Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Copyright 2006 by The Oceanography Society. All rights reserved. Permission is granted to copy this article for use in teaching and research. Republication, systemmatic reproduction,
T H E O C E A N S A N D H U M A N H E A LT H
or collective redistirbution of any portion of this article by photocopy machine, reposting, or other means is permitted only with the approval of The Oceanography Society. Send all correspondence to: info@tos.org or Th e Oceanography Society, PO Box 1931, Rockville, MD 20849-1931, USA.
Hurricane
Prediction
A Century of Advances
BY N A N D . WA L K E R , A L A R I C H A A G , S H R E E K A N T H B A L A S U B R A M A N I A N ,
R O B E R T L E B E N , I V O R V A N H E E R D E N , PA U L K E M P, A N D H A S S A N M A S H R I Q U I
Tropical cyclones, typhoons, and hur- duction in hurricane-related mortalities to modelers of hurricane track, inten-
ricanes are common words used around between 1900 and 2000 (Figure 1). sity, and coastal surge but to emergency
the world to describe the same natural However, since 1995, there has been managers, traffic engineers, the insur-
phenomenon—one of the most deadly, an upswing in Atlantic hurricane activ- ance industry, and government budgets.
costly, and feared weather systems on ity compared with the 1970s and 1980s In this article, we review the major ad-
Earth. These small, intense tropical (Webster et al., 2005). The strongest hur- vances in hurricane prediction during
weather systems have killed more people ricanes, categories 4 and 5 on the Saffir- the 20th century and the possibilities for
than any other natural catastrophe (see Simpson Scale (Figure 2), increased by continued technological advances that
Keim, this issue). In the United States 25 percent in the North Atlantic during will potentially improve public health
during the 20th century, ten times as 1990–2004 compared with 1975–1989, a and safety in the years to come.
many deaths and more than three times trend that was documented for all ocean
as much damage occurred from tropical basins (Webster et al., 2005). Although LO OKING BACK IN TIME:
cyclones as compared with earthquakes Emanuel (2005a) shows a correlation GALVE STON 1900
(Gray, 2003). The continuous rapid rise between increasing water temperatures At the turn of the 20th century, the only
in coastal populations along the hur- in the tropical Atlantic and hurricane organized weather information available
ricane-prone coast of the southeast energy, this relationship does not hold to hurricane forecasters was collected
United States since the 1950s (Figure 1) for other oceans (Webster et al., 2005). at land-based weather stations, as radio
has placed more of the public at risk to In 2005, records were broken when three communications with ocean-going ships
coastal and inland flooding (see Bowen Category 5 hurricanes intensified in the had not yet been developed. The “sur-
et al., this issue and Bowen case study, western Atlantic Ocean basin within a prise” hurricane that flooded the thriving
this issue). Nevertheless, advances in two-month period (Figure 3). The in- coastal city of Galveston on September 8,
technology, communication, and fore- creased vigor of hurricanes is a grow- 1900 need not have killed 10,000 people
casting have reduced risks to public ing concern for public health and safety, if two ships transiting the Gulf of Mexico
health as is shown by the significant re- and presents serious challenges not only had been able to report their weather in-
500 u 25
ini
Population (millions)
op tion of the path of this hurricane based
al P Virg
t
as to on their observations as it tracked over
400 Co xas 20
Te Cuba and their experience with former
300 15 hurricanes. Although the Cuban meteo-
rologists predicted that the hurricane
200 10
would move northwest across the Gulf of
100 5 Mexico, U.S. forecasters issued hurricane
warnings for the east coast of the Unit-
0 0
1900 1920 1940 1960 1980 2000 ed States, believing that the hurricane
Year would continue to turn north and then
Figure 1. Population growth along the southeast U.S. coastline compared with mor- northeast. Meanwhile, the weak hurri-
tality from hurricanes within the 20th century (modified from Willoughby [2003]). cane intensified rapidly over the eastern
and central Gulf, where the steamship
Louisiana recorded a pressure of 973 mb
with wind speeds of 100 mph (161 kph)
Category Central Winds (mph) Surge Damage Nan D. Walker (nwalker@lsu.edu) is As-
Pressure
sociate Professor and Director, Earth Scan
Millibars Inches Catastrophic Laboratory, Department of Oceanography
5 <920 <27.17 >155 >18' and Coastal Sciences, Louisiana State Uni-
Extreme versity (LSU), Baton Rouge, LA, USA. Alaric
944- 27.88-
4 920 27.17 131-155 13'-18' Haag is Systems Administrator, Coastal
Extensive
964- 28.47- Studies Institute Earth Scan Laboratory,
3 945 27.91 111-130 9'-12'
Moderate LSU, Baton Rouge, LA, USA. Shreekanth
979- 27.91-
2 96-110 6'-8' Balasubramanian is Computer Analyst,
965 28.50
980 28.94 Coastal Studies Institute Earth Scan Labora-
1 74-95
4'-5' Minimal
tory, LSU, Baton Rouge, LA, USA. Robert
Figure 2. Hurricane intensity is commonly rated using the Saffir-Simpson scale where categories Leben is Professor, Colorado Center for
1–5 provide information on central pressure, sustained maximum wind speed, storm surge, and Astrodynamics Research, University of Colo-
damage potential (courtesy of the National Hurricane Center; more information available at
rado, Boulder, CO, USA. Ivor van Heerden
http://www.nhc.noaa.gov).
is Associate Professor and Deputy Director,
LSU Hurricane Center, Department of Civil
and Environmental Engineering, LSU, Baton
Rouge, LA, USA. Paul Kemp is Associate
Professor, School of the Coast and Environ-
ment, LSU, Baton Rouge, LA, USA. Hassan
Mashriqui is Assistant Professor, Depart-
ment of Civil and Environmental Engineer-
ing, LSU, Baton Rouge, LA, USA.
on September 6. Later, the steamship coast of Florida or the Carolinas. toll was estimated at 8,000 to 12,000, and
Pensacola, bound for Galveston, was Meanwhile, along the Galveston the city of Galveston, built on a barrier
thrashed by the developing hurricane. beaches, heavy breakers had developed, island only a few feet above sea level, suf-
These ships had no forewarning of which alerted the chief of the Galves- fered nearly complete devastation (Lar-
this extreme weather in the Gulf of ton weather office of a storm in the son, 1999; Emanuel, 2005b).
Mexico. Because they had no means of Gulf, even before he received official
communicating with land stations, their notification from the Washington, D.C. TECHNOLO GICAL ADVANCE S
much-needed information on the inten- office. No official hurricane warning DURING THE 20 TH CENTURY
sifying hurricane only reached U.S. me- was released, however, and the city of Within a decade of the Galveston di-
teorologists after they were safely in port Galveston received a surprise assault saster, ships were instrumented with
(Emanuel, 2005b). Forecasters at the U.S. on the evening of September 8 when radio communications that augmented
Weather Bureau Central Office in Wash- it was quickly inundated by a 20-foot the sparse coverage from telegraphed
ington, D.C. finally issued storm warn- (6.1-meter) storm surge and impacted land stations (Willoughby, 2003). This
ings for the Gulf coast region when the by enormous waves and winds near advance was particularly important be-
hurricane never materialized along the 140 mph (225 kph). Eventually, the death cause hurricanes form, intensify, and
tion changed when scientists at Prince- statistical models of hurricane tracks errors for 24-, 48-, and 72-hour forecasts
ton started using computers for numeri- (Emanuel, 2005b). have been reduced by about one-half
cal weather forecasts and, in 1957, Akira Tropical cyclones present a challenge from 1990 to 2004 (Figure 5). However,
Kasahara at the University of Chicago to modelers, because a relatively small- during the same time period, little im-
performed the first numerical forecast scale circular symmetric disturbance is provement was realized in hurricane-
of hurricane motion. Computer mod- embedded in a large-scale surrounding intensity forecasts. They are still based
els became a primary tool for weather flow (DeMaria and Gross, 2003). Never- on statistical analyses of past hurricane
forecasters by the 1960s. However, it was theless, the prediction of hurricane tracks events rather than numerical modeling
not until the 1990s that the computer by the NHC has improved significantly (Figure 5) (DeMaria and Kaplan, 1994;
models began to out-perform simple over the past 15 years. Hurricane-track Emanuel, 1999; Franklin, 2005).
300 72 h
been developed over the years.
250
A quarter of a century ago, Chester
200 Jelesnianski (1972) of the U.S. Weather
Bureau (as it was then called), developed
150
SPLASH (Special Program to List Am-
100 plitudes of Surge from Hurricanes). This
50 model scored an immediate triumph,
predicting the devastating surge of
0
1990 1992 1994 1996 1998 2000 2002 2004 23 feet (7 meters) that hit Bay St. Louis,
Year
Mississippi, with the landfall of Hur-
ricane Camille in August 1969 (Sheets
NHC Official Intensity Error Trend: Atlantic Basin and Williams, 2001). Jelesnianski et al.
30
(1992) later developed SLOSH (Sea,
24 h
25 48 h Lake, and Overland Surges from Hur-
Forecast Error (naut. miles/hr)
ricanes in the area were used to calibrate to begin the contra-flow evacuation This advance enables interpretation in
the model for local conditions. The New process. Evacuation from New Orleans tandem with GIS products, making it
Orleans newspaper, the Times-Picayune, before Katrina’s landfall was the most of additional value for decision-mak-
took the surge prediction based on NHC successful on record. It is estimated that ing by local officials. These capabilities
advisory #18 and published a modified 80 percent of the greater New Orleans were tested by the New Orleans fire chief,
graphic in their Sunday morning edi- area evacuated the city, and 430,000 cars who shared the LSU Hurricane Center’s
tion (Figure 6). This public access to the were counted using the contra-flow ADCIRC output with his emergency
ADCIRC output is believed to be respon- evacuation process. The contra-flow teams. They went into the areas that were
sible for a second wave of evacuees leav- technique had been perfected during predicted to flood due to levee overtop-
ing that morning and early afternoon. previous hurricane evacuations. ping and moved residents who had not
State and local officials used both A major advantage of the ADCIRC yet evacuated (mostly the elderly) to
the NWS SLOSH outputs and the LSU products is the improvement in spatial higher ground, such as the Superdome.
ADCIRC predictions to determine when resolution along the coast and inland. Unfortunately, these first responders did
sometimes counteract the potential im- measurements should lead to significant Addressing the immediate, short-term,
pact of ocean heat content (Ritchie et improvements in the forecasting of hur- and long-term public-health impacts
al., 2003; Walker et al., 2005). Hurricane ricane intensity within the next decade. of future large hurricanes will require
winds create “cool wakes” due to the Technological advances already in mo- improvements in infrastructure and
mixing of cooler waters from below the tion for weather and ocean-observing contaminant inventories, evacuation
surface (Monaldo et al., 1997) or upwell- satellites to be launched after 2010 will planning, and GIS databases where the
ing within cold-core cyclones (Walker improve the availability and accuracy of data can be easily accessed. In addition,
et al., 2005) (Figure 9). Cool wakes can atmospheric and oceanic data to be used new avenues of communication need to
have an immediate impact on hurricane as model input. Satellite sensors have be explored and implemented among
intensity in addition to impacting subse- their limitations, however, and cannot emergency managers, the media, and
quent hurricanes passing over them. provide all the needed information on the public. Even the best forecast only
Although information on the thermal the vertical structure of the atmosphere becomes effective when it has been ade-
structure of the upper ocean is avail- or ocean. A comprehensive data-gather- quately communicated to the vulnerable
able from satellites in real time, this in- ing program is also needed to further the communities in the path of the storm
formation is not currently being used understanding and modeling of the rap- (Holland, 2003). The last challenge for
operationally for forecasting hurricane id intensity changes within hurricanes. emergency managers and others is to
intensity. Future advances in coupled Improving hurricane prediction mod- actually convince the public of the ne-
ocean-atmosphere models in tandem els is only part of the solution to solv- cessity for evacuation. Timely access to
with effective use of satellite and in situ ing public health and safety concerns. storm-surge predictions may provide the