You are on page 1of 11

Chapter 4 47

paper which prompted me to drill

Questioning even further into a word study of the


Hebrew word translated “cleansed” in
Dan 8:14. The findings will surprise
the answer many.

Readers are encouraged to confirm


the evidence presented in this chapter
The foregoing chapters now allow us
by consulting the following
to read the answer in Dan 8:14 as:
reference sources reliant on coded
text references in Strong’s
“Until when 2300 years have
Concordance:
passed then the heavenly
sanctuary will be cleansed”.
Theological Wordbook Of The Old
Testament by R.L Harris, G.L Archer
Let us now question the answer and
& B.K Waltke. Moody Bible
ask why the heavenly sanctuary
Institute Chicago (1980).
should require cleansing. Some
pp 752-755.
exhaustively read all Bible
commentaries and Bible translations
The Brown-Driver-Briggs Hebrew &
on the word translated “cleansed”. Is
English Lexicon by F. Brown, S.
it not preferable to first learn in what
Driver & C. Briggs. Hendrickson
context Bible writers use the word
Publishers, Massachusetts. 7th
translated “cleansed”? The gathering
printing. (Jan 2003).
of Bible teaching on the matter
safeguards against the prejudicial
The Interlinear Bible by J.P Green.
influence of commentator’s opinions.
Trinitarian Bible Society London.
Let the Bible be its own
(1976).
commentator.
If you experience difficulty obtaining
Word Study
or using the reference material please
Those of you who find a close
email me:
inspection of Hebrew words dull,
hkea@hkea.org.au
may I encourage you to take careful
notice of this chapter as it delivers a
Nitsdaq
fatal blow to many criticisms of SDA
The Hebrew verb ‘nitsdaq’ is the
interpretation of Dan 8:14. If you
word the KJV translates as
read no further than this chapter you
“cleansed”. This has come under
will have benefited much.
criticism as the traditional SDA
position has been to seize on that
I am indebted to the work of Dr A.M
word and find parallelism in Lev 16.
Rodriguez “The Sanctuary & Its
Modern translations treat the word
Cleansing” 1994 Adventist Review
differently. e.g. “re-consecrated” in
Supplement. It was Dr Rodriguez’s
the NIV; “restored to its rightful
47
Chapter 4 48

state” in the RSV. The fact there is are already justified! In the setting
so much disparity between English of the sanctuary, a person is righteous
translations of the word translated as who has been judged by God and
“cleansed” in the KJV should have declared innocent and is thereby
prompted many folk decades ago to vindicated. The individual who
complete a serious word study. Our knows he is innocent (Ps 7:8) goes to
last resort in circumstances where the sanctuary to be vindicated where
there is a ‘babel’ of translations on a God declares him innocent (1 Kings
key word such as this is a close 8:31, 32; Ps 9:4; 24:3-6; Isa 50:8, 9).
examination of how OT writers used God will not justify the wicked (Ex
the word. 23:7). In legal contexts such as this
where tsadaq is employed, the
The verb nitsdaq comes from the root righteous are declared innocent and
tsadaq which means “to be in the the accusers are not. (Deut 25:1; 2
right”, “to have a just case”, “to be Chron 6:23; Ps 7:8-9).
vindicated”, “to be righteous”.
Psalms 15:1-2 says that those who
A variety of interpretations for participated in the sanctuary services
nitsdaq have arisen because there are were required to be tamim
admittedly a number of problems in (blameless) and righteous (tsedeq).
correctly understanding its meaning. This righteousness was a gift from
It has been translated “shall be God and impossible apart from
cleansed” (KJV), “shall be restored to atonement because the righteous one
its rightful state” (RSV), “purified” (tsaddiq) was a person whose sins
(NAB), “be properly restored” God had forgiven (Ps 32:1, 5, 11).
(NASB), "be re-consecrated” (NIV).
One difficulty is that the verbal form The important distinction between
Daniel uses in verse 14 is not used tsadaq and our notion of justice is
anywhere else in the Old Testament restoring righteousness to those
(such as Leviticus 16) so comparative whose right to regain it has been
material for nitsdaq is non-existent. taken away. Punishment of the
The other difficulty is that the verbal wicked is manifested as God’s
root tsadaq nowhere else (except in righteousness on behalf of those
Dan 8:14) takes the sanctuary as its whom He vindicates. In contexts
object. Because tsadaq means “be in where tsadaq is used, “salvation” and
the right”, “be vindicated”, “be “righteousness” are linked together
righteous” it comes as no surprise (Ps 98:2-9; Isa 1:27, 28; 46:13).
that the primary use of tsadaq in God’s righteousness is His saving
Scripture is in a legal context where action on behalf of His people.
legal procedure is in view. If a Those whom he saves and vindicates
person is wrongly accused of a crime he also rescues from persecution.
tsadaq means the person’s legal Order is restored by destruction of the
rights are restored. If you are in oppressor (Ps 143:11, 12; 71:2-4, 24;
Christ your sad sin record wrongly 33:5-11). Salvation is an integral part
accuses you of a crime because you of tsadaq.
48
Chapter 4 49

In Leviticus a person had to be clean confession, forgiveness, atonement,


to gain access to the sanctuary (Lev vindication, righteousness by faith,
13:46; 14:1-20) and in Psalms access restoration, cleansing, and assurance.
required righteousness. A person The concept of righteousness is
declared clean is a person declared embedded in the sanctuary services
righteous. This duality is found in (Deut 33:19; Ps 4:5; 24:3-5; 51:19;
Isaiah 53:11-12. To be declared 118:19; 132:9). To be declared
righteous is the same as to be righteous by God is to be cleansed
cleansed. The cleansing of the from sin because our sin is borne by
sanctuary is the same as justification Him who justifies us (Isa 53:11).
by faith. The root tsadaq is also used as a
synonym for purity (Job 4:17; 17:9;
It comes as no surprise that there is a Ps 18:20; 51:4). The New Brown,
connection between tsadaq and the Driver, Briggs and Gesenius Hebrew
sanctuary services because the and English Lexicon defines tsadaq
sanctuary services typified all the as summarized in Table 1:
elements of the plan of salvation:
TABLE 1
qal Simple active be just, be righteous have a just cause, be in the right, be
voice justified in ones plea, by witnesses, by
acquittal, by condemnation of
opponent. Be just of God in His
government, in charging with sin. Be
just and righteous in conduct and
character.
niphal Passive voice To be put right To be put in a right condition. To be
justified, its cause vindicated.
Piel Intensive voice To justify To make appear righteous
Hiphael Causative Do justice in Declare righteous, justify. Vindicate the
voice administering law cause of, save. Make righteous, turn
to righteousness.
Hithpael Reflexive voice Justify ourselves Clear ourselves from suspicion.

49
Chapter 4 50

Table 2 lists all Old Testament usages1 (41 times) of the verb tsadaq:

TABLE 2
Qal Simple “be just” 3 times Job 4:17; 9:2; 33:12 (KJV)
active
“be justified” 8 times Job 11:2; 13:18; 25:4; Ps 51:4; 143:2;
voice
Isa 43:9, 26; 45:25
“be righteous” 10 times Gen 38:26; Job 9:15; 10:15; 15:14; 22:3;
34:5; 35:7; 40:8; Ps 19:9; Ezek 16:52 (KJV)
“justify self” 1 time Job 9:20 (KJV)
Niph’al Passive “be cleansed” 1 time Dan 8:14 (KJV)
voice
Pi’el Intensive “justify” 5 times Job 32:2; 33:32; Jer 3:11; Eze 16:51, 52
voice (KJV)
Hiph’al Causative “do justice” 2 times 2 Sam 15:4; Ps 82:2, 3 (KJV)
voice
“justify” 9 times Ex 23:6, 7; Deut 25:1; 1 Kings 8:32;
2 Chron 6:23; Job 27:5; Prov 17:15;
Isa 5:23; 50:8; 53:11 (KJV)
“turn to 1 time Dan 12:3 (KJV)
righteousness”
Hithpa’el Reflexive “clear selves” 1 time Gen 44:16
voice

1
Robert Young. Analytical Concordance of the Bible
translates zakah 2 times as “be
Table 2 confirms that in the majority clean”, 2 times as “cleanse”, 2 times
of cases the Old Testament uses the as “make clean”, once as “clear” and
word tsadaq to mean “be justified”, once as “count pure”.
“be righteous” and “justify”.
Adventism has been criticised for If all Old Testament uses of the word
depicting Daniel 8:14 as portraying a tsadaq are imported into Daniel 8:14,
heavenly judgment scene in which an (See Table 2) it is inescapable that
investigation is underway for the the word “cleansed” is entirely
purpose of vindicating the righteous. appropriate. Table 3 reviews all Old
Critics allege that the notion of Testament usages of tsadaq in
“vindication” was subsequently association with the two Hebrew
added and was not originally words tahor and zakah meaning
contemplated by Adventist pioneers. “clean” or “pure”. Each text is
Against Tables 1 and 2 those Hebrew poetry where the rhyme is a
criticisms appear manifestly hollow. rhyme of thought and not of sound.
They are examples of ‘synonymous
Tsadaq and “cleansed” parallelism’ where the first line of the
The KJV translates tahor 50 times as couplet means essentially the same as
“clean”, 41 times as “”pure”, 2 times the second line (See Table 3):
as “fair” and once as “pureness”. It

50
Chapter 4 51

TABLE 3
st nd
Text 1 line of couplet 2 line of couplet
Job 4:17 tsadaq “righteous” tahor “pure”
Job 15:14 zakah “pure” tsadaq “righteous”
Job 25:4 tsadaq “righteous” zakah “pure”
Psalm 19:9 tahor “pure” tsadaq “righteous”
Psalm 19:9 tahor “clean” tsadaq “righteous”
Psalm 51:4 tsadaq “justified” zakah “blameless”

Table 3 is clear enough that tsadaq new support to Adventist linking of


keeps company with “clean” or Daniel 8:14 to the typical Day of
“pure”. This is highly significant Atonement services. The numerous
because Leviticus 16:19, 30 uses the observations listed in this chapter so
word ‘tahor’ (clean or cleanse) to far pose considerable difficulty for
depict the purpose of the Day of those folk who consider that the
Atonement service: Adventist position on Dan 8:14 is
un-Scriptural and anti-gospel. May I
“He shall sprinkle some of the please repeat:
blood on [the horns of the
altar] with his finger seven If a person is wrongly accused of a
times, cleanse (taher) it, and crime ‘tsadaq’ means the person’s
consecrate it from the legal rights are restored. If you are
uncleanness of the children of in Christ your sad sin record
Israel”. (v 19) wrongly accuses you of a crime
because you are already justified!
“For on that day the priest
shall make an atonement for Without question the foregoing
you, to cleanse (taher) you, examination has indeed been tedious,
that you may be clean (taher) but it is impressive if for no other
from all your sins before the reason than this material was not
Lord” (v 30). known to Adventist pioneers. Our
microscopic analysis into original
The point is that the word taher languages manifestly supports and
which is close enough to be used in underpins the original Adventist
synonymous parallelism with tsadaq interpretation.
(Table 3) is used to describe the
purpose of the Day of Atonement Tsadaq and legality
service in Leviticus 16. It is Table 4 lists OT texts that use tsadaq
compelling that the word taher used to portray a legal setting with
in Leviticus 16 occurs in a vindication as its goal. Why cannot
synonymous way with the key verb tsadaq in Daniel 8:14 also carry the
tsadaq in Daniel 8:14 which lends same legal force?

51
Chapter 4 52

TABLE 4
Job 3:18 “justified” tsadaq “Behold now, I have ordered my cause; I know I
(KJV) shall be justified” (KJV)
“vindicated “See now, I have prepared my case, I know that
(NKJV) I shall be vindicated” (NKJV)
Isaiah 43:26 “acquitted” tsadaq “Put me in remembrance; let us contend
together; state your case, that you may be
acquitted”.
Genesis 38:26 “righteous” tsadaq “She has been more righteous than I”. (Tamar
was vindicated and her life was saved).
Psalm 82:1-3 “justice” tsadaq “..do justice to the afflicted and needy” (See also
Job 34:5; 40:8; Ps 143:2; Isa 50:8).
Deut 25:1 “justify” tsadaq “If there is a dispute between men and they
come to court, that the judges may judge them
and they justify the righteous and condemn the
wicked”
Genesis 44:16 “clear” tsadaq “How shall we clear ourselves?”
2 Sam 15:4 “justice” tsadaq “..and I would see that he gets justice”

Conclusion further examined in the remainder of


The foregoing reveals that Scripture this chapter.
repeatedly uses tsadaq synonomously
with “clean”, “pure”, and “clear”. It The foregoing also reveals that the
is specifically used with tahor which word tsadaq when used in
Leviticus 16 uses to describe the conjunction with the sanctuary,
ultimate purpose of the Day of justifies God’s restoration of order
Atonement service. The KJV through judgment, vindication,
translation “cleansed” is appropriate cleansing and salvation.
but not adequate. It also extends to
the expunging of one’s record as the Daniel 8:14 refers to an event that
natural outcome of a legal process leads to this consummation and can
that vindicates. The foregoing also only be understood within the context
reveals that Scripture repeatedly uses of the sanctuary services. You will
tsadaq in a legal setting. recall that this event can only take
The parallelism between the place after the chazon (vision) of the
judgment scene of Daniel 7 and the whole chapter is fulfilled. It must
cleansing of the sanctuary of Daniel 8 follow on after the tamid (daily
is set out in Table 5. Coupled with ministry) of the Prince. It vindicates
the linguistic basis already examined, God’s people who have been
the connection between cleansing the persecuted by the little horn whose
sanctuary and judgment rebellion and desecration is brought
(justification) of the righteous is not to an end. The little horn’s control
easily discounted. This connection is over the daily would come to an end

52
Chapter 4 53

at a particular moment of time when which verse 14 refers comes as no


the cleansing/vindication of the surprise.
sanctuary is taking place.
The sanctuary services embrace an
What event then is Dan 8:14 referring amalgam of judicial and redemptive
to? Is there a Biblical event that ideas. The daily services made
functions as a type for the last day divine forgiveness available to
event of Daniel 8:14? Is there a penitent sinners through sacrificial
Biblical parallel for the event atonement whereby sin and impurity
described in this text? were transferred to the sanctuary. On
the Day of Atonement God removed
Day of Atonement sin and impurity from the sanctuary
The Day of Atonement was an annual revealing that God’s dwelling place is
event that followed after the daily absolutely unrelated to sin. God’s
(tamid) ministry of the priests during holiness on that day was vindicated
the year. This satisfies our criteria by identifying Satan as the originator
that the event we are looking for “can of sin and in making him responsible
only take place after the chazon for the sin problem. Thus the
(vision) of the whole chapter is cleansing of God’s people reached its
fulfilled. It must follow on after the consummation. God’s court is in
tamid (daily ministry) of the Prince”. session on the Day of Atonement.
His people are evaluated. Those not
The Day of Atonement was part of in a faith relationship with Him are
the sanctuary services, impacted on removed from the camp of His people
God’s people and the sanctuary itself (Lev 23:27-31) and no sacrificial
and addressed the problem of flagrant atonement is made for them. So is
rebellion against God. This satisfies the fate of the little horn (Dan 8:25.
our criteria that the event we are Compare Eze 7:22; 25:3; 24:21; Jer
looking for addresses the question 51:11; Ps 74:3-14). The close of the
“How long shall be the pesha’ (the Day of Atonement brings a powerful
rebellion)..?” manifestation of God’s holiness and
righteousness, God’s people
Please remember verse 11-14 echoed experience a final salvation and the
immediate familiarity to the readers wicked are destroyed resulting in
in Daniel’s day because of the order and harmony.
sanctuary language employed. Three
times the word “daily” is used. Three It is to this amalgam of judicial-
times the word “sanctuary” is used. redemptive ideas to which Dan 8:14
The word nitsdaq (cleansed) would refers. Daniel’s apocalyptic vision
have had special meaning. It would renders a cosmic dimension to the
have been impossible for readers in Day of Atonement that results in the
Daniel’s day to disassociate the final resolution of the sin problem.
sanctuary from verse 14. That the The foregoing is supported by the
Day of Atonement has been parallelism in Table 5 between
identified as the typical event to Daniel 2, 7, 8:
53
Chapter 4

TABLE 5
DANIEL 2 DANIEL 7 DANIEL 8 MEANING
Gold head Lion - Babylon
Silver breast Bear Ram Medo-Persia
Brass girdle Leopard Goat Greece
Iron legs Beast Little horn phase 1 Pagan Rome
Feet 10 horns + little horn Little horn phase 2 Papal Rome
Stone Judgment scene Sanctuary scene Christ’s last work
Mountain Kingdom - God’s kingdom
established

There has been little dispute amongst The judgment scene in Dan 7: 9-10 is
Bible commentators from different introduced when the little horn was in
faiths that chapters 2, 7 and 8 the second phase of its work (Dan
progressively expand on scenes 8:8, 11). The judgment scene in Dan
presented. This progression 7: 26 is again introduced when the
amplifies details about the nature of little horn was in the second phase of
the great controversy between good its work (Dan 8:25). It has been
and evil and on specific events within persecuting the saints for three and a
salvation history. What is portrayed half times. The judgment clearly
as a rock in Daniel 2 representing the takes place towards the end of the
setting up of God’s Kingdom is little horn’s reign of terror because
“fleshed out” in more detail in the little horn loses its dominion and
subsequent chapters. The important is destroyed as a result of the
point is that you please observe the judgment. The vision of Daniel 7
connection between the judgment moves from persecution of the saints,
scene in Daniel 7 and the cleansing of to judgment, to God’s kingdom. The
the heavenly sanctuary in Dan 8:14. judgment in Dan 7:10-11 however
takes place before the little horn is
Combining the global view that Dan destroyed and before God’s kingdom
2, 7 and 8 present, it is quite clear is established.
that the judgment (Dan 7:9-10) and
the cleansing of the sanctuary (Dan What sort of judgment?
8:13-14) complement each other, Many hints are given in Dan 7:9-10
enriching our understanding of (and Dan 12:1-2) that an
Christ’s mediatorial work (Dan 8:11) investigation is underway.
shortly before the second advent Please note Table 6:
(Dan 2:34, 44). Compare Hebrews
9:19-28.

When did this judgment occur?


Chapter 4

TABLE 6
The occasion Verse
Takes place in heaven 9
God is present with his council 9, 10
Books are opened 10
God’s people living are judged 22
God’s people who have died are judged 12:1-2
Thousands of His messengers are present 10
The universe is interested in the proceedings 10

The foregoing point to an and defeating them, until the


investigation preceding the actual Ancient of Days came (cf 7:9)
execution of judgment. Some refer to and pronounced judgment in
these proceedings as the favor of the saints of the Most
“investigative judgment”. One could High and the time came when
also refer to them as the “vindicative they possessed the kingdom”
judgment” because God and the (NIV) and Dan 12:1-2 reads:
saints are vindicated before unfallen
heavenly beings. God is vindicated “But at that time your people
because His plan of salvation and His – everyone whose name is
government are shown to be just. found written in the book –
The saints are vindicated because of will be delivered. Multitudes
their faith in Christ. who sleep in the dust of the
earth will awake: some to
Record books in our own society everlasting life, others to
bothers most people and it is shame and everlasting
understandable that we recoil from contempt”.
the idea that there are record books in
heaven. But what says Scripture? The little horn cannot be judged in
See Ex 32:32-33; Neh 13:14; Ps 56:8; the sense of a vindicative judgment
69:28; 139:16; Isa 4:3; Mal 3:16; which is what is portrayed here
Phil 4:3; Rev 3:5; 13:8; 17:8; 20:12, although it is certainly condemned as
15; 21:27. a result of that judgment. The theme
of Daniel is vindication of God’s
Who is being judged? people who have been oppressed by
Dr Ford asserts it is the little horn powers contrary to God’s
which is on trial here and the government.
judgment scene in Dan 7:10-11 has
nothing to do with judgment of the
saints. However Dan 7:21-22 reads: Please review how the verb tsadaq
has to do with the notion of restoring
“As I watched, this horn was righteousness to those whose right to
waging war against the saints regain it has been taken away. (If you
Chapter 4 56

are in Christ your sad sin record with God. Is it about a perfect record
wrongly accuses you of a crime or simple faith in a perfect substitute?
because you are already justified!)
This type of judgment cannot apply Please note that Daniel looks forward
to the little horn. See Ps 7:8-9; 26:1- to the time when the salvation of
2 where the verb tsadaq is used. The God’s people will be final.
wicked one served as the accuser in Accepting Christ’s sacrifice by faith
court (Zech 3:1-4; Ps 35:1). What we makes them saints of the Most High
have in Dan 7:9-10 is vindication of because that simple act of acceptance
the righteous that confirms the evil of entitles them to the cleansing benefits
the wicked. In order to restore the of the sacrificial death of Christ (Dan
righteous the wicked that caused the 9:24-27). This act of faith allows
disruption are condemned and Christ to represent the believer in the
removed. In Dan 7:10-11 the heavenly court (Dan 7:13-14,18).
righteous are vindicated by judgment
and although the little horn is This is the gospel of righteousness by
condemned, its judgment and its final faith and justification by faith as the
destruction occurs after the Protestant community understands it.
millennium (Rev 20). Adventism’s sanctuary doctrine
considerably enhances that
These additional aspects of the plan understanding. The believer’s grimy
of redemption are not evident in the record is covered with Christ’s
traditional gospel teaching of the spotless record. The believer’s case
Protestant community who typically before the heavenly tribunal is
present the wonderful atonement mediated by Christ Himself who
secured for us at Calvary but leave presents His own blameless record as
unanswered how God deals with the if it were the believer’s record. This
sin problem in a cosmic sense. The is the gospel. It is the theme of both
sanctuary truth provides additional Old and New Testament. It provides
dimension to the plan of redemption. assurance now to all who come just
It reveals how God can be both just as they are and accept by faith the
and the justifier of those who have free gift of redemption. It is
transgressed. It reveals God’s significant that many hundreds of
solution to the sin problem that passages in Ellen White’s writings
ensures rebellion will not break out support this fundamental gospel
afresh after His kingdom has been principle.
established. If this is a subject into
which angels desire to look (1 Pet Justification is immediate to those
1:12) it behooves all believers to do with faith. God looks at believers as
so. if they possessed Christ’s
The gospel in the judgment righteousness as soon as and for as
Some believers look at the long as they are in Christ. Sin is
Investigative Judgment with fear. It instantly forgiven when confessed.
arises from uncertainty about exactly However the record of sin is not
what it is that makes a person right blotted out until the final
56
Chapter 4 57

consummation. Why the delay if a both as just and the justifier of those
believer has been instantly forgiven, who believe (Rom 3:26). Thus the
accepted, justified, saved and sanctuary is cleansed. God’s
redeemed? government and His plan of
redemption to save fallen mankind
During the typical Day of Atonement from the demands of His law have
God judged His people. We have been vindicated. The loyalty and
seen that the cleansing of the love of unfallen beings for God’s
sanctuary as depicted in Dan 8:14 government is gained by complete
also includes a work of judgment. openness about the destructive effects
We have seen that the verb tsadaq is of sin. Fallen mankind has been
primarily a legal term making it legally reconciled to God through
possible to interpret the work of the Christ’s sacrifice. Those who
Prince in judicial and redemptive specifically accept that gift by faith
terms, a forging of law and grace. As are in fact reconciled. This is the
in the typical Day of Atonement the gospel. What mechanism is there to
judgment’s purpose is to vindicate prevent a second Lucifer-like
God’s people. The Israelite who rebellion in the New Earth requiring a
confessed sin over the head of the second plan of redemption? Apart
sacrificial victim was forgiven that from Adventism few have considered
sin. The sin however was transferred the import of this question. The
by faith and in type to the earthly investigative judgment is God’s
sanctuary by means of sacrificial invention to prevent a second
blood (Lev 4:20, 26, 31, 35). outbreak of Lucifer-like rebellion in
Although forgiven it remained there the New Earth. God’s plan of
until the Day of Atonement. redemption has been justified. All
who are in Christ are regarded as
Similarly on the antitypical Day of righteous in the judgment because
Atonement the believer’s record is Christs’ perfect righteousness covers
examined. It is a grim record. The them. A believer’s record has
believer’s sins are forgiven and nothing to commend except faith in
covered by Christ’s spotless record. Christ’s righteousness. Sinners who
Although covered with Christ’s are in Christ can be admitted into
sinless record, the forgiven sin record God’s kingdom. God is just. He is
remains. The final consummation the justifier of all who believe.
blots out the believer’s sin record. Outbreaks of repeat rebellion in our
Believer’s names who are preserved own lives become unattractive
in the books inherit the Kingdom because of the Spirit’s conviction,
(Dan 7:22; 12:1-2). By allowing leading us to Christ for forgiveness,
unfallen beings to examine the cleansing and assurance that we are
heavenly records God is shown to be indeed right with God.

57

You might also like