You are on page 1of 7

Texto

The ABC Daycare Disaster of Hermosillo, Mexico


David G. Greenhalgh, MD,* Philip Chang, MD,* Pirko Maguina, MD,*
Elena Combs,* Soman Sen, MD,* Tina L. Palmieri, MD*

On June 5, 2009, the ABC Daycare facility in Hermosillo, Mexico, caught on fire with an
estimated 142 children and 6 adult caregivers inside. The purpose of this article is to de-
scribe the factors contributing to the disaster including care of the survivors, tertiary burn
center triage, patient transport, and treatment for this international mass casualty event.
Finally, the results of an investigation performed by the Mexican Government are reviewed.
A summary of the Mexican Governments investigation of the circumstances of fire and an
examination of prevention lapses in other Mexican daycare centers was obtained from their
public Web site. The demographic and clinical characteristics of the children transported to
the burn center were obtained from the patients medical records and transport data sheets.
The ABC Daycare had many fire safety breaches that contributed to the severity of the trag-
edy. Twenty-nine children died at the scene and more than 35 children were hospitalized
throughout Mexico. A total of 12 children were transported to two Shriners Hospitals, 9 to
Sacramento, and 3 to Cincinnati. The mean age of patients sent to the Shriners Hospitals
was 2.9 ! 0.16 years (2 4 years), with 5 being male and 7 female. The mean duration be-
tween injury and arrival was 9.2 ! 2.1 days, the burn size was 43.0 ! 6.8% TBSA (6.5
80%), and there were 3.75 operations per patient. Four had fourth-degree burns requiring
finger amputations (2), flaps to cover bone (1), or a through-knee amputation (1). Ten pa-
tients were admitted to the intensive care unit, and nine patients (seven with inhalation in-
jury) required mechanical ventilation for a mean of 23.6 ! 10.3 days. All the surviving chil-
dren were discharged after a mean length of stay of 45.9 ! 8.7 days. In the first year
postinjury, seven children were readmitted a total of 11 times for reconstructive surgery,
wound care, or rehabilitation. Ultimately, a total of 49 children died. A review of other
daycare centers in Mexico revealed similar safety lapses that could lead to future major di-
sasters. This burn disaster in Hermosillo was potentially preventable with adherence to
standard prevention principals. The young age of the victims and the need for an interna-
tional medical response posed special problems. Prevention efforts need to be improved to
prevent future disasters in Mexico. (J Burn Care Res 2012;33:235241)

Burn disasters are unfortunate realities that affect not strumental in the early formation of the burn centers
only the local community but also the entire country. in Boston.1 An air disaster in 1972 inspired local fire-
Disasters from massive fires have had a profound in- fighters to start our adult burn unit in Sacramento,
fluence on burn care and have stimulated advances in California. Fortunately, prevention measures have
burn care. Clearly, the Cocoanut Grove fire was in- been adopted to reduce the incidence of fire disasters in
many regions of the world. Although the frequency has
decreased, fire disasters still kill and injure large number
From the *Burn Department, Shriners Hospitals for Children of people.2 Unfortunately, the same prevention mea-
Northern California; and Department of Surgery, Burn
Division, University of California, Davis, Medical Center, sures have not kept pace in developing worlds. Poor
Sacramento. construction, lack of safety codes, and poor economies
Presented at the 15th Meeting of the International Society for Burn lead to a greater potential for disasters.
Injuries, Istanbul, Turkey, June 25, 2010.
Address correspondence to David G. Greenhalgh, MD, Shriners On June 5, 2009, a large daycare facility (the ABC
Hospitals for Children Northern California and UC Davis Daycare) in Hermosillo, Sonora, Mexico, ignited
Medical Center, 2425 Stockton Boulevard, Sacramento, trapping young children and a few supervising adults.
California 95817.
Copyright 2012 by the American Burn Association. Ultimately, 49 children aged 3 years or younger died.
1559-047X/2012 Children were dispersed throughout Mexico, and 12
DOI: 10.1097/BCR.0b013e3182335948 children were sent to two Shriners Hospitals for Chil-

235
Journal of Burn Care & Research
236 Greenhalgh et al March/April 2012

Figure 1. A schematic layout of the ABC Daycare revealing the location next to the paper warehouse. Just north of the ABC
was a tire store and the other side of the paper warehouse housed a car license warehouse. A gasoline station was just across the
street but fortunately did not ignite during the daycare fire.

dren in the United States. As with any fire disaster, an cue of the children are quite sketchy; so many details
investigation was initiated by the Mexican Govern- such as the sites of all of the deaths are not known.
ment. The results were made available to the public
through a Web site.3 Herein, we present information
about our experience with triage, transportation, and RESULTS
treatment of the children involved in this mass casu-
alty event. The goal of this article is to present the Factors Contributing to the Fire
causes of the fire, describe the dilemmas found in Hermosillo, Mexico, is in the heart of the Sonora
triage and treatment, and finally to improve safety Desert where the temperature, in June, commonly
efforts at schools to prevent future disasters. rises over 100F (37.8C) and has been known to
reach 122F (50C). The ABC Daycare is a part of a
series of daycares within Mexico that provides care for
children of working Mexican citizens. The daycare
METHODS was not owned by the government but we believe that
After obtaining permission from the University of it was subsidized by the government. The Hermosillo
California, Davis Human Subjects Review Commit- ABC Daycare managed up to 150 children in one part
tee patient data were collected from medical records of a warehouse that was a four complex structure
from two of the four Shriners Hospitals for Children (Figure 1). The warehouse had 24 rooms but only
Burn Hospitals (Northern California and Cincin- had 3 exits. Of the three, two doors were locked with
nati). (Boston did not receive any patients, and the the keys reportedly being located in an administrative
fourth Burn Hospital in Galveston was closed at the office desk. The keys were never found. The only exit
time because of hurricane damage.) Data concerning was through the administrative office. East of the day-
the Mexican Governments investigation were ob- care were two large rooms with the adjacent room
tained from their public Web site.3 This Web site, being a document warehouse and the farthest east
written in Spanish, was translated by one of the au- being a license warehouse. Just north of the daycare
thors (P.M.) who grew up in Peru and who is fluent in was a tire store.
Spanish. Some information was provided by the local The daycare and the warehouse shared a common
press (El Imparcial, Hermosillo) and by interviews wall that was made of cinderblocks without concrete
with patients and people present at the time of the filling. Only the daycare had drywall on the inside
disaster. Some pictures were obtained from the Web walls. The wall, according to code, was supposed to
site and others by the authors during subsequent vis- be a 2- to 3-hour fire retardant wall but the daycare
its. Many details of the actual fire and the actual res- was out of compliance. A large door between the
Journal of Burn Care & Research
Volume 33, Number 2 Greenhalgh et al 237

Figure 2. The floor plan of the ABC Daycare reveals the multiple rooms and the sites of the fire (taken from the Mexican
Governments website). Rooms 11 and 12 were next to the site where the fire started. As a result of being the first rooms to
be engulfed, 12 children died in room 11 and 20 died in room 12. The sites of entry created by driving a truck into the wall
are identified. The identity of each room is included: 1, Reception, main door; 2, Infirmary; 3, Toddler room A; 4,
Administration; 5, Kitchen; 6, Pantry; 7, Staff restrooms; 8, Staff breakroom; 9, Small infant restroom; 10, Classroom; 11,
Toddler room B1; 12, Toddler room B2; 13, Toddler room C1; 14, Toddler room C2; 15, Infant feeding room; 16,
Educational materials; 17, Patio; 18, Infant room A-B; 19, Infant room A-B; 20, Infant room C; 21, Play area; 22, Office; 23,
Maintenance; 24, Multipurpose with circus PVC tent ceiling.

daycare and warehouse had been closed with cinder- is likely that the polyvinyl chloride circus tent ceil-
blocks with the repurposing of the daycare (Figure 2). ing rapidly flashed over to create an explosive fire.
The roof was made of tin and was lined inside with In addition, the investigators felt that the ceiling tiles
polyurethane foam. There were ceiling tiles in the also ignited creating a rain of fire that involved
daycare rooms and in the large central area was a many of the rooms near the paper warehouse.
polyvinyl chloride circus tent cover. These materi- There were several factors that impeded the rescue
als were highly flammable. of the children. The only door that was open was
through the administrative office and the key to the
The Fire and Resulting Injuries other door was in a drawer and was unable to be
The children, estimated to be 142 in number, were found. Rescuers and family members arrived but were
almost all less than 5 years of age. Supervision was frustrated by the inability to enter the facility. Fire-
provided by six adults. The fire started in a cooler (a fighters attempted to use sledge hammers to break
form of air conditioner) in the paper warehouse (the down the wall. One parent used his truck as a batter-
building next to the daycare). The temperature on ing ram to create four holes in the cinderblock wall.
that day was 43C (109F), so the cooler was running Rescuers used these holes to extract the children.
continuously. Investigation of the fire revealed that Most of the deaths occurred deep inside the daycare
the damage to the coolers motor was more severe next to the document warehouse. Because this area
than its casing confirming that it was the source. Mo- was farthest away from the entry sites of the rescuers,
tor coils melted and likely caused sparks to ignite the it is likely that delays in finding these children con-
engine. In addition, there were hand-twisted wires tributed to their mortalities.
connected to the motor which was plugged into an Of the 148 people estimated to be inside the day-
extension cord with multiple plugs. The fire rapidly care, 29 children died at the scene (14 boys and 15
traveled to the nursery through the single wall and it girls). All of the deaths were in very young children (7
Journal of Burn Care & Research
238 Greenhalgh et al March/April 2012

children aged 3 years, 21 children aged 2 years, and 1 Table 1. Characteristics of the 12 children transferred
infant aged nine months). All but one child died of from the ABC Daycare to the Shriners Hospitals for
inhalation injury with the other child dying of his or Children, Northern California and Cincinnati
her burns. Of the 131 people injured in this fire, 75 Age (yr) 2.92 ! 0.16 (24)
children and 6 adults sustained burns. The adult in- Male/female 5/7
juries were relatively minor. Seventy-six had inhala- Time between injury and 9.2 ! 2.1
tion injury and were treated as outpatients. The chil- admission (d)
dren were sent to six local hospitals (Hospital Chavez, Burn size (%) 43.0 ! 6.8 (6.580) TBSA
4; Clinica del Noroeste, 2; Hospital General del Es- ICU length of stay (d), N " 10 30.6 ! 9.5
tado, 15; Centro Internacional de Medicina, 4; Hos- Ventilator days (d), N " 9 23.6 ! 10.3
pital Infantil de Sonora, 12; and Clinica 36, 2), and Total length of stay (d) 42.5 ! 8.2
Deaths 2
eventually some were sent to other hospitals in Mex-
Length of stay of survivors (d) 45.9 ! 8.7
ico (Guadalajara Centro Medico del Occidente, 8;
Obregon Hospital de Especialidades Numero 1, 5). Values expressed as mean ! SE of the mean (range).
Twenty-eight children were treated in hospitals and ICU, intensive care unit.
survived. Ultimately, 20 more children died in hospi-
tals, with 18 dying in Mexico and 2 expiring in 2
different Shriners Hospitals (Northern California and more detail (Table 1). The first child arrived in Cali-
Cincinnati). Thus, the total number of deaths ulti- fornia 1 day after the disaster. One or two of the
mately reached 49. There were 75 children and 6 children arrived daily for the ensuing week. The first
adults injured, leading to a total of 131 people suf- few were transported by the Mexican Air Force and
fering from some form of injury. the rest were transported by private transport compa-
nies. Cincinnati received their first patient 1 week
The Shriners Hospital Experience after the fire with the other two arriving around 3
Starting the day after the fire, transfers of the most weeks after injury. One of the patients transferred to
severely burned children to the Shriners Hospitals for Cincinnati was in such critical condition that she died
Children in the United States began. The Shriners within 24 hours of arrival.
Hospitals provide free care to children with burns in The mean age of the 5 boys and 7 girls transported
North America, including Mexico. Normally, the to the Shriners Hospitals was 2.9 years (2 4 years).
Galveston and Northern California Hospitals are the The mean burn size was 43% (6.5 80%) TBSA. The
pediatric tertiary referral centers for Mexico but at faces and hands were severely affected with many
this time Galveston was still closed after damage from needing finger amputations. Ten patients were ad-
Hurricane Ike. The Northern California Hospital is mitted to the intensive care unit and seven had smoke
the primary referral site for the Hermosillo region. inhalation injury. The mean number of ventilator
Transfer of patients to a Shriners Hospital is at the days was 23.6 (range 1 86) days, mean intensive care
request of the referring physician. The process is ini- unit stay of 22.9 (range 1 86) days, and the mean
tiated with a phone call, and if the patient is younger length of stay was 45.9 (range 194) days. Because of
than 18 years, acceptance is universal. The triage for the distance away from home and the ability for the
this disaster was orchestrated by one of the burn sur- Shriners Hospitals to keep children in an outpatient or
geons (T.L.P.) who triaged patient referrals to the inpatient facility, many children stayed at the hospital for
Shriners Hospitals based on acuity. To assist with therapy or social issues. All the children required surgical
triage, one of the Shriners surgeons (P.M.) traveled excision and grafting of their burn injuries. On the av-
to Hermosillo, Guadalajara, and Obregon. The hos- erage, each child required 3.75 operations (range 0 9).
pitals in the latter two cities did not wish to transfer The one girl required nine operations including multi-
any children (except one who was sent in extremis ple local flaps performed to cover exposed lower ex-
later in her hospital course). A total of 12 children tremity bones. Two children required amputations of
with the most severe burns were transferred to two of fingers, and one child from Cincinnati required a
the Shriners Hospitals over approximately 2 weeks through-knee amputation. Two children died of sepsis
after the fire. The Mexican Air Force transported and multiple organ dysfunction syndrome, one died 50
most of the children. Cincinnati accepted three pa- days after admission in Northern California, and one,
tients (45, 48, and 61% expired). The experience transferred in extremis, died the day after admission in
with the 12 children transferred to Shriners Hospitals Cincinnati (21 days after burn).
for Children Northern California and Shriners Hos- During the first year after their burns, seven chil-
pitals for Children Cincinnati will be described in dren required readmission for various reasons. There
Journal of Burn Care & Research
Volume 33, Number 2 Greenhalgh et al 239

were nine reconstructive procedures performed dur- nut Grove Nightclub.1 An excellent summary of the
ing these admissions. One child required readmission disaster was chronicled by Dr. Jeffrey Saffle in 1993.
for a chronic scalp wound and another required read- This summary reveals striking parallels to the ABC
mission for rehabilitation. In the ensuing 6 months, tragedy. The nightclub was overcrowded and filled
several children required further reconstructive pro- with flammable materials. Similar to the tent-like
cedures. The majority of these procedures have been ceiling in the ABC Daycare, the nightclub had a
for hand or facial reconstruction. Most of these chil- highly flammable blue satin ceiling in the room where
dren will require further reconstructive procedures to the fire started. Once the fire started, many doors
optimize their functional and cosmetic outcomes. were locked or difficult to find. The main exit was a
rotating door that rapidly became blocked by people
Safety Evaluation of the ABC Daycare and crushed by the crowds desperately pushing others to
Other Mexican Daycares escape. Another exit had a door that opened into the
The ABC Daycare disaster incited outrage through- room and so it was also blocked by the crush of ter-
out Mexico. In response and as per routine, the Mex- rified occupants. Those inside the building mainly
ican Government performed an evaluation of the died from hypoxia and smoke inhalation injury.
safety practices in the ABC Daycare and daycares Those who escaped also had severe inhalation injury
throughout Mexico. The results of these evaluations as documented by people showing up in Emergency
are published on a Web site produced by the govern- Departments and suddenly dying in front of provid-
ment review.3 The review revealed profound safety ers. Similar stories were reported in Hermosillo. We
lapses. At the ABC Daycare, there were no smoke were told that children arrived at the hospitals just
detectors, no fire extinguishers, no fire alarms, no seemed to stop breathing and died. As for Her-
emergency exits, no valid license to operate a daycare, mosillo, the Cocoanut Grove Nightclub had recently
no municipal inspections, no fire marshal inspections, passed fire code inspections, but there were reports of
and improper building materials (highly flammable violations that were ignored with possible political
materials circus tent ceiling). These lapses existed implications (not so for the ABC Daycare).
despite a report of passing an inspection on May 26, Of the many other fire disasters, the stories are very
2009 (10 days before the tragedy). similar. People are trapped inside a building with
These findings prompted a government inspection flammable materials rapidly flashing over to create a
of another 1480 daycares throughout Mexico. The major fire. In the panic to escape, people are trapped
results of this inspection were just as dismal. Overall, because the available exits are inadequate or are
53% had no valid license to function as a nursery and blocked so that people are crushed and overcome by
32% had no license to have a business in the building. the toxic and hypoxic smoke. The lessons learned in
In addition, 70% had no fire inspections, 75% had no developed countries have led to many building codes
fire drills, 72% had unacceptable electric installations, and regulations that have been strictly enforced.
and 52% had unacceptable gas installations. Of those These laws have led to a decrease in the numbers of
that were inspected, 85% failed at least one inspec- deaths in disasters between the first and second halves
tion. The inspections revealed that 43% had a smoke of the 20th century.2 Fire inspections are much
detector, 6% had no emergency exit, 13% had an stricter in the industrialized countries than in coun-
emergency exit greater than 40 m from the class- tries with lower economic status. Clearly, Mexico has
room, 86% had doors that pushed outward, and 6% knowledge of safety codes, but the compliance and
had fire extinguishers. Of those who failed inspection, enforcement of these codes is very lax. The survey of
77% did not implement any changes. other daycare centers confirmed major problems in
burn prevention regulations in the country. Unless
major changes occur, a similar disaster awaits Mexico.
DISCUSSION Mexico has suffered from previous fire tragedies.
There have been many fire-related disasters involving The most notable disaster occurred in 1984 in San
hundreds to even more than thousand deaths.2,4 11 Juanico.12 This town, 20 km north of Mexico City,
Documenting the causes of each disaster is essential was next to a major liquid petroleum gas storage fa-
to prevent future tragedies. These lessons should be cility. Over the course of years, houses had been built
translated into laws and codes that prevent similar within 130 m of the facility. Some of the houses were
lapses leading to more disasters. The ABC Daycare constructed illegally (too close to the facility) and
disaster has many characteristics that are very similar the streets were very narrow. In addition, there
to previously reported fire disasters. The best docu- were no water pipes in the town to use for extin-
mented disaster was the 1942 fire at Bostons Cocoa- guishing fires. On November 19, 1984, a boiling-
Journal of Burn Care & Research
240 Greenhalgh et al March/April 2012

liquid expanding-vapor explosion occurred to ig- ment of the laws and punishment of those schools
nite several of the storage tanks. Clouds of explosive which do not follow the codes.
vapor leaked and spread toward the town and then What became evident with the ABC Daycare di-
ignited. The explosions started at 5:35 AM in the saster was the limited amount of resources for burn
morning in a sleeping village. In the end, 300 people treatment in the Northwestern region of Mexico.
died at the scene and another 250 died in hospitals. As a matter of fact, the number of burn care facil-
The review describes 7230 people injured with 1970 ities in the entire country seemed to be inadequate.
hospitalized and 625 suffering from severe thermal One positive effect of the ABC Daycare disaster is
injuries. The injured were treated in various trauma the willingness of the country to address the burn
and burn centers. One center, Centro Medico, was care shortcomings. One must give credit to the
described as having a 48-bed burn unit but had re- government for examining other daycares to deter-
ceived 37 patients from another silo explosion 3 mine how extensive the shortcomings really are.
days before the San Juanico disaster. They received 88 Clearly, there are severe problems with the safety in
more burn patients from the liquid petroleum gas ex- these facilities. A second benefit is the govern-
plosion. In the end, there was an admirable gathering of ments recent efforts to improve Mexicos ability to
resources to treat the burn victims of this disaster. treat burn patients. There is a move to develop
There have also been several fire disasters at schools more burn care facilities in several communities
which have resulted in hundreds of deaths in chil- including Hermosillo. The government has also
dren.2,13 On March 8, 1908, 176 children died in the supported the training of burn team members in
Lakeview Elementary School, Collingwood, OH. On burn units in the United States (including ours). A
May 17, 1923, 76 children died at the Cleveland fellowship to train burn surgeons, supported by the
Rural Grade School in Camden, SC; and on Decem- Mexican Government, has been started in the Sac-
ramento, California, burn program.
ber 24, 1924, 36 more died in Babbs Switch School
in Hobart, OK. In an explosion with no subsequent
fire, 298 children died in the New London School- CONCLUSION
house in 1937. In 1958, at the Our Lady of Angels
(an appropriate name) School in Chicago, a fire A disaster is tragic enough because of the loss of
trapped many children resulting in 95 deaths and 93 potentially productive citizens. A burn conflagra-
injuries (many from children jumping out of windows tion involving very young children is even more
from the second floor).13 Locked exits also contrib- tragic. What would be worse, however, is if a disas-
uted to the high mortality rate in this fire. The ABC ter does not stimulate changes that might prevent
Daycare disaster in Hermosillo has many of the same future similar disasters from occurring. The ABC
characteristics as the previous pediatric tragedies. Daycare disaster had all the characteristics of many
Children, especially the very young, are more vulner- previous disasters that have occurred throughout
able because they lack many of the decision capabili- the world. Let us hope that lessons can be learned
to prevent future disasters from recurring not only
ties of adults. The ABC Daycare was especially vul-
in daycares and schools but also in all regions of the
nerable because most of the children were under 3
world. One can only hope that the disaster spurs
years of age and thus were dependent on adults for
better prevention strategies and better burn care
assistance with escaping the fire. Inadequate super-
facilities in Mexico.
vision, based on the low number of adults super-
vising, undoubtedly contributed to the deaths in
these children. These school disasters also make it REFERENCES
very clear why fire drills are extremely valuable to
1. Saffle JR. The 1942 fire at Bostons Cocoanut Grove Night-
train children as what to do in case of a real fire. club. Am J Surg 1993;166:58191.
Many factors were against the children; lack of su- 2. Barillo DJ, Wolf S. Planning for burn disasters: lessons
learned from one hundred years of history. J Burn Care Res
pervision, extremely flammable materials, lack of 2006;27:62234.
fire alarms and fire drills, and lack of adequate and 3. Informe Preliminar Sobre el Ejercicio de la Facultdad de
appropriate exits all made the odds of surviving the Investigacion 1/2009; available from http://www.scjn.
gob.mx/Documents/Informe_Preliminar_Comision_
Hermosillo daycare disaster very slim. One must ABC.pdf. Accessed May 11, 2010.
hope that improvements are enforced in schools in 4. Kuijper EC. The 2003 Everett Idris Evans Memorial Lecture:
the future. Mexico must examine its laws, codes, every cloud has a silver lining. J Burn Care Rehabil 2004;25:
4553.
and regulations to ensure the safety of children in 5. Vaghela KR. Plastic surgery and burns disasters. What impact
schools. Even more important will be the enforce- do major civilian disasters have upon medicine? Bradford City
Journal of Burn Care & Research
Volume 33, Number 2 Greenhalgh et al 241

Football Club stadium fire, 1985, Kings Cross Underground ing a combined burn trauma disaster in the post-9/11 world:
fire, 1987, Piper Alpha offshore rig disaster, 1988. J Plast lessons learned from the 2003 West Pharmaceutical Plant
Reconstr Aesth Surg 2009;62:755 63. explosion. J Burn Care Rehabil 2005;26:144 50.
6. Jordan MH, Hollowed KA, Turner DG, Wang DS, Jeng JC. 10. Lundin T, Jansson L. Traumatic impact of a fire disaster on
The Pentagon attack of September 11, 2001: the burn cen- survivorsa 25-year follow-up of the 1978 hotel fire in Bo-
ters experience. J Burn Care Rehabil 2005;26:109 16. ras, Sweden. Nord J Psychiatry 2007;61:479 85.
7. Yurt RW, Bessey PQ, Bauer GJ, et al. A regional burn centers 11. Potin M, Senechaud C, Carsin H, et al. Mass casualty inci-
response to a disaster: September 11, 2001, and the days dents with multiple burn victims: rationale for a Swiss burn
beyond. J Burn Care Rehabil 2005;26:11724. plan. Burns 2010;36:74150.
8. Mozingo DW, Barillo DJ, Holcomb JB. The Pope Air Force 12. Arturson G. The tragedy of San Juanicothe most severe
Base aircraft crash and burn disaster. J Burn Care Rehabil LPG disaster in history. Burns 1987;13:87102.
2005;26:132 40. 13. Cowan D. Great Chicago fires: historic blazes that shaped a
9. Cairns BA, Stiffler A, Price F, Peck MD, Meyer AA. Manag- city. Chicago: Lake Claremont Press; 2001.

You might also like