Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Spring 2010
powered by Loyalty 360
Customer:
What does
she have
to do with
loyalty?
Request your complimentary “Little Book” of Integrated Marketing, Integrated Email Marketing,
Web Engagement or Social Media Marketing – Visit www.alterian.com/littlebooks today.
34
First Step
8 Letter from the Editor
pg
10 Contributors
TECHNOLOGY,
TRENDS & REWARDS
sneak preview on page 59! 40 @Social Media: #Tweeting and #Loyalty
Michelle Marquardt
42 So Many Shiny Things, How Do I Choose?
40
Now (because of the new “CARD” act & the pending
financial reform bill)
Tom Koeppen, DataCo Solutions, LLC
pg
Loyalty Management
Editorial & Production Team
Erin Raese - Editor in Chief
What does
Mark Johnson - Contributing Editor
Elizabeth Heyer - Editorial Director
a customer
Kathleen Ninneman - Graphic Designer
Graphics Plus, Inc. - Print Production have to do
Loyalty 360 Team
with loyalty?
48
Mark Johnson - President & CEO
Erin Raese - COO
Amanda Chasteen - Manager, Marketing Operations
Charlie Deye - Director of Sales
Jessica Siegert - Sales & Account Manager pg
Julie Hellebusch - Controller
Contacts
Article Submissions: Erin Raese (erinraese@loyalty360.org)
Advertising: Charlie Deye (513.226.0925)
BEST BUSINESS PRACTICES
To subscribe to Loyalty Management, visit loyalty360.org.
48 What Does a Customer Have To Do with Loyalty?
Shiv Gupta, Farmers Insurance
We Want Your Feedback
50 A Time for Change
As a “voice of the customer” focused publication we Carlos Dunlap, Kobie Marketing
want to hear from you–our customers. What would
you like to see included in these pages? Share your 54 Creating Loyalty Inside, Outside a Company: Five
thoughts on articles and ideas for content. Strategies
Dianne Durkin, The Loyalty Factor
This is your platform. We would like to hear from you.
56 Voice of the Customer: What Does That Mean for
Write us at: mailbag@loyaltymangement.com
Loyalty and Engagement?
© 2010 Loyalty 360, Inc. and/or its Affiliates. All Rights Reserved. Mark Johnson, Loyalty 360
Reproduction and distribution of this publication in any form without prior written permis-
sion is forbidden. The information contained herein has been obtained from sources be-
lieved to be reliable. Loyalty 360 disclaims all warranties as to the accuracy, completeness 58 Loyalty Program Profile
or adequacy of such information. The opinions shared are those of the contributing uthors
and not necessarily reflective of Loyalty 360 and/or its affiliates. Loyalty 360 shall have no
ULTA Beauty
liability for errors, omissions or inadequacies in the information contained herein or for in-
terpretations thereof. The opinions expressed herein are subject to change without notice. 59 2010 Loyalty Expo Preview
what’s on loyalty360.org
Loyalty 360 brings you the best of the best in loyalty marketing
and supports your customer strategy needs. Some of the tools we offer include:
Dianne Durkin
Dianne Durkin is the president and founder Mark Johnson
of The Loyalty Factor, a training and Mark is the President and CEO of Loyalty
consulting firm that educates executives, 360. He has significant experience in selling,
managers and lower-level employees in ways designing and administering prepaid, loyalty/
to build customer and brand loyalty. CRM programs, as well as data-driven
marketing communication programs.
DIUHVKSHUVSHFWLYH RQHQJDJHPHQW
PDUNHWLQJ
www.young-america.com
1.800.533.4529
Tom Koeppen Laura Patterson
Tom Koeppen has over 20 years of success Laura Patterson is president and co-founder
increasing the effectiveness and profitability of VisionEdge Marketing, Inc, a leading data-
of marketing strategies and customer driven metrics-based strategic and product
relationship programs. Tom is Sr. Vice marketing firm.
President of Sales and Marketing Strategy
with DataCo Solutions LLC, a marketing
analytics consulting group. Karl Sharicz
Karl Sharicz is Manager of Customer
Intelligence at SimplexGrinnell. For more
Michelle Marquardt information about the company’s products
Michelle Marquardt is an interactive and services, visit www.simplexgrinnell.com.
marketing consultant with a focus on
social media, online and offline marketing
channels and in integrating web contact with
traditional marketing channels.
ȱȱȱȱǰȱȱǰȱȱ
ǯǯ
LOYALTY FORUM: YOUR VOICE
Ask the
Experts
Q: Banks and retailers are facing a variety of opportunities and challenges as
they try to make loyalty marketing meaningful to the individual customer
at the point of greatest value—the moment of purchase. What are you
doing to overcome these challenges? How are you using technology to
engage with customers during the purchase process?
GZYjXZY
J^[WddkWbc[[j_d]fbWY[\eh_dZkijho
eg^X^c\[dggZiV^aZgh
VcY\dkZgcbZci fhWYj_j_ed[hijeYh[Wj[h[bWj_edi^_fi"
ZmZXji^kZh
WYgk_h[fheÓjfheZkY_d]ijhWj[]_[iWdZi^Wf[
9EDH7:8HKII;BI j^[_dZkijhoÊi\kjkh[Z_h[Yj_edWdZ]hemj^
8hkii[bi"8[b]_kc
'&#'(CWo(&'&
=?<J97H:ILEK9>;HIEF;DBEEF
:_ij_d]k_i^[ZIf[Wa[h<WYkbjo_dYbkZ[i 7][dZW>ejJef_Yi
BWkdY^ehikffehjoekhiY^[c[WdZjWa[WmWoj^[bWj[ij
D[m^[
_hYk
_j _d\ehcWj_ededYkhh[djboikYY[ii\kbfh[fW_Zfhe]hWcc[i 7ZhiEgVXi^XZh[dg
jej Wa[h9 ijhWj[]_[i"jh[dZi"_iik[iWdZX[ijfhWYj_Y[i
If [ 9ZbdchigVi^c\i]Z7jh^cZhh
8VhZ[dgEgZeV^Y
E8J7?D[gZh]^YZVhh`^aahi]Vil^aaeVnd[[^bbZY^ViZanWVX`Vii]Zd[ÒXZ
OLEDD;M;IJ I?CED8KH9A>7H:J ;L7BK7J;:jgdeZÉhaViZhi\^[iXVgY!kdjX]ZgVcYdeZc"addehX]ZbZhVcY 6YYgZhh^c\EgZeV^Y
I7?DI8KHO J;B;<ED?97E( Deedgijc^i^Zh[dg7Vc`hVcY
hZgk^XZhidXdchigjXindjgegd\gVbbZWajZeg^ci
9P;9>H;FK8B?9
;^cVcX^Va>chi^iji^dch
:;L;BEFegdÒiVWaZgZVa"ldgaYhigViZ\^Zhi]gdj\]^ckVajVWaZVXXZhhidi]Zbdhi
Y^hi^c\j^h]ZY[VXjain^ci]Z:jgdeZVcegZeV^Y^cYjhignidYVn >cY^k^YjVaDeedgijc^i^Zh^ci]Z
;IJ78B?I>J>;JEEBIid9ECCKD?97J;ndjg\^[iXVgY!kdjX]ZgdgdeZc"adde EjWa^XHZXidgVcY>YZci^[n^c\
hX]ZbZbdgZZ[[ZXi^kZanidVXfj^gZVcYgZiV^cndjgiVg\ZibVg`ZiVcYWddhindjg EgZeV^YDeedgijc^i^Zh^c
7B;II7D:HE C7HA:;GK;HL7?D Wdiidba^cZ HeZX^VainBVg`Zih
7B87DE LK;;DJ;HJ7?DC;DJ
FEIJ;?J7B?7D; :edÊjC_iiKd_gk[?dj[]hWj[ZD[jmeha_d] Jh^c\EgZeV^YVhVc:[[ZXi^kZ
<[Wjkh[i<eh(&'& 9Za^kZgnBZX]Vc^hb[dg
D[m^[ _hYk
_j
AdnVain!>cXZci^kZVcYGZlVgYh
jej Wa[h9
I f [ :?7CED:9E9AJ7?BH;9;FJ?ED Egd\gVbbZh
IF;7A;H:?I9KII?EDBKD9>J78B;I AZ\VaVcYGZ\jaVidgn>hhjZh
:;9B7D8OHD; @;H;COEI8EHD; IF;;:D;JMEHA?D=M;B9EC;H;9;FJ?ED ^cBjai^"8djcignEgZeV^Y8VgY
J>;=?<J JK?JH7L;BFB9
LEK9>;HI>EFBJ:
Egd\gVbbZh
ÉJ;IJ#:H?L;79EDIKBJ7DJÊ
D[m^[ _hYk
_j
jej Wa[h9
[
HjeedgiZY
If
7n/ The World’s Leading Card Manufacturer
mmm$fh[fW_Z[nfe[khef[$Yec
K:EI9>M;;HI HE8;HJ97FB;>EHD
I;87= F7OF7B;KHEF;
LOYALTY FORUM: BEHIND THE BRAND/PEOPLE
Stuart Kiefer
Divison Manager of Loyalty Solutions
First Data
Stuart Kiefer is responsible for the strategic focus, new product
development and innovation for Loyalty and Personalized Marketing
at First Data. Kiefer has more than ten years of experience in creating,
launching and managing loyalty-marketing programs.
Prior to his current role, Stuart managed large direct/database marketing relationships on behalf
of First Data’s Donnelley Marketing Group. These efforts focused on the acquisition, retention and
profitability of various credit card portfolios as well as the cross-sell efforts of partnering financial
institutions.
What are the qualities you most admire in Which book(s) are you currently
a person? recommending?
Courage, integrity, and a good sense of humor. Extreme Measures by Vince Flynn. Stuart Coleman
The courage to try new things, integrity to follow is my kind of hero.
through with a consistent set of values and
principles, and the ability to laugh with people and What can we expect from First Data for
at yourself from time to time. the rest of 2010 and beyond?
First Data will continue its transformation from
If you could invite four people to dinner a payments processor to a technology company.
(past or present) who would they be? We are committed to ongoing investment, both
This is a great question and one that comes domestically and internationally, in cutting edge
up frequently in dinner conversations. The easy technology solutions in loyalty, direct marketing,
answers always seem to be Abraham Lincoln, prepaid, mobile, and ecommerce as well as our
Ghandi, Ronald Reagan, Warren Buffett or Bill traditional issuing and merchant lines of business.
Gates. Those are all great answers, but I’m going
to go off the reservation a bit and start with Jimmy What’s your advice for a novice loyalty
Buffett. I’m a big fan of Jimmy’s music and books. marketer?
I’ve always said if I ever hit the lottery, I would buy a Think like a consumer. Look at several programs
boat and sail around the Keys until I caught up with in the market today and make a list of what you
him. like and what you dislike about each. Take the list
Next, I would invite Brett Favre. First, I am of “likes” and evaluate how they could apply to
a lifelong Minnesota Viking fan. I’ve suffered your business. I recommend establishing a team of
through four Super Bowl losses and a couple of employees who represent the various disciplines
NFC Championship game losses in my life. I think within your company: marketing, I.T., finance
the Vikings best shot at getting to the big show and operations. Your success in contingent upon
next year is to get Brett to come back for one more cooperation and integration with all areas, but
season. I just want to do my part to help him see remember it’s a marketing program. L
the light.
My third guest is probably the biggest Brett Favre
talent when
fourth son to Mindy and me. Logan was tragically
killed by an automobile just before Christmas 2008,
forever changing our lives. Logan was a bright,
talent doesn’t
funny, athletic young man with a very bright future.
We miss him dearly.
Finally, if I’m inviting Logan and Brett, I have to
work hard.
invite Tyler Kiefer, my fifteen year old son. Like any
parent, I would do anything for my boys and if I
could give Tyler one more day with Logan, it would
be the greatest evening of my life.
Judy
Christa-
Cathey
Vice President Global Brand Marketing
Hampton Hotels
Many of us talk about building our cultures around
the customer experience, however many of us tend to
have a difficult time effectively executing, often due
to time or finance constraints. How are you able to
Hampton Hotels has been keep customer experience a priority?
Customer experience is a priority because our vision at Hamp-
recognized for being, one of the top ton Hotels is to set the standard for competitors to follow. Con-
hotel franchises in the nation and stantly listening to our customers is how we innovate and evolve
a part of Hilton Worldwide. A big in order to stay relevant to today and tomorrow’s customers. This
commitment to be a customer-centric brand is full circle at Hamp-
hotel chain with very high standards.
ton from hotel product innovation and team member training to
No matter which of our 1,800 hotels marketing and public relations messaging. At Hampton we believe
you check into, here’s what you can that it is our ability to connect and drive guest loyalty at the hotel
count on: friendly service, clean level that helps us build our circle of friends. We call our culture
“hamptonality,” one unstoppable brand with irresistible personality.
rooms, Clean and Fresh Hampton We celebrate team members who connect with guests. We always
bed washed fresh for every guest, keep customer experience a priority by leveraging guest insights for
delicious free hot breakfast, free the future while providing a consistent experience today and unify-
ing our brand voice internally and externally.
internet access and hotels that are
in touch with the needs of today’s Share how a focus on customer experience has built
travelers. Every time. Guaranteed. loyalty to your brand?
Four years prior to celebrating Hampton’s 20th anniversary,
Loyalty Management takes a closer we conducted a deep dive into what our most loyal and potential
guests preferred in a mid-scale hotel brand. These travelers helped
look at the woman behind the prioritize where Hampton needed to evolve and innovate to con-
brand – Judy Christa-Cathey, Vice tinue to be a leader. Hampton guest loyalty and award recognition
President, Global Brand Marketing, from business travel publications soared after our multi-year hotel
Hampton Hotels. product innovation launched, which included providing a hot free
breakfast instead of the traditional continental offering and intro-
ducing a new bed experience where the linens and duvets were
laundered fresh for every guest. Just as important as our product
innovations, our brand culture also evolved to align with guests, as
did our customer messaging. Always listening is our philosophy,
how we listen to guest allows us to innovate for the future.
Loyalty Reads
10 TRUTHS ABOUT LEADERSHIP…It’s Not Just About Winning
by Pete Luongo
August 2007 | Clerisy Press
In a world where greed and winning at all costs has permeated organizations from youth sports to Fortune
Top 50 companies and everything in between, everyone is faced with the same challenge: How do we not fall into the trap
of compromising our core values as we chase the end game? Can we create an environment where winning (success however you measure it) and
employees feeling valued, respected, and part of something special are mutually inclusive? The answer is a yes!
Prior to the publication of 10 Truths About Leadership…It’s Not Just About Winning and his full time speaking career, Pete was President/CEO of
the Berry Company, a 1.5 billion dollar yellow page advertising agency. Since retirement Pete has devoted himself to giving back through his book,
speaking engagements, board membership, and by serving as executive director of the Center for Leadership and Executive Development at the
University of Dayton where he also serves as an adjunct professor teaching leadership at both the undergraduate and graduate levels.
Pete has been fortunate to work with 100+ companies, collegiate athletic programs and numerous other organizations sharing his behavior
driven model “The Leadership Pledge”, developed while he was at Berry, that focuses on people, support, expectations, feedback, and accountability.
The ten truths are life’s lessons that help each of us understand that our lives will be valued by our willingness to make a difference in other people’s
lives. Coaching and inspiring leadership at all organizational levels is Pete’s passion: his message will move and inspire you.
“Pete Luongo didn’t decide to sit down and write a book on leadership, he was called to do so.
See, there are those times in one’s life where the ability to “not” do something is no longer
an alternative. Pete and his witty, charismatic and “loving” personality are mere byproducts
of a set of experiences he has noted, been moved by and found enormous success.”
—Curt W. Coffman, co-author of the New York Times bestselling First, Break all the Rules
THE INSPIRATION FACTOR: How You Can Revitalize Your Company Culture in 12 Weeks
by Terry Barber
March 2010 | Greenleaf Book Group Press
When all is said and done, everybody wants to know they have made a difference in someone’s life. Regardless of your
personality type, background or age, you can choose to create an inspirational transaction and positively impact people
around you, or as chief inspirational officer Terry Barber calls it, your “Inspiration Factor.”
And when the “Inspiration Factor” goes up, according to Barber, so does loyalty that can be applied to all facets of life—
family, employees, team members, customers, donors, and friends.
Barber reveals the seven principles of inspiration and how implementing even one of them can positively impact
someone’s life. Implement all seven and you will change the very culture in which you live and work. When the principles are
applied at home, families become safe and fun environments. When applied at work, team members become more loyal as
do customers, clients, and donors.
Throughout The Inspiration Factor, Barber uses insights, humor, and gripping stories to impart the seven proven principles
and will help you—as an individual and as part of an organization—to:
•Be the most valuable team leader in your company
•Grow your sphere of influence
•Manage up
•Get ahead by inspiring those around you
•Revitalize your company culture after a very difficult economic down time
Find out how the fate of your B2B Company rests in the hands of relatively few people, and what you need to do about it.
The world for executives in Business to Business (B2B) companies is critically different from the world of their
Business to Consumer (B2C) counterparts. All too often B2C strategies and tactics are applied to B2B companies, which
leads to disappointing, even disastrous results. B2B requires a completely different playbook.
“When I became CEO, status quo was not an option. I’ve witnessed the
impact Geehan’s approach has made with many firms. Applying these
transforming and results-driven principles was a top priority for me.”
—Joe Morgan, CEO, Standard Register
SELLING TO THE C-SUITE: What Every Executive Wants You to Know About Successfully
Selling to the Top
by Nicholas A.C. Read
August 2009 | McGraw-Hill
It’s the number one goal of every salesperson: getting access to Former executive director of Ernst and Young’s revenue
senior client executives—the C-Level decision growth and risk management practice and senior partner
makers responsible for approving top-dollar advisor at KPMG, Read, a recipient of the International
deals. But getting there may be harder than you Business Award for Best Sales Trainer, has sold in every
think…Did you know? conceivable forum—from the bazaars of Cairo to the kara-
oke boats of Tokyo; from the lounge rooms of Melbourne
•Today’ sale processes have a 97 percent failure
to the boardrooms of Manhattan…all with unbelievable
rate
success.
•2 of the top 3 reasons a salesperson wins or loses
In an informative and eye-opening interview, Read
sales is because of relationship and reputation
can reveal what every executive wants you to know
•When a salesperson ‘cold calls’ an executive they
about selling to the top including:
have a 4 percent chance of actually meeting them
•The 8 drivers of executive decision making and
•When a salesperson establishes a relationship
how each one dictates the sales process
with an executive’s subordinate and are introduced
•How to make sure you are not giving the right
through them, their chances of actually scoring a
message to the wrong audience
meeting with the executive jumps to 84 percent.
•The top secrets for persuading key decision mak-
Bottom line: to make it to the top, you have to know ers
what are most likely behind your customer’s thought process when it •How to gain access to senior client executives responsible for approving
comes to making investments with suppliers. top-dollar deals
•The steps to go from simple salesperson to top trusted advisor
Other anomalies include the endowment effect, whereby Applying Behavioral Economics and Evolving our
people place greater value on objects they own compared Institutions of Data
with objects they do not own. That is, people tend to demand At Gallup, our goal is to take the discoveries of behavior-
a higher price to part with an object they already own than al economics and apply them to management and business
they would be willing to pay for it to begin with. Another is problems. We develop tools and methods to measure and
the tendency for decision makers to be loss averse. People manage both the rational and irrational elements of human
feel more pain from losing than pleasure from achieving nature to drive business success. For Gallup, applied behav-
gains of equal size. For example, individuals tend to be re- ioral economics is the mathematical description of the role
luctant to accept the prospect of a 50-50 chance of winning human nature plays in just about…everything. This defini-
or losing money unless the amount to be won is at least twice tion spans the spectrum of issues from how customers and
the amount to potentially be lost. employees create real growth for organizations to how citi-
In the board room and at the leadership level, principles zens and institutions build stable and viable societies.
of behavioral economics play out in many decision-making Until recently, principles of neoclassical economics have
situations, with substantial implications for organization- guided capitalism. This discipline and its associated institu-
al performance. From the biasing effects of sunk costs, to tion of financial data—stock price, earnings per share, profit,
the tendency to be swayed by how a decision is positioned and growth—is what business leaders are trained upon to
or framed, to the tendency to be resistant to changing the steer their organizations, divisions, and departments. In
status quo, executive decisions are vulnerable to the ill ef- general, this model has served global business leaders quite
fects of cognitive and perceptual biases and heuristics. For- well. But recent developments in the global economy and the
tunately, many of these effects can be overcome—or at least financial markets since the beginning of 2008 underscore
reduced—with training, awareness, and discipline. But be- its limitations. It is becoming clear that without the insights
fore they can be overcome, executives must be made aware from fields such as networks and complex interactions, psy-
of them and the situations in which they are likely to arise— chology, and econometrics—neoclassical economics may
they need to increase their BE IQ. lead us down the wrong path. Classical economic indicators
Dozens of heuristics and biases have been documented provide trailing indicators of performance—by the time a
in behavioral economics literature—far too many to describe sale is made and the profit appears on the income statement,
here. But the upshot is that our emotional, cognitive, and it is too late to do anything about it. In addition, any incre-
perceptual processes limit how rationally we view the world mental benefits of accounting or other financial efficien-
around us and use the information we receive from it. These cies have largely already been realized. Further substantial
limits have a profound effect on the decisions we make—and gains in performance based on attention to neoclassical
on the way organizations need to think about how their em- economic metrics are relatively unlikely, and additional en-
ployees and customers make decisions and behave. hancements offer little in the way of competitive advantage
continued on next page »
for most firms. potential represents an internal economy with its own set
The next institution of data to emerge was tied to process of rules and dynamics—an emotional economy—that can be
improvement and quality management—Six Sigma, lean measured and managed to improve business performance.
manufacturing, and Total Quality Management, for exam- Most important, the emotional economy drives the neoclas-
ple. This institution of data worked well to improve output sical economy.
quality and wring inefficiencies and costs out of business
processes, making organizations more efficient, effective, What Is Your Behavioral Economics IQ?
productive, and profitable. But like financial metrics, much The rise of applied behavioral economics as a manage-
of the benefit of focusing on process and quality metrics has ment platform is of paramount importance to business lead-
been realized and big gains are harder to find. While quality ers because it compels us to rethink the traditional rational/
is necessary—and declining quality is likely to be a leading functional models of human decision making that guide
indicator of future declines in performance—improvements many business decisions. But before organizations can har-
in quality are unlikely to provide significant competitive ness the power of applied behavioral economics, they must
advantage for most companies. For many organizations, in- increase their BE IQ by gaining an understanding how the
cremental improvements in operational efficiency may con- emotional economy works in their organization and in the
tinue to provide some cost-reduction benefits, but they will larger marketplace. Next, they must align their business
yield little in the way of additional competitive advantage. processes and key performance metrics to take full advan-
We believe that the next big institution of data will be tage of the insights afforded by a behavioral economics per-
found in developing leadership initiatives and metrics based spective. Finally, they must deploy these insights effectively
on principles of behavioral economics because the gains to to manage and optimize their employee and customer rela-
be found are much larger than in other areas and the po- tionships.
tential is largely untapped. Mastery of applied behavioral From a behavioral economics perspective, high perfor-
economics holds the promise of realizing breakthrough im- mance organizations recognize the need to understand and
provements in employee productivity and customer reten- accept human nature and capitalize on it to select and posi-
tion—and real growth and profitability. tion employees, manage, motivate, and engage them, accel-
Our work with organizations around the globe has erate their development, and unleash innovation and pro-
taught us that every company has an enormous—but largely ductivity, all to ultimately engage the emotions of their most
untapped—potential for breakthrough improvements in em- valuable asset—their customers. Increasing your company’s
ployee productivity, customer retention, and real growth BE IQ is the next vital management discipline and the key to
and profitability by understanding and leveraging how hu- superior performance and long-term growth. L
man nature drives business performance. This unrealized
0-(Ƭ,-'0'(&+('(+,'(,(++,.
Ś0(,(Ƭ$0,"&'!'+0
-0'('+.
ŴƀƁƂŨƂŨŽƀżƄŴŬŮƁŴŻƂŮŸŸŴűŮŻƂHŬŨƂŨKŬƀŴƄŮŻŸżƇŨŸƂƇƁżŸƃƂŴżŻƁƂŲŨƂ
ŽƀżƄŴŬŮŴŻƁŴűŲƂƂżźŨŶŮƇżƃƀŸżƇŨŸƂƇŽƀżűƀŨźźżƀŮŮůůŮūƂŴƄŮFƂŴŸŴƈŴŻű
ƁƂŨƂŮżůƂŲŮŨƀƂŨŻŨŸƇƂŴūƁH ŴƀƁƂŨƂŨŮŻŨũŸŮƁƇżƃƂżƃŻŬŮƀƁƂŨŻŬƇżƃƀ
ūƃƁƂżźŮƀƁHŽƀŮŬŴūƂŽƃƀūŲŨƁŴŻűũŮŲŨƄŴżƀŨŻŬźŨƆŴźŴƈŮƀŮƄŮŻƃŮF
ŴƀƁƂŨƂŨŴƁƃŻŴſƃŮŸƇƁŶŴŸŸŮŬŨƂŽƀżƄŴŬŴŻűżƃƀūŸŴŮŻƂƁƅŴƂŲźżƀŮƀŮŸŮƄŨŻƂ
ŨŻŬƄŨŸƃŨũŸŮƀŮƅŨƀŬƁůżƀƂŲŮŴƀūƃƁƂżźŮƀƁHŴŻūƀŮŨƁŴŻűūƃƁƂżźŮƀ
ŨūſƃŴƁŴƂŴżŻŨŻŬƀŮƂŮŻƂŴżŻŨŻŬūƀŮŨƂŴŻűƁƂƀżŻűŮƀƀŮŸŨƂŴżŻƁŲŴŽƁF
Ś0Ƭ('&0'#+,ƴ'+,(,(.0&
“Sex Appeal”
Men and Women are
Loyal to Different Things
by Dr. Bob Deutsch, Brain Sells
QUALITY OR QUANTITY. For women, bigger and more is not necessarily better;
rather, a steady build is more compelling than an large, impulsive but short-lived
response. For men, size matters.
SOCIETY OR MARKETS. To women, numbers are not people; people have per-
sonal feelings and social intentions, and this is what society is comprised of. Num-
bers are mere abstractions. Males relate to markets as numbers because they can
be counted and the “goodies” duly noted.
Male: Do what you set out to do and finish the job. Female: Evolve.
Male: Achieve. Female: Experience.
Male: Stay on top of things. Female: Create good relationships.
Male: Get the biggest piece you can. Female: Seek inner peace.
Developing and engaging in a long-term relationship with women customers is
not as easy as ‘pretty in pink’ or ‘basic black.’ Men are not as straightforward as
“I’m Number One.” But knowing the inner reality of the genders can help generate
more loyal consumers and help marketers feel more in the pink by putting them
more in the black. L
Lessons
Customers want to know
when the repair will be
started and if it is not to be
from the completed when expected.
They want some idea of the
Frontline: cost. The communication
B-to-B
process needs to be ongoing.
If there is a change in when
the service is expected to
Service
by Lynn Daniel, The Daniel Group
ing. If there is a change in when the service is expected
to be initiated or completed, customers want to know. If
there are any “surprises” in the invoice, customers ex-
pect to be told BEFORE the bill arrives. One dealer has
gone so far as to call each customer with a repair above
a certain amount to let the customer know how much The importance of consistency is not surprising. Past
the invoice is, what was done, and answer any ques- experiences create a knowledge base for the customer.
tions. As a result, disputes have been greatly reduced If the experiences are generally positive, customers be-
and collections have improved. gin new service experiences with the assumption that
When effective communication doesn’t happen, we experiences are likely to be positive. If past experiences
see the impact. We ask customers to rate their willing- are less positive, too often customers start new service
ness to refer this client to someone else needing this experiences assuming the worst. Even if the new expe-
type of service. When the customer gives a low rating, rience is positive, it may not be seen that way because of
we ask why and code the reason(s). Reasons to do with accumulated experience.
poor communication (from the technician or other cli-
ent personnel) are either the first or second most fre- Performance Accountability Matters
quently mentioned reason for getting a low referral rat- The online system that is part of the ServicePerfor-
ing. Communication does TRULY matter! mance program is called LinkConnect. We use this tool
as the platform to manage client data, enter interview
Consistent Service Delivery Is Essential results, and share results with our clients. The system
When we compare the metrics of top-performing also provides information on who is using the tool.
clients with those of the bottom-performing clients Among the better performing clients, there are a few
we see significant differences and not just in the key things we have observed:
performance metrics. For these top-performing cli- a. Employees at better performing locations tend
ents, there is less variation in customer responses from to be more frequent users of the online system
location-to-location, period-to-period, and measure-to- than are others. They use the feedback to find
measure than for clients that are performing less well. out how the location is performing and make
This consistency speaks to two things these clients changes accordingly.
have done quite well. First, the processes they have in b. Senior level managers are frequent users as well.
place are effective, though not necessarily elaborate or They are able to drill down and see how a loca-
fancy. They allow customers to quickly reach a needed tion is performing. Those that need improve-
contact person. The employee has the needed tools and ment become a focus; those that are performing
information to effectively deliver the service. Employ- well are recognized.
ees pay attention to communication. Another trait of c. There is a regular review process in place to de-
the top- performing clients is the culture present in termine improvement opportunities.
the company. There is a palpable customer focus that is Our experience with ServicePerformance is con-
present among all employees. Employees are acknowl- firming the old adage that “you manage what you mea-
edged for doing a good job. There is a focus on effec- sure.” This was confirmed by the comments of one cli-
tively solving customer problems. ent not too long ago. This client is a newer client. She
called to discuss how their key metrics had improved over the
past few months. One of the things she made special note of was
the fact that the improvement had happened without “a single
special project or initiative.” The improvement happened when
managers were made aware of their performance measurement
and held accountable for it. We recommend finding an effective
way to measure your customer service delivery.
Performance improves
70%
Number over points is
60% monthly NPS score.
50% #Responses
October
August
February
May
July
January ‘08
April
June
July 55
August 24
September 41
I t was Peter Drucker who said “that the purpose of business is to create a customer.” Phil Kotler went on to tell us that marketing
plays a very important role in this effort when he defined marketing “as the science and art of finding, keeping and growing profit-
able customers,” (Kotler on Marketing, 1999). Over 20 years ago, the TARP (Technical Assistance Research Program, U.S. Office of
Consumer Affairs, 1986) studies found the cost of attracting a new customer was five times the cost of keeping a current customer.
Research since has well proven there is a link between customer satisfaction, purchase decisions, customer experience and customer
loyalty and tenure.
Research findings have consistently found that highly satisfied customers have a strong relationship with an organization and
generally buy more or own more of an organization’s products and services. And these highly satisfied customers are also more likely
to become recommenders. Customer buying more and referring more contributes to increased customer value. And the flip side also
seems to be true—sub-par customer experience leads to customer dissatisfaction, attrition, diminished purchases and ultimately
an increase in cost per customer, which erodes customer lifetime value. So it makes sound business sense to take care of our most
important asset, our customers and to maintain satisfied and loyal customers.
every company
Retention Equity
Customer Loyalty/
to develop Advocacy and
Share of Wallet
highly satisfied Customer Satisfaction
also shown a clear relationship between advocacy and value requires having a full understanding of their wants,
service quality. The MSR group study (published 2007) needs and desires. This often requires a company to
found that 65 percent of U.S. consumers are advocates switch from a transaction perspective to a loyalty-build-
of their bank, that is they are both willing to recommend ing perspective.
their bank and intend to open additional accounts (repur- FIVE STEPS TO KEEPING YOUR CUSTOMERS
chase). 1. UNDERSTAND WHAT CUSTOMERS VALUE
Studies in the hospitality industry found a link between a. Don’t assume you know what your customers
hotel employee engagement and guest satisfaction. Ho- want
tels with employees who can align their attitudes and be- b. Do your homework—Conduct frequent cus-
haviors with guest expectations are more likely to create tomer research
guest loyalty. The real challenge then is for every compa- 2. BE PROACTIVE—ANTICIPATE FUTURE NEEDS
ny to develop highly satisfied customers and strong advo- a. Understand whether solving future needs
cates. In the 1990s, customer satisfaction was all the rage means new or different product features, bene-
as a key metric. Today, it has been replaced with customer fits, changes in services, etc., and put these into
loyalty and customer experience. A recent study from play before the customers leave your company
Aberdeen Research, “Recessionary Marketing: How Best- to find what they want somewhere else.
in-Class Companies are Weathering the Storm”, polled 3. DELIVER ON YOUR PROMISES
250 marketers across various industries, and found that a. Your word is your bond
82 percent of respondents have reallocated their market- b. If anyone makes a promise, keep it.
ing spending to invest in more customer-centric activities 4. DELIVER YOUR PRODUCT AND SERVICES
that tie back to bottom-line revenue. As a result, their CONSISTENTLY EVERY TIME
metrics will need to change as well. Metrics related to 5. CULTIVATE LONG-TERM RELATIONSHIPS
brand awareness and shareholder value are being pushed
further down on the list, while metrics related to custom- In addition to customer retention (churn/attrition), cus-
ers such as share of wallet, loyalty, and customer reten- tomer satisfaction, and loyalty every company should be
tion equity are moving to the front of the line. familiar with and know how to calculate metrics related
In addition to lifetime value and retention, there are to experience, share of wallet, value and advocacy. These
six additional key metrics to consider when it comes to metrics are vital to helping you keep and grow the value of
your most important asset, your customers. L
Customer Satisfaction:
Keeping Score Is Only
the First Step
by Karl Sharicz, SimplexGrinnell
If you want to improve your customer relationships, you need to understand why
customers rate you the way they do; and you need a systematic way to respond to
their issues.
Conference
Best Practices That Leverage Innovation, Brand Differentiation,
Online Strategies & Effective Marketing Channels
June 22-23, 2010 • The New York Helmsley Hotel
Much in a
relationship
is exclusive to
the parties in it.
Trust is key to
any successful
relationship.
@SocialMedia: #Tweeting
and #Loyalty by Michelle Marquardt
The ending to this story provides reassurance for the over- for both of you. If the complaint is bogus, you are free to say
ly cautious marketers dragging their feet on launching social so—publically—which hurts the complainers legitimacy.
media strategies—the million plus Southwest Airlines twitter
followers are still loyal fans, and Kevin’s fans also remained Fourth: Understand the Players and Their
tried and true. In the end, both brands suffered some blows, “Twitterality”
but neither lost large numbers. Just like the “real” world, there are varying levels of influ-
For Southwest, it was a lesson of how to tackle such a ence online. Learn to distinguish the powerful from the meek.
high-profile crisis. A key to their quick recovery was address- There is a high level of discretion on the boards and tweeters
ing the issue head-on and then switching gears to more posi- (as well as Facebookers and other online participants) can
tive stories. Kevin Smith (the brand) also came out strong as quickly measure anyone’s authenticity.
he stirred up important discussions about a long established When you see complaints pay attention to them. Also
rule that may indicate unfair or cruel treatment of overweight critical to watch are the number of complaints a person posts,
passengers, reaching new audiences and communities. what types of reactions they garner, how many followers do
they reach, and how often they are retweeted. If you’re South-
Second: Listen First, Tweet Second west dealing with a Kevin Smith, you need to step up your
Don’t just jump into this without listening first. Use sites game. If you’re a company dealing with a one off person who
like TweetBeep (which works like Google Alerts—which you is having a bad day and has 2 followers, you have a lot less to
should also be using), to monitor your Brand name on Twitter. worry about.
You have a problem if you don’t get many results, and you
obviously have a problem if those results are negative. How- Finally: How to “Push” Using Social Media
ever in the second case you are presented with an audience It’s not impossible, but you have to be careful! Tweet-
(which equals opportunity.) ers and Facebookers are incredibly savvy and can sniff out
commercials, like a coupon—unless it’s an incredible deal.
Third: Leverage Existing Customer Service Leverage social media to establish your brand as a leader in
Protocols its respective industry, and the loyalty will follow. Seek out
To get started, you needn’t look any further than your Cus- common concerns or questions related to your industry and
tomer Service manual. You empower these reps to address provide free, no strings attached solutions and tips. Then
customer complaints and concerns, and the same respons- wait patiently, because eventually users that are benefitting
es can be re-purposed for online complaints. There is more from these messages will request product or purchasing in-
risk for companies that ignore online complaints than those formation. It’s social, not a sales call. Remember that this is
that allow employees to attempt to help. Ignorance is not the equivalent to a cocktail party— nobody likes getting stuck
bliss—and many people are satisfied with just feeling heard waiting in the bar line with that sleazy sales guy—they like the
and addressed. Keep in mind that it’s a wonderful thing to guy who is clever and tells you something you didn’t know.
be proactive about issues rather than wait for the inevitable Also remember that Tweets are 140 characters. It’s not the
complaint call. By then it may be too late to reverse a negative place to tell a complicated story—it’s a place to lead people
experience. By listening online and reaching out to unsatis- to that story. Quick stats, breaking news and valuable infor-
fied customers—you accomplish two things; one, you let the mation. This increases your chances of being retweeted or
complainer know you take them seriously and are offering to shared and thus reaching a broader audience. It also shows
help and two, you do this publically—creating accountability that you are playing the social game, not selling anything. L
innovative merchants.
Loyalty
Innovation
NEW PRODUCTS, ADVANCEMENTS,
& TECHNOLOGIES
Biometric Recognition
Biometric Recognition was formed to develop improvements in customer re-
lationship management in the retail point-of-sale and casino gaming operations
spaces. The goal was to apply cutting edge technology to the problem of accu-
rately capturing each customer identity when and where transactions take place.
The result has been the development of an award-winning product for the im-
provement of casino management systems. Biometric Recognition has recently
worked with Bally Technologies, one of the largest manufacturers of casino gam-
ing machines and casino management systems in the world, to implement player
tracking using biometric technology embedded into casino gaming machines.
Biometric Recognition holds seven patents issued by the U.S. Patent and
Trademark office for its inventions. These patents are currrently available for li-
censing from Biometric Recognition. Licenses are currently offered in the casino
gaming space separately from the retail point of sale space.
At the retail point-of-sale, the biometric identity of customers can be cap-
tured and compared to databases. The presence of undesirable customers may
trigger management actions. The transactions of customers may be appended
to their identity for use in the implementation of various types of marketing pro-
grams. These programs may be designed to induce customer loyalty, increase
purchasing volume, increase purchasing frequency, or alternatively, induce brand
switching or defection to competitive products. This marketing service may be
sold to product manufacturers or distributors, just like advertising, coupon place-
ment and direct mail services are sold, thus creating more revenue for the retailer.
All of this was made possible by advancements in biometric technologies, and
computer processing power, networks, data storage devices, and database man-
agement.
Infinian
Infinian has created a patent
pending, POS technology that en- Maritz Real-Time Rewards
ables closure of the last mile in mo- Engage customers in real-time at the Point of Sale to increase sales
bile coupons, promotions, loyalty and drive customer loyalty. When customers sign up for a retailer’s
cards, Mobile ticketing, and direct mail. The Plug and Play rewards program through Maritz Real-Time Rewards, they merely
software resides on the payment terminal and/or scanner, swipe a credit, debit or loyalty card and are instantly registered. The
easing the integration into your stores POS. Infinian’s pro- program then begins tracking
gram captures consumer behavior data at point-of-sales/ purchasing behavior in order
services for digital coupons and tickets to provide verifiable to deliver targeted promotions.
Redemption and measurement of ROI on Mobile Marketing These behaviors can include spend, number of visits, and time lapsed
campaigns & Mobile Commerce transactions. since the last visit. Maritz Real-Time Rewards enables retailers to set
Infinian has married their POS software with a SaaS based up promotions to drive frequency, increase average ticket, reward
cloud service for retailer enablement. The hosted Infinian best customers, cross sell, market new products or deliver targeted
Coupon Cloud (www.mycouponcloud.com) and Ticket Cloud messaging. In addition, retailers can drive customers towards higher
enables retailers and marketers to create, manage and dis- margin products and/or reward behavior with low cost items.
tribute coupons and tickets which are then tracked in real-
time on an individual consumer level via a Unique Code when This targeted approach ensures the right customer
the coupons/tickets are redeemed at Point of Sale (POS) gets the right offer, receiving exactly WHAT they want,
terminals. Their cloud-based service allows you to grow and WHEN they want it.
own your very own mobile database of customers. This da-
tabase provides detailed analytics, segmentation and con- For example:
sumer buying behavior, ultimately providing retailers with a Chad is a truck driver who stops at “Burger Land” every week.
one-to-one communication with their customers. When he uses his registered debit card, the printed receipt offers
With Infinian’s Coupon Cloud and POS Software, there him a free breakfast sandwich if he comes back in within five days.
is only one point of integration; one system. Infinian’s POS He does not need to bring the printed receipt back. He simply swipes
Software has little baring on a retailers sales terminal. Once his card to redeem his free sandwich next time.
in place, all other digital and mobile coupon distributers con- Liz is a frequent “Books & More” shopper and earns three points
nect to the retailers POS system via the Infinian Cloud. In do- for every dollar spent when she uses her “Bank of the Nation” credit
ing so, the Infinian platform ensures that each retailers digital card. Upon checkout at “Books & More,” she will be prompted at the
offer, regardless of the distributer, has the same redemption POS to use her “Bank of the Nation” reward points to pay for all or
process, unique codes per user and the redemptions are part of her purchase and reduce her out-of-pocket costs. This instant
guaranteed. Lastly, Infinian charges on a Per-Redemption ba- promotion requires nothing but the card Liz already uses.
sis, so pay for performance. For more information visit www.maritzrtr.com. L
To help, we’ve compiled the Top Five things Marketers should be doing, right now, because of the
CARD Act and the financial reform bill.
1. Intense Data Analysis
The companies with the best analytics (whether inhouse or outsourced) will be the survivors and winners in the new
consumer environment created by these laws and regulations.
If you aren’t using data and analytics to segment your customers and target your offers, you aren’t managing return
on investment of your marketing campaigns. While ROI is always relevant, the impact of the legislation will make finding
the right offer at the right price, and presenting it to the right customer, critical to profitability and legal and regulatory
compliance.
Extremely targeted (read as: has to make money) marketing initiatives, designed to attract ONLY those customers the
companies deem as “safe AND profitable” are only possible with intense data analysis.
The Human Connection® is about the people who affect your business success:
employees, channel partners and customers.
• Sales Incentives
• Employee Engagement
• Channel Performance
• Customer Loyalty Solving business challenges with people solutions
V oice of the customer…Engagement…Loyalty. What do these buzzwords mean? How do we use them to drive value?
Where are the best practices?
These often-used terms have connotative and denotative meanings that can be quite different depending on who uses
them and how they are used. Loyalty 360 - The Loyalty Marketer’s Association continues to see uncertainty about loyalty,
engagement, and voice of the customer. Questions posed by our members and partners about these buzzwords keep coming
fast and furiously.
The confusion indicates that in this challenging economic environment, the focus on loyalty and engagement is becoming
ever more important. Customers, clients, employers, brands and channel partners believe that voice of the customer, Web
3.0, the Groundswell, etc. can give them a well-needed competitive edge. Yet, they don’t know how to execute these initia-
tives effectively. They’re looking for best practice examples of groups creating engagement, excitement, and commitment to
help the answer the overriding question: HOW?
ULTA Beauty
loyalty program profile
THE VERDICT
Two Thumbs Up!
With great merchandise, friendly associates and gift cards, it’s easy and rewarding to get to the next reward level. ULTA places
$5 off a $10 purchase through bind-in coupons in specially targeted magazines—and as a subscriber, it’s a reminder for me to
get out and do some shopping! After all, I can always use another scented candle and who doesn’t like getting favorite mer-
chandise as a reward? Give it a try…I’m a fan!! L
Customers and employees are multi-dimensional, so the ways in which companies build strong, interactive
relationships with them must be as well. Loyalty Expo 2010 is bringing together a slate of best-in-class
speakers and partners to provide attendees with the insights, education, and proven tools they need to
build the strong bonds and emotional connections that drive loyalty and deliver long term success.
The thought-provoking agenda filled with keynotes, interactive sessions from Procter & Gamble, Delta,
Hilton Hotels, Best Buy, Farmer’s Insurance, Coca-Cola, Kroger, GNC, SunTrust Bank and many
others, and peer group discussions will drill down to teach executives how to implement an impactful
voice of the customer, high tech/high touch initiative to build and sustain strong relationships with their
customers, employees and partners.
Loyalty Expo 2010 will also feature a series of peer discussions groups during which marketing executives
can explore together many of the challenges and opportunities facing organizations today.
The next few pages are a preview of what you’ll learn at the 2010 Loyalty Expo.
Interested in our
Speakers & Sponsors?
Read biographies, explore session and workshop topics, and
register—all at loyaltyexpo.com!
This session takes you “behind the scenes” of the decision making that goes
on inside beloved companies. Through a series of real life examples, you
will discover the five decisions common to companies that customers and
employees call “beloved.” This session will do much more than rile you up!
As part of your transformation journey, you will learn how to make decisions
that yield outcomes that create financial prosperity and prosperity of the
human spirit.
Beyond learning about what others do, this session will provide you a
process for evaluating how you make decisions—a mirror to hold up to your
Jeanne Bliss
own personal decisions and to the decisions of your operation. As a result, Managing Partner,
you will see how far or close you are to making decisions like the beloved and Customer Bliss
prosperous companies.
Jeanne Bliss is not an
evangelist or observer of
companies. She’s been inside
Discover the following to sustain growth and profit through customer devotion:
them for twenty-five years,
•Do your decisions today earn your company beloved status? If so, how can arm wrestling them on behalf
you sustain it? If not, what changes do you need to make? of their customer!
•Do you have a reciprocal relationship of trust with your customers? With As “Chief Customer Zealot” for
your employees? five large U.S. market leaders,
Jeanne’s fought valiantly
•What does it take to provide clarity of purpose for those who serve to get the customer on the
customers? strategic agenda, redirecting
•How do customers and employees describe your “company personality?” priorities and creating
transformational changes
•How do you let customers’ lives inform the actions and behaviors of your
to the brands’ customer
operation?
experience. She has driven
•When mistakes happen, how can you apologize swiftly and with humility? achievement of 95 percent
loyalty rates, changing
customer experiences across
Filled with as many suggested actions as anecdotes, this session demystifies 50,000-person organizations…
and creates clarity on the road less traveled by beloved companies. It gives and convincing even the
you a path to follow in their footsteps—a path that is right for you, for your staunchest curmudgeons to
company, and for your people. help push the customer rock
up the hill.
Loyalty is not just some marketing theory. Nor is it the sum total of today’s ubiquitous points schemes. It is a real
engine of both emotional and rational aspect that fuels consumer engagement. It is a leading-indicator of customer
behavior and—if managed properly—a leading-indicator of sales and profitability. Its applications for planning—
going well-beyond demographics, past behavior, and satisfaction, is critical if brands wish to prosper. This session
has—unlike the usual industry presentation suspects—a real, in-market validity study attached that reports out
real ROI and proves the efficacy of how we define ‘loyalty,’ how we leverage it for brands, and how we implement it.
-Robert Passikoff, Contemporary Engagement Measurement
These real-life examples, fom Hilton and others, will help you create your own
customer experience framework and develop best practices for your company, and
your customers.
Our years of experience ensure we acknowledge, understand and anticipate marketplace and consumer trends, helping us
design programs to motivate your customers’ behavior. Some of the most recognizable brands have employed our services
to develop loyalty solutions to meet their profitability goals. We believe loyalty should be a business strategy with a positive
ROI. And our proven loyalty solutions repeatedly result in profitability for our clients.
Jake Sterling Philippe Bontemps Jonathan Silver Sandra Gudat Martha Kanner
Division Vice Vice President President and CEO, President and CEO, Point of Sale Loyalty
President Payment Business Affinity Solutions Customer Product Manager,
Technology, Development, Communications Alpha Bank Greece
Maritz Real-Time Welcome Real-Time Group
Rewards
Jake Sterling, Financial Services and Point-of-Sale technology expert, will lead an interactive discussion
about point of sale Loyalty and the value it creates. Alpha Bank will discuss their point-of-sale loyalty
program “Bonus”; providing campaign examples and results.
•Ways you can adapt your own program to utilize some of these
principles through interactive discussions
Build true loyalty
by building
better relationships.
june 6 - 8, 2010
OMNI CHAMPIONS GATE
ORLANDO, FLORIDA
www.loyaltyexpo.com