Professional Documents
Culture Documents
INCEPTION REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS) for
Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
APRIL 2011
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
Table of Contents
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
4.2.5 Mumbai Metropolitan Region Development Authority .................................. 4-6
4.2.6 Greater London Authority................................................................................ 4-8
4.2.7 Greater Toronto Area..................................................................................... 4-13
4.3 Key Points and Insights .................................................................................................. 4-21
4.3.1 Visions and Mission Statements .................................................................... 4-21
5. KEY ASPECTS NEEDING EARLY DEBATE AND RESOLUTION ................................................. 5-1
5.1 Overview of Population Growth...................................................................................... 5-1
5.2 A Picture of Future Transport .......................................................................................... 5-3
5.3 Potential Future Higher Order Transit Corridors............................................................. 5-4
5.3.1 Current Status .................................................................................................. 5-4
6. STUDY AREA AND STRATEGIC TRAFFIC ZONING ................................................................ 6-1
6.1 Study Area Definition ...................................................................................................... 6-1
6.2 Strategic Decisions and View........................................................................................... 6-1
6.3 Strategic Traffic Zoning Scheme ...................................................................................... 6-1
6.4 Principles towards Evolving the TAZs .............................................................................. 6-2
7. DEVELOPMENT OF IMMEDIATE ACTION PLAN (IAP) .......................................................... 7-1
7.1 Purpose – Pilot Efforts ..................................................................................................... 7-1
7.2 Focus and Approach ........................................................................................................ 7-2
7.2.1 Data Collection/ Analysis and Interpretation .................................................. 7-2
7.2.2 Analysis of Traffic Data and Accident Data ...................................................... 7-4
7.2.3 Develop Alternative Solutions/Plans ............................................................... 7-4
7.2.4 Stakeholder Consultations on Improvement Plans and Feedback .................. 7-5
7.2.5 Prepare and Submit Field Survey Report ......................................................... 7-6
7.2.6 Develop and Submit Immediate Action Plan ................................................... 7-6
7.3 Potential Intersections .................................................................................................... 7-6
7.4 Alternative Corridor Development .................................................................................. 7-7
7.5 Area Level Traffic Improvement .................................................................................... 7-11
8. COLLECT AND UPDATE THE DATA ..................................................................................... 8-1
8.1 Home Interview Survey ................................................................................................... 8-1
8.1.1 Demographic Distribution................................................................................ 8-1
8.1.2 Sampling Frame ............................................................................................... 8-2
8.1.3 Selection of Sample Household ....................................................................... 8-5
8.1.4 HIS Format........................................................................................................ 8-6
8.1.5 Training and Quality Assurance ....................................................................... 8-6
8.1.6 Monitoring Productivity ................................................................................... 8-8
8.2 Base Mapping .................................................................................................................. 8-8
8.3 Field Surveys .................................................................................................................. 8-10
8.3.1 Network and Speed........................................................................................ 8-10
8.3.2 Traffic Surveys ................................................................................................ 8-11
8.3.3 Transport Systems’ Assessment .................................................................... 8-14
8.3.4 User Surveys................................................................................................... 8-16
8.3.5 Goods Focal Point Survey............................................................................... 8-16
8.3.6 Other Past Data Compilation ......................................................................... 8-17
8.3.7 Proposed Field Survey Program ..................................................................... 8-17
II
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
9. URBAN TRANSPORT PLANNING MODEL ........................................................................... 9-1
9.1 Background...................................................................................................................... 9-1
9.2 Defining Modeling Domain.............................................................................................. 9-2
9.2.1 Attributes of Travel Demand ........................................................................... 9-3
9.2.2 Components of Travel Demand ....................................................................... 9-3
9.2.3 Spatial Extent of Travel .................................................................................... 9-3
9.2.4 Measures / Attributes of Travel Demand Generators ..................................... 9-3
9.2.5 Network & Transport System Characteristics .................................................. 9-4
9.3 Development Plans.......................................................................................................... 9-4
9.4 Land Use Parameters....................................................................................................... 9-5
9.4.1 Type of Land Use .............................................................................................. 9-5
9.4.2 Quantifying Land Use ....................................................................................... 9-5
9.5 Types of Models and likely application ........................................................................... 9-5
9.6 Transportation Models for HMA ..................................................................................... 9-7
9.6.1 Transportation Networks ................................................................................. 9-9
9.6.2 Time Periods .................................................................................................. 9-12
9.6.3 Trip Purposes ................................................................................................. 9-12
9.6.4 Household Characteristics Sub-Models ......................................................... 9-13
9.6.5 Destination Choice / Trip Distribution Model (DC/TDM)............................... 9-16
9.6.6 Mode Choice Model (MCM) .......................................................................... 9-16
9.6.7 External Trip Model (XTM) ............................................................................. 9-19
9.6.8 Goods Vehicle Model (GVM) ......................................................................... 9-20
9.6.9 Matrix Manipulation Sub-Model (MMSM) .................................................... 9-21
9.6.10 Trip Assignment Model (TAM) ....................................................................... 9-21
9.6.11 Model Validation............................................................................................ 9-22
9.7 Adopted EMME3 Software ............................................................................................ 9-23
10. LONG TERM TRANSPORT STRATEGY ............................................................................... 10-1
10.1 Focus.............................................................................................................................. 10-1
10.2 Components and Approach........................................................................................... 10-2
11. RESOURCE MOBILIZATION ............................................................................................. 11-1
11.1 Focus and Need ............................................................................................................. 11-1
11.2 Potential Sources ........................................................................................................... 11-1
11.2.1 Intergovernmental Transfers ......................................................................... 11-2
11.2.2 Local Revenues............................................................................................... 11-2
11.2.3 Private Investments ....................................................................................... 11-3
11.2.4 Borrowings ..................................................................................................... 11-3
11.3 Approach and Next Steps .............................................................................................. 11-3
12. INSTITUTIONAL DEVELOPMENT ..................................................................................... 12-1
12.1 Background.................................................................................................................... 12-1
12.2 Unified Metropolitan Transport Authority (UMTA) ...................................................... 12-1
12.2.1 Hyderabad UMTA........................................................................................... 12-2
12.2.2 International Experience ................................................................................ 12-2
12.3 Institutional Development ............................................................................................ 12-4
13. MEDIUM AND SHORT TERM INVESTMENT PROGRAM .................................................... 13-1
III
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
13.1 Introduction................................................................................................................... 13-1
13.2 Prioritization Parameters .............................................................................................. 13-1
13.3 Evolving Investment Program ....................................................................................... 13-2
14. SKILL AND KNOWLEDGE TRANSFER ................................................................................ 14-1
14.1 Focus.............................................................................................................................. 14-1
14.2 Levels of Training and Elements .................................................................................... 14-1
14.3 Incumbents .................................................................................................................... 14-3
14.4 Training Co-ordination .................................................................................................. 14-3
15. STUDY PROGRESS AND MONITORING THE OUTCOMES ................................................... 15-1
15.1 Study Progress ............................................................................................................... 15-1
15.2 Consultant’s Project Management Framework ............................................................ 15-1
16. FACILITATION AND ADVICE NEEDED ............................................................................... 16-1
16.1 Facilitation and Access to Information .......................................................................... 16-1
16.2 Feedback and Timely Advice ......................................................................................... 16-2
List of Tables
Table 2-1: Components of Hyderabad Metropolitan Development Area (HMDA) ............................. 2-1
Table 3-1: Population of Hyderabad (1901 – 2001) ............................................................................. 3-1
Table 3-2: Spatial Distribution of Population in HMA (1981- 2001) .................................................... 3-2
Table 3-3: Spatial Densities of population in HMA (1981 – 2001) ....................................................... 3-3
Table 3-4: Slum Population in GHMC................................................................................................... 3-3
Table 3-5: Occupational structure in HMDA – 2001 ............................................................................ 3-4
Table 3-6: Growth Trend of Motor Vehicles in Hyderabad ............................................................... 3-12
Table 6-1: Possible Range of TAZs in HMA........................................................................................... 6-3
Table 7-1: Proposed Junctions for Intersection Improvements in IAP ................................................ 7-7
Table 8-1: Spatial Distribution of Population in HMA (1981- 2001) .................................................... 8-2
Table 8-2: Spatial Distribution of HHs in HMA (Year 2001) ................................................................. 8-2
Table 8-3: Proposed number of sample households by various Constituents of Study Area ............. 8-5
Table 8-4: The Key Vector / Data layers Proposed to be digitized ...................................................... 8-9
Table 8-5: Road Categories for VDF ................................................................................................... 8-11
Table 8-6: Quantum of TVC / O-D / Occupancy Survey along OC / IC / SLs / Mid-Blocks.................. 8-12
Table 8-7: List of Intersection Proposed to be Surveyed ................................................................... 8-13
Table 8-8: Number of Traffic Volume Count Survey Locations
(Mid-Block under various Past Studies .............................................................................................. 8-17
Table 8-9: Field Survey Programme ................................................................................................... 8-18
Table 11-1: Per Capita Investment Cost by Sector............................................................................. 11-1
Table 11-2: Potential Sources of Funds for Urban Transport Infrastructure ..................................... 11-2
Table 13-1: A Typical Investment Plan (for illustration) .................................................................... 13-3
IV
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
List of Figures
Figure 2-1: Study Area.......................................................................................................................... 2-1
Figure 2-2: Growth Rates of population During 1991 - 2001 in Surrounding Municipalities of MCH2-3
Figure 2-3: Proposed Growth Centres in Erstwhile HUDA ................................................................... 2-3
Figure 2-4: Location of Road/Rail/ Air Terminal - Regional ................................................................. 2-7
Figure 2-5: Overall Approach of the Study .......................................................................................... 2-9
Figure 3-1: Stages of Development of Hyderabad ............................................................................... 3-1
Figure 3-2: Population Densities in HMA ............................................................................................. 3-3
Figure 3-3: Proposed Locations of the Employment centres in HUDA ................................................ 3-6
Figure 3-4: Existing Modal Splits .......................................................................................................... 3-7
Figure 3-5: Map Showing MMTS Phase-I in Hyderabad Urban Area .................................................. 3-8
Figure 3-6: Transportation Network in Hyderabad............................................................................ 3-10
Figure 3-7: Accident Statistics of Hyderabad and Cyberabad............................................................ 3-11
Figure 4-1: Revised Master Plan for Core Area (Erstwhile MCH Area) of GHMC dated 27.01.2010 ... 4-4
Figure 4-2: Greater London Authority & Transport for London .......................................................... 4-8
Figure 4-3: Government Structure in Greater Toronto Area ............................................................. 4-13
Figure 4-4: Downtown Toronto ......................................................................................................... 4-14
Figure 5-1: Base Population Forecast in Million .................................................................................. 5-1
Figure 6-1: Study Area and Traffic Zoning Scheme .............................................................................. 6-4
Figure 7-1: General Approach and Methodology for Preparation of IAP ............................................ 7-1
Figure 7-2: Intersections/ Corridors/ Area recommended for IAP .................................................... 7-16
Figure 8-1: Various Jurisdictions within Metropolitan Area of Hyderabad ......................................... 8-4
Figure 8-2: Outer Cordon, Inner Cordon, Screen-Lines identified in the study area ......................... 8-13
Figure 9-1: Proposed UTP Modeling Domain and Workflow for HMA ................................................ 9-2
Figure 9-2: Modeling Framework ........................................................................................................ 9-6
Figure 9-3: Generalized Form of Modeling Framework....................................................................... 9-8
Figure 9-4: Road and Transit Network Attributes for EMME/3 ......................................................... 9-11
Figure 9-5: Typical Household Size Model ......................................................................................... 9-13
Figure 9-6: Typical Household Workers Model.................................................................................. 9-14
Figure 9-7: Typical Household Income Model ................................................................................... 9-14
Figure 9-8: General Form of the Mode Choice Model ....................................................................... 9-18
Figure 9-9: General Form of the Access Mode Choice Sub-Model .................................................... 9-19
Figure 9-10: General Form of the External Trip Model...................................................................... 9-19
Figure 9-11: General Form of the Goods Vehicle Model ................................................................... 9-21
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
1. PURPOSE OF THIS REPORT
1.1 Background
HMDA1, with the approval of UMTA (and Government of Andhra Pradesh) and in consultation with
and support from the stake-holders viz. GHMC, Traffic Police, HMRL, APSRTC, etc., have taken up the
mandate of preparing a Comprehensive Transportation Study for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area
(HMA). Government of India, MoUD has agreed to extend advice and part funding to this major
study2. Towards this major and important effort, HMDA has retained LEA Group as the Consultants3.
1.2 Focus
Inception Report of CTS for HMA is first among the series of reports agreed to be submitted. This
report4 is expected to essentially review the past data/ studies and confirm and/or amend the work
plan by setting out the direction to the proposed study and methodology, time schedule, etc.,.
Therefore this report will be focusing on these very aspects apart from evolving refined method of
achieving key outcomes of work5. Inception Report also focuses on areas on which early discussion,
debate and resolution needed6, apart from potential actions that need to be contemplated from
now on to see that the mechanism is in place to carry forward the plan implementation7.
1
HMDA apart from addressing many issues and mandates related to transport sector within its jurisdiction and at times as advised by
GoAP, has further been contemplating to address the ever growing travel demand in Hyderabad Metropolitan Area. UMTA which was set
up by Governmen0t of Andhra Pradesh is more than concerned and seized with the problems. HMDA on obtaining clearance from UMTA
has sought participation and support from the stake-holders viz. GHMC, Traffic Police, HMRL, APSRTC, etc., to take up the mandate of
preparing a Comprehensive Transportation Study for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA), by informing that Government of India, MoUD
has agreed to extend advice and part funding to this major study. In this collective effort all the stake-holders are keenly taking part with
continuous advice and monitoring by the Technical Advisory Committee (TAC) that is being set up for this purpose.
2
HMDA had approached GoI for the advice and support on this major effort. With consent and approval of UMTA (and Government of
Andhra Pradesh), HMDA sent proposal to and followed with MoUD, GoI for consideration and support. GoI has kindly agreed to support
and advise this effort. Financial assistance is being given by the GoI.
3
LEA Group Companies viz. LEA Associates South Asia Private Limited (LASA) and LEA International Limited (LIL), joint venture is selected
to undertake this major study and prepare transportation plan for HMA.
4
The coverage of Inception report is stipulated in Page 30 of Contract Agreement.
5
We reconfirm that key project outcomes apart from others will be - Immediate Action Plan, Urban Transport Model, Long Term Strategy,
Medium and Short Term Investment Strategy, Resource Mobilization, and Institutional Development.
6
Early view and discussion needed as we would include the Visioning of the growth of HMA along with potential economic base. This will
depend on GoAP policies, apart from the view of Local authorities and governments. It is important to firm up the broad Land Use
Parameters viz. Population and employment by 2040, to move on with the evolution of growth scenarios which need to be addressed in
evolving long-term Transportation Strategy for HMA.
7
Plan implementation needs be thought from now on. It will involve two major elements – Institutional Development and Resource
Mobilization. View is required as to how far Capacity Building efforts and setting up of agencies within UMTA is required. Further, what
level of flexibility and instruments GoAP will have and use in mobilizing the resources. We submit that early thinking on these will help in
taking implementation relatively faster.
1-1
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
1.3 Structure
Inception Report is submitted in Four (4) Volumes8, as given under. The first Volume is the Main
Inception Report, which focuses on all thematic areas of importance, complying fully to the
contractual requirements and beyond. The main volume of the Inception Report is structured into 16
Chapters including this.
• Volume - 2: Literature Review and Insights: This focuses initial review of past works/ studies
and insights gained therein as appropriate at this stage. More review and work on this will be
done as we progress with the work.
• Volume -3: Detailed “Study Approach and Method”: This volume reconfirms of what we had
committed as part of our proposal and in Contract.
• Volume -4: Field Survey Formats: Specific formats for various type of surveys proposed under
this study for approval.
1.4 Mobilization
Project team and work is mobilized, as agreed on March 24, 2011.9 Series of initial meetings are also
held with several agencies/organs of GoAP such as HMDA, GHMC, HMRL, Traffic Police (Hyderabad
and Cyberabad), APSRTC etc..
LEA Group has established its’ full-fledged office in Hyderabad along with all logistical support and
facilities, at the address given under:
LEA Associates South Asia Private Limited
LEA International Limited
H. No. 1-4-879/54/1 A,
Street No. 8, Gandhinagar,
Opposite Vijaya Bank
Hyderabad – 500 080
Telephone: +91 40 27624284
Fax: +91 40 27624089
Email: lasahyd@lasaindia.com
Project work is done from the above office of LEA Group, apart from inputs/advice as appropriate
drawn from its’ Head Quarters Toronto, Canada and also from New Delhi, India.
8
Separate Volumes are decided to be submitted to ensure focus and not repeat what is already agreed and stated in the proposal and
contract in the main Inception Report. Volumes are developed to give HMDA and TAC a broader picture as we see today on all aspects of
study and restate/reconfirm our views/commitment on this major project.
9
On successful conclusion of Contract Negotiations on February 19, 2011, the Consultancy Contract Agreement on this study is signed on
February 24, 2011.
1-2
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
2. STUDY DOMAIN, APPROACH AND WORK PLAN
2-1
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
2.2 Objectives of the Study
Broad objectives of the study are to;
i) Plan and conduct necessary technical studies to identify the Socio-economic background of
the residents of HMA and assess their travel patterns in HMA.
ii) Select, develop and operationalise an Urban Transport Planning (UTP) model using the state-
of-the art modelling techniques and software packages appropriate to the conditions and
planning needs of HMA.
iii) Review and assess the earlier strategies of 1988 and identify the consequences of pursuing
alternative transport strategies and recommend /update an appropriate long term
comprehensive transport strategy for HMA up to 2042.
iv) Identify and suggest appropriate and affordable investment policies and policy proposals up
to 2042.
v) Assess Transit oriented developmental issues and integration of all public modes of
transport systems in HMA.
vi) Help to strengthen transport planning skills and transfer all data, planning models/tools and
knowledge obtained through the study to HMDA, GHMC, HMRL, APSRTC, Traffic Police and
other stakeholders.
vii) Formulate action plan for improving Service Level Bench Marks (SLBs) as per MoUD guide
lines.
2-2
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
2.3.1 Socio-economic Conditions
Apart from being a historical city, Hyderabad has now grown into a mega city with the thrust to be a
world class IT and financial hub extending over an area of 7,145 sqkm housing over 10 million people
from all economic strata. It is estimated that about 30% of the resident population live in slums with
sub-standard living conditions. In view of this, the approach for preparation of a comprehensive
transportation plan should have the bearings to meet the aspirations of population with wide
ranging socio-economic backgrounds.
2.3.2 Demography
Demographically, the HMA is tending to be polycentric with rapid growth of fringe areas both in
terms of employment and residential choices in them. This is evident from the rapid growth of
population recorded during 1991 to 2001 in the erstwhile Municipalities like Serilingmapalli,
Kukatpalli, Qutbullapur, Alwal, Kapra, Malkajgiri, Uppal, L.B.Nagar, Gaddiannaram. The growth of
population in these Municipalities varied from 52% to 103% while the growth in MCH was around
19% as shown in Figure 2-2. The master plan of HUDA 2011 envisages the development of district
centres in the fringe Areas of MCH as shown in Figure 2-3. The master plan proposals will propel
growth in the outer area of GHMC and increase the interaction between MCH and outer municipal
areas.
Uppalk. M 103%
Rajen. Ngr M 88%
Qutbul. M 81%
Malkaj. M 80%
L.B.Ngr M 72%
Alwal M 65%
Kapra M 63%
Seriling. M 63%
Kukat. M 56%
Gaddin. M 52%
Sec. Cntt 21%
MCH 19%
Ramach.-CT 13%
Os. Univ 10%
Figure 2-2: Growth Rates of population During 1991 - Figure 2-3: Proposed Growth Centres in Erstwhile
2001 in Surrounding Municipalities of MCH HUDA
Thus, overall, situation is dynamic and continuously in flux. For this reason, Consultants approach to
develop a “Transport Plan” for the region with a validation of residential choices as they are and as
they are expected to be in near and far distant future is important.
2-3
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
2.3.3 Economy of HMA
HMA has multi-sectoral economic base with many institutes of regional, national and even
international importance besides industries like pharmaceuticals, heavy electrical, processing units
located in it. Further, this multi-sectoral economy of Hyderabad region is undergoing a change with
decline in manufacturing sector and birth of new sectors such as financial services and IT/ITES,
freight logistics and entertainment.
2-4
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
It is needless to say that these directions will be preliminary indications for future corridors which
will be further analysed and supplemented when detailed analysis of travel demand is made with
the help of rigorous transportation demand modelling exercise during the course of the study.
Another associated issue with this major development is integration of APSRTC run city bus routes
with metro corridor. In some respect route rationalization by APSRTC would be inevitable so that on
the metro routes both services do not compete with each other rather complement. Focus of main
haul line of APSRTC bus route could be other than the metro route. At the same time on certain
nodal points of metro lines, APSRTC buses could act as feeder service. Possibly APSRTC may think of
introducing mini buses on some such feeder routes in future.
2-5
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
products, Household items etc. The container traffic handling in ICD Sanathnagar is about 6,000
TEUs per annum. Rail terminals/ Stations/ within HMA such as Secunderabad, Hyderabad also cater
to the need of regional freight traffic apart from regional passenger traffic.
In addition, Rajiv Gandhi International Airport (RGIA) is capable of handling 1 million tonnes of cargo
per annum. The present cargo traffic at RGIA is around 100,000 tonnes per annum (10% of the
capacity).
Hyderabad region also has some of the busiest warehouse complexes run by several agencies. It is
evident that such a freight logistics based activities generates enormous level of goods as well as
passenger traffic. Ensuring smooth flow of this cargo through Hyderabad Region is of national
importance. To that effect, we propose to conduct an in-depth study of the Freight Logistics
Establishments in the Hyderabad Region and come up with a reliable forecast for the same so that a
realistic assessment to incorporate the same in the Hyderabad’s future transportation strategy.
2-6
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
JBS
Secunderab
Nampally Kachegu
da
Imliban
Shamshabad
2-7
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
VI. Availability of parking spaces
VII. Road safety
VIII. Pollution levels
IX. Integrated land use transport system
X. Financial sustainability of public transport
In view of above, we in our overall approach and method have integrated establishing SLBs for
Hyderabad as an important component. This would be done based on intensive data collection
proposed in this study and its analysis and interpretation there on.
For Hyderabad, to our knowledge ASCI, Hyderabad has done few years ago one study related to
establishing SLBs. We propose to have a discussion with ASCI and review the report to understand
and connect the outputs of that study.
2-8
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
PROJECT INPUTS
HMA URBAN
Environment GEOGRAPHY PRIMACY
FORM
PROJECT DOMAIN
Relate to…
GOALS AND
ACCESSIBILITY AFFORDABILITY QUALITY SAFETY
OBJECTIVES
Reflected in…
PERFORMANCE LEVEL OF
TRIP LENGTH COST ACCIDENTS
MEASURES SERVICE
Defines Requirements for….
Used to Identify….
Requires Targeted…
Utilized by….
TRANSPORTATION
ALTERNATIVE DEMAND OPTIMIZING THE TRANSPORT SYSTEM CAPACITY INTEGRATED PUBLIC
STRATEGIES/ MANAGEMENT CAPACITIES ENHANCEMENT TRANSPORT
PLANS
Evaluated with…
Leads to…
Monitored through….
POST PROJECT
Over Time Affect….
SYSTEM
OPERATION
2-9
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
2.5 Work Plan
In order to meet the mandate given in the ToR and considering issues involved in the study, we have
conceptualised a sequential “Work Plan” for this assignment (Chart 2.1). The entire study has been
divided into eight Activities which have been further subdivided into 62 Tasks and their various Sub-
Tasks as appropriate. While first activity can be considered as “Inception Activity”, Activities 2 to 6
focus on the core objectives of the study and last two provide a value addition to the overall success
of the study and skill up-gradation of the core team of various stakeholders (HMDA, GHMC, APSRTC,
HMRL, Traffic Police) in Hyderabad towards the longevity of the planning process/UTP Model. The
activities are:
2-10
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
Chart 2.1: Study Methodology
Activity/ Apr-11 May-11 Jun-11 Jul-11 Aug-11 Sep-11 Oct-11 Nov-11 Dec-11 Jan-12 Feb-12 Mar-12 Apr-12 May-12 Jun-12 Jul-12 Aug-12 Sep-12 Oct-12 Nov-12 Dec-12 Jan-13 Feb-13 Mar-13
Task Description
Task No. 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4
Cont…….
2-11
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
Activity/ Apr-11 May-11 Jun-11 Jul-11 Aug-11 Sep-11 Oct-11 Nov-11 Dec-11 Jan-12 Feb-12 Mar-12 Apr-12 May-12 Jun-12 Jul-12 Aug-12 Sep-12 Oct-12 Nov-12 Dec-12 Jan-13 Feb-13 Mar-13
Task Description
Task No. 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4
Cont…….
2-12
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
Activity/ Apr-11 May-11 Jun-11 Jul-11 Aug-11 Sep-11 Oct-11 Nov-11 Dec-11 Jan-12 Feb-12 Mar-12 Apr-12 May-12 Jun-12 Jul-12 Aug-12 Sep-12 Oct-12 Nov-12 Dec-12 Jan-13 Feb-13 Mar-13
Task Description
Task No. 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4
Chart 2.1
2-13
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
2.6 Deliverables
The proposed deliverables with their time line is pictorially shown in Chart 2.2
Sl. Apr-11 May-11 Jun-11 Jul-11 Aug-11 Sep-11 Oct-11 Nov-11 Dec-11 Jan-12 Feb-12 Mar-12 Apr-12 May-12 Jun-12 Jul-12 Aug-12 Sep-12 Oct-12 Nov-12 Dec-12 Jan-13 Feb-13 Mar-13
Report
No. 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4
B. Completion and Submission of Reports
1 Inception Report
14 Progress Reports
2-14
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
3. HMA – INSIGHTS
The growth of Hyderabad city in space during year 1687 to 2010 can be better appreciated through
schematic development pattern shown in Figure 3.1. The urban agglomeration has grown 22 times
in three hundred years (from 32.4 sqkm to 736.1 sqkm) whereas in last 50 years (from 1959 to
2010), it is important to note that the city has expanded more than four times in area.
3-1
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
Realising the need for providing appropriate steps in effecting the balanced and sustainable
development of land use and the infrastructure the Government of Andhra Pradesh had identified
the Hyderabad Development Area (HDA) and constituted Hyderabad Urban Development Authority
(HUDA) in the year 1975 to administer its implementation under the Andhra Pradesh Urban Areas
(Development) Act. HUDA jurisdiction included the Municipal Corporation of Hyderabad (MCH), ten
surrounding municipalities, and 125 gram panchayaths covering a total area of 1,864.87 sqkm.
Further, HUDA has been reconstituted as Hyderabad Metropolitan Development Authority (HMDA)
by expanding its jurisdiction from 1864.87 sq.km to 7,145 sq.km by an Act of the Andhra Pradesh
Legislature.
From the Table 3-2 it can be seen that the decadal growth rate of population in MCH area is much
less as compared municipalities in the outskirts of MCH. Rest of HUDA area has also registered high
rate of growth in population. This trend is likely to continue till the outer areas get denser and
saturated. The provisional census-2011 results for Hyderabad indicate a population size of 74 lakhs.
Assuming this figure for Hyderabad urban agglomeration (GHMC plus SCB plus urban out growths),
Hyderabad has experienced a decadal population growth of over 30%. Table 3-3 presents the density
of population in the HMA over space.
3-2
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
Table 3-3: Spatial Densities of population in HMA (1981 – 2001)
Sl. Components of HMA Density of population / hectare
No Year 1981 Year 1991 Year 2001
1 Erstwhile MCH 127.2 177.2 212.0
2 Surrounding Municipalities (12 nos) 9.2 22.0 38.0
3 Secunderabad Cantonment 33.9 42.6 51.3
4 HADA 2.2 3.2 3.4
5 Rest of HUDA area 1.3 2.7 5.8
6 Extended Area of HMDA ( Outside HUDA area) 2.0 2.5 2.7
Source: Compiled by the Consultants.
3-3
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
% of Slum % Slum Population of
Corporation/ Slum Population
Number of Slums Population in total Slum Population
Municipalities (2001)
respective Town in Study Area
MCH 1,142 1,411,000 38.3 72.3
Serillingampally 59 73,866 49.1 3.8
Kukatpally 81 19,585 6.7 1.0
Qutbullahpur 77 138,360 61.3 7.1
Alwal 61 62,585 58.8 3.2
Malkajgiri 44 47,396 27.1 2.4
Kapra 33 47,064 29.6 2.4
Uppal Kalan 21 43,586 36.9 2.2
LB Nagar 75 23,478 9.0 1.2
Rajendranagar 38 84,287 58.9 4.3
Total 1,631 1,951,207 37.5 100.0
Source: CDP of GHMC.
Economic Base
All major economic activities of the HMDA area are concentrated in the state capital city of
Hyderabad. It is not only the administrative capital but also the economic and financial capital of
Andhra Pradesh. Being the largest contributor to the State’s gross domestic product, state taxes and
excise revenues, it has reached high levels of commercialization and monetization. It has a large
3-4
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
population that is growing and therefore has the potential to power and propel the State’s future
economic growth.
The urban economic profile has undergone a transformation in recent years with service industry
playing a major role in the economic development of Hyderabad. Manufacturing sector includes
activities as disparate as the manufacture of pharmaceuticals, electronic goods and other industrial
products. Pharmaceutical industry is a dominant player of the manufacturing sector and is expected
to play an increasing role even in future in the exports of pharmaceutical products. Hyderabad is
considered as the "bulk drug" capital of the country due to the presence of a large number of bulk
drug units accounting for about 30-35% of the total production in the country.
The economy of Hyderabad is witnessing a transformation from traditional manufacturing towards a
knowledge-based economy. This is primarily due to policies of the state government to promote
knowledge sector and tourism through a series of initiatives and programs. Knowledge sector,
particularly Information Technology and IT enabled services (ITES) along with the Biotechnology is
gaining momentum in the State. The tertiary or service sector has increased over the last twenty
years with a significant proportion of new jobs across a whole range of activities. Of late, this sector
has emerged as the single largest employer and will continue to grow as the dominant sector in the
future considering the developmental initiatives planned in the area. The sector contributed to more
than 72% of the total city’s workforce in 1991 and nearly 90% in 2001 due to the development of IT
sector, bio-technology and tourism, which are being identified as future growth engines.
3-5
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
development. These important centres are Upparapally, Ramachandrapuram, Shamshiguda,
Bowenpally, Alwal, Gondla Pochampally, Kapra, Karmanghat, and Hayatnagar etc.
Besides these commercial centres, 17 work centres are also proposed in Draft Master Plan 2020,
which are largely located just outside the erstwhile MCH. Proposal of these multiple commercial
and work centres expectedly perpetuate the existing directions of spatial growth of the city. These
proposals reinforce the idea of continuous body extension of core areas of Hyderabad. This is not a
desirable feature in so far as transportation systems efficiency is concerned.
3-6
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
3.5 Existing Transportation Scenario
3.5.1 Transportation System
3-7
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
and the Veera luxury services. All of which have similar seating capacity and run on ‘high-speed’
diesel. All the Buses ply on the same carriageway as that of other private vehicles and thus the level-
of-service offered by the bus system is severely limited by the heavily congested road-network. This
manifests in a situation where the bus system is unable to cater to the peak hour passenger demand,
resulting in over-crowded buses, longer waiting times and slower speeds. The fleet characteristics by
various types of services, routes, schedules etc. are given below:
3-8
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
Hyderabad Suburban Rail: In addition to MMTS service, South Central Railway run suburban rail
service on many sections around Hyderabad. The sections/ routes are:
• Secunderabad-Bolaram-Secunderabad: SB/BS, 2X5 trips, 9 halts in between, 13 km
• Falknuma-Umdanagar-Falknuma: FU/UF, 6+5 trips, 2 halts in between, 13 km
• Secunderabad-Manoharabad-Secunderabad: SMB/MBS, 2X4 trips, 14 halts in between, 38 km
• Secunderabad-Malkagiri-Bolaram: SMJ/MJB, 1+1 trips, 8 halts in between, 13 km
• Secunderabad-Medchal-Secunderabad: SM/MS, 2X6 trips, 12 halts in between, 25 km
Although suburban services are not very significant at present, these are potential demand/supply
corridors which can in future be served with MMTS and or more frequent suburban service.
3-9
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
3-10
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
S
Name of the Road S No Name of the Road
No
6 Road No:10 -Jubilee Hills-Hitech city road 34 Laxmi Nagar-Gudi Malkapur road
7 Film Nagar road 35 Chaderghat-Salarjung Jn
8 Ameerpet-Greenlands 36 Tilak road-Abids Bata-Ram Koti-Kachiguda Station road
9 SR Nagar to Balkampet 37 Shivam Road-Nallakunta road
10 Fatehnagar to Ameerpet 38 Ramnagar Gundu to Musheerabad
11 Fatehnagar to Sanathnagar 39 New Nagole Main road
LB Nagar-Saroor Nagar Rd-Saidabad PS-Dabeepura
12 Yusufguda to ESI Hospital 40
road-Chatta
Gaddi Annaram Rd (3 roads connecting Saroornagar
13 Sanathnagar-Motinagar-Yosufguda 41
colony
14 Minister's road 42 Yakutpura road- Station-Saidabad road
15 YMCA to Secundrabad 43 IRR (Jn-43)-Eid Bazaar-Talab Katta-Moghalpura
16 Sarojini Devi Road (Sangeet to Paradise) 44 IRR-Uppuguda-Lal Darwaja road-Shalibanda
17 Prenderghast road 45 Mithani-Kanchanbag
18 Lower Tank Bund road 46 Jn-37 IRR (P-7 road)
19 Kavadiguda road 47 Vanasthalipuram Rd-BN Reddy Nagar-Sagar road
20 Indira Park-RTC X Roads-Vidya Nagar 48 Bairamalguda Bypass
21 Shivam Road-OU-Tarnaka 49 Mettuguda-Malkajgiri-Safilguda-Neredmet
OU Rd.-Nallakunta-Fever Hospital-Barkatpura
22 50 Old Bowenpally (NH-7)-Trimulgherry-Kushaiguda Jn
Chaman-Kachi
23 Kachiguda Station road 51 Jeedimetla-NH-7
24 Liberty-Himayat Nagar-Narayanaguda-Barkatpura 52 Jeedimetla-Kukatpally (Usha Mullapoodi road)
PC Room-LB Stadium-Old MLA quarters-New
25 53 Nizampet road
science college
26 YMCA-King Koti road-Abids road (Hotel Taj) 54 St.John's Circle-Neredmet road
Lower Tank Bund-Basheerbagh-Abids GPO- Koti
27 55 Wellington Rd-Ordinance Rd-Malkajigiri road
AB-Mojamjah
Abids(Taj Ice cream Intersection)-Bazaar Ghat-
28
Vijaya Na
The service levels on these roads are very poor because of inadequate geometrics, mixed traffic
conditions, ineffectively managed traffic operations in the mid-blocks and as well at intersections. Of
overall road network in HMA, approximately 6,500 km municipal roads are under ownership of
GHMC. It includes apart from higher order roads, the colony roads providing access to and between
various properties.
3-11
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
This can be attributed to fairly high speeds of operation in that area. Appropriate measures need to
be evolved to reduce the numbers as well as severity.
As seen in the table the proportion of two wheelers is 76% and the cars & jeeps are 14%. The highest
percentage of growth has been observed in four-wheeler segment (75%) followed by two wheelers
(54%). Consultant shall further collect this information up to the latest year and try relating it with
vehicular ownership as established through home interview survey. This shall further be utilized in
building vehicle ownership sub-model in UTP model development in this study.
3-12
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
4. TRANSPORTATION PLANNING FOR LARGE URBAN METROPOLITAN
REGIONS - VISIONING, GOALS AND OBJECTIVES
4.1 Overview
Accommodating the expanding demands for urban transportation is often rated as the most difficult
challenge facing both stable and growing urban communities. Travel demands are increasing even in
communities that are not growing, because of life and work style mobility changes that are creating
new or longer trip making. Many people change jobs or homes for a variety of social and economic
reasons even if this increases their travel distances, times and costs. In the developing countries
greater workforce participation rates, particularly for females, is further increasing urban travel.
Changing demographic characteristics, where younger age population profiles are entering their
prime travel demand period of their lives further compounds travel growth. Expanding economies
and resulting quality of life expectations and people’s “value of time”, typically means that
congested travel conditions accepted by earlier generations are now unacceptable.
In India the size of urban communities are not only increasing from natural growth but significantly
by rural migration mainly driven by perceived job and education opportunities. Hyderabad, in
common with most other Indian metropolitan conurbations, is simultaneously being subject to all of
these changing travel growth factors. Compared to developed countries, in cities like Hyderabad,
these changes are happening in a much more compressed time frame. Concerns regarding global
warming, depletion of traditional transportation energy resources, international economic inter-
dependability and now greater understanding of the need for global and local environmental
sustainability, are adding to the challenges facing the Hyderabad Metropolitan Area. Many of the
older and perhaps more mature international cities were benefited by centuries of fairly slow
urbanization and have substantial “paid for” extensive inventories of institutional and transport
infrastructure. Most large Indian cities have a lot of catch-up to reach the same level of urban
services enjoyed by the toped ranked world cities. However Beijing and Shanghai have shown the
way that this can be done. But India is not China.
Comprehensive transportation planning in an area such as Hyderabad cannot be “comprehensive”,
unless it is integrated with the other critical aspects and forces that create cities. Land use,
environmental quality, economic growth and viability and achieving lifestyle objectives are obvious
factors that have to be taken into account in evolving a comprehensive plan. However, there are
more subtle factors that will have a bearing on final outcome of the CTS. For example the study
recommendations should be resilient to the inevitable changes and opportunities that cannot be
reasonably predicted at this time. The study will attempt to model the behaviour of people and
business activity some twenty and thirty years from now. Regardless how careful we measure what
is happening now, there will always be some level of uncertainty in forecasting the future. People
change. Businesses change. Political philosophies change.
4-1
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
The CTS report needs to be considered as a “living document” and this will have to be monitored and
regularly updated to reflect change and/or changes. The travel demand forecasting models are
specifically designed to facilitate the rapid assessment of change. An out of date model is not a
useful transportation decision tool.
4-2
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
• Capacity building of key stake holders including elected representatives for efficient urban
management.
• To facilitate planned development of national capital region.
• Creation of residential facilities for Government officials and office space for Government and
administration of CPWD.
4-3
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
4.2.3 HMDA Revised Master Plan for Core Area
The following was abstracted from a presentation for HMDA EC meeting.
Figure 4-1: Revised Master Plan for Core Area (Erstwhile MCH Area) of GHMC dated 27.01.2010
Aim of this revised Master Plan is to make Hyderabad Core City economically, infrastructurally,
environmentally and socially sustainable for the future.
4-4
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
City with options
• Multiple options of employment, good work-home relations, education, health & recreation.
Pedestrian Friendly City
o Pedestrian facilities to enable more walking.
o Mixed land use pattern
One Hour City
o To be able to reach ‘Below One Hour From Anywhere to anywhere’ within MCH Area
Low Carbon City
o A Self Sustainable City & Region with least carbon footprint.
o Keeping in view the conservation of environment and to tackle climate change issues
4.2.3.4 Overview
The above statements represent a compendium of urban visions, goals and objectives that are
somewhat overlapping. But taken as whole, are comprehensive and reflect the values and
aspirations of many other large metropolitan regions. The challenge in the CTS will be to formulate
an agreed set of progressively defined visions, goals, objectives and implementation strategies for
the whole of the HMA to guide the conduct of the CTS, as elaborated in Section 5 of this document.
4-5
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
4.2.4 City of Ahmedabad – Submission under JNNURM
4-6
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
1. The resiliency of the proposed public transport and road networks were assessed in relation to
several long term regional development scenarios covering a wide range of urban
intensification and Greenfield urbanization alternatives. Implementation priorities considered
the need and justification for these several futures. In summary, planning for future
uncertainties.
2. The adoption of the principle of “Public Transit First” in planning and implementation of
transportation investments.
3. The adoption of the principle “Growth should Pay for Growth” in the mobilization of
resources. In practice this requires the rationalization for and aggressive implementation of
development charges specifically applied for capital urban infrastructure.
4-7
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
4.2.6 Greater London Authority
The 47 year old Mayor Boris Johnson was formerly a journalist, newspaper editor and author and
served for seven years as an elected member of the British Parliament. The prose used in the
Mayor’s vision and objectives are reflective of this background.
4-8
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
Mayor’s Proposed Vision for London
‘I want London to be the best big city on earth.’ ‘To understand what needs to be done, try Googling our city with one of
those satellite maps. Zoom in and out of London from on high.
You will see how the world beneath you is divided into two categories. There is private space – that is, homes and gardens
occupied by individuals and their families.
But more than half of the London landscape – by area – is shared space: roads, parks, canals, rivers, squares, shops, piazzas,
malls, stations, monuments and museums. This shared space is a vast and complex environment in which millions of perfect
strangers must move, meet and negotiate.
What is it like in that shared space? Are people stressed, tense, crowded, unhealthy, unhappy, snappy or even downright
hostile? Or are they relaxed and good-humoured, surrounded by things of beauty both natural and man-made?
The genius of a big city lies in the way it organises that shared space, for the benefit of visitors and inhabitants alike.
We want to make that shared space ever safer, so that it is always pleasant to visit a park, and so that public transport is
never threatening.
We need to bridge the gap between rich and poor, to fight illiteracy and youthful poverty of ambition – not just because
they are evil in themselves, but because they lead to the criminal disorder that affects everyone.
To make that shared space safer, we need to make it more beautiful. That is why we are seeking a world reputation for new
and improved public spaces that Londoners will cherish for decades to come.
We will tackle stress and overcrowding by building houses that once again have decent-sized rooms, and we will insist on
architecture that once again delights the eye.
London is now poised to lead the world in new green technology – from electric cars to home insulation to a new low-
carbon bus to a bike hire scheme – that will help reduce CO2, sweeten the air, generate jobs and save consumers money at
the same time.
Wherever we can we want to plant more trees, protect green space and push ahead with the expansion of an efficient and
world-beating public transport system. These plans set out the fundamental economic and environmental importance of
these transport investments for the whole of the Greater London area.
We want to let Londoners make the most of their innate talent and flair so that they make London’s economy even more
productive and successful and we want all Londoners to have the opportunity to find fulfilling jobs. That also means
ensuring the conditions are right for the businesses that employ them to flourish.
This is a vast and disparate city, the product of centuries of immigration and technological change. But with energy and
enthusiasm we intend to bring our communities together – celebrating our different traditions while sharing the humour
and friendliness that unite us as Londoners.’
Boris Johnson
October 2009
4-9
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
• A city that delights the senses and takes care of its buildings and streets, with the best of
modern architecture while making the most of its built heritage. A place that gets the best out of
its wealth of open and green spaces and waterways, realising its potential for improving
Londoners’ health, welfare and development.
• A world leader in improving the environment locally and globally, at the forefront of policies to
tackle climate change, reduce pollution, develop a low carbon economy and consume fewer
resources and use them more effectively.
• A city where everyone can access jobs, opportunities and facilities with an efficient and effective
transport system that actively encourages walking and cycling and makes better use of the
Thames, and supports all the objectives of this plan.
The above “objectives” might be interpreted by others as vision and goal statements and reflects
who is “holding the pen” at the time.
There are numerous background studies and technical reports that were undertaken to support the
new London Plan. The draft proposals are summarized in a report covering various topics such as
overview, Objectives, The Mayor’s vision, context, London’s places, London’s people, London’s
economy, London’s response to climate change, London’s Transport, implementation, monitoring
and review etc.
4-10
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
4.2.6.4 London Plan - Transport
This chapter in London Plan sets out the Mayor's approach ensuring London as city, easy, safe and
convenient for everyone to access jobs, opportunities and facilities using an efficient and effective
transport system which actively encourages more walking and cycling and makes better use of the
Thames.
London Plan Key Transport Strategies Policies and Actions
The Plan identifies strategies, policies and actions under the following topics:
• Strategic approaches
• Providing public transport capacity and safeguarding land for transport
• Assessing transport capacity
• Enhancing London’s transport connectivity
• Funding strategically important transport infrastructure
• Aviation
• Better streets, buses and trams
• Inter-city bus coaches
• Cycling
• Walking
• Smoothing traffic flow and tackling congestion
• Road network capacity
• Parking
• Freight and strategic rail freight interchanges
4-11
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
An example of one of the policies of providing public transport capacity and safeguarding land for
transport is as follows
Strategic
A The Mayor will work with strategic partners to:
a improve the integration, reliability, quality, accessibility, frequency, attractiveness and
environmental performance of the public transport system
b coordinate measures to ensure that the transport network, now and in the future, is as
safe and secure as reasonably practicable
c increase the capacity of public transport in London over the plan period by securing
funding for and implementing the schemes and improvements set out in Table 6.3.
Planning decisions
B Development proposals that do not provide adequate safeguarding for the schemes outlined
should be refused.
LDF preparation
C Boroughs and any other relevant partners must ensure the provision of sufficient land, suitably
located, for the development of an expanded transport system to serve London’s needs by:
a safeguarding in DPDs existing land used for transport or support functions unless
alternative facilities are provided that enables existing transport operations to be
maintained
b identifying and safeguarding in DPDs sites, land and route alignments to implement
transport proposals that have a reasonable prospect of provision.
4-12
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
Travel by public transport needs to be improved to increase its appeal relative to the car, and the
issues set out in Policy need to be addressed to improve the attractiveness of the current and future
network for passengers. Boroughs need to safeguard the current range of land in transport uses and
allocate land in their relevant development plan documents so that the schemes outlined can be
implemented.
Securing the land needed for transport (for a range of purposes, from ventilation shafts to facilities
for bus drivers), and protecting it from development, has proved difficult in London. This pressure
had been felt most in the places where land is most required. Release of this transport land should
only occur in consultation with the relevant transport organisations, and where alternative transport
uses for the site concerned have been fully explored.
4-13
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
4-14
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
strong, clear policy direction on land use planning to promote strong communities, a clean and
healthy environment and a strong economy. It includes policies on key issues that affect
communities, such as: the efficient use and management of land and infrastructure; protection of
the environment and resources; and ensuring appropriate opportunities for employment and
residential development, including support for a mix of uses.
4-15
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
BUILDING STRONG COMMUNITIES - Managing and Directing Land Use to Achieve Efficient
Development and Land Use Patterns
Healthy, liveable and safe communities are sustained by:
a) promoting efficient development and land use patterns which sustain the financial well-being
of the Province and municipalities over the long term;
b) accommodating an appropriate range and mix of residential, employment (including
industrial, commercial and institutional uses), recreational and open space uses to meet
long-term needs;
c) avoiding development and land use patterns which may cause environmental or public
health and safety concerns;
d) avoiding development and land use patterns that would prevent the efficient expansion of
settlement areas in those areas which are adjacent or close to settlement areas;
e) promoting cost-effective development standards to minimize land consumption and
servicing costs;
f) improving accessibility for persons with disabilities and the elderly by removing and/or
preventing land use barriers which restrict their full participation in society; and
g) ensuring that necessary infrastructure and public service facilities are or will be available to
meet current and projected needs.
Sufficient land shall be made available through intensification and redevelopment and, if necessary,
designated growth areas, to accommodate an appropriate range and mix of employment
opportunities, housing and other land uses to meet projected needs for a time horizon of up to 20
years. However, where an alternate time period has been established for specific areas of the
Province as a result of a provincial planning exercise or a provincial plan, that time frame may be
used for municipalities within the area.
The Greater Toronto Area Greenbelt
The establishment of a greenbelt within and beyond the GTA was a major provincial initiative in
guiding and containing urbanization. A healthy natural environment with clean air, land and water
will characterize the region. The Greenbelt, including significant natural features, such as the Oak
Ridges Moraine and the Niagara Escarpment, has been enhanced and protected in perpetuity. These
form the key building blocks of the GTA’s natural systems.
4-16
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
4-17
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
4-18
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
4-19
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
4-20
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
4.3 Key Points and Insights
4.3.1 Visions and Mission Statements
Vision and mission statements can be succinct such as “our vision is of a life- sustaining Earth” or
quite wordy and slightly philosophical, such as the Mayor of London’s vision prefacing the draft new
London Plan. While the Mayor’s vision is highly personal, it may be problematical to incorporate
such a vision in a statutory document that could be subject to legal challenge.
The terms vision, image, goal, guiding principles, key policies or strategies and mission statements
are often used interchangeably. There is often a blurring between urban visions goals and objectives
as illustrated below:
“To facilitate creation of economically vibrant, inclusive, efficient and sustainable urban habitats”.
(Ministry of Urban Development Government of India)
The Mission is to promote cities as engines of economic growth through improvement in the quality
of urban life by facilitating creation of quality urban infrastructure, with assured service levels and
efficient governance”. (Ministry of Urban Development Government of India)
• To recognize that people occupy center-stage in our cities and all plans would be for their
common benefit and well being (NUTP Vision)
• To make our cities the most livable in the world and enable them to become the “engines of
economic growth” that power India’s development in the 21st century. (NUTP Vision)
• To allow our cities to evolve into an urban form that is best suited for the unique geography of
their locations and is best placed to support the main social and economic activities that take
place in the city. (NUTP Vision)
• To make Hyderabad Core City economically, infrastructurally, environmentally and socially
sustainable for the future (HMDA Revised Master Plan for Core Area)
• Improvement in quality of life for all citizens of all parts of the city (HMDA Revised Master Plan
for Core Area)
• A vibrant, productive, harmonious, sustainable and environment friendly, clean and liveable city
having a responsive local government offering its citizens a good quality of life. (Ahmedabad City
vision)
• “Ahmedabad – A Vibrant City, a City of Quality Life for all” (Ahmedabad City vision)
• “Transforming Mumbai into a world class city with a vibrant economy and globally comparable
quality of life”. (Mumbai First)
• to promote and sustain growth with social justice in a resource efficient manner. (MMRDA
Development Plan)
• ‘I want London to be the best big city on earth.’ (Mayor of London- London Plan)
• The policies provides strong, clear policy direction on land use planning to promote strong
communities, a clean and healthy environment and a strong economy (Ontario Provincial Policy
Statements)
4-21
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
The issues to be addressed in the CTS include:
• Should a vision/mission statement be prepared for the HMDA and/or for the CTS?
• Would a statement such as “The planning and development of the Hyderabad Metropolitan
Development Area will be based on the principles of social equity and environmental and
economic sustainability to improve the quality of life for its citizens” or something similar be
appropriate?
• Should policies dealing with strategies, goals, objectives and performance measures be
structured around the vision statement?
• Should these issues/policies/strategies incorporate the integration of land use and
transportation planning?
• Should these issues/policies/strategies incorporate the integration of land use, transportation
and other infrastructure planning that could influence the development of the HMDA?
4-22
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
5. KEY ASPECTS NEEDING EARLY DEBATE AND RESOLUTION
If the principle of integrating land use and transportation planning is followed, then an iterative
process of conceptualizing long
term urban visions, land
development and transportation
options should be considered.
These options could be subject
to screening assessment
techniques with options being
progressively defined and
detailed. With the magnitude of
urban growth, which is not too
dissimilar to the situation
experienced in conducting the
Mumbai CTS, there may be Figure 5-1: Base Population Forecast in Million
benefit in planning for several
land use futures.
5-1
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
5-2
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
5.2 A Picture of Future Transport
“The best way to predict the future is to invent it yourself”
India’s rapid change from a predominantly rural society, to a greater dependence on an urban living,
creates pressures such as the need to double the size of large urban conurbations like Hyderabad.
Expanding the urban economies to meet huge influxes of people entering the workforce, is
particularly challenging. What is the future for female employment in India, in London there are now
more women than men in the workforce? An efficient urban transport system is an absolute
prerequisite to meeting this challenge. A wealthy city has a richer public transit system. A world class
city has to have a world class public transport. A sustainable city has to have a sustainable public
transport system.
It is probably reasonable to suggest that, even at this very early juncture in the CTS, these maxims
will hold true for Hyderabad. But what form should higher order transit take? What transit
technologies will be available over the next 30 years? Will transit lead development or will it be led
by development? Can transit compete with the convenience of the door to door travel of private
modes? What will constrain the use of private modes, road capacity or parking space limitations or
both? Are wider roads, more flyovers, roads and footpaths choked with moving and parked vehicles
compatible with a sustainable, environmental friendly city? Is society prepared to embrace the NUTP
objective of “bringing about a more equitable allocation of road space with people, rather than
vehicles, as its main focus”? Or are these hollow words? Can limitations be placed on the use of
private transport modes unless an efficient public transport alternative is available? How can
investments in urban transport be funded? There should be early debate in the CTS on these issues,
goals and objectives.
5-3
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
5.3 Potential Future Higher Order Transit Corridors
5-4
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
There are many transit opportunities to be explored in the Study. Growing metropolises’ have to
continually expand with their higher order transit networks.
London’s first underground line was built in 1863 and they are still adding new lines, even in the
centre of the city. Metro building is a bold initiative that takes vision and perseverance.
Many metro lines that were planned in advance of urbanization were constructed on grade and the
urban form embraced this constraint and communities now would not have it any other way.
Each of diagrammatic lines on the following figures will present different implementation
opportunities. Rapid transit in order to compete with private vehicles will have to be rapid
particularly for longer journeys.
Most metros operate at average speeds of between 30-35 kph. Speeds increase if station spacing
increases. But in most large cities a 30-35 kph speed beats congested roads.
5-5
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
6. STUDY AREA AND STRATEGIC TRAFFIC ZONING
10
HMA as the Study Area is what is given in Contract Agreement. From our judgment also Study Area as defined now, includes areas
which developed, go for changes and/or transformation and also includes areas which have recently developed and areas that are
expected to develop over coming 30 years.
6-1
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
a zoning scheme to address all these complex issues. It presently appears that there will be a need to
develop the zoning system under 6 distinct sub-regions, as below:
• Greater Hyderabad Municipal Corporation (GHMC);
• Secunderabad Cantonment Board (SCB);
• Hyderabad Airport Development Authority (HADA);
• Rest of HUDA area that includes Outer Ring Road Growth Corridor (ORRGC); and
• Rest of HMA (Rural Areas plus two municipalities) i.e. extended area of HMDA
Each of these sub-regions will be divided into TAZs for modeling purpose. While an integrated
transportation model will be developed, it would be possible to provide separate planning inputs
and also analyze conditions, project or plan impacts etc. for each of these sub regions separately. It
is also proposed to retain the boundaries of now merged municipalities as an aggregation of TAZs for
data continuity and to account for and reflect subtle difference in socio-economic or physical
development related aspects in these areas.
6-2
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
Based on the above mentioned principles and our understanding of the study area, in HMA the
number of TAZs, we expect to be in the range of 1,000.11 This is significantly larger number (of zones)
as compared to any of the past traffic or transportation planning studies conducted in Hyderabad.
This would implicitly mean and will lead to an exponentially higher level of complexity and data
collection and organization effort. However, we strongly believe that this is a justified number
considering the geographical extent of HMA and the study objectives. While the large number of
zones can be handled reasonably well through the advanced software tools and models proposed, in
order to make the results and analysis more understandable and meaningful for taking strategic
view and/or decisions, apart from ease of comprehension, appropriate use of presentation
techniques and aggregation will be used. Table 6-1 presents possible range of TAZs within various
jurisdictions of HMA.
Table 6-1: Possible Range of TAZs in HMA
Sl. Area Population - Estimated Population No. of Possible
Area/ Jurisdiction
No. (Sqkm) 2001 - 2011 TAZs
Erstwhile MCH
1 172.60 36,44,000 42,02,000 100
• 7 Circles and 100 wards
Surrounding Municipalities (12
nos) 452.40 18,33,000 30,65,000 300-350
2
• 11 Circles and 50 wards
Secunderabad Cantonment Board
3 • Presently divided in seven 40.17 2,06,000 2,40,000 7-10
CB-Wards)
HADA
4 458.96 1,44,000 150,000 40-50
• 70 revenue villages
Rest of HUDA Area including
5 villages (Ghatkesar CT with eight 992.00 5,34,000 10,45,000 120-150
wards and 182 revenue villages)
Extended Area of HMDA ( Outside
HUDA area)
• Bhongir Municipal Council
with five wards
6 • Sangareddy Municipal 4,917.00 15,93,000 18,51,000 400-450
Council with six wards
• Eight Census Towns with 76
wards.
• 667 Revenue Villages
Total HMA Area 7,146.00 79,54,000 1,05,53,000 Approx. 1,000
The study area and its constituents along with possible number of TAZs are shown in Figure 6-1.
11
At this stage, this is our best judgment on TAZs based on principles we laid down to capture various aspects. This could go for some
refinement as we proceed further based on discussions.
6-3
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
6-4
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
7. DEVELOPMENT OF IMMEDIATE ACTION PLAN (IAP)
7-1
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
7.2 Focus and Approach
According to the contract, the IAP to be developed as part of the CTS shall address junction
improvement plans for 30 priority junctions, corridor improvement plan for 15 kms of roadway,
improvement plans for pedestrian facilities covering 50 kms of roadway network, parking facility
improvement plans for critical areas (10 kms of on-street and 6 kms of off-street parking), traffic
management schemes for select five areas and improvement plans for intercity bus terminals. Our
general approach for preparing an Immediate Action Plan is shown in Figure 7-1.
The general approach and methodology towards development of immediate action plan has been
translated into undertaking eight tasks as:
• Initial Field Visits and Consultation with Stakeholders
• Scoping of Work and Identification of Primary Survey Needs
• Data Collection/Field Surveys
• Analysis of Traffic Data and Accident Data
• Analysis of Traffic Data and Accident Data
• Develop Alternative Solutions/Plans
• Stakeholder Consultations on Improvement Plans and Feedback
• Prepare and Submit Field Survey Report (Stage-I)
• Develop and Submit Immediate Action Plan
Since inception of this study, the project team has visited several critical areas/ junctions and have
also interacted with key stakeholders to obtain their opinion. This has also been supported by review
and proposals of several studies those have been done in the past. With this understanding
Consultants have identified various intersections/ corridors/ area to be taken up for developing
immediate action plan and its related scope for primary surveys. Subject to approval from client, we
will move to other tasks under this activity as described below:
7-2
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
Survey Type and Analysis Purpose
• Field Reviews. Traffic conditions, including conflicts or undesirable motorist actions,
cannot be fully gauged by looking at traffic counts or crash data. Therefore, our traffic
engineers will conduct thorough field reviews to assess existing conditions, identify
potential operational/safety deficiencies, as well as opportunities and constraints at
each location. We will develop and utilize a Field Review checklist to make sure that all
key components are thoroughly investigated during field visits.
• Other traffic engineering studies such as gap studies, conflict studies, queue length
analysis, and intersection delay studies
• Use of turning movement counts and other data collected for preparing junction Traffic Management Plan
improvement plans. In addition, we will collect traffic volume counts at select locations at area level
(mid-block) for varying duration (16 hrs./ 12 hrs./ 4hrs.) based on study needs.
• Road network inventory (such as no. of lanes, type of roadway, one-way/two-way,
roadway width, median, sidewalks, etc.)
• Inventory of existing bus/IPT stops (formal/informal)
• Inventory of facilities for NMT and pedestrian traffic
• Data on major traffic generators (residential, recreational and commercial) within the
study area.
• Collect necessary data on emergency response agencies (location of Police/Fire Rescue
facilities, Hospitals, etc.)
• Location of schools and colleges/universities, and School Zone information (location,
speed, times)
• Existing and/or planned traffic management programs and enforcement programs
• Field reviews to assess traffic circulation patterns, land use characteristics, access
management issues, traffic operations/safety issues, roadway connectivity, parking, etc.
• Topographic Survey of the identified corridor(s) of approximate 15 km length covering Corridor Improvement
50 m on either side of the center line and 200 m length on each arm of each cross roads Plan
to prepare a base map showing all on-ground physical features, utilities, road signs,
traffic control devices, R/W, shoulders, sidewalks, bus/IPT stops and major activity
centers along the corridor.
• Travel Time and Delay Survey. At a minimum, two to four round trips will be made
during peak/off-peak periods on each link to ensure statistically sound results. At select
locations, we propose to measure spot speeds using a Radar Speedometer.
• Use of turning movement counts and other data collected for preparing junction
improvement plans.
• Field reviews to assess traffic circulation patterns, land use characteristics, access
management issues, traffic operations/safety issues, roadway connectivity, parking, etc.
• Safety analysis. Analyze crash data, prepare crash summaries and collision diagrams to
identify abnormal crash patterns
• Capacity analysis. The appreciation of road network characteristics is important to
assess existing capacity and level of service, to identify the constraints, if any, and to
assess the potential for improvement to meet increasing demands of traffic volumes.
• Collect other necessary data, such as existing and/or planned traffic/parking
management programs, enforcement programs, traffic control systems and other
measures, pedestrian facilities.
• Inventory of all identified terminals which require immediate attention. Traffic Circulation Plan
• Necessary traffic volume count at entry/exit points of the terminal, including count of around Intercity/ intra city
buses and other vehicles at entry/exit points. Information regarding number of buses bus and goods terminal
that operate from the terminal will be collected from respective offices.
• Prepare/study existing layout (bus parking bays, office area, buildings, depot area,
visitors parking) and vehicle circulation plan within terminal premises.
• Necessary turning movement survey (4hrs. during peak) at major intersections and mid-
block locations on adjacent roadways.
7-3
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
Survey Type and Analysis Purpose
• Parking facilities inside and outside the terminal (on-street and off-street).
• Physical infrastructure inventory at entry/exist such as median openings, turn lanes,
acceleration/deceleration lanes, turning radii, etc. will be measured and drawn on a
map. In addition, we propose to conduct terminal user survey (out bound/ inbound
passengers), if needed.
• Parking Survey. An inventory of the existing on-street and off-street parking facilities will Parking improvement
be prepared. The general methodology for both the surveys is similar, though minor plans
details can be different. The field survey will be carried out for all types of vehicles in the
area under study in order to determine the parking demand in terms of accumulation
and duration. Field studies will be conducted for 12 hours (06:00 am to 6 pm) during
weekdays.
• Pedestrian Volume. At select locations, pedestrian volume counts will be collected for a Improvement plans for
total of 12 hour period. pedestrian facilities
• Pedestrian Facilities (crosswalks, pedestrian signals, sidewalks, signs, etc.) Inventory
7-4
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
achieve efficient and safe movement of motorized and non-motorized traffic will be considered in
developing alternative plans.
The possible solutions under various components could include:
Junction Improvement Plan: Geometric improvements, re-organization of the available space for
efficient use, provision of pedestrian facilities (cross walks, pedestrian signals), pavement markings,
traffic signs, signal modifications, provision of channelized islands/medians/dividers, prohibiting
certain movements etc. are some of components that will be addressed in a comprehensive junction
improvement plan.
Traffic Management Plan at area level: Enhancing traffic circulation with provision of one-way/two-
way/ contra flow lanes, traffic calming measures, signing improvements, parking improvements,
declaring some of the roads as pedestrian only, all day or time based movement restrictions for
commercial vehicles, reduced speed school zones, and establishing enforcement/education
programs are some of the components addressed under traffic management plan. Some of the
junctions/intersections addressed above could be part of the area level plan.
Corridor Improvement Plan: This may include re-organization of the available space for efficient use,
minor widening, provision of bus/IPT stops, pedestrian facilities, pavement markings, signing
improvements, relocation of utilities, landscaping improvements, channelizing traffic movements,
provision for exclusive NMT (Cycle) lanes, bus priority schemes, junction improvements, and access
management improvements.
An access management master plan for a corridor is a proactive measure in many ways. It serves as a
road map for future project development, design and construction projects, and is also a vehicle for
coordination with the development review process of the applicable local government entities.
Therefore, buy-in from the local government agencies is essential for the plan’s success so that the
land use component is aligned with the primary function of the roadway.
The local governmental agencies can strategically combine the recommended access management
improvements and other safety modifications into an already programmed improvement at a
relatively low incremental cost. Combining the construction activities also minimizes the
inconvenience to the motoring public.
Traffic Management Plan around Terminals: The plan may include junction improvements,
geometric improvements at exit/entry points to the terminal, parking improvements, signing
improvements, traffic management measures, re-location of bus/IPT stops, and pavement markings.
7-5
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
7.2.5 Prepare and Submit Field Survey Report
A report on all field surveys undertaken will be prepared under this task. The broad contents of this
report would be:
• Identification process of junctions, corridors, critical pedestrian/parking areas, and bus terminals
for developing Immediate Action Plans.
• List and location of primary surveys undertaken along with methodology and survey format.
• Raw data
• Analysis, findings, interpretation of survey results.
• Exclude the intersections which fall on any of the three Metro Corridors.
• Pick the intersections which form part of some corridors so that problems can be handled at
network level.
• Traffic volume level and scope for physical improvement.
• Geographical spread.
• Limitation of scope.
We are recommending the list for consideration based on all above. However, we are open to
include or exclude some as per client’s feedback before undertaking the actual studies.
12
The list of Intersections/ Junctions suggested by Traffic Police, Hyderabad and Cyberabad respectively are enclosed in Attachment 1 for
reference and view.
7-6
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
Table 7-1: Proposed Junctions for Intersection Improvements in IAP
Sl. No. Junction Name Name of Traffic Police Station area
1 Bowenpally Trimulgherry
2 Tadbun Trimulgherry
3 Mothi Nagar S. R. Nagar
4 Monappa Panjagutta
5 Prashasan Nagar Banjara Hills
6 Bazarghat X Road Nampally
7 RethiBowli Asif Nagar
8 Tolichowki Asif Nagar
9 Humayun Nagar Asif Nagar
10 Mallepally, Noble Talkies Asif Nagar
11 Asifnagar Junction Asif Nagar
12 City College Charminar
13 Nagulchinta Falaknuma
14 MBNR X Road Falaknuma
15 Phisal Banda Falaknuma
16 DMRL X Road Falaknuma
17 Hafeez Baba Nagar Falaknuma
18 Owaisi Hospital Falaknuma
19 Road No.6, Amberpet Kacheguda
20 Shamshabad Market Airport PS
21 Old raidurga and wishper valli Madhapur
22 Kondapur Madhapur
23 ISB Madhapur
24 Hafeezpet Kukatpalli
25 BHEL Kukatpalli
26 Balanagar Balanagar
27 ECIL Bus stand Alwal
28 Neradimet Alwal
29 Uppal Bustand Uppal
30 Nagole X Roads L.B. Nagar
7-7
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
5. From Dilshuknagar to LBNagar
6. Fever Hospital to Tarnaka
7. From ECIL X roads to Neradimet Y Junction
8. Hafeezpet to Kondapur
9. Gulzar Hoze to Yakathpura station Junction
10. JBS to Tirumalgiri
11. Madina to City College
On this long list, we have applied the following parameters to select and recommend the corridors:
• Intent was to spread this pilot effort on larger area.
• If continuous intersection(s) have been selected already for improvement, we have tried to
exclude that corridor.
• Perceived level of congestion when travelled on those corridors.
• Opportunity to integrate at-grade pedestrian/ NMT movement with metro development in
general and metro station in particular.
• Limitation of scope and resources.
Based on above , we are recommending the list for consideration. However, we are open to include
or exclude some as per client’s feedback before undertaking the actual studies.
Corridor 1: From JNTU Kukatpalli to Kukatpalli village (2.75 km); This corridor passes through major
intersection like JNTU kukatpalli, Kukatpalli Housing board Junction and Ushamullapudi hospital road
Junction. This corridor covers the educational institutions like JNTU, Sri Chaitanya and Narayan junior
collages and Commercial/mixed land use establishments on both sides of the road.
7-8
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
Corridor 2: From ESI Hospital to Panjagutta
(3 km); This corridor passes through major
intersection like ESI, SR nagar, Maitrivanam
Junction, Ameerpet Junction, Srinagar colony
and Panjagutta Junction. This corridor covers
the major Commercial establishments from
SRNagar to Maitrivanam; Bigbazar, RS
Brothers, Chandana brothers in Ameerpet
area and Hyderabad cenral in panjagutta
area. Several Hospital like ESI, Chest, Unoni
and Image. At Maitrivana area there are
several software training institution which
attracts many students and there by
generates huge pedestrian movement on this
area.
Corridor 3: From Dilshuknagar to LBNagar
(4.3 km); This corridor passes through major
intersection like Dilsukhnagar junction,
Chaitanyapuri junction, Khothapet fruit
market junction , Saroornagar road junctions
and LBNagarJunctions. This corridor have
major commercial establishments at
Dilsukhnagar to Chaitanyapuri. Other part of the corridor have mixed land use charectiristics.
7-9
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
Corridor 4: From ECIL X roads to Neradimet Y Junction (2.65 km); This corridor connects major
intersections such as ECIL Junction, APHB Colony Junction, Naredimet junction. Residential colonies
are abutted on both sides of the corridor with mixed land use on road side properties.
Corridor 5: Gulzar Hoze to Yakathpura station Junction (1.8 km); This corridor passes through
Chowmaholla, Rangeela shah maholla and yakutpura. Mixed land use is observed on the both sides
of the corridor.
Corridor 6. Madina to City College (0.8 km): This corridor passes through High court of Andhra
Pradesh. It has full commercial establishments on one side of the road.
7-10
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
7.5 Area Level Traffic Improvement
Similar to what we done for selecting corridors, we visited different areas extensively and prepared a
long list as:
1. Lakdi-ka-Pul area
2. Panjagutta area
3. Mehidipatnam Area
4. Nizampet road area
5. Secunderabad area
6. Malkajgiri area
7. Madhapur area
8. Koti area
9. Sanikpuri area
Further, as per inputs received from HMDA, GHMC, Traffic Police and our own understanding of the
city, the following areas are recommended for consideration by client for developing area level
traffic improvement plan. The areas are:
1. Lakdi-ka-Pul area: This area covers the intersection and main roads as follows:
• Intersections: Khairathabad intersection in the north direction, Tankbund Junction in the east
direction, Chapel road junction in the south direction and Masab tank junction in the west
direction. The other important junctions in the area are Neckles road rotary, Telugutalli Junction,
Eikbalminar junction, Ravindhra Bharathi junctions, Lakdikapul junction, Dwaraka hotel junction,
Ayodhya junction, Nirankari junction, Mahaveer Hospital junction, Liberty junction, Basheerbag
junction, AR Petrol pump junction, Police control room junction, Bazar Ghat junction, and
Vijayanagar colony junction.
• Main Roads: Khairatabad to Public gardens, Tankbund to Masabtank, Tankbund to L B stadium,
Taj ice cream to Vijayanagar colony, redhills road, JNTU to Vijayanaga colony.
7-11
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
2. Mehidipatnam Area: This area covers the intersection and main roads as follows:
• Intersections: NMDC intersection in the east direction, Tolichowki Junction in the west direction,
Laxminagar road junction in the south direction and Rehibowli junction in the north direction.
The other important junctions in the area are Humayinnagar junction, Mehidipatnam rythubazar
Junction , Miraj café junction, Mehidipatnam Busdepot junctions, Saibaba temple junction,
Gudimalkapur junction, Nanalnagar junction, Padmanbhanagar junction and Military road
junction
• Main roads: NMDC to Tolichowki, Rethibowli to Crystal garden, Humayinnagar to Gudimalkapur,
Gudimalkapur to Nanalnagar, Nanal nagar to Langerhouz road and Mehidipatnam to Asifnagar
side road.
7-12
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
3. Secunderabad area: This area covers the intersection and main roads as follows:
• Intersections: Alugadda bhavi intersection in the east direction, Rasoolpura Junction in the west
direction, Bhuddabhavan Jn. in the south direction and CTO, Pared grounds Jn. in the north
direction. The other important junctions in the area are Patny junction, Paradise Junction, Clock
tower junction, Bata junctions, Bible house junction, Secunderabad station, Rathi file junction,
Maredipalli rotary junction, Sangeeth junction, Ranigung junction and Monda market junction.
7-13
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
• Main roads: SP road, SD road, RP road, MG road, Minister road, Sangeeth to Boiguda and
Secunderabad station road
4. Madhapur area: This area covers the intersection and main roads as follows:
• Intersections: Madhapur PS intersection in the east direction, Kondapur Jn. in the west
direction and Hitech city building Jn. in the south direction. The other important junctions in the
area are Cyber towers Jn., NAC road Jn., Botanical garden Jn., and Pride honda Jn.
• Main roads: Madhapur PS to Kondapur roads, Kondapur to Botanical garden road, Kavery hills to
shilparamam road and Cyber tower to old Bombay connecting road.
This area covers about seven intersections and four main roads.
5. Koti area: This area covers the intersection and main roads as follows:
• Intersections: Kachiguda, chaderghat causeway intersection in the east direction, M J Market
Junction in the west direction, YMCA, Science college junction in the south direction and
Afzalgung junction in the north direction. The other important junctions in the area are King koti
junction, Ram koti, Koti womens college Junction , Abits junction, Bata junctions, Chaderghat
bridge north & south junctions, Rangamahal junction, Begumbazar junction and Dharulshifa
junction.
• Main roads: Gunfoundry to Abits road, Abits to Afazal gung road, Koti to Chaderghat road,
YMCA to begum bazaar road, M J Market to chaderghat road, Afzalgung to Rangamahal road,
Abias to Kachiguda station, Tilak road and Koti womens college to ramkoti road.
7-14
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
7-15
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
7-16
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
8. COLLECT AND UPDATE THE DATA
8-1
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
distribution of population, growth over two decades and corresponding areas of the section in the
HMA.
Table 8-1: Spatial Distribution of Population in HMA (1981- 2001)
Population (Lakhs)
Sl. No Components of HMA Area (sq.km)
Year 1981 Year 1991 Year 2001
1 Erstwhile MCH 172.60 21.96 30.58 (39%) 36.44 (20%)
2 Surrounding Municipalities (12 nos) 452.40 4.18 9.96 (138%) 18.33 (84%)
3 Secunderabad Cantonment 40.17 1.36 1.71 (26%) 2.06 (20%)
4 HADA 458.96 1.02 1.47 (44%) 1.44* (-3%)
5 Rest of HUDA Area including villages 992.00 0.81 2.16 (167%) 5.34 (147%)
6 Extended Area of HMDA ( Outside HUDA area) 4,917.00 10.00 12.30 (23%) 15.93 (30%)
Total HMA Area 7,146.00 39.94 58.96 79.54 (35%)
*some of the villages considered earlier in HADA had been considered in Rajendra Nagar
Municipalities in year 2001 census.
Hyderabad Metropolitan Development Authority (HMDA) was established by an act of the Andhra
Pradesh Legislature. Its jurisdiction was extended from 1864.87 sq.km to 7,145 sq.km (excluding
Secuderabad Cantonment Board area). The HMA consists of the following revenue units:
• Hyderabad City District
• Rangareddy District
• Part of Medak District
• Part of Mahaboobnagar District
• Part of Nalgonda District
GHMC is highly urbanized area in HMA with about 70% of the total population of 7.87 million in 2001
concentrated in erstwhile MCH and surrounding 12 municipalities which constitute only 9% of total
HMA area. The next most urbanised area is Scecunderabad Cantonment area. In the extended
HMDA area, about 1.6 million population was spread over 5,000 sqkm of area.
8-2
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
Year 2001
SI.
District Components of HMA Density
No. Population HHs HH Size
(Person/sqkm)
Rangareddy Rajendranagar (M) 1,43,240 26,974 5.31
Rangareddy Serilingampally (M)- 50.87 sqkm 1,53,364 32,642 4.70
Ramachandrapuram (CT)- 34.34 sqkm including
Rangareddy 67,178 14,912 4.50
Patancheru (CT)
Rangareddy Patancheru (CT) 40,273 9,282 4.34
Rangareddy Qutubullapur (M)- 95.99 sqkm 2,31,108 52,188 4.43
Rangareddy Alwal (M)- 52.02 sqkm 94,372 19,748 4.78
Rangareddy Malkajgiri (M)- 25.32 sqkm 1,93,863 42,291 4.58
Medak Gaddianaram (CT)- 16.75 sqkm 52,835 12,053 4.38
Medak Kukatpally (M)- 43.12 sqkm 2,92,289 65,211 4.48
Secunderabad Cantonment Board (SCB)-40.2
3 Rangareddy 206,102 42,565 4.84
sqkm
Rangareddy CB - Ward No. 1 22,139 4,583 4.83
Rangareddy CB - Ward No. 2 55,256 11,194 4.94
Rangareddy CB - Ward No. 3 31,225 6,440 4.85 5,128
Rangareddy CB - Ward No. 4 31,937 7,045 4.53
Rangareddy CB - Ward No. 5 39,171 8,038 4.87
Rangareddy CB - Ward No. 6 15,209 3,165 4.81
Rangareddy CB - Ward No. 7 11,165 2,100 5.32
4 Rangareddy HADA (70 Revenue Villages)- 458.96 swkm 144,779 24,501 5.91 314
Rangareddy,
5 Rest of HUDA Area including villages 5,34,337 1,11,789 4.78
Medak
Rangareddy Ghatkesar (CT) 8 wards – 13.83 sqkm 18278 3680 4.97 538
Rangareddy,
182 Villages – 978.17 5,16,059 1,08,109 4.77
Medak
Rangareddy,
Medak, Extended Area of HMDA (Outside HUDA area)-
6 15,93,557 3,25,417 4.90
Mahaboobna 4917 sqkm
ga, Nalgonda
Nalgonda Bhongir (M) - Consist of 5 Wards – 9.6 sqkm 50,407 9,647 5.23
Choutuppal (CT) - Consist of 5 Wards – 12.80
Nalgonda 14,001 2,888 4.85
sqkm
Omerkhan Daira (CT) - Consist of 8 Wards – 25.0
Rangareddy 7,259 1,943 3.74
sqkm
Rangareddy Narsingi (CT) - Consist of 8 Wards – 6.90 sqkm 7,117 1,300 5.47
Rangareddy Meerpet (CT) - Consist of 16 Wards – 4.01 sqkm 12,935 2,748 4.71
324
Mahaboobnag Farooqnagar (CT) - Consist of 29 Wards – 13.58
34,470 6,704 5.14
ar sqkm
Medak Bollaram (CT) - Consist of 8 Wards – 8.40 sqkm 13,115 3,458 3.79
Medak Isnapur (CT) - Consist of 7 Wards – 9.0 sqkm 7,576 1,732 4.37
Medak Eddumailaram (CT) - Ward No.5 - 6.20 sqkm 13,592 3,185 4.27
Sangareddy (M) - Consist of 6 Wards – 14.50
Medak 57,113 10,480 5.45
sqkm
Rangareddy,
Medak, 667 Villages in 4 Surrounging Districts – 4807.01
13,75,972 2,81,332 4.89
Mahaboobnag sqkm
a, Nalgonda
Total HMA 79,56,843 15,61,127 5.04 1,131
8-3
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
Figure 8-1 presents various constituents of HMA and HH distribution within as per 2001 census.
As per the mandate of conducting home interview survey of 1.5% household residing in HMA, the
total population or households residing in the jurisdiction of HMA constitutes the universe for the
home interview survey. Our proposed approach is to cover approximately 1.5% of the total
households in HMA, selected on a random principle at various levels.
Census 2001 statistics suggests, the total number of households of all settlements (municipal and
non municipal towns, cantonment area as well as villages) contained within HMA as 1.56 million. The
latest provisional population figures and thereafter estimated number of households for Hyderabad
Metropolitan Area (HMA) suggests that it has reached to 2.25 million for the year 2011 (considering
10.5 million population and 4.75 as HH size). The proposed household sample for this survey (1.5%)
thus works out to be 33,000 households.
This total sample of 34,000 households has been further redistributed across high-density, moderate
density and low-density urban areas and separately for the rural hinterland. The logic used for
redistribution of this sample is as follows:
• For erstwhile MCH area with high population density, we shall be covering 1.1% of all
households contained within such cities.
• For rest of GHMC area which include 12 old municipal councils with moderate population
densities, we shall be covering 1.3% of all households.
• In Secunderabad Cantonment area which has similar densities we will cover around 1.3%
8-4
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
• HADA and rest of HUDA area which have lesser population density, we shall be covering 1.7% of
all households contained within.
• In extended HMDA area, a total of 8,000 sample HH will be surveyed which will make about
2.5%. Of which 2,000 samples will be taken from two municipalities and rest from over 700
villages.
• The balance number of households from 33,000 is being kept aside as a special sample to be
allotted to special interest groups/areas as the main survey progresses. In essence, these are
booster samples to be used to tackle any issue of under-representation in the main survey.
An estimate of number of HHs to be surveyed by each area is shown in Table 8-3.
Table 8-3: Proposed number of sample households by various Constituents of Study Area
Pop
Growth HH Size- Pop. – 2011 HH-2011 % HHs to be
Area HH-2001 Pop-1991 Pop-2001
between 2001 estimate estimate taken surveyed
1991-01
Erstwhile MCH 6,56,749 30,58,000 36,44,000 19% 5.55 42,02,000 8,13,000 1.10% 8,500
Surrounding
4,00,106 9,96,000 18,33,000 84% 4.58 30,65,000 7,18,000 1.30% 9,000
Municipalities (12 nos)
Secunderabad
42,565 1,71,000 2,06,000 20% 4.84 2,40,000 53,000 1.30%
Cantonment 700
HADA 24,501 1,47,000 144,000 -2% 5.88 1,50,000 27,000 1.70% 500
Rest of HUDA Area
1,11,789 2,16,000 534,000 147% 4.78 10,45,000 2,35,000 1.70%
including villages 4,000
Extended Area of
HMDA (Outside 3,25,417 12,30,000 15,93,000 30% 4.90 18,51,000 4,06,000 2.50% 9,300
HUDA area)
Total HMA 15,61,127 58,18,000 79,54,000 37% 5.10 1,05,53,000 22,52,000 32,000
8-5
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
Rural areas
About 13,000 HH samples is proposed to be covered from rest of the HUDA and extended HMDA
area which is primarily rural in nature with about 849 villages, two municipal councils and nine CTs.
As per the traffic zoning strategy, zoning in even undeveloped rural area will be fine enough with a
population holding capacity of 60-70,000 population in future years. This necessarily means that all
larger rural settlements/ villages and close surrounding agricultural/ vacant land will be a traffic
zone. To have sample representation from all such traffic zones, we will have to have sample
household survey in each large villages. At this stage, it is anticipated that each village with more
than 500 households will necessary have at least 12-15 household sample.
• Expected productivity
• Fieldwork period
• Frequency of reporting to the office and to whom
• Substitution at household level
• General approach to be adopted to convince respondent to give the interview
Mock Call
Mock call will be done to assess the interviewer’s understanding of the questionnaires. The
training/briefing sessions will go over a period 3 days, with the first two as classroom training and
the last one day for mock calls. The interviewers will be made to perform mock interviews, first
among themselves, and then, among randomly chosen Hyderabad residents (near the venue).
8-6
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
Accompaniment
The supervisor and the project executives will accompany investigators to at least some of the
household calls during the initial days of field work. The basic purpose behind this will be to impart
corrective field training to the investigators so as to fine-tune their abilities to administer the
questionnaire.
Back-check
The honesty and quality of work of an investigator will be verified through back checking. In the back
checking procedure the supervisor will contact the respondent personally and verify a few things
related to the work of an investigator. Key questions from the schedule will be administered again
just to check their consistency.
We are employing a professional group who has adequate experience of conducting interviews at
household level and have dedicated and trained investigators on their regular roll. The norms as
regards back-check generally followed in such survey will be as follows:
8-7
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
8.1.6 Monitoring Productivity
The field executives deployed for this study shall have the responsibility of monitoring productivity
of the investigators. This is crucial as the duration of the survey is limited and we have a rigid
completion date. The issues that the Filed Executives will be responsible to check are as follows:
• Keep a track of number of calls done by each investigator, on a daily basis, in a systematic
manner.
• Examine productivity of each investigator separately and find out the reason for low productivity
of concerned investigator and guide accordingly. If required, make a field visit to help the
investigator to increase productivity.
• Check the quality of work immediately of those who are giving a very high productivity. If
necessary, impose a ceiling for high productive investigators.
• Ensure each investigator goes to field during peak hours of availability of respondents targeted.
8-8
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
The best clarity possible with Cartosat image The best clarity possible with Google image
We view base map as a complete data set and not just a drawing as it used to be. As a first step
towards preparation of the base map the exercise of assimilating all spatial and attribute data from
various sources has been initiated. All the layers shall be overlaid with respect to their spatial
reference within the limits of accuracy and compatibility of the source data. This is essential to bring
all data, from different sources, to the same platform to be able to use it in a meaningful manner.
Also it will allow us to remodel and transform data in a format better suited for Transportation and
Traffic Modeling. For example the census data of 2001 when extracted is found to be spread across 5
districts in 36 Mandals with 849 villages and 26 towns, municipalities or corporations with 341
wards. While the village boundaries haven’t changed much over the period, the urban areas and
consequently the wards have undergone complete reorganization. At present there are 150 wards in
GHMC which covers 13 of the earlier municipalities. Two municipalities are still outside of GHMC
limits, though most of the census towns are amalgamated in one or the other of these 15 municipal
bodies. With so much reorganization it would be difficult to build a credible and usable urban
transport planning / modeling database without putting in significant investment in bringing diverse
sources (this is just one example!) of information together on a GIS platform.
The key vector / data layers proposed to be digitized for the strategic transport modeling and
planning purpose are listed below (Table 8-4). The spatial integrity and relationships will be enforced
and maintained through definition of topology rules to be defined within or across multiple layers of
spatial data as deemed necessary.
Table 8-4: The Key Vector / Data layers Proposed to be digitized
Category Sub Category Types Attributes Layer Description Topology
Network Links Roads (mixed Distance, Capacity, Speed, This layer to contain all network Link (Line)
traffic), BRT, Traffic management/ links with varied physical and
Rail, Metro restrictions, Volume, PT network attributes.
Routes & Schedules etc.
8-9
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
Category Sub Category Types Attributes Layer Description Topology
Nodes Intersections, Turn penalties / restrictions, This layer would provide Point
Bus stops, Saturation flows, Actual connections between links and
Transit Stops / Flows, Boarding / Alighting, used to define rules of direction
Interchanges etc. or mode change
Nodes Zone Centroids Trip Ends, All Zone Attributes These are pseudo nodes used to Point
represent a zone (an area) as a
point.
Links Dummy Links These are pseudo links used to Link (Line)
connect zone centroids to the
Network. Important and require
careful consideration to
realistically model traffic flows.
Land Use Existing Use Zones Area, Use Codes, Built up Area
area / FAR / FSI (Polygon)
Proposed Use Zones Area, Use Codes, Built up Area
area / FAR / FSI (Polygon)
Zones Boundaries TAZ Area, Population, Workers, Area
Students, Employment, etc. (Polygon)
8-10
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
network link. Towards this, selecting representative road sections and developing such VDF on each
is important. We at this stage propose to develop the exclusive VDF for the following categories (16
no.) of road sections. This, as per Consultant’s understanding represent the variety of roads that
HMA strategic road network has.
Table 8-5: Road Categories for VDF
Road Categories / Lane configuration Divided/ Undivided Traffic Management
SL/IL Undivided One Way
SL/IL Undivided Two Way
2/3 Lane Undivided One Way
2/3 Lane Undivided Two way
2 Lane Flyover Undivided One way
4 Lane (Effective 2 lane ) Divided Two way
4 Lane Undivided One Way
4 Lane Divided Two way
6 Lane Divided Two way
6 Lane (Flyover) Divided Two way
8 Lane Divided Two way
4 Lane NH (Rural portion) Divided Two way
4/6 Lane (Bypass/ORR) Divided Two way
Expressway Divided Two way
Long Bridge Divided Two way
8.3.2.1 Traffic Volume Count and or O-D / Occupancy Surveys at Outer Cordon/ Inner Cordon/
Screen Lines / Mid-block and Survey Locations
Study area is huge with many constituents such as GHMC, HADA, Cantonment board, urban out
growth, and rural pockets as well with varying travel characteristics and interaction level with rest of
the study area and rest of the state. The sole purpose of this survey is to assess three out of four
components of travel within study area such as Internal – External, External – Internal and External –
External by doing traffic volume count and O-D survey (for passenger and goods vehicles) at outer
cordon i.e. various gateways to study area. Since, study area is large with most of its population and
activity centre within GHMC, at all identified locations along Inner Cordon line too traffic volume
count and O-D survey will be conducted. Screen lines have been identified considering physical
barriers such as rivers, canals, and railway lines etc. or combination and previous studies. Further,
additional traffic volume count locations have been identified on important corridors for general
appreciation of traffic level, validation of the model and using it for preliminary round of potential
MRTS phase-II corridors for further analysis.
An attempt has been made to delineated outer-cordon lines, inner-cordon lines, screen-lines and
quantified survey requirement. The table below presents in summary, the quantum of surveys
identified along each of the cordon/screen lines.
8-11
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
Table 8-6: Quantum of TVC / O-D / Occupancy Survey along OC / IC / SLs / Mid-Blocks
Along Type of Survey Duration No. of Locations
Traffic Volume Count Survey 24 (Hrs.) 20
Outer Cordon Line
Origin – Destination Survey 24 (Hrs.) 20
Traffic Volume Count Survey 24 (Hrs.) 27
Inner Cordon Line
Origin – Destination Survey 24 (Hrs.) 27
Traffic Volume Count Survey 24 (Hrs.) 67
Screen-Line Occupancy Survey for Passenger
12 (Hrs.) 67
Vehicles
Mid-Block Locations Traffic Volume Count Survey 16 (Hrs.) 36
In all traffic volume count survey is proposed at 150 locations and O-D survey at 47 locations. Figure
8-2 in two parts present outer-cordon, inner-cordon, screen lines in the HMA area along with
identified survey locations. In view of ongoing traffic studies by GHMC on major roads in GHMC area,
exact locations of the mid-block traffic volume count survey will be decided in consultation with
client. Survey formats for traffic volume count and Roadside Origin-Destination Surveys are attached
in Volume 4 of this report.
8-12
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
Figure 8-2: Outer Cordon, Inner Cordon, Screen-Lines identified in the study area
8-13
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
Sl. No. Junction Name Location of Intersection In HMA area
14 Nacharan IDA jun East direction
15 Chandrayangutta South direction
16 Bhairamulguda South East ditection
17 Narsing West direction
18 APPA South west direction
19 Nalgonda X roads Core area
20 M J Market Core area
21 Nobel talkies Core area
22 Shapurnagar T Junction North direction( Jeedimetla road)
23 Indira seva sadan(IS sadan) Core area
24 Tirumalgiri X roads Sout East direction(on Bolaram Road)
25 Malkajigiri X roads Sout East direction
8-14
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
interview at regional terminal, interview of institutional population (3,000 such interview on
sample basis has been proposed) in hotels/ hostels/ guest houses, hospitals etc. We will have a
specific question to distinguish between local residents and floating population in all of the above
surveys so that characteristics and travel pattern of floating population can be separated.
8-15
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
Passenger survey - the IPT users will be interviewed to assess their trip characteristics in terms of
origin and destination of trip, purpose and cost of trips, home based or non-home based trips etc..
We will do 3,000 such interview covering Auto Rickshaw and Taxi users.
Operator Survey - this will provide IPT operational characteristics in terms of route of operation,
vehicle utilization, passengers carried/day, operating cost and revenue etc. We will do 500 such
interview of Auto / Taxi drivers.
The survey will be conducted at locations, like Railway stations, Bus Stations etc, with high
concentration of IPT modes and trips.
8-16
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
physical infrastructure available and its characteristics. This survey will be conducted at 10 locations
within HMA such as Kukatpally, ICD Sanat nagar, LB Nagar, Reti bowli, Sagar Road, Patan Cheruvu,
Gudi Malakpuri, Began Bazat, Monda market etc..
8-17
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
Table 8-9: Field Survey Programme
Sl. Proposed period of survey
Description of the survey
No. From To
Category 1
nd
1 Conducting Household Interview Survey June 2 week November last week
nd rd
2 Survey of Floating Population July 2 week August 3 week
Category 2
st th
3 Road Network Inventory Survey May 1 week August 4 week
nd th
4 Speed and Delay Survey July 2 week Sept 4 week
st rd
5 Surveys to Develop Speed – Flow Function Sept 1 week Oct 3 week
Category 3
Conduct Traffic Volume Count / O-D / Occupancy
nd
6 Surveys at Outer Cordon/ Inner Cordon/ Screen Lines / June 2 week August last week
Mid-block and Survey Locations
Turning Movement and Inventory Survey at Strategic nd nd
7 June 2 week August 2 week
Intersection/Junction
Category 4
nd nd
8 Traffic Surveys at Major Terminals (Road/ Rail/ Air) July 2 week Sept 2 week
nd
9 Goods Focal Point Survey May 2 week July last week
Category 5
nd rd
10 Work Place Survey May 2 week July 3 week
th nd
11 Commercial Vehicle Survey August 4 week Oct 2 week
Category 6
st rd
12 Parking Survey May 1 week June 3 week
st rd
13 Non-Motorized Traffic Survey Jun 1 week August 3 week
Category 7
rd th
14 MMTS / Sub-urban Railway Passenger Survey July 3 week August 4 week
th nd
15 Bus Passenger/On-Board Survey August 4 week Oct 2 week
rd th
16 IPT (Taxi and auto-rickshaw) Survey Sept 3 week Nov 4 week
st rd
17 Opinion Survey for (Bus, MMTS, IPT passengers) July 1 week August 3 week
8-18
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
9. URBAN TRANSPORT PLANNING MODEL
9.1 Background
Although transportation system is a complex urban function, the demand for travel is clearly
understood as primarily a function of land use characteristics and distribution. The purpose of the
urban transport planning (UTP) model is to simulate, as realistically as possible, the urban
transportation system in terms of demand supply interaction given the land use and transportation
system characteristics of the urban area.
To forecast travel demand under various policy and physical infrastructure levels, a mathematical
model needs to be built to simulate travel patterns of the region. These models should be capable
of:
• Modelling mode split, including walk, public transport modes (auto-rickshaws, taxi, bus and rail)
and private transport (motorcycle and car), good's vehicles.
• Assigning trips to MMTS and bus networks taking into account the characteristics like routes,
frequencies, speeds, fares and congestion etc. for these modes in comparison to each other and
to private modes of travel.
• Modelling impact of growth and development i.e. reflect changes in travel patterns due to
change in socio-economic characteristics, change in type and intensity of land use and the
transportation system:
- Reflecting the impact of introduction of new modes like Metro, BRT etc. on mode choice
and travel pattern.
- Reflecting the impact of network improvement and expansion.
- Reflecting the impact of new land use developments and /or control policies, including
residential, commercial or industrial areas, truck terminals, truck parking lots, interstate
bus terminal etc.
- Modelling the impact of land use conversion and change in densities on travel patterns.
• Reflecting impact of traffic demand management measures such as parking fees, road user
charges and congestion pricing, as well as the staggering of working hours, flexi hours and
multiple shift work.
The model so developed should be able to provide inputs to the economic evaluation of the
identified projects or bunch of the projects in terms of cost benefit analysis. It should allow the
economic feasibility to be expressed in terms of expected Net Present Value (NPV) and Economic
Internal Rate of Return (EIRR). It should be able to:
• Identify major items of likely economic benefits and dis-benefits.
• Establish appropriate value of travel time by trip purpose and vehicle operating costs
• Conduct a standard cost-benefit analysis for a project life cycle typically in the range of 20-30
years
• Conduct sensitivity analysis for investment program
• Assess project benefit distribution across the region
9-1
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
9.2 Defining Modeling Domain
The following sections define and describe the domain of the modeling exercise as envisaged for
developing the travel demand models for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA). In view of the
nature of the study and the geographical extent and complexity of development of the study area
the purview of modeling is fairly comprehensive to take into account all significant travel demand
determinants and reflect all aspects of travel demand. The implementation will be through a
sequence of sub-models that will use established practices and techniques, and be thoroughly
calibrated before final application. Improvisations, to established techniques, as per the specific
requirements or conditions of HMA will also be attempted and adopted after appropriate
benchmarking and testing. The Figure 9-1 is a simplified graphical representation of this modeling
domain and work flow.
Figure 9-1: Proposed UTP Modeling Domain and Workflow for HMA
9-2
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
9.2.1 Attributes of Travel Demand
The attributes of travel demand are used to describe the characteristics of travel in the city in
relation to the land use and transportation system. The following are the main attributes of travel
demand proposed to be analyzed and modeled through a series of sub-models.
• Trip Generations / Trip Rates
• Purpose of Travel / Activity
• Time of Travel
• Destination Choice
• Mode Choice
• Route Choice
• Travel Cost & Times
• Network / Links Capacity & Volumes
9-3
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
shall be understood through the analysis of vast secondary and primary data collected under the
study.
- Residential / Density
- Commercial / Employment
- Services / Employment / Capacity
- Industry / Production
• Population Characteristics: Understanding of the population in terms of its demographic and
socio-economic profile is equally important for understanding and modelling travel behaviour.
Following are some of the main parameters to be analysed for the purpose of travel demand
modelling.
- HH Size
- HH Income
- Vehicle Ownership
- Workers / Students Population
9-4
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
of preparation and is likely to be shortly release in the public domain for discussions and objection
process. While these development plans will be used to provide land use inputs to the UTP model,
the outputs of the model may be used to review the efficacy of these plans in terms of the
transportation system.
9-5
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
The modeling methodology proposed addresses all of the requirements of the TOR, provides a level
of detailed modeling not yet attempted in Hyderabad, to ensure a high level of usability for present
and compatibility for future requirements. A generalized form of the proposed modeling framework
is given in Figure 9-2 below.
9-6
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
As land use and network design are the primary planning interventions available with city planners,
the four-stage modeling gives them a strategic tool to evaluate the overall effectiveness and
efficiency of the land use or development plans prepared by them. This will be useful in defining the
long term vision for development and defining strategic growth pattern and direction for the HMA.
Further, the data and information generated from the model will be useful to all the agencies
involved in the operations, maintenance, management and regulation of the transportation and
traffic aspects in an incremental and ongoing basis. For example the APSRTC could use the model for
planning of bus routes and schedules, HMRL could use it for identification of potential metro routes
and assess ridership, GHMC and Traffic police will be able to assess traffic at mid-block sections and
intersections and suitably identify physical improvement and management or regulatory
interventions. Furthermore, all stakeholders will be able to assess the impact of any new
development or project or deviations from strategic plan on their area of operation through the
application of the model.
The land use and network are the main exogenic inputs to the modeling process. The “activity
system” or “land use” forecasts, which in practice consist of forecasts of the spatial (zonal)
distribution of population, employment etc. and detailed computer representation of the road and
transit networks (and their performance characteristics). An important point should be noted
concerning the way these inputs enter the four-stage process. Although the “activity system”
forecasts of population and employment distributions are shown as inputs to the trip generation
stage, characteristics of trip-makers can and, in fact, do enter as explanatory variables within other
stage of the process, in particular, mode split, within which variable such as age, occupation,
possession of a driver’s license, and number of household vehicles play important roles in
determining trip-makers modal choices.
The major outputs of the process shall be estimates of network links flows by mode (i.e. private and
public), as well as associated link flow related variables such as:
• average link travel times and speeds;
• link volume-to-capacity ratios;
• link operating costs by mode;
• various transit ridership characteristics such as boarding and alighting by transit line; and
• other variables which can be calculated as a function of links times, speeds and / or volumes
(e.g. vehicle emissions or energy consumption using -speed-based models).
9-7
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
approach to modeling and choice of specific tools or techniques will be determined on the basis of
our assessment of the quality, suitability and robustness of the data as it becomes available. A
generalized form of the proposed modeling framework is given in Figure below.
9-8
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
As Figure 9-3 shows, we are proposing a standard 4-stage; recursive model – with a number of
refinements to best address the unique properties of the transportation system of HMA. These
include:
• Modeling the sub-regions (within the overall regional model) using travel parameters specific to
each region (e.g. trip rates, trip distribution functions etc.);
• the role of IPT as an ‘auxiliary’ transit mode – in order to address its importance as an access
mode to rail;
• the use of capacity restrained assignments for transit – to take account of the difference in
existing MMTS and imminent Metro;
• a form of ‘destination choice’ model to more accurately distribute HBW and HBE trips. The very
significant proportion of the labor force that is in the ‘informal’ sector (upto 70%) requires that
these trips are allocated to the correct workplaces. Similarly, the large number of education trips
need to be correctly allocated to the appropriate institutions, and not at random; and
• an NMT model to specifically model NMT trips that are ‘all the way’, rather than just as an access
mode.
Our proposed approach to the detailed modeling of the HMA is a ‘holistic’ one, whereby we
recognize that each of the sub-regions of HMA may have their own specific socio-economic and trip-
making characteristics; and all co-exist, and interact, inter-dependently (rather than independently)
as vital, and dynamic, components of the metropolitan area.
We intend to understand the travel interaction within and between each sub-region as an integral
part of the model we will develop for the HMA. Socio-economic and infrastructural changes made in
one sub-region will inevitably affect travel patterns to/from other sub-regions, and we feel that we
must directly address these dynamic links between the sub-regions. Therefore, we will separately
calibrate and validate trip generation / attraction models for each sub-region. We will investigate the
practicality of separately developing trip distribution and modal choice models for each sub-region.
These sub-models will be calibrated (and validated) to each sub-region but will be applied to each
sub-region in their regional context. It presently appears that there will be a need to develop 6 sub-
regional models, as below:
• GHMC;
• HADA;
• CDA;
• ORRGC;
• Outer Municipalities
• Rest of HMA (Rural Areas);
The following sections describe, in more detail, the various components of the model.
9-9
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
schedules. The ‘potential’ schemes will be tested in the model and evaluated on traffic and
economic considerations, assuming that these schemes have been fully evaluated and that no
further financial analyses of these schemes will be required.
Separate road, bus and rail networks will be developed based on our own network inventories and
also on data provided by the relevant transit operators. Road, bus and rail networks will be
developed for each design year. All networks are described in terms of ‘nodes’ and ‘links’. However,
the attributes of each network type are very different.
The road network is defined in terms of:
• Link length;
• Link type;
• Link width / number of lanes;
• Volume / delay function etc.
The bus network is similarly described, as the buses operate on the same roads, but with additional
information on:
9-10
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
9-11
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
Transportation Modes
The modes to be modeled are:
For future years we will model additional new modes in order to incorporate proposed schemes
such as three metro corridors under HMRL are already under implementation through PPP.
One important consideration is that the model must be able to cater for travel by auto-rickshaw in
both of its roles as:
9-12
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
We anticipate that these will be the main purposes modeled – however, we will obtain clarification
of the relative importance of each trip purpose from the results of our Household Interview Survey
(HIS) and Roadside Interview Surveys (RIS’s).
For the purposes of forecasting it will be necessary to develop a relationship between average
household size and population density. Traditionally one would expect higher household sizes to be
associated with areas with high population densities. Given a future year zonal population (and
consequently a population density) it will possible to estimate the average zonal household size.
9-13
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
This same approach will be used to estimate the numbers of household members in full-time
education – as part of the Household Students Sub-Model (HEM).
9-14
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
9.6.4.4 Vehicle Availability Model (VAM)
The above models will provide the following inputs to the Vehicle Availability Model:
9-15
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
It is anticipated that the data will be suitably robust to enable us to develop trip generation and
attraction rates for each of the sub-regions separately. This would tend to shift preference towards a
multinomial regression approach in which a ‘sub-region’ variable could be included in the
formulation. This will be investigated.
9-16
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
It is further proposed to designate the primary mode of travel as follows:
9-17
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
Train
Bus
No vehicle
available
IPT
NMT
Households
Own Vehicle
Train
Vehicle
Bus
available
IPT
NMT
9-18
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
Access modes will also be modelled by means of a similar formulation:
Choose Transit
Access Modes
Trip End
Model
Trip
MAIN Highway Transit MAIN
Distribution
MODEL Networks Networks MODEL
Model
Matrix
Manipulation
GOODS MAIN
MODEL MODEL
9-19
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
The long travel distances associated with external trips renders trip distribution by gravity model
unsuitable. However, we will investigate the use of gravity models for these trips. Trip distribution
will most likely be undertaken by means of FRATAR techniques, but if time and resources permit, we
may also investigate the use of a ‘direct demand model’ to estimate and distribute external trips.
The projections of the regional travel demand will likely be based on the regional econometric
models considering economic growth as the basis of increased regional interactions.
9-20
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
Roadside Special Freight
Interview Generator Terminal
Surveys Surveys Surveys
Trip
Distribution
Model
Goods
Matrix EXT'NAL
Vehicle
Manipulation MODEL
Matrices
MAIN
MODEL
9-21
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
3. Access modes to rail and bus (i.e. NMT and IPT) will initially be assigned as person-trips so as
to facilitate the transfer of person-trips between NMT/IPT and transit modes. Assigned
person-trips on access links used by IPT will be post-processed to factor them to PCU-trip
volumes which will be preloaded to the road network;
4. The remaining IPT trips will be assigned to the road network as PCU-trips, together with the
private vehicle and goods vehicle PCU-trip matrices.
Bus PCU-trips will also be pre-loaded to the road network in order to represent their contribution to
traffic congestion and, consequently, congested road speeds; and
Private vehicle and goods vehicle PCU-trips will then be assigned to the road network.
This assignment is now the fully loaded road assignment. The resulting speeds on the road network
will be fed back into the bus network to ensure that congested road times are incorporated into the
bus transit assignment.
It may be that another series of assignments will need to be made at this stage in order to ensure
that the assigned road and bus speeds are in equilibrium.
Once equilibrium has been achieved at this level, it will be necessary to feed these congested speeds
back into the detailed model at the TEM stage so that the trip generation / attraction, trip
distribution and mode choice phases also incorporate congested speeds within their own processes.
This wider level equilibrium feedback loop will be repeated until the system-wide travel times across
all modes have converged to equilibrium.
It is envisaged that transit assignments will be on the basis of generalized cost (i.e. to incorporate
the effects of fares, waiting times, transfer times, access times etc. in the route-choice decision-
making mechanism). NMT will also be assigned using generalized cost parameters. For private
vehicle and goods vehicle assignment we will investigate whether time or generalized costs-based
assignments produce the more reliable results.
9-22
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
The validation process will ensure that the traffic model is able to satisfactorily synthesize base year
trip-making and travel patterns - at both the regional and sub-regional levels. The ability of the
model to satisfactorily ‘back forecast’ will give confidence in its ability to forecast trip-making and
travel patterns into the future.
Appropriate ‘goodness of fit’ and confidence intervals will be provided as an essential part of the
validation exercise.
9-23
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
Applications of outputs include performance estimates of Bus lanes and truck traffic, location
analysis of existing and future public transport and roadway facilities, and computation of least-cost
paths according to any desired cost function.
ArcGIS plug-in for EMME provides native access to geo-referenced maps and GIS data. ArcGIS map
layers appear alongside native EMME map layers, and provide a rich visual context to supplement
visualization, network editing, analysis, and report generation. EMME also provides built-in utilities
for shape file import and export. Import base network data directly from a route system
representation in a polyline shape file or from node/link shape files, and copy DBF attributes to
EMME native attributes. The Shape file to EMME Conversion tool retains the network's topology,
efficiently computes line crossings, and splits polyline shapes as needed. Shape file export utilities
create shape file representations of any planning scenario in the EMME Database, including nodes,
links and new link shape, transit lines and transit segments, so that it is possible to display and
analyze EMME results in GIS packages, or in other software that can read shape files.
9-24
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
10. LONG TERM TRANSPORT STRATEGY
10.1 Focus
The TOR describes in some detail the desired components of the CTS. The strategies must reflect the
agreed statements of the vision for the HMA and the specific goals, objectives, policies and
performance measures agreed with the TAC at the beginning of the study. However these should not
be considered as being cast in stone. If it is found that some revisiting and refinements are necessary
during the course of the study suggestions will be brought back to the TAC for their guidance and
confirmation, in order that the final CTS recommendations and the agreed set of goals, objectives
and policies are in harmony. During the course of the Mumbai CTS, it was found necessary to obtain
confirmation of key, interim strategic policies, that were not apparent at the study commencement,
but would significantly influence the conduct of the study and the formulation of final strategies and
project implementation recommendations
i. The strategies must be visionary as well as practical and be policy driven. The HMA is a complex
and evolving urban area in a country undergoing profound economic and social change. The
strategies and related plans may have to embody transportation solutions, priorities and
investments which cater to more than one potential long term future. Based on our discussion
with stakeholders it is recognized that shorter term strategies should be tightly defined but
should be more flexible in relation to the longer term. We should not hesitate to acknowledge
that there are limitations on our ability to predict the many values and activities that shape our
cities and set our priorities.
ii. The strategies must ensure the maintenance of the existing transportation services in a state of
good repair and promote positive change to overcome critical capacity deficiencies to support
economic growth and urban expansion.
iii. The strategies must be economically viable but from a broad perspective. The benefits of good
transportation extend far beyond traditional indicators such as reduced travel time and cost.
Among other factors, good transportation can promote increased job opportunities and reduced
housing costs by increasing accessibility to greater variety of housing and employment choices.
iv. The plan must be supportive of a “healthy HMA” but must recognize the increasing public
demands for greater mobility and freedom of choice of travel mode. Any consideration of
constraining private transport mobility carries the obligation of providing a reasonably
comparable alternative public transport mode.
v. The strategies should ensure that high quality transport consisting of urban freeways and
different types of transit systems, that predominately serves middle/ higher income segments of
the community, should be user funded and implemented at no or little financial or social risk to
the public at large particularly the poor.
vi. Strategies and plans must improve public safety which may require constraints on the freedom
of movement or greater user protection, discipline and enforcement.
vii. Immediate attention and allocation resources needed should be given to pedestrian travel and
safety. It is the largest and most sustainable form of urban travel but suffers from severe
10-1
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
degradation and neglect. It has been given very low priority from a level of service and safety
standpoint.
viii. Investments should be programmed to secure improvements to the ‘public realm’ compatible
with qualities that we expect in our private spaces.
ix. The strategies should perhaps promote the premise that transportation infrastructure capital
needs to meet growth demands, should be substantially paid for by growth, i.e. possibly
Development Charges
x. The strategies should promote the mobilization of financial resources from a wide spectrum of
other urban activities that benefit from an improved or well-maintained transport infrastructure.
xi. The strategies and implementation plans must be a HDA driven solution. However lessons
learned from other major competing cities can provide an insight and guidance on what can be
accomplished or what is needed to sustain an environmentally, economically and socially
successful city in a global context.
10-2
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
11. RESOURCE MOBILIZATION
Urban transport on an average accounts for nearly 68% of the urban infrastructure investments. In
metropolitan areas where elevated or underground rail based transit systems are required this may
further increase. The existing system of mobilizing financial resources is obviously inadequate
particularly so in case of urban transport.
13 “Report on Indian Urban Infrastructure and Services” High Powered Expert Committee, New Delhi, March 2011
11-1
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
Following Table 11-2 summarizes the sources of funds used by various metropolitan transport
agencies across the world.
Table 11-2: Potential Sources of Funds for Urban Transport Infrastructure
Sl. No. City Organization Sources of Funds (Other than PT Fares)
1 Paris Syndicat des Transports Dedicated employer tax; local, region, Department
d’lle-de-France (STIF) general revenue
2 London Transport for London (TFL) Congestion charges, central & local Govt. general
revenue
3 New York Metropolitan Federal, State and local Govt. general revenue;
Transportation Authority dedicated taxes on petroleum businesses, mortgages
(MTA) and real estate; bridge/tunnel tolls
4 Vancouver TransLink Dedicated gasoline, property, power, parking taxes
5 Madrid Consorcio Regional National, Regional and local Govt. subsidies (not
Transporte (CRTM) dedicated)
6 Singapore Land Transport Authority National (local) Govt. general revenue, much of which
(LTA) is derived from auto registration, gas taxes, parking,
congestion fees
Source: Sam Zimmerman “Institutions for Urban Transport” the World Bank
From the above, sources of funds could be broadly divided into four categories viz.
• Intergovernmental transfers
• Local revenues
• Private investment
• Borrowings
These are considered in some further details in following paragraphs.
11-2
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
Source Base
Fees
Transport Use Fees
Fare box revenues Trip undertaken by public transport
Road user charges Some measure of road usage, weighted for congestion
Tolls Use of road or bridge
Parking fees Time, location and duration of parking
Fuel cess Surrogate of road usage
Vehicle tax One time or annual
Development Impact Fee Impact of proposed development on off-site infrastructure
Transport Cess Sale of fuel in urban area
Use of Public Land Unlocking the value of public land
11.2.4 Borrowings
Since infrastructure investments are lumpy and with longer gestation period they are difficult to be
financed through accumulated savings of operating agencies. Borrowing therefore becomes
necessary and also helps in transferring of part of the cost to next generation who are also going to
be the beneficiaries of the investments. Borrowings could be from financial institutions or by directly
accessing capital markets through bonds. External aid is also a potential source. Borrowings for
projects in PPP mode are also necessary. Specialized agencies like India Infrastructure Finance
Company Limited (IIFCL) have been set up for financing infrastructure.
11-3
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
12. INSTITUTIONAL DEVELOPMENT
12.1 Background
Urban Transport sector is characterized by multiplicity of organizations mainly on account of the
evolutionary nature of the sector. Initially municipalities were responsible for constructing and
maintaining streets and providing streetlights. As the traffic grew, police had to be brought in to
control traffic and enforce rules. Railways that were essentially for long distance freight and
passenger movements began to provide suburban services in metropolitan cities. Hyderabad is not
an exception. Following agencies could be identified as the ones engaged in transport sector in
Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA).
• Greater Hyderabad Municipal Corporation (GHMC)
• Hyderabad Metropolitan Development Authority (HMDA)
• Hyderabad Metro Rail Ltd. (HMRL)
• Andhra Pradesh State Road Transport Corporation (APSRTC)
• Indian Railways for MMTS/ Suburban rail system
• Secunderabad Cantonment Board
• Hyderabad Airport Development Authority (HADA)
• Roads and Buildings Department, GoAP
• National Highways Authority of India (NHAI)
• Various Grampanchayats.
• District Administration
• Traffic Police
In such a context integrated development of transport infrastructure (with due recognition of
transport land use interdependence) and integrated delivery of services becomes an institutional
challenge.
12-1
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
Such Metropolitan Transport Authorities would need statutory backing in order to be meaningful”.
JNNURM also supported setting up of UMTA as a significant reform.
12-2
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
The functions of metropolitan transport authorities could be conceptualized as follows:
1. Strategic Planning
2. Investment, management, operations, policy planning
3. System/corridor planning
4. Financial planning
5. Long and short-term priority setting, decision making for investment, operating subsidies
6. Infrastructure project implementation
7. Service, operations regulation enforcement
8. Strategic service, operations managing
9. PT Service planning
10. Daily PT operation, management
How many of the above functions are performed by the metropolitan transport authorities are given
in matrix below.
Consorcio Regional
Transporte (CRTM)
Metropolitan
TransLink
(MTA)
(LTA)
(TFL)
Authority/ City
Si.
Functions Paris London New York Vancouver Madrid Singapore
No.
1 Strategic Planning √ √ √ √ √ √
Investment, management,
2 √ √ √ √ √ √
operations, policy planning
3 System/corridor planning √ √ √ √ √ √
4 Financial planning √ √ √ √ √ √
Long and short-term priority
setting, decision making for
5 √ √ √ √ √ √
investment, operating
subsidies
Infrastructure project
6 √ √ √ √ √
implementation
Service, operations regulation
7 √ √ √ √ √ √
enforcement
Strategic service, operations
8 √ √ √ √ √ √
managing
9 PT Service planning √ √
Daily PT operation,
10 √
management
12-3
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
Metropolitan Transport Authority (MTA) of New York is the only agency that performs all the 10
functions. Agencies in Paris, London and Vancouver do not perform the functions related to PT
service planning and daily PT operation and management.
In the context of the long term and medium term transport plans the functions of the Hyderabad
UMTA will be reviewed and suggestion will be given as appropriate.
12-4
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
13. MEDIUM AND SHORT TERM INVESTMENT PROGRAM
13.1 Introduction
Developing a program, which would enable implementation, is an important part of CTS. Due to the
limited resources with the implementing agency, it is required to identify projects which are of
relatively of greater importance than the others from the perspective of the society. Thereafter,
based on the resources available with the implementing agency, the phasing of implementation, and
hence the investment program, will be undertaken. This chapter highlights the steps which will be
followed for undertaking the activity.
13-1
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
13.3 Evolving Investment Program
Project implementation and investment program is expected to provide a guideline for the
implementing agency, and hence should be such that its implementation leads to maximisation of
the benefit to the society. For evolving the same, the projects, as prioritised, will be considered for
preparation of the investment program. The steps which will be followed are described below:
(i) Prioritised list of projects will be used for arriving at the formation of the corridors, since the
projects, as defined above, may be only a part of the full corridor;
(ii) The projects, leading to corridor formation, will be bunched together, while still maintaining
the priority;
(iii) From the financial analysis, the likely funding option, by each project will be identified;
(iv) Years required for implementation will be established by each project. This will result in
investment phasing by each project;
(v) The projects, as identified for short, medium and long term, shall be phased out over 30
years;
(vi) Based on the assessed likely source of funding, estimate the requirement of funds annually,
by the various sources - lending agencies in the form of loan, private sector or the
implementing agency – across all the projects;
(vii) Match with the institutional capacity in terms of annual availability of funds with the
government, the manpower available to undertake such works along with the expertise and
knowledge with the implementing agency;
(viii) Based on the above stated constraints, the project implementation will be phased out
further, ensuring a realistic project implementation and investment program, and at the
same time ensuring maximum benefits to the society.
An example of Medium and Short-Term investment plan from one of our previous experiences in
similar assignment is shown in Table 13-1 for illustration.
13-2
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
Table 13-1: A Typical Investment Plan (for illustration)
Investment Program with no Constraints (All investments in Mill Rs)
Likely
Likely
PPP
PPP Govt % Govt
Project Length Cost (Rs. Cum. Cost Candid
Project Name Candid SPV3 Funds/ Commit 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 - - 2032
No. (Kms.) Mill) (Rs. Mill) ate
ate with Annuity4 ment
without
Grant 2
Grant1
METRO SYSTEM
M7 XX 15.9 21942 21942 √ 0 4388 4388 4388
M5 XX 12.4 17112 39054 √ 0 3422 3422 3422
M11 XX 19.4 26800 65854 √ 0 5360 5360 5360 5360
-
M12 XX 27.2 31824 141078 √ 0 6365 6365 6365 6365 6365
M4 XX 7.5 10350 151428 √ 40 3105 3105 4140
-
M10 XX 29.9 56175 311091 √ 40 11235 11235 11235 11235 11235
M6 XX 17.2 51280 362371 √ 40 10256 10256 10256 10256 10256
-
M18 XX 18.8 35248 516938 √ 0 7050 7050 7050 7050 7050
M16 XX 13.2 34470 551408 √ 40 10341
M23 15.9 50241 601649 √ 0
Total From private Sector 28216 28216 49238 41427 42842 25313 36873 17713 27522 21368 21368 9808 16013 0
Total Grant from Government 0 0 14015 14015 18531 16875 24582 11809 13648 9545 9545 1839 5975 0
M17 XX 24.1 51690 51690 √ 40 10338 10338 10338
-
M20 XX 30.5 40280 108140 √ 100 8056 8056 8056 8056
-
M21 XX 13.8 21190 149970 √ 40
M22 XX 9.9 14408 164378 √ 100
SPV _govt (50% of total) 5169 5169 5169 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1799 0
SPV other than government (50% of total) 5169 5169 5169 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1799 0
Government Funding 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 4851 12907 14524 10651 10651 0
Total commitment + Grant 5169 5169 19184 14015 18531 16875 24582 11809 18499 22452 24069 12490 18425 0
78% private 22% govt (Same as Metro
Rolling stock for Metro Corridors 156760 156760 Corridors) 7125 7125 7125 7125 7125 7125 7125 7125 7125 7125 7125 7125 7125 7125
TOTAL INVESTMENT IN METRO SYSTEM
922787 45679 45679 80717 62568 68499 49314 68580 36647 53146 50946 52563 29424 43362 7125
- TOTAL PRIVATE
SECTOR
INVESTMENT 573889 33773 33773 54796 46985 48400 30871 42431 23271 33079 26926 26926 15366 21571 5558
- INVESTMENT
ON SPV
PROJECTS
OTHER THAN
GOVERNMENT
SECTOR 42435 5169 5169 5169 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1799 0
- TOTAL GOVERNMENT INVESTMENT
306463 6737 6737 20752 15583 20099 18443 26149 13376 20066 24020 25637 14058 19993 1568
SUB-URBAN RAIL SYSTEM
SR7 XX 13.9 8340 8340 √ 0 3336
SR1 XX 40.1 24060 32400 √ 0 4812 4812 4812
SR5 XX 26.9 16140 48540 √ 0 4842 6456
-
SR8 XX 5.4 3240 98100 √ 40 972 972 1296
SR2 XX 60.9 36546 134646 √ 40 7309 7309 7309 7309 7309
SR10 XX 12.5 7500 142146 √ 0 2250 2250 3000
S3 XX 10.6 6360 148506 √ 40
Total From private Sector 17796 23713 10849 8050 4386 4386 6636 6636 7386 0 0 0 0 0
Total Grant from Government 0 4025 4025 5366 2924 2924 2924 2924 2924 0 0 0 0 0
Rolling stock for new sub-urban lines/ operations
33330 100% Private Sector as for Rail lines 1515 1515 1515 1515 1515 1515 1515 1515 1515 1515 1515 1515 1515 1515
TOTAL INVESTMENT IN SUB-URBAN RAIL
181836
SYSTEM 19311 29253 16389 14931 8824 8824 11074 11074 11824 1515 1515 1515 1515 1515
- TOTAL PRIVATE SECTOR INVESTMENT
151258 19311 25228 12364 9565 5901 5901 8151 8151 8901 1515 1515 1515 1515 1515
- TOTAL GOVERNMENT INVESTMENT
30578 0 4025 4025 5366 2924 2924 2924 2924 2924 0 0 0 0 0
FREEWAY SYSTEM
H6 XX 34.0 7340 7340 √ 0 1835 1835 1835
H5 XX 22.0 4750 12090 √ 0 1188 1188 1188
-
H15 XX 26.0 5620 23130 √ 0 1405 1405 1405 1405
H12 XX 14.0 3030 26160 √ 40 909 909 1212
H14 XX 33.8 7300 33460 √ 0 1825 1825 1825 1825
H8 XX 35.5 7670 41130 √ 0 1918 1918 1918 1918
H23 XX 8.9 8010 49140 √ 0 2403 2403 3204
H16 XX 14.9 3220 52360 √ 40 966 966 1288
H10 XX 26.0 5610 57970 √ 0 1403 1403 1403 1403
H7 XX 18.6 4020 61990 √ 0 1206 1206 1608
-
H4 XX 18.1 21690 109090 √ 0 6507
Total From private Sector 5472 5821 10457 6159 6873 6146 3204 0 580 1982 3381 8000 14909 0
Total Grant from Government 0 233 596 674 485 0 0 0 386 386 515 961 961 0
H20 XX 26.0 62350 62350 √ 40 15588 15588 15588 15588
H21 XX 38.0 91200 153550 √ 40 22800 22800 22800 22800
H24 XX 21.2 4579 158129 √ 40 1145 1145
SPV _govt (50% of total) 0 0 0 0 0 7794 7794 19194 19194 11400 11400 572 572 0
SPV other than government (50% of total) 0 0 0 0 0 7794 7794 19194 19194 11400 11400 572 572 0
Government Funding 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total commitment + Grant 0 233 596 674 485 7794 7794 19194 19580 11786 11915 1533 1533 0
TOTAL INVESTMENT IN FREEWAY SYSTEM
267219 5472 6054 11053 6833 7358 21733 18792 38388 39354 25169 26697 10106 17015 0
- TOTAL PRIVATE
SECTOR
INVESTMENT 101970 5472 5821 10457 6159 6873 6146 3204 0 580 1982 3381 8000 14909 0
- INVESTMENT
ON SPV
PROJECTS
OTHER THAN
GOVERNMENT
SECTOR 79065 0 0 0 0 0 7794 7794 19194 19194 11400 11400 572 572 0
- TOTAL GOVERNMENT INVESTMENT
86185 0 233 596 674 485 7794 7794 19194 19580 11786 11915 1533 1533 0
OTHER COMPONENTS
Sub-urban rail improvements 132350 100% Govt Investment 6016 6016 6016 6016 6016 6016 6016 6016 6016 6016 6016 6016 6016 6016
Arterial Corridors: Upgradation 781.4 101010 100% Govt Investment 6734 6734 6734 6734 6734 6734 6734 8081
Arterial Corridors: New Links 419 60340 100% Govt Investment 4023 4023 4023 4023 4023 4023 4023 4827
Road Safety & Traffic 65450 100% Govt Investment 2975 2975 2975 2975 2975 2975 2975 2975 2975 2975 2975 2975 2975 2975
Bus System: Bus fleet & 50% each -Private and Govt sector
Depots for EBL operations 24500 investment 3063 3063 1531 1531 1531 1531 1225
Bus System: Bus fleet for 18300 100% Govt Investment 832 832 832 832 832 832 832 832 832 832 832 832 832 832
Passenger Water Transport 50% each -Private and Govt sector
(PWT) 4800 investment 686 686 686 686 686
Terminals (Truck, Bus, Inter- 50% each -Private and Govt sector
city rail) 30400 investment 1737 1737 1737 1737 1737 3040 3040 3040 3040
TOTAL INVESTMENT IN 437150 26065 26065 23002 23002 12246 9823 11354 25151 25151 25151 9823 9823 9823 26996
- TOTAL PRIVATE SECTOR INVESTMENT
29850 2743 2743 1211 1211 1211 0 766 2286 2286 2286 0 0 0 2133
- TOTAL GOVERNMENT INVESTMENT
407300 23322 23322 21791 21791 11034 9823 10588 22865 22865 22865 9823 9823 9823 24863
TOTAL TRANSPORT PLAN FINANCING
TOTAL INVESTMENT
96526 107050 131161 107334 96926 89694 109800 111260 129474 102780 90597 50867 71714 35636
TRANSPORT SYSTEM 1808992
GRAND TOTAL PRIVATE 856966 61299 67565 78828 63920 62384 42917 54551 33707 44845 32708 31822 24881 37995 9205
SECTOR
SPV PROJECT FUNDING
OTHER THAN GOVERNMENT 5169 5169 5169 0 0 7794 7794 19194 19194 11400 11400 572 2371 0
(50% OF SPV INVESTMENT) 121500
GRAND TOTAL GOVERNMENT
30059 34316 47164 43414 34542 38983 47455 58359 65435 58672 47375 25414 31349 26431
FUNDING
830526
- COUNTERPART FUNDING
9018 10295 14149 13024 10363 11695 14237 17508 19631 17601 14213 7624 9405 7929
REQUIRED (30% OF TOTAL) 249158
- LOAN FROM FUNDING 581368 21041 24021 33015 30390 24179 27288 33219 40851 45805 41070 33163 17790 21944 18502
AGENCIES (70% OF TOTAL)
1-100% investment from Private Sector
2- 40% of grant from Government and 60% investment from Private Sector
3 - 50% investment from Government and 50% from other sources than Government
4 - 100% from Government Funds
13-3
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
14. SKILL AND KNOWLEDGE TRANSFER
14.1 Focus
Transportation Plan development and implementation for a city like Hyderabad and its surrounding
areas falling in the Hyderabad Metropolitan Area is a very specialised and mammoth task. This is to
be performed by a multi-disciplinary teams with expertise in urban and regional Planning, Social
Sciences, Transportation Planning, Transport Systems Design and Development, Transport Systems
Operations, Traffic Systems Management, legal Aspects etc.,.
In many of the developed countries the transport systems in large cities are planned, developed and
operated in a very co-ordinated way for meeting the aspirations of the people. Invariably the city
transport system is ought to be people centric and not vehicle centric. In the sense the transport
systems will have to be so planned, designed, developed and operated to provide transportation at
the least cost, improve accessibility to all sections of the people, and cause minimal damage to the
living environment. At present in India the urban transport systems are mostly planned and
implemented in haphazard manner and operated in competition with each other resulting in
avoidable diseconomies and detrimental environmental conditions. Imparting training and getting
geared to this major challenge potentially needs major institutional and capacity building efforts and
reforms.
Chapter 12 of this Inception Report titled as “Institutional Development” has mentioned the list of
institutions / agencies involved in urban transport development, maintenance of infrastructure and
management. It has also deliberated on the need of having clear organization structure and skills to
perform the functions envisaged for each of the agencies. While need of strengthening and re-
organization of institutional set up to be able to handle urban transport related functions shall be an
outcome of the ongoing study, importance of skill enhancement of select officers can not be
overemphasized.
Towards this, several efforts and decisions are needed. It should be an ongoing effort. Some part of
this effort in this direction is envisaged as part of the CTS for HMA.
14-1
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
propose to take up this level of training as early as possible so that the senior functionaries, dealing
with the transport systems planning and development at high levels of decision making in HMA are
exposed upfront to appreciate some of the good practices followed in setting up the
organisations/institutions for accomplishing efficient, equitable, and environment friendly urban
transport systems in cities similar to the size of HMA.
Level –2: Overseas Training: Hands on Training on Transport Modelling and Allied Aspects
The purpose of this level of training is to ensure the transfer of knowledge and sustainability of
modelling method proposed. It is proposed for select 10 officers for two weeks in the original
software developer’s country so as to have hands on experience & interaction with software
developers. In this assignment, as EMME/3 is proposed to be used as UTP Modelling software,
Montreal (in Canada) will be the place to visit for training. Officers will be trained on EMME/3
model-concepts, procedures, network coding, calibration and validation of Model. This will be done
at INRO’s (developers of EMME/3) headquarters at Montreal, Canada. Further, the officers will
attend Lectures at LEA’s office in Toronto on application of EMME/3 model for Greater Toronto area.
Experts will conduct this program. In addition, these officers shall be participating with Consultants
team at Hyderabad, to work together, as team, as per the progress of modelling works.
Level-3: Basic concept of Transport Planning/ Modelling/ Project Financing & Engineering
The training is designed for engineers and planners entrusted with planning of transport projects in
GHMC, APSRTC, HMDA, HMRL, Traffic Police and other agencies and who are required to understand
quantitative methods of urban transport planning and demand modelling concepts. It is for about
10-15 officers. Duration could be decided as we progress further in the assignment and have more
interaction with client.
At the end of program the participants are expected to possess the basic understanding of the
transport planning and travel demand modelling concepts. This is expected to enable them in
appreciating models being developed for the HMA, its application to their respective areas, as part
of this study. The courses that will be taught are given under:
• Basic concepts of Transport Planning/Traffic Engineers
• Travel Demand Modelling/usage of UTP Model
• Data Management
• Project Evaluation/Prioritization
• Project Financing
• Investment Programming
• Transport Management and Implementation
• Social and Environmental Dimension in Transportation
• Any other aspects felt appropriate by the client.
Level-4: On-the-Job Training
At this level, we expect HMDA to deploy 3-4 junior level professionals qualified in traffic and
transportation in project office as counter-part staff to work with the project team. This we feel is
14-2
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
the only effective way to ensure complete knowledge transfer to a level who would be responsible
to handle the work beyond the tenure of the ongoing project.
14.3 Incumbents
List of incumbents shall be finalized by reviewing “Institutional Arrangement of Transport” in HMA.
This task aims at review of the existing systems and frameworks that would necessarily include a
capability assessment survey of the implementing agencies for short, intermediate and long term
urban transport development.
At the end, we would be able to suggest/advise on the list of officers to be considered for training at
various levels and seek consent of client.
14-3
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
15. STUDY PROGRESS AND MONITORING THE OUTCOMES
Apart from regular meetings with TAC, we propose to hold meetings once in two weeks in the first
six months and there after once in a month till the closure of study to discuss overall project
progress, issues and dependencies, if any with client to provide feedback and seek feedback on this
important study.
15-1
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
16. FACILITATION AND ADVICE NEEDED
16-1
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
16.2 Feedback and Timely Advice
HMDA has set up TAC to review and advise the study. In addition, at some important mile
stones/stages project team is to meet the UMTA and keep it informed on the progress and findings
to seek its’ guidance.
We would request to call TAC meeting, within a week on submission of a deliverable. This will give us
opportunity to discuss and present our view and findings as appropriate depending on the stage of
work, to see seek advise and inputs from TAC to move on with the project work, with respect to
assigned mandate as per the ToR and/Contract. Feedback in terms of comments and advice of TAC,
if any as appropriate can be incorporated in the subsequent submissions and works. We would like
to underline in assignment of this nature, timely advice and inputs (say within 15 days) are critical
for the team to proceed with the work. We would therefore request that the delays should be
avoided as much as possible.
We would request the UMTA and TAC, apart from others, to provide views and guidance on the
larger issues of importance, viz. Visioning, Economic Base, Population Size, Work Force Participation,
Women in Work Force, Growth Paradigms, Institutional Aspects, Financing Aspects, Instruments to
raise resources for Plan financing, Implementation Strategies, seeking central and external aid, etc.
We look forward to great interactions and advise from TAC and UMTA as we proceed with the
project work.
16-2
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
ATTACHMENT-1
List of the Intersections Suggested to be taken up for improvement Plan by Traffic Police in
Hyderabad
S. Name of Police Station S. Name of Police Station
No Intersection/Junction Limits No Intersection/Junction Limits
Traffic North District Traffic South District
Santoshi Maata Temple,
MJ Bridge
1 Gas Mandi Mahankali 1 Goshamahal
(Between Malakunta and
Ajantha Gate)
2 Allugadda Baavi Gopalpuram 2 Ek Minar x Road Goshamahal
Nampally Railway Station
3 Mettuguda Gopalpuram 3 Nampally
Bus Bay
4 St. John Rotary Gopalpuram 4 Bazarghat x Road Nampally
5 Bowenpally Trimulgherry 5 Rethi Bowli Nampally
6 Ratnaiah Petrol Pump Trimulgherry 6 Tolichowki Asif nagar
7 Brooke Bond Trimulgherry 7 Humayun Nagar Asif nagar
8 Tadbund Trimulgherry 8 Lunger Houz Asif nagar
9 S.R. Nagar SR Nagar 9 Mallepally, Noble Talkies Asif nagar
Al Sabha Hotel, Vijaya
10 Community Hall, SR Nagar SR Nagar 10 Asif nagar
nagar Colony
11 Mothi Nagar SR Nagar 11 Asifnagar Jn Asif nagar
12 Mythrivanam SR Nagar 12 Moghal ka Nala Asif nagar
13 Opp Chest Hospital 13 NMDC Asif nagar
14 U' Turn opp Axon Hospital SR Nagar 14 Bahadurpura Charminar
15 Rythu Bazaar, Erragadda 15 City College Charminar
16 Rajiv Nagar 16 Tarbund Charminar
17 Ranigunj Begumpet 17 Kishanbagh Charminar
18 Paradise Begumpet 18 Himmatpura Falaknuma
19 Karbala Maidan Begumpet 19 Nagulchinta Falaknuma
20 CTO Begumpet 20 MBNR x Road Falaknuma
21 Patny x Road Begumpet 21 Old Chandrayangutta Falaknuma
Engineer-in-Chief Office,
22 Panjagutta 22 Phisal banda Falaknuma
Erramanzil
23 DK Road Panjagutta 23 DMRL x Road Falaknuma
24 Panjagutta Panjagutta 24 Hafeez baba Nagar Falaknuma
25 Monappa Panjagutta 25 Owaisi Hospital Falaknuma
26 Krishna Nagar Banjara Hills 26 Shah Ali banda/Laldarwaza Falaknuma
27 Yousufguda Check Post Banjara Hills 27 Yakutpura Bada Bazar Mirchowk
28 Jubilee Hills Road No:36/59 Banjara Hills 28 Purana Haveli, Peel Dargah Mirchowk
Purana Haveli near Civil
29 Jubilee Hills Check Post Banjara Hills 29 Mirchowk
Courts
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
S. Name of Police Station S. Name of Police Station
No Intersection/Junction Limits No Intersection/Junction Limits
Traffic North District Traffic South District
Yellareddiguda RBI
30 Banjara Hills 30 Moghalpura Mirchowk
Quarters
31 Prashasan Nagar Banjara Hills 31 AP Tribunal Jn Mirchowk
32 Foodworld Banjara Hills 32 Saidabad T Jn Mirchowk
33 Bharatiya Vidya Bhavan Banjara Hills 33 Chanchalguda Rotary Mirchowk
34 Musheerabad Chikkadapally 34 Dabeerpura Darwaza Mirchowk
35 RTC x Road Chikkadapally 35 Fever Hospital Kacheguda
36 Ayodhya Saifabad 36 Road No 6, Amberpet Kacheguda
37 Liberty Saifabad 37 Amberpet T Jn Kacheguda
38 King Koti Abids 38 Golnaka Kacheguda
39 Tilak Nagar Kacheguda
40 Afzalgunj Island Sultan Bazar
41 Nalgonda x Road Malakpet
42 Gaddiannaram T Jn Malakpet
43 Moosarambagh Malakpet
44 Gaddiannaram Malakpet
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME I: Consultancy Services for
MAIN REPORT
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS)
for Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
Inception Report
List of the Intersections Suggested to be taken up for improvement Plan by Traffic Police in
Cyberabad.
S. No Name of Intersection/Junction Police Station Limits
1 Aaramgarh Rajendranagar
2 Shamshabad Market Airport
3 Hyderguda below Flyover Madhapur
4 Old Raidurga Jn Madhapur
5 Whisper Valley Jn Madhapur
6 Kothaguda Madhapur
7 Kondapur Madhapur
8 Vittal Rao Nagar Madhapur
9 Madhapur PS Jn Madhapur
10 ISB Jn Madhapur
11 Moosapet Balanagar
12 JNTU Kukatpally Kukatpally
13 Gajularamaram Kukatpally
14 Miyapur Kukatpally
15 Hafeez pet Kukatpally
16 BHEL Balanagar
17 Balanagar Balanagar
18 Narsapur Balanagar
19 Fatehnagar ROB Balanagar
20 Suchitra Jn Alwal
21 ECIL x Roads Malkajgiri
22 Radhika Jn Malkajgiri
23 Sharada Theater /Bus stop Jn Malkajgiri
24 Neredmet x Roads Malkajgiri
25 Uppal Uppal
26 Uppal Bus stand Uppal
27 Ramanthpur Street No:8 Uppal
28 Uppal Stadium Jn Uppal
29 Chaitanyapuri/Vivekananda Jn LB Nagar
30 Nagole x Roads LB Nagar
31 Byramalguda Jn LB Nagar
32 Karmanghat Jn LB Nagar
33 Kaminenei Jn LB Nagar
34 Alkapuri LB Nagar
35 Saroornagar LB Nagar
36 Balapur x Roads Vanasthalipuram
37 Vanasthalipuram Jn Vanasthalipuram
38 Auto Nagar Vanasthalipuram
39 Panama Jn Vanasthalipuram
40 Chintalakunta Jn Vanasthalipuram
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
Hyderabad Metropolitan Development Authority
INCEPTION REPORT
Consultancy Services for
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS) for
Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
APRIL 2011
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME II: Consultancy Services for
CONTENTS
PREFACE 1
11 Hyderabad Area Transportation Study (HATS) ............................................................................. 3
22 Data Base-Hyderabad Area Transportation Study........................................................................ 7
33 The Feasibility Study on Urban Mass Rail Transit System Construction Project in Hyderabad City
in India...................................................................................................................................... 10
44 Concept Plan for Hyderabad ..................................................................................................... 12
55 Detailed Project Report–Hyderabad Metro (Phase-I)................................................................. 26
66 Development of Hyderabad Multi Modal Suburban Commuter Transportation System on
Commercial Format .................................................................................................................. 29
77 Action Plan for Traffic and Transportation Management in Hyderabad Metropolitan Area........ 36
88 Feasibility Study and Detailed Project Report for the Project of Improvements to the Radial
Roads connecting Inner Ring Road and Outer Ring Road in Hyderabad Metropolitan Area ........ 41
99 Hyderabad Bus Rapid Transit System ........................................................................................ 45
1100 City Development Plan, Hyderabad ........................................................................................... 47
10.1 Traffic and Transportation Component............................................................................ 48
10.2 Traffic and Transportation Sector – Investment Plan ....................................................... 54
1111 Draft Master Plan for HMDA, HADA & CDA ............................................................................... 56
1122 Integrated Environmental Strategies (IES) Study for city of Hyderabad, India ............................ 62
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME II: Consultancy Services for
PREFACE
In order to identify major change in socio-economic profile and travel pattern over time, Consultants
have reviewed available past studies as listed below.
1. Hyderabad Area Transportation Study (HATS) by R E College, Warangal - 1988
2. Data Base-Hyderabad Area Transportation Study by R E College, Warangal - 2000
3. The Feasibility Study on Urban Mass Rail Transit System Construction Project in Hyderabad
State, Hyderabad City in India by JETRO - 1999
4. Concept Plan for Hyderabad - 2003.
5. Detailed Project Report – Hyderabad Metro (Phase-I)- June 2003 and May 2006.
6. Development of Hyderabad Multi Modal Suburban Commuter Transportation System on
Commercial Format – 2004.
7. Action Plan for Traffic and Transportation Management in Hyderabad Metropolitan Area, 2006
8. Feasibility Study and Detailed Project Report for the Project of Improvements to the Radial
Roads connecting Inner Ring Road and Outer Ring Road in Hyderabad Metropolitan Area –
2006.
9. Hyderabad Bus Rapid Transit System - 2008
10. City Development Plan – 2006
11. Draft Master Plan for HMDA, HADA & CDA -2003
Salient features of the aforesaid study reports/ plans that are significant to the present study are
discussed in the following sections. The Table 1 below shows a comparison of five of the above
mentioned studies, which were relatively comprehensive and covered the whole or at least
significant geographical area of Hyderabad. It is observed that over a period of almost 16 year
between 1988 and 2004 the change in travel behavior in Hyderabad was marginal with average per
capita vehicular trip rate changing from 0.96 to 0.977 and average vehicular trip length from 7.1 to
7.49. However, as per the BRTS study conducted in 2008 the vehicular PCTR may be expected to be
close to 1.05 now. A major change may however be expected in terms of travel purpose with
significant gain in share of education trips (up from about 34 to 44%) over the same period. In terms
of traffic composition also a significant change is observed with the share of private motorized
modes namely 2-wheelers and cars gaining immensely at the cost of primarily the NMT modes.
1
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME II: Consultancy Services for
Detailed Project
House hold survey (5000 Muncipal corporation Area(67),
Report for 40 Locations(16 For Major Roads 2Wheeler-39%, Car-7.8%, Auto-9%,
DMRC 2003 1905.04 samples – about 0.5 % of NA 129 Municipalities(10), HUDA 0.73 NA NA NA NA NA
Hyderabad Metro Hrs) Only Bus-44%,Rail-0.2%
households) Area(52)
(Phase-1)
Development of Same 129 zones of HATS study, For HUDA area Trip Purpose - Work+Employment -
50.5%, Education - 44.2%, Other - 2Wheeler-27%, 2Wheeler-53%,
Hyderabad Multi 11 Outer Cordon 1986 were taken. 18 zones were including walk-
5.3%. Auto(3+7Seater)-7%, Car- Auto(3+7Seater)-9%,
Modal Suburban Counts, 32 Home Interview Surveys: added to the existing zones in 1.5, Excluding
L&T 2004 1905.04 NA 147 0.977 NA NA Trip Length(Km) -Average Trip length 23.5%, Bus-9%, Goods- Car-13.5%, Bus-3%,
Commuter Screen line 10,900 households the area outside the Walk- 0.977,
excluding walk is 6.93 km and excluding 33%, Cycle-1%, Other- Goods-13%, Cycle-8%,
Transportation Counts for 24 Hrs municipalities, resulting in a Motorized- walk and slow moving vehicles is 0.07%. Other-0.3%.
System total of 147 zones. 0.887 7.49km
2
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME II: Consultancy Services for
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME II: Consultancy Services for
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME II: Consultancy Services for
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME II: Consultancy Services for
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME II: Consultancy Services for
S. No. Name Duration No. of Legs Total Traffic Peak hour Traffic
1 Kukatpally 16 Hrs 3 69,515 6,443
2 Ameerpet 16 Hrs 4 1,40,751 11,431
3 Visveswaraya Junction 16 Hrs 5 1,62,738 15,164
4 Taj Ice Cream junction, Nampally 16 Hrs 3 1,23,396 11,985
5 Mojamjahi Market 16 Hrs 4 1,89,926 15,776
6 Nalgonda X Roads 16 Hrs 3 1,30,257 11,223
7 L.B.Nagar 16 Hrs 4 47,965 3,794
8 Abids GPO 16 Hrs 4 1,02,177 10,050
9 Nizam College 16 Hrs 3 1,10,213 9,180
10 Ambedkar Statue(on tank bund) 16 Hrs 4 1,84,247 16,048
11 Karbala Maidan 16 Hrs 4 89,315 8,429
12 Paradise 16 Hrs 4 95,977 8,303
13 Greenlands 16 Hrs 3 2,92,898 12,856
14 HUDA Junction(Rasoolpura) 16 Hrs 4 1,15,730 9,444
15 Rajiv Gandhi Statue(Somajiguda) 16 Hrs 3 1,03,049 9,799
16 Hotel Viceroy Junction (Buddabhavan) 16 Hrs 3 48,760 4,845
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME II: Consultancy Services for
Classified directional traffic volume data for 24 hours at 27 screen line points
Total Traffic Peak hour Traffic
S.No. Name of Section
Vehicles PCU Vehicles PCU
1 Uppal – Nagole 26,691 30,061 2,195 2,252
2 Musharambagh – Amberpet 44,098 34,109 4,106 2,850
3 Dharulshifa – Imliban 56,285 48,224 4,983 3,946
4 Afzalgunj – charminar 1,07,452 83,027 9,010 6,661
5 Begambazar – Doodbowli 41,473 35,830 3,583 2,919
6 Bahadurpur – Puranapool 49,023 37,767 3,696 2,653
7 Rajendra Nagar - Mehidipatnam 29,087 33,646 2,319 2,879
8 Erragadda – Moosapet 50,329 56,269 5,113 4,543
9 Fathenagar – Balkampet 20,266 16,036 1,930 1,398
10 Begampet – Somajiguda 1,11,099 89,970 10,353 8,073
11 Tankbund - Paradise 65,802 54,440 6,062 4,553
12 RP Road - Bible House 71,461 58,315 6,187 4,797
13 Secundrabad Reservation complex - Bhoiguda 93,946 82,547 7,832 6,612
14 Sangeeth - Alugadda Bavi 60,334 49,634 5,596 3,875
15 Tarnaka - Lalapet 38,417 45,978 3,195 2,232
16 Ch.Gutta - Charminar 23,857 20,818 1,680 1,340
17 Moghalpura - Eizar 22,509 18,033 1,752 1,364
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME II: Consultancy Services for
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME II: Consultancy Services for
10
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME II: Consultancy Services for
11
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME II: Consultancy Services for
12
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME II: Consultancy Services for
13
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME II: Consultancy Services for
14
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME II: Consultancy Services for
15
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME II: Consultancy Services for
16
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME II: Consultancy Services for
Figure 2: shows the locations of the above projects in and around Hyderabad.
17
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME II: Consultancy Services for
18
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME II: Consultancy Services for
Technology Hub - Between HITEC City and Apparel Park – Figure 5 shows the proposed alignment in the
Technology Hub and the details of the proposed alignment is given in Table 3.
19
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME II: Consultancy Services for
20
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME II: Consultancy Services for
Emerging Technology Hub -Between Apparel Park and Film City via Bio – Technology Park –
Figure 6 shows the proposed alignment in the Emerging Technology Hub and the details of the proposed
alignment is given in Table 4.
21
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME II: Consultancy Services for
22
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME II: Consultancy Services for
Entertainment and Tourism Hub - Between Ramoji Film City and Proposed International Airport via
Hardware Park –Figure 7 shows the proposed alignment in the Entertainment and Technology Hub and
the details of the proposed alignment is given in Table 5.
23
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME II: Consultancy Services for
24
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME II: Consultancy Services for
As many as 85 intersections/ junctions are proposed to be improved along these roads as part of the
improved connectivity to economic drivers.
25
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME II: Consultancy Services for
Consultant: Delhi Metro Rail Corporation (DMRC) assisted by M/S RITES Ltd., EPTRI and NCAER
Client: Government of Andhra Pradesh
Year: Final report submitted in year 2003
The GoAP had engaged DMRC as Consultants to prepare DPR for Hyderabad Metro Rail project. The first
report of DPR was done in June 2003 and the second DPR report in June 2006.
Objective of the study was to prepare a DPR (Detailed Project Report) for Metro Rail System in
Hyderabad.
Apart from the data available in earlier studies, the study made use of the may data collected under this
study through primary surveys during March-April, 2003. The surveys conducted under this study were:
• Household survey (5000 samples - about 0.5% of households)
• Classified traffic volume survey along with O - D Survey (40 locations)
• Bus stop surveys
• Bus passenger boarding and alighting surveys
• Speed and Delay survey along major corridors
• Road network inventory for all major roads
Under this study, total daily person trips in the year 2003 are estimated to be 63.4 lakh. Of these,
vehicular trips are 50.5 lakh. Share of trips by bus is about 44% of total motorized trips. Only 0.2% of
trips are by rail. A staggering 39% of total vehicular trips are performed by two wheelers. Auto rickshaws
account for more than 9% of total vehicular trips. These figures indicate inadequate supply of mass
transport system. Higher use of personalized and Para-transit motor vehicles is resulting into acute
traffic congestion on roads.
TRANSPORT DEMAND FORECAST
Four stage transport planning process has been employed to carry out transport demand forecasts. This
comprises of trip generation, trip distribution, modal split and trip assignment.
Per Capita Trip Rates for the years 2003, 2011 and 2021 are as given in the following [Values]
In year 2003, the observed modal split between public, private and IPT transport was 45:45:10. With
introduction of Metro, the modal split in favor of public transport is assumed to be 65% by the year
2011 and 70% by 2021.
Selection of Alternative Metro Corridors
The different alternatives of Metro system have been worked out and evaluated. Road network and
Multi Modal Suburban Commuter Transport System, now under implementation, is common in all the
alternatives.
26
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME II: Consultancy Services for
i) Miyapur - Chaitanyapuri
ii) Secundrabad - Osmania Medical College - Charminar- Falaknuma Railway Station
Alternative 5
• Metro network
i) Miyapur - Chaitanyapuri
ii) Secundrabad - Osmania Medical College - Charminar- Falaknuma Railway Station
iii) Secundrabad - Hi-tech city
The Kukutpally - Dilsukhnagar corridor has been extended on both ends and is now Miyapur -
Chaitanyapuri corridor.
Table 6: Summary of Transport Demand for the year 2011
DMRC Analysis for 60.70 km length given in DMRC Analysis for 38.05 km length given
May-06 report for (Corridor-3) in June-03 report for (Corridors-1 & 2)
Section Length
No. of Passengers (lakh) No. of Passengers (lakh)
(km)
Miyapur – Chaitanyapuri (Corridor – 1) 25.50 8.40 8.07
Jubilee Bus Stand – Sec-bad –
14.40 4.45 4.14
Charminar – Falaknuma (Corridor – 2)
IICT – Sec-bad – Hitech City –
20.80 3.90 –
Shilparamam (Corridor – 3)
TOTAL 60.70 16.75 12.21
27
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME II: Consultancy Services for
28
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME II: Consultancy Services for
29
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME II: Consultancy Services for
30
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME II: Consultancy Services for
31
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME II: Consultancy Services for
32
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME II: Consultancy Services for
For analysis of the travel demand, HUDA area was divided into 147 zones. The external zones were
grouped into 10 zones for the analysis purpose. Distribution of trip lengths with respect to percentage of
trips, for the base year, is presented in following Figure 8.
33
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME II: Consultancy Services for
Travel Demand Model developed using the TRIPS software was used in arriving at the ridership
estimates for the various route potions considered for ranking as given above. Estimated ridership was
used to arrive at the revenues. Block cost estimates and O&M costs were also prepared for these
options. All the route options considered were evaluated for the economic viability.
Table 8: Peak Hour Ridership on Different Options for Horizon Years (In Trips)
Recommendations
Based on the secondary data analysis and the relative study of different systems RRT and based on the
goals to achieve efficient public transport system with reasonable tariff, scope for privatization and
balanced development in the study area, the Route Options were ranked and shown in Table 9.
34
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME II: Consultancy Services for
35
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME II: Consultancy Services for
In response to the writ petition and affidavits filed by the Government the honorable High Court of
Andhra Pradesh issued an order on 16th August 2005, concluding that there was a lack of a plan of action
for streamlining traffic in the cities of Hyderabad and Secundrabad. The court directed the Chief
Secretary to the state of A.P. to appoint a Committee comprising of Officials of Municipal Corporation,
Traffic Police, Public Works Department, RTA Department and also some experts within a period of two
weeks, which were to finalize its report within three months from the date of its constitution.
Government after having examined the matter have decided to appoint the Committee, as ordered by
the honorable High Court, with the following members and will be headed by the Special Chief Secretary
to Government and convened by the Additional Commissioner of Police (Traffic), Hyderabad city. The
Committee consists of:
1. Shri. A. Raghotham Rao
Special Chief Secretary to Government,
G.A.D. (G.P.M & A.R.) Dept Chairman.
2. Commissioner of Police, Hyderabad City Member
3. Commissioner of M.C.H. Hyderabad Member
4. Commissioner of Transport, Hyderabad Member
5. Commissioner of School Education, Hyderabad Member
6. Chief Engineer, Public Works, Hyd. Member
7. Additional Commissioner of Police (Traffic) Convener
36
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME II: Consultancy Services for
37
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME II: Consultancy Services for
38
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME II: Consultancy Services for
39
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME II: Consultancy Services for
40
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME II: Consultancy Services for
Consultant: CRAPHTS Consultants (India) Pvt. Ltd. in JV with National Consultancy for
Planning and Engineering
Client: Hyderabad Urban Development Authority
Year: Final report submitted in year 2006
41
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME II: Consultancy Services for
42
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME II: Consultancy Services for
43
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME II: Consultancy Services for
1. Radial no.2 from Indra reddy Jun. on IRR to Himayatsagar 6.6 KM for strengthening and
widening of existing 2 lane road to 4 lane divided carriage way with proper shoulders and
adequate footpaths with cross drainage works with space for services was estimated to a
cost of Rs. 12.39 crores.
2. Radial no.3 from Nanalnagar Jun on IRR to APPA jun.10.7 KM for strengthening and
widening of existing 2 lane road to 4 lane divided carriage way with proper shoulders and
adequate footpaths with cross drainage works with space for services was estimated to a
cost of Rs. 16.28 crores.
3. Radial no.28 from Chandrayangutta Jun. on IRR to Srinaga jun 15.66 KM for strengthening
and widening of existing 2 lane road to 4 lane divided carriage way with proper shoulders
and adequate footpaths with cross drainage works with space for services was estimated
to a cost of Rs. 22.56 crores.
4. Chord Link between RR-9 and RR-7 from JNTU Kukatpalli Jun. to Old Bombay road 6.4 KM
for formation of new road/strengthening of existing road to 4 lane divided carriage way
with proper shoulders and adequate footpaths with cross drainage works with space for
services and ROB for main spinal road was estimated to a cost of Rs. 43.00 crores.
5. Radial no.7 formation of road parallel to radial road 7 from Kavuri hills to Hitech City for
avoiding local bottlenecks and for geometric improvements was estimated to a cost of Rs.
11.00 crores.
44
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME II: Consultancy Services for
45
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME II: Consultancy Services for
46
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME II: Consultancy Services for
47
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME II: Consultancy Services for
Vision
The vision of the ‘Traffic and Transportation’ for Hyderabad city is to provide with the safe and reliable
transport system that is sustainable, environmental friendly and to significantly improve the share and
quality of public transport service that would improve the traffic management.
48
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME II: Consultancy Services for
Time Frame
Vision Indicators
2005-06 2011 2015 2021
Road Network as % of Total Area 9% 12% 15% 15%
Share of Public Transport 42% 45% 55% 75%
Rail transport as share of total public
2% 10% 30% 40%
transport
Average Speed - km/h 12 20 30 35
Sidewalks length to Total road length Half of the 75% of the 95% of the
25%
requirement requirement requirement
Usage of alternative fuels 5% 40% 60% 60%
Road accidents Reduced by Reduced by Reduced by
Not known
25% 50% 70%
Strategies
Short term measures including immediate trouble shooting actions and TSM actions such as intersection
improvement, signalisation etc., to be taken up regularly. These measures should be taken up on a
continuous basis as the travel characteristics and loading of different links, intersections etc., and
change very frequently owing to natural growth and changes in land use.
Medium term action plan aimed at development of transport infrastructure over a perspective plan
period of 5-10 years to bring about coordinated development among different components. These
measures typically will include various infrastructure projects, which will be directed at network
improvements such as parallel roads, link roads, slip roads, and bridges. Flyovers, alternate
transportation systems such as MRTS etc.
Long-term action plan aimed at development of structure plan for the Urban Area with Transit as one of
the lead components, which will direct the urban growth so as to bring about a structural fit between
transit infrastructure and Urban Growth. This will also examine a comprehensive multi-modal public
transit system to bring about the most optimal mix of commuting within the Urban Area and thus
providing a sustainable transit solution.
49
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME II: Consultancy Services for
50
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME II: Consultancy Services for
51
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME II: Consultancy Services for
52
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME II: Consultancy Services for
53
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME II: Consultancy Services for
54
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME II: Consultancy Services for
55
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME II: Consultancy Services for
MCH = 36.33
10 mplts = 17.17
Other parts = 8.29
Cantt = 2.04
56
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME II: Consultancy Services for
4. Density levels
Density by p/sq km
Area 2001 2011 2021
MCH 172.6 210.49 251.16 299.77
10 Mplts 418.58 41.02 69.26 121.51
Other parts 1273.9 6.51 12.38 24.28
Cantt 40.17 50.78 60.74 72.44
TOTAL 1905.04 33.51 47.53 71.62
57
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME II: Consultancy Services for
58
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME II: Consultancy Services for
59
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME II: Consultancy Services for
60
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME II: Consultancy Services for
61
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME II: Consultancy Services for
United States of Environmental Protection Agency (USEPA) and United States Agency for International
Development (USAID) have initiated the Integrated Environmental Strategies (IES) analysis in India. One
of the objectives of this study was to carry out Air Quality (AAQ) and Green House Gas (GHG) analysis for
Hyderabad Urban Agglomeration (UA) covering major contributing to air pollution, including the
transportation and industrial sectors, and to assess the likely reduction in pollution and GHG levels due
to various proposed mitigation measures.
In process of data collection Emissions Inventory has been done. As part of the study, data was collected
at over 550 small, medium and large scale combustion sources located within study area. Apart from
this air quality and traffic congestion issues have been correlated well using transport related
information available from earlier studies. As a part of the IES-India program, scope of work for this
study has following components:
- Scenarios for more effective bus transit service.
- Traffic management and measures to improve traffic flow.
- Technology/training measures relating to two-stroke vehicles.
The study utlises mostly data gathered as part of the earlier studies primarily “DPR for Metro Phase-I by
RITES in year 2003” related to;
a) Turning Movement, Traffic Volume Count along with vehicle occupancy at 29 major junctions,
b) Road network inventory
c) Speed & Delay Survey
d) Traffic signal time survey
e) Parking Survey
f) Pedestrian Surveys
g) Passenger Opinion Survey
h) Drivers Habits of 2 & 3 Wheelers
i) Household Surveys.
62
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME II: Consultancy Services for
The report has nicely mapped the environmental (air pollution) issues with respect to traffic and
congestion and recommends use of mass transport system to combat the same.
63
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
Hyderabad Metropolitan Development
Authority
INCEPTION REPORT
Consultancy Services for
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS) for
Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
APRIL 2011
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME III: Consultancy Services for
CONTENTS
1. STUDY APPROACH .................................................................................... 1-1
1.1 INTRODUCTION....................................................................................................... 1-1
1.2 ISSUES ..................................................................................................................... 1-1
1.2.1 Socio-economic Conditions ..........................................................................................1-1
1.2.2 Demography .................................................................................................................1-1
1.2.3 Economy of HMA ..........................................................................................................1-3
1.2.4 Establishing Consistent Base Line Data .......................................................................1-4
1.2.5 Strategy for Immediate Action Plan ..............................................................................1-4
1.2.6 Need of a Rigorous Modeling Strategy .........................................................................1-6
1.2.7 Hyderabad Region freight traffic needs.........................................................................1-6
1.2.8 Hyderabad Region Passenger Traffic Needs................................................................1-7
1.3 FRAMEWORK .......................................................................................................... 1-7
1.3.1 Define Vision and State Mission ...................................................................................1-7
1.3.2 Data Base and Information ...........................................................................................1-8
1.3.3 Analysis and Problem Domain ......................................................................................1-9
1.3.4 Models for Decisions.....................................................................................................1-9
1.3.5 Land use Transport Strategies....................................................................................1-10
1.3.6 Assessment of Travel Demand Scenario ....................................................................1-10
1.3.7 Evolving alternative Transport systems plans .............................................................1-10
1.3.8 Evaluation of Alternatives ...........................................................................................1-10
1.3.9 Implementation strategy of the selected Plan .............................................................1-10
1.3.10 Feasibility of Multi-modal Public Transport System ....................................................1-10
1.3.11 Institutional, Fiscal and Implementation Measures .....................................................1-10
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME III: Consultancy Services for
Figure 1-2: Growth Rates of population During 1991 - 2001 in Surrounding Municipalities of MCH ........1-2
Figure 2-1: General Approach and Methodology for Preparation of IAP .....................................................2-6
Figure 2-3: : Three components of travel viz. I-E, E-I and E-E of total travel demand of HMA .................2-20
Figure 2-4: Typical Coded Transport Network Map and Road and Transit Network Attributes in EMME .2-25
Figure 2-10: General Form of the Access Mode Choice Sub-Model .........................................................2-32
Figure 2-14: Typical procedure followed towards selection of preferred landuse strategy .......................2-38
Figure 2-16: Major / Minor growth centres in HMA surrounding Region ...................................................2-41
Figure 3-1: The Four Stage Urban Transportation Modeling Systems ........................................................3-2
ii
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME III: Consultancy Services for
1. STUDY APPROACH
1.1 INTRODUCTION
There are unique needs of Hyderabad Metropolitan Hyderabad Metropolitan Area
Area which have bearing on the approach to be TRANSPORT DIVISION
followed for the comprehensive transportation
study. Consultants have tried to summarize below
some issues which necessitated the need for fresh PASSENGER
FREIGHT
(Intracity & Intercity)
approach.
ROAD
WORK
1.2.1 Socio-economic Conditions MILK SEZ’S
AIRPORT
P BUSINESS
Apart from being a historical city, Hyderabad has UEDUCATION BREAK INDUST- ICD
R BULK RIES
grown in to a mega city with the thrust to be a world P SHOPPING
class IT and financial hub. Now Hyderabad O SOCIAL WARE-
S WATER
Metropolitan Area (HMA) with close 10 million RECREATION
E
HOUSING
1.2.2 Demography
Demographically, the HMA is tending to be polycentric with rapid growth of fringe areas both in terms of
employment and residential choices in them. This is evident from the rapid growth of population recorded
during 1991 to 2001 in the erstwhile Municipalities like Serilingmapalli, Kukatpalli, Qutbullapur, Alwal, Kapra,
Malkajgiri, Uppal, L.B.Nagar, Gaddiannaram. The growth of population in these Municipalities varied from
52% to 103% while the growth in MCH was around 19% as shown in Figure 1-2. The master plan of HUDA
2011 envisages the development of district centres in the fringe Areas of MCH as shown in Figure 1-3. The
master plan proposals will propel growth in the outer area of GHMC and increase the interaction between
MCH and outer municipal areas. Thus the overall situation of demography of HMA is dynamic and fast
changing. It is expected to continue in future with the fringe areas getting denser and larger in population
creating excessive demand for transportation.
1-1
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME III: Consultancy Services for
Uppalk. M 103%
Rajen. Ngr M 88%
Qutbul. M 81%
Malkaj. M 80%
L.B.Ngr M 72%
Alwal M 65%
Kapra M 63%
Seriling. M 63%
Kukat. M 56%
Gaddin. M 52%
Sec. Cntt 21%
MCH 19%
Ramach.-CT 13%
Os. Univ 10%
Figure 1-2: Growth Rates of population During 1991 - Figure 1-3: Proposed Growth Centres in Erstwhile
2001 in Surrounding Municipalities of MCH HUDA
Hyderabad metropolitan area is becoming more and more polycentric with employment centres getting
distributed over space and residences getting located on the basis of accessibility to work, schooling, social
circles, relations, recreational and cultural centres etc. While eastern sub region (Uppal, Vanastalipuram and
LBNagar) has accommodated the lion’s share of the HMA’s population living outside the core area of
Hyderabad, areas such as Rajendranagar, Langer House, Tolichowki in the south-western sub-region,
Gachibowli, Kondapur, Lingampalli, Madhapur, in western sub-region, Miyapur, BHEL, Nizampet, Kukatpalli,
in the north-western sub-region are catching up at a faster rate. Thus, overall, situation is dynamic and
continuously in flux. For this reason, consultant willapproach the planning of the region with a validation
of residential choices as they are and as they are expected to be in near and far distant future. This
will be in addition to the input received from HMDA regarding existing and future population levels of different
sub-regions.
DEMOGRAPHY TRANSITION (HMA)
Hyderabad has gradually transformed itself from a
monocentric to polycentric city. Transformation has been ‘by-
design’ (Hyderabad) as well as organic (Eastern, Northern,
Western & Southern Regions). Proportion of population living
outside the erstwhile MCH boundary has increased from 45%
in 1981 to 53% in 2001. Apart from the proportion, size of this
population has increased by more than two-folds i.e., from
1.8 million to 4.0 million while that of Greater Hyderabad has
registered an increase of 1.6 times i.e., from 2.2 million to 3.6
million in the last two decades.
1-2
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME III: Consultancy Services for
Hyderabad is a major centre for pharmaceuticals with companies such as Dr. Reddy's Laboratories, Matrix Laboratories,
Hetero Drugs Limited, Divis Labs, Aurobindo Pharma Limited, Lee Pharma and Vimta Labs being housed in the city.
Initiatives such as Genome Valley, Fab City and the Nano Technology park are expected to create extensive
infrastructure in bio-technology.
Many International and National Business Houses have set up retail chains here. The city has multiple Central Business
Districts (CBDs) .There are many major shopping districts from the older Charminar area to newer Kukatpalli. For
advancement of economic character of the city, government is building a skyscrapers at Manchirevula, with a 450 m
super tall structure with APIIC Tower at its centre.
1-3
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME III: Consultancy Services for
Economic change: Starting in the 1990s, Hyderabad’s economy has shifted from a primarily service city to a more
diversified profile (comprising of IT, trade, commerce, industry, transportation, storage, communication and construction
sectors). Service industry is the major contributor, with urban workforce constituting 90% of the total workforce. While the
manufacturing sector (pharmaceuticals, heavy electrical, electronic goods, and other industrial products), especially the
pharmaceutical industry is expected to play a dominant role even in future. Tertiary sector is emerging as the main
employment generator.
Hyderabad is the largest contributor to the State’s Gross Domestic Product (GDP), state taxes and excise revenues and
has reached high levels of commercialization and monetization. In terms of growth, GDP at current prices has grown at a
compounded annual growth rate (CAGR) of 10.7% over the five year period (FY2000 to FY2005). In real terms, GDP (at
constant prices of 1999–2000) has grown at a CAGR of 6.9% over the five year period. The above rapid growth in GDP
has resulted in increased per capita income, at current prices, which has grown from Rs.22,777 in 1999–2000 to
Rs.32,789 in 2004–05 at a CAGR of 9.5%. In real terms, the per capita income during this period has grown at a CAGR
of 5.7%.
IT is the overwhelming driver of the urban economy, accounting for 72% of output, steering the “modernization” of the
north-west side of the metropolis, particularly where the IT complexes (such as Manikonda, High Tech City, Ghachibowli)
tend to be concentrated.
Immediate action plan is intended to provide relief to the highly problematic locations in handling the traffic on
day to day basis. As envisaged in the TOR, a selection of 30 numbers of intersections/junctions will be made
in consultations with the clients from amongst a total of about 200 major intersections. This is with a view to
develop the approach/methodology of studying the problems of the intersections and the strategies to evolve
the solutions in mitigating the problems and provide respite to traffic circulation in the network. This will
facilitate the clients to study and develop appropriate improvement measures on their own by extending the
approach suggested in the study.
It is needless to say that improvement of one or two locations will not significantly change the traffic
operational efficiencies. This is to say that improvement of one intersection may affect adversely the
operations at the neighbouring intersections. Therefore it becomes necessary to identify and select a group of
1-4
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME III: Consultancy Services for
Hyderabad being a very large and densely populated city contains some of the corridors carrying very long
distance trips which need to be given due attention to improve their operating speeds to minimize the overall
travel time and monitoring efforts. The length of the corridors to be selected in consultation with the clients
may extend to about 15kms.
In general pedestrians are the most vulnerable group of road users and as such maximum people dying of
road accidents are pedestrians. Much of the problems faced by pedestrians are due to inadequate or total
absence of the facilities for their safe passage along and across the vehicular traffic movements. Keeping this
in mind, it is considered necessary to give due attention for assessing the required pedestrian facilities in
areas with intense pedestrian activities/traffic. While the earlier cited studies relating to intersection
improvements, area traffic management, corridor improvements will include these studies relating to
pedestrian facilities, it is considered necessary to cover about 50km of road stretch on the network to identify
and design the pedestrian facilities. These locations will be duly identified in consultations with the client.
The growing vehicle ownership in the country in general and the Hyderabad in particular is generating heavy
demand for parking and resultant occupation of carriageways reducing the discharge of traffic both on arterial
roads as well as distributor roads. The problem of parking gets aggravated in commercial areas like shopping
centres, recreational areas, and office complexes. With a view to identify the policies and control to manage
the parking demand and reduce the problems of parking certain selected areas ( two or three areas) will be
identified in consultations with clients. In these area scientifically designed parking studies will be conducted
to assess the parking characteristic of private vehicles (4/2 wheelers). On the basis of these study results
policies and control/regulations will be evolved for the areas covered for this purpose. These studies are
expected to provide guidance to the local bodies to conduct similar studies in the areas under their
jurisdictions.
The terminals of transport systems generate huge demand for circulation place because usually there will be
change of mode for passenger travel and transhipment in the case of goods traffic. To understand the
requirements of passenger terminals and truck terminals in the Hyderabad city one intercity and one Intra-city
terminals will be selected in consultations with clients for both goods and passengers for effecting the studies.
For the identified immediate action plans, broad cost estimates will be prepared and provided for benefiting
the local authorities to take up the schemes for implementation. In preparing the broad cost estimates the
experience of the local bodies in the past cases if any will be utilised besides the experience of the
consultants in the other cities for the projects of similar nature. Looking in to the local conditions and any
requirement of land acquisitions the improvement schemes will be prepared in phased manner in close co-
ordination with the clients/local authorities.
1-5
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME III: Consultancy Services for
The Hyderabad Metro Rail Limited has already embarked up on implementing the phase-I metro rail system
on three prime corridors extended over a length of about 72kms. It is needless to say that for a city size of
Hyderabad the presently proposed corridors will not suffice in meeting the travel requirements because the
catchment area of three corridors extends to only about 30% of the city. The remaining 70% needs to be
covered to meet the present and future travel demand. For identifying further routes of metro rail a detailed
travel demand estimation for present and future will be highly useful. But however a fair idea of the route
alignments/directions can be had with the help of traffic counts made on the network. The heavy flow of
passengers on the network could determine the directions for future metro corridors. It is needless to say that
these directions will be preliminary indications for future corridors which will be further analyzed and
supplemented when detailed analysis of travel demand is made with the help of rigorous transportation
demand modeling exercise during the course of the study.
Ragiv Gandhi International Airport (RGIA) is capable of handling 1 million tons of cargo per annum. The
present cargo traffic at RGIA is around 100,000 tons per annum (10% of the capacity).
1
More details on the selection of appropriate software and conceptual Model design is given in Chapter 8.
1-6
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME III: Consultancy Services for
Other than this, these are the following present terminals serving the needs of inter-regional traffic in public
domain.
• Bus Stations/ Terminals: MG Bus Stand (Imlibun) and Jubilee Bus Stand (Secunderabad)
• Railway Terminals: Secunderabad, Nampally and Kacheguda.
• Air Terminal: Rajiv Gandhi International Airport at Shamshabad.
The traffic studies will be appropriately planned to assess the present and future volumes of inter-regional
passenger traffic at all these terminals. Through these studies, efforts will be made to identify the future
terminal capacities that are required and recommendations will be made to improve the operations of the
present terminals and location of additional terminal facilities required for the future.
1.3 FRAMEWORK
Given the broad study and plan preparation framework, basic concepts, elements and steps, consultant have
evolved following method for the proposed plan preparation. The work plan is broadly presented in the
following sections.
1-7
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME III: Consultancy Services for
Consultant will have a meeting with clients designated officers/ the TAC and discuss our thoughts on overall
study/plan including work plan/programme given in the inception report.
1-8
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME III: Consultancy Services for
1-9
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME III: Consultancy Services for
1-10
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME III: Consultancy Services for
PROJECT INPUTS
HMA URBAN
Environment GEOGRAPHY PRIMACY
FORM
PROJECT DOMAIN
Relate to…
GOALS AND
ACCESSIBILITY AFFORDABILITY QUALITY SAFETY
OBJECTIVES
Reflected in…
PERFORMANCE LEVEL OF
TRIP LENGTH COST ACCIDENTS
MEASURES SERVICE
Defines Requirements for….
Used to Identify….
Requires Targeted…
Utilized by….
TRANSPORTATION
ALTERNATIVE DEMAND OPTIMIZING THE TRANSPORT SYSTEM CAPACITY INTEGRATED PUBLIC
STRATEGIES/ MANAGEMENT CAPACITIES ENHANCEMENT TRANSPORT
PLANS
Evaluated with…
Leads to…
Monitored through….
1-11
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME III: Consultancy Services for
2. STUDY METHODOLOGY
2.1 INTRODUCTION
Study method given under along with tasks list below, comprehensively addresses mandate given in the ToR
and issues involved in the study. Study is divided into eight activities which have been further subdivided into
62 tasks and their various sub-tasks as appropriate. While first activity can be considered as “Inception
Activity”, Activities 2 to 6 focus on the core objectives of the study and last two provide a value addition to the
overall success of the study and skill up-gradation of the core team of various stakeholders (HMDA, GHMC,
APSRTC, HMRL, Traffic Police) in Hyderabad towards the longevity of the planning process/UTP Model.
This method while addresses all the aspects, in detail may be needing modification and refinement as we
proceed with the work.
2-1
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME III: Consultancy Services for
2-2
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME III: Consultancy Services for
The focus of this task is to introduce the project with all the project team members; have team meetings to
define and come to an understanding of vision, objective and scope of project; present our thoughts to client,
and finally develop a work program suiting the project needs. Team interaction with client is essential for
appreciation and better co-ordination of the project work. In fact this is done to a great extent. Project is
envisaged to be undertaken in close harmony with all stakeholders of HMA. Hence, consultants be seeking
Launch meeting, in discussions with HMDA at appropriate stage to introduce the project team and seek
support and inputs as needed during project period.
TASK 1.2 REVIEW OF EARLIER STUDY REPORTS, PLANNING DOCUMENTS AND AVAILABLE
DATA/INFORMATION
This task aims at reviewing all earlier reports relevant to this project; to understand study area characteristics;
review all the planning efforts that have been taken in past; to identify key issues which are still unattended in
the city; and to assimilate key data useful for this assignment. Preliminary level of data/map collection from
the secondary sources to get an understanding on multiple facades of the study area will be the foremost
action under this task. Having reviewed the availability of information/data by various sources, we will be
developing a comprehensive data collection check list, which includes:
• Study Area Map(s) • Traffic and Travel Characteristics
• Data on Demography and Land use • Registered vehicles Growth
• Future Development Imperatives • Road Safety and Environmental Aspects
• Road/MMTS/Metro Network Data • Statistics on MMTS rail/ Bus passenger
It is important to mention here that data collected during proposal preparation stage will complement this task.
More importantly, data gaps, issues regarding availability of data on various aspects will be identified and
necessary strategy would be formulated to obtain missing information during primary surveys.
Towards model building, it is important to identify useful and available land use parameters. The most
important aspects here would be its availability at disaggregated level so that it can be translated at Traffic
Analysis Zone (TAZ) level. The parameters could be:
• Population – Time series at disaggregated level.
• Employment – by sectors such as primary secondary and tertiary and by location to estimate employment
at TAZ level.
• Area by TAZ - under various use such as residential, commercial, industrial, mixed, PSP, transport,
agriculture etc.
• Student Enrollment – Number of students and teachers by school with address again to estimate them at
TAZ level.
• Major activity centres – such as hospitals, Govt. offices, Malls, Universities etc. with employment etc., at
TAZ level
This task aims at identification of the issues and problems specifically related to traffic and transportation
which would in turn form the foundation for preparing the field survey program at the next stage.
City Growth - Under this activity, the direction and pattern of growth of the city, since its evolution, will be
studied. An appreciation will be made of the geographical, historical, economic and cultural factors, which
2-3
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME III: Consultancy Services for
Master Plan Proposals - At this stage, the master plans and comprehensive development plans prepared for
the different parts of HMDA will be studied and proposals, policies and strategies on future land-use and the
traffic and transport characteristics will be appreciated to substantial depth, so as to envisage the future level
of transport demand and supply patterns.
Transport System Characteristics – Consultant have already made an in depth analysis of available
information and have hence studied transport system characteristics. Further, consultant will review available
data to identify the traffic volume and travel characteristics on the primary network at different time-periods of
the day and the travel demand classified by modes for peak period, off-peak period and on an average
weekday. The information collected on public transport system characteristics will also be studied to
appreciate the functional and operational efficiency and Service Level Benchmarks (SLBs) in the city.
Identification of Critical Area - On completion of the aforesaid analysis, consultant will identify the critical
areas pertaining to the traffic and transportation aspects of the city to address the problem in a more focused
manner. The parameters that would be considered to measure the degree of criticality are as follows:
• Growth in vehicle registration
• Public Transport Supply -
• Congestion and delay
• Air and Noise Pollution
• Road accidents
• Pedestrian intensity
• On-street parking intensity
• Road configuration and condition, etc.
On evaluation of the above parameters (and any other additional parameters felt essential during early part of
the study), the section of network/area will be identified for in-depth study and preparation of immediate action
plan.
On accomplishment of the above tasks, the study area will be delineated in a more realistic and meaningful
manner for undertaking detailed surveys and further analysis. On the identified study area map, the outer
cordon line, screen lines, inner cordon line and the various types of traffic survey locations/stretches will be
marked, which will be finalized after discussing with client agency. Formats for primary surveys will be
included in the Inception Report for approval. The following types of primary surveys are envisaged and hence
respective formats are designed and submitted for client’s review:
• Household Travel O-D Survey – this format will be divided into three parts viz. a) household and
personal data b) person and ‘usual’ travel data c) trip diary for a typical day.
• Traffic Volume Count Survey - this format would include adequate classification of vehicle type
as present in study area and required for development of UTP model. The same format will be
used in following surveys:
o Traffic volume count survey at outer cordons,
o Traffic volume count survey at inner cordons,
o Traffic volume count survey at screen lines,
o Traffic volume count survey at any other mid-block location,
o Traffic volume count survey at the access roads to terminal, and
2-4
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME III: Consultancy Services for
On detailed comparison of all available and widely used commercial soft wares for four-stage travel demand
modeling we have recommended use EMME/3 with custom made soft wares for mode choice (logit) modeling.
We will be proceeding with EMME/3 for use in the study.
TASK 1.7 REVISIT THE WORK PLAN AND METHODOLOGY AND FINALISE
The Work Plan is discussed at the Contract Negotiations stage. Appropriate refinements are done suiting the
timing of project and deliverables, which is the focus of this task.
Inception Report in Four (4) Volumes is prepared and submitted. This is Volume 3 of the submittal.
2-5
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME III: Consultancy Services for
For the city of Hyderabad, to prepare an effective IAP, in line with our general approach and methodology,
consultant will undertake following seven tasks as described below:
Immediate Action Plan (IAP) would be concerned with Transportation Systems Management (TSM) actions
with extensive understanding of the problems. Consultant will visit the identified area first to select and
delineate the problem areas to be taken up for IAP. We will hold consultations with client and implementing
agencies (GHMC, Traffic Police, APSRTC etc.) before we proceed during the TAC.
TASK 2.2 SCOPING OF THE WORK AND IDENTIFICATION OF PRIMARY SURVEY NEEDS
Site visits are undertaken. Survey needs are defined. There could be some unconventional surveys in terms
of time/duration etc. For example, traffic volume count at some of the locations only for peak hours, patrolling
intervals for parked vehicles on long stretches, peak hour counting of turning movements of traffic at select
junctions/intersections, quick assessment of land availability for parking etc. All such conventional and
unconventional survey requirements are in the process of identification now. These are to some extent
2-6
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME III: Consultancy Services for
Based on the identified primary survey needs, under this task, field survey will be undertaken. The following
types of surveys will be conducted under this task:
Survey Type Purpose
• Traffic Volume Count Survey at Junctions/Intersections for 12 hours covering both AM & PM Junction
peak and off-peak at 30 locations as per direction of movement. Improvement Plan
• In addition, at select minor intersections, the same survey only for peak hours.
• Topographic Survey of the Junctions/Intersection covering 200 m length on each arm to
prepare a base map showing all on-ground physical features and utilities
• At signalized intersection – Signal/phase/cycle time survey
• Traffic volume count survey at select locations (mid-block) for varying duration (16 hrs./ 12 Traffic
hrs./ 4hrs.) as per the need Management Plan
• Road network inventory upto level of the network considered for evolving traffic management at area level
plan followed by Speed and Delay Survey
• Availability of parking space, location of existing bus/IPT stops (formal/informal) and other
possible potential location.
• Availability of facilities for NMT and pedestrian movement.
• Use of the turning movement survey data conducted for preparing junction specific
improvement plans.
• Topographic Survey of the identified corridor(s) of approximate 15 km length covering 50 m Corridor
on either side of the centre line and 200 m length on each arm of each cross roads to prepare Improvement Plan
a base map showing all on-ground physical features, utilities, road signs, bus/IPT stops and
major activity centres along the corridor.
• Speed and Delay Survey along the corridor through moving observer method.
• Area and network inventory of all identified terminals which require immediate attention. Traffic Circulation
• Necessary traffic volume count at entry/exit points of terminal. Plan around Inter
city/ intra city bus
• Study of existing layout plan and vehicle circulation plan within terminal premise.
and goods terminal
• Necessary turning movement survey (4hrs. during peak) at main intersection and mid-block
volume count survey on adjoining roads having direct impact of such terminals in close
vicinity.
Further under this task, based on site visits, discussion and data analysis, a thorough appreciation of the
following will be done:
• Existing traffic management schemes
• Existing traffic circulation pattern
• Existing parking management
• Existing traffic control system and other measures
• Existing pedestrian facilities
• Enforcement level and compliance level of existing plans, if any.
Having understood the problem and having analyzed and interpreted data, under this task consultant will
develop possible alternative solutions for each junction, each corridor, and each identified area. Intersections/
Corridors / Areas have been shortlisted and included in main volume of the Inception Report for approval.
2-7
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME III: Consultancy Services for
The alternative solutions for specific location/ area/ corridor developed under previous task will be discussed
with stakeholders/ implementing agencies such as GHMC/ Traffic Police/ APSRTC etc. for their valuable
feedback and comments. The same will be duly incorporated in the plan under subsequent task.
A report on all field surveys identified for IAP and undertaken under Task 2.2-Task 2.3 will be prepared under
this task. The broad contents of this report would be:
• Identification process of Junction, Corridor(s), Area and Terminals for developing appropriate IAP.
• List and location of primary surveys undertaken along with methodology and survey format.
• Particulars of raw data
• Analysis, findings, interpretation of survey results.
Having discussed and obtained feedback on various schemes, the accepted proposals will be improved and
finalized as required. A report on “Immediate Action Plan” will be prepared and submitted under this Task. The
report would broadly contain addressing each component exclusively:
• Background of the Plan
• A brief on selection process of Junctions/ corridors/ terminals and area for improvement.
• Appreciation of existing traffic management schemes
• Diagnosis of problem area requiring immediate attention
• Improvement measures with phasing (if required)
• Preliminary cost estimates
• Implementation mechanism
2-8
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME III: Consultancy Services for
On evolving Traffic Analysis Zone (TAZ), next most important task is to collect and collate possible and useful
land use / socio economic data at TAZ level. One of the objectives of this task to appreciate the land use and
socio-economic characteristics of the study area at a disaggregated level, i.e. by each traffic zone delineated
through Task 3.1.
We will collate the following Land use and socio – economic data at TAZ level:
Land use by Zones - The predominant categories of land use by which the ground coverage of the study area
will be characterized are:
• Residential • Health
• Recreational • Reserved Green
• Commercial • Vacant / Barren
• Industrial • Agricultural
• Institutional • Govt. owned land, etc
Zone wise Population - By each traffic zone, the population size, number of households for the base year,
growth trend over the years, etc. will be compiled under this task. This information will be first utilized in taking
decision on sample size for each TAZ for conducting household travel survey.
Employment by Zones - At this stage, the employment profile by each traffic zone will be prepared which
would include compiling the size of employment under various categories as follows:
• Primary Sector
• Secondary Sector
• Tertiary (Service) Sector
• Informal Sector (if available), etc.
2-9
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME III: Consultancy Services for
Student Enrolment by Zones - The number of students enrolled in each traffic zone will be compiled by
categories of existing institutions, like:
• Schools – Primary, Secondary & High School
• Colleges/ Universities
• Professional Institutes – Medical College, BBA, MBA etc.
• Technical Institutes – Poly Techniques, Engineering Colleges etc.
Here availability and access to the latest Census-2011 data would be very critical to benefit this landmark
study by having accurate base year data on many planning parameters.
TASK 3.3 DESIGN AND SUPERVISION OF HOUSEHOLD TRAVEL O-D SURVEY INCLUDING STATED
PREFERENCE
Study of urban travel characteristics by home interview survey is one of the most prevalent and important
techniques. By this survey the present day intra-city travel demand and its characteristics such as Origin,
Destination, Mode of Travel, Trip Length and Purpose of Trips can be understood and estimated. The trip
information is captured for primary trips and secondary (link) trips as well. This survey primarily gives the
characteristics of internal trips of the study area. The characteristics of the trips would include origin and
destination, mode used, start and end time, purpose, cost etc. In addition to the trip information the data
related to the household characteristics, personal characteristics, and employment characteristics will also be
collected.
The typical questionnaire for undertaking household travel survey is submitted with the Inception Report. At
this stage, consultant will review this questionnaire and finalize the same with the client/TAC. Questionnaire is
given in following four parts:
Part I: Household information including location, type of residence/ ownership, vehicle ownership. Personal
information includes age, sex, education level, occupation status, employment type for each member of the
household.
Part II: Person and Usual Travel data including exact location and type of employment, usual travel diary,
monthly income and expenditure on transport etc.
Part III: Trip Diary including origin, destination, purpose/ reason, modes of travel, cost, time including
information of all primary and link/ transfer trips
Universe: As per the objectives of the project, the total population/households living in the jurisdiction of
Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA), constitutes the universe of the survey.
Sample size: Keeping in view the objectives of the Project, it is to cover a random sample of 1.5 percent of
the total HHs in the area..
Survey of Floating Population / Institutional Population- Our initial observations during our site visit and
study of various documents related to Hyderabad demography reveal that Hyderabad has substantial
institutional and floating population. This population includes persons living temporarily or in semi-temporary
status in HMA and generating substantial travel demand. These people include persons living in hotels,
hostels of educational institutions, hospitals and other such places providing temporary accommodation.
2-10
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME III: Consultancy Services for
Sampling Design: The traffic demand is a function of some important variables depicting the socio economic
and cultural background of the people. For better estimation of traffic demand, the true representation of the
population living in the area is to be ensured through an appropriate sampling design. To achieve this, a
three-stage stratified random sampling design is given, with sub-divisions, zones within sub-divisions, and
Wards within zones as strata at various levels.
Various Constituents of HMA: All the constituents identified within HMA area will be included in the survey.
The total sample size will be distributed in proportion to their respective population sizes.
Zone: Within each Constituent there will be zones. All of them will be included in the survey. The sub-division
sample size will be further distributed to the zones in proportion to their respective population sizes.
Individuals from institutions: As mentioned above, besides covering the HHs population, the people living in
the institutions/non-residential buildings like hostels will also be covered. For this, if within or adjoining area of
the selected PSUs, if some institutions are existing, they will be covered. From these buildings, first it will be
ascertained as to who all are living. From them, required number will be selected and interviewed. In all,
such interviews would be 3,000.
A Technical Note on “Sampling Techniques and Sample Generation” will be submitted to HMDA/Technical
Advisory Committee (TAC) for review and observations.
Teams (comprising transport planner, supervisors and enumerators) responsible for different areas will be
trained fully by experts and be sent in to the field with finalised survey formats for pilot testing of formats and
on the job experience to the enumerators for a limited small number of households in GHMC, Secunderabad
cantonment area and outer areas of HMA.
Before initiating the pilot survey, a press note would be issued in the local dailies informing citizens about the
study background, the importance of the household survey and requesting the people of HMA to cooperate
and furnish the information. In this regard, HMDA is expected to provide widespread advertisements and
coverage through the mass media for this survey. Consultant will be responsible for tracing the address and
conducting surveys. Consultant believe, the press appeal for this type of survey generally proves to be very
helpful in eliciting public interest and cooperation.
2-11
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME III: Consultancy Services for
Report Submission- Having observations on our technical note, consultant will submit a report on “sampling
techniques / sample generation, detailed methodology for model development” at the end of three
months from the Inception of the study. Prior to this submission, Consultant will also discuss and agree upon
the contents of this report with client agency and initiate the household survey.
Household survey will be conducted by personal direct interview method at selected household. Data
regarding trips performed by each member of the households on the previous working day will be collected.
The information will be collected as discussed in sub-task 3.3.1.
TASK 3.4 IDENTIFY OUTER CORDON/ INNER CORDON/ SCREEN LINES / MID-BLOCK AND SURVEY
LOCATIONS
Study area is huge with many constituents such as GHMC, HADA, Cantonment board, urban out growth, and
rural pockets as well with varying travel characteristics and interaction level with rest of the study area and
rest of the state. The sole purpose of this survey is to assess three out of four components of travel within
study area such as Internal – External, External – Internal and External – External by doing traffic volume
count and O-D survey (for passenger and goods vehicles) at outer cordon i.e. various gateways to study
area. Since, study area is large with most of its population and activity centre within GHMC, consultant will
establish additional inner cordon line/point encompassing GHMC. At all identified locations along Inner
Cordon line too traffic volume count and O-D survey will be conducted.
Screen lines are those which cut across the study area into distinctive parts and limited access points for the
mobility. Rivers, canals, and railway lines etc. or any such physical barrier in combination are generally taken
as screen lines in the study area. The purpose of conducting traffic volume count and occupancy survey along
selected points on screen-lines is to assess quantum of vehicular and passenger movement across these
lines. This further helps in validating the travel demand estimation made from sample surveys and calibrated
base year UTP travel demand model.
Further, consultant have identified additional traffic volume count location on important corridors for general
appreciation of traffic level, validation of the model and using it for preliminary round of potential MRTS phase-
II corridors for further analysis.
TASK 3.5 DEVELOP SURVEY PROGRAMME AND CONDUCT TRAFFIC VOLUME COUNT AND OR
O-D/ OCCUPANCY SURVEYS
Consultant have made an attempt and have delineated outer-cordon lines, inner-cordon lines and screen-
lines. Consultant have also identified survey locations and have quantified survey requirement. The Table
below presents in summary form, the quantum of surveys identified along each of the cordon/screen lines.
Along Type of Survey Duration No. of Locations
Traffic Volume Count Survey 24 (Hrs.) 20
Outer Cordon Line
Origin – Destination Survey 24 (Hrs.) 20
Traffic Volume Count Survey 24 (Hrs.) 27
Inner Cordon Line
Origin – Destination Survey 24 (Hrs.) 27
Traffic Volume Count Survey 24 (Hrs.) 67
Screen-Line Occupancy Survey for Passenger
12 (Hrs.) 67
Vehicles
Mid-Block
Traffic Volume Count Survey 16 (Hrs.)/ 24 (Hrs.) 36
Locations
2-12
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME III: Consultancy Services for
In addition to very important household survey, traffic counts and O-D survey at outer cordon, inner cordon,
screen lines and other mid-block location, a number of other primary surveys will be conducted. Each of them
is discussed through exclusive sub-tasks. It could be noted that the following surveys and quantities are in
addition to the surveys for preparing Immediate Action Plan (IAP). However, they too, to some extent would
be utilized at various stages of UTP model development and plan preparation.
The study of intersections is vital in understanding, estimating and modeling of traffic flow on road networks
and thereby network capacity analysis. In the previous traffic studies many of the intersections might have
been covered. Consultant will collect such data and review its usability. In addition, consultants have identified
25 important intersections to conduct a turning movement surveys and inventory of the same. These would
include some of previously studied intersections as well as newly identified ones. In addition to physical
inventory, operational studies like turning movement surveys, saturation flow studies will be conducted for the
identified intersections. The survey would be conducted through manual counting capturing all movement at
identified intersections for 8 hours between 6:00 am and 10:00 pm during any working day of the week
covering AM and PM peak period (4hrs. each).
There are 15 major bus terminals (intra-city and or inter city), three rail terminals and one air terminal in
the study area. While present airport terminal at Samshabad has recently been developed other terminals are
quite old. Each of them possesses unique characteristics and associated problem/ issues. To identify such
problems and evolve solutions thereafter, each of the terminals will be taken and surveyed separately as per
the need.
Combination of survey for varying time period will be conceptualized such as traffic volume count at major
access road to the terminal, turning movement survey (peak period) at closest intersections, count of bus
entry/exit, count of other private vehicle entry/exit, parking inside and or outside.
Further to ascertain physical infrastructure inventory of area, bus parking bays, office area, buildings,
workshop, depot area, visitors parking area etc. will be measured and drawn on map. Information regarding
number of buses that operate from the terminal will be collected from respective offices.
At railway station similar exercise will be carried and similar information related to train operation will be
collected.
In addition, consultant will conduct terminal user survey (out bound/ inbound passengers) at every terminal to
capture trip information, personal profile and most importantly dispersal pattern. Approximately 100 such
sample surveys will be conducted at each regional terminal (road/rail/air).
The floating population of a town constitutes mainly two types. The first category is those types of people who
visit the place routinely but do not stay at the place. The reason for such visits is mainly for some job or work
associated with the town. The second type constitutes visitors or guests who might live for a small span of
time, but their duration of stay as well as next visit are not predictable. Often the second type of floating
population is seasonal visitors, like tourists. In a city like Hyderabad, such population will be significant. To
capture profile and associated characteristics of such population many surveys are identified which in addition
to its own defined purpose will serve this purpose too. For instance, O-D survey of passenger vehicle at
outer-cordon points, passenger interview at regional terminal, interview of institutional population
2-13
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME III: Consultancy Services for
The current network extends to about 47 kilometres with 26 stations, served by 12 rakes EMUs. As per the
reported statistics, MMTS cater to about 100,000 passenger trips per day in about 80 train trips. Under this
task, consultant will conduct two types of surveys as follows:
Boarding/Alighting Survey – on sample train trip, consultant will man gates of one coach and counting
boarding and alighting number of passengers at each station of the train trip from its origin to final destination.
This will expanded to estimate total boarding/alighting at every station, total passenger trip catered by each
route and by MMTS in a normal week day and level of ridership between stations. About 10- train trips will be
covered.
Interview of MMTS Passenger– on sample basis, consultant will interview MMTS users on pre-designed
proforma to capture personal details, trip characteristics with clear differentiation between home based and
non-home based trips, whether resident or floating population, opinion on the services etc. Consultant will
conduct approximately 500 such interview on sample basis.
Like MMTS passenger survey, Bus passenger survey on APSRTC city bus and SETWIN bus will also be
conducted. This survey will also be divided into two parts such as:
Boarding/Alighting Survey – on sample city bus route, Consultant will conduct on board boarding and
alighting survey to count number of passengers boarding and alighting at each stop (schedule/ request/
intersection) along with time stamp. This will expanded to estimate total passenger trip catered by each route/
by trip in a normal weekday and level of ridership/occupancy in bus between stops. About 200 bus-trips will be
covered.
Interview of Bus Passenger– on sample basis, consultant will interview Bus users on pre-designed proforma
to capture personal details, trip characteristics with clear differentiation between home based and non-home
based trips, whether resident or floating population, opinion on the services etc. Consultant will conduct
approximately 5,000 such interview on sample basis spread across the study area at selected bus stops or on
board.
The speed flow relationships and link volume travel time functions, or Volume Delay Functions (VDF), play an
important role at the traffic assignment stage in the travel demand modeling. The volume travel time functions
are entered as attributes of links, which in turn represent road sections. The purpose of these VDF is to
determine the travel time according to the volume on each network link. Towards this, selecting representative
road sections and developing such VDF on each is important. Although while reviewing earlier studies
consultant would also appraise the number and type of representative road sections that have been used in
past, consultant at this stage will develop the exclusive VDF for the following categories (16 no.) of road
sections. This consultant believe can represent the variety of roads that HMA strategic road network would
have.
Road Categories / Lane configuration Divided/ Undivided Traffic Management
SL/IL Undivided One Way
SL/IL Undivided Two Way
2/3 Lane Undivided One Way
2/3 Lane Undivided Two way
2 Lane Flyover Undivided One way
4 Lane (Effective 2 lane ) Divided Two way
4 Lane Undivided One Way
2-14
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME III: Consultancy Services for
On the identified sections, consultant willmeasure the speed and flow of all classified vehicles. Speed
measurement will be done by Registration Plate Method using recording devices, by noting the Registration
number and time at entry/exit. Spot speeds will also be measured using Radar Speedometer. Simultaneously
Vehicular Flows will be counted manually at 2 minutes interval period.
The recording device is a custom built Micro controller based on 16 bit data recorder or (Data logger) which
facilitates recording the registration numbers with a time and date stamp preset.
The survey will be carried out for a total period of 8 hours divided into early morning off-peak + morning peak
+ afternoon off-peak + start of evening peak. The above periods will capture the variation in flow, speed, side
friction, cross friction etc.
The objective of this survey is to assess the operational characteristics of the IPT (Auto Ricksaw), identity
problems & issues and suggest appropriate policies for its rational development. In this section survey will be
conducted to appreciate the current IPT system characteristics in the city and its user’s profile. There will be
two part of this survey
• Passenger survey - the IPT users will be interviewed to assess their trip characteristics in terms of origin
and destination of trip, purpose and cost of trips, home based or non-home based trips etc.. consultant will
do 3,000 such interview covering Auto Rickshaw and Taxi users.
• Operator Survey - this will provide IPT operational characteristics in terms of route of operation, vehicle
utilization, passengers carried/day, operating cost and revenue etc.. consultant will do 500 such interview
of Auto / Taxi drivers.
The survey will be conducted at locations, like Railway stations, Bus Stations etc, with high concentration of
IPT modes and trips.
2-15
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME III: Consultancy Services for
Mobility as defined by network characteristics is manifested in journey speed and delay characteristics. This
survey is conducted to assess mobility levels provided by the network and identify bottlenecks. The speed and
delay studies will be conducted using moving car observer method wherein in addition to journey time, delay
etc. vehicle coming from opposite direction, vehicle overtaking test car and vehicle overtaken by test car will
also be counted. Two round trips will be made on each link of the selected network for statistically sound
result during day hours (peak/off-peak period). Our initial appreciation of HMA’s road network suggests that
around 4,000 km will have to be covered under this survey.
The work place survey would involve on sample basis of commercial, industrial and institutional
establishments within the Study Area in order to understand the following aspects:
• Trip generation characteristics of various activities
• WTP for improved public transport facility
• Likely hood to divert to proposed metro based on improved level of service in Metro
• Response to congestion pricing
• Response to parking policy/ pricing
• Generalised cost parameters
The information on daily visitors and employees by each type of establishment would help in establishing a
parking-activity relationship. The establishments will be covered would include wholesale and retail shops,
government and private offices, schools and colleges, industries, warehouses, workshops and any other
public or private institutions of significance. The information to be collected would include the trip
characteristics of the visitors as well as characteristics of establishment including floor area, number of
employees, number of visitors per day, pattern and modes used for delivery of goods to their establishments
etc. Consultant will interview around 100 establishments and 3,000 visitors on sample basis as part of work
place survey.
There are number of goods terminals of varying size in the study area. This survey will provide the data
related to inflow and out flow of commodity and goods which are controlled by major goods terminals in the
city. This would supplement the O-D matrices for goods vehicle generated based on O-D survey at outer/inner
cordon points. The survey will also include terminal inventory to assess physical infrastructure available and
its characteristics. This survey will be conducted at 10 locations within HMA such as Kukatpally, ICD Sanat
nagar, LB Nagar, Reti bowli, Sagar Road, Patan Cheruvu, Gudi Malakpuri, Began Bazat, Monda market etc.
With the changing travel habits and increasing number of motor vehicles the problems are bound to become
serious in the absence of properly planned parking facilities. An inventory of the existing on-street and off-
street parking facilities will be prepared. The general methodology for both the surveys is similar, though
minor details can be different. The field survey will be carried out for all types of vehicles in the area under
study in order to determine the parking demand in terms of accumulation and duration. Field studies will be
conducted for 12 hours (06:00 to 18:00 hours) during weekdays. The data will be recorded through Patrolling
Method by the enumerators at about 10 locations/stretches in addition to the locations/stretches covered as
part of Stage-I survey for IAP.
2-16
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME III: Consultancy Services for
At identified location, NMT count survey including pedestrian will be conducted on pre-designed proforma for
a total 12 hours period. The period of survey will be split into two parts so as to capture both the AM and PM
peak period. These surveys will be located at/along stretches where the proportion/numbers of NMT are high.
Opinion survey will be integral part of the many of the interview survey, consultant will conduct surveys such
as Bus passenger survey, MMTS passenger survey, IPT user survey, wok place survey etc to ascertain user’s
perception on various services such as MMTS, Bus service, auto/taxi etc..
Commercial vehicle includes goods vehicles and taxis/ auto rickshaw operating in the study area. Objective of
this survey is to supplement the matrices of such travel pattern developed out of various surveys so as to
complete commercial vehicle movement matrix in the study area. Under this task consultant will identify gaps
in information and focus systematic data collection from various transport operators, IPT association etc.
The appreciation of road network characteristics is important to assess existing capacity and present level of
service of the roads, to identify the constraints, if any, and to assess the potential for improvement/up-
gradation of road network to cater to increasing demands of traffic movement. This sub-task will be achieved
through various steps.
• Identification of primary network – based on the map study, extensive reconnaissance survey, our own
experiences and other information.
• Designing the format to capture all intended and useful information in consultation with client.
• Actual Survey – this will be done by trained enumerators under the guidance of in-field qualified and
experienced engineers. The field survey will be conducted to measure physical characteristics of the
network in terms of right-of-way, carriageway, shoulders, footpath, median and drainage of each section.
Also the conditions of street lighting, telephone poles, existing traffic management measures, extent of
tree plantation and the predominant adjoining land use etc. will be recorded.
Consultant will conduct such survey on about 4,500 km of road network in HMA towards identifications of
strategic road network for UTP Model Development.
Besides data collection from primary surveys, such study do require many more information/ data to be
collected from various sources in the study area. Consultant will identify, collect, collate such data which
would complement the information collected through primary surveys and be used in various stages of the
study. At this stage, consultant feel following data would need to be collected:
• Satellite imageries at a scale of at least 1:12500 for the areas HMDA do not have GIS map including road
network: With the help of HMDA consultants will obtain the above imageries for selected areas in HMA to
prepare a detailed road network map of HMA and appreciate development pattern.
• Necessary Maps of the study area such as “Wards” boundaries in various municipalities and GHMC.
• Data on Demography, Economy and Land-use: Recent population and economic census data will be
collected and compiled at delineated Traffic Zonal level.
• Establishment Data with type, employment and location
• Network Characteristics: Digitized network map will be finalized after necessary ground verification. List
and ownership of the roads including ROW information.
2-17
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME III: Consultancy Services for
TASK 3.8 CODING, PROCESSING, ANALYSIS AND INTERPRETATION OF DATA COLLECTED FROM
ALL SOURCES
Under this task Consultant will do necessary coding and computerization of all data collected from both
primary surveys and secondary sources in appropriate database such as MS Excel, MS Access, SQL etc after
necessary validation. This would be available for even client agency to access any time. The complete
database, at the end of assignment will be handed over to HMDA for further use and reference in future.
The following information will be derived out of the household surveys pertaining to:
HOUSEHOLD CHARACTERISTICS
• Distribution of households by size
• Household size by income group
• Distribution of population by age group
• Distribution of population as per age and sex by area
• Educational level of population by area
• Occupation pattern of population by area
• Distribution of households by income groups
• Distribution of households by household size
• Household expenditure pattern as per income groups by area
• Household expenditure on travel according to mode by area
PERSONAL CHARACTERISTICS
The personal characteristics of an individual are often a key-determining factor in the trip making. The
following are the two most significant indicators of personal characteristics of a traveler or commuter:
• Income and
• Occupation
Both these aspects would be intercepted for each individual of the surveyed household
Apart from the above the user’s perception on the following aspects will also be obtained from the household
survey analysis.
• User rating of services by mode
• User perception of service by mode
• User suggestions for improvement of service by mode
2-18
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME III: Consultancy Services for
From the above set of findings consultant will derive the following information:
• Mode wise average trip lengths (km)
• Per capita trip rate (PCTR) for the city as a whole.
• Travel demand for different purposes
• Travel demand by different modes
Survey data will analyzed to know the perception of the users about the existing public transport system
(suburban rail/bus), reasons to choose public transport vis-a vis private modes, problems encountered in any
of the selection, factors which affect the choice.
In addition, other information collected during survey give an idea to plan an improved system or even to
upgrade or expand the existing system. Some of the outputs could be as follows:
• Average acceptable walking time in proposed or expanded system,
• Average acceptable walking distance in proposed or expanded system,
• Average acceptable waiting time in proposed or expanded system, etc.
• Acceptable fare structure
• Stated acceptable fare hike against time saving
A Technical Note on “Home Interview Surveys comprising O-D Matrices, Desire Line Diagram and other
characteristics” will be submitted to HMDA/Technical Advisory Committee (TAC) for review and
observations.
2-19
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME III: Consultancy Services for
Under this task, the whole range of traffic data pertaining to those of traffic volume counts and origin-
destination patterns of commuters, that have been collected in the surveys at outer cordon, inner cordon and
screen lines, mid-blocks will be analyzed and the findings from the same would be interpreted to form an input
to further transportation modeling and travel demand estimation.
Traffic flow characteristics - The traffic volume characteristics will be studied in terms of hourly variation and
composition of traffic including average daily traffic and peak hour traffic. An effort would be made to
understand the spatial variation in the traffic flow, while moving from core to the periphery of the study area.
The change in composition of traffic with the spatial distribution will also be analyzed at this stage.
Occupancy Patterns - The mode-wise occupancy data for different vehicles types that will be recorded on
sample basis, during the volume count survey itself. This will be compiled and through weighted average
method the average occupancy by each class of mode will be determined at different parts of the study area.
Turning Movement and Inventory Survey data Analysis – Analysis of the survey would provide us peak
hour flow diagram that can assist in the validation of UTP model at the same time addressing immediate
improvements of the junction. Inventory at junctions will be useful in planning the improvements to enhance
the capacity of each approach arm and thereby capacity of intersection/ junction as a whole. Purpose of this
sub-task would be to establish an equation (model) at representative strategic intersection, which can present
delay at all other similar intersections with given input of q/c. Where, q represents traffic flow/hour at the
intersection, and c stand for capacity (flow/hr) of the same intersection. This model is used for assigning turn
penalties during four-stage transport model development for each node excluding end/start/centroid.
Traffic Surveys Data collected at Major Terminals (Road/Rail/Air) - Terminals are essentially located at
high demand concentration points. In addition to being major boarding and alighting points terminals also
serve as waiting areas for passenger, interchanges, rest areas, parking area and so on, depending on specific
conditions. As discussed in the previous section every terminal will be treated on exclusive basis to identify
survey needs. Accordingly analysis at each terminal would vary. The data would be analyzed as per the
survey conducted at each terminal to assess terminal efficiency, operational characteristics, its access, area
and facility adequacy, any bottleneck in adjoining network etc.
Analysis of Survey of Floating Population – As discussed in sub-task 3.3.2, interview of the floating and
institutional population on sample basis will be conducted. Analysis of such data would provide in addition to
2-20
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME III: Consultancy Services for
MMTS Rail passenger Survey Analysis – Through the analysis of the collected data, Consultant will bring
forth issues relating to efficiency and effectiveness of the system at the same time of users preferences and
perceptions. While on-board survey data would provide total ridership, boarding and alighting numbers at
various stations etc., passenger interview would apart from general profile and trip characteristics of the
passenger will give users perception on the services and suggestions towards improvement. Such
opinion/suggestions would be used to identify potentials and constraints of the system, which could form an
important input to the stage of formulation of plans and strategies.
The other information collected from the secondary sources, once analyzed will elicit issues related to MMTS
rail system and its operational characteristics in a comprehensive manner, which would form input to the
adequacy analysis of the system “mode choice modeling” in subsequent stages. The analysis would be based
on detailed data collected from Indian Railways.
APSRTC Bus Passenger On-Board Survey Analysis - Analysis of the passenger on-board survey will help
us to identify bus users’ profile, trip characteristics, their perception on the service, and shortfalls between
expectations and available infrastructure. This analysis will further be substantiated with Bus Transport
System Characteristics including the aspects such as fleet size and growth, routing and scheduling,
performance indicators etc. Combining both analyses, at this stage, consultant will bring forth issues relating
to efficiency and effectiveness of the system at the same time of users preferences and perceptions. The
outputs would form input to the adequacy analysis “mode choice modeling” in subsequent stages.
Survey analysis to Develop Speed-Flow Function - As discussed in earlier section, data will be plotted and
curve is drawn enveloping all the points to assess the tentative lane capacity for each categories of the roads
separately. These tentative lane Capacities and Free flow Speeds derived from the enveloping curves are
taken as initial guess for calibration of different speed flow and volume delay models. Following the standard
procedure of calibrating various forms of speed flow functions such as BPR functions, modified BPR
functions, conical functions, and other empirical equations will be calibrated and compared before adopting in
this study. Some of the typical speed-flow functions developed by us in other similar assignments are shown
below.
VDF
Rank 89 Eqn 8010 Power(a,b,c)
r^2=0.56579138 DF Adj r^2=0.55770054 FitStdErr=71.59706 Fstat=105.54627
a=125.99449 b=341.5599
c=1.9071068
550 550
494.44 494.44
438.89 438.89
383.33 383.33
Actual Delay
Actual Delay
327.78 327.78
272.22 272.22
216.67 216.67
161.11 161.11
105.56 105.56
50 50
0.1 0.34444 0.58889 0.83333 1.0778
V/C
IPT (Taxi and auto rickshaw) Survey Analysis - The IPT both supplements and complements the public
transport system of a city and therefore needs to be duly considered. The objective here would be to
determine the operational and performance characteristics of IPT and determine their role in the total
transportation system of the city.
Speed and Delay Survey Analysis - The importance of speed and delay survey is to appreciate the
prevailing travel speed on the network. This survey is also important in order to measure the delays and
degree of congestion with reference to time of the day, location, duration or the magnitude as well as the
frequency with which such delays occur. Another important aspect of this study is the measurement of spatial
separation in terms of travel time between different zones of the city. The data analysis would result in journey
2-21
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME III: Consultancy Services for
Work Zone/Place Activity Survey Analysis - The data collected through surveys conducted at the work
zones will be analyzed initially to estimate the quantum and pattern of non-home based trips. Analysis will
also help in developing relationship between various kinds of activities and related traffic demand. The survey
analysis will provide the trip generating characteristics of Government, Industrial, and Commercial
establishments.
Consultant will develop trip generation and trip attraction rates for various kinds of activities so as to develop a
framework for undertaking Traffic Impact Studies on surrounding network for any kind of activities. It will
also provide the basis for formulating the guidelines in local planning decisions.
Goods Focal Point and Movement Survey Analysis - The data collected through traffic volume count at
outer cordons, inner cordons, screen lines together with O-D at same locations would be analyzed to devise
goods vehicle travel matrices. This would be further supplemented with the information collected from various
operators and freight terminals.
Parking Survey Analysis - People commute to perform some activity. At the end of the trip the vehicle that
was used to perform the trip has to be left behind to actually perform the activity. Except in the case of public
transport the vehicle has to be safely parked. This would lead to the conclusion that just as travel is a function
of activity so is parking, at least to the extent of private transport share. The objective of this task is to study
this relationship. Out of the survey, consultant will establish activity profile at the identified parking locations,
parking characteristics in terms of accumulation, parking duration, turnover etc. In addition, from numerous
examples it may be concluded that IPT is hardly ever provided with parking facility in a planned manner. This
result in lack of even remotely terminal/interchange like facilities for the IPT resulting in parking encroaching of
the ROW causing problems to all: the IPT users, other road users and the operators themselves. These and
other related issues would be considered in our analysis. Further, in absence of significant and organized
information available on IPT, little is known about its operation and operators. The operators who may be
expected from the economically lower sections of the society should be taken care of in any attempt to
improve, alter or modernize the city’s transportation system. This would be an attempt to assess the socio-
economic characteristics of the operators and their perceptions and problems.
Pedestrian and Non-Motorised Transport (NMT) Survey Analysis - The objective of this survey and
thereafter analysis would be to establish pedestrian flow patterns, NMT movement pattern and its impact on
stream flow, NMT travel characteristics, and estimating hazard indices. These would be used to identify critical
areas both for the present and in the future and would be addressed mostly through immediate action plan.
Opinion Survey Analysis – The opinion sought in various interviews (bus passenger, MMTS, rail passenger,
during roadside interview) on general perception of the public transport, road network, traffic management,
MMTS will be analyzed qualitatively and used at various stages of the study including the stage of transport
strategy and policy formulation.
Commercial Vehicle Survey Analysis – The data captured at outer/ inner cordon points regarding
commercial vehicle movement including goods vehicles and Taxis, and their trip characteristics will provide
general desire of the commercial vehicle movement in the study area. This will be supplemented with the
information collected from various commercial vehicle operators, commercial vehicle associations and whole
sale market union etc. to have a comprehensive understanding on commercial vehicle movement in the study
area.
The objective under this task would be to identify the primary and secondary network and appraise it critically.
This would be done through a combination of physical and functional considerations.
2-22
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME III: Consultancy Services for
As speeds is a function of physical characteristics of the link and the traffic characteristics, the results of
Speed & Delay surveys would be correlated with physical characteristics of the network. Further side friction
to flow due to abutting land use and parking, intersections also affect running and journey speeds and cause
delays. All such physical, functional and operational causes of delays causing bottlenecks would be
identified.
A Technical Note on “Road Inventory, Traffic Surveys and Analysis” will be submitted to HMDA/Technical
Advisory Committee (TAC) for review and observations.
TASK 3.9 DEVELOPMENT OF BASE YEAR TRANSPORT SYSTEM NETWORK MAP IN GIS
Transportation system network comprises of links. Links are the shortest segments on which trips are
assigned. Under previous tasks Consultant have identified first set of network on which inventory and speed
and delay surveys have been conducted. Under this task consultant willcode each and every link with their
key attributed in GIS.
Consultant will submit a comprehensive report on “Field Survey” conducted in Stage-II towards baseline data
collection in the study area. This report would contain details relating to the type of surveys, methodology
adopted, sample and quantity, formats followed, its codes used in computerization of data and raw data in
reportable format.
TASK 3.11 ESTABLISH THE EXISTING TRAFFIC AND TRANSPORT SCENARIO OF STUDY AREA
Having completed tasks 3.8 and 3.9, at this stage Consultant will synthesize all results, interpretation, issue
and potential identification. This will culminate to a comprehensive existing traffic and transport scenario of the
study area. The scenario would primarily cover base line socio-economic characteristics and land use pattern,
transport system characteristics, traffic and travel characteristics, PT and IPT characteristics, summary
findings and issues etc.
At the completion of Task 3.11, Consultant will submit the “Data Compilation and Statistical Analysis Report”
which will essentially have all the data collected from primary surveys and secondary sources in the electronic
form along with statistical analysis also presented in the graphical formats, initial findings and issues. This
th
task will be accomplished at the end of 12 month from the inception of the study.
At this stage, Consultant will present the findings to the client HMDA)/Traffic Advisory Committee (TAC).
2-23
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME III: Consultancy Services for
It has been a world wide growing concern now that a “predict and provide” approach can not provide a
solution to budding transport problems. Efforts to improve the supply of transport have to match by measures
in order to control transport demand. This emphasizes the role of land use planning as complement to
transport policy. Our approach would be to provide with broad guidance on the ways in which policy on land
use can complement and be combined in order to achieve integration. After all, objective of any integrated
transportation strategy is to have “a seamless, cost effective system for moving people, goods and resources
operating within HMA and its hinterland that:
• improves interaction and physical connectivity;
• enables communities and industries to meet their transport needs; and
• enhances the Region’s economic development and environmental wellbeing.”
Accordingly, to achieve the objectives, through our approach consultant would focus on the following four
aspects:
• strategic transport system;
• transport and industry;
• land use and transport planning; and
• principles and priorities for transport investment.
TASK 3.14 ESTABLISH SERVICE LEVEL BENCH MARKS FOR STUDY AREA
Consultant understand the need of measuring performance to urban transport activities in various cities of
India. To facilitate comparison between cities and changes in performance over time, it was felt important that
the performance levels are monitored against set benchmarks. It is in this context, that the MoUD has service
level performance benchmarks identified for the following areas of intervention:
• Public transport facilities • Availability of parking spaces
• Pedestrian infrastructure facilities • Road safety
• Non Motorized Transport (NMT)facilities • Pollution levels
• Level of usage of Intelligent Transport System • Integrated land use transport system
(ITS) facilities • Financial sustainability of public transport
• Travel speed (Motorized and Mass Transit)
along major corridors
Typically, four levels of service (LoS) have been specified, viz. 1, 2, 3, and 4 with 1 being highest LoS and 4
being lowest to measure each identified performance benchmark. Consultants understand the process, and
accordingly will do rating based on qualitative and quantitative analysis of available data for each of the
performance benchmarks.
Phase-I of MRTS development has recently begun through PPP in Hyderabad. It covers around 72 km of
length. The MRTS network is expected to be expanded to reach more areas in the city. In this regard, Govt./
client agency would want to identify next set of corridors to be bunched for Phase-II assignment.
Towards this, consultant will identify the corridors based on estimated traffic level, technical feasibility, and
connectivity to important activity centres as preliminary shortlist. This will be discussed and supported with
earlier studies in consultation with client and submitted for consideration.
A tentative list of Phase-II corridors of MRTS will be submitted at the end of 4 months from inception of the
study.
Thereafter, once UTP model is developed, validated and calibrated, consultant will test these corridors again
in view of integrated transport strategy and as per the agreed evaluation framework in Task 4.4.
2-24
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME III: Consultancy Services for
This task will begin from the background of Task 3.9. Digitized (vector format) and finalized through ground
verification road network map will be used for network coding which will form one of the important inputs for
developing and running transport planning models. Node numbers will be given as per the requirement of the
software chosen/decided for modeling purpose.
Consultant will compile attribute data for the network (link and node characteristics). Consultant will also
prepare input files including network coding based on the inventory collected as a part of Sub-Task 3.6.15.
Finally, the network would be built up as a link-node map. The nodes can be defined as points of transition
which may be a point with a significant change in activity on interaction substantial with significant addition or
diversion of traffic i.e. the significant junctions. A connection between two nodes forms a link, which would
then be a homogeneous section in terms of physical and functional properties. It is essential to build up the
network as a link-node map in order to assess the network capacity, identify bottlenecks, missing connections
and also to suggest specific improvement options. The link and nodes characteristics would form the link –
node database, which would determine the levels of connectivity, accessibility and consequently route choice
and actual traffic movement.
A typical coded transport network map along with input data format for model development in EMME is shown
in Figure 2-4.
Figure 2-4: Typical Coded Transport Network Map and Road and Transit Network Attributes in EMME
Other input data for model development such as O-D matrices by mode, purpose and time (day/peak/off-
peak), speed-flow functions developed in the Task 3.8 will be used in further model calibration.
Having identified and collected planning data from various sources (field surveys, secondary sources), the
prime objective of this task is to break all data at traffic zone level. For the purpose, Consultant will prepare a
check list depending upon finalized modeling approach to select the planning parameters which are to be
used in the base year model development and predictable for future years with reasonable accuracy. Such
planning parameters could be:
2-25
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME III: Consultancy Services for
This Section describes in more detail our modeling methodology for the study – as consultant perceive at
this present time. As the various data challenges become more apparent, consultant will during the course of
the study adopt the methodology to best accommodate those challenges without diluting basic requisites of
the UTM model. With this in mind, this remains an indicative methodology. The preferred approach will be
determined on the basis of our assessment of the quality, suitability and robustness of the data as it becomes
available.
The modeling methodology addresses all of the requirements of the TOR, provides a level of detailed
modeling significantly greater than anything yet attempted in Hyderabad, whilst still attempting to ensure a
high level of usability. A generalised form of the modeling framework is given in Figure 2-5 below.
As Figure 2-5 shows, consultant will adopt a standard 4-stage, recursive, model – with a number of
refinements to best address the unique properties of HMA’s transportation system. Our approach to the
detailed modeling of the HMA is a ‘holistic’ one, whereby consultant recognise that each of the constituents of
HMA has their own specific socio-economic and trip-making characteristics; and all co-exist, and interact,
inter-dependently (rather than independently) as vital, and dynamic, components of the HMA. The modeling
methodology would cover the requisite of TOR as follows:
• Modeling mode split, including walk, public transport modes • Mode Choice Model (MCM)
(auto rickshaws, taxi, bus and rail) and private transport
(motorcycle and car), good's vehicles
• Assigning trips to MMTS and bus networks taking into • Trip Assignment Model (TAM) considering
account the condition in trains, variations in bus speeds and generalized cost and speed, frequency etc. as
frequency due to changes in overall traffic volume, and fares attributes to transit lines built into an integrated
Transport network.
• Reflecting the impact of new land use developments and /or • Trip End Model (TEM)
control policies, including Truck Terminals, Truck parking
lots, Interstate Bus Terminal etc
• Responding to traffic demand management measures such • Trip Distribution and Trip Assignment Model
as parking fees, road user charges and congestion pricing, (TAM)incorporating the increased generalised costs
as well as the staggering of working hours, flexi hours and
multiple shift work
• Assessing impacts of the introduction of Mass Transit • Trip Assignment Model (TAM) with integrated
System (Rail/Road based system) Transport network
A report on the “methodology for UTP Model development, calibration and validation will be submitted to client
before actual start of this task.
2-26
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME III: Consultancy Services for
HMA
The following sections describe, in more detail, the various components of the model.
TIME PERIODS
Consultant will develop trip matrices for the following time periods:
• AM 4-hour Peak Period;
• PM 4-hour Peak Period; and
• Daily (24 hour)
2-27
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME III: Consultancy Services for
As the economic viability of transportation projects is largely determined by their daily (and annual) travel
demand and resulting revenue streams, Consultant will develop daily trip matrices to supplement these peak
matrices. AM and PM peak period matrices will be derived from the Daily (DY) trip matrices.
TRIP PURPOSES
On the basis of our reviews of previous studies, and our national and international experience, we expect the
main purposes of travel in HMA to be:
• Home Based Work (i.e. Home to Work/Work to Home) - HBW
• Home Based Education (i.e. Home to School/College & School/College to Home) - HBE
• Home Based Shopping (i.e. Home to Shopping/Shopping to Home) - HBS
• Home Based Other (other Home Based trips e.g. social, personal etc.) - HBO; and
• Non-Home Based (i.e. trips where neither end was at the Home) - NHB
It may also prove necessary to further disaggregate Work trips by income (e.g. low, medium & high) and
Education trips by institution (e.g. upto Primary, beyond Primary / upto Secondary, & College / University).
Consultant anticipate that these will be the main purposes modelled – however, consultant will obtain
clarification of the relative importance of each trip purpose from the results of our Household Interview Survey
(HIS) and Roadside Interview Surveys (RIS’s).
Consultant will develop trip-end estimation models for each of the above trip purposes in the model. In order
to do so, a number of sub-models will be developed to categorise households within the HMA into groupings
with identifiable household characteristics which are shown to be reliable determinants of vehicle availability
and trip-making. These sub-models will be developed from the results of the HIS. It is anticipated that these
sub-models will include:
2-28
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME III: Consultancy Services for
The HIS data will also be examined to investigate the practicality of developing additional sub-models, such a
Household Drivers Licence Sub-Model (HLM).
The above models will provide the following inputs to the Vehicle Availability Model:
• Number of households with 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6 and 7 or more residents;
• Number of households with 0, 1, 2, 3, 4 or more employed residents;
• Number of households with 0, 1, 2, 3 or more persons in full-time education; and
• Number of households with household incomes falling in each of 4 household income quartiles.
The ‘Vehicle Availability Model’ will be calibrated separately for each sub-region. The model is expected to be
a logit formulation, and will estimate the number of households in a zone with 0, 1, 2 and 3 or more vehicles.
Consultant will investigate the practicality of disaggregating vehicle availability into 2-wheelers and
cars/jeeps/vans separately. This is an important distinction as 2-wheeler growth is very high in Hyderabad,
2-29
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME III: Consultancy Services for
The Trip End Model will estimate trip productions & attractions by Vehicle Availability Group (VAG) and Trip
Purpose. As described previously, four vehicle availability groups will be modelled, together with five trip
purposes (HBW, HBE, HBS, HBO and NHB).
During the execution of the assignment consultant will examine whether the trip-end model will comprise a
multiple regression formulation or will take the form of category analysis/cross-classification. The decision on
the precise formulation will depend upon analysis of the survey data. The category analysis approach is more
straightforward, but will be complicated by the potentially large numbers of dimensions required to fully
address the trip generation characteristics of Hyderabad.
In terms of trip purposes, it may prove better to further disaggregate HBW trips by income (e.g. low, medium &
high) and HBE trips by institution (e.g. upto Primary, beyond Primary / upto Secondary, & College /
University).
Stratification of HBW trips by income is an option to address the presence of a very significant ‘informal’
employment sector. If this is not addressed at the trip-end level then the repercussions in the trip-end
distribution and mode split components could be very significant. Consultant expect that 3 to 4 income levels
should be sufficient segmentation. To further this approach consultant will also investigate a Destination
Choice Model to facilitate a better matching of trip generations (e.g. low income HBW) to trip attractiveness
(e.g. zonal number of employees in the formal sector). This is a similar approach to trip distribution, but uses
absolute values of attraction parameters rather than attraction trip-ends. This will be investigated more fully at
the appropriate time.
Consultant expect that a similar approach will be required for HBE trips.
It is anticipated that the data will be suitably robust to enable us to develop trip generation and attraction rates
for each of the sub-regions separately. This would tend to shift preference towards a multinomial regression
approach in which a ‘sub-region’ variable could be included in the formulation. This will be investigated.
Consultant will also consider incorporating accessibility as a factor into the trip generation/attraction models.
As discussed earlier, the requirement to satisfactorily pair particular categories of work trips with the
appropriate workplaces and categories of work is critical in a situation where such a large informal sector is in
operation. In an attempt to address this issue consultant will investigate developing a Destination Choice
Model stratified by income (at the home zone end) and number of jobs (by category e.g. informal / retail /
manufacturing / commercial / government etc.) at the attraction zone end. The approach is similar to trip
distribution except that absolute numbers of workers / jobs are used rather than trip ends. For the purpose of
this study consultant will distribute these trips using separate gravity models, A similar approach will be
investigated to allocate HBE trips (upto primary, primary to secondary, and beyond secondary) to their
appropriate institutions.
Traditional gravity models will be developed to distribute HBO, HBS and NHB trips.
2-30
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME III: Consultancy Services for
However, for the purpose of this study consultant will consider that all passengers will have the choice
between train and bus modes (whether or not they have access to a private vehicle).
The following PRIMARY/ACCESS mode combinations are not uncommon in the Hyderabad situation (Figure
2-9).
2-31
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME III: Consultancy Services for
As discussed earlier, consultant will develop peak-period matrices in addition to daily matrices separately for
the Morning, Evening periods, for each of the trip purposes to be modelled.
For assignment purposes, these peak-period matrices will be factored to single, representative peak hours by
application of suitable factors derived from analyses of survey data.
As the economic viability of transportation projects is largely determined by their daily (and annual) travel
demand and resulting revenue streams, intend to develop daily trip matrices to supplement these peak
matrices. The Daily (DY) trip matrices will be produced by summation of the relevant AM, and PM.
2-32
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME III: Consultancy Services for
etc.).
Goods
Matrix EXT'NAL
Vehicle
Manipulation MODEL
Trip generation/attraction rates will be developed using Matrices
The many matrices produced in the modeling process will require manipulation in order to prepare them for
assignment to their respective networks.
• Firstly, production/attraction (P/A) matrices will need to be reformatted into origin/destination (O/D)
matrices;
• Secondly, the matrices to be assigned to the highway network (i.e. private vehicle, autorickshaw, taxi) will
need to be converted from person trips to vehicle/PCU (passenger car units) trip matrices. This will
require application of vehicle occupancy factors to convert from person trip to vehicle trips, and then PCU-
factors will be applied to convert from vehicle trips to PCU trips; and
• Finally, all matrices will be manipulated to produce hourly trip matrices for each of the time periods to be
assigned. This is particularly critical in the case of the highway-based assignments as the highway
capacities to be modelled, and the volume-delay functions used, are intuitively hourly based.
It is anticipated that the rail, bus, IPT, NMT, private vehicle and goods vehicle matrices will be assigned
simultaneously as part of a equilibrium Multi-User Class (MUC) assignment. In a MUC assignment:
1. Rail passenger trips will first be assigned to the rail network;
2. Bus passenger trips will then be assigned to the bus network;
3. Access modes to rail and bus (i.e. NMT and IPT) will initially be assigned as person-trips so as to
facilitate the transfer of person-trips between NMT/IPT and transit modes. Assigned person-trips on
access links used by IPT will be post-processed to factor them to PCU-trip volumes which will be
preloaded to the highway network;
4. The remaining IPT trips will be assigned to the highway network as PCU-trips, together with the private
vehicle .
5 Goods vehicle PCU-trip matrices will be assigned on to the network with due regard to the restrictions/
regulations of movement on the network. Bus PCU-trips will also be pre-loaded to the highway network
in order to represent their contribution to traffic congestion and, consequently, congested highway
speeds; and
2-33
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME III: Consultancy Services for
Private vehicle trips and IPT trips will then be assigned on to the pre-loaded network with congestion factored
into travel times of the links.
This highway assignment is now the fully loaded highway assignment. The resulting speeds on the highway
network will be fed back into the bus network to ensure that congested highway times are incorporated into
the bus transit assignment.
It may be that another series of assignments will need to be made at this stage in order to ensure that the
assigned highway and bus speeds are in equilibrium.
Once equilibrium has been achieved at this level, it will be necessary to feed these congested speeds back
into the detailed model at the TEM stage so that the trip generation/attraction, trip distribution and mode
choice phases also incorporate congested speeds within their own processes. This wider level equilibrium
feedback loop will be repeated until the system-wide travel times across all modes have converged to
equilibrium.
It is envisaged that transit assignments will be on the basis of generalised cost (i.e. to incorporate the effects
of fares, waiting times, transfer times, access times etc. in the route-choice decision-making mechanism).
NMT will also be assigned using generalised cost parameters. For private vehicle and goods vehicle
assignment consultant will investigate whether time or generalised costs-based assignments produce the
more reliable results.
In order to ensure the robustness of the model (and its various components and sub-models) consultant will
undertake a thorough validation exercise. The model will be run in forecasting mode to synthesise base year
trip-making and travel patterns. The synthesised base year trip matrices will be assigned to their respective
networks and validation will be based on:
• Statistical comparison of observed and synthesised inter-sectoral movements (based on a system of
Coarse traffic sectors) by mode and purpose;
• Comparison of observed and synthesized trip length distributions – by mode and purpose;
• Comparison of observed and synthesized traffic and passenger volumes across screen lines and cordons
(at both regional and sub-regional levels) by mode and purpose;
• Comparison of observed and synthesized traffic and passenger volumes at selected validation count
locations with the sub-regions; and
• Comparison of observed and synthesized journey times on selected highway and transit routes/corridors.
The validation process will ensure that the traffic model is able to satisfactorily synthesise base year trip-
making and travel patterns - at both the regional and sub-regional levels. The ability of the model to
satisfactorily ‘back forecast’ will give confidence in its ability to forecast trip-making and travel patterns into the
future.
Appropriate ‘goodness of fit’ and confidence intervals will be provided as an essential part of the validation
exercise.
Evaluation of development strategies in general and specific projects in particular is the key important thing for
arriving at an optimum medium and long term transport development strategy.
Under this task, consultant will develop a framework/procedure for economic evaluation wherein travel
demand model outputs such as traffic volumes and speed by mode, travel time on individual links, travel time
2-34
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME III: Consultancy Services for
For monetisation of the model outputs, unit Value of travel time (VOT) and Vehicle Operating Cost (VOC) will
be estimated. The assessment of unit VOT will be undertaken with the primary data collected through home
interview surveys as well as the O-D surveys. The VOT thus assessed will be reflective of the mode of travel
as well as the economic profile of the zone from where the trip is getting originated.
As for the NMV’s though not much effort has been made at the national level, consultant shall, however, make
an attempt at arriving at a VOC for the same, as well. Benefits will be quantified in terms of savings in Vehicle
Operating Cost (VOC) and savings in time (VOT) because of reduced traffic delays and improvements in
public transit service. Consultant will also make an effort to quantify benefits like improvement in
environmental quality, and traffic safety in the context of the study area, based on the experiences consultant
have elsewhere.
Economic evaluation will be presented in terms of Net Present Value (NPV), Economic Internal Rate of Return
(EIRR) and Benefit–Cost Ratio for the project, over a time period of twenty years.
The model will also have the capacity of undertaking a sensitively analysis to cover the traffic risk, capacity
risk (which anyway will have an impact on the traffic as well as speeds), cost overrun risks and benefit
reduction due to any other reason.
Assessment of Project Benefit Distribution: The above developed model will be used to identify the actual
beneficiaries of the project by mode and by income category. Thus the total benefit from the project will be
distributed.
A Technical Note on “Vehicle Operating Cost and Value of Time” will be submitted HMDA/Technical
Advisory Committee (TAC) for review and observations.
Consultant will submit a report on “Development, Validation and Calibration of UTP Model, Scenarios and
Travel Demand Forecast” at the end of 16 months from the inception of the study. The report will cover the
complete gamut of model development including sub-models and its validation to reflect the ground situation
in the base year.
2
There are no equations, so far, which have been derived for estimation of the VOC in an urban situation.
RUCS, however, is more appropriate for rural/regional roads. In the absence of any other estimates which can
reflect the urban traffic situation, the VOC equations which have been given in RUCS will be used after
incorporating changes for making these equations more suitable for urban conditions, eg. removing the upper
limit of congestion, etc.
2-35
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME III: Consultancy Services for
“A Metropolitan Area can grow in number of ways! Any one of a number of ultimate regional development
forms can be set with an objective. Each direction of development open to the region represents a particular
response to the manner in which growth has occurred to date; each represents a particular interpretation of
goals to be established. The first task in planning for a metropolitan area therefore is to choose the
development form which offers the greatest promise or attaining the goals elected.”
Scenarios are evolved with a vision. The ultimate objective of the scenario development would be to offer high
quality of life, access to economic opportunities to all the resident and community groups in HMA area. The
three important components that constitute any urban system are residences, activity centers and
transportation networks. Spatial and geographical distribution of activity centers and residential places defines
urban form. The pattern of transport network defines the urban structure. In urban areas work and education
trips constitute 75% of trips. Improper distribution of activity centers and population with eccentric
development in urban area leads to increase in trip length (Time and distance) and pass-km. Hence one of
the objectives of good transportation planning exercises is to reduce transportation activity in terms of Pass-
Km and mean trip lengths. Transportation activity (Pass-Km and Mean Trip Lengths) can be minimized
through optimal distribution of activity and residential locations. Often development in metropolitan areas is
transport driven and sprawl has been taking place along the corridors.
HMA area does not have a land use plan for entire area up to a horizon, Consultant are talking in the study.
Therefore it would be important to develop alternative land use scenario for HMA up to year 2041 in line with
Master Plan -2020. Our approach to develop land use scenario will be based on:
• FSI – prevailing policies of FSI in different areas of HMA.
• Slum Areas – There are about 2 million slum population spread in around 1,600 small to medium sized
pockets.
• Restricted Cantonment Area
• Changing household size and current housing topology
• Changing Work Force Participation Rate (WFPR)
• Increase in women work participation ratio
• Declining formal to informal employment ratio
• Declining share of primary and secondary sector employment.
• Migration to HMA area.
• Housing stock
• Development trend
• Land suitability etc.
Consultants believe all the above affect choices of residential and activity locations and hence should be
considered in scenario building effort. A generic land use scenarios for HMA could be:
Potential of developing Strategic Urban Expansion Potential of carrying out Potential of carrying out
ring towns along with respect to Transit body expansion of the city body expansion along the
important radial corridors Oriented Development in in a ring fashion or through select growth directions in
in the extended area of HMA an urban band to guide its extended HMDA area.
HUDA to guide its future future urban form in the
urban growth extended area of HUDA.
2-36
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME III: Consultancy Services for
• Growth Direction,
• Accessibility to Major Transport
network,
Land Use Strategies
• Land suitability for various type
of land use,
Land Use Strategy 1
T
R
A
N
Land Use Strategy 2 Evaluation Final Land
S
Use Strategy
P
O
R
T
Land Use Strategy 3
• Holding capacity of the area for
residential purpose,
• Development Control Regulations,
and
• Overall trend in change in socio-
economic factors.
The procedure followed in one of our earlier studies is showing in Figure 2-14.
2005
2005 Pop. 20.8 Mil Population
MCGM 12.9 Mil
2005 Emp. 7.8 Mil RoR 7.9 Mil
2-37
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME III: Consultancy Services for
2005 P2 P3
3.4
Population Distribution
Employment Distribution
Figure 2-14: Typical procedure followed towards selection of preferred landuse strategy
Base year planning parameters have been identified and compiled by TAZ in Task 4.2. Under this task,
consultant will further identify those parameters which have been used on model building (Trip Generation/
Trip Attraction or Trip End Model) and forecast them for future years. Forecasting of such parameters will be
done based on a combination of approaches such as:
• Trend based
• Policy based
• Vision based
At this stage consultant will make use of all available long term development plans from concerned authorities
in the region.
TASK 4.8 IDENTIFY AND DEVELOP BROAD TRANSPORT SYSTEM NETWORK FOR FUTURE YEAR
Consultant will take transport network on which UTP models were validated and calibrated for the base year
as a base to start developing the transport network for future years. Consultant will further proceed on
identifying committed transport investments by different time horizon under the prevailing population, and land
use growth scenario.
Adding them to the existing network will become the desired transport network in business as usual scenario.
Process of additional network identification and preparation of an integrated transport network development is
shown in Figure 2-15.
2-38
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME III: Consultancy Services for
MMR Suburban Rail and Metro Network 2031 MMR Higher Order Highway Network 2031
Figure 2-15: Identification of additional transport network
TASK 4.9 PREDICT FUTURE PLANNING PERIODS TRAVEL DEMAND AND SUBMIT REPORT
Based on forecasted planning parameters, future transport network in business as usual scenario, under this
Task, consultant will run the calibrated UTP model in future mode and forecast travel demand by mode and
purpose for the years 2016, 2021, 2026, 2031, 2036, and 2041. This task will be accomplished by using the
calibrated UTP models and inputs finalised in previous sub tasks. Travel demand on each link/ corridor will
provide indications on the likely traffic problems in the future years and hence basis to develop long term
transportation strategies.
A report will be submitted covering travel demand forecast by mode on the existing transport network and on
committed transport network including metro for the year 2016, 2021, 2026, 2031, 2036, and 2041.
Having reviewed various planning documents pertaining to HMA including Regional Plan -2020 under Task
1.3, at this stage consultant will conclude the reviewing process and quantify proposals at HMA level and
traffic zone levels. In this regard, consultant will first adopt the land use proposals made in the regional plan
(2010) till the year 2020 and extend the various scenario as per the discussions held in Task 4.6.
This task aims at review of the existing systems and frameworks that would necessarily include a capability
assessment survey of the implementing agencies for short, intermediate and long term urban transport
development. There should be a proper appreciation of legal mandate as existing and as may be anticipated
as a result of national and regional policy shifts. A review of the legal framework regarding involvement of
private sector in the development of urban transport sector, especially the urban transport infrastructure will
2-39
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME III: Consultancy Services for
The understanding of the regulatory framework of the above agencies is important in reviewing the
institutional framework. Therefore review of the present regulations those define the responsibilities, functional
administrative structure; the employment and training of staff and all initiatives on capacity building, etc., will
be undertaken.
At the end, consultant would be able to suggest/advise on the needs and possible scope of:
• Suggestion on Institutional and Policy reform
• Suitable professional development and Training Program in transport planning, management and
implementation.
Consultants are also aware that Unified Metropolitan Transport Authority has already been set-up in
Hyderabad for effective delivery of transport system in the city. Consultant will co-ordinate with UMTA further
to analyze any necessary improvement in the present setting.
Goals - After the exhaustive analysis of the data collected and forecasting of the future level of travel demand,
consultants will formulate the goal(s) and objectives of Transportation strategies. Consultant will envisage the
goal to be established for two distinct time horizons.
Medium Term Goal – which would determine the steps that need to be taken up for rolling program of
investment and management proposals sufficient and appropriate for the period till the year 2021.
Long Term Goal - This would aim at developing the strategies towards formulation of a transportation plan
which on implementation would be able to cater to the travel demand till horizon year (i.e. 2031 and 2041) in a
most efficient and economic manner.
Objectives- Under this activity, the objectives of the development of long-term integrated transport strategies
will be defined.
• To improve interaction and physical connectivity
• To enable communities and industries to meet their transport needs,
• To enhance the HMA’s economic development and environmental wellbeing
2-40
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME III: Consultancy Services for
Transport Strategy will be a combination of policies and physical improvement. A good balance between two
will lead to faster implementation and acceptance by the people.
In case of HMA, scope to manage transport demand by control of land-use development is limited but the
implication of transport developments on land use developments are great. Hence, transport strategies should
consider this fact.
Consultant will develop transport infrastructure driven strategy to promote development in less developed
area at the same time retaining developed area to its current level of service. This will be an iterative process
where major transport development will guide the land use to some extent. If some change in land use
strategy can ease major transport problem, consultant will advise HMDA to consider.
Further, while developing alternative transport strategies following aspects will be considered:
• Economic growth,
• Current initiatives in HMA,
• The need to conserve and enhance the urban environment,
• Land use plans and likely land use development patterns etc.
Consultant believe, consultant have given regard to these factors while understanding the study area (HMA)
and have narrated in the very first chapter of this section II.
A Technical Note on “Development Scenarios and Network Options for different Horizons” will be
submitted to HMDA/Technical Advisory Committee (TAC) for review and observations.
2-41
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME III: Consultancy Services for
In principle consultant agree with HMDA to evaluate the alternative transportation strategies and will do four-
step evaluation of alternative transportation strategies at strategic planning level as follows:
• Step 1-Economical Viability: a life cycle cost benefit analysis will be done based on the established
framework for the same in Task 4.4.
• Step 2-Social Viability: Special attention will be given to the socio-economic-political factors, services to
the poor and vulnerable group.
• Step 3-Environmental Sustainability: preliminary environmental impact assessment will be done for
alternative strategies.
• Step 4-Financial Viability: Availability of funds/budgets/other resources for implementing the projects
and getting the returns on the investments.
Under this sub task, preliminary cost estimates will be done for individual transportation development works
and for alternative transportation strategies along with cost on transport in do minimum/ business as usual
scenario. Initial cost estimates will include capital cost, operation cost, maintenance cost, environmental
mitigation, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Cost.
Benefit stream will include the following aspects for each transportation strategies:
• Savings in Vehicle Operating Cost
• Savings in Value of Travel Time
• Benefits due to reduced emission level, improved energy efficiency and improved air quality
• Improved life standard for economically weaker section, vulnerable group etc.
All the above will be estimated in relation with transport development in do minimum/ business as usual
scenario.
Environmental Impact - Consultant will quantify environmental impacts of alternate strategies to extent
possible on following parameters:
• Emissions,
• Energy Efficiency, and
• Ambient Air Quality
Outputs of UTP travel demand models i.e. travel demand by mode will be used for this purpose.
R&R Cost - For each transportation development strategy, effort will be made to estimate social impact and
have a broad R&R cost based on prevailing regulation in this regard with HMDA.
Budget/Resource/Revenue - This sub task will have inputs from sub tasks 5.4.1 and 5.4.2 Further consultant
will compile budgets available in future years along with revenues from individual projects.
Four-step evaluation of alternative transportation strategies will be done as presented in the following figure
and be ranked accordingly to select the preferred one.
At this stage consultant will revisit Land use strategy once again if required based on the outputs of travel
demand forecast and then again refine travel demand and long-term transportation strategy.
2-42
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME III: Consultancy Services for
Parameters Outputs
Alternative Environmental
EIRR R&R Cost FIRR
Strategies Benefits
Alternative 1 XX XX XX XX
Alternative 2 XX XX XX XX
Alternative 3 XX XX XX XX
XXXXX XX XX XX XX
Based on the comprehensive evaluation parameters and other qualitative consideration, consultant will
recommend preferred Long-Term Transportation Strategy for HMA.
2-43
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME III: Consultancy Services for
A review of the role and responsibilities of various agencies involved in execution and implementation of
transport development projects in HMA will be undertaken. Since transport development projects are cost
intensive, supply in transport has never matched the growing transport demand in HMA. Gap in demand and
supply has grown manifold over the last two/three decades.
Road/Transit development works are implemented by various agencies as per their mandate in their
jurisdiction as per their financial capabilities. Focus of this task, however, would be to develop a
comprehensive picture of the capital required for transport infrastructure development in future and also
identify overall funds/budgets available with these implementing agencies in the same time period (future
years) based on the assessment of level of funding available with all these annually during last five
years. It is most likely that available level of funding/budget would be far less than the requirement.
As we know, comprehensive transportation strategy would involve development on all the sectors viz. Road,
Transit and Air (dispersal). In the first step, consultant will segregate the transportation proposals in these
three sectors to relate the lead implementing agencies in respective transportation sectors.
Based on a number of assumptions and scenario, consultant will estimate resources likely to be available for
the investment in transport sector for future years in HMA. This will be done in a very close collaboration with
HMDA.
In order to assess the other possible resources to fund development of some of the projects, consultant will
identify likelihood of private sector financing, Public Private Partnership (PPP), by undertaking financial
feasibility of some individual projects which are to be implemented through toll or user fees imposition.
Experience has shown that toll or user fee alone is not sufficient to make a project viable. Therefore, the
option of development of nodes, like commercialisation of stations and interchanges, will also be explored for
generation of additional revenue and for making the projects more lucrative for private sector financing. The
exercise will take due consideration of the ground reality, ie, only those nodes will be incorporated in the
analysis, which have the possibility of getting developed from the perspective of the availability of land as well
as the demand for it. Besides this, other avenues of making the project commercially attractive willbe studied,
to ensure that the proposals required for development of the HMA get realised in the shortest time with
minimum burden on the Authority exchequer.
This Task will conclude the previous Task after having discussion with client agency. Any observations and
feedback given at this stage will be incorporated before formal submission of report on the same.
TASK 5.7 REPORT ON LONG-TERM TRANSPORT STRATEGIES FOR THE TRANSPORT SECTOR
The strategy document will cover but not limited to the following aspects.
• Current Situation: Major findings and issues of our huge data collection and analysis exercise will be
given in objective terms. Transport situation (indices) in Hyderabad in comparison with other comparable
cities of India and other developing countries.
• Traffic Growth: Trend so far in Hyderabad, potential vehicular growth rates (regional traffic/vehicular
ownership in HMA, increase in PCTR etc), potential problems etc.
• Long Term Trend and Prospects: Relationship between transport and economic growth & Land use
development.
2-44
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME III: Consultancy Services for
HMDA, with its pro-active attitude of meeting up with the future transport demand in the region, is in the
process of identifying various projects. These projects will be taken into consideration, identifying the projects
for implementing the selected transport strategy. This exercise will result in identification of various transport
projects, to meet the future travel demand. The projects, as they are likely to emerge will be linked to the need
based time frame. For each of the identified project, a base case, along with the variations in options, in terms
of alignment, capacity design, technology of construction and the year of operation will be worked out. The
inputs for undertaking the feasibility study will be established for each of the identified project by options:
• Costs – the cost and nature of the project will reflect on whether the project can be implemented under
private sector participation. This will further be expanded to include operation and maintenance cost if it is
likely to take PPP route.
• Traffic – each of the identified project and its options will be studied in the context of the total transport
network, to arrive at the final traffic demand levels, for the project as well as to assess its impact on the
transport network by doing repeated traffic assignment exercises.
• Revenue – In case a project is to be implemented under private sector participator, then the pricing of the
facility will be undertaken on the basis of the stated willingness to pay against time saving.
The evaluation of each of the options will be undertaken under two parts:
• The first will comprise of more qualitative, and if required quantitative assessment as well, which will test
the following:
o operational feasibility: whether the operational aspects will be viable in the given scenario.
2-45
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME III: Consultancy Services for
The first part of the evaluation will highlight the strengths and weaknesses of certain options, and may also
result in omitting- some from the second part of the analysis. This case will arise for those options, where the
negative impacts cannot be mitigated.
• The second part of the evaluation will necessitate an economic analysis of all projects, by options, and
financial analysis in those cases, when it is relevant. Based on the economic viability results, the best
option will be selected for each identified project.
The finally recommended options will be integrated and the UTP model run again to see that each selected
project compliments the other on a network based assignment.
TASK 6.3 PRIORITISE THE INVESTMENT PROJECTS AND FORMULATE AN INVESTMENT PROGRAM
Bank-wide, the following lessons from previous urban transport assistance have been identified: (a) institutional reform is
critical to obtain sustainable improvement, and demonstrated commitment to these reforms must be obtained prior to
project implementation; (b) there must be a commitment to an overall transport strategy; (c) counterpart funding must be
assured; (d) financial mechanisms must be identified to support Govt. expenditures and/or subsidies; (e) capacity building
is important through a combination of training and technical assistance; (f) an integrated approach to transport planning is
required.
Source: Liaoning Urban Transport, World Bank Group
Table 2-1: : Project Phasing based on need assessment and economic benefits
(no. of projects)
Components Projects 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026
P1 2 - 1 1 - 4 - - 10 - -
Transit System - - - - - - - - - - - -
Pn - 1 - - 2 - - 1 - - -
P1 - - - - - - - - - - -
Highway/ Road Network - - - - - - - - - - - -
Pn 1 - - 2 - - 4 - - 3 -
P1 - 2 - 3 - - 12 - - 7 -
Bus System - - - - - - - - - - - -
Pn - - 4 - - 10 - - 5 - 2
P1 10 - - 4 - - 8 - 5 6 -
Traffic Management - - - - - - - - - - - -
Pn - - 7 - - 3 - 6 - - 1
2-46
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME III: Consultancy Services for
2-47
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME III: Consultancy Services for
The institutional capacity and counter funding availability of the implementing agency, will be identified as given
in the chart.
Components Projects 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026
Transit Systems P1
-
Pn
Highway/ Road P1
Network -
Pn
Bus System P1
-
Pn
Traffic P1
Management -
Pn
…
If the projects, require higher level of manpower, expertise, other resources, including the counter part funding
availability, than what is available with the concerned implementing agency, considering other commitments,
then some of the projects, based on the priority study undertaken earlier, will be shifted into the future years.
2-48
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME III: Consultancy Services for
The availability of funds with HMDA will be understood. The finally arrived at investment phasing program will
be matched with the former to identify the gaps in fund availability, if any. The annual gaps in fund availability
will be identified, and then resource mobilization strategy will be worked out to bridge the gap. This would
include, besides the resource mobilization through borrowings from domestic and multilateral funding
agencies, certain innovative techniques of generating revenue for the implementing agencies. This will be
arrived at after a study of the existing taxation structure, and a suggestion on the restructuring of those, in
case it helps in increasing the total receipts of the government. If possible additional levies on the
beneficiaries will be suggested. The finally arrived at resource mobilization strategy, will be supported by
international experiences.
Here at the end of this task consultant will submit two technical notes “1. Financial Assessments and Funding
Analysis, 2. Economic and Operation Assessment of network improvements” these will be submitted to
HMDA/Technical Advisory Committee (TAC) for review and observations.
Following Task 6.1 through 6.3, at this stage a report on alternative analysis and recommended “Short and
Medium Term Investment Strategy” will be submitted to client at the end of 18 months from inception of this
project.
Preliminary identification of MRTS Phase-II corridors had been done through Task 3.15. Under this task,
having UTP Model up-running for future years, having transport and land use strategy agreed, and evaluation
framework ready, consultant will once again validate the recommended MRTS Phase-II corridors by adding or
modifying transit stations. While doing this, if need be, consultant will propose some changes and/or different
alignments. The final recommendations on Phase-II corridors will include estimated ridership on each section
as well.
TASK 6.6 PREPARATION AND SUBMISSION OF THE DRAFT FINAL REPORT AND EXECUTIVE
SUMMARY
nd
At the end of 22 month, consultant will submit the “Draft Final Report”, which will cover but not limited to the
following:
• Data analysis, salient findings of all the surveys conducted in this study,
• UTP Model development and validation,
• Development scenario,
• Long-Term Transportation strategies, evaluation and final transport strategy recommended for HMA,
• Network option, and pre-feasibilities of various transport projects in the selected transport strategy,
• Short and medium term investment program, and
• Travel Demand forecast, graphical presentation etc.
• Resource mobilization and funding program
• Institutional arrangements and implementation framework
The main report will be comprehensive enough to cover all dimensions of the study. Along with this consultant
will also submit “Executive Summary” for wider circulation and quick review of the outcome of the study.
Consultant will give a comprehensive presentation at this stage to TAC plus other stakeholders (as felt
appropriate by HMDA) to obtain their necessary feedback on the outcome. Following this, consultant will meet
“steering committee” as well to obtain their valuable feedback and suggestion on the study.
2-49
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME III: Consultancy Services for
Under this task, consultant will incorporate observations (if any) given by the client and Traffic Advisory
Committee (TAC) on the Draft Final Report. Consultant will also present the study report to the Steering
Committee and conclude the study within given time period (24 months from the inception of the study).
Consultants understand this study will be very useful for decision makers in other agencies too in HMA, hence
consultant will prepare a handy “Executive Summary” of the Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS) for
HMA and submit along with the “Final Report”.
Task 5.2 will result in assessing number of officers with transport planning background in HMDA, GHMC,
HMRL, APSRTC, Traffic Police and other planning authorities. Based on further discussion with HMDA, a
core team will be identified for training in transport planning and on rigorous usage of UTP Model. It is
expected that in the first round of screening, around 15-20 officers will be identified for this purpose.
At this stage, consultant will interact with short-listed officers and assist HMDA in finalising the list of core
team. During the interaction following aspects will be assessed:
• Academic background
• Attitude and aptitude
• Inclination towards learning
• Current responsibilities
• Experience in transport planning
• Level of computer awareness
• Age profile
• Trainee’s expectation on training
Having done this, consultant will detail out actual need on training in transport planning and on the usage of
UTP Model.
At this stage, based on comprehensive need assessment, a training needs assessment report will be
prepared and submitted at the end of six months. Part of the training need and capacity building could be
covered through this project.
Consultant expect from HMDA to provide us a list of the nominated officers for overseas training on Transport
Planning, Management and Implementation as being practiced in a city of a developed country well in
advance. This will help in finalizing the detailed training schedule and also help identifying and fixing other
experts in Toronto (LEA office).
Approach of the overall training will be discussed at this stage and updated (if felt necessary).
2-50
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME III: Consultancy Services for
As per agreed time slot and expectation of the officers on training, Consultant will develop a preliminary
training program and submit to the HMDA for necessary approval.
Consultant will conduct this pre-training orientation program in Hyderabad giving an overview on:
• Training objectives;
• Review the need and resource assessment;
• Description of the training plan and program;
• Formal lecture on overall Transport Planning Process with special focus on pre-study and post-study
activities; and
• Explanation on methods of training
Training tour will include visits to Toronto (Canada) and San Francisco (USA). Major features to be studied in
both the counties are listed below:
Place (Country) Period Aspects Medium
Toronto/Montreal Two weeks (for 10 Transport Planning Lectures/presentation
(Canada) core technical Multimodal Public Transport Round Table Discussions
staff) Project Evaluation Field Visits
Transport Financing Workshop
Implementation Exposure on Software usage
Travel Demand Modeling
San Francisco (USA), One week (6 Transport Planning, management and Interaction with various agencies
Toronto (Canada) persons) implementation
Overseas technical visit will have six nominated officers for about a week to the cities of developed
countries of comparable size. This training tour would focus on interaction with organization responsible for
transport planning and management, implementation of transportation projects.
Within 15 days from arrival back to India, consultant will submit a training report on overall overseas training
undertaken by the Consultants.
As described in Section III of the proposal, (Skill and Knowledge Transfer), besides OJT, a series of
lectures/presentation/seminars, workshops, round table discussions will be arranged for effective transfer of
knowledge. Team Leader-cum-Transportation Planner will be the lead in coordinating this training
programme throughout the study period. The following aspects will be covered in the overall training
programme to the core team (comprising of 10-15 officers) selected for the training in Hyderabad:
Aspects Medium Time Period
Transport Planning Lectures/seminar 4th – 6th month
Travel Demand Modeling/usage of UTP Model OJT/Lectures/Workshops 9th – 13th month
Data Management OJT/Lecture 6th – 9th month
Project Evaluation/Prioritization Lecture/RTD 10th – 13th month
Project Financing Lecture/RTD 11th – 12th month
Investment Programming Lecture/RTD 13th – 15th month
Transport Management and Implementation Lecture/RTD 13th – 15th month
Social and Environmental Dimension in Transportation Lecture/RTD 12th – 13th month
RTD: Round Table Discussion, OJT: On-the-Job Training
2-51
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME III: Consultancy Services for
Sub-Task 7.4.1 Conduct Workshop for Senior Officers on the usage of Model
In addition, a two days workshop on the usage and its application will be conducted for senior officers where
the software is installed. It is anticipated that there will be approximately 15 officers for such workshop.
Sub-Task 7.4.2 On-the-Job Training (OJT) to the Designated Officers during Model Development and
Calibration
This sub-task is meant for the counterpart staff as nominated by HMDA to work along with Consultants team
during various stages of the project for on-the-job-training.
Sub-Task 7.4.3 Conduct Seminars on the process and Important stages of the CTS
Consultant will conduct two awareness programme for the concerned staff of HMDA / GHMC / Traffic Police/
APSRTC/ HMRL and other organisations dealing in HMA’s traffic and transport management at important
stages of the assignment. Further schedule is as follows:
• Upon submission of Immediate Action Plan.
• Upon development of UTP model, Scenario and Travel demand forecast for future years.
At the end, consultant will submit a comprehensive report on “Capacity building” to HMDA at the end of 20 month.
At all the three stages, stakeholder identification will be undertaken to determine who will be directly or
indirectly affected, positively or negatively, by the transport strategy or investment or final plan, and who can
contribute to or hinder its success (commonly called other relevant stakeholders). It is important to be
comprehensive in identifying and prioritizing all project stakeholders, including the disadvantaged and
vulnerable population. Those identified will then need to be consulted at strategic points during the study.
A plan will be prepared for public consultation as a tool to guide the HMDA in involving project-affected groups
and other stakeholders in the development of scenarios and strategies.
Prior to finalization of transport strategy, public awareness about the study will be carried out to assess the
views of the persons/ groups by stimulating self-evaluation and analysis of local needs and priorities. It will
ensure involvement by providing a platform in decision-making process through mutual consent.
In view of the widespread effect of transport investments, identification of stakeholders representing the true
social matrix becomes one of the most significant tasks of the project.
2-52
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME III: Consultancy Services for
Local population or community will be the prime stakeholder depending on extent to which their livelihoods
and quality of life gets affected by the level of transportation infrastructure. Most of these primary
stakeholders will be those who are captive users i.e., directly dependent on the public transport.
Various departments of the Government related to transportation and urban planning HMA are the secondary
stakeholders that are directly involved in the designing, formulating and implementation of the projects at
various stages.
Various line departments that will be having a supportive role in assisting at the designing and implementation
stage of the project form the tertiary level of stakeholders.
At the first stage, the plan will help in considering the issues that will need to be addressed. The main aim will
be to ascertain stakeholder’s perception of the transportation problem in Hyderabad. It will be an important
tool to:
• gain the trust of people who will potentially be affected by the project;
• acknowledge that local people have knowledge and expertise to contribute to the project; and
• demonstrate the intention to consider concerns of people throughout the study.
Consultant will conduct these consultations separately for the three level of stakeholders by way of organising,
on HMDA behalf, Focus Group Discussions which will have a pre-defined agenda. Minutes of Meeting will be
recorded and, after due approval of HMDA, will be release in the form of Press Release for wider reach.
Public consultation during the stage of ‘medium term investment plan’ preparation will assist in assessing
the project’s beneficial impacts and the acceptability of the components. Public consultation will allow finding
out valuable information known by local people, which can aid in projectising and prioritising the study.
Furthermore, by consulting stakeholders, HMDA ensures that the investments will be locally acceptable and
culturally appropriate, thus reducing downstream efforts to rectify dissatisfied stakeholders, after the
measures have been implemented.
Consultant will conduct these consultations by way of various presentations on the investments. Cost and
benefits will be visualised in these presentations so their impact is widely communicated to all concerned.
Consultant will help HMDA in preparing these presentations and holding them in form of seminars or
workshops.
Having two consultations done and incorporating views of primary, secondary and tertiary stakeholders as
appropriate in planning process, consultant at this stage will present outcome of the assignment which has
been submitted in form of draft Final Report. Consultation at this stage would help in obtaining their views as
how ideas and concerns can be translated in to a plan.
As appropriate, their feedback along with feedbacks from TAC, steering committee etc. will be incorporated in
Final Report in consultation with HMDA.
2-53
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME III: Consultancy Services for
This chapter on the design of Modeling framework is divided into six sections. Section 8.2 provides a brief
overview discussion of the standard four-stage modeling process which defines the conceptual starting point
for model to be designed considering TOR requirements. Section 8.3 comprehensively reviews major
application software and provides a parameters for software selection to implement the modeling framework.
Section 8.4 then presents most of the major definitions and assumptions embedded within Model including
recommended software for this study. Section 8.5 provides an overview of the model characteristics
methods employed in Model development.
3.2 OVERVIEW
The starting point for the development of Model will be the adoption of the standard four – stage approach to
model urban travel demand, which has been developed over the last forty five-plus years (its origins trace
back to the pioneering urban transportation planning studies in the 1950s and 1960s in Detroit, Chicago and
elsewhere) and which to this day remains the dominant operational approach to this very complex and
challenging problem. The four-stage process has been severely criticized for almost as long as it has been in
existence. Many travel demand modellers believe that consultants are on the verge of a “paradigm shift’ which
will see radically new modeling methods being implemented within the next decade or so. Despite both the
criticism of the four-stage approach and the considerable optimism concerning alternate methods, the four-
stage process is currently the most practical operational approach to model urban travel demand. The
challenge therefore is to develop as sound a modeling procedure as is possible within this basic four-stage
paradigm.
The four-stage approach derives its name from the fact that it breaks the demand forecasting problem down
into four sequential stages or sub-models, each one of which deals with one key dimension of travel demand.
These four stages are:
• Trip Generation. This stage predicts the total number of trips which originate in or are destined for each
zone in the urban area (by trip purpose and time of day).
• Trip Distribution. This stage “links” the “trip ends” computed in the trip generation phase into flows of trips
from origin zones to destination zones.
• Modal Split. This stage takes the origin-destination (O-D) flows computer in the trip distribution phase and
“splits” them into O-D flows by mode (auto PT etc.)
• Trip Assignment. This stage takes the O-D flows for a given mode (e.g. car) and “assigns” them to specific
paths from origin to destination, thereby generating estimates of the link flows on each link (e.g. road
segment) in the transport network.
Figure 3-1 depicts this four-stage process, both in terms of a simple flow chart which illustrates the way
outputs from the one stage become the inputs to the next stage and a schematic which illustrates the way in
which the detailed representation of urban trip-making is sequentially built up within the process.
3-1
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME III: Consultancy Services for
Trip Generation
Oi Di
Trip Distribution
I J
Trip Distribution
Tij
Transportation
Mode Split Network
Tij, car
Attributes
I Mode Split J
Trip Assignment
Tij, PT
I
Link & O-D flows,
Times, Costs etc. Assignment
Route taken from I to j
J
Figure 3-1: The Four Stage Urban Transportation Modeling Systems
The following are the main exogenic inputs to the modeling process. “activity system” or “land use” forecasts,
which in practice consist of forecasts of the spatial (zonal) distribution of population, employment etc. and
detailed computer representation of the road and transit networks (and their performance characteristics).
As land use and network design are the primary planning interventions available with city planners, the four-
stage modeling gives them a strategic tool to evaluate the overall effectiveness and efficiency of the land use
or development plans prepared by them. This will be useful in defining the long term vision for development
and defining strategic growth pattern and direction for the HMA. Further, the data and information generated
from the model will be useful to all the agencies involved in the operations, maintenance, management and
regulation of the transportation and traffic aspects in an incremental and ongoing basis. For example the
APSRTC could use the model for planning of bus routes and schedules, HMRL could use it for identification
of potential metro routes and assess ridership, GHMC and Traffic police will be able to assess traffic at mid-
block sections and intersections and suitably identify physical improvement and management or regulatory
interventions. Furthermore, all stakeholders will be able to assess the impact of any new development or
project or deviations from strategic plan on their area of operation though the application of the model.
An important point should be noted concerning the way these inputs enter the four-stage process. Although
the “activity system” forecasts of population and employment distributions are shown as inputs to the trip
generation stage, characteristics of trip-makers can and, in fact, do enter as explanatory variables within other
stage of the process, in particular, mode split, within which variable such as age, occupation, possession of a
driver’s licence, and number of household vehicles play important roles in determining trip-makers modal
choices.
As is also indicated in Figure 3-1 the major outputs of the process willbe estimates of network links flows by
mode (i.e. private and public), as well as associated link flow related variables such as:
• average link travel times and speeds;
• link volume-to-capacity ratios;
• link operating costs by mode;
• various transit ridership characteristics such as boardings and alighting by transit line; and
• other variables which can be calculated as a function of links times, speeds and / or volumes (e.g. vehicle
emissions or energy consumption using -speed-based models).
3-2
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME III: Consultancy Services for
3 Lei Yu, Peng Yue & Hualiang Teng,, A Comparative Study of EMME/2 and QRS-II for Modeling a Small Community, 82nd Annual Meeting of the Transportation Research Board, Washington, DC, U.S.A, January 2003
4 Trip Chaining involves more than two trips combined by a common middle destination, which doubles up as origin for the next trip. A trip to market while coming back from work is an example of such phenomenon.
This trend is bound to become more common in a megalopolis like Mumbai where middle and lower income people try to minimise their transport cost.
3-3
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME III: Consultancy Services for
EMME/3 provides several tools to achieve sub-area focussing by extracting sub-networks and the associated
O-D matrices. Link attributes, which have been judiciously coded to identify the desired sub-networks, can be
used to export any of the sub-networks in the form of an ASCII file which is in the proper format to be read into
another EMME/3 data bank. If the link attributes do not contain this information, the desired sub-network can
be identified by using an EMME/3 module which performs node and link scatter-grams. The desired sub-
network can be identified by changing node and/or link attributes and then exporting the so identified sub-
network as above. A feature of the equilibrium assignment of EMME/3 called traversal can be used to obtain,
for the identified sub-network, an O-D matrix which is entirely consistent with the regional O-D matrix and its
assignment on the regional network. The traversal matrix which is so obtained may also serve as input to
traffic micro-simulation models. A similar approach can be applied for focussing on a transit network.
3-4
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME III: Consultancy Services for
EMME/3 supports the development of a single “scenario” which contains both the road and transit networks
defined over a common set of links and nodes. To use our model to generate travel demand forecasts for a
given future year, the analyst will first define the “scenario” which will specify the road and PT networks to be
tested for the forecast year.
5
Task 4.3 of Activity-4
3-5
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME III: Consultancy Services for
HMA
3-6
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME III: Consultancy Services for
The study will be completed within a span of 24 months from the date of work order. The time allocation for
main mile stones identified will be as follows:
Outputs No. of Copies Completion / Submission time
Inception Report 25 at the end of 1st month -
presentation required
(including finalized approach & methodology and proposal
regarding software / development of model for Stage I and
Stage II)
STAGE I
Field Surveys Report 25 at the end of 3 months
(Traffic Surveys as required for immediate action plan)
Immediate Action Plan 25 at the end of 8 months
HMR (MRTS) Phase – II Proposals 24 at the end of 4 months
STAGE II
Field Surveys Report 25 at the end of 10 months
(HIS and other surveys)
Data compilation and Statistical Analysis 25 at the end of 12 months
Development of UTP Model, Scenarios and Travel demand 25 at the end of 16 months
forecasts
Report on Long Term Strategy for the Transport Sector 25 At the end of 17 months
4-1
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME III: Consultancy Services for
In addition to the above, the consultants will submit monthly progress reports indicating the progress of the
study in terms of schedule activity versus actual status, reasons for delay, if any and the likely action plan for
the following months.
4-2
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
Hyderabad Metropolitan Development Authority
INCEPTION REPORT
Consultancy Services for
Comprehensive Transportation Study (CTS) for
Hyderabad Metropolitan Area (HMA)
JULY 2011
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME IV: Consultancy Services for
INDEX
Sl. Page
Description of the survey Form Name
No. No.
Category 1
HIS-PART 1. Household Data Sheet 1
1 Household Interview Survey HIS-PART 2. Person & ‘Regular’ Travel Data 2
HIS-PART 3. Previous Day Trip Diary 3
2 Survey of Floating Population Floating Population Survey 4
Category 2
3 Road Network Inventory Survey Road Network Inventory 5
4 Speed and Delay Journey Time (Speed and Delay) Survey 6
Surveys to Develop Speed – Flow Classified Traffic Volume Count Survey (Speed-Flow
5 7
Function Function)
Category 3
Conduct Traffic Volume Count / O-D / Classified Traffic Volume Count Survey 8
Occupancy Surveys at Outer Cordon/ Road Side Interview (O-D) Survey: Passenger Vehicle 9
Inner Cordon/ Screen Lines / Mid-block
Road Side Interview (O-D) Survey: Bus 10
and Survey Locations Road Side Interview (O-D) Survey: Goods Vehicle 11
Turning Movement and Inventory Survey Classified Traffic Volume Count Survey at Intersection/
12
at Strategic Intersection/Junction Junction by Movement
Category 4
Traffic Surveys at Major Terminals
Regional Terminal User Survey-Passenger 13
(Road/ Rail/ Air)
Classified Traffic Volume Count Survey at Goods
14
Terminal Entry / Exit
Goods Focal Point Survey Goods Vehicle On-street Parking (Registration Number) 15
Interview of Goods Vehicles at Terminal / On-Street
16
Parking
Category 5
Work Place Survey 17
Work Place Survey
Work Place Survey- goods 18
Commercial Vehicle Survey Commercial Vehicle/ Goods Transport Operators Survey 19
Category 6
Parking Survey On-Street Parking 20
Non-Motorized Traffic Survey Pedestrian Count Survey 21
Category 7
MMTS / Sub-urban Railway Passenger MMTS Rail/ Suburban Rail Passenger: On Board Survey 22
Survey Interview of MMTS/Suburban Passenger 23
Public Transport (Bus): On-Board Survey 24
Bus Passenger/On-Board Survey
Bus Passenger Interview Survey 25
IPT Auto/ Maxi Cab/ Taxi: Operator/ Driver Survey 26
IPT (Taxi and auto-rickshaw) Survey
Interview of Auto/ Maxi Cab/ Taxi Passenger 27
Opinion Survey for (Bus, MMTS, IPT
Opinion Survey for Passenger/ Citizens 28
passengers)
Establishment Survey Establishment Survey 29
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME IV: Consultancy Services for
HOUSEHOLD LOCATION: Assembly No. Electoral Booth No. Map Reference: Sheet of
1
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME IV: Consultancy Services for
PART 2. Person & 'Regular' Travel Data Sheet of Household serial number:
Street Name
Location 1
Location 2
Landmark 1
Landmark 2
If you drove, or were driven, to work - 1 On Street 1 On Street 1 On Street 1 On Street 1 On Street 1 On Street 1 On Street
where did you park? 2 Off Street 2 Off Street 2 Off Street 2 Off Street 2 Off Street 2 Off Street 2 Off Street
If public bus (APSRTC/Setwin) was used, which routes numbers were used (in order of use )
1st Bus ( 1)
2nd Bus ( 2)
3rd Bus ( 3)
If a train (MMTS/Suburban/ Long distance) was used, what stations did you use. (1st station first, last station last, and transfer stations in between).
First Station
1 1 1 1 1 1 1
2 2 2 2 2 2 2
Last Station
4 4 4 4 4 4 4
Do you usually use a Bus / Rail pass? 1 Yes 2 No 1 Yes 2 No 1 Yes 2 No 1 Yes 2 No 1 Yes 2 No 1 Yes 2 No 1 Yes 2 No
If yes, what is the cost? (Rs / month)
How much do you normally spend on transport costs every month (all respondents please - in the case of children ask the adults)
Rupees per month
of Travel (Rs
Willing to Pay
How much are you willing to pay for Time (hh:mm) 10%
per trip)
cost)
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME IV: Consultancy Services for
Sheet
Trip Time of Reason at End Modes of Mode Time (mins) Cost of Mode Transfer / Interchange / If Mode is Car
Place at which this trip started Place at which this trip ended
No. Journey (Destination) Travel Used Transfer Travel (Rupees) Intermediate Location or Station or 2-wheeler
3
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME IV: Consultancy Services for
01 Residing in Hyderabad 02 Staying at a Hotel 01. Employed (Full Time) 06. Seeking Employment
03 Staying at friends of relatives' place in Hyderabad 02. Employed (Part Time) 07. Homemaker/Housewife
04 Not staying in Hyderabad (will leave today itself) 03. Self Employed 08. Retired
Street Name 04. Daily Wages 09. Maid / Driver / Caretaker
Landmark 1 / District 4. Trip Reason (What is the purpose of your visit here)
7. Total travel time for this trip from starting (origin) place to this place. Include time spent
in all modes used and intermediate waiting or change over time.
Hrs minutes
8. Total cost of travel for this trip if not using own mode e.g. Taxi / Bus / Train. If using own
vehicle only state payments other than vehicle operating cost e.g. Toll.
Rs.
9. Place you would be going from here? 10. Trip Reason (What would be the purpose for which you
01 Home 02 Normal Place of work would make this next trip)
04 Other 03 Normal Place of education 01. Return Home
Establishment Name 02. Regular Work 07. Eating Out
Building Name / Number 03. School 08. Social
Street Name 04. Shopping 09. Entertainment/Recreation
Locality / Area Name Personal Business 10. Employers Business
05.
City / Village / Work Related 11. Drop-off passenger
Landmark 1 / District 06. Health 12. Other Reason
Landmark 2 / State
4
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME IV: Consultancy Services for
Pavement Type
Foot Path (m) if no footpath put - or 0
Service Road Width (m)
Hard/Earthen Shoulder (m)
Drainage
Abutting Landuse (Broad)
Number of Road side property direct access
entry / exits
Number of median openings
Encroachment if any (approximate in m)
Significant On-Street Parking (Circle the 1. Paid 2. Free / Unpaid 1. Paid 2. Free / Unpaid
number that applies) 3. Not Present 3. Not Present
5
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME IV: Consultancy Services for
MP: Morning Peak, EP: Evening Peak, OP: Off Peak Date:_____________
Survey Starting Time:________________ Weather: 1. Sunny or Clear / 2. Cloudy / 3. Rain Day:______________
EP
OP
MP
EP
OP
MP
EP
OP
MP
EP
OP
Reasons for Delay: 1. Signalised/Non-Signalised intersection, 2. Level Crossing, 3. Congestion, 4. Stray Animals, 5. Others (Parking, Loading/Unloading, Pedestrian etc.), 6. Religious Structure
6
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME IV: Consultancy Services for
:00
:15
Sub Total
:15
:30
Sub Total
:30
:45
Sub Total
:45
:00
Sub Total
Total
Name of Enumerator: Supervisor:
7
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME IV: Consultancy Services for
:00
:15
:15
:30
:30
:45
:45
:00
Total
Name of Enumerator: Supervisor:
8
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME IV: Consultancy Services for
State: State:
5. Car/Jeep/Van (other than Taxi) 1. Yes 6. Health
Landmark1: Landmark1:
17. Animal Drawn 9. Others (pl. specify)
State: State:
5. Car/Jeep/Van (other than Taxi) 1. Yes 6. Health
Landmark1: Landmark1:
17. Animal Drawn 9. Others (pl. specify)
State: State:
5. Car/Jeep/Van (other than Taxi) 1. Yes 6. Health
Landmark1: Landmark1:
17. Animal Drawn 9. Others (pl. specify)
9
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME IV: Consultancy Services for
District: District:
7. APSRTC Bus
State: State:
8. Other Bus
If within HMDA: If within HMDA:
Landmark1: Landmark1:
Landmark2: Landmark2:
District: District:
7. APSRTC Bus
State: State:
8. Other Bus
If within HMDA: If within HMDA:
Landmark1: Landmark1:
Landmark2: Landmark2:
District: District:
7. APSRTC Bus
State: State:
8. Other Bus
If within HMDA: If within HMDA:
Landmark1: Landmark1:
Landmark2: Landmark2:
District: District:
7. APSRTC Bus
State: State:
8. Other Bus
If within HMDA: If within HMDA:
Landmark2: Landmark2:
Location (Village/Taluka): Location (Village/Taluka):
6. Mini Bus
District: District:
7. APSRTC Bus
State: State:
8. Other Bus
If within HMDA: If within HMDA:
Landmark1: Landmark1:
Landmark2: Landmark2:
10
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME IV: Consultancy Services for
11
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME IV: Consultancy Services for
:00
:15
:15
:30
:30
:45
:45
:00
Total
Name of Enumerator: Supervisor:
12
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME IV: Consultancy Services for
13
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME IV: Consultancy Services for
Goods Vehicles
MAV
2-Axle 3-Axle Tractor-
LCV (Truck Tractor
Truck Truck Trolly
Trolly)
:00
:15
Sub Total
:15
:30
Sub Total
:30
:45
Sub Total
:45
:00
Sub Total
Total
Name of Enumerator: Supervisor:
14
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME IV: Consultancy Services for
Supervisor:
15
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME IV: Consultancy Services for
11. Empty
11. Empty
16
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME IV: Consultancy Services for
01 Residing in Hyderabad 02 Staying at a Hotel 01. Employed (Full Time) 06. Seeking Employment
03 Staying at friends of relatives' place in Hyderabad 02. Employed (Part Time) 07. Homemaker/Housewife
04 Not staying in Hyderabad (will leave today itself) 03. Self Employed 08. Retired
City / Village
Landmark 1 / District 4. Trip Reason (What is the purpose of your visit here)
7. Total travel time for this trip from starting (origin) place to this place. Include time spent
in all modes used and intermediate waiting or change over time.
Hrs minutes
8. Total cost of travel for this trip if not using own mode e.g. Taxi / Bus / Train. If using own
vehicle only state payments other than vehicle operating cost e.g. Toll.
Rs.
9. Place you would be going from here? 10. Trip Reason (What would be the purpose for which you
01 Home 02 Normal Place of work would make this next trip)
04 Other 03 Normal Place of education 02. Regular Work 07. Eating Out
Establishment Name 03. School 08. Social
Building Name / Number 04. Shopping 09. Entertainment/Recreation
Street Name 05. Personal Business 10. Employers Business
Locality / Area Name / Work Related 11. Drop-off passenger
City / Village 06. Health 12. Other Reason
Landmark 1 / District
Landmark 2 / State
17
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME IV: Consultancy Services for
Day Month H H m m
Interview ee
Schedule No.
Status 02. Departing Vehicle Date & Time of Interview:
18
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME IV: Consultancy Services for
3. Areas of Operation:_________________________________
Vehicle Start Time of Via/Int. Stop for Commodity Pay Load (in Travel Time Travel
SI No. Trip/ Tour No. Trip Origin Trip Destination
Type Trip delivery of goods Type Tonnes) (hh:mm) Distance (km)
1
2
Landmark2: Landmark2: -
Landmark1: Landmark1: 3
Landmark1: Landmark1: 3
Transport Cost
(Rs)
Landmark1: Landmark1: 3
Transport Cost
(Rs)
19
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME IV: Consultancy Services for
20
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME IV: Consultancy Services for
:00
:15
:15
:30
:30
:45
:45
:00
Total
:00
:15
:15
:30
:30
:45
:45
:00
Total
:00
:15
:15
:30
:30
:45
:45
:00
Total
:00
:15
:15
:30
:30
:45
:45
:00
Total
21
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME IV: Consultancy Services for
No of No of Coach Status
Time of
Sl.No. Name of the Station Time of Arrival Passengers Passengers (General/
Departure
Alighted Boarded Reserved)
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
Name of Enumerator:
Supervisor:
22
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME IV: Consultancy Services for
Landmark1: Landmark1:
District: District:
Landmark2: Landmark2:
State: State:
4. Occassionally
Is Returning Home? /
16. Others 16. Others
Destination is Home?
1. Yes 2. No
1. What was your overall experience of MMTS travel?
01. Reasonably Good 02. Somewhat Congested but managed
03. Somewhat Congested and poorly managed 04. Very Congested but managed
05. Very Congested and poorly managed
2. What are the main reasons for using MMTS
01. Station near to origin 02. Station near to Destination
03. Comfort of travel 04. To avoid Pollution and traffic congetion
05. Cheap travel cost / Most Economical 06. No Other Option Available
3. What is the openion on MMTS time punchuality
1. Daily late (specify minutes) 2. Rarely late (specify minutes)
3. Always on time
4. What are the suggetion for improving MMTS service. Rate in order of preference with 1 as highest and 3 as lowest
1. Increase frequency / Reduce waiting time at station 2. Increase speed / Reduce journey time
3. Improve Station Connectivity / Feeder Bus etc. 4. Increase no of coaches / capacity of trains
5. Improve Comfort / Cleanliness / Station facilities 6. Provide facility for parking at stations
5. How much would you be willing to pay for reduction in your travel time?
Willing to Pay (Over present cost) 0% 10% 25% 50% 100% 200%
Trave Time Saving (minutes)
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
6. What is total monthly household income (Rs / month)
A. Upto 2,500 D. 8,001-12,000 G. 35,001-50,000
B. 2,501-5,000 E. 12,001-20,000 H. 50,001-100,000
C. 5,001-8,000 F. 20,001-35,000 I. Above 100,000
23
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME IV: Consultancy Services for
24
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME IV: Consultancy Services for
Landmark1: Landmark1:
State: State:
4. Occassionally
Is Returning Home? /
16. Others 16. Others
Destination is Home?
1. Yes 2. No
03. Somewhat Congested and poorly managed 04. Very Congested but managed
2. What are the main reasons for using Bus. Rate in order of preference with 1 as highest and 3 as lowest
01. Bus Stand / Stop near to origin 02. Bus Stand / Stop near to Destination
4. What are the suggetion for improving Bus service. Rate in order of preference with 1 as highest and 3 as lowest
1. Increase frequency / Reduce waiting time at Bus Stand / Stop 2. Increase speed / Reduce journey time
3. Improve Bus Stand / Stop Connectivity / Feeder Bus etc. 4. Increase no of bus stops on the route
5. Improve Comfort / Cleanliness / Bus Stand / Stop facilities 6. Provide facility for parking at Bus Stand / Stops
5. How much would you be willing to pay for reduction in your travel time?
Willing to Pay (Over present cost) 0% 10% 25% 50% 100% 200%
Trave Time Saving (minutes)
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
6. What is total monthly household income (Rs / month)
A. Upto 2,500 D. 8,001-12,000 G. 35,001-50,000
B. 2,501-5,000 E. 12,001-20,000 H. 50,001-100,000
C. 5,001-8,000 F. 20,001-35,000 I. Above 100,000
25
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME IV: Consultancy Services for
Location:____________________________ Date:_______________
Day:_______________
26
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME IV: Consultancy Services for
Location of survey :
Origin Destination
If within Hyderabad: If Outside Hyderabad If within Hyderabad: If Outside Hyderabad
Landmark1: Landmark1:
District: District:
Landmark2: Landmark2:
State: State:
4. Occassionally
Is Returning Home? /
17. No mode (reached destination)
Destination is Home?
1. Yes 2. No
1. What was your overall experience of (Auto/Maxi Cab/Taxi) travel? Rate as 1. Very Good, 2. Good, 3. Average, 4. Poor, 5. V Poor
01. Cost (cheap is good , expensive is poor) 02. Speed (fast is good, slow is poor)
04. Access / Availability (Less waiting time easy
03. Riding Comfort
availability is good, more waiting is poor)
05. Safety / Driver Behaviour (Safe driving is good, unsafe is poor)
1. Fixed rate Bargaining / Not by the meter 2. Meter reading seems always higher than normal
3. What are the suggetion for improving IPT service. Rate in order of preference with 1 as highest and 3 as lowest
1. Ensure Charging by meter and avoid meter tampering 2. Discourage rash driving
27
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME IV: Consultancy Services for
03. Somewhat Congested and poorly managed 04. Very Congested but well managed
2. What you think are the three main traveling / traffic problems experienced by you in Hyderabad? Rate in order of preference with 1 as highest and 3 as
lowest
01. Having to travel long distances 02. Having to travel long hours (travel time)
03. Expensive to travel (High fuel costs etc.) 04. Expensive to travel (Expensive Public Transport)
05. Difficult driving conditions / Haphazard traffic 06. Road Safety / (Fear of ) Accidents
07. Public transport not available where required (Coverage) 08. Public transport not available when required (Schedules)
09. Poor quality Public Transport (Traveling Comfort &
10. Lack of (or Poor) facilities at bus stops / terminals
Convenience)
11. Lack of information (Don't know how or where to travel, 12. Lack of walking space / pedestrian facilities (sidewalks
fares etc) / FOB etc)
13. Lack of space / facilities / poor quality or congested
14. Expensive parking facilites
Parking
15. Others (Specify)
3. What are the three main reasons for traffic problems in Hyderabad? Rate in order of preference with 1 as highest and 3 as lowest
01. Haphazard Development / Lack of Planned Development 02. Lack of road space / less width of roads
03. Poor Road Condition 04. Poor traffic Management / Signage
05. Lack of (good) public transport 06. Lack of traffic sense (in public)
07. Too many vehicles 08. Poor / Lack of travel information
4. What are the three main steps that should be taken to improve travel & traffic conditions in Hyderabad? Rate in order of preference with 1 as highest and
3 as lowest.
01. Better Planning / Regulation of Development (What,
02. Road Widening
where, how much)
03. Road Improvements (Riding Quality etc) 04. Improve Management / Safety
05. Improve Public Transport Service 06. Improve Public Transport Facilities (Terminals / Stops)
08. Better Information on roads / traffic conditionds / fare /
07. Traffic Education (in public)
public transport
09. Restriction / Regulation on vehicles (use / purchase) 10. Improve / Provide more Public Parking
6. What is the best way to promote and fund transport / traffic improvements for the city? How? Rate in order of preference with 1 as highest and 3 as
lowest.
01. Increased Municipal Taxes 02. Higher Vehicle Cost / Registration Charges
03. Increase Public Transport Fare 04. Increase fuel cost / fuel surcharge
05. Development Charges (Pay more to build more or in
06. Increase Parking Fees
specific areas)
07. High Compounding Fee / Challan / Penalty for traffic
08. More funding not required. Better manage existing funds.
violations
09. Others (Specify)
7. How much would you be willing to pay for reduction in your travel time?
Willing to Pay (Over present cost) 0% 10% 25% 50% 100% 200%
Trave Time Saving (minutes)
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
28
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor
VOLUME IV: Consultancy Services for
ESTABLISHMENT LOCATION:
Map Reference: Sheet of
1. What is the main Activity the establishment is 2. What is the Ownership Status of 3.
Geographical coverage of Market
engaged in? Tick all those apply. the establishment?
Multi Brand-Multi Product Retail / Private Individual / 01 Local
01 01
Departmental Stores Parnership 02 Regional / State
02 Single Brand / Product Retail 02 Corporate 03 National
Retail
34 Municipal Services / Water / Electricity building under single owner / occupier and put to dedicated use)
4
35 Back Office / Operations Support Shared use by multiple establishments (e.g. Malls, Business Parks,
02
36 IT / ITES Office buildings etc.)
37 Others
38 Consumer Goods 11. Total built-up area occupied by the
Manufacturing
Sq m
Automobiles / Mechanical / establishement at present location.
39
Engineering Goods
5
40 Hitech Electronics 12. Total land area and built-up area (floor Land (Sq m) Total Built-up (Sq m)
41 Chemicals / Pharmaceutical area of entire building / complex) of the
42 Others premises.
29
PDF compression, OCR, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of CVISION PDFCompressor