Matthew Janzen I From: Matthew Janzen Sent: Friday, May 04, 2018 10:54 AM To: Blake Nakamura Subject: Convietion Integrity Case State v. David Eugene Hawkins (061402321) DA 06020088 Blake, have reviewed all the materials you provided me regarding this conviction integrity question. Upon my review, | see the conviction as sound and the present recantation by victim and his brother to be suspect. The CIC interviews appear to me to be honest recitations from memory of actual events made in age appropriate language. There appears to be no evidence of coaching by anyone, especially his brother. The victim and witness brother's events were consistent throughout the court proceedings. There was also information that the original disclosure remained consistent in therapy sessions, although we did not have the therapy records. In contrast, there Is troubling information regarding family pressure being placed upon Jeremy and Nathan to presently recant there statements. Jeremy and Nathan’s explanation that then 13 year old Jeremy convinced 9 year Nathan to allege abuse inerely because he was upset with his father has greater inconsistencies than the original disclosure. Hopefully this will be of help to you in your evaluation of the case. Matthew B. Janzen Deputy Distct Attorney Salt Lake District Attorney's Office 235 Eest 500 South Salt Lake City, UT 84114 Tel. (385) 468-7630 Muanzen@sieo.org This email and all attachments contain confidential information protected by the Electronic Communleations Privacy At, 18 U;S.C. 2510-2521, tha unlawful interception sulting in eriminal fines, mpzisorment, andlor civil damages. Furthermore, this email and all attachments are ArtorNey Work Proouct andior LEGALLY PRIVLEGED and CONFIDENTIAL INFORMATION intended only forthe use of the person(s) named therein. Ifyou are not the intended recipien, you are legally prohibited from retaining, viewing, using, copying, dlstrbuting or otherwise disclosing ths information in any manner. Please reply tothe sender that you have recoived this, ‘communication in eror and then immediatoly delete this message from your computer. Thank you.