You are on page 1of 5

Share your ideas and opinions 15 August 2016 (Vol III - Issue 4)

JALLIKATTU SLOGANS REVEAL THIS IS NOW A BATTLE FOR


TAMIL TRADITION AND PRIDE

If your idea of India is one of tails; stab and jab them with sickles,
spears, knives and sticks; cause
ancient temples thick with incense
and chanting masses worshiping them intense pain by yanking their
dimly lit deities covered with nose ropes; and punch them, jump
vermilion paste and crushed on them and drag them to the
marigolds, then Tamil Nadu is ground. In bullfights, the round ends
where your mental images will be when one of the frightened and
replaced by vivid memories. injured bulls manages to flee or is
Occupying a long stretch of the Bay killed.Participants and spectators are
of Bengal coastline known as the also at risk. From 2010 to 2014,
Coromandel Coast, India's media outlets reported that there
southernmost state is dominated by were some 1,100 human injuries and
a rich cultural and religious heritage 17 deaths caused by jallikattu-style
that touches every aspect of life. events, including the death of a
Ruled predominantly by the child. The actual number is probably
powerful Chola, Pallava, and higher since many injuries likely
Pandyan dynasties, Dravidian werent reported in the news.
culture flourished for more than
A brief history
1,000 years, developing a unique Legal grounds based on
political and social hierarchy, and an Jallikattu has been in a traditional practice since 400-100 B.C. and was which PETAs actions for
architectural temple style that has traditionally a part of finding a strong groom. The person who successfully
come to typify the south. In spite of the ban gained
tamed the bull would get to marry the maiden. The sport was played by the
globalization and the political ancient Mayor or Yadava in the ancient Tamil country and later evolved to be a momentum
dominance of the north, Tamil Nadu sport played to display their strength and to win prize money. The customary
has retained its fervent nationalist sport is played during Pongal as a way to include Lord Muniswara. The PETA claims to target all cruelty to
sensibility -- an almost zealous pride Adhichanallur excavations of Iron Age artefacts showed many links to the animals, not just jallikattu. A 7 July
in Tamil language and literature, and olden culture, like one of them is the Jallikattu, even the Indus Valley 2011 notification in The Gazette of
in its delicious and varied cuisines. Civilization shows a stone carved art depicting a scene from jallikattu. India made using bulls as
Out of various traditional spectacle, performing animals illegal. This
one which is quite a famous one or applies to jallikattu, kambala, bull
the infamous one, attracting tourists Why did PETA create a stir by trying to put an end to an age races, bullfights and other uses of
and now debates, protests and media bulls for performances.
attention is the Jallikattu(or
old tradition?
In its 7th May 2014 judgement, the
sallikkattu), also known as eru Honourable Supreme Court
thazhuvuthal and manju virattu. In People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals (PETA )
confirmed this ban on the use of
this Bos Indicus bull, commonly of is an American animal rights organization based in Norfolk, Virginia, and led bulls for performances. The court
the Kangayam breed, is released by Ingrid Newkirk, its international president. A nonprofit corporation with also ruled that cruelty is inherent in
into a crowd of people and multiple 300 employees, it claims that it has 3 million members and supporters (5 these events, as bulls are not
human participants attempt to grab million in total) and is the largest animal rights group in the world. Its slogan is anatomically suited to them. It
the large hump of the bull with both "animals are not ours to eat, wear, experiment on, use for entertainment, or observed that forcing bulls to
arms and hang on to it while the bull abuse in any other way." participate, subjects them to
attempts to escape. Participants hold unnecessary pain and suffering, so it
the hump for as long as possible, As per PETA, Jallikattu exploits bulls natural nervousness as prey animals by ruled that such races are not
attempting to bring the bull to a deliberately placing them in a terrifying situation in which they are forced to permitted by law.
stop. In some cases, participants run away from those they perceive as predators. As PETA India has
must ride long enough to remove documented in Animal Welfare Board of India (AWBI)authorised Jallikattu, bull races and other
flags on the bull's horns. Jallikattu is inspections, the bulls become so frightened by the mob of men who participate similar events also violate the
typically practiced in the Indian that they slip, fall, run into barriers and traffic and even jump off cliffs in Prevention of Cruelty to Animals
state of Tamil Nadu as a part of their desperate attempts to escape frequently leading to broken bones or (PCA) Act, 1960. This means the
Pongal celebrations on Mattu death.As can be seen in the documentation, jallikattu participants purposely causing of unnecessary suffering to
Pongal day. disorient the bulls by forcing them to consume alcohol; twist and bite their bulls which is inherent in these
events has been illegal for 56 years.
2

Section 77 of the 7 May 2014 (issued by UPA in 2011) and


Supreme Court judgement says, 77. A brief timeline Mass Reaction declared that the sport could
PETA, therefore, hold that AWBI is continue despite the existing ban.
right in its stand that Jallikattu, This was in direct contravention
Bullock-cart Race and such events Thousands of people in Indias with the top court order, and was
per se violate southern Tamil Nadu campaigned duly challenged by animal welfare
against the ban at Marina beach in organisation such as People for the
Sections 3, 11(1)(a) and 11(1)(m)(ii) the states capital, Ethical Treatment of Animals
of PCA Act and hence we uphold 15 August 2016 (Vol III - Issue 4)
(PETA). Subsequently, a stay order
the notification dated 11.7.2011 was issued by the court. Political
issued by the Central Government, reasons may dominate the NDA
consequently, Bulls cannot be used 2006 : Madras High Court governments 2016 move. The
as performing animals, either for the unilaterally banned jallikattu Jallikattu belt is dominated by the
Jallikattu events or Bullock-cart while hearing an unrelated writ politically powerful OBC Thevar
Races in theState of Tamil Nadu, petition seeking permission to community which has politicians
Maharashtra or elsewhere in the conduct bullock cart race and considerable clout in several
country.Section 3, 11(1)(a) of the parties. It was important for BJP to
PCA Act, 1960, makes it illegal if 2 0 0 9 : T h e Ta m i l N a d u be seen as being with the people
Chennai (Madras).Protesters said ahead of the Assembly elections in
any person beats, kicks, over-rides, government passed Regulation of Legal grounds based on
that the tradition was a part of their April. Tamilisai Soundararajan, state
over-drives, over-loads, tortures or Jallikattu Act (TNRJA) giving
conditional permission for
whichofPETAs
identity. Angry people took to social president the BJP,actions
had saidfor
lifting
otherwise treats any animal so as to media calling out to each other to of the
subject it to unnecessary pain or holding jallikattu between the ban gainedhelp the party in
ban would
join the protest.Tamil cinema actors, the polls. Soundararajan said party
suffering or causes, or being the January and May of any year. momentum
including Vijay, GV Prakash Kumar chief Amit Shah had had several
owner permits, any animal to be so and Suriya have backed the protest. meetings with Environment Minister
treated. Section 11(1)(m)(ii) of the November 2010: The Supreme
Civilians voiced their opposition Prakash Javadekar to ensure the ban
Court also gave conditional
PCA Act, 1960, makes it illegal if against the ban through twitter and was lifted. All parties in Tamil Nadu
permission to Jallikattu under the
any person confines or causes to be soon the entire nation had an welcomed the Centres decision.
provisions of TNRJA , for a
confined any animal (including opinion about the ban. The country Apart from this, the newly anointed
period of five months starting 15
tying of an animal as a bait in a tiger was shaken by the wild uproar of the A I A D M K g e n e r a l s e c r e t a r y,
January of any year
or other sanctuary) so as to make it mob. Peta [animal rights group] Sasikala Natarajan was embroiled in
an object or prey for any other may have won a campaign in the a war of words with DMK working-
11 July 2011 : The Ministry of court of law but has lost in the president M K Stalin over the
animal.The Supreme Court Environment and Forest under
clarified, Fight can be with an people's court. Their claim that traditional sport. Stalin accused the
Jairam Ramesh of the Congress Jallikattu is inimical to bulls is full AIADMK government of doing
animal or a human being. Its order banned the use of bulls as of lies. They talk about cruelty to little to overturn the Jallikattu ban.
said, Section 5 of TNRJ Act performing animals, effectively bulls but they don't realise that by In return, Sasikala pointed out that it
envisages a fight between a Bull and banning the traditional sport of banning Jallikattu, they are aiding in was under the UPA rule, of which
Bull tamers, that is, Bull tamer has Tamil Nadu, Jallikattu the extinction of rare cattle breed," DMK was a key alliance partner,
to fight with the bull and tame it. Suriya said in a statement. While the that the ban was first imposed.
Such fight is prohibited under 7 May 2014: The Supreme Court protests began in Madurai,
Section 11(1)(m)(ii) of PCA Act struck down the TNRJA , banning Sivaganga, and Pattukottai, where
read with Section 3 of the Act.The the sport altogether,when UPA Jallikattu events were reported
Tamil Nadu Regulation of Jallikattu was still in power despite the ban, the state capital
Reasons against the
(TNRJ) Act was struck down by the
January 2016: The Ministry of
became the hotbed after the arrest of ban of Jallikattu
Supreme Court because it was 200 protesting youths in
Environment, Forests and Alanganallur village proved to act as
inconsistent and in direct collision Climate Change under Modi
with Section 3, Section 11(1)(a), a catalyst. Chennais Marina beach Tamilians argued that a foreign
g o v e r n m e n t a m e n d e d 2 0 11 saw an unexpected crowd of organization like PETA is purposely
11(1)(m)(ii) and Section 22 of the notification, allowing Jallikattu
PCA Act read with Articles 51A(g) Jallikattu supporters who camped at trying to attack the tradition that is
and bullock cart races across the beach even during the night of gently entwined with culture. The
& (h) of the Constitution and hence Maharashtra, Karnataka and January 19. By midnight, the crowd bulls are treated as part and pride of
repugnant to the PCA Gujarat with specific conditions had swelled to about 6,000. the family, according to people.India
Act.Furthermore, Section 429 of Students, software professionals, was being hailed as a soft target for
the Indian Penal Code reads, 429. May 2016: The Congress party in playback singers, filmmakers, bank PETA advertisement to popularize
Mischief by killing or maiming its manifesto for Tamil Nadu employees all gathered to protest the organization. The ban would
cattle, etc., of any value or any elections in 2016, promised to ban against the ban on Jallikattu. The also result in an unwanted rift
animal of the value of fifty rupees. Jallikattu if voted to power demands made by the protesters between rural and urban India.Under
Whoever commits mischief by include lifting the ban on Jallikattu, the Convention on Biological
killing, poisoning, maiming or July 2016: The Supreme Court, banning PETA and relief for Diversity and heritage status
rendering useless, any elephant, on a petition filed by Animal drought-affected Tamil Nadu practices worldwide, it is customary
camel, horse, mule, buffalo, bull, We l f a r e B o a r d a n d P E TA farmers.
represented by Abhishek Manu that these ancient traditional
cow or ox, whatever may be the practices are left as they are but with
Singhvi, Congress spokesperson
value thereof, or any other animal of overturned the Modi The political hue rules to organise and regulate
the value of fifty rupees or upwards, governments decision and once them.If jallikattu is banned,
shall be punished with again banned Jallikattu
of the protest livestock keepers will be forced to
imprisonment of either description abandon the raising of native
for a term which may extend to five In 2016, the Environment Ministry livestock, which already stands
years, or with fine, or with both. modified its earlier notification threatened due to the extensive use
3

of motor pumps, tractors and lakes, rivers and wild life, and to increased incentive to sell their bulls these bulls and that keep the animals
mechanised agriculture. If the sport have compassion for living to slaughter.The Times of India in their lives without the cruelty
is banned, it would be the death creatures.Section 42 of the 7 May quoted Dhana Kumar, a resident of thats been deemed unacceptable by
knell of native cattle species in 2014 Supreme Court judgement Manickampatti near Palamedu in the Supreme Court.PETA has
Tamil Nadu.The people will not says, The Statement of Objects and Madurai district, as saying, I have consistently argued how it is not
only lose their breeds but also our Reasons of the TNRJ Act refers to two children, but I love my bull possible to completely eradicate the
self-sufficiency in milk production ancient culture and tradition and Karuppasamy more. I have caned animal cruelty without the ban. The
does not state that it has any my children, but not my bull. elements of brutality can range from
as well as promotion of organic 15 August 2016 (Vol III - Issue 4)
religious significance. Even the Usually the jallikattu bulls are bulls being doped with strong
farming. If locals lose their breeds
ancient culture and tradition do not pledged to God and we consider liqueur and other substance to them
and import foreign breeds, support the conduct of Jallikattu or them sacred. If the bulls are being hit with sharp object to create
multinational commercial Bullock cart race, in the form in considered sacred, surely selling anger, their tails being bent to create
which they are being conducted at them to slaughter shouldnt even be p a i n a n d a n g e r P e o p l e w h o
present. Welfare and the well-being considered.Slaughter isnt the only c o n s u m e d a l c o h o l o r d r u g s
of the bull is Tamil culture and suffering that the bulls face. There participate in the event without any
tradition, they do not approve of are many different types of cruelty, decorum, thus manhandling the
infliction of any pain or suffering on and theyre all wrong to commit. creatures.
the bulls, on the other hand, Tamil However, although they shouldnt
tradition and culture are to worship be, bulls do end up at the Legal grounds based on
the bull and the bull is always slaughterhouse when they are
considered as the vehicle of Lord injured in training or during which PETAs actions for
Shiva. Yeru Thazhuvu, in Tamil jallikattu which happens often or the ban gained
companies will dominate the dairy tradition, is to embrace bulls and not when theyre deemed no longer momentum
industry in India. The livelihood of overpowering the bull, to show useful. Bulls have also died during
millions in rural India is at stake human bravery. It concluded, the events themselves, including this
Jallikattu or the bullock cart race, one who ran directly into a bus in
here.People who want a ban on
as practised now, has never been the his panic.To protesters claiming that
jallikattu are far removed from tradition or culture of Tamil banning Jallikattu will eliminate
village life and do not know how Nadu.Section 43 of the same native breeds of cattle, PETA argued
this chain works.The Supreme Court judgement reads, PCA Act, a that Cattle breeds in India have been
and the Government of India needs welfare legislation, in our view, changing for many years because of
to look at the big picture behind over-shadows or overrides the so- a variety of factors, even during the
Editor Speak
jallikattu. The Convention on called tradition and culture. decades when jallikattu was
Biological Diversity (CBD) supports Jallikattu and Bullock cart races, the allowed, so to claim this change is
traditional practices to keep the manner in which they are primarily a result of banning Regardless of the outcome of this
chain intact and thus enable conducted, have no support of Tamil jallikattu is preposterous. Cattle agitation, the agrarian crisis and
conservation of native breeds. As an tradition or culture. Assuming, it has breeds are largely manipulated by farmer suicides in Tamil Nadus
ancient nation with an ancient been in vogue for quite some time, humans to suit their own needs delta districts will continue to
practice going back millennia, in our view, the same should give such as increased milk production. unfold. Before the month of
jallikattu should be preserved. There way to the welfare legislation, like Changes in breed dont mean the Chithirai (April-May) is through,
is no torture of any animal of any the PCA Act which has been enacted e x t i n c t i o n o f a s p e c i e s . and the jallikattu season comes to an
sort that takes place during the sport to prevent infliction of unnecessary Domesticated cattle are not at risk of end, there will not be enough water
pain or suffering on animals and being on the endangered species to drink, leave alone to give the
and the evidence of this can be seen
confer duties and obligations on list.It is said by those who make this Kangeyam bull its daily bath. The
from live media telecasts. The time persons in-charge of animals.There argument that stud bulls are reared bull may be the symbol of Tamil
a bull spends engaged in the sport is was also a group who tried by people for jallikattu. The ones agrarian culture. But the real
less than 30 seconds. If required, reasoning against the ban by who win jallikattu are in greater backbone of that culture is the
rules can be implemented to claiming that if the bulls were not demand for impregnating cows. poromboke or commons the
enhance the safety of the animals used, they shall be send to slaughter- However, an end to jallikattu does meichal (grazing) poromboke and
and men if required. India has to which The Indian Express not stop bulls from being used for the wetlands. The wholesale
already lost many cattle breeds and reported in a 12 January article titled this purpose. Its said that small takeover of these commons needs to
it cant afford to lose any more. Explained: In Jallikattu, Questions farmers cant afford to keep stud be countered far more vigorously
of Tradition and Cruelty to Animals bulls, so each village has a common and over a far longer duration if we
that no tickets are sold for Jallikattu temple bull who is used for stand any chance of making it
Arguments for the or bullock-cart races. It further impregnating the cows of the through the remaining century.The
states, Jallikattu events do not offer village. However, since theres erosion of the commons mirrors the
ban of Jallikattu any major monetary benefits, and essentially no monetary benefit from erosion of the cultures of the
prizes are mostly a dhoti, towel, jallikattu, this can still continue. In poromboke, by the entry of
betel leaves, bananas and token cash addition, a veterinarian would be commercialisation and industry.
Countless Tamilian PETA India that is rarely more than Rs 101 able to inform villagers which bull is When seen in the context of rampant
supporters are against jallikattu and on a silver plate. Mixer-grinders, healthy much better than the industrialisation, the decimation of
are saddened by those who call refrigerators and furniture have been outcome of a jallikattu event could. native breeds of cattle, poultry and
harming bulls Tamil culture. added to the list of prizes at some Furthermore, while some bulls are crops, the jallikattu ban raises flags
Indias culture is one of kindness, events over the last few years.If used for jallikattu, others are used as about the robustness and depth of
not cruelty. Article 51A(g) of the theres essentially no monetary draught animals in transport and such single-species, charismatic
Indian Constitution makes it the benefit to the farmer and no tickets farming a practice which could megafauna conservation measures.
mandate of every Indian citizen to are sold, then the farmers arent e a s i l y c o n t i n u e w i t h o u t The tragedy is that despite having
protect and improve the natural financially worse off with a ban on jallikattu.The community can come the undivided attention of the world
environment including forests, jallikattu and should have no up with ways that genuinely honour media, the opponents of the ban
4

have failed to articulate a larger


vision of Tamil culture that is
inclusive, socially just and
environmentally sensitive.Of all the
reasons to criticise jallikattu, cruelty Against the Ban
against the bulls, I feel, is the
flimsiest. This single-point argument
If Spain can protect its
custom why not we?

Integral part of Tamil culture


and tradition

Bull not harmed;simply taming


by the pro-banners also exposes how
far removed they are from the Court should stay out of religious
realities in rural Tamil Nadu. I can matters
think of at least two other reasons to
be critical of jallikattu.One, it
celebrates a certain machismo at a Its tyranny of North,it doesnt
time when the need of the hour begs understand South Indian culture
for less machismo particularly of
this simmering violent kind. Even
the protests exude a machismo, with For the Ban Most people of TN want it and in
democracy,the majority prevails
many of the protestors tending to
paint any dissent as pro-PETA and Its not right to cherry pick
refusing to go beyond the chest- Only hindu customs are targeted,
thumping declarations of Naan
one aspect of a foreign culture
Tamizhan da, Naan Tamizhachi da! and compare it to ours courts have not stopped goat
I am Tamil, I am Tamil.Second, the slaughter on Eid
sport and the festivities reek of caste Traditions that harm anyone
discrimination, and the failure of the should be stopped Most powerful bull wins and its
movement to highlight it, and bring
its reform as part of its agenda is a While taming animals and used for breeding, thus preserving
fatal lapse. In southern Tamil Nadu, humans do get hurt genetic strength of indigenous
where jallikattu is in vogue, the breeds
sport and its festivities are exclusive, Courts have to ensure that the
and dalits are not allowed to
participate in the sport or festivities
rights of all including animals
as equals. Dalit political parties have are protected
rightly broken ranks with the
ongoing agitation against the ban, Even if majority want it, does
triggering a rash of abusive not mean majority is right
comments by their historical
oppressors. It is not that they seek to From alimony (in Shah Bano
be included in the celebrations. case) to triple talaqs,courts
Rather, they see this as cultural
revivalism with the associated caste
have ruled against ill
connotations unchanged.Curiously, practices
no petition has sought to reform
that. No Supreme Court order There are scientific methods
mentions this. Its failure to evolve for selective breeding of
into an inclusive festival is indigenous breeds
jallikattus biggest lapse. If the
movement refuses to reform this,
that will be the movements biggest
mistake. True reform would then lie
in restoring a jallikattu tradition that
is devoid of cruelty to animals,
inclusive of all communities and
practiced in a context where there is
real reason for agrarian communities
to celebrate.
5

Current Scenario
News Headlines
Mukherjee's assent and 36 Injured In
thanked Prime Minister Jallikattu Event At
Amid continuing protests over Narendra Modi for his
Jallikattu ban across the state, the support in enabling the bull Avanipuram
Tamil Nadu Assembly had on taming sport to 15
be August
held in
2016 (Vol
FebIII - Issue
06: 4)
Thirty-six people
January 23 unanimously passed an the state.
amendment bill, clearing the path
Supreme Court Slams were injured, one of them
seriously, in a Jallikattu
for conducting Jallikattu without Tamil Nadu On Jallikattu event held at Avanipuram in
any hindrance. Tamil Nadu Chief Protests, But No Stay On the district amid high
Minister O Panneerselvam on Petition A
security on Sunday in which
February 1 said the Bill to replace New Law 'Misadventure', Says more than 900 bulls were
an ordinance for the conduct of used, police said.All the
Jallikattu had received President Jan 31: Tamil Nadu's recent law to bring
Madras High Court
injured were being treated at
Pranab Mukherjee's assent and back Jallikattu bypassing a Supreme Dismissing Plea the medical camp put up
thanked Prime Minister Narendra Court ban was spared today but the top near the venue, police
Modi for his support in enabling the court ripped into the state over the
Seeking PETA Ba
said.More than 700 bull-
massive protests that forced tamers participated in the
extraordinary measures to restore the Feb 03 : The Madras High events, which were
ancient bull-taming tradition."Law and Court has dismissed a witnessed by thousands of
order situation is the primacy in a Public Interest Litigation spectators.
civilised society. Convey this to your (PIL) seeking a ban on
executive to maintain law and order. We PETA, holding the plea was
passed a stay order one year ago. Why 'a misadventure' filed for Reintroduce
t h e s e p ro t e s t s n o w ? " t h e c o u r t publicity against the
questioned the Tamil Nadu government, b a c k d ro p o f J a l l i k a t t u Kambala? First Say
referring to the massive protests on the protesters demanding a ban It Right, Insists
Marina Beach in Chennai and other on the animal rights
parts of the state. advocacy group. 15 August 2016 (Vol Siddaramaiah
III - Issue 4)
"We find this a misadventure Feb 07: After the bull-
only for publicity sake, given taming sport Jallikattu was
Jallikattu Bill Receives the current social context on permitted in neighbouring
account of the role of PETA
President Pranab vis-a-vis the Jallikattu issue.
Tamil Nadu through an
e x e c u t i v e o r d e r, t h e
Mukherjee's Assent This petition is dismissed," Karnataka legislature is
the first bench, comprising trying to bring back the
bull taming sport to be held in the Feb 01 : Tamil Nadu Chief Minister O Chief Justice Sanjay Kishan
state.The Bill had been 'reserved' for buffalo-racing sport,
Panneerselvam today said the Bill to Kaul and Justice M Sundar Kambala. And the chief
the President's assent by Governor replace an ordinance for the conduct of said.
Ch Vidyasagar Rao and it "has minister's first challenge is
Jallikattu has received President Pranab making sure people say it
received the Hon'ble President's
assent on 31.1.2017," he said. right.

bought or sold inside Singapore and there is a


DID YOU KNOW Dont pay unless full $500 fine for spitting out gum on the streets.

In Danish restaurants, you dont have to pay


Being overweight in for your food unless, by your own opinion, In France, it was illegal to
Japan is illegal you are full at the end of your meal. If not, wear pants
you can proceed without paying the bill at
all. In 1799, a Paris law made it illegal for women to
According to the metabo law, every wear pants in public without special approval
men and women aged 40 and over Chewing Gum is illegal in from the police. It was once amended in 1892 to
must not have a waist measuring over allow women to sport trousers while riding
than 32 inches and 36 inches Singapore horses and again in 1909 to permit the ladies to
respectively. For individuals, there is wear pants while on bicycles. And finally in
no penalty or punishment in law. Its Chewing gum is completely illegal in
Singapore since 1992. There is a ban on 2013, the French government has revoked this
aimed at putting pressure on local 214-year-old law.
governments and companies. importing chewing gum into Singapore. No
gum is allowed to be

Article Submitted by Moonmoon Karmakar

You might also like