Professional Documents
Culture Documents
UNIVERSITY OF MUMBAI.
OF PROFESSIONAL COURSES.
T.Y.BBI
SUBMITTED BY
KAMLESH VAISHNAV
GUIDED BY
1
Declaration
I Kamlesh Vaishnav student of T.Y.BBI hereby declare
that I have completed this project on FRAUDS IN
COMMERCIAL BANK. All The information submitted is
true and original to the best of my knowledge.
Signature of Student
KAMLESH VAISHNAV
2
Name
KAMLESH R. VAISHNAV
Roll Number
50
Title of Project
Subject Area
Sign Of Student
3
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
4
I would also like to thank the co-coordinator and
the project guide Mr. Vivek Wankhedefor their
constant encouragement, intellectual solution and
valuable suggestions throughout the making of this
project. I thank him for spending his valuable time
and efforts towards my cause.
5
TABLE OF CONTENT
6
Title Page
Certificate
Declaration
Acknowledgeme
nt
Table of Content
Chapter No. Topic
Frauds In
1
Banking Sector
Frauds in
2 Commercial
Bank
3 Banking Fraud
Banking Fraud
4 Survey-
2012
5 Case Study
6 News About Banking
Fraud
7
Questionnaire
8 Conclusion
9 Bibliography
Chapter 1
7
1.1 Introduction of Bank
8
1.1 INTRODUCTION TO BANK
9
discounts notes, makes loans, and invests in securities;
collects cheques, drafts, and notes, makes loans, and invests
in securities; collects cheques, drafts and notes; certificate
depositors checks; and issue drafts and cashiers checks.
10
1.4DEFINITION of 'Commercial Bank'
11
1.5 IOMORTANT OF COMMERICAL BANK
1.6DEFINITION OF FRAUD
12
RBI had, not defined the term form in its
guidelines on frauds. A definition of fraud was, however,
suggested in the context of electronic banking in the Report
of RBI Working Group on Information Security, Electronic
Banking, Technology Risk Management and Cyber Frauds,
which reads as under:-
A deliberate act of omission or commission by any
person, carried out in the course of a banking transaction or
in the books of accounts maintained manually or under
computer system in banks, resulting into wrongful gain to
any person for a temporary period or otherwise, with or
without any loss to the bank.
14
As is evident from the above table, the cumulative
number of frauds reported by the banking sector and the
total amount involved inThese fraud cases have a major
share in the frauds reported by all entities Under RBIs
supervisory jurisdiction.
16
Old 2271 1.34 1707.7 5.71
Private 1`
Sector
Banks
new 91060 53.8 2140.4 7.16
private 2 8
Sector
Banks
Sub Total 93331 55.1 3848.1 12.87
(Private 6 9
Banks)
Foreign 46206 27.3 1233.9 4.12
Banks 1 2
Total 16919 100 29910. 100
0 12
Chapter 2
BANKING FRAUD
18
2.1 Mechanics of Bank Fraud against Banks
Stolen Cheques
Accounting Fraud
Demand Draft Fraud
Fraudulent Loan
Payment Loan Application
Internet Fraud
19
Fraudsters
Wire Transfer Fraud
Identity Theft
Phishing
20
inflate the worth of the companys assets or state a profit
when the company is operating at a loss.
21
Fraudsters:- Fraudsters may seek access to facilities such
as mailrooms, post offices, offices of tax authority, a
corporate payroll or a social or veterans, benefit office, which
process cheques in large numbers. The fraudsters then may
open account under assumed names and deposit the
cheques, which they may first alter in order to appear
legitimate, so that they can subsequently withdraw
unauthorized finds.
23
Scale of employee level fraud
Many ways for bank employee to commit fraud
Loan fraud is the area of highest risk
But embezzlement remains high on the list
Two categories of employee fraud for banks
24
Over seven years, Pereira tempered with more than 60
customer accounts by executing thousands of fraudulent
debits and credited.
25
2.3MANAGEMENT LEVEL FRAUD
Sources of Frauds
26
Illegal Financial Transactions And Corruption
Chapter 3
27
1.1 About the Survey
28
The survey was conducted over three months from
November 2011 To January 2012, to gather the views of key
people responsible for fraud risk management in banks.
29
Fraud prone areas
300
200
2011 Column1
100
0
SBI Bank of India PNB IDBI Bank United Bank
30
The average loss per incident for nearly half of the
respondents is more than Rs 10 lack.
The Issue
What happened?
31
How was it discovered?
32
With the current economic scenario, an
overwhelming 83% of the respondents have indicated that
the fraud incidents will increase with 64% of them indicating
that the increase will be between 6-25%.
33
it had risen by 5 to 10% and one in every four indicating it to
be more than 10%.
34
50% of these respondents detected frauds using technology
solutions.
Not Disclosed 7%
35
With de-regulation, increased competition and IT revolution
making it possible to provide ease and flexibility in
operations to customers, banks are also evolving and trying
to become one stop financial supermarkets. However, the
entire range of banking operations can be segmented into
four broad heads - retail, wholesale or corporate banking
businesses, treasury operations and other banking activities
including advisory services termed as _private banking_ to
"high relationship value" clients. Fraud follows opportunity
and attacks weakness in the system. It is important to know
the areas
which are vulnerable to fraud before organizations can start
working towards controlling them. With banks operating in
various we specifically asked the respondents on the areas
where they gave encountered fraud and the root cause
analysis of the incidents.
36
77%
57%
33%
10% 13%
3% 3%
37
Largest chunk of cpmplaints (29.22per
cent) to ATM/Debit card/Credit card
disputes
38
financial statements along with asset stripping and incorrect
sanctioning, besides fraudulent documentation, are
Some of the other types of frauds increasingly encountered
by the respondents in corporate banking area. Since banks
are encountering frauds which encompass the whole
spectrum of corporate banking process from incorrect
sanctioning to siphoning of funds, it is important that banks
not only review their sanctioning, but also enhance
disbursement and their post disbursement monitoring
process. A good practice could be to undertake a closer
monitoring of accounts where early signals of stress are
seen. The RBI circular of 15 January 2011,
provides illustrative steps for banks which may be followed
to ensure effective monitoring of end use by the corporate
for the credit facilities granted to them.
39
area. Siphoning of funds and overvaluation/ non-existence of
collateral are some of the frauds where the most incidents
have happened, apart from fraudulent documentation. High
to very high incidents of frauds involving Identity theft is also
identified by 26% of respondents. Since many of the priority
sector customers may face challenges in providing the
requisite KYC documents, this loophole may be exploited by
fraudsters to steal the identity of gullible people and defraud
banks. This brings us to the question of customer due
diligence process adopted by the banks for this segment.
Since standard identity documents like PAN cards, etc., may
not be available with these customers, this problem may
continue to persist for some time to come. Hopefully, the
Aadhar program should provide some relief to banks in the
future to contain this risk.
40
that miss selling is considered as a low risk, especially in
view of the recent incidents highlighted in the media.
very high
high
account takeover misselling Identity Theft
medium
low
Fradulent Documentation
very low
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90
41
very high
others-business target
high
low
Collussion with external parties
very low
0 Un-accounted
10 20 traders in error accounts
30 40
50 60
70 80
90 100
42
hotline. However, the disturbing part 20% of the cases were
detected by accident and another 43% whereby anonymous
complaints by third parties, indicating that despite various
anti-fraud measures adopted by banks, a significant number
of frauds were
53%
43% 40%
37%
43
With acquisitions and expansions spurring the growth
in size and customer base, banks are witnessing a
substantial rise in the numbers and complexity of fraud
scenarios. As such, there is a stringent need for robust
monitoring.
44
fraud deterrent processes and the technological capabilities
of
the institution.
45
1.8 Prevention from Banking Fraud
46
4. Consideration of the source of funds used to open
an Account
Consumer Education
47
Ensure you know the person /entity you are
giving information to over the Internet.
48
Never divulged personal information to
anyone, As identity thieves often obtain information through
social engineering.
49
Chapter 4
Case Study
50
HARSHAD MEHTA SCAM- 4000 Cr.
51
Mehta mastered the tricks of the trade set out on dangerous
plan.
COBBLER SCAM
52
Daya of Dawood shoes, Rafique Tejani of metro shoes, and
Kishore Signapur of Milano shoes were arrested for creating
leather co-operative societies which did not exist.
Chapter 5
Questionnaire
53
1. How many percentages contributed to fraud due to
Business pressure to meet targets?
54
Ans. (b)
50%
Ans. (c)
Mumbai
Ans. (c)
13293 cases
55
Chapter 6
CONCLUSION
56
CONCLUSION
Risks are would like to deal with. But the fact is that frauds are on the rise
and organizations need to put their business affairs in order by having
effecting control mechanism internal controls can weaken over time by
having over due to technological advances or human intervention
(Management override or collusion) or because of the rise in new fraud
schemes. Implementing anti-fraud controls is not a foolproof measure
against frauds. Nonetheless, having anti-fraud measures in an organizations
Control environment can go a long way in deterring individuals from fraud
because the message going down the line is that the within the organization.
To protect your money from electronic theft, identity theft, and other forms
of fraud, its important to implement basis precautions such as shredding
account statements having complex passwords and only doing online
banking through internet connections.
57
BIBLIOGRAPHY
www.economictimes.com
www.wikipedia.bankingfraud.com
www.timesofindia.com
DNA news
Economics Times
58