Professional Documents
Culture Documents
1
Types of machining according to the method of cooling: environment. Most industries apply cutting fluids/coolants
dry machining, wet machining, minimum quantity when their use is not necessary. The coolants and lubricants
lubrication (MQL) machining, vortex tube jet assisted used for machining represents 16–20% of the
(VTJA) machining. manufacturing costs, hence the unnecessary use of these
fluids should be restricted. Moreover there are certain
2.1 Dry Machining
materials that are considered as difficult to machine, for
According to Shrijit et. al (2000) machining without the machining of such materials dry machining is advisable.
use of any cutting fluid is known as dry or green An attempt is made here to carry out study with dry, MQL
machining. It is becoming increasingly more popular due as well as dry machining using cold air stream coming out
to concern regarding the safety of environment. Most of vortex tube, and the work piece is analyzed thermally as
industries apply cutting fluids/coolants when their use is well as metallographically.
not necessary. The coolants and lubricants used for The results are promising and have shown better
machining represents 16–20% of the manufacturing costs, results for cold air machining using vortex tube. The
hence the extravagant use of these fluids should be machining is performed using two grades of materials
restricted. However, it should also be noted that some of the namely H13A, and AISI1050 with coated carbide tools. The
benefits of cutting fluids are not going to be available for tests are conducted with coolant, without coolant and with
dry machining and also dry machining will be acceptable cold air stream as coolant, After the tests the thermal plots
only whenever the part quality and machining times and metallographic study for hardness and surface finish
achieved in wet machining are equaled or surpassed. have revealed that using cold air as coolant produces better
“Open-faced operations such as milling and boring can be surface finish while maintaining the tool tip and work
effectively run dry.” The resulting chips can be easily surface at significantly lower temperatures.The same is
moved away from the tool/work piece interface. In these being termed here as Vortex Tube Jet Assisted (VTJA)
cases, there is not as great a need for lubricity, and the heat machining. [1 ]
generated can be managed. In contrast, closed-face
machining operations such as drilling and tapping cannot C. Veiga, J. P. Davim and A.J.R. Loureiro)
be efficiently run dry because the metal chip remains in worked on Titanium alloys.That are widely used in the
close proximity to the tool/work piece interface. This engineering field, namely in the aerospace, automotive and
possibility increases the prospects of chips damaging the biomedical parts, because of their high specific strength
tool and the work piece surface because there is no and exceptional corrosion resistance.2] However, the
mechanism in place for their removal. machinability of titanium alloys is difficult due to their low
2.2 Wet Machining thermal conductivity and elastic modulus, high hardness at
elevated temperature, and high chemical reactivity. This
In wet machining (Kaum et. al, 2014) both the tool and the article reviews the state of the art of machinability of
workpiece must be supplied with right quantity of coolant. titanium alloys by using CBN inserts, and focuses on the
Due to the use of coolant, heat is extracted and the chips analysis of the process details, namely the especial
are removed at the same time. The dirtied cooling lubricant techniques for cutting improvement, machining forces,
runs from the machine tool into the dirt tank and is fed by a chip formation and cutting temperature. The influence of
filter pump (dirt pump / lift pump) into the filter. The titanium properties on the machinability is also
cleaned medium flows through the filter into the clean highlighted. Particular attention is given to the turning
tank. A system pump feeds the cleaned cooling lubricant process of Ti-6Al-4V alloy.
back to the machine tool. Tools used in wet machining are
cooled externally or internally, depending on the The research work (Mitsuo Niinomi) on titanium
machining process and the material of the work piece. The explain as Nb, Ta and Zr are the favorable non-toxic
cooling fluid fed by the pump also carries away any swarm alloying elements for titanium alloys for biomedical
produced during the cutting process. applications. Low rigidity titanium alloys composed of non-
2.3 Vortex Tube Jet Assisted Machining toxic elements are getting much attention. The advantage
Vortex tube jet assisted machining utilizes high pressure air of low rigidity titanium alloy for the healing of bone
initially which is introduced at tool work piece interface fracture and the remodelling of bone is successfully proved
through vortex tube (Selek et. al 2011). Vortex tube is a by fracture model made in tibia of rabbit. Ni-free super
device capable of converting the high pressure jet of air elastic and shape memory titanium alloys for biomedical
into two streams viz. cold and hot stream based on the heat applications are energetically developed. Titanium alloys
transfer principles. The hot stream of air escaping out of for not only implants, but also dental products like crowns,
the vortex tube is allowed to escape into the atmosphere dentures, etc. are also getting much attention in dentistry
and the cold stream jet is directed to interface. Using vortex Bioactive surface modifications of titanium alloys for
tube it is possible to produce cold air at near zero and biomedical applications are very important for achieving
below zero degrees. The air stream comes out at sufficient further developed biocompatibility. [3 ]
velocity and thus it helps to clean the swarf accumulated at
the interface. This is a clean and cost effective solution to Narutaki, Murakoshi, Takeyama performed
machining problems associated with dry machining of turning tests on alloys Ti-6Al-4V & Ti-5Al-2.5Sn with
difficult to machine metals. cutting speeds 0.5 to 5.0 m/s, depth of cut 0.5 mm, feed 0.1
mm/rev and cutting fluid of soluble type and found that for
On going through the research work conducted by ( Balaji both the work pieces,CBN tool exhibited an excellent
Nelge, Kiran Devade, A.T. Pise, V.M. Kale),which involve cutting performance compared to other tools like straight
machining without the use of any cutting fluid is known as tungsten carbide (WC-K10),cemented TiN, pure aluminium
dry or green machining. It is becoming increasingly more oxide type of ceramic,coated TiC and sintered diamond.
popular due to concern regarding the safety of Cutting force for Ti-alloy was claimed to be about one half
of that of a carbon steel (0.45%C) and cutting temperature
2
to be about 2500C higher than that of carbon steel because hardness of work piece will be measured using digital
of low thermal conductivity and low density of Ti-alloys. hardness testing machine unit HV.
Material selection
3
Lathe Tool Dynamometer Respective Forces mesurement in Dynamometer
Lathe Tool Dynamometer is a cutting force measuring
instrument used to measure the cutting forces coming on Development of temprature Distribution Model using
the tool tip on the Lathe Machine. The sensor is designed ABAQUS
in such a way that it can be rigidly mounted on the tool
post, and the cutting tool can be fixed to the sensor
directly. This feature will help to measure the forces So the program is been generated and saved, In with the
accurately without lose of the force. The sensor is parameters such as speed, feed & depth of cut will be
made of single element with three different wheat stones changed after every reading. Photo 7.1 shows the input
strain gauge bridge. Provision is made to fix 1/2" size control panel inserting program for cutting as per user
Tool bit at the front side of the sensor. The tool tip of requirement. Readings will be taken using thermal camera
the tool bit can be grind to any angle required. & infrared temperature gun. For each unit seven temp (T1,
T2, T3, T4, T5, T6, T7) will be measured where T1 will be
ambient temperature & other will be machining temp will
be noted down.
SPECIFICATION
Table No. 5.2
Sensor Strain gauge based Three axis force
sensor
Capacity X - Force 500 Kg Photo – 4.1 Control panel of CNC machine
Y - Force 500 Kg
Z - Force 500 Kg
Forces acting on work piece
4
Metal cutting is one of the most widely used manufacturing
techniques in the industry and there are lots of studies to
investigate this complex process in both academic as well
as industrial world. Predictions of important process
variables such as temperature, cutting forces and stress
distributions play significant role on designing tool
geometries and optimizing cutting conditions.
Model Formulation
Three main formulations are used in finite element
simulation of metal cutting:
Lagrangian, Eulerian and Arbitrary Lagrangian-Eulerian
(ALE).
5
for an analysis takes a lot of time and the user has to be
experienced.
Figure 5.3. Orthogonal metal cutting simulation by using Heat exchange is defined on the boundaries D-A and A-B.
Abaqus (Source: Ozel, et al. 2007) Boundaries B-C and D-C are sufficiently away from cutting
edge therefore their temperature is fixed 20 ºC.
Steps Followed By Simulation Of Metal Cutting Table 5.3. Force & Temp Readings
Fc [N] Fa [N] X Y(-) Z(-) Tavg
The modelling part of metal cutting simulation is very (-) (oC)
important step to achieve accurate results. In this Part, 588.1 153.6 50 9 0.5 41
details of modelling tool, work piece and cutting system are
presented. During analysis, it is assumed that work piece does not
7.5.1. Tool Modelling undergo elastic deformation and it is allowed to show only
plastic behavior. Finite element mesh of work piece is
For Example, In analysis, cutting tool is assumed to be a modelled using 3130 nodes and 3005 isoperimetric
rigid body. Geometric variables of the tool are given in quadrilateral elements. The work piece is created at least
Table 5.1. 20 feeds long and10 feeds high therefore the predicted
results are not sensitive to the displacement boundary
Table 5.1. Geometric variables of the cutting tool conditions and steady state can be reached. Mesh of
Rake Angle, Clearance Angle, Tip Radius, deformation zone is modelled very dense in order to reduce
α (º) c (º) Tr (mm) calculation time and obtain more accurate results.
0 4 0.05 Heat exchange is defined on the boundaries A-D and D-C.
Boundaries A-B and B-C are sufficiently away from cutting
Tool material was selected uncoated tungsten carbide edge therefore their temperature is fixed 20 ºC. In addition
(WC). Thermal and mechanical properties of WC are given to plastic properties of work piece, its thermal properties
in Table 7.2. depending on temperature have to be given to the software
for heat transfer calculation. Thermal conductivity, thermal
Table 5.2. Thermal and mechanical properties of Titanium expansion and heat capacity of AISI 1045 are shown.
Ti-6AL-4V(ref. azom.com)
Elastic Modulus, E (GPA) 110 System Modelling
Poisson’s Ratio 0.25 After modelling metal cutting components one by one, the
Thermal Expansion (1/ºC) 7.6e6 next step is to assembly them due to cutting conditions.
Thermal Conductivity (W.m-1.K- 17 Cutting conditions are shown in Table 7.5.
1)
Spec. Heat (J.g-1.K-1) 0.5 Table 5.4. Cutting conditions
Cutting Feed Rate, f Depth of
Finite element mesh of tool is modelled using 1185 nodes Velocity, Vc (mm/rev) Cut, b (mm)
and 1127 elements. Iso-parametric quadrilateral elements (rpm)
are used for the analysis. The distribution of mesh on tool 1000 0.2 1.2
is not uniform. Mesh density of tool tip and a part of rake
face are modelled high with using mesh windows in the Displacement boundary conditions of the system are shown
software to obtain more accurate temperature distribution in Figure 5.4 The tool is supported by fixing the nodes on
results. This design is shown in Fig. the boundary C-D-E in both x and y direction. The work
piece is fixed at y direction and it is moved against the tool
by applying a constant cutting velocity at the bottom
boundary A-B
6
Figure 5.5 Displacement boundary conditions of the
cutting system
Figure 5.7 Contact generation between the tool and the
For the heat transfer calculations, the following work piece
assumptions are made:
i) The contact between the tool and the chip is thermally In the analysis, updated Lagrangian model formulation
perfect. Hence a very large value of the interface heat with automatic remeshing method is used. Chip flow is
transfer coefficient (hint) is used and it is fixed to 1000 achieved by remeshing hence there is no need to use a
kW/m2K (Filice, et al. 2007). separation criterion. When element distortion is detected,
ii) The boundaries are sufficiently away from the cutting mesh generation is started as shown in Figure 7.12.
zone remain at room temperature (T∞=20 ºC) Remeshing module will divide the contact boundary, add
iii) The chip and tool loss heat due to heat convection up suitable internal node or smooth elements and then
(h=20 W/m2 ºC)on the free surfaces on the W/P interpolate stress, strain data for new mesh. As a second,
iv) Heat loss due to radiation is very small and it is plain strain assumption is made.(a) (b) & (c)
neglected.
Thermal boundary conditions of the system can be defined
as
T =T QUOTE --------------------3.1
-k QUOTE =h inter (T-TC)----------------------
-3.2
-k QUOTE =h QUOTE (T-T
QUOTE )-----------3.3
-k QUOTE =0
------3.4
Figure 5.6 Thermal boundary conditions of the cutting Using titanium the component which can are manufactured
system are listed and explained below.
2. Military weapons.
Operating temperature of titanium is higher compared
to Stainless steel and Mild steel. So most of the
component utilized in arms and weapons are
manufactured using titanium.
7
Human body is one of the most dedicated part in 2003.
world. Titanium being non magnetic is used for
manufacturing some of the body parts, Such Bones, [4] Bharatkumar M. Sutaria & Dhananjay V. Bhatt
Knee’s, Joints, Valves & much more. Chakradhar Bandapalli, "High Speed Machining of Ti-
alloys- A Critical Review,".
4. Aerospace ( HYPERLINK
"http://www.boeing.com/commercial/787/"Boeing: [5] (2003) wikipedia. [Online]. "www.wikipedia.org"
787 Dreamliner ) www.wikipedia.org
The Boeing 787 makes greater use of composite
materials in its airframe and primary structure than [6] Aerospace metals inc. [Online]. "www.asm.com"
any previous Boeing commercial airplane. The result is
an airframe comprising nearly half carbon fiber www.asm.com
reinforced plastic and other composites. This approach
offers weight savings on average of 20 percent [7] CBN selection manual. Sandvik. [Online].
compared to more conventional aluminum designs. HYPERLINK "www.sandvik.com" www.sandvik.com
5. Sports [8] Fluke Inc., Infrared thermometer user manual, 2006.
Normally in sports such as badminton & lawn tennis,
the bats used are made up of titanium to provide light [9] H.A. Salaam, T.M.Y.S. Tuan Ya, S.Y. Phoon, C.F. Tan
weight & good strength.
and M.A. Akiah Zahari Taha1, "VORTEX TUBE AIR
COOLING: THE EFFECT ON SURFACE
VI. RESULTS /CONCLUSION ROUGHNESS AND POWER CONSUMPTION IN
DRY TURNING," International Journal of Automotive
We have consulted a large number of articles, research papers,
and Mechanical Engineering (IJAME), July-Dec 2013.
web links, hard copies, journals on the above said topic and
found that our project topic is a very pressing topic in the[10] Mitutoyo Inc. (2012) Mitutoyo. [Online].
"www.mitutoyo.in" www.mitutoyo.in
critical industries such as
viz. Aerospace (both civilian and military ), Defence ,[11] (2010) Machining forum. [Online]. HYPERLINK
Nuclear, Petrochemical and tooling industries. "www.machiningforum.org" www.machiningforum.org
Also one of the most important consumer of this metal is[12] S. Narendranath and S. Basavarajappa M. Manjaiah,
companies making Gas Turbine engines as the gas exhaust "application of EDM and WEDM on titanium materials
," 2013.
temp. is (>1500 K) here titanium is invaluable as nozzles.
As the above said industries have the lion’s share in the[13] J. P. Davim and A.J.R. Loureiro C. Veiga, "REVIEW
consumption of titanium (>65%) it is quite satisfying on our ON MACHINABILITY OF TITANIUM ALLOYS:,"
2013.
part to find out a solution that benefits them. It is said that the
machinability of Titanium is one of the poorest with[14] Ambati, R. 2008. Simulation and Analysis of
Orthogonal Cutting and Drilling Processes using LS-
machinability index(MI) of about 45.
DYNA. Msc. Thesis. University of Stuttgart.