Professional Documents
Culture Documents
INTRODUCTION
The authors are respectively Professor, Universita Cattolica del Sacro Cuore; Assistant
Professor, Bocconi University and Lecturer, SDA Bocconi; and Associate Professor, Bocconi
University and Director, Public Management and Policy Department, SDA Bocconi, Italy.
Address for correspondence: Ileana Steccolini, Bocconi University, Via Bocconi 8, 20136
Milan, Italy.
e-mail: ileana.steccolini@sdabocconi.it
C 2008 The Authors
Journal compilation
C 2008 Blackwell Publishing Ltd, 9600 Garsington Road,
Oxford OX4 2DQ, UK and 350 Main Street, Malden, MA 02148, USA. 321
322 ANESSI-PESSINA, NASI AND STECCOLINI
C 2008 The Authors
Journal compilation
C 2008 Blackwell Publishing Ltd
DETERMINANTS OF LOCAL GOVERNMENTS ACCOUNTING CHOICES 323
Innovations in financial and accounting techniques are a fundamental com-
ponent of these reforms, providing the technical lifeblood of NPM (Olson
et al., 1998, p. 18). Their common orientation has been towards the introduction
of accruals accounting, management control, and performance measurement,
with an increasing emphasis on external reporting (Hood, 1995 and Guthrie,
1998).
Initially, public-sector reforms were trustily welcomed by academics and
practitioners. Potential benefits were claimed for and promised. While the NPM
literature has generally focused on the expected effects of reforms (see Lapsley
and Pallot, 2000, p. 215), however, attempts at studying their actual consequences
show that reforms can run slowly, do not always produce the expected benefits,
and often originate undesired results. Gaps between intended and actual effects
of the reforms often emerge as the result of both (i) gaps between the formal
design of change and its actual development and (ii) gaps between the expected
and the actual uses of managerial tools (see for example, Olson et al., 1998; and
ter Bogt and van Helden, 2000).
A central feature of public-sector and, specifically, accounting reforms has
been the introduction of accruals accounting. Many countries worldwide have
been experimenting with accruals accounting for all or some tiers of government
(International Federation of Accountants - Public Sector Committee, 1997 and
OECD, 2002): among them New Zealand, Australia, the United Kingdom, Spain,
Sweden, Canada, France, Belgium, Ireland, and Finland. The European Union
and the United Nations have recently chosen to adopt IPSASs. Official discourse
on public-sector reforms praises the benefits deriving from accruals accounting.
In the international literature, the new basis of accounting is claimed to have
a number of advantages (Barrett, 1993; Evans, 1995; Mellor, 1996; Funnel
and Cooper, 1998 and International Federation of Accountants - Public Sector
Committee, 2002, pp. 710). Nevertheless, an increasing body of literature has
criticised the adoption of accruals accounting by public organisations on both
theoretical grounds (Oettle, 1990; Ma and Matthews, 1993; McRae and Aiken,
1994; Guthrie and Johnson, 1994; Carnegie and Wolnizer, 1995; Lewis, 1995;
Montesinos et al., 1995; Stanton and Stanton, 1998; Guthrie, 1998; Monsen
and Nasi, 1998, 1999 and 2000; Christiaens, 1999; Ellwood, 1999; and Monsen,
2002) and practical considerations (Guthrie, 1998; Stanton and Stanton, 1998;
Newberry, 2002; Carlin and Guthrie, 2003; and Hodges and Mellett, 2003).
In principle, an appealing compromise could be for budgetary and accruals
accounting to coexist, letting governments combine the benefits of both worlds.
Thus, some authors have contended that accruals and budgetary accounting
can be usefully integrated, as in the case of enterprise cameralistics (Monsen,
2002) or the Mega General Ledger (Christiaens and Vanhee, 2002), which
can facilitate the production of data for both accounting systems. At the same
time, however, such coexistence may cause confusion in managers, who receive
conflicting signals by the two sets of parallel accounting numbers (Guthrie, 1998)
and usually end up disregarding accruals data (Anthony, 2000).
C 2008 The Authors
Journal compilation
C 2008 Blackwell Publishing Ltd
324 ANESSI-PESSINA, NASI AND STECCOLINI
The accounting system remains homogeneous across all the LGs organisa-
tional units and activities. In other words, there is nothing comparable to
the GASBs distinction between the rules for governmental and proprietary
funds.
The budget is still structured according to the commitment basis of ac-
counting. It consequently shows the LGs estimated accounts receivable on
the revenues side and its commitment appropriations on the expenditures
side.
Accounting recognises revenues and expenditures according to both the
commitment basis (that is, in terms of establishments of amounts receiv-
able and commitments) and the cash basis (that is, in terms of recoveries
and payments).
Financial reports similarly show actual revenues in terms of both estab-
lishments of amounts receivable and recoveries, and actual expenditures
in terms of both commitments and payments.
In addition, however, financial reports are also expected to include an
accrual-based statement composed of a balance sheet and an operating
statement. The formats of these statements are similar to those mandated
on Italian private companies following the EUs 4th Directive.
Double-entry bookkeeping is not mandatory. Alternatively, LGs can derive
their balance sheets and operating statements from their budgetary-
accounting statements through a complex system of year-end adjustments.
LGs can thus choose between a traditional and an integrated accounting
system. The former emphasises budgetary accounting and relies on year-
end adjustments to produce a balance sheet and an operating statement.
The latter records transactions according to both budgetary and accruals
accounting rules and has consequently no need to translate cash and
commitment-based data into accruals at year-end.
C 2008 The Authors
Journal compilation
C 2008 Blackwell Publishing Ltd
DETERMINANTS OF LOCAL GOVERNMENTS ACCOUNTING CHOICES 325
A specific reconciliation statement must be included in the overall year-end
financial report to reconcile the budgetary-accounting statement (showing
establishments of amounts receivable and recoveries, commitments and
payments) with the balance sheet and the operating statement.
Accounting standards for both budgetary and accruals accounting have
only recently started to be developed. D.lgs. 77/95 did provide some
guidance, but only in very general terms, especially with respect to accruals
accounting. LGs have consequently been free to draw from other sets
of standards (e.g., IFRSs, IPSASs, Italian national standards for private
firms), if any.
Audit committees must now include professional auditors. Nevertheless,
auditing has remained weak and often unable to significantly affect
budgeting, accounting and reporting practices, as recently emphasised by
the National Court of Auditors (Corte dei Conti, 2004) and acknowledged
by the association of LG auditors itself on its website (see http://ancrel.
clubdeirevisori.it/norme 587.zip).
Empirical research on the implementation and the effects of the new legis-
lation is still scant, as the debate has mostly swung between purely theoretical
considerations and anecdotal evidence. According to this research (Caperchione,
2003; Steccolini, 2004; Caccia and Steccolini, 2005; Nasi and Steccolini, 2008; and
Anessi-Pessina and Steccolini, 2007), however, significant variations exist across
LGs in terms of implementation choices and effects.1
C 2008 The Authors
Journal compilation
C 2008 Blackwell Publishing Ltd
326 ANESSI-PESSINA, NASI AND STECCOLINI
C 2008 The Authors
Journal compilation
C 2008 Blackwell Publishing Ltd
DETERMINANTS OF LOCAL GOVERNMENTS ACCOUNTING CHOICES 327
H 1 : (Size): Larger LGs are more likely to adopt accruals accounting.
Organisational size has been found to facilitate innovation (see Brudney and
Selden, 1995), although the literature presents positive associations as well as
evidence of no association. Size, however, may be viewed as reflecting different
determinants such as organisational complexity or visibility.
With specific respect to accounting and measurement systems, size as
organisational complexity refers to the governments information-processing
environment, i.e., to the magnitude and scope of information which must be
handled by the organisation in its ongoing activities. As organisations become
larger, they need to handle and provide greater quantities of information, which
leads to more detailed control tools (Khandwalla, 1972; Child and Mansfield,
1972; Burns and Waterhouse, 1975; Merchant, 1981; Anderson and Lanen, 1999;
and Haldma and Laats, 2002). From a contingency perspective, therefore, size
as organisational complexity may be expected to increase a LGs likelihood to
adopt accruals accounting.
Size, on the other hand, may also reflect visibility. From an institutional per-
spective, the higher an organisations visibility, the greater its attention towards
the adoption of administrative techniques which are considered desirable and
innovative. Once again, then, size can be expected to favour the introduction of
accruals accounting.
H 2 : (Geographic location): A LGs geographic location influences its likelihood
to adopt accruals accounting.
Geographic location is a proxy for the cultural, social, political, and economic
configuration of community environment and, in turn, affects public policies and
innovation decisions. Norris and Moon (2005) highlight that regional location
and urban/rural status have often been found to be associated with innovation
adoption. Bingham (1978) recalls that the socio-economic characteristics of the
communities have been studied by many economists and political scientists as
factors affecting decision making and city policies.
In Italy, significant regional differences exist across a wide range of features,
including the communities ability to react to stimuli. The country is convention-
ally divided into cultural and political areas, where people are more likely to
express certain political preferences and attitudes, mostly as a result of historical,
cultural, and socio-economic background. More specifically, from a political
viewpoint, four areas are usually identified: the white, catholic and politically
right-of-centre regions, to be found mainly in the North-East; the red, politically
left-of-centre areas, to be found mainly in the North-West and especially in the
Centre; and the Southern regions, traditionally more conservative and right-wing
(Colloca, 2003). Existing research shows that, in general, the Northern part of
Italy is more keen on innovation than the rest of the country (Putnam et al.,
1993).
C 2008 The Authors
Journal compilation
C 2008 Blackwell Publishing Ltd
328 ANESSI-PESSINA, NASI AND STECCOLINI
C 2008 The Authors
Journal compilation
C 2008 Blackwell Publishing Ltd
DETERMINANTS OF LOCAL GOVERNMENTS ACCOUNTING CHOICES 329
Among senior officials, those whose commitment seems particularly important
for accounting innovation are CFOs. This is also because Italian LGs can
be viewed as silo organisations (Rebora, 1983), where individual departments
develop their own culture, goals, functions and working methods, and where
each department head (including CFOs) has his own professionalism, decides
for his own group, and defends his turf from other departments interferences.
CFOs embody the professionalism of public-sector accountants. Their com-
petencies and skills have generally been focused on (when not strictly limited
to) the traditional system of budgetary accounting. However, the public-sector
accounting profession has increasingly been subjected to calls for innovations
through the adoption of accruals accounting and managerial control systems.
To some extent, it has itself relayed such calls to its own members. CFOs may
thus want to conform to the institutional pressures coming from their profession,
showing that they adopt innovative and desirable accounting tools.
H 6 : (Slack). The presence of slack resources may affect the adoption of
accruals accounting by LGs, although the relationship cannot be signed
a priori.
Rosner (1968) views slack resources as the capacity of an organisation to
afford the purchase of costly innovations, to absorb failures, and to explore new
ideas in advance of actual needs. Slack resources thus provide the opportunity
for innovation (Rosner, 1968; and Damanpour, 1991): organisations that have
more resources than they minimally require to maintain operations are in a
better position to adopt innovations. This applies to both technological and
administrative innovations, although more strongly to the former, for the greater
initial investments they usually require (Damanpour, 1991, p. 680).
Motive, on the other hand, leaves more room for doubt. Better performing
organisations may have more incentives to produce complete and accurate
financial statements, while laggards may prefer to limit disclosure or to
selectively focus disclosure on peripheral elements in order to divert stakeholder
attention. In some cases, however, it is unsatisfactory performance that prompts
an improvement in the information provided, due to the need to justify the poor
results. Moreover, the presence of slack may improve a governments legitimacy
under some circumstances, but damage it under others; the introduction of an
accounting system that can better disclose these extra means may thus end up
being alternatively encouraged or discouraged.
Based on these considerations, the presence of slack may reasonably affect
LGs likelihood to introduce accruals accounting, but its effect cannot be signed
a priori.
H 7 : (Activities performed). LGs that focus on inherently governmental activities
are less likely to adopt accruals accounting.
Technology, including the nature of the production process, its degree of
routine and the variety of its tasks, has been said to influence accounting
C 2008 The Authors
Journal compilation
C 2008 Blackwell Publishing Ltd
330 ANESSI-PESSINA, NASI AND STECCOLINI
information (Emmanuel et al., 1990; and Haldma and Laats, 2002). In this
regard, the public sector carries out three main types of activities, which
require largely different competencies, task organisation, and routines (Anessi-
Pessina, 2002; and Borgonovi, 2004): (a) regulation; (b) income redistribution;
and (c) direct provision of goods and services. Budgetary accounting is more
consistent with the first two types of activities, which can be viewed as inherently
governmental. The comparative benefits of accruals accounting, on the contrary,
emerge when governments engage in complex economic activities aimed at the
direct provision of goods and services, where cash inflows and outflows no longer
provide an acceptable approximation for revenues and expenses (Anessi-Pessina,
2002). In Italian LGs, where the accounting system may not be differentiated
across types of activities or organisational units, the incentives to adopt accruals
accounting can thus be expected to be comparatively weaker for governments
that focus on inherently governmental activities.
METHODS
To test the hypotheses, we conducted a survey of all LGs with populations above
40,000 (184 Municipalities and 103 Provinces as of January 1, 2004, for a total
of 287 LGs). The exclusion of smaller LGs has two main motivations. On the
one hand, large LGs have had a longer experience with the accounting reform,
since they were required to implement it in 1997 (for LGs with populations
above 100,000) or 1998 (for LGs with populations of at least 40,000). On the
other hand, small LGs are less likely to have the resources (human, financial
and organisational capital) to fully take advantage of the reforms, also because
their processes, activities, and volumes of transactions do not justify complex
interventions.
The survey was conducted through phone interviews to Chief Financial
Officers (CFOs). Phone interviews were preferred to personal interviews due
to the large number and wide geographical dispersion of the interviewees.
They were also preferred to mail surveys because the latter seldom achieve
adequate response rates: LGs CFOs are continuously asked to fill out forms and
questionnaires for official purposes and are thus reluctant to respond to academic
surveys. To reduce potential bias, the interviews were based on a structured
questionnaire designed by the researchers.
The questionnaire was divided into three sections that were respectively aimed
at: (i) discovering the current configuration of the LGs accounting system
(traditional vs. integrated); (ii) investigating the CFOs perceptions and beliefs
about the current accounting system, the system that would in principle be
most desirable, the strengths and weaknesses of accruals accounting; and (iii)
identifying who within the LGs had chosen the current configuration of the
accounting system, and why.
The final return rate was 82%, although some interviews failed to collect the
entire information set. Further data on LGs organisational and environmental
C 2008 The Authors
Journal compilation
C 2008 Blackwell Publishing Ltd
DETERMINANTS OF LOCAL GOVERNMENTS ACCOUNTING CHOICES 331
features were drawn from a variety of public data bases, details of which are
provided below. Table 1 summarises the model for this study.
The hypotheses were tested using logistic regressions. The dependent variable
(CONFIG) was defined as a dummy for whether the LG adopted a traditional
or an integrated accounting system. The relevant information was drawn from
the survey.
To test hypothesis 1, size was considered as both an organisational factor
reflecting complexity and an environmental factor reflecting visibility. In
organisational terms, it was measured by the LGs number of employees
(EMPLOYEES) as reported in the survey. In environmental terms, it was defined
as the LGs population (POPULATION), as reported in the 2001 census of the
National Statistical Institute (ISTAT). The expected sign was positive for both
variables.
For hypothesis 2, Italy was divided into the four areas identified by ISTAT
(North-West, North-East, Centre and South), producing three dummy variables
(NE, CTR, STH). The expected sign was negative at least for variable STH.
For hypothesis 3, the amount of social capital was measured by a dummy
variable (UNI) for the presence of universities in the LGs territory. This is
an admittedly gross proxy, but the economic and social determinants that
are commonly discussed in the literature are not adequately measured in the
Italian context, at least at such a detailed level as individual municipalities and
provinces. The expected sign was positive.
For hypothesis 4, access to capital markets was measured by two dummy
variables: one (RATING) for whether the LG has been rated by at least one
major rating agency (Moodys, S&P, Fitch), as reported in the agencies websites;
the other (BONDS) for whether the LG has issued bonds, as reported by the
Department of the Interior. The expected sign was positive for both variables.
For hypothesis 5, CFOs perceptions were summarised by the answer to one
of the surveys questions, i.e., what accounting system they would prescribe if
they could affect legislation. More specifically, the dummy variable MYCONFIG
was set to one if the responding CFO supported the replacement of budgetary
accounting with accruals accounting. The expected sign was positive.
Hypothesis 6 was tested using the LGs 2004 per-capita cumulated surpluses
(CUMSURPLUS), as measured by traditional budgetary accounting (risultato di
amministrazione) and reported by the Department of the Interior. The variable
could not be signed a priori.
For hypothesis 7, the relative weight of non-inherently governmental activities
performed by each LG (e.g., water provision, waste disposal, pharmacies) was
measured by the percentage of personnel expenditures devoted to such activities
in 2003 (PCTNIG), as computed from the budgetary-accounting statements
collected by the Department of the Interior. The expected sign was again positive.
Finally, a control dummy (GOVTYPE) was introduced to distinguish between
the two types of LGs: provinces (0) and municipalities (1). Italian Provinces are
intermediate level local authorities whose main functions relate to regulation
C 2008 The Authors
Journal compilation
C 2008 Blackwell Publishing Ltd
332
Table 1
Model of the Study
Journal compilation
(CTR); South (STH)
ANESSI-PESSINA, NASI AND STECCOLINI
Putnam (2000)
RESULTS
for mid-sized LGs (65%) compared to LGs with populations above 250,000
(59%) or below 100,000 (48%),
in the North-East (66%) than in the Centre (60%), the North-West (57%),
and especially the South (43%).
The survey also gave some insights on the role of CFOs in the introduction
and implementation of accruals accounting. In the majority of responding LGs
(80.63%), the current configuration of the accounting system was chosen by the
CFOs themselves, whereas in the remaining LGs this was a political decision.
Responding CFOs were also asked to mention the main forces affecting the
choice of accounting system. Organisational, human, and financial constraints
were mentioned by about 42% of the CFOs, compliance with law by about 36%.
The remainder underlined the relevance of technical issues.
In LGs with traditional accounting systems, CFOs generally argue that
accrual-based financial statements are not very useful because (i) decisions still
rely on the cash- and commitment-based system, which is used to appropriate
resources and constrain expenditures; (ii) accrual-based financial statements
derived from cash- and commitment-based data produce information with
limited accuracy and reliability; and (iii) public managers are not familiar with
accruals accounting techniques and perceive their implementation in LGs as a
merely formal requirement. In LGs with integrated systems, on the contrary,
CFOs usually point out that accruals-based statements provide them with a
better sense of the value of their assets and resources. Consistent with the
international literature (Bromwich and Lapsley, 1997; Anthony, 2000; and
Paulsson, 2006), most of them emphasise the importance of accruals accounting
C 2008 The Authors
Journal compilation
C 2008 Blackwell Publishing Ltd
DETERMINANTS OF LOCAL GOVERNMENTS ACCOUNTING CHOICES 335
for internal, management control purposes as opposed to external accountability.
At the same time, many underline that concepts such as returns, profits and
losses do not belong to the LGs realm, that public organisations missions and
objectives are radically different from private companies, and that accruals
accounting cannot therefore be acritically transferred from the private to the
public sector.
From an explanatory viewpoint (see Table 2), hypotheses 2 (Geographic location)
and 5 (Preparers perceptions) were supported at the 10% and 5% significance
levels, respectively. For the remaining hypotheses, all variables are statistically
insignificant. These results were obtained after removing the three worst-
fit, most influential outliers and have proven robust to variations in the
model specification, including the use of separate regressions for provinces and
municipalities.
In the interpretation of results, a fruitful starting point may be to remember
that hypotheses 2 and 5 stem mainly from the institutional literature. This is
consistent with the importance attributed to coercive isomorphism (compliance
with the law) in the descriptive analysis. Rational/structural elements such
as complexity, types of activities performed, presence of surpluses, and access
to capital markets, on the contrary, are seemingly unhelpful in explaining
why a LG decides to introduce accruals accounting. What counts are the
perceptions of CFOs (whose key role in the choice of the accounting system
was confirmed by the descriptive analysis) and the North-South divide. Further
investigation is obviously in order, also because the model leaves a large amount
Table 2
Logistic Regression
C 2008 The Authors
Journal compilation
C 2008 Blackwell Publishing Ltd
336 ANESSI-PESSINA, NASI AND STECCOLINI
C 2008 The Authors
Journal compilation
C 2008 Blackwell Publishing Ltd
DETERMINANTS OF LOCAL GOVERNMENTS ACCOUNTING CHOICES 337
difficult to reconcile with the descriptive analysis (many CFOs cite human
and financial resource constraints as hindering accounting innovation). This
apparent inconsistency may have different explanations. One is that the proxy
for slack resources may be unsatisfactory. Another is that CFOs may be trying
to find ex-post, rational justifications for their behaviours, feeling that they will
be more acceptable than institutional ones.
CONCLUSIONS
C 2008 The Authors
Journal compilation
C 2008 Blackwell Publishing Ltd
338 ANESSI-PESSINA, NASI AND STECCOLINI
specific features. For Italian LGs, the reliability and relevance of accruals
accounting statements is seemingly jeopardised by at least two major design
faults: the coexistence with traditional budgetary accounting, on the one hand;
and the only marginal and superficial adjustments from private-sector standards,
on the other.
If rational explanations for the adoption of accounting innovations do not
hold, the importance of institutional and cultural variables when introducing
public sector reforms is further confirmed. In our study, particularly important
was the role of CFOs, who seem to exert a fundamental influence on the design
of LGs accounting systems. When explaining their choices, responding CFOs
often underlined the need to comply with legal requirements. Interestingly, this
was particularly true for LGs that had maintained a traditional system, but only
slightly rarer among those that had chosen an integrated system. Thus, it is likely
that in some cases (where the traditional system was maintained), the reforms
were seen as a formal requirement and the traditional system as the simplest
way to comply with the new legislation without significantly affecting the LGs
culture and structure. In other cases, however, the law was seized as an excuse
to justify a more profound change and, for CFOs, to follow the prescriptions of
their professional networks.
In terms of policy implications, the most immediate is that CFOs and their
networks can significantly affect the successful implementation of accounting
reforms and must consequently be involved in policy formulation and reassured
about their potential role under the new system of accounting. CFOs must also
be encouraged to focus not only on the best technical design of the accounting
system, but also on its organisational impacts and its consistency with user needs
and accountability requirements. Another implication is that change cannot
be achieved by introducing innovative legislation only: other variables must be
taken into account, including the competencies, abilities, perceptions and overall
willingness to change of managers and politicians.
In terms of future research, several avenues can be mentioned. First, the
determinants of accounting innovation should be further investigated by looking
at other sets of variables, such as LG political orientation and stability on the one
hand, human factors (see, for instance, Nedovic et al., 1996) on the other. Second,
the relationship between accounting innovation and LG autonomy/accountability
could be fruitfully analysed using international comparisons. Third, it could
be interesting to investigate the relationship between the general attitude
towards organisational innovation and the specific attitude towards accounting
innovation. Fourth, the static and predominantly external perspective adopted in
this paper could be complemented by a dynamic, processual approach that also
pays due attention to internal variables: cases and longitudinal analyses which
study the evolutionary path of accounting changes over time and the unfolding
and interaction of internal and external variables could significantly enrich our
findings.
C 2008 The Authors
Journal compilation
C 2008 Blackwell Publishing Ltd
DETERMINANTS OF LOCAL GOVERNMENTS ACCOUNTING CHOICES 339
NOTE
1 LGs are likely to have only partially succeeded in conducting the reform. Under the integrated-
system label, in other words, different approaches and speeds of implementation can be found.
However, the focus of this paper is not on the degree and direction of implementation, but
rather on the determinants of the choice of whether to adopt an integrated system of accrual.
REFERENCES
Abrahamson, E. (1991), Managerial Fads and Fashion: The Diffusion and Rejection of Innovation,
Academy of Management Review, Vol. 16, No. 3, pp. 586612.
and L. Rosenkopf (1993), Institutional and Competitive Bandwagons: Using Mathematical
Modeling as a Tool to Explore Innovation Diffusion, Academy of Management Review, Vol. 18,
No. 3, pp. 487517.
Adams C.A. (2002) Internal Organisational Factors Influencing Corporate Social and Ethical
Reporting, Accounting, Auditing and Accountability Journal, Vol. 15, No. 2, pp. 22350.
Alexander, M. (2007), Determinants of Social Capital: New Evidence on Religion, Diversity and
Structural Change British Journal of Political Sciences, Vol. 37, pp. 36877.
Anderson S.W. and W.N. Lanen (1999), Economic Transition, Strategy and the Evolution of
Management Accounting Practices: The Case of India, Accounting, Organisations and Society,
Vol. 24, Nos. 5/6, pp. 379412.
Anessi-Pessina, E. (2002), Principles of Public Management (EGEA, Milano).
and I. Steccolini (2005), Evolutions and Limits of NPM-Inspired Budgeting Practices in
Italian Local Governments, Journal of Public Budgeting and Finance, Vol. 25, No. 2 (Summer),
pp. 114.
(2007), Effects of Budgetary and Accruals Accounting Coexistence: Evidence from
Italian Local Governments, Financial Accountability & Management, Vol. 23, No. 2(May), pp.
11331.
Anthony, R.N. (2000), The Fatal Defect in the Federal Accounting System, Public Budgeting and
Finance, Vol. 20, No. 4, pp. 110.
Barrett, P. (1993), Managing in an Accrual Accounting Environment, RIPA Conference (Canberra).
Bingham, R.D. (1978), Innovation, Bureaucracy, and Public Policy: A Study of Innovation Adoption
by Local Government, The Western Political Quarterly, Vol. 31, No. 2, pp. 178205.
Blomquist C. and C. Deegan (2000), Stakeholder Influence on Corporate Reporting: An
Exploration of the Interaction Between the World Wide Fund for Nature and the Australian
Minerals Industry, Working Paper (University of Southern Queensland, Darling Heights,
Toowoomba).
Bogt, H. ter and G.J. van Helden (2000), Accounting Change in Dutch Government: Exploring
the Gap Between Expectations and Realizations, Management Accounting Research, Vol. 11,
No. 2, pp. 26379.
Bolton, M.K. (1993), Organisational Innovation and Substandard Performance: When is Necessity
the Mother of Innovation, Organisational Science, Vol. 4, No. 1, pp. 5775.
Bromwich M. and I. Lapsley (1997), Decentralisation and Management Accounting in Central
Government: Recycling Old Ideas, Financial Accountability & Management, Vol. 13, No. 2,
pp, 181201.
Brudney, J. and S.C. Selden (1995), The Adoption of Innovation by Smaller Local Governments:
The Case of Computer Technology, American Review of Public Administration, Vol. 25, No. 1,
pp. 7186.
Bruns Jr. and J.H. Waterhouse (1975), Budgetary Control and Organisational Structure, Journal
of Accounting Research (Autumn), pp. 177203.
Budros, A. (1999), The Conceptual Framework for Analysing Why Organisations Downsize,
Organisation Science, Vol. 10, No. 1, pp. 6982.
Caccia, L. and I. Steccolini (2005), Accounting Change in Italian Local Governments: Whats
Beyond Managerial Fashion?, Critical Perspectives on Accounting, Vol. 17, Nos. 2/3, pp. 15474.
Caperchione, E. (2003), Local Government Accounting System Reform in Italy: A Critical Analysis,
Journal of Public Budgeting, Accounting and Financial Management, Vol. 15, No. 1, pp. 11045.
C 2008 The Authors
Journal compilation
C 2008 Blackwell Publishing Ltd
340 ANESSI-PESSINA, NASI AND STECCOLINI
Carlin, T. and J. Guthrie (2003), Accrual Output Based Budgeting Systems in Australia: The
Rhetoric-Reality Gap, Public Management Review, Vol. 5, No. 2, pp. 14562.
Carnegie, G. and P. Wolnizer (1995), The Financial Value of Cultural, Heritage and Scientific
Collections: An Accounting Fiction, Australian Accounting Review, Vol. 5, No. 11, pp. 3856.
Chenhall R.H. (2003), Management Control Systems Design Within its Organisational Context:
Findings from Contingency-Based Research and Directions for the Future, Accounting,
Organisations and Society, Vol. 28, pp. 12768.
Child J. and R. Manfield (1972), Technology, Size and Organisation Structure, Sociology, Vol. 6,
No. 3, pp. 36993.
Christiaens, J. (1999), Financial Accounting Reform in Flemish Municipalities: An Empirical
Investigation, Financial Accountability & Management, Vol. 15, No. 1, pp. 2140.
and C. Vanhee (2002), The Concept of a Mega General Ledger in Belgian Provinces,
in V. Montesinos and J.M. Vela (eds), Innovations in Governmental Accounting Systems (Kluwer:
Dordrecht), pp. 191202.
Colloca, C. (2003), Subcultura, in Per leggere la societa (eds G. Bettin Lattes) (Firenze University
Press, Firenze), pp. 30336.
Corte dei Conti (2004), Relazione al Parlamento: La gestione finanziaria degli enti locali. Esercizi 2002-2003
(Roma).
Damanpour, F. (1987), The Adoption of Technological Administrative, and Ancillary Innovations:
Impact of Organisational Factors, Journal of Management, Vol. 13, No. 4 pp. 67588.
(1991), Organisational Innovation: A Meta-Analysis of Effects of Determinants and
Moderators, Academy of Management Journal, Vol. 34, No. 3, pp. 55590.
(1992), Organisational Size and Innovation, Organisational Studies, Vol. 13, No. 3 pp. 375
402.
(1996), Organisational Complexity and Innovation: Developing and Testing Multiple
Contingency Models, Management Science, Vol. 42, No. 5 pp. 693716.
Deegan C., M. Rakin and J. Tobin (2002), An Examination of the Corporate Social Environmental
Disclosures of BHP from 1983-1997. A Test of Legitimacy Theory, Accounting, Auditing &
Accountability Journal, Vol. 5, No. 3, pp. 31243.
Dowling J. and J. Pfeffer (1975), Organisational Legitimacy: Societal Values and Organisational
Behaviour, Pacific Sociological Review, Vol. 18, No. 1, pp. 12236.
Edwards D. (1998), The Link Between Company Environmental Disclosure and Financial Performance
(Earthscan, London).
Ellwood, S. (2001), Accruals Accounting Approaches in the UK Public Sector: Diversity and
Convergence, in A.D. Bac (ed.), International Comparative Issues in Government Accounting (Kluwer,
Boston), pp. 21332.
Emmanuel C., D. Otley and K. Merchant (1990), Accounting for Management Control (2nd ed., London:
Chapman & Hall).
Evans, M. (1995), Resource Accounting and Budgeting (CIPFA, London).
Fountain, J. (2001), Building the Virtual State (Brookings Institution Press, Washington DC).
Funnel, W. and K. Cooper (1998), Public Sector Accounting and Accountability in Australia (University
of New South Wales Press, Sydney).
Gordon L.A. and D. Miller (1976), A Contingency Framework for the Design of Accounting
Information Systems, Accounting, Organisations and Society, Vol. 1, No. 1, pp. 5969.
Guthrie, J. (1998), Application of Accrual Accounting in the Australian Public Sector: Rhetoric or
Reality?, Financial Accountability & Management, Vol. 14, No. 1, pp. 119.
and M. Johnson (1994), Commercialisation of the Public Sector: Why, How and for What?
A Prospective View, in K. Whiltshire (ed.), Governance and Economic Efficiency (CEDA: Sydney),
pp. 87108.
Haldma T. and K. Laats (2002), Influencing Contingencies on Management Accounting Practices
in Estonian Manufacturing Companies (University of Tartu - Faculty of Economics and
Business Administration Working Paper Series, No. 13).
Hayes, D.C. (1977), The Contingency Theory of Managerial Accounting, Accounting Review,
Vol. 52, No. 1, pp. 2239.
Heintze, T. and S. Bretschneider (2000), Information Technology and Restructuring in Public
Organisations: Does Adoption of Information Technology Affect Organisational Structures,
Communications, and Decision Making?, Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory,
Vol. 10, No. 4, pp. 80130.
C 2008 The Authors
Journal compilation
C 2008 Blackwell Publishing Ltd
DETERMINANTS OF LOCAL GOVERNMENTS ACCOUNTING CHOICES 341
Hodges, R. and H. Mellett (2003), Reporting Public Sector Financial Results, Public Management
Review, Vol. 5, No. 1, pp. 99113.
Hood, C. (1991), A Public Management for all Seasons?, Public Administration, Vol. 69(Spring),
pp. 319.
(1995), The New Public Management in the 1980s: Variations on a Theme, Accounting,
Organisations and Society, Vol. 20, Nos. 2-3, pp. 93109.
International Federation of Accountants - Public Sector Committee (1997), Occasional Paper
No. 3: Perspectives on Accrual Accounting (IFAC, New York).
(2002), Study 14: Transition to the Accrual Basis of Accounting: Guidance for Governments
and Government Entities (IFAC, New York).
Iyer, S. et al. (2005), Social Capital, Economic Growth and Regional Development, Regional Studies,
Vol. 39, No. 8, pp. 101540.
Kanter, R. and B. A. Stein et al. (1992). The Challenge of Organisational Change: How Companies Experience
it and Leaders Guide it (New York, Free Press).
Khandwalla P. (1972), The Effect of Different Types of Competition on the Use of Management
Controls, Journal of Accounting Research, Vol. 10, No. 2, pp. 27585.
Lapsley, I. (1999), Accounting and the New Public Management: Instruments of Substantive
Efficiency or a Rationalising Modernity?, Financial Accountability & Management, Vol. 15,
Nos. 3/4 (August/November), pp. 2017.
and J. Pallot (2000), Accounting, Management and Organisational Change: A Comparative
Study of Local Government, Management Accounting Research, Vol. 11, No. 2, pp. 21329.
Lawrence, P.R. and J.W. Lorsch (1967), Organisation and Environment: Managing Differentiation and
Integration (Harvard University, Boston, Mass).
Lewis, N. (1995), AAS 29. A Critique, in ASCPA (ed.), Readings in Accounting Developments in the
Public Sector 1993-1994 (Melbourne), pp. 1625.
Lindblom C.K. (1994), The Implications of Organisational Legitimacy for Corporate Social
Performance and Disclosure, Critical Perspectives on Accounting Conference (New York).
Ma, R. and R. Matthews (1993), Financial Reporting by Government Departments: ED 55 - A
Dissenting View, Australian Journal of Corporate Law, Vol. 3, pp. 6786.
McRae, M. and M. Aiken (1994), AAS29 and Public-Sector Reporting: Unresolved Issues,
Australian Accounting Review, Vol. 4, No. 2, pp. 6572.
Mellor, T. (1996), Why Governments Should Produce Balance Sheets, Australian Journal of Public
Administration, Vol. 55, No. 1, pp. 7881.
Merchant K.A. (1981), The Design of the Corporate Budgeting System; Influences on Managerial
Behaviour and Performance, Accounting Review, Vol. 56, No. 4, pp. 81329.
Meyer, J.W. and B. Rowan (1991), Institutionalized Organisations: Formal Structure as Myth and
Ceremony, in W. Powell and P. Di Maggio (eds.), The New Institutionalism in Organisational
Analysis (The University of Chicago Press, Chicago).
Monsen, N. (2002), The Case for Cameral Accounting, Financial Accountability & Management,
Vol. 18, No. 1, pp. 3972.
and S. Nasi (1998), The Contingency Model of Governmental Accounting Innovations: A
Discussion, European Accounting Review, Vol. 7, No. 2, pp. 27588.
(1999), Comparing Cameral and Accrual Accounting in Local Governments,
in A.D. Bac (ed.), International Comparative Issues in Government Accounting (Kluwer, Boston).
pp. 13557.
(2000), Is Accrual Accounting Appropriate for Governmental Organisations?,
EIASM Conference (Zaragoza).
Montesinos, V. et al. (1995), Comparative Analysis of Governmental Accounting Systems in OECD
Countries: An Empirical Approach,in V. Montesinos and J.M. Vela (eds.), International Research
in Public Sector Accounting, Reporting and Auditing (Instituto Valenciano de Investigaciones
Economicas, Valencia). pp. 16184.
Moon M. J. (2002), The Evolution of e-Government Among Municipalities: Rhetoric or Reality?,
Public Administration Review, Vol. 62, No. 4, pp. 42433.
Nasi G. and I. Steccolini (2008), Implementation of Accounting Reforms: An Empirical Investiga-
tion into Italian Local Governments, Public Management Review, Vol. 10, No. 2, pp. 17394.
Nedovic-Budic Z. and D. R. Godschalk (1996), Human Factors in Adoption of Geographic
Information System: A Local Government Case Study, Public Administration Review, Vol. 56,
No. 6 (November/December), pp. 55467.
C 2008 The Authors
Journal compilation
C 2008 Blackwell Publishing Ltd
342 ANESSI-PESSINA, NASI AND STECCOLINI
C 2008 The Authors
Journal compilation
C 2008 Blackwell Publishing Ltd