ltd. v. Nattrass, [1971] 2 All E.R. 127, Dias United Publishing Company Ltd.
v. The Police (1982) 2 CLR 229, Alithia Ekdotiki Eteria Limited and another v. the Police (1984) 2
CLR 431, Costas Michael Hailis v. the Police (1982) 2 CLR 99

2016 Kypros Ioannides

40
()

1.

3.6

2 .
.

3.7


.
. 3.

1
Dias United Publishing Company Ltd. v. The Police (1982) 2 CLR 229
2
. 5
3
. 113, 15(2)

2016 Kypros Ioannides

41
4

4.1

4.1.1


1.
2.


.
3
, .


4.
15 5.

()
()
, 8,54 17,09


( ) 8,54 17,09
8,54 17,09

- -

1
. 113, 19(1)
2
487 9/2/1961
3
. . 14
4
. 113, 19(1)
5
. 113, 137

2016 Kypros Ioannides

42
4.1.2

, , ,
,
,
, , 6
, 1.
,

.


, 42.72
.



6 . 2
3

4
5. ,
,

, 6.

4.1.3

, ,
,
( )7.
8.

1
. 113, 19(2)
2
Stelel Catering Ltd v. , (2000) 4 788, Glasboro Enterprises Ltd v.
, . . 1310/99 . 11/01/02
3
Cyprotoys & Crafts Ltd v. (1990) 3() A.A.. 2358
4
Moschovakis v. Cyprus Broadcasting Corporation (1988) 3 CLR 750
5
Cyprotoys & Crafts Ltd v. (1990) 3() A.A.. 2358
6
Cyprotoys & Crafts Ltd v. (1990) 3() A.A.. 2358
7
. 113, 19(3)
8
. 113, 19(1)

2016 Kypros Ioannides

43


.
,
1.

4.1.4

,
, , 2
3.
4. ,
:

() , , ,
, ,
()
,
() .


5 .
,

.

. ,
,
,
,

.


,
1
. 113, 19(4), Neoptolemos Spyropoullos v. Transavia Holland N.V. Amsterdam (1979) 1
CLR 421
2
4545 18/3/1965
3
. 113, 20(2)
4
. 113, 20(1)
5
. 113, 20(3)

2016 Kypros Ioannides

44
1.


, . 113
"" 2, 3
4.

(
)
""

.


427,15
(250) .

4.2


,
5.


,

6:

()
()
()
()


()

1
. 113, 20(6)
2
. 113, 4
3
. 113, 103
4
. 113, 20(4), 113, 118
5
. 113, 6
6
. 113, 7(1)

2016 Kypros Ioannides

45
()

() .



,


1.


,

2.


3.

(petition) 4
5.

6
,
.

,


7.


1
. 113, 23
2
. 113, 24
3
. 113, 7(2).
.
4
. 113, 24(1), , .5
5
. 113, 2 209, , .2
6
, .8
7
. 113, 7(3)

2016 Kypros Ioannides

46
1 . ,
,
,

2.

, 3.

,


4. 15
(
).
85.43 (50)
.
,
,
5.

4.3

6,

. 113.

15 7. ,

42,728.


1
. 113, 7(3)
2
. 113, 7(5)
3
. 113, 7(4)
4
. 113, 7(6)
5
. 113, 7(6)
6
. 113, 12(1)
7
. 113, 137(1)
8
. 113, 137(5)

2016 Kypros Ioannides

47

,


1.

,

2 .
,
3.

42,72
4.

4.4
.



, 5.


6.

,
(petition) 7.

1
. 113, 23
2
. 113, 137(2)
3
. 113, 137(3)
4
. 113, 137(6)
5
. 113, 24(1)
6
. 113, 24(3)
7
. . 4.2 , . 113, 24(4)

2016 Kypros Ioannides

48
5

5.1
5.1.1

1


2. 3:
,

.

,
,
.

.
4.

,
5.

5.1.2 (ultra vires)

,

6.
(ultra vires doctrine).
1
. 113, 4()
2
v. . (1966) (1990) 1 673, L & T
Partners Communications Services Ltd Pr Partners .. v. ..
. 2362/2006, 18/1/2007 (-)
3
v. . (1966) (1990) 1 673
4
v. . (1966) (1990) 1 673
5
v. (1991) 3 398
6
v. . (1966) (1990) 1 673, T.J.S. Enterprises
Limited .. v. () . 2362/2006,
18/1/2007 (-), . v. .
. 1208, 8/9/2006 (-)

2016 Kypros Ioannides

49
:


.

. ,
/ .

: ultra vires ( )

(memorandum
of association), ultra vires,
.1

2:

()
,

()
.


,
. 3,
, ,

.
.

4 . 5 ultra vires

(memorandum of
1
v. .. (2009) 1A 479
2
v. .. (2009) 1A 479
3
. 5.1.1
4
v. . (1966) (1990) 1 673
5
. Nicosia Palace Hotel Co Ltd v.
(2003) 1 ... 722, T.J.S. Enterprises Limited .. v.
() . 2362/2006, 18/1/2007 (-),
() . . 1. Parson Emporio Ltd .. . 149/2007 .
7/3/2012

2016 Kypros Ioannides

50
association)
, ,

, .


, 1,

,
.

5.1.3 ultra vires



2 3
4 5 . ,



6.
1
v. . (1966) (1990) 1 673
ultra-
vires .
(.
European Communities Act 1972. s. 9(1).
.

.
2
v. . (1966) (1990) 1 673
3
68/151/ 9 1968 (
2009/101/ , 16 2009)
4
. 21()/1997, . 151()/2000, . 70()/2003
5
. 113, 33: . 33.
(1) ,
,
,
:
,
, ,

, :
,
, , .
6
L & T Partners Communications Services Ltd Pr Partners .. v.

2016 Kypros Ioannides

51
1 ,
,
.
( )


, .
,
, , .

,
, .


.


2.

5.2
5.2.1
( Royal British Bank v. Turquand3)

(indoor management rule)


:


.


. 4 ,
Nicosia Palace Co Ltd Nicosia Palace Hotel
.
,

.. . 2362/2006, 18/1/2007 (-)


1
. 113, 33
2
L & T Partners Communications Services Ltd Pr Partners .. v.
.. . 2362/2006, 18/1/2007 (-)
33
[1843 1860] All ER 435
4
Nicosia Palace Hotel Co Ltd v. (2003) 1 722

2016 Kypros Ioannides

52
7,000.
Nicosia Palace
7,000.
Nicosia Palace Co Ltd
. H Nicosia Palace
.

,
.

Royal British Bank v. Turquand1



,
. :

.


.
.
, .

5.2.2

2 :

()
.

()

.

()


.. 3.
1
[1843 1860] All ER 435
2
Nicosia Palace Hotel Co Ltd v. (2003) 1 722
3
. Helly-Hutchinson v. Brayhead Ltd

2016 Kypros Ioannides

53
() .1

5.2.3

2
3

, ,
, .


Turquand4.


,

.
Turquand 5.

5.3
1
Nicosia Palace Hotel Co Ltd v.
(2003) 1 722 :

( ,
).
Turquand (constructive
knowledge) .

. (obiter dictum).
,
.
2
68/151/ 9 1968
( 2009/101/ ,
16 2009)
3
. 113, 33(2)
4
33(2)

.
5
. 5.3

2016 Kypros Ioannides

54
5.3.1


, ,
.
() (
) () ,
() .
,
1.

5.3.2

, ,


2.

,
.
,
3.

,
.

4.

.
Limited
.
5.

5.3.3

1
Ferguson v. Wilson [1866] L.R. 2 Ch. 77; A.D. Hotel & Catering Ltd v. Takis Pilava (1982) 1 CLR 81
2
Ferguson v. Wilson [1866] L.R. 2 Ch. 77; A.D. Hotel & Catering Ltd v. Takis Pilava (1982) 1 CLR 81
3
Ferguson v. Wilson [1866] L.R. 2 Ch. 77; A.D. Hotel & Catering Ltd v. Takis Pilava (1982) 1 CLR 81
4
. & v. (2000) 1 954
5
Ferguson v. Wilson [1866] L.R. 2 Ch. 77; A.D. Hotel & Catering Ltd v. Takis Pilava (1982) 1 CLR
81, . 113, 103(4)

2016 Kypros Ioannides

55
( ) :
.


1. ,
2 .. .

3
, ..


.


.
,
.

5.


.

1
, . 149, 146, Freeman and Lockyer v. Buckhurst Pak Properties
(Mangal) Ltd. [1964] 1 All E.R. 630, Hely-Hutchinson v. Brayhead, Ltd. and Another [1967] 3 All E.R.
98, Liopetri Transport Co v. Loucas Constantinou (1971) 1 CLR 424
2
, . 149, 147
3
, . 149, 147
4
. 149
. ( 197)

, .
,
(estoppel) 29
14/60, ,
. 149: v. (1999) 1 551
5
Freeman and Lockyer v. Buckhurst Pak Properties (Mangal) Ltd. [1964] 1 All E.R. 630, Hely-
Hutchinson v. Brayhead, Ltd. and Another [1967] 3 All E.R. 98, Liopetri Transport Co v. Loucas
Constantinou (1971) 1 CLR 424

2016 Kypros Ioannides

56

500 .
500


5001.

3.13 .

.

5.3.4

Georgios Demetriou v. Cyprofrota2

:
Cyprofrota
( )
.
.


.
.
,

.
Turquand3.

Liopetri Transport Co v. Loucas Constantinou4

,
.
( )
1
Freeman and Lockyer v. Buckhurst Pak Properties (Mangal) Ltd. [1964] 1 All E.R. 630, Hely-
Hutchinson v. Brayhead, Ltd. and Another [1967] 3 All E.R. 98, Liopetri Transport Co v. Loucas
Constantinou (1971) 1 CLR 424
2
Georgios Demetriou v. Cyprofrota (1974 -7) 9 JSC 847
3
. 5.2.1
4
Liopetri Transport Co v. Loucas Constantinou (1975)1 CLR 424

2016 Kypros Ioannides

57
,
.
Hely Hutchinson1 Freeman & Lockyer2
.

A.D. Hotel & Catering Ltd v. Takis Pilava3

, ,
193
.

.



.

.
108.085.
, , , :

(1)
,

, .



, .

(2) ,

,

. ,
,
.

1
Hely-Hutchinson v. Brayhead, Ltd. and Another [1967] 3 All E.R. 98
2
Freeman and Lockyer v. Buckhurst Park Properties (Mangal) Ltd. [1964] 1 All E.R. 630
3
A.D. Hotel & Catering Ltd v. Takis Pilava (1982) 1 CLR 81

2016 Kypros Ioannides

58
Paneuropean Insurance Co Ltd v. 1

,
, , 597,96
.
, Eurohouse
Insurances Ltd.

.
Eurohouse
.
(ostensible
or apparent authority) 197
. 149.
.


197
. 149 (ostensible or
apparent authority).

(1)

Eurohouse
.

(2)
Eurohouse
.
(ostensible or apparent authority).

(3)
, (estoppel)
29 1960 (. 14/60),
, ,
. 149.

(
:
1
Paneuropean Insurance Co Ltd v. (2004) 1 713

2016 Kypros Ioannides

59
Eurohouse,
Eurohouse .
, ,
.
, .
Eurohouse

,
[ ]. ,
Eurohouse .



(ostensible or apparent authority) 197
. 149 :


,

Eurohouse,
Eurohouse , Eurohouse
, Eurohouse ,
.

197 . 149.

v. 1

1991 / Barclays.
,
, .
. 1992,

. , ,
, , ,
, .
1992 .

/ .
8
1
v. (1999) 1 551

2016 Kypros Ioannides

60
,
, ' ,
. .
,
. , ,

(apparent or ostensible authority). To
. ,

,
8 .

.

.

: 1.

Barclays , . 2.
"
Barclays " "
Barclays
", . 3.

,
,
.

, , :

(1) '
, ,
.
.
,
, .
.
.
. '
, ,
1984
(broker) ,
, .

2016 Kypros Ioannides

61
.
. 149
. ( 197)

,
.

(2)
, (estoppel)
29 14/60,
,
. 149.

(3) .
,
,
. ,
'
,
.

5.4

2003,

. 1

, :
,

.
. , , .
"
"2.

2003 , 3, ,

, ,
1
& v. (2003) 1 1663
2

.
3
. 70()/2003

2016 Kypros Ioannides

62
,
.
, 1.

,
,
.
, 2.

3.

5.5

2009,
,
( 1960) ,
.



,

,
4.

5 6,

, ,
.

,
:

()
,
,
1
. 113, 15(1)
2
. 113, 15(2)
3
. 113, 15(3)
4
Electricity Authority of Cyprus v. Petrolina Company Ltd (1971) 1 CLR 19
5
. 113, 33
6
. 99(I)/2009, 3

2016 Kypros Ioannides

63
1,

()
,


2,

()


3.

,

, ,
4.



5.

,

6.

1
. 113, 33(1)()
2
. 113, 33(1)()
3
. 113, 33(1)()
4
. 113, 33(1)
5
. 113, 33(2)
6
. 113, 33(3)

2016 Kypros Ioannides

64
6

6.1

6.1.1

,

1 .
.
1.000 1.000 1
.


2
3 .

4.
.


.
5.

6.1.2 -

( ) -
.
( )
6 .
, -

1
. 113, 4(4)()
2
. 113, 4(4)()
3
. 113, 4(4)()
4
. 113, 15(2)
5
Lavinia Investments Ltd v. (1998) 3 827
6
. 113, 3(2)()

2016 Kypros Ioannides

65
.
.

6.1.3 -


.
( )
.



1. ,
,
2.

6.1.4

, ,
.

6.1.5

,
:

() :
25,629 (15,000)3.
()
25% . 113 47(3)4.
()

5.

1
. 113, 58()
2
. 113, 59
3
. 113, 4
4
. 113, 47(3)
5
. 113, 47 47

2016 Kypros Ioannides

66
6.2

6.2.1

, .

1.


2.

:
5.000
5.000 1 10.000 10.000
1 5.000
1 ,
.


, 15
3
4 .
,
5.

,

5

5 6.

6.2.2

1
. 113, 60(1)()
2
. 113, 60(2). ,
. 113 ( 44)
.
3
. 113, 62(1)
4
. 113, 62(2)
5
. 113, 62(3)
6
. 113, 62(2)

2016 Kypros Ioannides

67
,
,
,

1.

,
:

() , 25%

2 (.. 1
2,
1,25).

() ,
5 3 .
4.

,
5
,
6.

6.3

,
:

6.3.1


7.
1
. 113, 59(1)
2
. 113, 60(1)()
3
. 113, 60(1)()
4
. 113, 60(2) 47
5
,

6
. 113, 60(1)
7
. 113, 60(1)()

2016 Kypros Ioannides

68
6.3.2


(stock)
1 .

6.3.3



,
, ,
2.

6.3.4



,
3.
4.


,
5.

6.4

6.4.1

1
. 113, 60(1)()
2
. 113, 60(1)()
3
. 113, 60(1)()
4
. 113, 60(2)
5
. 113, 61, 16

2016 Kypros Ioannides

69

1:

. ,
, ,
, .
,
,
. ,

,
,
.
,
. .
,
, , ,
, .

,

, ,
.
.

[] ,

,

, ,
, ,
.
.

,
.
. ,
,
, .
1
Lavinia Investments Ltd v. (1998) 3 827

2016 Kypros Ioannides

70

,
.
.
,
, ( Pennington on Company
Law, 4 , . 139, 140).
, , .

, ,
.
(Gowers Principles of
Modern Company Law, 4 , . 403).

,
(Borlands Trustee v. Steel Brothers & Co [1901] 1 Ch. 279, 288.
In Re Paulin [1935] 1 K.B. 26),

(Oakbank Oil Co v. Crum (1882) 8 App. Cas. 65).

,
, ,

1.

6.4.2


(.. 5.000 2.000 2
1.000 1 ).

6.4.3

2

,
.
1
. 113, 21, . 2, 2.4
2
. 113 105(1)

2016 Kypros Ioannides

71
1 .
(
)
2.

,

.

6.4.4 .

,
3
(
).
4.


, ( )

5.

( )
.



6.

H
30 ,

7.

1
. 113 105(2)
2
. 113 105(3)
3
. 113 106(1)
4
. 113 106(3)
5
. 113 108(1)
6
. 113 108 (3), (4)
7
. 113 110

2016 Kypros Ioannides

72
6.4.5

,
,

, ,
, ,
1.


. , ,


.


.

111 . 113

.
/ / ,

111
2.

6.4.6

, ,
3.

6.4.7

,

1
. 113 111(1)
2
. . , (2004) 1 ... 866, Ritchie
Russell , (2008) 1 ... 639
3
. 113 112

2016 Kypros Ioannides

73
1.

,
2
.

1
. 113 71
2
. 113 21(1)

2016 Kypros Ioannides

74
7

7.1


.
. ,

,

.



( )
.


.
,
,
.

, ,
,
,
.

7.2

(
)
.


( ) ,
. 113 1
1
. 70()/2003, 77/91/

2016 Kypros Ioannides

75
1.

7.3


(.
25% )
.

2.

()

.

() 1
.

()
3 1
( ).

7.4

,
1
. 113, 169 169
2
. 113, 56(1)
3
. 113, 56(3)

2016 Kypros Ioannides

76
1
, 2.

7.5

3 .
, 4
, ,
5.

, ,

6.




.

7.6



1
. 113, 57
2
9 99() 2009.
3
Trevor v. Whitworth (1887) 12 App. Cas. 409 (H.L.).
4
. 135()/2000, . 70()/2003
5
. 113, 57 57
6
. 1113, 28(1)

2016 Kypros Ioannides

77
.

, 1
( )
.

53 . 113 :

, ,
, , ,


.

()
,
,

() ,

,

() , ,
,


.

2,
,
3 :

()
,
() ,
90%
.
1
. 113, 53
2
. 99() 2009.
3
,
.

2016 Kypros Ioannides

78
7.7

,
, ,

.

. ,
(
)
, 1.

2
.

,
.


3.

4:

()
,

() ,
,

() ,

.
1
Progress Property Company Ltd v Moorgarth Group Ltd [2010] UKSC 55
2
. 113, 64
3
. 113, 64(2)
4
. 113, 64

2016 Kypros Ioannides

79
()

()
,
1.


2.


.
,
.
Companies Rules 1933.
,
( ) .

: (petition)
(summons).
,
.

, ,

.

,
3.

,

,
.
1
. 113, 55
2
.. v.
(1993) 4 2677
3
. 113, 65, Re Ratners Group plc [1988] BCLC 685

2016 Kypros Ioannides

80
, ,

.



1.

1
. 113, 67

2016 Kypros Ioannides

81
8

8.1

,

1.
,
, ,
.
.



2.

8.2

,

3.
, , ,
4.


.
5,
.


.


.6
1
. 113, 27(2)
2
. 113, 71
3
. 113, 73
4
. 113, 73
5
. 209()/2004 1963 . 19/1963
6
, 23

2016 Kypros Ioannides

82
8.3

8.3.1

, ,
1
2 , .

8.3.2


3.
.

.


.

, , :

24. (
)

4.

25.

() 125

()



1
. 113, 216
2
. 113, 265
3
. 113, 29(1)()
4
, , 24

2016 Kypros Ioannides

83
() .1

, I , :

3. ,
,
.2

,

3.

8.4


,
.

4.





,
5.


,

, (
) 6 .

1
, , 25
2
, , 3
3
.. v.
(2003) 1 778
4
. 113, 75
5
. 113, 77
6
.. v.
.. (2002) 1A 497

2016 Kypros Ioannides

84
1.

, ,
,
2.

8.5

3 ,

4.

,

5. ,
, ,
,
,




6.


,
7.

( ),

8 ,
1
. 113, 27(2)
2
. 113, 76(1)
3
""
. 113, 78(2).
4
. 113, 78(1)
5
. 113, 78(2)
6
. 113, 78(3)
7
. 113, 79
8
57

2016 Kypros Ioannides

85
1.

1
. 113, 113

2016 Kypros Ioannides

86
9 :

9.1

, ,
,
, .


. ,

, ,
, .


,
( )
.

.

()1:
.
.

2: .
.

3 : (

, ).

,
,
, .
1
. 113, 27
2
. 113, 170
3
. 113, 171

2016 Kypros Ioannides

87
.
" ,
.

9.2


(construction)
, ,
1.

80 :

80. ,

,
,
, , , ,
,
,
, .
,

.

, ,
,
2.

, 3.

9.3

1
Filter Syndicate Co. v. Cuninghame [1906] 2 Ch. 34, C.A., Gramophone and Typewriter, Limited v.
Stanley [1908] 2 K.B.D. 89, Michaelides v. Gavrielides (1980) 1 CLR 244.
2
Filter Syndicate Co. v. Cuninghame , Gramophone and Typewriter [1906] 2 Ch. 34, C.A.
3
Shaw & Sons (Salford) Ltd v. Shaw [1935] 2 K.B. 113, C.A., Scott v. Scott [1943] 1 All ER 582

2016 Kypros Ioannides

88
9.3.1


1.


2.

3.

,

, 4.

9.3.2

113
5,
.


.
, ,
( )
. 75
:

75.

.

( )

6.
1
. 113, 2
2
. 113, 170
3
192(2)(), . 113
4
. 113, 171 (. 172).
5
. 177, . 113, . 175

6
. 113, 192(5)

2016 Kypros Ioannides

89
9.3.3


1
, 942. , 3,
,
(

).



(

) 4 . ,
,
,
.
5.


.

. ,
.

9.3.4


,
6,
.

1
, 89-97
2
, 94
3
, 95
4
. 113, 177
5
. . 113, 174
6
. 113, 178

2016 Kypros Ioannides

90
.
,
(
).
( ),
.

,
.
,
. ..
1
.
,

2.


( .. )
( 1/3) ,
. .

9.4

,

.

, 3
.
,

)4.

1
, 76
2
. 113, 183:
.
3
.. 80
4

2016 Kypros Ioannides

91
9.4.1


.

1 .
,
2 ,
3 4.

9.4.2

,
,
.
:

98. ,
, ,


,
.

9.4.3

,

.
. :

99.
,
1
, 106
2
, 102
3
, 81
4
, 107-109

2016 Kypros Ioannides

92
.

9.4.4


1.

.

.
.
.
,
2.

1
, 98
2
Barron v. Potter [1914] 1 Ch 895

2016 Kypros Ioannides

93
10 :

10.1

1:

()
,
()
.

() :
,
, .

2 .
3.

() :
,
.

() :


.
,
,

4.
1
. 113, 27
2
. 113, 4(4)()
3
. 113, 4(4)()
4
v.
(2003) 1 778:



.

2016 Kypros Ioannides

94

18 ,
(
) 1.

.
2, :

() ,

() 3,

() , ,
4.

10.2


5:

() ,

() ,

() ,

() ,

() ,
.

, , ,

195
,
.
1
, . 149, 11
2
. 113, 57 57
3
. 113, 28
4
. 113, 53
5
. 113, 105

2016 Kypros Ioannides

95
.
,
1.

( )
( ) 2
2 .
. 30

3.


4. ,
5.



6.

10.3


.
.

. ,

.


.

7
.

1
. 113, 105(3)
2
. 113, 108
3
. 113, 110
4
. 113, 113
5
. 113, 112
6
. 113, 111
7
. 60()/2010

2016 Kypros Ioannides

96
3 : , .

10.3.1

, ,
1
3
1.

,

, .

.

13
,
.

,
, ,
.

,

.

10.3.2


2.

18
.

,
15
1
. 113, 124.
104 .
.
2
. 113, 125

2016 Kypros Ioannides

97
.
.


, ,

.

10.3.3


,
:

- ,
,
- ,
- ,
- .

1 ,
,
.


, ,

,

, ,
. .

4.2.9
.
,
1
, 9

2016 Kypros Ioannides

98

,
,
.

10.3.4


1.


2.

, , ,
50%

,
, 28
,
56 .

3.


,
. , ,
4.


1
, 48
2
, 49
3
. 113, 169(1)
4
. 113, 169(2)

2016 Kypros Ioannides

99

,

1/10
1.

21 ,

3 2 . ,

.

,
, 3.

10.3.5

4:

: 21 .

: 14 .


: 21 5

,
.


1
. 113, 126
2
. 113, 128()
3
. 113, 129
4
. 113, 127
5
. 113, 135

2016 Kypros Ioannides

100
: ()
()
95% .


, ,
. ,


1.


..
178 .
28
.
2.

10.4

10.4.1


. ,

3.

10.4.2

.
2
3 4.

10.4.3

1
Tiessen v. Henderson [1899] 1 Ch. 861
2
. 113, 136
3
. 113, 128(2)
4
. 113, 128(1)()

2016 Kypros Ioannides

101

.

1.



.
..
2.

10.4.4

,

.

, ,
( )
.
.

, ,

3.

,
.



.
.
4 .
.
.

5.
1
. 113, 128(1)()
2
National Dwellings Society v. Sykes [1894] 3 Ch. 159
3
. 113, 132
4
Northern Counties Securities Ltd v. Jackson & Steeple Ltd [1974] 1 WLR 1133
5
Puddlephatt v. Leith [1916] 1 Ch. 200

2016 Kypros Ioannides

102
10.4.5


, ,
1.


.

( )
.


48
2.

10.4.6

,





.

3.

10.4.7



4.

1
. 113, 130
2
. 113, 130(3)
3
. 113, 128
4
. 113, 139

2016 Kypros Ioannides

103
10.5

10.5.1


.
,
.

()

()

()

()

()

10.5.2


, .

.

.
, .

10.5.3

1 :

() 3/4 ,

1
. 113, 135(1)

2016 Kypros Ioannides

104
() ,

()
.

10.5.4

1
21
.

()

()

()

()

10.5.5



2.


. 113
3.
1
. 113, 135(2)
2
. 113, 137
3
. 89()/2015
Russel v. Northern Bank Development Corp and others [1992]
BCLC

2016 Kypros Ioannides

105
, 90%
,
(. 75%).


178, .

2016 Kypros Ioannides

106
11 :

11.1


.

(fiduciary position)
, .



. ,

.


,
.

() ,
() .


, ,
.

11.2



1.

1
. 113,169

2016 Kypros Ioannides

107

Re City Equitable Fire Insurance Co.1 , Romer
:

() :
.

() : ,

( )
.

..
.

() :
.

.

,
.

() :
,
, ,
, ,

.

Romer,

.



.


Romer. Equitable Fire
Insurance
1
Re City Equitable Fire Insurance Co. [1925] Ch. 407

2016 Kypros Ioannides

108
. .
,
Romer
. .

Re DJan of London Ltd 1


:

()
,
,
() ,
.

, In
Re Barings Plc (No 5)2 :

() , ,

.

() (
) ,
,

.

()
() . ,

,
.

, Equitable Life Assurance


Society v Bowley & Ors3, Langley
Romer . Equitable

.
.
1
Re DJan of London Ltd [1994] 1 BCLC 561 (Chancery Division)
2
In Re Barings Plc (No 5) [2000] 1 BCLC 523, 535
3
Equitable Life Assurance Society v Bowley & Ors [2003] EWHC 2263 (Comm) (17 October 2003)
(QBD, Commercial Court)

2016 Kypros Ioannides

109
11.3

(fiduciary)
.
(trustee)
.

3
:

11.3.1

(bona fides)
.



1.

Re W. & M. Roith
Limited2
. ,
,
.
,
.

:
,

.
.

11.3.2

1
In Re Smith & Fawcett Limited [1942] Ch. 304 C.A., . 306
2
Re W. & M. Roith Limited [1967] 1 W.L.R. 432

2016 Kypros Ioannides

110
,

.


. Howard Smith
v. Ampol Ltd 1 Privy Council
.

.
( .. )

.

.

,
2.

11.3.3 ,
,

,


.


,
1
Howard Smith v. Ampol Ltd [1974] A.C. 821, P.C.
2
Mills v. Mills (1938) 60 CLR 150 (High Court of Australia)

2016 Kypros Ioannides

111
1.

.

2.

500 .
. , 3 ,

.
.

,
.
4.



,

.



5.

House of Lords Regal


(Hastings) Ltd v. Gulliver 6. , Regal
.
. Regal

, Regal
.
1
Aberdeen Rly Co. v. Blaikie Bros (1854) 1 Macq 461 (House of Lords)
2
. 113, 191
3
Hely-Hutchinson v. Brayhead Limited [1968] 1 QB 549, C.A.
199 Companies Act 1948
4
North-West Transportation Co. Ltd v. Beatty (1887) 12 App Cas 589 (P.C.)
5
Cook v. Deeks [1916] 1 AC 554 (Privy Council)
6
Regal (Hastings) Ltd v. Gulliver [1942] 1 All ER 378

2016 Kypros Ioannides

112
Regal . Regal (
)
.
.

Regal .
.
,
, .

Peso-Silver Mines Ltd v.


Cropper1
( )

.



, ,
,
2.

1
Peso-Silver Mines Ltd v. Cropper (1966) 56 DLR (2d) 1 (Supreme Court of Canada)
2
.. v. 10953/19.5.2006

2016 Kypros Ioannides

113
12

12.1

(
)
. ,
,
.


.

,
. .

.
. ,
,
.


.


. .

.
,
.

, ,
..
75%


.

2016 Kypros Ioannides

114
.

12.2 Foss v. Harbottle


12.2.1


Foss v. Harbottle1.

Edwards v. Halliwell2 3:

()
, , .

()

,
,
. ,
,
.


.
,
.

12.2.2

O Foss v. Harbottle .

1
Foss v. Harbottle (1843) 2 Hare 461 (Court of Chancery)
2
Edwards v. Halliwell (1950) 2 All E.R. 1064 . 1066 - 1067
3
. . MAESTRO ENT. (FAMAGUSTA) LIMITED,
. 564/00 9.4.2001 ( ) (. ..)

2016 Kypros Ioannides

115

.
, :

,
, ,
, 1.

2 3:

() (ultra vires)4
.

()
.

..
.

.

()

,

. ..

.

Z&I
Mediterranean Leisure Investments Limited .. v. - 5
3 ,
1 . 3 ,
1
Jenkings LJ, Edwards v. Halliwell [1950] 2 All ER 1064 (CA) ( )
2
.. v. , . . . 11784, 24.11.2006, v.
Investylia Public Co. Ltd (2008) 1B 1117 (
, ).
3
(act or transaction) ,
,
, .. , v. Investylia
Public Co. Ltd (2008) 1B 1117
4
. 5.1.2
5
Z&I Mediterranean Leisure Investments Limited .. v. - . . .
159/2005, 25.5.2007

2016 Kypros Ioannides

116
, 82%, 18%.


3 , ,
1, .
3

1,
.
3,
, ,
,
18% 14%. , ,
3,
2 ,
3,
1 . , ,
1,
,
,
, ,
126 , . 113. ,
,
. , ,
,
1 1

Foss v. Harbottle.
, ,

()

(fraud)
,

.

2016 Kypros Ioannides

117
Daniels v. Daniels1 Templeman.
( ):

() Alexander v. Automatic Telephone Co.2




.
,
Foss v.
Harbottle ,
.

() Cook v. Deeks3

. ,
,
,

.

() ,

, . Pavlides v. Jensen 4



.



.


Templeman Daniels v. Daniels ()

,
,
, .

1
Daniels and others v. Daniels and others (1978) 2 All E.R. 89
2
Alexander v. Automatic Telephone Co. (1900) 2 Ch. 56
3
Cook v. Deeks(1916) 1 AC 554
4
Pavlides v. Jensen (1956) Ch. 565

2016 Kypros Ioannides

118
v. 1 ,

, , ,

.


Foss v. Harbottle

,

.

() (
)
(
,
, )
.


, ,
.
Pavlides . Jensen 2

, Prudential Assurance Co Ltd. v. Newman
Industries Ltd (No.2)3 ,


.

Glass v. Atkin4,
50% ,
50%
1
.. v. , . . . 11784, 24.11.2006
2
Pavlides v. Jensen (1956) Ch. 565
3
Prudential Assurance Co Ltd. v. Newman Industries Ltd (No.2) [1981] Ch. 257
4
Glass v. Atkin [1967] 65 D.R.L. 2D 501

2016 Kypros Ioannides

119
, 50%

.

v. 1,
(
... )

.

12.2.3


. []

Foss v. Harbottle.

.
.2

H
() Foss v. Harbottle (
)
, "
" (minority shareholders action) "
" (derivative action)

. ,
. ,
.
:
, ,

.

,
1
v. . . 11387, 23/1/2004 ( )
2
J.H. FARRAR, COMPANY LAW (1985), . 363, Personal Rights (
) ( )

2016 Kypros Ioannides

120
(nominal defendant).

(
). (
), 1.


(substantive defendants)
2.


v. 3 ,
( .9 .9) :

.
, Foss
v.Harbottle
.
.

.
( Gower, Modern Company Law, 3
(1969) . 587,
, . .. .
(2004) 1 ... 136).

,
4:

,
, ,
.
Foss v. Harbottle (1843) 2
Hare 461. , ,

,

1
v. .. . . 255/2010, 13/6/2013
2
v. Investylia Public Co. Ltd (2008) 1B 1117
3
.. v. , . . . 11784, 24.11.2006
4
Michael N Ioannides Manufacturing Trading Ltd v.
, . 1/2012, 18/6/2013

2016 Kypros Ioannides

121
. ,

,
,
,
.
Derivative Action (: Palmer, , . 65-02 65-05,
. 976-980).

1:


,
.
,

.

, Foss v. Harbottle (1843)


67 E.R. 189, , ,
,
. ,
,
.

, ,
.. . (2006) 1 ... 1263 .. .
(2004) 1 ... 136.

,

2.


3.

12.3
1
Yiannis G. Mammous .. . Willstrop .., . . 363/08, . 24/1/12, v.
.. . . 255/2010, 13/6/2013
2
.. v. , . . . 11784, 24.11.2006, v. .
. 11387, 23/1/2004 ( )
3
v. .. . . 255/2010, 13.6.2013

2016 Kypros Ioannides

122
1

.

In re Pelmako
Developments Limited2, 202
210
Company's Act 1948.
.

12.3.1

()
,

()
3,

() ( )
.

In re Pelmako
Developments Limited 4 ( ) , ,
:

Re Five Minute Car Wash Service, Ltd


""
202 . 113,

() ,
() ,
() , ,
,
.

""
Scottish Co- Operative Wholesale Society Ltd.
1
. 113, 202
2
Pelmako Development Ltd, (1999) 1 ... 1369
3
. 211(), . 113
4
In re Pelmako Development Ltd, (1991) 1 ... 246

2016 Kypros Ioannides

123
v. Meyer.
(probity), (fair dealing)
. , (inefficiency)
,
.

" " (just and equitable),


. , "equitable"
"just". , (term of
art), (equity),
.

(equity).
.

,

, ,

, .

() ,
-.
() .
() .

Karaoglanian & Sons v. Karaoglanian1.

12.3.2


202 :

()
.

()
1
Karaoglanian & Sons v. Karaoglanian 4 JSC 488

2016 Kypros Ioannides

124

()
.

202 petition
1933.
. In re
Pelmako Developments Limited1 ,

, '
,
,
.

202

. '
. ,
,
202
.

1
In re Pelmako Developments Limited . . 8966/10.9.1999

2016 Kypros Ioannides

125
13
2014
2015
.

13.1

.
. ,
.


. ,
.

.
.
,
.


1 .
,
.


.
1
. , . . , 2013

2016 Kypros Ioannides

126
1600

1400

1200

1000

800

600

400

200

0
1996 1998 2000 2002 2004 2006 2008 2010 2012

V VI
, 203 344.

,
:

() ,

() ,

() .

13.2

13.2.1



1.

(petition)
19332.
1
. 209, . 113
2
. 213, . 113

2016 Kypros Ioannides

127
13.2.2

1:

()
,
()
,
()
,
()
.
,

,
.
() ,
()
[just and equitable] .

(SE)
SE
64 () . 2157/2001 8
2001 (SE).2

13.2.3

() ,
3:

() 854
( ),
,
,
,
() ,
1
. 211, . 113
2
. 211(), . 113
3
. 212, . 113

2016 Kypros Ioannides

128
,
,
() ,
,
,
.

13.2.4

(),

202 . 113.

In re Pelmako Developments Limited 1 ,


:

" " (just and equitable),


. , "equitable"
"just". , (term of
art), (equity),
.

(equity).
.


, :

() ,
-.
() .
() .

13.2.5

1
In re Pelmako Developments Limited (1991) 1 AA 246

2016 Kypros Ioannides

129
1:

() ,
() ,
() (
) .
()
163 .
()
.

13.2.6

,
, .

2
.

.
.

, ,

3. ,

4.

13.2.7

,
5.

.

1
. 213, . 113
2
. 227, . 113
3
. 215, . 113
4
. 220, . 113
5
. 219, . 113

2016 Kypros Ioannides

130
,
1.

,
,
, ,
,
, 2.


3.

4 ,
5.

,
, , .

6.

,

7.


8. ,
9.


, ,
,
, ,
,
10.
1
. 218(), . 113
2
. 216, . 113
3
. 217, . 113
4
. 13.2.6
5
. 220, . 113
6
. 228, . 113
7
. 229, . 113
8
. 231, . 113
9
. 232, . 113
10
. 233, . 113

2016 Kypros Ioannides

131

1.

() ,
()
, ()

,
2.



,


3.


,

,
4.

,

, .


, ,
,
, , ,
.


, .


,
1
. 224, . 113
2
. 225, . 113
3
. 240(), . 113
4
. 240(), . 113

2016 Kypros Ioannides

132
1.

13.2.8

, ,
,
.

2.

13.3


.
3 3:

() , ,
, , ,
,

,
() ,
()
,
.

13.3.1


4.
5.

13.3.2

1
. 239, . 113
2
. 260, . 113
3
. 261, . 113
4
. 263, . 113
5
. 262, . 113

2016 Kypros Ioannides

133

1.

,
,
12 2.
.

,
. ,

,
3.

13.3.3

,
4.
, ( )
.
5.

13.3.4

, ,
,
6.

,
,
, 7.


1
. 266(4), . 113
2
. 266, . 113
3
. 276, . 113
4
. 268, . 113
5
. 277, . 113
6
. 264, . 113
7
. 265, . 113

2016 Kypros Ioannides

134
1 ( 2)
.

13.3.5

,


3.
4.



.
5.

13.4



, ,
6.


7:

()
.
()
, ,
, ,
,
.
()
1
. 272, . 113
2
. 282, . 113
3
. 273, . 113
4
. 283, . 113
5
. 272 283, . 113
6
. 293, . 113
7
. 295, 216 217, . 113

2016 Kypros Ioannides

135
.

()
1.
()
2.

,
, ,

3.

13.5

,
4 .
:

() ,
() (

)
()
,

.

,
,
.
,

.

1
. 296, . 113
2
. 297, . 113
3
. 297, . 113
4
. 300, . 113

2016 Kypros Ioannides

136
2016 Kypros Ioannides

137

You might also like