Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Bimonthly Publication of the Kern-Kaweah Chapter of the Sierra Club — July/August 2006
IN CONCLUSION. The real strength of the Sierra Club is its thousands of grass roots activists. They
don’t set their priorities based on edicts from on high. They work on issues most important to them
personally. You don’t try to tell Sierra Club activists what to work on. We like to pick our own fights.
Those of us who have devoted our lives to protecting Wilderness and public lands will continue that
work. We won’t disappoint John Muir. It is up to our elected leadership to adopt carefully considered
policies and allocate resources in a balanced manner. And it is up to us in the grass roots ranks to make
our voices heard. Be ready to speak up now!
BUSH ADMINISTRATION YANKS SEQUOIA’S FIRE PLAN
A year ago, in response to a lawsuit filed by the State Attorney General, a federal judge found the
Plan violated requirements for environmental study and public participation and ordered the Forest
Service to comply with law. The Forest Service issued another Fire Plan without the required
environmental documents, hoping new wording would take them off the hook as to the need to comply
with environmental laws. When it appeared that strategy would fail, the Bush Administration responded
by pulling the Plan with no intent to issue another.
The Forest Service contends that their Fire Plan made no land management decisions but was only
administrative, pulling together directions already existing in other documents and spelling out the
logistics for the use and response to fire. If this had been the case, there would have been no basis for a
lawsuit.
In actuality, the Fire Plan was far more than a mere fire response planning document; it also prede-
termined where prescribed burning and prescribed natural fire (“let burn” of naturally caused wild fire)
could occur and where mechanical thinning would be the only method allowed for treating fuel build-up.
In the fire-dependent, fire-deprived, and fire-prone Sierra Nevada and sequoia groves, such decisions
should have been accompanied by a full environmental discussion, consideration of scientific research,
and public involvement. But the Fire Plan was signed in the back office with no documentation whatso-
ever for the public to review.
The Sierra Club, Tule River Conservancy, Sequoia Forest Keeper and other organizations filed a law-
suit against the Management Plan for the Giant Sequoia National Monument in part because the Plan
relied almost totally on logging as a management tool and as a strategy for funding “restoration.” The
Monument Plan disallowed a discussion about where and when fire could be used in the Monument,
saying such decisions were already made in their earlier (but non-public) Fire Plan.
It was totally inappropriate to predetermine the use of fire and the reliance on logging in the
Monument, particularly since fire and the use of fire is one of the most important aspects of management
and protection of the giant sequoia ecosystem. The Monument Plan had little or no discussion of fire
strategies such as those carried out by the adjacent Sequoia and Kings Canyon National Parks. All
scientific studies indicate that the use of fire, not logging, results in a fire-resistant forest, nutrient
recycling, seed scarification, disease control, with less impacts to species and soils. There was no
discussion of these elements regarding fire’s role in the Sequoia Monument Plan and EIS.
We are expecting the judge to rule on our Sequoia Monument Plan lawsuit in midsummer.
The Forest Service and those who are opposed to our concerns with management of the Monument
are likely to portray the withdrawal of the Fire Plan as evidence that our challenges to the Forest Service
somehow jeopardize the forest. The truth is that the portion of the Fire Plan that deals with response to
fire and protection of the public is spelled out in many other Forest Service regulations and policies. The
Forest operated with no Fire Plan at all from 1988 until 2002.
The 1988 Land Management Plan for Sequoia National Forest directed that a Fire and Fuels Manage-
ment Plan be written as an amendment to the Forest Plan. A decade later, the National Fire Plan called
for every National Forest to have a Fire Plan, but it is unclear whether or not the Forest Service is
violating a law by choosing to not have one. If they have one, it must be prepared in accordance with
environmental law. Clearly the administration would rather have no Fire Plan at all than to allow
scientific and public scrutiny into the process of developing one. - Carla Cloer, Sequoia Task Force
THE ROADRUNNER 3
MIDGEBUZZINGS
SINCE THE middle 80’s in this country we have increasingly confronted the “super-size” phenomenon.
Borrowing from the hamburger king’s vision of American preferences, we’ve begun calling super-sized
things McThis and McThat: McTrucks and SUV’s, McMeals, McAirliner seats and, worst of all,
McMansions. I have even encountered the phenomenon when trying to replace drinking glasses for the
dinner table. It’s difficult to find anything under what can only be called the Big Gulp size. Environ-
mentalists are appalled by the voracious use of natural resources in our pursuit of the biggest of
everything. However, the national Sierra Magazine, two issues ago, took on the subject for an altogether
different reason, and it is mainly that which I want to bring to your attention now.
Recently I returned from a visit with friends in Virginia. They have lived for years in a charming home
on a quiet street in the town of Fairfax. There they raised their family, enjoyed their neighbors, and
delighted in the serenity of the community. Arriving at their home I was entirely unprepared for a shock.
The houses on both sides have been torn down and replaced by generic McMansions, not only hideously
ugly, but also occupying all but a tiny bit of the property. They have literally been built from one side of
the property to the other, and from the back to the front, leaving no more than a patch of ground between
the houses and the sidewalk. Apparently the reason for this is the same for all these projects. Developers,
running short of land for the customary sprawl, construct these monsters in existing neighborhoods,
selling them, ostensibly, to single families. Then two or three other families move in claiming to be
relatives. The resulting traffic and noise destroy the quality of life so that people like my friends are
forced to sell their homes as well.
This appears to be happening all over the country, and I’m sorry to report that it has begun even in my
neighborhood, which I think is the loveliest in Bakersfield. We have been especially blessed here with
distance from any major traffic thoroughfare, and our northern boundary is a bluff that overlooks a large
nature preserve beside the Kern River so that we enjoy unusual quiet in an otherwise noisy world.
However, several years ago one such McMansion was built on a beautiful street west of mine, with a
result somewhat similar to what I saw in Fairfax. Walking by it this morning I counted six cars, not
including those no doubt parked in the McGarage. As it happens the occupants are quiet, and the house
is at the end of the street so that one is not aware of it until he is almost there. Had it been built in mid-
block, the quality of the street would have been ruined. Only those neighborhoods with association rules
are safe from this phenomenon since there is no county ordinance to prevent it. Be assured that no one
THE ROADRUNNER 5
living outside such an association in Kern County is protected, regardless of the quality and value of the
homes in his neighborhood.
According to Sierra Magazine, Arlington County in Virginia has been quick to put a stop to the plague
so apparent in neighboring Fairfax County. They have legalized an ordinance making it impossible for
anyone to build or rebuild a house that takes up more than 25 percent of the property. If we in Kern
County can stop irresponsible building as we seem to be doing now in the Northeast Bakersfield.
Perhaps we can consider such an ordinance for the good of us all. It’s worth talking about.
- Ann Williams
GOOD NEWS CLIPS
STEELWORKERS JOIN SIERRA CLUB to promote economic equity and environmental sustainability.The
850,000-member steelworkers union and the 750,000-member Sierra Club have joined to work together
to further these causes. Carl Pope said, “Our new alliance allows us to address the great challenge of the
global economy in the 21st century—how to provide good jobs, a clean environment and a safer world.”
A step forward!
Tejon Industrial Complex Challenged Again by Center of Biological Diversity (CBD). In 2004
CBD and others successfully challenged Kern County’s environmental report for the Industrial Complex
project, a 1000-acre project proposed for the south end of the Valley. In March 2006, Kern County court
concluded that the County had addressed the original report’s defects. CBD disagrees. One trigger for
this second suit relates to a deal struck between the project’s developer, Tejon Ranch Co., and the San
Joaquin Valley Air Pollution Control District. More news about this later.
Condor Group MORE INFO? call Mary Ann Lockhart, 661.242.0432. PMC DATES
AND TIMES FOR ALL Condor Gp HIKES: Fourth Saturday of each month, 8 AM. Persons planning to hike with us need
to call ahead of time to indicate they are coming. Meeting place is the parking lot of Pine Mountain Club’s clubhouse in Pine
Mountain Club. Call Leader, Dale Chitwood, 661.242.1076, More info? Barb Nusbaum, 661.242.1843 or Mary Ann
Lockhart, 661.242.0432.
July 22 (Sat) Our wonderful Peak to Peak Hike. The trail goes between Mt. Pinos and Cerro Noroeste, 8
miles of beautiful views, clean air, altitude over 8000 ft. Strenuous. Starts at 8 AM from PMC. Must call
ahead as some car-pooling may be involved.
August 5 (Sat) Mountain Lions. Presenter from Mountain Lions Association will provide information
on this magnificent animal, which is encountered in this area. Potluck 6 PM, Program 7 PM in the Pine
Mountain Clubhouse. Pine Mountain Club.
August 28th (Sat) Toad Springs Trail. This close-at-hand trail will lead to the area of a big slide that
closed off the further side of the trail. We will discuss the hows and whys of such slides, predictions for
the future. Moderate. Please, no children under 16 years. Meet at 8 AM at PMC tennis courts.
Mineral King Group Visalia. More info? call Kim Loeb, 559.798.1764
Please visit mineralking.sierraclub.org for more info on our events and activities
July 8 (Sat) 9 AM – Outing – Day hike to Mist Falls out of Cedar Grove in Kings Canyon National
Park. Moderate 8-mile round trip hike along the beautiful Kings River. The hike will begin at Roads
End in Cedar Grove at 9 AM. The ride from Visalia takes about 21/2 half hours so we will camp there
Friday evening. Those who wish to camp with us are welcome. Any who plan to camp and/or do the
hike must call Leaders Joanne and David at 559.733-2078 or Allen at 559.739.8087 by Friday, June 29.
July 12 (Wed) 6 PM Dinner Social at Keo Thip Restaurant, 619 Murray Ave. Visalia. Please RSVP
to Bev at 559.732.3785 or gmachine@psnw.com.
July 24 (Mon) 5:30 PM Executive Committee Meeting at Baker’s Square Restaurant, 3301 S. Mooney
Blvd., Visalia. All members welcome. To RSVP, contact Bev at 559.732.3785 or gmachine@
psnw.comJuly 29 (Sat) 8 AM – Outing – A day at Grant Grove. Sequoia National Park. Designed to
be an easy hike or series of short hikes; final choices will be made on the trip to Sequoia. Possibilities:
Spend the day in the Grove, take the Big Stump Trail (easy 2 miles; goes through the Converse Basin
Grove of downed trees), the Hitchcock Meadow Trail (easy 2.6 miles; goes to a waterfall) and/or the
North Grove and Dead Giant Loops (easy 2.5 miles; Grant Grove and logged areas). If we are more
ambitious there are a few moderate 4–6 mile hikes in the area. Meet at 8 AM at Martha’s Vineyard by
the Taco Bell. Leaders Joanne and David at 559.733.2078 or Allen at 559.739.8087. Inform by Friday,
June 29.
August 9 (Wed) 6 PM – Dinner Social at Black Bear Diner, 1161 E Tulare Ave., Tulare. Please RSVP
to Bev at 559.732.3785 or gmachine@psnw.com.
August 19 (Sat) 8 AM – Outing – The Lakes Trail – a moderate 6–8 mile hike to Heather Lake. On
the way up, we will pass by the Watchtower and look down on Tokopah Falls. We could take the Hump
Trail back, which is a somewhat shorter and steeper (going downhill). Meet at 8 AM at Martha’s
Vineyard by the Taco Bell. More info? Leaders Joanne and David at 559.733.2078 and Allen at
559.739.8087.
August 28 (Mon) 5:30 PM – Executive Committee Meeting at Baker’s Square Restaurant, 3301 S.
Mooney Blvd., Visalia. All members welcome. To RSVP, contact Bev at 559.732.3785 or gmachine@
psnw.comSave the date: Oct 2 (Sat) 7 AM – Outing – Day trip to and hikes at Glacier Point in Yo-
semite National Park. We will meet at 7 AM in the parking lot by Taco Bell in Martha’s Vineyard. We
plan to do two short hikes with beautiful and unique views of Yosemite Valley without all the crowds of
Yosemite Valley. Call Leaders Joanne and David at 559.733.2078 or Allen at 559.739.8087 for details.
Owens Peak Group More general and hike info? call Leaders Dennis Burge,
760.375.7967, Jim Nichols, 760.375.8161. email: dennis93555@yahoo.com Meets in
Ridgecrest, Maturango Museum
July 15 (Sat) ARMY PASS POINT AND LOOP (point is .7 mi ENE of New Army Pass; 12360+ ft
elevation; gain 2640 ft; 14.4 mi RT) This is a reschedule of a hike we were rained out of 2 years ago.
The hike will loop up over Old Army Pass and climb Army Pass Point, which dominates the
Cottonwood Lakes. We will (optionally) descend a fine lost route used by Carl Heller, E of the New
Army Pass trail, that shortens the descent from New Army Pass. This old shortcut E of New Army Pass
trail needs to be rediscovered. Army Pass Point is visible from everywhere in the Cottonwood Basin and
provides great photo opportunities of the Basin. Should be interesting, and a good workout. Call Leaders
Dennis Burge at 760.375.7967 or Jim Nichols at 760.375.8161 for more info.
Aug 19 (Sat) EAST DRAGON LAKES (11401 ft elevation; 2200 ft gain; 4.8 mi RT) These lakes,
situated .5 mi E of Dragon Peak, are the jumping off places for climbing Dragon peak and crossing the
Sierra Crest at Dragon Pass. Knowledge of this route needs to be a part of every Sierra hiker’s bag of
tricks. The lakes are gorgeous, the flowers should be in full bloom, and the hike is not too strenuous for
8 THE ROADRUNNER
August, when we are all in good shape. “E Dragon Lakes” are reached N out of Onion Valley. Moderate
hike. Meet Sat, Aug 19 at 7:30 AM at the Ridgecrest Cinema parking lot. Call Leaders Dennis Burge at
760.375.7967 or Jim Nichols at 760.375.8161 for more info.
Meetings: All Sierra Club members welcome to attend. Call Chair to verify meeting times, places.