Professional Documents
Culture Documents
FORMAT - 'S'
APPRAISAL MEMORANDUM
Note: 1. That the proposal have already been sanctioned by Central Bank of India , Jail Chungi Branch on
11-03-2005 as follows:
1. CC (Hyp. of Stock) Rs. 10 Lacs
2. Term Loan Fresh
Against Land Rs. 62.50 Lacs
Against Building Rs.22.50 Lacs Rs. 85 Lacs
The Party have already been taken up a term loan of Rs. 62.50 Lacs against land and the party had
purchased a land measuring 2724.17 sq. mtrs valued Rs. 127 Lacs including stamp duty on 16-04-2005
and started his construction for building for setting up a Petrol Pump of Reliance Industries Ltd. in their
supervision and direction.
2. We have canvassed the party to shift their proposal in our bank by offering the enhanced credit facilities
as above . Our AGM Sh. Alreja Ji has also visited the site and satisfied with the proposal and directed to go
ahead.
The proposal falls within the power of DGM as
1.4 Activity
Dealer for Reliance Outlet* by setting up a petrol pump at Major Dhyan Chand Nagar, Main Delhi
Road, Meerut.
Activity –
Dealer for Reliance Outlet* by setting up Group/promoters 1. Sh. Yogesh Chandra
a petrol pump at Major Dhyan Chand
Nagar, Main Delhi Road, Meerut.
CEO Sh. Yogesh Chandra
Date of
Incorporation - August 1, 2004
Banking with us GROP Nil
since/new EXPOSURE
connection* Take over from Central
Bank of India, Jail Chungi, Meerut
Date of last FB 130 Lacs
Renewal : Not Applicable
NFB Nil
Total 130 Lacs
Total (indebtedness) Nil 130
Investments Nil
Leasing Nil
Total (exposure) Nil 130
Note:
1. That the net sales are expected to increase atleast 5% per annum and estimated sales are calculated by
assuming 360 working days in a year and calculation of sales are as under:
2. That the firm is also planning to open a café and small departmental store as per specification and
direction of RIL therefore, we have planned to extension of building as and when required necessary
from our internal accruals. Hence, the above gross block shows a increasing value.
3. In spite of above all other ratios including TOL/TNW, Current Ratio as well as Cash accruals shows a
sound and satisfactory position of the firm.
Industry
Exposure : FBL
NFBL
Total
No. of units
Data Not Applicable
% of gross NF
C & I limits at C.
Centre
NPA amount
% age of NPAs to
exposure
Sh. Yogesh Chandra Gupta proprietor of M/s Lalsons Enterprises is a approved army contractor and general
order suppliers for last 20 years and effected sales 39.15 Lacs during the financial year 2003-04 and he applied for a
setting up a petrol pump on 30-08-2004 for appointment as dealer for Reliance Retail Outlet located at Delhi Road,
Meerut City (U.P.) Reliance Industries Ltd has already issued a letter of Indend (LOI) on 15-01-2005 for setting up a
petrol pump at Major Dhyan Chand Nagar, Delhi Road, Meerut by taking Rs. 3 Lacs in advance as signing amount and
proprietor have already purchased required land 2724.17 Sq. Mtr. at Major Dhyan Chand Nagar, Delhi Road, Meerut for
amounting to Rs. 127.00 Lacs and construction of Building have already been started.
The proprietor of M/s Lalsons Enterprises have already been obtained NOC from Distt. Fire Officer Meerut, Distt..
Supply Officer Meerut, Director of Industries Meerut copy of NOC’s is enclosed for your kind reference.
5. Performance & financials (whether overall financial condition is considered satisfactory including trends in sales,
profitability, tangible networth, TOL/TNW and current ratio- No. descriptive Remarks to attempted):
Proprietor have a good reputation in Meerut, being a new proposal/establishment past records of the unit are not
available.
As we all know that these petroleum products are used to run two wheelers, motorcars, commercial vehicles, etc
and during last few years the consumption of these petroleum products had increasing very drastically as the number of
vehicles on road had increased too much. Further, the future scope of these petroleum products is also very bright as
there is no substitute to it.
Detailed Survey regarding market of the proposed products have been conducted by the Reliance Industries
Limited. Copy of the survey report with Central Bank of India, Jail Chungi Meerut it would be available after the takeover
of the proposal. The loacation of the site is highly suitable being the existing developed area. The firm has decided to
open a Coffee Shop and a Small level Departmental Store having emphasis on confectionery & other eatable products at
a later stage.
It would be pertinent to mention here that there is no petrol pump in the density of 3 to 5 km at the side of
proposed petrol pump.
7. Fund flow analysis: (only brief observations, regarding cash accruals vis-à-vis projections, repayment of TLs,
infusion of E/QE, investment in FA/Dividends, retention of profits and diversion if any).
The firm is engaged in petroleum products which are generally sold out in cash and estimated sales projection in
the coming years are very lower side because firm has estimated sales of 1000 Ltr. of Petrol and 10000 of Ltr. Diesal per
day. Keeping in view the situation of petrol pump it is very very justified. Hence, cash accruals as estimated in CMA are
nearby actuals because dealer firm will earn Rs. 1.20 on Diesal and Rs. 0.80 on Petrol and all the future expenditure has
already been considered including salaries to sales delivery men electricity, generator exp., repair & maintenance and
other selling expenses.
Keeping in view the cash accruals of the firm, and DSCR during the financially year 2006-07 to 2012-13 which is
not less than 1.84 and average DSCR 1.88, the repayment of term loan will be made easily. The proprietor will withdraw
only a small amount for his house hold exp. And most of the profits will be retained in the firm.
8. Term Loan/DPG : (where applicable) The proposed term loan is considered acceptable in terms of the detailed
appraisal as per Annexure-I
9. Working capital assessment : (The proposed working capital facilities are considered acceptable in terms of the
detailed appraisal as per annexure-II
The proposal has already been sanctioned by Central Bank of India, Jail Chungi, Meerut and we have canvassed
to the party to shift their account in our bank.
The proposal will fall under the scheme of setting up a petrol pump of Reliance Industries vide circular no.
dated
10.4 Details of retail banking / any other business generated through the account.
Bank’s sign board will be displayed on the premises of petrol pump which will attract the retail business.
10.6 Use of provisional/un-audited data - In case earlier renewal / encashment was based on provisional / un-audited
data whether review with audited data, as specified was carried out and appropriate steps initiated?
Not Applicable
10.8 Loan Policy guidelines The following quantitative parameters as set out in the loan Policy Document have been
examined:
If any of the above indicative minimum/maximum parameters is not met by the company, please state whether it is
considered acceptable (only brief comments):
In addition to debt/equity ratio are within acceptable level and shows a sound position of the firm. Keeping in view
the unsecured loans from relatives and friends which is part and parcel of equity because these unsecured loans will not
be the paid till the continuances of the bank term loan therefore unsecured loans should be treated as a equity/capital.
Hence, debt/equity ratio would be 0.92 only which is highly acceptable.
10.10 Whether
a) the name of the company/directors appears in RBI's list of defaulters/RBI's list of defaulters / RBI's list of
willful defaulters: : NO
We confirm that the Board approved Bank's policy regarding granting of facilities to the company has been strictly
followed and granting of facilities to M/s Lalsons Enterprises is acceptable to the Bank.
10.11 Status of auditor's remarks, which have an impact on credit risk on the unit
M/s Lalsons Enterprises is a proprietorship firm and corporate governance are not applicable but all policies of
corporate governance will be followed.
There are no past record available in our bank. Hence, conducting of account could not be comment.
10.14 Details of other borrowing arrangements and defaults, if any (excluding information given under credit limits on
page 1)
Nil
10.15 Comparison of pricing and other terms and conditions with SBI/Associate Banks
10.16 Legal Compliance Certificate : Legal compliance certificate will be obtained after sanction.
10.17 CIBIL clause (state whether stipulated in the terms) : will be obtained
The firm is going to setup a petrol pump of Reliance Industries Ltd. and projected cost of Building and other fixed
assets have been analysied by Reliance Industires Ltd. and detailed market survey conducted by M/s Reliacne Industries
Ltd and a copy of letter indend has been issued to the party by taking Rs. 3 Lacs as signing amount. Further the Central
Bank of India sanctioned a term loan of Rs. 85 Lacs i.e. Rs. 62.50 Lacs purchasing a Land and Rs. 22.50 Lacs against
building at a margin of 50%. We have considered the cost of building Rs. 50 Lacs cost and recommended as follows:
1. Term Loan against Land Rs. 62.50 Lacs with a margin of 50%
2. Term Loan against Building Rs. 30.00 Lacs with a margin of 40%
3. Security/Advance payment to RIL Rs. 17.50 Lacs with a margin of 25%
2. Working Capital
Keeping in view the holding level of stock as well as debtors. The firm has to invest heavy funds in working capital
of the business and the firm has to maintained a level of stock for smooth running of our business. Therefore, we
recommend a working capital limit of CC(H) Rs. 20.00 Lacs with a sub limit of 10 Lacs against book debts not older than
30 days.
Calculation of Average Stock
Diesal
Normal 40000 20000 31.27 625400
Premium 40000 20000 33.12 662400
Lubricants
Mobile Oils, Lubricants etc. 585000
Total 2750000
15. Pre-Sanction visit comments: Pre-Sanction visit was conducted by Branch Manager alongwith Field Officer.
16. Comments on opinion Report of Existing Banker (s) if any:
Existing banker Central bank of India Jail Chungi, Meerut will try their best to retain his accounts but and their
opinion are seems to be good.
Signature :
Date:
Place:
Annexure – I
ZONE : Delhi - III
Branch : Meerut City
Company : M/s LALSONS ENTERPRISES
Term Loan/DPG :
The investment in Land have already been incurred of Rs. 127 Lacs while the projected cost of Construction of
Building of Rs. 50 Lacs are estimated by Reliance Industries Ltd.’s architect and detailed map have already been
submitted for your kind reference which was also appraised by Central Bank of India and the detailed architect estimate
was submitted to Central Bank of India and Rs. 5 Lacs approx. for interest of construction period has been estimated
which will be capitalized in the cost of building.
The cost of Plant & Machinery Rs. 2 Lacs includes, DG Set, Water cooler, Air Compressor Machine and other
tools which is required smooth running of petrol pump.
The cost of other assets Rs. 25.50 Lacs includes Rs. 23.50 Lacs of security/advance payment to Reliance
Industries Ltd. and Rs. 2 Lacs for computer, fax, furniture & fixture etc.
g) Production factors
The petrol pump is not a production unit, it is a retail outlet of M/s Reliance Industries Ltd. located on national
highway Delhi Meerut Road, Meerut and is surrounding by well developed industrial area as well as well developed new
colonies.
h) Marketing
The firm will perform its activity under the proprietorship of Shri Yogesh Chandra and will be trading in various
petroleum products viz Petrol, Diesel, Mobile Oils, Lubricants, etc. These petroleum products are extensively used to run
two wheelers, motor cars, commercial vehicles, etc. During last few years the consumption of these petroleum products
had increasing very drastically as the number of vehicles on road had increased too much. Further, the future scope of
these petroleum products is also very bright as there is no subsitute to it and there is no petrol pump within two three five
K.M. in the side of proposed unit. Hence, no problem for selling the petroleum products.
The gross DSCR are continuously increasing this seems to a strong position of the firm and the minimum gross
DSCR 1.55 have been increased upto 2.01 while the net DSCR Average is 1.88 which is more than the acceptable level.
j) Security margin
Particulars
WDV of fixed assets
Agg. TL/DPG outstanding
Security margin available
% of margin
1. Term Loan
The firm is going to setup a petrol pump of Reliance Industries Ltd. and projected cost of Building and other fixed
assets have been analysied by Reliance Industires Ltd. and detailed market survey conducted by M/s Reliacne Industries
Ltd and a copy of letter indend has been issued to the party by taking Rs. 3 Lacs as signing amount. Further the Central
Bank of India sanctioned a term loan of Rs. 85 Lacs i.e. Rs. 62.50 Lacs purchasing a Land and Rs. 22.50 Lacs against
building at a margin of 50%. We have considered the cost of building Rs. 50 Lacs cost and recommended as follows:
1. Term Loan against Land Rs. 62.50 Lacs with a margin of 50%
2. Term Loan against Building Rs. 30.00 Lacs with a margin of 40%
3. Security/Advance payment to RIL Rs. 17.50 Lacs with a margin of 25%
Annexure-II
Assessment of WC facilities
(If the assessment of the WC limits is based on any other parametrs, please specify them
alongwith an explanation)
P P P P
Particulars 31-03-2007 31-12-2008 31-03-2009 31-03-2010
Net sales to total tangible assets (times) 5.10 5.23 5.34 5.44
PBT to total tangible assets (%) 8.87 9.67 10.41 11.11
Operating cost to sales (%) 97.56 97.55 97.55 97.56
Bank finance to CA (%) 24.91 22.78 20.78 18.96
Inventory + receivables to net sales
(days) 14 15 16 17
All the above ratios shows a improving position of the firm. While inventory+receivable to net sales (days) a
slightly go up by one day in one year, which is acceptable due to increase in working of the firm.
Petrol
Normal 20000 10000 43.08 430800
Premium 20000 10000 44.64 446400
Diesal
Normal 40000 20000 31.27 625400
Premium 40000 20000 33.12 662400
Lubricants
Mobile Oils, Lubricants etc. 585000
Total 2750000
Keeping in view the above calculation CC Limit of Rs. 20 Lacs are justified and acceptable with a sub limit of Rs.
10 Lacs against book debts not older than 30 days.
Annexure – III
ZONE : Delhi - III
Company : M/s Lalsons Enterprises
A. Security
Term Commercial Land at 1. Equitable Mortgage of Residential House situated Personal guarantee of Smt. Sushma
Loan – I Major Dhyan Chadn at A-4, Jawahar Quarters, Begum Bridge Road, Chandra W/o Sh. Yogesh Chandra
Rs. 62.50 Nagar, Main Delhi Meerut measuring around 306.85 Sq. Mrts. In the Net worth 66.60 Lacs as on 31-03-
Lacs Raod, Meerut. name of Sh. Yogesh Chandra valued Rs. 71.16 2005
Measuring 2724.17 as per valuation report dated 21-02-2005.
sq. mtr. in the name of 2. Equitable Mortgage of Residential House situated
Sh. Yogesh Chandra at 94-E, Jawahar Quarters, Begum Bridge Road,
S/o Late Sh. Nursing Meerut measuring around 160.00 Sq. Mts. In the
Bihari Lal R/o A-4, name of Sh. Yogesh Chandra. Valued Rs. 9.52
Jawahar Quarters, Lacs as pr valuation report dated 21-02-2005
Kutchery Road, 3. Shop No. 15/6 at Part of Banglow 47/H1-New 20
Meerut valued Rs. Jawahar Quarters, Civil Lines, Meerut. Valued Rs.
127.00 Lacs 4.05 Lacs as per valuation report dated 21-02-
2005
4. Equitable mortgage of commercial property
Term Building to be situated at Shop no. 16 part of Banglow 47/H-1,
Loan - II constructed for (Old) 20 New Jawahar Quarters, Meerut city in
Rs. 30.00 amounting to Rs. 50 the name of Sh. Yogesh Chandra valued Rs. 3.96
Lacs Lacs at Major Dhyan lacs as per valuation report dated 21-02-2005
Chand Nagar, Main
Delhi Road, Meerut.
Term Security/Advance
Loan – III payment to RIL of Rs.
Rs. 17.50 23.50 Lacs
Lacs
New Proposal
Justification for deviation from existing margins, if any to be provided in the proposal under item 13.
The Central Bank of India has sanctioned a fund based limit of Rs. 95 Lacs which is in the Regional Manager and
considered the margins 50% for building. While we have considered a reasonable margin of 40% against construction of
building and 25 % margin for against security/advance payment RIL.
D. Rate of interest (Floating): 7.5% per annum on monthly rest as per circular no. dated
Note: Any change in the terms and conditions should be justified in the proposal under item 13.
Annexure – D
Review, based on audited financials, of credit limits earlier renewed / enhanced on the basis of provisional / un-
audited data NOT APPLICABLE BEING A NEW UNIT
5. Sanctioned by :
9. Quality aspects
9.1 Any significant deviations observed from the provisional / un-audited data submitted earlier which may have
impact on company’s credit worthiness.
NIL
9.2 Any adverse comments by the company’s auditors having impact on the company’s credit worthiness
NIL
9.3 Any adverse comments in the Credit Audit, I & A, Statutory Audit, RBI inspection subsequent to the renewal /
enhancement.
NOT APPLICABLE.
9.4 Indications on achievement of the estimated performance as observed from quaterly/half yearly data.
NOT APPLICABLE.
A) Term Laon
1. Term Loan against Land Rs. 62.50 Lacs
2.Term Loan against Building Rs. 30.00 Lacs
3.Term Loan for security to RIL Rs. 17.50 Lacs
Other Stipulations:
1. The Term loan for construction of Petrol pump building should be disbursed in three stages. After completing the
every stage the company will submit architect’s certificate for completing of work alongwith cost incurred for the
same with provisional Balance Sheet duly verified by C.A. The branch shall make an inspection and after
satisfying about the progress of construction and end use of the amount already disbursed, may disburse the
installment for the subsequent stage of construction. The company shall also submit bills/receipts in taken of
having incurred such expenses. After completion of the construction in final certificate form architech shall be
obtained within 10 days for the due completion of work with the senior manager finance inspection report to this
effect. Inspection report of Senior Manager of the branch should be submitted before the disbursement of
installment of the the term loan.
2. Book Debt finance will be granted only against Book Debts pertaining to first class parties.
3. Drawings will be allowed only against paid-up stocks.
4. The company will deal withus exclusively.
5. Branch Manager will ensure, before release, to obtain legal opinion reports in respect of properties accepted as
collateral securities and will also ensure that valid equitable mortgage is created
6. General Terms and conditions as applicable to such advances will also apply.
Date:
Branch Head:
Controlling Authority
FORMAT “AS”
( To be used as appraisal note for reviews, ad hoc limits, corporate loans, interchangeability, changes in security / margin
and other matters. For corporate loan, repayment schedule and DSCR are to be furnished.)
2. CRA:
The Party have already been taken up a term loan of Rs. 62.50 Lacs against land and the party had
purchased the land of Rs. 127 Lacs including stamp duty on 16-04-2005 and started his construction for
building for setting up a Petrol Pump of Reliance Industries Ltd. in their supervision and direction.
3. We have canvassed the party to shift their proposal in our bank by offering the above credit facilities. Our
AGM Sh. Alreja Ji has also visited the site and satisfied with the proposal and directed to go ahead.
6.2 The proposal falls within the powers of DGM because total credit facilities required 130 Lacs submitted for
sanction.
7. Indebtedness/Exposure :
(Rs. In lacs)
Indebtedness Existing as on 30-06-2005 Proposed
Fund based Nil 20
Non fund based Nil 110
Total (indebtedness) Nil 130
Leasing Nil Nil
Investments Nil Nil
Total Exposure Limits Nil 130
8.Financial arrangement :
(sole banking /consortium/multiple banking) : Sole Banking
Industry
Exposure
- FB DATA NOT AVAILABLE
- NFB
Total number of units
% of gross non food credit
NPA in the exposure
% age of NPA
10. Security
i) Primary
Security margin
Nature Existing Proposed
Working Capital Limit
Hypothecation of all kind of stock 25%
such as petrol, diesal, lubricants
and other goods.
33.33 %
Receivables (cover 30 days)
Letter of credit (Import)
Term Loan
Against Land 50%
Against Building 40%
Against Security/Advance 25%
Payment
ii) Collateral
i) Gurantee
Justification for change, if any, from the existing position: New Proposal
The firm is going to setup a petrol pump of Reliance Industries Ltd. and projected cost of Building and other fixed
assets have been analysied by Reliance Industires Ltd. and detailed market survey conducted by M/s Reliacne Industries
Ltd and a copy of letter indend has been issued to the party by taking Rs. 3 Lacs as signing amount. Further the Central
Bank of India sanctioned a term loan of Rs. 85 Lacs i.e. Rs. 62.50 Lacs purchasing a Land and Rs. 22.50 Lacs against
building at a margin of 50%. We have considered the cost of building Rs. 50 Lacs cost and recommended as follows:
4. Term Loan against Land Rs. 62.50 Lacs with a margin of 50%
5. Term Loan against Building Rs. 30.00 Lacs with a margin of 40%
6. Security/Advance payment to RIL Rs. 17.50 Lacs with a margin of 25%
2. Working Capital
Keeping in view the holding level of stock as well as debtors. The firm has to invest heavy funds in working capital
of the business and the firm has to maintained a level of stock for smooth running of our business. Therefore, we
recommend a working capital limit of CC(H) Rs. 20.00 Lacs with a sub limit of 10 Lacs against book debts not older than
30 days.
(We confirm that the Board approved Bank’s Policy regarding granting of facilities to the company has been
strictly following and granting of facilities of M/s Lalsons Enterprises is acceptable to the Bank”
13. Recommended for sanction /approval/confirmation/submitted for control : (In case of control report, date of
sanction and sanctioning authority to be indicated) :
Place :
Date :
Nil
ANNEXURE ‘A’
INDICATIVE CHECKLIST
- If it is a running unit
- Details of its existing borrowing arrangements
- Past performance – 3 years financial statements
- Details of major shareholders