Professional Documents
Culture Documents
July 2017
Revenue Recognition time for management and those charged with governance
In May 2014, the Financial Accounting Standards Board to prepare for implementation, if you have not already done
(FASB) issued a new revenue recognition standard so, because the task may take longer than anticipated.
Accounting Standards Codification (ASC) Update 2014- In assessing your adoption status in the implementation
09, Revenue from Contracts with Customers. The standard process, you may want to ask the following:
is effective for annual reporting periods beginning after Has an evaluation been performed to identify
Dec. 15, 2017, for financial institutions that are public impacted revenue?
business entities (PBEs), while the effective date for non- Although interest related revenue streams will
PBEs is one year later. A question to consider: with only generally not be impacted by the standard, several
six full months left until the effective date for PBEs, is your types of non-interest revenues will be affected.
financial institution ready for implementation? Now is the
Listed below are typical revenue types of a financial revenue or revenue group source and contract to
institution and the possible applicability: determine whether the revenue falls within the scope
of the standard. In addition, the standard indicates
Likely to be Not likely to be
Not affected by the a five-step approach for analyzing and recognizing
affected to some significantly
new standard
degree affected revenue for each contract:
Sales of other Loans (interest 1. Identifying the contract,
Monthly service
real estate income & other 2. Identifying the performance obligation in the
charges
owned lending fees)
contract,
Securities 3. Determining the transaction price,
Insufficient fund
Trust services (interest &
fees
dividend income) 4. Allocating the transaction price to the performance
obligations in the contract and
Administration
services for 5. Recognizing revenue when or as the financial
customer ATM fees Derivatives
institution satisfies the performance obligation.
deposit
accounts Although these steps may appear straightforward,
Asset
actual analysis may be more complex and time
Wire transfer Repurchase consuming than anticipated. In addition, to comply
management
fees agreements
fees with internal controls over financial reporting, the
Loan servicing
financial institutions considerations under the five-
fees step process should be documented.
Stand-by loan Has the impact on customers been considered?
guarantee fees This standard will not only affect the financial
Most credit card institutions revenue but also will impact the financial
fees results of many of the institutions borrowers, which
would in turn affect debt covenants. Consideration
should be given to training credit analysts and loan
While most credit card fees are not subject to
officers, so they understand how the upcoming
the standard, credit card arrangements should
changes from this standard will impact the financial
be evaluated for applicability. For example, if an
results and debt covenants of loan borrowers.
institution offers asset trust services to its credit
card holders for a fee, then the fees would be Has the transition method been determined?
subject to the new standard provisions. In addition, Companies can select either the full retrospective
there are multiple views on whether interchange or the modified retrospective method to adopt the
fees are impacted by the standard the institution standard. The full retrospective method requires a
should analyze each of its contracts from which it restatement of all presented prior period financial
earns interchange fees to ensure proper treatment. statements this method would likely be preferable
Institutions should communicate and involve their to financial statement users in the event there are
independent auditors in their conclusions as early in material changes to the comparability of the periods
the adoption process as possible. After adoption and presented resulting from adoption. In many cases, the
going forward, nonrecurring transactions should be impact may not be material, and therefore, this method
evaluated individually to determine the proper revenue may not be necessary. The modified retrospective
recognition. approach requires a cumulative effect adjustment
to the opening retained earnings of the period in
Are areas other than the accounting department
which the new revenue standard is applied, and while
involved in the transitioning process?
comparative periods are not adjusted, disclosures
As the standard will impact several business lines, the
are required to reflect the results under legacy GAAP
process for implementation should include a diverse
for the initial year of adoption. In practice, this would
project team from each business line to understand
require dual recordkeeping for the year of adoption to
and determine the impact on each revenue stream.
comply with the disclosure requirements.
The process should first include an inventory of each