Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ISSN: 2456-9992
Abstract: The city of Abuja is blessed with rich tradition of creative modelling because of the availability of the modelling medium i.e
clay. The introduction of plastercine a modern creative modelling medium of instruction, posed challenges to the students over the
traditional medium. Therefore this study examines the comparative effectiveness of modern and indigenous creative modelling instructional
media (clay and plastercine) on the junior secondary creative arts education in Abuja, Nigeria. Gender influence on students’ performances
was also examined. Three questions were raised and three hypotheses were tested using Analysis of Covariance. The study adopted quasi
experimental design, of pre-test and post-test non-randomized control group. Sample comprised of 90 students drawn from three Junior
Secondary Schools. Researchers’ designed instruments of Clay-Plastercine Performance Test (CPPT), Clay substances and Plastercine
material were treatment and test instruments. Finding indicated that there is no significant difference between the performance of students
taught with clay and plastercine. Student gender was also not a factor in students’ performance. Therefore, the recommendation was made
that clay and plastercine should be encouraged for teaching creative modelling in Nigerian Junior Secondary Schools context.
Key words: Clay, Clay-Plastercine Performance Test, Gender, Modelling and Plastercine,
INTRODUCTION modelling is used for study of snakes and birds. Also, for
Modelling is the act of producing 2 or 3 dimensional creating artificial animals and eggs that serve as prey. In
object from malleable substances. Modelling features the same vein, modelling promotes effortless way of
prominently in Creative arts, Science and Technology. It teaching and learning of industrial and mechanical tools.
performs religion, aesthetic, decorative and educative In essence, it is useful for crafts in creative and visual arts
functions. The most known medium for modelling is clay. (Golomb, 1989; Kridli & Orady, 2003; Moore &
Clay is a natural resource from the earth surface that are of Robinson 2004). Modelling brings into reality household,
two types; the primary and secondary. The primary clay is decorations and kitchen utensils (Ibrahim-Banjoko, 2009).
called kaolin found at the site of formation and the A technique of developing and creating educational
secondary clay is a composition of particle of rock, material, tools and equipment in Mechanical Engineering
minerals, decayed plants and animals. The clay features (Abdullah, Muda & Samad 2008). Biological Sciences
are of different colours, this depends on the colour at site. creates lizards with mode on imitation of the habitat
Clay have the chemical formula as A1203-2S03-2H20. The selection (Steffen, 2009). Studies in Ecology, employed
modelling with clay start from clay collection, modelling in forming reptile and amphibian (Harper and
preparation, preservation, designing, production and Pfennig 2007), salamanders, and toads (Saporito 2007;
exhibition. Clay modelling is important and it is utilised in Noonan & Comeault 2009). Productions of different signs,
production of many things for example literature punctuation marks, numerals and alphabets in different
confirmed that Clay is even employed in the designing languages for educational purposes (Marshall & David,
and producing car prototype. (Casson 1977; Sorby, & 2005). In essence, Clay and plastercine modelling
Veurink, 2010; Mathide 2014; Ogboji & Igbokwe 2014; provides teaching and learning material for both children
Ogboji & Igbokwe 2014; Usman, Odewumi, Obotuke, and adult. Students creates modelling objects in clay and
Apolola, & Ogunyinka, 2014; Odewumi , Okeke, plastercine which elicits happiness regardless of their
Abdulhammed, Uzoma, Okuche, 2015). Plasticine is a impairment (Marshall 2003; Tomascoff 2004; Warwick,
modern modelling media, that has the components of wax- 2005 & Jaramillo, 2008). On Gender and modelling,
based, calcium salts, principally calcium carbonate, studies stressed that female students frequently respond to
petroleum Jelly. A long chain of aliphatic acid, added the ads by introducing their personality attribute to
resulting a very soft, plastic, for the easy modelling. The modelling. Women modelling works shows facts of
plastercine is characterised of gradual drying process, this woman exhibiting characteristics like hairdo, Jewries;
uniqueness make it distinct and differ from other earrings and necklaces (Freedman 1994; Andersson &
modelling educative media (Brodie, 1993; Vazquez, Andersson 2009). Girls and boys were free to engage in
Sweeney, Wallace, Wolff, Ober & Altan, 1996; Kothar forming different 3 dimensional modelling objects from
and Luckham 2014; Obasuyi, 2016) Studies confirmed clay, but the craft is mostly consider to be that of male
that modelling is used in educating learners. For example, than female, whereas, female are producer of modelling
objects from clay for domestic uses (Trinity Session
Volume 2 Issue 4, April 2018 27
www.ijarp.org
International Journal of Advanced Research and Publications
ISSN: 2456-9992
2003). The female, act of modelling assist greatly in class two (JSS II) students in the Federal Capital Territory,
forming the basis for anatomy studies, it also provides a Abuja. Nigeria. Purposive sampling was utilised to select
foundation for learning, because this enabled them to three school for study. A total number of ninety Junior
visualised human body structure and features and how it Secondary Students II (Two) in Abuja Metropolis was
all look like (Monsour, 2011). The development of two or sampled and they were total thirty students in each group
more educative packages and comparison of their which consisted of fifteen male and fifteen female. The
effectiveness has been reporting to improvement, speeds criteria for selection of the schools and the students were
up learning rate, enhances better retention, and encourages based on the following; Schools that have being exposed
the development of better attitude in learners. According to 9-year Basic Education Curriculum Examination
to Alabi, Emmanuel, and Falode, (2015) study on the (BECE) and having presenting candidates for creative arts
effects of videodisc mediated and computer assisted examination for the past (10) ten years. Schools with
instructional packages on achievement of Junior qualified instructors handling effectively creative arts
Secondary School Mathematics students in Geometry in curriculum, and the availability and accessibility of
Minna, Nigeria. The findings showed that videodisc Creative arts studio with electric and manual potter wheel.
mediated instructional package performed significantly The selection of the creative arts students was done
better than the Computer Assisted Instructional packages randomly from the schools purposively chosen schools.
and the control group, while there is no significant The experimental groups’ for the study were group I (one)
difference in the mean achievement of male and female. and II (two) which were exposed to through team teaching
However, the extent to which the comparative of Modelling with both technology of Platercine and Clay
effectiveness of indigenous and modern modelling from the researcher and the resource personnel
technology of instruction enhance learning on Junior respectively. In the same vein, the control group was
Secondary Students in Nigeria, is still unknown. The taught with conventional teaching method from a qualified
study therefore investigated the comparative effectiveness creative arts teacher with appropriate modelling materials
of modern and indigenous instructional modelling media and tools. The main instruments of study were the Clay
on the on Junior Secondary Students in Abuja. The study and the Plastercine, these were employed for modelling of
also examined the performances of junior secondary different functional objects. The topic for the study were
school students taught modelling with technology of extracted from the Junior Secondary School Curriculum
Plastercine, Clay and those taught with conventional produced by the Federal Ministry of Education through
method. the Nigeria Educational Research and Development
Council (NEDEC) for Junior Secondary Schools in
Research Question Nigeria. Therefore, the topics for the study were;
The study will answer the following question: Definition of clay, Sources of clay, Clay preparation,
1. Is there any difference in the students’ scores Modelling tools and modelling of functional objects. On
when they are taught with Modelling using the teaching guide, relevant textbooks, internet and
Plastercine and Clay and those taught with experienced creative personnel were contacted to come up
Conventional method of teaching. with a course wear on the given topics. The test
2. Is there any difference between the scores of instrument was the researcher designed Clay and
male and female students taught with Modelling Plastercine Academic Performance Test (CPAPT), which
using Plastercine. were twenty-five (25) multiple choice objective items,
3. What is the difference between the scores of male meant to determined a specific learning outcomes in
and female students taught with Modelling using relating to the topic and concept of the study. The data for
Clay? testing the hypotheses were the learners scores obtained
from the test administered, based on the learners
Research Hypotheses performance in pre-test, that is before the treatment and
These hypotheses were tested at 0.05 level of significance the post-test which was after the treatment. The treatment
in the study: in the study lasted for twelve periods of six weeks through
H01: There is no significant difference in the students’ teaching on both theory and practical with plastercine and
scores when they are taught with modelling clay on the specified topics. Learners were later engaged
instruction using Plastercine and Clay. with summative test of post-test on usual paper pencil
H02: There is no significant difference between the method. Clay and Plastercine Academic Performance Test
scores of male and female students’ exposed to (CPAPT) was pilot tested and found to satisfy the content,
modelling instruction using Plastercine. face and construct validity by a lecturer, specialised in
H03: There is no significant difference between the Test Measurement and Evaluation in the Faculty of
scores of male and female students’ when they Education, Obafemi Awolowo University Ile-Ife, a
are exposed to modelling instruction using Clay. lecturer of Educational Technology with knowledge of
Creative and Visual arts at Department of Educational
Methodology technology University of Ilorin, Nigeria. In the same vein,
The research designed utilised for this study was the quasi items analysis of the study instrument was also carried out
experimental. This consists of the pre-test and post-test, purposely to determine the facility and discrimination
non-randomized of the control group. This study consisted indices, after which the final items for the instrument were
of three specific groups, divided into I, II and III, which selected. For the reliability of the study instrument, the
are exposed to modelling technology of instruction with instruments were administered to twenty students that
Plastercine, Clay and the conventional method. The were out of the study, in another Junior Secondary School,
sample for this study was all Junior Secondary School, in a town in South-west Nigeria. The reliability coefficient
[2] S. O. Abiodun, , T. E. Akinde, “Transfer as a [14] S. R. Justi, K. J. Gilbert, “Modelling, teachers’ views
alternative to direct drawing in Yoruba hand built on the nature of modelling, and implications for the
pottery,” International Journal of African Culture education of modellers,” International Journal.
and Ideas,14 (1&2), pp.169-186. 2014. Science Education, 24 (4), pp. 369-387, 2002.
[3] T. O. Alabi, O. Emmanuel, , C. O. Falode, “Effects [15] C Kothar, P. F. Luckham, “Modelling, Simulation of
of videodisc mediated and computer assisted Visco-Elastic Plastic Behaviour for Soft-Solids by
instructional packages on achievement of junior CONE Indenters. International Journal of Innovative
secondary school mathematics Students in geometry Research in Science, Engineering and Technology,
in Minna, Nigeria,” Journal of science, technology, 3(10), pp. 1624-16432, 2014.
mathematics and education (JOSTMED), 11(3), pp.
224-231, 2015. [16] A. Marshall, D. Davis Brain function spell reading
and sweep-sweep-spell, 2005. Dyslexa Association
[4] P. P. Ambose, L. S. Cheong. “Effect of the clay International. Retrieved from
modelling program on the reading behaviour of http://www.dyslexia.com [accessed: August 12th
children with dyslexia: A Malaysian Case Study.” 2015].
The Asia Pacific Education Researcher, 20 (3),123-
132, pp. 2011. [17] Marshall, “Brain scan shows dyslexa reader better
than with alternative strategies Davis. 2003, Dyslexa
[5] I Andersson, S. B. Andersson, “Aesthetic Association International. [Online] Available:
representations among Himba people in Namibia,” http://www.dyslexa.com [Accessed:12th August
International Art in Early Childhood Research, 1(1), 2015].
pp. 1-14, 2009.
[18] Mathide, “Modelling clay and mouldable plastic for
[6] K. Antonishen, “The use of clay sculpting as a prototyping. 2014, Available:
method of learning about muscles in an introductory http://www.makingsocietycommodellingclay
human anatomy course,” International conference on [Accessed: 23rd of August 2015].
the future of education 4th edition. Pp. 1-3, 2011.
[19] R. P. Moore, W. D. Robinson, “Artificial bird nests,
[7] K. Antonishen (), “The use of clay sculpting as a external validity, and bias in ecological field
method of learning about muscles in an introductory studies,” Ecology, 85(6), pp. 1562-1567. (2004).
human anatomy course. International conference on
the future of education 4th edition. Pp. 35-40, 2011. [20] Noonan, A. Comeault, “The role of predator
selection on polymorphic aposematic poison frogs,”
[8] M. Casson, “The craft of the potter: a practical guide Biology Letters, 5(1), pp. 51-54, 2009.
to making pottery,” London, British Broadcasting
Corporation, for mimicry of Pacific newts, 1977.
Volume 2 Issue 4, April 2018 31
www.ijarp.org
International Journal of Advanced Research and Publications
ISSN: 2456-9992