You are on page 1of 30

Chapter 31

Evolution of North Sea Rift System


P.A. Ziegler*
Shell Internationale Petroleum Maatschappij B. V.
The Hague, The Netherlands

B. vanHoorn
Shell Internationale Petroleum Maatschappij B. V.
The Hague, The Netherlands

ABSTRACT
The Mesozoic North Sea rift forms an integral Sea. Geophysical data indicate an important dis-
part of the Arctic-North Atlantic rift system. Rift- crepancy between upper and lower crustal thinning
ing activity in the North Sea commenced during across the North Seariftsystem. This raises doubts
the earliest Triassic, peaked during the Late about the concept that during rifting the crust is
Jurassic-earliest Cretaceous, and terminated dur- thinned by mechanical stretching only. It is argued
ing the Paleocene. During the early Middle Jurassic that during the rifting process the Moho-
a major rift dome developed in the central North discontinuity can be seriously destabilized.

Sea area became consolidated during the Caledonian oro-


INTRODUCTION genic cycle. The eastern deformation front of the Caledoni-
The Mesozoic North Sea rift system consists of the Viking, dan fold belt can be traced from the Oslo graben through
Central, and Moray Firth-Witch Ground grabens and the southernmost Norway and the North Sea into the border
Horda-Egersund half-graben. The Viking and Central gra- area of Denmark and Germany. The eastern parts of the
bens are about 1000 km long and cross-cut the structural North Sea are underlain by a late Precambrian basement
grain of the Caledonian basement. Devonian, Carbonifer- complex that forms part of the Fennoscandian Shield. The
ous, and Permian sediments form part of the prerift western deformation front of the Caledonides is recognized
sequence, the distribution of which is only partly known in the Hebrides, from where it extends northwestward into
because of its deep burial beneath Mesozoic synrif t deposits central East Greenland (Figure 2).
and thick Cenozoic postrift sediments. The Scottish-Norwegian Caledonides, crossing the north-
The Mesozoic North Sea rift system forms an integral part ern North Sea, are characterized by a northeast to south-
of the Arctic-North Atlantic megarift system, the evolution west-striking structural grain. In contrast, the North
of which culminated in earliest Eocene crustal separation German-Polish Caledonian fold belt, which branches off
between Greenland and northern Europe. In the North Sea from the Scottish-Norwegian Caledonides in the central
area, rifting commenced during the earliest Triassic, intensi- North Sea, is probably characterized in the central North Sea
fied during the Middle Jurassic to earliest Cretaceous, and by a north to south-trending structural grain and in the
subsequently abated gradually. south-central and southern North Sea by a southeasterly to
The Cenozoic postrift evolution of the North Sea is charac- easterly trending structural grain. Late Paleozoic and in part
terized by the development of a broad thermal sag basin Mesozoic fault trends suggest at least a partial reactivation of
(Ziegler, 1982, 1988a). The North Sea is the most important these basement trends. Stratigraphic evidence from the Oslo
hydrocarbon province associated with the Arctic-North graben area, the Ardennes, and southern England indicates
Atlantic megarift as demonstrated by the large number of oil that the late Caledonian orogenic cycle came to a close dur-
and gas fields (Figure 1). Its productive fairway is closely ing the early Gedinnian (Ziegler, 1982,1986,1988a).
associated with the Viking and Central grabens. Ultimate
recoverable reserves in established accumulations are of the Devonian and Carboniferous Evolution
order of 32 billion bbl of oil and 120 tcf (trillion cubic feet) of of the North Sea Area
gas (Ziegler, 1980). During the Devonian the postorogenic collapse of the
Arctic-North Atlantic Caledonides, of which the Scottish-
Crystalline Basement Norwegian Caledonides of the northern North Sea form a
Much of the crystalline basement underlying the North part, was accompanied by a major sinistral translation
Present address: Geological Paleontological Institute, University of Basel, between Laurentia-Greenland and the Fennoscandian
Basel, Switzerland. Shield. In the northern North Sea area these movements

471
472 Ziegler, van Hoorn

"LOMOND**,
*A * ULA

F
| 0 4 I S 5 Fx " ^ V
JOANNE X ALBUSKJELL
,

FULMAR # ^> ^ l ^ r m
% > U K % CLYDE" * , | ^ L o n S K
N
* DUNCAN N ' f v A L H A I
ARGYLL \^HOD T DENMARK
ADOAJ
- * ROAR /TYRA
)00 Km A/6-1^-% X6PRW
a
x /SKdOLD
x o \ /c*l
N
x " < ^ \ DAN^
NORTHERN AND CENTRAL
NORTH SEA

OIL AND GAS FIELDS F/3 *


/ NETHERLANDS

Figure 1Location map showing oil and gas fields and location of cross sections Figure 19.
Evolution of North Sea Rift System 473
*
a.
o
u
u
3
IB
c
.1
474 Ziegler, van Hoorn

gave rise to the rapid subsidence of wrench-induced basins east-west direction across the central North Sea. It was sepa-
(Midland Valley, Orcadian basin, Hornelen-Solund basins) rated from the Southern Permian basin by the mid-North
in which thousands of meters of Devonian Old Red sand- Sea-Ringktfbing-Fyn trend of highs, which developed dur-
stone elastics accumulated. ing the Stephanian-Autunian. The Southern Permian basin
The Carboniferous evolution of the British Isles was gov- extends from the coast of England across the southern North
erned by tensional stresses. Several northeast-trending gra- Sea and northern Germany into Poland. Its configuration is
bens (Northumberland and Midland Valley), as defined well constrained by numerous boreholes and seismic data.
onshore, appear to strike into the central North Sea, where The Southern Permian basin is broadly saucer shaped. Sub-
they are, however, poorly defined. Another Carboniferous sidence of this basin was accompanied by minor faulting
basin is recognized in the Moray Firth area (Figure 2). only, except in its easternmost parts where the northwest-
During the Devonian and early Carboniferous the south- striking Polish Trough developed by the Saxonian. Lower
ern North Sea area formed part of the tensional Rhenohercy- Permian Rotliegende continental red-bed and basinal shales
nian basin that developed in the area of the Mid-European and evaporites reach a maximum thickness of about 1500 m
and North German-Polish Caledonides. With the late Visean in the Southern Permian basin. Rotliegende elastics in the
onset of the Variscan (Hercynian) orogenic cycle, the ten- Northern Permian basin are as thick as about 600 m (Ziegler,
sional setting of this basin terminated and, in its place, the 1982; Glennie 1984,1986).
Variscan foreland basin developed. During the late Carbonif- At the transition to the Late Permian, the Zechstein Sea
erous the central and southern North Sea were occupied by advanced from the Norwegian-Greenland Sea rift south-
the distal (cratonward) parts of this basin, in which a ward and flooded the Rotliegende basins of northwest
southward-expanding wedge of paralic coal measures accu- Europe (Figure 5). In both basins the basal Zechstein trans-
mulated. gressive Kupferschiefer corresponds to a chronostrati-
During the late Westphalian, terminal phases of the Varis- graphic marker. This thin, highly organic shale was
can orogeny, the Carboniferous grabens of the British Isles deposited below wave base and, as such, indicates that the
became inverted in response to intraplate compressional Northern and Southern Permian basins had subsided below
stresses (Ziegler, 1982,1986,1988a, 1988b). mean sea level prior to the apparently catastrophic Zechstein
During the latest Carboniferous-early Permian northwest transgression.
Europe was transected by the late Hercynian post-orogenic From the Norwegian-Greenland Sea rift, the Late Permian
system of conjugate shear faults (Figure 3). In the North Sea sea advanced southward into the Faeroe-Rockall rift, and
area wrench faulting triggered widespread intrusive and presumably entered via the Irish Sea area and the English
extrusive magmatism, the subsidence of the highly volcanic Midlands into the Southern and Northern Permian basins.
Oslo graben, and deformation of the sedimentary fill of the As there is no evidence for the occurrence of Zechstein series
Variscan foreland basin. Paleomagnetic data also indicate in the northern Viking graben, it is uncertain whether it had
that the Great Glen fault, transecting the Scottish High- already started to subside differentially during the Late Per-
lands, was reactivated during this time (Storetvedt, 1987). mian, thus providing a second, important avenue for the
Regional (thermal?) uplift of the North Sea area during the Zechstein transgression.
Stephanian and Autunian was accompanied by the deep Repeated glacio-eustatic sea-level fluctuation governed
truncation of Carboniferous and Devonian series. Seismic the accumulation of the highly cyclical Zechstein carbonate,
and well data from the North Sea area allow only a tentative sulfate and halite series. The distribution of the carbonate/
reconstruction of the subcrop patterns of Paleozoic series sulfate banks that developed along the basin margins during
beneath the regional Early Permian unconformity (Figure 2). Zechstein cycles 1 and 2, and of the thick basinal Zechstein-2
Particularly in the central and northern North Sea, the salts, indicates that both the Northern and Southern Per-
configuration of Devonian and Carboniferous basins cannot mian basins were elongated in an east-west direction (Zieg-
be resolved on the basis of available seismic data. However, ler, 1982; Taylor, 1984). The mid-North Sea-Ringkdbing-Fyn
locally there is evidence for the presence of thick Devonian trend of highs corresponded to a string of shoals. Although
and/or Carboniferous rocks beneath the base Triassic or base Zechstein facies patterns suggest that the Horn graben, tran-
Permian unconformity. The presence of such basins requires secting the Ringk0bing-Fyn High in a north-south direction
a commensurate amount of crustal thinning that obviously in the prolongation of the Oslo graben, did subside differen-
can neither be quantified nor areally defined. Despite this, it tially during the Late Permian, comparable evidence is lack-
must be assumed that by Early Permian time the North Sea ing for the Danish segment of the North Sea Central graben.
area was characterized by a mature continental crust having Furthermore, seismic data suggest that the Zechstein salts,
an average thickness of about 35 km, at least in areas devoid which are preserved in the southern Viking graben, form
of thick Devonian-Carboniferous series. part of the downf aulted prerift sequence that is eroded over
The widespread occurrence of Permian-Carboniferous the adjacent rift flanks.
volcanics and intrusives suggests, however, that large parts Overall, it appears that during the Late Permian rifting
of the lithosphere in the North Sea area were thermally propagated from the Norwegian-Greenland Sea area south-
destabilized. This is borne out by its late Early to Late Per- ward into the Faeroe-Rockall Trough and that the Northern
mian evolution. and Southern Permian basins continued to subside in
response to thermal contraction of the lithosphere, which
Permian Basins was loaded by water and sediments (Ziegler, 1988a). Along
At the end of the Autunian, wrench-fault and volcanic the southern margin of the Southern Permian basin minor
activity abated in northwest Europe, and the Northern and faulting controlled Zechstein facies patterns in Germany
Southern Permian basins began to subside during the Saxo- and the Netherlands (M.A. Ziegler, in press). In the eastern
nian, presumably in response to the decay of thermal anom- parts of the Southern Permian basin the Polish Trough con-
alies that were induced during the Stephanian-Autunian tinued to subside differentially.
phase of wrench faulting (Figures 4 and 5) (Ziegler 1982, In the central North Sea, the Zechstein series attained pri-
1988a, Sfrensen, 1985). mary thicknesses of about 1500 to 2000 m (Olsen, 1987).
The ill-defined Northern Permian basin extended in an Their present thickness distribution is, however, highly vari-
Evolution of North Sea Rift System 475

SEDIMENTARY BASINS
100 200 300 KM
WITHOUT VOLCANICS DIKE SWARMS 1

WITH VOLCANICS MAJOR SILLS, INTRUSIONS

VOLCANICS

Figure 3 Stephanian-Autunian paleogeography. Legend and explanation of abbreviations used in this and subsequent
figures shown on Figures 20 and 21.
476 Ziegler, van Hoorn

100 200 300 KM


I I

Figure 4Rotliegende paleogeography.


Evolution of North Sea Rift System 477

EROSIONAL EDGE Z-2/4SALTS 100 200 300 KM


I I l

Figure 5Zechstein paleogeography.


478 Ziegler, van Hoorn

able because of salt diapirism and erosion at the base-mid- renders it difficult to reconstruct the Triassic subsidence pat-
Jurassic unconformity. As there is little evidence for Late terns; this also impedes the assessment of the amount of
Permian rifting activity governing Zechstein facies patterns crustal extension that occurred during the Triassic. How-
in the North Sea, the Zechstein series is considered to form ever, in the northern Viking graben, where the Triassic series
part of the prerift sequence. rests on basement and is conformably overlain by Lower
Jurassic sediments, the interface between the basement and
Triassic-Early Jurassic Rifting Stage the Triassic red beds is largely nonreflective. Thus the
At the transition from the Permian to the Triassic, rifting amount of crustal extension that occurred during the Triassic
activity accelerated in the Norwegian-Greenland Sea area cannot be quantified within an acceptable degree of cer-
and in the Tethys domain. By Early Triassic time northwest tainty; the net amount of 18 km of intra-Triassic crustal
and central Europe as a whole were subjected to regional stretching across the northern Viking graben, as indicated in
tensional stresses which caused differential subsidence of a Figure 19, should be regarded as a highly tentative value.
complex set of multidirectional grabens and troughs During the Rhaetian and Hettangian, open marine condi-
(Figure 6). tions were established in the southern and south-central
Tensional reactivation of Permian-Carboniferous fracture North Sea, whereas continental, coal-bearing sandstones
systems was probably responsible for the localization of accumulated in the subsiding Viking graben and on the
some of the Triassic grabens (such as the North Danish Horda Platform (Statfjord Sands) (Figure 7). These sands
basin), whereas others, such as the Viking and Central gra- were derived from the Fennoscandian Shield, the Scottish
bens, were entirely new features (Ziegler, 1988a). Highlands, and the Shetland Platform; they form an impor-
Rifting activity continued through the Triassic into the tant reservoir for major oil accumulations in the northern
Jurassic with little evidence of discrete rifting pulses. Viking graben (such as the deeper pools in the Brent and
Stratigraphic evidence indicates that during the earliest Staffjord fields; Bowen, 1975; Karlsson, 1986; Spencer etal.,
Triassic the Norwegian-Greenland Sea rift propagated rap- 1987).
idly into the North Sea area causing the differential subsi- During the late Sinemurian the Arctic and Tethys seas
dence of the Viking and Central grabens, the linked up via the Viking graben and the Horda Platform as
Horda-Egersund half-graben, and the Moray Firth-Witch recorded by the open marine shales of the Dunlin Group
Ground graben system (Figure 6). At the same time the Horn (Figure 8). Lower Jurassic series reach maximum thicknesses
graben was reactivated. The Viking and Central grabens of about 500 m in the northern Viking graben, 750 m in the
clearly cross-cut Caledonian basement trends. However, Islorth Danish basin, and 250 to 500 m in the southern parts
individual fault segments, particularly in the northern of the Central graben.
Viking graben, suggest a reactivation of Caledonian base- Although Lower Jurassic series have been largely removed
ment discontinuities (Johnson and Dingwall, 1981). from the Central North Sea area by early mid-Jurassic ero-
The Triassic graben system of the North Sea is almost per- sion, it is assumed that the Central graben and the Horda-
pendicular to the axis of the Northern Permian basin and the Egersund half-graben, which are similar to the Viking
mid-North Sea-Ringk0bing Fyn trend of highs. Particularly graben and the Dutch part of the Central graben, continued
in the Danish part of the Central graben, there is clear evi- to subside differentially during the Early Jurassic. The
dence for the Early Triassic onset of subsidence. amount of crustal dilation that occurred during the Early
Triassic sediments attain maximum thicknesses of about Jurassic, however, cannot be quantified. In the North Sea
2000 m in the Central graben, 3000 m in the northern Viking area volcanic activity was at a very low level during the Early
graben, 4000 m in the Horn graben, and 6000 m in the North Jurassic; moreover, there is no evidence for rift-induced ther-
Danish half-graben. Restored isopachs of the Triassic series mal doming.
indicate, however, that also the Northern and Southern Per-
mian basins continued regional subsidence during the Trias- Mid-Jurassic Thermal Doming Stage
sic (Ziegler, 1982). At the transition from the Early to the Middle Jurassic, the
This suggests that the onset of Triassic rifting was not asso- central North Sea area was uplifted and formed a broad arch
ciated with major lithospheric thermal perturbances. In fact, transected by the Central graben. The dimensions of this
the Triassic rifts of the North Sea display a very low level of arch can be reconstructed by mapping areas of continued
volcanic activity, and there is only limited evidence for Lower and Middle Jurassic sedimentation and by tracing the
simultaneous uplift of the rift flanks (such as the southern subcrop of Lower Jurassic and Triassic series against the base
Viking graben). mid-Jurassic unconformity (mid-Kimmerian unconformity;
Overall, Permian basin edges became progressively over- Figure 9). Uplift of this rift dome was coupled with the inter-
stepped during the Triassic. During the latest Permian, the ruption of connections between the Arctic and Tethys seas
Zechstein seas withdrew from the North Sea area. In the (Ziegler, 1982,1988a).
northern and central North Sea, Triassic series are devel- The central North Sea dome extended in a north-south
oped in a red-bed facies. Lower and Middle Triassic shales direction from the southern Viking graben into the southern
and sandstones (Smith Bank Formation) are overlain by the North Sea over a distance of approximately 700 km, and in a
sandier Upper Triassic Skagerrak Formation, which was west-east direction from England to Denmark over a dis-
mainly derived from the Fennoscandian Shield. Cyclical tance of about 1000 km. Uplift of this dome was accompa-
Middle and Late Triassic marine incursions, originating nied by the development of a large volcanic complex at the
from the Tethys shelves, did not advance beyond the Danish triple junction between the Viking, Central, and the Moray
part of the Central graben and touched only the southeast- Firth-Witch Ground grabens. Subsidiary volcanic centers
ern parts of the Egersund basin (Ziegler, 1982; Fisher, 1986). are found in the southern Viking graben in the Egersund
In the central North Sea, accumulation of the Triassic basin, in coastal Norway, and in the Central graben. Vol-
series and syndepositional faulting triggered diapiric defor- canics display the bimodal mafic-felsic alkaline chemistry
mation of the Zechstein salts during the Middle and Late Tri- typical of intracratonic rifts (Dixon and Fitton, 1981). Most of
assic. This, in combination with the Middle Jurassic deep these volcanics were extruded during the Bajocian.
truncation of the Triassic series in the central North Sea area, Whereas the northern Viking graben continued to subside
Evolution of North Sea Rift System 479

sfefete
^.TW^

DEPOSITIONAL EDGE OF MIO-MUSCHELKALK SALT 0 100 200 300KM


L_ _l l I

Figure 6Middle Triassic paleogeography.


480 Ziegler, van Hoorn

100 200 300 KM


i_ I I

Figure 7 Rhaetian-Hettangian paleogeography.


Evolution of North Sea Rift System 481

Q,I ~ i-^ y-

100 200 300 KM

Figure 8Sinemurian-Toarcian paleogeography.


482 Ziegler, van Hoorn

MIDDLE JURASSIC EROSION TRUNCATING

' . ' . Areas of non-deposition during Early and Middle Jurassic Lower Jurassic series

: Areas without major hiatus at base Middle Jurassic Triassic series

\"jt Baiocian-Bathonian igneous activity Paleozoic series

100 200 300 KM


i i I

Figure 9Early Middle Jurassic paleotectonic map.


Evolution of North Sea Rift System 483

differentially during the Aalenian to Bathonian, the Central apparently accelerated, and tectonic activity now concen-
graben was uplifted and subjected to erosion, particularly trated on the Viking and Central grabens and the Moray
during the late Aalenian and early Bajocian. On its even Firth-Witch Ground graben system. Crustal dilation across
more drastically elevated rift flanks, erosion cut deeply into the Central graben was compensated at its southern termi-
rocks of the Triassic series, in places into Permian strata, and nation by a system of dextral wrench faults that controlled
locally even to basement levels (Figure 9). The structural the subsidence of the Sole Pit, Broad Fourteens, West Neth-
relief of the central North Sea dome was probably about 1500 erland, and Lower Saxony basins (Ziegler, 1982,1988a).
to 2500 m. Whereas the fault system delimiting the Horda Platform
Erosion products, consisting mainly of recycled Triassic and the Egersund basin to the east became largely inactive
sandstone, were deposited in adjacent subsiding basins in during the early Cretaceous, tectonic activity continued
major deltaic complexes, such as the regressive- along the Fennoscandian borderzone forming the northeast-
transgressive Brent Group in the Viking graben (Graue et ern boundary of the North Danish basin. The Horn graben
al., 1987), the Scalby Sandstone in Yorkshire (Hemmingway, was apparently inactive during the Late Jurassic.
1974), the Haldager Sandstone of the North Danish basin During the Oxfordian and Kimmeridgian, deeper water
(Hamar et al., 1983), and the Sonninia and Coronata Sand- conditions were established in the Viking and Central gra-
stones of northern Germany (Hoffmann, 1949) (Figure 10). bens and also in the Moray Firth-Witch Ground graben sys-
The sandstones of the Brent Group attain thicknesses of 300 tem (Figures 12 and 13). By late Kimmeridgian time the
to 400 m and form an outstanding hydrocarbon reservoir in mid-North Sea High had subsided to the degree that an
the northern Viking graben (for example, in the Brent, open marine connection was established between the cen-
Ninian, Statfjord, and Gullfaks fields; all in the billion-barrel tral North Sea and southern England.
class; Ziegler, 1980; Brown 1984; Karlsson, 1986; Spencer et Throughout the central and northern North Sea, Kimme-
a l , 1987). ridgian to Berriasian shales are developed in a kerogenous
Within the Central graben sedimentation resumed during source rock fades; their thickness and richness is highly vari-
the middle Bajocian and Bathonian under continental to able. These shales are the principal source of hydrocarbon
lacustrine conditions, initially in tectonically silled basins accumulations in the central and northern North Sea
and later on a broader scale (Figure 11). During the (Barnard and Cooper, 1981; Cornford, 1984; Baird, 1986).
Bathonian, increased subsidence of the Viking and Central During the Callovian and Oxfordian the Shetland Plat-
grabens combined with a relative rise in sea level caused form and the Hebrides Shelf became relatively uplifted, pos-
backstepping of the Brent-Pentland delta system into the sibly in conjunction with thermal doming of the Faeroe-
southern Viking graben (Harris and Fowler, 1987) and first northern Rockall rift zone (Figure 12). Particularly during the
marine transgressions into the Central graben. This may Oxfordian and Kimmeridgian, elastics were shed eastward
reflect the onset of collapse of the North Sea rift dome, as from these uplifted areas into the southern Viking graben
suggested by the widespread accumulation of the continen- and the Moray Firth-Witch Ground graben system, where
tal upper Bathonian and Bajocian Hladager Sandstone in the they accumulated in submarine-fan complexes. In the south-
Egersund-Horda basin (Hamar et al., 1983). During the Cal- ern Viking graben these deposits provide a number of
lovian and Oxfordian the central North Sea dome area con- important, largely stratigraphically trapped oil and gas/
tinued to subside, as illustrated by a regional transgression condensate accumulations (Brae field area; Stow et al., 1982;
in the southern Viking graben, the Central graben, and the Brown, 1984; Spencer et al., 1987; Turner et al., 1987).
Horda-Egersund-North Danish basins (Figure 12). At the The Faeroe-northern Rockall dome foundered rapidly dur-
same time, clastic influx into the basins of the southern ing the Kimmeridgian. At the same time the area occupying
North Sea and of northern Germany abated. By Oxfordian the triple junction between the Faeroe Trough, Viking gra-
and Kimmeridgian time also, the rift shoulders of the Cen- ben, and Mid-Norway rift zone was uplifted (Figure 13).
tral graben gradually became inundated. Subaereal exposure of the Nordfjord Ridge and the northern
Transgressive Bajocian to lower Kimmeridgian sandstone parts of the Tampen Spur (north of Gullfaks field) caused
(Pentland and Hugin formations) contain important hydro- erosion of the Brent and Statfjord sandstones and rocks of
carbon accumulations in the Central graben and the Outer the Triassic series (Karlsson, 1986; Nelson and Lamy, 1987).
Moray Firth basin (for example, in the Fulmar, Ula, Piper, Erosion products were shed southward into the Viking gra-
and Claymore fields; Maher, 1981; Spencer et al., 1986). A ben area, where they were deposited as submarine fans,
Callovian-Oxfordian deltaic system, prograding from forming the reservoir of the Magnus fields (Magnus Sand-
coastal Nonvay onto the northern Horda Platform, forms stone; De'Ath and Schuyleman, 1981).
the reservoir of the giant Troll gas field (Hellem et al., 1986). During the late Kimmeridgian, the supply of elastics from
By Oxfordian-Kimmeridgian times deeper water conditions Norwegian coastal areas to the northern parts of the Horda
were established in the Viking and Central grabens, and basin abated and remained at a relatively low level during
paralic conditions persisted only in its southernmost, Dutch the Early Cretaceous.
parts. At the transition from the Jurassic to the Cretaceous, rift-
In summary, the mid-Jurassic uplift of the central North ing activity accelerated in the entire Arctic-North Atlantic rift
Sea area has substantially contributed to the development of system. In the North Sea, this so-called "late Kimmerian"
major sandstone reservoirs that contain the bulk of the rifting pulse affected mainly the Viking and Central grabens
hydrocarbon reserves in the Viking graben and that are also and the Moray Firth-Witch Ground graben system. The late
of importance for the hydrocarbon potential of the Central Kimmerian tectonic activity in the general North Sea area
graben. Furthermore, sands shed southward from the North was accompanied by a relative drop in sea level, reflecting
Sea rift dome contain a number of oil accumulations in perhaps less a truly eustatic lowering of sea level than broad-
northern Germany. scale positive lithospheric deflections (Cloetingh et al.,
1987).
Late Jurassic-Early Cretaceous Rifting Stage Latest Jurassic-early Cretaceous intensified rifting activity
During the Kimmeridgian to Berriasian/Valanginian (?) the in the Faeroe-West Shetland Trough and the mid-Norway
rate of crustal extension across the North Sea rift system basin was paralleled by the rapid subsidence of the Nordf-
484 Ziegler, van Hoorn

VOLCANICS 100 200 300 KM


_l I I

Figure 10Bajocian-Bathonian paleogeography.


Evolution of North Sea Rift System
486 Ziegler, van Hoorn

100 200 300 KM

Figure 12Callovian-Oxfordian paleogeography.


Evolution of North Sea Rift System 487

100 200 300 KM


i I I

Figure 13Kimmeridgian-Tithonian paleogeography.


488 Ziegler, van Hoorn

jord dome along a set of listric normal faults (Duindam and Palinspastic reconstructions of a regional cross section
van Hoorn, 1987; Nelson and Lamy, 1987). through the northernmost Viking graben indicate that
In the Viking graben, rapid differential subsidence of rota- crustal extension by faulting amounted to some 2.5 km dur-
tional fault blocks in response to accelerated crustal exten- ing the Late Cretaceous (Figure 19); most of this extension
sion resulted in the development of a submarine relief of was accommodated along the boundary fault of the Magnus
about 1000 m. Highs were swept clean by contour currents Block, which subparallels the strike of the Faeroe-West Shet-
whereas pelagic shales accumulated in intervening lows in land and the mid-Norway basin fault systems. For the Cen-
which sedimentation was more or less continuous across the tral graben, fault offsets indicate an extension value of about
Jurassic-Cretaceous boundary. In the Central graben con- 1.5 km during the Late Cretaceous and Paleocene.
temporaneous rift tectonics are less obvious, as much of the Isopach maps and facies patterns of the Upper Cretaceous
tensional deformation at pre-Permian levels was taken up by and Paleocene series of the North Sea basins suggest that its
plastic deformation in the Zechstein salts and thus dissi- late rifting stage evolution was mainly governed by regional
pated to shallower levels. thermal subsidence. The global Late Cretaceous rise in sea
In the North Sea area, the largely submarine, and in many level played an important role in the progressive overstep-
places composite, late Kimmerian unconformity is region- ping of the basin margins and a rapid decrease in clastic
ally correlative (Rawson and Riley, 1982). Its origin is proba- influx. This trend was reversed during the middle Paleo-
bly related to drastic changes in the current regime caused by cene.
rapid subsidence of the Viking and Central grabens and an In the North Sea basin, clear-water conditions prevailed
important drop in relative sea level. This change in current during the Cenomanian as evidenced by the onset of chalk
regime was associated with stronger oxygenation of the bot- deposition. This sedimentary regime persisted until Danian
tom waters, as reflected by the regional termination of times (Figure 16). Upper Cretaceous to Danian chalks attain
kerogenous shale deposition. thicknesses of 1000 to 2000 m in the Central graben, thin over
Following the late Kimmerian rifting pulse the rate of its shoulders to some 25 m, and thicken toward its erosional
crustal extension across the North Sea graben system dimin- edges near the present-day coastlines of Norway and the
ished gradually. Within the Viking and Central grabens, the United Kingdom. In the Viking graben chalks give way
throw on many faults decreases and disappears upward in northward to pelagic marls and clays that range in thickness
Lower Cretaceous shales. However, master faults delineat- from 1000 to 2500 m. It is likely that Late Cretaceous basin
ing the Viking and Central grabens remained active through- edges had substantially overstepped the present-day coast-
out Early and Late Cretaceous times. During the Early lines of Norway and the British Isles.
Cretaceous, continued differential subsidence of this graben Upper Cretaceous chalks and marls progressively infilled
system was accompanied by gradual infilling of its relief the sea-floor topography of the Central and Viking grabens,
with deep-water shales and minor pelagic carbonates rang- as suggested by their onlap against intrabasinal highs and
ing in age from Berriasian to Albian (Figures 14 and 15). the graben flanks (Figure 19).
Lower Cretaceous shales attain a thickness of about 1000 m Although Upper Cretaceous sedimentation rates some-
in the Viking graben and 250 to 500 m in the Central graben. what exceeded subsidence rates and gradually rising sea lev-
In the inner Moray Firth basin, Lower Cretaceous, partly tur- els, shallow-water conditions were never established in the
biditic sandstone series reach a maximum thickness of axial parts of the North Sea graben system (Hancock and
1000 m. Scholle, 1975; Watts et al., 1980; Hatton, 1986; Kennedy,
During the Early Cretaceous a general rise in sea level 1987).
resulted in the progressive overstepping of basin edges and Maestrichtian and Danian chalks form the reservoir of
a gradual decrease in clastic influx into the North Sea area. In major hydrocarbon accumulations trapped in salt-induced
the Viking and Central grabens, only minor hydrocarbon structures, particularly in the Norwegian and Danish parts
accumulations have been established in Lower Cretaceous of the Central graben (as in the Ekofisk, Eldfisk, Albuskjell,
series which, in general, lack good reservoir development. Dan, and Gorm fields; Ziegler, 1980; D'Heur, 1986; Damtoft
Palinspastic reconstructions of regional structural cross et al., 1987; Spencer et al., 1987). These high-porosity, low-
sections indicate that measurable fault offsets across the permeability reservoirs are characterized by very low hydro-
northern Viking graben account for 19 km of crustal stretch- carbon recovery factors (less than 10%; Stfrensen et al.,
ing during the Jurassic and Early Cretaceous. In comparison, 1986).
crustal dilation across the central North Sea by Triassic to During the Senonian, igneous activity increased along the
Early Cretaceous faulting amounts to some 25 km, of which Faeroe-West Shetland and mid-Norway rift zone and culmi-
about 8.5 km can be assigned to the Late Jurassic and Early nated during the Paleocene in a major volcanic event (Thu-
Cretaceous. lean volcanism) that affected much of the Arctic-North
Atlantic borderlands. Following earliest Eocene crustal sepa-
Late Cretaceous and Paleocene Late Rifting Stage ration between Greenland, the Rockall-Hatton Bank, and
During the Late Cretaceous, rifting activity abated further Norway, this volcanic activity ceased abruptly (Ziegler,
in the North Sea area, whereas the Norwegian-Greenland 1988a). The regional earliest Eocene ash marker of the North
Sea and the Faeroe-West Shetland rift system remained Sea basin (Jacque and Thouvenin, 1975) is thought to be
active (Bukovics and Ziegler, 1985, Duindam and van related to a short-lived pulse of explosive subaerial volcan-
Hoorn, 1987). In the Norwegian-Greenland Sea crustal sep- ism that accompanied the actual crustal separation phase in
aratior was achieved at the transition from the Paleocene to the northern North Atlantic and the Norwegian-Greenland
the Eocene. Sea (Roberts et al., 1984).
In the graben systems of the North Sea, many of the faults During the Senonian and Paleocene, northwest Europe as
that control the structural relief of the late Kimmerian uncon- a whole became affected by intraplate compressional
formity diminish upward within Upper Cretaceous strata, stresses that can be related to the Alpine collision of Africa
and only a few master faults show continuous displacement and Europe (Ziegler, 1987) .These stresses induced the inver-
growth during the Late Cretaceous and Paleocene. How- sion of Mesozoic grabens and troughs at distances of as
ever, intra-Senonian block faulting is locally evident. much as 1300 km to the north of the Alpine collision front.
Evolution of North Sea Rift System 489

100 200 300 KM


__l i I

Figure 14Berriasian-Valanginian paleogeography.


490 Ziegler, van Hoorn

0 100 200 300 KM


I I l l

Figure 15Aptian-Albian paleogeography.


Evolution of North Sea Rift System 491

100 200 300 KM


_J I I

Figure 16Senonian paleogeography.


492 Ziegler, van Hoorn

Such inversion movements are evident in the North Danish compaction over deep-seated horst blocks (as in the Forties
and Egersund basins and in the Dutch and Danish parts of and Frigg fields; Ziegler, 1980).
the Central graben (Figure 17). In the latter they are respon- The thickness of Eocene and younger sediments generally
sible for the formation of structural traps (as in the Tyra gas expands from the margins of the North Sea basin toward its
field). Moreover, earthquakes may have triggered mass axis. Notable exceptions, however, are the Oligocene deltaic
flows of chalk during the Danian, as evident in the reservoirs complexes that prograded from the Shetland Platform into
of the Norwegian and Danish chalk fields (Hatton, 1986). At the deeper waters of the Viking graben (Ziegler, 1982).
the transition from the Paleocene to the Eocene these com- With the Neogene development of the north European
pressional intraplate stresses apparently relaxed. river system, deltas began to prograde during the Miocene
The timing of inversion movements in the central and and Pliocene into the southern North Sea and also from the
southern North Sea and the buildup of the Thulean volcanic Fennoscandian borderzone through Denmark into the cen-
event suggests that these Alpine intraplate compressional tral North Sea. Clastic influx from the Norwegian coast,
stresses counteracted tensional forces governing the evolu- however, remained at a generally low level. In the central
tion of the northern North Atlantic and the Norwegian- North Sea, Neogene and Quaternary open marine clays are
Greenland Sea (Ziegler, 1988a). Moreover, these stresses about 2000 m thick. In this area, shallow-marine conditions
may have contributed toward the Senonian and Paleocene were established during the Miocene, suggesting that sedi-
subsidence of the North Sea basin, the mid-Paleocene uplift mentation rates outpaced subsidence rates. During the Mio-
of the northern British Isles, and the regional relative sea- cene and Pliocene repeated sea-level fluctuations strongly
level fluctuations by inducing broad-scale lithospheric influenced sedimentation patterns in the North Sea, particu-
deflections (Cloetingh et al., 1987; Kooi and Cloetingh, larly in its marginal parts, where regionally correlative dis-
1989). conformities are evident, for instance at the base and top of
In conjunction with the Thulean volcanic event, areas bor- the Miocene. In the central North Sea, Quaternary series
dering the Rockall and Faeroe-West Shetland Trough range in thickness from 500 to 1000 m (Caston, 1979; Nilsen
became progressively domed during the latest Cretaceous et al., 1986) and thus reflect a sharp acceleration of subsi-
and Paleocene. From the uplifted northern British Isles elas- dence rates. This may be related to a renewed buildup of
tics were initially shed during the Danian into the Viking gra- north-northwest- to south-southeast-oriented compres-
ben. Clastic influx into the North Sea basin accelerated sional intraplate stresses, as evident from borehole breakout
sharply at the e n d of the Danian. This coincides with the data and the analysis of earthquake focal mechanisms (Klein
regional termination of chalk deposition. During the mid- and Barr, 1986; Kooi and Cloetingh, 1989).
Paleocene to early Eocene, deltaic complexes prograded Along the eastern margin of the North Sea basin, Cenozoic
from the Shetland Platform and the Scottish Highlands and Mesozoic series were deeply truncated during the Pleis-
toward the margins of the partly fault-controlled Viking and tocene, probably in conjunction with the isostatic adjust-
Central grabens (Figures 11 and 17). Repeated slope failure ment of the Fennoscandian Shield to Pleistocene glaciation
triggered density currents that transported sands into the and deglaciation. Furthermore, compressional intraplate
axial parts of the Viking and Central grabens, where they stresses may have contributed to the uplift of the Fennoscan-
accumulated in complex submarine-fan systems in water dian Shield (Figure 19).
depths of about 500 m (Heritier et al., 1979; Morton, 1982; The great thickness of the Cenozoic series has contributed
Conort, 1986). much toward maturation of the upper Jurassic source rocks
These sandstones contain important gas accumulations in in the Viking and Central grabens. However, in the
the Viking graben (as in the Frigg and Heimdal fields; Spen- Egersund-Horda basin, parallel to the coast of southern Nor-
cer et al., 1987) and oil and gas/condensate fields mainly in way, the thickness of Cenozoic deposits is generally insuffi-
the British parts of the Central graben (as in the Forties and cient for the regional maturation of the Kimmeridgian source
Montrose fields; Fowler, 1975; Carman and Young, 1981). All rock that is well developed in these basins. In the Egersund
of these fields are charged with hydrocarbons generated basin only local hydrocarbon kitchens developed during the
from Kimmeridgian source rocks. Neogene, in salt-induced Cretaceous subsidence centers.
In the North Sea, Oligocene and younger series contain
Eocene to Holocene Post-Rifting Stage only minor biogenic gas accumulations.
Following early Eocene crustal separation in the northern
North Atlantic and the Norwegian-Greenland Sea, the CRUSTAL CONFIGURATION AND
North Sea basin became tectonically quiescent, and its sub- AMOUNT OF UPPER CRUSTAL
sequent evolution was essentially governed by thermal EXTENSION
relaxation of the lithosphere and its loading by sediments.
The isopach map for the Cenozoic indicates that the North The present-day crustal configuration of the North Sea
Sea basin developed by broad crustal downwarping (Figure basin as derived from gravity, reflection, and refraction seis-
18). In the central parts of this saucer-shaped basin Cenozoic mic data, shows that the zone of maximum crustal thinning
series reach a thickness of 3.5 km; its axis is aligned with the coincides closely with the trace of the Viking and Central gra-
trace of the Viking and Central grabens. bens (Figure 19) (Donato and Tully, 1981; Barton and Wood,
There is no evidence for post-Paleocene reactivation of the 1984; Hospers et al., 1985; Beach et al., 1987; Zervos, 1987;
Mesozoic North Sea graben system, and the Eocene and Ziegler, 1988a). Refraction and deep reflection seismic lines
younger Rhine rift clearly die out northward in the coastal indicate that the Moho rises from a depth of 33 to 34 km
areas of the Netherlands. In the central and southern North under the coast of Norway to 22 to 24 km and 20 km under
Sea, local subsidence anomalies and faulting are caused by the Viking and Central grabens, respectively, and descends
the diapirism of Permian salts that played an important role again to a depth of 30 and 32 km under Britain and the Shet-
as a trap-forming mechanism at Mesozoic and lower Tertiary land platforms, respectively. Under the axial parts of the
reservoir levels (as in the Ekofisk province of southern Nor- Viking and Central grabens, in which sediments reach a
way). Additional traps containing major hydrocarbon accu- thickness of 8 to 10 km, the continental crust is 60% thinner
mulations developed during the Tertiary by differential than beneath Britain, the Shetland Platform, and the Fen-
Evolution of North Sea Rift System 493

:TLAND "

AREAS INVERTED DURING 100 200 300 KM


DIKE SYSTEMS
MID a LATE PALEOCENE l l l
VOLCANICS

Figure 17Late Palcoeene paleogeography.


494 Ziegler, van Hoorn

NEOGENE VOLCANICS 100 200 300KM


_l I I

Figure 18Cenozoic isopach map.


Evolution of North Sea Rift System 495

noscandian Shield. Available refraction data indicate that lated by the stretching model for the Witch Ground and
the upper mantle of the North Sea area is characterized by a outer Moray Firth area is at variance with the amount of
velocity of 8.1 to 8.2 km/sec (Barton and Wood, 1984). extension observed on reflection seismic lines (Christie and
Deep reflection profiles show that under the Viking and Sclater, 1980; Smythe et a l , 1980).
Central grabens the lower crust is highly reflective and dif- For the Danish part of the Central graben and the Horn
fractive, and that its reflectivity decreases toward the Nor- graben, reflection seismic data suggest a combined exten-
wegian coast and the Shetland platform, where a fairly sion value of no more than 15 km.
discrete Moho reflection is evident (Beach, 1985; Beach et al., Palinspastic reconstructions of the two regional seismic
1987; Gibbs, 1987a, 1987b; Ziegler, 1988a). lines crossing the Viking and the Central grabens (Figure 19)
If the crust of the North Sea is assumed to have been suggest that most of the crustal extension across the North
thinned during its Mesozoic rifting phase by mechanical Sea rift system occurred during Triassic to earliest Creta-
stretching only (McKenzie, 1978), the amount of extension ceous times. There is no evidence to support separation of a
across the Central graben would be about 100 to 105 km Triassic-early Jurassic rifting phase from a late Jurassic-early
(Wood and Barton, 1983; Barton and Wood, 1984; Sclater et Cretaceous phase, other than the rift-induced mid-Jurassic
al., 1986), and for the Viking graben about 100 to 130 km. In thermal doming in the central North Sea. Although not
the latter case the large range of uncertainty is due to the readily quantifiable, there is evidence that the rate of crustal
poor definition of the base of the synrift sediments; the high stretching accelerated during the Late Jurassic and earliest
value corresponds to the hypothetical base Triassic as shown Cretaceous and thereafter abated rapidly.
in Figure 19. As discussed earlier, it is uncertain and proba- Quantitative subsidence analyses for the central North Sea
bly unlikely that the crust of the North Sea had a uniform suggest basinwide extension of 50 to 80 km (Christie and
thickness of 32 to 34 km at the end of the Paleozoic. Sclater, 1980; Wood and Barton, 1983; Barton and Wood,
Multichannel reflection seismic data across the Viking gra- 1984; Hellinger et al., in press). The validity of this type of
ben and the Horda Platform show that extension of synrift approach to the quantification of crustal extension is ques-
sediments by faulting is, at base Jurassic levels, only about 20 tionable, particularly because in long-lived rifts the remnant
km (Figure 19). Although the base of the early synrift Triassic thermal anomaly at the end of the rifting stage cannot be
sediments cannot be mapped on a regional scale, it is directly related to a crustal stretching factor (Ziegler, 1988).
unlikely that the total amount of Mesozoic crustal extension Moreover, the realization that basin subsidence can be
across the northern Viking graben exceeds 30 km. This is in strongly influenced by compressional and tensional intra-
keeping with the geometry of inrra-Triassic reflections that plate stresses (Cloetingh, in press; Kooi and Cloetingh,
show no major divergence from the hanging-wall to the foot- 1989) raises further doubts about the validity of the concept
wall portion of individual fault blocks. Moreover, there is no that subsidence curves for passive margins, and in particular
evidence for low-angle normal faults being cut by a second for abandoned rifts, can be unreservedly translated into
generation of steeper fault systems. Correspondingly, upper crustal stretching factors. In the case of the North Sea basin,
crustal stretching factors for the North Viking graben during such analyses have to account for the latest Cretaceous-
the Mesozoic were on the order of 1.16. Paleocene compressional paleostress field and also the Holo-
This compares with a stretching factor of about 1.5 for the cene stress field (Klein and Barr, 1986).
southern parts of the West Shetland Platform, where Discrepancies observed between "stretching" factors
Permian-Triassic red beds, contained in half-grabens, are derived from crustal configuration, upper-crustal extension
characterized by strongly diverging reflection patterns. For based on reflection seismic data, and quantitative subsi-
the West Shetland Trough, Late Jurassic to Paleocene dence analyses cannot be easily reconciled with each other in
stretching factors of about 1.3 are indicated by reflection seis- terms of the original stretching model (McKenzie, 1978).
mic data (Duindam and van Hoorn, 1987; Kirton and Hit- Upper-crustal extension values, as determined from
chen, 1987). This shows that reflection seismic data are reflection seismic data, do not appear to differ substantially
indeed able to resolve the structural configuration of basins across the northern and the central North Sea. In the central
characterized by higher extension factors than those North Sea, Cenozoic sediments attain a maximum thickness
observed in the North Sea, an aspect that has sometimes of 3.5 km, whereas in the northern North Sea they range
been contested. from 2 to 2.5 km in thickness. The subsidence center of the
In the central North Sea, extension values obtained at the Cenozoic North Sea basin coincides with the largest gravity
level of the base Zechstein prerift sequence are in the range anomaly (Hospers et al., 1985; Zervos, 1987) and, perhaps
of 25 km (Figure 19). Although this amount possibly can be not coincidentally, also with the central parts of the mid-
increased by about 10 km on account of numerous small Jurassic North Sea rift dome.
faults, which are subject to interpretational differences or The available data point toward an important discrepancy
that cannot be detected by the reflection seismic tool, it is between upper crustal mechanical stretching and lower
unlikely that displacements along such faults could account crustal "attenuation" factors and the possibility that the
for a doubling or even a quadrupling of the amount of net mass of the lower crust is not being conserved during rifting.
extension, as required by the stretching model (McKenzie, Similar evidence from other rifted basins (Pinet et a l , 1987)
1978; Wood and Barton, 1983; Ziegler, 1983; Barton and suggests that during rifting processes the geophysically
Wood, 1984; Shorey and Sclater, in press). defined Moho may be displaced upward by physicochemical
In the central North Sea, as in the Viking graben, there is processes, possibly involving permeation of the lower crust
no seismic evidence for flat-lying extensional faults being cut by mantle-derived melts. This process may be associated
by a second generation of steeper faults. Moreover, fault with the development of laminations in the lower crust, as
blocks as defined at the base Zechstein salt level, are gener- defined by seismic reflection methods. However, it is real-
ally characterized by gentle dipslopes. This is not compatible ized that apart from basaltic sills, metamorphic layering and
with the arguments advanced by Shorey and Sclater (in shear zones can also contribute to lower crustal reflectivity
press), who claim that "hidden" faults could account for a (Beach et al., 1987, Ziegler, 1988a).
doubling of the measured extension value to some 60 km. If most of the lower crustal reflections can, indeed, be
Similarly, the amount of upper crustal extension postu- related to injection of mantle-derived material (Matthews,
496 Ziegler, van Hoorn

LITHOLOGICAL SYMBOLS

v :o-.'.' i
Sand ond conglomerate 11 Carbonate ond shale * * Halite
o" :''''?''.
1

:
Sond
z^" = Shole, some carbonote A A A Sulphate

--1' Sond ond shale I~I Shale o o

...... . Organic shale _


1 Carbonate and sand . Cool
1 -

1 Carbonate
1 i
1

TECTONIC SYMBOLS

Steep reverse and thrust


Normal fault faults, active deformation
front of fold belt

Transcurrent fault Fold axis

SPECIAL SYMBOLS

yr Volcanics, local
<> < irection of clastic influx

^ Batholiths Direction of marine incursion

Eroslonal edge of map interval Direction of intra-basinal


clastic transport

Figure 20Legend to paleogeographic maps.

1986; Meissner, 1986; Bois et al., 1988), it seems plausible bens, the Moray Firth-Witch Ground grabens, and the
that this process may ultimately cause a change of the physi- Horda-Egersund half-graben reached a peak during the
cal properties of the lower crust and a gradual upward dis- Jurassic and earliest Cretaceous. Rifting activity abated dur-
placement of the geophysically defined crust/mantle ing the Cretaceous and terminated with the earliest Eocene
boundary, similar to the process discussed by Beloussov crustal separation in the Norwegian-Greenland Sea and the
(1960, 1962). The crustal configuration of the central North northern North Atlantic. The total rifting period in the North
Sea and its post-Middle Jurassic evolution suggest that such Sea spans some 175 m.y.
processes may become particularly effective in areas where, An important feature in the evolution of the North Sea rift
during a rift-doming stage, asthenospheric melts have system is the early Middle Jurassic uplift of a major rift dome
ascended to the crust/mantle boundary. in the central North Sea, causing a reversal in the subsidence
pattern of its Central graben. Uplift of this dome was respon-
sible for the development of important hydrocarbon reser-
CONCLUSIONS voirs, both in the central and northern North Sea.
The Mesozoic North Sea rift forms an integral part of the Although less well documented, the area of the Faeroe-
Arctic-North Atlantic megarift system. West Shetland rift and the triple junction between the Viking
At the transition from the Permian to the Triassic the graben and the Norwegian-Greenland Sea rift apparently
Norwegian-Greenland Sea rift propagated southward into became thermally domed during the Callovian-Oxfordian
the North Sea area. In the North Sea, crustal extension that and the Kimmeridgian, respectively. Uplift of these domes is
caused differential subsidence of the Viking and Central gra- responsible for the accumulation of Upper Jurassic sand-
Evolution of North Sea Rift System 497

BF Broad Fourteens Basin NL West Netherland Low


CB Channel Basin NN North Netherland Swell
CG Central Graben NO Nordfjord High
CR Cardigan Bay NR Neurupiner Lineament
EA Eichsfeld-Altmark Swell OZ Osning Zone
EB Egersund Basin PO Portsdown Swell
EL Emsland Low YF Pays-de-Bray Fault
ET Emsland Trough RGR Rostock-Gramzower Lineament
FH Friesland High RFH Ringk0bing-Fyn High
FSB Fennoscandian Border Zone SH Sub-Hercynian Basin
GT Gluckstadt Trough SHL Sunn-Hordland Area
GTL Gifhorn Trough Lineament SP Sole Pit Basin
HB Horda Basin SPF Sticklepath Fault
HG Horn Graben SWB Solway Basin
HR Hunsruck Mountains TB Trier Embayment
HS Hunte Swell TF Thuringian Forest
HSB Hampshire Basin TW Thuringian-West Brandenburg Depression
HZ Harz Mountains T-IJ-H Texel-IJsselmeer High
KB Kish Bank Basin US Unst-Basin
LS Lower Saxony Basin VB Vosges-Black Forest Highs
MA Mendip Axis VG Viking Graben
MF Moray Firth Basin VL Vlieland Basin
MM Moreton-in-the-Marsh Axis WA Western Approaches Trough
MNH Mid North Sea High WB Wessex Basin
MW Market-Weighton Axis WD Weser Depression
MX Manx-Furness Basin WG Worcester Graben
ND North Danish Basin WN West Netherland Basin
NF Normandy Fault ZR Zandvoort Ridge

Figure 21List of abbreviations.

stone reservoirs in the southern and northern Viking gra- advanced for the development of extensional basins (Badley
ben. All of these rift domes foundered shortly after being etal., 1988).
uplifted, long before rifting activity in the respective grabens Furthermore, none of these models takes into account the
had ceased. temporary uplift of such rift domes as the early Middle Juras-
The latest Cretaceous to Paleocene Thulean volcanic sic central North Sea arch. The development of such domes
event, preceding crustal separation in the northern North can be related to the diapiric intrusion of asthenospheric
Atlantic and the Norwegian-Greenland Sea, was paralleled melts to the crust-mantle boundary, where they spread out
by the buildup of intraplate compressional stresses in north- laterally upon reaching their density equilibrium (astheno-
west Europe. These can be related to the Alpine collision of lith; tensional failure model, Turcotte, 1981; Ziegler, 1982,
Africa and Europe. The earliest Eocene crustal separation 1988; Turcotte and Emerman, 1983; magmatic underplating,
between Eurasia, Laurentia, and Greenland coincides with Keen and de Voogd, 1988). In the case of the central North
the relaxation of these intraplate stresses. Sea dome, thermal uplift of the Central graben area
Paleocene-early Eocene thermal uplift of areas bordering exceeded its contemporaneous isostatic subsidence that was
the Rockall-Faeroe-West Shetland Trough gave rise to the caused by continued crustal stretching. Evidence for contin-
accumulation of deep-water fan deposits in the Viking and ued Middle Jurassic crustal stretching across the North Sea
Central grabens. rift system is provided by the subsidence pattern of individ-
The axis of the Cenozoic North Sea thermal sag basin coin- ual fault blocks in the northern Viking graben (Brown et al.,
cides with the Viking and Central grabens. This illustrates 1987), and in the Central graben by the subcrop and onlap
that the zone of maximum crustal thinning corresponds also pattern of Triassic and Jurassic strata, respectively, against
to the zone of maximum lithospheric attenuation. This the regional mid-Kimmerian unconformity. The amount of
speaks in favor of the pure shear, depth-dependent stretch- Middle Jurassic extension that occurred in the Viking and
ing model (McKenzie, 1978; Rowley and Sahagian, 1986). Central grabens is, however, difficult to quantify on a
Geophysical data, however, indicate a major discrepancy regional scale.
exists between upper and lower crustal thinning across the The foundering of temporary rift domes prior to termina-
North Sea rift system. Therefore, it is questioned whether tion of rifting activity in the respective grabens can be related
the geophysically defined crust/mantle boundary remains to a number of processes such as cooling and contraction of
stable during rifting processes. Crustal attenuation during the asthenolith, thermomechanical subcrustal erosional
rifting may be achieved by a combination of crustal stretch- processes involving the injection of mantle-derived material
ing and physiochemical processes affecting the crust/mantle into the lower crust, causing an increase in its density, and
boundary. This hypothesis needs to be substantiated by possibly also phase changes (Moretti and Pinet, 1987; Pinet
additional geophysical data, also from other rifts; however, et al., 1987).
if applicable, this concept would require a basic revision of These processes may be associated with a gradual ascent
the currently favored stretched models that have been of the crustal isotherms and a commensurate upward dis-
498 Ziegler, van Hoorn

placement of the ductile-brittle deformation transition zone. ume I, Geology: Barking, Applied Science Publishers Ltd.,
This could be partly responsible for the increasingly strong p. 353-377.
rotation of individual fault blocks during the latest Jurassic- Brown, S., 1984, Jurassic, in K.W. Glennie, ed., Introduction to the
earliest Cretaceous phases of accelerated crustal extension petroleum geology of the North Sea: Oxford, Blackwell Scientific
Publications, p. 103-131.
that affected t h e formerly d o m e d Faeroe-West Shetland
Brown, S., PC, Richards, and A.R. Thomson, 1987, Patterns in the
Trough, t h e North Sea graben system, a n d also the area of
deposition of the Brent Group (Middle Jurassic), UK, North Sea,
the Nordf jord Ridge. in J. Brooks and K. Glennie eds., Petroleum geology of north
From a geodynamic point of view, it is interesting to note west Europe: London, Graham & Trotman, p. 899-915.
that particularly in the North Sea, the late Kimmerian rifting Bukovics, C , and P.A. Ziegler, 1985, Tectonic development of the
pulse, spanning p e r h a p s less t h a n 10 m.y., was neither asso- mid-Norway continental margin: Marine and Petroleum Geol-
ciated with significant volcanic activity, nor with renewed ogy, v. 2,p. 2-22.
d o m i n g of the Central graben area. It is speculated that tec- Carman, G.J., and R. Young, 1981, Reservoir geology of the Forties
tonic subsidence caused by crustal extension exceeded ther- oilfield, in L.V. Illing and G.D. Hobson, eds., Petroleum geology
mal uplift induced by lithospheric thinning, a n d that as a of the continental shelf of north-west Europe: London, Heyden
and Son, p. 371-379.
consequence of the mid-Jurassic thermal pulse the density of
Caston, V.N.D., 1979, The Quaternary history of North Sea: Acta.
the lower crust/upper mantle h a d decreased. Thus the den- University Uppsala Symposium, University Uppsala, Annum
sity contrast between asthenospheric melts a n d the litho- Quingentesimum Celebrantis, v. 2, Uppsala, p. 23-28.
s p h e r e m a y h a v e b e e n insufficient to drive large-scale Christie, P.A., and J.G. Sclater, 1980, An extensional origin of the
diapirism. Buchan and Witchground graben in the North Sea: Nature,
v. 283, p. 729-732.
Cloetingh, S., K. Lambeck, and H. McQueen, 1987, Apparent sea-
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS level fluctuations and a paleostress field for the North Sea
region, in J. Brooks and K. Glennie, eds., Petroleum geology of
The authors are indebted to their colleagues in Shell's north west Europe: London, Graham & Trotman, p. 49-57.
North Sea Exploration teams for their contributions to the Cloetingh, S., in press, Intraplate stress: a new element in basin
synthesis p r e s e n t e d in this chapter. Special t h a n k s are analysis, in K. Kleinspehn and C. Paola, eds., New perspectives
extended to Mrs. Ineke Hilberding, w h o assisted in con- in basin analysis: New York, Springer Verlag.
structing the paleogeographic m a p s , to Mrs. Josje Kriest for Conort, A., 1986, Habitat of Tertiary hydrocarbons, South Viking
preparing the regional structural cross sections, to Mr. Ruud graben, in A.M. Spencer et al., eds., Habitat of hydrocarbons on
v a n Aarle for drafting, and to Mrs. Monique Molenaar a n d the Norwegian continental shelf, Norwegian Petroleum Society,
Mrs. Wilma Ruggenberg for typing the manuscript. Permis- p. 159-170, (London, Graham & Trotman).
Cornford, C , 1984, Source rocks and hydrocarbons of the North
sion to publish this chapter was granted by Shell Internatio-
Sea, in K.W. Glennie, ed., Introduction to the petroleum geology
nale Petroleum Mij. B.V. a n d is gratefully acknowledged. of the North Sea: Oxford, Blackwell Scientific Publications,
p. 171-204.
REFERENCES CITED Damtoft, K., C. Andersen, and E. Thomsen, 1987, Prospectivity and
hydrocarbon plays of the Danish Central Trough, in J. Brooks
Badley, M.E., J.D. Price, C. RambechDahl, andT. Agedestein, 1988, and K. Glennie, eds., Petroleum geology of north west Europe:
The structural evolution of the Northern Viking graben and its London, Graham & Trotman, p. 403-417.
bearing upon extensional mode of basic formation: Journal of De'Ath, N.G., and S.F. Schuyleman, 1981, The geology of the Mag-
The Geological Society of London, v. 145, p. 455-472. nus Field, in L.V. filings and G.D. Hobson, eds., Petroleum geol-
Baird, R.A., 1986, Maturation and source rock evaluation of Kim- ogy of the continental shelf of north-west Europe, Vol. 1,
meridge Clay, Norwegian North Sea: American Association of Geology, London, Heyden and Son, p. 342-351.
Petroleum Geologists Bulletin, v. 70, p. 1-11. D'Heur, M., 1986, The Norwegian chalk fields, in A.M. Spencer et
Barnard, P.C., and B.S. Cooper, 1981, Oils and source rocks of the al., eds., Habitat of hydrocarbons on the Norwegian continental
North Sea area, in L.V. Illing and G.D. Hobson, eds., Petroleum shelf: London, Graham and Trotman, London, p. 77-89.
geology of the continental shelf of north west Europe: London, Dixon, J.E. and J. G. Fitton, 1981, The tectonic significance of post-
Heyden and Son, p. 169-175. Carboniferous igneous activity in the North Sea basin, in L.V.
Barton, P., and R. Wood, 1984, Tectonic evolution of the North Sea Illing and G.D. Hobson, eds., Petroleum geology of the conti-
basin: crustal stretching and subsidence: Geophysical Journal of nental shelf of north-west Europe: London, Heyden and Son,
the Royal Astronomical Society, v. 79, p. 987-1022. p. 121-137.
Beach, A., 1985, Some comments on sedimentary basin develop- Donato, J.A., and M.C. Tully, 1981, A regional interpretation of
ment in the northern North Sea: Scottish Journal of Geology, North Sea gravity data, in L.V. Illing and G.D. Hobson, eds.,
v. 21,p. 493-512. Petroleum geology of the continental shelf of north-west
Beach, A., T. Bird, and A. Gibbs, 1987, Extensional tectonics and Europe: London, Heyden and Son, p. 65-75.
crustal structure: deep seismic reflection data from the northern Duindam, P., and B. van Hoorn, 1987, Structural evolution of the
North Sea Viking graben, in M.P. Coward, J. F. Dewey, and PL. West Shetland continental margin, in J. Brooks and K. Glennie,
Hancock, eds., Continental extensional tectonics: Geological eds., Petroleum geology of north west Europe: London, Graham
Society Special Publication 28, p. 467-476, (Oxford, Blackwell & Trotman, p. 765-773.
Scientific Publications). Fisher, M.J., 1986, Triassic, in K.W. Glennie, ed., Introduction to the
Beloussov, V.V., 1960, Development of the earth and tectogenesis: petroleum geology of the North Sea: Oxford, Blackwell Scientific
Journal of Geophysical Research, v. 65, p. 4127-4146. Publications, p. 113-133.
Beloussov, V.V., 1962, Basic problems in geotectonics: New York, Fowler, C , 1975, The geology of the Montrose field, in A.W. Wood-
McGraw-Hill, 809 p. land, ed., Petroleum and the continental shelf of north-west
Bois, C , M. Cazes, A. Hirn, A. Mascle, P. Matte, L. Montadert, and Europe, Volume 1, Geology: Barking, Applied Science Pub-
B. Pinet, 1987, Crustal laminations in deep seismic profiles in lishers Ltd., p. 467-477.
France and neighbouring areas, in D.H. Matthews and BIRPS Gibbs, A.D., 1987a, Linked tectonics of the Northern North Sea
Group, eds., Deep seismic reflection profiling of the continental basins, in C. Beaumont and A.J. Tankard, eds., Sedimentary
lithosphere: Geophysical Journal of the Royal Astronomical basins and basin forming mechanisms: Canadian Society of
Society, 89, p. 297-304. Petroleum Geologists Memoir 12, p. 163-171.
Bowen, J.M., 1975, The Brent oil field, in A.W. Woodland, ed., Gibbs, A.D., 1987b, Deep seismic profiles in the northern North
Petroleum and the continental shelf of north-west Europe, Vol- Sea, in J. Brooks and K. Glennie, eds., Petroleum geology of
Evolution of North Sea Rift System 499

northwest Europe: London, Graham & Trotman, p. 1025-1028. Kirton, S.R., and K. Hitchen, 1987, Timing and style of crustal
Glennie, K.W., 1984, Early Permian-Rotliegend, in K.W. Glennie, extension north of the Scottish mainland, in M.P. Coward, J.F.
ed., Introduction to the petroleum geology of the North Sea: Dewey, and PL. Hancock, eds., Continental extensional tecton-
Oxford, Blackwell Scientific Publications, p. 41-60. ics: Geological Society London Special Publication 28, p. 501-
Glennie, K. W., 1986, Development of N.W. Europe's Southern Per- 510, (Oxford, Blackwell Scientific Publications).
mian gas basin, in J. Brooks, J.C. Goff, and B. van Hoorn, eds., Klein, R.J., and M.V. Barr, 1986, Regional state of stress in western
Habitat of Paleozoic gas in N.W. Europe: Geological Society Spe- Europe, in O. Stephensson, ed., Rock stress and rock stress mea-
cial Publication 23, p. 3-22. surements: Lund, Centek Publishers, p. 33-44.
Graue, E., W. Helland-Hansen, J. Johnsen, L. Lomo, A. Nottvedt, Kooi, H., and S. Cloetingh, 1989, Intraplate stress and the tectonic-
K, Ronning, A. Ryseth, and R. Steel, 1987, Advance and retreat stratigraphic evolution of the central North Sea, this volume.
of Brent delta system, Norwegian North Sea, in J. Brooks and K. Maher, C.E., 1981, The Piper oilfield, in L.V. Illing, and G.D. Hod-
Glennie, eds., Petroleum geology of north west Europe: Lon- son, eds., Petroleum geology of the continental shelf of north-
don, Graham&Trotman, p. 915-937. west Europe: London, Heyden and Son, p. 358-371.
Hamar, G.P., T. Fjaeran, and A. Hesjedal, 1983, Jurassic stratigraphy Matthews, D.H., 1986, Seismic reflections from the lower crust
and tectonics of the south-southeastern Norwegian offshore, in around Britain, in J.B. Dawson, D.A. Carswell, J. Hall, and K.H.
J.P.H. Kaasschieter and T.J.A. Reijers, eds., Petroleum geology Wedepohl, eds., The nature of the lower continental crust: Geo-
of the southeastern North Sea and the adjacent onshore areas: logical Society Special Publication, p. 11-22, (Oxford, Blackwell
Amsterdam, De Bussy Ellermans Harms B.V., p. 103-115. Scientific Publications).
Hancock, J.M., and P.A. Scholle, 1975, Chalk of the North Sea, in McKenzie, D.P., 1978, Some remarks on the development of
A.W. Woodland, ed., Petroleum and the continental shelf of sediimentary basins: Earth and Planetary Science Letters, v. 40,
north-west Eurpe, Volume I, Geology: Barking, Applied Science p. 25-32.
Publishers Ltd., p. 413-427. Meissner, R., 1986, The continental crust, a geophysical approach,
Harland, W. B., A. V. Cox, P. G. Llewellyn, C. A.G. Pickton, A. G. in W.L. Donn, ed., International Geophysical Series Volume 34:
Smith, and R. Walters, 1982, A geologic time scale, Cambridge London, Academic Press, 426 p.
University Press, 131 p. Moretti, I., and B. Pinet, 1987, Discrepancy between lower and
Harris, J.P., and R.M. Fowler, 1987, Enhanced prospectivity of the upper crustal thinning, in C. Beaumont and A.J. Tankard, eds.,
mid-Late Jurassic sediments of the South Viking graben, north- Sedimentary basins and basin forming mechanisms: Canadian
ern North Sea, in J. Brooks and K. Glennie, eds., Petroleum geol- Society of Petroleum Geologists Memoir 12, p. 233-239.
ogy of north west Europe: London, Graham & Trotman, Morton, A.C., 1982, Lower Tertiary sand development in the Viking
p. 879-898. graben, North Sea: American Association of Petroleum Geolo-
Hatton, I.R., 1986, Geometry of allochthonous Chalk Group mem- gists Bulletin, v. 66, p. 1542-1559.
bers, Central Trough, North Sea: Marine and Petroleum Geol- Nelson, P.H.H., and J. Lamy, 1987, The More/West Shetlands area: a
ogy, v. 3: p. 79-98. review, in J. Brooks and K. Glennie, eds., Petroleum geology of
Hellem, T., A. Kjemperud, and O.K. Ourebo, 1986, The Troll field: a north west Europe: London, Graham & Trotman, p. 775-784.
geological/geophysical model established by the PL085 Group, Nilsen, O.B., S. Srensen, J. Thiede, andO. Skarbo, 1986, Cenozoic
in A.M. Spencer et al., eds., Geology of the Norwegian oil and differential subsidence of North Sea: American Association of
gas fields: London, Graham & Trotman, p. 217-241. Petroleum Geologists Bulletin, v. 70, p. 276-298.
Hellinger, S.J., J. G. Sclater, and J. Giltner, in press, Mid-Jurassic Olsen, J.C, 1987, Tectonic evolution of the North Sea region, in J.
through mid-Cretaceous extension in the Central graben of the Brooks and K. Glennie eds., Petroleum geology of north west
North Sea: Part 1, Estimates from subsidence: Basin Research. Europe: London, Graham & Trotman, p. 389-403.
Hemmingway, J.E., 1974, Jurassic, in D.H. Raynes and J.E. Hem- Pinet, B., L. Montadert, A. Mascle, M. Cazes, and C. Bois, 1987,
mingway, eds., The geology and mineral resources of Yorkshire: New insights on the structure and the formation of sedimentary
Yorkshire Geological Society, p. 161-223. basins from deep seismic profiling in western Europe, in J.
Heritier, F.E., P. Lossel and E. Wathne, 1979, Frigg fieldlarge sub- Brooks and K. Glennie, eds.: Petroleum geology of north west
marine fan trap in lower Eocene rocks of North Sea Viking gra- Europe: London, Graham & Trotman, p. 11-31.
ben: American Association of Petroleum Geologists Bulletin, Rawson, P.F., and L.A. Riley, 1982, Latest Jurassic-Early Cretaceous
v. 63, p. 1999-2020. events and the "Late Cimmerian unconformity" in the North
Hoffmann, K., 1949, Zur Paleogeographie des Nordwestdeutschen Sea area: American Association of Petroleum Geologists Bulle-
Lias und Dogger, in A. Benz ed., Erdoel und Tektonik in tin, v. 66, p. 2628-2648.
Nordwest Deutschland. Hannover-Celle, p. 97-113. Roberts, D.G., J. Backman, A.C. Morton, J.W. Murray, and J.B.
Hospers, J., E.G. Finnstrom, and J.S. Rathore, 1985, A regional Keene, 1984, Evolution of volcanic rifted margins: synthesis of
gravity study of the northern North Sea (56-62N): Geophysical leg 81 results on the western margin of the Rockall Plateau, in
Prospecting, v. 33, p. 543-566. D.G. Roberts, D. Schnitker et al., eds.: Initial reports of the Deep
Jacque, M., and J. Thouvenin, 1975, Lower Tertiary tuffs and vol- sea Drilling Project, Volume 81: Washington D.C., U.S. Govern-
canic activity in the North Sea, in A.W. Woodland, ed., Petro- ment Printing Office, p. 883-911.
leum and the continental shelf of N.W. Europe, Volume I, Rowley, D. B., and Sahagian, D., 1986, Depth-dependent stretch-
Geology: Barking, Applied Science Publishers Ltd., p. 455-465. ing: A different approach: Geology, v. 14, p. 32-35.
Johnson, R.J., and R. G. Dingwall, 1981, The Caledonides: their Sclater, J.G., M. Hellinger, and M. Shore, 1986, An analysis of the
influence on the stratigraphy of the north-west European conti- importance of extension in accounting for post-Carboniferous
nental shelf, in L.V. Filing and G.D. Hobson, eds., Petroleum subsidence of the North Sea basin: University of Texas, Institute
geology of the continental shelf of north-west Europe: London, for Geophysics, Technical Report 44, 38 p.
Heyden and Son, p. 85-98. Shorey, M.D., and J.G. Sclater, in press, Mid-Jurassic through mid-
Karlsson, W, 1986, The Snorre, Statfjord and Gullfaks oilfields and Cretaceous extension in the Central graben of the North Sea,
the habitat of hydrocarbons on the Tampen Spur, offshore Nor- Part 2: Estimates from faulting observed on a seismic reflection
way, in A.M. Spencer et al., eds., Habitat of hydrocarbons on the line: Basin Research.
Norwegian continental shelf: London, Graham & Trotman, Smythe, D.K., A.G. Skuce, and J.A. Donate, 1980, Geological
p. 181-197. objections to an extensional origin of the Buchan and Witch-
Keen, C.E., andB. de Voogd, 1988, The continent-ocean boundary at ground graben in the North Sea: Nature, v. 287, p. 467-468.
the rifted margin off eastern Canada: new results from deep seis- Stfrensen, K., 1985, Danish basin subsidence by Triassic rifting on a
mic reflection studies: Tectonics, v. 7, p. 107-124. lithosphere cooling background: Nature, v. 319, p. 660-663.
Kennedy, W.J., 1987, Sedimentology of Late Cretaceous-Paleocene S^rensen, S., M. Jones, R.F.P. Hardman, W.K. Leutz, and P.H. Sch-
Chali reservoirs, North Sea Central graben, in J. Brooks and K. warz, 1986, Reservoir characteristics of high- and low-
Glennie, eds., Petroleum geology of north west Europe: Lon- productivity chalks from the Central North Sea, in A.M. Spencer
don, Graham & Trotman, p. 469-481. et al., eds., Habitat of hydrocarbons on the Norwegian continen-
500 Ziegler, van Hoorn

tal shelf: London, Graham & Trotman, p. 91-110. area, North Sea: deposition in a slope and base of slope environ-
Spencer, A.M., P.C. Home, and V. Wiik, 1986, Habitat of hydrocar- ment: Geology, v. 8, p. 217-221.
bons in the Jurassic Ula trend, Central graben, Norway, in A.M. Wood, R., and P. Barton, 1983, Crustal thinning and subsidence in
Spencer et al., eds., Habitat of hydrocarbons on the Norwegian the North Sea: Nature, v. 302, p. 134-136.
continental shelf: London, Graham & Trotman, p. 111-127. Zervos, F., 1987, A compilation and regional interpretation of the
Spencer, A.M., C.J. Campbell, S.H. Hanslien, P.H.H. Nelson, E. northern North Sea gravity map, in M.P. Coward, J.F. Dewey,
Nijsaether, E.G. Ormaasen, andE. Holter (eds.), 1987, Geology and PL. Hancock eds., Continental extensional tectonics: Geo-
of the Norwegian oil and gas fields: London, Graham & Trot- logical Society of London Special Publication 28, p. 477-493,
man, 493 p. (Oxford, Blackwell Scientific Publications).
Storetvedt, K.M. 1987, Major late Caledonian and Hercynian shear Ziegler, M.A., in press, North German Zechstein facies patterns
movements on the Great Glen fault: Tectonophysics, v. 143, with regard to their older substrate: Geologische Rundschau.
p. 253-267. Ziegler, P.A., 1980, Northwestern European basin: geology and
Stow, D.A.V., C D . Bishop, and S.J. Mills, 1982, Sedimentology of hydrocarbon provinces: Canadian Society of Petroleum Geolo-
the Brae oil field, North Sea: fan models and controls: Journal of gists Memoir 6, p. 653-706.
Petroleum Geology, v. 5, p. 129-148. Ziegler, P.A., 1982, Geological atlas of western and central Europe:
Taylor, J.CM., 1984, Late Permian-Zechstein, in K.W. Glennie, ed., Amsterdam, Scientific Publishing Co., 130 p.
Introduction to the petroleum geology of the North Sea: Oxford, Ziegler, PA., 1983, Crustal thinning and subsidence in the North
Blackwell Scientific Publications, p. 61-83. Sea; matters arising: Nature, v. 304, p. 561.
Turcotte, D.L., 1981, Riftstensional failures of the lithosphere, in Ziegler,PA., 1986, Geodynamic model for the Paleozoic crustal con-
papers presented to the Conference of Processes of Planetary solidation of western and central Europe: Tectonophysics,
Rifting, Christian Brother's retreat house, Napa Valley, Califor- v. 126, p. 303-328.
nia, Dec. 3-5, 1981: Lunar and Planetary Institute contribution Ziegler, P.A., 1987, Late Cretaceous and Cenozoic intra-plate com-
451,p. 5-8. pressional deformations in the Alpine forelanda geodynamic
Turcotte, D.L., and S.H. Emerman, 1983, Mechanisms of active and model: Tectonophysics, v. 137, p. 389-420.
passive rifting: Tectonophysics, v. 94, p. 39-50. Ziegler, P.A., 1988a, Evolution of the Arctic-North Atlantic rift sys-
Turner, C.C, J.M. Cohen, E.R. Connell, and D.M. Cooper, 1987, A tem; American Association of Petroleum Geologists Memoir 43,
depositional model for the South Brae oilfield, in J. Brooks and K. 198 p.
Glennie, eds., Petroleum geology of north west Europe: Lon- Ziegler, P.A., 1988b, Laurussia-the Old Red continent, in J. McMil-
don, Graham & Trotman, p. 853-864. lan, N.J. Embry, and D.J. Glass, eds., Devonian of the world:
Watts, N.L., L.F. Lapre, F.S. van Schijndel, and A. Ford, 1980, Canadian Society of Petroleum Geologists, p. 15-48.
Upper Cretaceous and lower Tertiary chalks of the Albuskjell

You might also like