Professional Documents
Culture Documents
This paper describes the design and construction of The News Building in London, UK, home of The Times
newspaper and winner of the Institution of Civil Engineers London building award in 2013. Together
with its sister building The Shard, the 140million project redefines the London Bridge area, offering a
new piazza, retail mall and Breeam-excellent-rated offices. It has an innovative and complex steel frame
that cantilevers over London Bridge transport hub, which allows it to achieve nearly 50% more building
mass than otherwise would have been possible. The creative approach taken resulted in an ambitious
and challenging development that minimised the impact on the operation of the underlying bus and rail
stations while ensuring the safety of those involved remained paramount at all times.
115
Downloaded by [] on [19/07/17]. Copyright ICE Publishing, all rights reserved.
Civil Engineering The News Building, London: design and construction
Volume 168 Issue CE3 August 2015 cantilevering over a live transport hub
Adams, Lemmens and Massey
Figure2. Building model showing underground railway assets, viewed from (a) east, (b) south, (c) west
116
Downloaded by [] on [19/07/17]. Copyright ICE Publishing, all rights reserved.
Civil Engineering The News Building, London: design and construction
Volume 168 Issue CE3 August 2015 cantilevering over a live transport hub
Adams, Lemmens and Massey
significant archaeological finds by the Museum of London shared services zone using 320 mm deep openings through the
Archaeology, including many medieval burials and Roman villas beams for services distribution. This had the added benefit of
reorientation of the bus station islands from north-west minimising the storey height and so maximising the net lettable floor
south-east to eastwest and upgrading the bus station while area achieved within the height limitation of the planning permission.
maintaining an operational bus station throughout Minimising the storey height through combined zoning and
existing large-diameter piles and pile caps, the foundations of composite construction has allowed efficient use of materials,
New London Bridge House saving cost and reducing the amount of embodied carbon dioxide
a previously unidentified Second World War access tunnel on the project. It also maximises the net lettable area for the client.
servicing air-raid shelters located in the former City and South
London underground train line. 4.2 Cantilevering over existing assets
The key to maximising the potential of the site was to squeeze
larger floor plates into the space occupied by the former tower
4. Design solutions and analysis without losing usable floor area by such means as a two-storey-
deep transfer structure.
The structural design is a response to the brief and to the site as it Adopting twin cores with inclined columns springing from level
existed with its constraints to development. Major plant equipment 3 or 4 and extending to level 10, 11 or 12, floor plates extending
was located within a single-storey basement, the shape of which was 14m from the core were created above the 55% of the site where
dictated by the concessions zones from the London Underground no foundations could be placed.
assets. The depth was limited during design development to de-risk The raking columns impart significant in-plane forces in the
the project and shorten the construction programme. floors, which then carry the load back to the concrete cores. Where
Designed by structural and services engineer, WSP UK perimeter columns could not be used due to site constraints,
Ltd, the development consists of an 18-storey composite steel vertical hangers support the lower floors, transferring the load in
superstructure over a single-storey basement. The basement tension to the top of the raking columns at the building perimeter.
consists of a secant wall, propped in the permanent case by the The raking columns induce tie or strut forces at each level which
ground-floor and basement slabs. must be transferred into the cores. Unique bearing details were
The basement slab ranges from between 1 and 2m deep and required within the core to deal with the high compressive stresses
is supported on large-diameter bored piles acting as a piled raft. from the raking columns.
Plunge columns were provided to enable a top-down construction As a result of detailed review it was decided to use tie beams
sequence and jump-start of the cores, thereby accommodating the generally in place of Macalloy bars to transfer the tie forces to the
archaeological investigation works and achieving the challenging reinforced-concrete cores. The steel tie beams have been sized to
construction programme. cater for the calculated tie forces.
In addition, the floor slabs needed to be reinforced for an element
4.1 Efficient floor plates of the tie forces to which they are subject as the steel beams are
The large, efficiently planned floor plates were arranged around connected by shear connectors to achieve composite action.
twin cores housing vertical transportation, escape stairs and Generally tie beams are connected to the reinforced-concrete cores
primary vertical services distribution. Depth of floor plate from using embedded plate connections.
facade to core is approximately 135m to make best use of natural There are, however, a small number of locations where, due to
light over at least 50% of the floor area. the magnitude of the tie force to be transmitted, Macalloy bars are
Floor plans were developed to suit either an open-plan arrangement cast into the concrete core walls to ensure transference of the load
or cellular offices with corner break-out spaces. The ceiling build-up into the cores.
is an efficient 650mm including a combined structural and services
zone that utilised composite construction to minimise steel weight
and provide 2750mm clear floor-to-ceiling heights with an efficient 4.3 Out of balance
3700mm storey height. Typical floor zoning is shown in Table1. As the loads on each side of the core are not balanced, the core
Composite construction was used to achieve a maximum beam carries a gravity-induced moment down to the pile cap in addition
depth of 500mm while minimising steel weight and providing a to the moments generated by wind and other lateral loading. The
concentrated loads from the hangers are applied to the core through
the steel beams that are fixed to the core with embedded plates. The
Zone Vertical dimension: mm composite deck is also relied on to transfer load back into the core.
Floor-to-ceiling space 2750 In most cases the embedded plates tie robustly into walls that are
well anchored into the core. The east core is significantly less stiff than
Raised floor zone 150
the west core when considering bending in the eastwest direction.
Structural slab 130
As such, a significant proportion of lateral loads that are applied
Beam zone 500 to the east core will be shed to the stiffer west core, therefore
Deflection 20 requiring a robust load path between the cores.
Ceiling and lighting zone 150
Total 3700 4.4 Superstructure
The superstructure is constructed using Fabsec beams acting
Table1. Typical floor zoning compositely with the lightweight concrete slabs. The floor slab
117
Downloaded by [] on [19/07/17]. Copyright ICE Publishing, all rights reserved.
Civil Engineering The News Building, London: design and construction
Volume 168 Issue CE3 August 2015 cantilevering over a live transport hub
Adams, Lemmens and Massey
is a 130mm thick in situ concrete slab laid on permanent metal A third-party check was carried out by an independent consultant,
decking designed to act compositely with the steel floor beams. GCG, on behalf of London Underground. The tunnel expansion,
The fabricated steel beams are provided at a maximum of 3m compression, rotations, bending moments and axial force, based on
centres to suit the span of the metal decking and are generally the structural engineers assessment, were considered to be within
limited to a maximum depth of 500mm. The 300mm thick plant the tunnels tolerable limits.
room slab at roof level is supported on 600mm deep beams.
Typical composite floor slab construction was designed using 4.6 Fire engineering
standard tables for Corus Comflor 51 re-entrant deck, for the A structural fire engineering study was carried out by the
appropriate fire period, and anti-cracking mesh was provided. structural engineer to optimise the provision of fire protection
Additional reinforcement was provided as required by the fire and to be applied to the structural elements to meet the 120min fire
progressive collapse engineering analysis. In locations where the slab resistance rating for the structure.
was subjected to high tensile or compressive stresses, designs were A performance-based approach was used to justify an optimised
carried out to provide additional reinforcement where necessary. scheme for the beams to the main floor plates. All other elements
The steel beams incorporate a series of 320mm diameter holes of structure were protected to the prescriptive requirements of
and elongated slots, designed and positioned to suit fan coil units approved document B of the building regulations for England and
or chilled beam air-conditioning system options. Wales (HMG, 2010).
At level 14 south elevation, the introduction of a transfer Fire protection ratings for the main beams were indicated on a
structure to support the 3m colonnade columns has resulted in the series of structural drawings. Generally, intumescent paint was used
adoption of pairs of 630mm deep box girders. The box sections are as the method for provision of fire protection to the steel structure;
set with their top level with the top of slab and are therefore non- however, in some cases concrete filling of hollow sections was
composite. used in tandem with intumescent paint to minimise the coating
thickness.
4.5 Ground movement assessment
Due to the close proximity and sensitive nature of the existing 4.7 Safety in tall buildings
London Underground buried assets, ground movement predictions The design was developed to prevent disproportionate collapse
were carried out to investigate the effect of the proposed work. in line with the latest thinking on protection against the possible
Three-dimensional finite-element analysis was carried effects of an extreme event and in accordance with part A of the
out to predict the effect of the proposed development on the building regulations (ODPM, 2004). The determination of specific
existing assets. The analysis was carried out using a Plaxis measures to be implemented to enhance the robustness of the
software model to predict the ground movement around the building was outlined in more detail in a separate report.
basement structure. The predicted ground movement field was The building core was constructed using reinforced-concrete
then used as an input for a 3D finite-element analysis using construction enclosing the exit stairs and vertical transportation
Abaqus structural software to assess the structural implications components of the building, providing a robust construction around
(movement and deformations) of the ground movements on the the escape routes.
existing assets. Part A of the building regulations has been revised since the
The original ground movement analysis indicated that the September 2001 attacks in the USA and all buildings are now
greatest movements were predicted in the eastbound Jubilee line categorised in accordance with building type, occupancy and
running tunnel. The analysis indicated the maximum Jubilee number of storeys. Table 11 of the approved document A, part 3
line tunnel movements occurred at the end of the basement of the regulations defines the development as a class 3 building
excavation. However, settlement derived from the construction of requiring a specific risk assessment.
the superstructure and during long-term conditions reduced the The requirements of part A have been met as described below.
maximum tunnel movements. In addition, the Institution of Structural Engineers report Safety in
The maximum angular distortion of the eastbound Jubilee tall buildings (IStructE, 2002) and recommendations regarding the
running tunnel was assessed to be 1 in 2630 once the basement had use of robust structure, alternative load paths, the use of elements
been excavated. with robust, ductile and energy-absorbing properties tied together
with strong, ductile connections have been followed.
British standards BS 5950 (BSI, 1994) and BS 8110 (BSI, 1997)
Much of the structure is require the following.
cantilevered from the two General tying: by providing horizontal ties at each floor level
cores to prevent loading in two directions.
Tying of edge columns: by providing horizontal ties at each
existing assets below ground. floor level in two directions.
Continuity of columns: by ensuring columns are continuous
This is achieved predominantly through beam to column connections and are capable of
by raking columns springing resisting a minimum tensile force at splice locations.
Resistance to horizontal forces: to be provided by regular
from level 3 or 4 connection to the principal core.
118
Downloaded by [] on [19/07/17]. Copyright ICE Publishing, all rights reserved.
Civil Engineering The News Building, London: design and construction
Volume 168 Issue CE3 August 2015 cantilevering over a live transport hub
Adams, Lemmens and Massey
The design was developed in adapt a number of innovative techniques for faster construction and
had to deal with the following challenges.
line with the latest thinking
on protection against extreme 5.1 Building around existing assets
The occupation of the site and demolition sequence meant that
events. The building cores that superstructure construction could not proceed evenly on the
were constructed using four quadrants of the building, on a building which is already
unevenly loaded in its final condition.
reinforced concrete enclosing Construction proceeded on the west side in advance of the east,
while the north was in advance of the south. As a result of the
the exit stairs and vertical limited area for foundations there are areas of suspended structures
transportation components, adjacent to ground-bearing columns.
Figure3. Piling works started in 2010 but were limited to 45% of the
building plan area
119
Downloaded by [] on [19/07/17]. Copyright ICE Publishing, all rights reserved.
Civil Engineering The News Building, London: design and construction
Volume 168 Issue CE3 August 2015 cantilevering over a live transport hub
Adams, Lemmens and Massey
Figure4. Top-down sequence with core jump-start: (a) install plunge digging for basement level; (d) continue steelwork, cast basement slab
columns, bearing piles, construct slab to prop secant wall; (b) start slip and infill walls
form and digging, install props and waling beam; (c) start steelwork,
So as not to impart load onto the adjacent London Underground construction had to be paused at level 14 so as not to overload
assets, a 20m long steel slip-liner was also installed. The pile was the plunge columns of piles. To do this, 2000m3 of concrete was
formed using 560m3 of bentonite and 280m3 of concrete, which continuously poured over a 26h period.
was poured continuously over 21h.
5.5 Pre-set core in three directions
5.4 Large single basement concrete pour Due to the shape of the site and the relatively small area
Casting the main basement raft was critical because, until available for locating the cores, the geometry of the floor plates
the substructure and cores walls were completed, the building is irregular and the spans vary around the footprint. As a result,
there is an out-of-balance both in the northsouth axis and the
The cores were pre-set 40mm eastwest. To overcome this issue, an industry-leading technique
was applied. The cores were pre-set 40mm to the west and 20mm
to the west and 20mm to the to the north from their vertical lines during construction so that
subsequent permanent works loading brought the cores back to
north from their vertical lines vertical at completion of shell and core construction (Figure6).
during construction so that The movement will continue during the building life in the form
of long-term creep and these predicted movements were taken
subsequent permanent works into account when delivering the design of the various building
elements (most importantly lifts and cladding).
loading brought the cores back The cores were also pre-set high to deal with axial shortening
to vertical at completion of and pile movements. Key to achieving pre-sets within tolerances
was continuous monitoring of the cores during slip-forming by
shell and core construction using lasers and monitoring from street level.
120
Downloaded by [] on [19/07/17]. Copyright ICE Publishing, all rights reserved.
Civil Engineering The News Building, London: design and construction
Volume 168 Issue CE3 August 2015 cantilevering over a live transport hub
Adams, Lemmens and Massey
Figure6. Cores were pre-set 40mm west and 20mm north during
construction to allow for the cantilevered steelwork loading to bring Figure7. Macalloy hangars were used for temporarily suspending the
them back to vertical cantilevered steelwork over the bus station until the raking columns
were completed
121
Downloaded by [] on [19/07/17]. Copyright ICE Publishing, all rights reserved.
Civil Engineering The News Building, London: design and construction
Volume 168 Issue CE3 August 2015 cantilevering over a live transport hub
Adams, Lemmens and Massey
(a) (b)
122
Downloaded by [] on [19/07/17]. Copyright ICE Publishing, all rights reserved.
Civil Engineering The News Building, London: design and construction
Volume 168 Issue CE3 August 2015 cantilevering over a live transport hub
Adams, Lemmens and Massey
Acknowledgements
The project team for the structure was as follows: Sellar Property
Group development manager; Mace main contractor (design
and build); Renzo Piano Building Workshop architect; Adamson
Associates executive architect; WSP UK Ltd structural
and building services engineer; Severfield Rowen steelwork
subcontractor; Byrne Bros. concrete subcontractor; Robert
Figure10. The prestigious 17-storey building was officially opened by Bird & Partners client monitoring team (structures); and Troup
London mayor Boris Johnson in September 2014
Bywater & Anders mechanical and electrical services.
The proof of the pudding was that cladding erection was able to
commence without entire floor plates being available and that the References
predictions were accurate, and installation and jacking operations and
survey checks were carried out to such a degree of expertise by all BSI (1994) BS 5950-4:1994 Structural use of steelwork in building. Code
of practice for design. Composite slabs with profile steel sheeting. BSI,
parties involved that the superstructure was constructed such that the London, UK.
cladding fitted within allowable tolerances. It was a great success that
BSI (1997) BS 8110-1:1997 Structural use of concrete. Code of practice for
allowed the extremely challenging programme to be met (Figure10). design and construction. BSI, London, UK.
HMG (Her Majestys Government) (2010) The Building Regulations
6. Conclusion Approved Document B Fire Safety. NBS, Newcastle upon Tyne, UK.
IStructE (Institution of Structural Engineers) (2002) Safety in Tall Buildings
and Other Buildings with Large Occupancy. Institution of Structural
This paper describes the design and construction of a 17-storey Engineers, London, UK.
high-quality office building in the congested centre of London. ODPM (Office of the Deputy Prime Minister) (2004) The Building Regulations
It describes the engineering challenges of working over a live Approved Document A Structure. ODPM, London, UK.
bus station, in front of one of the citys busiest rail terminals and Parker (2013) Engineering The Shard, London: tallest building in western
surrounded by London Undergrounds critical buried assets. It Europe. Proceedings of the Institution of Civil Engineers Civil
explains how these challenges were overcome by integrated design Engineering 166(2): 6673, http://dx.doi.org/10.1680/cien.12.00036.
and construction teams working in a truly collaborative way and by
using bold techniques. What do you think?
Formerly known as The Place, the building won the Institution If you would like to comment on this paper, please email up to 200 words
of Civil Engineers London region building award on its completion tothe editor at journals@ice.org.uk.
in 2013. The judges said, The Places innovative steel frame If you would like to write a paper of 2000 to 3500 words about your own
cantilevers over one of Londons busiest transport hubs, allowing it experience in this or any related area of civil engineering, the editor will be
happy to provide any help or advice you need.
to grab 50% more space than a conventional building would.
123
Downloaded by [] on [19/07/17]. Copyright ICE Publishing, all rights reserved.