You are on page 1of 8

m-*g-

Optimized Design and Operating m911


24& 7
Parameters for Minimizing Emissions
During VOC Thermal Oxidation
by Edward Donley and David Lewandowski,
Process Combustion Corp., Pittsburgh

T he Clean Air Act (CAA)


Amendments of 1990 are in-
tended to reduce emissions of
volatile organic compounds (VOCs)
by 70 to 90%. They specifically desig-
nocuous by-products. A generic repre-
sentation of this process is shown
below:
VOC + 0, + CO, + H,O (I)
destruction efficiency varies with the
specific compoiuh treated. That is, a
higher destruction cfficiency will be
achieved for some compunds in com-
parison to others at a spculic temper-
nate 189 compounds as hazardous air Heat is evolved as these reactions ature. One method of asswing the
pollutants (HAPs). The EPA estimates occur; however, unless the quantity of difficulty of destroying an organic
that the aerospace industry generates VOCs present is very large, additional compound is its Thermal hbility
208,000 tons per year of HAPs plus an energy is required to raise the VOC to Ranking.* Although conditions 'iir
additional 145,000 tons per year of the temperature required for complete achieving a given degree of destructioh
VOCs. Maximum Achievable Control destruction. This is usually supplied by are not idenlified specifically, it does
Technology (MACT) standards for an auxiliary fuel such as natural gas. provide a relative ranking ofthe degree
regulating HAP emissions from the Thermal oxidation is not the orily of difficulty of destroying over 300
aerospace industry were proposed by process that can be used to treat VOCs; organic compounds.
the EPA. The most common HAPs however, it offers several advantages Another generally accepted method
found in the aerospace industry are when comparcd with competing pro- of determining the temperature re-
glycol ethers, xylene, toluene, methyl cesses. These are listed in Table 1. The quired for destruction of an organic
ethyl ketone, trichloroethane, and me- primary advantage is that the VOCs compound is its Auto-Ignition Temper-
thyl isobutyl ketone. Most HAP emis- are destroyed rather than captured. ature (AIT). Compounds with higher
sions come from clean-up solvents. Capturing the VOCs requires further auto-ignition temperatures arc usually
Thermal oxidation systems play, and treatment for their ultimate disposal. more difficult to destroy. AITs of com-
will continue to play, a prominent role in mon VOCs are shown on Table 11.
meeting CAA-mandated VOC and HAP
emission-reduction targets. According to OPERATING PARAMETERS
R e s i d e n c e Time
a study conducted for the American In- Thermal oxidation systems can Residence time does not have the
stitute of Chemical Engineers in 1993, achieve very high levels of VOC de- s a n e impact as temperature on VOC
oxidation systems are projected to be the destruction; however, sufficient time
struction when properly designed and
technology of choice in 43% of the ap- operated. The parameters that define must be allowed for the chemical ki-
plications requiring VOC reduction.' these conditions have been historically netic reactions to occur. Generally,
Thermal oxidation systems can he ap- described by the three Ts of destruc- thermal oxidizer residence limes range
plied to 80% of the compounds classi- tion: time, temperature, and turhu- from 0.5 to 2.0 seconds. Lower resi-
tied as HAPS under the CAA. lence. A fourth item must also be in- dence times correspond to lower de-
On the one hand, thermal oxidation of cluded, excess oxygen. VOC struction efficiencies and vice versa. A
VOCs is a very simple process. Organic destruction efficiencies greater than 1.0-second residence time is generally
compounds are bumed to innocuous by- 99.99% can be attained if these four applied when a destruction efficiency
products. But on the other hand, proper parameters are in the proper ranges. of 99.99% or higher is required; how-
design principles must be applied to en- ever, the Toxic Substances Control Act
sure complete destruction of the organics (TSCA), which regulates wastes con-
while minimizing formation of undesir- Temperature taining polychlorinated biphenyls
able by-products. Both design and oper- No parameter has a greater impact
ating parameters affect performance. on VOC destruction than the operating
Table I.Advantages of Thermal Oxidation
This article discusses those principles temperature of the thermal oxidizer.
used to maximize VOC destruction Generally, this temperature is held in VOC destruction greater than 99.99%
while minimizing the emissions of other the range of 1,400 to 2,200'E The Minimal number of process components
exception is total reduced sulfur (TRS) Ease of operation and control
pollutant species.
Amenable to variations 01 wade flow and
compounds. These ciin he effectively composition
THERMAL OXIDATION destroyed at temperaturcs as low iis Continuous process
FUNDAMENTALS 1,200~F.Examples of TRS compounds No byyoduct disposal
are hydrogen sulfide, methyl mercip Can be applied to more than 80% of CAA air
tan, and dimethyl sulfide. toxics
As ils name implies, thermal oxida-
tion oxidizes organic compounds to in- At a given operating temperature, CAA, Clean Air Act: VOC, volatile organic compound.

52 0 Copyright Elsevier Science Inc. METAL FINISHING NOVEMBER 1996


Table 11. Auto-Ignition Temperatures of Table 111. VOC Destructim Efficiency versus Time a n d Temperalure
Common Organic Compounds
Destruction Ejficiency (%j
- Degrees Above Auto-lgnilion Temperature 0 Residence rime (sec.)
Compound Auto-Ignition Temperalure rF)
95 300 0.5
669 Acetone 98 4cQ 0.5
1,204 Ammonia 99 475 0.75
1.097 Benzene 99.9 550 1.0
840 Butadiene 99.99 650 2.0
693 Butanul
257 Carbon disulfide VOC, voialiie organic compound.
1,128 Carbon monoxide
1,245 Chlorobenzene
1,185 Olchiarmnethane are interrelated. For example, velocity companies that have accumulated
403 Dimethyl sulfide is dependent upon o.iidizer ID. Veloc- years of operating data at a variety of
950
... Ethane ity, density, and viscosity are depen-
907 Elhyi acetate
conditions; however, with this caveat,
799 Ethand
dent on temperdture. I'urthennore, the Table I11 provides guidelines for VOC
870 Ethyibenzeoe composition of thc products of com- destruction efficiency as a function of
965 Ethyl chioride bustion generally fall wilhin n fairly temperature and residence time. This
775 Ethylene dichloride narrow range. Thus. the density and table assumes that at least 3.0% oxy-
775 Elhylene glycol viscosity vary within a very rimow gen concentration is present in the
1,076 Hydrogen
1,000 Hydrogen cyanide range for a given temperature. products of combustion, and that suf-
500 Hydrogen sulfide Not intuitively obvious is the re- ficient turbulence, as defined above, is
490 Kerosene quirement for high-r velocities at present.
890 Maieic anhydride higher temperatures. This occurs he-
999 Methane
878 Melhanoi
cause the gas density decrenses and
980 Methyl ethyl ketone viscosity increases ;it higher tempera- Halogenated Compounds
1,224 Methylene chionde tures. As a rule of tilumh, maintaining Thermal oxidation of compounds
475 Mineral spirits gas velocities above 25 ftlaec will en- containing hnlogens requires special
475 Petroleum naphtha sure adequate turbulence under all con- considerations. In general, these c o n -
924 Nitrobenzene pounds are among the most difficult to
1,084 Phthalic anhydride ditions.
874 Propane destroy. Examples are chlorinated sol-
940 Propylene vents (e.g., methylene chloride, chlo-
915 Styrene
Oxygen Concenrration robenzene, dichloromethane, trichloro-
932 Trichloroethane The concentration of oxygen mole- ethane). This difficulty in destruction
997 Toluene cules is another important component is reflected in their high AITs.
488 Turpentine of thermal oxidation reactions. These
800 Vinyl Acetate There are additional consideratio!ls
are generally supplied by the addition when destroying halogenated c.)m-
924 Xylene
of combustion air or, in the case of a pounds. One is acid gas emissions. For
VOC-contaminated air stream, may be example, with chlorinated compounds,
(PCBs), requires a temperature of present as part of the waste stream the chlorine atoms in the original VOC
2,192-F (1,200'C) with a 2-second gas itself. To ensure that VOC molecules are converted to a mixture of primarily
residence time. come in contact with oxygen mole- hydrogen chloride gas (HCl) plus a
cules, excess oxygen is supplied to the small amount of chlorine gas (CIJ.
Turbulence system. Spically, this excess oxygen Environmental regulations limit
Complete mixing of oxygen and is established hq maintaining an oxy- chlorine (HCI or CIJ emissions to the
VOC molecules is required for the gen concentnation in the products of atmosphere. These compounds cari he
chemical oxidation reactions to occur. combustion of at least 3.0%. removed with an acid gas scrubber
This is accomplished by ensuring a downstream of the thermal oxidizer;
high degree of turbulence within the VOC Destruction Efficiency however, hydrogen chloride can be re-
thermal oxidizer. Turbulence is gener- VOC destruction rates =e difficult moved simply by scrubbing with water
ally defined by the gas Reynolds num- to quantify from a purely theoretical while chlorine gas requires a caustic
ber. The Reynolds number is calcu- standpoint. A statistical model has agent such as caustic soda (sodium
lated as follows: been proposed from laboratory stud- hydroxide). By operating the thermal __
i e s 3 This model relates design and op- oxidizer at a higher temperature, the
Re = DVp/p (2) erating parameters with VOC charac- proportion of chlorine gas generated
where D is the inside diameter of the teristics; however, this model was versus hydrogen chloride decreases.
oxidizer, V is the gas velocity, p i s the developed under plug flow conditions, An example is shown on Table IV. By __
gas density, and p is the gas viscosity. which do not exist io red systems. It operating at a high tenipemtiire, the
To ensure complete turbulence, the only applies to destruction efficiencies cost and complexity of ciiustic scrub-
Reynolds number should be greater of 99% or greater. Waste gas stream bing may he avoided.
than 10,000, characteristics can vary over a wide Another consideration with haloge-
A simplification can be made by range. Selection of thermal oxidizer nated compounds is acid gas dewpoint.
recognizing that some of the parame- operating parameters to achieve opti- For example, HCI formed can combine
ters in the Reynolds number equation mum VOC destruction is best left to with water vapor in the products of

METAL FINISHING NOVEMBER 1996 53


Table IV. Chlorine Eauilibrium Concentration versus Temperature thermal l'ixation of nitrogen in the
combustion air. The generally accepted
mechanism of thermal NO, formation
1,600 3,850 12 0 is described by the Zeldovich equilib-
i,OOO 3,843 5.7 rium reactions shown below.
2,000 3,828 3.0
2.200 3.8fO 1.7 Nz+ O* = N O f N" (3)
Example: 4 SCfm 01 methyl chloride in a 1.000 sclm air stream. O2 + N' = NO + 0" (4)
The N* and 0' are produced by the
thermal dissociation of N2 and 0, at
combustion, condense on a cold oxi- Nitrogen Oxides elevated temperatures. Reducing the
dizer inner metal shell, and initiate cor- Nitrogen oxides (NO,) are one ot peak flame temperature is a well estab-
rosion. This can be prevented by oper- six chemical species classified as a lished method of reducing the NO,
ating with a relatively hot shell criteria pollutmt under the National generation rate.
(>30VF). At this temperature, con- Ambient Air Quality Standards Fuel or chemically hound NO, is
densation cannot occur. The hot shell (NAAQS). NO, in combination with generated from nitrogen compounds
temperature is achieved by selecting a VOCs present in the atmosphere can present in the waste gas or auxiliary
less insulating inner refractory mate- combine in the presence of sunlight to fuel. Generally, gaseous fuels, such as
rial, reducing the amount of refractory, form ozone. Ozone has been found to natural gas or propane, are free of ni-
or externally insulating the thermal ox- be damaging to human health in con- trogen compounds; however, a signif-
idizer outer shell. These same consid- centrations as low as 0. I ppmv, icant amount of fuel-bound NO, can
erations should be applied to ducting, NO, are formed to some extent in all be generated from liquid fuels such as
boiler economizer tubes, and stacks if combustion processes. They exist in fuel oils, which can contain as much as
associated with a thermal oxidizer sys- two different chemical forms: nitric 1% of nitrogen by weight. Nitrogen-
tem destroying halogenated com- oxide (NO) and nitrogen dioxide containing constituents of the waste
pounds. Hot surfaces should be (NO,). At normal thermal oxidation gas also produce fuel-bound NO,. For-
shielded for personnel protection. temperatures, the nitric oxide form ty-two of the 189 compounds listed as
prevails; however, when combustion HAPS under Title III of the CAA
offgases containing NO enter the at- amendments contain nitrogen.
mosphere, the NO is converted to NO, Fuel or waste nitrogen compounds are
BY-PRODUCT EMLSSIONS as the gas cools. only partially converted to the equivalent
NO, are formed from one of three amount of NO,. The rate of conversion
Carbon Monoxide sources in a combustion process: ther- is much less than I:l in most cases. The
All combustion processes have the mal NO,, fuel bound NO,, and prompt exact conversion rate is a complex func-
potential to produce undesirable by- NO,. Most NO, emissions from com- tion of stoichiometry, temperature, and
products. Carbon monoxide (CO) is bustion processes are generated from the specific nitrogen compound oxi-
one of these; however, its formation
can be minimized through selection of
proper operating conditions. CO emis-

i
sions. are a very strong function of
temperature and a we&er function of
excess oxygen.
With waste gases that do not already 95
loo
contain CO, CO emissions will be less /
than 0.02 Ib/MM BTU of heat release /
S'
if operating temperatures are greater /
than 1,600"F. The CO emissions in-
crease exponentially below 1,60VF
and can be as high as 0.10 Lb/MM
BTU of heat release at 1,400"F.
Many times, CO is a constituent of
waste gases. It has a relatively high
AIT (1,128'F) and, as such, is more
difficult to destroy than most VOCs. A
plot of temperature versus destruction
efficiency for CO is shown on Figure I ~

assuming at least 3.0% oxygen in the 1400 1450 1500 1550 I600 I650
combustion products. The dramatic af- TEMPERATURE ("F]
fect of operating temperature is evi-
dent. Figure 1. Carbon monoxide destruction versus temperature.

54 METAL FINISHING NOVEMBER 1996


quantified in Figure 3. Increasing the
temperature from 1,600F to 2,400F
doubles the NO, generation rate.
The oxygen concentration in the
GAS flame envelope also affects NO, gen-
eration. At lower oxygen levels, in-
creasing the oxygen concentration in- . ~~~

creases NO,; however, a point is


CONVENTIONAL BURNER reached at which the sensible heat load
of increased excess air mnre than off-
sets the effect of oxygen concentration ~

due to the reduction in peak flame


GAS temperature. The corresponding oxy-
200 400 600 800 1000
AIR PREHEAT TEMPERATURE (g
gen concentration for peak NO, gener-
ation varies with burner type and op-
Figure 2. Effect of air preheat on No, con- LOW NOx BURNER erating conditions. Figure 4 shows a
ventional versus low NO, burner (at 3% generic curve for ambient combustion
oxygen and 1OOF). Figure 5. Conventional versus low NO,
air?
burner.
dized; however, for most compounds Combustion Control Techniques
and conditions, the conversion rate is nificant in fuel-rich flames that inher- There are many methods to reduce
in the range of 20 to 70%. ently produce low NO, levels. Thus, NO, generation in VOC themial oxi-
A lesser known type of NO, forma- prompt NO, is usually a minor contrib- dation systems. The most economical
tion is termed prompt NO,. Here, utor to overall NO, emissions. method of NO, control is the use of
hydrocarbon radicals (CH, CH,, etc.) Thermal oxidizer operating parame- low NO, bumers. Recirculation of
formed from fuel fragmentation react ters can also effect the NO, generation products of combustion back into the
with nitrogen in the combustion air to rate. In many applications, the com- flame envelope is a well-established
form a hydrogen cyanide (HCN) inter- bustion air is preheated through heat method of NO, reduction.
mediate. The HCN then reacts with exchange with the oxidizer products of A low NO, bumer design is com-
oxygen and nitrogen in the combustion combustion. This increases the thermal pared with a conventional bumer de-
air to form nitrogen oxides as shown efficiency of the process and lowers sign in Figure 5. In the low NO,
below. the auxiliary fuel requirements; how- bumer, a baffle arrangement using
CH* -t N, = HCN t N* (5) ever, it also produces a higher flame only four holes provides a space be-
temperature and consequently higher tween the air holes to allow for recir-
HCN + OH* = CN + H,O (6) NO, emissions. The effect of combus- culation of products of combustion
tion iir preheat temperature on NO, back to the primary combustion zone.
CN + 0, = NO + CO (7)
emissions is shown in Figure 2 for both There is also an additional recircula-
The formation of prompt NO, is conventional and low NO, bumers. tion zone in the center of the burner at
proportional to the number of carbon Even with low NO, burners, preheat- the point of gas injection.
atoms present in the fuel and has a ing the combustion air to 1,000Fdou- Another method of NO, reduction is
weak temperature dependence and a bles with NO, generation rate. The air staging. It is usually applied to fuels
short lifetime. Prompt NO, is only sig- effect is much more dramatic with con- or wastes containing nitrogen. With
ventional bumers. this method, the combustion air is split
The oxidizer operating temperature into two streams. The first is mixed
also effects NO, generation. This is with the fuel or high BTU waste in

RELATIVE
THERMAL
NOx

I I I ! ! I
Ibbb 1800 2000 2200 2400 5
COMEUSrOR TEMPERATURE iTJ
% OXYGEN IN PRODUCTS OF COMBUSTION b

Figure 3. Effect of combustor treatment on


No, (at 3% oxygen and 1,600F). Figure 4. Generic curve lor ambient combustion air,

56 METAL FINISHING - NOVEMBER 1996


as high as 99% can be achieved using
this technique.

4I A
-
A schematic of an actual air-staged
thermal oxidation system is shown on
Figure 6 for a waste gas without nitro-
MTURU
Rf:iElNG OXlDlZlNG OFF-GAS gen bearing compounds. Here, the air
QAS
14s.) UIBTWIR)
ZONE TO STACK and waste gas (Absorber Off-Gas) . ~

1642 *F (12 PPM NOx) streams are split such that the upstream
zone of the thermal oxidizer is operat-
ing substoichiometric or reducing. By
combusting the waste gas and auxiliary ~

fuel in an oxygen-deficient atmo-


sphere, thermal NO, formation is min-
imized due to the absence of oxygen.
Figure 6. Schematic of an air-staged thermal oxidation system. The remaining air is then injected
downstream to complete combustion
of the carbon monoxide and hydrogen
WASTELh?UlLlS produced in the reducing zone. The
total heat release of tliis system is 100
MM BTUhr. NO, emissions were 7
and 12 ppmv (at 3% oxygen) for 1,550
and 1,650'F operating temperatures,
respectively.

4
In this case, the organic constituents

-
of the waste gas were propane, propy-
lene, acrylic acid, acetic acid, formal-
R::{ZNG OXlDlZlNG OFF-GAS dehyde, and acrolein. The VOC de-
NAPRIA
P . # MB W R ) ZONE TOSTACK struction efficiency was 99.91% at
2600F 1800 "F 1,550'F and 99.997% at 1,650'E For
this case, CO was also a major constit-
uent of the waste gas at concentrations
near 1.0%.CO destruction efficiencies
Figure 7. Schematic 01 staged-air combustion system with wastes having chemically bound were 92.4% at 1,550"F and 99.96% at
nitrogen. 1,650'F.
Another staged-air system is shown
WASlEWulDs on Figure 7. In this case, the wastes
consist of compounds with chemically
bound nitrogen. These compounds
produce extremely high levels of NO,
if oxidized using a single-stage design:
however, by staging the air entry, a
high-temperature-reducing zone oc-

NMHl
4
(0.6 w BTwlRl
*
R::{ZNG
2600%
OXlDlZlNG
ZONE
1800 O F
- OFF-GAS
TO STACK
curs upstream of the oxidizing zone.
Due to the absence of excess oxygen in
the reducing zone, nitrogen com-
pounds are converted primarily to mo-
lecular nitrogen gas rather than NO,.
Also, CO and hydrogen produced un-
der reducing conditions react with the
small amount of NO, that is formed
Figure 0. Schematic of tueiatage thermal oxidation system. and convert it back to molecular nitro- ~

gen. Again, second-stage air is injected


into the oxidizing zone to combust CO
substoichiometric quantities to pro- conditions for a residence time of 0.5 and hydrogen produced in the reducing
duce a reducing environment. The sec- to 1.0 second converts most of the zone. Based on measured NO, emis- ~

ond is injected downstream to com- nitrogen to molecular nitrogen rather sions, only about 2% (by weight) of
plete combustion. than NO,. To achieve a high level of the chemically bound nitrogen was
Air staging can also be applied to NO, reduction, the reducing zone sto- converted to NO,.
the overall thermal oxidizer design. ichiometty must be controlled in a Fuel staging can also be used to
This is typically done with wastes con- range of 0.5 to 0.8. The resulting tem- minimize NO, formation. In contrast
taining large quantities of nitrogen perature falls in the range of 1,500 to to air staging, the fuel is split into two
compounds. Operating under reducing 2,800'F. Fuel-bound NO, reductions streams. A portion of the fuel is mixed

METAL FINISHING NOVEMBER 1996 57


with all of the combustion air in the to competing technologies, thermal ox- Thermal Stability Ranking of Harard-
primary combustion zone. Because of idation destroys rather than captures ous Organic Compound lncinerability,
the high level of excess air, the peak VOCs. Thus, no additional treatment is Environmental Science and Technology,
flame temperature is lowered, resulting necessary. vol. 24; 1990
in correspondingly lower NO, genera- As with any combustion process, 3. Lee, K.C. et al., Revised Model for the
tion. Secondary fuel is then injected small amounts of undesirable by-prod- Prediction of the Time-Temperature Re-
downstream. A schematic of a fuel ucts can be produced if thermal oxida- quirements for Thermal Destruction of
tion systems are not operated correctly. Dilute Organic Vapors and Its Usage for
staged thermal oxidation system is
Predicting Compound Destructibility,
shown on Figure 8. In this case, a These are primarily oxides of nitrogen Proceedings ofthe 75th Annual Meeting
low-BTU waste gas serves as the sec- and CO: however, by applying proper of the A i r Po/!uiiun Cont~o/.4ssociur~/~~,
ondary fuel. design and operating principles, the New Orleans, June 20-25, 1982
production of these pollutant species 4. Nutcher, P.B. and D.A. Lewandowski,
can be minimized. Maximum Achievable Control Tech-
CONCLUSIONS
nology for NO, Emissions from VOC
By judicious selection of operating References Thermal Oxidation, Proceedings ofthe
parameters, thermal oxidation systems 1. VOC Control: Current Practices and 87th Annual Meeting of rhe Air and
can provide VOC destruction levels to Future Trends, Chemicai Engineering Waste Manu,qemenr Association, Cin-
meet all current and future environ- - , ~Julv
PmPress.
~ ~ 1993
, 1 ~~
cinnati. June 19-24, 1994 MF
mental emission limits. In comparison 2. Dellinger, B. et al,, Development of

The Chemical Analysis of Electroplating Solutions


ly T H Imine 182 pages $65.00
Chapters in this work are divided into groups in accordance with the periodic table of elements. Though the procedures are traditional, theoretical aspects :
included with other i n f o n t i o n . Anyone who studies this book carefully will derive a helpful understanding ofwhat he or she is doing so that unexpected res
can be rnrched out for causer and corrected
Srnd Ordm lo: METAL FINISHING* 660 white PIainr Rd, Tanytoyn, NY10.591-5153
Forf h r mvicc, call (914) 333-2578 or FMyour order lo (914) 333-2570
All book orders must be prepaid NY,NJ, and MA residents add appropriate sales t u . Please include $5.00 shipping and handling for delivery of each
book via UPS to addresses in the US.,$10.00 for each book shipped express to Canada; and $20.00 for each book shipped express to all other countries.

Filter Presses
.5 -.Automatic
200 cu. ft. capacity
hydraulic COSUre or
our cost saving manual closure
.Totally air operated
.Heavy duty steel ConStrmtiOn
+aiypro gasketed or diaphragm
membrane plates
.Comer or center feed
.Standard sizes or custom built
to your specs
:EE&eyded
.Ship ed fully assemblsd
PA approved lreatmen
I
Sludge Dryers. 1- 75 cu. ft. capaCi&
10
systems
.Uses tow cost steam. hot water or electrical heat source
.Stainless steel internal parts
.Reduces sludge volume up to 15%
-Space saving,design allows unit to fit under the filter pres
Clarifiers. 5 - 1000 GPM flow or elsewhere in the plant
.Meets EPA requirement for sludge reduction
.Parallel late design for efiicient solids settling with
remvagle piate racks
Compact size with low height
Cone bottom for sludge storage
.Floculation tank With mixer is standard
.Optional catwalk and ladder avallabie
.Heavy duty epoxy coated steei Construction
.Shipped fuiiy,assembied
.Meets PA discharge limits for industrial Waste Water

Low Prices Fast Delivery Waste Treatment Systems


777 E 82 St .1 - 300 GPM flow
Continuous flow or batch treatment
Cleveland, Ohio 44103 *Skid mounted or component instaiialion
in your plant
.S stems include drawings and EPA paperwo
216-881-7900 Fax: 216-881-8950 . E ~ Acompliance our specialty
~
Circle 085 on reader inlormation card

58 METAL FINISHING m NOVEMBER 1996

You might also like