Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Images haven’t loaded yet. Please exit printing, wait for images to load, and try to
Dan Hill Follow
print again.
Designer, urbanist, etc. Associate Director, Arup, London. Visiting professor at UCL Bartlett;
Adjunct professor at RMIT. cityofsound.com, Dezeen, Strelka &c.
Oct 3, 2015 · 10 min read
The tools, as well as a huge chunk of the value, may be shifting from
buildings and hard infrastructure to services and experiences — like
Uber, Lyft, Bridj noted here, and this essay focuses more on transport,
compared to SQM’s focus on Airbnb — hence at least some part of
architectural practice needs to move on from having buildings as the
only output. The answer to every urban question cannot always be a
building, clearly. Whilst buildings may be part of some solutions, there
are broader, deeper questions in play — good architects see this, but the
practice (from education up) is still not exploring this implied question
broadly enough. That’s what this piece is probing away at, using
technology as one way of opening that up.
https://medium.com/butwhatwasthequestion/urban-parasites-data-driven-urbanism-and-the-case-for-architecture-e773d4069d64 1/8
20/03/2018 Urban parasites, data-driven urbanism and the case for architecture
https://medium.com/butwhatwasthequestion/urban-parasites-data-driven-urbanism-and-the-case-for-architecture-e773d4069d64 2/8
20/03/2018 Urban parasites, data-driven urbanism and the case for architecture
By altering the way the city performs, the way it is experienced, the
way it is constructed and enacted, our sense of the city changes,
without radically altering its physical built fabric. 20th century
architecture was largely concerned with the latter, across numerous
philosophical and practical movements. So what happens to
architecture when meaningful changes to the city don’t rely on
architecture’s traditional vehicle — the building?
The signi cant cultural cachet associated with that Roark-ian 20th
century mode has long lost its lustre either way. The architect, limited
by an inability to create and drive new business models or modus
operandi beyond eliciting design fees for each building, has ended up in
an abusive relationship with the construction industry. It’s a long way
from being the master builder. Like some other mid-century modern
design trades — such as furniture design, for instance — it is
increasingly sidelined by the currently-rampant technology sector,
whose propulsive drive is characterised by Marc Andreessen’s
statement: “software is eating the world.” As Kazys Varnelis has said
“technology is our modernity”; the substitution of trades associated
with prior versions of modernity (e.g., architecture, furniture,
interiors) with those of contemporary modernity (e.g. code) is nearing
completion.
https://medium.com/butwhatwasthequestion/urban-parasites-data-driven-urbanism-and-the-case-for-architecture-e773d4069d64 3/8
20/03/2018 Urban parasites, data-driven urbanism and the case for architecture
Services like AirBnB use software to enable an entirely new model for
accommodating travelers. They now list more rooms than the Hilton
hotel chain, all extracted from the existing urban fabric; hotel rooms
we didn’t know were hotel rooms, wheedled out of previously inert
space. It took Hilton 110 years to build their empire, hotel by hotel,
brick by brick; AirBnB have enabled more rooms in roughly six years,
without building anything except code. (Imagine how annoying that is
for the Hilton chain.)
https://medium.com/butwhatwasthequestion/urban-parasites-data-driven-urbanism-and-the-case-for-architecture-e773d4069d64 4/8
20/03/2018 Urban parasites, data-driven urbanism and the case for architecture
All these ‘urban parasites’ revolve around a clear and often consistent
set of ideas, centred on uncovering and exploiting resource ine ciency
via data, allied to an individualistic ‘user pays’ funding principle, hyper-
convenience and quality user experiences. Software turns urban
ine ciencies (i.e., the ‘redundancy’ of unused parked cars, unoccupied
rooms, waiting bus queues, etc) into the basis of new services–ones that
change our perception of the city, its responsiveness and malleability.
While there are few distinctly urban philosophies at the heart of these
services–they work in cities, because that’s where ine ciencies can be
most pro tably scaled–there are, nonetheless, distinct ideologies. They
often exemplify what Richard Barbrook and Andy Cameron called ‘The
Californian Ideology’ (1995).
https://medium.com/butwhatwasthequestion/urban-parasites-data-driven-urbanism-and-the-case-for-architecture-e773d4069d64 5/8
20/03/2018 Urban parasites, data-driven urbanism and the case for architecture
Writers like Adam Green eld have powerfully warned against these
often veiled ideologies, as well as the political and ethical shortcomings
underpinning the wide variety of services bundled under the ‘smart
city’ banner. Alexandra Lange has written convincingly “against civic
crowd funding”, noting that “making something big happen at an urban
scale is more than a popularity contest.” Bryan Boyer notes that “the big
innovations of Silicon Valley are not technical but social (and) as Uber
and others who are developing social innovations wrapped in
technology have discovered, the technical challenges of building an app
are either matched or dwarfed by the social, political, and legal issues.”
Not only would engaging with these issues be a way out of the the
aforementioned abusive relationship with the construction industry,
and the concomitant self-pitying navel-gazing, but it would position the
architect at the heart of contemporary decision-making about the city
once again, rather than being shunted to the margins of building.
https://medium.com/butwhatwasthequestion/urban-parasites-data-driven-urbanism-and-the-case-for-architecture-e773d4069d64 6/8
20/03/2018 Urban parasites, data-driven urbanism and the case for architecture
. . .
https://medium.com/butwhatwasthequestion/urban-parasites-data-driven-urbanism-and-the-case-for-architecture-e773d4069d64 7/8
20/03/2018 Urban parasites, data-driven urbanism and the case for architecture
https://medium.com/butwhatwasthequestion/urban-parasites-data-driven-urbanism-and-the-case-for-architecture-e773d4069d64 8/8