You are on page 1of 16

DARTMOUTH BUSINESS JOURNAL

June 1, 2009 | Spring Issue

MAIN FEATURE:
The Life of a Consultant
AN INTERVIEW WITH JIM BRENNAN ’96, PARTNER
AT McKINSEY & COMPANY

1
DARTMOUTH BUSINESS JOURNAL June 1, 2009

Table of Contents
Jim Brennan, Life of a Consultant Jack Liu, Kunal Arya, Giulia Siccardo
An Interview with Jim Brennan, a ’96 Graduate of Dartmouth College and a partner at McKinsey &
Company.

Structured Finance Nicolas Santoni


An exploration of credit rating in the context of CDO's and other related securities, and how they will
impact the creation of new investment vehicles in the future.

Setting Business Strategy During Economic Crisis Kunal Arya


Should a CEO invest precious cash in productivity increases in this economic climate?

The Girl Effect Anoosha Reddy


Investing in the education of girls in developing nations will lead to stability at both the
microeconomic and macroeconomic levels.

Development Aid Roberto Marawanga


Development Aid will work to lower poverty rates by creating the vital incentive to invest in growing
economies.

The Zimbabwean Dollar: Dying to Live? Kedar Mulpuri


As hyperinflation plagues the Zimbabwean economy, the nation must turn to production.

TGV Trains: The Pride of France SangHee Chung


France's high-speed train is the pride of the nation; it's success depends on a unique business
model.

Drop in Oil Exploration a Dangerous Path to Pursue? David Kellenberger


Oil Shale and Tar Sand in the US and Canada are the oil reservoirs of the future, but only if the price
gets high enough.

14
6
12

2
DARTMOUTH BUSINESS JOURNAL June 1, 2009 presenting things in a clear and
Jim Brennan, compelling way.
Life of a So those skills are what
Consultant McKinsey’s looking for in
Interview by Jack Liu, Kunal Arya, and employees?
Giulia Siccardo
McKinsey’s definitely looking for those
The two career paths you almost always skills. They make up a big part of what
hear about at Dartmouth are we do.
investment banking and consulting. Yet,
few realize the diversity of specialties Are there any additional things you
within those two huge fields. In would advise Dartmouth students
particular, consulting spans a broad who are looking at consulting?
range of industries and topics. To get a
more detailed perspective on this field, No, I don’t think so. I think those skills
we contacted Jim Brennan ‘96, a are the biggest aspects.
partner at McKinsey & Company. We
found out immediately that a Can you tell us about your time at
consultant, especially a partner, has very Dartmouth? What did you study
little unscheduled time. Nevertheless, we here?
managed to steal a half hour of Jim’s
time as he was getting ready for a At Dartmouth, I studied government. It
dinner. was what I was interested in. I never took
and deliver more income back to the a math or business course at college or
On a day to day basis, what type of company. law school. So it’s kind of interesting
consulting do you do for from the perspective of what you decide
McKinsey? Are most of the projects that you study and what you end up doing. I mean
work with turnaround projects? they ended up being pretty different. I
I’m a partner at Mckinsey & Company. I How about startups? spent most of my time, as most people do
spend most of my time working on at Dartmouth, hanging out with my
strategy and go-to market issues with It’s not just turnaround. We also work friends and going to parties. From the
consumer package goods and retail with brands that are doing well and activity front, I was probably most
companies. continue to do well. Most of the work I involved with the Rockefeller Center. I
do though is for pretty big and spent a lot of time there helping the
What do you mean by go-to market established manufacturers and not administration of the center and also
issues? startup companies. working with some of the political
candidates that went on campus.
By go-to market, I mean I work with the When you are doing these types of
way that companies bring goods to the projects, what type of skills are the Do you think that put you at a
market and customers through retail. most important to your success? disadvantage compared to
students who focused on
Are there any projects you are I actually think the most important skill is economics or went to business
currently working on or recently the ability to work well with people and school instead of law school?
finished you can tell us about? build relationships with them. That could
be with the client or within McKinsey Not really. Obviously I had to figure out
I can’t give client names for itself. I have to be able to work with them excel before I started working. I never
confidentiality reasons, but typically I in a one-on-one way. The other skills are used it before that. But it really wasn’t a
work with large manufacturers of food, probably logical thinking and clear disadvantage. But I do think that’s worth
personal care products, snacks, or candy. communication. noting. The other skills I mentioned are
An example project that I would work on much more important that just being
would be working with a multinational How did you acquire those skills? able to punch numbers all the time.
food and personal care company to help Dartmouth? Law school? That’s my perspective.
them develop a turnaround strategy for
one of their products that has been losing I think it is sort of mixed. At Dartmouth, Would you say that networking
market share. So we come up with ways it was relating with people and with other Dartmouth graduates
to reposition their product and come up interacting with them. In law school, it has helped you?
with a gross strategy so that it can grow was a lot of logical thinking and

3
DARTMOUTH BUSINESS JOURNAL June 1, 2009 Not directly. I didn’t work with people in 2008 and yet had been advertised as a investing in these securities due to their
that went to Dartmouth. I do certainly AAA security less than a year before. score without fully revealing the naiveté
continue to have friends from Dartmouth and optimism of their models. Finally,
that I spend a lot of time with. I am The problem lies in the details of these the investors themselves should feel guilty,
actually married to a ’96 as well, so I’d seemingly safe products. CDO’s are since they aggressively bought relatively
say there is a good amount of Dartmouth securities backed by pools of loans, new and complex securities without
discussion that goes on at home. bonds, or mortgages and are often clearly understanding them.
referred to as a tranche, with each
After Dartmouth when you decided tranche having a different maturity or However, structured finance should not
to go to law school, were you risk associated with it. The different be completely cast-off in the future
thinking about practicing law? mortgages located in this pool were because of the drastic mistakes overly
supposedly uncorrelated, meaning that greedy individuals and corporations took.
I just went to law school because I there is a low likelihood that they will all Now that both the sell-side and the buy-
thought it was interesting, which it was. default. This allowed the underwriters of side of the market finally understand the
But once I got there, I decided I didn’t these securities to create senior, underlying characteristics of these
want to practice law. Most of the big law mezzanine, and junior tranches that were securities (after hundreds of billions of
firms I looked at weren’t doing things I supposedly very different. Senior dollars in losses and the almost collapse
thought were very interesting. securities with a .1% chance of default of the market), we might see the
could be attributed a AAA rating, while emergence of new and better products.
What led you to consulting? junior tranches with a 10% of default
were given a below investment grade
I thought it had a good mix of having score. The differences between these two
clients and personal interactions. It securities are that the junior tranche is
seemed a much more interesting context the first one to suffer if a mortgage from
for work. the pool defaults and that due to the
lack of correlation, it would be very
hard for several of the mortgages to
default and make the senior tranche
Structured vulnerable.

Finance: Unfortunately, as the credit agencies


One of the labeled thousands of securities with the
top score, the models that provided this
Underlying score failed to consider what would
Instruments behind happen in the case of national economic
distress. For example, a drop of 2% in
the Economic home prices would reduce many AAA Securities based on more realistic
Meltdown securities to BBB and an actual recession
and drastic drop in home prices would
markets that actually take into
consideration systemic risk and are
By Nicolas Santoni make even the most senior tranche of backed by assets that are actually
almost all these securities junk. This is uncorrelated could spring up in the
The tremendous growth of structured especially true, since the mortgages future and dominate once again the
finance products during the real estate backing up most of these securities had a markets as structured finance did in
bubble that ended in 2007 could be high percentage of being subprime. 2006. But, at the same time, after this
primarily attributed to the seemingly Thus, as subprime delinquencies rose disaster it might take some time before
endless advantages that it presented to while home prices dropped, these investors start once again to demand
both its underwriters in fees and to its securities labeled as almost default-free these products. In the long run, however,
investors in higher yields for AAA started defaulting in masses. financial innovation should not only
securities. However, the typical structured create products with higher short-term
finance product, the collateralized debt In pursuit of the easy profits created
profit margins, but that should also
obligation (CDO), cost the financial through securitization of subprime
reduce real risk and improve long-term
industry not only hundreds of billions of mortgages, due to their high demand and profits. It is a pity though, that history
dollars in write-downs, but it also underwriting fees, most investment banks
only verifies the first goal of financial
destroyed the reputation of investment and mortgage-related financial
innovation.
banks and rating agencies while companies almost brought the collapse of
effectively bringing down Lehman the financial industry. Meanwhile, the
Brothers and Bear Stearns. Therefore, credit agencies should feel humiliated for
investors and outsiders alike wander how incentivizing relatively risk-averse
such a product caused so much damage investors, such as pension funds, into

4
DARTMOUTH BUSINESS JOURNAL June 1, 2009 Along with consumer
Setting Business deleveraging, there is the trend
Strategy During of corporate deleveraging.
Obviously, the economy that
Economic Crisis emerges from this recession will
By Kunal Arya be one with significantly less
leverage in the system. This
The current recession and the arrangement will reward
financial crisis underlying it have companies that can innovate
caused severe problems for heavily improvements in productivity,
leveraged financial situations and and break into new markets
automobile manufacturers with rather than companies that are
substantial pension obligations. financially creative and require
Many of these companies have large amounts of leverage to
accepted government loans simply to make a reasonable return (Davis
stay liquid. However, the economic 2009). This means that anybody
recession also has had an effect on who invests in increasing their
companies with healthy finances. productivity (either by growing
These organizations face demand through acquisitions and
attrition, a tough credit market, and creating synergies or focusing on
a generally risk averse climate. innovation in new sectors) will
However, anyone with cash to spare come out in a stronger
currently has a wealth of competitive position. Since the
opportunities around them. For example, first is the expected increase in domestic price of these investments is currently
financially troubled competitors can be savings as consumers who had leveraged
low, executives should be seriously
acquired at a steep discount, as there are their lives – taking on debt and
considering beginning to take advantages
decreasing their savings rate, reverse that
no investment banks with deep pockets to of the opportunities that abound around
outbid, and the government has relaxed trend. Research from the McKinsey
them.
its enforcement of antitrust legislation in Global Institute shows that the
“economic impact of further US
the face of economic collapse. McKinsey’s recent models predict
Investments in marketing, human capital, consumer deleveraging will depend on
that “even scenarios assuming
and R&D are cheaper than ever (Dobbs income growth” (Atkins and Lund 2009).
Without income growth, every increase conservative levels of market
and Koller 2009). In other words, a
market downturn is the perfect time to in savings will be a direct cut to performance (as indicated by the
create long term value for a fairly stable consumption, with it; consumers can experience of past recessions) suggest
reduce their debt burden without major that many industries may be reaching
company. However, there are risks
inherent in such a strategy. Moving too cuts in spending. The ultimate key to
the point when acting sooner would
quickly, before the economy hits bottom, rising out of this recession is productivity
growth, which is closely linked to the be as appropriate as—if not better
could lead a relatively healthy company
aforementioned income growth. The than—acting later. Managers who
to exhaust the cash cushion it will need if
the downturn ends up being longer than lowest-hanging fruit lies in industries like wait may be failing to maximize the
health care and government, which, creation of value” (Dobbs and Koller
expected. Currently, these risks have
deterred companies with the ability and unlike manufacturing and retailing, have 2009). Of course, such a course of
opportunity to begin a string of not yet undergone productivity
revolutions. In other words, how bad this action should not be pursued
acquisitions or to commit to innovation
recession will be depends on the ability of recklessly; managers in every industry
in an emerging field from doing so. They
have instead chosen to wait out the industries to innovate and push for must take the time and resources to
recession, confidant that they will emerge productivity improvement, breakthroughs analyze the state of their business,
in a better position than their competitors and R&D and other such projects. If no their prospects for the future, and the
companies are willing to engage in these
and that they can then engage in these health of their company before they
same activities with reduced risk of endeavors due to the risk of spending
down the cash they need to weather the make their decision. But the current
illiquidity.
downturn, then it will be much more aversion to any and all risk is a
There are several factors that could slow severe than expected even by today’s function of the times, and may not be
recovery from this economic crisis. The pessimistic forecasts. justified for many companies,

5
DARTMOUTH BUSINESS JOURNALJune 1, 2009

The Girl Effect


By Anoosha Reddy

“Imagine a girl living in poverty. Let’s put her in a school uniform and see Member nations of the UN have recognized the importance of
her get a loan to buy a cow and use the profits from the milk to help her education and the impact that an educated populace can have
family. Pretty soon, her cow becomes a herd and she becomes the business on a country’s economic and political growth. A lack of
owner who brings clean water to the village, which makes the men respect education could lead to a vicious cycle of poverty and lifelong
her good sense and invite her to the village council where she convinces destitution.
everyone that all girls are valuable. Soon, more girls have a chance and the
village is thriving. Food. Peace. Lower HIV. Healthier Babies. Education. However, the year is now 2009, and there are still 104 million
Commerce. Sanitation. Stability. Which means the economy of the entire children between the ages of six and eleven who are not in
country improves and the whole world is better off. This is called the girl school. Forty percent of these out-of school children live in sub-
effect. Multiply that by 600 million girls in the developing world, and Saharan Africa, and 35% live in South Asia (UNESCO 2003).
you’ve just changed the course of history.” The UN places a special emphasis on educating women as
demonstrated by their third goal, which aims to eliminate
In recent months, this message has been rapidly circulating gender inequality and empower women. The situation is dire:
around the web via a short two-minute video designed by the 60 million of those 104 million children not in school are girls
Nike and NoVo Foundations. The concept is simple but the (Herz and Sperling 2004). In a 2004 Report on the State of the
ramifications of the “girl effect” are far-reaching and World’s Children, UNICEF “…identified 25 countries where
monumental. Invest in the potential of half the human race, ‘girl’s education’ will be treated as a case for urgent—even
and societies will be permanently altered. Empowering women emergency—action. Of the 25 countries chosen, ten have more
and giving them a chance to engage in society socially, than 1 million girls out of school” (Herz and Sperling 2004).
economically and politically will make the world a better place Young women are simply not receiving the education that they
in which to live. need and deserve.

The second of the eight United Nations Millennium Educating women creates economic stability at both the
Development Goals is to “ensure that, by 2015, children microeconomic level and the macroeconomic level. It has been
everywhere, boys and girls alike, will be able to complete a full proven that “an additional year of primary school boosts girl’s
course of primary schooling” (The United Nations 2008). eventual wages by 10-20% and an extra year of secondary

6
DARTMOUTH BUSINESS JOURNAL June 1, 2009
“Educating
women creates
economic
stability at both
the
microeconomic
level and the
macroeconomic
level.”

school by 15-25%” (Patrinos and spending which will then further twins and Beatrice’s family used the milk
Psacharopoulos 2002). This is significant stimulate the economy. With regard to from weaning the goat twins to feed their
not only in and of itself but rather poorer nations, education and malnourished children and sold the
because of what most females choose to development are self-reinforcing. If more surplus—the profits from the milk
do with these higher wages: “When women are educated, the country will eventually accumulated and Beatrice’s
women and girls earn income, they prosper, allowing for increased education, family could finally afford to provide her
reinvest 90% of it into their families, as which will further bolster the economy. with an education. Beatrice did so well in
compared to only 30-40% for a It’s a win-win situation. Returns to school that she eventually received
man” (Borges 13). This implies that a education for women are significantly multiple scholarships to attend a prep
household with a working woman will higher than they are for men. Investing in school in Massachusetts and went on to
probably benefit more than one with a educating girls is a surefire way to ensureattend Connecticut College.
working male (holding all other factors economic growth for any nation.
equal). Studies demonstrate that increases World-famous Economist Jeffrey Sachs,
in female income improve child survival The “Girl Effect” is very much real in inspired by Beatrice’s story, came up with
rates 20 times more than do increases in today’s world. In his article “The what he jokingly refers to as the “Beatrice
male income. Similarly, children’s weight- Luckiest Girl”, New York Times writer Theorem” of development economics,
height measures improve eight times Nicholas Kristof shows the girl effect in which says that small inputs can lead to
more (Stanford University). If a woman action. The girl that we are asked to large outcomes (Kristof 2008). Imagine if
is able to support and help her family, her “imagine” is given a name and identity— the other hundreds of millions of girls in
sense of empowerment will continue to that girl is Beatrice Biira, a young woman the developing world were given the same
grow. who just graduated last year with a opportunity as Beatrice. The future of
bachelor’s degree from Connecticut humanity would be altered. If a girl
According to the World Bank, female College. Beatrice was born in western succeeds, everyone around her will reap
education promotes per capita income Uganda to a family who could not afford the benefits of her success. Societies will
growth. “Increasing the share of women to put her in school. She was on her way boom and the world will change for the
with secondary education by 10% boosts to becoming another statistic, just better. Sometimes, the answers to the
annual per capita income growth by 3% another girl amidst the masses of African world’s biggest problems can be found in
on average” (Herz and Sperling 2004). If girls destined to a life of domestic the smallest of solutions. The answer to a
women are more educated, they can drudgery. Through Heifer International, better tomorrow lies in Beatrice and her
enter the workforce and contribute to the a non-profit aid group, a group of female counterparts around the world.
nation’s economic growth. Increased students in Connecticut donated money The answer is the Girl Effect.
income will also lead to an increase in to get a goat for Beatrice. The goat had

7
Development Aid
DARTMOUTH BUSINESS JOURNAL June 1, 2009

By Roberto Marawanga “The economic recession will


Make no mistake; most international development literature therefore lead to undermined
has made clear that developmental aid is rather ineffective. growth and decreased aid for the
There are many obstacles to development that can render
massive amounts of monetary aid ineffectual. International
world's poor.”
aid faces problems with governments that are not fully
committed to development goals, infrastructural problems
that prevent money from reaching the people who need it
most, and even issues when it comes to determining the best
way to combat poverty (2002). However, it has been shown
that appropriately allocated developmental aid can be
successful in bettering the lives of the bottom billion. For
example, within the healthcare sector, aid has helped to
increase life expectancy in developing countries over the last
four decades by 20 years (Goldin et al. 1). In addition, over
the past 30 years we have seen a 50% reduction in illiteracy
rates and an increase in quality education due in part to aid.
Furthermore, we have seen a decrease in the number of
people living on less than a dollar a day (Godlin et al, 2).
Lastly, a study showed that per capita economic growth was
higher in countries that received more aid than in the
countries that received less aid (Easterly 2003 24). This
growth provided an incentive for more investment into these
developing nations and lowered poverty rates as a result.

Therefore, international aid plays a role in the improvement


of quality of life in many regions all over the world.
Collectively, “the West,” has spent around $2.3 trillion dollars
on developmental aid in the last five decades (Easterly 2006 4)
The United States government alone spends around $22
billion dollars on foreign aid where about $10 billion dollars
more are contributed by private citizens. However, as donor
countries face economic turmoil in the global recession, there
will be a drop in aid because they will not be able to afford to members of that bottom billion have never really benefitted
give away the same percentage of their GDP that they did in from the aid in the first place.” So if the international
more prosperous times. It is speculated that official aid to development community wants to really help the third-world
developing countries might fall by around $20 billion dollars poor, they must provide safety nets to protect the poor in
this year due to the economic meltdown. Perhaps more developing nations during times of crisis, economic or
importantly commodity prices will fall during this economic otherwise, because they are the ones most hurt.
recession, and countries that depend on exporting will be hurt.
Since 1949, the United States has devoted itself to, in Truman's
Suzanne Freidberg, Assistant Professor of Geography at words, “aid the efforts of economically underdeveloped areas to
Dartmouth College, notes that historically, economic recessions develop their resources and improve their living
have negatively affected developing exporting countries, citing conditions” (Pronk et al., 2004). The International Monetary
the bankruptcy of Upper Volta (now Burkina Faso) during the Fund was founded upon these words, to be an institution that
Great Depression. The economic recession will therefore lead helped countries grow economically and reduce poverty around
to undermined growth and decreased aid for the world's poor. the world (IMF 2009). The IMF provides loans to countries on
Yet Freidberg warns not to take a simplistic view of this crises conditional terms, so that the countries can grow economically
by reminding us, “...falling commodity prices can be bad for under global guidance. The World Bank also provides loans,
countries that are dependent on exporting... cotton or copper credit and grants for developing countries to grow (World Bank
or whatever, but the extent of the price of the goods they need 2009). In the past however, their system of aid and loans have
falls as well, like [fuel]. That may balance it out.” She goes on hurt the developing world as much if not more than they have
to warn us about an over exaggeration of the affects of this helped it. Professor Freidberg notes that during the “economic
economic crisis on the third-world poor, because “many recession of the 1980's... the difficulties were compounded by

8
DARTMOUTH BUSINESS JOURNAL June 1, 2009 the structural adjustment policies that economy of developing nations, because that could lead to steady economic
were imposed by the World Bank and they are more dependent on world growth. That with the coupling of access
IMF.” And in the wake of this economic markets. So in this time of global to credit...
crisis, both NGOs are working to speed recession, a movement away from
the recovery, but their post-crisis actions supporting these kinds of businesses that An effective insurance model, but one
cannot necessarily save the world's poor are particularly sensitive to world markets that would be hard to institute, would be
from being unduly hurt by the global would not hurt. an insurance net that protected the
recession. Furthermore, considering the world's poor. Now, this kind of safety
relatively slow recovery process of A simple way to insure the world's would be impractical for the governments
developing countries from economic poorest from the problems that arise as a of developing regions to implement
shocks, post-recession measures will do result of economic turmoil is to make because it would not be cost effective for
little for the world's poor, whereas sure the programs implemented by the these generally inefficient governments to
protection against economic crises would international development community set up such a system. It would have to be
go a lot further in helping (Dercon 2003). provide as many different protections of implemented by the NGOs operating in
The world's poor need insurance against the poor as possible. In 2005, an the developing countries. Micro-
these global crises that start in the estimated one in six people raised insurance, that could protect the poor
developed world and trickle down. themselves above the $2-a-day poverty from economic shocks, environmental
line, yet due to this economic crisis an shocks etc. would be a feasible way to
Due to the economic crisis, world trade is estimated 65 million people will fall provide a safety net (and Roland
expected to drop by more than 13%, below that $2-a-day poverty line this year Bénabou 2006). The model would be a
which has detrimental affects to the alone (Economist 2009). Thus, it is slight variation from the micro-credit
developing world (Carstens 2009). That imperative that developmental programs programs that have already been
fact coupled with the decreased levels of provide their beneficiaries with as many implemented in developing regions all
aid will exponentially affect the poorest safeguards as possible. For example, the over the world (Dercon 2003). On micro-
countries due to magnification. The NGO KickStart that sells micro- insurance, Professor Freidberg states
global recession has hurt NGOs like irrigation technologies, such as pumps, to “think micro-insurance is something that
World Neighbors, a 60-year old poor farmers to increase their crop yield would be...I mean insurance in general,
international developmental organization offers a one-year replacement guarantee be useful, regardless of the state of the
that helps around 500,000 people a year. for their product (KickStart 2009). They global economy, because micro-insurance
The organization's budget has dropped also test every single one of their for small farmers for example. For a lot of
from $10 million, ten months ago, to $6 products before they sell them to the risk- small farmers the more perennial
million today (2009). This is a substantial averse farmers. If a product the farmers concern is the weather. And that’s
loss in aid available to give for buy fails them, then that could be the something that they need insurance for.”
development and will result in many difference between life and death. So it is It is easy to think that a fall in
programs for the world's poor being imperative that the international international development aid will have
undermined and scaled back. “If development communities try to shield cataclysmic effects on the third-world
international aid does fall dramatically, the poor from shocks like the economic poor, yet in reality the truth is that the
then certainly people who are dependent meltdown we are seeing today or more global poor have a history of survival.
on certain kinds of programs will be hurt direct shocks like those disasters due to They are people avoiding destitution, and
by it.” says Professor Freidberg. weather. the creation of the informal economy is a
testament to the sophisticated ways in
The question of how we can protect the In developing countries there are also which they have managed to survive.
world's poorest people from feeling the informal risk-sharing networks, through Professor Freidberg expresses this notion
magnified effects of this time of one’s family or tribe that protect people by saying that, “F, people [in third world
economic hardship and falling from crises. It would help to formalize countries] have been coping with crisis
international aid is one that has many these institutions and ideally create a kind for years.” So we should not fall prey to
answers. One answer is for the of collective insurance system for poor the dire predictions of extreme poverty in
international development community to communities so they could shield the third-world due to this economic
shift into promoting lower risk activities themselves from times when, the world crisis, because there always has been
that will make it harder for the economy is bad or when there is drought extreme poverty in these nations and the
developing area to be adversely affected (Dercon 2003). poor have always found ways of
by the economic recession (Derocon surviving. Instead of post-crises measures,
2003). However, a shift into low risk Another way the international the international development
activities also leads to lower returns on development community can protect the community should focus on protecting
investment. This is a problem, because poor is by teaching and encouraging the poor from crises in the future.
the rapid economic growth we all would saving techniques amongst them. If the Working to teach savings techniques,
like to see in the developing world cannot poorest people have savings, they will be offering micro-insurance, and putting in
come from low-risk activities. According able to survive even in times of crisis. place safeguards for development
to Professor Freidberg, economic They will have insurance to continue programs will all help the bottom billion
recessions heavily affect the formal their lives and invest in low risk activities immensely during times of crisis.
9
DARTMOUTH BUSINESS JOURNAL June 1, 2009
The Zimbabwean Dollar:
Dying to Live?
By Kedar Mulpuri

Since the dawn of the 21st century, the


hyperinflationary measures of the
Zimbabwean dollar (ZWD) have
plagued the economics progress of the
nation.

When Rhodesia gained sovereignty from


Britain on April 18, 1980, the former
colony became known as Zimbabwe and
proceeded to replace the Rhodesian
dollar with the ZWD (Central
Intelligence Agency n.d.). At its peak,
the ZWD was once worth 1.59 United
States dollars (USD) but experienced agricultural productivity and the ZWD. 2004, the rate of inflation was 624%
sharp declines after land reforms in the In order to compensate the lack of food (Crisis Times). In a desperate attempt to
early 1990s contributed to the currency’s production and revenues, the fix the currency value, the Zimbabwean
hyperinflation, causing it to become Zimbabwean government continued to government revalued the currency from
extremely devalued (Rukuni 2001). These print money (Greenspan 2007, 339). 1000 ZWDs to 1 ZWD. This was highly
land reforms that arose under President unsuccessful in stopping the monstrous
Robert Mugabe’s policies caused According to Former Zimbabwean inflation, however, as the ZWD
inexperienced black farmers to gain land Foreign Affairs Minister Jafari Banda, continued in the established pattern of
from more experienced white farmers, estranged from the Zimbabwean hyperinflation, reaching 1,730% in 2006.
resulting in plunging of Zimbabwean government after a failed assassination Dr. Gideon Gono, the governor of the
attempt on Mugabe, “What Reserve Bank of Zimbabwe, announced
happened in Zimbabwe is the currency had to be printed in order
that production stopped. to buy foreign currency to pay overdue
An endless cycle of payments to the International Monetary
corruption brought a cease Fund (Seria and Mutizwa 2007). In
in production. We were not addition, currency had to be printed to
producing anything. The account for the rise in salaries for civil
corruption led to a servants, including soldiers and
disruption in the industrial policemen (Chikwanda 2008).
and agricultural
infrastructure, which are The Zimbabwean government could
the backbone of the barely print enough currency to match
economic sector. We the hyperinflation, so it requested citizens
weren't producing, we to add 0 digits at the end of existing
weren't mining, no industry, currencies’ value. On the day of
no commerce, no farming.” introduction of the 100 billion dollar bill
(~1 USD) in July 2008, the amount was
With these land reforms able to purchase a measly three eggs at
continuing well into the 21st the average local market (BBC News
century, the country 2008). In its latest figure, Zimbabwe had
experienced spiraling reached inflation rates of almost 516
hyperinflationary rates. By quintillion percent with a monthly rate of

10
DARTMOUTH BUSINESS JOURNAL June 1, 2009 79.6 billion percent or a daily rate of currency that has low inflation and high Professor Feyrer also notes, “If
98% (Berger 2008). The greatest cause of international credibility. The US actually Zimbabwe intends to reintroduce a
this new surge in hyperinflation is the benefits because there is seigniorage on domestic currency the only way to regain
ongoing cholera outbreak that decimated the dollars being used in Zimbabwe. the public trust is to credibly promise to
the country starting August 2008, This amount to a very small amount make the new currency stable. One way
resulting in even greater food shortages since the Zimbabwe economy is so small to do this is to peg the currency to a
(Shaw 2008). This correlated to a relative the US economy.” stable currency or have a currency board
doubling of prices almost every 24.7 where there is 1:1 backing of the new
hours, akin to the hyperinflation of post About the effect of dollarization on the currency with the dollar or other stable
Second World War Hungary (Hanke economies of countries involved, Banda currency. Pegs can be broken, however,
2009). The ZWD reached such inflated had to say, “It leads to distortions because and it may take time to regain the trust of
rates that 100 trillion dollar bills the price of commodities is regulated by the public.”
eventually came into production in supply and demand, which varies from
January 2009 (BBC News 2009). These country to country. The effect is perhaps About the dynamics of the economy,
bills themselves could hardly purchase negligible depending on the size of the Banda had to say, “Zimbabwe needs to
any goods in the market. ‘parasite’ economy and commerce. The restart production. Get the industries
intent behind dollarization is to generate running and farm the lands you seized.
By this point, Zimbabwean traders foreign currency in order to participate in All will be futile unless there is a
completely abandoned the ZWD, foreign trade. But if it is the ZAR, the use conducive political atmosphere in order
adopting the more stable US dollar or of it Zimbabwe would greatly negate its to encourage foreign investors to invest
South African rand (ZAR) instead. The strength and stability. In comparison, the and operate businesses that would restart
Zimbabwean government legalized the Zimbabwe Reserve Bank at peak would commerce, industry, and farming.”
use of these new bills in February 2009, hold 5 million USD to support the entire
while it tried to revalue the currency economy whereas 5 million USD isn’t The currency issue brings up many
(BBC News 2009). The government was even operational for a Bank of America important consequences for the future of
able to bring the value of its currency to branch. Zimbabwe. Now that Zimbabweans
more manageable face value, reducing removed the ZWD from use in their daily
the once $1,000,000,000,000 bill to $1 in For a while, Mugabe and his Zimbabwe lives, how will it affect the stability of the
February 2009 (Reuters 2009). The new African Nation Union – Patriotic Front Zimbabwean economy? How will
currency was almost completely (ZANU-PF) denied their policies as the international trade operate under this
irrelevant as most of the citizens in major cause of Zimbabwean new system of dollarization? With the
Zimbabwe refused to use it. The hyperinflation, blaming international new combined party coalition ruling, will
government officially ceased production sanctions by the US, EU and Australia Zimbabwe be able to surmount the
of the ZWD in April 2009 and does not on politicians and businessmen loyal to overwhelming economic pressures? Will
plan on reintroducing it again until 2010 the Zimbabwean government (Ababa the ZWD ever gain the trust of the
(Seria 2009). 2009). However, with opposition running people and come back into popular use?
high, Mugabe’s administration While economists are still gathering data
According to Economics Professor James apologized numerous times and on these economic implications, we can
Feyrer at Dartmouth College, “My attempted to fix the crisis. Mugabe all hope that in the meantime Zimbabwe
understanding is that the dollar (and eventually succumbed to popular will be able to forge a new future.
other "hard" currencies like the Euro) demands for him to share power with
were acting as defacto currencies long opposition party leader Morgan
before they finally abandoned the Tsvangirai of the Movement for
Zimbabwean dollar. If you were Democratic Change – Tsvangirai (MDC-
exporting to Zimbabwe you had no T) party. Tsvangirai was officially sworn
interest in taking the Zimbabwean dollar in as Prime Minister on February 11,
as payment. The dollarization formalizes 2009 (GlobalPost 2009).
this and should increase the volume of
trade. For Zimbabwe they get to use a

11
DARTMOUTH BUSINESS JOURNAL June 1st, 2009

TGV Trains: The Pride of France


By SangHee Chung

The French pride themselves on many things – as


much as they relish in fine wine and culture, they
“There is no question about the
carry enormous pride over their transportation success of the TGV. It’s a
systems. The TGV (Train à Grande Vitesse) is a technological success and a
high-speed rail service connecting over 200 cities in commercial one.”
France and several neighboring countries. With the
world record for the fastest train and with tickets Brigitte Mosenthal, Dartmouth College French
Professor
starting from 17 Euros (under $23), the TGV is an
attractive alternative to airline travel. Their website Guillaume Pepy, chairman of SNCF, the French
impressively utilizes an eco-comparer, which allows National Railway, hopes to establish TGV as a
passengers to compare ticket prices and carbon household brand for the middle class. In an
dioxide emissions of trains and low-cost airlines. interview with The Spectator, he states, “It’s a
customer good. Think of it: [Dannon], Pepsi, Nike,
According to Dartmouth College French professor TGV… Students might buy a DVD, download more
Brigitte Mosenthal, “There is no question about the music or buy a ticket for the train. I want to see
success of the TGV. It’s a technological success and TGV tickets in bubble packs in supermarkets, so
a commercial one.” Although there are many people can buy themselves little treats.” (Collins 3)
competitors in France’s transportation industry, the After Mr. Pepy took charge in 1997, the high-speed
TGV stands out because of its dynamic marketing railway began to see profits, due to its management
and constant stream of new ideas that attempts to and marketing. It uses a low-cost airline-pricing
appeal to a wider variety of consumer groups. In model, in which prices rise closer to the date of
addition, the TGV is expanding its boundaries – in departure. In 2008, ridership within France reached
2007, a new line was added in eastern France, 98 million, a 9.1 percent increase from 2007 and
connecting over 20 cities and 37 million more occupancy was over 80 percent.
people. The line is not only a success for TGV, but
for the cities’ inhabitants as well by changing how Constant innovations since its conception have also
(and where) business is conducted. made the TGV a fierce competitor among high-

12
DARTMOUTH BUSINESS JOURNAL June 1, 2009

speed railway services. The first double-decker train actually becomes a feasible idea. According to
was built in 1995 and is still in production. The Mosenthal, “one can have a great quality of life but
trains carry 50 percent more passengers, allowing can still compete with larger companies.”
TGV to achieve economies of scale. Less than three
years ago, SNCF launched iDTGV, which offers Nancy, in fact, prides itself on the investment
passengers several options between iDzen, a more opportunities it has to offer. With over 10,000 m2 of
relaxing atmosphere which offers sleeping kits, and immediately available office space, it has become
iDzap, which provides a barista, books and Portable one of the largest markets for office space.
PlayStations (PSPs) for hire. The iDNiGHT According to Nancy’s Development and Urban
concept, which targets travelers aged from 18 to 30, Planning Agency, Nancy has over 1,800 new
has a bar coach with DJ entertainment and a businesses created every year and over 24 million
separate lounge space for card games and DVD consumers within a 200-mile radius. The addition
rentals. According to Mosenthal, “[The TGV] has of the train line also makes connections to London
been amazingly aggressive with their and Brussels possible.
advertisements, and it’s worked. The train has been
used by every branch of the population, yet there is The LGV Est européenne is still currently under
a certain prestige. Politicians use them all the time – construction and plans to connect several cities in
they’re even willing to be interviewed on the train.” Germany and Switzerland (for a total of over 300
km of tracks planned) and it is unlikely that projects
In 2007, TGV launched the LGV Est européenne, would stop there. Although the United States has
connecting Paris and major eastern cities in France, yet to create a major high-speed train service across
including Strasbourg, Nancy, and Metz. The the country, there may still be hope in the coming
addition has significantly cut travel time – a car ride years. As President Obama stated, “What we need,
to Nancy, for instance, which would take four hours then, is a smart transportation system equal to the
from Paris, is now only 90 minutes away. An needs of the 21st century, a system that reduces
accessible train line essential brings the capital travel times and increases mobility, a system that
closer to the city’s inhabitants, and Mosenthal reduces congestion and boosts productivity, a system
describes this as the “decentralization of business,” that reduces destructive emissions and creates
where establishing business in cities such as Nancy jobs.” (Knowlton 16)
13
DARTMOUTH BUSINESS JOURNAL June 1, 2009
“Lowering long term investment in
exploration as well as
reinvestment in current fields will
lead to an even worse situation
when oil prices correct with the
global economic recovery.”

Drop in Oil Exploration a Dangerous Path to


Pursue?
By David Kellenberger

On February 16, 2009 Christophe de Margerie, the Chief contemporary peak price (Energy Prices). While prices around
Executive of Total, a French oil corporation, said that, $50 a barrel are advantageous for economic recovery, this glut
“National oil companies, which control the vast majority of the of supply effectively reduces the amount of exploration done
world's oil, and independent producers, which play a key role in by independent producers and integrated oil corporations.
finding new sources, were substantially limited in their ability to
fund investments in the current [financial] Marcel Coutu, President and CEO of Canadian Oil Sands
environment” (Hoyos). What de Margerie is speaking of is the Trust, the largest single shareholder in the Canadian tar sands
fact that a current lack of oil demand has brought about Syncrude project, “…[anticipates] natural production declines
decreased investment in exploration. At the moment, the price due to lower industry reinvestment in producing fields and
of oil is hovering around $50 a barrel, one-third of its production cuts by OPEC nations” (Harrison). It is this “lower

14
DARTMOUTH BUSINESS JOURNAL June 1, 2009 industry reinvestment” that will
lead to problems in the coming
years (Harrison). Western oil
reserves and production will
once again become strapped
upon economic recovery, and
the last thing that we need to
see is less investment in
producing fields.

If almost all longer-term future


projections predict decreasing
oil supply and rising demand
from developing countries like
India and China, then why is
investment being reduced? One
would think that investment in
exploration and reinvestment in
currently active fields would be
increasing. However, this is not
the case. Robert M. Grant, in
his book, Strategic Planning in a same models in turn would fuel problems in the future industry.
Turbulent Environment: Evidence from the Oil Majors, touches upon For example, the high levels of petroleum production pushed
on how major oil corporations strategize in the market place. oil prices down to the $10-$20 level, a level that had not been
He notes that for the major oil corporations (Exxon Mobil, seen since the 1973 oil shock. This price drop sent profits
Chevron, Shell, etc.), “…the planning systems of the 1970s and plummeting across the board. The popular response to this
1980s were highly formalized” (Grant). However, “By dilemma was to develop much shorter-term strategies so they
1996-1997, planning systems were far more informal: there was would not be left vulnerable to these nearer term price swings
less emphasis on like the one in the 1990s. However, while these strategies help
written shelter the corporations from short- term losses, they do this by
documentation, lowering long term investment. Lowering long term investment
strategic plans in exploration as well as reinvestment in current fields will lead
were to an even worse situation when oil prices correct with the
shorter” (Grant). global economic recovery. Forecasts on future supply are
Ever since the oil already harsh enough, and the added impact of fewer new
industry slump of findings and less expenditures on new equipment will only
the early 1990s increase the pain.
due to very high
levels of supply, While oil corporations’ responses to short term conditions with
they have followed long-term courses of action protects them from overproduction
shorter strategic plans and a loss of profit, it lowers future oil supply. This is inherent
(Grant). Thus to how these companies operate. The solution to this problem
they reduce would seem to be increased investment in clean alternative
investment, as oil energy research and also in untapped, non-traditional sources
demand in the near of energy, such as the Canadian Tar Sands. This investment in
future is not predicted to rise. future energy supplies will offset the decreased investment by
integrated and independent oil corporations. It will also aid in
Even though the longer term, formalized models earlier used the process of finding a clean alternative to crude oil, and in
by oil corporations led to high production in the 1990s, these longer run reduce our carbon emissions.

15
Current Officers Contributors Content Editors
President: Rubin Srimal Business: Bryon Alston
Treasurer: Tony Deng Kunal Arya Ryan McClafferty
Secretary: Alexander Villar Mike Katz Sisi Yao
Head of Business Section: Kunal Arya Dave Kellenberger Mike Novosel
Kihyun Kim
Head of International Section: Giulia Siccardo Nathaniel Kanefield
Ray Leoni
Head of Investment Section: Kareem Halim Irfan Mulic
Head of Interviews: Tony Deng Youngsoo Park
Head Content Editor: Bryon Alston Blair Randall
Layout Editors: Anoosha Reddy & Ellena Kim Rubin Srimal
Website Development: Jack Liu Alexander Villar

International:
Giulia Siccardo
SangHee Chung
Michael C. Joseph
Alex Lucey
Roberto Marwanga
Kedar Mulpuri
Anoosha Reddy
Long Sha
John Spradling
Valentin Yanev

Investments:
Kareem Halim
John W. Spradling
Nicolas Santoni
Works
William Cited
Mergner
David Rogg

Central Intelligence Agency. "The World Factbook - Zimbabwe." https://www.cia.gov/library/


Setting Business Strategy During Economic Crisis publications/the-world-factbook/geos/zi.html (accessed May 17, 2009).
Dobbs, Richard and Tim Koller. “The Crisis: Timing Strategic Moves.” The McKinsey Quarterly. Chikwanda, Kuda. "Zimbabwe: Inflation Shocker - 1 700 000 Percent." Zimbabwe Independent, May
(April 2009), http://www.mckinseyquarterly.com/The_crisis_Timing_strategic_moves_2347 26, 2008.
Davis, Ian. “The New Normal.” The McKinsey Quarterly. (March 2009), Crisis Times. "Hyperinflation - Effects and How to Survive It." Crisis Times. http://crisistimes.com/
http://www.mckinseyquarterly.com/The_new_normal_2326 hyperinflation.htm (accessed May 17, 2009).
Atkins, Charles and Susan Lund. “The Economic Impact of Increased US Savings.” The McKinsey GlobalPost. "Tsvangirai sworn in as Zimbabwe's new prime minister." GlobalPost, February 11, 2009.
Quarterly. (March 2009), Greenspan, Alan. The Age of Turbulence: Adventures in a New World. New York: Penguin Press,
http://www.mckinseyquarterly.com/The_economic_impact_of_increased_US_savings_2327 2007.
Structured Finance Hanke, Steve H. "R.I.P. Zimbabwe Dollar." Cato Institute, February 9, 2009.
Reuters. "Zimbabwe revalues currency again." Reuters, February 2, 2009.
Coval, Joshua, Jakub Jurek, and Erik Stafford. “The Economics of Structured Finance.”
Unpublished essay, 2008. Harvard Business School, Boston. Rukuni, Charles. "Zimbabwe: Hell for Locals, Paradise for Those With Forex." The Insider (Harare),
July 31, 2001.
The Girl Effect Seria, Nasreen. "Zimbabwean Dollar Won’t Be Reintroduced for a Year." Bloomberg, April 20, 2009.
Borges, Phil. 2007. Women Empowered: Inspiring Change in the Emerging World. New York: Seria, Nasreen and Godfrey Mutizwa. "Zimbabwe Devalues Currency by 98% to Boost Exports."
Universe. Bloomberg, April 26, 2007.
Herz, Barbara, Gene B. Sperling, and Council on Foreign Relations. 2004. What Works in Girls' Shaw, Angus. "Zimbabwe calls for help as cholera overwhelms doctors." The Independent, December
Education: Evidence and Policies from the Developing World. 4, 2008.
Kristof, Nicholas D. 3 July 2008. The Luckiest Girl. New York Times. 3 July 2008. http://
www.nytimes.com/2008/07/03/opinion/03kristof.html?ex=1372737600&en TGV
=17eefa72e2388b12&ei=5124&partner=permalink&exprod=permalink>. Collins, Neil. “French trains: faster, cheaper, greener, sexier.” The Spectator. 7 April 2007: 28-29.
Patrinos, Harry Anthony and George Psacharopoulos. 2002. Returns to Investment in Education: A Faithfull, Marl. “Rapid trains of thought.” Business Travel World. May 2007: 18-19.
Further Update. Policy Research Working Paper Series 2881, The World Bank. Knowlton, Brian. “Obama Seeks High-Speed Rail System Across U.S.” The New York Times. 17
Stanford University. Economic Barriers to Education in Kenya. http://www.stanford.edu/ April 2009: 16.
group/womenscourage/GirlsEducation/kersten_economic_barriers.html. Promoting business and economic development in Greater Nancy. 2009. Urban Community of
The United Nations. The Millennium Development Goals Report. http://www.un.org/ Greater Nancy. 30 April 2009 < http://www.eco-grandnancy.com/anglais/index.php4>.
millenniumgoals/pdf/The%20Millennium%20Development%20Goals%20Report%202008.pdf (accessed “SNCF Eco-Comparer.” SNCF.18 May 2009. 30 April 2009
April 17, 2009). < http://www.sncf.com/en_EN/html/page/CH0006-Ecomobility/BR0530-SNCF-Eco-
UNESCO. 2003. Education for All Global Monitoring Report 2003/4.http://portal.unesco.org/ comparer.html>
education/en/ev.php-URL_ID=23023&URL_DO=DO_TOPIC&URL_SECTION=201.html. “TGV Train” RailEurope. 2009. 22 April 2009 < http://www.raileurope.com/train-faq/european-
trains/tgv/index.html>
Development Aid Wells, Paul. “Now Even the French Go Faster Than Us.” Maclean’s. 7 Sept. 2007: 12.
"About the IMF." International Monetary Fund. 1 May 2009 <www.imf.org>
"About Us." The World Bank. 1 May 2009 <>. Drop in Oil Exploration a Dangerous Path
"The global crisis and the poor: The Toxins Trickle Downward." The Economist: International 12 Mar. Hoyos, Carola. "Total says oil output is near its peak." Financial Times (2009): 22.
2009. Grant, Robert M.. Strategic Planning in a Turbulent Environment: Evidence from the Oil Majors .
"What We Do." KickStart. 1 May 2009 <http://www.kickstart.org/> Strategic Management Journal. 24, John Wiley & Sons, 2003.
Dercon, Stefan. "Insurance Against Poverty." United Nations University: World Institute for "Energy Prices." Bloomberg. 2009. <http://www.bloomberg.com/markets/commodities/
Development Economics Research (2003). energyprices.html> (accessed May 5, 2009).
Easterly, William Russell. White man's burden why the West's efforts to aid the rest have done so Harrison, Lynda. "Canadian Oil Sands' Profit Takes Deep Dive." The Daily Oil Bulletin. Nickle’s
much ill and so little good. New York: Penguin P, 2006. Energy Group. May 1, 2009. (accessed May 5, 2009).
Freidberg, Susanne. "On International Development and the Economic Crisis." Personal interview. 6
May 2009.
Picture Credits
http://3quarksdaily.blogs.com/3quarksdaily/2007/01/below_the_fold_.html
Hwang, Inyoung. "Foreign aid suffers as financial crisis persists." Medill Reports Washington 14 Apr. http://www.moroccansands.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2008/11/tgv-maroc.jpg
2009. http://www.tianjinenergy.com/images/oilandgas/asaramatoru_field_2.jpg
Kosack. "Effective Aid: How Democracy Allows Development Aid to Improve the Quality of Life." http://gaietyschoolofacting.files.wordpress.com/2009/04/recession-2.jpg
World Development 31 (2003): 1-22. http://practicalaction.org/images/IMG_0091.jpg
Mookherjee, Dilip, and Roland Bénabou. Understanding poverty. US: Oxford UP, 2006. http://stan.uio.no/blog/flexlearn/images/zimbabwe_money.jpg
Pronk, Jan, James K. Boyce, John Degnbol-Martinussen, A. Geske Dijkstra, Gustaf Edgren, Louis http://transracial.files.wordpress.com/2009/04/zimbabwe-cash-inflation1.jpg
Emmerij, Wil Hout, Santosh Mehrotra, James Petras, Singh, Ajit, Henry Veltmeyer, Morag Bell, and http://www.flickr.com/photos/telstar/2982768959/sizes/m/
Hanlon, Joseph. Catalysing Development? A Debate on Aid (Development & Change Special Issues). http://www.flickr.com/photos/cicciopizzettaro/56566449/sizes/o/
Grand Rapids: Blackwell Limited, 2004. http://www.flickr.com/photos/financialaidpodcast/2851531354/sizes/m/
Singer, Peter. "Charity in Hard Times." International Business Times 21 Mar. 2009. http://www.flickr.com/photos/identity-chris-is/34782525/
The Zimbabwean Dollar: Dying to Live?
Ababa, Addis. "Mugabe: Western Sanctions to Blame for Zim Crisis." Mail & Guardian, February 3,
2009.
BBC News. "Zimbabwe Abandons Its Currency." BBC News, January 29, 2009.
BBC News. "Zimbabwe Introduces Z$100bn Note." BBC News, July 19, 2008.
BBC News. "Zimbabwe Rolls Out Z$100tr Note." BBC News, January 16, 2009.
Berger, Sebastien. "Zimbabwe hyperinflation 'will set world record within six weeks." Telegraph,
November 13, 2008.

You might also like