Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Abstract
In the early days of abundant resources and minimal development pressures, little attention was paid to growing environmental
concerns in Malaysia. The haze episodes in Southeast Asia in 1983, 1984, 1991, 1994, and 1997 imposed threats to the environmental
management of Malaysia and increased awareness of the environment. As a consequence, the government established Malaysian Air
Quality Guidelines, the Air Pollution Index, and the Haze Action Plan to improve air quality. Air quality monitoring is part of the
initial strategy in the pollution prevention program in Malaysia. Review of air pollution in Malaysia is based on the reports of the
air quality monitoring in several large cities in Malaysia, which cover air pollutants such as Carbon monoxide (CO), Sulphur
Dioxide (SO2), Nitrogen Dioxide (NO2), Ozone (O3), and Suspended Particulate Matter (SPM). The results of the monitoring
indicate that Suspended Particulate Matter (SPM) and Nitrogen Dioxide (NO2) are the predominant pollutants. Other pollutants
such as CO, Ox, SO2, and Pb are also observed in several big cities in Malaysia. The air pollution comes mainly from land
transportation, industrial emissions, and open burning sources. Among them, land transportation contributes the most to air
pollution. This paper reviews the results of the ambient air quality monitoring and studies related to air pollution and health
impacts.
r 2003 Elsevier Science (USA). All rights reserved.
Keywords: Air pollution; Sources of air pollution; Air quality; Ambient air quality guideline; Health Impact
0013-9351/03/$ - see front matter r 2003 Elsevier Science (USA). All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/S0013-9351(02)00059-2
72 R. Afroz et al. / Environmental Research 92 (2003) 71–77
Fig. 1. Sources of air pollution in Malaysia, 1996. Source: Department of the Environment (1997).
Table 2 Table 3
Stack gas emission standards The Malaysia air pollution index
relatively low levels of other gaseous pollutants such as Kuantan and Kuchhing, as the intercept SPM values
carbon monoxide, nitrogen dioxide, sulfur dioxide, and were not significantly different from zero. The highest
ozone (Awang et al., 2000; Noor, 1998). During this level of nonbiomass related pollution was found in
period, the PM10 concentration rose beyond the Petaling Jaya with an intercept level of 5078 mg/m3
Malaysian Air Quality Guideline (MAQG, 1989) level (Awang, 1998).
in almost all areas monitored. It increased 4-fold higher
in the Klang Valley and up to 20-fold in Kuching
(Awang et al., 2000). In a study coordinated by the 6. Health impacts of air pollution in Malaysia
Department of the environment to determine the origin,
formation, and composition of aerosol haze in Malaysia There are possible short-term and long-term health
(Department of the Environment, 1997), approximately effects of exposure to air pollution. In the short term,
200 representative samples collected by the Malaysian high levels of air pollution lead to an acute condition. In
Meteorological Service for total suspended particulate addition, blockage of sunlight may promote the spread
and PM10 measurements during the haze episode in 1994 of harmful bacteria and viruses that would otherwise
and in the nonhaze years 1995 and 1996 were analyzed be killed by ultraviolet B (Beardsley et al., 1997). The
by particle-induced X-ray emission at NERI in Den- possible long-term health effects of exposure to air
mark. The objective of the study was to apportion the pollution are unknown and difficult to detect. Compo-
sources of the 1994 haze episode based on two nents of smoke haze, including polycyclic aromatic
mechanism that had been proposed for the explanation hydrocarbons, are known carcinogens the effects of
of the haze episode. The first mechanism relates to the which may not be apparent for years. The consequences
more stable atmospheric conditions that exist in the dry may be more severe for children, for whom the
season. This would allow the rather continuous emis- particulates inhaled are high relative to body size.
sions from traffic and industry to build up high local There are a very limited number of studies that relate
concentrations of pollutants. This could explain why the air pollution to its health impact in Malaysia. The lack
heavily industrialized Klang Valley during haze epi- of data gathering for environmental epidemiological
sodes, often was more polluted than other parts of the analysis makes it difficult to estimate the health impact
country, during haze episodes, but it does not explain of air pollution. Recent studies in this country have
why some localities with little traffic and industries, such examined possible health effects of the 1997 forest fires.
as Kuching in Sarawak, in some years were polluted For example, outpatient visits in Kuching, Sarawak
with suspended particulate matter at levels of the same increased between two and three times during the peak
magnitude as in the Klang Valley or even higher. The period of smoke haze and respiratory disease outpatient
second mechanism relates to fire in South Sumatra and visits to Kuala Lumpur General Hospital increased
the Kalimantan forests, which reoccur every year in the from 250 to 800 per day (World Health Organization,
dry season but in some years, tend to get out of control. 1998). Data were assembled that indicated an increase
The results of the analysis ruled out the first in cases of asthma, acute respiratory infection, and
mechanism, as there was a poor correlation with lead, conjunctivitis during August–September 1997 at a
which are the marker for local pollution. The good number of major hospitals in Kuala Lumpur (Brauer,
correlation with sulfur supports, on the other hand, the M., and Jamal, H.H., 1998). For respiratory diseases,
casual relation with forest fires or other biomass Selangor recorded a significant increase in the total
burning, as sulfur and potassium are the essential number of cases during the September haze. Asthma
constituents in biomass. The Suspended Particulate cases increased from only 912 in June to more than 5000
Matter (SPM)/sulfur ratios found at geographically in September. The total number of acute respiratory
widespread locations in peninsular Malaysia (Penang, infection cases increased from about 6000 to more than
Kuantan, Klang Valley, and Johor) were very much the 30,000 during the same period. Apart from respiratory
same, corresponding to almost constant contents of diseases, conjunctivitis increased significantly during the
sulfur in the SPM (mass ratio 7–8%). This pointed to haze period. In Selangor, the total number of increased
a common origin (and/or type) of source, possibly the from only 207 cases in June to as high as 3496 cases
reported forest fires in South Sumatra. The high levels in October. The same trend was observed in Sarawak.
found in the Klang Valley could have been due to the In addition, the daily incidence of conjunctivitis in
combined effects of the geographical vicinity of the Sarawak during September was found to have a positive
source area, an unfortunate position in the prevailing correlation with the API (representing PM10 concentra-
direction of the wind flow, and possibly some trapping tion). However, the number of cases gradually decreased
of the biomass burning plume (4%). This pointed to toward the June value as the concentration of PM10
a different biomass burning source, probably fires in began to decrease after September. When the air quality
Kalimantan. The results also showed that pollution not was almost back to the values of a nonhaze period in
related to biomass burning was not imperceptible in October, the number of cases returned to normal. The
76 R. Afroz et al. / Environmental Research 92 (2003) 71–77
trend indicated that short-term exposure to high levels effects for Kuala Lumpur and Selangor during the haze
of PM10 was detrimental to human health (Awang et al., were also high, since both states recorded an average
2000). Effects were found to be greatest in children, the PM10 of 170.6 and 131.22 mg/m3, respectively.
elderly, and people with pre-existing respiratory pro- Another study conducted by Othman and Shahwahid
blem; youngsters are among the most resistant. A (1999) revealed that in the 1997 haze episode the
preliminary survey carried out among secondary school population at risk was from all states of the country
children in Kuala Lumpur and Klang revealed that less except in Kelantan, Terengganu, and Pahang; this
than 50% of these school children sought medical population is estimated to be 18 million people. But
treatment each time they fell sick (Awang et al., 2000). the incidence of risk varied among states in terms of
A study conducted by Nasir et al. (2000) suggested intensity and length of the haze. The incremental cost
that in the 1997 haze episode the total health effects were incurred by the population at risk for treatment of haze-
estimated to include 285,227 asthma attacks, 118,804 related illnesses from both public and private clinics and
cases of bronchitis in children, 3889 cases of chronic hospitals and for self-treatment (mainly the purchasing
bronchitis in adults, 2003 respiratory hospital admis- of medicine) was estimated to be RM 5.02 million
sion, 26,864 emergency room visits, and 5,000,760 during the period August–October 1997. The incremen-
restricted activity days. The whole population from all tal cost incurred for hospital admissions was estimated
states in the country was at risk except Perlis, Kelantan, to be RM 1.18 million during the same period. This
and Sabah. The total health damage cost was signifi- study also revealed that the country incurred productiv-
cantly high due to the long duration of the haze. The ity losses as a result of haze-related illnesses. These
results show that restricted activity days accounted for productivity losses occurred in foregone production
about 79.3% of the health damage cost while asthma opportunities during the idled workdays when workers
attack contributed 10.7% to the total health damage were in hospital and on sick leave. Those not
cost (Fig. 2). The contributions of the other three health hospitalized and not granted sick leave, who managed
effects such as respiratory, hospital admission, emer- to continue working are believed to have experienced
gency room visits, and chronic bronchitis were insigni- reduced activity days arising from the haze-related
ficant. Each of the above-mentioned effects actually illnesses they suffered. These sources of haze-related
contributed less than 1% of the total health damage productivity losses are estimated to be RM 4.3 million.
costs. The total health damage costs were estimated to
be RM 129 million, with a lower estimate of RM 36
million and a higher estimate of RM 258 million. 7. Conclusions
Among the 11 states of Malaysia, Sarawak was badly hit
by the particulate pollution with the largest number of Studies related to air pollution conducted in Malaysia
health effects, which comprised 23.8% of the total have been few. It is already 23 years since the
health effect during the haze. The estimated health Environmental Quality (Clean Air) Regulations 1978
90
79.34
80
70
60
Percentage(%)
50
40
30
20
10.7
10 5.67
0.88 0.94 2.28
0.19
0
Respiratory Emergency Restricted Bronchitis in Asthma Attack: Asthma Attack: Chronic Bronchitis
Hospital Room Activity Children Adult Children
Admission Visits Day
Health Effects
Fig. 2. Percentage distribution of health damage costs. Source: Nasir et al. (2000).
R. Afroz et al. / Environmental Research 92 (2003) 71–77 77
were introduced in the country. Many strategies, such as Department of the Environment, Malaysia, 1996. Malaysia Environ-
recycling, changes in engineering control equipment, mental Quality Report. Department of the Environment, Ministry
and air cleaning systems, have been applied to improve of Science, Technology and Environment, Malaysia.
Department of the Environment, Malaysia, 1997. A study to
air quality. Many studies can be conducted to evaluate Determine the Origin, Formation and Composition of Aerosol
the strengths, weaknesses, the impacts of the country’s Haze in Malaysia. Preliminary Report Sept. 1997. Department of
adopted, regulations, programs, and strategies. Environment, Ministry of Science, Technology and Environment,
Malaysia.
Department of the Environment, Malaysia, 2001. Clean Air
Regional Workshop—Fighting Urban Air Pollution: From Plan
References to Action.
Nasir, M.H., Choo, W.Y., Rafia, A., Md., M.R., Theng, L.C., Noor,
Awang, M.B., 1998. Environmental studies to control the atmospheric M.M.H., 2000. Estimation of Health Damage Cost For 1997-Haze
environment in Southest Asia. In: Proceedings of Asia Forum Episode in Malaysia Using the Ostro Model. Proceedings
Network, Kumamoto Prefectural Government, Japan. Malaysian Science and Technology Congress, 2000. Confederation
Awang, M.B., Jaafar, A.B., Abdullah, A.M., Ismail, M.B., Hassan, of Scientific and Technological Association in Malaysia (COST-
M.N., Abdullah, R., Johan, S., Noor, H., 2000. Air quality in AM), Kuala Lumpur, in Press.
Malaysia: impacts, management issues and future challenges. Noor, H.M., 1998. Haze and health: Malaysian experience. Paper
Respirology 5, 183–196. presented at the Workshop on the Impacts of Transboundary Haze
Awang, M.B., Noor Alshrudin, S., Hassan, M.N., Abdullah, A.M., Pollution of the 1997/98 Fires Episode on Health, Kuala Lumpur,
Yunos, W.M.Z., Haron, M.J., 1997. Air Pollution in Malaysia: Malaysia.
Proceedings of National Conference on Air Pollution and Health Othman, J., Shahwahid, O.H.M., 1999. Cost of Trans-boundary haze
Implications. Centre for Environmental Research, Institute for externalities. J. Economi Malaysia 33, 3–19.
Medical Research in Malaysia. Sham, S., 1979. Mixing Depth, Wind speed and Air Pollution Potential
Beardsley, R., Bromberg, P.A., Costa, D.A., Devlin, R., Dockery, in Kuala Lumpur Petaling Jaya Area. Malaysia, UKM Press.
D.W., Frampton, M.W., Lambert, W., Samet, J.M., Speizer, F.E., Sham, S., 1991. The August 1990 haze. In: Malaysian Meteorological
Utell, M., 1997. Smoke Alarm: Haze From Fires Might Promote Services Technical Report. Report No. 49.
Bacterial Growth. Sci. Am. 24–25. Sham, S., 1994. Air pollution studies in Klang Valley, Malaysia. Some
Brauer, M., Jamal, H.H., 1998. Fires in Indonesia: Crisis and policy implications. Asian Geogr. 3, 43–50.
Reaction. Environ. Sci. Technol. 404–407. U.S. Department of Commerce, 1998. Market Assessment. URL:
Cheang, 1991. Haze Episode October 1991. Malaysian Meteorological http://strategis.gc.ca.
Service Information Paper No. 2. World Health Organization, 1998. Report of the Bioregional Work-
Chow, K.K., Lim, J.T., 1983. Monitoring of suspended particles in shop on Health Impacts of Haze Related Air Pollution. WHO,
Petaling. In: Urbanization and Ecodevelopment with Special Manila, Philippines.
Reference to Kuala Lumpur, Institute for Advanced Study, Yap, K.S., 1995. Haze in Malaysian. In: Meteorological Service
University of Malaya, Kuala Lumpur, pp. 178–185. Technical Report.