Professional Documents
Culture Documents
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
REPORT ON STRATEGIC
MANAGEMENT
Submitted to:
Sir. Mehmood shah
Submitted by:
Iftikhar Ali Khan
Muhammad Kashif
1
Letter of Transmittal
Sincerely,
2
Executive Summary
FedEx is one of the fastest growing companies in America and in the world. It is
recognized as one of the largest airlines in the world, mostly consumed with
shipping freight rather than people. FedEx makes a business out of many
different markets and concepts. It works with IT, business solutions, and even e-
commerce so it is well documented that FedEx is a broad company trying to
reach every consumer.
In this strategic audit, we aim to inform educators and analysts of the various
important factors in the company’s internal and external environments and how
those factors can affect the FedEx both positively as well as negatively. Also we
intend to highlights the facts and issues that can be critical for FedEx in the long
run.
After having considered all the circumstances and factors affecting the company,
we judge that the strategic issues that FedEx is confronting with include, pilot
unionization & employees’ satisfaction, fuel price fluctuations, and complicated
organizational structure and diminishing competitive advantage of FedEx.
So to coup up with such concerns, we recommend that FedEx should run its
subsidiaries together. It should contracts with large corporations and go for joint-
ventures in order to add cost-saving and value-adding benefits to its services. In
order to deal with fuel price fluxes, it should focus on the utilization of alternate
energy, lowering cost by enhancing freight capacity, and enter into strategic
contracts with oil suppliers. The issue relating to pilot unionization & employees’
satisfaction can be tackled by ensuring that the employees, especially pilots, are
well compensated. Since FedEx is a service company, employees are critical to
its success.
3
Corporate Analysis
Background
Philosophy
Objectives
4
Corporate Strategy
o Integrate with other companies when there is a common synergy that helps
save costs and provide new business opportunities.
Business Portfolio
FedEx is considered to be the U.S. market leader in providing next-day and 2nd-
day regional less-than-truckload (LTL) freight services. It ships more than 80,000
shipments daily, holds approx 36,000 employees. In 2007, Fortune Magazine
ranked FedEx as number six in most admired companies in the world.
FedEx Freight- One of the top 5 carriers providing next-day and second-day
regional LTL (less than- truckload) heavyweight consolidated freight services,
over 150 lbs in both the United States and international markets.
5
FedEx Kinko’s- Provides personal and business publishing/copying solutions as
well as being a FedEx shipping center, through a network of more than 1,200
digitally connected locations in 10 countries.
FedEx Supply Chain Services- FedEx Supply Chain Services, Inc., a contract
logistics provider.
6
The FedEx Global Network
Today the FedEx network links customers to many locations in over 220 countries and territories, in two to three business
days.
7
Competitive Advantage
Several business customers are signed up for FedEx services like Virtual Order,
and had created extensive online catalogs. This was essentially an online catalog
and hosting system. The idea was to provide an integrated e-commerce
backbone, and let the business customer figure out the product offering. The
customer could build a catalog from scratch, and use it on this backbone, which
incorporated FedEx's traditional services like online tracking (see figure below).
Individual customers could also build integrated web sites using FedEx APIs
(Applications Programming Interfaces), and incorporate the free Web page code
that would enable their customers to track packages directly from their site
through the interface. Some of these included, Carsons Ribs, a Chicago based
company that sold barbecued ribs, and Unique Photo, a wholesaler of
photographic supplies.
8
Performance Analysis
Service-Profit Chain
Growing from within – 91% of promotions are internal. Allow to keep the culture
strong. Top-bottom approach: they teach by example.
Employee satisfaction
Greatest asset for FedEx is their people. They are committed to providing a
workplace where their employees and contractors feel respected, satisfied and
Operating Strategy a
appreciated. Their policies are designed to promote fairness and respect for
everyone. They hire, evaluate and promote employees, and engage contractors,
based on their skills and performance. With this in mind, they will not tolerate
9
Asks for 3 basic questions:
1) How would employees rate their overall satisfaction with working at FedEx?
2) Would they recommend it to others as a place to work?
3) How likely is the employee to continue working at FedEx?
Among the 100 best companies to work for – 9 years in a row. 2006, ranked 64th.
UPS was not in that list. It is one of the 50 companies in America for minorities.
“When people are placed first, they will provide the highest possible service and
profits will follow”
Frederick Smith (FedEx CEO and founder)
Employee retention
They do the careful and transparent selection of employees. It costs more but
results in very low attrition rate. They also measure the Employee Loyalty Index
(ELI) yearly.
Employee productivity
Purple promise: make every FedEx experience outstanding (inside and out)
Customer satisfaction
At FedEx, people from different places and different backgrounds rallying around
a common mission: To make every customer experience outstanding. Our
customer is at the heart of everything we do.
No matter what your transportation needs, lucky for you, there is a FedEx for
that…
We provide resources to help you increase your efficiency and security in getting
your products to Market
10
• Global Network: connecting nearly 90% of the world’s GDP in less than 48
hours
• Supply Chain Services and consulting
• Phenomenal portfolio of tailored products and services to fit the unique
needs of our customers
Frederick Smith
The key element to FedEx’s strategic success was offering its customers the
“whole package” of products and services that could not be reproduced by
competitors. Patented products, strong brands and reputations, its position in the
industry, and strengthening its relationships with suppliers and customers allowed
FedEx to increase its competencies. Not only was FedEx able to compete with
others in packaging and delivering, they were able to dominate their industry
because they valued their goals and objectives.
Customer Loyalty
Integration strengthens the relationship and favours open communication and
commitment on each side which affect loyalty positively.
Revenue Growth
Average over last 5 years: FedEx: 8.4%, UPS: 7.0%
Profitability
Return on sales: FedEx: 12.7%; UPS: 9.1%
Financial Data
Acc
Current Current Total Total Total Net Fixed Receiv
Year Sales Assets Liabilities Debt Assets Equity Income Assets ables
2003 22,487 3,941 3,335 8,097 15,385 7,288 830 11,444 2,627
2004 24,710 4,970 4,732 11,098 19,134 8,036 838 14,164 3,027
2005 29,363 5,269 4,734 10,816 20,404 9,588 1,449 15,135 3,297
2006 32,294 6,464 5,473 11,179 22,690 11,511 1,806 16,226 3,516
2007 35,214 6,629 5,428 11,344 24,000 12,656 2,016 17,371 3,942
11
Financial Ratios
Sales Data
N et In co m e
3000
1,806 2,016
2000 1,449
830 838
1000
0
2003 2004 2005 2006 2007
2.20 2.03
1.96 1.94 1.99
2.00
1.74
1.80
1.60
2003 2004 2005 2006 2007
2.20 2.03
1.96 1.94 1.99
2.00
1.74
1.80
1.60
2003 2004 2005 2006 2007
12
Receivable Turnover
9.50 9.18
8.91 8.93
9.00 8.56
8.50 8.16
8.00
7.50
2003 2004 2005 2006 2007
Return-on-Assets
Debt-to-Asset Ratio
0.80 0.78
Debt-to-Equity Ratio
1.50 1.38
1.24
1.11
0.97 0.90
1.00
0.50
0.00
2003 2004 2005 2006 2007
0.08 0.06
0.05 0.06
0.06 0.04 0.03
0.04
0.02
0.00
2003 2004 2005 2006 2007
Current Ratio
1.22 1.30
1.18 1.18
1.11 1.20
1.05 1.10
1.00
0.90
2003 2004 2005 2006 2007
13
Environmental Analysis
P.E.S.T. ANALYSIS
Political-Legal
Opportunities
Threats
Economic
Opportunities
Globalization—as a trend, the world's economy has become more fully integrated,
and barriers and borders to trade continue to decrease.
Threats
14
Unpredictable energy prices—a substantial reduction of oil supplies from oil-
producing regions or refining capacity and other events as well causing a
substantial reduction in the supply of aviation fuel. It could have an adverse effect
on FedEx operations.
Socio-cultural
Opportunities
Business customers increasingly seek for a single solution that can meet all of
their global transportation needs, and more businesses are outsourcing their non-
core operations.
15
friendly recycled and recyclable packaging and has attempted to reduce
harmful emissions into the environment through the usage of hybrid
vehicles.
Such FedEx’s posture toward environmentalism gives consumers an
impression that FedEx does make contribution to environmental protection
and safeness.
Threats
o Customers have become less tolerant of service failures and likely to
expect better services that are more than the average.
o Consumers today demand more for personalized services. It can be a
difficult task for FedEx and other businesses to satisfy all customer needs
and still be profitable.
Technological
Opportunities
In Asia, it's experimenting with a digital/ink pen called Anoto Chatpen. The cigar
sized device, made by Ericsson, uses Bluetooth wireless technology to transport
written information, such as a signature or an address, into a database.
The Internet—FedEx.com gets about 4.5 million unique visitors a month, which is
saving the company $25 million each month by eliminating human involvement in
processing package tracking requests.
Threats
High implementation, maintenance and failure cost associated with the adoption
of sophisticated information technologies.
16
Growing concern over hacking and protection of customer information.
Porter’s MODEL
There is a high barrier for new entrants to overcome because it is very expensive
and time consuming to start up an express transportation company that is so
large. Acquiring a large fleet of aircraft and/or trucks along with quickly creating a
large efficient distribution network are the primary operational hurdles that deter
potentials entrants, in addition to the massive marketing costs needed to establish
a presence (within an already very competitive industry). Another factor
threatening potential entrants is trade tariffs and international regulations. Most
companies currently in the industry have already established relations with foreign
countries. New companies will have to prove themselves to foreign companies,
suppliers, and customers. Lastly, the fact that FedEx exploits new technology as
soon as it becomes available makes the barrier even harder to overcome since
regularly updated technology is harder to imitate.
17
Bargaining Power of Buyers
Opportunities
The enhanced infrastructure FedEx has through alliances with such companies
as La Poste may cause customers to perceive FedEx as a better company to do
business with due to expanded service coverage and reliability.
Threats
Since shipping is a ubiquitous service and while FedEx is not the only carrier in
the various market segments it operates in, these conditions allow customers a
variety of choices. With internet access, buyers can easily and quickly compare
prices and services of other carriers to FedEx’s.
Due to the extremely competitive industry nature of its Freight and Trade
Networks subsidiaries, time-volume contracts with large customers are the norm.
Large buyers can easily negotiate rates and can play competitors against each
other to obtain lower prices.
Although FedEx has differentiated itself with the reliability of its services coupled
with powerful, user friendly IT services for tracking and account oversight, it still
may not be enough. Fax machines, electronic communications such as EDI, and
other technologies offer an alternative for delivering bills, statements, shared
business data and personal messages.
Suppliers that are involved in this industry are: vehicle manufacturers, airplane
manufacturers, fuel suppliers, labor, airports, and shipping materials
manufacturers.
Opportunities
FedEx has ensured that they have the best suppliers with a scorecard system
where FedEx scores its suppliers to measure their performances while the
supplier in return gets to give FedEx feedback on how FedEx can improve.
Because the system helps both sides, it may strengthen the customer-supplier
relationship.
18
Threats
FedEx’s tracking and ERP systems are very crucial to their business operations,
thus consultants and contract programmers contributing to it are very important to
the company. Although certain long-term IT projects can be outsourced abroad to
save money, FedEx cannot bargain with suppliers for remedying crucial business
functions that need immediate attention.
This is a strong force in this industry because the competitors use price cuts to
compete, and the companies in this industry diversify and acquire other
companies for strategic growth and synergy
Thus FedEx has to move up with new strategies & additional strategic alliances
and acquisitions in Europe, South America, and Asia to tackle the fierce
competition.
S.W.O.T. Analysis
Company Strengths:
Innovation: Federal Express took airplanes and trucks and used them differently
than any other company before them. This is innovation. They have a first-mover
advantage in name recognition because of this innovation. This has helped them
to remain the industry leader since 1973.
19
of total revenues, for information technology. That commitment keeps customers
from switching to other providers. Federal Express also has excellent
communication with their customers. They use tracking devices on all shipments,
and customers can find out where their shipment is through many different
avenues including a user-friendly web site.
Company Weaknesses:
Labor Disputes with Pilots: Federal Express pilots have formed the FedEx
Pilots Association. This organization demanded changes in the pilots’ salaries,
retirement benefits, and the fact that Federal Express outsourced some foreign
flights instead of giving their own pilots the job. The pilots have a web site where
news is posted and feelings are discussed. During a busy Christmas season in
past, the pilots threatened to strike. Federal Express and the FedEx Pilots
Association have developed a tentative agreement, which is published on the
pilots’ web site. However, the pilots do not believe this agreement fully meets their
expectations. This dispute is definitely an internal weakness for Federal Express,
considering they have a huge pilot base, employed with them. Their operations
would suffer if there were strikes. When UPS employees went on strike in 1997,
Federal Express took the extra 800,000 shipments a day. If Federal Express
employees went on strike, their competitors could gain an advantage.
Rising Prices: Federal Express’ prices are above their competitors’. This can be
a weakness if their customers do not perceive a difference between Federal
Express and its competitors’ services.
Company Opportunities:
20
Expansion Internally: Federal Express can continue to acquire more companies,
and expand into new technologies or areas in their industry.
Joint-Ventures: Federal Express can form joint ventures, such as already with
Netscape and American Express, to enjoy the growth of integrating their customer
bases.
Company Threats:
Resource Analysis
MARKETING
Strengths
21
o High brand awareness—with the image of high-quality service, reliability
and speed.
FedEx Express
• Delivering packages, documents and freight to a large
number of countries.
• Overnight service virtually extends to the entire United States
population.
• Offers the most comprehensive international freight service in the
industry.
• Backed by a money-back guarantee, real-time tracking and
advanced customs clearance.
• Alliances with certain retailers for drop-off sites—providing
customers the opportunity to drop off packages at locations in office
buildings, shopping centers, corporate or industrial parks and
outside U.S. Post Offices.
22
• Also provided to 100% of the Canadian population through a
subsidiary.
FedEx Freight
• Has a fully integrated Website, Freight.FedEx.com, which combines
the resources of its operating company websites to create information
source, including a bill of lading generator and e-mail delivery
notification, make freight shipping easier and bring customers closer to
their own account information.
FedEx Services
• To enhance its single-point-of-access strategy.
• Much of marketing activities for FedEx Express and FedEx Ground
are combined under FedEx Services to more effectively sell the entire
portfolio of express, ground and e-commerce services.
• Sells and markets the full portfolio of services offered by
subsidiaries and provides customer-facing solutions that meet customer
needs.
Weaknesses
Strengths
23
• FedEx Express, Ground, and Services are ISO 9001 certified, which is
currently “the most rigorous standard for Quality Management and
Assurance.”
• Each of FedEx’s subsidiaries serves a separate and specific market
sector where it has expertise, which results in “optimal service quality
levels, reliability and profitability from each of the businesses.” This
strategy is known as the “operate independently, compete collectively,
manage collaboratively”
Weaknesses
• The air operations of FedEx are vulnerable to strikes from its pilots which
belong to the Air Line Pilots Association, FedEx’s only union.
• FedEx Supply Chain Services is a subsidiary of FedEx Services, and not
a distinct company such as other large companies has. Examples include:
Maersk Logistics, and UPS Supply Chain Solutions.
HUMAN RESOURCES
Strengths
• FedEx Express has over 52% of its employees being part-time, which
allows for flexibility in scheduling and adjusting to variable periods of
demand.
• All Part-time employees at FedEx are offered full benefits. FedEx Express
has been able to reduce its workforce to meet flat growth rates in its
domestic business through "early retirement incentives with enhanced
pension and postretirement healthcare benefits" to certain employees
aged 50+, and through voluntary cash severance incentives offered to
eligible employees.
Weaknesses
• The Airline Pilots Association contends that FedEx "often forces its pilots
to put in as many hours as it can and gives them little say on flight
schedules." This is a result of its flyers working primarily at nighttime and
the growth of FedEx's international business.
• Some pilots are flying longer and "more tiring" flights. If a new agreement
with the pilots' union isn't reached, there can be serious ramifications for
short-term operations suspension.
INFORMATION SYSTEMS
24
Strengths
• FedEx Ship Manager Software, API, and server for pickup, cancellation,
and tracking.
• FedEx Insight, a web-based system for enhanced level of shipment
visibility.
• FedEx Global Trade Manager, which provides import/export forms,
licensing requirements, country regulation/duty/embargo information.
• FedEx NetReturn API, which integrates with a company’s order/inventory
management apps.
• FedEx EDI Electronic Invoice and Remittance, which sends invoice data
electronically into the Accounts Payable systems of its clients.
• MyFedEx.com offers a customized portal solution for registered customers
that offered personalized services, going “beyond simple tracking and
tracing.”
Strategic Issues
PILOT UNIONIZATION:
The formation of Pilot’s union is itself a threat to FedEx. Demand for increment in
salaries and retirement benefits have already been on their top agenda. Same
issues have already been posted on website prepared by Pilot’s association.
Strike by UPS employees in recent past provided extra shipment to FedEx. If
3500 FedEx pilot’s go on strike then it would result in colossal revenue loss to
FedEx because much of the business would then be taken by its competitors.
Recommendations:
If FDX doesn’t profit from running the subsidiaries separately, they can
change to integrating their operations to achieve better synergies and
economies of scale.
To stay the industry leader, Federal Express should form contracts with
companies who will add cost-saving or value-adding benefits to their
services.
o Joint-Ventures:
Federal Express can form joint ventures, such as already with Netscape
and American Express, to enjoy the growth of integrating their customer
bases.
26
o Use of alternate energy:
They should look for alternate energy sources for their transportation since
there is a hike in fuel price and this trend seems to remain in future. FedEx
should focus on solar power or bio-fuels as an alternative energy source.
FedEx should increase the capacity of their planes in order to carry large
number of packages which will drastically cover their cost of transportation.
Ensure that the employees, especially pilots, are well compensated. Since
Federal Express is a service company, employees are critical to its success.
Place pilots’ salaries at or above the industry average. They need to maintain a
strong presence on the Internet, in case of a shakedown, and find ways to make
their e-commerce user-friendly and profitable through its IT staff. They need to
keep prices within 10 % of their competitor’s prices, or make sure that their
customers view their service as worth the price.
27