Professional Documents
Culture Documents
RATINGS
of IOWA
TABLE OF CONTENTS
The American Conservative Union Foundation is proud to present our ratings of the 2018 meeting of the Iowa Legislature. Like our
Ratings of Congress, which date back 47 years, our state ratings are meant to reflect how elected officials view the role of government
in an individual’s life. We begin with our philosophy i.e., conservatism is the political philosophy that sovereignty resides in the person,
and then apply our understanding of government (its essential role is to defend Life, Liberty and Property).
Because our ratings are designed to educate the public about how consistently elected officials adhere to conservatism, we carefully
examine the entire docket of legislation introduced in each state every year. We select the most meaningful bills and publish
the results after the dust has settled. ACUF state ratings—launched in 2011 with ratings for five states—have become a nationally
recognized resource for evaluating over 8,000 elected officials comprising each of America’s 99 state legislative chambers.
Each election cycle, citizens choose leaders whose vision for the state most closely matches their own, hoping that candidates’
promises will be kept. ACUF’s ratings measure whether those promises were fulfilled or forsaken. With nearly a decade of data on
state legislators’ voting records and average scores for every legislative chamber, citizens in every state can assess how effectively their
lawmakers have applied conservative philosophy to the role of government.
We at ACUF believe, as Ronald Reagan once said, that freedom is never more than one generation away from extinction. We hope
that by providing this unique tool, these ratings will empower Americans to exercise their right to protect our unique American
democracy from tyranny.
Sincerely,
Matt Schlapp
Chairman
American Conservative Union Foundation
2
AMERICAN CONSERVATIVE UNION FOUNDATION’S 2018 Ratings of Iowa
ACUF ACU
Executive Committee Executive Committee
Matt Schlapp Ron Christie
Matt Schlapp
Chairman Secretary
Chairman
Millie Hallow
Charlie Gerow Ed Yevoli SELECTING THE VOTES
Vice Chairman At-Large
Vice Chair
Carolyn D. Meadows Dan Schneider ACU researched and selected a range of bills
Van D. Hipp, Jr.
2nd Vice Chair Executive Director before the Iowa Legislature that determine
Treasurer
Bob Beauprez a member’s adherence to conservative
Kimberly Bellissimo
Treasurer principles. We selected bills that focus on
Secretary
Ronald Reagan’s philosophy of the “three-
Dan Schneider legged stool”: 1) fiscal and economic: taxes,
Executive Director Board Members budgets, regulation, spending, healthcare,
and property; 2) social and cultural: 2nd
Jackie Arends Ed McFadden amendment, religion, life, welfare, and
Board Members
Larry Beasley Priscilla O’Shaughnessy education; and 3) government integrity:
José Cárdenas voting, individual liberty, privacy, and
Kimberly Bellissimo Ron Robinson
Gordon Chang transparency. This wide range of issues
Morton C. Blackwell Mike Rose are designed to give citizens an accurate
Jonathan Garthwaite
Jamie Burke Peter Samuelson assessment that conveys which of Iowa’s
Charlie Gerow elected leaders best defend the principles of
José Cárdenas Sabrina Schaeffer
Niger Innis a free society: Life, Liberty and Property.
Muriel Coleman Terry Schilling
Adam Laxalt
Sean Fieler Matt Smith
Willes K. Lee
Alan M. Gottlieb Chris Turner
Mary Matalin
Van D. Hipp, Jr. Bill Walton
Carolyn D. Meadows
Dr. M. Zuhdi Jasser Thomas Winter
Thomas Winter
The ACUF
Francis Finnegan Fred McGrath Luke Schneider
Legislative
Larry Hart Tyler Muench
Ratings Team
3
AMERICAN CONSERVATIVE UNION FOUNDATION’S 2018 Ratings of Iowa
<= 10%
BREITBACH KLEIN WINDSCHITL
COALITION OF THE WILLS
RADICAL LEFT BROWN HIGHFILL HUSEMAN
KAUFMANN
KAPUCIAN GASSMAN LANDON
SENATE HOUSE CARLIN SIECK WATTS
ZAUN
EDLER
FEENSTRA
GARRETT
GREENE
BEHN
GUTH
4
AMERICAN CONSERVATIVE UNION FOUNDATION’S 2018 Ratings of Iowa
81% 33%
OVERALL
AVERAGE
22
20
18
LOWEST
REPUBLICAN 16
COSTELLO
# OF 14
STATE
71%
12
SENATORS
10
6
HIGHEST
4
DEMOCRAT
2
BOWMAN 0
50%
0-9% 10-19% 20-29% 30-39% 40-49% 50-59% 60-69% 70-79% 80-89% 90-100%
5
AMERICAN CONSERVATIVE UNION FOUNDATION’S 2018 Ratings of Iowa
6
AMERICAN CONSERVATIVE UNION FOUNDATION’S 2018 Ratings of Iowa
9. SF 2117 Maintaining a Balanced Budget through Spending Cuts. This 13. HF 2297 Easing Regulations on Boilers and Hot Water Heaters. This
rescissions bill makes $35.5 million in budget cuts to various state bill eases inspection requirements of hot water boilers and expand
services and programs in order to fix Iowa’s revenue shortfall and the exemptions to include those commonly found in residential
maintain a balanced budget. ACU supports spending cuts rather than homes (i.e., those with capacities of 50 gallons to 120 gallons). ACU
tax increases to meet budget shortfalls and supports this bill as an supports reducing burdensome regulations that increase business and
example of fiscal responsibility for other states to follow. The Senate consumer costs and supported this bill. The Senate passed the bill on
passed the bill on March 21, 2018 by a vote of 28-21. March 27, 2018 by a vote of 26-21.
10. SF 2349 Permitting Employers and Nonprofits to Bypass Obamacare 14. SF 192 Mandating Licensure to Practice Applied Behavior Analysis. This
Health Care Mandates. This bill permits employers to purchase health bill forces anyone who practices “applied behavior analysis” to become
insurance for their workers through “association health plans,” which licensed by the state. ACU opposes this licensing regime which
do not carry costly and unnecessary Obamacare health mandates. establishes unnecessary and burdensome standards for those who
Furthermore, the bill declares that health benefit plans offered by assist individuals with autism, and other conditions, thus reducing
nonprofit agricultural organizations (such as the Iowa Farm Bureau competition and raising caregiving costs and opposed this bill. The
Association) are exempt from Obamacare mandates. ACU believes Senate passed the bill on March 28, 2018 by a vote of 46-0.
individuals should be free to purchase the health care plan that best
fits their needs and has long opposed the mandates under Obamacare 15. SF 2169 Limiting Liability of Establishments Serving Alcohol. This bill
that have crippled the health care industry and led to skyrocketing establishes a $250,000 cap for most non-economic damages for which
costs and supported this bill. The Senate passed the bill on March 27, a licensed establishment serving alcohol is responsible in the event
2018 by a vote of 37-11. an intoxicated customer causes serious injury or death to another.
Additionally, the bill only holds an establishment liable if the customer
11. HF 2253 Expanding Government Competitive Bidding Requirements. was visibly intoxicated, as opposed to the previous standard which
This bill expands the state’s public construction competitive bidding stated the establishment “should have known the person was, or would
requirements to cover “lease-purchase agreements.” ACU supports become, intoxicated.” ACU supports tort reform and placing reasonable
protecting taxpayers from waste by requiring competitive bidding for caps on damages to keep insurance and business costs in check and
government contracts whenever possible and supported this bill. The supported this bill. The Senate passed the bill on April 4, 2018 by a vote
Senate passed the bill on March 27, 2018 by a vote of 27-20. of 32-17.
12. SF 2347 Reforming Antiquated Alcohol Laws. This bill implements a 16. SF 481 Banning Sanctuary Cities and Requiring Cooperation with Federal
number of positive reforms governing bootlegging and the importation Immigration Authorities. This bill prohibits local governments from
of alcohol into the state. For example, individuals can now transport establishing “sanctuary cities,” or regions where federal immigration
up to 4.5 gallons of beer and 9 liters of wine into the state for personal laws are not enforced. Additionally, local authorities are directed to
consumption, and the cap on personal liquor imports is raised from enforce all applicable immigration laws and cooperate with federal
one liter to 9 liters. ACU supports this regulatory reform that increases authorities on detainer requests. ACU assisting the federal government
competition and expands personal liberties and supported this bill. The perform its constitutional role to enforce the nation’s immigration laws
Senate passed the bill on March 27, 2018 by a vote of 47-1. and supported this bill. The Senate passed the bill on April 4, 2018 by a
vote of 28-18.
7
AMERICAN CONSERVATIVE UNION FOUNDATION’S 2018 Ratings of Iowa
17. SF 2407 Providing a Special Interest Tax Break to the Knoxville Raceway. 20. HF 2234 Protecting Property Rights by Reducing Foreclosure Redemption
This bill guarantees the Knoxville Raceway a $1.8 million tax rebate by Periods and Extending Rent Collection Limits. This bill is designed to
building upon previous legislation passed in 2014. ACU does not believe increase property right protections by shortening the foreclosure
it is the proper role of government to subsidize raceways, and opposes process and extending the statute of limitation period (from five years
special interest tax breaks which weaken the tax base and result in to 10 years) in which landlords are able to collect unpaid rent. The bill
higher tax burdens on the rest of the population and opposed this bill. also shortens the period of time in which a homeowner can delay a
The Senate passed the bill on April 30, 2018 by a vote of 30-8. foreclosure sale, and reduces the amount of time a homeowner can
redeem their property (by paying owed debt) after a home has been
18. SF 2311 Protecting Utility Ratepayers from Costly Energy Efficiency sold at foreclosure. ACU Foundation’s Center for 21st Century Property
Programs. This bill updates the laws governing regulated public utility Rights is a leading voice on these issues and works to ensure all
companies, including capping the amount utility companies can spend property owners have rightful title to their property and any generated
on energy efficiency programs. Under the bill, natural gas companies earnings. ACU supports these reform which help better protect
cannot spend more than 1.5 percent, and electric companies more than property owners from losses and supported this bill. The Senate passed
2 percent, of their revenue on energy efficiency programs. Additionally, the bill on May 2, 2018 by a vote of 27-19.
the bill provides an avenue for ratepayers to become exempt from the
energy efficiency programs and resulting costs. ACU opposes driving 21. SF 2417 Providing Corporate and Individual Income Tax Cuts. This bill
up the costs of utilities and forcing individuals to pay for unspecified reforms the state’s tax code by providing nearly $2.86 billion in net tax
energy efficiency programs, of which they may receive no benefits, and cuts over the next six years. Under the bill, all corporate and individual
opposed this bill as a step in the right direction. The Senate passed the income tax brackets are reduced, with the top corporate rate falling
bill on April 30, 2018 by a vote of 28-20. 12 percent to 9.8 percent, and the top individual rate falling from 8.98
percent to 8.53 percent (and to 6.5 percent by 2023). However, sales tax
19. SF 359 Banning Abortions once a Fetal Heartbeat is Detected. This bill exemptions are eliminated for subscription services, ridesharing, digital
requires a woman seeking an abortion to undergo and ultrasound purchases, and photography. Additionally, all online and out-of-state
test and prohibits an abortion from occurring if a baby’s heartbeat is retailers who have sales exceeding $100,000 are required to collect
detected (but with exceptions for medical emergencies). Furthermore, sales taxes. ACU supports this pro-growth tax reform, which is the
the bill prohibits anyone from using or transferring a fetal body part. largest net tax cut in state history, and supported this bill. The Senate
ACU believes abortion is a human tragedy, supports restrictions on the passed the bill on May 5, 2018 by a vote of 28-20.
practice and educating patients and supported this bill. The Senate
passed the bill on May 1, 2018 by a vote of 29-17.
8
AMERICAN CONSERVATIVE UNION FOUNDATION’S 2018 Ratings of Iowa
HJR 2009
HF 2286
HF 2253
HF 2297
HF 2234
SF 2407
SF 2349
SF 2293
SF 2344
SF 2257
SF 2333
SF 2347
SF 2169
SF 2148
SF 2231
SF 2417
SF 2311
SF 2117
SF 359
SF 481
SF 192
ACU Votes 2018 2017 LIFETIME
Party Dist. Votes Cast % % AVG
Bolkcom D 43 + - + - - + - - - - - + - - - - - + - - - 5 21 24% 4% 7%
Dvorsky D 37 + - - - - + + - - - - + - - - X - + - - - 5 20 25% 8% 6%
Hogg D 33 - - - - - + - - - - - + - - - - - + - X - 3 20 15% 8% 6%
Jochum D 50 + - - - - + + - - - - + - - - - - + - - - 5 21 24% 8% 9%
9
AMERICAN CONSERVATIVE UNION FOUNDATION’S 2018 Ratings of Iowa
HJR 2009
HF 2286
HF 2253
HF 2297
HF 2234
SF 2407
SF 2349
SF 2293
SF 2344
SF 2257
SF 2333
SF 2347
SF 2169
SF 2148
SF 2231
SF 2417
SF 2311
SF 2117
SF 359
SF 481
SF 192
ACU Votes 2018 2017 LIFETIME
Party Dist. Votes Cast % % AVG
Mccoy D 21 + - - - - + + - - - - + - - - - - + - - - 5 21 24% 9% 8%
“+” Member voted with ACU’s position † Legislator did not vote on enough of the selected bills and as a result the 2018 percentage was
“-” Member voted against ACU’s position not rated. 2/3rds of the selected bills must be voted on to receive a score.
“X” Member was absent for vote
“E” Member was excused for vote
10
AMERICAN CONSERVATIVE UNION FOUNDATION’S 2018 Ratings of Iowa
80% 29%
OVERALL
AVERAGE
35
30
LOWEST
REPUBLICANS 25
HEATON
# OF
20
STATE
MCKEAN
REPS
15
63% 10
0
HIGHEST 0-9% 10-19% 20-29% 30-39% 40-49% 50-59% 60-69% 70-79% 80-89% 90-100%
DEMOCRAT
2018 ACUF PERCENTAGE
McCONKEY
47%
11
AMERICAN CONSERVATIVE UNION FOUNDATION’S 2018 Ratings of Iowa
12
AMERICAN CONSERVATIVE UNION FOUNDATION’S 2018 Ratings of Iowa
10. SF 2349 Permitting Employers and Nonprofits to Bypass Obamacare 14. SF 2169 Limiting Liability of Establishments Serving Alcohol. This bill
Health Care Mandates. This bill permits employers to purchase health establishes a $250,000 cap for most non-economic damages for which
insurance for their workers through “association health plans,” which a licensed establishment serving alcohol is responsible in the event
do not carry costly and unnecessary Obamacare health mandates. an intoxicated customer causes serious injury or death to another.
Furthermore, the bill declares that health benefit plans offered by Additionally, the bill only holds an establishment liable if the customer
nonprofit agricultural organizations (such as the Iowa Farm Bureau was visibly intoxicated, as opposed to the previous standard which
Association) are exempt from Obamacare mandates. ACU believes stated the establishment “should have known the person was, or would
individuals should be free to purchase the health care plan that best become, intoxicated.” ACU supports tort reform and placing reasonable
fits their needs and has long opposed the mandates under Obamacare caps on damages to keep insurance and business costs in check and
that have crippled the health care industry and led to skyrocketing supported this bill. The House passed the bill on April 2, 2018 by a vote
costs and supported this bill. The House passed the bill on March 21, of 61-36.
2018 by a vote of 69-30.
15. SF 481 Banning Sanctuary Cities and Requiring Cooperation with Federal
11. SF 2293 Interfering in Motor Vehicle Franchise Agreements. This bill Immigration Authorities. This bill prohibits local governments from
triggers state involvement in negotiations between automobile dealers establishing “sanctuary cities,” or regions where federal immigration
and manufacturers in order to help dealers charge higher prices. laws are not enforced. Additionally, local authorities are directed to
Specifically, the bill forces manufacturers to compensate dealers enforce all applicable immigration laws and cooperate with federal
for warranty and recall work at retail market prices. ACU believes authorities on detainer requests. ACU assisting the federal government
manufacturers and dealers should be free to negotiate their own perform its constitutional role to enforce the nation’s immigration laws
private contracts and opposes this government interference that will and supported this bill. The House passed the bill on April 3, 2018 by a
result in higher consumer costs and weaker consumer warranties and vote of 55-45.
opposed this bill. The House passed the bill on March 22, 2018 by a vote
of 94-0. 16. HF 2234 Protecting Property Rights by Reducing Foreclosure Redemption
Periods and Extending Rent Collection Limits. This bill is designed to
12. SF 2347 Reforming Antiquated Alcohol Laws. This bill implements a increase property right protections by shortening the foreclosure
number of positive reforms governing the importation of alcohol into process and extending the statute of limitation period (from five years
the state. For example, individuals can now transport up to 4.5 gallons to 10 years) in which landlords are able to collect unpaid rent. The bill
of beer and 9 liters of wine into the state for personal consumption, and also shortens the period of time in which a homeowner can delay a
the cap on personal liquor imports is raised from one liter to 9 liters. foreclosure sale, and reduces the amount of time a homeowner can
ACU opposes restricting consumer choices to only in-state options and redeem their property (by paying owed debt) after a home has been
supports this regulatory reform that increases competition and expands sold at foreclosure. ACU Foundation’s Center for 21st Century Property
personal liberties and supported this bill. The House passed the bill on Rights is a leading voice on these issues and works to ensure all
March 22, 2018 by a vote of 86-8. property owners have rightful title to their property and any generated
earnings. ACU supports these reforms which help better protect
13. HF 2253 Expanding Government Competitive Bidding Requirements. property owners from losses and supported this bill. The House passed
This bill expands the state’s public construction competitive bidding the bill on April 4, 2018 by a vote of 79-19.
requirements to cover “lease-purchase agreements.” ACU supports
protecting taxpayers from waste by requiring competitive bidding for
government contracts whenever possible and supported this bill. The
bill passed the House on March 28, 2018 by a vote of 59-41.
13
AMERICAN CONSERVATIVE UNION FOUNDATION’S 2018 Ratings of Iowa
17. SF 2311 Protecting Utility Ratepayers from Costly Energy Efficiency 19. SF 2417 Providing Corporate and Individual Income Tax Cuts. This bill
Programs. This bill updates the laws governing regulated public utility reforms the state’s tax code by providing nearly $2.86 billion in net tax
companies, including capping the amount utility companies can spend cuts over the next six years. Under the bill, all corporate and individual
on energy efficiency programs. Under the bill, natural gas companies income tax brackets are reduced, with the top corporate rate falling
cannot spend more than 1.5 percent, and electric companies more than 12 percent to 9.8 percent, and the top individual rate falling from 8.98
2 percent, of their revenue on energy efficiency programs. Additionally, percent to 8.53 percent (and to 6.5 percent by 2023). However, sales tax
the bill provides an avenue for ratepayers to become exempt from the exemptions are eliminated for subscription services, ridesharing, digital
energy efficiency programs and resulting costs. ACU opposes driving purchases, and photography. Additionally, all online and out-of-state
up the costs of utilities and forcing individuals to pay for unspecified retailers who have sales exceeding $100,000 are required to collect
energy efficiency programs, of which they may receive no benefits, and sales taxes. ACU supports this pro-growth tax reform, which is the
opposed this bill as a step in the right direction. The House passed the largest net tax cut in state history, and supported this bill. The House
bill on April 26, 2018 by a vote of 52-42. passed the bill on May 5, 2018 by a vote of 54-32.
18. SF 359 Banning Abortions once a Fetal Heartbeat is Detected. This bill
requires a woman seeking an abortion to undergo and ultrasound
test and prohibits an abortion from occurring if a baby’s heartbeat is
detected (but with exceptions for medical emergencies). Furthermore,
the bill prohibits anyone from using or transferring a fetal body part.
ACU believes abortion is a human tragedy, supports restrictions on the
practice and educating patients and supported this bill. The House
passed the bill on May 1, 2018 by a vote if 51-46.
14
AMERICAN CONSERVATIVE UNION FOUNDATION’S 2018 Ratings of Iowa
HJR 2009
HF 2286
HF 2297
HF 2253
HF 2234
SF 2349
SF 2293
SF 2257
SF 2333
SF 2347
SF 2169
SF 2231
SF 2417
SF 2311
SF 2117
SF 220
SF 359
SF 481
SF 192
ACU Votes 2018 2017 LIFETIME
Party Dist. Votes Cast % % AVG
Gaines D 32 - - - - - - - + - - - + - - - - X X X 2 16 13% 6% 9%
15
AMERICAN CONSERVATIVE UNION FOUNDATION’S 2018 Ratings of Iowa
HJR 2009
HF 2286
HF 2297
HF 2253
HF 2234
SF 2349
SF 2293
SF 2257
SF 2333
SF 2347
SF 2169
SF 2231
SF 2417
SF 2311
SF 2117
SF 220
SF 359
SF 481
SF 192
ACU Votes 2018 2017 LIFETIME
Party Dist. Votes Cast % % AVG
16
AMERICAN CONSERVATIVE UNION FOUNDATION’S 2018 Ratings of Iowa
HJR 2009
HF 2286
HF 2297
HF 2253
HF 2234
SF 2349
SF 2293
SF 2257
SF 2333
SF 2347
SF 2169
SF 2231
SF 2417
SF 2311
SF 2117
SF 220
SF 359
SF 481
SF 192
ACU Votes 2018 2017 LIFETIME
Party Dist. Votes Cast % % AVG
Oldson D 41 - - - - - - - + - - - + - - - - + - - 3 19 16% 5% 7%
17
AMERICAN CONSERVATIVE UNION FOUNDATION’S 2018 Ratings of Iowa
HJR 2009
HF 2286
HF 2297
HF 2253
HF 2234
SF 2349
SF 2293
SF 2257
SF 2333
SF 2347
SF 2169
SF 2231
SF 2417
SF 2311
SF 2117
SF 220
SF 359
SF 481
SF 192
ACU Votes 2018 2017 LIFETIME
Party Dist. Votes Cast % % AVG
“+” Member voted with ACU’s position † Legislator did not vote on enough of the selected bills and as a result the 2018 percentage was
“-” Member voted against ACU’s position not rated. 2/3rds of the selected bills must be voted on to receive a score.
“X” Member was absent for vote
“E” Member was excused for vote
18