You are on page 1of 6

2nd IFAC Workshop on Advanced Maintenance Engineering,

Services and Technology


Universidad de Sevilla, Sevilla, Spain. November 22-23, 2012

Application of Artificial Intelligence in Maintenance Modelling and Management


Khairy A H Kobbacy

School of Built Environment, University Of Salford, Salford, England UK M54WT

Abstract: Over the past 3 decades many attempts have been made to apply Artificial Intelligence (AI)
techniques in maintenance modeling and management. Essentially the use of AI is an attempt to replace
human intelligence with machine intelligence. The ultimate objective is to achieve more effective
maintenance management and in some cases to make achieving this goal a viable option. The AI
techniques used are numerous ranging from the classic expert systems that utilizes rule based reasoning
to the more cumbersome optimization techniques used in Genetic Algorithms. Over the past decade there
has been a shift towards developing hybrid intelligent management systems in operations that use more
than one AI technique. The application areas of AI in maintenance extends widely from the intelligent
maintenance optimization models to the more practical applications such as cost budgeting of
maintenance projects and selecting optimal repair methods. This paper presents an overview of the
applications of AI techniques in maintenance over the past decades identifying specific applications and
extent of use of techniques. The paper discusses the applications of AI techniques and recent trends.
Keywords: Artificial Intelligence, Fuzzy Logic, Rule Based Reasoning, Case Based Reasoning, Genetic
Algorithms, Maintenance Modelling, Maintenance Management.

been applied. Over the past decade there has been a shift to
1. INTRODUCTION
developing hybrid methods that use two or more AI
Maintenance management is an integral part of management techniques in order to produce more powerful systems that
of operations i.e. the organization function that is responsible have more than one “dimension” of intelligence e.g.
for the production of goods and/or services. There have been reasoning, learning etc. The application areas extend widely
many publications and organized conferences that address to all industries such as nuclear, chemical, petrochemical,
intelligent management systems in operations since the late building etc.
1990s. The author has contributed to a number of review
papers that addresses the broad area of AI in operations e.g. This paper presents an overview of the applications of AI
Kobbacy and Vadera(2011) and Kobbacy et al (2007). There techniques in maintenance over the past decades identifying
is also a publication on AI in Maintenance (Kobbacy 2008) specific applications and extent of use of techniques. There
that provides a review covering maintenance and fault are no restrictions made to the aspects of maintenance
diagnosis and also addresses the design and development of decision making process covered except for not including the
intelligent maintenance optimization systems. This paper has area of fault diagnosis. This is a distinctive area of research
a more focused objective to address the maintenance and has vast publications, see Kobbacy and Vadera (2011).
modelling and management aspects, to provide an up to date The paper also presents recent trends in developing AI
overview, to draw conclusions on the extent of applying the systems in maintenance that may help projecting future
various AI techniques in maintenance and the application developments based on understanding of the needs of the
areas and identify recent trends. subject area.

Over the past 3 decades many attempts have been made to The Science Direct database was used to carry out the
use AI techniques in maintenance modeling and literature search using the name of the AI technique with
management. Essentially this work is about the use of AI in search carried out on the title and abstract and keywords. In
order to replace human intelligence with machine intelligence most cases it was sufficient to make a judgement and extract
in order to solve complex or large scale problems or indeed sufficent information based of reading the abstract. In some
systems that changes regularly. The ultimate objective is to cases the author had to consult the full article. The search
achieve more effective maintenance management and in covers publications up to June 2012.
some cases to make achieving this goal a viable option. The
AI techniques used are numerous ranging from the classic
expert systems that utilize rule based reasoning to the more 2. AI APPLICATIONS IN MAINTENANCE
cumbersome optimization techniques used in Genetic
Algorithms. However not all the AI techniques are suitable to 2.1 Knowledge Based Systems (KBS)
address issues in this area and indeed not all techniques have

978-3-902823-17-5/12/$20.00 © 2012 IFAC 54 10.3182/20121122-2-ES-4026.00046


2nd IFAC A-MEST
Sevilla, Spain. November 22-23, 2012

MYCEN the diagnostic medical expert system was designed operation. Khan and Haddara (2004) presents a structured
in the early 1970 at Stanford University and generated lots of risk-based inspection and maintenance methodology that uses
interest despite the fact that it was never used in anger. KBS fuzzy logic to estimate risk by combining (fuzzy) likelihood
which is closely linked to Expert Systems witnessed the of occurrence and its (fuzzy) consequence. They demonstrate
revival of AI in the 1980s. It generated great interest at the case studies based on oil and gas operations. Singh and
time with a promise of solving interesting problems. Initial Markeset (2009) presents a methodology for risk based
interest in applying AI techniques in maintenance started inspection programme for pipes using a fuzzy logic
with KBS. The early paper by Dhaliwal (1986) argued for the framework.
use of AI techniques in maintenance management of large
scale systems. Kobbacy (1992) proposed the use of KBS in 2.3 Case Based Reasoning (CBR)
this area and that was followed by a paper , Kobbacy et
al(1995) detailing “IMOS”, an Intelligent Maintenance CBR uses index schemes, similarity functions and adaptation
Optimisation system that uses KBS. to utilise past experiences in solving new problems. When
combined with other AI techniques it can provide powerful
Over the years the interest in KBSs in maintenance varied but hybrid systems that are able to solve complex problems
in general maintained moderate interest. Applications also through the use of machine learning capability.
covered a wide range of areas. Batanov et al (1993) presents
a prototype KBS system for maintenance management Yu et al (2003) studies remote maintenance decision making
(EXPERT-MM) that suggests maintenance policy, provides and identifies the need not only to advice from supplier to
machine diagnosis and offers maintenance scheduling. Su et customer but also requires their negotiation and cooperation
al (2000) presents a KBS system for analysing cognitive type based on knowledge. The paper presents a multi-agents, CBR
recovery for preventive maintenance. Gabbar et al(2003) based E-maintenance DSS system for maintenance problem
suggests a computer aided Reliability Centred Maintenance solving. Chou (2009) outlines the development of a Web-
(RCM) based plant maintenance management system. The based CBR prototype system to assist decision makers in
adopted approach utilises a commercial Computerised project screening and budget allocation. The system
Maintenance Management System (CMMS). determines preliminary project cost with information based
on previous experience of pavement maintenance related
2.2 Fuzzy Logic (FL) construction. Cai et al(2011) presents a framework for
command forces system, based on CBR, of equipment
FL is a popular AI technique that has many applications and maintenance support. The paper provides an analysis of the
frequently employed with other AI techniques in developing CBR based method of representation and storage of
hybrid systems. The paper by Zadeh in 1965 introduced the equipment maintenance case.
concept of fuzzy sets. In a later publication Zadeh(1999)
defines narrow FL which aims at a formalization of Cheng et al (2008) presents an Intelligent Reliability Centred
approximate reasoning and wide FL which is coextensive Maintenance Analysis (IRCMA). CBR is used to utilise
with fuzzy set theory and is far broader than narrow FL. historical records of RCM analysis on similar items to
Today, the term fuzzy logic is used predominantly in its wide analyse a new item.
sense.
2.4 Genetic Algorithms (GAs)
There is a steady interest in applying FL in modelling
maintenance problems due to its convenience in dealing with GA is an optimisation technique that was developed in the
uncertainty. Mozami et al(2011) uses FL to prioritise 1970s. It is based on the principles of genetics and natural
maintenance activities based on pavement condition index, selection i.e. solutions can be evolved through mutation and
traffic volume, road width and rehabilitation and weaker solutions become extinct. GAs have superior and
maintenance cost. Al-Najjar and Alsyouf (2003) assesses the versatile features compared with the classic optimisation and
most popular maintenance approaches using a fuzzy multiple search techniques. For example it can work with large
criteria decision making (MCDM) evaluation methodology. number of continuous or discrete variables and optimise
Derigent et al(2009) presents a fuzzy methodology to assess extremely complex cost functions though it has the drawback
component proximity based on which opportunistic of requiring high computing power that may require the use
maintenance strategy can be implemented. They use of parallel processing (Haupt and Haupt, 2004). Because of
component proximity fuzzy modelling which targets the these features GAs are appealing in solving many complex
system components ‘‘close to’’ a given reference component, maintenance management problems.
on which a maintenance action is planned. Sasmal and GA is the most popular AI technique applied in maintenance.
Ramanjaneyulu (2008) develops a systematic procedure and Indeed there are many publications on applying GAs in a
formulations for condition evaluation of existing bridges wide range of maintenance problems and applications though
using Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP). Malik et al (2012) mostly of operational rather than strategic nature. There are
uses UV/VIS spectroscopy based FL to assess transformer oil numerous recent developments and applications of GAs in
health. maintenance that we cannot cover all in this preview paper.
Risk based maintenance/ inspection are becoming a popular In what follows we will highlight the most popular
approach to ensure safe as well as economically viable maintenance problem situations and industrial applications.

55
2nd IFAC A-MEST
Sevilla, Spain. November 22-23, 2012

Maintenance scheduling problems represent large scale and planning period. The uncertainty of future pavement
complex applications due to the large amount of variables conditions is simulated based on the calibrated deterioration
involved and their interdependence. Planning preventive model and GA is used to solve the combinatorial
maintenance is indeed one of the most complex activities due optimisation problem. Also note the examples in chemical
to the nature of the problem and the typical lack of data. Lapa process industry below.
et al (2006) presents a model for PM planning using GAs.
The paper aims at presenting a GA approach to optimize PM Levitin and Lisnianski (2000) addresses the problem of
schedules automatically considering factors such as the optimising imperfect PM for multi state systems i.e. systems
probabilities of requiring repairs and their costs, the typical with different levels of output at a point of time. They used
downtime, PM costs, maintenance impact on the systems GA to find an optimal sequence of minimum cost PM actions
reliability, probability of imperfect maintenance, etc. A case while providing the required level of system reliability.
study of High Pressure Injection System (HPIS) of a typical Nahas et al (2008) proposes an improved optimisation
4-loop Pressurized Water Reactor (PWR) was used to approach to find the optimal PM actions based on the
evaluate the methodology. Volkanovski et al (2008) presents extended great deluge algorithm which is simpler and
a GA approach to optimise maintenance schedule of a produced the best solution.
generating unit of a power system. Tsai et al (2001) optimise Examples of applying GAs in maintenance optimisation in
PM for mechanical component. They consider a choice of Nuclear Power system include the work of Lapa et al (2000)
either a PM intervention to partially renew the component or which used GA to maximise availability of nuclear power
a replacement with new component. The optimal activities- system through maintenance scheduling. Jiejuan et al (2004)
combination at each PM stage is decided by using GA to utilizes Probabilistic Safety Assessment (PSA) technology to
minimise the system unit-cost life. The optimal minimum- study the effect of testing and PM on component
cost life is reached at the point in time when the system's unavailability and build a maintenance risk-cost model for
unit-cost life is less than its discarded life at PM intervention. global maintenance optimisation in a nuclear power plant. A
Sortrakul et al (2005) presents a heuristic based on GA for GA is used to obtain the optimal maintenance strategy.
integrated PM planning and production scheduling for a Another application in nuclear industry has been discussed
single machine. Yang and Yang(2012) uses GA to optimise earlier in this section ( Lapa et el (2006)).
aircraft maintenance plan.
Tan and Kramer (1997) presents a general framework for PM
There are few attempts to use GAs to optimise maintenance
optimisation in chemical process operations using GAs and
of parallel/ series systems. Levitin and Lisnianski (1999)
Monte Carlo simulation. It is suggested that the proposed
addresses the problems of redundancy and reliability for a
framework can easily be integrated with general process
multi-level system with different levels of output at point in
planning and scheduling and can be applied for opportunistic
time. The optimal system structure and replacement policy
maintenance problems. Nguyen and Bagajewicz (2008) also
provide the desired level of system reliability with minimal
uses GA to optimise PM scheduling in a process plant. Monte
cost of maintenance and failures measured by unsupplied
Carlo simulation is used to evaluate the maintenance cost,
demand. Monga and Zuo (2001) study optimal design of
economic loss and to assess maintenance performance.
series-parallel systems considering maintenance and salvage
values. A reliability based design model is developed with
Another important application area for GA in maintenance is
deteriorating components and considering the effects PM and
in manufacturing and flow-shop. Chung et al (2009) indicates
asset depreciation. GA is used to perform constrained
the importance of system reliability in manufacturing which
optimization of the system cost function subject to both
is even more critical for a multi-factory production networks
active and non-active constraints. Nourelfath et al(2012)
as a failure may cause a chain of reactions. This paper
studies the joint redundancy and imperfect PM optimisation
proposes a double tier GA approach for multi-factory
for a series-parallel multistate degraded system. They used a
production networks to keep the system’s reliability within
heuristic based on combined GAs and Tabu Search to solve
acceptable range and minimize the makespan of the jobs.
the formulated problem.
Moradi et al(2011) proposes a bi-objective model for joint
There are few publications on the combined use of GAs production and maintenance scheduling problem in flexible
together with MonteCarlo simulation. Marseguerra et al job shop problem (FJSP). The model aims at minimising both
(2002) uses GA to determine the optimal degradation level the unavailability and makespan using GAs.
beyond which preventive maintenance has to be performed
for a continuously monitored multi-component system. 2.5 Neural Networks (NNS)
Marseguerra and Zio (2000) presents an interesting study on
using Monte Carlo simulation in terms of economic costs and NNs are based on the idea of emulating human brain. They
are often used in modelling and statistical analysis (Gurney,
revenues of operation of a plant. GA is then used to optimise
1997) and in classification and optimisation.
the components maintenance periods and number of repair
teams. Chootinan et al (2006) introduces a pavement
Siener and Aurich (1995) presents a concept for quality
maintenance programming methodology that can account for
uncertainty in pavement deterioration using a simulation- oriented maintenance scheduling. Artificial NN is used to
based GA approach. This GA approach is capable of predict the influence of individual machines on final product
quality based on expected conditions of quality relevant
planning the maintenance activities over a multi-year

56
2nd IFAC A-MEST
Sevilla, Spain. November 22-23, 2012

process objects. Mazhar et al(2007) estimates the remaining interest in maintenance applications. Few applications have
life of used components using a two step approach based on been found on CBR and NNs in maintenance but none using
integrating reliability assessment model using Weibull DM. Few hybrid systems have been developed in the
analysis and ANN model which utilises the degradation and maintenance area.
condition monitoring data. The authors show the advantages
of using this approach for sustainable management of supply 3.2 Trends
chains. Lee et al (2008) proposes an approach to improve
Bridge Management Systems (BMS) by utilising an ANN Table 1 below shows the number of papers published during
based prediction model for generating historical bridge the period 2005-09 based on Kobbacy and Vadera(2011) and
condition ratings using limited bridge inspection records. The the finding of current study for 2010 to June 1012.
model is used to predict the missing historical condition
ratings of individual bridge elements leading to improvement Table (1) Number of published papers during 2005-09 and
of BMS reliability in predicting the future bridge condition. 2010-June 12 and % annual change

2.6 Data Mining (DM) AI Tech 2005-09 2010-June12 % Annual


Change
DM uses statistical and machine learning techniques to KBS 4 0 -100%
automate the detection of data patterns in a data base and to FL 7 8 128%
develop predictive models to support decision making CBR 4 2 No change
(Berson et. al. 2000). We have not identified publication on GAs 7 12 243%
using DM in maintenance modelling and management. NNs 0 1 -
However it is expected with the increased volumes of DM 0 0 No change
maintenance databases that DM will used in the future to Hybrid 5 5 100%
identify patterns and trends. Total 27 28 107%
2.7 Hybrid Systems
As it can be seen GAs has the largest increase in publication
rate since 2009. That is followed by FL. NNs increased from
Hybrid Systems are those which employ two or more AI
none to one paper with none in KBS and CBR,
techniques. In maintenance applications the most frequently
used AI technique in a hybrid system is FL when used with Although the number of hybrid system publications is
NN and GAs. Hybrid systems using other combinations in limited, its publication rate since 2010 has doubled. That is
maintenance include CBR with AHP and GAs with Artificial
consistent with the belief of the author that more hybrid
Immune Systems and Simulated Annealing.
systems will be developed in the future to take advantage of
the increased power and effectiveness of such systems. That
Christodoulou et al (2009) presents neurofuzzy DSS for
is also supported by the study of Kobbacy and Vadera (2011)
urban water distribution networks. The system undertakes which confirms that despite its limited applications the
multi-factored risk-of failure analysis and asset management. number of hybrid systems developed in a range of operations
Huang (1998) proposes a genetic-evolved fuzzy system for
management areas including maintenance has tripled during
maintenance scheduling of generating units. Kim(1994)
the period 2005 to 2009.
introduces a method for maintenance scheduling using GA
and simulated annealing.
3.3 Application Areas
Kobbacy et al (2000) presents the next generation of IMOS
It has been observed based on the above overview that FL
discussed above under KBS. The Hybrid IMOS, HIMOS,
applications cover a range from the more policy type
uses a hybrid approach of KBS and Case Based Reasoning
applications e.g. the study of Al-Najjar and Alsouf(2003)
which provides a much needed learning capability to the
which assesses maintenance approaches to the operational
system. type application e.g. of Sasmal and Ramanjaneyulu (2008)
on condition evaluation of bridges. KBS also shows similar
spread of applications including the system which suggests
3. DISCUSSION AND ANALYSIS maintenance policy of Batanov et al(2003) to the plant
maintenance management system of Gabbar et al(2003).
3.1 Use of AI Techniques CBR also seems to be applied on policy type applications e.g.
Yu et al(2003) and Chou(2009) and also to the operational
The above review shows that over the past two decades many type e.g. Cheng et al(2008).
AI techniques have been applied in maintenance management
and modelling. The most popular of the AI techniques In contrast with the above techniques, GAs and NNs have
applied in maintenance is GAs. That can be explained by the more focus on operational level applications. Examples of
powerful optimisation methods GA offers which can deal the GAs overviewed applications is the work of Lapa et
with complex maintenance planning problems. Both al(2006) on PM planning, Tsai et al (2001) on optimising PM
Knowledge Based Systems and FL have received moderate for mechanical components and Sortakul et al (2005) on

57
2nd IFAC A-MEST
Sevilla, Spain. November 22-23, 2012

integrated PM planning. All are operational level type of Cai, J., Jia, Y., Gu, C. and Wu, W. (2011) Research of
studies. The same applies to NNs with studies on Wartime Equipment Maintenance Intelligent Decision-
maintenance scheduling by Aurich (1995) and estimation of making Based on Case-Based Reasoning. Procedia
components’s residual lives by Mazhar et al (2007). Engineering, Vol 15, 163-167.
Cheng, Z., Jia, X., Gao,P. Wu, S. and Wang, J. (2008) A
Kobbacy et al(2007) attempts to identify the suitability of the framework for intelligent reliability centered
various AI techniques to problem types. They indicate that maintenance analysis. Reliability Engineering & System
due to their nature and ability to deal with uncertainty Safety, Vol 93, 6, 806-814.
techniques such as FL, KBR and CBR are more suitable to Chootinan, P. , Chen, A., Horrocks, M.R., and Bolling, D.
deal with unstructured problems that are typical of higher (2006) A multi-year pavement maintenance program
level executive type problems. The more optimisation like using a stochastic simulation-based genetic algorithm
techniques including GAs and NNs are more suitable to approach. Transportation Research Part A: Policy and
operational level problems. Based on the discussion of the Practice, Vol 40,9, 725-743.
previous paragraph one can argue that not so many strategic Christodoulou, S., Deligianni, A., Aslani,P. and
type problems have been encountered in this review. Agathokleous, A. (2009) Risk-based asset management
However there is an element of consistency in that the of water piping networks using neurofuzzy systems.
applications of GAs and NNs almost all are in the more Computers, Environment and Urban Systems, Vol 33, 2,
operational category. On the other hand FL, KBR and CBR 138-149.
seems to cover problems ranging from the more operational- Chou, J.S. (2009) Web-based CBR system applied to early
structured type to the semi structured tending to deal with the cost budgeting for pavement maintenance project Expert
policy/ strategy type problems. Systems with Applications, Vol 36, 2, Part 2, 2947-2960.
Chung, S.H., Lau, H.C.W., Ho, G.T.S. and Ip, W.H. (2009)
Optimization of system reliability in multi-factory
4. CONCLUSIONS
production networks by maintenance approach. Expert
This study presents an overview of AI applications in Systems with Applications, Vol36, 6, 10188-10196.
planning and modelling in maintenance. Due to the limitation Derigent,W., Thomas, E., Levrat, E. and Iung, B.(2009)
of space not all published studies are covered. The study was Opportunistic maintenance based on fuzzy modelling of
not limited in the time period it covers but this subject is component proximity. B. CIRP Annals - Manufacturing
relatively young and relevant publications started to appear Technology, Vol 58,1,29-32.
from the mid 1980s. Haupt, R.L. and Haupt, S.E.(2004) Practical genetic
Algorithms, 2nd Edition. John Wiley & Sons, Inc.,
The study revealed that GAs is the most popular AI technique Hoboken, New Jersey.
applied in maintenance due to its nature which offers Huang, S.J.(1998) A genetic-evolved fuzzy system for
powerful optimisation tools that can deal with complex maintenance scheduling of generating units.
maintenance planning problems. Both KBS and FL show International Journal of Electrical Power & Energy
moderate interest with fewer studies using CBR and NNs. No Systems, Vol 20, 3, 191-19.
studies were found on using DM the author expects interest Gabbar, H., Yamashita. H., Suzuki, K. and Shimada, Y.
in using DM in maintenance should be forthcoming. (2003) Computer-aided RCM-based plant maintenance
management system Robotics and Computer-Integrated
As expected FL, KBS and CBR applications cover both Manufacturing, Vol 19, 5,449-458.
policy type as well as operational type maintenance decision Jiejuan,T., Dingyuan,M. and Dazhi,X. (2004) A genetic
problems while GAs and NNs are mainly focused on algorithm solution for a nuclear power plant risk–cost
operational problems such as PM planning and scheduling. maintenance model. Nuclear Engineering and Design,
Vol 229,1, 81-89.
The study of publications’ trends GAs showed large increase Khan, F.I., Sadiq, R. and Haddara, M.M. (2004) Risk-based
in rate of publication with both FL and Hybrid system inspection and maintenance (RBIM) multi-attribute
publications increased significantly. CBR sustained its decision-making with aggregative risk analysis. Process
moderate number of publication with interest started in NNs. Safety and Environmental Protection, Vol 82, 6, 398-
No publications were found using KBS and DM. 411.
Kim, H., Nara, K. and Gen, M. (1994) A Method for
REFERENCES
maintenance scheduling using GA combined with SA.
Al-Najjar, B. and Alsyouf, I. (2003) Selecting the most Computers & Industrial Engineering, Vol 27, 1–4, 477-
efficient maintenance approach using fuzzy multiple 480.
criteria decision making International Journal of Kobbacy, K.A.H. and Vadera, S. (2011) A survey of AI in
Production Economics, Vol 84, 1,85-100. operations management from 2005 to 2009. J of
Batanov, D., Nagarur, N. and Nitikhunkasem, P.(1993) Manufacturing technology Management, Vol. 22, 22,
EZPERT-MM: A knowledge-based system for 706-733.
maintenance management. Artificial Intelligence in Kobbacy, K.A.H.(2008). Artificial Intelligence in
Engineering, Vol 8, 4, 283-291. Maintenance. In Kobbacy and Murthy (ed.), Complex

58
2nd IFAC A-MEST
Sevilla, Spain. November 22-23, 2012

System Maintenance Handbook, 209-231. Springer, Nahas,N., Khatab,A., Ait-Kadi,D., Nourelfath, M. (2008)
London. Extended great deluge algorithm for the imperfect
Kobbacy , K.A.H., Vadera, S.and Rasmi, M. (2007) AI and preventive maintenance optimization of multi-state
OR inmanagement of operations: history and trends. systems. Reliability Engineering & System Safety, Vol
Jornal of the OR Society, Vol 58, 10-28. 93,11,1658-1672.
Lapa, C.M.F., Cláudio, M. N.A., Pereira,C.M.N.A. and Mol Nourelfath, M., Châtelet, E. and Nahas, N. (2012) Joint
A. C. (2000) Maximization of a nuclear system redundancy and imperfect preventive maintenance
availability through maintenance scheduling optimization for series–parallel multi-state degraded
optimization using a genetic algorithm. Nuclear systems. Reliability Engineering & System Safety, Vol
Engineering and Design, Vol 196, 2, 219-231. 103, 51-60.
Celso M.F. Lapa, Cláudio M.N.A. Pereira, Antônio Sasmal, S. and Ramanjaneyulu, K. (2008) Condition
Carlos de A. Mol. evaluation of existing reinforced concrete bridges using
Lapa, C.M.F., Cláudio, M. N.A. Pereira,C.M.N.A. and Paes fuzzy based analytic hierarchy approach. Expert Systems
de Barros, M. (2006) A model for preventive with Applications, Vol 35, 3, 1430-1443.
maintenance planning by genetic algorithms based in Siener,M. and Aurich, J.C.(2011) Quality oriented
cost and reliability, Reliability Engineering &System maintenance scheduling. CIRP Journal of Manufacturing
Safety, Vol.91, 2, 233-240. Science and Technology, Vol 4,1, 15-23.
Jaeho Lee,J., Sanmugarasa,K., Blumenstein,M. and Loo, Singh, M. and Markeset, T. (2009) A methodology for risk-
Y.C.(2008) Improving the reliability of a Bridge based inspection planning of oil and gas pipes based on
Management System (BMS) using an ANN-based fuzzy logic framework Engineering Failure Analysis,
Backward Prediction Model (BPM) Automation in Vol 16,7,2098-2113.
Construction, Vol 17, 6, 758-772. Sortrakul, N., Nachtmann, H.L. and Cassady, C.R. (2005)
Levitin,G. and Anatoly Lisnianski, A. (1999) Joint Genetic algorithms for integrated preventive
redundancy and maintenance optimization for multistate maintenance planning and production scheduling for a
series–parallel systems Reliability Engineering & System single machine. Computers in Industry, Vol 56, 2, 161-
Safety,Vol64,1, 33-42. 168.
Levitin, G. and Lisnianski, A(2000) Optimization of SU, K. W., Hwang, S.L. amd Liu, T.H. (2000) Knowledge
imperfect preventive maintenance for multi-state architecture and framework design for preventing human
systems. Reliability Engineering &System Safety, error in maintenance tasks. Expert Systems with
Vol.67,2 , 193-203. Applications, Vol 19, 3,219-228.
Malik, H., Singh, S., Kr, M. and Jarial, R.K. (2012) UV/VIS Tan, J.S. and Kramer, M.A. (1997) A general framework for
Response based fuzzy logic for health assessment of preventive maintenance optimisation in chemical process
transformer oil. Procedia Engineering, Vol 30, 905-912. operations. Computers & Chemical Engineering, Vol
Marseguerra, M. and Zio, E. (2000) Optimizing maintenance 21,12,1451-1469.
and repair policies via a combination of genetic Tsai,Y.T., Wang, K.S. and Teng, H.Y. (2001) Optimizing
algorithms and Monte Carlo simulation. Reliability preventive maintenance for mechanical components
Engineering & System Safety, Vol 68,1, 69-83. using genetic algorithms. Reliability Engineering &
Marseguerra, M., Zio, E. and Podofillini, L. (2002) System Safety, Vol 74, 1, 89-97.
Condition-based maintenance optimization by means of Yang, Z. and Yang, G. (2012) Optimization of Aircraft
genetic algorithms and Monte Carlo simulation. Maintenance plan based on Genetic Algorithm. Physics
Reliability Engineering & System Safety, Vol 77, 2, 151- Procedia, Vol 33, 580-586.
165. Yu,R., Iung, B. and Panetto, H. (2003) A multi-agents based
Mazhar, M.I., Kara,S. and Kaebernick,H. (2007) Remaining E-maintenance system with case-based reasoning
life estimation of used components in consumer decision support. Engineering Applications of Artificial
products: Life cycle data analysis by Weibull and Intelligence, Vol 16, 4,321-333.
artificial neural networks. Journal of Operations Volkanovski,A., Mavko, B., Boševski,T., Čauševski, A. and
Management, Vol 25, 6, 1184-1193. Čepin, M. (2008) Genetic algorithm optimisation of the
Moazami,D., Behbahani,H. and Muniandy,R. (2011) maintenance scheduling of generating units in a power
Pavement rehabilitation and maintenance prioritization system, Reliability Engineering & System Safety, Vol 93,
of urban roads using fuzzy logic. Expert Systems with 6,779-789.
Applications, Vol 38, 10,12869-12879. Zadeh, L.A.(1965) Fuzzy Sets. Information and Control, Vol
Monga, A. and Zuo, M.J. (2001) Optimal design of series- 8, 3, 338-353.
parallel systems considering maintenance and salvage Zadeh, L.A. (1999) Fuzzy Logic and the Calculi of Fuzzy
values. Computers & Industrial Engineering, Vol 40, 4, Rules,Fuzzy Graphs, and Fuzzy Probabilities. Computers
323-337. & Mathematics with Applications, Vol 37, 11–12, 35.
Moradi,E., Fatemi Ghomi, S.M.T., Zandieh, M. (2011) Bi-
objective optimization research on integrated fixed time
interval preventive maintenance and production for
scheduling flexible job-shop problem. Expert Systems
with Applications, Vol 38, 6, 7169-7178.

59

You might also like