Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Contents
Why and how? page 5
What does fatigue mean for the ship and safety? page 6
Appendix page 38
In preparing this guidance, Seahealth Denmark took tours aboard Publisher: Seahealth Denmark
numerous ships and interviewed seamen and shipowners on their Responsible Editor: Connie S. Gehrt
experience with watch systems and rest/off-duty time. Text: Bo S. Jacobsen
Eva Thoft, Grontmij Carl Bro a s
We would like to thank:
Cover photo: Jan Richardt (HFV 2009)
m.f. Bergensfjord, Fjord Line Danmark A/S
Other photos: Finn Salomon Nielsen (HFV 2008),
m.f. Mette Mols og m.f. Maren Mols, Mols Linien A/S
Carsten Gydahl-Jensen
m.t. Fiona Swann, UNI-TANKERS A/S
Torkil Adsersen, Danish Maritime Museum.
m.s. Brage R, Rohde Nielsen A/S
Illustrations: Lars-Ole Nejstgaard
Scandlines Danmark A/S
Graphical design: martinsonnedesign
SIMAC Svendborg International Maritime Academy
Printed by: Grefta
A.P. Mller-Mrsk A/S
English version: Michael Stebbing
Seahealth Denmark, 2010, Copenhagen. Thanks to: Jan Ovesen, Scansleep,
All rights reserved, All trademarks acknowledged. Jesper B. Rasmussen, Consultant.
Limited copying permitted subject to acknowledgement of source.
ISBN: 978-87-92084-05-7
4
WHY AND HOW? REST AT SEA
5
REST AT SEA WHAT DOES FATIGUE MEAN FOR THE SHIP AND SAFETY?
of vessels
Since then, hundreds gone
ve
around the world ha instances
m an y
aground and in
a part. In an
fatigue has played Accidents
n
in-depth investigatio 003
-2
at sea between 1994 ine
Mar
carried out by the
ion Branch
Accident Investigat oundings
gr
(MAIB), a third of ficer in need
by an of
were caused
of sleep.
vestigation
The Norwegian in
orwegian
from 2006 by the N showed
ate
Maritime Director fallen
ha d
that officers who
as a resu lt of atch were involved
Accidents at sea if they could asleep on w 88 groundings.
fatigue are pointle
ss in eight out of
dent s number of
have been avoided. W hen acci
te n A nd meanwhile the tigue is
nces are of lating to fa
occur, the conseque xon Valdez accidents re
Ex not falling.
serious. When the on Blight
ro un d in 19 89
went ag 07
er on watch Navigare 04.10.20
Reef, the third offic of sleep.
ck
was suffering of la
6
The rules - in general REST AT SEA
Getting enough sleep depends on the size of the crew and the Maintaining a safe watch on the bridge and engine room.
distribution of working and rest time. So there are also rules for Servicing and maintaining life saving equipment.
crew size and for how much rest crew should have when working Servicing and maintaining damage control, fire-fighting
at sea. and communication equipment.
Safety-related maintenance and cleaning.
Crew size Mooring duties.
The Maritime Authority sets the minimum manning requirement Catering and health issues.
on the basis of a detailed application from the company. This
means that the crew size is set for every individual ship taking into
account the type of ship, its design, equipment, use and routes. In
that way, the size and composition of the crew make it possible to
cover all the operations that are important for the safety of the ship
and those aboard, including:
7
REST AT SEA THE RULES in general
When deciding the crew size the Maritime Authority must con- In the collective agreement, you can see whether variations from the
sider the watch system aboard, shift work, the actual working hours general rule apply to you or your ship. There are also various situations
of individual teams in line with the provisions of working hours when rest hours can be varied for a while. See exceptions from the
legislation and the use of unit manning. The Maritime Authority rule on page 36.
must ensure sufficient duty watches in the crew setting. Sufficient
duty watches mean that the Watch-keeping Order must always One further issue is that on Sundays and public holidays, seamen
be complied with, including bridge, engine room, radio watches, must not be required to do work that can be postponed.
lookouts, etc.
There are extra requirements for young people under 18 which give
But the Maritime Authority does not basically consider the re- them more opportunity for rest.
sources required to deal with commercial or possibly maintenance
duties on the ship which do not directly influence the safety of If you wish to know more, please see Order 515 of
those aboard or the ship; for example administrative duties relating 21/6 2002
to cargo, engine room/deck maintenance, and serving and sales The rules are drawn up by ILO (International Labour Organisa-
to passengers or administration of the ship. This means that the tion), IMO (International Maritime Organization). You can read
company needs to consider whether there are duties which the more about the rules and how they should be interpreted on page 36.
manning can do and still comply to the rules on rest time. If not,
the company should consider shore-based assistance, such as dock The Danish rules are given in Danish Maritime Authority Order
workers for loading and discharging cargo, fixing lashings, providing 515 of 21/6 2002, with subsequent amendments.
the ISPS watch at the ships gangway, repair gangs sailing aboard,
maintenance while docked. Or the crew could be relieved by way
of technical solutions or whether there are administrative duties
aboard that could be made easier by IT solutions or possibly which
could be moved to the shore-based organization. WHERE DOES IT SAY SO?
The company is responsible for ensuring that the rules on rest are
STCW-convention: Section VIII/1
always complied with and it should regularly assess whether the
The STCW-convention (Standards of Training,
crew aboard is actually sufficient to meet the rest time legislations.
This means, that the company always should consider the extra Certification and Watchkeeping) also contains rules
work required for example due to sailing new waters, a new use for on rest time. These rules set the minimum standard for
the ship or that the ship has become older and therefore requires watch-keeping seamen. The convention is amongst oth-
additional routine maintenance and repairs. ers implemented in Danish law by Order 515 of 21/6
2002 on rest time.
Rest hour rules
The general rule for seamen is that there should be ten hours of rest EU Council Directive 1999/63 of 21 June1999
daily and 77 hours of rest in a week. Rest hours should at most be - Working hours Directive
split into two periods of which one period must be at least six hours. The Directive implements the general rule of the ILO
This general rule can be varied but only subject to the minimum Convention on the basis of an agreement with the organisations
standards set in the STCW Convention. This means that rest time on working hours for seafarers made between the European
can be reduced to a minimum of six hours in 24 twice in a week at Community Shipowners Associations (ESCA) and the
most, on condition that total rest time in a week is at least 70 hours. Federation of Transport Workers Union (FST).
On the other days, rest time must be at least ten hours within a 24
hour period, taken from the time when first going on duty in the Order 515 of 21/6 2002
calendar day. The Order implements EU Council Directive in Danish
law. Order 515 of 21/6 2002 was amended by Order 1053
At a diplomatic conference in Manila in June 2010 a revision of the of 28/10 2008. The Order on seafarers rest hours is to be
STCW-convention was passed by IMO. The revised convention found in Danish Shipping Acts 3-A 170.
take effect from 2012.
8
The rules - in general REST AT SEA
Minimum daily hours of rest (as per Order 515 of 21/6 2002)
Hours of work 8 hours 6 hours
Hours of rest 6 hours 4 hours
There shall be rest time of at least ten hours in every working day. A working day is a period of 24 hours starting when a
seaman goes on duty. Rest time can at most be split into two periods, with one period lasting at least six hours and the other
never less than one hour. The time between two periods of rest must not exceed 14 hours.
A minimum rest time of ten hours in 24 is too little if you are working seven days a week, see the figure below.
Minimum weekly hours of rest (as per Order 515 of 21/6 2002)
Hours of work 91 hours
Hours of rest 77 hours
9
REST AT SEA Case
SE
CA
A rating, John, is standing on a hatch. It is just past noon and He shakes his head. The dockers have positioned them
the sun is beating down on his arms and shoulders. He can wrongly. If only the mate could just check up on the dockers.
taste salt when he licks his lips. It will be nice to get work Then there would be no reason for John here to be walking
finished. He just has to check the last lashings after leaving around.
port. Then he can go in and have a nice cool shower and get
into his bunk. He looks over his shoulder up to the bridge. No, they cannot
see him. If he forgets about getting the fall arrest, he can
He was on watch all night because his mate reported sick. quickly fix the lashings and get back to his bunk. He reaches
He is well aware that he is tired and he occasionally makes for the further edge but his foot is jammed. He loses his
some small stupid mistakes. A moment ago, he nearly balance. The blue colour of the deck rushes up towards him.
tripped over a lashing on the hatch. John gets to the last
lashings placed on the side of the ship. He curls up to save himself - but too late.
10
CASE HVILETID TIL SS
11
REST AT SEA What does fatigue mean for health and performance at work?
A study of more than a million people over six years showed The need for sleep thus builds up during the course of the days
that people who sleep about 7 hours had the lowest mortality activities. And it falls again while we sleep. You sleep according to
rates and those getting less than 4 hours had the highest the need you have built up and then wake up well rested. But if
mortality. The study also showed that you can have too you get less sleep, you feel tired and insufficiently rested.
much sleep. Those getting more than nine hours of sleep
a day had increased mortality. When we sleep, we are unconscious but can be woken up again.
M.D. Daniel F. Kripke,, How easily we wake up, depends on the stage of sleep we are in.
University of California, San Diego, www.uscd.edu
12
Case REST AT SEA
CA
S E
It was close to 01:00 hours and Michael had been Michael checked his watch. He could hardly be
relieved by the deck watch around midnight. He had bothered to go to bed. He would not actually have had a
been on duty for the past six hours. Then he went up to proper sleep when they came and woke him in an hour.
the bridge just to check that the charts were in order and He would just be feeling totally shattered. He could just
that the route was ready on the GPS. He had worked as well sit and watch a film.
on the route during the afternoon and he just wanted
to make sure that everything was alright. They had to After the bridge was all clear, he went out on deck for
depart in a couple of hours and he didnt want to have to departure at 03:00. He could actually feel that he had
think about it when getting up to get things ready on the not had any sleep, other than a couple of hours around
bridge. noon the previous day. But he pulled himself together.
If the others can, so can I, he thought.
13
REST AT SEA What does fatigue mean for health and performance at work?
If you are allowed to sleep undisturbed, you slide into deep sleep, In the first part of a period of sleep, there is very deep sleep in
stage 3 and 4. Here it is very difficult to wake you. If you are woken, every cycle. During the course of a period of sleep, the proportion
getting back to full consciousness is not so easy as from stage 2. of deep sleep in an individual sleep cycle diminishes. In the last
Your brain would prefer to go back to sleep again and does not part of a period of sleep, you are mainly in light sleep - stage 1, stage
function as when you are really alert. This means that if you have 2 and REM.
to deal with problems in this condition, there is an increased risk
of making a wrong decision. If trying to sleep after being awake for longer than normal, for
example when approaching or leaving port or in major maintenance
On the other hand, if you are allowed to sleep undisturbed in deep jobs, you will find that you quickly glide into deep sleep. There will
sleep, it disappears after about 30-40 minutes. You glide up to also be more deep sleep in the individual sleep cycles. This means
stage 2 again and possibly stage 1 and enter dream sleep (REM - that you are catching up on lost sleep by sleeping more heavily.
Rapid Eye Movements). In this stage, the eyes move rapidly So you do not need to replace lost sleep hour for hour.
A sleep cycle with the stages of sleep. A sleep cycles takes about 1 hours.
Awake
REM
5-30 mins REM dreams
Stage 2: 15-40 mins relatively easy to wake Stage 2: 15-40 mins relatively easy to wake
Stage 3 and 4: 30-40 mins difficult to wake Stage 3 and 4: 30-40 mins difficult to wake
14
What does fatigue mean for health and performance at work? REST AT SEA
24 hour day and night rhythm Especially if you already are in lack of sleep. And if you have to sit
The longer we are awake, the harder it is to stay awake, especially still, monitor things and keep a lookout in the dark, it becomes even
if we do not stay physically active. It is especially difficult to stay more difficult to stay awake.
awake at night. We do in fact have an inner clock at the centre of
our brains which is very regular. It operates to its own rhythm and Many of us have tried nodding off, with the head falling forward
sends signals that we should be active during daylight hours and and the eyes closing. You fall asleep but perhaps wake up imme-
quiet and relaxed during the dark part of the day. And this contin- diately as the head falls forward. You have then had a micro sleep
ues even though we try to turn the day around. event. But in the worst case, people do not wake up as the head
falls forward. They continue to sleep until woken by an alarm
For example, it generally takes a whole week to change your daily or someone else. This involves falling properly asleep. And not
rhythm if flying to USA or China. When you arrive, your body watching the signals that they are meant to be keeping an eye
clock does not correspond to the rhythm that people in USA or on. And even if you are just sleepy, reaction times can be longer,
China have. They are either several hours ahead or behind. It meaning that you do not react in time and in some situations this
takes a good week before the body and inner clock adjust to the can have catastrophic consequences.
new time.
When you are finally relieved and can go to your bunk, it can
Our inner clock controls our body temperature and hormones, be difficult to fall asleep despite having a large lack of sleep. It is
including cortisol and melatonin. The concentrations of both because your daily rhythm has signalled your body and brain that
hormones in the blood depend on the time of day. High cortisol it should be alert and active. If you are lucky enough to fall asleep,
levels provide for more stimulus and activity. High melatonin levels you risk waking up again easily. Partly because your body clock is
make us slow down and feel sleepy. During the day, body tempera- signalling activity and partly because it is day with noise and light
ture and cortisol level is high and melatonin level is low. And vice that can disturb you. Most people find it gets better after a few
versa at night. Then the body temperature and cortisol level fall nights. The inner clock begins to adapt to a new daily rhythm and
and the level of melatonin rises. Sunlight is the strongest factor that after 5 - 6 days, most people find they have adapted to the new
controls our inner clock. It degrades melatonin. Which is why spe- rhythm. Even so, very few who work at night get the same amount
cial full spectrum daylight lamps in control rooms or deck offices, of sleep. It is more difficult to get good sleep during the day than at
for example, help make people feel less sleepy. Other factors are night. So periods of working at night often mean constant lack of
physical activity and meals. Sometimes we can help make the clock sleep.
adjust to a new daily rhythm by adjusting these factors.
The longer you spend with the same hours of work and the fewer
Consequences of daily rhythm changes changes, the fewer problems it gives. Ideally, half the crew should
Working at night means working at a time when the brain is ready only work and be busy at night and sleep during the day while the
for sleep, until it has adapted to a new daily rhythm. This means other half sleeps at night and works during the day.
that you think a little slower and reaction times can be a little longer.
The risk of making mistakes follows the inner clock. If you switch Unfortunately this is seldom possible. Every time you change,
from a normal daily rhythm of sleeping at night and being awake in you get out of your rhythm and it takes several days to get back to
the day, you can manage reasonably well for the first hours of the normal.
night. But between 03.00 - 05.00 hours, reaction times are longer
and the ability to concentrate has declined. It becomes very dif-
ficult to keep your eyes open. This means that there is a great risk
of mistakes and accidents.
15
REST AT SEA Case
ES
CA
It has just gone 04.30 hours and it is still dark outside. He sits still in his chair. It gets more difficult to focus on the
The mate has just poured yet another cup of coffee to stay radar screen and the picture becomes fuzzy and monotonous.
awake. He has been on watch since midnight and there are His thoughts slide slowly to his forthcoming holiday and
still some hours before he is relieved. It will be good to get things to do when he gets home. They could take a holiday
to his bunk after the last few days of hard work in port. cottage. He can see the children in front of him - they are on
a swing. He wakes up with a shock through his whole body.
He quickly calculates: 6-8 hours of sleep a day but split The alarm has gone off..
into bits meaning he has only had 3 - 5 uninterrupted hours
of sleep at a time. But that was what he had to do to get
everything to work out.
16
Watch systems and fatigue REST AT SEA
The watch system provides the framework for how much rest indi- Also be aware that there can be other issues that mean you do not
vidual seamen can get. At sea, there are two special watch systems: get sufficient sleep. These might be changes in duty hours which
a 2-shift watch where there are two watches to share the working could affect your daily rhythm, or working at night and noise which
hours of the day and a 3-shift watch where there are three watches means that you sleep badly.
to share the day. It is the company that makes the final decision
about crew size based on the minimum manning laid down by the 2-shift watches
Maritime Authority and thus also which watch system is used On a 2-shift watch, you work on principle 12 hours on and 12 hours
aboard. off. This does not give any immediate problems with the rest time
regulations, over a day or a week. But this system means slightly
By focusing on watch schedules, duties and how they are distributed, greater challenges, for example if you opt for the common 6:6 watch
it is possible to try and create better opportunities for the crew to system. This makes it difficult to get much more than five hours of
get sufficient sleep. sleep at a time even if you go directly to your cabin when you go
off-duty. First, it takes time to get to your cabin and then it takes a little
3-shift watches time to calm down so that you can fall asleep.
On a 3-shift watch, you get about eight hours on watch and the
possibility of 16 hours off-duty in a day if you do not overlap others A Swedish survey confirmed that seamen on 3-shift watches were
shifts. This basically means that there should be no problem in more rested then seamen on 2-shift watches.
complying with the rest time legislation either in a day or a week.
But there can be situations when it might be necessary to work The survey (VTI-report) is entitled Fatigue at Sea - A field study in
overtime and then it is important to keep an eye on compliance Swedish shipping.
with the rest time regulations.
17
REST AT SEA Watch systems and fatigue
There are other watch systems than the 6:6 model, for example the Then the person relieving you has to get up at 04.00 and 05.00
8:4 system. It provides better conditions for getting enough sleep in the morning. You should also avoid people being woken in the
because one period of rest is long enough. On the other hand, the first hours after they have fallen asleep. This is when they get most
system has some other disadvantages. Even so, it is a good idea to of their deepest sleep. So if you are woken in this period it reduces
check whether other watch systems might fit better with the ship the quality of your sleep. Note that if you wake somebody in a deep
and the duties involved. sleep phase, they will find it difficult to wake up and their ability to
concentrate and reactions will be very poor.
When setting up a watch system, there is many things to be taken
into consideration, such as duties, docking and meal times. The If for various reasons it is necessary to place a shift in this critical
schedule below gives an assessment of the various systems for time, it is important to ensure that crew are as rested as possible
2-shift watches. The time when watches change is important. If before the watch starts.
you are in a natural day rhythm, you are very tired at night and
especially at the end of the night, that is between 03.00 - 05.00. On page 20 there are some examples of watch planning. When
This means that it is not good to have to get up and stand watch at deciding on watch systems, you need to consider the duration of
these times. This is a problem for the 4-4-8-8 and 5-5-7-7 systems if periods of rest and the time when the watch changes.
the watch schedule starts at 00.00 hrs.
18
Case REST AT SEA
CA
S
E
Engineer Sergey has just finished his evening rounds and is In the morning he is sitting groggily eating his breakfast.
ready to head for bed. He is on-call but just hopes that there The First Engineer comes and sits at his table: Morning
are no alarms during the night because he is tired. Sergey, all bright and fit - ready for boiler maintenance?
19
REST AT SEA Watch systems and fatigue
Advantages: Disadvantages:
- Both offer the option of sufficiently long periods of sleep - Only one sleeps at night
- Watches fit with mealtimes
- The person on night duty has a long rest before going on watch
Below we show how planning might be for a ship if 7-5-5-7 was introduced.
Remember that this is only an example; you need to adapt your watch system so that the planning fit your ship.
Advantages: Disadvantages:
- All can get long enough sleep. Two get a good nights sleep, - nil
someone has to stand watch at night but there is a lengthy
period with the opportunity for rest.
- Shifts match mealtimes
20
CASE REST AT SEA
CA
S
E
Peter sat down for dinner in the mess after he had managed First a whole working day, he still had to do the last
a bath and done his rounds. He had been doing scheduled evening round and then arriving at night and when would
maintenance all day and he was getting tired. But they they be finished with the exhaust valve? Probably some-
would be docking during the night and after arrival, they time tomorrow morning. Why on earth couldnt they
had to get ready to overhaul the exhaust valve on the have planned things so that he could have slept until they
main engine. Just the thought of it almost made him feel arrived?
exhausted.
21
REST AT SEA Choice of watch system and planning
Unforeseen factors:
Accident aboard or breakdown Plan so that you are rested when changing from a 3-shift
Weather watch to a 2-shift watch where there is less chance to sleep.
Delays
Plan watch changes to coincide with arrivals. Then more
It is of course the company that sets the overall planning frame- resources are available at a time when they are needed.
work for the ship. So the company should start by discussing the
options first. What policies and guidelines should apply for watch Focusing on the abilities and qualifications of the crew
planning? When these have been fixed, specific decisions about instead of rank and title will get more pieces of the planning
planning can be made aboard individual vessels. puzzle to fall into place. Why is it always the mate who
checks the fire-fighting equipment? Could the galley mate
be the ISPS watch? Could the duty officer take care of
officials rather than the captain?
22
Choice of watch system and planning REST AT SEA
23
REST AT SEA Choice of watch system and planning
24
Choice of watch system and planning REST AT SEA
Keep a sharp eye on how you use your resources When you have left port, consider whether your planning was in
Will somebody exceed their work hours? line with the realities. And use your experience to improve planning
Could someone preferably be switched to other duties? for your next docking.
Are there too few crew members to do a job properly?
Could others with sufficient qualifications do the job? This procedure may not solve all rest hour problems but it can help
Could somebody else who is already up and about do you take into account the many issues that could otherwise conflict
the job so the people off duty are not disturbed? with rest hours.
IN
Contact personnel
Agent
Payments
por
Line handling
Bunkering Bunker watch
Person i/c
Person i/c
Prvisioning Duty crew
OUT
Person i/c
Maintenance
Duty crew
Pilot ladder Crew, fore and aft
Pilot Manual steering Departure Gangway
Look out Anchor standby
25
REST AT SEA Choice of watch system and planning
Sample watch schedule This naturally means he has to be off-duty during the day since
At page 27 you can see an example of a completed watch schedule. he will have to work again later that evening.
Duties have been inserted in the upper part of the schedule. The guidance includes a blank schedule template that you
A line has been drawn through 16.00 hrs since that is when we can copy and use. You could also use a normal squared pad.
arrive. In the example we therefore plan the change of watch to Finally, you can find an Excel file on the enclosed CD.
happen at the arrival time, as described on page 27.
Figure page 27: Blue is working hours. Light blue is crew members
At the bottom of the schedule, crew have been assigned to duties. on stand by.
There has been a check on whether the plan complies with the
rest hour regulations and whether it will work aboard. More people
have been involved so as to solve the puzzle - here for example we
have used the motorman for arrival.
26
Choice of watch system and planning REST AT SEA
PORT: Bergen + PILOT 14:30 ETA: 16:00 ETD: 09:00 - PILOT 10:30
DUTIES 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 00 01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 10 11
Pilotage
Pilot ladder
Look out
Manual steering
Arrival
Crew, fore and aft
Gangway
Lashings
Duty teams
Loading/discharging
ISPS
Cargo planning
Agent
Contact personnel
Payments
Officials
Contact personnel
Person i/c
Bunkering
Lines handling
Bunker watch
Officer i/c
Provisioning
Contact personnel
Maintenance
Person i/c
Duty crew
Departure
Crew, fore and aft
Gangway
Anchor standby
Pilot
Pilot ladder
Look out
Manual steering
CREW 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 00 01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 10 11
CPT
CH OFF
OFF 1
OFF 2
AB 1
AB 2
AB 3
AB4
Cook
Galley Mate
CH Eng
ENG 1
ENG 2
ENG 3
Motorman/oiler
27
REST AT SEA What you can do yourself
28
What you can do yourself REST AT SEA
Switch from night watch to normal daily rhythm Driving after night watches (mostly for ferry crews)
When you get home, avoid sleeping during the day or in any case, After a night watch, there is always the risk of your reaction times
sleep as short a time as possible and as early in the day as possible. being slower. If you are going to drive home after work, there could
Get out in the sunshine. After several days of night duty, your brain be a risk that you will fall asleep due to the monotony in driving.
will secrete melatonin during the day. This will make you sleepy The most effective way of reducing this risk is by sleeping. That
but the effect is reduced by sunlight because it degrades melatonin. means sleeping before you drive or if you feel tired while driving,
If you can avoid sleeping, you will build up a need for sleep which pull over to the side and have a nap.
will make it easier to fall asleep at normal bedtime.
Avoid jet-lag
If you feel really sleepy during the day, go for a run or do something Try as early as possible to live by the local time where you are
else physical to get the body up to speed again. But remember to going. This means trying to sleep at the same time as people at the
stop 3 - 4 hours before going to sleep. Try not to sleep late the next destination you are heading to. By reducing your sleep when travel-
morning even though it is a day off. Get up at the normal time to ling, you can make your need for sleep greater than normal at the
re-establish your normal daily rhythm. time you will be going to bed at your destination. This will make it
easier to fall asleep even though the time does not fit in with your
If you cannot fall asleep when you go to bed at night, then do not body clock.
stay in bed. Get up and wait until you feel sleepy and try again.
It is not unusual to sleep badly the first night after a period of night
duty but after two-three nights most people find their daily rhythm
is re-established.
Staying awake
on night watch
If you have to work in the dark
and with the lack of activity, such
as when working on the bridge, it
is especially difficult to stay alert.
Try the following:
Take a little physical exercise,
for example running on the
spot. This boosts the body and
gets the brain going too.
Eat some fruit /carrots, as the
taste stimulates an area in the
brain and chewing stimulates
another area.
Drink a single cup of
coffee or tea - it freshens
and stimulates you.
29
REST AT SEA What you can do yourself
The company should plan the start of tours and travel so that if If you suspect that you are suffering some of these things, and it is
possible you can start your duties well rested. affecting your sleep, you should get in touch with Radio Medical or
your own physician when you are home.
Reduce sleepiness from your body clock by getting out into the
sunshine. This reduces the effect of melatonin which the body There is sleeping medication in the A and B medical chest but
produces at night. it has to be prescribed by Radio Medical. And if you take some
sleeping pills with you that have been prescribed by your physi-
Some sleep problems do not come from working at night or changing cian, they must be registered on the checklist under Other and
watches. These may be due to a range of conditions such as snoring new medication.
or sleep apnoea which gives a feeling of suffocation during sleep
and discomfort in the legs and arms.
30
Cabin & bunk REST AT SEA
The requirements for accomodation areas are stated in the Danish Preconditions
Maritime Authority Notice B, chapter II-3, paragraph 11, rule 5. for good sleep
32
WHO DOES WHAT? REST AT SEA
The various players on and about the ship can contribute in various Company management should also consider the type of watch system
ways to a watch schedule that ensures the crew get sufficient rest. if seamen on call for unattended engine rooms are often woken by
alarms. This means they fail to comply with the hours of rest regulations
Company management because they do not get at least six hours of uninterrupted rest. If
It is the company that is responsible for managing the route plan. there are more permanent issues, company management should
And it is they who set the overall framework for planning hours consider having an engine room watch on duty instead.
of work and rest. Company management here need to consider
whether work aboard involves extra duties which would require a Lack of skills can mean senior crew being disturbed too often while
larger crew on the ship. off-duty because the crew feel they have to consult them when they
are in doubt.
Company management should recognize the experience of the
ship in route planning, Small changes could make it easier to do Company management cannot plan for such issues unless they are
reasonable planning aboard. A larger crew may be needed if work- aware of them. So they should ensure that there is transparency on
ing hours are frequently exceeded due to issues that cannot be the hours of rest and non-compliance and ensure that they gather
resolved immediately. experience from their ships. Company management could also offer
sparring and experience exchange sessions so that ships manage-
ments and crews can learn from each others experience of planning.
33
REST AT SEA Who does what?
The Master is also responsible for registering hours of rest and it is You can contribute your experience and be prepared to do things
important to ensure that this is done properly. Registration is actually differently than you usually do. With respect to rest hour registration,
necessary for being able to assess whether the watch system you you are also responsible for proper registration so that ship and
have complies with the rules and provides for proper rest. And company management can see how well the watch system is working.
finally, the Master is responsible for ensuring that crew who work
overtime in excess of the rest period get time off in compensation.
34
DISCUSS THINGS ABOARD REST AT SEA
Making changes aboard means you need to get the other crew Agreement aboard
members to agree to your ideas. Previous experience has shown When ships management has decided that there have to be
that understanding why changes are required and the feeling of changes, the remainder of the crew must be involved. This can
having been involved in a decision are significant for crew involvement be done in line with the above.
in new activities. Something so vital as changes to the watch system
and working hours must naturally be generally accepted. If these To ensure that the meeting focuses on the changes you want to
are not accepted, and if people feel they have not been involved, make and to help you get as broad a backing aboard as possible,
human resistance to change will ruin any initiative. Ships manage- it is important to consider the following tips for holding meetings:
ment should therefore agree on making changes and especially why.
Ensure that agenda items have been prepared and that the
The extent of changes must be broadly agreed with the involve- people involved know who is to prepare which items
ment of the entire crew. This could be done for example by calling Introduce the meeting with a contract, which is an explanation
an extraordinary safety committee meeting with everybody invited. of what the meeting is intended to achieve, how much time is
This procedure will create the best basis for getting your message available and any priority for agenda items.
accepted. Keep an eye on the time
Restrict discussions to agenda items
Ships management - agreement Ensure that all points of view are heard
When you call a meeting and wish to make changes that impact Ensure that decisions are made
on other peoples daily routines - and your own - it is important that End the meeting with a summary of what has been achieved
you yourself can say why these changes are important and that you and who is to do what and when
can argue for them. You should therefore consider the following: Follow up on decisions made at the meeting
What are you trying to achieve from the meeting?
What will be discussed /decided at the meeting? You can find further material and tips for holding meetings on page
What information will the others present need to be able 72 of our Seahealth publication, A Good Working Life at Sea.
to make a decision?
You should first issue an invitation to the meeting and give the other
participants at least two days notice of the meeting. This gives them
the opportunity to think about their own approach and to come up
with arguments for them.
35
REST AT SEA The rules - more details
IMO initially issued a resolution defining what rest meant and the Deviation from the agreement - s. 5
factors leading to a lack of rest. ILO drew up a proposal for the It is possible for watch-keeping seamen or those working on ships
general rule we now know: 10 hours of daily rest and 77 hours of on short voyages, taking into account more frequent or longer
rest a week. This general rule was included in regulation VIII/1 of periods of leave or being granted compensatory free days off, to
the STCW Convention which sets minimum standards for watch- deviate from the provisions on hours of rest in s. 4 (2 - 3), provided
keeping seamen. The STCW Convention also stipulated that that due account is taken of the health and safety of the seamen.
daily hours of rest hours could be reduced to a minimum of 6 hours
in 24 at most twice a week provided that the individual seaman It is possible to arrange for deviation from the rules of collective
received a minimum of 70 hours of rest a week. agreements. Agreements must be approved by the Danish Maritime
Authority which currently has registered about 60 deviation agree-
In 2002, ILOs work and rest hour convention entered into force. ments from collective agreements.
This meant that the general rule of ten hours of rest, etc., took
effect but at the same time it introduced the possibility of arranging Deviations on Danish ships are generally those involving compliance
exemptions from the general rule by way of collective agreements, with parts of the STCW Convention instead of the ILO Convention.
although subject to the minimum rules of the STCW Convention. As noted above, the requirements for rest are less demanding.
At a diplomatic conference in Manila in June 2010 a revision of You may find deviation from the Hours of Rest Order in your
the STCW-convention was passed by IMO. The revised conven- agreement. These deviations may be used when secs 6, 8 and 9
tion take effect from 2012. are not applicable. It is not the idea that work should be planned to
benefit from these exemption options but that they can be used in
Exemptions from the general rules situations when there is the need for flexibility.
There are various provisions in the Danish Order 515 of 21/6 2002
that modify the general rule. You can read how this should be On-call watch - s. 6
interpreted here: Seamen on call must have a compensatory period of rest if their
normal period of rest is interrupted as a result of work. An on-call
Registration of hours of rest by the Master - s. 2 (2) watch is therefore not rest time if you are called in during the watch.
Section 4 (1- 4 & 6), s. 5(1), s. 9, s. 10 and s. 11 (1 & 4) apply to It is not a requirement for compensation to be granted for all the lost
masters who stand regular bridge watches on merchant ships. hours of rest on a 1:1 basis. The results of being called in may also be
Section 4(1) applies regardless of whether the master stands a that rest time is split into more than two periods. It is up to the Master
bridge watch. Masters who stand a bridge watch are subject to a to decide what compensation is required. When registering your
range of regulations on rest hours, including registration of hours hours of rest, record the actual hours of rest and in the comments box,
of work and rest. On the other hand, if they do not stand a bridge note that there has been a s. 6 deviation.
watch, they are not required to register hours of work and rest.
36
The rules - more details REST AT SEA
Drills - s. 8
Mustering, fire-fighting and lifeboats drills and other mandatory Safety means situations or duties which could lead to an accident
drills should be held so they interrupt hours of rest as little as if they were not dealt with. This does not cover situations or work
possible and do not lead to fatigue. that have been planned.
This means that even though you attend a muster, fire or evacua- Crew are to be given appropriate time for rest as soon as possible
tion drill after you go off duty, you will not have interrupted your after conditions have returned to normal. When entering hours of
rest. Unless you are ordered to take part in clearing up after the rest, record the actual hours of rest and in the comments box, note
drill. So it is important for ships management to ensure that it is that there has been a s. 9 deviation.
not always the same person who has to participate in drills when
off-duty.
When you register your hours of rest, you should state the time you
spend on these drills as rest time if you are off-duty then.
WHERE DOES IT SAY SO?
Ship safety s. 9
The Master can require seamen to work when required for the STCW-convention: Section VIII/1
immediate safety of the ship, those aboard or its cargo or to assist The STCW-convention (Standards of Training,
other ships or persons in distress at sea. Certification and Watchkeeping) also contains rules
on rest time. These rules set the minimum standard
In special circumstances, the Master can set aside the rest time
for watch-keeping seamen. The convention is amongst
regulations at a critical period. The reason must be that it is
required by the immediate safety of the ship, persons or cargo, or others implemented in Danish law by Order 515 of
if the ship is to provide assistance to other ships or persons in need. 21/6 2002 on rest time.
37
REST AT SEA ENCLOSURE
The following national laws, regulations and/or collective agreements governing limitations on minimum rest periods
apply to this ship:
Mned:
Month:
Dag Hvileperioder (fra-til) Hviletid i alt Kommentarer
Day Periods of rest (from-to) Hours of rest totally Comments
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
38