2014 Supreme Court Decisions

G.R. NO.

120051

215427

193100
204745
165451
198928

187589

184203

1908181

201195
198677

197590

210987

175707/180035/
181092
185969
198076
175410

125346

177332

190021

183421

197228

192398

180290
190198
212536-37

180651

183664

205055
181836
161759
205543

189440

197591
181459
185432
197525
197192

166018, 167728

197561

179260

182399
169778
202071

184360,
184361, 184384

188497
194105
183880
191498
198729-30
190928
197760

2015 Supreme Court Decisions

G.R. NO.

209324

207112
212920

193253

210836
195175 &
199645
 192173

203054-55

210646
167679

175188

207843

207575

207791

187631

200670

209353-54/
211733-34

192024
204117
202789
209830
181756

173241

183531

206019
203774
185115
172509
185666
206526

203351

188016

168950

193383-84/
193407-08
 198756

2016 Supreme Court Decisions

G.R. NO.
195876
209303
193321
183416

212530

216130
199422
215950
194065
195147

180110

205002

215534/215557

213394

182737
202695

180402

180434

G.R. No.
184450/G.R. No.
184508/G.R. No.
184538/G.R. No.
185234
G.R. No.
203514
4 Supreme Court Decisions

CASE

City of Manila, Hon. Alfredo S. Lim, as Mayor of the City of Manila, et al. Vs. Hon. Angel Valera Colet, as Presiding

Philippine Amusement and Gaming Corporation (PAGCOR) Vs. The Bureau of Internal Revenue, et al.

Samar-I Electric Cooperative Vs. Commissioner of Internal Revenue

Mindanao II Geothermal Partnership Vs. Commissioner of Internal Revenue
LG Electronics Philippines, Inc. Vs. Commissioner of Internal Revenue
CBK Power Company Limited Vs. Commissioner of Internal Revenue

Commissioner of Internal Revenue Vs. The Stanley Works Sales (Phils.), Incorporated

City of Lapu-Lapu Vs. Philippine Economic Zone Authority/Prove of Bataan, represented by Governor Enrique T. G

Metro Manila Shopping Mecca Corp., Shoemart, Inc., SM Prime Holdings, Inc., Star Appliances Center, Super Valu

Taganito Mining Corporation Vs. Commissioner of Internal Revenue

Commissioner of Internal Revenue Vs. Basf + Inks Phils, Inc.

Bureau of Internal Revenue, as represented by the Commissioner of Internal Revenue Vs. Court of Appeals, Spou

The Philippine American Life and General Insurance Company Vs. The Secretary of Finance and the Commissione

Fort Bonifacio Development Corporation Vs. Commissioner of Internal Revenue, et al.

AT&T Communications Services Phils., Inc. Vs. Commissioner of Internal Revenue

Taganito Mining Corporation Vs. Commissioner of Internal Revenue
SMI-ED Philippine Technology, Inc. Vs. Commissioner of Internal Revenue

La Suerte Cigar & Cigarette Factory Vs. Court of Appeals, et al/Commissioner of Internal Revenue Vs. Fortune Tob

National Power Corporation Vs. City of Cabanatuan, represented by its City Mayor, Hon. Honorato Perez

Commissioner of Internal Revenue Vs. Burmeistor and Wainscandinavian Contractor Mindanao, Inc.

CIR vs Aichi Forging Company of Asia, inc.

Duty Free Philippines Vs. Bureau of Internal Revenue, represented by Hon. Anselmo G. Adriano, acting Regional D

Commissioner of Internal Revenue Vs. Pilipinas Shell Corporation

Commissioner of Internal Revenue Vs. Philippine National Bank

Commissioner of Internal Revenue Vs. CE Luzon Geothermal Power Company, Inc.
 Commissioner of Internal Revenue and Commissioner of Customs Vs. Philippines Airlines, Inc.

Nursery Care Corporation, et al. Vs. Anthony Acevedo, in his capacity as the Treasurer of Manila, and The City of

Airlift Asia Customs Brokerage Inc., and Allan G. Benedicto Vs. Court of Appeals, CIR

Commissioner of BIR vs. Team Sual Corporation

BPI vs. Commissioner of BIR
Commissioner of Customs vs. Oilink International Corp.
San Roque Power Corp. vs. CIR

CIR vs. Mindana II Geothermal Partnership

Taganito Mining Corp. vs. CIR

CIR vs. MERALCO
Miramar Fish Co. Inc. vs. CIR
Visayas Geothermal Power Co. vs. CIR
CIR vs. The Insular Life Assurance Co. Ltd.

HSBC vs. CIR Vise Versa

Coca-Cola Bottlers Phils., Inc. vs. City of Manila

CIR vs. Team Phils Operations Corp.

CS Garments, Inc.
CIR vs. Silicon Phils., Inc.
Procter & Gamble Asia PTE Ltd. vs. CIR

Silicon Phils., Inc. vs. CIR

CIR vs. Pilipinas Shell Petroleum Corp.

CIR vs. Team Sual Corp.
CIR vs. Toledo Power Co.
CIR vs. Mindanao II Geothermal Partnership
CBK Power Co. Ltd. vs. CIR
Team Energy Corp. vs. CIR
Team Energy Corp. vs. CIR

Supreme Court Decisions

CASE

Republic of the Philippines, represented by the Bureau of Customs Vs. Pilipinas Shell Petroleum Corporation

Pilipinas Total Gas, Inc. vs. Commissioner of Internal Revenue

Commissioner of Internal Revenue Vs. Nippon Express (Phils.) Corporation

Bureau of Customs Vs. The Honorable Agnes Vst Devanadera, et al.

Chevron Philippines, Inc. Vs. Commissioner of Internal Revenue

Commissioner of Internal Revenue Vs. Toledo Power Company

Commissioner of Internal Revenue Vs. Standard Chartered Bank

Commissioner of Internal Revenue Vs. Court of Tax Appeals and CBK Power Company Limited

Commissioner of Internal Revenue Vs. Air Liquide Philippines, Inc.

ING Bank N.V. Vs. Commissioner of Internal Revenue

Commissioner of Internal Revenue Vs. La Tondea Distillers, Inc. (LTDI) [Now Ginebra San Miguel]

Commissioner of Internal Revenue Vs. Court of Tax Appeals (Second Division) and Petron Corporation

Hedcor, Inc. Vs. Commissioner of Internal Revenue

The City of Davao represented by the City Treasurer of Davao City Vs. The intestate Estate of Amado S. Dalisay,

Batangas City, Maria Teresa Geron, In her capacity as City Treasurer of Batangas City, et al. Vs. Pilipinas Shell Pe

Clark Investors and Locators Association, Inc. Vs. Secretary of Finance and Commissioner of Internal Revenue

Republic of the Philippines, rep. by the Commissioner of Customs Vs. Philippine Airlines, Inc. (PAL) / Commissione

Fortune Tobacco Corporation Vs. Commissioner of Internal Revenue

China Banking Corporation Vs. City Treasurer of Manila
Commissioner of Internal Revenue Vs. Puregold Duty Free, Inc.
Mitsubishi Motors Philippines Corporation Vs. Bureau of Customs
Macan Cebu International Airport Authority (MCIAA) Vs. City of Lapu-Lapu, et al.

Silicon Philippines, Inc. (formerly Intel Philippines Manufacturing, Inc.) Vs. Commission of Internal Revenue

Eastern Telecommunications Philippines, Inc. Vs. Commissioner of Internal Revenue

Philippine National Bank Vs. Commissioner of Internal Revenue

Cargill Philippines, Inc. Vs. Commissioner of Internal Revenue
Northern Mindanao Power Corporation Vs. Commissioner of Internal Revenue
China Banking Corporation Vs. Commissioner of Internal Revenue
Nippon Express (Philippines) Corporation Vs. Commissioner of Internal Revenue
Winebrenner & Inigo Insurance Brokers, Inc. Vs. Commissioner of Internal Revenue

Panay Power Corporation (Formerly Avon River Power Holdings Corp.) Vs. Commissioner of Internal Revenue

Commissioner of Internal Revenue vs. Team (Phils.) Energy Corporation (formerly Mirant [Phils.] Energy Corp.)

ROHM Apollo Semiconductor Philippines, Inc. Vs. Commissioner of Internal Revenue

CBK Power Company Limited Vs. Commissioner of Internal Revenue/Commissioner of Internal Revenue Vs. CBK P
 Banco De Oro, Bank of Commerce, China Banking Corporation, Metropolitan Bank & Trust Company, Philippine B

Supreme Court Decisions

CASE
Pilipinas Shell Petroleum Corporation Vs. Commission on Customs
National Power Corporation Vs. The Provincial Treasurer of Benguet, et al.
Tekenaka Corporation - Philippine Branch Vs. Commissioner of Internal Revenue
Provicial Assesor of the Agusan Del Sur Vs. Filipinas Palm Plantation, Inc.

Bloomberry Resorts and Hotels, Inc. Vs. Bureau of Internal Revenue, represented by Commissioner Kim S. Jacinto

Commissioner Internal Revenue Vs. Goodyear Philippines, Inc.

Comissioner of Internal Revenue vs Kepco Corporation
Tridharma Marketing Corporation Vs. Court of Tax Appeals, et al.
Philippine Bank Communications Vs. Commissioner of Internal Revenue
Commissioner Internal Revenue Vs. Philippine National Bank

Capitol Wireless, Inc. Vs. The Provincial Treasurer of Batangas, the Provicial Asseso of Batangas, The Municipal Tr

Commissioner of Customs, Collector of Customs of the Port of Batangas and The Bureu of Customs Vs. Pilipinas S

Commissioner of Internal Revenue Vs. Liquigaz Philippines Corporation/Liquigaz Philippines Corporation/Commis

Spouses Emmanuel D. Paquiao and Jinkee J. Paquiao Vs. The Court of Tax Appeals (1st Division) and the Commis

Silicon Philippines, Inc. Vs. Commissioner of Internal Revenue

Commissioner of Internal Revenue Vs. GJM Philippines Manufacturing, Inc.

Commissioner of Internal Revenue Vs. Pilipinas Shell Petroleum Corporation

Commisioner of Internal Revenue Vs. Mirant Pagbilao Corporation

Jaime N. Soriano, et al. vs. Secretary of Finance and the Commissioner of Internal
Revenue/Senator Manuel A. Roxas vs. Margarito B. Teves and Lilian B. Hefti/Trade Union
Congress of the Philippines (TUCP) represented by its President, Democrito T. Mendoza vs.
Margarito B. Teves, in his capacity as Secretary of the Department of Finance and Lilian B.
Hefti, in her capacity as Commissioner of the Bureau of Internal Revenue/Senator Francis
Joseph G. Escudero, et al. vs. Trade Union Congress of the Philippines (TUCP) represented by
its President, Democrito T. Mendoza vs. Margarito B. Teves, in his capacity as Secretary of
the Department of Finance and Lilian B. Hefti, in her capacity as Commissioner of the
Bureau of Internal Revenue
Commissioner of Internal Revenue vs. St. Luke's Medical Center, Inc.
 DATE LAST NAME FIRST NAME

10-Dec-14 LEHAYAN LYLE

10-Dec-14 MAULIT REYNOLD

10-Dec-14 CUADRA ROSE ANN

8-Dec-14 DIVINAGRACIA JAY ANN
3-Dec-15 FELISCO CARMINA
3-Dec-14 JOCSON JOCELUD

3-Dec-14 GENER ELAINE

26-Nov-14 SOGONGON CUS

10-Nov-14 RIVERA DAVID ISRAEL

26-Nov-14 RAMOS REXFORD

26-Nov-14 PAGSUGUIRAN XHEENA MAE

24-Nov-14 VILLANUEVA JAIRRENE

24-Nov-14 ROXAS ROSE ANN

19-Nov-14 ACERON MAECHENELIE

19-Nov-14 CASTRO MARYLAND

19-Nov-14 ARCIAGA ANA LIZA
12-Nov-14 DELACRUZ ANRIS

11-Nov-14 AGTARAP ALEXIS

1-Oct-14 LIM MARK CHESTER

October 22,
RAMOS GABRIEL JUSTINE
2014
22-Oct-14 DANDAN MA. ELENA

8-Oct-14 DULNUAN GLORIA DIANA

29-Sep-14 MALALUAN-CRUZ RIA

29-Sep-14 HERNANDEZ MARINELLA

17-Sep-14 GALANZA FRANCES ANNE
 27-Aug-14 SEMBRANO HYUGI

30-Jul-14 SALVADOR REY III

28-Jul-14 MONIS MARIA CRISTINA

18-Jul-14 NASIS JOVELYN

9-Jul-14 RIVERA CELESTE MARIE
2-Jul-14 SOTELO ERBY JENNIFER
30-Jun-14 ADALIA CRISTINA
MEDIENNE
18-Jun-14 CASTILLON
ISABELLE
18-Jun-14 FELICIANO LUIGI
9-Jun-14 ANDRES JIMBO
4-Jun-14 ACERON MAECHENELIE
4-Jun-14 ADALIA CRISTINA
4-Jun-14 AGTARAP ALEXIS

4-Jun-14 ANDRES JIMBO

7-Apr-14 ARCIAGA ANA LIZA

MEDIENNE
2-Apr-14 CASTILLON
ISABELLE
12-Mar-14 CASTRO MARYLAND
12-Mar-14 CUADRA ROSE ANN
19-Feb-14 DANDAN MA. ELENA

19-Feb-14 DELACRUZ ANRIS

19-Feb-14 DIVINAGRACIA JAY ANN

5-Feb-14 DULNUAN GLORIA DIANA
20-Jan-14 FELICIANO LUIGI
15-Jan-14 FELISCO CARMINA
15-Jan-14 GALANZA FRANCES ANNE
13-Jan-14 GENER ELAINE
13-Jan-14 HERNANDEZ MARINELLA

DATE

9-Dec-15 JOCSON JOCELUD

8-Dec-15 LEHAYAN LYLE

16-Sep-15 LIM MARK CHESTER

8-Sep-15 MALALUAN-CRUZ RIA

1-Sep-15 MAULIT REYNOLD

10-Aug-15 MONIS MARIA CRISTINA

 29-Jul-15 NASIS JOVELYN

29-Jul-15 PAGSUGUIRAN XHEENA MAE

29-Jul-15 RAMOS GABRIEL JUSTINE

22-Jul-15 RAMOS REXFORD

15-Jul-15 RIVERA DAVID ISRAEL

15-Jul-15 RIVERA CELESTE MARIE

15-Jul-15 ROXAS ROSE ANN

15-Jul-15 SALVADOR REY III

8-Jul-15 SEMBRANO HYUGI

6-Jul-15 SOGONGON CUS

6-Jul-15 SOTELO ERBY JENNIFER

1-Jul-15 VILLANUEVA JAIRRENE

1-Jul-15 ARCIAGA ANA LIZA
22-Jun-15 FELICIANO LUIGI
17-Jun-15 DELACRUZ ANRIS
15-Jun-15 ANDRES JIMBO

25-Mar-15 AGTARAP ALEXIS

25-Mar-15 LEHAYAN LYLE

18-Mar-15 LIM MARK CHESTER

11-Mar-15 MAULIT REYNOLD
18-Feb-15 RAMOS GABRIEL JUSTINE
4-Feb-15 CUADRA ROSE ANN
4-Feb-15 DANDAN MA. ELENA
28-Jan-15 DIVINAGRACIA JAY ANN

21-Jan-15 DULNUAN GLORIA DIANA

January14, 2015 FELISCO CARMINA

14-Jan-15 MALALUAN-CRUZ RIA

14-Jan-15 JOCSON JOCELUD

 13-Jan-15 HERNANDEZ MARINELLA

DATE
5-Dec-16 GENER ELAINE
14-Nov-16 GALANZA FRANCES ANNE
19-Oct-16 SOGONGON CUS
5-Oct-16 SEMBRANO HYUGI

30-Aug-16 RIVERA DAVID ISRAEL

3-Aug-16 SALVADOR REY III

21-Jun-16 RAMOS REXFORD
20-Jun-16 MONIS MARIA CRISTINA
20-Jun-16 NASIS JOVELYN
11-Jun-16 PAGSUGUIRAN XHEENA MAE

30-May-16 RIVERA CELESTE MARIE

20-Apr-16 VILLANUEVA JAIRRENE

18-Apr-16 SOTELO ERBY JENNIFER

6-Apr-16 ROXAS ROSE ANN

2-Mar-16 ADALIA CRISTINA

29-Feb-16 ACERON MAECHENELIE
MEDIENNE
10-Feb-16 CASTILLON
ISABELLE
20-Jan-16 CASTRO MARYLAND

24-Jan-17 ARCIAGA ANA LIZA

13-Feb-17 MALALUAN-CRUZ RIA
Add some people

Ria M. Malaluan-CruzMaryland CastroAxel AgtarapLyle LehayanLuigi FelicianoAris

Cruz Dela CruzReynold-Laila MaulitGabriel Justine RamosRose Ann CuadraGloria
Diana Catti DulnuanMarinella HernandezElaine GenerFranch GalanzaCus
SorongonHyugi SembranoDavid Israel Feliciano RiveraRexford P RamosJovelyn
NasisCeleste Marie Rivera-NugalErby Jennifer Sotelo-Gesell