Professional Documents
Culture Documents
DOI 10.1007/s00701-016-2802-8
that is furthest away from the respective body part that un-
dergoes surgery [15]. Previous studies have investigated this
commonly accepted iatromathematical model of unfavor-
able zodiac signs [24], surgical complications [11, 16] and
outcome [11] and have not been able to find any correlations.
To the best of our knowledge, there are no studies on the
reliability of moon calendars when it comes to predicting
complications or outcomes in the field of neurosurgery.
In the current study, we tested the null hypothesis that rates
of intraoperative complications, re-do surgeries and positive
4-week response to elective spine surgery for DDD are similar
when the procedure is done on a day with an unfavorable
lunar or zodiac constellation.
Data collection
Table 1 Baseline variables experience. Additional analyses were run for operations per-
Parameter Waxing moon Waning moon p-value formed on dates with a full moon and on dates when the moon
passed through the Leo zodiac sign. Results are presented in
Age (mean SD) 64.2 13.6 63.4 14.0 0.358 odds ratios (ORs) and 95 % confidence intervals (CIs).
Gender
Male 237 (48.4 %) 228 (52.5 %) 0.206
Female 253 (51.6 %) 206 (47.5 %) Results
Type of surgery
ACDF 131 (26.7 %) 150 (34.6 %) 0.036 Data of a total of 924 patients who previously had undergone
Lumbar microdisc. 56 (11.4 %) 45 (10.4 %) elective surgery for DDD were available. Male and female
Lumbar decompr. 303 (61.9 %) 239 (55.0 %) genders were equally represented (n = 465, 50.3 %; n = 459,
Extent of surgery 49.7 %), and the mean age of the whole cohort was 63.8
1 level 304 (62.0 %) 233 (53.7 %) 0.010 13.8 years (standard deviation). Anterior cervical
2 levels 186 (38.0 %) 201 (46.3 %) discectomy and fusion (ACDF) was performed in 281
Primary surgeon (30.4 %), microdiscectomy for lumbar disc herniation
Senior surgeon 299 (61.0 %) 291 (67.0 %) 0.057 (LDH) in 101 (10.9 %) and microscopic lumbar decompres-
Junior surgeon 191 (39.0 %) 143 (33.0 %) sion for lumbar spinal stenosis (LSS) in 542 (58.7 %).
Discharge A total of 490 patients underwent surgery during a waxing
Home 367 (74.9 %) 329 (75.8 %) 0.749 moon and 434 during a waning moon. Among these cases,
Rehabilitation 123 (25.1 %) 105 (24.2 %) surgery was performed on a full moon in 26 (2.8 %) and on
n = 490 n = 434 days when the moon passed through the unfavorable zodiac
sign Leo in 65 (7.0 %).
SD = Standard deviation Table 1 shows that important baseline variables such as age
and gender were equally distributed among the study groups.
Statistical methods At the time of the waxing moon, more lumbar decompression
procedures and fewer ACDFs were performed than at the time
The null hypothesis was that the rates of intraoperative com- of the waning moon, and those were also more often single
plications and re-do surgeries as well as the postoperative 4- level. There was also a trend toward a higher number of pro-
week outcomes are similar for operations performed during cedures performed by junior surgeons during the waxing
waxing and waning moons. First, patients operated on during moon (Table 1).
a waxing moon were compared to those operated on during a The relationship between the occurrence of intraoperative
waning moon for important baseline variables using Pearson complications and a waxing moon is demonstrated in Table 2.
2 tests for categorical and rank-sum tests for continuous Patients operated on during a waxing moon were 1.73 times as
variables. Rates of intraoperative complications, the need for likely as patients operated on during a waning moon to suffer
re-do surgery until 4 weeks after surgery and the 4-week re- from an intraoperative complication (OR 1.73, 95 % CI 1.25
sponder status to surgery were the dependent variables of in- 2.38, p = 0.001). This relationship was slightly attenuated
terest. The waxing moon was our independent variable. when corrected for the above-mentioned baseline group dif-
Univariate logistic regression was used to estimate the rela- ferences (OR 1.54, 95 % CI 1.072.21, p = 0.019). The likeli-
tionship between any of the dependent and independent vari- hood of intraoperative complications was similar on days with
ables. As the study groups turned out to differ in some impor- a full moon or unfavorable zodiac sign. Figure 2 is a graph-
tant baseline variables, an additional multivariate model was ical display of the likelihood of intraoperative complications
built in order to adjust estimates for the parameters type of in relation to each day of the lunar cycle as described by
surgery, single vs. multilevel surgery and surgeons Kuehnl et al. [9]. As becomes evident, there is no phase of
Multivariate analysis was corrected for type of surgery, experience of the primary surgeon and extent of surgery
Acta Neurochir
the 30-day lunar cycle where this likelihood is significantly (Fig. 3c; 5.9 vs. 6.1 days; p = 0.234) were not different during
elevated (all CI bars cross the reference line at y = 1). the LP.
However, the trend to higher odds at a waxing moon and In this series, two patients were operated on under the con-
lower odds at a waning moon is deducible. stellation of a full moon in addition to the zodiac sign Leo. No
Table 3 describes the relationship between a favorable 4- intraoperative complications occurred. One of these two pa-
week responder status to surgery and a waxing moon. The tients underwent re-do surgery, but both were considered pos-
likelihood of responding positively to surgical treatment was itive responders to surgery at 4-week follow-up.
the same for patients who were operated on during a waxing
moon. Similarly, the likelihood of a favorable 4-week re-
sponder status was equal on days with a full moon or the Discussion
unfavorable zodiac sign.
Table 4 estimates the relationship of the need for re-do Based on the moon calendar for Eastern Switzerland, we
surgery within 4 weeks after surgery and the independent assessed the complication rates and outcomes in 924 elective
variables. Note that patients operated on during a waxing spine surgery cases to challenge common superstitious beliefs
moon were not more likely to undergo re-do surgery during about the influence of LP on surgery. We found no significant
the follow-up. In multivariate analysis, there was even a ten- association whatsoever between a waxing moon and clinical
dency toward a lower revision rate during a waxing moon (OR outcomes or re-do surgery rates or between a full moon and an
0.51, 95 % CI 0.231.16, p = 0.109). unfavorable zodiac sign for any of the primary or secondary
Figure 3ac shows that operation time (Fig. 3a; 103.7 vs. outcomes except for one: Much to our own surprise, patients
105.4 min; p = 0.697), EBL (Fig. 3b; 109.1 vs. 115.7 ml; undergoing surgery during a waxing moon were 73 % more
p = 0.451) and length of postoperative hospitalization likely to experience an intraoperative complication (OR 1.73,
Table 3 Estimation of the relationship between the 4-week responder status after elective spine surgery and a waxing moon, full moon or
unfavorable zodiac sign. Multivariate analysis was corrected for type of surgery, experience of the primary surgeon and extent of surgery
OR 95 % CI p-value OR 95 % CI p-value
Multivariate analysis was corrected for type of surgery, experience of the primary surgeon and extent of surgery
95 % CI 1.252.38, p = 0.001). From the unadjusted model it study groups (Fig. 3b). Also, surgical site hematomas in our
cannot be concluded with certainty that the observed effect series were not more frequent during waxing moons (1.19 %
was exclusively due to the waxing moon as the study groups vs. 1.17 %, Pearson 2 0.0005, p = 0.982), full moons (0.0 %
were unbalanced. Patients operated on during a waxing moon vs. 1.22 %, Pearson 2 0.2958, p = 0.587) or days with an
were more often subject to a lumbar decompression and more unfavorable zodiac sign (2.0 % vs. 1.12 %, Pearson 2
often operated on by a supervised resident, which per se could 0.3090, p = 0.578). At this point, it should also be mentioned
explain the higher complication rate. However, when account- that on earth the gravitational pull on the human body by the
ing for these imbalances in a multivariate analysis, patients moon is negligible. It depends on the alignment of the moon,
who underwent surgery during a waxing moon were 54 % earth and sun, and not on the actual LP [4]. Andrews often
more likely to experience an intraoperative complication cited (unblinded) report on increased blood loss during
(OR 1.54, 95 % CI 1.072.21, p = 0.019). This finding is in adenotomy and tonsillectomy around a full moon [1] did not
line with moon experts recommendations not to undergo withstand statistical validation [24], and other studies reported
elective surgery during a waxing moon, but other findings of no significant moon-dependent increased loss of blood [5, 17].
the study put this into perspective: The likelihood of re-do In line with the literature [11, 16], the moons passing
surgery until the 4-week follow-up tended to be lower in pa- through an unfavorable zodiac signLeo in case of spine
tients operated on during a waxing moon (OR 0.51, 95 % CI surgery [15]did not increase the rates of surgical complica-
0.231.16, p = 0.109), and the 4-week responder status was tions or re-do surgeries and had no influence on the 4-week
equal (Table 3). Thus, our patients who suffered from a com- outcome. Since we could not even observe trends in this con-
plication during a waxing moon apparently had similarly fa- siderable number of surgical cases that we analyzed here, we
vorable outcomes at 4-week follow-up at outpatient clinics. can confidently refute this theory. Even the two patients who
Moreover, in light of the lack of a plausible explanation, we underwent surgery under the most unfortunate circum-
question the causality. It is conceivable that being operated on stances of a full moon passing through Leo at the time did
by tired surgeons might lead to more complications because not have any intraoperative complications, and the 4-week
their night sleep has been disturbed by moonlight, which is outcome was favorable in both cases.
usually brightest during a full moon. However, our data sug- To the best of our knowledge, this is the first study to assess
gest equal or even slightly lower complication rates on dates the effects of lunar or zodiac constellations on neurosurgery.
with a full moon (Table 2). The theory that lunar gravitational Contrary to our original intention, we cannot completely dis-
forces account for higher blood loss during a waxing moon count patients beliefs concerning moon calendar-based elec-
[15] is refuted by our data as EBL was similar between the tive surgery scheduling as absurd, since we formally have to
Fig. 3 ac Operation time (3A; 103.7 vs. 105.4 min; p = 0.697), EBL waxing and waning moon for elective spine surgery. The figures
(3B; 109.1 vs. 115.7 ml; p = 0.451) and length of postoperative display the median with the 25th75th percentile (box), the upper and
hospitalization (3C; 5.9 vs. 6.1 days; p = 0.234) did not differ during the lower adjacent values (whiskers) and outliers (dots)
Acta Neurochir
reject the null hypothesis of the current study. However, in the moon calendars in surgical scheduling, which alleviates the
absence of any rational explanations and in light of a missing burden on operation planning logistics. Nevertheless, patients
negative influence of a waxing moon on any of the other beliefs and concerns should always be taken seriously. To reas-
outcomes, we suspect that this finding is due to a type II error. sure anxious patients and to better estimate the influence of the
This error might result from group imbalances with respect to moon on surgical complications and outcomes, more data
the type of surgery and level of training, despite statistical preferably from prospective spine registriesare desirable.
adjustment [12]. It would be interesting to re-test the null
hypothesis with larger databases from spine registries and in Acknowledgments The authors thank Dario Jucker, medical student at
the University of Zurich, for helping with the data acquisition. We thank
a prospective fashion to build balanced study groups and pos-
Dr. Nicolas Smoll for his advice on the statistical part of the manuscript.
sibly also to take into account the physiologic data in addition Figure 1 was obtained from the Abbey Library of St. Gallen (UNESCO
to LP, for example, the surgeons previous nights sleep hours. World Heritage Site). We thank U5 for editing Fig. 2.
The present work might confirm the superstition of moon
believers and foster socioeconomic problems in terms of sur- Compliance with ethical standards
gical logistics concerning staff and operating room capacities Funding No funding was received for this study.
[7, 11, 16]. At the end of the day, patients beliefs and con-
cerns should be respected [9] regardless of how irrational they Conflict of Interest None.
may seem to a rational mind. In our opinion, anxious patients
Ethical approval For this type of study formal consent is not required.
should be advised that surgery during a waxing moon is safe
and reassured by quoting primarily studies that disprove an Informed consent Informed consent was obtained from all individual
influence of the LP on surgical complications and outcomes. participants included in the study.
Limitations
13. Meiser A, Casagranda O, Skipka G, Laubenthal H (2001) Geburt unseres Herrn Jesu Christi. Kalenderverlag Steinhauser
Quantification of blood loss. How precise is visual estimation and GmbH Kempten
what does its accuracy depend on? Anaesthesist 50:1320 20. Stienen MN, Joswig H, Jucker D, Hildebrandt G, Schaller K,
14. Peters-Engl C, Frank W, Kerschbaum F, Denison U, Medl M, Gautschi OP (2015) Anterior cervical discectomy and fusion: is
Sevelda P (2001) Lunar phases and survival of breast cancer pa- surgical education safe? Acta Neurochir (Wien) 157:13951404
tientsa statistical analysis of 3,757 cases. Breast Cancer Res Treat 21. Stienen MN, Smoll NR, Hildebrandt G, Schaller K, Gautschi OP
70:131135 (2014) Early surgical education of residents is safe for microscopic
15. Riezler L (201015) Der Mondkalender. Natrlich und gesund lumbar disc surgery. Acta Neurochir (Wien) 156:12051214
leben mit dem Mond. Holzer Druck und Medien Weiler im Allgu 22. Stienen MN, Smoll NR, Tessitore E, Schaller K, Hildebrandt G,
16. Schuld J, Slotta JE, Schuld S, Kollmar O, Schilling MK, Richter S Gautschi OP (2015) Surgical resident education in non-
(2011) Popular belief meets surgical reality: impact of lunar phases, instrumented lumbar spine surgery: a prospective observational
friday the 13th and zodiac signs on emergency operations and in- study with a 4.5-year follow-up. World Neurosurg 84:15891597
traoperative blood loss. World J Surg 35:19451949 23. Vorarlberger Schreib-Kalender (201015) Bregenzer Kalender fr
17. Smyrk J, Fekitoa R (1991) Effect of lunar phase on blood usage in a das Schaltjahr nach der gnadenreichen Geburt unseres Heilandes
Sydney hospital. Skeptic 11:1012 Jesu Christi. J.N. Teutsch Bregenz
18. St. Galler Bauernverband (201015) St. Galler Bauer. galledia ag
24. Wunder E, Schardtmller M (2002) Is there a lunar effect on peri-
Flawil
operative hemorrhage and other forms of surgical and perisurgical
19. Steinhauser O (201015) Steinhauers Kempter Kalender. Neuer
complications? Z Anomalistik 2:91108
Schreib-Kalender auf das Schaltjahr nach der gnadenreichen