You are on page 1of 4

TECHNCIAL COMMENTS SHEET

Strategic Reservoirs At Makkah Phase II &


Taif Phase I
Designer Name METSCOO
Document Reference - Comments Originator: Nethi Rajesh

Document Title Engineering document list Total no of Sheets. 3

Current Date 11-04-2018 Need Date of Response: 14-04-2018

Sl.no AICC comments METSCOO Response


Dated 11-04-2018 Dated xx-xx-xx
A General Comments.
All the document shall be presented in a scheduled form as
mentioned in the following sections
 Section 9 of QC10-H-049 M09 Steel Tanks-Rev6
A.1
 Section 7 of QC10-H-061 M21 Painting of Piping,
Equipment and Structural Steelwork-Rev2
METSCOO to revise the EDL according.
B Mechanical Comments.

The following documents is missing EDL under the section


Engineering Drawings and documents

 CFD analysis report for each tank (Passive mixing


system)
 hydraulic analysis of the inlet piping system for each
tank (Passive mixing system)
 Datasheet for passive mixing system
 Vendor Technical submittal for tank passive mixing
system
 Technical specification for aluminum dome roof
 Finite Element Analysis of roof structure
 Nozzle Orientation Drawing
 Tank shell structural and stiffness analysis software
B.1
report (shall include Detailed verification of each type
of structural element , Structural analysis for each type
of joint, the roof support detail, the roof panel and the
tension ring, roof calculation shall be based on the
actual tank layout , Tank interface design review for
dome roof and shell load )
 Shell Appurtenances details
 Roof Appurtenances details
 Logo and tank numbering details
 Drainage sumps and wear box details
Pipe Support Layout And Details
 Tank clean out door detail Drawings
 External and internal tank piping support calculation
report

4/1
TECHNCIAL COMMENTS SHEET
Strategic Reservoirs At Makkah Phase II &
Taif Phase I
Designer Name METSCOO
Document Reference - Comments Originator: Nethi Rajesh

Document Title Engineering document list Total no of Sheets. 3

Current Date 11-04-2018 Need Date of Response: 14-04-2018

 External and internal tank piping support details


 Tank annular plate development details drawing shall
be include along with Bottom & shell Plate
Development Layout for each tank
 Structural design criteria for steel tanks

METSCOO to check and indicate the same.

The following documents is missing EDL under the section


Calculations

B.2  Aluminum Dome Design Load & Reactions


 Forces During Dome Lifting

METSCOO to check and indicate the same.

The following documents is missing EDL under the section “


drawings of aluminum doom roof “

 Aluminum Dome general arrangement, top view


dome shall also incl. access hatch & pipe boot
 Aluminum Dome walkway & stairs detail and views
 Aluminum Dome walkway & stairs mounting detail
 Aluminum Dome walkway & stairs post assembly
detail
 Aluminum Dome typ. strut, gusset joint detail &
B.3 eyebolt
 Aluminum Dome typical gusset joint plan
 Aluminum Dome access hatch with stairs
 Aluminum Dome detail pipe boot vent pipe
 Aluminum Dome emergency relief vent
 Aluminum Dome top view lift plan
 Aluminum Dome lifting pneumatic & electric scheme
 Aluminum Dome Lifting Equipment Detail

METSCOO to check and indicate the same for each tank.

4/2
TECHNCIAL COMMENTS SHEET
Strategic Reservoirs At Makkah Phase II &
Taif Phase I
Designer Name METSCOO
Document Reference - Comments Originator: Nethi Rajesh

Document Title Engineering document list Total no of Sheets. 3

Current Date 11-04-2018 Need Date of Response: 14-04-2018

Any shop drawing shall include all the below details as per
Section 9 of QC10-H-049 M09 Steel Tanks-Rev6 and submit
for

A Material List
This document shall be presented in a scheduled form. It shall
be established from the nozzles list shown on the general
arrangement drawing, it shall include:
B.4 - Identification (or item), quantity and diameter of nozzles,
size, type, rating, facing and material of flanges.
- Schedule or thickness of nozzle necks
- Diameter, thickness of reinforcements
- Material, thickness and rating of blind flanges
- Size, quantity, thickness, rating, type and material of
gaskets
- Instrument end connection details.

Any calculation report shall include all the below notes as per
Section 9 of QC10-H-049 M09 Steel Tanks-Rev6 and submit
for

B Calculation Notes
Calculation notes shall be established by the Contractor for
B.5 each tank. These documents shall include full reference to
information sources (codes, formulas etc.) used for the
design.
They shall be transmitted for approval. The Engineer's
approval shall in no case relieve the Contractor from his
responsibilities.

Painting specification shall include all drawings and


documents as mentioned in Section 7 of QC10-H-061 M21
Painting of Piping, Equipment and Structural Steelwork-Rev2

- Material specifications, data sheets


B.6 - Painting schedules for all piping, equipment and structural
steelwork

- Final external Color Code details

- List of measuring equipment (dry film thickness, humidity,


temperature, etc.)

4/3
TECHNCIAL COMMENTS SHEET
Strategic Reservoirs At Makkah Phase II &
Taif Phase I
Designer Name METSCOO
Document Reference - Comments Originator: Nethi Rajesh

Document Title Engineering document list Total no of Sheets. 3

Current Date 11-04-2018 Need Date of Response: 14-04-2018

4/4

You might also like