You are on page 1of 7

Art Psychofherapy, Vol. 6, pp. 155-161, 1979. Pergarnon Press Ltd. Printed in the USA.

FROM SH~NIS~ TO ART THERAPY*

SHAUN McNIFF, PH.D.

Dean, Institute for the Arts and Human Development


Lesley College Graduate School

SH~ANIS~ AND THE oped in response to the groups need for social
NECESSITY OF ART equilibrium (Levi-Strauss, 1963). Like the artist, the
shaman achieves balance by engaging imbalance, ten-
The therapeutic role of the arts in alleviating sion and uncertainty (McNiff, 1977). The confronta-
human suffering and in resolving emotional conflict tion of ~reate~g elements is supported by those
predates the creation of the professional art ther- who participate in and observe the shamans enact-
apist by thousands of years. The novelty of art ment. People are in turn stimulated and renewed
therapy lies in the introduction of these practices through the process. Durkheim felt that these early
into the relatively new field of psychiatry and the shamanic rituals were a celebration of the groups
formal practice of psychotherapy which are specific sacred in groupness.
to our contemporary historical epoch. As technical It seems that the shaman is always a person who
methodologies psycho~erapeutic systems are rarely functions within social groups. The skill of the sha-
culturally interchangeable. As interpersonal processes man was measured by his/her ability to structure the
however, they continue the life sustaining functions enactment in a manner which paralleled the con-
of religion, communal ritual and the family. The figuration of the individual or group conflict. The
earliest m~ifestation of what we now call the ther- ritual and symbols had to fit the problem and
apist was the shaman who has been known as a facilitate its expression. In discussing this aspect of
medicine man, one who works with the super- sh~~ism Qaude Levi-Strauss feels that both the
natural, a technician of the sacred, a master of psychoanalyst and the shaman must work toward the
ecstasy, mystic, healer, priest and artist. In essence, creation of a healing experience and the formation of
the work of the shaman involves all of these things. a life ordering system. He believes that the sha-
Eliade (1964) in his comprehensive study, Sham- manistic process and psycho~~ytic treatment are in
nism, describes the district quality of the shaman at essence the same but their operational principles
his/her ability to create an ecstatic trance through differ. The analyst is cast as a listener and the
which the soul departs from the body and travels on a shaman as a speaker/actor (Levi-Strauss, 1963, p.
mythological journey to spirit worlds . . . The 199). Although 1 do not question these distinctions,
shaman is the great specialist in the human soul (p. the truth of the matter seems to lie somewhere in
8). between. Polarization tends to over-simplify. The
Societies in virtualiy every geographic region of contemporary psychotherapist speaks considerably
the world have appreciated the importance of experi- and, in the case of the arts, engages in action. On the
encing and enacting dreams and conflicts. Within other hand, the shamans successful enactments are
early communities the shaman was the person who dependent on sensitive listening and diagnosis.
helped the group to relate to and maintain a dialogue With regard to training, the shaman was instructed
with inner experience. The shamans role was devel- in the use of culturally inherited techniques which

*Requests for reprints should be sent to ShaunMcNiff, Ph.D., Dean, Institute for the Arts and Human Development, Lesley
College Graduate School, 35 Mellen Street, Cambridge, Mass. 02138. Please enclose stamped, self-addressed enveiope.

0090-9092/79/0301~~~7$02.00/0
Copyright =1979 Pergamon Press Ltd.
156 SHAUN McNIFF

enabled the group to give tangible form to their capable of accepting behavior expressive of psy-
dreams and visions. They were in this way able to chological disequilibrium.
become more aware of private experiences and share Lommel (1967, p. 25) describes the shaman as a
them with others. As with the history of art the doctor in the psychological/psychoanalytic realm.
actual methods and practices of the shaman have Observers note how the shaman practices a form of
been characterized by great multiplicity and indi- group therapy in which the entire community parti-
vidual styles. As opposed to the standardization of cipates. The shamans technique is often one of
religious traditions celebrated by priests, shamanism enacting the forces and life dramas that are disturbing
is tied to the particular personality of the shaman the patient so that the invisible tensions can be
whose techniques of transcendence relate to the directly confronted and dispelled. This methodology
unifying myths and beliefs of the community. is comparable to the psychoanalytic process of
Due to misleading associations of the behavior of transference where the patient unconsciously sees
the shaman with madness and hallucinatory states of in the person of the therapist the qualities of the
a schizophrenic nature, the essentially constructive parent or other person who is a source of conflict.
role of the true shaman has been overlooked. Mircea The enactment of the psychological conflict is also
Eliade has stressed the discipline and skill of the directly parallel to the contemporary. process of
professional shaman whose formative crisis can be psychodrama where problematic situations are dra-
likened to the initiation into other religious voca- matized in a therapeutic context.
tions. He feels that the shaman was separated from The struggle of the shaman to find meaning and
the group by the intensity of his religious experi- order within the flux of experience is akin to the
ence and not by psychopathology. This position is artistic process. Like the dramatists of later cultures
confirmed by the extensive field studies of Nadel the shaman attempts to attach spiritual significance
(1946) who never observed the disintegration of the to unsettling and tragic circumstances. Contact with
shamans professional hysteria into emotional intense emotions such as grief and psychological
disturbance. states of anxiety, depression or isolation awaken the
For Eliade The shaman and mystics of primitive shaman to forces beyond the immediate realm of
societies are considered - and rightly - to be superi- functional experience. According to Eliade (1958, p.
or beings . . . The shaman is the man who knows and 89) The total crisis of the future shaman, sometimes
remembers, that is, who understands the mysteries of leading to a complete disintegration of their per-
life and death. (1958, p. 102) There were of course sonality and to madness, can be valuated not only as
female shamans. In describing Siberian shamanism an initiatory death, but also as symbolic return to the
Czaplicka (1914) noted that although at times it was precosmogonic chaos, to the amorphous and inde-
virtually a male profession, there is evidence sug- scribable state that preceded any cosmogony.
gesting that in Siberia during earlier epochs it was The shaman is capable of engaging primary pro-
primarily a female cult (p. 30). James (1955) has cess and returning to more controlled behavior. This
gone further in reporting that in Africa, Indonesia can be likened to Freuds description of the artist.
and America female magicians and shamans are some- The immersion into spiritual realms brings renewal
times more numerous than their male counterparts. for both the shaman and the community which is
Although the shamans vocation is purportedly vicariously engaged. In making a comparison of the
revealed through experiences of hysteria and what we shamanistic trance to schizophrenia Silverman (1967,
refer to as psychotic episodes, the initiate must be p. 28) provides a description of the shamans altered
able to work through the crisis and resolve the various state of consciousness which is directly parallel to
psychological tensions before becoming a shaman. It artistic activity and the process of art therapy . . . if
is more than likely that in many cases the shamans one conceives of the total psyche as a self-regulating
crisis was more mystical than psychopathological. system, the eruption of ordinarily unconscious
Nevertheless, if the shaman was able to heal himself/ (dream-like) imagery is, under such crisis conditions,
herself and others, it is because he/she understood the absolutely necessary for restoring balance and whole-
process of emotional disturbance. It is likely that the ness to the system. Silverman emphasizes that com-
shaman did experience the same kind of existential munity support enabled shamanism to become a total
life crisis that precipitates emotional disturbance psychological adjustment to emotional turmoil. In
today, but the culture in which he/she lived was early cultures psychic disturbance was accommodated
FROM SHAMANISM TO ART THERAPY 157

within the general social balance of opposing emo- the passive role of mirroring the clients behavior. The
tional forces. With shamanism the integration of community, which is to be adapted to, is often an
conflicting elements became a natural and functional invisible system of behavioral constraints which the
part of individu~ and communal life. therapist must help the client survive in..The artist,
The parallels between shamanism and the newly like the shaman, provides an alternative mode of
emerging field of art therapy seem to lie in the action in demonstrating how one can live with
commitment of both to work with psychological heightened sensitivity and awareness. In this respect
conflict and struggle through creative action and art therapy offers the premise that a person can
enactment. Just as the society of today has a low consciously give value to existence through the artis
tolerance for the expressive and aberrant behavior of tic consciousness. The art therapist as shaman
the person in emotional crisis, it has shown a similar becomes a role model for creative adaptability and
lack of empathy for emotionally charged artistic expression.
statements which deviate from cultural norms. Thus, Like the art therapist, the personality, experience,
as Ruth Benedict states in Patterns of Cultire, (1934, techniques and training of the shaman have a direct
p, 2701, the dysfunction of ~dividu~s in society is effect on the quality of the healing process. In his
not necessarily a result of their abnormality but is book, 77ze Shamans Doorway, Stephen Larsen men-
more likely due to the lack of value that the society tions , , , that even the intrepid shaman does not
places on their behavior. venture into the realm of primary meaning without a
The artist, the shaman and the person suffering myth in mind. (1976, p. 34) Through the myth the
from emotional unrest are open to and struggle with persons internal drama is connected to the con-
the disequ~ib~um of existence. Rather than attemp tinuities and patterns of the community and the
ting to treat the eruptions of psychological tension shaman uses his/her expressive and evocative powers
with external forces of tranquilization, the artist and to guide the group in contacting the sacred and
the shaman go to the heart of the inner storm and transcend everyday experience. The drum and elabor-
enact its furies in a way which is of value to the ate costuming serve as tools of transcendence which
individu~ and the community. The end result is not assist in bringing about a separation from profane
just emotional catharsis but deepened insight into the existence through trance-like repetitions and what we
nature of human emotion. Where the general ten- might describe today as relaxation exercises. Virtually
dency of society is to walk a continuously straight every form of shamanism utilizes some form of
and balanced line of behavior, the artist and the sensory focusing and fixation on a particular series of
shaman maximize the social value of imbalance. They stimuli in order to alter consciousness. Eliade feels
see that struggle gives si~i~cance to existence. Life is that the skillful shaman rarely depended upon hal-
perceived as a dynamic system which proceeds to a lucinogenic drugs to achieve ecstasy whereas MC
natural order and expands if allowed to do so. Kenna and McKenna maintain that hallucinogens
(Amheim, 1971) were a natural feature of all forms of shamanism.
In their study of shamanism, McKenna and In time the practices of shamanism developed into
McKenna reafcrm the need today for doctors of the established patterns and belief systems and further
soul and see the modem shaman in the person of the evolved into st~dard~ed religions where priests,
artist who understands how consciousness and iden- rather than the shaman, led rituals related to ortho-
tity are not fixed properties but are rather evolving dox spiritual principles. As Larsen (1976) states there
processes, constantly in motion, To the artist it is an occurred . , . a victory of the principles of a socially
accepted fact that the way to personal fulfillment lies anointed priesthood over the highly dangerous and
in the process itself, in the creative and spontaneous unpredictable force of individual endo~ent (p.
adaptation to the kinetic, changing and dynamic 161).
principles of evolving life. The artist is thus actively Within our expanding technological society the
engaged with both material and spiritual realities, role of the priest is giving way to the socially
This active versus passive role is perhaps one of the appointed role of the psychotherapist and psy-
most fundamental differences between shamanism chologist who give meaning to life through their
and the contempora~ mental health field. Where the knowledge of the behavioral sciences. They clarify
shaman enacts conflict and life dramas for the benefit existence not through ritual and communal worship
of the community, todays psychotherapist is cast in but through their individual insights and inter-
158 SHAUN McNIFF

pretations. This approach to explaining life is psychiatry in the ancient continuities of art healing
accepted by the society just as early cultures accepted and sham~ism. Like sham~ism, art therapy offers a
belief systems which attributed all causality to the natural way of being *and healing which societies seem
influence of the stars or a divine being. These new to consistently find when they become excessively
professionals have moved people away from a reliance mechanized, disoriented and disconnected from their
on religious dogma and teaching for a definition of spiritual beginnings. At these points of crisis they
existence, and toward a dependence on contemporary seem to turn to art which provides an alternative to
psychological theory. However, in the mental health alienation and imbalance in the unifying aesthetic
field there is a growing realization that scientific consciousness.
formulations are limited in dealing with problems of
the human spirit. Ernst Cassirer (1955) in his P~~l~so-
ART, ACTION AND
phy of Symbolic Forms supports the role of the arts PSYCHOTHERAPEUTIC HISTORY
and myth in the development of consciousness and
self-awareness. To the factual world which sur- In the recent history of art psychotherapy influen-
rounds and dominates it the spirit opposes an inde- tial thinkers have advocated procedures in keeping
pendent image world of its own - more and more with what we found in shamanism.
clearly and consciously it confronts the force of the Early psychotherapists, including C.G. Jung, J.L.
impressions with an active force of expression (p. Moreno and Otto Rank, were keenly aware of the
23). artistic and spiritual roots of psychotherapy. Rank
Today the various roles of the shaman are divided (1959) spoke of the analyst as . . . a new artist-type.
between different professional groups - psycho- such as has not existed since the Creek period and
therapists, artists, priests, physicians, etc. With regard had not been needed since ihe Christian era began.
to the resolution of emotional conflict this role The type of artist who works in living human mate-
fragmentation has taken away the shamans source of rial, who seeks to create men not like parents,
power which is the integration of mind, body, art and physically, but spiritu~ly like God (pp. 272-273).
spirit. Rank was disheartened by the growing materialistic
The art therapist brings the psychotherapy process tendencies of psychology which in his mind tried to
into contact with the continuities of healing through destroy the soul. Beginning with, and including
art, ritual and ceremony in a manner which allows for Freud, psycholo~ has attempted to explain the
the direct communication and expression of personai unconscious in scientific terms and has thus elimi-
imagery and bodily sensations. In no uncertain terms nated its spiritual content which Rank felt gave birth
the expressive art therapist can be a modem mani- to psychology, He believed that no matter how much
festation of the shaman in that he/she is responding the psychologist tries to avert attention from issues of
to the fundamental necessity of the human spirit to death and immort~ity, they are the dete~ining
seek transcendence; to intensify sensory experience; factors of adult consciousness. The psychoanalytic
to restore the balance between the individual and the terminology of the unconscious attempted to take
community; to gain a Sense of control over life the place of the soul and behavioral psychology has
processes or, more realistic&y, an abiiity to respond gone even farther in attending only to manifestations
creatively to existential fluctuations and change; to of overt physical activity. Rank goes to the extreme
bring the human spirit to a sense of participation in a of believing that Psychology is the souls worst
purposeful cosmos; and to respond to the need of the enemy, because in creating its own consolation for
individual for life clarifying belief systems and values. death it becomes compelled by the self-knowledge it
The expressive art therapist is appearing in the creates to prove that the soul does not exist, thus it
mental health field at a time when society has few becomes both a scientific psychology without a soul
unifying myths and when the fragmentation of the and a kind of overburdening of the inner spiritual self
mind, the loss of the drive for self-fulfillment, per- which, with no support from an inherent belief in
ceptual confusion, and an inability to appreciate the immortality, goes to pieces in a way the neuroses
struggle of existence are typical characteristics of show so well. ( 1950, . 3 1)
emotional disturbance. As the expressive art therapist In taking the artist metaphor further, Rank
begins to take on the role of healer in our time, it is reacted against the determinist theories of Freud by
well to look for precedents beyond the horizon of emphasizing the importance of the conscious will and
FROM SHAMANISM TO ART THERAPY 159

the potential of each person to act as artist who can Traditional psychotherapists are handicapped in
creatively shape his/her personal character. Ranks introducing action modes into the therapeutic session
position was reminiscent of Nietzsche who believed because of their own inability to be confident and
that existence can be justified only through aesthetic comfortable with the enactment of feelings and con-
perception. In trying to liberate the conscious mind flict. Many therapists who support the theory of
Nietzsche was an antecedent of the self-actualization creative action in therapy are insecure when they are
therapists and the art therapist in his advocacy of the required to move in space without the support of
will to power and the ability of each person to their chairs. Therefore they do not engage in more
reach elf-transcendence through aesthetic perception expressive and body oriented therapies. The appreci-
and the process of constantly giving new valuations ation of the healing potential of the arts is also not
to experience through art. clear to the traditional therapist largely because
The dramatic implications of therapists and clients he/she is but a part of a society which is influenced
acting together within an artistic process was taken by the dominant aesthetic theory that art is some-
further yet by Moreno who first introduced creative thing that is removed and separate from daily life
action modes to the p~cho~erapeutic experience. functions. This approach to art is a continuation of
Today we find that Morenos contributions are having Kants philosophy of aesthetic disinterestedness
a major influence on contemporary therapeutic which views true artistic perception as an end com-
approaches. His techniques of role-playing, role- pletely in itself - what we sometimes refer to as art
reversal and his emphasis on the enactment of the for arts sake. Unfortunately, this obsession with the
drama of each persons Iife are the basis of gestalt exalted properties of the art experience has led to
therapy and other recent psycho~erapeu~c practices. widespread social misunderstanding as to the practical
Morenos innovations grew out of his frustration with and life supporting functions of art.
orthodox psychoanalytic therapy where the slightest The expressive techniques of Moreno are closer to
suggestion of acting out was discouraged and where historical practices of art healing and shamanism than
the therapist and client (lying on a couch) attempted the work of many art therapists who have identified
to verbally resolve unconscious conflict and tension. themselves with classic modes of verbal psycho-
Observing the lessons of theater and other healing therapy where graphic art is often only an addition to
rituals, Moreno realized that only through spon- otherwise traditional psychotherapeutic methods.
taneous action can a person recreate and work Within this therapeutic structure the visual expres-
through emotional problems which are rooted as sions of clients are sometimes more accurately
much in the body as in the mind. Through the efforts described as graphic diagrams and communications
of Moreno, Reich, Lowen and others, psychothera- rather than as visual art. I might also add that the
pists have been stimulated to come to grips with practice of art therapy as we now know it is rarely
Cartesian duality of mind and body that permeates characterized by the enactment of feelings through
classical psychoanalytic techniques. the complete expressive apparatus of the body. Art
The psychodramatic approach realizes that healing therapy as it is commonly practiced does not open
comes from action and the complete artistic catharsis itself to the totality of art and mind/body integra-
described by the Greeks. Morenos system of real life tion. Only through a uni~cation of the various arts in
enactment of psychic conflict is tied to the ancient therapy will the creative art therapist begin to revive
continuities of art healing, where the community or the multi-dimensional skills of the shaman who was
group enacts its uncertainties under the guidance of capable of relating to all spheres of sensory activity as
the shaman. The shamans enactments were the begin- well as dream experiences. This integration is sug-
nings of theater which later grew more distant from gested most clearly today in the work of Moreno who
immediate life experience with the progressive devel- unified the psycholo~c~ methods of his time with
opment and enlargement of civilization. Through his the sacred spheres of life. Morenos therapeutic
psychodramatic explorations Moreno also helped the experimentations brought the arts together in an
contemporary theater to rediscover its artistic roots attempt to maximize the creative spontaneity of
in the emotional intensities of each persons life individuals and groups. His thesis was that the locus
(Bentley, 1970). As Hera&us said in 500 BC, Man of the self is spontaneity and spontaneity is the
is estranged from that with which he is most famil- matrix of creativity. Moreno tried to liberate
iar. people in a fashion similar to Nietzsche by em-
160 SHAUN McNIFF

phasizing the godliness in each person and the striving experiences which evoke feelings of renewal through
to fulfill our creative potential which in hisview was the classical myth cycle of separation-penetration-
the esthetic demonstration of freedom. In taking and return. Dramatic improvisations and visual art
the content of art from the everyday lives of people expressions often border on totemism with partici-
he deals with creation at a level where the neat pants identifying themselves with animals which per-
separation of the esthetic from the therapeutic is sonify both desirable and malevolent attributes.
meaningless . . . Rather than stressing the creation of Tutelary spirits are created in art activities for the
an immortal, permanent product, he places the purpose of expressing needs for support and protec-
emphasis on true spontaneity and the qualitative tion. In all of these manifestations of contemporary
immersion in the moment. This approach to art and art therapy, essential and unchanging projections of
therapeutic theater is comparable to the enactment of the human spirit are expressed in a manner which
the shaman in that the persons play before them- bears a striking resemblance to shamanism.
selves . , , the same life again. The place of the
conflict and of its theater is one and the same . . .
CONCLUSION
they re-experience it, they are master . . . It does not
only emerge in order to heal itself, for relief and The task ahead from a broad social perspective is
catharsis, but it is also the love for its own demons vast in that the arts need a general cultural environ-
which drives the theater on to unchain itself . . . not ment which is supportive of personal artistic develop-
like a renewal of suffering rather it confirms the rule: ment. Advances in this direction have been made in
every second time is the liberation from the first mental health clinics and schools where expressive art
(Moreno, 1973, pp. 90-9 1). therapy is taking root. Just as the shaman must create
In addition to these philosophical parallels, the an interpersonal and physical space that facilitates
role of the psychodrama director and the shaman are transcendence and heightened perception, SO too the
closely related. Moreno describes how the leader is art therapist must think environmentally and con-
the one most deeply possessed by the idea of the struct a workspace that helps people to separate
play. The leader must be completely immersed in themselves from inhibiting life experiences which act
the process of re-enactment and helps other people to as barriers to creative expression. Like the shaman,
warm-up to levels of heightened spontaneity and the art therapist must create a trusting or what might
transcendence. In these contemporary therapeutic be called a sacred place where people can begin to
practices Moreno began to re-enact the ancient prac- penetrate and explore their perceptions, values and
tices of art healing. Through research and ongoing expressions as represented in the immediacy of
experimentation we must continue to explore the present actions. Across the country art therapists are
specific ways in which present therapeutic methods creating communities of adults, children and ado-
are culturally interchangeable. Rather than remain lescents tied together and supportive of each other as
one-sidedly attached to the disciplines of psychology in the very first communities of the world. In these
and psychiatry, the expressive art therapist should programs art intensifies relationships with other
utilize the fields of anthropology together with the people and the physical environment and enables
history of art and religion to explore how the thera- them to relate directly to primary life functions and
peutic use of the arts can be more fully expanded in emotions. The expressive art therapist offers an alter-
our society. Research will indicate that we are re- native to a society which has focused its attention
enacting ancient shamanistic practices often without exclusively on the art object as an end in itself while
being aware of the parallels. Drama and dance ther- neglecting the creative needs of each individual mem-
apists find themselves spontaneously celebrating ber of the community. The potential for the thera-
rituals of passage through which obstacles are con- peutic use of the arts is of a revolutionary order in
fronted and overcome. Catharsis, chant, rhythmic that art therapy and other humanizing experiences
drumming and group participation typify their work. challenge the very fouundations of the existing
Poetry therapy enourages naming and personalizing mental health system with its emphasis on behavioral
the physical environment. All of the arts sanctify control rather than human expression. In this respect
place and make the profane sacred through symbolic the art therapists must be cautious and avoid being
transformations, Shamanistic journeys of ascent and absorbed into the regularities of the mental health
descent are similar to todays guided imagery field. The action modes of the expressive therapist are
FROM SHAMANISM TO ART THERAPY 161

at times perceived as deviant and contrary to the ELIADE, MIRCEA (1958) Birth und Rebirth. New York:
Harper and Row.
environmental and behavioral norms of mental hospi- ELIADE, MIRCEA (1964) Shamanism: Archaic Techniques
tals, clinics and other human service institutions. of Ecstasy. New York: Pantheon.
Nevertheless, the artist has made great inroads into JAMES, E.O. (1955) 7he Nature and Function of Priesthood.
Glasgow, Scotland: Robert Maclehose.
the mental health field over the past ten years. In my LARSEN, STEPHEN (1976) 7&e Shamans Doorway. New
opinion, the obstacles, questions and lack of accept- York: Harper and Row.
ance we have encountered have increased the fervor LEVISTRAUSS, CLAUDE (1963) Structural Anthropology.
New York: Basic Books.
and moral conviction of those intent upon human-
LOMMEL, ANDREAS (1967) Shamanism: The Beginnings of
izing the field and connecting it to the ancient Art. New York: Harper and Row.
continuities of the human spirit. McKENNA, D.J. AND McKENNA T.K. (1975) The Invisible
Landscape. New,York: Seabury Press.
McNIFF, SHAUN (1977) Motivation in art, Art Psycho-
REFERENCES therapy, Volume 4, pp. 125-l 36.
MORENO, J.L. (1973) The Theutre of Spontaneity. New
ARNHEIM, RUDOLPH (1971) Enfrophy und Art: An Essay York: Beacon House.
on Order and Disorder. Berkeley and Los Angeles: Univer- NADEL. S.F. (1946) A study of Shamanism in the Nuba
sity of California Press. Mountains, i Anth. Inst. of Great Britain and Ireland.
BENEDICT, RUTH (1934) Puftems of Culture. Boston: NIETZSCHE. FRIEDRICH (1917) 77rus Spake Zarathustra.
Houghton-Mifflin. New York: Macmillan.
BENTLEY, ERIC (1970) Theatre and therapy, in neorre POWER, JOSEPH (1975) Moreno and the god controversy,
of War. New York: Viking. Group Psychotherapy & Psychodrama, Vol. 28, I, pp.
CAMPBELL, JOSEPH (1972) Myths to Live By. New York: 164-167.
Viking. RANK, OTTO (1950) Psychology and the Soul. Philadelphia:
CAMPBELL, JOSEPH (1949) The Hero with (I Thousand University of Pennsylvania Press.
Faces. New York: Pantheon. RANK. OTTO (1959) The Mvth of the Birth of the Hero and
CASSIRER, ERNST (1955) The Philosophy of Symbolic Other Writings. Ed. by Philip Freund. New York: Vintage.
Forms: Volume 2, Mystical Thought. New Haven: Yale SILVERMAN, JULIAN (1967) Shamans and acute schizo-
University Press. phrenia, American Anthropologist, Vol. 69, pp. 21-31.
CZAPLICKA, M.A. (1914) AboriginuZ Siberia, Oxford: Uni- WHITEHEAD, ALFRED NORTH (1929) Process und Reul-
versity Press. ity: An Essuy in Cosomology. New York: Macmillan.

You might also like