Professional Documents
Culture Documents
2
Chapter 1
INTRODUCTION
1.1 INTRODUCTION
Defining microinsurance:
3
A mechanism to protect poor people against risk (accident,
illness, death in the family, natural disasters, etc.) in exchange
for insurance premium payments tailored to their needs,
income, and level of risk (ILO's Microinsurance Innovation
Facility, 2008).
1.2OBJECTIVE
To study the micro insurance industry in India
To understand the demand and supply of micro insurance in
India
4
To examine the various micro insurance products available in
India
To look at the regulatory framework provided by IRDA
5
The project studies the history, need, importance, demand and
supply of micro insurance, its various products and regulations
by the IRDA.
6
CHAPTER 2
REVIEW OF LITERATURE
2.1 Introduction
2.2 BOOKS
8
the prospective SHG members and clients. He emphasized the
need to sensitise the field staff in banks, microfinance
institutions, NGOs and insurance companies to recognize the
special needs of the rural communities. The author insisted
that a comprehensive communication strategy for marketing
the concept of rural micro insurance was very much needed.
The service provider should also maintain a suitable database
of insured/uninsured SHG members based on ones own life
micro insurance needs.
2.3 JOURNALS
a) Prabhakaran (2007), Creating Consumer Awareness: Life
Insurance, IRDA Journal, November, pp. 36 - 38.
Prabhakaran (2007)2 stated in his study that the issue of
consumer awareness had a deeper significance in emerging
markets as the economic growth outweighed the social growth
due to the absence of awareness levels on the financial tools
like life micro insurance. The author also opined that creating
awareness on intangible financial services like life micro
insurance was a challenging task. He pointed out the two
facets to life insurers with reference to the need for creating
life micro insurance awareness. One was the business interests
and the other was part of their overall corporate social
responsibility. The author further revealed that awareness was
an ingredient that enhanced the acceptance levels of the life
micro insurance products.
b) Dror. D and Radermacher (2005), Integrating Health
Insurance for the Poor into the Indian Insurance Scenario,
Insurance Watch, Vol.3 (12), pp. 11 - 15.
9
Dror and Radermacher (2005)13 mentioned the factors that
could be explored within the existing structure of open market
competition with multiple players, to make health micro
insurance more accessible to rural poor in India. The authors
highlighted that there was an untapped market due to low
penetration of health micro insurance products. The paper
recommended that the government could invest in the
environment and infrastructure building efforts to support this
sector.
c) Das (2006), Community-Based Health Insurance Services in
India: Exploring an Equitable Health Financing Mechanism,
The Journal of Insurance Institute of India, Vol. XXXII
Das (2006)18 suggested that the potential health micro
insurance market was 600 billion rupees in 2007. Since the
share of the elderly in the total population would increase to
6.9 per cent and the total number of senior citizens would
increase by 107 per cent to 113 million by 2016, immense
scope should be provided for the sectors unprecedented
growth.
d) . Ito.S and Kono (2010), Why is the take-up of Micro
insurance So Low? Evidence from a Health Insurance Scheme
in India. Developing Economies. Vol.48 (1), pp. 74 - 101.
Ito and Kono (2010)22 carried out experiments which found
that age, household size, gender, value of land assets, credit
constraints, sickness, hyperbolic risk preference, risk loving
and location dummies were factors significantly explaining
health micro insurance uptake. In their model education,
financial status, non-land asset value, piped water, sewage,
10
toilet, having small children, periodic instalment for the
insurance and risk aversion were included but not found to be
significant.
11
CHAPTER 3
MICROINSURANCE
3.1 HISTORY
12
iii. more than twenty five per cent of the male working population is
engaged in agricultural pursuits.
13
informational disadvantage and high transaction costs in
providing insurance to the low-income people. This way
micro-insurance combines positive features of formal
insurance as well as those of informal insurance. In the
absence of a nodal agency, the low resource base of the poor,
coupled with high transaction costs gives rise to the
affordability issue. Lack of affordability prevents their latent
demand from expressing itself in the market. Hence the nodal
agencies that organise the poor, impart training, and work for
the welfare of the low-income people play an important role
both in generating both the demand for insurance as well as
the supply of cost-effective insurance.
Defining microinsurance:
15
insurance, disability insurance, insurance for natural disasters,
etc.
16
which in turn ensures viability of the provision of such
services to the low income market.
17
Poverty and vulnerability reinforce one another forming an
ever-growing downward spiral, not only the exposure to risks
results in substantial financial losses but vulnerable families
suffer the continued uncertainties about when and how loss
may occur. Due to this long-lasting concern, poor people are
less likely to take advantage of income generation
opportunities which may reduce poverty. The majority try to
manage their risks and deal with the consequences. Saving
money, working extra time on other activities and asking for
loans from friends or relations constitute some of the
strategies used to avoid financial loss which is inefficient and
exacerbates poverty.
18
insurance industry venture with promising results. Yet, some
commercial insures and Policy makers still tend to believe that
providing insurance cover to the poor is the responsibilities of
the state and in practical terms it is difficult to insure poor
people on a cost covering basis. They suspect that poor
households either cannot pay for their insurances or the
informality of their living situation makes them unattractive as
clients because they do not have formal employment, have ID
cards and are illiterate.
19
TRADITIONAL MICRO INSURANCE
INSURANCE
CLIENT Low risk environment High risk
Established culture e x p o s u r e / high
environment vulnerability
Weak insurance culture
Distribution Sold by licensed Sold by non-traditional
model intermediaries or by intermediaries to clients
insurance companies with little experience
directly to wealthy of insurance
clients or companies that
understand insurance
Policies Complex policy Simple language
documents with many Few if any exclusions
Group policies
exclusions
Premium Good statistical data Little historical data
collection Pricing based on Group pricing
Very price sensitive
individual risk
market
Control of Limited eligibility Broad eligibility
insurance risk Significant Limited but effective
documentation required control
Screening such as Insurance risk included in
medical test required premium rather than
excluded
Linked to other services
like credit
Claims Complicated process Simple and fast
handling Extensive verification of procedures of small firms
documents Efficient fraud control
20
3.5 Salient features of Microinsurance:
1) USAGE:
Though no figures are available on the exact size of the
microinsurance market in India, a rough estimate would
place it at around 14m individuals, or approximately
2% of the adult population. The low take-up can be
ascribed to a general lack of awareness of insurance as
a financial product, even in the high to m i d d l e -
i n c o m e m a r k e t ( a f a c t o r t h a t e me rge d s t r o n g l y
f r o m t h e f o c u s g r o u p findings). In addition a lack of rural
financial services infrastructure for distribution p u r p o s e s ,
as well as a lack of actuarial data, inhibit
t h e d e v e l o p m e n t o f t h e microinsurance market.
2) PLAYERS:
Though the state-owned insurers still have the largest market
share, there are now a total of 32 licensed insurers. A
feature that sets India apart from o t h e r c o u n t r i e s i s
the fact that microinsurance is mostly
p r o v i d e d b y l a r g e , corporate insurers. This is due
to a cautious regulatory approach in response tithe
fact that small and cooperative financial institutions
have not performed well historically that limits the
players in the non-bank field to large cap institutions. T h e
cooperative/mutual sector therefore does not
feature as a provider o f microinsurance, though
21
corporate insurers use it as a distribution channel. Informal
i n s u r a n c e i s v i r t u a l l y e x c l u s i v e l y t h e d o ma i n o f
f o r m a l e n t i t i e s s u c h a s h e a l t h insurance schemes
not registered for insurance purposes, rather than
community risk-pooling groups, and is estimated to only
comprise 20% of the market.
3) PRODUCTS
Microinsurance in India is for the most part driven by
compulsory credit life insurance on the back of
microfinance. Due to the limited reach of the public
health system, there is also a high natural demand for
health insurance. Many MFIs therefore provide a
package of compulsory insurance cover to their clients
that are credit-linked this includes life, asset as well as
health insurance. The cover is for the term of credit (usually 1
year). Health cover provided in such packages is not
comprehensive and it covers only certain listed diseases for
which hospitalization is required. Accident cover is a rider on
life insurance and is a fixed payout. India is therefore fairly
unique in that compulsory insurance cover extends beyond life
cover. It is estimated that only 10% of microinsurance policies
are sold on a voluntary basis. Of these, up to 90% are
endowment products rather than pure r i s k p r o d u c t s ,
indicating a preference among the low-
22
i n c o m e p o p u l a t i o n f o r financial products that provide
some payout regardless of whether a risk event has occurred.
4) DISTRIBUTION:
Distribution is an important part of the
m i c r o i n s u r a n c e landscape in India. Regulations were
issued in 2005 to create a microinsurance agent
category for the dedicated distribution of
microinsurance. Currently such a g e n t s however
only distribute about 20% of all
microinsurance. Instead, distribution mainly
takes place through MFIs who either do not
qualify as microinsurance agents under the
regulations or who find the r e g ul a t i o n s too
restrictive, as partners or agents of f o r ma l
i n s u r e r s . We c a n di s t i n g u i s h f o u r institutional models
for providing microinsurance which help us to understand
how c o r p o r a t e i n s u r e r s , g o v e r n m e n t b o d i e s a s
well as other institutions.
23
CHAPTER 4 THE DEMAND AND SUPPLY OF
MICROINSURANCE
Out of 80 listed
insurance products, 45 (55%) cover only a single risk. The
other products, covering a package of risks, mostly focus
on 2 (20%) or 3 (18%) risks.
The available products cover a wide range of risks. However,
the broad majority of the insurance products cover life (40
products or 52%) or accident-related risks. The health
coverage remains very limited (12 products). Most life
insurance products (23 out of 42) are addressed to individuals.
However, some products may be bought both by individuals
and groups.
24
Out of 42 life insurance products, 23 are pure risk products.
The other 19 products propose various types of maturity
benefits.
25
incumbent public insurers have been in the market for a
number of years now.
26
4.3 DEMAND FOR MICRO-INSURANCE
On the demand side too, the ILO (2004b) has recently
prepared an inventory of micro-insurance schemes operational
in India. Based on this list some of the observations
Are made below:
Life and health are the two most popular risks for which
insurance is demanded: 59% of schemes provide life
insurance and 57% of them provide health insurance. In
SEWAs9 experience health insurance tops the list of risks for
which the poor need insurance.
27
Twenty-five out of 37 schemes received some external funds
to initiate their schemes. Twenty out of 32 schemes received
external technical assistance in the form of advisory services,
technical services, training or even referral services for their
schemes.
28
adopted a mix of voluntary and compulsory contributions
(based on the type of service provided).
Clearly, health and life are two most important risks for which
insurance is demanded. Indeed, at low-income level, when
much of the income goes into meeting basic needs, the scope
of having varying priority needs is very limited. On the supply
side we observe that out of 80 odd products only 7 products
are health insurance products that provide for reimbursement
of hospital expenses. Admittedly, compared to life insurance,
which is a relatively straightforward business, health
insurance is a much more complex service as it involves
addressing the provision of healthcare that is location specific.
The design and sale of products are currently driven by the
objective of meeting the regulatory obligation and the making
of profits or reducing losses. In this situation, there is a danger
of certain priority needs getting neglected by the insurance
companies.
29
and uncertain to enable payment of premium in one go, and
more so when only a part of the remuneration is paid in cash.
In the above, we find only a few schemes offer flexibility in
paying premium. This could act as a serious drawback in
increasing the membership.
We find that most of the schemes are concentrated in the
southern region of the country. The southern regions are well
known for the social mobilization of low-income people. In
contrast, the northern region is bereft of such mobilization as
the nodal agencies are either non-existent or dysfunctional.
Creating and nurturing nodal agencies can be quite involved
and can take a long time to develop. Local government, that
can
Also perform the role of nodal agency, will take a long time to
strengthen as a result of decentralization process currently
underway in most Indian states. There has to be alternative
approaches to extending insurance in regions where nodal
agencies do not exist.
30
Finally, the type of contingency and the number of people
covered under it are important parameters, but so is the extent
of benefit provided should the contingency happen. Currently,
the benefit or protection provided under some insurance
schemes is quite shallow.
The attitude of insurers on these obligations has been mixed.
Some have taken a positive view of the regulatory obligations
and have made a genuine attempt to understand the rural and
low-income segment of the market. Indeed, a few insurers
have actually surpassed their obligations by a wide margin.
These companies have realised that there is potential in the
rural and low-income segment but tapping that potential
requires a different kind of approach. In some cases, insurance
companies have actually cross subsidised their micro-
insurance products while in other cases insurers have been
able to find a donor for paying premium, at least in part, on
behalf of the low-income people.
The impact of rural and social obligations on extending
insurance to the intended people has been positive. However,
development of micro-insurance needs further guidance from
the insurance regulator by way of supplementary provisions.
Sensing this, the insurance regulator has already come out
with a concept paper on micro-insurance11 in which it has
spelled out its thinking on what these supplementary
provisions could
31
Microinsurance is a good step for financial inclusion and to
tackle out the problems and vulnerabilities of BPL people, but
the outreach of microinsurance is not enough to tackle it. This
section analysed the gaps between demand and supply of
microinsurance. The gaps are analysed by considering
following aspects.
4.4.1 Operational gap
4.4.2 Gap of financial illiteracy
4.4.3 Low Awareness and Gaps in Understanding Concepts
and Procedures
4.4.4 Gap in risks and vulnerabilities faced by BPL people and
covered by insurance companies
4.4.5 Gap in microinsurance policies demanded by BPL
people and provided by insurance companies
4.4.6 Gap in services provided by insurance companies to
BPL people
4.4.7 Gap in coverage of insurance companies
32
So, the operation of microinsurance is limited only in urban
areas but the requirement of microinsurance is more in rural
areas not in urban areas.
33
4.4.4 GAP IN RISKS AND VULNERABILITIES FACED
BY BPL PEOPLE AND COVERED BY
MICROINSURANCE COMPANIES
Microinsurance is the protection of low-income people
against specific perils in exchange for regular premium
payment proportionate to the likelihood and cost of the risks
involved. As definition depicts that the microinsurance
specially designed for protecting the poor people from various
risks and vulnerabilities they faced. Poor people faced various
problems like Death of family member, Expenditure on
sickness or illness, Loss of crop, Disease or death of livestock,
Loss of business, Natural disaster and Theft/ robbery (see
table and figure 3.2). This research analysed that from these
risks and vulnerabilities, insurance companies mainly covered
only two risks and they are Death of family member,
Expenditure on sickness or illness.
So, because of covering only two risks and vulnerability by
insurance companies there exists a wide gap between demand
and supply of microinsurance in covering the risks of poor
people because they demanded insurance not only for these
two but for all those perils which they faced.
Risks and Vulnerabilities faced by poor people
1. Death of family member
2. Expenditure on sickness or illness
3. Loss of crop
4. Disease or death of livestock
5. Loss of business
6. Natural disaster
7. Theft/ robbery
Risks And Vulnerabilities covered by Insurance Companies
1. Death of family member
34
2. Expenditure on sickness or illness
This research analysed that the poor people need all type of
insurance policies but insurance companies provides
insurance cover only for life and health i.e., life insurance and
health insurance. The gap between microinsurance policies
demanded by poor people and the insurance policies provided
by insurance companies is depicting below.
35
facilities like good claim settlement, effective application
process, sufficient amount of premium, the well insurance
executives behaviour and so on.
1. Life Insurance
2. Health Insurance
3. Crop Insurance
4. Cattle Insurance
37
5. Disaster Insurance
6. Disability Insurance
7. Property Insurance
8. Unemployment Insurance
9. Reinsurance
Insurance Policies provided by Insurance Companies
1. Life Insurance
2. Health Insurance
38
CHAPTER 5
MICROINSURANCE PRODUCTS
5.1 INTRODUCTION
Microinsurance, like regular insurance, may be offered for a
wide variety of risks. These include both health risks (illness,
injury, or death) and property risks (damage or loss). A wide
variety of microinsurance products exist to address these risks,
including crop insurance, livestock/cattle insurance, insurance
for theft or fire, health insurance, term life insurance, death
insurance, disability insurance, insurance for natural disasters,
etc.
39
people's inability to continue improving their economic
conditions. Several MFIs have therefore, either started their
own health insurance programs or have linked their clients to
existing programs.
Problems faced-
a) High cost of Health insura0nce product as compared to life
insurance product b) Lack of interest among the members to
buy a health insurance product It also poses the question of
should the health insurance product be made compulsory and
how can government intervene to provide the insurance
benefit to the poor at an affordable cost
c) Absence of a robust MIS to track details related to insured
family members
d) Lack of competence on the part of the MFI to monitor the
cases e.g. it may not be possible for the member/ family to
report the illness to the concerned MFI person , due to which
it becomes hard to keep a track of the genuine cases
e) Inability of the MFIs to keep a track of the different
documents related to health insurance claims
f) Lack of technical competence of the MFI to understand the
treatment for the illness involved which might be inflated to
increase the cost of treatment g) Lack of proper awareness
among the MFIs members about the inclusions and exclusions
of the health insurance product
h) The tendency of the MFI members of get benefit of each
rupees spent in paying the insurance premium
i) In case of absence of networking hospitals , it might take
long time to get a approval from the insurance companies
40
Pricing of the Micro health insurance products depends on the
difference in the incidence of illness, the cost associated with
the treatment, as well as the geographical location of the MFI.
As such the same product cannot be replicated to meet the
needs in different geographical areas. A place with high
incidence of malaria, people would like to get covered for its
treatment; however the other surrounding places might never
face such an illness and might like to go for covering some
other illness. In hilly area the risk of accidents might be high
whereas in some other area there might be high incidence of
cholera and typhoid. As such in most of the cases the products
floated are either basic in nature, ensuring the client against
the loss of daily wages during hospitalization or takes care of
the health treatment with requires minimum 24hrs of
hospitalization.
Property Insurance- Property insurance provides coverage
against loss or damage of assets. Providing such insurance is
difficult because of the need to verify the extent of damage
and determine whether loss has actually occurred.
41
ability of rural farmers to repay loans from agricultural
development banks (ADBs), many governments developed
crop insurance programs in the 1970s and 1980s. Crop
insurance
42
estimating the damage suffered by the crop. The second type
of crop insurance guarantees the farmer a fixed income in
spite of crop failure or fluctuations in the market price The
different types of risk perceived can be well combined into a
crop insurance package to benefit the poor and marginal
farmers.
44
ICICI Prud. Sarv Jana Suraksha
6 IDBI Fortis Life Insurance Co. Ltd.
IDBI Fortis Group Micro insurance Plan
7 ING Vysya Life Insurance Co. Ltd.
ING Vysya Saral Suraksha
8 Life Insurance Corporation of India
LIC's Jeevan Madhur. LIC's Jeevan Mangal.
9 Met Life India Met Vishwas
10 Sahara India Life Insurance Co. Ltd.
Sahara Sahayog (Micro Endowment Insurance without profit
plan).
11 SBI Life Insurance Co. Ltd. SBI Life Grameen Shakti. SBI
Life Grameen Super Suraksha.
12 Shriram Life Insurance Co. Ltd. Shri Sahay. Sri Sahay
(AP).
13 Star Union Dai-ichi Life Insurance Co. Ltd.
SUD Life Paraspar Suraksha Plan.
14 TATA AIG Life Insurance Co. Ltd.
Ayushman Yojana. Navkalyan Yojana. Sampoorn Bima
Yojana. Tata AIG Sumangal Bima Yojana.
45
its financial transactions with low-income groups that would
otherwise be too costly to set up. The partnership model uses
the comparative advantage of each partner so that each can
focus on its core business, the insurance provider is
responsible for designing and pricing the product, the final
claims management, and the investment of reserves, and
absorbs all the insurance risks. In addition to selling the
policies, the agent offers its infrastructure for product
servicing such as marketing the product, premium collection,
and assists in claims management.
46
the agent to earn as commission without risk, while the insurer
earns profits. Major limitation of this model is that the insurers
depend on the quality of the agent. So reputation and
performance of the agents is crucial. Conflicts of interest may
occur, especially when working with non-financial
institutions. NGOs or MFIs staff or management may develop
sympathy for a client and be lax about underwriting or claims
verification. It should be noted that this is less likely to occur
with an MFIs partner that is used to financial discipline with
its lending activities
47
livestock insurance and ICICI Lombard for rainfall insurance.
BASIX is also actively working with these and other insurers
to design a suitable health insurance product for its rural
clients. In 2003, BASIX was also given a Corporate Agency
license by the IRDA to distribute retail life insurance products
from AVIVA. Source: E -mail communication with authors.
48
they vary greatly in their capacity and desire to work with
commercial insurers. 9
Potential partners: Banks Most private banks do not lend to
low-income clients so connections like the one Bajaj Allianz
AG has with Standard Chartered Bank would not be of much
use in the low-income market. This explains the use of
microfinance institutions. But there may be some unexplored
possibilities with banks.
49
year, some people having accumulated savings up to Rs.
10,000, with their SHG or in private bank accounts.At present,
NABARD operates through state-owned banks, and it requires
that insurance be sold by borrowers who take up a NABARD-
funded loan. These loans are not through self-help groups,
however, and tend to be towards somewhat wealthier farmers.
The insurance is part of the state-run National Agricultural
Insurance Scheme (NAIS) or Rashtriya Krishi Bima Yojana
(RKBY), a crop insurance scheme mentioned in the section on
products.
50
Moreover, banks cannot establish such a costly service
structure for offering integrated insurance services to the
poor.10 Health insurance and hospitalization insurance require
special care and supervision and an indemnity regulation
system that would overcharge the banking system completely.
Those banks with substantial experience with a new group of
clients, particularly the self-organized women from the poorer
strata of the population, have not yet applied those insurance
systems for their new SHG clients. They found it difficult to
identify, design and sell adequate insurance products on their
own or in cooperation with insurance companies.
51
Banks that work with SHGs are important potential partners.
It would be useful to create awareness of the potential among
state banks and to help build their capacity to deliver
microinsurance to SHGs.
Many NGOs and MFIs that partner with insurer s are in need
of capacity-building to help ensure that (a) they get the best
deal from the insurer and (b) manage the relationship
efficiently. In order to get the best deal from insurers, NGOs
and MFIs need to know exactly how much it will cost them to
do the agency work. Very few NGOs and MFIs cost their
activities effectively, and this adversely affects their
sustainability. It would be useful to assist them in costing their
52
2. AGENCY MODEL The agency model:
How does it work? In this model the insurer uses its normal
agency office and sells microinsurance products directly.
The client comes to the agency office for sales and
servicing of the product. Insurers described this model but
the authors could find no examples of it operating in
practice.
Pros
Cons
53
AIG, Vijay Artherye. The central building blocks of the model
are Rural Community Insurance Groups (CRIGs) supervised
by rural organizations such as churches, NGOs or MFIs.
CRIGs are a partnership firm formed of five women from a
self-help group (SHG). The leader of the CRIG is licensed as
an agent. The CRIG is a de facto brokerage firm (in the
technical, not the legal sense of the term). All CRIGs in the
same geographic area meet in a single centre, usually
organized with the assistance of the rural organization, and
receive training and assistance from Tata -AIG. This practice
reduces training costs.
54
The CRIG leader and members are involved in promotion,
sales and collection of insurance proceeds and maintaining
records. The CRIG leader will document all fortnightly CRIG
meetings and all weekly meetings with the NGO concerned.
Cons
55
The transaction costs of the sales agent are cheap at first
but increase as soon as the agent has sold to all the
peoples/he knows and needs to sell to strangers, especially
to those living far away;
In many cases in the partnership model, when a claim
arises the MFI or NGO investigates the claim, pays the
benefit immediately, and then claims it back from the
insurer. Immediate payment of claims helps maintain
client confidence, and this is not possible under the CRIG
system;
This model is new, and much more experience is needed
before it can be reasonably evaluated.
56
products come in addition to mainstream credit and savings
services.
In the countries of Sub-Saharan Africa, many mutualised
health insurances have also been created on the basis of a
voluntary membership. In exchange for the premiums they
send to a fund, policyholders are entitled to certain benefits.
The community has an important role in designing and
managing the programme.
57
informal) provides all or part of the covered services, such as
health-care or funeral services. By providing a tool to finance
use of the covered services, the supplier is able to increase
access to, and demand for, these services. At the same time, as
the supplier, it has control of the quality of the service
provided, which is a crucial element in client satisfaction and
retention. The major drawback of this model is the potential
inadequacy of the service provider to bear the necessary risk
or perform other functions required of an insurer, particularly
if it is informal. In certain countries regulatory restrictions to
this model exist.
58
technological solutions may simplify outreach to large
numbers, but lack many of the benefits of group-based
products.
2) COOPERATIVES
59
They have come along way in insuring their members by tying
up with a suitable insurer or a insurance provider. One of the
examples can be the health insurance provided by the
Yeshasvini Trust, of Karnataka. Here the cooperatives act as a
channel for delivery of health insurance. The main target
being the members of the cooperative. Since cooperatives
have a good network that can ensure the insurance reaches to a
larger group of people, they have been identified as main
sources or channels for delivery of micro-insurance product.
4) NGOS/MFIS/CBP
60
As far as Formal Banks and RRBs, Post Offices and Internet
& Rural Kiosks are concerned they have not developed their
potential in delivering the insurance product.
61
c) It would also be distributed in local language to the
members so that they comprehend and avail the benefits
mentioned in the document.
PREMIUM COLLECTION
62
f) In case of inhouse insurance a part of the loan is covered as
insurance fees, which is then used to create a pool for paying
the claims
PRODUCT FEATURES
PROCESSES
CLAIM ADMINISTRATION
63
a) A facilitator at branch office level to take care of the reported
claims in case of life insurance
b) b) Branch to be responsible for collection of relevant
documents from the clients for processing the claims
c) c) Payout in the center meetings
d) d) Use of TPS or rural BPO to take care of the claims in case
of health insurance. This saves the MFIs from the
complexities of the health insurance claims
65
India
Life Insurance Corporation of LIC's Bhagya Lakshmi
India
66
CHAPTER 6
REGULATIONS BY IRDA
6.1 INTRODUCTION
67
insurance products as specified in Regulation (4) and made
over to the insurer carrying on general insurance business:
69
5. (I) A micro-insurance agent shall be appointed by an insurer
by entering into a deed Of agreement, which shall clearly
specify the terms and conditions Of such appointment,
including the duties and responsibilities Of both the micro-
insurance agent and the insurer:
70
(i) Where the micro insurance agents are authorized to collect
and remit the premiums, they shall be mandated by the
insurers for issuing acknowledgements on collection Of
premiums and every Insurer shall put in place procedures to
enable Micro Insurance Agents issue such acknowledgments.
71
Provided that no such notice shall be necessary, where the
termination is account of any misconduct or indiscipline Or
fraud committed by the micro insurance agent.
72
insurance product. Remuneration Commission shall be
payable only on
73
ii. No Micro Insurance Agent shall employ the specified working
for another Micro Insurance Agent.
74
Provided that the insurer shall ensure compliance Of the Code
of Conduct, advertisements and disclosure norms by every
micro Insurance agent.
75
6.8 ISSUANCE OF MICRO INSURANCE POLICY
CONTRACTS
76
(3) Notwithstanding the provisions of Regulation 9(1) the
insurers may also allow the Micro Insurance Agents to print
the policy contract on a plain A 4 size paper for Onward
transmission to Micro Insurance Policy holder. The evidence
of payment of policy stamp may be shown on the printed
policy document.
UNDERWRITING
CAPACITY BUILDING
77
accordance to Regulation 4(2) Of these regulations in those
lines Of business to which Such Micro insurance Agent is
appointed shall undergo additional 25 hours of the 'raining at
the expenses of the insurer.
REMUNERATION/COMMISION
78
(a) For Life Insurance Business:
(3) For group insurance products, the insurer may decide the
commission subject to overall limit as specified in sub-
regulation (1).
79
13, (I) Every insurer shall ensure that all transactions in
connection with micro-insurance business are in accordance
with the provisions Of the Act as amended from time to time
the Insurance Regulatory and Development Act, 1999, and the
80
15. (I) It shall be the responsibility of the insurer to handle and
dispose of complaints against a micro insurance agent with
speed and promptitude.
INSPECTION BY AUTHORITY
SUBMISSION OF INFORMATION
81
claims figures relating to social security schemes of
State/Central Government and administered on behalf of any
Government Shall be excluded.
Schedule II
SCHEDULE - III
82
and pension products offered under micro insurance platform
shall subject to the following :
83
e) The non-linked variable insurance policy. shall:
2. The insurer shall not levy any charge to the policy account
from the date of surrender
request.
84
more than those mentioned under 'Table b' hereunder. No
other fee shall be charged.
maximum Of 200
SPSingle premium
CHAPTER 7
85
AS PER THE IRDA ANNUAL REPORT 2015-2016
Micro Insurance:
INDIVIDUAL GROUP
87
Total 5 7 5
88
Private 3382 6392 1307 8467
total
89
Micro-Finance Institution(MFI), RBI regulated NBFCMFIs,
District Cooperative Banks, Regional Rural Banks, Urban Co-
operative banks, Business correspondents, Primary
Agricultural Cooperative Societies and Other Cooperative
Societies.
90
contributed a lot in development and promotion of micro
insurance products by insurers in India.
91
SUGGESTION
In areas where there is a dearth of banking facilities small
savings should be pooled and utilized instead of regular
premium on the village level. Thus, micro insurance can be
aligned with micro savings and micro credit to achieve
better results.If the pooled resources generate some
income, the same should be ploughed back for the benefit
of poor people
The writer is the deputy general manager-legal at OCL
India Ltd.
92
attractive not only to clients but also to potential aggregators
(agents like MFIs and NGOs), they would need to
distinguish their products from competition on some basis
other than price. Discussion with a number of MFIs and
NGOS has indicated that one of their major difficulties is the
lack of service from their insurance partners. This has often
caused them to change insurance partners. It would be
worthwhile looking at the reasons for Allianz AGs
successful relationship with ASA (Activists For Social
Alternatives, an NGO working for the development of the
poor in the drought prone, poverty ridden area of central
Tamil Nadu).
Marketing microinsurance
Tata-AIG has had success building trust with the potential
microinsurance market by emphasizing its Tata links. Tata is
a trusted company or at least deemed unlikely to
misappropriate premiums by low-income clients. Others
insurers with trusted local partners could make use of their
connection to these partners for the same purpose.
In addition, public reimbursement of claims, for example at
village meetings, is important. It demonstrates the
advantages of having insurance with a real example.
Other microinsurance marketing tools used are exposure
tours, where village leaders from villages with policyholders
are sent to other villages to show the advantages of having
insurance.
Also important are careful, well-managed rejection of
claims where the reasons are made clear to all the villagers.
93
Finally, as with high premium insurance, monitoring of
customer satisfaction is critical, especially with respect to
lapses and non-renewals, reinforced by a mechanism to act
on the information that emerges from this monitoring.
Supporting microinsurance innovation The Terms of
Reference of this report did not include the design of new
products. Research was confined to describing and
analyzing existing products. Innovations are few and far
between in India, and most of this text reports on different
replications of the partner -agent model. It would be
worthwhile to design innovative products.
As resources are limited and (credit) life insurance is a
rather simple product, assistance is required in developing
the following products: endowment policies, health
insurance, weatherbased insurance and other suitable
insurance packages. A crucial area of involvement is the
provision of technical assistance to insurance companies
prepared to provide innovative products. This has been
done, seemingly successfully, by DFID, which supported
Tata -AIG in its development of the micro-agent model, and
the World Bank, which supported ICICI Lombard in its
development of weather insurance.
Banks that work with SHGs are important potential
partners. It would be useful to create awareness of the
potential among state banks and to help build their capacity
to deliver microinsurance to SHGs.
Gender and microinsurance - There is a lack of tools to
understand the gender -specific demand for microinsurance
94
in India. It is important to know what women want from
microinsurance and what they are willing to pay for. In
particular, it is crucial to consider the benefit package. In life
insurance, for example, it may be important for the
beneficiary to be the daughter (held in trust for her if she is a
minor) rather than the husband. In health insurance, it may
be important to ensure that the entire family is covered
rather than just the women if the women are in a weak
position in the household. Because many of the concerns of
women are not easily insurable, e.g., maternity costs, it
would make sense to consider combining insurance and
savings. In this way, for example, a woman could use her
savings to cover the cost of a normal delivery, and insurance
to cover the cost of unexpected complications
CONCLUSION
Way forward
Micro insurance in India can be compared to a glass of water
either half empty or half full. If one is optimistic, there is a
huge scope for developing the segment in the country. Many
NGOs and MFIssuch as Swayakrushi, Sewa and
Spanadana Foundation are alreadydoing commendable
work for betterment of the deprived people in villages. They
can be recognised as agents and their infrastructure can be
used by insurance companies governed by IRDA. Many
companiesthrough their trusts and CSR activitiesare
extending their support for betterment of villagers.
97
implies (ambiguously) that one MFI or NGO can only have a
relationship with one insurance company. If the regulation
comes to pass it will make using the partnership model as a
distribution method more difficult.
98
outweigh the costs and whether such a system would be useful
policy in other countries
Expanding the industry The IRDA is tasked with promoting
the insurance industry. The IRDA already runs televisions
campaign aimed at middle-income consumers endorsing the
safety and security of the insurance firms that it regulates. It
would be good if such a campaign could be extended to
microinsurance. Other mediums could be explored for this,
including radio. UNDP and/or GTZ could support such
campaigns.
Two major events shook the Indian financial markets First, the
insurance industry saw some serious turbulence with
regulatory control on ULIPs and corporate agency guidelines.
The industry, for the first time in a decade registered negative
growth. Almost, all the private insurers, for the first time in
their brief history, have reduced their branch network and have
focused on cost optimisation. In parallel, some major
investors left the insurance industry (including New York Life,
ING, Bharti), some of the insurers have been restructured with
the entry of banks into joint ventures (Met Life, AVIVA, Birla
Sunlife), one of the insurers has been semi-acquired by
another insurer (BhartiAxa) and some new investors entered
(e.g. Japanese investors like Nippon and Mitsui Sumitomo)
the industry. Such turbulence necessarily will reshape the
industry in favour of alternative approaches.
99
Secondly, in almost the same period, the microfinance sector,
once portrayed as poster-child of alternative finance,
witnessed disappointment with the drying up of bank funding
and a less than timely intervention by RBI and the
government. Both of these sectors are found searching for
opportunities to repair their reputations and build their
businesses. While insurers are looking forward to innovative
low cost distribution channels, the microfinance institutions
(MFIs) are striving to re-innovate and diversify their product
portfolios. Microinsurance, as the silent offspring of the two
industries will have to adapt to the emerging trends in both the
industries. Some of the possible future trends are enumerated
in the sections below.
100
the MFIs have also acknowledged the value of providing
multiple products and services to the clients, instead of plain
vanilla group microcredit. They realise that a comprehensive
product portfolio can create client loyalty, which is vital for
their operations. Besides, in the absence of adequate bank
funding, insurance business can prove to be an alternate
income source for these MFIs. The MFIs, as aggregators,
therefore, are expected to demand new products from the
insurers, which can cater to the needs and demands of their
clients. 6.3. Business Correspondents of Banks may emerge
as the channel of choice
101
already considering the channel favourably for distribution of
microinsurance. Though the economics of agent banking
channel depends largely on product rationalisation, in the near
future, the sector can expect innovation in both product and
processes around this distribution channel.
102
BIBLIOGRAPHY
A. BOOKS
i. Maez. M. S and Wong. S (2006), Insurance in
Emerging Markets: Sound Development
ii. Chatterjee. M and Vyas (undated), Organizing
Insurance for Women Workers: The SEWAs
Experience
iii. Gaurav. S, Anna Paola Gomez Acosta and Luis
Flores Ballesteros (2008), Innovating at the
BoP: Delivering Micro insurance in Kalahandi
and Beyond
iv. Ajit Kanitkar (2005), Learning from Micro
Insurance for SHGs of Pragathi
B. JOURNALS
i. Prabhakaran (2007), Creating Consumer
Awareness: Life Insurance, IRDA Journal,
November, pp. 36 - 38.
ii. Dror. D and Radermacher (2005), Integrating
Health Insurance for the Poor into the Indian
Insurance Scenario, Insurance Watch, Vol.3 (12),
pp. 11 - 15.
iii. Das (2006), Community-Based Health
Insurance Services in India: Exploring an
Equitable Health Financing Mechanism, The
Journal of Insurance Institute of India, Vol.
XXXII
iv. . Ito.S and Kono (2010), Why is the take-up of
Micro insurance So Low? Evidence from a
Health Insurance Scheme in India. Developing
Economies. Vol.48 (1), pp. 74 - 101.
C. E-DATA
103
WEBSITES
i. SHODHGANGA
ii. WWW.ICRIER.COM
iii. WWW.UNDP.COM
iv. WWW.MICROSAVE.NET
v. WWW.ILO.ORG
vi. DAILYFINTECH.COM
104