You are on page 1of 7

Evaluating the root causes of rubber molding

defects through virtual molding


by Matt Proske and Harshal Bhogesra, Sigma Plastic Services PI (proportional integral) controller or on/off settings, type and
thickness of insulation plates, platen heater and the molding
Injection (and transfer) molding of elastomers is a complex process, as previously described. Virtual molding will auto-
operation. It may not seem very complicated, but when you matically calculate heat flow through all the mold components,
look into the details, it really is. The combination of material, and the heat lost from the cavities due to radiation, while the
process, mold design and molding machine capabilities is mold is open. It will also show why the mold will need to be
among the primary ingredients for this “stew” of sorts. Every shut down after 50 cycles because it is losing too much heat
new mold, however, is like making a new stew; it might not from insufficient heaters and insulation.
turn out the way you planned. Then there is a big pot of bad This does not mean part design evaluations are not possible,
stew that nobody wants, customers that are hungry, and you are or that they are not valuable. It simply means that in order to
back to the drawing board to figure out what did not work out replicate what happens in production, more information is re-
as planned and how to fix it. Was it the carrots or the store I quired. In order to know how much pressure is required to fill
bought them from? Was it the temperature or the time? Let us the cavity in a controlled way, temperature and shear rate de-
face it, we have been making stew for 4,000 years and rubber pendent viscosity information, actual local mold temperature
parts for a little more than 100. We do not have 4,000 years to information, and a realistic 3D representation of the mold, part
develop recipes for every possible combination of molded and runner are all required. The difference here is that virtual
product. In this article, we explore a different way to evaluate molding software is developed specifically for this approach,
molding problems to help unlock some of the mystery behind and traditional flow simulation software is not. For example, if
these secret recipes for quality molded elastomers. a mold has two different mold inserts, one made of P20 steel
Virtual molding is a unique approach to molding simulation and another made of MoldMax HH (ref. 1), they will both ab-
technology which combines the most relevant molding aspects sorb and dissipate heat at different rates, which is calculated
so they can interact in a simulation together as they do in live during the virtual molding simulation, as are the effects on the
production. Temperature, time and shear rate dependent elasto- curing reaction. Not only one molding cycle, but multiple
mer material properties, thermo-physical mold, insert and insu- molding cycles, are calculated to match the real world molding.
lation properties, electrical heaters, wattage and thermocouple This distinction is very important.
location(s) comprise the complete injection molding process. A virtual molding analysis either uses existing CAD for the
Fill speed, pressure limit, melt temperature, thermocouple set mold/parts/runner, or they can be created inside the software if
point temperatures, mold opening and closing times, and post they are not available. Typically, .step assembly files are used,
curing processes are all critical pieces of information used by but other file types such as .STL or .SAT are also possible, as
the simulation for the virtual molding production. Combining are some native formats. Once CAD is imported, the entire as-
all of the inputs in one model allows for a comprehensive sembly is automatically converted into millions of calculation
evaluation of potential production issues. The following ques- points for the multi-physics software to compute the continu-
tions are answered in this article: ously changing environment. This process is often referred to
• What is virtual molding? as “meshing” (ref. 2) (figure 1). These millions of calculation
• How does it work? points are populated throughout all the components of the mold
• What inputs are required?
• What do the outputs (results) look like?
• Which problems can be evaluated? Figure 1 - geometry of the mold before
The first important question is: Did the simulation results meshing (l), and after meshing (r)
come from a part design evaluation (emulation), or did they
Part
come from a virtual molding simulation? Readers beware: A Gate
part design evaluation typically only consists of some basic Movable mold
material properties, a part geometry and a gate location. The 318 Ejector pin
validity of the results based on this approach in a production
environment is skeptical at best. There is just not enough infor-
mation for the results to reflect what happens in a molding
machine. Virtual molding, on the other hand, is a fully coupled -318
212 Z (mm)
318
3D heat and fluid flow program capable of simulating a real Y(mm)
production trial, including how the mold is preheated and what -106
-212
process is used for the first 5, 10 or 100 production cycles. It
requires runner geometry, mold components, BOM (bill of X
materials), electrical heater wattages, thermocouple locations, Y Z

20 RUBBERWORLD.COM

12RW - 20,21,22,23,24,25,26.indd 20 3:36:13 PM


in seconds. Each calculation point is contained by an element the cavity, which means certain areas fill much earlier than oth-
which contains initial information, such as specific volume, ers. When this happens, the local pressure of the early filled
material type and starting temperature (depending on what areas goes too high and the mold flashes anyway. This typi-
geometric domain it is part of). cally results in a process which requires the machine to slow the
Prior to starting the simulation, the molding process must be injection speed as the cavity fills to avoid generating this high
described. It is broken into two distinct sections, including pre- local pressure. This can make it difficult to fill the other areas
heating and production. The preheating phase starts the mold at of the cavity. Accurate mold temperature plays a significant
room temperature and activates the electrical heaters based on role in the ability to properly understand what will happen. Will
the thermocouple locations. Each heating zone is controlled in- the rest of the part fill and without scorch? This is why virtual
dependently. Once the integrated PI controller finds a solution for molding considers the complete mold and multiple consecutive
how much wattage each heater will require to maintain the set molding cycles. The mold temperature is always changing, and
point temperature, the simulation can proceed to the production mold temperature during the first cycle is quite different from
phase. This phase consists of previously described process infor- the mold temperature after the 100th cycle. Also, if the mold
mation, as well as any post molding curing process information cavity temperatures are evaluated at the 100th cycle, it will not
(if applicable). The same molding process can be repeated over be the same everywhere. Certain areas will be cold at the same
and over again, or the production cycles can be interrupted, the time other areas are hot. So in every cycle, heat is exchanged
process changed and further production cycles calculated. between the mold, parts, heaters and other components. All of
These two steps assure that the thermal gradient of the mold these heat flow calculations are occurring simultaneously, and
is accurately established. If there is a problem getting the mold these hot and cold spots inside the mold will lead to uneven or
up to the desired temperature or keeping it there, the heaters uncontrolled curing of the rubber part. Some areas will cure
will run at full power and the mold temperature will decline, faster, while other areas will cure slower, depending on the
just as it can in reality. The result will be a mold running cold local temperature of the mold surface in contact with each area
and uncured parts when the mold opens. It is also possible to of the part. The late areas of curing will increase the cycle time,
prescribe the best locations for thermocouples and to identify reduce the quality of the parts or even require a post molding
where higher or lower wattage heaters are needed. Different curing process to cure completely. As one can see, injection
thickness insulation plates or blankets can also be evaluated. It molding elastomers is actually a very complex process.
is clear that mold temperature is not only critical for curing, but While the virtual molding simulation is in process, various
also for filling. Therefore, the questions arise: Is the mold tem- graphs like mold temperature versus time, or heater power
perature under control, or does it just exist and we find a way versus time, are available (figures 2a and 2b). This information
to make production despite this lack of control?
Once the mold is up to temperature, the cold rubber flows
into it. The rubber temperature rises due to its interaction with Figure 2a - mold temperature versus time
the higher temperature mold and shear heating. Shear heating is
249
a phenomenon where internal friction within the rubber, while it 248
Temperature (C)

is flowing, creates heat and locally reduces the melt viscosity. 247
This can affect how much pressure is required to fill the runner 246
and cavity, and can create unexpected filling patterns. If the rub- 245
ber temperature rises too much, either due to shear heating or 244
243
mold temperature, it can begin to cure during cavity filling. This 242
creates problems with mechanical strength because crosslinking
14,000
2,000

4,000

6,000

10,000
0

8,000

12,000
progressed too far for the material to bond sufficiently with
other merging melt fronts. This is typically referred to as scorch.
If the rubber cures too much during filling, the viscosity will Time (seconds)
rise and some areas may not fill properly. This can also be related
to trapped air in the cavity and poor venting. Trapped air can
produce bubbles, burn marks, non-fill or poor mechanical proper- Figure 2b - heater power versus time
ties. Venting must be properly located and properly sized. When
Relative power
air is trapped, the air volume decreases due to encroaching higher 2,000
pressure rubber. As the air pocket volume decreases, its tempera- 1,600
Power (watts)

ture rises. If too much air was trapped, the air pressure will be- 1,200
come so high that the air temperature will rise above the burning 800
temperature of the rubber, and voila, a burn mark is created. 400
Filling pattern and melt pressure are critical to a robust pro- 0
cess. We must have enough machine pressure to fill the cavity,
14,000
2,000

4,000

6,000

10,000
0

8,000

12,000

but enough clamp force to keep the mold closed at the same
time. If not, the fill pressure must be reduced so the mold does
not flash (as much). In some cases, the filling is not balanced in Time (seconds)

FOLLOW US ON TWITTER @rubberworld 21

12RW - 20,21,22,23,24,25,26.indd 21 3:36:13 PM


Figure 3 - jetting inside part cavities

Temperature Temperature
(°C) (°C)
161.1 139.2
Empty Empty
128.0
160.0
153.6 120.6
147.1 113.3
140.7 105.9
134.3 98.6
127.9 91.2
121.4 83.9
115.0
108.6 76.5
102.1 69.2
95.7 61.8
89.3 54.5
82.9 47.1
76.4 39.8
70.0 ShinEtsu optical lense 32.4 Z
Z Filling, temperature Y
98.66 25.1
X 1.028s, 13.01%
Y 25.05 X

provides important insights to process engineers about poten- high velocity or low viscosity (or a combination) of the flowing
tial problems related to temperature control of the mold. Know- polymer. Jetting can create trapped air, but the most common
ing if there are enough heaters, proper thermocouple locations problem is that it leads to uncontrolled filling susceptible to
or appropriate insulation for the mold is a powerful position to small process or material changes.
be in before the mold is even built. Trapped air also creates certain challenges. Initially, it ends
Once the mold is brought up to temperature, the production up in the final part, which is, of course, the problem. The chal-
cycles begin. If the mold continues to lose heat during the pro- lenge is finding out where it came from and how to get rid of
duction cycles, even when all the heaters are operating at it. Figure 4 shows where contamination from air is located in
maximum power, it is a clear sign the mold needs more (or the part. The user scale displays the percent concentration of
higher wattage) heaters or insulation. From these graphs, we air. Red areas have higher concentrations.
can clearly visualize this would be a production issue. Solving Was the air trapped in the nearby rib because the melt
this issue in a real mold is an expensive ordeal. A new heating flowed too quickly below the rib and encapsulated the air? Or
system must be designed in an existing mold. Retrofitting maybe the venting was not sufficient, and the air pressure in the
molds like this is never optimum because there are already so cavity was just too high? Actually, it was not either of these.
many constraints regarding the existing design. This may be
combined with more effective insulation around the mold, but
this can also be accomplished virtually. Figure 4 - contamination from air inside
There can also be a wide variety of filling related issues the part
commonly found in injection molded elastomers. Each image
contains a color scale (user scale) at the right side of the mold- Air
ed product. Values always decrease from top (red) to bottom entrapment
(%)
(blue). Colors in the molded product correspond to values in 88.79
the user scale. Empty
10.00
Figure 3 shows the filling of a thick-walled cylindrical part 9.29
with two small gates on the top surface (left), and a thin-walled 8.57
7.86
part gated with an optical grade LSR (right). Both scales represent 7.14
temperature to show heat exchange differences between thick and 6.43
5.71
thin walled parts. No real heat exchange occurs in the thick part 5.00
because the rubber does not yet have contact to the walls com- 4.29
3.57
pared to the thin part where the thermal gradient is stronger. 2.86
Melt “jets” into the cavity because the melt does not engage 2.14
Z 1.43
with the surface of either the mold or the insert, so it does not Y 0.71
slow down. Rather, it enters the cavity and travels through the X 0.00
0.01
part to the opposite side. This behavior can also be attributed to

22 RUBBERWORLD.COM

12RW - 20,21,22,23,24,25,26.indd 22 3:36:16 PM


Figure 5 - progression of melt with trapped air inside the part

Air Air
entrapment (%) entrapment (%)
99.27 98.68
Empty Empty
10.00 10.00
9.29 9.29
8.57 8.57
7.86 7.86
7.14 7.14
6.43 6.43
5.71 5.71
5.00 5.00
4.29 4.29
3.57 3.57
2.86 2.86
2.14 2.14
1.43 1.43
0.71 0.71
0.00 0.00
Z Z
Y 0.01 Y 0.01
X X

Air Air
entrapment (%) entrapment (%)
94.81 89.20
Empty Empty
10.00 10.00
9.29 9.29
8.57 8.57
7.86 7.86
7.14 7.14
6.43 6.43
5.71 5.71
5.00 5.00
4.29 4.29
3.57 3.57
2.86 2.86
2.14 2.14
1.43 1.43
0.71 0.71
Z 0.00 Z 0.00
Y Y
X 0.01 X 0.01

The second series of images (figure 5) shows where it came tricky to nail down (figure 6). The user scale represents veloc-
from. Providing clarity of the root cause of molding issues ity to identify which areas are moving faster than others. Near
makes virtual molding not only a predictive tool, but a teaching the end of the fill, the red areas indicate highest velocity to-
tool. wards the unfilled cavities. Once the prematurely filled cavities
The highest concentration of air (shown in red) was initially are full, all of the incoming melt is directed towards the unfilled
trapped inside the ribs at the gated side of the part. Now, vir- cavities, resulting in higher velocity. This image was taken
tual molding becomes a communication tool to show others when the cavity is 96% filled, and we observe that the center
exactly what they need to see. This elastomer part has adequate four cavities are completely filled, while the remaining four
venting around the parting line. But the image shows that cavities are still unfilled, even when the flow length for all of
sometimes, even when we have adequate venting, it may not be them is the same.
sufficient to allow all of the air to escape through the vents, The mold is hotter at the center, so the steel swells more and
depending on the filling pattern. the runners are bigger (unlikely), or the mold temperature is
In this example, air contaminates the rubber and becomes higher and it affects the viscosity (getting warmer); actually, the
trapped inside the part due to its filling pattern. It does not even viscosity is affected by the local shear rate the rubber experi-
reach the parting line where the vents are located. In this case, ences. When rubber flows faster at one specific location than
the part design or the gate location should be changed, if pos- the location immediately next to it (figure 7), there is a shear
sible, in order to get all the air out of the cavity. Another option rate difference. The higher the shear rate, the greater the fric-
might be to include vented ejector pins at the base of the ribs. tional heat and the larger the effect on viscosity.
Virtual molding allows such variants to be modeled and com- The issue is that the viscosity is not affected uniformly ev-
pared. erywhere; it is only affecting the material at the higher shear
Filling imbalances in a multi-cavity runner system can be rate. This creates a problem that lower viscosity material flows

FOLLOW US ON TWITTER @rubberworld 23

12RW - 20,21,22,23,24,25,26.indd 23 2/22/2017 3:36:18 PM


Figure 6 - filling Imbalances inside an Figure 8 - areas with higher and lower
eight-cavity tool scorch inside the part

Unbalanced velocity Absolute velocity Scorch


cm/s 0.3013 (-)
65.65 Empty
Empty 0.2800
21.00 0.2600
19.50 0.2400
18.00 0.2200
16.50
15.00 0.2000
13.50 0.1800
12.00 0.1600
10.50 0.1400
9.00 0.1200
7.50
6.00 0.1000
4.50 0.0800
3.00 0.0600
1.50
0.00 Z 0.0400
X 0.0200
Y
Z 7.547e-007 0.0000
X Y 1.535e-007

more easily under pressure, so the low viscosity areas flow higher and lower scorch using virtual molding, as shown in
faster and filling imbalances are created. If the imbalance is big figure 8.
enough, some cavities will fill too early, resulting in high pres- The user scale for scorch value is set to 2%, meaning the
sure and potential flashing at those cavities. Again, the process scale result of 1 shows the curing degree of 2% or more is fully
would require slowing the injection speed towards the end of achieved. Yellow areas indicate a higher degree of scorch (or
filling, possibly resulting in unfilled cavities. These issues can premature crosslinking). Scorch values can be lower if the mold
only be fixed if they are quantifiably understood. I would not temperatures are reduced, or if the material is sheared less.
attempt to trial and error my way through this kind of issue. I Weld lines are created where the two melt flow fronts meet
did once, many years ago, and that left a terrible taste in my inside the part. Computer-generated tracer particles are auto-
mouth; worst stew ever. matically deposited as each weld line is formed (figure 9). The
Scorch results show how much material is cured during fill- user scale displays temperature to convey the melt front tem-
ing. In the rubber molding industry, sometimes the gate dimen- peratures when they engage. These tracer particles aid in visu-
sions are reduced in order to initiate high shear during filling. alizing what is happening behind the flow front or beneath the
Due to increased shearing, the polymer temperature will rise, surface skin. They are used during the filling, packing/holding
which will ultimately jumpstart the curing of the material dur- and curing phase to evaluate the molding conditions, such as
ing the filling process. It is easier to identify the areas with mixing polymer, stagnation or re-direction of the polymer flow

Figure 7 - differences in temperature and viscosity inside the runner system

Temperature Low Temperature High Dyn. visc.


(°C) Viscosity
(Pa·s)
164.8 1.767c-004
Empty Empty
135.0 12.500
133.2 12,143
131.4 11,786
129.6 11,429
127.9 11,071
126.1 10,714
124.3 10,357
122.5 10,000
120.7 9,643
118.9 9,285
117.1 8,929
115.4 8,571
113.6 8,214
111.8 7,857
Y 110.0 Y 7,500
High Z X 100 Low Z X 2,538

24 RUBBERWORLD.COM

12RW - 20,21,22,23,24,25,26.indd 24 3:36:19 PM


Figure 9 - tracer particles deposited at Figure 11 - non-uniform temperature
the weld line gradient in the metal insert

Temperature (°C) Insert temperature rise Temperature


180 (°C)
138.5
160.0 Empty
155.0 124.0
150.0 118.0
145.0 112.0
140.0 106.0
135.0 100.0
130.0 94.0
125.0 88.0
120.0 82.0
115.0 76.0
110.0 70.0
105.0 64.0
Z 100.0 58.0
X 95.0
Z 52.0
90.0 46.0
Y Y X
40.0
85.55
60.97

through the weld line regions.


Tracer particles not only show the location of the weld lines, thickness. From the outside surface, the parts are fully cured,
but also provide specific information to determine if they will but inside the core of the wall thickness, they are still uncured.
be comparatively strong or weak. Important parameters such as In order to cure these parts completely, they might need to be
the temperature, curing degree, pressure, contact angle and placed inside an oven after molding. Secondary curing is also
velocity at which the flow fronts meet are considered by the fully coupled to the production phase and simulated in virtual
weld line strength results. This information is used to determine molding. Decisions can be made very early in the design about
how effectively the flow fronts will fuse together during the whether or not we prefer to have a longer cure cycle, higher
molding process. mold temperature or a post ejection curing process. The virtual
Figure 10 displays the curing degree inside the part when molding “oven” is also calculating the curing progression with
the mold opens at the end of the molding cycle. The user scale respect to time and temperature. The curing state is monitored
represents curing degree in percent. Orange and red areas have to calculate production rate and energy cost prior to building
achieved a higher degree of cure (90-95%) compared to the the mold.
blue areas (25%). Part of a comprehensive virtual molding environment in-
The parts are sliced to visualize the inside core of the wall cludes the ability to consider over-molded inserts placed into
the cavity during each cycle. These inserts are ejected with the
part and often used to provide higher mechanical properties.
Figure 10 - curing degree inside the part The metal inserts can be preheated or placed into the mold at
at ejection ambient temperature. Once placed, the insert exchanges heat
with the mold at a rate defined by their different temperatures,
Percent cured (%) thermo physical properties and amount of surface contact.
95.34 However, the heat exchange is not uniform (figure 11). The
Empty user scale displays temperature and is used to convey the mes-
95.00 sage that the insert is not always the same temperature every-
90.00 where due to thermal exchange that occurs between the insert
85.00
80.00 and the mold/part.
75.00 On the surfaces in contact, there is heat transfer from con-
70.00
65.00 duction, but the exposed surfaces exchange heat with the envi-
60.00 ronment through radiation. This non-uniform temperature also
55.00 produces non-uniform expansion, and it can lead to potential
50.00
45.00 shut-off or other dimensional issues. Over-molded inserts can
40.00 distort, depending on pressure during filling or due to a non-
Z 35.00
X uniform shrinkage of the rubber that occurs during the curing
30.00
25.00 and cooling process (figure 12). The user scale shows displace-
Y 0.0004138 ment from the original insert shape in mm. Original shape ap-
pears transparent for reference.

FOLLOW US ON TWITTER @rubberworld 25

12RW - 20,21,22,23,24,25,26.indd 25 3:36:20 PM


Figure 12 - distortion of the metal insert Figure 13 - part at 50% filled (l); core pin
deflection during filling (r)
Total displacement (mm)
0.3605 Pressure (bar) Displacement X
Empty (mm)
103.2
0.3605 Empty 0.0000218
0.3356 Empty
103.2 +0.0002
0.3106 95.9 -0.0227
0.2857 88.6 -0.0457
81.3 -0.0686
0.2607 74.0 -0.0916
0.2358 66.7 -0.1145
59.4 -0.1374
0.2108 52.1 -0.1604
0.1858 44.8 -0.1833
0.1609 37.5 -0.2063
30.2 -0.2292
0.1359 22.9 -0.2522
0.1110 15.6 -0.2751
8.3 -0.2980
0.0860 1.0 -0.3210
Y 0.0611 1
0.0361 Z Z -0.321
X
0.0111 Y Y
X X
Z 0.01115

While measuring these material properties, it is also impor-


It also results from the insert design not having enough tant to capture the data to cover the entire processing range for
strength to withstand this pressure from the rubber part. Time the particular elastomer. If the material will be processed at
in contact also plays an important role in the thermal exchange 120°F, then rheology should be measured at 100, 120 and
between insert(s) and mold, especially if multiple inserts need 140°F to cover material behavior at, above and below the initial
to be placed, one at a time. This produces significant variation temperature. If the mold will operate at 350°F, then curing de-
and should be avoided. gree curves should be measured at 330, 350 and 370°F.
Deflection of core pins during filling due to high pressure Various models are provided to fit the material data inside
imbalances are also difficult to quantifiably prove and fix. the virtual molding database. Rheology models include Cross-
When the melt pressure on one side of a core pin is higher than Arrhenius, Carreau WLF, Carreau Yasuda WLF and interpo-
the other side, there is a potential for the pin to bend. If it will, lated viscosity. For reaction kinetics, common models are
it is because the pin does not have the mechanical strength to Kamal and Deng-Isayev. Similarly, various models are includ-
resist the net pressure. ed for fitting the PVT, for curing shrinkage calculations (ref. 3),
Having a material database of temperature dependent ther- and reactive viscosity data.
mo-physical and mechanical properties of a wide variety of Overall, virtual molding is a completely different approach
mold materials makes these calculations possible. If the pin will to understanding injection molded elastomers because the en-
bend, the filling pattern will need to change to reduce the pres- tire mold, material properties and process are fully coupled and
sure imbalance (figure 13). The user scales represent melt pres- calculated over multiple consecutive molding cycles to match
sure (1) during filling and resulting core pin deflection (r) in the real world production environment. Automatic meshing
mm. The deflection is magnified for clarity. and process specific user interfaces support such comprehen-
Material data for the mold, inserts, insulation, heaters, and a sive calculations.
variety of polymers and elastomers, are already present in the Various tools like x-ray, clipping, scale, zoom, rotate,
virtual molding database. However, many, if not most, elasto- etc., can be used to visualize, evaluate and communicate the
mers are custom materials whose properties can be measured molding issues and the root causes for quantifiable solu-
through a material testing laboratory. tions. The examples shown clearly identify multiple poten-
Temperature, pressure, shear rate and time dependent prop- tial elastomer molding issues and some potential solutions.
erties are required for the virtual molding simulation, and these Virtual molding is a unique approach which makes produc-
properties include thermal conductivity, specific heat capacity, tion visible.
rheology, pressure volume temperature (PVT) curves and cur-
ing kinetics. References
All types of elastomers are possible, including natural rub- 1. Virtual Molding: http://www.virtualmolding.us/.
ber (NR), nitrile rubber (NBR), hydrogenated nitrile butadiene 2. https://materion.com/Products/Alloys/MoldMAX-Alloys/In-
rubber (HNBR), fluoroelastomer (FKM), ethylene propylene jection-Molding.aspx.
diene monomer rubber (EPDM), styrene-butadiene rubber 3. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/224453190_Com-
(SBR) or liquid silicone rubber (LSR). It is imperative to have prehensive_material_characterization_of_organic_packag-
accurate material data in order to achieve accurate results. ing_materials.

26 RUBBERWORLD.COM

12RW - 20,21,22,23,24,25,26.indd 26 3:36:21 PM

You might also like