Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Contact us
617-314-7685
800-646-3575 (toll-free)
www.wallstreetprep.com
The tutorial and enclosed models are proprietary to Wall Street Prep and are designed
for illustrative and training purposes only. Distributing, sharing, copying, duplicating or
altering these models in any way is prohibited without the expressed, written permission
of Wall Street Prep, Inc. The Self Study Program is designed for illustrative purposes only
and does not, in any way, constitute any investment thesis or recommendation.
Copyright
Wall Street Prep, Inc. All rights reserved. "Wall Street Prep", "Wall Street Prep", and
various marks are trademarks of Wall Street Prep, Inc.
Cash flow /
Year Cash flow (1+r)t
2007 10,500.0 9,545.5
2008 11,025.0 9,111.6
2009 11,576.3 8,697.4
2010 12,155.1 8,302.1
2011 12,762.8 7,924.7
Sum: 43,581.21
Using the growth in perpetuity formula, we can arrive at a value for the hot dog
stand as illustrated:
DCF in practice
$ in millions
250.0
synergies separately from the 200.0
business 150.0
72.5 79.7 87.7
100.0 54.5 59.9 65.9
45.0 49.5
DCF Disadvantages 50.0
0.0
Present values obtained are sensitive 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012
to assumptions and methodology Years
Terminal value represents a significant portion of value and is highly sensitive to valuation
assumptions
Need realistic projected financial statements over at least one business cycle (7 to 10
years) or until cash flows are normalized
Sales growth rate, margin, investment in working capital, capital expenditures, and terminal
value assumptions along with discount rate assumptions are key to the valuation
An investment property should theoretically equal the present value rental income is
of its rental income (minus required maintenance). In the same unlevered, rental
way, the enterprise value of a firm equals the present value of its income minus
FCF, where the appropriate FCF are before the effect of leverage mortgage is
(meaning FCF has not been adjusted down for interest or principal levered
payments). Such cash flows are called unlevered FCF.
Isnt rental income the same regardless of how the rental property was financed? Isnt it fair
to say that the leverage does not affect the expectation of future rental income? Similarly,
debt-related payments such as interest expense and principal are ignored (i.e. we pretend
there is no debt, or resulting interest expense and tax shield) when calculating FCF used to
determine the enterprise value.
Of course, when discounting the unlevered FCF back to the present, they must be
discounted at a rate commensurate with the riskiness of the cash flows which is
absolutely a function of leverage. In other words, even though the expectation of rental
income is unaffected by leverage, the discount rate applied to determine the present value
of expected rental income is indeed a function of the capital structure and expected returns
of the providers of capital.
Indeed, unlevered FCF should be discounted using the weighted average cost of capital
(WACC), reflecting the costs of debt and equity weighted by their respective proportions of
the total capital invested in the enterprise.
If I project future rental income of an investment property and discount it to the present
using the WACC, the value obtained will be the total value of the property, or enterprise
value. I can subtract all non-equity claims from this value to arrive at my equity value. This
approach at arriving at equity value is called the unlevered DCF approach because
unlevered FCF are projected and discounted.
Alternatively, If I project future rental income minus interest and principal (i.e. mortgage)
and discount it to the present at the cost of equity, I will directly arrive at my equity value.
This approach is called the levered DCF approach because the projected cash flows are
levered. In other words, interest expense, the interest tax shield, and principal payments
are explicitly projected in the calculation of cash flows, which represent cash flows only to
equity holders, and the discount rate reflects the cost of capital only to equity holders.
Both approaches should theoretically yield the same equity value. In line with
The unlevered DCF approach is the predominant approach for standard practice,
valuing most businesses because it is easier to implement1 (with the we will focus on
exception of the valuation of financial institutions, for which levered unlevered DCF in
DCF is preferred). this module
Footnote 1
For the DCF analysis to be usable, we must assume a relatively stable capital structure for the life of the
business. When using the levered DCF approach and explicitly projecting interest expense and principal
payments in a way that maintains a stable debt/equity ratio, we would have to explicitly recalibrate
debt/equity weights each year, possibly along with the costs of debt and equity themselves. This is far more
difficult to implement than the unlevered DCF approach.
Licensed to Sheikh Sadik. Email address: shehab91@outlook.com
14
For illustrative Purposes Only
Unlevered vs. levered DCF
The process of DCF analysis
Sensitivity analysis
DCF valuation is based on assumptions assumptions for future free cash flows, for
the terminal value, and for the discount rate
Therefore, DCF values should be represented in ranges
Key assumptions to sensitize:
Discount rate
Sales growth
EBITDA margin
WACC
Exit multiple
Perpetuity growth rate Licensed to Sheikh Sadik. Email address: shehab91@outlook.com
18
For illustrative Purposes Only
Table of contents
SECTION 1: OVERVIEW
DCF in theory and in practice
Unlevered vs. levered DCF
Before proceeding, make sure you have downloaded the following files:
1. Colgates 10-K for fiscal year ending December 31, 2006.
2. The DCF model
DCF model includes a tab with a completed financial statement model from the
financial statement modeling module.
The DCF model also includes a completed DCF analysis, as well as a blank DCF
template. We will be working together through the empty template, building the
model step-by-step.
If at any point you run into questions, review the completed DCF tab for guidance.
About the tax deductibility of interest expensedoesnt that provide real tax benefits?
Very true. We ignore this for now, but will factor it into the discount rate, by adjusting the
companys cost of debt by the tax shield. More on this later.
Calculation
= days post-deal date / 365
Input WACC of 10% for now
Calculate EBIAT
Also called NOPAT (Net operating profit after taxes)
Reference D&A and working capital inflows/outflows from core model as illustrated
Reference capital expenditures from the core models cash flow statement. Include any other
required investments when applicable (acquisitions of intangible assets, etc.)
Present value of cash flow stream: The present value calculation takes into
account the cost of capital by placing greater value on those cash flows generated
earlier in the projection period versus later cash flows1.
Calculate PV of FCFs
We have calculated the present value of unlevered FCF for CL through 2015
Clearly the firm is expected to generate cash flows beyond this period, but we cannot
project free cash flows on an annual basis indefinitely with any degree of accuracy
As a result, we make simplifying assumptions at the end of the explicit projection
period in order to calculate terminal value using a perpetuity formula namely, we
assume that after the explicit forecast period, the firm slows down into mature,
normalized, and sustainable EBIAT, growth rates, and WACC
The terminal value represents value of a business at the end of the projection period
Accounts for all the cash flows to be generated beyond the projection period
Assumes that the business is held in perpetuity and that the free cash flows
continue to grow at an assumed perpetual rate
The terminal value often represents a significant portion of the total enterprise value
derived in a DCF model
As a result, the assumptions used to arrive at the terminal value are extremely
important
2 popular methods in practice
There are two common approaches to estimating the terminal value in practice:
Growth in perpetuity method
Exit multiple method Licensed to Sheikh Sadik. Email address: shehab91@outlook.com
41
For illustrative Purposes Only
Terminal value using growth in perpetuity approach
Terminal value growth in perpetuity method
Assumes that the business will grow in perpetuity after the explicit forecast period at a
constant, long-term nominal industry-demand growth rate1 with normalized FCF and
sustainable WACC.
Implementation: The perpetuity growth method takes the free cash flow in the last year
of the projection period and grows it one more year2. This free cash flow is then divided
by the discount rate (WACC) minus the perpetual growth rate:
1 No business can be expected to have cash flows that grow forever above the economy.
Be conservative when estimating growth rates in perpetuity. In practice long-term
nominal GDP growth is an acceptable proxy.
2 Recall that the perpetuity growth formula is based on the principle that the terminal value
of a business is the value of its next cash flow, divided by the difference between the
discount rate and a perpetual growth rate. Licensed to Sheikh Sadik. Email address: shehab91@outlook.com
42
For illustrative Purposes Only
Terminal value using growth in perpetuity approach
Terminal value growth in perpetuity method
Additional considerations
If the estimated terminal year + 1 cash flows do not reflect steady-state
relationships between revenues and EBIAT, working capital, capital expenditures and
depreciation, they may need to be revised.
Commonly, higher-growth companies whose capital expenditures during the explicit
forecast period were very high relative to depreciation and revenue growth will need
to be adjusted when calculating the terminal year + 1 free cash flows to reflect lower
required capital investments to sustain lower growth rates. Remember since we are
projecting macroeconomic terminal growth rates, companies should essentially be
spending just enough to replace older equipment.
Working capital may also need to be adjusted to reflect realistic perpetuity working
capital inflows/outflows.
Discounting the terminal value to the present
Once calculated, the terminal value reflects the value at the end of the explicit
projection period.
In order to calculate its present value, it must be discounted back to the valuation
date using the relevant WACC.
Mid-year adjustment
The mid-year adjustment
also applies to the growth in
perpetuity formula, which
otherwise assumes all future
cash flows are generated at
year-end.
Discounting
Remember that the value
obtained using the perpetuity
formula is for the present value
at the terminal year. This value
must be discounted back to the
valuation date.
Dilutive securities Stock options are issued in stock compensation plans and
Defined as securities that used to pay and motivate employees. This type of security
are not common stock in gives selected employees the option to purchase common
form, but that enable their stock at a given price over an extended period of time.
holders to obtain Warrants are similar to options. They are certificates
common stock upon entitling the holder to acquire shares of stock at a certain
exercise or conversion. price within a stated period. When warrants are exercised,
The most notable the holder must pay a certain amount of money to obtain
examples include stock the shares. Also, when stock warrants are attached to debt,
options, warrants, the debt remains after the warrants are exercised.
convertible bonds, and Convertible bonds company issues bonds which can be
convertible preferred converted into common shares. The conversion feature
stock. For general allows the corporation an opportunity to obtain equity capital
valuation analysis, without giving up more ownership control than necessary
dilution is only assumed and/or entice investors to accept lower interest rates than
from exercisable (vested) they would normally accept on a straight debt issue.
options. For M&A Convertible preferred stock is similar to convertible debt,
analysis, all outstanding except that preferred stock, instead of debt, is originally
options are assumed to issued.
be exercisable. Licensed to Sheikh Sadik. Email address: shehab91@outlook.com
65
For illustrative Purposes Only
Shares outstanding using the treasury stock method
Dilutive effect from options: = 1.5 million ($10.00 * 1.5 million) = 0.5 million shares
$15.00
Diluted shares
outstanding
Set up the
shares
outstanding
schedule as
illustrated
Diluted shares
outstanding
Set up the
shares
outstanding
schedule as
illustrated
Total $ proceeds
In-the-$ shares x avg. strike price
Calculate option proceeds using the
SUMPRODUCT function
Total shares repurchased
Proceeds / current share price
Convertible securities
Information about
convertible securities can
usually be found on the
balance sheet and in the
footnotes of a companys
Licensed to Sheikh Sadik. Email address: shehab91@outlook.com
For illustrative Purposes Only
10-K and 10-Qs. 74
Shares outstanding using the treasury stock method
Use the market value of the equity (dil. shares x market share price) to calculate the
WACC (even though you are using a market-based valuation of equity to determine the
weight, this calculation is designed only to provide context for a target capital structure).
Estimating private company capital structure
1) Use an equity value derived from a comps analysis for the purposes of calculating
capital structure, or:
2) Use the equity value derived in the DCF valuation to determine the weight. This is also
acceptable for public companies if you expect that the derived fair value of equity is a
better indicator of the future capital structure. Recognize that this creates a circular
calculation because the WACC in turn is used to derive the value of equity, so be sure
that iterations are checked to 100 in Excel under Tools > Options and a circuit breaker
is in place.
Licensed to Sheikh Sadik. Email address: shehab91@outlook.com
80
For illustrative Purposes Only
Modeling the weighted average cost of capital (WACC)
Market value of debt
In practice, we use the book value of debt as an approximation for market value of debt
unless interest rates have changed substantially since debt issuance. In this case, use the
market price of the companys debt if it is actively traded; otherwise value each bond by
discounting its cash flows (face value x coupon rate) by the yield to maturity of
comparably-rated debt.
Tax shield
Because interest is tax deductible, the true cost of debt is the after-tax rate due to the
ability of interest expense to shield taxes. The tax rate used should be the marginal tax
rate for each specific company.
Tax shield
Tax Think of it this way: $1 of interest expense reduces earnings not by $1, but
shield by $1 x (1 - marginal tax rate) because interest expense is tax deductible
(assuming, of course, that the company is profitable and has sufficient pre-
tax profit to use the shield provided by interest expense).
Company XYZ has 50 million common shares outstanding trading at $20 per share
It has $200 million in debt outstanding at a 10% interest rate, and this is the current rate
in the market
The marginal tax rate is 40%
The expected equity return in this company is 15%
WACC = 13.5%
The Capital Asset Pricing Model (CAPM) classifies risk into two parts:
1. Unsystematic risk: Company-specific risk that can be eliminated by investing in a
diversified portfolio. Since diversified investors will not consider this risk when
making investment decisions, equity prices will not reflect this risk.
2. Systematic risk: Risk related to investing in the stock market and to sensitivity of
the specific security to the overall market. Since systematic risk is unavoidable,
investors should be rewarded with an equivalent return.
where:
cov(Ri,Rm) = Covariance between security i and the market index
2(Rm) = Variance of the market index
(Ri,Rm) = Correlation coefficient between security i and the market index
(Ri) = Standard deviation of returns of security i
(Rm) = Standard deviation of market returns
Company xyz returns vs. S&P 500 monthly returns (last 60 months)
20.0%
2
R = 0.4884
10.0%
5.0%
0.0%
-15.0% -10.0% -5.0% 0.0% 5.0% 10.0% 15.0% 20.0% 25.0%
-5.0%
-10.0%
Company XYZ returns
Returning to our CAPM formula, the beta value determines how much of the market
risk premium will be added to the risk-free rate. Since the cost of capital is an
expected value, the beta value should reflect an expected value as well.
Licensed to Sheikh Sadik. Email address: shehab91@outlook.com
91
For illustrative Purposes Only
Modeling the weighted average cost of capital (WACC)
Application
When daily stock prices for the business are available, some bankers use projected
betas provided by services such as Barra. Other services such as Bloomberg and
S&P also provide Beta calculations, but both are based on historical prices and are
therefore not forward looking. As such, the preferred source of forward looking betas
is Barra.
However, calculating raw betas from historical returns and even projected betas is an
imprecise measurement of future beta because of estimation errors (i.e. standard
errors create a large potential range for beta).
As a result, it is recommended that we use an industry beta. In other words, we
should calculate the unlevered beta (more on this shortly) of companies in the same
industries facing similar operational risks. Assuming the errors are uncorrelated, they
will cancel each other out the more companies are added.
Delevering and relevering betas of comparable companies
Comparable companies with similar operating characteristics may very
well have substantially different financial (capital structure) characteristics.
We need to undo the distorting impact of different capital structures on
beta because more highly leveraged companies will have higher observed
betas. Why? Because cash flows to equity holders are more volatile due
to the higher fixed interest payments
As a result, we need to delever betas of comparable companies so that we can relever
Licensed to Sheikh Sadik. Email address: shehab91@outlook.com
them at the target companys target For
capital structure.
illustrative Purposes Only
92
Modeling the weighted average cost of capital (WACC)
Delevering beta
(Unlevered) = (Levered)
1+ (Debt/Equity) (1-tr)
Relevering beta:
Once you have derived the unlevered beta, you need to relever it at the target capital
structure using the reverse of the formula:
(Levered) = (Unlevered) x [1+(Debt/Equity) (1-tr)]
Modeling synergies
Synergies can be discounted independently or by adjusting the explicitly
projected free cash flows.
Common error: When modeling revenue synergies, dont forget that these
incremental revenues have costs associated with them that need to be modeled
in as well (typically at the companys tax-effected EBIT margin).
Contact us
617-314-7685
800-646-3575 (toll-free)
www.wallstreetprep.com
Copyright
Wall StreetPrep, Inc. All rights reserved. "Wall StreetPrep", "Wall Street Prep", "The
EDGE Self Study Program", and various marks are trademarks of Wall Street Prep, Inc.