Professional Documents
Culture Documents
The original letters AL received from the Bash Cars plc was a
request for information and did not amount to offers to purchase
filters from Al ( Harvey v Facey) ( 1893). The first was made by
AL when he wrote to both Bash Cars plc stating his terms of
supply. Bash Cars plc was at liberty to accept Al’s offer to supply
the 1000 filter at 50 each and thus enter into a binding contract,
which AL would have had to perform and stand liable to pay
damages for any breach of the contract. However, Bash cars plc
did not accept the original offer, stating that it was only willing to
pay 45 per filter. That letter amounted to counter offer, this made
AL the offeree rather than the offeror, as he originally been. The
effect of such counter offers was to destroy AL original offer, so
that it could no longer be accepted (Hyde v Wrench 1940) without
further negotiations. Al’s next letter restating his original terms
represented a further counter offer to the companies own counter
offer. That letters restored AL to his position as the offeror with
Bash Cars reassuming the role offerees, who could accept or reject
the terms as it wished.