Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Review
Urol Int 2005;75:291–297
DOI: 10.1159/000089160
Dominic Frimberger
John P. Gearhart Ambiguous Genitalia and
The Brady Urological Institute, Intersex
The Johns Hopkins University School
of Medicine, Baltimore, Md., USA
Abstract Introduction
Intersex disorders are rare congenital malformations Intersex disorders are rare congenital malformations
with over 80% being diagnosed with congenital adrenal and the reported incidences of the different malforma-
hyperplasia (CAH). It can be challenging to determine the tions are mostly based on small series. Bertrand et al. [1]
correct gender at birth and a detailed understanding of and David et al. [2] reported about their 25 years’ experi-
the embryology and anatomy is crucial. The birth of a ence of 325 infants with intersexuality. Altogether 167
child with intersex is a true emergency situation and an patients were diagnosed with female pseudohermaphro-
immediate transfer to a medical center familiar with the ditism, of which 80% were found to have congenital ad-
diagnosis and management of intersex conditions should renal hyperplasia (CAH). Hyperandrogenism due to
occur. In children with palpable gonads the presence of overproduction by the mother was found in 3% only. Ab-
a Y chromosome is almost certain, since ovotestes or normal male sex differentiation was diagnosed in 150
ovaries usually do not descend. Almost all those patients children, 27% of those with either gonadal dysgenesis or
with male pseudohermaphroditism lack Mullerian struc- male pseudohermaphroditism. Hormonal problems like
tures due to MIS production from the Sertoli cells, but testicular deficiencies were found in 13% and androgen
the insufficient testosterone stimulation leads to an in- insensitivity syndrome in 16% [1, 2]. It can be challeng-
adequate male phenotype. The clinical manifestation of ing to determine the correct gender at birth and even
all CAH forms is characterized by the virilization of the more difficult to establish the right diagnosis inside the
outer genitalia. Surgical correction techniques have various intersex disorders.
been developed and can provide satisfactory cosmetic In order to understand the wide variety of genital am-
and functional results. The discussion of the manage- biguity it is crucial to be aware of the regular sexual dif-
ment of patients with intersex disorders continues. Cur- ferentiation process. Appreciating the embryologic devel-
rent data challenge the past practice of sex reassign- opment and the hormonal influence on the development
ment. Further data are necessary to formulate guidelines of the fetus in utero is essential to counsel the parents ap-
and recommendations fitting for the individual situation propriately about sex assignment, necessary treatments
of each patient. Until then the parents have to be sup- and the surgical possibilities [3]. Sexual differentiation of
plied with the current data and outcome studies to make the embryo starts after the 7th week of gestation. Before
the correct choice for their child. that time point the urogenital ridge in both sexes holds
Copyright © 2005 S. Karger AG, Basel
mesonephric (Wolffian) and paramesonephric (Mulleri- identify the correct diagnosis as early as possible in order
an) duct structures. The differentiation into each gender to counsel the anxious parents appropriately towards the
is dependent on the exact sequence of events occurring at sex of rearing.
specific time points, dependent on chromosomal, hor-
monal and hormonal receptor function. While the genet-
ic sex and the gonadal differentiation are determined by Evaluation and Diagnostic Pathway of the
the sex chromosomes, the phenotype is dependent on the Newborn with Ambiguous Genitalia
influence of the hormonal secretions from the testes. The
sex-determining region on the Y chromosome (SRY) is The birth of a newborn with ambiguous genitalia often
the main gene required to differentiate the bipotential comes as a surprise for the parents, treating physicians
gonad into a testis [4, 5] which than give raise to the Ser- and nursing staff. Although some authors report that 60%
toli cells. In the absence of male Mullerian-inhibiting sub- of affected children are diagnosed prenatally [8], many
stance (MIS) from the Sertoli cells and testosterone from parents are faced with the situation at birth.
the Leydig cells a female phenotype will develop. In males The child should immediately be transferred to a med-
the Wolffian ducts develop under testosterone production ical center familiar with the diagnosis and management
while the Mullerian ducts regress under the influence of of intersex conditions. Not only life-threatening situation
MIS. In females on the other hand the lack of testosterone as in salt-wasting CAH have to be addressed immediate-
and MIS cause the Wolffian ducts to regress and the Mul- ly, but also the psychological devastation of the parents.
lerian ducts to develop, respectively. The differentiation For the referring inexperienced physician, it is often best
of the external genitalia is under the control of dihydrotes- not to confuse the situation by discussing the issue with
tosterone (DHT), a metabolite of testosterone under the the parents but rather transfer the child to a center. Until
enzymatic control of 5␣-reductase. Much like the gonads, a diagnosis is made and a sex of rearing has been decided,
the external genitalia have bipotential in the fetus and the parents should be encouraged not to name the child
develop into a male phenotype only under the influence or register the birth to prevent later changes and explana-
of DHT, while a lack of DHT will irreversibly lead to a tions to their social surroundings [9].
female external phenotype in both chromosomal sexes The evaluation should begin with a detailed history
[6]. The complexity of the physiologic sexual differentia- from the parents towards ambiguity, hirsutism or unex-
tion explains the wide range of intersex disorders and the plained sudden infant death in the family. Additionally
variety of presentation among the subgroups. The most the maternal exposure to hormonal medications or corti-
definite and undisputable factor is the genetic sex, deter- sone during the pregnancy has to be evaluated.
mined by the karyotype. Therefore, it seems logic to clas- Serum studies should be initiated, including electro-
sify the intersex disorders into female pseudohermaphro- lytes to rule out salt-wasting CAH, testosterone, DHT,
dites (FPH) with a female karyotype (46,XX) and mas- 17-hydroxyprogesterone and certainly a karyotype to de-
culine features caused by an excess amount of androgens termine the chromosomal sex. The testosterone level can
in utero (e.g. CAH) and male pseudohermaphrodites help to determine if the intersex condition is due to a lack
(MPH) with a male karyotype (46,XY) and female fea- of androgen or cortisone synthesis or rather due to a re-
tures due to a lack of testosterone or androgen receptors ceptor defect. Key to the physical examination is the pal-
[7]. Some patients cannot be placed into these two catego- pation of the groin and scrotal or labial folds to determine
ries, e.g. those with chromosomal abnormalities like the presence of the gonads. The outer genitals are inspect-
Klinefelter’s (47,XXY) or Turner syndrome (45,X0). Ad- ed and presence and length of the phallus noted. A rectal
ditional groups, which are not considered to be ambigu- exam can confirm the presence of a uterus and cervix and
ous, include phenotypical females with vaginal atresia should always be performed. The examination should be
(Mayer-Rokitansky-Küster-Hauser syndrome), pheno- done in the presence of the parents to familiarize them
typic males with additional female internal structures due with the situation.
to lack of MIS, or males with a micropenis. Further evaluations include a pelvic and abdominal
The birth of a child with intersex is a true emergency ultrasound for the evaluation of female internal organs
situation. Acute life-threatening situations can arise in and to rule out possible accompanying urological or ad-
children with CAH from electrolyte disturbances caused renal anomalies. The urogenital sinus can be anatomi-
by salt-wasting 21-hydroxylase deficiencies. But besides cally defined by a retrograde genitogram, localizing the
the medical emergencies, it is of utmost importance to position and entrance of the urethra and vagina into the
in their sexual development to patients with Turner syn- Management of Intersex Disorders and Sex
drome (45,X0) but lack the syndrome-typical features Assignment
[13].
The wide range of chromosomal, hormonal and clini-
cal presentations along with the expectations and cultur-
True Hermaphroditism al circumstances of the family require an individualized
treatment of each patient. After the clinical diagnosis is
The unique feature in true hermaphrodites is the co- determined a careful evaluation of the situation with the
existence of regular testicular and ovarian tissue in the help of psychiatrists, endocrinologists and pediatric urol-
same individual. The chromosomal distribution in about ogists has to be provided to the parents who ultimately
65% of individuals is 46,XX, although 46,XY and mo- have to decide the appropriate gender for their child.
saic forms like 45,XO/46,XY are possible. The patients Since 70% of patients have FPH, the actual need for as-
can either have a testis on one and an ovary on the other signing a different sex of rearing from that of the karyo-
side or they have a combination of both tissues in the typical gonadal sex is quiet small.
same gonad (ovotestis). The external phenotype is depen- Lately there has been an active discussion in the lit-
dent on the amount of androgens produced by the gonads, erature concerning sex assignment of children born with
but most patients are masculinized and about 75% are intersex disorders or other anomalies involving the outer
raised as males [14]. Almost all patients have a uterus and genitalia like cloacal exstrophy or traumatic penile loss.
a urogenital sinus. On the side of the ovary, usually a fal- In the past it was believed that children without adequate
lopian tube is found while the testis side always has a vas. male genitals should be assigned to the female sex of rear-
If an ovotestis is present, more than 65% will have a fal- ing [18, 19]. This common view was challenged by reports
lopian tube only, while the rest either have only a vas or of chromosomally male patients raised in the female sex
both structures [15]. A cunning and interesting fact is the who, although they did not know about their previous sex
existence of a testis in 46,XX patients, however the testis assignment, converted back to their chromosomal sex lat-
part of the ovotestis is usually dysgenetic and even preg- er in life [20–22]. Schober [23] reported about 10 inter-
nancies are possible from follicles of the ovarian part of sexuals who for the most part preferred sex partners that
the ovotestis [16]. had the same sex as their own assigned ones at birth. Ad-
ditionally the author concludes that the individuals are
successful in partnering and are satisfied with their sexu-
Disorders of Gonadal Differentiation al function and that hormonal factors may influence the
behavior more than the correct anatomical situation. Mi-
Conditions in this category include seminiferous tu- geon et al. [24] followed 39 46,XY patients with sexual
bule dysgenesis, like in Klinefelter‘s syndrome (47,XXY), ambiguity. Individuals assigned to the male gender had
with small firm testes, gynecomastia, azoospermia, eu- significantly more surgeries and a worse surgical appear-
nuchoid statue and increased serum gonadotropins. Oth- ance than females, but the majority was satisfied with
er chromosomal aberrations are seen in Turner syndrome their body image in both groups. Although 23% were dis-
(45,X0) with short statue, lack of secondary sexual char- satisfied with their sex of rearing determined by their par-
acteristics, webbed neck, and coaractation of the aorta. ents, the majority of patients was exclusively heterosexu-
Mixed gonadal dysgenesis in most cases is character- al and viewed themselves according to their assigned sex.
ized by a chromosomal distribution of 45,X0/46,XY. Adding to the controversy whether feminizing genitoplas-
They usually present with an intraabdominal testis on ties should be performed is a recent study by Crouch et
one and a streak gonad on the other side [17]. Equivalent al. [25]. Using questionnaires and functional assessments,
to PAIS, patients present with a wide range of incomplete 6 women who underwent genitoplasties in the past were
masculinization, dependent on the degree of the gonadal found to have severely impaired sensory and sexual func-
mal-development and the amount of androgens and MIS tion. But it has to be considered that most of these pa-
secreted [15]. The Mullerian structures on the testis side tients were operated upon years ago by children’s sur-
are usually regressed but can be in place on the streak go- geons. These observations along with pressure from sup-
nad side. port groups question the practice of sex reassignment and
pose the question whether children with ambiguous gen-
italia should be raised in an intersex gender until they can
position of a sigmoid bowel loop as vaginal replacement lular collagen matrices derived from donor corpora. They
is commonly used today since it eliminates the need for concluded that this might be useful techniques in the fu-
dilatation while the intestinal mucus provides lubrication ture to replace lost erectile tissue for penile reconstruction
of the neovagina and allows excellent results [44, 45]. [48]. Currently human embryonic stem cells are under
Labioplasty. The labioplasty is performed at the time investigation to regenerate the bladder in a rat model.
of the vaginoplasty and gives the external genitalia a nor- Therefore, with further research in tissue engineering it
mal female appearance. The dorsal hood of the foreskin might be possible in the future to replace and enhance
is incised and brought down to create labia minora, the underdeveloped phalluses and vaginas [49].
labia majora are moved inferiorly using a YV plasty
[28].
Phalloplasty. Testosterone stimulation in puberty can Conclusion
increase the size of the phallus and should be substituted.
Radical mobilization at the time of hypospadias repair The evaluation and diagnosis of the patient with geni-
can increase phallic length. tal ambiguity is challenging. Affected children should be
Phalloplasty using vascularized skin flaps with later immediately transferred to a medical center familiar with
insertion of penile prosthesis can be applied after puber- the management of these complex disorders. Accurate
ty in patients with complete absence of penis. diagnosis, close psychological support and information
However, currently there is no tissue available to in- are necessary to help the parents to deal with the situa-
crease the size of an underdeveloped phallus in humans. tion. Surgical correction techniques have developed and
But several groups are investigating the possibilities in can provide satisfactory cosmetic and functional results.
tissue engineering to replace or create lost or mal-devel- The discussion of the management of patients with
oped tissue or organs. Kropp et al. [46] used porcine in- intersex disorders continues. Current data challenge the
testinal submucosa for the repair of corporal deviations. past practice of sex reassignment. Further data are neces-
Kim et al. [47] seeded chondrocytes isolated from human sary to formulate guidelines and recommendations fitting
ears on rod-shaped biodegradable polymer scaffolds and for the individual situation of each patient. Until then the
implanted them subcutaneously into athymic rats. The parents have to be supplied with the current data and
same group successfully seeded human cavernosal smooth outcome studies to make the correct choice for their
muscle and endothelial cells on three-dimensional acel- child.
1 Bertrand J, Francois R, David M, et al: Les 19 Money J, Hampson JG, Hampson JL: An ex- 35 Gonzales R, Fernandes ET: Single stage femi-
ambiguïtiés sexuelles d’origine gonadique. Re- amination of some basic sexual concepts: The nization genitoplasty. J Urol 1990;143:776.
vision du concept diagnostique. Rev Fr Endo- evidence of human hermaphroditism. Bull 36 Snyder H 3rd, Retik AB, Bauer SB, et al: Fem-
crinol Clin 1988;29:261–369. Johns Hopkins Hosp 1955;97:301. inizing genitoplasty: A synthesis. J Urol 1983;
2 David M, Forest M, Chatelain P, et al: Pseu- 20 Reiner WG, Gearhart JP: Discordant sexual 129:1024–1026.
dohermaphrodisms feminis. Pediatrie 1990; identity in some genetic males with cloacal ex- 37 Fortunoff S, Lattimer JK, Edson M: Vagino-
45:65s–71s. strophy assigned to female sex at birth. N Engl plasty technique for female hermaphrodites.
3 Forest MG: Ambiguous genitalia/intersex: En- J Med 2004;22:333–341. Surg Gynecol Obstet 1965;118:545.
docrine aspects; in Gearhart J, Rink R, Mouri- 21 Reiner WG, Gearhart JP, Jeffs R: Psychosex- 38 Hendren W, Atala A: Repair of the high vagina
quand P (eds): Pediatric Urology. Philadel- ual dysfunction in males with genital anoma- in girls with severely masculinized anatomy
phia, Saunders, 2001, vol 1, pp 623–658. lies: Late adolescence, Tanner stages IV to VI. from the androgenital syndrome. J Pediatr
4 Swain A, Lovell-Badge R: Mammalian sex de- J Am Acad Child Adolesc Psychiatry 1999;38: Surg 1995;30:91–94.
termination: A molecular drama. Genes Dev 865. 39 Hendren WH, Crawford JD: Androgenital
1999;13:735–767. 22 Diamond M: Sexual identity, monozygotic syndrome: The anatomy of the anomaly and
5 Jacobs PA, Strong JA: A case of human inter- twins reared in discordant sex roles, and a BBC its repair. J Pediatr Surg 1969;4:49–58.
sexuality having a possible XXY sex-determin- follow-up. Arch Sex Behav 1982;11:181–185. 40 Pena A: A total urogenital mobilization – An
ing mechanism. Nature 1959;183:302–303. 23 Schober JM: Sexual behaviours, sexual orien- easier way to repair cloacas. J Pediatr Surg
6 Peterson RE, Imperato-McGinley J, Gautier tation and gender identity in adult intersexu- 1997;32:267–268.
T, Sturla E: Male pseudohermaphroditism due als: A pilot study. J Urol 2001; 165: 2350– 41 Frank RT: The formation of an artificial vagina
to steroid 5␣-reductase deficiency. Am J Med 2353. without operation. Am J Obstet Gynecol 1938;
1977;62:170–191. 24 Migeon CJ, Wisniewski AB, Gearhart JP, Mey- 35:1053–1055.
7 Migeon JM, Wisniewski AB: Human sex dif- er-Bahlburg HF, Rock JA, Brown TR, Casella 42 McIndoe A: Treatment of congenital absence
ferentiation and its abnormalities. Best Pract SJ, Maret A, Ngai KM, Money J, Berkovitz and obliterative conditions of the vagina. Br J
Res Clin Obstet Gynaecol 2003;17:1–18. GD: Ambiguous genitalia with perineoscrotal Plast Surg 1930;2:254–267.
8 Nihoul-Fekete C: Surgical management of the hypospadias in 46,XY individuals: Long-term 43 Klingele CJ, Gebhart JB, Croak AJ, DiMarco
intersex patient: An overview in 2003. J Ped medical, surgical, and psychosexual outcome. CS, Lesnick TG, Lee RA: McIndoe procedure
Surg 2004;39:144–145. Pediatrics 2002;110:31. for vaginal agenesis: Long-term outcome and
9 American Academy of Pediatrics: Committee 25 Crouch NS, Minto CL, Laio LM, Woodhouse effect on quality of life. Am J Obstet Gynecol
on Genetics: Evaluation of the newborn with CRJ, Creighton SM: Genital sensation after 2003;1569–1572.
developmental anomalies of the external geni- feminizing genitoplasty for congenital adrenal 44 Tillem SM, Stock JA, Hanna MK: Vaginal re-
talia. Pediatrics 2000;106:138–142. hyperplasia. BJU Int 2004;93:135–138. construction in children. J Urol 1998; 160:
10 Swyer GIM: Male pseudohermaphroditism: A 26 Diamond M: Pediatric management of ambig- 186–190.
hitherto undescribed form. BMJ 1955;2:709– uous and traumatized genitalia. J Urol 1999; 45 Parsons JK, Gearhart SL, Gearhart JP: Vaginal
712. 162:1021–1028. reconstruction utilizing sigmoid colon: Com-
11 Grumbach MM, Conte FA: Disorders of sexu- 27 Slijper FME, Drop SLS, Molenaar JC, de- plications and long-term results. J Pediatr Surg
al differentiation; in Wilson JD, Foster DW, Muinck Keizer-Schrama SMPF: Long-term 2002;37:629–633.
Kronenberg HM, Larsen PR (eds): Williams psychological evaluation of intersex children. 46 Kropp BP, Cheng EY, Pope JC 4th, Brock JW
Textbook of Endocrinology. Philadelphia, Arch Sex Behav 1998;27:125–144. 3rd, Koyle MA, Furness PD 3rd, Weigel ND,
Saunders, 1998, pp 1303–1425. 28 Oesterling JE, Gearhart JP, Jeffs RD: A unified Keck RW, Kropp KA: Use of small intestinal
12 Manuel M, Katayama KP, Jones HW Jr: The approach to early reconstructive surgery of the submucosa for corporal body grafting in cases
occurrence of gonadal tumors in intersex pa- child with ambiguous genitalia. J Urol 1987; of severe penile curvature. J Urol 2002; 168:
tients with a Y chromosome. Am J Obstet Gy- 138:1079–1082. 1742–1745.
necol 1976;124:293. 29 Migeon CJ, Wisniewski AB: Congenital adre- 47 Kim BS, Yoo JJ, Atala A: Engineering of hu-
13 Simpson JL: Disorders of sexual differentia- nal hyperplasia owing to 21-hydroxylase defi- man cartilage rods: Potential application for
tion, etiology and clinical delineation. New ciencies: Growth development and therapeutic penile prostheses. J Urol 2002; 168: 1794–
York, Academic, 1976. considerations. Endocrinol Metab Clin North 1797.
14 Blyth B, Duckett JW Jr: Gonadal differentia- Am 2001;30:193–206. 48 Falke G, Yoo JJ, Kwon TG, Moreland R, At-
tion: A review of the physiological process and 30 Van Wyk JJ, Ritzen EM: The role of bilateral ala A: Formation of corporal tissue architec-
influencing factors based on recent experimen- adrenalectomy in the treatment of congenital ture in vivo using human cavernosal muscle
tal evidence. J Urol 1991;145:689–694. adrenal hyperplasia. J Clin Endocrinol Metab and endothelial cells seeded on collagen matri-
15 Berkovitz GD, Fechner PY, Zacur HW, et al: 2003;88:2993–2998. ces. Tissue Eng 2003;9:871–879.
Clinical and pathologic spectrum of 46XY go- 31 Spence HM, Allen TD: Genital reconstruction 49 Frimberger D, Lakshmanan Y, Morales N,
nadal dysgenesis: Its relevance to the under- in the female with the androgenital syndrome. Gearhart JD, Gearhart JP: Human pluripotent
standing of sex differentiation. Medicine (Bal- Br J Urol 1973;45:126–130. stem cells in bladder regeneration using a ro-
timore) 1991;70:375–383. 32 DeJong T, Boemers M: Neonatal management dent model. Abstract, presented at the Ameri-
16 Starceski PJ, Sieber WK, Lee PA: Fertility and of female intersex by clitorovaginoplasty. J can Academy of Pediatrics, Annual Meeting,
true hermaphroditism. Adolesc Pediatr Gyne- Urol 1995;154:830–832. Nov 1–3, 2003, New Orleans, USA.
col 1988;1:55–56. 33 Kogan SJ, Smey P, Levitt SB: Subtunical total
17 Migeon CJ: Male pseudohermaphroditism. reduction clitoroplasty: A safe modification of
Ann Endocrinol 1980;41:311. existing techniques. J Urol 1983; 130: 746–
18 Zucker KJ: Intersexuality and gender identity 748.
differentiation. Annu Rec Sex Res 1999;10:1. 34 Gearhart JP, Burnett A, Owen JH: Measure-
ment of pudendal evoked potentials during
feminizing genitoplasty: Technique and appli-
cations. J Urol1995;153:486–487.