Professional Documents
Culture Documents
DarrenE. Randall
Department
of Geological
Sciences,
University
of Plymouth,
Plymouth,
England,
UnitedKingdom
Andrew J. Tomlinson
ServicioNacionalde Geologiay Miner/a,Santiago,Chile.
GraemeK. Taylor
Department
of Geological
Sciences,
University
of Plymouth,
Plymouth,
England,
UnitedKingdom
Abstract. A paleomagnetic studyof Paleocene,Cretaceous, separated transandean faults. Instead, the rotations are
and Jurassicunits in the ?recordilleraof northernChile (26øS consistentspatially, and temporally and in their sense and
to 27øS) demonstrate a complexpatternof crustalrotations. magnitude with the Eocene transpressionaldeformation
The region was selectedto investigatethe pattern of associated with the DomeykoFault System;the deformational
deformationassociatedwith the SierraCastillo-AguaAmarga event that generatedmost of the importantstructuresin the
Fault and its associated structural subdomains, which form studiedarea. The data emphasizethe significanceof local
part of the Domeyko'Fault System,the fault systemthat tectonicsin controlling rotations in this part of the south
controls much of the structure of the Chilean Precordillera. centralAndesand the importanceof understanding the local
Paleocenelavasfrom the centerof the studyarea passa fold structureof regionssampledfor paleomagnetic study.
test,indicatingthe primarynatureof the remanencein these
rocks. A secondgroupof lavasfrom the southhasa similar
1. Introduction
formation mean inclination after tilt correction for a uniform
dip, which coupledwith the presence of reversals,suggests Paleomagneticinvestigationscarried out in the central
that theselavasalso carry a primaryremanence.The data Andeshave identifieda fairly consistentpatternof clockwise
indicateclockwiserotationsof-35 ø and 42ø respectively,for rotationsto the southof the Arica Deflection (Figure l a) and
the two samplinglocalities. Threegeographically
separate counterclockwiserotations to the north [e.g., Beck, 1988,
areas of Lower Cretaceousred beds also reveal primary
1998; Roperch and Carlief, 1992; Somoza et ai., 1996;
remanencesbased on the presenceof sites with reversed Randall, 1998]. Individual rotations and the large-scale
polarityat two of the localitiesand an inclination-only fold pattern observedhave been attributedto various tectonic
test of the three localitymean directionsfor this formation. modelsand mechanisms.At the centerof controversyin the
Thesesamplingareasyield remanence directions that reveal differing models is the role of large-scaleversus local
30ø of counterclockwise and 31ø of clockwiserotationas well
processesin the generationof the overall rotationpattern.
asan areawithoutstatistically significantrotation.Thesedata
include the first well-constrained counterclockwise rotation to
Large-scalemechanismsincludeforearcwide rotationsdue to
oroclinalbendingproducedby differentialshortening[Isacks,
be recovered from rocks in the southern central Andes,
1988; Roperch and Carlief, 1992; Butler et al., 1995;
althoughmappingsuggests the blockinvolvedis of limited
MacFadden et al., 1995] and large-scaledomino-styleblock
geographic extent.Jurassic stratafailedto yieldanyreliable
rotation by widely separatedtransandeanbasementfaults
results. Overall,the data indicatea greatervariabilityin the
[Abelsand Bischoff,1999]. Local processes includerotations
rotationpatternthan has previouslybeenobservedin most
of smaller-scale crustal blocks in response to oblique
comparable areassouthof theAricaDeflection.Thevariation
subduction[Beck, 1988; Hartley et al., 1988; Forsytheand
cannotbe explainedby large-scale rotationmechanisms, such
Chisholm, 1994; Randall et al., 1996; Somoza et al., 1996;
asoroclinalbendingor domino-style blockrotationby widely
Taylor et al., 1998] and rotation of detachedor partially
detachedthrust sheets[Hartley et al., 1992a, Butler et al.,
1995].
tNow at The Environment Agency,Exeter,England,United This paper presentsresultsfrom a paleomagneticstudy in
Kingdom
the Andean Precordilleraof northern Chile. The study area
lies between 26 ø and 27øS and 69015 ' and 69ø40'W, in the
Copyright2001 by theAmericanGeophysical
Union
region of the major mining districts of El Salvador and
Papernumber1999TC001180. Potrerillos(Figure 1). Jurassicto Paleocenevolcanic rocks
0278-7407/01/1999TC001180512.00 and Cretaceous sedimentary units were sampled for
235
236 RANDALL ET AL.: FAULT-CONTROLLED ROTATIONS, PRECORDILLERA, CHILE
69ø30' 69o15,
/I
El Salvador
26ø15 '
0
I 5 17krn
Approximate limit
of central domain
Central
Domain
i• figures
Areaof map
Potrerillos
Southern
Domain
Figure 2
69"30'
26"15'
UndifferentiatedTertiary volcanics
Jurassic-Cretaceous volcanic rocks
comprisingthe Sierra Fraga
Formation, Sierra Mantos Gruesos
sequence and Llanta Formation
Pedernales Fm.
Unit contact
Fault
Thrust
-I-•-- Fold
ß IQMl1-16tSamplinglocalityor localities
P Potrerillos
MV Mina Vieja
0
I 5 10 15 27km
Randall et al., 1996]. Subsequently, in the Late Cretaceous Varas and West FissureFault Systems,to the north,comprise
and Paleogenethe Precordillerawas itself the locationof arc the Domeyko Fault System [Maksaev and Zentilli, 1988;
magmatism[Cornejoet al., 1997], andduringthe Oligocene Tomlinsonet al., 1993; Mpodoziset al., 1993]. The SC-AA
thelocusof magmatism againmigratedeastwardto itspresent Fault separatestwo areaswith contrastingMesozoichistories,
positionin the Andean Cordillera, suchthat the Precordillera indicating activity of the SC-AA Fault since the Jurassic
formspartof the present-dayforearc. [Cornejoet al., 1993; 1997].
The major structuralfeatureof the studiedareais the north- The Mesozoicgeologywest of the SC-AA Fault comprises
southtrendingfault systemcomprisingthe SierraCastilloand a Jurassic-Cretaceous successionof predominantlyvolcanic
Agua AmargaFaults(SC-AA) (Figure 1), which togetherwith rocks intercalated with marine limestones, terrigenous
the La TerneraFault System,to the south,and the Sierrade sandstones,volcaniclasticsandstones,andbreccias(Figure2).
238 RANDALL ET AL.: FAULT-CONTROLLED ROTATIONS, PRECORDILLERA, CHILE
The succession is dominatedby the-3000 m thick Jurassic Lower Cretaceous succession of marine and continental facies
Sierra Fraga Formation[Sepglvedaand Naranjo, 1982], sedimentary rocks and sparse volcanic rocks in
whichformstheoldestexposed unitwestof theSC-AA Fault. unconformablecontact with Paleozoic basementcomprising
The successionhas limited areal extent and contrasts in facies graniticand volcanicrocks(Figure2) [Cornejoet al., 1997,
with coeval units east of the SC-AA Fault, suggesting 1998; Tomlinsonet al., 1999]. The basal sedimentaryunits
depositionin an extensional basinwherethe SC-AA Fault were depositedduringback arc conditionsprevailingduring
wasoneof themajorextensional faultsbounding theeastside the early Mesozoic. The Upper Triassicto Middle Jurassic
of the basin[Cornejoet al., 1993, 1997; Tomlinsonet al., rocks comprise limestone, shale, and terrigenous and
1999]. volcaniclastic sandstones of the Quebrada del Salitre,
East of the SC-AA Fault the pre-middle Cretaceous Montand6n,andAsientosFormationsthat were depositedin a
Mesozoicgeologyis characterized by an Upper Triassicto west facing platform environment [Harrington, 1961;
358 ø 0 ø
o N
e) t [fold
Reverse
trendsfault
stdkes
and
•i•.
•"• Bedding
strikes
::::::..:::.-:::::::::::::::::,:::::::::::-"::::
Fault strikes of dextral strike-slip
:!11::il;i;;11;;•ii!1111:•ii'!11':;il}:i:iii::i!:::i;:i
faultsin central
domain
84 ø
'-•• faults
Fault strikesofdextral
near Mina Vieja strike-slip
Figure 3. Rose diagramsfor the strikesof beddingand faults and trendsof folds in the northernand central
domains. The arrows indicate the mean direction for the correspondingdata. (a) northern domain, (b) central
domainexceptits southwestsector,(c) southwest sectorof the centraldomainexcludingthe areaof the Mina Vieja
samplinglocality,(d) areaof the Mina Vieja samplinglocality,(e) Comparison of fault strikesfor dextralstrike-slip
faultsthroughoutthe centraldomainwith thoseat the Mina Vieja locality. In Figure 3e and comparingFigure 3d
with 3c structuresin the Mina Vieja areaare revealedto be systematically
oriented350-40ø counterclockwise with
respectto the equivalentstructuresin the surroundingarea.
RANDALL ET AL.' FAULT-CONTROLLED ROTATIONS, PRECORDILLERA, CHILE 239
.,,/• Potrerillos
Cobre
Porphyryintrusion,
36 Ma
N •- Strike-slipfaults
-- -• --- Fault-bend
antidine
0 1 km
32-• Bedding
727' Cleavage
OIQM9-141Sam plinglocality
.....
'-'"•• Cerro
Valiente
Sequence
i:::.:::
•.::t Qda.
Mortardes
Fm.
........
':'• Pedernales
Fm.
i?,?,iiiiiiii;i!;;?•ii?,!ii
Qda.VicunitaSequence
':-:f:• Montandon/Asientos
Fms.
Figure 4. Geologicalmapof the Mina Vieja area. Units andsymbolsare the sameas thosein Figure2 exceptfor
those indicatedin the legend. Fault A, fault B, and the Bailey Willis Fault, on the north, south and west,
respectively,boundan area which containsbedding,fold, and fault orientationsthat are counterclockwise with
respectto thosein the surrounding area. The younger-on-olderrelationshipacrossthe northernpart of the Bailey
Willis Fault is the resultof incompleteEoceneinversionof a Paleocenenormalfault (A. Tomlinson,unpublished
data,1994). (Redrawnfrom Tomlinsonet al. [ 1999]).
reverse faults, and folds in the domain have strikes and trends NW faultsandcounterclockwise
rotations.Considering
the
of-10-25 ø (Figure 3a). (2)The Central domain is locatedat evidentimportanceof shorteningin the systemand the
the southernmost end of the fold-and-thrust belt and is a
sinistralslip senseof the NW faults, a clockwiserotationis
complex region of thrusting and folding associatedwith expected.The centraldomainis morecomplexin that it is
numerousdextralE-W strike-slipfaults. In this domain,the part of the fold-and-thrust belt and so could have
lower, easterly positioned thrust faults have decreasing counterclockwise rotationsbut also has a componentof
displacementsalong striketo the southwestand die into tip dextralE-W simpleshearing relatedto displacement
transfer
line folds or terminate in the eastern ends of dextral E-W
in the locus of shorteningand so could have clockwise
strike-slipfaultswhich transferthe thrustdisplacement to the rotations.
nexthigherandwesterlypositionedthrust. Otherthrustfaults
unite directly with higher thrusts. As a consequence, the 4. PaleomagneticSamplingand Analytical
shorteningon lower thrustsis progressively replacedto the Procedures
southwestby added movement on higher thrusts. In this
manner, the domain is interpretedto be a displacement Samplesfrom 66 siteswere collectedand analyzedfrom
transferzone in which shorteningacrossa broad zone in the the central and southern structural domains east of the SC-AA
northern domain is transferredto a few higher thrusts, Fault and from a small area abovethe Agua Amargathrust,
particularlythe Agua Amarga thrust. Over much of the west of the main trace of the SC-AA Fault (Figure 2).
central domain the regional structural features have Sampleswere collectedfrom the CerroValiente(Paleocene)
orientationsof 0300-045ø (Figure3b). In the southwestsector andQuebradaVicufiita(UpperJurassic)sequences and from
of the domain,where the higher reversefaults dominatethe the QuebradaMonardes(LowerCretaceous) andSierraFraga
shortening,the structuraltrends shift to a N-S orientation (Jurassic)Formations. The Cerro Valiente and Quebrada
(Figure3c), exceptin a-•2 x 2 km areanearMina Vieja where Vicufiita sequenceswere sampled from the southernand
the structurestrend350-40ø counterclockwise with respectto central domains. The Quebrada Monardes Formation was
thosein the surroundingarea (Figures3d, 3e, and 4). This sampledin the southerndomain and at Mina Vieja in the
observationled Cornejoet al. [1993] to predictthat this small central domain, where the structurestrend counterclockwise
block had experiencedcounterclockwise rotations.(3) The with respectto the equivalentstructuresin the surrounding
Southern domainis characterized by sinistralstrike-slipfaults area. The northerndomainwas not sampledbecauseof its
with a NW orientation.The NW trendingfaultswith greatest inaccessibility,
and only the SierraFragaFormationcould be
continuityand displacementoccurin the QuebradaCi•naga sampledfrom west of the SC-AA Fault(Figure2).
area(Figure 2) and connectthe southernend of reversefaults Natural reinanent magnetizations(NRM) were measured
in the central domain to NNE orientedhigh-anglereverse mainly using a Molspin MS2 or Geofyzika JR4 spinner
faultsin the La Coipaarea(Figure1). They are interpretedto magnetometer. A CCL cryogenic magnetometerwas also
represent another transfer zone [Cornejo et al., 1993]. usedfor someof the QuebradaMonardesFormationsamples.
Outsidethis transferzone the faulting is minor, and instead, Specimenswere stepwisedemagnetizedby thermal or two-
deformationis dominatedby shorteningrelated to the Agua axis tumblingalternatingfield (AF) methodsthroughat least
Amargathrust. 12 stepsuntil they becameunstable,or to 700øC or 100 mT,
Syntectonic andpost-tectonic intrusionsassociatedwith the respectively. During thermal demagnetization,bulk
faults indicatethat regional deformationwas initiated by 42 susceptibility was measured after each thermal
Ma, continueduntil at least 36 Ma, and ended by 32 Ma demagnetization
stepto detectheat-induced
mineralchanges.
[Tomlinsonet al., 1993; Mpodoziset al., 1994; Cornejoet al., Remanencedirections were determinedusing principal
1997]. The SC-AA Fault and associateddomainsdefine a componentanalysis[Kirschvink,1980]. Components were
wide deformation zone with structure orientations and definedby a minimumof three pointson vectorendpoint
kinematics consistent with development in response to diagramsand were consideredstable when they had a
sinistraltranspression where the SC-AA acted as the master maximum angular deviation (MAD) not exceeding15ø,
fault to the structuralsystem. In mosttypesof transpression, althoughin most casesthe observedMAD were < 10ø In
clockwiseand counterclockwiserotation of passivemarkers somecases,multiplemagneticcomponents with overlapping
of different orientationsare expected[Fossen and Tikoff, blocking or coercivity spectra required the use of
1998]. Folds formed at an angle to the masterfault rotate remagnetizationcirclescombinedwith endpoints[McFadden
toward it with progressivetranspression[Sandersonand and McElhinny, 1988] to isolatethe characteristic
remanent
Marchini, 1984; damison, 1991]; thereforecounterclockwise magnetization(ChRM). Mean directionsfor eachgeological
rotationsmay be anticipatedin the fold-and-thrust belt of the unit and samplinglocalitywere calculatedby combiningsite
northerndomain. In the southerndomain,if slip on the NW meandirections[Fisher, 1953].
faultsaccommodates rotation,thesefaultsand the intervening
blocks might rotate either clockwiseor counterclockwise 5. PaleomagneticResults
dependingon the relative importanceof the pure and simple
shearingcomponentsin the deformationhistory,with system- 5.1 Cerro Valiente Sequence(Paleocene)
perpendicular pure shearing(contraction)producingsinistral A total of 19 sites,mostlyorientedhand samples,were
slip on the NW faults and clockwiserotationsand system- collected and demagnetized from the Cerro Valiente
parallelsinistralsimpleshearinggeneratingdextralslip on the sequence,10 (CV 1-10) from the centraland 9 (CV 11-19)
RANDALL ET AL.: FAULT-CONTROLLED ROTATIONS, PRECORDILLERA, CHILE 241
a)
b) NN
CV14-1-1 ß
/••/•10
mT •670øC•qRM'••
•30 mT
'•-*
+*++***++++*
E, UP
ß ' ' 3(•0
,
c) N CV11-1-1
N.M
670oC 500
Figure5. Representative
orthogonal
andequal-area
projections
for samples
fromtheCerroValientesequence.In
orthogonal
plots,open(solid)circlesrepresent
vertical(horizontal)
projections;
intensities
are in mArn
'• On
stereoplots,
open(solid)circlesrepresentnegative(positive)inclinations.All plotsare showntilt corrected.
Table1. Results
FromtheCerroValienteSequence
a
Uncorrected Tilt Corrected
Site n/N Dec. Inc. TC Dec. Inc. k a95
Central Domain
CV1 b 5/6 232.9 64.4 210/43 271.7 33.0 18.6 19.5
CV2 5/5 206.0 48.9 121/35 241.9 41.0 1560.0 1.9
CV3 3/6 196.7 17.3 260/30 206.0 43.2 47.4 18.1
CV4 b 6/6 194.5 51.6 320/35 134.4 68.8 72.1 8.5
CV5 3/3 243.3 27.0 355/29 231.8 53.0 97.4 14.7
CV6 b 6/6 222.5 20.2 208/61 232.6 -2.2 51.8 9.4
CV7 6/6 303.9 55.0 090/77 213.2 29.7 72.6 8.5
CV8 5/7 8.4 6.0 251/46 14.6 -34.2 52.4 10.6
CV9 4/7 221.7 6.1 259/46 235.1 30.9 73.4 10.8
CV10 7/8 36.3 -28.4 330/8 40.7 -30.0 14.3 16.5
Mean IS 7/10 38.1 -28.7 5.1 29.5
Mean TC 40.1 -38.5 26.0 12.1
Southern Domain
CV11 6/6 24.0 -57.7 190/33 57.6 -39.7 26.6 13.2
CV12 6/6 19.9 -45.5 202/31 48.2 -38.7 56.3 9.0
CV13 6/6 356.3 -51.3 198/36 43.1 -50.1 54.4 9.2
CV14 6/6 16.3 -38.4 196/36 41.2 -30.0 207.5 4.7
CV15 6/6 357.0 -77.6 180/27 63.7 -61.1 271,.4 4.1
CV16 6/6 36.6 -52.3 226/10 49.7 -52.8 352.7 3.6
CV17 7/7 177.9 71.5 180/50 246.2 38.2 27.2 11.8
CV18 6/6 10.8 -49.3 180/50 45.9 -23.2 41.6 11.3
CV19 6/7 173.2 32.0 180/50 202.1 24.7 156.7 5.4
Mean IS 9/9 11.2 -53.6 22.7 11.0
Mean TC 47.5 -40.5 24.2 10.7
a Notationis as follows:n, the numberof samplescontributingto the mean;N, the total numberof demagnetized
samplesfor thesite;Dec. andInc., thedeclination
andinclinationof thesitemeanmagnetization vector(in degrees);TC,
thetilt correction,givenas strikeanddip;k anda95, the statisticalparameters
of Fisher[1953]. Mean IS is the in situ
mean direction and Mean TC is the tilt-corrected mean direction.
bIndicatessitesexcludedfrom the sitemeancalculation.
between 40 and 10% of its initial intensity and was the 5.2 Quebrada Monardes Formation (Lower Cretaceous)
preferredtreatmentmethodas manysamplesbrokeup when
heated. When a direction could be recovered from the
Twenty-foursiteswere collectedfrom the Quebrada
Monardes
Formation
(Figure2) asoriented
handsamples
and
hematitecomponent, it wasfoundto have'thesamedirection field-drilledcores. SitesQM1 to QM8 werecollectedfrom a
asthe componentcarriedby magnetite.
Of the 10 sites from the central domain, seven carry a
gentlySW plunging, openanticlinein thesouthof thestudy
consistent tilt-corrected direction, taken to be the ChRM,
areanearQuebradaCerrosBravos. SitesQM15 to QM24
were collectedfarthernorth,from a NW trendinganticlinein
directedto the NE with moderateinclinationor its antipode
(Table 1 and Figure 6). Three sites excludedfrom the Quebrada
Cignaga. Both of thesesamplinglocalitieslie
formation mean all have remanence directions that lie > 2cs within the southerndomainof NW trendingstrike-slipfaults.
awayfrom the ChRM aftertilt correction.The groupingof SitesQM9 to QM14 comefrom a 20 m plusthick section
the sevensitesis significantlybetteraftertilt correctionand withapproximately
constant
dipnearMinaVieja(Figure4) in
passesa fold test at the 99% confidencelevel [McElhinny, an areahavinganomalous
structural
trendsin the southwest
1964]. All nine sites from the southerndomaincarry a sectorof the centraldomain,aspreviouslydescribed.
ChRM, again directedto the NE with moderateupward The total NRM intensitiesfor thesered bed samplesrange
inclinationor, in two sites,its antipode(Table 1 and Figure between
0.5and187mAm
-•,withthemajority
< 50mAm
-•
6). The uniformityof the beddingcorrections meansthat a Demagnetization behaviorin the samplesis variableand
meaningfulfold test cannot be performedon this data. typicallymulticomponent
(Figures7a- 7d). In somecasesthe
Applicationof a reversaltest [McFaddenand McElhinny, components have overlappingblockingspectra(Figure7d),
1990]yieldsan indeterminate resultfor bothstudyareasat the andthe ChRM is onlyrecoveredas a linearsegmentin two or
95% confidencelevel, probablya consequence of the uneven three samplesfrom the site, while others only define
distributionof normal and reverse polarity sites at each remagnetizationcircles. When clearly isolated, low
samplinglocality. In both casesthe angle betweenthe unblocking temperature componentstendto be eitherpresent-
polarity groups is smaller in tilt-correctedthan in situ day field directions,interpretedas long-termVRM, or are
coordinates. dispersed,representing laboratory-induced
VRM. Despitethe
RANDALL ET AL.' FAULT-CONTROLLED ROTATIONS, PRECORDILLERA, CHILE :243
N N
a) Dec.= 40.1 +
Inc.= -38.5 ø
= 12.1o
+\ • I•e.:......• \
o•95
..:.:.:.• • •
Jr.- + + + + + + + • + + + + + + + +
+ +
/. • ,.....
%
•
,... 47.5II +
IDec.= o
•(b ",
,
• \ "-•"-"•
i,,o.___,0.,ol + \,.k,_•..:•¾
I_. _ 4rt.7ol• +
0 + 0
........ + ............ +
a) N,N
NRM
b)
NN
580øC
NRM
8
E,
5-5A
QMI-1
N
200øC
•600øC, :
E, UP
640øC
N
N
c) E, UP
QM2-1A
10øC
N..eRa
'"%.
NN N
A
I •_.o.o .O .
eoøc
;
Figure
7. Representative
o•hogonal
andequal-area
projections
forsamples
fromtheQuebrada
Monatales
Formation.
In o•hogonal
plots,
open(solid)
circles
represent
vertical
(horizontal)
projections;
intensities
arein
•']. Onstereoplots,
open(solid)
circles
represent
negative
(positive)
inclinations.
All plots
areshowntilt
corrected.
RANDALL ET AL.: FAULT-CONTROLLED ROTATIONS, PRECORDILLERA, CHILE 245
Table 2. ResultsFromtheQuebrada
MonardesFormation
a
Uncorrected Tilt Corrected
Site n/N Dec. Inc. TC Dec. Inc. k ix95
QuberadaCerrosBravosRegion
QM1 5/7 52.5 -34.5 090/10 47.8 -27.9 32.9 13.9
QM2 5/6 174.6 60.2 085/8 174.7 52.2 58.7 10.1
QM3 6/6 25.0 -35.5 121/12 25.7 -23.6 19.6 17.2
QM4 6/7 26.6 -35.1 126/10 27.5 -25.2 40.6 11.1
QM5 6/7 3.1 -60.4 155/12 18.1 -53.3 36.9 12.0
QM6 4/6 29.6 -52.7 173/15 41.8 -42.4 38.0 15.1
QM7 4/5 6.6 -27.9 230/26 22.0 -43.4 29.0 17.3
QM8 7/7 194.9 41.4 202/20 212.5 40.8 17.8 14.9
Mean IS 8/8 20.8 -44.7 20.4 12.5
Mean TC 27.8 -39.5 23.8 11.6
Mina Vieja Region
QM9 6/6 305.3 4.8 181/34 308.6 -23.0 34.1 12.1
QM10 6/6 309.9 -11.2 185/37 321.9 -39.7 14.0 18.9
QM11 7/7 315.7 -37.9 160/31 343.1 -44.0 44.4 9.2
QM12 4/5 325.4 -24.7 160/30 340.7 -28.5 22.6 22.8
QM13 6/6 304.0 -28.7 159/37 330.1 -43.3 45.7 10.0
QM14 3/4 309.7 -13.6 182/28 318.3 -34.7 79.1 14.0
Mean IS 6/6 311.5 - 18.7 23.5 14.1
Mean TC 326.6 -36.2 34.2 11.6
a Notation is as for Table 1.
N N
+ //
a) ,, t /
!
Dec.=27.6
øI
\ Inc.=-39.3ø• ...}_./
•,•s - 11.6ø• 4- "•--"
+
4- +
,,,..•/--'% Dec.=358.5
ø
b) CO,
'- 4,,• F-,.,,-4..
½•••O
•Inc.
=-47.8
+
ø ....O" •,• = 8.8ø
+ + + + 4- + + + 4- +
Jr- + + + + + + +
c)
remanence
aswell as inducedmagnetizations.As mostof the 6. Discussionand Interpretation
drilled samplesbroke up explosivelyon heating,high-
temperature
susceptibility
studiesof powderedsampleswere 6.1 Interpretation of the Mean Directions
moresuccessful
in confirmingthe high-coercivity
carrieras In the Cerro Valiente sequence,sevenof 10 sites in the
hematite. central and all nine sites from the southerndomain carry a
Visualinspection
of samplesfromthe QuebradaMonardes ChRM. The demagnetizationbehavior from this unit is
Formationshowsa rangeof redcoloration;
IRM experiments relatively simple, and the within-site variation is much less
werethereforeperformedon a broadrangeof samples, and than that observed in the other formations. Site directions
end-member examples areshownin Figure10. Thesamples from the central domain pass a fold test, indicating a
displaya mixtureof low- and high-coercivity carriersin prefolding remanence. Uniformity of the structural
varyingproportionsthat demagnetizeat-580 ø and 670øC, correctionsin the southerndomain prohibitsa meaningful
respectively,consistentwith a mixture of magnetiteand fold test. The inclination of the formation mean direction
hematitecarryingIRM andNRM. from the south is, however, much closer to that from the
RANDALL ET AL.: FAULT-CONTROLLED ROTATIONS, PRECORDILLERA, CHILE 247
800
i i i i i i i i i i
• 6o0
t• 4o0
i i i i i i i i i
.ø.9.
._•
,- 200
.
o•--•'7--? .......
o •o 2o 3o 4o so 60 7o 8o 9o •oo
% Unfo{d{ngl
Figure 9. Plot of precisionparameterk againstpercent
unfolding for the formation mean inclinations of the
QuebradaMonardesFormation. The plot demonstrates
the
improvedclusteringof the formationmean inclinationsafter
100% untilting,followingthe methodof McFaddenand Reid
[•982].
248 RANDALL ET AL.: FAULT-CONTROLLED ROTATIONS, PRECORDILLERA, CHILE
Some sites in the QuebradaVicufiita sequenceand Sierra amounts of rotation with, in most cases, insignificant
FragaFormationshowthe influenceof lightningstrikes. The latitudinal displacement(Table 5). Both formation mean
reason for the failure of other sites to yield reliable directions from the Cerro Valiente sequence indicate
paleomagneticdirectionsin theseJurassicunits is lesscertain. statistically significant southward latitudinal transport,
Thin sectionanalysisdid, however,revealpervasivealteration contraryto the insignificantshift suggestedby the Quebrada
of theserockswith a mineral assemblageconsistentwith the Monardes Formation data and the regional geologic and
effectsof hydrothermalfluids. paleomagnetic data sets, which indicate margin-parallel
transportin the centralAndes is negligible[e.g., Beck et al.,
6.2 Comparisonwith PaleomagneticReferenceDirections 1994; Randall, 1998]. This apparentinconsistency with the
The apparentpolarwanderpathfor SouthAmericaremains Paleocenedatamay resultfrom a problemwith the Paleogene
the subjectof muchdebateowingto the poor constraints on reference pole determination [Randall, 1998]. When
manyof the availablepoles[e.g., Beck, 1988, 1998; Randall, compared with other proposed reference poles for the
1998]. As the remanences recoveredin thisstudypredatethe Paleogeneor Paleocene[e.g., Beck, 1988;Butler et al., 1991;
Eocene folding and are regardedas primary, the Cerro Roperch and Carlief, 1992], the amount of latitudinal
Valiente sequenceand QuebradaMonardesFormationmean displacement is variable and sometimes statistically
directionsneedto be comparedwith Paleoceneand Early significant,suggestingthat the availablePaleocenereference
Cretaceouspoles,respectively. polesmay not be well determinedyet.
Comparison of the formation mean directions with The results from both localities in the Cerro Valiente
directions calculated from appropriatereference poles sequencereveal statisticallysignificant clockwise rotations.
[Randall,1998] clearlydemonstrates
significantandvariable Two of the three studiesin the QuebradaMonardesFormation
RANDALL
ETAL.'FAULT-CONTROLLED
ROTATIONS,
PRECORDILLERA,
CHILE 249
35O
ii
(:3 (:3
100 200 300 400 500 600 700
Applied
Field(roT) Temperature
(øC)
3OOO
IRM coercivity
QMll-3
Jmax=3.55 A
/ -m-50mT
•300mT
ß: 2000
E --•-800mT
o.5 1.o
• n,' 1000
o:::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::
0 100 200 300 400 500 600 700
Applied
Field(roT) Temperature
(øC)
Figure10.Isothermal
Remanent
Magnetization
(IRM)acquisition
anddemagnetization
curves
forsamples
from
theQuebrada
Monardes
Formation,
following
thetechnique
ofLowtie
[1990].
Applied
fields
areupto800mTand
areplotted
onalogscale.
Both
samplesindicate
amixture
ofmagnetite
andhematite
carriers
with(a)magnetite
dominantand(b) hematitedominant.
Table5. Calculation
ofRotation
andFlattening
a
Mean Direction
a)
vertical
dextral
strike-slipfaults
.•,••ault
bend
anticline
postrotationintrusionand
associated cleavage
Figure
13.Block
diagram
modeling
formation
ofthecounterclockwise
rotation
attheMina
Vieja
locality.
(a)
Inferred
prerotation
orientation
ofthestructures
inthearca.
(b)Impedance
ofthrust
displacement
onthenorth
but
downstepping
andcontinued
displacement
ofthethrustonthesouthresults
inrotation
ofthehanging
wallfault
bendanticline
andassociated
minorfaults.Afterrotation,
the36 Ma Potrerillos
Cobre
porphyry
intrusion
is
eraplaced
intothecoreoftheanticline,
andacleavage
forms
initscontact
aureole,
crosscutting
therotated
anticline.
to be recordedin the southerncentralAndes. Hartley et al. distinctdomainsof differing tectonicstyle, rotation amounts,
[1992b] report data from the Mejillones Peninsula which and rotation senses.
likewisesuggestcounterclockwise rotations. However, many Results from the southerndomain of sinistral strike-slip
of the site mean directionsare poorly determinedstatistically, faults demonstrate a decrease in clockwise rotation with
andthe rangeof rotationsamongsitesis so largethat they did increasingeastward distance from the master fault trace,
not calculate a mean for the formation or area. They irrespectiveof the age of the sampledunit. This is consistent
attributed the rotations to small-scale fault block rotations, with the rotationsbeingrelatedto activityof the SC-AA Fault.
with eachsite representingan independent recordof rotation. Furthermore,the clockwise senseof the rotationsis consistent
The Mina Vieja rotationis apparentlyhighlylocalized,and so with the structural style that indicates a dominance of
no inferencescan be drawn from this data about the large- shorteningover margin-parallelshear in the transpressive
scaletectonicsof the studiedareaor the tectonichistoryof the system. Sinceunits as youngas Paleoceneare affected,the
Andean margin, but it does serve to demonstratethe rotationsmustbe post-Paleocene in age. The resultfrom the
importanceof local tectonicsfor rotationsin the southcentral central domain likewise recordsa post-Paleoceneclockwise
Andes. rotation and is interpreted in terms of rotation due to
This is now one of several studiesin the Andean margin differentialmotionon thrustsheetsin a displacement transfer
wheredetailedpaleomagnetic samplingoversmallstructurally zone between the fold-and-thrust belt to the north and the N-S
well-constrainedareas has revealed complex patterns of trendingreversefaults, includingthe Agua Amargathrust,to
rotation. Other examplesfrom the ArgentinePuna [Aubryet the south. Sites collected from the Quebrada Monardes
al., 1996] and the Bolivian Altiplano [Butler et al., 1995] Formationin the Mina Vieja area recorda counterclockwise
havealso showntemporaland spatialvariabilityof rotations. rotationthat is highly localizedand interpretedas a resultof
Togethertheseintegratedstudieshighlightthe importanceof E-W sinistralsheardevelopedduring differential movement
localtectonicinfluenceson the observedrotationpatternsand of the underlyingthrust;the differentialmovementpossibly
demonstrate that an understandingof local structureis crucial being imposedby along-strikemechanicalheterogeneities in
to the interpretationof rotation data. Furthermore,care the block through which the thrust propagated. The
shouldbe taken when using paleomagneticdata to interpret counterclockwise rotation affects Eocene structures but not a
the large-scaletectonic evolution of the Andes and other cross-cuttingcleavage developed late in the deformation
tectonicallyactivemargins. history and associatedwith the 36 Ma Potrerillos Cobre
porphyry intrusion. These relations therefore bracket the
8. Conclusions timing of rotationto the Eocene.
Overall, the data highlight the importanceof localized
The presenceof dual magneticpolaritiesat four of the five tectonicsin controllingrotations,even wherethe rotationsare
samplinglocalities,a positiveinclination-onlyfold testin the the consequence of a single deformational event.
QuebradaMonardesFormation,and a positivefold test in the Furthermore,it underscoresthe significanceof relating
Cerro Valiente sequence indicates that all units carry a rotationsinterpretedfrom paleomagneticdata in terms of the
predeformational and probably primary remanence. structureandtectonichistoryof the samplinglocality.
Comparison with appropriate reference poles indicates
varyingamountsof rotationin the regioneastof the SC-AA Acknowledgments. Financial support for this project was
provided by a University of Plymouth studentshipto D.E.R.
Fault. The patternis too complexto be explainedby large- Paleomagneticresearch in Chile is supportedby NERC grant
scale tectonic rotation mechanisms alone, whether it be (GR3/11199) to G.K.T. Logisticalsupportfor the fieldwork was
oroclinalbendingor large-scaledomino-styleblock rotation. provided by the Servicio Nacional de Geologia y Mineria
The model proposedto explain the interpretedrotationsis (SERNAGEOMIN-Chile). We would like to thank Paula Comejo
and Antonio Diaz for their assistancein the field. Paleomagnetic
thereforeone of discrete,localized,in situ rotationsresulting analysiswas carriedout usingRandyEnkin's software.Constructive
from an Eocenesinistraltranspressive eventwhereinresponse reviewsby R. Butler,J. Kley, and P. Roperchhavehelpedimprove
to the transpressional
deformationis varied and forms several the manuscript.
References
Abels, A, and L. Bischoff, Clockwise block of South America, J. S. Am. Earth Sci , 1, 39- structures,transportd•rectionsand dune types
rotations •n northern Chile' Indicators for a 52, 1988 in Mesozmc aeolian sandstones,Atacama
large-scaledomino mechanismdunng the Beck, M E., Jr., On the mechamsmof crustal block region, Chile, Sedtmentology,38, 289-300,
middle-late Eocene, Geology, 27, 751-754, rotationsm the centralAndes, Tectonophysics, 1991
1999 299, 75-92, 1998 Butler,R F., F. Herv•, F Munizaga,M E BeckJr.,
Arddl, J, S Flint, G Chong, and H W•lke, Beck, ME, Jr., Paleomagnetm
recordof plate- RF Burroester, and E.S Oviedo,
Sequence stratigraphy of the Mesozoic margin tectomc processesalong the western Paleomagnetismof the ParagonJanPlateau
Domeyko basin, northernChile, J. Geol. Soc., edgeof North America,J. Geophys.Res., 85, basalts, southern Chile and Argentina, J.
155, 71-88, 1998 7115-7131, 1980. Geophys.Res., 96, 6023-6034, 1991
Aubry, L., P Roperch, M. de Urre•ztleta, E Beck, M.E., Jr., R F. Burroester,R E Drake, and Butler, R F, DR. Richards,T. Sempere,and L.G
Rossello,andA Chauv•n,Paleomagnetic study P.D. Riley, A tale of two continents Some Marshall, Paleomagnetic determinations of
alongthe southeasternborderof the Alhplano- tectonic contrasts between the central Andes vertical-ams tectomc rotations from Late
Puna plateau:Neogene tectonic rotahons,J. and the North American Cordillera, as Cretaceous and Paleocene strata of Bolivia,
Geophys.Res., 101, 17,883-17,899, 1996. •11ustratedby their paleomagnetms•gnatures, Geology,23, 799-802, 1995.
Beck, M.E, Jr Analysisof Late Jurassic-Recent Tectonics, 13, 215-224, 1994 Cornejo, P., C Mpodoz•s, C.F Ramirez, and A J
paleomagnet•cdata from achveplatemargins Bell, CM., The relahonship betweensedimentary Toml•nson,EstudioGeo16gicode la regi6n de
254 RANDALL ET AL.: FAULT-CONTROLLEDROTATIONS,PRECORDILLERA,CHILE
Potrerlllos y El Salvador (260-27ø Lat S), temperatureproperties,Geophys.Res.Lett., 17, Mesozoic rocks from the central Andes of
RegisteredRep. IR-93-01, 258 pp, 12 maps, 159-162, 1990. southernPeru' Importanceof rotationsin the
1:50,000 scale, Serv Nac de Geol y Miner., MacFadden,B J, F. Anaya, and C C. SwisherIII, development of the Bolivian orocline, J
Santiago,Chile, 1993. Neogene paleomagnetism and oroclinal Geophys.Res.,97, 17,233-17,249,1992.
Cornejo, P., R.M. Tosdal, C. Mpodozis, A J bending of the central Andes of Bolivia, d. Sanderson, D.J., and R.D Marchini,
Tomlinson, O. Rivera, and C.M Fanning, El Geophys.Res.,I00, 8153-8167, 1995. Transpression,J. Struct. Geol., 6, 449-458,
Salvador, Chile porphyry copper deposit Maksaev,V., and M Zentfili, Marco metalogemco 1984.
revisited: Geologic and geochronologlc regionalde los megadep6sitosde tlpo p6rfido Scheuber, E., and K.-J. Reutter, Magmatic arc
framework, Int. Geol. Rev., 39, 22-54, 1997. cuprifero del Norte Grande de Chile, in l/ tectonics In the central Andes between 21 ø and
Cornejo, P., C. Mpodozis, and A.J. Tomlinson, CongresoGeol6gicoCh•leno,Actas,pp. B181- 25øS, Tectonophyslcs, 205, 127-140, 1992
Hoja Salarde Maricunga,Regi6n de Atacama, B212, Unlv de Santiago, Santiago, Chile, Sepalveda,P, and J.A. Naranjo, Hoja Carrera
Mapas Geol. 7, 1'100,000 scale, Serv. Nac. de 1988 Pinto, Regi6n de Atacama, Carta Geol. de
Geol. y Miner, Santiago,Chile, 1998. Marsh, T M, M T Elnaudl, and M. McWllliams, Chile, 53, 1'100,000 scale,Serv Nac de Geol
Demarest, H H, Error analysis of the Ar4ø/Ar 39geochronology of Cu-AuandAu-Ag y Miner, Santiago,Chile, 1982.
determination of tectonic rotation from mlneralization m the Potrerillos district, Chile, Somoza, R S. Singer, and B. Coira,
paleomagneticdata, d. Geophys. Res., 88, Econ. Geol., 92, 784-806, 1997 Paleomagnetism of upperMiocene ignimbrites
4321-4328, 1983. McElhinny, M W., Statisticalsignificanceof the at the Puna: An analysis of vertical axis
Dewey, J.F., R.E. Holdsworth,and R A Strachan, fold test in palaeomagnetism, Geophys.d. R. rotationin the centralAndes,J. Geophys.Res.,
Transpression and transtension zones, •n Astron. Soc., 8, 338-340, 1964 I01, 11,387-11,400, 1996.
Continental Transpressional and McFadden, P L., and A.B. Reid, Analysis of Somoza, R., S Singer, and A J Tomlinson,
Transtensional Tectonics, edited by R.E. paleomagneticinclinationdata, Geophys.d. R. Paleomagneticstudy of Upper Miocene rocks
Holdsworth,R A. Strachan,and J.F Dewey, Astron. Soc., 69, 307-319, 1982. from northernChile Implicationsfor the origin
Geol.Soc.Spec.Publ., 135, 1-14, 1998. McFadden, P L., and M W. McElhlnny, of Late Miocene-Recent tectonic rotations In
Fisher,R A., Dispersionon a sphere,Proc. R. Soc. Classification of the reversal test in the southerncentral Andes, J. Geophys.Res,
London, Set. A, 217, 295-305, 1953 paleomagnetism,Geophys.d. Int., 103, 725- 104, 22,923-22,936, 1999
Forsythe,R.D, and L. Chisholm,Paleomagnetic 729, 1990. Sonder, L.J., P.C England, and G A Houseman,
and structural constraints on rotations In the McFadden, P L., and M.W. McElhlnny, The Continuum calculations of continental
northern Chilean coastal ranges, J. S. Am. combinedanalysis of remagnetlsationcircles deformation In transcurrent environments, J.
Earth Scl., 7, 279-294, 1994 and direct observationsIn palaeomagnetism, Geophys.Res.,91, 4797-4810, 1986.
Fossen, H., and B. Tlkoff, Extended models of Earth Planet. Scl. Lett., 87, 161-172, 1988. Sufirez,M., and C M, Bell, Sabkhascontinentales
transpresslon and transtension,and application Mpodozis, C, and V.A. Ramos, The Andes of y costrerosen el Tnfisico Supenor-Cretficico
to tectonic settings, in Continental Chile and Argentina,In Geologyof the Andes Inferior de Atacama, Chile, Rev. Geol. Chile,
Transpressional and TranstensionalTectonics, and Its Relation to Hydrocarbon and Mineral 24, 145-153, 1985.
editedby R E Holdsworth,R A Strachan,and Resources,edited by G.E Ericksen,M.T Carlas Taylor, G.K., J. Grocott, A. Pope, and D.E
J F. Dewey,Geol. Soc,Spec.Publ., 135, 15-33, Pinochet and J.A Reinemund, Earth Sci. Randall, Mesozoic fault systems,deformation
1998. Ser.,vol 11, pp 59-90, Circum-PaclfiC Council and fault block rotation in the Andean forearc
Garcia,F, Geologicadel Notre Grande de Chile, for Energyand Miner Resourc.,Houston,Tex., A crustalscalestrike-slipduplexin the Coastal
Sympostum sobre el GeosinclinalAndino, vol. 1989. Cordillera of northernChile, Tectonophysics,
3, 138 pp, Soc Geol de Chile., Santiago, Mpodozis,C, N Marlnovlc, and I. Smoje,Eocene 299, 93-109, 1998.
Chile, 1967. left lateral strike-slip faulting and clockwise Tomllnson, A.J., Relaciones entre el p6rfido
Hamngton, H, Geology of parts of Antofagasta block rotations in the Cordillera de Domeyko, cuprifero y la falla lnversa de la Mina de
and Atacama provinces of northern Chile, west of Salar de Atacama, northern Chile, in Potrenllos' Un caso de intrus•6n sintect6mca,
AAPG Bull., 45, 169-197, 1961. 2nd International Symposium on Andean in VII CongresoGeol6gtcoCh#eno,Actas,pp
Hartley,A J, P. Turner,G. Williams, and S Flint, Geodynamics, pp. 225-228, t•ditionsde 1629-1633, Univ de Concepci6n,Concepci6n,
Paleomagnet•sm of the Cordillerade la Costa, I'ORSTOM, Colloques et Semlnaires, Paris, Chile, 1994.
northern Chile: Evidence for local forearc 1993 Tomllnson,A., C Mpodozis, P Cornejo,and C
rotation, Earth Planet Sci. Lett., 89, 375-386, Mpodozis,C AJ Tomlmson,and P Cornejo, Ramirez, Structural geology of the Sierra
1988. Aceradel'controlestructural de intrusivos Castillo-Agua Amarga Fault System,
Hartley, A.J., E.J. Jolley, and P Turner, eocenosy p6rfidos cupriferosen la region de Precordilleraof Chile, El Salvador-Potrenllos,
Paleomagneticevidence for rotation in the Potrerillos-El Salvador, in I/II Congreso in 2"a Internanonal Symposium, on Andean
Precordillera of northern Chile Structural Geo16gtcoChtleno, Actas, vol. 2, pp 1596- Geodynamtcs, pp. 259-262, Editions de
constraintsand implications for the evolution 1600, Univ. de Concepci6n, Concepci6n, I'ORSTOM, Colloques et Seminalres, Paris,
of the Andean forearc, Tectonophysics, 205, Chile, 1994. 1993.
49-64, 1992a. Nelson,M.R, and C.H Jones,PaleomagnetlsmTomlinson,A J, P Cornejo,and C Mpodozis,
Hartley, A J, P Turner, DC Rex, and S Flint, and crustal rotations along a shear zone, Las Hoja Potrenllos, Regi6n de Atacama, Mapas
Palaeomagnetic, geochronological and Vegas Range, southern Nevada, Tectonics,6, Geol., 14, 1'100,000 scale,Serv.Nac. de Geol
geologicalconstraintson the tectonicevolution 13-33, 1987. y Miner, Santiago,Chile, 1999
of the Mejlllones Peninsula, northern Chile, Nlemeyer, H, Nuevos datos cinemfiticospara la
Geol. J., 27, 59-74, 1992b. Falla Sierra Castillo en Quebradadel Carrlzo, D E Randall, The EnvironmentAgency,
Isacks,B L, Uplift of the central Andean plateau Precordillerade la Regl6n de Atacama,Chile, ManleyHouse,KestrelWay, Sowton,Exeter,EX2
and bending of the Bolivian oroclme, J. Rev Geol. Chile, 26, 159-174, 1999. 7LQ, UK (darrenrandall•envlronment-
Geophys.Res.,93, 3211-3231, 1988 Randall, D E, A new Jurassic-Recentapparent agencygov uk)
Jamlson,W R, Kinematicsof compressional fold polar wander path for South America and a G. K. Taylor, Deptartment
of Geological
developmentin convergentwrench terranes, review of central Andean tectonic models, Sciences,Universityof Plymouth,Drake Circus,
Tectonophysics, 190, 209-232, 1991 Tectonophysics, 299, 49-74, 1998. Plymouth, PL4 8AA, UK
Klrschvink, J L, The least-squareline and plane Randall, D.E, G K Taylor, and J Grocott, Major (GTaylor•Plymouthac uk)
and the analysis of paleomagnetlc data, crustal rotations in the Andean margin A J. Tomllnson
Geophys. J. R Astron.Soc.,62, 699-718, 1980 Paleomagnetlc results from the Coastal Serviclo Nacional de Geologia y Mlneria,
Kley, J, Transition from basement-involved to Cordilleraof northernChile, J Geophys Res, Avenida Santa Maria 0104, Santiago, Chile
thin-skinned thrusting in the Cordillera 101, 15,783-15,798, 1996. (atomllns•sernageomln.cl)
Oriental of southern Bolivia, Tectomcs, 15, Reyes,M, Mina Potrerlllos,uneditedreport,Div
763-775, 1996 El Salvador,Corp. Nac Del Cobre, Santiago, (ReceivedNovember24, 1999,
Lowrle, W Identification of ferromagnetic Chile, 1981 revisedJuly24, 2000,
mineralsin a rockby coercivityandunblocking Roperch, P., and G. Carllet, Paleomagnetismof acceptedDecember1,2000 )