Professional Documents
Culture Documents
RUSSIA
CITATION LATITUDE
Our InStructOrS
instructors Wide
range of experience
Skilled Maintenance
Aviation professionals from around the world trust us to provide the highest quality training and outstanding service. Reducing workload, one the many perks of SBAS. SBAS-FMS Family LP/LPV Monitor, UNS-1Lw, -1Fw and -1Ew
More than 1,800 highly experienced professional instructors deliver aircraft- and mission-specific courses, using our
comprehensive training systems and advanced-technology flight simulators designed to enhance safety. Trust your
Visit uasc.com to learn more.
training to FlightSafety. Youll see why so many aviation professionals make the same choice. And have since 1951.
For information, please contact Steve Gross, Vice President, Sales 314.785.7815
sales@flightsafety.com flightsafety.com A Berkshire Hathaway company uasc.com sales@uasc.com (800) 321-5253 (520) 295-2300
Upfront
From the Editor
"A brand for a company is like a reputation for a person. You earn reputation by trying to do hard
things well."
Jeff Bezos
Mark Huber SEPTEMBER - OCTOBER - 2015
Helicopter Editor Volume XXVII - No 4
Bernard Fitzsimons
BART No 158
MRO Editor WWW.BARTINTL.COM
PREMIER TRANSATLANTIC
BUSINESS AVIATION MAGAZINE Kirby J. Harrison
New-York Editor
CONTRIBUTING EDITORS
Fernand M. Francois
Fabio Gamba, Nick Klenske,
Louis Smyth, Giulia Mauri, SECTIONS
Derek A. Bloom,
Editor and Publisher 3
Guy Visel, Aoife O'Sullivan
Kathy Ann Francois EDITORIAL
Associate Publisher PRODUCTION
Tanguy Francois 6
Paul Walsh Production Manager POINTER
Managing Editor
ADVERTISING 8
Marc Grangier
Kathy Ann Francois FAST TRACK
Senior Editor
Advertising Director
Captain LeRoy Cook, kafrancois@bartintl.com 22
Michal Grninger TRANSATLANTIC UPDATE
Safety Editors MARKETING
Titi Kusumandari
Steve Nichols Marketing Manager 28
Avionics Editor tkusumandari@bartintl.com BUSINESS NEWS
CONTENTS
30 62
RESILIENCE IN RUSSIA
This years Jet Expo promises to showcase the WEATHER RADAR
resilience of the Russian market. The latest developments in weather radar can and
do save lives as Steve Nichols reports.
44 66
ROTOR REPORT
Mark Huber reports on the latest trends among PILOT DISCIPLINE
Russian rotorcraft buyers. Self discipline is the key to safe flying says LeRoy
Cook in his latest installment from the cockpit.
52 70
FLIGHT TRAINING
Flight Simulators have improved dramatically MAINTENANCE MATTERS
in recent years. Kirby Harrison reports Theres now a range of technology on offer for
on the latest technology. engine noise reduction. Bernard Fitzsimons looks
at the main players.
58 80
ECONOMIZING ENGINES
More power with less fuel: thats the key to a A NEW REGISTRY
successful engine to todays environment. Read our We visit Shannon, Ireland to learn about an exciting
special report on engines to find out more. new registry thats tailor made for business jets.
OUR ADVERTISERS AND THEIR AGENCIES
19 Avfuel Corporation
27 Concorde Battery Corporation
9 CAE
13 Dassault Falcon (PUCK L'AGENCE)
Member 23 Duncan Aviation
69 EBACE 2016
2 FlightSafety International (GRETEMAN GROUP)
17 Garmin
51 GCS Safety Solution
41 Geneva Airpark SA
7 Gulfstream Aerospace Corporation
71 Hubbard Aviation Technologies
15 Jet Aviation
79 JetNetLLC
39 Jet Expo 2015
57 Jet Support Services Inc (JSSI)
25 NBAA 2015
43 Rockwell Collins ARINCDirect
11 Rolls-Royce
73 Textron Aviation Customer Support (Sullivan Higdon & Sink)
84 Textron Aviation Jet Sales (Sullivan Higdon & Sink)
83 Universal Avionics Systems, Corp.
37 Universal Weather and Aviation, Inc
29 West Star Aviation Inc.
BART International Business Aviation Real Tool, Premier Transatlantic Business Aviation Magazine. ISSN 0776-7596. Printed in
Belgium and published by-monthly by Socit Anonyme Frankie&Lette 20 rue de lIndustrie at BE1400 Nivelles, Belgium.
Phone +326 788 3603; Fax +326 788 3623. Email info@bartintl.com. With offices in Texas and Arizona, BART International is
governed by the International copyright laws. Single copy USD12.00 our EUR12.00.
Annual Professional Subscription available at USD10.00 or EUR10,00.
Administration and Circulation Titi Kusumandari
Email: tkusumandari@bartintl.com
International Distribution ASENDIA. USPS 016707
Periodical postage paid. For details call IMS at 1 (800) 428 3003
Belgian Posting Office: BE1380 Lasne
Office Manager Paul Walsh
Responsible Publisher Fernand M. Francois
POINTER IN SEQUENCE
BRIEFING ROOM
Events North Atlantic Ops
Trial Implementation of Reduced
Lateral Separation Minimum
Evolution in aircraft avionics and air traffic flight data processing has driven an
initiative to reduce current lateral separation minima over the North Atlantic.
General Aviation (GA) operators have the opportunity to participate in a
Reduced Lateral Separation Minimum (RLatSM) trial program going into effect
November 12, 2015, on the North Atlantic Tracks (NATs). The goal is to
increase capacity on optimal flight routings over the North Atlantic. Long-term
Agenda
benefits include the potential to greatly expand the number of available NATs
and boost capacity on preferred routings/optimal Flight Levels (FLs).
Proposed changes
Lateral separation on the NATs is currently one degree, or 60 Nautical Miles
(NM). The RLatSM trial program reduces separation to half a degree. The ini-
tial phase of this was the Controller Pilot Data Link Communications reuire-
ments that were implemented earlier within the NATs. On CPDLC-designated
routes, specific onboard equipment is necessary in order to operate between
Jet Expo FL 360 and 390 on certain airways. Today, its still possible to operate outside
Sep 10-12 FL 360-390 CPDLC airways if an operator is not CPDLC-equipped. But, even-
Moscow, Russia tually, its anticipated that all operators may need to be CPDLC-equipped to fly
airways at all FLs within the NATs.
Participation in the trial
Operators do not need to apply to participate in Phase 1 of the RLatSM trial.
During the time theyre cleared for NAT operations, they may be offered rout-
ings with reduced lateral separation, based on PBN equipment listed in sec-
NBAA Convention tion 18 of their ICAO flight plans. Be mindful that flight communications, navi-
November 17-19 gation, and surveillance (CNS) systems must remain operational during flight
Las Vegas, USA and crew are required to report any failure or malfunction of GPS, ADS-C, or
CPDLC to ATC. To participate in Phase 1 of the trial, operators will be using
different equipment including CPDLC and FANs 1/A. When theres an issue
with this onboard reporting technology, operators must be ready and prepared
to go back to voice communications.
If you have any questions about this article or would like assistance with
Scheduler & Dispatcher Conference any flight planning needs, contact Mark Miller markmiller@univ-wea.com
Jan 19-22 - 2016 at Universal Weather & Aviation Inc.
Tampa Fl, USA
OU
For 13 consecutive years, aircraft owners have voted Gulfstream number one in
product support. It is an achievement that inspires our steadfast commitment
ANYTIME. ANYWHERE. and, more importantly, your confidence. When it comes to service experience,
Consider it Done choose the best. Gulfstream Product Support: Consider It Done.
To learn more, visit gulfstream.com/network.
To contact a Gulfstream representative in your area, for either sales or service, visit gulfstream.com/contacts.
Gulfstream was recently voted number one in Aviation International News annual product support survey for the 13th consecutive year.
JET AVIATION ST. LOUIS LANDS THREE EMBRAER LINEAGES
Jet Aviation St. Louis is performing maintenance on three
Embraer Lineage business jets at the same time a first for
the aviation service center. All three Lineages are based in
North America, but represent different owners.
The arrival of the three narrow-body jets Embraers largest
business jet for maintenance over the last week marks the
first time Jet Aviation St. Louis has had three in its facility.
Jet Aviation St. Louis is the first and only Independent
Service Center for Lineages in North America, said Sales
Director Aaron Kreissler. We received the designation from
Embraer in 2013 and have performed a variety of inspections
and maintenance services on Lineages since then. Were
proud to have three Lineages here at the same time. It
demonstrates the depth of our capabilities on narrow-body
business jets.
TrainWithCAE.com
CorporateCare-
a global liquid asset
Now you have two choices for superior, ultra-long-range capability. The 5,950 nm Falcon 7Xthe fastest selling Falcon ever (and with
good reason). Or the new, 6,450 nm Falcon 8X, destined to become a favorite of world travelers. Both have the awe-inspiring ability
to fly long distances from short and challenging runways such as Aspen and London City. The 8X is more than three feet longer, with
over 30 cabin layouts. Fly far. Fly in comfort. Achieve more.
With the Garmin G950/G1000 integrated flight deck upgrade, youll breathe new life into your Beech 1900D,
Twin Commander, Twin Otter, Piper Meridian, Metroliner or Cessna 501 and 525. Besides solving avionics
obsolescence issues and improving your dispatch reliability, youll ensure your aircraft is equipped for the future,
with moving maps, electronic charts, WAAS/LPV approach capability, integrated FMS, ADS-B, traffic and weather
links, plus available SVT 3-D synthetic vision displays. And youll gain increased utility and tangible cost benefits
at a fraction of the cost of traditional flight deck retrofits.
For more information, contact Scott Frye, Garmin Integrated Flight Deck Sales Manager at
Scott.Frye@garmin.com or 913-440-2412. Or visit Garmin.com/aviation. G1000/G950 Upgrade
2015 Garmin Ltd. or its subsidiaries
*ADS-B is not available with Citation 525 installations
GCS STRENGTHENS AFRICAN PRESENCE AS IT BEGINS CONTRACT IN FIFTH AFRICAN COUNTRY
Great Circle Services, GCS, the Switzerland-based aviation safety consulting compa-
ny is continuing to strengthen its African presence following the commencement of
a consulting role in a fifth African country. The latest contract will see the consultan-
cy providing advice and training to support the undisclosed customers preparation
for the IATA Operational Safety Audit (IOSA) which will assess the airlines opera-
tional management and control systems. The airline is scheduled to undertake the
audit in 2016 and will work with GCS to ensure all the required systems are functioning safely and efficiently
This is the fifth African country where GCS has worked in just under four years. It undertook its first contract in Africa in 2011 when
based in Kinshasa, the capital of the Democratic Republic of the Congo; it audited three airlines for safety on behalf of a major interna-
tional humanitarian organization. Subsequent consultancy roles have included training an Egyptian airlines management across all mat-
ters of safety, and working with a Moroccan flight department to improve safety and compliance.
PRO LINE FUSION-EQUIPPED BEECHCRAFT KING AIR 250 AWARDED TYPE CERTIFICATE
Beechcraft Corporation has announced that it has
received type certification from the Federal Aviation
Administration (FAA) for the latest version of its new pro-
duction Beechcraft King Air 250 turboprop, allowing
deliveries to commence this quarter. The upgraded King
Air is equipped with the Pro Line Fusionavionics system
and new cabin enhancements. The aircraft is making its
North American debut at the EAA Airventure in
Oshkosh, Wisconsin.
We are pleased to put the upgraded King Air 250 in
the hands of our customers so quickly after announce-
ment two months ago, said Christi Tannahill, senior
vice president, Turboprop Aircraft and Interior Design.
This aircraft brings the latest technology to the cock-
pit and cabin allowing pilots and passengers alike to
experience the Beechcraft King Air in a whole new
way. EAA Airventure is a great venue for attendees to
experience firsthand the investments we are making in
this proven platform.
DUNCAN AVIATION JOINS THE ROBOTIC SKIES NETWORK
Duncan Aviation, Inc., and Robotic Skies have announced that
Duncan Aviation has joined the Robotic Skies network of ser-
vice centers that are optimized to provide certification, main-
tenance and repair for the emerging commercial unmanned
aircraft fleet. Duncan Aviation adds 17 new locations through-
out North America to the Robotic Skies network, raising the
global footprint to more than 80 Robotic Skies service center
locations around the world.
"Duncan Aviation is considered an industry leader in the manned
aviation maintenance world. The company is an authorized facto-
ry service center for nearly every major brand of business air-
craft, avionics, and engine on the market today. Now, through
our service network, Duncan Aviation will bring that same capa-
bility and professionalism that has made them so successful to
the unmanned aircraft world," said Brad Hayden, President and
CEO of Robotic Skies.
WEST STAR AVIATION NOW FITTING HONEYWELL PRIMUS EPIC CDS/R FULL COLOR
The new installation will satisfy all of the existing mandates and increase the value of the aircraft.
This LCD glass upgrade provides many benefits to the operator, increasing situational awareness, enhanced features, and information
management Improved system reliability and maintainability, reduced weight, electrical power consumption, and future upgrade capabil-
ity will be recognized by the flight department.
The installation includes: Four new LCD displays, Dual
Advance File Graphics Servers (AFGS) and XM graphical
weather.
The system is equipped with NZ-2000 FMS 6.1 software
WAAS/LPV and TCAS 7.1
All current mandates will be incorporated into the system and
most existing line replaceable units (LRUs) are retained, such
as radar, air data computers, autopilot, radios and inertial refer-
ence systems. Other upgrade options available include radio
tuning units, Honeywell Smart Runway/Smart Landing, the L-3
Avionics GH-3900 SIS, ASD-B Out, and CPDLC.
Join 25,000 industry professionals for the most important three days of business aviation,
with over 1,000 exhibitors, 100 business aircraft on static display, and dozens of
education sessions. Visit the NBAA2015 website to learn more and register today.
www.nbaa.org/2015/bart
/U.S.A.
TRANSATLANTIC
NBAA'S NEW GUIDELINES
HELP OPERATORS FLY QUIETLY
The National Business Aviation Association (NBAA) today released its much-
anticipated and updated Noise Abatement Program (NAP), which provides business
aviation operators, as well as airport authorities, with recommended guidelines for
reducing aircraft noise impacts to communities surrounding the nations airports.
The safe, standardized and straightforward operating procedures were developed
for todays business jet aircraft, which are quieter, climb faster and often operate at
airports that are far more congested than when the NAP was first launched in 1967.
NBAA is proud to offer the business aviation community and the many airports
across the country which have recommended use of our NAP over the years a
completely updated program that is the result of several years of hard work,
technical studies and vetting by NBAA staff and committee members and our
partner consultant, HMMH, said Ed Bolen, NBAA president and CEO. Even though
the U.S. has the quietest jet aircraft fleet in the world, NBAA believes that it is of
paramount importance for business aviation operators to do everything possible to
minimize noise impact whenever and wherever feasible.
Information on the updated NAP was presented today at NBAAs Regional Forum in
Teterboro, NJ by Gabriel Andino, NBAA Access Committee chairman and noise
expert with AvPORTS at Teterboro Airport (TEB). The revised guidelines help
EU-resident employee of the company and flies that
reduce overall noise levels to communities surrounding airports, while still meeting
person (along with the other passengers) within the new ATC requirements, said Andino.
EU.
Once these flights are completed, the aircraft Andino added that the NBAA procedures should be used in the absence of
recommended noise abatement procedures from the aircrafts manufacturer.
departs the EU. Finally, the aircraft also carried
company materials/brochures and IBAC asked if this
would be deemed "industrial or commercial
transport of goods." The EC responded that this NBAA CONCERNED ABOUT
scenario would be considered private use for
customs purposes since no remuneration is EPA'S PLANS FOR
involved.
Assuming the conditions described above are met, AIRCRAFT-EMISSION REGULATIONS
temporary admission would be available for this The National Business Aviation
operator. Regarding the transportation of company Association (NBAA) is closely evaluating an
materials/brochures, the EC responded that since announcement, unveiled today by the
transportation of these materials is not the main Environmental Protection Agency (EPA),
purpose of the flight, this is not considered as the that the agency intends to consider new
regulations for carbon emissions from
commercial transport of goods and is private use.
aircraft, based on an a view by agency
In addition to EU residents that are carried on board officials that such emissions may pose a
for a business purpose, it is possible to carry EU human-health concern because they
residents for non-business purposes. Again, the contribute to global warming.
aircraft owner must prepare a letter stating that the When the EPA's intention was announced
EU residents are authorized to be on board. If the today, NBAA was quick to raise concerns of its own, pointing out that aviation
transportation of EU residents meets the conditions emissions account for a mere two percent of all transportation emissions globally,
described above, operators are still generally and emissions from general aviation aircraft account for only a tiny portion of all
permitted to use the temporary admission process. aviation emissions.
With this guidance now in place, NBAA and its The agency's announcement detailed in an advanced notice of proposed
rulemaking (ANPRM) is based on an "endangerment finding," focused on aircraft
counterparts with the European Business Aviation
emissions. The endangerment finding could prompt the EPA to propose any new
Association (EBAA) are closely monitoring the aircraft-emissions regulations under the Clean Air Act of 1970.
response by customs officials to operators using the The EPA's ANPRM is not an actual proposed rule, but simply a notice that the
temporary admissions regime while meeting this agency may move ahead in proposing aircraft-emissions regulations. NBAA is
established criteria for private use. thoroughly reviewing the ANPRM to determine what specific implications the EPA's
Our respective organizations are also working with plans might have for business aviation. NBAA President and CEO Ed Bolen said the
regulatory bodies across the EU to ensure that these Association will file comments on the ANPRM following a review of the document,
principles are understood and practiced, so that which NBAA will undertake in collaboration with its Member Companies and the
Business Aviation operators around the world may broader aviation community.
continue to receive appropriate customs treatment NBAA has continually worked with a coalition of other industry stakeholders
regarding aircraft emissions. The Association has representation on national and
throughout the EU and its customs territories.
international working groups represented by general aviation, the airlines,
manufacturers and others that is focused on emission policies.
CONCORDE
RG SERIES BATTERIES
A world leader in valve regulated lead acid aircraft batteries, Concorde Batterys proven reliability and
excellent performance has resulted in more certified installations as Original Equipment or Replacements
than any other lead acid aircraft battery manufacturer.
RG-CIS25
RG-25XC
RG-407
RG-380E/44
RG24-15 RG-350
RG-380E/44KSH
RG24-11M
RG-500
RG24-16
RG-390E
Concorde designs and manufactures over 90 models of Concorde Batteries are installed as Original Equipment
lead acid batteries for OE and direct replacements. With and adopted by military aircraft operators worldwide. All
a reputation for designing application specific solutions, RG Batteries are transported Hazmat Exempt.
Outlook Exceptional
SERVICE.
Textron confirmed its 2015 earnings per share from con-
tinuing operations guidance of $2.30 to $2.50 and its expec-
tation for cash flow from continuing operations of the man-
ufacturing group before pension contributions of $550 to
$650 million with planned pension contributions of about
$80 million.
MAINTENANCE AVIONICS PAINT INTERIOR
Textron Aviation
Revenues at Textron Aviation were down $59 million, pri-
marily reflecting a change in the mix of jets delivered in the
quarter. Textron Aviation delivered 36 new Citation jets and
30 King Air turboprops in the quarter, compared to 36
Citations and 34 King Airs in last years second quarter.
Textron Aviation recorded a segment profit of $88 million
in the second quarter compared to $28 million a year ago.
The increase is primarily due to improved performance,
reflecting a $27 million lower fair value step-up adjustment
and the benefit of the integrated cost structure of
Beechcraft and Cessna.
Textron Aviation backlog at the end of the second quarter
was $1.4 billion, up $145 million from the end of the first
quarter.
At West Star we value the importance of experience and
Bell understand its duality. Specifically, how our experience directly
Bell revenues decreased $269 million, primarily the result impacts yours as the customer. But theres more to it than just
of lower aircraft deliveries and a $41 million impact from claims of hands-on, day-to-day experience.
the settlement of the SDD phase of the ARH program in
last years second quarter. Beyond experience, theres skill, intellect and passion. These are
Bell delivered 6 V-22s and 6 H-1s in the quarter, compared some of the characteristics that make experience truly valuable
to 10 V-22s and 8 H-1s in last years second quarter and 39 to our customers. These are the characteristics that allow our
commercial helicopters, compared to 46 units last year. experience to exceed your every expectation and provide truly
Segment profit decreased $40 million primarily due to the exceptional maintenance, avionics, paint & interior services.
lower aircraft deliveries and a $16 million favorable impact
in 2014 related to the ARH program, partially offset by Contact West Star to see just how valuable real experience can be.
favorable performance.
Bell backlog at the end of the second quarter was $4.8 bil- Where Experience Shines
lion, down $477 million from the end of the first quarter.
By Paul Walsh
DIVERSITY
Aircraft of
different shapes
its to our operators, even in a down Helicopter usually leads the charge, The Bell 407GX and Bell 429 are and sizes are
market. with the Bell 407GX and the Bell 429 our best selling models in Russia and entering the
One company profiting from the being of particular interest to buyers. the Bell 429 is the most popular air- Russian market.
Russians love of heavy irons is We have seen tremendous growth craft among all light twin engine heli- Airbus ACJ 190
Airbus, and it ACJ319 is particularly in both the Bell 407GX and the Bell copters in the country, said (top),
sought after by Russian buyers. 429 in Russia, said Patrick Moulay, Alexander Evdokimov, General Embraer Legacy
Business jets are a powerful Bell Helicopters managing director of Director of Jet Transfer. We expect to 650 (center),
enabler, especially in uncertain times, Europe. These aircraft not only pro- continue to grow the Bell 429 fleet, Pilatus PC-12
and Airbus corporate jets are the top vide superior performance and trusted especially for VIP/corporate missions (bottom left)
of the productivity pyramid, with the reliability, but they are also designed as well as special operations, HEMS Nextant 400 XTI
ability to carry more people, more to support a variety of mission needs. and air taxi services. (bottom right).
Connectivity
Like all Business Aviation markets
connectivity is becoming an increas-
ingly important requirement for users.
One company taking advantage of this
demand is Satcom Direct.
At the recent Baltic Business
Aviation Forum, Satcom Direct had a
high-profile presence, sponsoring the
events important networking evening
reception attended by leading aviation
A
lthough its a challenging time
for Russian Business Aviation,
there are still many positives.
For one thing the downturn is forcing
buyers to be more considerate when
choosing a business jet, and think of
the aircraft more as a tool for business
rather than an excess or luxury.
People are reflecting more on the
missions they fly, said one analyst,
they recognize that they dont need a
large long range jet if theyre mostly
flying within Russia.
One beneficiary of the downturn is
the charter market which is taking
up demand from former business jet
owners. With the fall in the ruble,
some people have been forced to sell shifting, and there are opportunities tificates of airworthiness, registration,
their aircraft. But these people con- out there for manufacturers to sell and insurance policy, along with
tinue flying Business Aviation, just jets. requested routings and flight informa-
now its a chartered jet instead of Another plus point is that building tion regions. Permits are valid +24
their own. airports is still a priority for the hours. At least 24 hours is required for
And while some businesspeople Russian government, in a climate permit revisions. Note that if you wish
POSITIVES are suffering because of the down- where Russias aviation industry is to arrive earlier than the approved per-
Russia is turn others are profiting. People slowly maturing. Much of the airport mit time even 10 minutes early
gearing up for who have their wealth tied up in for- contracts were sanctioned before the youll need to revise your permit.
the 2018 World eign assets, are using the current downturn and havent been scrapped. He adds that its best to confirm air-
Cup. situation to grow their market share In short the Russian government craft parking in advance and avoid any
Transaeros in certain areas. And they see the knows that the country needs more changes to schedule that may impact
imperial cabin value of Business Aviation. Its an airports and theyre determined to confirmed parking, airport slots, or
(top). interesting time, some wealth is build them. landing permits. Once an aircraft is
How much does a chance for delay or an inaccurate fuel quote really cost you? Lost time,
missing taxes and hidden fees can quickly add up.
With the UVair Fuel Programme, you and your team have access to resources that can
help you look at fuel beyond the transaction to ensure the success of your trips.
You have the support of:
Recognition and acceptance at over 5,000 locations worldwide,
and a network of proven suppliers
A 24/7 team of experts with detailed knowledge of pricing, taxes,
regulations, and supply
Monitoring and alerts for supply issues that threaten your trips
Confidence that you arent overpaying for fuel, whatever your
aircrafts size
VAT-exempt and VAT-compliant invoicing for 18 European
countries
SEE FUEL DIFFERENTLY.
Apply today at uvair.com/save.
Call us at N. America +1 (866) 864-8404 or Worldwide +1 (713) 378-2708, or visit uvair.com to learn more.
REPORT BUSINESS AVIATION IN RUSSIA
By Richard Koe
Managing Director WINGX Advance
T
here were a little over 3,000
Business Aviation flights between
Russia and the European area in
July 2015. That represented a 24%
decline on the same flight activity this
time last year. A hefty fall, and worry-
ingly an increase in the year to date
trend of 22%, suggesting that the
repercussions from the outbreak of
the Ukraine crisis 18 months ago are
far from over. As far as Business
STAGNANT Aviation is concerned at least, its
Demand for clear that demand for private jet flights
private jet flights out of Russia, crippled last year, arent
out of Russia showing any signs of recovery in 2015.
has yet to There should not be any surprise.
recover. Sukhoi Last years stand-off between Russia
Superjet 100 and Europe, particularly since the
(top). shooting down of MH17, heavily
Manufacturers
A more obvious loser from the drop in
the Russian market are the aircraft
manufacturers, particularly the heavy
and long-range jet providers
Gulfstream and Bombardier.
Bombardier in particular is in some tur-
moil this year as it cuts production and
employment in response to falling
demand for its premium Global aircraft.
For both manufacturers, Russia was an
indispensably strong market in the last
few years, as European markets contin-
ued to sag. Between 2007 and 2013
Gulfstream saw its fleet in Russia grow
from 7 to 53 aircraft. This year, new jet
deliveries to Russia, as well as China,
have slumped. At least Gulfstream has
the relative protection of its exceptional
backlog of G650 orders. For
Bombardier, the collapse of the
Russian market is a real problem. sanctions are lifted, its businesses
The extent of Bombardiers exposure and consumers will not recover their
is evident in its jets flight activity in appetite for private jets any time
Russia this year. There have been over soon.
3200 flights in Bombardier aircraft this
year, almost three times as many as the
next most popular brand of aircraft, but Richard Koe is joint Managing Director
18% fewer than last year. The ultra-long of WINGX, taking the lead on strategy,
range aircraft types, such as the Global business development and sales initia-
Express, are relatively least affected, tives. Together with Christoph Kohler,
flights down by just 4%, which may Richard has grown WINGX to be the
reflect the relatively resilience of their leading provider of market intelligence
WANING super wealthy users. Heavy jet flights, in to the global business aviation industry.
Manufacturers contrast, which comprise 40% of all activ- As well as managing WINGX, Richard
have ity out of Russia, have collapsed by 25%. is a regular speaker, panellist and mod-
experienced a The Challenger 850, which has been a erator at industry conferences world-
fall in demand in very popular jet for Russian customers, wide, writes on a wide range of business
Russia. Vnukovo is flying a third less. The midsize Learjet aviation issues, and works closely with
airport (top) 60s activity is down by 45%. Other regional regulators and industry associ-
Dassault 7X OEMs jets are also flying less, with the ations.
(center). notable exception of the Falcon 7X. WWW.WINGX-ADVANCE.COM
By Mark Huber
RUSSIAN HELICOPTER
T
he Russian helicopter market
Light Helicopters
In recent years, light helicopter
imports into Russia have surged. Over
the next three years, the Russian
Helicopter Industry Association
expects the countrys civil fleet to
increase by 500 with fully two-thirds of
those coming from the light and medi-
um models. The light market is lead-
ing the charge. Between 2009 and
2014, the number of native light civil
sector helicopters grew from 234 to
523 according to RHIA. Officially,
executives from Russian Helicopters
Maintenance
Providing the necessary service and
support is key to successful penetra-
tion of the Russian market. notes a
2013 study from the U.S. Commercial
Service. When entering the Russian
market, foreign helicopter manufactur-
ers choose strategies varying from
sales and partnerships with indepen-
dent market players to teaming up Aviation (UWCA) facility in recently re-organized as part of a
with state holdings and authorities. As Yekaterinburg. Teaming with deal to sell ten new AW189 super-
a first step, initial market entry can UWCA presents an immediate medium twins to RN-Aircraft, a sub-
include selling helicopters in coopera- strategic advantage, as it already sidiary of state oil company Rosneft.
tion with a Russian partner (dealer). has MRO capabilities. We believe The latter inked a deal in late 2014
Past experience indicates that a sold- there is a strong demand for the that could see it taking up to 160 new
and-forgot attitude led to market fail- Bell 407GXP and we are delighted helicopters from the JV by 2025,
ure for a number of brands. to establish a strong local presence including AW189s assembled at
Thus, European helicopter manufac- in Russia, said Patrick Moulay, vice HeliVert. Under the reorganization,
turers who have been in the market president of global sales and mar- AgustaWestland would cede 10 per-
for a while have made a transition keting at Bell Helicopter. This is a cent of its interest in the JV and
PARTNER from just selling helicopters to selling key milestone for Bell Helicopter Rosneft would receive a 30 percent
Helivert (center) their lifecycle, including setting up a that we expect will lead to further share in it. Russian Helicopters
is a joint venture developed maintenance infrastruc- opportunities within the Russian would see its share diluted to 30 per-
between ture. market. We are committed to con- cent. Officially, AW said the move
AgustaWestland Bell announced in May that it tinue supporting the success of our was designed to strengthen its
(top) and would assemble its 407GXP turbine Russian business partners as we industrial collaboration with its
Russian single for the Russian market in strongly believe in the long term Russian partners and its commercial
helicopters. Russia at a JSC Ural Works of Civil potential of the market. presence.
SANCTIONS IMPACT
RUSSIAN BUSINESS AVIATION
By Derek Bloom
E
U and U.S. sanctions are negative-
ly affecting the Russian business
jet market. A certain number of
wealthy Russian persons and large
corporations are specifically named in
EU and US sanctions. These persons
may not be sold aircraft by the major
manufacturers, and cannot receive
maintenance, warranty and navigation
services from some Western
providers. Accordingly, several of
these persons have gone to some
lengths to sell aircraft they own, and
are not acquiring new aircraft, but are
presently using charter aircraft.
ond half of 2014, and possibly into proposal, information about owner-
2015, with the application of OFAC ship of real estate, aircraft and yachts
SDN sanctions to Mr. Timchenko. It would only be made available to per-
was widely reported in the fall of 2014 sons holding a power of attorney
that Mr. Timchenko had said publicly from the owner to access such infor-
that Gulfstream had broken off contact mation.
with him and would not service the air- The Federal Security Service (FSB)
craft. Mr. Timchenkos aircraft was has proposed the information would
grounded for several months. still be freely available to state
Prior to the imposition of sanctions organs, but all other bodies would
on Mr. Timchenko, he had been seek- need permission from the relevant
ing U.S. government funding, appar- property owners to access their
ently from the Export-Import Bank of details. According to the authors of
the United States, to buy up to 11 the new bill, this information can at
Gulfstream aircraft, having a value present be used for criminal purpos-
from $173 to $710 million. es, for example blackmail. The new
Presumably, since Gulfstream still has law is expected to come into force in
a substantial backlog to produce March 2016.
G650s, the loss of this piece of busi- In conclusion, coming back to the
ness, if it ever had a chance at realiza- was aware of the transaction before it question posed by navigation, Where
tion, is offset by the other business occurred. So, presumably, Gulfstream are we now?, the Russian business
that Gulfstream does have. Gulfstream is now able to service that particular aviation market is clearly in a reces-
did address the situation with Mr. G650 once again. sion due to there being fewer wealthy
Timchenko directly. Gulfstream is persons, and those who are remain-
continuing efforts to sell and maintain Confidentiality ing are not spending and investing as
aircraft in Russia while also navigating The identity of Russian owned air- freely as in the past. There will be a
economic sanctions by the USA and craft is intentionally well hidden, and continued desire by Russian owners
Europe that target certain individuals accurate information about the place to own their aircraft through owner-
including some of the companys of registration of Russian owned air- ship structures outside of Russia that
clients. craft is also hard to establish. There is will be opaque to both the Russian
Regarding Mr. Timchenko, who an interesting website operated in the government and to Western aircraft
reportedly owned the sixth G650 off Russian language by Aviaforum where manufacturers and other foreign buy-
the assembly line, Mr. Timchenko had a large number of interested persons, ers and sellers seeking to do business
complained to Russias ITAR-TASS perhaps industry sales persons, and with a Russian counterpart. Russian
news agency in a July 31, 2014 report perhaps hobbyists, exchange informa- owners will continue to register their
that his G650 was effectively grounded tion about which Russia persons own aircraft outside of Russia. There will
because of the sanctions. He says which particular aircraft, and where remain a very limited constituency for
Gulfstream has informed him they they are located. According to one legal reform to promote business avi-
cannot send spare parts or allow his summary published here, of 565 ation in Russia, and to lobby for an
pilots to use the maps included in the Russian owned aircraft, the Isle of exemption from import VAT, for
aircrafts navigation system. The inci- Man is the champion with the most example. Russian owners of aircraft
dent put Gulfstream in the awkward Russian owned aircraft, being 101 air- have gone to great lengths to make
position of wanting to support cus- craft. In second place is Austria with themselves and their aircraft into for-
tomers while still fully complying with 71 aircraft, and, surprisingly, in third eigners just visiting Russia when they
US and European trading rules. A place is Russia itself with 70 aircraft are here.
Gulfstream spokesperson said registered here. The information sum-
Gulfstream can still deliver and sup- marized here does not go on to list any
port aircraft linked to Russian clients, other totals, but Malta, the UK and
despite the sanctions. It just depends Switzerland and the U.S. would likely Derek Bloom is a Partner with Marks
DOWNTURN on where theyre at on that sanctions follow. and Sokolov's Moscow office.
With less wealth list. Certain people in Russia youre At the same time that Russian own- He is a member of the District of
in Russia, its not able to do a lot of business ers of aircraft are motivated to own Columbia Bar Association. Before mov-
Business with...Are we able to still do business? and register their aircraft outside of ing to Russia, Mr. Bloom practiced law
Aviation market Yes we can. We just have to be careful Russia, notably there is proposed leg- in Washington, D.C. from 1984 to 1995
is in recession. about how we do it. islation in Russia that would make it as a partner in a securities law firm
Russian The word on the street is that Mr. secret information to know who and focused on securities issuances by US
President Timchenkos aircraft was eventually what legal entities may have regis- financial institutions.
Vladimir Putin sold to a person not subject to the tered ownership of real estate, air- dbloom@mslegal.com
(top). OFAC SDN sanctions, and that OFAC craft and yachts in Russia. Under the www.marks-sokolov.com
Management
SMS implementation suppor t
Bahnhofweg 2 CH-6048 Horw / Luzern phone + 41-41 460 46 60 contact@gcs-safety.com www.gcs-safety.com Great Circle Services AG
FOCUS FLIGHT TRAINING
By Kirby Harrison
RESEMBLING
F
light simulator training has come
By Paul Walsh
WEATHER RADAR
We always see a peak in interest in
the summer when storms are more
prevalent and operators realize their
weather radar isnt up to scratch, has
T
to distinguish ground from weather. Its
hunderstorms can be lethal to
high receiver sensitivity also allows the
any aircraft and having early
radar to detect extremely weak signals
advance warning of potential pre-
from distant storms.
cipitation or turbulence threats allows
Rainfall intensity levels are displayed
the pilot to either request a route
in four different colours with magenta
diversion or climb over the hazard (if
and red showing severe rainfall,
possible).
though yellow and green, which repre-
Modern Doppler systems can also sents light rain.
sense the speed of the movement of Chris McKenna, Honeywells
rain towards and away from the air- Director, Marketing and Product
craft by looking at small changes in Management, said that its RDR-4000
the return frequency of the microwave solid state radar is also available for
reflection. This can help detect turbu- larger business jets. This features
lence and wind shear. Honeywells patented IntuVue 3-D sys-
But the earlier the warning pilots can tem that automatically scans at differ-
get of bad weather the better. ent tilt angles to build up a 3D volu-
SAFETY Weather radar systems have become metric buffer of the weather from the
Weather radar smaller and lighter in recent years ground to 60,000 feet across a 320 nm
can save lives. thanks to the advent of solid state elec- detection range.
Honeywell (top) tronics. Early systems used weighty IntuVue also has an integrated
Honeywell microwave magnetrons that consumed ground database so that the system
Primus 880 a lot of current, but had very high can tell the difference between weath-
(center). power outputs. er and terrain, said McKenna.
Gary Harpster Gary Harpster, Senior Avionic Sales It also uses algorithms to take out
Senior Avionic at Duncan Aviation, said: Newer solid ground returns and works with the
Sales state systems rely on having lower out- FMS to give the pilot the best view of
Duncan Aviation puts, but more sensitive receivers to the weather ahead, given the flight
(bottom). get the same or better capability. plan. Overall, it reduces pilot workload
BUSINESS AVIATION
In maintenance Dassault Aircraft
Services-Sorocaba recently completed
a major expansion to better accommo-
THRIVES AT LABACE
date the demands of Brazilian and
other South American customers.
The expansion added 10,000 square
feet of hangar space.
The company owned Sorocaba
Service Center is authorized to
perform line maintenance and air-
frame inspections on all Falcon
models except the legacy Falcon
20 and Falcon 100. In addition, the
facility is qualified to provide
engine maintenance on the CFE-
738, Honeywell TFE731 series
engines and Pratt & Whitney
Canada PW307A and PW308C
models. Specialized non-destruc-
tive testing (NDT) services, such
as penetrant and eddy current test-
ing can also be performed. A full
service battery shop is available to
repair, replace or recharge main
and emergency batteries on
Falcon and other aircraft models.
By Paul Walsh
I
n spite of the economic downturn
in Latin America, the evidence
from this years LABACE, which
ran from August 13-15, was that
Business Aviation continues to thrive,
particularly in Brazil, which is home to
a growing market of 772 registered
business jets.
So manufacturers werent paying
attention to any doom and gloom
headlines and arrived in Sao Paulo for
the show, ready to take advantage of
what the Latin American market had
to offer.
DISCIPLINE
IS KEY
By LeRoy Cook I can still recall training myself for The discipline behind successful
the ATP checkride, fighting to main- piloting starts with understanding the
M
uch has been made recently of tain the close tolerances demanded best technique to achieve the desired
a general deterioration in man- by the test standards. Allowing the outcome, and believing that it can be
ual flying skills, leading to a crossed needles to stray outside the done, even if it doesnt work out on the
dumbing down of flight abilities in CDIs central doughnut meant a go- first attempt. A methodical, disciplined
order to fill cockpits seats. But, when around, on one engine, and a very approach leads to taxiing on the cen-
faced with an inflight crisis, it still expensive retest. At times, it didnt terline, subconsciously, without even
takes a professional crew to avoid dis- seem possible that one could keep concentrating on steering. That desire
aster, even if the aircraft only requires those needles centered while under to guide the aircraft precisely trans-
one pilot. pressure to accurately fly the proce- lates into a takeoff and landing roll
There is a danger that were training dure. Gradually, I learned to that also adheres to the stripe.
new pilots to be excellent system ana- increase my scan rate, make early,
lysts and procedure adherents, to the timely corrections, and get ahead of Takeoff Discipline
exclusion of being able to creatively the airplane instead of chasing it. In In a takeoff profile, there is a target
belly-flop an Airbus into a river when the end, I was subconsciously will- speed to be achieved in the initial
bird ingestion leaves them without ing the airplane to hold a tight climbout, usually a different one for
power. Everyone agrees that automa- course, making it an extension of all-engines or engine-out configura-
tion is a useful resource, a load-shed- my mind. tions. The airplane cannot be driven
ding tool that allows pilots to concen- Self discipline, then, is the way to to this state; it has to be guided there
trate on critical decision-making. What improve piloting skills. Visualizing by a disciplined pattern of raising the
it should not be is a means of prolong- where we want the airplane to be, and nose into the correct attitude, at a con-
ing decisions, or a substitute for main- using thrust, pitch, yaw and roll to trolled rate, so as to make the wheels
tenance of basic skills. The discipline achieve that end, does not come natu- leave the ground at an airspeed slight-
needed to avoid stagnation of ability rally. It takes practice, initially in a pro- ly above minimum-unstick, accelerat-
has to begin with active participation cedures trainer or simulator, but even- ing toward the climbout speed with
in the pilots seatnot by thumbing a tually in the airplane. Theres no sub- minimal pitch change. This flow of
IMPROVE procedures manual or programming stitute for the feedback of loading and events does not happen without disci-
Self discipline is an FMS. Whenever possible, we need motion found in actual flight. The best plined practice.
the best way to to click off the autopilot, or navigate of simulators is still a simulation, use- Behind precise piloting is a desire to
develop piloting with basic equipment, just to remem- ful in its own right but not the real be better. To accept mediocrity is to
skills. ber how it can be done. thing. invite atrophy of skill. If you repeated-
www.ebace.aero/2016/bart
MAINTENANCE
MATTERS
SILENCING YOUR JET
First-generation business jets will
need modifying if they are to
continue operating in the
United States after the end of
the year By Bernard Fitzsimons
T
he US ban on operations by Stage compares very favourably with a used some people who are ready to go but
2 business jets that takes effect at GIV, which has 500 miles more range they are waiting, maybe because they
the beginning of next year means and about 25 gallons per hour better feel they have some time left before
owners will have to modify their air- fuel burn but costs $5-8 million. The the end of the year. We try to say that
craft, sell them to a jurisdiction where GIIIs Spey engine is less expensive to the earlier that you sign up the better,
they are still allowed, or scrap them. overhaul than the GIVs Tay, he adds. because you dont want to wait till the
For a few of the types there is no Ben Brown of rival Gulfstream hush- end. But were producing enough kits
remedy. Jet Commanders, JetStars, kitter Quiet Technologies Aerospace so that we will have them in stock to
Sabres and Viper-engined 125s will agrees that the cost-benefit equation meet the demand.
have to retire or find new homes pits the cost of the kit against the cost
abroad. But there is a hush kit for the of a replacement aircraft. If you want Gulfstream II, IIB and III
Falcon 20, and more than one option a cabin of that size youre going to be QTA has a long background in
for the 20-series Learjets and looking at a 601 Challenger or a GIV, hush kits: We did the hush kits for
Gulfstream IIs and IIIs that constitute he says, with a decent 601 costing Stage 2 as well, and we also did the
the majority of the affected fleet. $1.8-$3 million. For a GIV youre Stage 3 hush kits for the 707, DC-8
The cost of a hush kit is substantial going to spend between $2 million and and KC-135 stage 2 and 3, says Ben
from around $70,000 for a Learjet 20 to $6 million, and theres not really much Brown. Installations of the QTA kit
more than ten times that for a in the $2 million range, those are air- for the GII/GIII started in 2003 and
Gulfstream. But the scrap value of the planes you need to spend a million totalled 128 by early July.
aircraft is minimal: the FAA puts it at bucks on so really its $3 million, We install them anywhere in the
just $1,335 for a Learjet or $8,075 for a depending on whether you get the world, says Brown. Usually we have
Gulfstream, not counting the cost of Dunlop wheels and brakes, where the the repair station that were working
delivering the aircraft to the scrap- engines are at in the maintenance pro- with remove the pylon board and the
yard. And replacement jets are not grams, whether its an SP or not, and thrust reverser per the Gulfstream
cheap. so on. procedures and send them to our fac-
Bernie Weiss, president and COO of Mark Rooke, president of Learjet 20 tory for modification. The modified
Gulfstream hush kit vendor Hubbard series kit supplier Alloy Aerospace, boards are then reinstalled with an
Aviation Technologies, sees it as a says there is no direct replacement for exchange set of overhauled thrust
POPULAR sound investment. if you install our the model, and owners are divided reversers.
So far Hubbard QS3 hush kit for $1,000,000 your GIII equally between those moving quickly The pylon boards have to be modi-
has equipped is capable of flying for the foreseeable to incorporate the upgrade and those fied because they are aircraft specific,
more than a future, he points out. Given the cur- opting to wait. We have quite a few a procedure that takes four or five
dozen aircraft rent price points of used GIIIs in the people who right away came on board days. Reinstallation takes a further two
with its QS3 $1-1.5 million range you have a total and placed orders, who wanted to be days, and is done by QTA under its
hush kit. investment of, say, $2.5 million. This ahead of the curve, he says. We have Part 145 repair station approval. The
The kits list price is $70,000 for air- of the engine. Because theres a high
craft with straight nozzles, he says, pressure seeks low pressure type of
or $75,000 for those with reversers. It eductor from the NACA ducts
comes with installation instructions through the exhaust nozzle were
and manuals, and the owner or opera- able to draw the air through and cool
tor can have it installed by their cho- it sooner.
sen MRO or FBO. Installation takes Installation takes five business days
between 10 and 17 hours per engine, at Trines facility in Colorado
he estimates, depending on whether Springs. The company can handle
it has thrust reversers, and Alloy can two aircraft a week and plans to add
despatch a technician to help if capacity for a third line later in the
required. Alternatively, Alloy offers a year. It also intends to announce two
factory installation. additional installation facilities in
Butler National Subsidiary Avcon other regions once certification is
tially reduced noise on the ground and Industries certified its own husk kit achieved. Weve had interest from
in the cabin during thrust reverser use. last year. Its a major difference if about 60 people and about 26 of
youre on the ramp and you hear a those want to contract slots right
Learjet 23, 24, 25 and 28 20-series airplane, says Butlers Eric now, Ham says.
The first Learjet 20 hush kit was made Peters of the kit, which consists of an
Trines kit costs $70,000 installed. It
by Aviation Equipment (AEI), but pro- eight-lobed nozzle and fairing. And
will also be available in kit form at
duction ended some time ago. Los if youre inside the cabin you can feel
the same price from the beginning of
Angeles-based Alloy Aerospace bought a difference.
next year, Ham says: Were trying to
AEI in 2012 and decided to revive the Installation takes between seven
put incentives out there to bring the
programme, says Mark Rooke: AEI days and two weeks, depending on
airplanes here as we do the first kits.
basically sold what they had in stock whether the aircraft has thrust
There are some things that we want
and didnt do any more production reversers. Avcon carries out the
to kind of keep under our wing as the
because there was no federal mandate at installation at its base in Newton,
first airplanes are being modified and
the time, so there was no market. Kansas, 20 miles north of Wichita,
at a later date well let that out. We
Alloy itself has a 35-year history of and has upgraded eight aircraft so
assume that people will be buying
manufacturing exhaust system assem- far. I think everybodys kind of wait-
this kit for the next 24 months.
blies and has developed hush kits for ing, says Peters. Adding the hush
multiple aircraft types, Rooke says. kit means losing the thrust reversers,
We decided to retool for it and revive but its a trade-off to get to fly your Falcon 20
the programme because a lot of the airplane. It usually takes about two
A hush kit for the Falcon 20s CF700
owners and operators of these Lears weeks with thrust reversers. Retail
was developed in the early 1990s and
were coming to us and saying, we love price of the kit is $125,000.
is currently available from Kalitta
this airplane. Theres nothing really Trine Aerospace & Defense was
Turbines of Ypsilanti, Michigan. It
like it out there, and its a workhorse expecting certification of its hush kit
consists of a new exit guide vane
in a lot of different ways. for the Learjet 20 to be finalised by
assembly with additional vanes.
The Alloy Aerospace kit consists of mid-August. The kit involves an inter-
Kalittas John Horn says installation
an eight-lobe daisy nozzle to replace nal eductor with a series of chevron
involves removing the engine from the
the existing nozzle and a daisy fairing cutouts around the aft end of the
aircraft. The fan section of the engine
that extends beyond the aft end of the exhaust nozzle and a bullet located a
has to be split in half to replace the
nozzle. For Learjets without thrust few inches aft of the exit area, plus
exit guide vane with the new hush kit
reversers, installation involves remov- nine NACA ducts in the aft section of
guide vane, he explains.
ing the existing nozzle and replacing it the cowling. The chevrons and bullet
with the new parts. Its basically simi- create vortices in the exhaust flow, The company carries out the installa-
lar to a line maintenance operation, allowing hot exhaust to mix with cool tion itself and currently has more than
says Rooke. With the nozzle only its ambient air prior to exiting the 50 orders for kits for both freighter
probably a two to three day job. engine cowling. Trines is the only and passenger Falcons, though opera-
For aircraft with thrust reversers the design that enables the thrust tors are typically waiting until the last
process is similar, Rooke says: You reversers to be retained. minute to schedule the installation.
remove the thrust reversers and blank We modify the engine nacelles to End to end, he says, the process takes
out and change some linkage and basically create bypass air, com- about a week, including a day and a
some other items in the airplane, ments Britt Ham, Trines president half to install the guide vane assembly.
QUIETEN because you no longer have the thrust and CEO. The loud bang that you Removing, replacing and re-rigging
Avcon Industries reversers. I would say the installation hear from the jet is the hot air hitting the engine accounts for the rest of the
Hush-Kit for the time is three or four days, depending the cold air, so what we try to do is time.
Learjet. on your learning curve. mix it prior to coming out of the back
With the largest, most extensive service network of any aviation manufacturer, we keep your aircraft flying no matter
where you are. Whether you fly a Beechcraft , Cessna or Hawker , its essential to us that you are never grounded.
Thats why our European centers service it all. Learn more and find your nearest service center at service.txtav.com.
s e r v i ce.t x t av.co m
MISSION IMPOSSIBLE
approach restriction at destination.
To meet noise abatement proce-
dures the aircraft should have
climbed at a speed of 167 KIAS up to
4500 ft AMSL. In any case, he
cleaned up the aircraft configuration
and lowered the nose of the aircraft
to 12 Attitude Nose Down.
The aircraft lost altitude and accel-
erated to 230 KIAS. At 22:07 LT the
aircraft impacted the frozen ground
still within the airport perimeter.
Wreckage and debris covered the
area between the departure end of
runway 34 and the threshold of run-
way 14. Both pilots perished.
Old School
Eagle Air was an operator with only
two aircraft. The founder and owner
occupied all major functions himself
and governed his staff with an iron
fist. His management style is
By Michael R. Grninger coordinator and flight dispatcher, described as authoritarian. He kept
of Great Circle Services AG (GCS) and had urged his crew to return the air- close telephone contact with the
Capt. Carl C. Norgren craft on the same evening to Eagle pilots during their duties, he would
Airs home base at Berne airport. lay down specific instructions for
2
001, just before Christmas, a dark Since Berne airport closed at 22:00 their actions even during flying
night at Zurich Airport. The cold LT, he had arranged for a special duties. When acting as a commander,
front had passed and patches of permission to extend the opening he acted in a dominant and non-team
fog started to form under a cold and hours until 22:30 LT. Thus EAB 220 oriented way.
clear sky. Low visibility operations had to fly as quickly as possible to Eagle Air was certified under Swiss
were imminent. make the night curfew of Berne. national legislation. Although the
The crew of HB-VLV, a Cessna 560 The pilot flying was probably the Swiss Civil Aviation Authority
Citation V business jet operated by co-pilot. He was a free-lance pilot (FOCA) had already implemented
Eagle Air, was preparing for their third with around 1,000 flight hours expe- JAR-OPS 1 for major operators, small
and last flight of the day. They had rience and no training for night IMC operators were still certified under
landed at 19:31 LT and were sched- take-offs. The commander was a for- the old national regulatory frame-
uled to ferry the aircraft to their home mer airline pilot with more experi- work. Thus FOCA did not require
base in Bern. enced in night IMC operations. Eagle Air to seek approval for low
Due to the ATC restrictions imposed During the take-off roll, the aircraft visibility operations, including low
by deteriorating visibility conditions veered 10 right of the centerline visibility take-offs.
and the strict noise abatement consid- due to asymmetric thrust caused by As a non-JAR-OPS-1 operator, Eagle
erations governing Zurich Airport poor maintenance. Take off was Air had not developed comprehen-
operations, estimated departure time uneventful. The pilot flying then sive standard operating procedures
was delayed to about 22:00 LT. ignored the noise abatement proce- beyond the basic checklists supplied
While waiting, the co-pilot kept the dures by accelerating the aircraft by the manufacturer and the external
right-hand engine running and the only 13 seconds after becoming air- flight training provider.
pilot was using a scraper to remove ice borne. Pilots had to rely on their own expe-
deposits from the left wing. Finally, at Since the attitude indicator on the rience, since the company did not
21:56 LT the ground controller cleared right side of the single-pilot offer training to complement weak-
the crew could taxi to RWY 34. At designed aircraft was an electro- nesses in pilot skills and knowledge.
22:05 LT they set take-off power for a mechanical one, the co-pilot might The company did not describe nor
rolling take off in meteorological visi- have turned his head to monitor the implement a comprehensive and
AMATEUR bility of 100m with partial fog for a commanders more precise electron- clear concept for cooperation and
An absence of direct flight to Berne as flight EAB ic attitude director indicator. He implementation of procedures in the
SOPs led to a 220. might as well have become disorien- cockpit. There was no standardized
Cessna 560 The founder, owner and CEO, who tated by the strobes glare in the fog. method of working in the cockpit.
crash in 2001. on that night acted as operations Or he simply wanted to accelerate as Were these the good old times?
Safety First,
as long as the boss is happy
Pilots are today very aware of the
dangers of excessive commercial and change. Still the crew knowingly Even the best company minded
time pressure. SOPs empower the accepted the loadsheet. pilots fail in an impossible mission
pilots to give safety considerations Time and economic pressure probably impossible.
precedence over non-safety related led to this deviant behaviour. By taking
pressures they face in daily opera- additional fuel the crew avoided the
tions. time delay of re-fuelling in Zurich, as Michael R. Grninger is Managing
When pilots consistently apply SOPs directed by the CEO. In addition, they Director of Great Circle Services (GCS)
over time, a culture of compliance avoided paying duty on the fuel for a Safety Solutions and Capt. Carl C.
becomes ingrained in the DNA of an domestic flight from Zurich to Berne. Norgren is a freelance contributor to
operator. Deviations from SOPs are Deviation had become a norm at Safety Sense. GCS assists in the whole
the exception, not the rule. Pilots are Eagle Air, as far as this accident sug- range of planning and management
thus required to justify deviations gests. issues, offering customized solutions to
from SOPs. strengthen the position of a business in
At Eagle Air such a culture was not Conclusion the aviation market. Its services include
in place. In fact: On the previous sec- The attitude of making the impossi- training and auditing (IS-BAO, CRASH
tor from East Midlands to Zurich the ble possible often counteracts the IOSA), consultancy, manual develop- HB VLV
crew completed a loadsheet showing habit of safe operation. A working day ment and process engineering. GCS can impacted the
an actual take-off mass of 600 lbs of making the impossible happen, for be reached at www.gcs-safety.com and frozen ground
above the maximum take-off mass. the sake of the company and even for +41-41 460 46 60. The column Safety within the airport
The commander reduced the excess some personal interests of the pilots, Sense appears regularly in BART perimeter at
to 400 lbs with a fictitious last-minute ended in failure. International since 2007. Berne airport.
By Linda Werfelman
STATES OF MIND
S
hifting Aeromedical require-
ments could lead to new methods
for dealing with mental health.
Aeromedical authorities are mulling
changes in their requirements for rou-
tine aviation medical examinations
that they say could ultimately focus
new attention on pilots mental health.
The International Civil Aviation
Organization (ICAO) is considering a
move to upgrade into a requirement
an existing recommendation that
national aviation authorities imple-
ment a health education system for
holders of pilot licenses. If approved
by ICAOs Air Navigation
Commission, the requirement would,
by late 2016, become part of a larger
program to ad- dress pilots mental
health, Anthony Evans, chief of
ICAOs Aviation Medicine Section,
says.
We need an industry-wide (regula-
tors, airlines, pilot associations)
approach to the issue, Evans said,
Mismatch
ICAOs proposal has been under
review for months, long before the
Germanwings crash, and as long ago
as 2012, the ICAO Manual of Civil
Aviation Medicine had noted the need
to pay more attention to mental health
issues.
Shifting aeromedical requirements
could lead to new methods of dealing
with mental health.
adding that the approach must include investigation, preliminary reports indi- Particularly in the younger license
better education associated with a cate that the first officer locked the holder, the Manual says, there is an
system to support those who have a captain out of the cockpit and set the apparent mismatch between the likeli-
mental health problem. A320 on a collision course with the hood of the existence of particular
The proposed requirement would ground. News reports have quoted pathologies of flight safety importance
direct pilot licensing authorities in German authorities as saying that the (mainly mental and behavioral prob-
ICAO member states to implement first officer had been treated for lems) and the tools being used to
appropriate aviation-related health depression for a lengthy period before detect them (the traditional medical
education for licence holders subject receiving his pilot license and that he examination).
to a medical assessment to reduce had shown suicidal tendencies. The Aerospace Medical Association
future medical risks to flight safety. Mental health issues have figured only (AsMA) has voiced similar concerns,
Evans made the remarks in the after- rarely in commercial transport aviation and in comments posted on the orga-
math of the March 24 crash of a accidents and incidents, and in some nizations website after the
CHECKS Germanwings Airbus A320 in the cases, accident investigators have Germanwings crash, AsMA President
Mental health French Alps. All 150 people in the air- been unable to agree on the role Philip J. Scarpa Jr. said that there is
screening for plane were killed, and, although the played by a pilots mental state. room for improvement in the airline
pilots needs to French Bureau dEnqutes et Nevertheless, aeromedical authorities industry for mental health screening
improve. dAnalyses has not completed its have revised guidelines in recent in pilots.
Nov. 29, 2013 Bwabwata National Park, Namibia Embraer ERJ-190 Aicraft Damage: Destroyed. Injuries: 33 fatal
Preliminary information indicates that while he was alone in the cockpit, the LAM captain re-programmed the alti-
tude preselector to a lower altitude and manually reselected the airspeed, which was near maximum operating
speed until the end of the flight. Sounds of pounding on the cockpit door were heard on the cockpit voice recorder.
Oct. 31, 1999 Atlantic Ocean Boeing 767 Aircraft Damage: Destroyed. Injuries: 217 fatal
The EgyptAir 767 crashed in the Atlantic Ocean shortly after takeoff from New York. U.S. investigators said the
relief first officer, alone in the cockpit, shut off the autopilot and the engines and pushed the flight controls forward.
The captain returned to the cockpit but was unable to recover the airplane. Egyptian authorities disputed the conclu-
sion.
Oct. 11, 1999 Gaborone, Botswana ATR-42 Aircraft Damage: Destroyed. Injuries: 1 fatal
An Air Botswana captain who was grounded for medical reasons took off in one of his airlines ATR-42s, demanding
to talk to airline officials and the president of Botswana. He told air traffic control that he planned to crash the air-
plane, which later struck two ATR-42s parked on the apron.
Dec. 19, 1997 Near Palembang, Indonesia Boeing 737 Aircraft Damage: Destroyed. Injuries: 104 fatal
Both flight recorders stopped functioning before the SilkAir 737 began a rapid descent, broke up and crashed into
the Musi River delta. Indonesian authorities could not explain the crash, but U.S. investigators said it appeared the
cockpit voice recorder was intentionally disabled and that the descent resulted from manual nose-down flight control
inputs.
Aug. 21, 1994 Near Tizounine, Morocco ATR 42 Aircraft Damage: Destroyed. Injuries: 44 fatal
The Royal Air Maroc airplane crashed after takeoff from Agadir. Accident investigators said the pilot had disconnect-
ed the autopilot and put the airplane into a steep dive. The pilots union challenged those findings.
Feb. 9, 1982 Tokyo McDonnell Douglas DC-8 Aircraft Damage: Destroyed. Injuries: 24 fatal
As the Japan Air Lines DC-8 descended through 164 ft on the approach, the captain shut off the autopilot, pushed
the controls forward and pulled the throttle levers to idle. The first officer struggled to take control of the airplane,
but It crashed short of the runway in Tokyo Bay. The captain had recently returned to duty after a year off because
of a psychosomatic disorder.
Sept. 26, 1976 Novosibirsk, Russia Antonov 2 Aircraft Damage: Destroyed. Injuries: 12 fatal
A pilot stole an Aeroflot An-2 and flew it into buildings on the street where his ex-wife lived. The pilot and 11 people
on the ground (not including the ex-wife) were killed.
He cited recent studies that estimate Nevertheless, he said, you can extrap-
10 to 15 percent of the general popula- olate that if its that bad in general
tion experience depression sometime society, it could be just as bad in the
in their lives and that the risk of sui- aviation industry.
cide among depressed patients is
about 20 times greater than in the gen- This article is reproduced with permis-
eral population. sonfrom the June issue of this years
Data are not available to determine the AeroSafety World, the official publica-
EVASIVE extent of depression among pilots, Frey tion of the FlightSafety Foundation,
Pilots may said, adding that when pilots are ques- www.flightsafety.org.
underreport their tioned about mental health issues, they
mental health tend to under- report their weaknesses
weaknesses. and over-report their strengths.
We make it easier.
KNOW MORE.
A
By Paul Walsh nd now Shannon is attempting to feedback Ive had from financiers
replicate its success with com- and other operators is that they like
Ireland may be known for mercial aircraft in Business it very much. Especially for opera-
beautiful scenery and bad Aviation. At EBACE Shannons tors who are looking at the quality
weather but did you know that International Aviation Centre (IASC) of their provision. People dont want
its also an international aviation unveiled a new Irish aircraft register, to be seen as been connected with
heavyweight? In fact of the EJ, thats targeted specifically at busi- registries that are not of a gold stan-
8,000 leased commercial ness aircraft. dard.
aircraft in the world today, Thanks to Irelands booming leas- For Shannon airport and its sur-
approximately half are ing industry, our existing EI register rounding region, the EJ register is
has been a huge success, says another way to attract business. The
managed from the Emerald
CENTER Patrick Edmond, MD of IASC. It has airport become independent from the
Ireland wants to
Isle, with Shannon Airport and its over 750 large cabin transport aircraft Dublin Airport Authority in 2013, and
be a hub for surrounding tax free zone on it, many of which never even come since its succeeded in growing traffic
Business serving as a hub for much of to Ireland. That says something about and attracting more business to the
Aviation. this financial activity. its reputation. region.
US Pre-Clearance
Another string to Shannons bow is
that all US bound passengers can have
immigration, customs and agriculture
inspections at Shannon prior to depar-
ture. Pre-clearance saves time and be
very beneficial for Business Aviation
passengers who can fly straight to air-
ports in the US that dont have cus-
toms facilities. Its also very helpful
for passengers who are flying
Business Aviation into to large com-
mercial airports in the US, adds
Patrick.
With all of these advantages in place
it seems the job now to is get out there
and let people what Shannon offers. efficiencies and achieving profit European marketplace. Our transfor-
Would it make sense, for instance, to growth at each of the four separate mation must continue to evolve this
target large Business Aviation MROs business units. The plan also incorpo- year with emphasis on change, contin-
and bring heavy maintenance facilities rates an ambitious capital investment uous improvement and improved effi-
at Shannon? program to ensure the Group remains ciencies, combined with ensuring we
Its something were looking at. We firmly focused on delivering growth continue to build the platform for the
already have three big commercial opportunities, which will be essential future sustainability of Shannon
MROs in Shannon; they form a key to maintain the competitiveness of the Group.
part of the cluster here. They have Groups business. With the creation of our five-year
approvals for airliner based business Through the generation of sustain- strategic plan, we now have a road
jets, but for other aspects of the busi- able growth and profitability across all map on which to build an exciting and
ness jet market we are very keen to of our businesses and by the imple- sustainable future. CONVENIENT
look at how things develop. mentation of our five-year strategic Indeed, Shannon Airports profitabili- US Pre-clearance
Shannon Groups first annual report plan, combined with an ongoing focus ty for the full financial year 2014 at Shannon
noted that it is now embarking on a on innovation, I am confident that improved considerably, with earnings saves time for
programme to address group-wide Shannon Group will make an enduring before interest, taxes, depreciation, passengers.
fic showed the largest gains with a 70% ground," said Derek Collins, General Excellence for Business Aviation,"
increase. Transatlantic traffic contin- Manager, Universal Aviation Ireland - says Pakey. "Universal's new lounge is
ued to perform strongly, increasing by Shannon. "We have listened carefully a high-quality and timely addition to
10% and UK traffic recorded a 5% to our clients' feedback, and we're the services available at the airport,
increase. The Groups intention to proud that we have enhanced our FBO and we credit Universal Aviation for
develop a cargo hub at the airport was with the features and amenities they investing in this way. We look forward
also boosted this week by Turkish requested." to continuing to work successfully
Airlines, through its subsidiary Universal reports that traffic at the with Universal Aviation in the years to
Turkish Cargo, who announced that it FBO (which has been open since May come as we jointly develop more
is to commence Irelands only direct 2003), continues to grow, partly Business Aviation activity at Shannon."
all-cargo air service to North America because they've been busy promoting "Shannon is known for being an
from Shannon. the airport's value-added services, excellent tech stop, but it is also an
such as United States Customs & increasingly popular destination," adds
Universal Aviation Border Protection pre-clearance. Sean Raftery, Managing Director
PRESENCE Revamps Shannon FBO According to Neil Pakey, Chief Universal Aviation UK and Ireland.
Universal One company that has already expe- Executive Officer, Shannon Airport, "This renovation is just the latest in
Aviation is one rienced aviation success at Shannon is Shannon's U.S. pre-clearance facility is our ongoing commitment and invest-
of Shannons Universal Aviation, which recently the only one of its type in either ment to enhancing our clients' experi-
success stories. announced the complete renovation of Europe or the Gulf region and offers ence at strategically important loca-
Renovated FBO its FBO. The update includes a reno- business jet operators the opportunity tions throughout Europe and the
(center left). vated VIP departures lounge as well as to pre-clear Customs & Immigration to world - whether through full ground
Welcoming all new crew and operations the U.S., and proceed directly to their handling facilities or highly cus-
Prince Charles offices."Our focus is always firmly on destination within the U.S. tomized supervisory services."
to Ireland (center our customer, and leaving them with a "Universal Aviation is a key partner
right). memorable experience on the in the development of our Centre of
Our InStructOrS
instructors Wide
range of experience
Skilled Maintenance
Aviation professionals from around the world trust us to provide the highest quality training and outstanding service. Reducing workload, one the many perks of SBAS. SBAS-FMS Family LP/LPV Monitor, UNS-1Lw, -1Fw and -1Ew
More than 1,800 highly experienced professional instructors deliver aircraft- and mission-specific courses, using our
comprehensive training systems and advanced-technology flight simulators designed to enhance safety. Trust your
Visit uasc.com to learn more.
training to FlightSafety. Youll see why so many aviation professionals make the same choice. And have since 1951.
For information, please contact Steve Gross, Vice President, Sales 314.785.7815
sales@flightsafety.com flightsafety.com A Berkshire Hathaway company uasc.com sales@uasc.com (800) 321-5253 (520) 295-2300
158
158 - SEPT - OCT - 2015 OUR 27th YEAR
RUSSIA
CITATION LATITUDE