Professional Documents
Culture Documents
_______________
* THIRD DIVISION.
111
_______________
112
_______________
113
1
THE COURT A QUO ERRED IN NOT FINDING
THAT THE CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION (CSC)
HAS NO APPELLATE JURISDICTION OVER THE
CASE;
2
THE COURT A QUO SERIOUSLY ERRED IN
FAILING TO REALIZE THAT RESPONDENT DE
LEON HAS NO INTENTION TO DISMISS
PETITIONER FROM THE SERVICE AND IT WAS
SERIOUS ERROR ON THE PART OF THE CSC TO
MODIFY THE SAME OR TERMINATE
PETITIONER FROM THE SERVICE WITHOUT
ANY AUTHORITY;
3
GRANTING ARGUENDO THAT THE CSC HAS
CONSTITUTIONAL CONTROL OVER THE PNRC,
THE COURT A QUO ERRED IN NOT FINDING
THAT THE CSC DID NOT ACQUIRE OR HAD LOST
APPELLATE JURISDICTION OVER THE CASE;
[and]
114
4
THE COURT A QUO ERRED IN NOT FINDING
THAT THE COMMENT (INITIATORY PLEADING)
FILED BY THE KAPUNAN LOTILLA FLORES
GARCIA & CASTILLO LAW FIRM IN BEHALF OF
THE RESPONDENTS, DATED MARCH 31, 2009, IS
NOT VERIFIED NOR ACCOMPANIED BY A
CERTIFICATION AGAINST FORUM SHOPPING.
_______________
115
116
117
118
_______________
119
_______________
120
_______________
_______________
_______________
10 Carpio v. Rural Bank of Sto. Tomas (Batangas), Inc., 523 Phil. 158,
163; 489 SCRA 492, 497 (2006), citing Santo Tomas University Hospital
v. Surla, 355 Phil. 804, 813-814; 294 SCRA 382,391-392 (1998).
11 Moreno, Federico B., Philippine Law Dictionary (3rd edition)
(1988), citing Lepanto Consolidated Mining Co. v. Commercial Union
Assurance Co., Ltd., 555948-R, May 23, 1975, p. 169.
123
··o0o··