You are on page 1of 8

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF GERIATRIC PSYCHIATRY, VOL.

8: 685-692 (1993)

COMMENT
‘I DON’T FEEL OLD’: THE SIGNIFICANCE OF
THE SEARCH FOR MEANING IN LATER LIFE
PAUL THOMPSON
Research Professor, Department of Sociology, University of Essex, Colchester, Essex C 0 4 3SQ. UK

SUMMARY
A critique of the study of ageing by social scientists is provided in this article, on the basis of the comparative
neglect of life history studies across the whole lifespan. It points to the skewed nature of studies reported in
the literature. As a corrective, results from a UK life history based study are presented. It focuses on work, leisure,
grandparenting, and intimate relationships between adults, leading to conclusions about the factors determining
later life experiences and self-perceptions of the meaning of old age.

KEY woms-Ageing, meaning of life, life satisfaction.

It is an unfortunate paradox that the energy which Clark and Anderson, 1967)-not as a once-for-all
social science researchers have put into the docu- event, but as a process. Hence the interests and
menting of the social problems and deprivations wishes of the old are not created from nothing at
of older people in the present has in itself reinforced the moment of retirement. They are the culmination
conventional misunderstanding and demeaning of a whole life which has ‘sculpted their present
attitudes towards the old. The result has been a problems and concerns’, a life itself built around
neglect of the ordinary experience of ageing in many different ‘life-threads’-education, work,
favour of the pathological. The difficulties of under- marriage, children, hobbies, and so on-so that it
standing ordinary old people have been com- is best understood, both in psychological and social
pounded by the lack of interest of both life story terms, ‘as a complex of strands running for different
sociologists (Plummer, 1983) and oral historians lengths of time throughout a life biography and
(Thompson, 1988) in tracing their lives as a whole. moulding its individuality’ (Johnson, 1976; Rosen-
The need for such research has certainly been mayer, 1981). Only a life history approach can
recognized, for three reasons. The first has been unravel these threads.
a growing acceptance in the policy field that ‘older The third reason follows from the complexity
people are entitled to select their own destiny, which this implies in old people’s life patterns. Both
within given limits’. It therefore follows that we Johnson and the Rapoports have attacked the
need to know what it means to be old to them, assumption of ‘an unrealistic homogeneity’ among
for even at the most practical, simple level, those the elderly and emphasized ‘the importance of
concerns and aspects of their lives ‘which are not viewing people in the later phase of life in a less
highly valued by external observers may well be stereotyped and more differentiated way’ (Johnson,
amongst the most significant’ (Johnson, 1976; 1976; Rapoport and Rapoport, 1975, p. 312).
Rapoport and Rapoport, 1975, p. 315). This new Indeed, in certain respects there is a greater variety
willingness to listen to their clients has been very of life patterns among the elderly than among ear-
strongly reinforced in the 1980s by the growing lier age groups just because their day-to-day lives
therapeutic use of reminiscence by health and social are no longer structured by education or work. ‘The
workers (Butler, 1963; Norris, 1986; Coleman, elderly are distinctive not because they can choose,
1986; Oral History, 1989). within broad constraints, but because they must
Secondly, ageing is now seen-building on much choose; responsibility for structuring their lives is
earlier American work (Cumming and Henry, 1961; uniquely their own.’ In a pilot report which we

08854230/93/080685-08$09.00
0 1993 by John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
686 P. THOMPSON

found particularly helpful, Taylor and Ford (198 1) over 75, two-thirds have no physical difficulties
remarked on the ‘seemingly endless’ diversity of with ordinary daily activities. For the great major-
life patterns they found through interviewing old ity of the old in Britain, the immediate problem
people in Aberdeen. They might focus on their is quite different. Not only socially but probably
wider family, or their spouse, or a continuing job, physically too, the most damaging threat to them
or a social cause or a hobby, or their own (ill-) is loss of life purpose and boredom.
health; and ‘some lead such active lives that we The fundamental message which we have learnt
found it difficult to arrange a time for interview, from our informants is in our title. Unless they
while others are so isolated and lonely that our are physically ill or depressed, they do not feel,
interviewers felt guilty about terminating the inter- in their real selves, that they are old. And given
view and leaving them to themselves’. Taylor and the common stereotypes of old age, they are absolu-
Ford argued for an approach which sees later life tely right. Because later life normally brings losses
as a continuing process: ‘a constant struggle to of unprecedented seriousness-retirement from
maintain cherished life-styles against the threaten- paid work, and the death of lovers, friends and
ing impact of both external events and internal kin-it is a time of active challenge. So far from
changes’, in which different styles of life will prove implying passivity, it demands an exceptional abi-
to have different kinds of resilience. lity to respond imaginatively to change. To succeed,
Despite such calls, there has been an inadequate older men and women have to be able to draw
response from social science researchers in Britain. on their full resources, built up over a lifetime. They
In contrast to the United States, we have neither have to fight against the stereotypes of dependence
longitudinal studies with cross-sections of ordinary to maintain their own sense of independent purpose
older people using in-depth interviewing nor even and meaning in life.
a disconnected series of major works like the earlier Denial of old age is defiance of a spoiled identity.
Williams and Wirths (1965) and Clark and Ander- They all fear going into an old people’s home, and
son (1967) (both of which partially foreshadow only a tiny majority can even think of joining an
Taylor and Ford’s position) or, more recently, old people’s club. The old to them-as to so many
Myerhoff s classically sympathetic life story study social scientists-are typified by the dependent
(1979) and Kaufman (1986). There has also been inmates or members of such institutions; they will
more popular feminist life story work (Ford and call them ‘old’ even when chronologically younger
Sinclair, 1987). British feminist contributions have than themselves, especially when working for them
been much more focused on the burden of caring as volunteer social assistants, to emphasize their
for the old which is imposed on younger women. distance from such a condition. Their own need,
Otherwise, the liveliest work is dominated by a rather than feeling their age, is to feel themselves,
class-based policy sociology (Phillipson, 1978, grown from the past and growing into the future.
1982). As a 74-year-old farmer put it to me at the end
Our own research study, now published as Z of an interview, returning to the land after giving
Don’t Feel Old: The Experience of Later Life it up six times, ‘You see, my life’s just beginning’.
(Thompson et al., 1990), therefore stands strangely Z Don ’t Feel Old explores the varying strategies
alone. It is based on 55 life story interviews with which underlie such resilience in the search for
informants born between 1899 and 1928 (then aged meaning and fulfilment in later life.
60-87) who were the grandparents in a randomly
selected national sample of families in Britain. We
do not wish in any way to suggest that problems WORK
of poverty and ill-health are not crucial in shaping
the experience of later life. Class differences show There are four basic spheres in which meaning is
up immediately in terms of resources for transport sought: some new, some old. but each needing to
or telephoning or holidays. We find that a retired be actively sought.
middle-class man lives in a manor house furnished The first is work. The rise of obligatory retire-
with antiques, while an ex-collier sleeps on a camp ment has created quite new problems for older peo-
bed in his bedsitter. Nevertheless, fear of absolute ple, and above all for men. They solve this in a
destitution has certainly gone, while in health variety of ways. Some insist on retaining work
terms, a mere one in 20 of those over 65 lives in habits. The ex-India policeman still rises at dawn;
hospital or an institution, and even among those the former country-house butler changes his shirt
‘I DON’T FEEL OLD’ 687

three times a day. Others devise work-like activities Women, with the exception of those who were
at home, constructing house extensions, or repair- professional nurses, seemed much less identified
ing clocks for a whole neighbourhood. Yet others with their work. Their ‘retirement’ crises are more
continue zealously to seek work, finding it above often related to their unpaid role as carers, They
all in poorly regulated and underpaid sectors: men face crucial needs to change, first when their chil-
in road transport and women in domestic service, dren leave home; then when their husband retires,
shop work or private nursing. often becoming a more active presence in the house;
A classic case is Bill Duncan (b.1912), son and and again, on widowhood. Each time it proves
grandson of Scots miners and a miner himself until much easier for those who have already developed
an accident in his forties, when he became a hospital alternative life roles.
nurse and clerical worker. His model of later life
goes back to his childhood. His father died relati-
vely young, but he was strongly influenced by his LEISURE
uncle, who continued as a working miner into his
mid-seventies, and by his grandfather, who turned The second sphere is that of leisure: an opportunity
professional gardener and remained ‘always an whose growth mirrors the decline of paid work.
active man, right t’more or less aboot the last year We found a remarkable diversity in the extent of
that he died. He was always active, yes; oh aye, such activities. At one extreme, a quarter of those
he had a marvellous garden, he had more or less who described their lives to us had very few leisure
green fingers my grandfather. He could grow any- pursuits. None of them were very happy, and they
thing’. Although he comes from a large family, Bill included some of the most discontented in our sam-
rarely sees them, and he has few leisure interests. ple. At the other extreme, a smaller group had deve-
Socially, he always depended on work. ‘I’ll say this loped special new leisure skills in later life, such
aboot the pits. As far as comradeship was con- as toymaking and wine-making, flower arranging
cerned, the pits was the best thing I was ever in. or sequence dancing, activities which brought
For comradeship oh aye.’ But he continued to make intense pleasure and meaning into their lives. It
good friendships later, often with younger work- is particularly striking how leisure activities can
mates. Working for a health authority, he had no remain fulfilling for those whose physical health
choice but to retire at 65. It came as a shock: ‘We’d would make paid work impossible. Thus Annie
never made any plans, no . . . No, I didna expect Mimms (b. 1908), happily married to a retired elec-
it to be as bad as it was. I just felt that I wouldna trical worker turned gardener, is deaf and diabetic
be that bored’. To make matters worse, in the and dare not walk out on her own, but she puts
second week his wife died. Utterly shaken, Bill all her energies into sewing curtain and chair covers
tolerated only a fortnight’s retirement. Taking a and clothes for her family and friends. ‘I don’t feel
walk up the street, he noticed the unemployed men old, no, I do all me knitting and loads of sewing
outside the pub at the corner, and resolved, ‘There’s . . . You’re as old as you feel, are’nt you? . . . I feel
no way this is gonna happen to me’, so he bought quite jovial and jolly . . . I want to live till I’m 100
an evening paper, found an advertisement, and got you know . . . I’ve got lots of things I want to do
work as a van driver. This job lasted 5 years; and . . . - making things.’ Similarly, Sadie King
then he succeeded in finding another similar job (b. 1906), widow of a furrier with whom she worked
for two more years; and finally a brief job as a herself, is so crippled by arthritis that she is house-
milk driver, until forced out by the refusal of insur- bound, takes 20 minutes to get her clothes on, and
ance cover because of his age. ‘I’ve no had another has to climb down her stairs backwards, yet with
job since-I would take one tomorrow if I could her constant knitting of creative toys and patterns
get it. Ye’ve got to have something you know. I for charity, she characterizes old age as a time of
mean this just sitting around . . . I would like t’have ‘contentment ’.
a job. To me it is important.’ And when asked later A striking instance is Sarah Smith (b.1912). Her
what was the best thing about his whole life, Bill father, a Lancashire signwriter, died when she was
had no doubt that it was to have been able to work in her twenties, and to her great anger her mother
when others could not: ‘to think that the people remarried a much younger lorry driver. Sarah’s
that I was serving had no more time for me, and own marriage to a workaholic tailor was turbulent
I could get another job in another station and be and conflictual. She is a very heavy smoker who
accepted and carry on’. has severe breathing problems and has had two
688 P. THOMPSON

major operations for cancer, the first 25 years ago. INTIMATE ADULT RELATIONSHIPS
Yet despite this catalogue of longstanding damag-
ing experiences, Sarah is a woman of energy and The last sphere is intimate relationships between
enthusiasm, a compulsive talker, to whom ‘life’s adults. Later life is a time when these relationships
very sweet’ and ‘I feel too young to go yet’. The need to be continually rebuilt. In this it is more
turning point in her life was when she retired from like youth than the middle years of life. Those who
her job as a laundry milliner at the age of 60 and remain married must adjust to retirement and to
threw herself into the world of flower arranging. children leaving home. The most vulnerable appear
She attended regular classes for 4 years, joined a to be those who have focused through their adul-
flower club, entered competitions, helped at volun- thood on a single sphere of activity: work-centred
teer flower stalls and joined in excursions to men and child-centred women in role-divided mar-
country gardens, both making new friends and win- riages, which we found also tended to be less inti-
ning approval for her successes. She transformed mate and sexually unfulfilled. Even if after
her garden into a systematic source for suitably retirement they tried to shift their day-to-day roles
coloured leaves at all seasons. In the interview she at home, it seemed too late to create either new
talked lyrically about her plants and her compe- fulfilments in outside activities or a truly nurturing
tition entries. ‘It’s very satisfying, you know; it’s mutual relationship. The quality of marriage in
a lovely hobby . . . I’ve got to win a First before later life to a marked extent was shaped by earlier
I die.’ choices.
Two other factors seemed particularly import-
ant. The first was the transmission of particular
GRANDPARENTING family cultures. There was clear evidence in a
number of families of transgenerational marital
The third sphere is grandparenting. Here we found, problems. A second crucial influence was age at
in contrast to recent American research (Cherkin marriage. The discontented couples had married
and Furstenberg, 1986), strong continuities with at an average age 3 years below that of the con-
past patterns: the almost universal pleasure, and tented.
often intense joy, felt in becoming a grandparent; Still more strikingly, however, some of those in
the mutuality of support between the generations; second marriages seemed the happiest of all-like
and also the continuing salience of grandmothers. honeymoon couples. They had experienced unhap-
The degree of intimacy between grandparents and piness and loneliness and had now seized a new
grandchildren differed principally between families chance of life. Jackie Stephen (b. 1916), for instance,
with continuing patterns of their own, and also by a Lancashire coachbuilder’s widow who worked
gender. There was no sign yet of a trend among as a market stall assistant, remarried a factory qua-
grandfathers towards active involvement in child- lity controller 4 years younger, also widowed, when
care. she was 60. It is transparently a love-match. They
For both men and women, however, grandpar- sit in the house, she knitting and sewing while he
enting is essentially a mutually optional relation- plays the organ or writes stories, or doing a cross-
ship. Grandparents cannot count on natural word or playing scrabble together; they go out to
loyalty. Again, like so much else in later life, it walk by the sea; and above all, two or three times
builds on the choices of earlier years: those who each week they dance. She had had no meaningful
give more of themselves to their children when sexual relationship for 20 years, and was deeply
younger are more likely to stay closer to them and hesitant when he wanted to marry her, making him
to be given the chance to become active grandpar- wait 2 years, but ‘I’ve never regretted it. We’ve had
ents-just as they are likely to be especially well a marvellous 10 years, both of us’.
cared for if they find themselves in need later in The greatest challenge of all in later life comes
their lives. Whatever their views on family obli- with the loss of intimates: husbands, wives, and
gations, people make individual distinctions among also friends. One historically unique feature of con-
their own kin. Meaningful grandparenthood is not temporary ageing is that longer life expectancy has
automatic, but has to be achieved. Even this most also brought a new strangeness to death itself,
biological aspect of ageing cannot be realized in which is no longer a common experience right
social terms without sensitivity, imagination and through life. Today many people only have to come
commitment. to terms with close loss through death, and the
‘I DON’T FEEL OLD’ 689

imminence of their own mortality, in later life. cular local communities-in terms of friendship
Whether they confront or evade it, this will be one networks, transport and education, health and wel-
of the most difficult tasks they ever face. Little can fare-vary greatly. The second is the long shadow
take away the pain and suffering which this brings of class, in terms not only of material resources
(Bowling and Cartwright, 1982; Marris, 1958). but also of health and life itself. Formerly working-
Recovery demands both determination and class men and women suffer more physical disabili-
social skill, and is approached differently by women ties as well as dying earlier (Bytheway et al., 1989).
and men. Women commonly form new social The third constraint is universal: the spoiled per-
networks of other widows, with whom they often sonal identity threatened by widespread demeaning
mix exclusively. Widowers, by contrast, have both popular images of old age.
male and female friends, including younger cou- The men and women whom we interviewed are
ples. On the other hand, widowers appeared to by definition survivors of their generation. There
suffer from a special problem in expecting to find are many reasons why some have lived longer than
intimacy physically through sex rather than others. Women survive men. Differences in income,
through talking about their feelings. They therefore housing, occupational hazards, diseases and stress,
tended to have more difficulty in finding sustaining drinking and smoking, and possibly diet, help to
friendships after bereavement. More eager to load the class dice. But the ability to maintain a
remarry, they adapt with much more persisting meaningful life focus may be equally crucial.
reluctance to life on their own. Recent British medical research by Murphy el al.
There are certainly widows who find that living (1988) has suggested that among the elderly,
alone can be turned into a positive source of oppor- depression can precipitate a fatal illness, and may
tunity. Marjorie Dickens (b. 1907), banker’s widow even bring a doubling of deathrates. Similarly,
of 80, still active at golf, is off to Tunisia with an Antonovsky (1979, 1987), through a longer series
older brother. She has the financial means to fulfil of studies in Israel of how people who had suffered
this dream. ‘I like it that I can do as I please, go intense stress managed to stay reasonably healthy,
where I want to, and if I can afford it, buy what has concluded that ‘the sense of coherence’ is their
I want to and eat what I want . . . I would never key defence. Recent work by British psychologists
have dreamt of marrying again.’ And with less and sociologists has begun to explore more particu-
means, but in a similar spirit, Glenys Howells lar sources of meaning: Sixsmith (1986), for exam-
(b.1914), Welsh pitman’s widow, who spends her ple, the importance of house and home, Evers
days with family or friends or out walking on the (Fennel1 et al., 1988) that of daily routines, and
hills on her own, puts it, ‘I think the freedom I’ve Coleman (1986) that of remembering itself; while
got now is something I enjoy, because I get up in an American anthropologist, Kaufman (1986), has
the morning and if I wanna go out for the day picked out a wider variety of thematic sources of
there’s nothing to stop me. I’ve got no one to think meaning in later life in The Ageless Self. She identi-
about. So I can just pack up me bag and go’. If fies the key to later life in how ‘individuals symboli-
she doesn’t meet somebody to talk to, she just lis- cally connect meaningful past experiences with
tens to the trees, and dreams of trips to Shanghai current circumstances’.
and the Grand Canyon. To a greater or lesser extent all the stories we
recorded convey this search for meaning. Physical
ageing does not necessarily imply feeling old. Men
and women in their twenties or thirties or forties
CONCLUSIONS can feel they have failed to find the right person
to marry, or have made the wrong career choice,
Later life is a time of constant reconstruction. I and that they are ‘too old’ to start again. Feeling
have emphasized the variety with which older men old is feeling exhausted in spirit, lacking the energy
and women describe how they build, how they find to find new responses as life changes. It is giving
meaning. It is a particular strength of life history up. Feeling ourselves means feeling the inner energy
evidence that it allows us to examine this individual which has carried us thus far in life. It means accept-
consciousness and praxis. ing our own pasts as part of our present. It means
These personal accounts need to be situated feeling a whole person.
within a frame of three types of constraint. The In later life this remains essentially the same. You
first is place. The social resources offered by parti- may be categorized as an ‘old person’ with a pen-
690 P. THOMPSON

sion and cheap travel concessions at 65, or accord- people but enable them to make younger friend-
ing to medical and sociological specialists you may ships, good cheap public transport, and so on.
cross from the ‘young old’ to the ‘old’ at 75, but Equally, it is no wonder that those whom we
there is no reason why you should not still feel interviewed do not recognize themselves in this
the same person inside. The real turning points are image. Later life from the inside-like life at any
in your own life: giving up work or starting a age-is a story with its dark side, its pain and suffer-
hobby, losing a loved one, or finding a new friend. ing. But the message which comes most strongly
And what matters, in later life just as earlier, is from these accounts is of resilience in the face of
how you can respond to the challenge of change. the twists of fate; of adaptability; and in some of
The fact is that you are by now a survivor. So long these lives, of a powerfully continuing ability to
as you feel yourself, you can still make the best seize or create chances for fulfilment, whether in
of your life. work, leisure or love.
Feeling yourself and feeling old thus remain
essentially different at any age. Nor is this surpris-
ing given the image of old age which is constantly
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
thrust at us: an image of later life which is, in fact,
completely misleading. Thus the standard warning
sign for old people crossing the road is of a grotes- This research depended on many kinds of h e l p
quely hunched old couple leaning on a stick, evi- from those who were interviewed, Michele Abend-
stern, Catherine Itzin and Graham Smith as
dently both suffering from osteoporosis, ill as much
as old. An actor will typically portray an old person research officers, other interviewers, transcribers
with the exaggerated shakiness of Parkinson’s dis- and the comments of colleagues and friends-more
ease. The typical old person is transformed into fully acknowledged in Z Don ’t Feel Old (Thompson
patronized welfare recipient, only one step removed et al., 1990). An earlier and longer version of the
from the ‘poor dears’ in nursing homes, not to be present article was published in Ageing and Society
listened to very seriously, if at all, ‘not quite whole (1992) 12, 2347. The project on ‘Life Stories and
Ageing’ was funded by the Economic and Social
people, not people like us’. But everyone knows
Research Council.
real old people who do fit the stereotypes, so the
active next-door neighbour, the national political
leader, artist or intellectual, the well-to-do couple
on their constant travels, are defined out of the REFERENCES
frame. ‘They are not a problem, they have no
obvious needs, hence they cannot really be elderly’ Abrams. M. (1978, 1980) Beyond Three Score and Ten,
(Fennel1 et al., 1988). Even the most outstanding 2 vols. Age Concern, London.
sociologists of ageing in Britain, such as Townsend Allat, P. et al. (Eds) (1987) Women and the Life Cycle.
(1957, 1964), have effectively fed this false image. Macmillan, Basingstoke.
The vast majority of British old people look after Antonovsky, A. (1979) Health, Stress and Coping. Jossey-
Bass, San Francisco.
themselves in their own homes with no more than Antonovsky, A. (1987) Unravelling the Mystery of
occasional help from their family. Despite heart- Health. Jossey-Bass, San Francisco.
rending titles like Old and Alone, even among those Beauvoir, S. de (1972) Old Age. Penguin, Harmonds-
over 75, four-fifths do nor feel lonely (Tunstall, worth.
1966; Abrams, 1978). Bell, C. (1968) Middle Class Families. Routledge and
The image of old age which we absorb is there- Kegan Paul, London.
fore a seriously unbalanced version of the realities Blumer, H. (1979) Critiques of Research in the Social
of later life. It is not only scientifically wrong, but Sciences, revised edition. Social Science Research
helps to sanction social and health policies which Council, New Brunswick.
focus on the old in crisis, rather than ‘preventive’ Blythe, R. (1979) The View in Winter: Reflections on Old
Age. Allen Lane, London.
measures which can encourage their resourceful- Bowling, A. and Cartwright, A. (1982) Lije after a Death.
ness and which need to start at least in middle age, Routledge and Kegan Paul, London.
such as adult education, occupational health pro- Breytspaak, L. M. (1984) The Development of Self in
grammes, marital counselling, facilities for specia- Later Life. Little, Brown, Boston.
lized activities like dancing, bowls or the University Bromley, D. B. (1988) Human Ageing; An Introduction
of the Third Age which are popular with older to Gerontology, 3rd edn. Penguin, Harmondsworth.
‘I DON’T FEEL OLD’ 69 1

Butler, R. N. (1963) The life review: An interpretation Johnson, M. (1976) That was your fife: A biographical
of reminiscence in the aged. Psychiatry 26,65-76. approach to later life. In Dependency or Znterdepen-
Butler, R. N. (1975) Why Survive? Being Old in America. dency in Old Age J. M. A. Munichs and W. J. A. Van
Harper, New York. den Heuvel, (Eds). Martinus Nijhoff, The Hague, pp.
Bytheway, B., Keil, T., Allat, P. and Brynan, A. (1989) 148-61.
Becoming and Being Old: Sociological Approaches to Kaufman, S. (1986) The Ageless Self: Sources of Meaning
Later Life. Sage, London, pp. 115-1 16. in Later Life. University of Wisconsin Press, Madison.
Carver, V. and Liddiard, P. (Eds) (1978) An Ageing Popu- Laslett, P. (1989) A Fresh Map of Life: The Emergence
lation. Open University/Hodder and Stoughton, Lon- of the Third Age. Weidenfeld and Nicholson, London.
don (includes Johnson, Rosenmayer, Sontag, Laslett). Leblanc, D. (1987) Case studying the philosophy, inte-
Cavan, R. (1962) Self and role adjustment during old grity, and emotional health of the elderly. Educ. Geron-
age. In Human Behaviour and Social Processes (A. M. tol. 13, 387402.
Rose, Ed.). Routledge and Kegan Paul, London, pp. Levin, J. and Levin, W. C. (1980) Ageism: Prejudice and
52636. Discrimination Against the Elderly. Wadsworth, Cali-
Cherkin, A. and Furstenberg, F. (1986) The New Ameri- fornia.
can Grandparent. Basic Books, New York. Markson, E. W. (Ed.) (1983) Older Women: Issues and
Clark, M. and Anderson, B. (1967) Culture and Ageing: Prospects (including Braito and Anderson, ‘The ever
An Anthropological Study of Old Americans. Langley single elderly woman’, and M. E. Szinovacz, ‘Beyond
Porter Institute, California. the hearth: Older women and retirement’). Lexington
Coleman, P. (1986) The Ageing Process and the Role of Books, Aldershot.
Reminiscences. Wiley, Chichester. Marris, P. (1958) Widows and their Families. Routledge
Cumming, M. E. and Henry, W. H. (1961) Growing Old: and Kegan Paul, London.
The Process of Disengagement. Basic Books, New Mason, J. (1987) Women, marriage and inequality in
York. later life. In Women and the Life Cycle: Transition and
Cunningham-Burley, S . (1984a) The Meaning and Sign$- Turning Points (P. Allatt, Ed.). Macmillan, Bas-
cance of Grandparenthood. Aberdeen PhD. ingstoke, pp. 9&105.
Cunningham-Burley, S. (1984b) ‘We don’t talk about Matthews, S. (1979) The Social World of Older Women:
it . . .’: Issues of gender and method in the portrayal Management of Self-Identity. Sage, Beverly Hills.
of grandfatherhood. Sociology 18,325-38. Murphy, E., Smith, R., Lindsay, J. and Slattery, J. (1988)
Fennell, G., Phillipson, C. and Evers, H. (1988) The Increased mortality rates in later-life depression. Brit.
Sociology of Old Age. Open University Press, Milton J. Psychiat. 152,347-53.
Keynes. Myerhoff, B. (1979) Number Our Days: A Triumph of
Finch, J. and Groves, D. (Eds) (1983) A Labour of Love: Continuity and Culture Among Jewish Old People in
Women, Work and Caring. Routledge and Kegan Paul, an Urban Ghetto. Dutton, New York.
London. Neugarten, B. and Weinstein, K. (1964) The changing
Ford, J. and Sinclair, R. (1987) Sixty Years On: Women American grandparent. J. Marriage Fam. 26, 199-204.
Talk About Old Age. Women’s Press, London. Norris, A. (1986) Reminiscence with Elderly People.
Frankl, V. E. (1978) The Unheard Cryfor Meaning: Psy- Winstow Press, London.
chotherapy and Humanism. Simon and Schuster, New Oral History (1989) Reminiscence, Special Issue, 17,2.
York. Phillipson, C. (1978) The experience of retirement: A
Gibson, M. J. (1984) Sexuality in later life. Ageing Inter- sociological study. Durham PhD.
national 11(1, Spring), 8-13. Phillipson, C. (1982) Capitalism and the Construction of
Green, H. (1985) Informal Carers. General Household Old Age. Macmillan, London.
Survey, 15, Supplement A. HMSO, London. Phillipson, C. and Walker, A. (Eds) (1986) Ageing and
Hareven, T. (1982) Family Time and Industrial Time: The Social Policy. Gower, Aldershot.
Relationship between Family and Work in a New Eng- Plummer, K. (1983) Documents of Life. George Allen
land Industrial Community. Cambridge University and Unwin, London.
Press, Cambridge. Pulling, J. (1987) The Caring Trap. Fontana, Glasgow.
Hareven, T. and Adams, K . (Eds) (1982) Ageing and Life Rapoport, R. and Rapoport, R. (1975) Leisure and the
Course Transitions: An Interdisciplinary Perspective. Family Life Cycle. Routledge and Kegan Paul, Lon-
Guildford Press, New York. don.
Hemmings, S . (1985) A Wealth of Experience. Pandora, Roberts, E. (1984) A Woman’s Place. Blackwell, Oxford,
London. pp. 170-91.
Hunt, A. (1976) The Elderly at Home. HMSO, London. Rosenmayer, L. (1981) Objective and subjective perspec-
Jerrome, D. (1981) The significance of friendship for tives of life span research. Ageing Soc. 1,29-50.
women in later life. Ageing Soc., 175-98. Russell, C. (1981) The Ageing Experience. Sydney.
Jerrome, D. (Ed.) (1983) Ageing in a Modern Society. Seabrook, J. (1980) The Way We Are Now: Old People
Croom Helm, London. Talk about Themselves. Age Concern, Mitcham.
692 P. THOMPSON

Sixsmith, A. (1986) The meaning of home: An explora- Townsend, P. (I 957) The Family Life of Old People: An
tory study of environmental experience. J. Environ- Inquiry in East London. Routledge and Kegan Paul,
ment. Psychol. 6,281-98. London.
Sontag, S. (1978) The double standard of ageing. In An Townsend, P. (1964) The Last Refuge. Routledge and
Ageing Population (V. Carver and P. Liddiard, Eds). Kegan Paul, London.
Hodder and Stoughton, Sevenoaks, pp. 72-80. Tunstall, J. (1966) Old and Alone. Routledge and Kegan
Taylor, R. and Ford, G. (1981) Lifestyle and ageing. Paul, London.
Ageing Soc. 1, 32945.
Ungerson, C. (1 987) Policy is Personal: Sex, Gender and
Thompson, P. (1978; 2nd edn 1988) The Voice of the
Past: Oral History. Oxford University Press, Oxford. Informal Care. Tavistock, London.
Thompson, P., Itzin, C . and Abendstern, M. (1990) I Whitbourne, S. K. (1987) Personality development in
Don't Feel Old: The Experience of Later Life. Oxford adulthood and old age: Relationships among identity
University Press, Oxford. style, health, and well-being. Ann. Rev. Gerontol. Ger-
Thomson, I).(1984) The decline of social security: Fall- iat., 189-216.
ing state support for the elderly since early Victorian Williams, R. and Wirths, C . (1965) Lives Through the
times. Ageing SOC.4,451-82. Years. Atherton Press, New York.

You might also like