Project : Brunei Fertilizer Complex

Project No. KXEO-00045

Subject : Review of WPS and PQR
Reference : T-PDE-BFI-1744, Dated 20 March 2019
S.No WPS No Comment on WPS
1 PDE-CMG-G00-DZ-0204 1. A. No is mentioned as 5 but in PQR it is 4
2 PDE-CMG-G00-DZ-0206 1. A. No is mentioned as 5 but in PQR it is 4
3 PDE-CMG-G00-DZ-0331 Comments given by tkIS is still not revised
4 PDE-CMG-G00-DZ-0334 Comments given by tkIS is still not revised
5 PDE-CMG-G00-DZ-0333 Comments given by tkIS is still not revised
6 PDE-CMG-G00-DZ-0336 Comments given by tkIS is still not revised
7 PDE-CMG-G00-DZ-0338 Comments given by tkIS is still not revised
8 PDE-CMG-G00-DZ-0340 Comments given by tkIS is still not revised
QW 403 and 404
1. Groove Thickness Range is specified as 16mm to 24.9mm
9 PDE-CMG-G00-DZ-0510
but Weld Metal deposited thickness is specified as Max. 39
mm. QW 407
1. In QW 410, Multiple or Single Electrode is not Specified
PDE-CMG-G00-QC-0018
10 in WPS
1. In QW 410, Multiple or Single Electrode is not Specified
PDE-CMG-G00-QC-0020
11 in WPS
1. In QW 410, Multiple or Single Electrode is not Specified
12 PDE-CMG-G00-QC-0024
in WPS
Project : Brunei Fertilizer Complex
Project No. KXEO-00045
Subject : Review of WPS and PQR
Reference : T-PDE-BFI-1744, Dated 20 March 2019
1 PQR No. Comment on PQR
1. Welder Name and ID not mentioned in Welding
2 PDE-CMG-G00-DZ-0198 Parameters Record.
2. Mill Test Certifcate is not readable
3 PDE-CMG-G00-DZ-0197 Mill Test Certificate is not readable

1. Welder Name in PQR and Welding Parameters Record is

different. 2. Unit
4 PDE-CMG-G00-DZ-0330
of Temperature and energy is not mentioned in PQR
3. Mill Test Certificate attached with PQR is not readable.

1. Unit of Temperature and energy is not mentioned in

5 PDE-CMG-G00-DZ-0327
PQR
1. Unit of Temperature and energy is not mentioned in
6 PDE-CMG-G00-DZ-0332
PQR

1. Unit of Temperature and energy is not mentioned in PQR

7 PDE-CMG-G00-DZ-0337
2. Mill Test Certificate attached with PQR is not readable.

1. Unit of Temperature and energy is not mentioned in PQR

8 PDE-CMG-G00-DZ-0339 2. In RT Report Comments given by tkIS is not been revised.
3. Filler Metal Certificate is not attached in the PQR

1. Unit of Temperature and energy is not mentioned in PQR

9 PDE-CMG-G00-DZ-0341
2. RT report number mentioned in PQR is incorrect.

QW 170
1. Unit of Temperature and energy is not mentioned in PQR
.
2. In Welding Parameters Record, In Dimension section it is
mentioned as "Plate" and the actual dimension is not
10 PDE-CMG-G00-DZ-0509
Specified. 3. In Welding
Parameters Record, Batch/Lot No of filler metal is 18680
which is different from the attached Filler Metal Certificate
4. Visual Inspection report "BFI-LLM-PQR-VT-TK-012" is not
atatched with PQR
1. Visual Inspection report "BFI-LLM-PQR-VT-TK-009" is not
PDE-CMG-G00-DZ-0513
11 attached with PQR
1. Visual Inspection report "BFI-LLM-PQR-VT-TK-010" is not
PDE-CMG-G00-DZ-0515
12 attached with PQR
 1. QW-170, Value 63 mentioned in Toughness Test Column
is irrelevant 2.
PDE-CMG-G00-DZ-0517
Visual Inspection report "BFI-LLM-PQR-VT-TK-011" is not
13 attached with PQR
1. Visual Inspection report "BFI-LLM-PQR-VT-TK-007" is not
PDE-CMG-G00-DZ-0519
14 attached with PQR
1. Base Material Ceritificate attached with PQR is not
PDE-CMG-G00-DZ-0522
15 readable.
1. QW 170, Unit of Temperature and energy is not
mentioned in PQR .
PDE-CMG-G00-DZ-0531
2. Two Coupon used for Qualifcation Test results of which
16 coupon is used need to confirm
PQR, Base Metal and Filler Metal Certificates are not
PDE-CMG-G00-QC-0039
17 readable