Filing # 54760323 E-Filed 04/06/2017 04:38:07 PM
IN THE CIRCUIT COURT FOR THE SEVENTH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT,
IN AND FOR PUTNAM COUNTY, FLORIDA.
JONATHAN KINNEY, candidate for
Putnam County Sheriff,
Plaintiff,
v, No: 54-2016-CA-425CAAXMX,
jon: Circuit Civil
PUTNAM COUNTY CANVASSING
BOARD, by and through its members
Nancy Harris, Elizabeth Ann Morris, and
Charles L, Overturf, III; and HOMER D.
DELOACH, IIL, candidate for Putnam
County Sheriff,
Defendants,
PLAINTIFF'S UNOPPOSED REQUEST FOR JUDICIAL NOTICE
(COURT RECORDS REFLECTING FELONY CONVICTIONS)
In accordance with sections 90,202 and 90.203 of the Florida Statutes, Plaintiff Jonathan
Kinney requests that this Court take judicial notice of certain court records reflecting convictions
of felony offenses in the courts of this state.
1. This is an election contest action based in part on the grounds that illegal votes
were cast in the 2016 General Election in Putnam County by 32 individuals who have been
convicted of felony offenses and have not had their right to vote restored pursuant to law, and
that the number of illegal votes received is sufficient to change or place in doubt the result of the
election of Defendant DeLoach to the office of Putnam County Sheriff by a certified margin of
16 votes. § 102.168(3)(c), Fla. Stat
2. Under section 90.203, a court “shall take judicial notice” of any matter in section
90.202 when a party requests it, gives each adverse party timely written notice of the request,
Electronically Filed Putnam Case # 16000425CAAxM¥x 04/06/2017 04:38:07 PMproof of which is provided to the court, and furnishes the court with sufficient information to
enable it to take judicial notice of the matter.
3. Plaintif'has complied with the procedural requirements of section 90.203. Timely
notice has been given to each adverse party both before and through the filing of this Request for
Judicial Notice, Plaintiff has also provided each defendant a copy of the court records referenced
below. All defendants have also stipulated to the introduction of these records as a part of the
parties’ Joint Pre-Trial Stipulation
4. In addition to the parties’ stipulations regarding the records identified below, the
records have also been provided to the Court as proposed Plaintiff's Exhibits 1-19 (excluding
IIA and 14A) and 37-49,
5. The court records referenced below are subject to judicial notice under section
90.202(6), as they are “records of any court of this state...”
6. The specific court records for which judicial notice is sought have been provided
to the Cott as proposed Plaintifi’s Exhibits 1-19 (excluding 11A and 14) and 37-49, and
involve the following individuals and Case Numbers:
1. Charles 5, Ball, DOB [EEEFourt documents from Case Number 94-CF-3319 from
Seminole County reflecting a felony conviction.
2. Mattie H. Brinson, DOB| [court documents from Case Number 89-1566CF
from Putnam County reflecunms Tetony conviction.
3. Tyrone Davis, DOB MMII court documents fom Case Number 96-1628CF from
Clay County reflecting a felony conviction.
4, Gregory Allen Futch, DOB court documents from Case Number 82-339CF
from Putnam County reflecti
5. Jimmie Lee Gilmore, DOB] lourt documents from Case Number 2011
000174 from Clay County rl fony conviction.
6 Tommie Lee Johnson, DOB court documents from Case Number 80-
1g a felony conviction.
7. James Jordan, DOB| court documents from Case Number 48-05-CF-7616-
OVA from Orange County reflecting a felony conviction.
8. Ruben James Josey, Jcourt documents from Case Number 13-0192-CP-
52 from Putnam County reflecting a felony conviction,9. Cleophus Tyrone Matthews, DO! , court documents from Case Number 13-
001427CF from Putnam County reflecting a felony conviction.
10, Clinton Donovan Mims, D0; a court documents from Case Number 42-
2014-CF-001411 from Marion County reflecting a felony conviction.
11, Melvin Oxendine, DOB court documents from Case Number 98-0633CF
from Putnam County reflecting g felony conviction.
12, Bryan W. Padgett, Sr. DOB — court documents from Case Number 99-0670-
CF from Putnam County reflecting a felony conviction.
13. Deloris Pearce, DOB — ‘court documents from Case Number 92-369-CF from
Putnam County reflecting a felony conviction, certified court documents from Case
Number 95-819-CF from Putnam County reflecting a felony conviction, and certified
court documents from Case Number 96-62CF from Putnam County reflecting a felony
conviction,
14, Daniel J. Pierce, DOB [EEE court documents from Case Number 06-2414-CF-52
from Putnam County reflecting a felony conviction,
15, Michelle Angelina (Moreau) Scotland, DOB MEE, court documents from Case
Number 08-CF-005180 from Palm Beach County reflecting a felony conviction, certified
court documents from Case Number 05-12224CFAOV fiom Palm Beach County
reflecting a felony conviction, certified court documents from Case Number 05-
12773CFAOV from Palm Beach County reflecting a felony conviction, and a marriage
certificate from Putnam County, Florida from 05/19/2014 showing a groom’s name of
James Stuart Scotland and a wife’s name of Michelle Angelina Moreau, DOB
07/06/1985
16, William F. St, Sauveur, DOr ur documents from Case Number 92-1368-
CF from Putnam County reflecting a felony conviction and a copy of the sexual offender
registry entry for Willi eur.
17. Harold F. Sylvan, ma court documents from Case Number 08-2589-CF
from Putnam County reflecting a felony conviction.
18, James P. Williams alka Clinton B. Williams, DOB {EEE court documents from
Case Number 2004-CF-7859 from Sarasota County reflecting a felony conviction and a
Sarasota County Sheriff's Office Memorandum concerning the fingerprint analysis
linking the alias name,
19. Clark J. Wood, DOB IEEE, court documents from Case Number 95-487-CF-S2
from Putnam County reflecting a felony conviction.
20. Steven J Miller, aaa court documents from Case Number 97-1442;
1938CF from Putnam County reflecting a felony conviction,
21, Natividad Aguayo III, ay | court documents from Case Number 97-0838-CF
from Putnam County reflecting a felony conviction.
22. Anthony Pride, DOP I court ‘documents from Case Number 97-2263CF from
Putnam County reflecting a felony conviction.
23. Davis L Allen, DOB = court documents from Case Number 2000-11569-CF
from Duval County reflecting a felony conviction.
24, Ronnie L Barber, a] court documents from Case Number 10-1075-CF
from Putnam County reflecting a felony conviction.
25. Calvin A Bonfour Il, | court documents from Case Number CF97-2138
from St, Johns County reflecting a felony com26. Charles H Burkley, DOBEEEEEEEEE, court documents from Case Number 75-2172 from
Dade County reflecting a felony conviction.
27. Joc C, Cancel Jr, DOB (EEE, court documents from Case Number 07-1327-CF
from Putnam County reflecting a felony conviction.
28. James K Harris, aa court documents from Case Number CRC 02-
09168CFANO-B from Pinellas County reflecting a felony conviction.
29, Holland Miller Jr, DOB ourt documents from Case Number 04-2155-CF-53
from Putnam County ret fony conviction.
30. Lloyd L Wiggins, DO! court documents from Case Number 92-1209-CF-J
from Putnam County reflecting a felony conviction.
31, Alechia B William 7 a court documents from Case Number 01-2011-CF-
000428-A from Alachua County reflecting a felony conviction.
32. Yvonne M Zuzich, DOB SEE court documents from Case Number 85-472-C
Volusia County reflecting a felony conviction.
9, Plaintif's counsel has conferred with alll opposing counsel of record and
represents that this request is not opposed.
WHEREFORE, Plaintiff respectfully requests that this Court take judicial notice of the
court records identified in this motion,
Respectfully submitted,
Keller Legal Suurrs & BoweN LLP
is/ Zachery Lucas Keller {s/Daniel B, Nordby
Zachery Lucas Keller, FBN: 109146 DANIEL E. NORDBY (FBN 014588)
Service email address: zkeller@kellerlegal.org Email: dnordby@shutts.com
417 St. Johns Avenue, Suite 8 DEEDEE BITRAN (FBN 123493)
Palatka, Florida 32177 Email: dbitran@shutts.com
(386) 530-2279 (telephone) SuuTTs & BOWEN LLP
(888) 383-9077 (facsimile) 215 South Monroe Street, Suite 804
Tallahassee, Florida 32301
Co-counsel for Plaintiff Jonathan Kinney (850) 521-0600
-and-
200 East Broward Boulevard, Suite 2100
Fort Lauderdale, Florida 33301
(954) 524-5505
Counsel for Plaintiff Jonathan Kinney(CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I HEREBY CERTIFY that a copy of this document was served by email on April 6,
2017, to:
Ronald A. Labasky
Brewton Plante, P.A.
225 South Adams Street, Suite 250
Tallahassee, Florida 32301
rlabasky@bplawfirm.net
fsase@bplawfirm.net
John T. LaVia, HD
1300 Thomaswood Drive
Tallahassee, Florida 32308
jlavia@gbwlegal.com
Rhonda@gbwiegal.com
Counsel for Defendant Putnam
County Canvassing Board
Charles T. Douglas, Jr.
Douglas & Hedstrom, P.A.
601 Saint Johns Avenue
Palatka, Florida 32177
charlie@dhelawyers.com
Efiling@dhclawyers.com
vikki@dhclawyers.com
Counsel for Defendant DeLoach