Professional Documents
Culture Documents
AbstractVoltage source converter (VSC)-based high- the isolation between two different high-voltage sources. This
voltage direct current (HVDC) transmission systems have paper proposes a control method of a dc fault-resilient converter
attractive advantages compared to classical thyristor- with high-frequency isolation and ultrafast electronic isolation
based HVDC transmission systems. However, VSC-based
HVDC transmission systems are vulnerable to dc side
capability following dc fault which can be protected against
fault, and expensive dc circuit breakers are required to dc fault without using expensive dc circuit breakers. In this
protect them against dc fault. This paper proposes a control topology, the high-frequency isolation is also provided [7].
method of a dc fault-resilient VSC which can be protected In the VSC configuration proposed in [7], several ac/dc mod-
against dc fault without using expensive dc circuit break- ules in all three phases are connected in series, so the voltage
ers. In the VSC conguration, several H-bridge modules balancing control of multiple floating dc capacitors is required.
are connected in cascade, so the voltage balancing control
of several oating dc capacitors is required. In this paper, In this paper, the phase voltage balancing controller is pro-
an appropriate control structure with the capacitor voltage posed to ensure that the sum of capacitor voltages of A-phase
balancing controller is proposed. The appropriate control is equal to the sum of capacitor voltages of B-phase and
algorithm for dc fault operation and recovery after dc fault C-phase. The common-mode point voltage is used to perform
is also proposed. PSCAD simulation results are presented phase voltage balancing control. The module voltage balancing
to validate the proposed control structure under normal and
dc fault operating conditions. Real-time-digital-simulator
controller [8], [9] is also used to guarantee that the capacitor
results are also presented to verify the control structure. voltage of each module in each phase is similar to the capacitor
voltage of other modules in that phase.
Index TermsCapacitor voltage balancing controller, dc
Both dc cables and overhead transmission lines can be used
fault, high-voltage direct current (HVDC) transmission sys-
tems, recovery after dc fault, voltage source converter for the HVDC transmission systems. Although dc cables are
(VSC). mostly used, the application of dc cables in some mountainous
areas is limited. In these areas, dc overhead lines are used. In dc
I. I NTRODUCTION overhead lines, dc-link short circuit is so common because of
insulation breakdown following lightning strikes [10], [11]. In
V OLTAGE source converter (VSC)-based high-voltage di-
rect current (HVDC) transmission systems have attractive
features compared to classical thyristor-based HVDC transmis-
this paper, the detailed control algorithm is proposed to protect
the VSC-based HVDC transmission systems against dc faults
sion systems. Flexibility in bidirectional power flow control is on dc overhead lines.
the main advantage of VSC-based HVDC transmission systems In the following, this paper is organized as follows. In
[1], [2]. However, the VSC-based HVDC transmission system Section II, the VSC-based HVDC transmission system config-
is susceptible to dc side fault, and expensive dc circuit breakers uration is briefly explained. In Section III, the control structure
are necessary to protect the converter against dc fault [3], [4]. of the VSC configuration under normal operating condition
DC circuit breakers can be used to achieve dc fault clearance, is proposed. In Section IV, the appropriate control algorithm
but the availability of dc circuit breakers with high-voltage and for dc fault operating condition and recovery after dc fault is
large current is so limited [5]. Recently, several topologies with presented. Section V explores the dynamic performance of the
dc fault ride through capability have been proposed. A full- VSC-based HVDC system under dc fault operating condition
bridge modular multilevel converter [6] can clear dc-link fault through PSCAD simulation. In Section VI, real-time digital
current. However, in this topology, the galvanic isolation is simulator (RTDS) simulation results are presented to verify the
not provided in the VSC configuration. In HVDC transmission proposed control algorithms. Finally, Section VII presents the
systems, the proposed structure should be able to provide concluding remarks.
Manuscript received April 30, 2014; revised August 20, 2014 and
September 29, 2014; accepted October 24, 2014. Date of publication II. VSC-B ASED HVDC T RANSMISSION
November 20, 2014; date of current version May 8, 2015. S YSTEM C ONFIGURATION
The authors are with North Carolina State University, Raleigh,
NC 27695 USA (e-mail: nyousef@ncsu.edu; anarwal@ncsu.edu; In this section, the configuration of the VSC-based HVDC
sbhattacharya@ncsu.edu). transmission system is explained. The configuration of the
Color versions of one or more of the figures in this paper are available
online at http://ieeexplore.ieee.org. VSC-based HVDC transmission system is shown in Fig. 1.
Digital Object Identifier 10.1109/TIE.2014.2371431 Every power conversion module consists of two stages: the
0278-0046 2014 IEEE. Personal use is permitted, but republication/redistribution requires IEEE permission.
See http://www.ieee.org/publications_standards/publications/rights/index.html for more information.
3684 IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON INDUSTRIAL ELECTRONICS, VOL. 62, NO. 6, JUNE 2015
Fig. 2. Power conversion module with high-frequency link dc/dc C. Phase Voltage Balancing Controller
converter.
If each phase has N power conversion modules, the sum
ac/dc converter and high-frequency link dc/dc converter as
of N capacitor voltages of A-phase should be balanced with
shown in Fig. 2. As can be seen, the isolation is also provided
the sum of N capacitor voltages of phase-B and phase-C. The
by the high-frequency transformer in the dc/dc converter.
phase voltage balancing can be achieved by controlling the
common-mode voltage. Each phase power can be calculated by
III. C ONTROL S TRUCTURE OF VSC-B ASED HVDC the multiplication of phase voltage and phase current as (6).
T RANSMISSION S YSTEM Based on (6), the phase power can be written as (7)(9). When
In this section, the control scheme of the VSC-based HVDC the common-mode voltage is considered as (10), the phase
transmission system is presented. In this configuration, several power can be expressed as (11)(13). Each phase power has
floating dc capacitors in all three phases are connected in an average value and a second-order harmonic component. The
series. Therefore, the voltage balancing algorithm is required to average value of each phase power can be written as (14)(16).
match the dc capacitor voltages in all power electronic building The average value of each phase power with the common-mode
blocks. The voltage balancing algorithm is implemented in voltage can be written in the stationary reference frame as (17).
ac/dc submodule. The control scheme for the ac/dc submodule
has four layers, including the power flow controller, dc-bus volt- va = Vm cos(t); ia = Im cos(t + i )
age controller, phase voltage balancing controller, and module vb = Vm cos(t 2/3); ib = Im cos(t + i 2/3) (6)
voltage balancing controller. The detailed control scheme of
each layer is shown in Fig. 3. In the following, each part of vc = Vm cos(t + 2/3); ic = Im cos(t + i + 2/3)
the proposed controller will be explained in detail. Pa = va ia = 0.5Vm Im cos(i ) + 0.5Vm Im cos(2t + i ) (7)
Pb = vb ib = 0.5Vm Im cos(i )
A. Power Flow Controller
+ 0.5Vm Im cos(2t + i + 2/3) (8)
The power flow controller determines the reference value of
the dc-bus voltage of each terminal. For power flow control, the Pc = vc ic = 0.5Vm Im cos(i )
dc overhead line can be simply modeled with the inductor and
+ 0.5Vm Im cos(2t + i 2/3). (9)
resistor as shown in Fig. 4. The dc-bus voltage at the sending-
end and receiving-end terminals can be defined as (1) and (2), The energy balance in the capacitors for all three phases can
respectively. The transferred power is defined as the average be written as (18). This three-phase energy can be expressed
power of the sending-end and the receiving-end power as in the stationary reference frame as (19). This dq-axis energy
VdcT 1 = Vdcave + 0.5V (1) variation can be compensated with the common-mode voltage.
These energy variations are fed to the proportionalintegral
VdcT 2 = Vdcave 0.5V (2) (PI) controller. The outputs of the PI controller should be the
VdcT 1 + VdcT 2 added power reference to compensate the energy variation as
P = Vdcave Idc = Idc . (3) (20). Using (17), the dq-axis power references are transformed
2
YOUSEFPOOR et al.: CONTROL OF HVDC TRANSMISSION SYSTEM UNDER DC FAULT OPERATING CONDITION 3685
Fig. 3. Detailed proposed control scheme of VSC-based HVDC transmission system. (a) Power flow controller. (b) Terminal dc-bus voltage
controller. (c) Phase voltage balancing controller. (d) Module voltage balancing controller. (e) Control scheme of dc/dc submodule.
3686 IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON INDUSTRIAL ELECTRONICS, VOL. 62, NO. 6, JUNE 2015
Fig. 8. Control algorithm of VSC-based HVDC transmission system for
t
Vc (t) = V0 e cos 02 2 t recovery after dc fault.
I0
+ V0 02 2 et sin 02 2 t
C
(23)
where = R/2L;0 = 1/ LC;C = Cm /n . The time when
the capacitor voltage becomes zero can be computed by
V C 2 2
arctan 0I0 V00C
t1 = t0 + . (24)
02 2
TABLE I.
VSC-BASED HVDC S YSTEM PARAMETERS
Fig. 16. Zero crossing time with respect to fault location and
Ldc PSCAD simulation results.
Fig. 15. Zero crossing time with respect to fault location and
Ldc theoretical results.
VII. C ONCLUSION
This paper has proposed a control method of a dc fault-
resilient converter which can be protected against dc fault
without using expensive dc circuit breakers. In this paper, an ap-
propriate control structure with the capacitor voltage balancing
controller was proposed. The proposed control scheme consists
of four layers to control the power flow and terminal dc-bus
voltage as well as the dc capacitor voltages of each module.
The control algorithm for dc fault operation and recovery
after dc fault was proposed. The performance of the converter
was thoroughly analyzed under dc fault operating condition,
and PSCAD simulation results were presented to validate the
control structures. The feasibility of the VSC-based HVDC
transmission system operation via controller hardware-in-the-
loop simulation with RTDS was demonstrated, and RTDS
simulation results verified the controller performance under dc
Fig. 19. Terminal 1 dc/dc capacitor voltage variationRTDS result. fault operating conditions.
R EFERENCES
[1] A. Egea-Alvarez, F. Bianchi, A. Junyent-Ferre, G. Gross, and O. Gomis-
Bellmunt, Voltage control of multi-terminal VSC-HVDC transmission
systems for offshore wind power plants: Design and implementation in
a scaled platform, IEEE Trans. Ind. Electron., vol. 60, no. 6, pp. 2381
2391, Jun. 2013.
[2] R. T. Pinto et al., A novel distributed direct-voltage control strategy
for grid integration of offshore wind energy systems through MTDC
network, IEEE Trans. Ind. Electron., vol. 60, no. 6, pp. 24292441,
Jun. 2013.
[3] L. Tang and B. T. Ooi, Locating and isolating dc faults in multi-terminal
dc systems, IEEE Trans. Power Del., vol. 22, no. 3, pp. 18771884,
Jul. 2007.
[4] L. Tang and B. T. Ooi, Protection of VSC-multi-terminal HVDC against
dc faults, in Proc. 33rd IEEE PESC, 2002, vol. 2, pp. 719724.
[5] N. Flourentzou, V. G. Agelidis, and G. D. Demetriades, VSC-based
HVDC power transmission systems: An overview, IEEE Trans. Power
Electron., vol. 24, no. 3, pp. 592602, Mar. 2009.
[6] H. Akagi, Classification, terminology, application of the Modular Multi-
level Cascade Converter (MMCC), IEEE Trans. Power Electron., vol. 26,
no. 11, pp. 31193130, Nov. 2011.
Fig. 20. Terminal 2 dc/dc capacitor voltage variationRTDS result. [7] R. Gupta, Resilient multi-terminal HVDC networks with high-voltage
high-frequency electronics, GE Global Res., Schenectady, NY, USA,
Arpa-e Proj. Award DE-AR0000224, 2012.
reduced to zero, and all the switching signals of dc/dc converter [8] M. Hagiwara and H. Akagi, Control and experiment of pulse width
modulated modular multilevel converters, IEEE Trans. Power Electron.,
switches will be turned off. As a result, the total energy of vol. 24, no. 7, pp. 17371746, Jul. 2009.
all dc capacitor voltages is discharged. When dc-bus voltage [9] M. Hagiwara and H. Akagi, PWM control and experiment of modular
becomes zero, the magnitude of dc current is reduced. When multilevel converters, in Proc. IEEE PESC, 2008, pp. 154161.
[10] J. Yang, J. E. Fletcher, and J. OReilly, Short-circuit and ground fault
the magnitude of dc current becomes zero, the circuit breaker analyses and location in VSC-based dc network cables, IEEE Trans. Ind.
will be opened to disconnect terminal 1 from terminal 2. Three- Electron., vol. 59, no. 10, pp. 38273837, Oct. 2012.
phase ac current in both terminals is also shown in Fig. 18. [11] X. Li et al., Protection of nonpermanent faults on dc overhead lines in
MMC-based HVDC systems, IEEE Trans. Power Del., vol. 28, no. 1,
DC fault is cleared at t = 33 s, and the control algorithm for pp. 483490, Jan. 2013.
recovery after dc fault is implemented. First, the switching [12] D. Costinett, D. Maksimovic, and R. Zane, Design and control for high
signals of dc/dc converters are enabled at t = 33 s. At this time, efficiency in high step-down dual active bridge converters operating at
high switching frequency, IEEE Trans. Power Electron., vol. 28, no. 8,
dc-bus voltage is regulated at 320 kV. At t = 38 s, terminal 1 pp. 39313940, Aug. 2013.
is connected to terminal 2. Then, the reference value of active
power is increased to 320 MW at t = 40 s.
Capacitor dc-bus voltages of dc/dc converters for terminals 1
and 2 are shown in Figs. 19 and 20, respectively. When dc
fault is detected at t = 30 s, the switching signals of dc/dc
converters are disabled. Therefore, the capacitor voltages of
dc/dc converters become zero. When dc fault is cleared at
t = 33 s, the switching signals of dc/dc converters are enabled,
and the capacitor voltages of dc/dc converters are regulated at Authors photographies and biographies not available at the time of
106.67 kV. publication.