Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Deryan Vela
ENC1101-2177-4728
Professor Massey
Legal and illegal immigration has been a problem for the United States. Every year,
thousands of immigrants, from around the world, come into the U.S. In todays world this
phenomenon isnt new and have caught the attention from many Americans. Many reports from
USCIS have told that many illegal immigrants have come into US through either the Mexico
border that are on the states of California, Arizona, New Mexico, or the Pacific Ocean, or
through many other ways. It is also known that people from other countries have entered the U.S.
legally through a visit visa, however, these people stayed illegally and are working in various
places. Americans see immigration as a double-edged sword because it can provide the local
economy with a lot of benefits nevertheless these illegal immigrants do not pay taxes sometimes
they cannot support the economy of the country. It is known that are pros and cons of illegal
immigration and it is crucial to be aware of why there is more immigration in the United States
and to spread good information of this topic to all Americans, so Americans can look for
Immigration has played an important role in America in the last decade. On July 2016,
the population of the immigration was around 43.7 million (legal and illegal) making it the
highest number and percentage in 96 years. Also, it is planned that the immigrant share of the
population will pass 14.7% in 2023. (Steven A. Camarota) This quote explains how during the
Vela2
year of 2016, legal and illegal immigration has been a part of America society from the last 96
years and the number of increased immigrants that will come to the country will increase up to
14.7% in the year of 2023. As Steven A. Camarota states that there are 10.9 million students
from immigrant households in public schools showing there are 64 public school students per
100 immigrant households. And the states with the largest share of public school students from
immigrant households are California with 47%, Nevada 37%, New York and New Jersey 33%,
and Texas 32% showing that immigrants are increasing its population. The states with more
than 20% of immigrant people living in there are: California, New York, New Jersey, and
Florida. Most of immigrants who came to the US are from Latin America and Mexico. (Roman)
And this quote shows that the most famous states of the United States are the ones who received
more illegal immigrants and it tells that the immigrants come from the south part of the world
such as Latin America and Mexico making the connection between two cultures where every
Immigrants, instead of harming the U.S. society, are largely contributing to its economy
however president Trump and opponents of immigration reveal that a major concern among U.S.
citizens is that immigrants tend to take jobs from American workers and they take those jobs to
another country and this will decrease the economy of the U.S. Even though some of these
concerns are true, immigrants come to the U.S to persuade a better life. Deporting millions of
undocumented people will make the economic worst since most immigrants are creating and
persevering American manufacturing jobs. (Martin) with this quote American can understand
that deporting the illegal immigrant can make some of these manufacturing jobs to disappear
since most of the Americans prefers to let others due the hard work. As Hernan Schwartz says
Vela3
Trumps harsh assault on undocumented immigrants will damage the U.S in many key areas.
Much of the recent growth has been in service occupations like retail, hospitality, home care, and
health care. By this Hernan explains that if President Trump decides to get rid of all illegal
immigrants it can be a terrible decision to restore a good economy to the country since the Labor
Department expects
by 40 percent in the
of undocumented
Figure 1. On the year of 2017, many rallies supporting immigration take place in the immigrants are in these
state of New York.
occupations. During
campaign President Trump has promised to create millions of good jobs to the US economy
and to raise the gross domestic product by more than 4 percent annually. However, many
economics including a New York Times economic reporter Nelson Schwartz describes Trumps 4
percent target as audacious at best and fanciful a worst. And with this people can see that some
of the numbers that the President Trump want to achieve will be very difficult if first he decides
to deport the immigrants and to get to the point of 6 percent he need more people to work on
places.
Proposing new ways to face immigration will create reaction against the immigrant
community, but it is crucial to face the big problem about immigration, and see alternatives that
Vela4
dont create fear and dont spread immigrants families since fear has been increasing during the
last 3 years when the President want to face immigration by threating this people of sending
them back to their countries where some of them dont have anything over there. Two-thirds of
the people in immigration detention (25,000 out of 37,000) do not have a final order of removal,
which means that they may ultimately be allowed to remain in the United States. Of these 25,000
individuals, approximately 15,000 have no criminal record whatsoever. (Marouf) Here the
author wants to show that most of the people that are capture on immigration detention do not
have order of removal since most of them dont have a criminal record, and by this some
American protest outside the White House, so these kinds of attack to those good people that
have families and want to persuade a better life can be left alone. Fear is now present in many
immigrant communities and professor Peter Markowitz says, I have never seen the level of
panic that is gripping our immigrant communities. This demonstrate that while President Trump
keep saying to the whole U.S that he will send all immigrants away from this country, people
will be afraid of living in this country where if they call for help of the police they also have the
Most Americans tend to think that eliminating illegal immigration is impossible and no
matter what the government is doing, it will not work, and the results will be the same. This is
not true. As Marouf states that Illegal immigration can be repealed if the government takes the
proper measures by facing this problem from the roots it can be reduced with effective measures.
Some of these measures require money; some require political will; many can be accomplished
by the President without new legislation. Adopted as part of a comprehensive approach, these
measures will be effective. Adopted selectively, they will fail. (Marouf) And with this Marouf
want to show that by looking from many different points of view, illegal immigration can be
Vela5
solved with different ways such as using money to reinforce the security, asking help from
political people or the president himself however the people need to understand that to face this
Overall immigration continues to be the subject of intense debate between the American
people. The more than one million immigrants arriving each year have a very significant effect
on many areas of American life. We see that immigrants and their young children now account
for more than one in five public school students. The large share of immigrants who arrive as
adults with relatively few years of schooling is the primary reason so many live-in poverty, use
welfare programs, or lack health insurance, not their legal status or an unwillingness to work.
Nonetheless, there is always people such as President Trump that belief that dealing with
immigration is an easy duty but if he wants to make a different the president need to look for
good solution that tries not to harm many immigrant communities by spreading families apart. In
conclusion, immigration is in a lot of peoples minds. The thought of it being bad or being good
can cause discussion. But the United States need to tried harder to decrease illegal immigration
and reinforce border control, so this problem can be measured so in future, it will not be a chaos
of dealing with this subject. Also, if Americans get good information about this subject, many
solutions will come without sending this immigrant people back where they left everything to
Works Cited
Chacon, Jennifer M. "Immigration and the Bully Pulpit." Harvard Law Review (2017): 243-268.
Document.
Hanson, Gordon H. "Immigration and Economic Growth." CATO Journal (2012): 25-34. Document.
Marieta, Melissa. "Undocument Immigrants Should Recieve Social Services." International Social Science
Review (2006): 61-66. Document.
Marouf, Fatma E. "Alternatives to Immigration Detention." Cardozo Law Review (2017): 2141-2192.
Document.
Martin, Philip. "Trump and U.S. Immigration Policy." California Agriculture (2017): 15-17. Document.
Roman, Steven Camarota and Ediberto. "Immigrants and the Economy: Do They Help Spur Growth?"
(2017): 169-192. Documen.
Schwartz, Hernan. "How Trump's Assault on Immigrants Will Damage the Economy." Nation (2017): 16-
18. Documen.
Steven A. Camarota, Karen Zeigler. Center for Immigration Studies. 3 October 2016. Document. 30
November 2017.