Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Little is known of the earliest mathematics, but the famous Ishango Bone from Early
Stone-Age Africa has tally marks suggesting arithmetic. The markings include six
prime numbers (5, 7, 11, 13, 17, 19) in order, though this is probably coincidence.
The advanced artifacts of Egypt's Old Kingdom and the Indus-Harrapa civilization
imply strong mathematical skill, but the first written evidence of advanced arithmetic
dates from Sumeria, where 4500-year old clay tablets show multiplication and
division problems; the first abacus may be about this old. By 3600 years ago,
Mesopotamian tablets show tables of squares, cubes, reciprocals, and even logarithms,
using a primitive place-value system (in base 60, not 10). Babylonians were familiar
with the Pythagorean Theorem, solutions to quadratic equations, even cubic equations
(though they didn't have a general solution for these), and eventually even developed
methods to estimate terms for compound interest.
Also at least 3600 years ago, the Egyptian scribe Ahmes produced a famous
manuscript (now called the Rhind Papyrus), itself a copy of a late Middle Kingdom
text. It showed simple algebra methods and included a table giving optimal
expressions using Egyptian fractions. (Today, Egyptian fractions lead to challenging
number theory problems with no practical applications, but they may have had
practical value for the Egyptians. To divide 17 grain bushels among 21 workers, the
equation 17/21 = 1/2 + 1/6 + 1/7 has practical value, especially when compared with
the "greedy" decomposition 17/21 = 1/2 + 1/4 + 1/17 + 1/1428.)
The Pyramids demonstrate that Egyptians were adept at geometry, though little
written evidence survives. Babylon was much more advanced than Egypt at arithmetic
and algebra; this was probably due, at least in part, to their place-value system. But
although their base-60 system survives (e.g. in the division of hours and degrees into
minutes and seconds) the Babylonian notation, which used the equivalent of IIIIII
XXXXXIIIIIII XXXXIII to denote 417+43/60, was unwieldy compared to the "ten
digits of the Hindus." (In 2016 historians were surprised to decode ancient Babylonian
texts and find very sophisticated astronomical calculations of Jupiter's orbit.)
The Egyptians used the approximation (4/3)4 (derived from the idea that a circle
of diameter 9 has about the same area as a square of side 8). Although the ancient
Hindu mathematician Apastambha had achieved a good approximation for 2, and the
ancient Babylonians an ever better 2, neither of these ancient cultures achieved
a approximation as good as Egypt's, or better than 25/8, until the Alexandrian
era.
The earliest mathematician to whom definite teachings can be ascribed was Lagadha,
who apparently lived about 1300 BC and used geometry and elementary trigonometry
for his astronomy. Baudhayana lived about 800 BC and also wrote on algebra and
geometry; Yajnavalkya lived about the same time and is credited with the then-best
approximation to . Apastambha did work summarized below; other early Vedic
mathematicians solved quadratic and simultaneous equations.
Other early cultures also developed some mathematics. The ancient Mayans
apparently had a place-value system with zero before the Hindus did; Aztec
architecture implies practical geometry skills. Ancient China certainly developed
mathematics, though little written evidence survives prior to Chang Tshang's famous
book.
Thales was the Chief of the "Seven Sages" of ancient Greece, and has been called the
"Father of Science," the "Founder of Abstract Geometry," and the "First Philosopher."
Thales is believed to have studied mathematics under Egyptians, who in turn were
aware of much older mathematics from Mesopotamia. Thales may have invented the
notion of compass-and-straightedge construction. Several fundamental theorems about
triangles are attributed to Thales, including the law of similar triangles (which Thales
used famously to calculate the height of the Great Pyramid) and "Thales' Theorem"
itself: the fact that any angle inscribed in a semicircle is a right angle. (The other
"theorems" were probably more like well-known axioms, but Thales proved Thales'
Theorem using two of his other theorems; it is said that Thales then sacrificed an ox to
celebrate what might have been the very first mathematical proof!) Thales noted that,
given a line segment of length x, a segment of length x/k can be constructed by first
constructing a segment of length kx.
Thales was also an astronomer; he invented the 365-day calendar, introduced the use
of Ursa Minor for finding North, invented the gnomonic map projection (the first of
many methods known today to map (part of) the surface of a sphere to a plane, and is
the first person believed to have correctly predicted a solar eclipse. His theories of
physics would seem quaint today, but he seems to have been the first to describe
magnetism and static electricity. Aristotle said, "To Thales the primary question was
not what do we know, but how do we know it." Thales was also a politician, ethicist,
and military strategist. It is said he once leased all available olive presses after
predicting a good olive season; he did this not for the wealth itself, but as a
demonstration of the use of intelligence in business. Thales' writings have not
survived and are known only second-hand. Since his famous theorems of geometry
were probably already known in ancient Babylon, his importance derives from
imparting the notions of mathematical proof and the scientific method to ancient
Greeks.
Thales' student and successor was Anaximander, who is often called the "First
Scientist" instead of Thales: his theories were more firmly based on experimentation
and logic, while Thales still relied on some animistic interpretations. Anaximander is
famous for astronomy, cartography and sundials, and also enunciated a theory of
evolution, that land species somehow developed from primordial fish! Anaximander's
most famous student, in turn, was Pythagoras. (The methods of Thales and Pythagoras
led to the schools of Plato and Euclid, an intellectual blossoming unequaled until
Europe's Renaissance. For this reason Thales may belong on this list for his historical
importance despite his relative lack of mathematical achievements.)
Despite Pythagoras' historical importance I may have ranked him too high: many
results of the Pythagoreans were due to his students; none of their writings survive;
and what is known is reported second-hand, and possibly exaggerated, by Plato and
others. Some ideas attributed to him were probably first enunciated by successors like
Parmenides of Elea (ca 515-440 BC). Archaeologists now believe that he was not first
to invent the diatonic scale: Here is a diatonic-scale song from Ugarit which predates
Pythagoras by eight centuries.
Pythagoras discovered that harmonious intervals in music are based on simple rational
numbers. This led to a fascination with integers and mystic numerology; he is
sometimes called the "Father of Numbers" and once said "Number rules the universe."
(About the mathematical basis of music, Leibniz later wrote, "Music is the pleasure
the human soul experiences from counting without being aware that it is counting."
Other mathematicians who investigated the arithmetic of music included Huygens,
Euler and Simon Stevin.)
The Pythagorean Theorem was known long before Pythagoras, but he is often credited
with the first proof. (Apastambha proved it in India at about the same time; some
conjecture that Pythagoras journeyed to India and learned of the proof there.) He may
have discovered the simple parametric form of primitive Pythagorean triplets (xx-yy,
2xy, xx+yy), although the first explicit mention of this may be in Euclid's Elements.
Other discoveries of the Pythagorean school include the construction of the regular
pentagon, concepts of perfect and amicable numbers, polygonal numbers, golden ratio
(attributed to Theano), three of the five regular solids (attributed to Pythagoras
himself), and irrational numbers (attributed to Hippasus). It is said that the discovery
of irrational numbers upset the Pythagoreans so much they tossed Hippasus into the
ocean! (Another version has Hippasus banished for revealing the secret for
constructing the sphere which circumscribes a dodecahedron.)
Panini's great accomplishment was his study of the Sanskrit language, especially in
his text Ashtadhyayi. Although this work might be considered the very first study of
linguistics or grammar, it used a non-obvious elegance that would not be equaled in
the West until the 20th century. Linguistics may seem an unlikely qualification for a
"great mathematician," but language theory is a field of mathematics. The works of
eminent 20th-century linguists and computer scientists like Chomsky, Backus, Post
and Church are seen to resemble Panini's work 25 centuries earlier. Panini's
systematic study of Sanskrit may have inspired the development of Indian science and
algebra. Panini has been called "the Indian Euclid" since the rigor of his grammar is
comparable to Euclid's geometry.
Although his great texts have been preserved, little else is known about Panini. Some
scholars would place his dates a century later than shown here; he may or may not
have been the same person as the famous poet Panini. In any case, he was the very last
Vedic Sanskrit scholar by definition: his text formed the transition to the Classic
Sanskrit period. Panini has been called "one of the most innovative people in the
whole development of knowledge;" his grammar "one of the greatest monuments of
human intelligence."
Zeno of Elea (ca 495-435 BC) Greek domain
Zeno, a student of Parmenides, had great fame in ancient Greece. This fame, which
continues to the present-day, is largely due to his paradoxes of infinitesimals, e.g. his
argument that Achilles can never catch the tortoise (whenever Achilles arrives at the
tortoise's last position, the tortoise has moved on). Although some regard these
paradoxes as simple fallacies, they have been contemplated for many centuries. It is
due to these paradoxes that the use of infinitesimals, which provides the basis for
mathematical analysis, has been regarded as a non-rigorous heuristic and is finally
viewed as sound only after the work of the great 19th-century rigorists, Dedekind and
Weierstrass. (Eubulides was another ancient Greek famous for paradoxes, e.g. "This
statement is a lie" -- the sort of inconsistency later used in proofs by Gdel and
Turing.)
Zeno's Arrow Paradox (at any single instant an arrow is at a fixed position, so where
does its motion come from?) has lent its name to to the Quantum Zeno Effect, a
paradox of quantum physics.
Hippocrates (no known relation to Hippocrates of Cos, the famous physician) wrote
his own Elements more than a century before Euclid. Only fragments survive but it
apparently used axiomatic-based proofs similar to Euclid's and contains many of the
same theorems. Hippocrates is said to have invented the reductio ad absurdem proof
method. Hippocrates is most famous for his work on the three ancient geometric
quandaries: his work on cube-doubling (the Delian Problem) laid the groundwork for
successful efforts by Archytas and others; his circle quadrature was of course
ultimately unsuccessful but he did prove ingenious theorems about "lunes" (certain
circle fragments); and some claim Hippocrates was first to trisect the general angle.
Hippocrates also did work in algebra and rudimentary analysis.
(Doubling the cube and angle trisection are often called "impossible," but they are
impossible only when restricted to collapsing compass and unmarkable straightedge.
There are ingenious solutions available with other tools. Construction of the regular
heptagon is another such task, with solutions published by four of the men on this
List.)
Some scholars think Pythagoras and Thales are partly mythical. If we take that view,
Archytas (and Hippocrates) should be promoted in this list.
Eudoxus journeyed widely for his education, despite that he was not wealthy, studying
mathematics with Archytas in Tarentum, medicine with Philiston in Sicily, philosophy
with Plato in Athens, continuing his mathematics study in Egypt, touring the Eastern
Mediterranean with his own students and finally returned to Cnidus where he
established himself as astronomer, physician, and ethicist. What is known of him is
second-hand, through the writings of Euclid and others, but he was one of the most
creative mathematicians of the ancient world.
Many of the theorems in Euclid's Elements were first proved by Eudoxus. While
Pythagoras had been horrified by the discovery of irrational numbers, Eudoxus is
famous for incorporating them into arithmetic. He also developed the earliest
techniques of the infinitesimal calculus; Archimedes credits Eudoxus with inventing a
principle eventually called the Axiom of Archimedes: it avoids Zeno's paradoxes by, in
effect, forbidding infinities and infinitesimals. Eudoxus' work with irrational numbers,
infinitesimals and limits eventually inspired masters like Dedekind. Eudoxus also
introduced an Axiom of Continuity; he was a pioneer in solid geometry; and he
developed his own solution to the Delian cube-doubling problem. Eudoxus was the
first great mathematical astronomer; he developed the complicated ancient theory of
planetary orbits; and may have invented the astrolabe. He may have invented the
365.25-day calendar based on leap years, though it remained for Julius Caesar to
popularize it. (It is sometimes said that he knew that the Earth rotates around the Sun,
but that appears to be false; it is instead Aristarchus of Samos, as cited by
Archimedes, who may be the first "heliocentrist.")
Four of Eudoxus' most famous discoveries were the volume of a cone, extension of
arithmetic to the irrationals, summing formula for geometric series, and viewing as
the limit of polygonal perimeters. None of these seems difficult today, but it does
seem remarkable that they were all first achieved by the same man. Eudoxus has been
quoted as saying "Willingly would I burn to death like Phaeton, were this the price for
reaching the sun and learning its shape, its size and its substance."
Aristotle is considered the greatest scientist of the ancient world, and the most
influential philosopher and logician ever; he ranks #13 on Michael Hart's list of the
Most Influential Persons in History. His science was a standard curriculum for almost
2000 years. Although the physical sciences couldn't advance until the discoveries by
great men like Newton and Lavoisier, Aristotle's biology and anatomy were superb,
serving as paradigm until modern times.
Aristotle was personal tutor to the young Alexander the Great. Aristotle's writings on
definitions, axioms and proofs may have influenced Euclid. He was also the first
mathematician to write on the subject of infinity. His writings include geometric
theorems, some with proofs different from Euclid's or missing from Euclid altogether;
one of these (which is seen only in Aristotle's work prior to Apollonius) is that a circle
is the locus of points whose distances from two given points are in constant ratio.
Even if, as is widely agreed, Aristotle's geometric theorems were not his own work,
his status as the most influential logician and philosopher makes him a candidate for
the List.
There are many famous quotations about Euclid and his books. Abraham Lincoln
abandoned his law studies when he didn't know what "demonstrate" meant and "went
home to my father's house [to read Euclid], and stayed there till I could give any
proposition in the six books of Euclid at sight. I then found out what demonstrate
means, and went back to my law studies."
Archimedes discovered formulae for the volume and surface area of a sphere, and
may even have been first to notice and prove the simple relationship between a circle's
circumference and area. For these reasons, is often called Archimedes' constant. His
approximation 223/71 < < 22/7 was the best of his day. (Apollonius soon surpassed
it, but by using Archimedes' method.) Archimedes' Equiarea Map Theorem asserts
that a sphere and its enclosing cylinder have equal surface area (as do the figures'
truncations). Archimedes also proved that the volume of that sphere is two-thirds the
volume of the cylinder. He requested that a representation of such a sphere and
cylinder be inscribed on his tomb.
That Archimedes shared the attitude of later mathematicians like Hardy and Brouwer
is suggested by Plutarch's comment that Archimedes regarded applied mathematics
"as ignoble and sordid ... and did not deign to [write about his mechanical inventions;
instead] he placed his whole ambition in those speculations the beauty and subtlety of
which are untainted by any admixture of the common needs of life."
Some of Archimedes' greatest writings (including The Method and Floating Bodies)
are preserved only on a palimpsest rediscovered in 1906 and mostly deciphered only
after 1998. Ideas unique to that work are an anticipation of Riemann integration,
calculating the volume of a cylindrical wedge (previously first attributed to Kepler);
along with Oresme and Galileo he was among the few to comment on the
"equinumerosity paradox" (the fact that are as many perfect squares as integers).
Although Euler and Newton may have been the most important mathematicians, and
Gauss, Weierstrass and Riemann the greatest theorem provers, it is widely accepted
that Archimedes was the greatest genius who ever lived. Yet, Hart omits him
altogether from his list of Most Influential Persons: Archimedes was simply too far
ahead of his time to have great historical significance. (Some think the Scientific
Revolution would have begun sooner had The Method been discovered four or five
centuries earlier. You can read a 1912 translation of parts of The Method on-line.)
Eratosthenes was one of the greatest polymaths; he is called the Father of Geography,
was Chief Librarian at Alexandria, was a poet, music theorist, astronomer (e.g.
calculating the Earth's diameter, distance to the Sun, etc.), mechanical engineer
(anticipating laws of elasticity, etc.), and was an outstanding mathematician. He is
famous for his prime number Sieve, but more impressive was his work on the cube-
doubling problem which he related to the design of siege weapons (catapults) where a
cube-root calculation is needed.
Eratosthenes had the nickname Beta; he was a master of several fields, but was only
second-best of his time. His better was also his good friend: Archimedes of Syracuse
dedicated The Method to Eratosthenes.
In evaluating the genius of the ancient Greeks, it is well to remember that their
achievements were made without the convenience of modern notation. It is clear from
his writing that Apollonius almost developed the analytic geometry of Descartes, but
failed due to the lack of such elementary concepts as negative numbers. Leibniz wrote
"He who understands Archimedes and Apollonius will admire less the achievements
of the foremost men of later times."
Chinese mathematicians excelled for thousands of years, and were first to discover
various algebraic and geometric principles. There is some evidence that Chinese
writings influenced India and the Islamic Empire, and thus, indirectly, Europe.
Although there were great Chinese mathematicians a thousand years before the Han
Dynasty, and innovations continued for centuries after Han, the textbook Nine
Chapters on the Mathematical Art has special importance. Nine Chapters (known in
Chinese as Jiu Zhang Suan Shu or Chiu Chang Suan Shu) was apparently written
during the early Han Dynasty (about 165 BC) by Chang Tshang (also spelled Zhang
Cang).
Nine Chapters was probably based on earlier books, lost during the great book
burning of 212 BC, and Chang himself may have been a lord who commissioned
others to prepare the book. Moreover, important revisions and commentaries were
added after Chang, notably by Liu Hui (ca 220-280). Although Liu Hui mentions
Chang's skill, it isn't clear Chang had the mathematical genius to qualify for this list,
but he would still be a strong candidate due to his book's immense historical
importance: It was the dominant Chinese mathematical text for centuries, and had
great influence throughout the Far East. After Chang, Chinese mathematics continued
to flourish, discovering trigonometry, matrix methods, the Binomial Theorem, etc.
Some of the teachings made their way to India, and from there to the Islamic world
and Europe. There is some evidence that the Hindus borrowed the decimal system
itself from books like Nine Chapters.
No one person can be credited with the invention of the decimal system, but key roles
were played by early Chinese (Chang Tshang and Liu Hui), Brahmagupta (and earlier
Hindus including Aryabhata), and Leonardo Fibonacci. (After Fibonacci, Europe still
did not embrace the decimal system until the works of Vieta, Stevin, and Napier.)
Ptolemy may be the most famous astronomer before Copernicus, but he borrowed
heavily from Hipparchus, who might be considered the greatest astronomer ever
(ahead even of Galileo and Edwin Hubble). Careful study of the errors in the catalogs
of Ptolemy and Hipparchus reveal both that Ptolemy borrowed his data from
Hipparchus, and that Hipparchus used principles of spherical trig to simplify his work.
Classical Hindu astronomers, including the 6th-century genius Aryabhata, borrow
much from Ptolemy and Hipparchus.
Menelaus wrote several books on geometry and trigonometry, mostly lost except for
his works on solid geometry. His work was cited by Ptolemy, Pappus, and Thabit;
especially the Theorem of Menelaus itself which is a fundamental and difficult
theorem very useful in projective geometry. He also contributed much to spherical
trigonometry. Disdaining indirect proofs (anticipating later-day constructivists)
Menelaus found new, more fruitful proofs for several of Euclid's results.
Ptolemy was one of the most famous of ancient Greek scientists. Among his
mathematical results, most famous may be Ptolemy's Theorem
(ACBD = ABCD + BCAD if and only if ABCD is a cyclic quadrilateral). This
theorem has many useful corollaries; it was frequently applied in Copernicus' work.
Ptolemy also wrote on trigonometry, optics, geography, map projections, and
astrology; but is most famous for his astronomy, where he perfected the geocentric
model of planetary motions. For this work, Cardano included Ptolemy on his List of
12 Greatest Geniuses (but removed him from the list after learning of Copernicus'
discovery).
The mystery of celestial motions directed scientific inquiry for thousands of years.
With the notable exception of the Pythagorean Philolaus of Croton, thinkers generally
assumed that the Earth was the center of the universe, but it becomes very difficult to
explain the orbits of the other planets. This problem had been considered by Eudoxus,
Apollonius, and Hipparchus, who developed a very complicated geocentric model
involving concentric spheres and epicyles. Ptolemy perfected (or, rather, complicated)
this model even further, introducing 'equants' to further fine-tune the orbital speeds;
this model was the standard for 14 centuries. While some Greeks, notably Aristarchus
and Seleucus of Seleucia, proposed heliocentric models, these were rejected because
there was no parallax among stars. (Aristarchus guessed that the stars were at an
almost unimaginable distance, explaining the lack of parallax. Aristarchus would be
almost unknown except that Archimedes mentions, and assumes, Aristarchus'
heliocentrism in The Sand Reckoner. I suspect that Archimedes accepted
heliocentrism, but thought saying so openly would distract from his work. Hipparchus
was another ancient Greek who considered heliocentrism but, because he never
guessed that orbits were ellipses rather than cascaded circles, was unable to come up
with a heliocentric model that fit his data.) Aryabhata, Alhazen, Alberuni, and
Regiomontanus are other great mathematicians who at least accepted the possibility of
heliocentrism.
The great skill demonstrated by Ptolemy and his predecessors in developing their
complex geocentric cosmology may have set back science since in fact the Earth
rotates around the Sun. The geocentric models couldn't explain the observed changes
in the brightness of Mars or Venus, but it was the phases of Venus, discovered by
Galileo after the invention of the telescope, that finally led to general acceptance of
heliocentrism. (Since the planets move without friction, their motions offer a pure
view of the Laws of Motion; thus the heliocentric breakthroughs of Copernicus,
Kepler and Newton triggered the advances in mathematical physics which led to
Scientific Revolution.)
Liu Hui made major improvements to Chang's influential textbook Nine Chapters,
making him among the most important of Chinese mathematicians ever. (He seems to
have been a much better mathematician than Chang, but just as Newton might have
gotten nowhere without Kepler, Vieta, Huygens, Fermat, Wallis, Cavalieri, etc., so
Liu Hui might have achieved little had Chang not preserved the ancient Chinese
learnings.) Among Liu's achievements are an emphasis on generalizations and proofs,
incorporation of negative numbers into arithmetic, an early recognition of the notions
of infinitesimals and limits, the Gaussian elimination method of solving simultaneous
linear equations, calculations of solid volumes (including the use of Cavalieri's
Principle), anticipation of Horner's Method, and a new method to calculate square
roots. Like Archimedes, Liu discovered the formula for a circle's area; however he
failed to calculate a sphere's volume, writing "Let us leave this problem to whoever
can tell the truth."
Although it was almost child's-play for any of them, Archimedes, Apollonius, and
Hipparchus had all improved precision of 's estimate. It seems fitting that Liu Hui
did join that select company of record setters: He developed a recurrence formula for
regular polygons allowing arbitrarily-close approximations for . He also devised an
interpolation formula to simplify that calculation; this yielded the "good-enough"
value 3.1416, which is still taught today in primary schools. (Liu's successors in China
included Zu Chongzhi, who did determine sphere's volume, and whose approximation
for held the accuracy record for nine centuries.)
Very little is known about Diophantus (he might even have come from Babylonia,
whose algebraic ideas he borrowed). Many of his works have been lost, including
proofs for lemmas cited in the surviving work, some of which are so difficult it would
almost stagger the imagination to believe Diophantus really had proofs. Among these
are Fermat's conjecture (Lagrange's theorem) that every integer is the sum of four
squares, and the following: "Given any positive rationals a, b with a>b, there exist
positive rationals c, d such that a3-b3 = c3+d3." (This latter "lemma" was investigated
by Vieta and Fermat and finally solved, with some difficulty, in the 19th century. It
seems unlikely that Diophantus actually had proofs for such "lemmas.")
Pappus, along with Diophantus, may have been one of the two greatest Western
mathematicians during the 13 centuries that separated Hipparchus and Fibonacci. He
wrote about arithmetic methods, plane and solid geometry, the axiomatic method,
celestial motions and mechanics. In addition to his own original research, his texts are
noteworthy for preserving works of earlier mathematicians that would otherwise have
been lost.
Pappus' best and most original result, and the one which gave him most pride, may be
the Pappus Centroid theorems (fundamental, difficult and powerful theorems of solid
geometry later rediscovered by Paul Guldin). His other ingenious geometric theorems
include Desargues' Homology Theorem (which Pappus attributes to Euclid), an early
form of Pascal's Hexagram Theorem, called Pappus' Hexagon Theorem and related to
a fundamental theorem: Two projective pencils can always be brought into a
perspective position. For these theorems, Pappus is sometimes called the "Father of
Projective Geometry." Pappus also demonstrated how to perform angle trisection and
cube doubling if one can use mechanical curves like a conchoid or hyperbola. He
stated (but didn't prove) the Isoperimetric Theorem, also writing "Bees know this fact
which is useful to them, that the hexagon ... will hold more honey for the same
material than [a square or triangle]." (That a honeycomb partition minimizes material
for an equal-area partitioning was finally proved in 1999 by Thomas Hales, who also
proved the related Kepler Conjecture.) Pappus stated, but did not fully solve,
the Problem of Pappus which, given an arbitrary collection of lines in the plane, asks
for the locus of points whose distances to the lines have a certain relationship. This
problem was a major inspiration for Descartes and was finally fully solved by
Newton.
For preserving the teachings of Euclid and Apollonius, as well as his own theorems of
geometry, Pappus certainly belongs on a list of great ancient mathematicians. But
these teachings lay dormant during Europe's Dark Ages, diminishing Pappus'
historical significance.
Alexander the Great spread Greek culture to Egypt and much of the Orient; thus even
Hindu mathematics may owe something to the Greeks. Greece was eventually
absorbed into the Roman Empire (with Archimedes himself famously killed by a
Roman soldier). Rome did not pursue pure science as Greece had (as we've seen, the
important mathematicians of the Roman era were based in the Hellenic East) and
eventually Europe fell into a Dark Age. The Greek emphasis on pure mathematics and
proofs was key to the future of mathematics, but they were missing an even more
important catalyst: a decimal place-value system based on zero and nine other
symbols.
Decimal system -- from India? China?? Persia???
It's still hard to believe that the "obvious" and so-convenient decimal system didn't
catch on in Europe until the late Renaissance. Ancient Greeks, by the way, did not use
the unwieldy Roman numerals, but rather used 27 symbols, denoting 1 to 9, 10 to 90,
and 100 to 900. Unlike our system, with ten digits separate from the alphabet, the 27
Greek number symbols were the same as their alphabet's letters; this might have
hindered the development of "syncopated" notation. The most ancient Hindu records
did not use the ten digits of Aryabhata, but rather a system similar to that of the
ancient Greeks, suggesting that China, and not India, may indeed be the "ultimate"
source of the modern decimal system.
The Chinese used a form of decimal abacus as early as 3000 BC; if it doesn't qualify,
by itself, as a "decimal system" then pictorial depictions of its numbers would. Yet for
thousands of years after its abacus, China had no zero symbol other than plain space;
and apparently didn't have one until after the Hindus. Ancient Persians and
Mayans did have place-value notation with zero symbols, but neither qualify as
inventing a base-10 decimal system: Persia used the base-60 Babylonian system;
Mayans used base-20. (Another difference is that the Hindus had nine distinct digit
symbols to go with their zero, while earlier place-value systems built up from just two
symbols: 1 and either 5 or 10.) The Old Kingdom Egyptians did use a base-ten
system, but it was not place-value (1, 10, 100 were depicted as separate symbols).
Conclusion: The decimal place-value system with zero symbol seems to be an obvious
invention that in fact was very hard to invent. If you insist on a single winner then
India might be it. But China, Babylonia, Persia and even the Mayans deserve
Honorable Mention!
Indian mathematicians excelled for thousands of years, and eventually even developed
advanced techniques like Taylor series before Europeans did, but they are denied
credit because of Western ascendancy. Among the Hindu mathematicians, Aryabhata
(called Arjehir by Arabs) may be most famous.
While Europe was in its early "Dark Age," Aryabhata advanced arithmetic, algebra,
elementary analysis, and especially plane and spherical trigonometry, using the
decimal system. Aryabhata is sometimes called the "Father of Algebra" instead of al-
Khowrizmi (who himself cites the work of Aryabhata). His most famous
accomplishment in mathematics was the Aryabhata Algorithm(connected to continued
fractions) for solving Diophantine equations. Aryabhata made several important
discoveries in astronomy, e.g. the nature of moonlight, and concept of sidereal year;
his estimate of the Earth's circumference was more accurate than any achieved in
ancient Greece. He was among the very few ancient scholars who realized the Earth
rotated daily on an axis; claims that he also espoused heliocentric orbits are
controversial, but may be confirmed by the writings of al-Biruni. Aryabhata is said to
have introduced the constant e. He used 3.1416; it is unclear whether he
discovered this independently or borrowed it from Liu Hui of China. Although it was
first discovered by Nicomachus three centuries earlier, Aryabhata is famous for the
identity
(k3) = ( k)2
Thabit produced important books in philosophy (including perhaps the famous mystic
work De Imaginibus), medicine, mechanics, astronomy, and especially several
mathematical fields: analysis, non-Euclidean geometry, trigonometry, arithmetic,
number theory. As well as being an original thinker, Thabit was a key translator of
ancient Greek writings; he translated Archimedes' otherwise-lost Book of Lemmas and
applied one of its methods to construct a regular heptagon. He developed an important
new cosmology superior to Ptolemy's (and which, though it was not heliocentric, may
have inspired Copernicus). He was perhaps the first great mathematician to take the
important step of emphasizing real numbers rather than either rational numbers or
geometric sizes. He worked in plane and spherical trigonometry, and with cubic
equations. He was an earlier practitioner of calculus and seems to have been first to
take the integral of x. Like Archimedes, he was able to calculate the area of an
ellipse, and to calculate the volume of a paraboloid. He produced an elegant
generalization of the Pythagorean Theorem:
AC 2 + BC 2 = AB (AR + BS)
(Here the triangle ABC is not a right triangle, but R and S are located on AB to give
the equal angles ACB = ARC = BSC.) Thabit also worked in number theory where he
is especially famous for his theorem about amicable numbers. While many of his
discoveries in geometry, plane and spherical trigonometry, and analysis (parabola
quadrature, trigonometric law, principle of lever) duplicated work by Archimedes and
Pappus, Thabit's list of novel achievements is impressive. Among the several great
and famous Baghdad geometers, Thabit may have had the greatest genius.
Ibn Sinan, grandson of Thabit ibn Qurra, was one of the greatest Islamic
mathematicians and might have surpassed the great Thabit had he not died at a young
age. He was an early pioneer of analytic geometry, advancing the theory of
integration, applying algebra to synthetic geometry, and writing on the construction of
conic sections. He produced a new proof of Archimedes' famous formula for the area
of a parabolic section. He worked on the theory of area-preserving transformations,
with applications to map-making. He also advanced astronomical theory, and wrote a
treatise on sundials.
Mohammed ibn al-Hasn (Alhazen) `Abu Ali' ibn al-Haytham al-Basra (965-1039)
Iraq, Egypt
In number theory, Alhazen worked with perfect numbers, Mersenne primes, the
Chinese Remainder Theorem; and stated Wilson's Conjecture (sometimes called Al-
Haytham's Theorem though it was first proven by Lagrange). He introduced the
Power Series Theorem (later attributed to Jacob Bernoulli). His best mathematical
work was with plane and solid geometry, especially conic sections; he calculated the
areas of lunes, volumes of paraboloids, and constructed a heptagon using intersecting
parabolas. He solved Alhazen's Billiard Problem (originally posed as a problem in
mirror design), a difficult construction which continued to intrigue several great
mathematicians including Huygens. To solve it, Alhazen needed to anticipate
Descartes' analytic geometry, anticipate Bzout's Theorem, tackle quartic equations
and develop a rudimentary integral calculus. Alhazen's attempts to prove the Parallel
Postulate make him (along with Thabit ibn Qurra) one of the earliest mathematicians
to investigate non-Euclidean geometry.
Al-Biruni has left us what seems to be the oldest surviving mention of the Broken
Chord Theorem (if M is the midpoint of circular arc ABMC, and T the midpoint of
"broken chord" ABC, then MT is perpendicular to BC). Although he himself
attributed the theorem to Archimedes, Al-Biruni provided several novel proofs for,
and useful corollaries of, this famous geometric gem. While Al-Biruni may lack the
influence and mathematical brilliance to qualify for the Top 100, he deserves
recognition as one of the greatest applied mathematicians before the modern era.
Omar Khayym (aka Ghiyas od-Din Abol-Fath Omar ibn Ebrahim Khayyam
Neyshaburi) is sometimes called the greatest Islamic mathematician. He did clever
work with geometry, developing an alternate to Euclid's Parallel Postulate and then
deriving the parallel result using theorems based on the Khayyam-Saccheri
quadrilateral. He derived solutions to cubic equations using the intersection of conic
sections with circles. Remarkably, he stated that the cubic solution could not be
achieved with straightedge and compass, a fact that wouldn't be proved until the 19th
century. Khayym did even more important work in algebra, writing an influential
textbook, and developing new solutions for various higher-degree equations. He may
have been first to develop Pascal's Triangle (which is still called Khayym's Triangle
in Persia), along with the essential Binomial Theorem (Al-Khayym's Formula):
(x+y)n = n! xkyn-k / k!(n-k)!
Khayym was also an important astronomer; he measured the year far more accurately
than ever before, improved the Persian calendar, and built a famous star map. He
emphasized science over religion and proved that the Earth rotates around the Sun.
His symbol ('shay') for an unknown in an algebraic equation might have been
transliterated to become our 'x'. He also wrote treatises on philosophy, music,
mechanics and natural science. Despite his great achievements in algebra, geometry,
and astronomy, today Omar al-Khayym is most famous for his rich poetry (The
Rubaiyat of Omar Khayym).
Bhscara (also called Bhaskara II or Bhaskaracharya) may have been the greatest of
the Hindu mathematicians. He made achievements in several fields of mathematics
including some Europe wouldn't learn until the time of Euler. His textbooks dealt with
many matters, including solid geometry, combinations, and advanced arithmetic
methods. He was also an astronomer. (It is sometimes claimed that his equations for
planetary motions anticipated the Laws of Motion discovered by Kepler and Newton,
but this claim is doubtful.) In algebra, he solved various equations including 2nd-order
Diophantine, quartic, Brouncker's and Pell's equations. His Chakravala method, an
early application of mathematical induction to solve 2nd-order equations, has been
called "the finest thing achieved in the theory of numbers before Lagrange" (although
a similar statement was made about one of Fibonacci's theorems). (Earlier Hindus,
including Brahmagupta, contributed to this method.) In several ways he anticipated
calculus: he used Rolle's Theorem; he may have been first to use the fact that dsin x
= cos x dx; and he once wrote that multiplication by 0/0 could be "useful in
astronomy." In trigonometry, which he valued for its own beauty as well as practical
applications, he developed spherical trig and was first to present the identity
sin a+b = sin a cos b + sin b cos a
Bhscara's achievements came centuries before similar discoveries in Europe. It is an
open riddle of history whether any of Bhscara's teachings trickled into Europe in
time to influence its Scientific Renaissance. (Another mathematician, Bhscara I who
lived five centuries before Bhscara II, was also outstanding. He was famous for
advancing the positional decimal number notation, for a formula giving an excellent
approximation to the sin function, and for being first to state Wilson's Conjecture.)
Leonardo is most famous for his book Liber Abaci, but his Liber
Quadratorum provides the best demonstration of his skill. He defined congruums and
proved theorems about them, including a theorem establishing the conditions for three
square numbers to be in consecutive arithmetic series; this has been called the finest
work in number theory prior to Fermat (although a similar statement was made about
one of Bhaskara's theorems). Although often overlooked, this work includes a proof
of the n = 4 case of Fermat's Last Theorem. (Leonardo's proof of FLT4 is widely
ignored or considered incomplete. I'm preparing a page to consider that question.)
Another of Leonardo's noteworthy achievements was proving that the roots of a
certain cubic equation could not have any of the constructible forms Euclid had
outlined in Book 10 of his Elements.
Leonardo provided Europe with the decimal system, algebra and the 'lattice' method
of multiplication, all far superior to the methods then in use. He introduced notation
like 3/5; his clever extension of this for quantities like 5 yards, 2 feet, and 3 inches is
more efficient than today's notation. It seems hard to believe but before the decimal
system, mathematicians had no notation for zero. Referring to this system, Gauss was
later to exclaim "To what heights would science now be raised if Archimedes had
made that discovery!"
... as a consequence of marvelous instruction in the art, to the nine digits of the
Hindus, the knowledge of the art very much appealed to me before all others, and for
it I realized that all its aspects were studied in Egypt, Syria, Greece, Sicily, and
Provence, with their varying methods;
... But all this even, and the algorism, as well as the art of Pythagoras, I considered as
almost a mistake in respect to the method of the Hindus. Therefore, embracing more
stringently that method of the Hindus, and taking stricter pains in its study, while
adding certain things from my own understanding and inserting also certain things
from the niceties of Euclid's geometric art, I have striven to compose this book in its
entirety as understandably as I could, ...
Had the Scientific Renaissance begun in the Islamic Empire, someone like al-
Khowrizmi would have greater historic significance than Fibonacci, but the
Renaissance did happen in Europe.Liber Abaci's summary of the decimal system has
been called "the most important sentence ever written." Even granting this to be an
exaggeration, there is no doubt that the Scientific Revolution owes a huge debt to
Leonardo `Fibonacci' Pisano.
Tusi was one of the greatest Islamic polymaths, working in theology, ethics, logic,
astronomy, and other fields of science. He was a famous scholar and prolific writer,
describing evolution of species, stating that the Milky Way was composed of stars,
and mentioning conservation of mass in his writings on chemistry. He made a wide
range of contributions to astronomy, and (along with Omar Khayym) was one of the
most significant astronomers between Ptolemy and Copernicus. He improved on the
Ptolemaic model of planetary orbits, and even wrote about (though rejecting) the
possibility of heliocentrism.
Tusi is most famous for his mathematics. He advanced algebra, arithmetic, geometry,
trigonometry, and even foundations, working with real numbers and lengths of curves.
For his texts and theorems, he may be called the "Father of Trigonometry;" he was
first to properly state and prove several theorems of planar and spherical trigonometry
including the Law of Sines, and the (spherical) Law of Tangents. He wrote important
commentaries on works of earlier Greek and Islamic mathematicians; he attempted to
prove Euclid's Parallel Postulate. Tusi's writings influenced European mathematicians
including Wallis; his revisions of the Ptolemaic model led him to the Tusi-couple, a
special case of trochoids usually called Copernicus' Theorem, though historians have
concluded Copernicus discovered this theorem by reading Tusi.
There were several important Chinese mathematicians in the 13th century, of whom
Qin Jiushao (Ch'in Chiu-Shao) may have had particularly outstanding breadth and
genius. Qin's textbook discusses various algebraic procedures, includes word
problems requiring quartic or quintic equations, explains a version of Horner's
Method for finding solutions to such equations, includes Heron's Formula for a
triangle's area, and introduces the zero symbol and decimal fractions. Qin's work on
the Chinese Remainder Theorem was very impressive, finding solutions in cases
which later stumped Euler.
Other great Chinese mathematicians of that era are Li Zhi, Yang Hui (Pascal's
Triangle is still called Yang Hui's Triangle in China), and Zhu Shiejie. Their teachings
did not make their way to Europe, but were read by the Japanese mathematician Seki,
and possibly by Islamic mathematicians like Al-Kashi. Although Qin was a soldier
and governor noted for corruption, with mathematics just a hobby, I've chosen him to
represent this group because of the key advances which appear first in his writings.
Zhu Shiejie was more famous and influential than Qin; historian George Sarton called
him "one of the greatest mathematicians ... of all time." Zhu is especially famous for
his work with multivariate polynomials; he anticipated the Sylvester matrix method
for solving simultaneous polynomial equations.
Gersonides (aka Leo de Bagnols, aka RaLBaG) was a Jewish scholar of great renown,
preferring science and reason over religious orthodoxy. He wrote important
commentaries on Aristotle, Euclid, the Talmud, and the Bible; he is most famous for
his book MilHamot Adonai ("The Wars of the Lord") which touches on many
theological questions. He was likely the most talented scientist of his time: he
invented the "Jacob's Staff" which became an important navigation tool; described the
principles of the camera obscura; etc. In mathematics, Gersonides wrote texts on
trigonometry, calculation of cube roots, rules of arithmetic, etc.; and gave rigorous
derivations of rules of combinatorics. He was first to make explicit use of
mathematical induction. At that time, "harmonic numbers" referred to integers with
only 2 and 3 as prime factors; Gersonides solved a problem of music theory with an
ingenious proof that there were no consecutive harmonic numbers larger than (8,9).
Levi ben Gerson published only in Hebrew so, although some of his work was
translated into Latin during his lifetime, his influence was limited; much of his work
was re-invented three centuries later; and many histories of math overlook him
altogether.
Gersonides was also an outstanding astronomer. He proved that the fixed stars were at
a huge distance, and found other flaws in the Ptolemaic model. But he specifically
rejected heliocentrism, noteworthy since it implies that heliocentrism was under
consideration at the time.
Oresme was of lowly birth but excelled at school (where he was taught by the famous
Jean Buridan), became a young professor, and soon personal chaplain to King Charles
V. The King commissioned him to translate the works of Aristotle into French (with
Oresme thus playing key roles in the development of both French science and French
language), and rewarded him by making him a Bishop. He wrote several books; was a
renowned philosopher and natural scientist (challenging several of Aristotle's ideas);
contributed to economics (e.g. anticipating Gresham's Law) and to optics (he was first
to posit curved refraction). Although the Earth's annual orbit around the Sun was left
to Copernicus, Oresme was among the pre-Copernican thinkers to claim clearly that
the Earth spun daily on its axis.
In mathematics, Oresme observed that the integers were equinumerous with the odd
integers; was first to use fractional (and even irrational) exponents; introduced the
symbol + for addition; was first to write about general curvature; and, most famously,
first to prove the divergence of the harmonic series. Oresme used a graphical diagram
to demonstrate the Merton College Theorem (a discovery related to Galileo's Law of
Falling Bodies made by Thomas Bradwardine, et al); it is said this was the first
abstract graph. (Some believe that this effort inspired Descartes' coordinate geometry
and Galileo.) Oresme was aware of Gersonides' work on harmonic numbers and was
among those who attempted to link music theory to the ratios of celestial orbits,
writing "the heavens are like a man who sings a melody and at the same time dances,
thus making music ... in song and in action." Oresme's work was influential; with
several discoveries ahead of his time, Oresme deserves to be better known.
Despite the accomplishments of the Kerala school, Madhava probably does not
deserve a place on our List. There were several other great mathematicians who
contributed to Kerala's achievements, some of which were made 150 years after
Madhava's death. More importantly, the work was not propagated outside Kerala, so
had almost no effect on the development of mathematics.
Ghiyath al-Din Jamshid Mas'ud Al-Kashi (ca 1380-1429) Iran, Transoxania (Uzbekistan)
Al-Kashi was among the greatest calculaters in the ancient world; wrote important
texts applying arithmetic and algebra to problems in astronomy, mensuration and
accounting; and developed trig tables far more accurate than earlier tables. He worked
with binomial coefficients, invented astronomical calculating machines, developed
spherical trig, and is credited with various theorems of trigonometry including the
Law of Cosines, which is sometimes called Al-Kashi's Theorem. He is sometimes
credited with the invention of decimal fractions (though he worked mainly with
sexagesimal fractions), and a method like Horner's to calculate roots. However
decimal fractions had been used earlier, e.g. by Qin Jiushao; and Al-Kashi's root
calculations may also have been derived from Chinese texts by Qin Jiushao or Zhu
Shiejie.
Using his methods, al-Kashi calculated correctly to 17 significant digits, breaking
Madhava's record. (This record was subsequently broken by relative unknowns: a
German ca. 1600, John Machin 1706. In 1949 the calculation record was held
briefly by John von Neumann and the ENIAC.)
Regiomontanus was a prodigy who entered University at age eleven, studied under the
influential Georg von Peuerbach, and eventually collaborated with him. He was an
important astronomer; he found flaws in Ptolemy's system, realized lunar observations
could be used to determine longitude, and may have believed in heliocentrism. His
ephemeris was used by Columbus, when shipwrecked on Jamaica, to predict a lunar
eclipse, thus dazzling the natives and perhaps saving his crew. More importantly,
Regiomontanus was one of the most influential mathematicians of the Middle Ages;
he published trigonometry textbooks and tables, as well as the best textbook on
arithmetic and algebra of his time. (Regiomontanus lived shortly after Gutenberg, and
founded the first scientific press.) He was a prodigious reader of Greek and Latin
translations, and most of his results were copied from Greek or Arabic works;
however he improved or reconstructed many of the proofs, and often presented
solutions in both geometric and algebraic form. His algebra was more symbolic and
general than his predecessors'; he solved cubic equations (though not the general
case); applied Chinese remainder methods, and worked in number theory. He posed
and solved a variety of clever geometric puzzles, including his famous angle
maximization problem. Regiomontanus was also an instrument maker, astrologer, and
Catholic bishop.
Leonardo da Vinci is most renowned for his paintings -- Mona Lisa and The Last
Supper are among the most discussed and admired paintings ever -- but he did much
other work and was probably the most talented, versatile and prolific polymath ever to
live; his writings exceed 13,000 folios. He developed new techniques, and principles
of perspective geometry, for drawing, painting and sculpture; he was also an expert
architect and engineer; and surely the most prolific inventor of all time. Although
most of his paper designs were never built, Leonardo's inventions include reflecting
and refracting telescope, adding machine, parabolic compass, improved anemometer,
parachute, helicopter, flying ornithopter, several war machines (multi-barreled gun,
steam-driven cannon, tank, giant crossbow, finned mortar shells, portable bridge),
pumps, an accurate spring-operated clock, bobbin winder, robots, scuba gear, an
elaborate musical instrument he called the 'viola organista,' and more. (Some of his
designs, including the viola organista and a large single-span bridge, were finally built
five centuries later.) He developed the mechanical theory of the arch; made advances
in anatomy, botany, and other fields of science; he was first to conceive of plate
tectonics. He was also a poet and musician.
He had little formal training in mathematics until he was in his mid-40's, when he and
Luca Pacioli (the other great Italian mathematician of that era) began tutoring each
other. Despite this slow start, he did make novel achievements in mathematics: he was
first to note the simple classification of symmetry groups on the plane, may have
discovered a new elegant proof of the Pythagorean Theorem, achieved interesting
bisections and mensurations, and developed an approximate solution to the circle-
squaring problem. He was first to discover the 60-vertex shape now called
"buckyball." Along with Archimedes, Alberuni, Leibniz, and J. W. von Goethe,
Leonardo da Vinci was among the greatest geniuses ever; but none of these appears
on Hart's List of the Most Influential Persons in History: genius doesn't imply
influence. (However, M.I.T. prepared a list of the Twenty Most Influential Persons in
History; their list includes five missing from Hart's list: Gandhi, Leonardo,
Archimedes, Socrates and Nelson Mandela.)
Leonardo was also a writer and philosopher. Among his notable adages are
"Simplicity is the ultimate sophistication," and "The noblest pleasure is the joy of
understanding," and "Human ingenuity ... will never discover any inventions more
beautiful, more simple or more practical than those of nature."
Until the Protestant Reformation, which began about the time of Copernicus'
discovery, European scientists were reluctant to challenge the Catholic Church and its
belief in geocentrism. Copernicus' book was published only posthumously. It remains
controversial whether earlier Islamic or Hindu mathematicians (or even Archimedes
with his The Sand Reckoner) believed in heliocentrism, but were also inhibited by
religious orthodoxy.
Girolamo Cardano (or Jerome Cardan) was a highly respected physician and was first
to describe typhoid fever. He was also an accomplished gambler and chess player and
wrote an early book on probability. He was also a remarkable inventor: the
combination lock, an advanced gimbal, a ciphering tool, and the Cardan shaft with
universal joints are all his inventions and are in use to this day. (The U-joint is
sometimes called the Cardan joint.) He also helped develop the camera obscura.
Cardano made contributions to physics: he noted that projectile trajectories are
parabolas, and may have been first to note the impossibility of perpetual motion
machines. He did work in philosophy, geology, hydrodynamics, music; he wrote
books on medicine and an encyclopedia of natural science.
But Cardano is most remembered for his achievements in mathematics. He was first to
publish general solutions to cubic and quartic equations, and first to publish the use of
complex numbers in calculations. (Cardano's Italian colleagues deserve much credit:
Ferrari first solved the quartic, he or Tartaglia the cubic; and Bombelli first treated the
complex numbers as numbers in their own right. Cardano may have been
the last great mathematician unwilling to deal with negative numbers: his treatment of
cubic equations had to deal with ax3 - bx + c = 0 and ax3 - bx = c as two different
cases.) Cardano introduced binomial coefficients and the Binomial Theorem, and
introduced and solved the geometric hypocyloid problem, as well as other geometric
theorems (e.g. the theorem underlying the 2:1 spur wheel which converts circular to
reciprocal rectilinear motion). Cardano is credited with Cardano's Ring Puzzle, still
manufactured today and related to the Tower of Hanoi puzzle. (This puzzle may
predate Cardano, and may even have been known in ancient China.) Da Vinci and
Galileo may have been more influential than Cardano, but of the three great
generalists in the century before Kepler, it seems clear that Cardano was the most
accomplished mathematician.
Cardano's life had tragic elements. Throughout his life he was tormented that his
father (a friend of Leonardo da Vinci) married his mother only after Cardano was
born. (And his mother tried several times to abort him.) Cardano's reputation for
gambling and aggression interfered with his career. He practiced astrology and was
imprisoned for heresy when he cast a horoscope for Jesus. (This and other problems
were due in part to revenge by Tartaglia for Cardano's revealing his secret algebra
formulae.) His son apparently murdered his own wife. Leibniz wrote of Cardano:
"Cardano was a great man with all his faults; without them, he would have been
incomparable."
Franois Vite (or Franciscus Vieta) was a French nobleman and lawyer who was a
favorite of King Henry IV and eventually became a royal privy councillor. In one
notable accomplishment he broke the Spanish diplomatic code, allowing the French
government to read Spain's messages and publish a secret Spanish letter; this
apparently led to the end of the Huguenot Wars of Religion.
More importantly, Vieta was certainly the best French mathematician prior to
Descartes and Fermat. He laid the groundwork for modern mathematics; his works
were the primary teaching for both Descartes and Fermat; Isaac Newton also studied
Vieta. In his role as a young tutor Vieta used decimal numbers before they were
popularized by Simon Stevin and may have guessed that planetary orbits were ellipses
before Kepler. Vieta did work in geometry, reconstructing and publishing proofs for
Apollonius' lost theorems, including all ten cases of the general Problem of
Apollonius. Vieta also used his new algebraic techniques to construct a regular
heptagon. He discovered several trigonometric identities including a generalization of
Ptolemy's Formula, the latter (then called prosthaphaeresis) providing a calculation
shortcut similar to logarithms in that multiplication is reduced to addition (or
exponentiation reduced to multiplication). Vieta also used trigonometry to find real
solutions to cubic equations for which the Italian methods had required complex-
number arithmetic; he also used trigonometry to solve a particular 45th-degree
equation that had been posed as a challenge. Such trigonometric formulae
revolutionized calculations and may even have helped stimulate the development and
use of logarithms by Napier and Kepler. He developed the first infinite-product
formula for . In addition to his geometry and trigonometry, he also found results in
number theory, but Vieta is most famous for his systematic use of decimal notation
and variable letters, for which he is sometimes called the "Father of Modern Algebra."
(Vieta used A,E,I,O,U for unknowns and consonants for parameters; it was Descartes
who first used X,Y,Z for unknowns and A,B,C for parameters.) In his works Vieta
emphasized the relationships between algebraic expressions and geometric
constructions. One key insight he had is that addends must be homogeneous (i.e.,
"apples shouldn't be added to oranges"), a seemingly trivial idea but which can aid
intuition even today.
Descartes, who once wrote "I began where Vieta finished," is now extremely famous,
while Vieta is much less known. (He isn't even mentioned once in Bell's famous Men
of Mathematics.) Many would now agree this is due in large measure to Descartes'
deliberate deprecations of competitors in his quest for personal glory. (Vieta wasn't
particularly humble either, calling himself the "French Apollonius.")
PI := 2
Y := 0
LOOP:
Y := SQRT(Y + 2)
PI := PI * 2 / Y
IF (more precision needed) GOTO LOOP
Vieta's formula for is clumsy to express without trigonometry, even with modern
notation. Easiest may be to consider it the result of the BASIC program above. Using
this formula, Vieta constructed an approximation to that was best-yet by a
European, though not as accurate as al-Kashi's two centuries earlier.
Stevin was one of the greatest practical scientists of the Late Middle Ages. He worked
with Holland's dykes and windmills; as a military engineer he developed fortifications
and systems of flooding; he invented a carriage with sails that traveled faster than with
horses and used it to entertain his patron, the Prince of Orange. He discovered several
laws of mechanics including those for energy conservation and hydrostatic pressure.
He lived slightly before Galileo who is now much more famous, but Stevin discovered
the equal rate of falling bodies before Galileo did, and correctly explained the
influence of the moon on tides (which Galileo later got wrong). He was first to write
on the concept of unstable equilibrium. He invented improved accounting methods,
and (though also invented at about the same time by Chinese mathematician Zhu
Zaiyu and anticipated by Galileo's father, Vincenzo Galilei) the equal-temperament
music scale. He also did work in descriptive geometry, trigonometry, optics,
geography, and astronomy.
In mathematics, Stevin is best known for the notion of real numbers (previously
integers, rationals and irrationals were treated separately; negative numbers and even
zero and one were often not considered numbers). He introduced (a clumsy form of)
decimal fractions to Europe; suggested a decimal metric system, which was finally
adopted 200 years later; invented other basic notation like the symbol . Stevin
proved several theorems about perspective geometry, an important result in
mechanics, and the Intermediate Value Theorem attributed to Bolzano and Cauchy.
Stevin's books, written in Dutch rather than Latin, were widely read and hugely
influential. He was a very key figure in the development of modern European
mathematics, and may belong on our List.
Napier was a Scottish Laird who was a noted theologian and thought by many to be a
magician (his nickname was Marvellous Merchiston). Today, however, he is best
known for his work with logarithms, a word he invented. (Several others, including
Archimedes, had anticipated the use of logarithms.) He published the first large table
of logarithms and also helped popularize usage of the decimal point and lattice
multiplication. He invented Napier's Bones, a crude hand calculator which could be
used for division and root extraction, as well as multiplication. He also had inventions
outside mathematics, especially several different kinds of war machine.
Galileo discovered the laws of inertia, falling bodies (including parabolic trajectories),
and the pendulum; he also introduced the notion of relativity which Einstein later
found so fruitful. He was a great inventor: in addition to being first to conceive of the
pendulum clock, he developed a new type of pump, and the best telescope,
thermometer, hydrostatic balance, and cannon sector of his day. As a famous
astronomer, Galileo pointed out that Jupiter's Moons, which he discovered, provide a
natural clock and allow a universal time to be determined by telescope anywhere on
Earth. (This was of little use in ocean navigation since a ship's rocking prevents the
required delicate observations.) His discovery that Venus, like the Moon, had phases
was the critical fact which forced acceptance of Copernican heliocentrism. His
contributions outside physics and astronomy were also enormous: He invented the
compound microscope and made early discoveries with it. He also made very
important contributions to the early development of biology; but perhaps Galileo's
most important contribution was to postulate universal laws of mechanics, in contrast
to Aristotelian and religious notions of separate laws for heaven and earth.
Galileo is often called the "Father of Modern Science" because of his emphasis on
experimentation. He understood that results needed to be repeated and averaged (he
used mean absolute difference as his curve-fitting criterion, two centuries before
Gauss and Legendre introduced the mean squared-difference criterion). For his
experimental methods and discoveries, his laws of motion, and for (eventually)
helping to spread Copernicus' heliocentrism, Galileo may have been the most
influential scientist ever; he ranks #12 on Hart's list of the Most Influential Persons in
History. (Despite these comments, it does appear that Galileo ignored experimental
results that conflicted with his theories. For example, the Law of the Pendulum, based
on Galileo's incorrect belief that the tautochrone was the circle, conflicted with his
own observations.) Despite his extreme importance to mathematical physics, Galileo
doesn't usually appear on lists of greatest mathematicians. However, Galileo did do
work in pure mathematics; he derived certain centroids using a rudimentary calculus
before Cavalieri did; he named (and may have been first to discover) the cycloid
curve. Moreover, Galileo was one of the first to write about infinite equinumerosity
(the "Hilbert's Hotel Paradox"). Galileo once wrote "Mathematics is the language in
which God has written the universe."
Kepler was interested in astronomy from an early age, studied to become a Lutheran
minister, became a professor of mathematics instead, then Tycho Brahe's understudy,
and, on Brahe's death, was appointed Imperial Mathematician at the age of twenty-
nine. His observations of the planets with Brahe, along with his study of Apollonius'
1800-year old work, led to Kepler's three Laws of Planetary Motion, which in turn led
directly to Newton's Laws of Motion. Beyond his discovery of these Laws (one of the
most important achievements in all of science), Kepler is also sometimes called the
"Founder of Modern Optics." He furthered the theory of the camera obscura, and was
first to study the operation of the human eye, telescopes built from two convex lenses,
and atmospheric refraction. Kepler was first to explain tides correctly. (Galileo
dismissed this as well as Kepler's elliptical orbits, and later published his own
incorrect explanation of tides.) Kepler ranks #75 on Michael Hart's famous list of the
Most Influential Persons in History. This rank, much lower than that of Copernicus,
Galileo or Newton, seems to me to underestimate Kepler's importance, since it was
Kepler's Laws, rather than just heliocentrism, which were essential to the early
development of mathematical physics.
According to Kepler's Laws, the planets move at variable speed along ellipses. (Even
Copernicus thought the orbits could be described with only circles.) The Earth-bound
observer is himself describing such an orbit and in almost the same plane as the
planets; thus discovering the Laws would be a difficult challenge even for someone
armed with computers and modern mathematics. (The very famous Kepler Equation
relating a planet's eccentric and anomaly is just one tool Kepler needed to develop.)
Kepler understood the importance of his remarkable discovery, even if
contemporaries like Galileo did not, writing:
"I give myself up to divine ecstasy ... My book is written. It will be read either by my
contemporaries or by posterity I care not which. It may well wait a hundred years
for a reader, as God has waited 6,000 years for someone to understand His work."
Besides the trigonometric results needed to discover his Laws, Kepler made other
contributions to mathematics. He generalized Alhazen's Billiard Problem, developing
the notion of curvature. He was first to notice that the set of Platonic regular solids
was incomplete if concave solids are admitted, and first to prove that there were only
13 Archimedean solids. He proved theorems of solid geometry later discovered on the
famous palimpsest of Archimedes. He rediscovered the Fibonacci series, applied it to
botany, and noted that the ratio of Fibonacci numbers converges to the Golden Mean.
He was a key early pioneer in calculus, and embraced the concept of continuity
(which others avoided due to Zeno's paradoxes); his work was a direct inspiration for
Cavalieri and others. He developed the theory of logarithms and improved on Napier's
tables. He developed mensuration methods and anticipated Fermat's theorem (df(x)/dx
= 0 at function extrema). Kepler once had an opportunity to buy wine, which
merchants measured using a shortcut; with the famous Kepler's Wine Barrel Problem,
he used his rudimentary calculus to deduce which barrel shape would be the best
bargain.
Kepler reasoned that the structure of snowflakes was evidence for the then-novel
atomic theory of matter. He noted that the obvious packing of cannonballs gave
maximum density (this became known as Kepler's Conjecture; optimality was proved
among regular packings by Gauss, but it wasn't until 1998 that the possibility of
denser irregular packings was disproven). In addition to his physics and mathematics,
Kepler wrote a science fiction novel, and was an astrologer and mystic. He had ideas
similar to Pythagoras about numbers ruling the cosmos (writing that the purpose of
studying the world "should be to discover the rational order and harmony which has
been imposed on it by God and which He revealed to us in the language of
mathematics"). Kepler's mystic beliefs even led to his own mother being imprisoned
for witchcraft.
Johannes Kepler (along with Galileo, Fermat, Huygens, Wallis, Vieta and Descartes)
is among the giants on whose shoulders Newton was proud to stand. Some historians
place him ahead of Galileo and Copernicus as the single most important contributor to
the early Scientific Revolution. Chasles includes Kepler on a list of the six responsible
for conceiving and perfecting infinitesimal calculus (the other five are Archimedes,
Cavalieri, Fermat, Leibniz and Newton). (www.keplersdiscovery.com is a wonderful
website devoted to Johannes Kepler's discoveries.)
Grard Desargues (1591-1661) France
Desargues invented projective geometry and found the relationship among conic
sections which inspired Blaise Pascal. Among several ingenious and rigorously
proven theorems are Desargues' Involution Theorem and his Theorem of Homologous
Triangles. Desargues was also a noted architect and inventor: he produced an
elaborate spiral staircase, invented an ingenious new pump based on the epicycloid,
and had the idea to use cycloid-shaped teeth in the design of gears.
Desargues' projective geometry may have been too creative for his time; Descartes
admired Desargues but was disappointed his friend didn't apply algebra to his
geometric results as Descartes did; Desargues' writing was poor; and one of his best
pupils (Blaise Pascal himself) turned away from math, so Desargues' work was largely
ignored (except by Philippe de La Hire, Desargues' other prize pupil) until Poncelet
rediscovered it almost two centuries later. (Copies of Desargues' own works surfaced
about the same time.) For this reason, Desargues may not be important enough to
belong in the Top 100, despite that he may have been among the greatest natural
geometers ever.
Fermat developed a system of analytic geometry which both preceded and surpassed
that of Descartes; he developed methods of differential and integral calculus which
Newton acknowledged as an inspiration. Solving df(x)/dx = 0 to find extrema
of f(x) is perhaps the most useful idea in applied mathematics; this technique
originated with Fermat. Fermat was also the first European to find the integration
formula for the general polynomial; he used his calculus to find centers of gravity, etc.
Fermat's contemporaneous rival Ren Descartes is more famous than Fermat, and
Descartes' writings were more influential. Whatever one thinks of Descartes as
a philosopher, however, it seems clear that Fermat was the better mathematician.
Fermat and Descartes did work in physics and independently discovered the
(trigonometric) law of refraction, but Fermat gave the correct explanation, and used it
remarkably to anticipate the Principle of Least Action later enunciated by Maupertuis
(though Maupertuis himself, like Descartes, had an incorrect explanation of
refraction). Fermat and Descartes independently discovered analytic geometry, but it
was Fermat who extended it to more than two dimensions, and followed up by
developing elementary calculus.
Gilles Personne de Roberval (1602-1675) France
Roberval was an eccentric genius, underappreciated because most of his work was
published only long after his death. He did early work in integration, following
Archimedes rather than Cavalieri; he worked on analytic geometry independently of
Descartes. With his analysis he was able to solve several difficult geometric problems
involving curved lines and solids, including results about the cycloid which were also
credited to Pascal and Torricelli. Some of these methods, published posthumously, led
to him being called the Founder of Kinematic Geometry. He excelled at mechanics,
worked in cartography, helped Pascal with vacuum experiments, and invented the
Roberval balance, still in use in weighing scales to this day. He opposed Huygens in
the early debate about gravitation, though neither fully anticipated Newton's solution.
Wallis began his life as a savant at arithmetic (it is said he once calculated the square
root of a 53-digit number to help him sleep and remembered the result in the
morning), a medical student (he may have contributed to the concept of blood
circulation), and theologian, but went on to become perhaps the most brilliant and
influential English mathematician before Newton. He made major advances in
analytic geometry, but also contributions to algebra, geometry and trigonometry.
Unlike his contemporary, Huygens who took inspiration from Euclid's rigorous
geometry, Wallis embraced the new analytic methods of Descartes and Fermat. He is
especially famous for using negative and fractional exponents (though Oresme had
introduced fractional exponents three centuries earlier), taking the areas of curves, and
treating inelastic collisions (he and Huygens were first to develop the law of
momentum conservation). He was the first European to solve Pell's Equation. Like
Vieta, Wallis was a code-breaker, helping the Commonwealth side (though he later
petitioned against the beheading of King Charles I). He was the first great
mathematician to consider complex numbers legitimate; and first to use the symbol .
Wallis coined several terms including continued
fraction, induction, interpolation, mantissa, and hypergeometric series.
Also like Vieta, Wallis created an infinite product formula for pi, which might be (but
isn't) written today as:
= 2 k=1, 1+(4k2-1)-1
Pascal was an outstanding genius who studied geometry as a child. At the age of
sixteen he stated and proved Pascal's Theorem, a fact relating any six points on any
conic section. The Theorem is sometimes called the "Cat's Cradle" or the "Mystic
Hexagram." Pascal followed up this result by showing that each of Apollonius'
famous theorems about conic sections was a corollary of the Mystic Hexagram; along
with Grard Desargues (1591-1661), he was a key pioneer of projective geometry. He
also made important early contributions to calculus; indeed it was his writings that
inspired Leibniz. Returning to geometry late in life, Pascal advanced the theory of the
cycloid. In addition to his work in geometry and calculus, he founded probability
theory, and made contributions to axiomatic theory. His name is associated with the
Pascal's Triangle of combinatorics and Pascal's Wager in theology.
Like most of the greatest mathematicians, Pascal was interested in physics and
mechanics, studying fluids, explaining vacuum, and inventing the syringe and
hydraulic press. At the age of eighteen he designed and built the world's first
automatic adding machine. (Although he continued to refine this invention, it was
never a commercial success.) He suffered poor health throughout his life, abandoned
mathematics for religion at about age 23, wrote the philosophical
treatise Penses ("We arrive at truth, not by reason only, but also by the heart"), and
died at an early age. Many think that had he devoted more years to mathematics,
Pascal would have been one of the greatest mathematicians ever.
Christiaan Huygens (1629-1695) Holland, France
Christiaan Huygens (or Hugens, Huyghens) was second only to Newton as the
greatest mechanist of his era. Although an excellent mathematician, he is much more
famous for his physical theories and inventions. He developed laws of motion before
Newton, including the inverse-square law of gravitation, centripetal force, and
treatment of solid bodies rather than point approximations; he (and Wallis) were first
to state the law of momentum conservation correctly. He advanced the wave
("undulatory") theory of light, a key concept being Huygen's Principle, that each point
on a wave front acts as a new source of radiation. His optical discoveries include
explanations for polarization and phenomena like haloes. (Because of Newton's high
reputation and corpuscular theory of light, Huygens' superior wave theory was largely
ignored until the 19th-century work of Young, Fresnel, and Maxwell. Later, Planck,
Einstein and Bohr, partly anticipated by Hamilton, developed the modern notion of
wave-particle duality.)
Huygens is famous for his inventions of clocks and lenses. He invented the
escapement and other mechanisms, leading to the first reliable pendulum clock; he
built the first balance spring watch, which he presented to his patron, King Louis XIV
of France. He invented superior lens grinding techniques, the achromatic eye-piece,
and the best telescope of his day. He was himself a famous astronomer: he discovered
Titan and was first to properly describe Saturn's rings and the Orion Nebula. He also
designed, but never built, an internal combustion engine. He promoted the use of 31-
tone music: a 31-tone organ was in use in Holland as late as the 20th century.
Huygens was an excellent card player, billiard player, horse rider, and wrote a book
speculating about extra-terrestrial life.
As a mathematician, Huygens did brilliant work in analysis; his calculus, along with
that of Wallis, is considered the best prior to Newton and Leibniz. He also did brilliant
work in geometry, proving theorems about conic sections, the cycloid and the
catenary. He was first to show that the cycloid solves the tautochrone problem; he
used this fact to design pendulum clocks that would be more accurate than ordinary
pendulum clocks. He was first to find the flaw in Saint-Vincent's then-famous circle-
squaring method; Huygens himself solved some related quadrature problems. He
introduced the concepts of evolute and involute. His friendships with Descartes,
Pascal, Mersenne and others helped inspire his mathematics; Huygens in turn was
inspirational to the next generation. At Pascal's urging, Huygens published the first
real textbook on probability theory; he also became the first practicing actuary.
Huygens had tremendous creativity, historical importance, and depth and breadth of
genius, both in physics and mathematics. He also was important for serving as tutor to
the otherwise self-taught Gottfried Leibniz (who'd "wasted his youth" without
learning any math). Before agreeing to tutor him, Huygens tested the 25-year old
Leibniz by asking him to sum the reciprocals of the triangle numbers.
Seki Takakazu (aka Shinsuke) was a self-taught prodigy who developed a new
notation for algebra, and made several discoveries before Western mathematicians
did; these include determinants, the Newton-Raphson method, Newton's interpolation
formula, Bernoulli numbers, discriminants, methods of calculus, and probably much
that has been forgotten (Japanese schools practiced secrecy). He calculated to ten
decimal places using Aitkin's method (rediscovered in the 20th century). He also
worked with magic squares. He is remembered as a brilliant genius and very
influential teacher.
Seki's work was not propagated to Europe, so has minimal historic importance;
otherwise Seki might rank high on our list.
James Gregory (Gregorie) was the outstanding Scottish genius of his century. Had he
not died at the age of 36, or if he had published more of his work, (or if Newton had
never lived,) Gregory would surely be appreciated as one of the greatest
mathematicians of the early Age of Science. Inspired by Kepler's work, he worked in
mechanics and optics; invented a reflecting telescope; and is even credited with using
a bird feather as the first diffraction grating. But James Gregory is most famous for his
mathematics, making many of the same discoveries as Newton did: the Fundamental
Theorem of Calculus, interpolation method, and binomial theorem. He developed the
concept of Taylor's series and used it to solve a famous semicircle division problem
posed by Kepler and to develop trigonometric identities, including
tan-1x = x - x3/3 + x5/5 - x7/7 + ... (for |x| < 1)
Gregory anticipated Cauchy's convergence test, Newton's identities for the powers of
roots, and Riemann integration. He may have been first to suspect that quintics
generally lacked algebraic solutions, as well as that and e were transcendental. He
produced a partial proof that the ancient "Squaring the Circle" problem was
impossible.
Gregory declined to publish much of his work, partly in deference to Isaac Newton
who was making many of the same discoveries. Because the wide range of his
mathematics wasn't appreciated until long after his death, Gregory lacks the historic
importance to qualify for the Top 100.
Newton is so famous for his calculus, optics, and laws of gravitation and motion, it is
easy to overlook that he was also one of the very greatest geometers. He was first to
fully solve the famous Problem of Pappus, and did so with pure geometry. Building
on the "neusis" (non-Platonic) constructions of Archimedes and Pappus, he
demonstrated cube-doubling and that angles could be k-sected for any k, if one is
allowed a conchoid or certain other mechanical curves. He also built on Apollonius'
famous theorem about tangent circles to develop the technique now called hyperbolic
trilateration. Despite the power of Descartes' analytic geometry, Newton's
achievements with synthetic geometry were surpassing. Even before the invention of
the calculus of variations, Newton was doing difficult work in that field, e.g. his
calculation of the "optimal bullet shape." His other marvelous geometric theorems
included several about quadrilaterals and their in- or circum-scribing ellipses. He
constructed the parabola defined by four given points, as well as various cubic curve
constructions. (As with Archimedes, many of Newton's constructions used non-
Platonic tools.) He anticipated Poncelet's Principle of Continuity. An anecdote often
cited to demonstrate his brilliance is the problem of the brachistochrone, which had
baffled the best mathematicians in Europe, and came to Newton's attention late in life.
He solved it in a few hours and published the answer anonymously. But on seeing the
solution Jacob Bernoulli immediately exclaimed "I recognize the lion by his
footprint."
Newton ranks #2 on Michael Hart's famous list of the Most Influential Persons in
History. (Muhammed the Prophet of Allah is #1.) Whatever the criteria, Newton
would certainly rank first or second on any list of physicists, or scientists in general,
but some listmakers would demote him slightly on a list of pure mathematicians: his
emphasis was physics not mathematics, and the contribution of Leibniz (Newton's
rival for the title Inventor of Calculus) lessens the historical importance of Newton's
calculus. One reason I've ranked him at #1 is a comment by Gottfried Leibniz himself:
"Taking mathematics from the beginning of the world to the time when Newton lived,
what he has done is much the better part."
Mathematics was just a self-taught sideline for Leibniz, who was a philosopher,
lawyer, historian, diplomat and renowned inventor. Because he "wasted his youth"
before learning mathematics, he probably ranked behind the Bernoullis as well as
Newton in pure mathematical talent, and thus he may be the only mathematician
among the Top Fifteen who was never the greatest living algorist or theorem prover. I
won't try to summarize Leibniz' contributions to philosophy and diverse other fields
including biology; as just three examples: he predicted the Earth's molten core,
introduced the notion of subconscious mind, and built the first calculator that could do
multiplication. Leibniz also had political influence: he consulted to both the Holy
Roman and Russian Emperors; another of his patrons was Sophia Wittelsbach
(Electress of Hanover), who was only distantly in line for the British throne, but was
made Heir Presumptive. (Sophia died before Queen Anne, but her son was crowned
King George I of England.)
Leibniz' thoughts on mathematical physics had some influence. He was one of the
first to articulate the law of energy conservation; and developed laws of motion that
gave different insights from those of Newton. His cosmology was opposed to that of
Newton but, anticipating theories of Mach and Einstein, is more in accord with
modern physics. Mathematical physicists influenced by Leibniz include not only
Mach, but perhaps Hamilton and Poincar themselves.
Jacob Bernoulli studied the works of Wallis and Barrow; he and Leibniz became
friends and tutored each other. Jacob developed important methods for integral and
differential equations, coining the word integral. He and his brother were the key
pioneers in mathematics during the generations between the era of Newton-Leibniz
and the rise of Leonhard Euler.
Jacob liked to pose and solve physical optimization problems. His "catenary" problem
(what shape does a clothesline take?) became more famous than the "tautochrone"
solved by Huygens. Perhaps the most famous of such problems was the
brachistochrone, wherein Jacob recognized Newton's "lion's paw", and about which
Johann Bernoulli wrote: "You will be petrified with astonishment [that] this same
cycloid, the tautochrone of Huygens, is the brachistochrone we are seeking." Jacob
did significant work outside calculus; in fact his most famous work was the Art of
Conjecture, a textbook on probability and combinatorics which proves the Law of
Large Numbers, the Power Series Equation, and introduces the Bernoulli numbers. He
is credited with the invention of polar coordinates (though Newton and Alberuni had
also discovered them). Jacob also did outstanding work in geometry, for example
constructing perpendicular lines which quadrisect a triangle.
Johann Bernoulli learned from his older brother and Leibniz, and went on to become
principal teacher to Leonhard Euler. He developed exponential calculus; together with
his brother Jacob, he founded the calculus of variations. Johann solved the catenary
before Jacob did; this led to a famous rivalry in the Bernoulli family. (No joint papers
were written; instead the Bernoullis, especially Johann, began claiming each others'
work.) Although his older brother may have demonstrated greater breadth, Johann had
no less skill than Jacob, contributed more to calculus, discovered L'Hpital's Rule
before L'Hpital did, and made important contributions in physics, e.g. about
vibrations, elastic bodies, optics, tides, and ship sails.
It may not be clear which Bernoulli was the "greatest." Johann has special importance
as tutor to Leonhard Euler, but Jacob has special importance as tutor to his brother
Johann. Johann's son Daniel is also a candidate for greatest Bernoulli.
He was a close friend and muse of Isaac Newton who told people who asked
about Principia: "Go to Mr. De Moivre; he knows these things better than I do."
Brook Taylor invented integration by parts, developed what is now called the calculus
of finite differences, developed a new method to compute logarithms, made several
other key discoveries of analysis, and did significant work in mathematical physics.
His love of music and painting may have motivated some of his mathematics: He
studied vibrating strings; and also wrote an important treatise on perspective in
drawing which helped develop the fields of both projective and descriptive geometry.
His work in projective geometry rediscovered Desargues' Theorem, introduced terms
like vanishing point, and influenced Lambert.
Taylor was one of the few mathematicians of the Bernoulli era who was equal to them
in genius, but his work was much less influential. Today he is most remembered for
Taylor Series and the associated Taylor's Theorem, but he shouldn't get full credit for
this. The method had been anticipated by earlier mathematicians including Gregory,
Leibniz, Newton, and, even earlier, Madhava; and was not fully appreciated until the
work of Maclaurin and Lagrange.
Johann Bernoulli had a nephew, three sons and some grandsons who were all also
outstanding mathematicians. Of these, the most important was his son Daniel. Johann
insisted that Daniel study biology and medicine rather than mathematics, so Daniel
specialized initially in mathematical biology. He went on to win the Grand Prize of
the Paris Academy no less than ten times, and was a close friend of Euler. He
developed partial differential equations, preceded Fourier in the use of Fourier series,
did important work in statistics and the theory of equations, discovered and proved a
key theorem about trochoids, developed a theory of economic risk (motivated by the
St. Petersburg Paradox discovered by his cousin Nicholas), but is most famous for his
key discoveries in mathematical physics, including the Bernoulli Principle underlying
airflight. Daniel Bernoulli is sometimes called the "Founder of Mathematical
Physics."
Euler was a very major figure in number theory: He proved that the sum of the
reciprocals of primes less than x is approx. (ln ln x), invented the totient function and
used it to generalize Fermat's Little Theorem, found both the largest then-known
prime and the largest then-known perfect number, proved e to be irrational,
discovered (though without complete proof) a broad class of transcendental numbers,
proved that all even perfect numbers must have the Mersenne number form that
Euclid had discovered 2000 years earlier, and much more. Euler was also first to
prove several interesting theorems of geometry, including facts about the 9-point
Feuerbach circle; relationships among a triangle's altitudes, medians, and
circumscribing and inscribing circles; the famous Intersecting Chords Theorem; and
an expression for a tetrahedron's volume in terms of its edge lengths. Euler was first to
explore topology, proving theorems about the Euler characteristic, and the famous
Euler's Polyhedral Theorem, F+V = E+2 (although it may have been discovered by
Descartes and first proved rigorously by Jordan). Although noted as the first great
"pure mathematician," Euler's pump and turbine equations revolutionized the design
of pumps; he also made important contributions to music theory, acoustics, optics,
celestial motions, fluid dynamics, and mechanics. He extended Newton's Laws of
Motion to rotating rigid bodies; and developed the Euler-Bernoulli beam equation. On
a lighter note, Euler constructed a particularly "magical" magic square.
Euler combined his brilliance with phenomenal concentration. He developed the first
method to estimate the Moon's orbit (the three-body problem which had stumped
Newton), and he settled an arithmetic dispute involving 50 terms in a long convergent
series. Both these feats were accomplished when he was totally blind. (About this he
said "Now I will have less distraction.") Franois Arago said that "Euler calculated
without apparent effort, as men breathe, or as eagles sustain themselves in the wind."
The reputations of Euler and the Bernoullis are so high that it is easy to overlook that
others in that epoch made essential contributions to mathematical physics. (Euler
made errors in his development of physics, in some cases because of a Europeanist
rejection of Newton's theories in favor of the contradictory theories of Descartes and
Leibniz.) The Frenchmen Clairaut and d'Alembert were two other great and influential
mathematicians of the mid-18th century.
Alexis Clairaut was extremely precocious, delivering a math paper at age 13, and
becoming the youngest person ever elected to the Paris Academy of Sciences. He
developed the concept of skew curves (the earliest precursor of spatial curvature); he
made very significant contributions in differential equations and mathematical
physics. Clairaut supported Newton against the Continental schools, and helped
translate Newton's work into French. The theories of Newton and Descartes gave
different predictions for the shape of the Earth (whether the poles were flattened or
pointy); Clairaut participated in Maupertuis' expedition to Lappland to measure the
polar regions. Measurements at high latitudes showed the poles to be flattened:
Newton was right. Clairaut worked on the theories of ellipsoids and the three-body
problem, e.g. Moon's orbit. That orbit was the major mathematical challenge of the
day, and there was great difficulty reconciling theory and observation. It was Clairaut
who finally resolved this, by approaching the problem with more rigor than others.
When Euler finally understood Clairaut's solution he called it "the most important and
profound discovery that has ever been made in mathematics." Later, when Halley's
Comet reappeared as he had predicted, Clairaut was acclaimed as "the new Thales."
During the century after Newton, the Laws of Motion needed to be clarified and
augmented with mathematical techniques. Jean le Rond, named after the Parisian
church where he was abandoned as a baby, played a very key role in that
development. His D'Alembert's Principle clarified Newton's Third Law and allowed
problems in dynamics to be expressed with simple partial differential equations; his
Method of Characteristics then reduced those equations to ordinary differential
equations; to solve the resultant linear systems, he effectively invented the method of
eigenvalues; he also anticipated the Cauchy-Riemann Equations. These are the same
techniques in use for many problems in physics to this day. D'Alembert was also a
forerunner in functions of a complex variable, and the notions of infinitesimals and
limits. With his treatises on dynamics, elastic collisions, hydrodynamics, cause of
winds, vibrating strings, celestial motions, refraction, etc., the young Jean le Rond
easily surpassed the efforts of his older rival, Daniel Bernoulli. He may have been first
to speak of time as a "fourth dimension." (Rivalry with the Swiss mathematicians led
to d'Alembert's sometimes being unfairly ridiculed, although it does seem true that
d'Alembert had very incorrect notions of probability.)
D'Alembert was first to prove that every polynomial has a complex root; this is now
called the Fundamental Theorem of Algebra. (In France this Theorem is called the
D'Alembert-Gauss Theorem. Although Gauss was first to provide a fully rigorous
proof, d'Alembert's proof preceded, and was more nearly complete than, the attempted
proof by Euler-Lagrange.) He also did creative work in geometry (e.g. anticipating
Monge's Three Circle Theorem), and was principal creator of the major encyclopedia
of his day. D'Alembert wrote "The imagination in a mathematician who creates makes
no less difference than in a poet who invents."
Lambert is famous for his work in geometry, proving Lambert's Theorem (the path of
rotation of a parabola tangent triangle passes through the parabola's focus). Lagrange
declared this famous identity, used to calculate cometary orbits, to be the most
beautiful and significant result in celestial motions. Lambert was first to explore
straight-edge constructions without compass. He also developed non-Euclidean
geometry, long before Bolyai and Lobachevsky did.
Lagrange once wrote "As long as algebra and geometry have been separated, their
progress have been slow and their uses limited; but when these two sciences have
been united, they have lent each mutual forces, and have marched together towards
perfection." Both W.W.R. Ball and E.T. Bell, renowned mathematical historians,
bypass Euler to name Lagrange as "the Greatest Mathematician of the 18th Century."
Jacobi bypassed Newton and Gauss to call Lagrange "perhaps the greatest
mathematical genius since Archimedes."
Gaspard Monge, son of a humble peddler, was an industrious and creative inventor
who astounded early with his genius, becoming a professor of physics at age 16. As a
military engineer he developed the new field of descriptive geometry, so useful to
engineering that it was kept a military secret for 15 years. Monge made early
discoveries in chemistry and helped promote Lavoisier's work; he also wrote papers
on optics and metallurgy; Monge's talents were so diverse that he became Minister of
the Navy in the revolutionary government, and eventually became a close friend and
companion of Napoleon Bonaparte. Traveling with Napoleon he demonstrated great
courage on several occasions.
Laplace was the preeminent mathematical astronomer, and is often called the "French
Newton." His masterpiece was Mecanique Celeste which redeveloped and improved
Newton's work on planetary motions using calculus. While Newton had shown that
the two-body gravitation problem led to orbits which were ellipses (or other conic
sections), Laplace was more interested in the much more difficult problems involving
three or more bodies. (Would Jupiter's pull on Saturn eventually propel Saturn into a
closer orbit, or was Saturn's orbit stable for eternity?) Laplace's equations had the
optimistic outcome that the solar system was stable.
Laplace advanced the nebular hypothesis of solar system origin, and was first to
conceive of black holes. (He also conceived of multiple galaxies, but this was
Lambert's idea first.) He explained the so-called secular acceleration of the Moon.
(Today we know Laplace's theories do not fully explain the Moon's path, nor
guarantee orbit stability.) His other accomplishments in physics include theories about
the speed of sound and surface tension. He was noted for his strong belief in
determinism, famously replying to Napoleon's question about God with: "I have no
need of that hypothesis."
Laplace viewed mathematics as just a tool for developing his physical theories.
Nevertheless, he made many important mathematical discoveries and inventions
(although the Laplace Transform itself was already known to Lagrange). He was the
premier expert at differential and difference equations, and definite integrals. He
developed spherical harmonics, potential theory, and the theory of determinants;
anticipated Fourier's series; and advanced Euler's technique of generating functions. In
the fields of probability and statistics he made key advances: he proved the Law of
Least Squares, and introduced the controversial ("Bayesian") rule of succession. In the
theory of equations, he was first to prove that any polynomial of even degree must
have a real quadratic factor.
Others might place Laplace higher on the List, but he proved no fundamental
theorems of pure mathematics (though his partial differential equation for fluid
dynamics is one of the most famous in physics), founded no major branch of pure
mathematics, and wasn't particularly concerned with rigorous proof. (He is famous for
skipping difficult proof steps with the phrase "It is easy to see".) Nevertheless he was
surely one of the greatest applied mathematicians ever.
Legendre was an outstanding mathematician who did important work in plane and
solid geometry, spherical trigonometry, celestial mechanics and other areas of
physics, and especially elliptic integrals and number theory. He found key results in
the theories of sums of squares and sums of k-gonal numbers. He also made key
contributions in several areas of analysis: he invented the Legendre transform and
Legendre polynomials; the notation for partial derivatives is due to him. He invented
the Legendre symbol; invented the study of zonal harmonics; proved that 2 was
irrational (the irrationality of had already been proved by Lambert); and wrote
important textbooks in several fields. Although he never accepted non-Euclidean
geometry, and had spent much time trying to prove the Parallel Postulate, his inspiring
geometry text remained a standard until the 20th century. As one of France's premier
mathematicians, Legendre did other significant work, promoting the careers of
Lagrange and Laplace, developing trig tables, geodesic projects, etc.
There are several important theorems proposed by Legendre for which he is denied
credit, either because his proof was incomplete or was preceded by another's. He
proposed the famous theorem about primes in a progression which was proved by
Dirichlet; proved and used the Law of Least Squares which Gauss had left
unpublished; proved the N=5 case of Fermat's Last Theorem which is credited to
Dirichlet; proposed the famous Prime Number Theorem which was finally proved by
Hadamard; improved the Fermat-Cauchy result about sums of k-gonal numbers but
this topic wasn't fruitful; and developed various techniques commonly credited to
Laplace. His two most famous theorems of number theory, the Law of Quadratic
Reciprocity and the Three Squares Theorem (a difficult extension of Lagrange's Four
Squares Theorem), were each enhanced by Gauss a few years after Legendre's work.
Legendre also proved an early version of Bonnet's Theorem. Legendre's work in the
theory of equations and elliptic integrals directly inspired the achievements of Galois
and Abel (which then obsoleted much of Legendre's own work); Chebyshev's work
also built on Legendre's foundations.
Joseph Fourier had a varied career: precocious but mischievous orphan, theology
student, young professor of mathematics (advancing the theory of equations), then
revolutionary activist. Under Napoleon he was a brilliant and important teacher and
historian; accompanied the French Emperor to Egypt; and did excellent service as
district governor of Grenoble. In his spare time at Grenoble he continued the work in
mathematics and physics that led to his immortality. After the fall of Napoleon,
Fourier exiled himself to England, but returned to France when offered an important
academic position and published his revolutionary treatise on the Theory of Heat.
Fourier anticipated linear programming, developing the simplex method and Fourier-
Motzkin Elimination; and did significant work in operator theory. He is also noted for
the notion of dimensional analysis, was first to describe the Greenhouse Effect, and
continued his earlier brilliant work with equations.
Fourier's greatest fame rests on his use of trigonometric series (now called Fourier
series) in the solution of differential equations. Since "Fourier" analysis is in
extremely common use among applied mathematicians, he joins the select company of
the eponyms of "Cartesian" coordinates, "Gaussian" curve, and "Boolean" algebra.
Because of the importance of Fourier analysis, many listmakers would rank Fourier
much higher than I have done; however the work was not exceptional
as pure mathematics. Fourier's Heat Equation built on Newton's Law of Cooling; and
the Fourier series solution itself had already been introduced by Euler, Lagrange and
Daniel Bernoulli.
Fourier's solution to the heat equation was counterintuitive (heat transfer doesn't seem
to involve the oscillations fundamental to trigonometric functions): The brilliance of
Fourier's imagination is indicated in that the solution had been rejected by Lagrange
himself. Although rigorous Fourier Theorems were finally proved only by Dirichlet,
Riemann and Lebesgue, it has been said that it was Fourier's "very disregard for rigor"
that led to his great achievement, which Lord Kelvin compared to poetry.
Although he published fewer papers than some other great mathematicians, Gauss
may be the greatest theorem prover ever. Several important theorems and lemmas
bear his name; he extended Euclid's Fundamental Theorem of Arithmetic (prime
factorization is unique) to the Gaussian (complex) integers; and he was first to
produce a rigorous proof of the Fundamental Theorem of Algebra (that an n-th degree
polynomial has n complex roots). Gauss himself used "Fundamental Theorem" to
refer to Euler's Law of Quadratic Reciprocity; Gauss was first to provide a proof for
this, and provided eight distinct proofs for it over the years. Gauss proved the n=3
case of Fermat's Last Theorem for Eisenstein integers (the triangular lattice-points on
the complex plane); though more general, Gauss' proof was simpler than the real
integer proof; this simplification method revolutionized algebra. Other work by Gauss
led to fundamental theorems in statistics, vector analysis, function theory, and
generalizations of the Fundamental Theorem of Calculus.
Gauss built the theory of complex numbers into its modern form, including the notion
of "monogenic" functions which are now ubiquitous in mathematical physics.
(Constructing the regular 17-gon as a teenager was actually an exercise in complex-
number algebra, not geometry.) Gauss developed the arithmetic of congruences and
became the premier number theoretician of all time. Other contributions of Gauss
include hypergeometric series, foundations of statistics, and differential geometry. He
proved a surprising fundamental theorem about the curvature of manifolds. He also
did important work in geometry, providing an improved solution to Apollonius'
famous problem of tangent circles, stating and proving the Fundamental Theorem of
Normal Axonometry, and solving astronomical problems related to comet orbits and
navigation by the stars. Ceres, the first asteroid, was discovered when Gauss was a
young man; but only a few observations were made before it disappeared into the
Sun's brightness. Could its orbit be predicted well enough to rediscover it on re-
emergence? Laplace, one of the most respected mathematicians of the time, declared
it impossible. Gauss became famous when he used an 8th-degree polynomial equation
to successfully predict Ceres' orbit. Gauss also did important work in several areas of
physics, developed an important modification to Mercator's map projection, invented
the heliotrope, and co-invented the telegraph.
Much of Gauss's work wasn't published: unbeknownst to his colleagues it was Gauss
who first discovered non-Euclidean geometry (even anticipating Einstein by
suggesting physical space might not be Euclidean), doubly periodic elliptic functions,
a prime distribution formula, quaternions, foundations of topology, the Law of Least
Squares, Dirichlet's class number formula, the key Bonnet's Theorem of differential
geometry (now usually called Gauss-Bonnet Theorem), the butterfly procedure for
rapid calculation of Fourier series, and even the rudiments of knot theory. Gauss was
first to prove the Fundamental Theorem of Functions of a Complex Variable (that the
line-integral over a closed curve of a monogenic function is zero), but he let Cauchy
take the credit. Gauss was very prolific, and may be the most brilliant theorem prover
who ever lived, so many would rank him #1. But several others on the list had
more historical importance. Abel hints at a reason for this: "[Gauss] is like the fox,
who effaces his tracks in the sand."
Gauss once wrote "It is not knowledge, but the act of learning, ... which grants the
greatest enjoyment. When I have clarified and exhausted a subject, then I turn away
from it, in order to go into darkness again ..."
Simon Poisson was a protg of Laplace and, like his mentor, is among the greatest
applied mathematicians ever. Poisson was an extremely prolific researcher and also an
excellent teacher. In addition to important advances in several areas of physics,
Poisson made key contributions to Fourier analysis, definite integrals, path integrals,
statistics, partial differential equations, calculus of variations and other fields of
mathematics. Dozens of discoveries are named after Poisson; for example the Poisson
summation formula which has applications in analysis, number theory, lattice theory,
etc. He was first to note the paradoxical properties of the Cauchy distribution. He
made improvements to Lagrange's equations of celestial motions, which Lagrange
himself found inspirational. Another of Poisson's contributions to mathematical
physics was his conclusion that the wave theory of light implies a bright Arago spot at
the center of certain shadows. (Poisson used this paradoxical result to argue that the
wave theory was false, but instead the Arago spot, hitherto hardly noticed, was
observed experimentally.) Poisson once said "Life is good for only two things,
discovering mathematics and teaching mathematics."
Bernard Placidus Johann Nepomuk Bolzano (1781-1848) Bohemia
Bolzano was an ordained Catholic priest, a religious philosopher, and focused his
mathematical attention on fields like metalogic, writing "I prized only ... mathematics
which was ... philosophy." Still he made several important mathematical discoveries
ahead of his time. His liberal religious philosophy upset the Imperial rulers; he was
charged with heresy, placed under house arrest, and his writings censored. This
censorship meant that many of his great discoveries turned up only posthumously, and
were first rediscovered by others. He was noted for advocating great rigor, and is
appreciated for developing the (, ) approach for rigorous proofs in analysis; this
work inspired the great Weierstrass.
Bolzano gave the first analytic proof of the Fundamental Theorem of Algebra; the
first rigorous proof that continuous functions achieve any intermediate value
(Bolzano's Theorem, rediscovered by Cauchy); the first proof that a bounded
sequence of reals has a convergent subsequence (Bolzano-Weierstrass theorem); was
first to describe a nowhere-differentiable continuous function; and anticipated
Cantor's discovery of the distinction between denumerable and non-denumerable
infinities. If he had focused on mathematics and published more, he might be
considered one of the most important mathematicians of his era.
After studying under Monge, Poncelet became an officer in Napoleon's army, then a
prisoner of the Russians. To keep up his spirits as a prisoner he devised and solved
mathematical problems using charcoal and the walls of his prison cell instead of
pencil and paper. During this time he reinvented projective geometry. Regaining his
freedom, he wrote many papers, made numerous contributions to geometry; he also
made contributions to practical mechanics. Poncelet is considered one of the most
influential geometers ever; he is especially noted for his Principle of Continuity, an
intuition with broad application. His notion of imaginary solutions in geometry was
inspirational. Although projective geometry had been studied earlier by
mathematicians like Desargues, Poncelet's work excelled and served as an inspiration
for other branches of mathematics including algebra, topology, Cayley's invariant
theory and group-theoretic developments by Lie and Klein. His theorems of geometry
include his Closure Theorem about Poncelet Traverses, the Poncelet-Brianchon
Hyperbola Theorem, and Poncelet's Porism (if two conic sections are respectively
inscribed and circumscribed by an n-gon, then there are infinitely many such n-gons).
Perhaps his most famous theorem, although it was left to Steiner to complete a proof,
is the beautiful Poncelet-Steiner Theorem about straight-edge constructions.
Augustin-Louis Cauchy (1789-1857) France
Cauchy was extraordinarily prodigious, prolific and inventive. Home-schooled, he
awed famous mathematicians at an early age. In contrast to Gauss and Newton, he
was almost over-eager to publish; in his day his fame surpassed that of Gauss and has
continued to grow. Cauchy did significant work in analysis, algebra, number theory
and discrete topology. His most important contributions included convergence criteria
for infinite series, the "theory of substitutions" (permutation group theory), and
especially his insistence on rigorous proofs.
One of the duties of a great mathematician is to nurture his successors, but Cauchy
selfishly dropped the ball on both of the two greatest young mathematicians of his
day, mislaying key manuscripts of both Abel and Galois. Cauchy is credited with
group theory, yet it was Galois who invented this first, abstracting it far more than
Cauchy did, some of this in a work which Cauchy "mislaid." (For this
historical miscontribution perhaps Cauchy should be demoted.)
Mbius worked as a Professor of physics and astronomy, but his astronomy teachers
included Carl Gauss and other brilliant mathematicians, and Mbius is most noted for
his work in mathematics. He had outstanding intuition and originality, and prepared
his books and papers with great care. He made important advances in number theory,
topology, and especially projective geometry. Several inventions are named after him,
such as the Mbius transformation and Mbius net of geometry, and the Mbius
function and Mbius inversion formula of algebraic number theory. He is most
famous for the Mbius strip; this one-sided strip was first discovered by Lister, but
Mbius went much further and developed important new insights in topology.
Chasles was a very original thinker who developed new techniques for synthetic
geometry. He introduced new notions like pencil and cross-ratio; made great progress
with the Principle of Duality; and showed how to combine the power of analysis with
the intuitions of geometry. He invented a theory of characteristics and used it to
become the Founder of Enumerative Geometry. He proved a key theorem about solid
body kinematics. His influence was very large; for example Poincar (student of
Darboux, who in turn was Chasles' student) often applied Chasles' methods. Chasles
was also a historian of mathematics; for example he noted that Euclid had anticipated
the method of cross-ratios.
Jakob Steiner (1796-1863) Switzerland
Jakob Steiner made many major advances in synthetic geometry, hoping that classical
methods could avoid any need for analysis; and indeed, like Isaac Newton, he was
often able to equal or surpass methods of analysis or the calculus of variations using
just pure geometry; for example he had pure synthetic proofs for a notable extension
to Pascal's Mystic Hexagram, and a reproof of Salmon's Theorem that cubic surfaces
have exactly 27 lines. (He wrote "Calculating replaces thinking while geometry
stimulates it.") One mathematical historian (Boyer) wrote "Steiner reminds one of
Gauss in that ideas and discoveries thronged through his mind so rapidly that he could
scarcely reduce them to order on paper." Although the Principle of Duality underlying
projective geometry was already known, he gave it a radically new and more
productive basis, and created a new theory of conics. His work combined generality,
creativity and rigor.
Steiner developed several famous construction methods, e.g. for a triangle's smallest
circumscribing and largest inscribing ellipses, and for its "Malfatti circles." Among
many famous and important theorems of classic and projective geometry, he proved
that the Wallace lines of a triangle lie in a 3-pointed hypocycloid, developed a
formula for the partitioning of space by planes, a fact about the surface areas of
tetrahedra, and proved several facts about his famous Steiner's Chain of tangential
circles and his famous "Roman surface." Perhaps his three most famous theorems are
the Poncelet-Steiner Theorem (lengths constructible with straightedge and compass
can be constructed with straightedge alone as long as the picture plane contains the
center and circumference of some circle), the Double-Element Theorem about self-
homologous elements in projective geometry, and the Isoperimetric Theorem that
among solids of equal volume the sphere will have minimum area, etc. (Dirichlet
found a flaw in the proof of the Isoperimetric Theorem which was later corrected by
Weierstrass.) Steiner is often called, along with Apollonius of Perga (who lived 2000
years earlier), one of the two greatest pure geometers ever. (The qualifier "pure" is
added to exclude such geniuses as Archimedes, Newton and Pascal from this
comparison. I've included Steiner for his extreme brilliance and productivity: several
geometers had much more historic influence, and as solely a geometer he arguably
lacked "depth.")
Steiner once wrote: "For all their wealth of content, ... music, mathematics, and chess
are resplendently useless (applied mathematics is a higher plumbing, a kind of music
for the police band). They are metaphysically trivial, irresponsible. They refuse to
relate outward, to take reality for arbiter. This is the source of their witchery."
Julius Plcker (1801-1868) Germany
Plcker was one of the most innovative geometers, inventing line geometry
(extending the atoms of geometry beyond just points), enumerative geometry (which
considered such questions as the number of loops in an algebraic curve), geometries
of more than three dimensions, and generalizations of projective geometry. He also
gave an improved theoretic basis for the Principle of Duality. His novel methods and
notations were important to the development of modern analytic geometry, and
inspired Cayley, Klein and Lie. He resolved the famous Cramer-Euler Paradox and
the related Poncelet Paradox by studying the singularities of curves; Cayley described
this work as "most important ... beyond all comparison in the entire subject of modern
geometry." In part due to conflict with his more famous rival, Jakob Steiner, Plcker
was under-appreciated in his native Germany, but achieved fame in France and
England. In addition to his mathematical work in algebraic and analytic geometry,
Plcker did significant work in physics, e.g. his work with cathode rays. Although less
brilliant as a theorem prover than Steiner, Plcker's work, taking full advantage of
analysis and seeking physical applications, was far more influential.
Finding the roots of polynomials is a key mathematical problem: the general solution
of the quadratic equation was known by ancients; the discovery of general methods
for solving polynomials of degree three and four is usually treated as the major math
achievement of the 16th century; so for over two centuries an algebraic solution for
the general 5th-degree polynomial (quintic) was a Holy Grail sought by most of the
greatest mathematicians. Abel proved that most quintics did not have such solutions.
This discovery, at the age of only nineteen, would have quickly awed the world, but
Abel was impoverished, had few contacts, and spoke no German. When Gauss
received Abel's manuscript he discarded it unread, assuming the unfamiliar author
was just another crackpot trying to square the circle or some such. His genius was too
great for him to be ignored long, but, still impoverished, Abel died of tuberculosis at
the age of twenty-six. His fame lives on and even the lower-case word 'abelian' is
applied to several concepts. Liouville said Abel was the greatest genius he ever met.
Hermite said "Abel has left mathematicians enough to keep them busy for 500 years."
Jacobi's most significant early achievement was the theory of elliptic functions, e.g.
his fundamental result about functions with multiple periods. Jacobi was the first to
apply elliptic functions to number theory, producing a new proof of Fermat's famous
conjecture (Lagrange's theorem) that every integer is the sum of four squares. He also
made important discoveries in many other areas including theta functions (e.g. his
Jacobi Triple Product Identity), higher fields, number theory, algebraic geometry,
differential equations, q-series, hypergeometric series, determinants, Abelian
functions, and dynamics. He devised the algorithms still used to calculate
eigenvectors and for other important matrix manipulations. The range of his work is
suggested by the fact that the "Hungarian method," an efficient solution to an
optimization problem published more than a century after Jacobi's death, has since
been found among Jacobi's papers.
Like Abel, as a young man Jacobi attempted to factor the general quintic equation.
Unlike Abel, he seems never to have considered proving its impossibility. This fact is
sometimes cited to show that despite Jacobi's creativity, his ill-fated contemporary
was the more brilliant genius.
Dirichlet did seminal work in analysis and is considered the founder of analytic
number theory. He invented a method of L-series to prove the important theorem
(Gauss' conjecture) that any arithmetic series (without a common factor) has an
infinity of primes. It was Dirichlet who proved the fundamental Theorem of Fourier
series: that periodic analytic functions can always be represented as a simple
trigonometric series. Although he never proved it rigorously, he is especially noted for
the Dirichlet's Principle which posits the existence of certain solutions in the calculus
of variations, and which Riemann found to be particularly fruitful. Other fundamental
results Dirichlet contributed to analysis and number theory include a theorem about
Diophantine approximations and his Class Number Formula.
William Rowan (Sir) Hamilton (1805-1865) Ireland
Hamilton was a childhood prodigy. Home-schooled and self-taught, he started as a
student of languages and literature, was influenced by an arithmetic prodigy his own
age, read Euclid, Newton and Lagrange, found an error by Laplace, and made new
discoveries in optics; all this before the age of seventeen when he first attended
school. At college he enjoyed unprecedented success in all fields, but his
undergraduate days were cut short abruptly by his appointment as Royal Astronomer
of Ireland at the age of 22. He soon began publishing his revolutionary treatises on
optics, in which he developed Hamilton's Principle of Stationary Action. This
Principle refined and corrected the earlier principles of least action developed by
Maupertuis, Fermat, and Euler; it (and related principles) are key to much of modern
physics. His early writing also predicted that some crystals would have an hitherto
unknown "conical" refraction mode; this was soon confirmed experimentally.
Hamilton's Principle of Least Action, and its associated equations and concept of
configuration space, led to a revolution in mathematical physics. Since Maupertuis
had named this Principle a century earlier, it is possible to underestimate Hamilton's
contribution. However Maupertuis, along with others credited with anticipating the
idea (Fermat, Leibniz, Euler and Lagrange) failed to state the full Principle correctly.
Rather than minimizing action, physical systems sometimes achieve a non-minimal
but stationary action in configuration space. (Poisson and d' Alembert had noticed
exceptions to Euler-Lagrange least action, but failed to find Hamilton's solution.
Jacobi also deserves some credit for the Principle, but his work came after reading
Hamilton.) Because of this Principle, as well as his wave-particle duality (which
would be further developed by Planck and Einstein), Hamilton can be considered a
major early influence on quantum theory.
Hamilton once wrote: "On earth there is nothing great but man; in man there is
nothing great but mind."
Grassmann was an exceptional polymath: the term Grassmann's Law is applied to two
separate facts in the fields of optics and linguistics, both discovered by Hermann
Grassmann. He also did advanced work in crystallography, electricity, botany,
folklore, and also wrote on political subjects. He had little formal training in
mathematics, yet single-handedly developed linear algebra, vector and tensor calculus,
multi-dimensional geometry, new results about cubic surfaces, the theory of
extension, and exterior algebra; most of this work was so innovative it was not
properly appreciated in his own lifetime. (Heaviside rediscovered vector analysis
many years later.) Grassmann's exterior algebra, and the associated concept of
Grassmannian manifold, provide a simplifying framework for many algebraic
calculations. Recently their use led to an important simplification in quantum physics
calculations.
Of his linear algebra, one historian wrote "few have come closer than Hermann
Grassmann to creating, single-handedly, a new subject." Important mathematicians
inspired directly by Grassmann include Peano, Klein, Cartan, Hankel, Clifford, and
Whitehead.
Liouville did expert research in several areas including number theory, differential
geometry, complex analysis (especially Sturm-Liouville theory, boundary value
problems and dynamical analysis), topology and mathematical physics. Several
theorems bear his name, including the key result that any bounded entire function
must be constant (the Fundamental Theorem of Algebra is an easy corollary of this!);
important results in differential equations, differential algebra, differential geometry; a
key result about conformal mappings; and an invariance law about trajectories in
phase space which leads to the Second Law of Thermodynamics and is key to
Hamilton's work in physics. He was first to prove the existence of transcendental
numbers. (His proof was constructive, unlike that of Cantor which came 30 years
later). He invented Liouville integrability and fractional calculus; he found a new
proof of the Law of Quadratic Reciprocity. In addition to multiple Liouville
Theorems, there are two "Liouville Principles": a fundamental result in differential
algebra, and a fruitful theorem in number theory. Liouville was hugely prolific in
number theory but this work is largely overlooked, e.g. the following remarkable
generalization of Aryabhata's identity:
for all N, (da3) = ( da)2
where da is the number of divisors of a, and the sums are taken over all
divisors a of N.
Kummer was an inspirational teacher; his famous students include Cantor, Frobenius,
Fuchs, Schwarz, Gordan, Joachimsthal, Bachmann, and Kronecker. (Leopold
Kronecker was a brilliant genius sometimes ranked ahead of Kummer in lists like this;
that Kummer was Kronecker's teacher at high school persuades me to give Kummer
priority.)
Galois' ideas were very far-reaching; for example he is sometimes credited as first to
prove that trisecting a general angle with Plato's rules is impossible. Galois is
sometimes cited (instead of Archimedes, Gauss or Ramanujan) as "the greatest
mathematical genius ever." His last words (spoken to his brother) were "Ne pleure
pas, Alfred! J'ai besoin de tout mon courage pour mourir vingt ans!" This tormented
life, with its pointless early end, is one of the great tragedies of mathematical history.
Although Galois' group theory is considered one of the greatest developments of 19th
century mathematics, Galois' writings were largely ignored until the revolutionary
work of Klein and Lie.
Weierstrass demonstrated extreme brilliance as a youth, but during his college years
he detoured into drinking and dueling and ended up as a degreeless secondary school
teacher. During this time he studied Abel's papers, developed results in elliptic and
Abelian functions, proved the Laurent expansion theorem before Laurent did, and
independently proved the Fundamental Theorem of Functions of a Complex Variable.
He was interested in power series and felt that others had overlooked the importance
of Abel's Theorem. Eventually one of his papers was published in a journal; he was
immediately given an honorary doctorate and was soon regarded as one of the best
and most inspirational mathematicians in the world. His insistence on absolutely
rigorous proofs equaled or exceeded even that of Cauchy, Abel and Dirichlet. His
students included Kovalevskaya, Frobenius, Mittag-Leffler, and several other famous
mathematicians. Bell called him "probably the greatest mathematical teacher of all
time." In 1873 Hermite called Weierstrass "the Master of all of us." Today he is often
called the "Father of Modern Analysis."
Weierstrass once wrote: "A mathematician who is not also something of a poet will
never be a complete mathematician."
George Boole was a precocious child who impressed by teaching himself classical
languages, but was too poor to attend college and became an elementary school
teacher at age 16. He gradually developed his math skills; as a young man he
published a paper on the calculus of variations, and soon became one of the most
respected mathematicians in England despite having no formal training. He was noted
for work in symbolic logic, algebra and analysis, and also was apparently the first to
discover invariant theory. When he followed up Augustus de Morgan's earlier work in
symbolic logic, de Morgan insisted that Boole was the true master of that field, and
begged his friend to finally study mathematics at university. Boole couldn't afford to,
and had to be appointed Professor instead!
Although very few recognized its importance at the time, it is Boole's work in
Boolean algebra and symbolic logic for which he is now remembered; this work
inspired computer scientists like Claude Shannon. Boole's book An Investigation of
the Laws of Thought prompted Bertrand Russell to label him the "discoverer of pure
mathematics."
Boole once said "No matter how correct a mathematical theorem may appear to be,
one ought never to be satisfied that there was not something imperfect about it until it
also gives the impression of being beautiful."
Chebyshev was also a premier applied mathematician and a renowned inventor; his
several inventions include the Chebyshev linkage, a mechanical device to convert
rotational motion to straight-line motion. He once wrote "To isolate mathematics from
the practical demands of the sciences is to invite the sterility of a cow shut away from
the bulls."
Arthur Cayley (1821-1895) England
Cayley was one of the most prolific mathematicians in history; a list of the branches
of mathematics he pioneered will seem like an exaggeration. In addition to being very
inventive, he was an excellent algorist; some considered him to be the greatest
mathematician of the late 19th century (an era that includes Weierstrass and
Poincar). Cayley was the essential founder of modern group theory, matrix algebra,
the theory of higher singularities, and higher-dimensional geometry (building on
Plcker's work and anticipating the ideas of Klein), as well as the theory of invariants.
Among his many important theorems are the Cayley-Hamilton Theorem, and Cayley's
Theorem itself (that any group is isomorphic to a subgroup of a symmetric group). He
extended Hamilton's quaternions and developed the octonions, but was still one of the
first to realize that these special algebras should be subsumed by general matrix
methods. He also did original research in combinatorics (e.g. enumeration of trees),
elliptic and Abelian functions, and projective geometry. One of his famous geometric
theorems is a generalization of Pascal's Mystic Hexagram result; another resulted in
an elegant proof of the Quadratic Reciprocity law.
Cayley may have been the least eccentric of the great mathematicians: In addition to
his life-long love of mathematics, he enjoyed hiking, painting, reading fiction, and had
a happy married life. He easily won Smith's Prize and Senior Wrangler at Cambridge,
but then worked as a lawyer for many years. He later became professor, and finished
his career in the limelight as President of the British Association for the Advancement
of Science. He and James Joseph Sylvester were a source of inspiration to each other.
These two, along with Charles Hermite, are considered the founders of the important
theory of invariants. Though applied first to algebra, the notion of invariants is useful
in many areas of mathematics.
Cayley once wrote: "As for everything else, so for a mathematical theory: beauty can
be perceived but not explained."
Hermite studied the works of Lagrange and Gauss from an early age and soon
developed an alternate proof of Abel's famous quintic impossibility result. He
attended the same college as Galois and also had trouble passing their examinations,
but soon became highly respected by Europe's best mathematicians for his significant
advances in analytic number theory, elliptic functions, and quadratic forms. Along
with Cayley and Sylvester, he founded the important theory of invariants. Hermite's
theory of transformation allowed him to connect analysis, algebra and number theory
in novel ways. He was a kindly modest man and an inspirational teacher. Among his
students was Poincar, who said of Hermite, "He never evokes a concrete image, yet
you soon perceive that the more abstract entities are to him like living creatures....
Methods always seemed to be born in his mind in some mysterious way." Hermite's
other famous students included Darboux, Borel, and Hadamard who wrote of "how
magnificent Hermite's teaching was, overflowing with enthusiasm for science, which
seemed to come to life in his voice and whose beauty he never failed to communicate
to us, since he felt it so much himself to the very depth of his being."
Although he and Abel had proved that the general quintic lacked algebraic solutions,
Hermite introduced an elliptic analog to the circular trigonometric functions and used
these to provide a general solution for the quintic equation. He developed the concept
of complex conjugate which is now ubiquitous in mathematical physics and matrix
theory. He was first to prove that the Stirling and Euler generalizations of the factorial
function are equivalent. He was first to note remarkable facts about Heegner numbers,
e.g.
e163 = 262537412640768743.9999999999992...
(Without computers he was able to calculate this number, including the twelve 9's to
the right of the decimal point.) Very many elegant concepts and theorems are named
after Hermite. Hermite's most famous result may be his intricate proof that e (along
with a broad class of related numbers) is transcendental. (Extending the proof
to was left to Lindemann, a matter of regret for historians, some of whom who
regard Hermite as the greatest mathematician of his era.)
Eisenstein was born into severe poverty and suffered health problems throughout his
short life, but was still one of the more significant mathematicians of his era. Today's
mathematicians who study Eisenstein are invariably amazed by his brilliance and
originality. He made revolutionary advances in number theory, algebra and analysis,
and was also a composer of music. He anticipated ring theory, developed a new basis
for elliptic functions, studied ternary quadratic forms, proved several theorems about
cubic and higher-degree reciprocity, discovered the notion of analytic covariant, and
much more.
Eisenstein was a young prodigy; he once wrote "As a boy of six I could understand
the proof of a mathematical theorem more readily than that meat had to be cut with
one's knife, not one's fork." Despite his early death, he is considered one of the
greatest number theorists ever. Gauss named Eisenstein, along with Newton and
Archimedes, as one of the three epoch-making mathematicians of history.
Kronecker was a businessman who pursued mathematics mainly as a hobby, but was
still very prolific, and one of the greatest theorem provers of his era. He explored a
wide variety of mathematics -- number theory, algebra, analysis, matrixes -- and
especially the interconnections between areas. Many concepts and theorems are
named after Kronecker; some of his theorems are frequently used as lemmas in
algebraic number theory, ergodic theory, and approximation theory. He provided key
ideas about foundations and continuity despite that he had philosophic objections to
irrational numbers and infinities. He also introduced the Theory of Divisors to avoid
Dedekind's Ideals; the importance of this and other work was only realized long after
his death. Kronecker's philosophy eventually led to the Constructivism and
Intuitionism of Brouwer and Poincar.
Riemann's teacher was Carl Gauss, who helped steer the young genius towards pure
mathematics. Gauss selected "On the hypotheses that Lie at the Foundations of
Geometry" as Riemann's first lecture; with this famous lecture Riemann went far
beyond Gauss' initial effort in differential geometry, extended it to multiple
dimensions, and introduced the new and important theory of differential manifolds.
Five years later, to celebrate his election to the Berlin Academy, Riemann presented a
lecture "On the Number of Prime Numbers Less Than a Given Quantity," for which
"Number" he presented and partially proved an exact formula, albeit weirdly
complicated. Numerous papers have been written on the distribution of primes, but
Riemann's contribution is incomparable, despite that his Berlin Academy lecture was
his only paper ever on the topic, and number theory was far from his specialty. In the
lecture he posed the Hypothesis of Riemann's zeta function, needed for the missing
step in his proof. This Hypothesis is considered the most important and famous
unsolved problem in mathematics. (Asked what he would first do, if he were
magically awakened after centuries, David Hilbert replied "I would ask whether
anyone had proved the Riemann Hypothesis.") (.) was defined for convergent cases
in Euler's mini-bio, which Riemann extended via analytic continuation for all cases.
The Riemann Hypothesis "simply" states that in all solutions of (s = a+bi) = 0,
either s has real part a=1/2 or imaginary part b=0.
Despite his great creativity (Gauss praised Riemann's "gloriously fertile originality;"
another biographer called him "one of the most profound and imaginative
mathematicians of all time [and] a great philosopher"), Riemann once said: "If only I
had the theorems! Then I should find the proofs easily enough."
Henry Smith (born in Ireland) was one of the greatest number theorists, working
especially with elementary divisors; he also advanced the theory of quadratic forms. A
famous problem of Eisenstein was, given n and k, in how many different ways
can n be expressed as the sum of k squares? Smith made great progress on this
problem, subsuming special cases which had earlier been famous theorems. Although
most noted for number theory, he had great breadth. He did prize-winning work in
geometry, discovered the unique normal form for matrices which now bears his name,
anticipated specific fractals including the Cantor set, the Sierpinski gasket and the
Koch snowflake, and wrote a paper demonstrating the limitations of Riemann
integration.
Smith is sometimes called "the mathematician the world forgot." His paper on
integration could have led directly to measure theory and Lebesgue integration, but
was ignored for decades. The fractals he discovered are named after people who
rediscovered them. The Smith-Minkowski-Siegel mass formula of lattice theory
would be called just the Smith formula, but had to be rediscovered. And his solution
to the Eisenstein five-squares problem, buried in his voluminous writings on number
theory, was ignored: this "unsolved" problem was featured for a prize which
Minkowski won two decades later!
Henry Smith was an outstanding intellect with a modest and charming personality. He
was knowledgeable in a broad range of fields unrelated to mathematics; his University
even insisted he run for Parliament. His love of mathematics didn't depend on utility:
he once wrote "Pure mathematics: may it never be of any use to anyone."
Luigi Cremona made many important advances in analytic, synthetic and projective
geometry, especially in the transformations of algebraic curves and surfaces. Working
in mathematical physics, he developed the new field of graphical statics, and used it to
reinterpret some of Maxwell's results. He improved (or found brilliant proofs for)
several results of Steiner, especially in the field of cubic surfaces. (Some of this work
was done in collaboration with Rudolf Sturm.) He is especially noted for developing
the theory of Cremona transformations which have very wide application. He found a
generalization of Pascal's Mystic Hexagram. Cremona also played a political role in
establishing the modern Italian state and, as an excellent teacher, helped make Italy a
top center of mathematics.
Maxwell published a remarkable paper on the construction of novel ovals, at the age
of 14; his genius was soon renowned throughout Scotland, with the future Lord
Kelvin remarking that Maxwell's "lively imagination started so many hares that before
he had run one down he was off on another." He did a comprehensive analysis of
Saturn's rings, developed the important kinetic theory of gases, explored elasticity,
knot theory, soap bubbles, and more. He introduced the "Maxwell's Demon" as a
thought experiment for thermodynamics; his paper "On Governors" effectively
founded the field of cybernetics; he advanced the theory of color, and produced the
first color photograph. One Professor said of him, "there is scarcely a single topic that
he touched upon, which he did not change almost beyond recognition." Maxwell was
also a poet.
Dedekind was one of the most innovative mathematicians ever; his clear expositions
and rigorous axiomatic methods had great influence. He made seminal contributions
to abstract algebra and algebraic number theory as well as mathematical foundations.
He was one of the first to pursue Galois Theory, making major advances there and
pioneering in the application of group theory to other branches of mathematics.
Dedekind also invented a system of fundamental axioms for arithmetic, worked in
probability theory and complex analysis, and invented prime partitions and modular
lattices. Dedekind may be most famous for his theory of ideals and rings; Kronecker
and Kummer had begun this, but Dedekind gave it a more abstract and productive
basis, which was developed further by Hilbert, Noether and Weil. Though the
term ring itself was coined by Hilbert, Dedekind introduced the terms module, field,
and ideal. Dedekind was far ahead of his time, so Noether became famous as the
creator of modern algebra; but she acknowledged her great predecessor, frequently
saying "It is all already in Dedekind."
Dedekind was concerned with rigor, writing "nothing capable of proof ought to be
accepted without proof." Before him, the real numbers, continuity, and infinity all
lacked rigorous definitions. The axioms Dedekind invented allow the integers and
rational numbers to be built and his Dedekind Cut then led to a rigorous and useful
definition of the real numbers. Dedekind was a key mentor for Georg Cantor: he
introduced the notion that a bijection implied equinumerosity, used this to define
infinitude (a set is infinite if equinumerous with its proper subset), and was first to
prove the Cantor-Bernstein Theorem, though he didn't publish his proof. (Because he
spent his career at a minor university, and neglected to publish some of his work,
Dedekind's contributions may be underestimated.)
Lie was twenty-five years old before his interest in and aptitude for mathematics
became clear, but then did revolutionary work with continuous symmetry and
continuous transformation groups. These groups and the algebra he developed to
manipulate them now bear his name; they have major importance in the study of
differential equations. Lie sphere geometry is one result of Lie's fertile approach and
even led to a new approach for Apollonius' ancient problem about tangent circles. Lie
became a close friend and collaborator of Felix Klein early in their careers; their
methods of relating group theory to geometry were quite similar; but they eventually
fell out after Klein became (unfairly?) recognized as the superior of the two. Lie's
work wasn't properly appreciated in his own lifetime, but one later commentator was
"overwhelmed by the richness and beauty of the geometric ideas flowing from Lie's
work."
Clifford was a versatile and talented mathematician who was among the first to
appreciate the work of both Riemann and Grassmann. He found new connections
between algebra, topology and non-Euclidean geometry. Combining Hamilton's
quaternions, Grassmann's exterior algebra, and his own geometric intuition and
understanding of physics, he developed biquaternions, and generalized this
to geometric algebra, which paralleled work by Klein. In addition to developing
theories, he also produced ingenious proofs; for example he was first to prove
Miquel's n-Circle Theorem, and did so with a purely geometric argument. Clifford is
especially famous for anticipating, before Einstein, that gravitation could be modeled
with a non-Euclidean space. He was a polymath; a talented teacher, noted
philosopher, and outstanding athlete. With his singular genius, Clifford would
probably have become one of the greatest mathematicians of his era had he not died at
age thirty-three.
Cantor's revolutionary set theory attracted vehement opposition from Poincar ("grave
disease"), Kronecker (Cantor was a "charlatan" and "corrupter of youth"),
Wittgenstein ("laughable nonsense"), and even theologians. David Hilbert had kinder
words for it: "The finest product of mathematical genius and one of the supreme
achievements of purely intellectual human activity" and addressed the critics with "no
one shall expel us from the paradise that Cantor has created." Cantor's own attitude
was expressed with "The essence of mathematics lies in its freedom." Cantor's set
theory laid the theoretical basis for the measure theory developed by Borel and
Lebesgue. Cantor's invention of modern set theory is now considered one of the most
important and creative achievements in modern mathematics.
Cantor demonstrated much breadth (he even involved himself in the Shakespeare
authorship controversy!). In addition to his set theory and key discoveries in the
theory of trigonometric series, he made advances in number theory, and gave the
modern definition of irrational numbers. His Cantor set was the early inspiration for
fractals. Cantor was also an excellent violinist. He once wrote "In mathematics the art
of proposing a question must be held of higher value than solving it."
Gottlob Frege developed the first complete and fully rigorous system of pure logic;
his work has been called the greatest advance in logic since Aristotle. He introduced
the essential notion of quantifiers; he distinguished terms from predicates, and simple
predicates from 2nd-level predicates. From his second-order logic he defined
numbers, and derived the axioms of arithmetic with what is now called Frege's
Theorem. His work was largely underappreciated at the time, partly because of his
clumsy notation, partly because his system was published with a flaw (Russell's
antinomy). He and Cantor were the era's outstanding foundational theorists;
unfortunately their relationship with each other became bitter. Despite all this, Frege's
work influenced Peano, Russell, Wittgenstein and others; and he is now often called
the greatest mathematical logician ever.
Frege also did work in geometry and differential equations; and, in order to construct
the real numbers with his set theory, proved an important new theorem of group
theory. He was also an important philosopher, and wrote "Every good mathematician
is at least half a philosopher, and every good philosopher is at least half a
mathematician."
Klein's key contribution was an application of invariant theory to unify geometry with
group theory. This radical new view of geometry inspired Sophus Lie's Lie groups,
and also led to the remarkable unification of Euclidean and non-Euclidean geometries
which is probably Klein's most famous result. Klein did other work in function theory,
providing links between several areas of mathematics including number theory, group
theory, hyperbolic geometry, and abstract algebra. His Klein's Quartic curve and
popularly-famous Klein's bottle were among several useful results from his new
approaches to groups and higher-dimensional geometries and equations. Klein did
significant work in mathematical physics, e.g. writing about gyroscopes. He facilitated
David Hilbert's early career, publishing his controversial Finite Basis Theorem and
declaring it "without doubt the most important work on general algebra [the leading
German journal] ever published."
Klein is also famous for his book on the icosahedron, reasoning from its symmetries
to develop the elliptic modular and automorphic functions which he used to solve the
general quintic equation. He formulated a "grand uniformization theorem" about
automorphic functions but suffered a health collapse before completing the proof. His
focus then changed to teaching; he devised a mathematics curriculum for secondary
schools which had world-wide influence. Klein once wrote "... mathematics has been
most advanced by those who distinguished themselves by intuition rather than by
rigorous proofs."
Markov had a son, also named Andrei Andreyevich, who was also an outstanding
mathematician of great breadth. Among the son's achievements was Markov's
Theorem, which helps relate the theories of braids and knots to each other.
Despite his early show of genius, Peano's quest for utter rigor may have detracted
from his influence in mainstream mathematics. Moreover, since he modestly
referenced work by predecessors like Dedekind, Peano's huge influence in axiomatic
theory is often overlooked. Yet Bertrand Russell reports that it was from Peano that he
first learned that a single-member set is not the same as its element; this fact is now
taught in elementary school.
Vito Volterra founded the field of functional analysis ('functions of lines'), and used it
to extend the work of Hamilton and Jacobi to more areas of mathematical physics. He
developed cylindrical waves and the theory of integral equations. He worked in
mechanics, developed the theory of crystal dislocations, and was first to propose the
use of helium in balloons. Eventually he turned to mathematical biology and made
notable contributions to that field, e.g. predator-prey equations.
Any one man can only do so much, so the greatest mathematicians should help
nurture their colleagues. Hilbert provided a famous List of 23 Unsolved Problems,
which inspired and directed the development of 20th-century mathematics. Hilbert
was warmly regarded by his colleagues and students, and contributed to the careers of
several great mathematicians and physicists including Georg Cantor, Hermann
Minkowski, Hermann Weyl, John von Neumann, Emmy Noether, Alonzo Church,
and Albert Einstein.
Eventually Hilbert turned to physics and made key contributions to classical and
quantum physics and to general relativity. He published the Einstein Field
Equations independently of Einstein (though his writings make clear he treats this as
strictly Einstein's invention).
Hausdorff had diverse interests: he composed music and wrote poetry, studied
astronomy, wrote on philosophy, but eventually focused on mathematics, where he
did important work in several fields including set theory, measure theory, functional
analysis, and both algebraic and point-set topology. His studies in set theory led him
to the Hausdorff Maximal Principle, and the Generalized Continuum Hypothesis; his
concepts now called Hausdorff measure and Hausdorff dimension led to geometric
measure theory and fractal geometry; his Hausdorff paradox led directly to the famous
Banach-Tarski paradox; he introduced other seminal concepts, e.g. Hausdorff
Distance. He also worked in analysis, solving the Hausdorff moment problem.
As Jews in Hitler's Germany, Hausdorff and his wife committed suicide rather than
submit to internment.
lie Joseph Cartan (1869-1951) France
Cartan worked in the theory of Lie groups and Lie algebras, applying methods of
topology, geometry and invariant theory to Lie theory, and classifying all Lie groups.
This work was so significant that Cartan, rather than Lie, is considered the most
important developer of the theory of Lie groups. Using Lie theory and ideas like
his Method of Prolongation he advanced the theories of differential equations and
differential geometry. Cartan introduced several new concepts including algebraic
group, exterior differential forms, spinors, moving frames, Cartan connections. He
proved several important theorems, e.g. Schlfli's Conjecture about embedding
Riemann metrics, and fundamental theorems about symmetric Riemann spaces. He
made a key contribution to Einstein's general relativity, based on what is now called
Riemann-Cartan geometry. Cartan's methods were so original as to be fully
appreciated only recently; many now consider him to be one of the greatest
mathematicians of his era. In 1938 Weyl called him "the greatest living master in
differential geometry."
Borel exhibited great talent while still in his teens, soon practically founded modern
measure theory, and received several honors and prizes. Among his famous theorems
is the Heine-Borel Covering Theorem. He also did important work in several other
fields of mathematics, including divergent series, quasi-analytic functions, differential
equations, number theory, complex analysis, theory of functions, geometry,
probability theory, and game theory. Relating measure theory to probabilities, he
introduced concepts like normal numbers and the Borel-Kolmogorov paradox. He
also did work in relativity and the philosophy of science. He anticipated the concept
of chaos, inspiring Poincar. Borel combined great creativity with strong analytic
power; however he was especially interested in applications, philosophy, and
education, so didn't pursue the tedium of rigorous development and proof; for this
reason his great importance as a theorist is often underestimated. Borel was decorated
for valor in World War I, entered politics between the Wars, and joined the French
Resistance during World War II.
Levi-Civita was noted for strong geometrical intuition, and excelled at both pure
mathematics and mathematical physics. He worked in analytic number theory,
differential equations, tensor calculus, hydrodynamics, celestial mechanics, and the
theory of stability. Several inventions are named after him, e.g. the non-archimedean
Levi-Civita field, the Levi-Civita parallelogramoid, and the Levi-Civita symbol. His
work inspired all three of the greatest 20th-century mathematical physicists, laying
key mathematical groundwork for Weyl's unified field theory, Einstein's relativity,
and Dirac's quantum theory.
Landau was one of the most prolific and influential number theorists ever; he was also
adept at complex function theory. He was especially keen at finding very simple
proofs: one of his most famous results was a simpler proof of Hadamard's prime
number theorem; being simpler it was also more fruitful and led to Landau's Prime
Ideal Theorem. In addition to simpler proofs of existing theorems, new theorems by
Landau include important facts about Riemann's Hypothesis; facts about Dirichlet
series; key lemmas of analysis; a result in Waring's Problem; a generalization of the
Little Picard Theorem; a partial proof of Gauss' conjecture about the density of classes
of composite numbers; and key results in the theory of pecking orders, e.g. every
flock has at least one "king," never exactly two kings, and exactly one king only if that
king is an "emperor." (If every chicken except X is pecked either by X or someone
pecked by X, then X is defined as a "King." Landau's pecking orders are now
described as round-robin tournaments.) Landau was also the inventor of big-O
notation. Hardy wrote that no one was ever more passionately devoted to mathematics
than Landau.
Godfrey Harold Hardy (1877-1947) England
Hardy was an extremely prolific research mathematician who did important work in
analysis (especially the theory of integration), number theory, global analysis, and
analytic number theory. He proved several important theorems about numbers, for
example that Riemann's zeta function has infinitely many zeros with real part 1/2. He
was also an excellent teacher and wrote several excellent textbooks, as well as a
famous treatise on the mathematical mind. He abhorred applied mathematics, treating
mathematics as a creative art; yet his work has found application in population
genetics, cryptography, thermodynamics and particle physics.
Hardy once wrote "A mathematician, like a painter or poet, is a maker of patterns. If
his patterns are more permanent than theirs, it is because they are made with ideas."
He also wrote "Beauty is the first test; there is no permanent place in the world for
ugly mathematics."
Maurice Frchet introduced the concept of metric spaces (though not using that term);
and also made major contributions to point-set topology. Building on work of
Hadamard and Volterra, he generalized Banach spaces to use new (non-normed)
metrics and proved that many important theorems still applied in these more general
spaces. For this work, and his invention of the notion of compactness, Frchet is
called the Founder of the Theory of Abstract Spaces. He also did important work in
probability theory and in analysis; for example he proved the Riesz Representation
Theorem the same year Riesz did. Many theorems and inventions are named after
him, for example Frchet Distance, which has many applications in applied math, e.g.
protein structure analysis.
Albert Einstein (1879-1955) Germany, Switzerland, U.S.A.
Albert Einstein was unquestionably one of the two greatest physicists in all of history.
The atomic theory achieved general acceptance only after Einstein's 1905 paper which
showed that atoms' discreteness explained Brownian motion. Another 1905 paper
introduced the famous equation E = mc2; yet Einstein published other papers that
same year, two of which were more important and influential than either of the two
just mentioned. No wonder that physicists speak of the Miracle Year without
bothering to qualify it as Einstein's Miracle Year! (Before his Miracle Year, Einstein
had been a mediocre undergraduate, and held minor jobs including patent examiner.)
Altogether Einstein published at least 300 books or papers on physics. For example, in
a 1917 paper he anticipated the principle of the laser. Also, sometimes in
collaboration with Leo Szilard, he was co-inventor of several devices, including a
gyroscopic compass, hearing aid, automatic camera and, most famously, the Einstein-
Szilard refrigerator. He became a very famous and influential public figure. (For
example, it was his letter that led Roosevelt to start the Manhattan Project.) Among
his many famous quotations is: "The search for truth is more precious than its
possession."
Einstein is most famous for his Special and General Theories of Relativity, but he
should be considered the key pioneer of Quantum Theory as well, drawing inferences
from Planck's work that no one else dared to draw. Indeed it was his articulation of the
quantum principle in a 1905 paper which has been called "the most revolutionary
sentence written by a physicist of the twentieth century." Einstein's discovery of the
photon in that paper led to his only Nobel Prize; years later, he was first to call
attention to the "spooky" nature of quantum entanglement. Einstein was also first to
call attention to a flaw in Weyl's earliest unified field theory. But despite the
importance of his other contributions it is Einstein's General Theory which is his most
profound contribution. Minkowski had developed a flat 4-dimensional space-time to
cope with Einstein's Special Theory; but it was Einstein who had the vision to add
curvature to that space to describe acceleration.
Einstein certainly has the breadth, depth, and historical importance to qualify for this
list; but his genius and significance were not in the field of pure mathematics. (He
acknowledged his limitation, writing "I admire the elegance of your [Levi-Civita's]
method of computation; it must be nice to ride through these fields upon the horse of
true mathematics while the like of us have to make our way laboriously on foot.")
Einstein was a mathematician, however; he pioneered the application of tensor
calculus to physics and invented the Einstein summation notation. That Einstein's
equation explained a discrepancy in Mercury's orbit was a discovery made by Einstein
personally (a discovery he described as 'joyous excitement' that gave him heart
palpitations). He composed a beautiful essay about mathematical proofs using the
Theorem of Menelaus as his example. Certainly he belongs on a Top 100 List: his
extreme greatness overrides his focus away from math. Einstein ranks #10 on Michael
Hart's famous list of the Most Influential Persons in History. His General Theory of
Relativity has been called the most creative and original scientific theory ever.
Einstein once wrote "... the creative principle resides in mathematics [; thus] I hold it
true that pure thought can grasp reality, as the ancients dreamed."
Oswald Veblen's first mathematical achievement was a novel system of axioms for
geometry. He also worked in topology; projective geometry; differential geometry
(where he was first to introduce the concept of differentiable manifold); ordinal theory
(where he introduced the Veblen hierarchy); and mathematical physics where he
worked with spinors and relativity. He developed a new theory of ballistics during
World War I and helped plan the first American computer during World War II. His
famous theorems include the Veblen-Young Theorem (an important algebraic fact
about projective spaces); a proof of the Jordan Curve Theorem more rigorous than
Jordan's; and Veblen's Theorem itself (a generalization of Euler's result about cycles
in graphs). Veblen, a nephew of the famous economist Thorstein Veblen, was an
important teacher; his famous students included Alonzo Church, John W. Alexander,
Robert L. Moore, and J.H.C. Whitehead. He was also a key figure in establishing
Princeton's Institute of Advanced Study; the first five mathematicians he hired for the
Institute were Einstein, von Neumann, Weyl, J.W. Alexander and Marston Morse.
Brouwer is often considered the "Father of Topology;" among his important theorems
were the Fixed Point Theorem, the "Hairy Ball" Theorem, the Jordan-Brouwer
Separation Theorem, and the Invariance of Dimension. He developed the method of
simplicial approximations, important to algebraic topology; he also did work in
geometry, set theory, measure theory, complex analysis and the foundations of
mathematics. He was first to anticipate forms like the Lakes of Wada, leading
eventually to other measure-theory "paradoxes." Several great mathematicians,
including Weyl, were inspired by Brouwer's work in topology.
Brouwer is most famous as the founder of Intuitionism, a philosophy of mathematics
in sharp contrast to Hilbert's Formalism, but Brouwer's philosophy also involved
ethics and aesthetics and has been compared with those of Schopenhauer and
Nietzsche. Part of his mathematics thesis was rejected as "... interwoven with some
kind of pessimism and mystical attitude to life which is not mathematics ..." As a
young man, Brouwer spent a few years to develop topology, but once his great talent
was demonstrated and he was offered prestigious professorships, he devoted himself
to Intuitionism, and acquired a reputation as eccentric and self-righteous.
Intuitionism has had a significant influence, although few strict adherents. Since only
constructive proofs are permitted, strict adherence would slow mathematical work.
This didn't worry Brouwer who once wrote: "The construction itself is an art, its
application to the world an evil parasite."
Noether's work has found various applications in physics, and she made direct
advances in mathematical physics herself. Noether's Theorem establishing that certain
symmetries imply conservation laws has been called the most important Theorem in
physics since the Pythagorean Theorem. Several other important theorems are named
after her, e.g. Noether's Normalization Lemma, which provided an important new
proof of Hilbert's Nullstellensatz. Noether was an unusual and inspiring teacher; her
successful students included Emil Artin, Max Deuring, Jacob Levitzki, etc. She was
generous with students and colleagues, even allowing them to claim her work as their
own. Noether was close friends with the other greatest mathematicians of her
generation: Hilbert, von Neumann, and Weyl. Weyl once said he was embarrassed to
accept the famous Professorship at Gttingen because Noether was his "superior as a
mathematician." Emmy Noether is considered the greatest female mathematician ever.
Waclaw Sierpinski (1882-1969) Poland
Sierpinski was first to prove Tarski's remarkable conjecture that the Generalized
Continuum Hypothesis implies the Axiom of Choice. He developed three famous
fractals: a space-filling curve; the Sierpinski gasket; and the Sierpinski carpet, which
covers the plane but has area zero and has found application in antennae design. Borel
had proved that almost all real numbers are "normal" but Sierpinski was the first to
actually display a number which is normal in every base. He proved the existence of
infinitely many Sierpinski numbers having the property that, e.g. (785572n+1) is
composite number for every natural number n. It remains an unsolved problem (likely
to be defeated soon with high-speed computers) whether 78557 is the smallest such
"Sierpinski number."
Birkhoff is one of the greatest native-born American mathematicians ever, and did
important work in many fields. There are several significant theorems named after
him: the Birkhoff-Grothendieck Theorem is an important result about vector bundles;
Birkhoff's Theorem is an important result in algebra; and Birkhoff's Ergodic Theorem
is a key result in statistical mechanics which has since been applied to many other
fields. His Poincar-Birkhoff Fixed Point Theorem is especially important in celestial
mechanics, and led to instant worldwide fame: the great Poincar had described it as
most important, but had been unable to complete the proof. In algebraic graph theory,
he invented Birkhoff's chromatic polynomial (while trying to prove the four-color
map theorem); he proved a significant result in general relativity which implied the
existence of black holes; he also worked in differential equations and number theory;
he authored an important text on dynamical systems. Like several of the great
mathematicians of that era, Birkhoff developed his own set of axioms for geometry; it
is his axioms that are often found in today's high school texts. Birkhoff's intellectual
interests went beyond mathematics; he once wrote "The transcendent importance of
love and goodwill in all human relations is shown by their mighty beneficent effect
upon the individual and society."
Vladimir Vizgin wrote "To this day, Weyl's [unified field] theory astounds all in the
depth of its ideas, its mathematical simplicity, and the elegance of its realization."
Weyl once wrote: "My work always tried to unite the Truth with the Beautiful, but
when I had to choose one or the other, I usually chose the Beautiful."
John Littlewood was a very prolific researcher. (This fact is obscured somewhat in
that many papers were co-authored with Hardy, and their names were always given in
alphabetic order.) The tremendous span of his career is suggested by the fact that he
won Smith's Prize (and Senior Wrangler) in 1905 and the Copley Medal in 1958. He
specialized in analysis and analytic number theory but also did important work in
combinatorics, Fourier theory, Diophantine approximations, differential equations,
and other fields. He also did important work in practical engineering, creating a
method for accurate artillery fire during the First World War, and developing
equations for radio and radar in preparation for the Second War. He worked with the
Prime Number Theorem and Riemann's Hypothesis; and proved the unexpected fact
that Chebyshev's bias, and Li(x)>(x), while true for most, and all but very large,
numbers, are violated infinitely often. Some of his work was elementary, e.g. his
elegant proof that a cube cannot be dissected into unequal cubes; but most of his
results were too specialized to state here, e.g. his widely-applied 4/3 Inequality which
guarantees that certain bimeasures are finite, and which inspired one of
Grothendieck's most famous results. Hardy once said that his friend was "the man
most likely to storm and smash a really deep and formidable problem; there was no
one else who could command such a combination of insight, technique and power."
Littlewood's response was that it was possible to be too strong of a mathematician,
"forcing through, where another might be driven to a different, and possibly more
fruitful, approach."
Ramanujan's most famous work was with the partition enumeration function p(),
Hardy guessing that some of these discoveries would have been delayed at least a
century without Ramanujan. Together, Hardy and Ramanujan developed an analytic
approximation to p(), although Hardy was initially awed by Ramanujan's intuitive
certainty about the existence of such a formula, and even the form it would have.
(Rademacher and Selberg later discovered an exact expression to replace the Hardy-
Ramanujan approximation; when Ramanujan's notebooks were studied it was found
he had anticipated their technique, but had deferred to his friend and mentor.)
In a letter from his deathbed, Ramanujan introduced his mysterious "mock theta
functions", gave examples, and developed their properties. Much later these forms
began to appear in disparate areas: combinatorics, the proof of Fermat's Last
Theorem, and even knot theory and the theory of black holes. It was only recently,
more than 80 years after Ramanujan's letter, that his conjectures about these functions
were proven; solutions mathematicians had sought unsuccessfully were found among
his examples. Mathematicians are baffled that Ramanujan could make these
conjectures, which they confirmed only with difficulty using methods not available in
Ramanujan's day.
Thoralf Skolem proved fundamental theorems of lattice theory, proved the Skolem-
Noether Theorem of algebra, also worked with set theory and Diophantine equations;
but is best known for his work in logic, metalogic, and non-standard models. Some of
his work preceded similar results by Gdel. He developed a theory of recursive
functions which anticipated some computer science. He worked on the famous
Lwenheim-Skolem Theorem which has the "paradoxical" consequence that systems
with uncountable sets can have countable models. ("Legend has it that Thoralf
Skolem, up until the end of his life, was scandalized by the association of his name to
a result of this type, which he considered an absurdity, nondenumerable sets being, for
him, fictions without real existence.")
George Plya (Plya Gyrgy) did significant work in several fields: complex analysis,
probability, geometry, algebraic number theory, and combinatorics, but is most noted
for his teaching How to Solve It, the craft of problem posing and proof. He is also
famous for the Plya Enumeration Theorem. Several other important theorems he
proved include the Plya-Vinogradov Inequality of number theory, the Plya-Szego
Inequality of functional analysis, and the Plya Inequality of measure theory. He
introduced the Hilbert-Plya Conjecture that the Riemann Hypothesis might be a
consequence of spectral theory; he introduced the famous "All horses are the same
color" example of inductive fallacy; he named the Central Limit Theorem of statistics.
Plya was the "teacher par excellence": he wrote top books on multiple subjects; his
successful students included John von Neumann. His work on plane symmetry groups
directly inspired Escher's drawings. Having huge breadth and influence, Plya has
been called "the most influential mathematician of the 20th century."
Stefan Banach (1892-1945) Poland
Stefan Banach was a self-taught mathematician who is most noted as the "Founder of
Functional Analysis" and for his contributions to measure theory. Among several
important theorems bearing his name are the Uniform Boundedness (Banach-
Steinhaus) Theorem, the Open Mapping (Banach-Schauder) Theorem, the Contraction
Mapping (Banach fixed-point) Theorem, and the Hahn-Banach Theorem. Many of
these theorems are of practical value to modern physics; however he also proved the
paradoxical Banach-Tarski Theorem, which demonstrates a sphere being rearranged
into two spheres of the same original size. (Banach's proof uses the Axiom of Choice
and is sometimes cited as evidence that that Axiom is false.) The wide range of
Banach's work is indicated by the Banach-Mazur results in game theory (which also
challenge the axiom of choice). Banach also made brilliant contributions to
probability theory, set theory, analysis and topology.
Banach once said "Mathematics is the most beautiful and most powerful creation of
the human spirit."
Norbert Wiener entered college at age 11, studying various sciences; he wrote a PhD
dissertation at age 17 in philosophy of mathematics where he was one of the first to
show a definition of ordered pair as a set. (Hausdorff also proposed such a definition;
both Wiener's and Hausdorff's definitions have been superceded by Kuratowski's (a,
b) = {{a}, {a, b}} despite that it leads to a singleton when a=b.) He then did
important work in several topics in applied mathematics, including stochastic
processes (beginning with Brownian motion), potential theory, Fourier analysis, the
Wiener-Hopf decomposition useful for solving differential and integral equations,
communication theory, cognitive science, and quantum theory. Many theorems and
concepts are named after him, e.g the Wiener Filter used to reduce the error in noisy
signals. His most important contribution to pure mathematics was his generalization
of Fourier theory into generalized harmonic analysis, but he is most famous for his
writings on feedback in control systems, for which he coined the new
word, cybernetics. Wiener was first to relate information to thermodynamic entropy,
and anticipated the theory of information attributed to Claude Shannon. He also
designed an early analog computer. Although they differed dramatically in both
personal and mathematical outlooks, he and John von Neumann were the two key
pioneers (after Turing) in computer science. Wiener applied his cybernetics to draw
conclusions about human society which, unfortunately, remain largely unheeded.
Carl Ludwig Siegel (1896-1981) Germany
Carl Siegel became famous when his doctoral dissertation established a key result in
Diophantine approximations. He continued with contributions to several branches of
analytic and algebraic number theory, including arithmetic geometry and quadratic
forms. He also did seminal work with Riemann's zeta function, Dedekind's zeta
functions, transcendental number theory, discontinuous groups, the 3-body problem in
celestial mechanics, and symplectic geometry. In complex analysis he developed
Siegel modular forms, which have wide application in math and physics. He may
share credit with Alexander Gelfond for the solution to Hilbert's 7th Problem, Siegel
admired the "simplicity and honesty" of masters like Gauss, Lagrange and Hardy and
lamented the modern "trend for senseless abstraction." He and Israel Gelfand were the
first two winners of the Wolf Prize in Mathematics. Atle Selberg called him a
"devastatingly impressive" mathematician who did things that "seemed impossible."
Andr Weil declared that Siegel was the greatest mathematician of the first half of the
20th century.
Aleksandrov worked in set theory, metric spaces and several fields of topology, where
he developed techniques of very broad application. He pioneered the studies of
compact and bicompact spaces, and homology theory. He laid the groundwork for a
key theorem of metrisation. His most famous theorem may be his discovery about
"perfect subsets" when he was just 19 years old. Much of his work was done in
collaboration with Pavel Uryson and Heinz Hopf. Aleksandrov was an important
teacher; his students included Lev Pontryagin.
Artin was an important and prolific researcher in several fields of algebra, including
algebraic number theory, the theory of rings, field theory, algebraic topology, Galois
theory, a new method of L-series, and geometric algebra. Among his most famous
theorems were Artin's Reciprocity Law, key lemmas in Galois theory, and results in
his Theory of Braids. He also produced two very influential conjectures: his
conjecture about the zeta function in finite fields developed into the field of arithmetic
geometry; Artin's Conjecture on primitive roots inspired much work in number
theory, and was later generalized to become Weil's Conjectures. He is credited with
solution to Hilbert's 17th Problem and partial solution to the 9th Problem. His prize-
winning students include John Tate and Serge Lang. Artin also did work in physical
sciences, and was an accomplished musician.
Dirac had a severe father and was bizarrely taciturn, but became one of the greatest
mathematical physicists ever. This Nobel Prize-winner developed Fermi-Dirac
statistics, applied quantum theory to field theory, predicted the existence of magnetic
monopoles, and was first to note that some quantum equations lead to inexplicable
infinities. His most important contribution was to combine relativity and quantum
mechanics by developing, with pure thought, the Dirac Equation. From this equation,
Dirac deduced the existence of anti-electrons, a prediction considered so bizarre it was
ignored -- until anti-electrons were discovered in a cloud chamber four years later.
Dirac's mathematical formulations, including his Equation and the Dirac-von
Neumann axioms, underpin all of modern particle physics. After his great discovery,
Dirac continued to do important work, some of which underlies modern string theory.
He was also adept at more practical physics; although he declined an invitation to
work on the Manhattan Project, he did contribute a fundamental result in centrifuge
theory to that Project.
The Dirac Equation was one of the most important scientific discoveries of the 20th
century, but I've left Dirac off of the Top 100 since his work didn't advance "pure"
mathematics. Like many of the other greatest mathematical physicists (Kepler,
Einstein, Weyl), Dirac thought the true equations of physics must have beauty, writing
"... it is more important to have beauty in one's equations than to have them fit
experiment ... [any discrepancy may] get cleared up with further development of the
theory."
Alfred Tarski (born Alfred Tajtelbaum) was one of the greatest and most prolific
logicians ever, but also made advances in set theory, measure theory, topology,
algebra, group theory, computability theory, metamathematics, and geometry. He was
also acclaimed as a teacher. Although he achieved fame at an early age with the
Banach-Tarski Paradox, his greatest achievements were in formal logic. He wrote on
the definition of truth, developed model theory, and investigated the completeness
questions which also intrigued Gdel. He proved several important systems to be
incomplete, but also established completeness results for real arithmetic and
geometry. His most famous result may be Tarski's Undefinability Theorem, which is
related to Gdel's Incompleteness Theorem but more powerful. Several other
theorems, theories and paradoxes are named after Tarski including Tarski-
Grothendieck Set Theory, Tarski's Fixed-Point Theorem of lattice theory (from which
the famous Cantor-Bernstein Theorem is a simple corollary), and a new derivation of
the Axiom of Choice (which Lebesgue refused to publish because "an implication
between two false propositions is of no interest"). Tarski was first to enunciate the
remarkable fact that the Generalized Continuum Hypothesis implies the Axiom of
Choice, although proof had to wait for Sierpinski. Tarski's other notable
accomplishments include his cylindrical algebra, ordinal algebra, universal algebra,
and an elegant and novel axiomatic basis of geometry.
Von Neumann pioneered the use of models in set theory, thus improving the
axiomatic basis of mathematics. He proved a generalized spectral theorem sometimes
called the most important result in operator theory. He developed von Neumann
Algebras. He was first to state and prove the Minimax Theorem and thus invented
game theory; this work also advanced operations research; and led von Neumann to
propose the Doctrine of Mutual Assured Destruction which was a basis for Cold War
strategy. He invented cellular automata, famously constructing a self-reproducing
automaton. He invented elegant definitions for the counting numbers (0 = {}, n+1 = n
{n}). He also worked in analysis, matrix theory, measure theory, numerical analysis,
ergodic theory, group representations, continuous geometry, statistics and topology.
Von Neumann discovered an ingenious area-conservation paradox related to the
famous Banach-Tarski volume-conservation paradox. He inspired some of Gdel's
famous work (and independently proved Gdel's Second Theorem). He is credited
with (partial) solution to Hilbert's 5th Problem using the Haar Theorem; this also
relates to quantum physics. George Plya once said "Johnny was the only student I
was ever afraid of. If in the course of a lecture I stated an unsolved problem, the
chances were he'd come to me as soon as the lecture was over, with the complete
solution in a few scribbles on a slip of paper."
Von Neumann did very important work in fields other than pure mathematics. By
treating the universe as a very high-dimensional phase space, he constructed an
elegant mathematical basis (now called von Neumann algebras) for the principles of
quantum physics. He advanced philosophical questions about time and logic in
modern physics. He played key roles in the design of conventional, nuclear and
thermonuclear bombs; he also advanced the theory of hydrodynamics. He applied
game theory and Brouwer's Fixed-Point Theorem to economics, becoming a major
figure in that field. His contributions to computer science are many: in addition to co-
inventing the stored-program computer, he was first to use pseudo-random number
generation, finite element analysis, the merge-sort algorithm, and a "biased coin"
algorithm. By implementing wide-number software he joined several other great
mathematicians (Archimedes, Apollonius, Liu Hui, Hipparchus, Madhava, and (by
proxy), Ramanujan) in producing the best approximation to of his time. At the time
of his death, von Neumann was working on a theory of the human brain.
Henri Cartan, son of the great lie Cartan, is particularly noted for his work in
algebraic topology, and analytic functions; but also worked with sheaves, and many
other areas of mathematics. He was a key member of the Bourbaki circle. (That circle
was led by Weil, emphasized rigor, produced important texts, and introduced terms
like in-, sur-, and bi-jection, as well as the symbol.) Working with Samuel
Eilenberg (also a Bourbakian), Cartan advanced the theory of homological algebra.
He is most noted for his many contributions to the theory of functions of several
complex variables. Henri Cartan was an important influence on Grothendieck and
others, and an excellent teacher; his students included Jean-Pierre Serre.
Gdel, who had the nickname Herr Warum ("Mr. Why") as a child, was perhaps the
foremost logic theorist ever, clarifying the relationships between various modes of
logic. He partially resolved both Hilbert's 1st and 2nd Problems, the latter with a proof
so remarkable that it was connected to the drawings of Escher and music of Bach in
the title of a famous book. He was a close friend of Albert Einstein, and was first to
discover "paradoxical" solutions (e.g. time travel) to Einstein's equations. About his
friend, Einstein later said that he had remained at Princeton's Institute for Advanced
Study merely "to have the privilege of walking home with Gdel." (Like a few of the
other greatest 20th-century mathematicians, Gdel was very eccentric.)
Two of the major questions confronting mathematics are: (1) are its axioms consistent
(its theorems all being true statements)?, and (2) are its axioms complete (its true
statements all being theorems)? Gdel turned his attention to these fundamental
questions. He proved that first-order logic was indeed complete, but that the more
powerful axiom systems needed for arithmetic (constructible set theory) were
necessarily incomplete. He also proved that the Axioms of Choice (AC) and the
Generalized Continuum Hypothesis (GCH) were consistent with set theory, but that
set theory's own consistency could not be proven. He may have established that the
truths of AC and GCH were independent of the usual set theory axioms, but the proof
was left to Paul Cohen.
Shiing-Shen Chern (Chen Xingshen) studied under lie Cartan, and became perhaps
the greatest master of differential geometry. He is especially noted for his work in
algebraic geometry, topology and fiber bundles, developing his Chern characters (in a
paper with "a tremendous number of geometrical jewels"), developing Chern-Weil
theory, the Chern-Simons invariants, and especially for his brilliant generalization of
the Gauss-Bonnet Theorem to multiple dimensions. His work had a major influence in
several fields of modern mathematics as well as gauge theories of physics. Chern was
an important influence in China and a highly renowned and successful teacher: one of
his students (Yau) won the Fields Medal, another (Yang) the Nobel Prize in physics.
Chern himself was the first Asian to win the prestigious Wolf Prize.
Alan Mathison Turing (1912-1954) Britain
Erds was a childhood prodigy who became a famous (and famously eccentric)
mathematician. He is best known for work in combinatorics (especially Ramsey
Theory) and partition calculus, but made contributions across a very broad range of
mathematics, including graph theory, analytic number theory, probabilistic methods,
and approximation theory. He is regarded as the second most prolific mathematician
in history, behind only Euler. Although he is widely regarded as an important and
influential mathematician, Erds founded no new field of mathematics: He was a
"problem solver" rather than a "theory developer." He's left us several still-unproven
intriguing conjectures, e.g. that 4/n = 1/x + 1/y + 1/z has positive-integer solutions
for any n.
Erds liked to speak of "God's Book of Proofs" and discovered new, more elegant,
proofs of several existing theorems, including the two most famous and important
about prime numbers: Chebyshev's Theorem that there is always a prime between
any n and 2n, and (though the major contributor was Atle Selberg) Hadamard's Prime
Number Theorem itself. He also proved many new theorems, such as the Erds-
Szekeres Theorem about monotone subsequences with its elegant (if trivial)
pigeonhole-principle proof.
Shannon's initial fame was for a paper called "possibly the most important master's
thesis of the century." That paper founded digital circuit design theory by proving that
universal computation was achieved with an ensemble of switches and boolean gates.
He also worked with analog computers, theoretical genetics, and sampling and
communication theories. Early in his career Shannon was fortunate to work with
several other great geniuses including Weyl, Turing, Gdel and even Einstein; this
may have stimulated him toward a broad range of interests and expertise. He was an
important and prolific inventor, discovering signal-flow graphs, the topological gain
formula, etc.; but also inventing the first wearable computer (to time roulette wheels
in Las Vegas casinos), a chess-playing algorithm, a flame-throwing trumpet, and
whimsical robots (e.g. a "mouse" that navigated a maze). His hobbies included
juggling, unicycling, blackjack card-counting. His investigations into gambling theory
led to new approaches to the stock market.
Shannon worked in cryptography during World War II; he was first to note that a one-
time pad allowed unbreakable encryption as long as the pad was as large as the
message; he is also noted for Shannon's maxim that a code designer should assume
the enemy knows the system. His insights into cryptology eventually led to
information theory, or the mathematical theory of communication, in which Shannon
established the relationships among bits, entropy, power and noise. It is as the
Founder of Information Theory that Shannon has become immortal.
Selberg may be the greatest analytic number theorist ever. He also did important work
in Fourier spectral theory, lattice theory (e.g. introducing and partially proving the
conjecture that "all lattices are arithmetic"), and the theory of automorphic forms,
where he introduced Selberg's Trace Formula. He developed a very important result in
analysis called the Selberg Integral. Other Selberg techniques of general utility
include mollification, sieve theory, and the Rankin-Selberg method. These have
inspired other mathematicians, e.g. contributing to Deligne's proof of the Weil
conjectures. Selberg is also famous for ground-breaking work on Riemann's
Hypothesis, and the first "elementary" proof of the Prime Number Theorem.
Jean-Pierre Serre (1926-) France
Serre did important work with spectral sequences and algebraic methods,
revolutionizing the study of algebraic topology and algebraic geometry, especially
homotopy groups and sheaves. Hermann Weyl praised Serre's work strongly, saying it
gave an important new algebraic basis to analysis. He collaborated with Grothendieck
and Pierre Deligne, helped resolve the Weil conjectures, and contributed indirectly to
the recent proof of Fermat's Last Theorem. His wide range of research areas also
includes number theory, bundles, fibrations, p-adic modular forms, Galois
representation theory, and more. Serre has been much honored: he is the youngest
ever to win a Fields Medal; 49 years after his Fields Medal he became the first
recipient of the Abel Prize.
Grothendieck's radical religious and political philosophies led him to retire from
public life while still in his prime, but he is widely regarded as the greatest
mathematician of the 20th century, and indeed one of the greatest geniuses ever.
Lennart Axel Edvard Carleson (1928-) Sweden
Atiyah's career has had extraordinary breadth and depth. He advanced the theory of
vector bundles; this developed into topological K-theory and the Atiyah-Singer Index
Theorem. This Index Theorem is considered one of the most far-reaching theorems
ever, subsuming famous old results (Descartes' total angular defect, Euler's
topological characteristic), important 19th-century theorems (Gauss-Bonnet,
Riemann-Roch), and incorporating important work by Weil and especially Shiing-
Shen Chern. It is a key to the study of high-dimension spaces, differential geometry,
and equation solving. Several other key results are named after Atiyah, e.g. the
Atiyah-Bott Fixed-Point Theorem, the Atiyah-Segal Completion Theorem, and the
Atiyah-Hirzebruch spectral sequence. Atiyah's work developed important connections
not only between topology and analysis, but with modern physics; Atiyah himself has
been a key figure in the development of string theory. This work, and Atiyah-inspired
work in gauge theory, restored a close relationship between leading edge research in
mathematics and physics. Atiyah is known as a vivacious genius in person, inspiring
many, e.g. Edward Witten. Along with Serre, Atiyah is often considered to be one of
the very greatest living mathematicians.
Atiyah once said a mathematician must sometimes "freely float in the atmosphere like
a poet and imagine the whole universe of possibilities, and hope that eventually you
come down to Earth somewhere else."
As Fields, Presidential and (twice) Putnam Medalist, as well as winner of the Abel,
Wolf and two Steele Prizes; Milnor can be considered the most "decorated"
mathematician of the modern era.
Langlands started by studying semigroups and partial differential equations but soon
switched his attention to representation theory where he found deep connections
between group theory and automorphic forms; he then used these connections to make
profound discoveries in number theory. Langlands' methods, collectively called the
Langlands Program, are now central to all of these fields. The Langlands Dual
Group LG revolutionized representation theory and led to a large number of
conjectures. One of these conjectures is the Principle of Functoriality, of which a
partial proof allowed Langlands to prove a famous conjecture of Artin, and Wiles to
prove Fermat's Last Theorem. Langlands and others have applied these methods to
prove several other old conjectures, and to formulate new more powerful conjectures.
He has also worked with Eisenstein series, L-functions, Lie groups, percolation
theory, etc. He mentored several important mathematicians (including Thomas Hales,
mentioned briefly in Pappus' mini-bio).
Langlands once wrote "Certainly the best times were when I was alone with
mathematics, free of ambition and pretense, and indifferent to the world." He was
appointed Hermann Weyl Professor at the Institute for Advanced Study and now sits
in the office once occupied by Albert Einstein. This seems appropriate since, as the
man "who reinvented mathematics," his advances have sometimes been compared to
Einstein's.
Conway has done pioneering work in a very broad range of mathematics including
knot theory, number theory, group theory, lattice theory, combinatorial game theory,
geometry, quaternions, tilings, and cellular automaton theory. He started his career by
proving a case of Waring's Problem, but achieved fame when he discovered the
largest then-known sporadic group (the symmetry group of the Leech lattice); this
sporadic group is now known to be second in size only to the Monster Group, with
which Conway also worked. Conway's fertile creativity has produced a cornucopia of
fascinating inventions: markable straight-edge construction of the regular heptagon (a
feat also achieved by Alhazen, Thabit, Vieta and perhaps Archimedes), a nowhere-
continuous function that has the Intermediate Value property, the Conway box
function, the aperiodic pinwheel tiling, a representation of symmetric polyhedra, the
silly but elegant Fractran programming language, his chained-arrow notation for
large numbers, and many results and conjectures in recreational mathematics. He
found the simplest proof for Morley's Trisector Theorem (sometimes called the best
result in simple plane geometry since ancient Greece). He proved an unusual theorem
about quantum physics: "If experimenters have free will, then so do elementary
particles." His most famous construction is the computationally complete automaton
known as the Game of Life. His most important theoretical invention, however, may
be his surreal numbers incorporating infinitesimals; he invented them to solve
combinatorial games like Go, but they have pure mathematical significance as the
largest possible ordered field.
Conway's great creativity and breadth certainly make him one of the greatest living
mathematicians. Conway has won the Nemmers Prize in Mathematics, and was first
winner of the Plya Prize.
Gromov is considered one of the greatest geometers ever, but he has a unique "soft"
approach to geometry which leads to applications in other fields: Gromov has
contributed to group theory, partial differential equations, other areas of analysis and
algebra, and even mathematical biology. He is especially famous for his
pseudoholomorphic curves; they revolutionized the study of symplectic manifolds and
are important in string theory. By applying his geometric ideas to all areas of
mathematics, Gromov has become one of the most influential living mathematicians.
He has proved a very wide variety of theorems: important results about groups of
polynomial growth, theorems essential to Perelman's proof of the Poincar conjecture,
the nonsqueezing theorem of Hamiltonian mechanics, theorems of systolic geometry,
and various inequalities and compactness theorems. Several concepts are named after
him, including Gromov-Hausdorff convergence, Gromov-Witten invariants, Gromov's
random groups, Gromov product, etc.
Using new ideas about cohomology, in 1974 Pierre Deligne stunned the world of
mathematics with a spectacular proof of the Weil conjectures. Proof of these
conjectures, which were key to further progress in algebraic geometry, had eluded the
great Alexandre Grothendieck. With his "unparalleled blend of penetrating insights,
fearless technical mastery and dazzling ingenuity," Deligne made other important
contributions to a broad range of mathematics in addition to algebraic geometry,
including algebraic and analytic number theory, topology, group theory, the
Langlands conjectures, Grothendieck's theory of motives, and Hodge theory. Deligne
also found a partial solution of Hilbert's 21st Problem. Several ideas are named after
him including Deligne-Lusztig theory, Deligne-Mumford stacks, Fourier-Deligne
transform, the Langlands-Deligne local constant, Deligne cohomology, and at least
eight distinct conjectures.
Tao was a phenomenal child prodigy who has become perhaps the greatest living
mathematician. He has made important contributions to partial differential equations,
combinatorics, harmonic analysis, number theory, group theory, model theory,
nonstandard analysis, random matrices, the geometry of 3-manifolds, functional
analysis, ergodic theory, etc. and areas of applied math including quantum mechanics,
general relativity, and image processing. He has been called the first since David
Hilbert to be expert across the entire spectrum of mathematics. Among his earliest
important discoveries were results about the multi-dimensional Kakeya needle
problem, which led to advances in Fourier analysis and fractals. In addition to his
numerous research papers he has written many highly regarded textbooks. One of his
prize citations commends his "sheer technical power, his other-worldly ingenuity for
hitting upon new ideas, and a startlingly natural point of view."
Much of Tao's work has been done in collaboration: for example with Van Vu he
proved the circular law of random matrices; with Ben Green he proved the Dirac-
Motzkin conjecture and solved the "orchard-planting problem." Especially famous is
the Green-Tao Theorem that there are arbitrarily long arithmetic series among the
prime numbers (or indeed among any sufficiently dense subset of the primes). This
confirmed an old conjecture by Lagrange, and was especially remarkable because the
proof fused methods from number theory, ergodic theory, harmonic analysis, discrete
geometry, and combinatorics.