Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Authored By:
Dan Montone
Haydon Kerk Motion Solutions
/ Pittman Motors
When applying DC motors to any type of it becomes clear that motor performance determined
application, temperature effects need to be using a rapid dynamometer test with a room tempera-
considered in order to properly apply the ture motor is significantly different than the motor per-
motor. Performance will change as the formance when operated at its maximum temperature
under load.
motor temperature changes. When reviewing
DC motor curves, the user needs to ask the The DC Motor Curve
question “Do these curves represent perfor- DC motor performance curves can be generated under
mance of the motor at room temperature, or various conditions. For example, the motor curve illus-
do these curves illustrate performance at the trated in Figure 1 is representative of an open-loop mo-
maximum rated temperature?” Depending tor tested rapidly (to prevent heating) on a dynamom-
on the temperature and the required operating eter. The test would be done by quickly loading the
point on the motor curve, the performance motor from no-load to locked rotor (stall) using a fixed
difference between “cold” and “hot” terminal voltage from a power supply with low output
conditions can be significant. impedance. A test like this is done in order to get a
“baseline” measure of motor performance while the
Once a motor design is finalized including motor motor is at room temperature. Motor shaft speed and
dimensions, magnetic circuit, and motor winding current are plotted as a function of motor torque. From
configuration, several characteristics that deter- this test and a few resistance readings, the torque con-
mine motor performance become “theoretically” stant, voltage constant, and terminal resistance values
fixed; the torque constant (KT), voltage constant (KE), can be determined. This information is very useful to
and motor terminal resistance (Rmt). These three ballpark basic motor performance and can be sufficient
values will determine the output torque, motor for an application that requires intermittent operation
speed, and the resulting output power at any point with a long rest period between each duty cycle.
on the motor curve at a given terminal voltage, as
well as the overall slope of the motor curve.
www.HaydonKerkPittman.com
1 Haydon Kerk Motion Solutions: 203 756 7441 / Pittman Motors: 267 933 2105
TEMPERATURE EFFECTS ON
MOTOR PERFORMANCE
Table 1. Symbols and Units running conditions of the same DC motor. The
“hot” motor curve demonstrates how much the
performance can change when operating the
Symbol Description Units motor at an elevated temperature.
www.HaydonKerkPittman.com
Haydon Kerk Motion Solutions: 203 756 7441 / Pittman Motors: 267 933 2105
2
TEMPERATURE EFFECTS ON
MOTOR PERFORMANCE
Equations 1 and 2 illustrate the relationship between TABLE 3. Temperature Coefficients for Various
winding temperature, winding resistance, and watts Permament Magnet Materials
dissipated.
Magnetic Material αmagnet( / °C) Tmax(°C)
EQUATION 1. Change in Winding Resistance
Ceramic -0.0020 / °C 300 °C
Samarium Cobalt (SmCo) -0.0004 / °C 300 °C
Aluminum Nickel Cobalt (AlNiCo) -0.0002 / °C 540 °C
Neodymium Iron Boron (NdFeB) -0.0012 / °C 150 °C
EQUATION 2. Watts Lost Due to Winding Resistance
EQUATION 3. Change in KT and KE ( KT = KE when using SI Units )
www.HaydonKerkPittman.com
3 Haydon Kerk Motion Solutions: 203 756 7441 / Pittman Motors: 267 933 2105
TEMPERATURE EFFECTS ON
MOTOR PERFORMANCE
Another term referring to the slope of the DC motor EQUATION 5b. Motor Locked Rotor (Stall) Torque
curve is “regulation”. Motor regulation describes how
much the shaft speed will change with a given change
in shaft load when applying a fixed terminal voltage to
the motor (operating as an open loop system). A flatter
speed-torque curve will result in a smaller change in
shaft speed with increased load. As the motor tempera-
ture increases and the curve becomes steeper, shaft
speed Equation
will drop 4a.
more for the same
Theoretical increase
Motor in load.
Regulation
Using Motor Constants
EQUATION 5c. Motor No Load Speed
Equation 4a. Theoretical Motor Regulation
EQUATION 4a. Theoretical Motor Constants
Using Motor Regulation Using Constants
R
Rmtmt
mR = 9.5493
9.5493 xx R
R mt
Rm
m = 9.5493 xx TT x EEK xxmtK
K K
m 9.5493 K KTT x K
KEE
Equation 4b. Motor Regulation Using The user needs to be careful when designing the
EQUATION 4b. Motor Regulation Curve
Performance Using AData
Performance Curve system to insure the shaft speed meets the minimum
Equation 4b. Motor Regulation Using
Performance Curve Data specification at a given load at an elevated motor
n00 temperature. In a more complex motion system using
Rm = T
n00 a closed-loop controller, shaft speed can be controlled
Rm
m=
m
TLR
T LR
TLR within a given range to remain “fixed” as the load re-
LR quirements change. The example that follows assumes
Equations 4 and 5 can be used to illustrate the dramatic the motor is operated open-loop with a regulated DC
effect on motor performance resulting from a decrease terminal voltage.
in magnetic flux and increase in winding resistance.
Although there will be an increase in motor no-load
speed as well as a decrease in locked rotor torque, the How much can motor performance
difference in “cold” versus “hot” locked rotor torque is change under a given set of conditions?
greater compared with the difference in “cold” versus
“hot” no-load speed.
ROOM TEMPERATURE DATA
The locked rotor torque is heavily dependent on both
the resistance (Rmt) and torque constant (KT). Although Terminal Voltage VT 24 V
the no load speed will also be affected by the higher re-
No Load Speed n0 3160 RPM
sistance at an elevated temperature, the resistance fac-
tor has a much smaller effect on no-load speed because No Load Current I0 0.30 A
it’s multiplied by the no load current (I0), a relatively
small number (compare equation 5b and 5c). Locked Rotor Torque TLR 2.88 Nm
Locked Rotor Current ILR 40.7 A
EQUATION 5a. Motor Locked Rotor (Stall) Current
Terminal Resistance Rmt 0.59 Ω
Voltage Constant KE 0.071 V/(rad/s)
www.HaydonKerkPittman.com
Haydon Kerk Motion Solutions: 203 756 7441 / Pittman Motors: 267 933 2105
4
TEMPERATURE EFFECTS ON
MOTOR PERFORMANCE
ILR = VT / Rmt( f )
ILR = 24V / 0.83Ω
ILR = 28.92A
www.HaydonKerkPittman.com
5 Haydon Kerk Motion Solutions: 203 756 7441 / Pittman Motors: 267 933 2105
TEMPERATURE EFFECTS ON
MOTOR PERFORMANCE
Figure 5. Motor Performance Comparison @ 25°C and 125°C EQUATION 6a. Motor Output Power (at any point)
www.HaydonKerkPittman.com
Haydon Kerk Motion Solutions: 203 756 7441 / Pittman Motors: 267 933 2105
6
TEMPERATURE EFFECTS ON
MOTOR PERFORMANCE
In reality, the higher resistance (Rmt) combined with The example motor curve as shown in Figure 1 removes
the reduced magnetic flux density (lower KT) reduces all other variables and assumes the motor is tested
the locked rotor torque much more than just a reduction with a fixed terminal voltage using a low impedance
in magnetic flux density alone, which accounts for the power supply and progressively loaded with a dyna-
reduction in maximum output power. mometer. The test is performed as quickly as possible
to minimize motor temperature rise. If the motor being
Maximum output power @ 25°C tested is a small sub-fractional horsepower motor, the
dynamometer may load the motor until shaft speed hits
Pmax(i) = 0.25 x ω
0
x TLR zero or close to zero RPM. In the case of larger motors,
the dynamometer may be set to progressively load the
Pmax(i) = 0.25 x 331 rad/s x 2.88 Nm
motor to approximately the maximum power point. The
Pmax(i) = 238 W remainder of the curve may then be extrapolated. The
resulting data in either case are (theoretically) linear
Maximum output power @ 125°C speed versus torque and current versus torque curves.
Pmax( f ) = 0.25 x ω 0
x TLR Some manufacturers, in particular those that supply
Pmax( f ) = 0.25 x 417 rad/s x 1.65 Nm complete servo systems, may present performance
curves as a “blend” of information that includes sys-
Pmax( f ) = 172 W
tem-level limitations. The limitations considered can
include many things such as continuous current capa-
The maximum power at the elevated temperature is
bility, peak current capability, drive/amplifier power
approximately 70% of the maximum power at room
limitations, maximum dc bus voltage, maximum motor
temperature. This is a significant change, and it’s a
temperature ratings, motor saturation, and mechanical
direct consequence of the increased motor resistance.
speed limitations. Many manufacturers may illustrate
Equation 6c will give results that are within 1 or 2% of
motor torque on the “Y” axis and speed on the “X”
the numbers above. This equation is very helpful in
axis. The example curves in Figures 7a and 7b illus-
rapidly estimating the maximum power capability of
trate how data might look if factors such as maximum
any DC motor.
rotational speed, maximum temperature rise, and peak
drive current are considered. No matter how the data is
published or what other system factors are considered,
the motor parameters Rmt, KT, and KE are critical for
understanding the true capabilities of the motor.
www.HaydonKerkPittman.com
7 Haydon Kerk Motion Solutions: 203 756 7441 / Pittman Motors: 267 933 2105
TEMPERATURE EFFECTS ON
MOTOR PERFORMANCE
www.HaydonKerkPittman.com
Haydon Kerk Motion Solutions: 203 756 7441 / Pittman Motors: 267 933 2105
8
TEMPERATURE EFFECTS ON
MOTOR PERFORMANCE
The Pittman motor line spans a wide variety of DC motor sizes and
technologies ranging from extremely compact brushless slotless
DC motors used in high speed medical applications to large NEMA
frame DC servo motors used in sophisticated automation equipment.
www.HaydonKerkPittman.com
© All rights reserved. AMETEK Advanced Motion Solutions. No part of this doc-
ument or technical information can be used, reproduced or altered in any form
without approval or proper authorization from AMETEK, Inc and global affiliates.