Professional Documents
Culture Documents
11
FUTURES:
Trading multiple
systems p. 10
OIL’S
slippery slope p. 39
SPREAD TRADING
with the A-D line p. 22
PROFITABLE
delta-neutral trading p. 14
BASICS:
The put-call ratio p. 24
CONTENTS
Trading Basics
Put-call ratio . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .24
This widely watched indicator compares the
activity in put options to call options.
Learn about its variations and uses.
By Chris Peters
News
Contributors . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .5 More exchanges move toward
electronic platforms . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .26
Market Movers . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .6 The CBOE and the MGEX move toward
Futures markets are down across the board all-electronic platforms as open outcry gets even
as traders and investors divest themselves quieter.
of holdings.
CME Group offerings expand with
Trading Strategies plastics, swaps contracts . . . . . . . . . . . . . .27
Two systems are better than one . . . . . . .10 Merc keeps the new-contract spigot open.
Combining multiple trading systems can
improve the performance of your portfolio.
continued on p. 4
By Richard Weissman
TM
TM
Rated Best for: Frequent Traders H Options Traders H International Traders H Trading Technology H Trade Experience
/VERALL "EST /NLINE "ROKER
Stocks Options Futures Forex Member NYSE, FINRA, NFA and SIPC
IMPORTANT INFORMATION: No offer or solicitation to buy or sell securities, securities derivative or futures products of any kind, or any type of trading or investment advice,
recommendation or strategy, is made, given or in any manner endorsed by TradeStation Securities, Inc. or any of its affiliates. • Past performance, whether actual or indicated by
historical tests of strategies, is no guarantee of future performance or success. • Active trading is generally not appropriate for someone of limited resources, limited investment
or trading experience, or low-risk tolerance. • There is a risk of loss in futures trading. Options and Security Futures trading is not suitable for all investors. Please visit our Web site
for relevant risk disclosures. • System access and trade placement and execution may be delayed or fail due to market volatility and volume, quote delays, system and software
errors, Internet traffic, outages and other factors. • All proprietary technology in TradeStation is owned by TradeStation Technologies, Inc., an affiliate of TradeStation Securities,
Inc. • Trading foreign exchange carries a high level of risk and may not be suitable for all investors. There is a possibility that you may sustain a loss equal to or greater than
your entire investment; therefore, you should not invest or risk money that you cannot afford to lose. You should be aware of all risks associated with foreign exchange trading.
Barron’s awards are based on a review of TradeStation’s brokerage products and services by a Barron’s journalist. Barron’s is a registered trademark of Dow Jones & Company.
Leader in Rule-Based Trading tag line based on industry awards and reviews. © 2008 TradeStation Securities, Inc. All rights reserved.
CONTENTS
Ablesys PFGBEST.com
eSignal RS of Houston
OptionsMentoring
Ad sales over the U.S., Asia, and Australia on behalf of the CBOE’s
West Coast and Southwest only: Options Institute, the Options Industry Council, and
Allison Chee
achee@futuresandoptionstrader.com
the Australian Stock Exchange. As a mentor for
DsicoverOptions.com, he teaches select students how to use complex
Classified ad sales: Mark Seger
options strategies and develop a consistent trading plan. Lentz is con-
seger@futuresandoptionstrader.com
stantly developing new strategies on the use of options as part of a com-
Volume 2, Issue 11. Futures & Options Trader is pub- prehensive profitable trading approach. He regularly speaks at special
lished monthly by TechInfo, Inc., 161 N. Clark Street,
Suite 4915, Chicago, IL 60601. Copyright © 2008
TechInfo, Inc. All rights reserved. Information in this
events, trade shows, and trading group organizations.
publication may not be stored or reproduced in any
form without written permission from the publisher.
The information in Futures & Options Trader magazine Jim Graham (advisor@optionvue.com) is the product
is intended for educational purposes only. It is not
meant to recommend, promote, or in any way imply manager for OptionVue Systems and a registered invest-
the effectiveness of any trading system, strategy, or
approach. Traders are advised to do their own ment advisor for OptionVue Research.
research and testing to determine the validity of a trad-
ing idea. Trading and investing carry a high level of
risk. Past performance does not guarantee future
results.
Energy
Last month
crude oil fell well
below half its
July all-time high,
with the December futures
(CLZ08) hitting $61.30 on Oct. 27.
After a small bounce that took
the market up to $70, crude
opened November on a weak
note, turning back below $65 Source for all: TradeStation
before leaping back above $70 on
election day, Nov. 4.
The selling was imitated in the other major energy futures — gasoline
(RB), natural gas (NG), and heating oil.
Metals
The big story in
precious metal
futures has been Grains
the lack of story:
Gold refused to budge as the
Grains, like all com-
stock market disintegrated. It
modities, were down
looked like it might make a run
across the board, with
on Oct. 10 when the December
wheat (W) showing the
contract (GCZ08) pushed above
most signs of life — attempting to
$935 (topping the September
spike higher on a few days in late
high), but the move turned out to
October and early November — as the
be a feint: The contract closed down and over the next three weeks dropped
markets stabilized.
as low as 681. Silver and copper also wallowed near long-term lows as
November trading began.
The rationalization for gold’s weakness has been lack of inflationary pres-
sures in the market. However, this argument handily sidesteps the lack of the
expected “safe-haven” move into gold as stocks collapsed — something gold
bugs had been anticipating.
Treasuries
Like gold, T-
notes failed to
produce the
perhaps-antici-
pated rally in October. However,
as discussed in “The flight-to-
quality trade” (Active Trader,
October 2008), the sell-stocks,
buy-treasuries phenomenon does-
n’t occur as often as people think.
December 10-year T-note
futures (TYZ08) fell from a high above 119 in mid-September to a low of 111-
12.5/32 in mid-October. By Nov. 4, the market had rebounded to around 115.
Stock
indices
Stock index futures
went on a wild ride in
October, posting huge intraday swings
and lurching higher and (mostly) lower
from day to day. After the spike low on
Oct. 10, the E-Mini S&P 500 futures zig-
zagged crazily before slightly exceeding
Meats that low on Oct. 27 and 28. The market
rallied the next few days, closing strong-
Toward the end of
ly on Nov. 4.
October, live cattle
Detailed coverage of the stock market
(LC) managed to
and the financial crisis can be found
stage a small rally off
in the current issue of Active Trader
its lows while lean hogs
(http://www.activetradermag.com).
(LH) continued to push to new lows.
December live cattle (LCZ08) traded as
high as 93.80 on Nov. 3 — the highest
level in nearly three weeks.
Currencies
The big story in the forex world was the dollar’s renewed
strength as the financial panic deepened. The buck gained
against all major currencies except the Japanese yen.
The dollar index (DXY) pushed to its highest level since 2006. (For currency
strategies, news, and analysis, go to http://www.currencytradermag.com).
8 November 2008 • FUTURES & OPTIONS TRADER
AbleTrend is designed to seek profits
in volatile markets with managed risk
FREE Interactive Webinar Award
Winning
Trading
Register FREE at: www.ablesys.com Software
Monday 4pm, Wednesday 7pm and Friday 2pm EST
Bring your own symbols and find out what AbleTrend 7.0 says about your
positions. Learn if any buy/sell signals have occurred. Identify support levels.
And get the answers instantly! Whether you trade stocks, comodities, FOREX,
the E-MINIs, or the ETFs . . . whether you prefer day trading, swing trading or
1997 - 2008
position trading . . . you will see results on the spot.
For Stocks,
AbleTrend 7.0
and RESISTANCE in real
Now You Can Subscribe to a Test Drive of time and 3. entering
Abletrend 7.0 With FREE One-On-One Consultation on retracements, which is
about controlling losses.
Also, STAYING IN THE
TREND. Your software
shows me how to do these
things with precise
accuracy and elegant
simplicity. The software
you have developed has
the most accurate support
and resistance levels I
have seen. They will
indicate the pivots in “
advance, a feature that
alone is worth the price.
— John Meyer MD. Atlanta, GA
0 D a y Trial
3 Today!
Sta$2r0 tDiscou81n2t Code:
Get Started Today!
T RA DE RS '
RE S OURC E
FPM
Reader’s Choice Awards
LINK S 1997-2008 in Stock Trading
System; Futures Trading System Call Free (888) 272-1688
& Option Trading System
www.ablesys.com
Ablesys Corp. • 20954 Corsair Blvd. • Hayward, CA 94545 • Tel: 510-265-1883 • Fax: 510-265-1993
These results are based on simulated or hypothetical performance results that have certain inherent limitations. Unlike the results shown in an actual performance record, these
results do not represent actual trading. Also, because these trades have not actually been executed, these results may have under-or over-compensated for the impact, if any, of
certain market factors, such as lack of liquidity. Simulated or hypothetical trading programs in general are also subject to the fact that they are designed with the benefit of
hindsight. No representation is being made that any account will or is likely to achieve profits or losses similar to these being shown. The testimonial may not be representative of
the experience of other clients and the testimonial is no guarantee of future performance or success CTA Firm
TRADING STRATEGIES
Two systems
are better than one
Taking trade signals from multiple systems can help smooth out a portfolio’s equity curve.
The trick is to pick the right strategies.
BY RICHARD WEISSMAN
Avg. Percentage
trade Avg. Max. time
Total No. of Trades length Avg. annual Max. consecutive P:MD Winning in the
Market net profit trades per year (days) trade profit drawdown* losers ratio percentage market
British pound futures (BP) $33,466 34 3.4 25 $984.29 $3,346.60 -$11,631 2 2.88 82.35 32.63
Euro futures (EC) $20,410 23 2.3 25 $887.39 $2,041.00 -$15,212 2 1.34 69.57 22.41
Japanese yen futures (JY) -$527 27 2.7 28 -$19.52 -$52.70 -$20,625 2 -0.03 59.26 28.87
Natural gas futures (NG) -$10,800 40 4 20 -$270.00 -$1,080.00 -$57,560 4 -0.19 45 29.87
Crude oil futures (CL) $22,430 28 2.8 25 $801.07 $2,243.00 -$15,800 1 1.42 71.43 26.87
Gold futures (GC) $14,810 27 2.7 29 $548.52 $1,481.00 -$10,350 2 1.43 74.07 30.58
Sugar futures (SB) -$118 25 2.5 32 -$4.72 -$11.80 -$5,958 2 -0.02 72 31.15
Soybean futures (S) -$27,900 24 2.4 39 -$1,162.50 -$2,790.00 -$32,350 2 -0.86 56.52 34.59
Wheat futures (W) $11,417 30 3 25 $380.57 $1,141.70 -$12,625 2 0.9 76.67 28.74
10-year T-note futures (TY) $6,541 27 2.7 30 $242.26 $654.10 -$12,350 2 0.53 66.67 30.89
E-Mini S&P 500 futures (ES) $7,252 21 2.1 32 $345.33 $725.20 -$11,212 1 0.65 71.43 26.03
1. Go long if the nine-day RSI is below 35, price 4. Exit short trade if the RSI closes below 35 or with
closes above its 200-day SMA, and today’s volume a $7,500 stop-loss.
is less than yesterday’s volume.
Figure 2 shows a daily chart of Eurocurrency futures (EC)
2. Exit long trade if RSI closes above 65, or with a with a profitable long trade. On May 2 the RSI fell below 35
$7,500 stop-loss. and price remained above its 200-day SMA, triggering a
long trade. The RSI closed above 65 on May 22 and the
3. Sell short if the nine-day RSI is above 65, price trade was exited the next day.
closes below the 200-day SMA, and today’s Table 2 shows back-test results for the same futures mar-
kets over the past 10 years. Unlike the Bollinger Band
breakout system, the countertrend RSI system had a high
Related reading winning percentage — 67.65 percent. In addition, the E-
Mini S&P 500 futures, which was the trend-following strat-
“Multi-system testing” egy’s poorest performer, was profitable and had a 0.65
Active Trader, December 2008. P:MD ratio ($7,252 net profit/$11,212 maximum draw-
This Trading System Lab shows there is more to trading down). Finally, the countertrend system had only six con-
multiple systems than first meets the eye. secutive losing trades compared to 18 for the Bollinger
Band system.
“Allocating capital to multiple trading signals” Of course, the RSI strategy had its own weaknesses, espe-
Active Trader, November 2006. cially a lengthy 43-month drawdown before hitting a new
Find out how a multi-signal system performed using equity high and a mediocre 1.78 P:MD ratio. If traded alone,
three different capital-allocation techniques.
these weaknesses would be troublesome, but the goal is to
combine it with the Bollinger Band system. Therefore, the
You can purchase and download past articles at
strengths of the latter system will offset the weaknesses of
http://store.activetradermag.com.
the former.
Avg.
trade Avg. Max.
Total No. of Trades length Avg. annual Max. consecutive P:MD Winning
Market net profit trades per year (days) trade profit drawdown* losers ratio percentage
British pound futures (BP) $38,733 132 13.2 15.35 $293.43 $3,873.30 -$13,100 7 2.96 47.73
Euro futures (EC) $50,738 119 11.9 16.13 $426.37 $5,073.80 -$17,362 7 2.92 41.18
Japanese yen futures (JY) $18,209 120 12 17.15 $151.74 $1,820.90 -$16,901 5 1.08 41.67
Natural gas futures (NG) $97,970 134 13.4 15.79 $731.12 $9,797.00 -$56,520 7 1.73 38.06
Crude oil futures (CL) $48,320 121 12.1 15.78 $399.34 $4,832.00 -$17,390 12 2.78 47.11
Gold futures (GC) $3,300 133 13.3 16.25 $24.81 $330.00 -$16,090 9 0.21 39.85
Sugar futures (SB) $754 119 11.9 17.78 $6.34 $75.40 -$5,946 6 0.13 40.34
Soybean futures (S) $15,424 108 10.8 20.33 $142.81 $1,542.40 -$14,314 4 1.08 50
Wheat futures (W) $3,432 136 13.6 14.87 $25.24 $343.20 -$11,188 7 0.31 37.5
10-year T-note futures (TY) $20,737 115 11.5 18.52 $180.32 $2,073.70 -$11,732 7 1.77 48.7
E-Mini S&P 500 futures (ES) -$26,472 119 11.9 15.53 -$222.45 -$2,647.20 -$33,492 10 -0.79 35.29
Portfolio $271,145 1,356 135.6 14.93 $199.96 $27,114.50 -$50,351 16 5.39 42.33
*24 months — beginning of drawdown to new equity high (1/01-1/03)
Combining low-correlation countertrend RSI system (24 months your broker to prevent one strategy’s
systems vs. 43 months). More importantly, the long positions from offsetting anoth-
Table 3 shows the results of combining combined system had a 5.39 P:MD er’s short positions.
the systems. The combined portfolio ratio, which is superior to either of the
had a higher winning percentage than component strategies. For information on the author see p. 5.
the Bollinger Band strategy (42.33 per- One disadvantage to trading mul-
cent vs. 35.14 percent) and a shorter tiple systems is you might have to
peak-to-valley drawdown than the open additional subaccounts with
Short Exit:
RSI(@,9)[-1] > 65 OR OpenPositionAverageEntryPrice(@,ThisTradeOnly) -
Dollar2Price(@,7500) / OpenPositionSize(@,ThisTradeOnly)
Gamma scalping
In uncertain times smart traders focus on volatility, not market direction.
BY DAN PASSARELLI
Buying volatility
with straddles
Table 1 lists the daily closing prices of
the Nasdaq 100 tracking stock (QQQQ)
in August. Disregarding direction, the
average close-to-close price change
was $0.50. Let’s assume you thought Source: OptionVue
daily change could climb to $0.90 in
the next six weeks. TABLE 2 — OPTION GREEKS
On Sept. 4, QQQQ closed at $43.66, and you could have
When QQQQ closed at $43.66 on Sept. 4, you could have
bought 10 October 43-strike calls for 2.05 each and 10
bought Oct. 43-strike calls for 2.05 each and Oct. 43-strike
October 43 puts for 1.33 each — a total of 3.38 ($338) each.
puts for 1.33 each — a total cost of 3.38. The position is vul-
When you buy this straddle, you acquire Greeks risk, nerable to changes in the underlying’s price (delta), delta’s
meaning the position is vulnerable to changes in the under- value (gamma), time (theta), and implied volatility (vega).
lying’s price (delta), delta’s value (gamma), time (theta),
and implied volatility (vega). Table 2 lists the long strad- 10 Oct. 10 Oct. 10 Oct.
dle’s cost and Greeks values. 43 calls 43 puts 43 straddles
Figure 1 shows the long straddle’s potential gains and Value (per contract) 2.05 1.33 3.38
losses on three dates: trade entry (Sept. 4, dotted line), Delta 5.88 -4.15 1.73
halfway until expiration (Sept. 26, dashed line), and expira- Gamma 0.93 0.94 1.87
tion (Oct. 18, solid line). The position will typically make Theta -0.2 -0.18 -0.38
money if QQQQ either rallies or falls, but it must move Vega 0.58 0.58 1.16
enough to offset the negative effect of time decay. As time
passes, the straddle’s value drops, and the Nasdaq 100
tracking stock must move further in either direction to be of the Nasdaq 100 tracking stock. And as QQQQ rallies
profitable. higher, the delta will rise further.
However, the goal here isn’t simply to hold the straddle On the other hand, if QQQQ falls, the straddle’s delta
and wait for the underlying to make a large move. Instead, will drop by gamma’s value. So if the Nasdaq 100 tracking
we plan to capture small profits as QQQQ fluctuates each stock drops $1 to $42.66, the straddle’s delta slips from 1.73
day, which requires monitoring the position’s Greeks to -0.14 by the gamma value of 1.87. Now, the straddle’s
closely. delta resembles 14 short shares. And as QQQQ falls lower,
the delta will become more negative. If the underlying
Tracking delta and gamma drops $1 further to $41.66, the straddle’s gamma (1.87) will
The straddle has a delta of 1.73, meaning its directional risk cause the delta to change to -2.01 from -0.14. As QQQQ’s
is similar to 173 QQQQ shares. If the Nasdaq 100 tracking decline intensifies, the more the straddle will earn for each
stock climbs by $1, the straddle will gain $1.73 ($173). But $1 drop.
considering you are holding 20 contracts, representing 2,000
underlying shares, this is a fairly flat position at this point. Creating a delta-neutral position
Gamma tracks delta’s rate of change as the underlying Ideally, the long straddle will have a delta of zero, but the
moves. Therefore, if QQQQ rises $1 from $43.66 to $44.66, October 43 straddle has a long delta bias (1.73). If QQQQ
the straddle’s delta will climb by 1.87 — gamma’s value — fell from $43.66, the only benefit positive gamma offers is to
to 3.60. At that point, the straddle will resemble 360 shares continued on p. 16
BY GEORGE HOEKSTRA
Discount customers bought more calls as the technology bubble inflated in the
late 1990s.
Who sells calls?
Figure 2 shows who sold calls from
1990 to 2001. Customers of full-service
brokerage firms held 70 percent of the
short-call open interest. These cus-
tomers include hedge funds and retail
investors who often use more sophisti-
cated investment strategies. Most of
their positions hedge long stock posi-
tions — i.e., covered calls.
Another interesting conclusion is
some advanced strategies that get a
great deal of attention in trading litera-
ture and textbooks weren’t used
much.
The following strategies weren’t as
popular as you might think:
Straddles, strangles, and butterfly
spreads. Options educators often focus
on ways options can be used to specu- Source: Option Market Activity
late on changes in stock volatility.
Straddles, strangles, and butterflies FIGURE 4 — SHERWIN WILLIAMS SEPTEMBER 60 CALL
are volatility-based strategies. But
Trading volume tends to pick up as interest grows and the contract moves closer
the study’s data reveals “volatility
to expiration.
trading through straddles, stran-
gles, and butterflies — whether for
speculative or hedging purposes —
explains at most a small fraction of
option trading.” Traders may enjoy
discussing these positions, but few
use them in real-world situations.
Protective puts. Another high-pro-
file strategy is buying puts to hedge
long stock positions. This is a sensi-
ble strategy that resembles buying
insurance on the underlying stock.
However, the study shows that
very few traders use protective
puts. Indeed, traders rarely bought
puts for any reason; Figure 1 shows
only 9 percent of total open interest
was long puts.
Source: OptionsXpress
Dot-com bubble fueled call
buying
The study also found discount customers bought more calls bubble (1990-1994), early-bubble (1994-1997), peak-bubble
as the technology bubble inflated in the late 1990s. Before (1998-March 2000), and post-bubble (April 2000-2001).
reaching this conclusion, researchers analyzed the average Figure 3 shows that call buying by discount customers
volume of opening purchases in four time periods: pre- continued on p. 20
doubled from the initial pre-bubble period to the early-bub- For example, Figure 4 shows a daily chart of a Sherwin
ble period (1990-1994 vs. 1994-1997). Then, as the bubble Williams (SHW) September 2008 60 call. Charts of individ-
peaked from 1998 to March 2000, discount customers ual options are available on most brokers’ Web sites. The
bought nearly 2.5 times as many calls than before the bub- SHW September 60 call began trading in February 2008.
ble began. After the bubble, discount customers bought
only one-third as many calls as they did during the peak. TABLE 1 — TIME AND SALES DATA
Clearly, the technology boom attracted discount cus-
tomers who speculated that stocks would continue to rise. The more an option contract trades, the more likely you
will be able to get a better filled price on a limit order.
And many of them were probably new options traders.
Volume was concentrated in long calls on large growth Date Time Exchange Size Price
stocks. By contrast, the study didn’t find increased call buy- 9/4/08 9:31:12 10 2.3
ing among other types of investors. 9/4/08 9:45:45 CBOE 5 2.39
(Click here to download the full Option Market Activity 9/4/08 11:09:25 48 2.15
article.) 9/4/08 11:09:25 46 2.15
9/4/08 11:09:25 53 2.15
Lessons from this study
9/4/08 11:09:25 84 2.15
First, most options traders use simple strategies such as
9/4/08 11:09:25 19 2.15
buying calls and selling covered calls. It makes sense to
keep things simple. Don’t get caught up in the idea that you 9/4/08 11:11:35 2 2.15
should trade complex strategies, which usually require a 9/4/08 11:11:36 9 2.15
great deal of capital to execute consistently and add to 9/4/08 11:11:37 5 2.15
transaction costs. 9/4/08 11:11:43 123 2.15
Also, the study contradicts a common myth that most 9/4/08 11:11:44 CBOE 2 2.15
retail option traders are wide-eyed, unsophisticated gam- 9/4/08 11:11:44 111 2.15
blers who buy calls to make short-term, high-leverage bets
9/4/08 11:13:29 47 2.25
on stocks. To some extent, this caricature was likely accu-
9/4/08 11:13:29 PSE 15 2.25
rate during the dot-com bubble, but even then, call buying
was only a small part of the total picture, and it has dried 9/4/08 11:13:29 PSE 11 2.25
up since 2000. 9/4/08 11:13:29 CBOE 78 2.25
A corollary to this myth is that selling covered calls is a 9/4/08 11:13:29 30 2.25
smart way to take advantage of the overabundance of call 9/4/08 11:13:29 PSE 6 2.25
buyers who bid up option prices to excessive levels to pay 9/4/08 11:13:29 10 2.25
for high-leverage bets. However, the study’s data suggests 9/4/08 11:13:40 CBOE 9 2.25
the supply-demand balance among non market-makers is
9/4/08 11:14:23 21 2.2
tilted toward an oversupply of call sellers. If more traders
9/4/08 11:14:23 9 2.2
want to sell calls than buy them, prices will tend to be driv-
en down. Therefore, that bias may work to call buyers’ 9/4/08 11:59:43 10 2
advantage. 9/4/08 15:07:08 4 1.6
9/4/08 15:07:41 11 1.6
Dig into trading data 9/4/08 15:28:26 CBOE 10 1.6
Can you benefit from studying trading data on options that 9/4/08 15:28:26 10 1.6
seem attractive? The Options Market Activity authors used 9/4/08 15:37:14 12 1.6
some clever analysis, along with available data, to learn
9/4/08 15:37:17 4 1.6
when and how options trades took place. This kind of data
9/4/08 15:37:18 8 1.6
is increasingly available to anyone.
Many options are thinly traded, meaning only a few 9/4/08 15:37:22 4 1.6
trades are executed each day. These contracts usually have 9/4/08 15:37:23 4 1.6
wide bid-ask spreads. Today, it is possible to study how a 9/4/08 15:39:10 6 1.6
day’s trading unfolds, tick-by-tick. If you are considering 9/4/08 15:39:10 54 1.6
buying or selling options on a stock, it makes sense to dig Source: OptionsXpress
into that data and see what you can learn.
Price and volume data is shown from Sept. 4. There were a couple of small
its initial offering in February to Sept. trades at 9:31 a.m. and 9:45 a.m., but
5, two weeks before it expired on Sept. then no trades occurred until the five-
19. minute interval from 11:09 a.m. to
Trading volume was sparse in 11:14 a.m. when volume exceeded the
February and March as the call didn’t total number of contracts traded so far.
trade at all on most days. But volume What does this mean? One clue is
picked up in July and August as expi- whether the trades are filled at the bid
ration drew closer. The first time its price, ask price, or in between. You can
daily volume exceeded 100 contracts find other clues by examining other
was July 18. By August the contract Sherwin Williams options. For exam-
traded nearly every day, and in ple, did volume climb in same-strike
September, its expiration month, vol- puts or calls with different strikes or
ume increased considerably, including expirations?
one day with 900 contracts traded. The idea is to study the trades in
This pattern of gradually increasing attractive options to find patterns. If,
trading volume is typical as interest for example, you see volume spurts
grows and the contract moves closer to occasionally either at the bid or ask
expiration. price, you might be able to enter a
limit order and wait for it to get filled
Gleaning insight from at a more attractive price. If a contract
time and sales data never trades, you probably won’t be
Another way to examine an option’s able to buy it much below the ask
trading activity is to use its time and price. But if a contract trades more fre-
sales data available in the quotes sec- quently, you might get a better fill on a
tion of most brokers’ Web sites. limit order if you are patient.
Table 1 shows the time and sales
data for the SHW September 60 call on For information on the author see p. 5.
Put-call ratio
Tracking the volume and open interest of put options vs. call options
can highlight investor sentiment extremes.
BY CHRIS PETERS
Related reading
“Getting sentimental about options” “The put-call ratio as a contrarian indicator”
Active Trader, March 2002. Active Trader, March 2006.
Successful option trading depends on a number of variables, but Many traders believe the put-call ratio’s extremes signal market
one many traders overlook is sentiment analysis. Find out what turning points, but interpreting this indicator isn’t that simple.
different sentiment tools represent and how they can round out The following analysis shows how the S&P 500 tracking stock
your trading. (SPY) behaved in the two weeks after extreme daily highs and
lows in both OEX and equity put/call ratios since 1997.
“Put-call inversions: Separating the smart money
from the dumb,” Active Trader, June 2002. “Going against the crowd,” Active Trader, November 2000.
Contrary to popular belief, there’s more than one put-call ratio, The put-call ratio has long been used as a measure of market
and looking at the wrong one at the wrong time can give you a sentiment. Here’s a new twist on an old approach that can help
misleading picture of the market. you catch turning points based on short-term put-call extremes.
“CBOE put-call ratio,” Active Trader, October 2007. You can purchase and download past articles at
This Trading System Lab tests extreme put-call ratio readings as http://store.activetradermag.com.
mechanical buy and sell signals on individual stocks and index-
based exchange-traded funds.
This information is for educational purposes only. Futures & Options Trader provides this data in good faith, but it cannot guarantee its accuracy or timeliness. Futures & Options
Trader assumes no responsibility for the use of this information. Futures & Options Trader does not recommend buying or selling any market, nor does it solicit orders to buy
or sell any market. There is a high level of risk in trading, especially for traders who use leverage. The reader assumes all responsibility for his or her actions in the market.
MOST-LIQUID OPTIONS*
Indices Symbol Exchange Options Open 10-day move / 20-day move / IV / IV / SV ratio —
volume interest rank rank SV ratio 20 days ago
S&P 500 index SPX CBOE 277.4 1.13 M 0.81% / 0% -14.38% / 0% 55.4% / 91.9% 41.4% / 36.2%
Russell 2000 index RUT CBOE 123.9 471.2 -4.17% / 0% -19.37% / 0% 61.8% / 87.7% 47.3% / 37.3%
S&P 500 volatility index VIX CBOE 86.2 501.9 -6.97% / 0% 38.97% / 0% 229.5% / 310.5% 250% / 136.6%
Mini Nasdaq 100 index MNX CBOE 35.5 288.8 1.59% / 0% -10.54% / 0% 57.2% / 93.6% 46.8% / 40%
Nasdaq 100 index NDX CBOE 33.5 163.4 1.60% / 0% -10.54% / 0% 57.9% / 86.7% 47.8% / 38.1%
Stocks
Apple Inc AAPL 281.4 983.0 8.98% / 0% 10.93% / 0% 66% / 118% 92.6% / 73.5%
Citigroup C 250.9 3.64 M -17.55% / 0% -41.73% / 0% 100.2% / 159% 92.9% / 117.8%
Bank of America BAC 188.3 2.41 M -6.06% / 0% -37.37% / 0% 83.7% / 159.9% 77% / 110.6%
Microsoft MSFT 187.5 2.12 M -6.45% / 0% -13.79% / 0% 56.6% / 98.4% 47.9% / 47.2%
General Electric GE 161.4 1.54 M -2.71% / 0% -12.64% / 0% 75.5% / 105.9% 68.8% / 83.6%
Futures
Eurodollar ED-GE CME 594.6 7.91 M 0.44% / 0% 1.06% / 0% 69.2% / 73.6% 63.7% / 47.1%
Crude oil CL NYMEX 47.8 317.5 -6.01% / 0% -30.14% / 0% 76.9% / 87.1% 56.5% / 60.3%
Corn C-ZC CME 40.4 426.0 6.50% / 0% -9.82% / 0% 51.3% / 56.5% 39.3% / 39%
10-year T-notes TY-ZN CME 35.6 348.7 0.97% / 0% -1.72% / 0% 10.2% / 11.2% 11% / 10.6%
E-mini S&P 500 futures ES CME 24.6 106.1 2.02% / 0% -14.63% / 0% 56.4% / 99.5% 43.6% / 40.6%
VOLATILITY EXTREMES**
Indices - High IV/SV ratio
Swiss franc index XDS PHLX 1.7 12.6 0.11% / 0% -0.19% / 0% 21.4% / 13.4% 14.8% / 14%
Euro index XDE PHLX 1.7 13.3 -3.72% / 0% 3.72% / 0% 28% / 18.7% 14.5% / 14%
LEGEND:
Options volume: 20-day average daily options volume (in thousands unless otherwise indicated).
Open interest: 20-day average daily options open interest (in thousands unless otherwise indicated).
IV/SV ratio: Overall average implied volatility of all options divided by statistical volatility of underlying instrument.
10-day move: The underlying’s percentage price move from the close 10 days ago to today’s close.
20-day move: The underlying’s percentage price move from the close 20 days ago to today’s close. The “rank” fields for each time window (10-day moves, 20-
day moves) show the percentile rank of the most recent move to a certain number of previous moves of the same size and in the same direction. For example,
the “rank” for 10-day moves shows how the most recent 10-day move compares to the past twenty 10-day moves; for the 20-day move, the “rank” field shows
how the most recent 20-day move compares to the past sixty 20-day moves.
Options Watch: Consumer Staples ETF components (as of Oct. 29) Compiled by Tristan Yates
The following table summarizes the expiration months available for the top components of the Consumer Staples exchange-traded fund (XLP).
It also shows each stock’s average bid-ask spread for at-the-money (ATM) October options. The information does NOT constitute trade signals.
It is intended only to provide a brief synopsis of potential slippage in each option market.
Option contracts traded
2008 2009 2010 2011 Bid-ask spreads
Bid-ask
spread as %
June
Dec.
Nov.
Feb.
Jan.
Mar.
Jan.
Jan.
Apr.
May
Closing of underlying
Stock Ticker price Call Put price
Altria Group Inc MO X X X X X X 19.14 0.03 0.04 0.18%
Wal-Mart Stores Inc WMT X X X X X X 55.02 0.10 0.11 0.19%
Coca-Cola Co KO X X X X X X X 43.85 0.15 0.18 0.37%
General Mills Inc GIS X X X X X X 66.81 0.26 0.30 0.42%
HJ Heinz Co HNZ X X X X X X 42.59 0.19 0.23 0.48%
Kimberly-Clark Corporation KMB X X X X X X 59.09 0.30 0.29 0.50%
Costco Wholesale Corp COST X X X X X X 56.88 0.28 0.30 0.51%
Kellogg Co K X X X X X X 50.02 0.25 0.28 0.52%
Colgate-Palmolive CL X X X X X X X 60.00 0.38 0.29 0.55%
Pepsico Inc PEP X X X X X X 55.00 0.38 0.24 0.56%
Kraft Foods Inc KFT X X X X X X 28.47 0.16 0.16 0.57%
Philip Morris Intl Inc PM X X X X X X 41.55 0.26 0.23 0.59%
Walgreen Co WAG X X X X X X 23.74 0.15 0.14 0.61%
Archer-Daniels-Midland ADM X X X X X X X 21.42 0.13 0.15 0.64%
Kroger Co KR X X X X X X 26.50 0.18 0.18 0.66%
CVS Caremark Corp CVS X X X X X X X 26.31 0.18 0.18 0.67%
Sysco Corp SYY X X X X X X X 24.86 0.18 0.16 0.68%
Proctor & Gamble Co PG X X X X X X 61.33 0.55 0.46 0.83%
UST Inc UST X X X X X 67.74 0.66 0.48 0.84%
Anheuser-Busch Companies BUD X X X X X X 59.83 0.48 0.60 0.90%
Select Sector SPDR Consumer Staples XLP X X X X X X 23.29 0.31 0.25 1.21%
Legend:
Call: Four-day average difference between bid and ask prices for the front-month ATM call.
Put: Four-day average difference between bid and ask prices for the front-month ATM put.
Bid-ask spread as % of underlying price: Average difference between bid and ask prices for front-month, ATM call, and put divided by the underlying's closing price.
tion category — otherwise known as small traders — i.e., Double calendar spread: A calendar spread involves
the general public. purchasing an option and selling a shorter-term, same-
strike option of the same type (call or put) against it. Double
Covered call: Shorting an out-of-the-money call option calendars have two strikes: one put calendar spread below
against a long position in the underlying market. An exam- the current underlying price and one call calendar spread
ple would be purchasing a stock for $50 and selling a call above it. The goal is to collect premium and capture theta
option with a strike price of $55. The goal is for the market from the shorter-term sold options as expiration approach-
to move sideways or slightly higher and for the call option es. Single calendars only profit in a fairly narrow range of
to expire worthless, in which case you keep the premium. underlying prices, so the double calendar widens this range
and increases its chances of success.
Credit spread: A position that collects more premium
from short options than you pay for long options. A credit European style: An option that can only be exercised at
spread using calls is bearish, while a credit spread using expiration, not before.
puts is bullish.
Exercise: To exchange an option for the underlying
Debit: A cost you must pay to enter any position if the instrument.
components you buy are more expensive than the ones you
sell. For instance, you must pay a debit to buy any option, Expiration: The last day on which an option can be exer-
and a spread (long one option, short another) requires a cised and exchanged for the underlying instrument (usual-
debit if the premium you collect from the short option does- ly the last trading day or one day after).
n’t offset the long option’s cost.
Intermonth (futures) spread: A trade consisting of
Debit spread: An options spread that costs money to long and short positions in different contract months in the
enter, because the long side is more expensive that the short same market — e.g., July and November soybeans or
side. These spreads can be verticals, calendars, or diagonals. September and December crude oil. Also referred to as a
futures “calendar spread.”
Deep (e.g., deep in-the-money option or deep
out-of-the-money option): Call options with strike In the money (ITM): A call option with a strike price
prices that are very far above the current price of the under- below the price of the underlying instrument, or a put
lying asset and put options with strike prices that are very option with a strike price above the underlying instru-
far below the current price of the underlying asset. ment’s price.
Delivery period (delivery dates): The specific time Intrinsic value: The difference between the strike price
period during which a delivery can occur for a futures con- of an in-the-money option and the underlying asset price. A
tract. These dates vary from market to market and are deter- call option with a strike price of 22 has 2 points of intrinsic
mined by the exchange. They typically fall during the value if the underlying market is trading at 24.
month designated by a specific contract - e.g. the delivery
period for March T-notes will be a specific period in March. Iron condor: A market-neutral position that enters a bear
call spread (OTM call + higher-strike call) above the market
Delta-neutral: An options position that has an overall and a bull put spread (OTM put + lower-strike put) below
delta of zero, which means it’s unaffected by underlying the market. Both spreads collect premium, and profit when
price movement. However, delta will change as the under- the market trades between the short strikes by expiration.
lying moves up or down, so you must buy or sell All options share the same expiration month.
shares/contracts to adjust delta back to zero.
Logarithm: The exponent by which a certain base, such as
Diagonal spread: A position consisting of options with 10, is raised to produce another number. For example, the
different expiration dates and different strike prices — e.g., logarithm of 10,000 is 4 because 10 to the 4th power equals
a December 50 call and a January 60 call. 10,000.
contains short, higher-strike puts and long, lower-strike Relative strength index (RSI): Developed by Welles
puts. A bear put spread is structured differently: Its long Wilder, the relative strength index (RSI) is an indicator in
puts have higher strikes than the short puts. the “oscillator” family designed to reflect shorter-term
momentum. It ranges from zero to 100, with higher read-
Ratio spread: A ratio spread can contain calls or puts and ings supposedly corresponding to overbought levels and
includes a long option and multiple short options of the low readings reflecting the opposite. The formula is:
same type that are further out-of-the-money, usually in a RSI = 100 – (100/[1+RS])
ratio of 1:2 or 1:3 (long to short options). For example, if a where
stock trades at $60, you could buy one $60 call and sell two RS = relative strength = the average of the up closes over
same-month $65 calls. Basically, the trade is a bull call the calculation period (e.g., 10 bars, 14 bars) divided by the
spread (long call, short higher-strike call) with the sale of average of the down closes over the calculation period.
additional calls at the short strike.
Overall, these positions are neutral, but they can have a For example, when calculating a 10-day RSI, if six of the
directional bias, depending on the strike prices you select. days closed higher than the previous day’s close, subtract
Because you sell more options than you buy, the short the previous close from the current close for these days, add
options usually cover the cost of the long one or provide a up the differences, and divide the result by 10 to get the up-
net credit. However, the spread contains uncovered, or close average. (Note that the sum is divided by the total
“naked” options, which add upside or downside risk. number of days in the look-back period and not the number
of up-closing days.)
EVENTS
Event: Traders Expo Las Vegas Event: The Options Intensive Two-day Seminars
Date: Nov. 19-22 Dates: Dec. 4
Location: Mandalay Bay Resort & Casino, Las Vegas Location: CBOE Options Institute, Chicago
For more information: http://www.tradersexpo.com For more information: http://www.cboe.com
Event: Middle East Investor Conference Event: TradeTech Foreign Exchange 2009
Date: Nov. 20 Date: Feb. 9-11
Location: The Monarch Dubai Hotel, Dubai, U.A.E. Location: Bridgewaters, NYC
For more information: For more information:
http://dubai.nasdaqinvestorprogram.com
http://www.TradeTechForeignExchange.com
Simple moving average: A simple moving average Vertical spread: A position consisting of options with
(SMA) is the average price of a stock, future, or other mar- the same expiration date but different strike prices (e.g., a
ket over a certain time period. A five-day SMA is the sum of September 40 call option and a September 50 call option).
the five most recent closing prices divided by five, which
means each day’s price is equally weighted in the calcula- Volatility: The level of price movement in a market.
tion. Historical (“statistical”) volatility measures the price fluctu-
ations (usually calculated as the standard deviation of clos-
Straddle: A non-directional option spread that typically ing prices) over a certain time period — e.g., the past 20
consists of an at-the-money call and at-the-money put with days. Implied volatility is the current market estimate of
the same expiration. For example, with the underlying future volatility as reflected in the level of option premi-
instrument trading at 25, a standard long straddle would ums. The higher the implied volatility, the higher the option
consist of buying a 25 call and a 25 put. Long straddles are premium.
designed to profit from an increase in volatility; short strad-
dles are intended to capitalize on declin-
ing volatility. The strangle is a related
strategy.
CQG, Inc., the charting, analytics, and trade-routing plat- language. Wave59 RT is a charting and analysis program
form for global electronically traded futures markets, has designed around versions of classical technical tools, as well as
added SEB Futures to its list of Futures Commission Merchant a suite of proprietary algorithms. For additional information on
(FCM) partners. CQG has teamed with SEB to connect traders Wave59 RT 3.0, contact Jonn Millarkie at (866) 494-7613 or visit
to Euronext, Globex, ICE, and Eurex. Traders clearing through http://www.wave59.com to download a 30-day free trial.
SEB have access to CQG’s market analysis tools and advanced
order execution software. Vhayu Technologies has partnered with Alphacet,
Inc., a developer of software for quantitative analysts, portfo-
CME Group and BM&FBOVESPA announced the order lio managers, and traders, to provide customers with an inte-
routing of BM&F derivatives products on CME Globex. The grated tick database and alpha generation solution. It enables
order routing linkage enables customers using the CME Globex quants to create, backtest, and analyze multi-layer models in
electronic trading platform to trade BM&FBOVESPA products hours-to-days instead of weeks-to-months. This partnership
directly, including futures and options on one-day Inter-Bank combines Vhayu Velocity, which can process, analyze, and
Deposits, the Bovespa Stock Index (pending regulatory store tick and bar data, with Alphacet Explorer, a codeless his-
approval), and commodities such as Arabica coffee, live cattle, torical backtesting engine designed specifically for Vhayu
and corn. BM&FBOVESPA customers will have the ability to Velocity for use across asset classes and instrument types.
trade CME Group products directly through their
BM&FBOVESPA connections, including CME Group futures Dow Jones has signed a strategic alliance with Agencia
and options on interest rates, equity indices, foreign exchange, EFE to develop a joint Spanish-language news service — EFE
commodities, and energy and metals products. More informa- Dow Jones News — to serve financial professionals, corpora-
tion on the agreement can be found at http://www.cmegroup- tions, media, institutions, and private investors in Spain. The
bmfbovespa.com. CME Group also has launched the latest new real-time newswire will draw upon coverage of Spanish
version of CME E-quotes, a real-time streaming market data companies and policy-making in EFE’s economic service, EFE-
application offering quotes, charting, advanced analytics, and COM, and the international financial and market reporting of
news on CME Group-traded products, including interest rates, Dow Jones en Español to offer clients expanded coverage of
equity indices, foreign currencies, commodities, energy, metals, Spanish business, including regional reporting and analysis of
and alternative investments. It also offers access to prices for small- and mid-cap stocks. For more information about Dow
products listed on the Minneapolis Grain Exchange and the Jones Newswires, visit http://www.dowjonesnewswires.com.
Kansas Board of Trade, which are available for electronic trad-
ing on CME Globex. For more information and a free two-week HedgeCo Networks, LLC has launched its online ana-
trial, visit http://www.cmegroup.com/e-quotes. lytical and reporting tool, the Hedge Fund Calculator. Available
as a monthly or annual subscription service, the Hedge Fund
Option-industry denizen and author Dan Passarelli Calculator was designed for hedge funds and funds of hedge
launched a new mentoring company designed to educate funds, and facilitates the computation of quantitative statistics,
option traders. Market Taker Mentoring (http://market- net performance numbers, and the creation of branded market-
taker.com) offers an educational service to do-it-yourself ing materials. Key features of the Hedge Fund Calculator
traders as well as seasoned professionals. Passarelli’s new include: online access, branded and customized tearsheets, a
organization takes a personal approach to mentoring. In the contact manager, and benchmark analysis. To view a demo or
six-week course, students receive one-on-one time with sign up for a free Webinar visit http://www.hedgefundcalcu-
Passarelli in a program tailored to their specific educational lator.com.
levels. For more information and a free excerpt from
Passarelli’s book Trading Option Greeks, click here. BarclayHedge and Global Fund Technologies,
LLC announced the launch of http://www.myfund-
Adaptrade Software’s Market System Analyzer (MSA) finder.com, a capital introduction platform designed to match
version 3 is available. MSA software for futures and stock hedge fund managers with institutional and high net worth
traders applies position sizing, Monte Carlo analysis, depend- investors. MyFundFinder.com is a web-based platform
ency analysis, equity curve crossover trading, and other designed to provide hedge-fund managers with a capital-rais-
money-management methods. Version 3 includes full portfolio ing tool and to provide investors free access to search online
analysis, portfolio optimization, correlation analysis, support through more than 1,900 hedge funds, funds of funds, and
for non-US traders, and more. The software works with any managed futures funds (CTAs) to discover, match, and connect
trading system or method and requires only a list of profits and with those that meet their investment needs. Additional plat-
losses as input. An EasyLanguage interface to TradeStation is form features include industry discussion forums, geographi-
included. A 30-day trial can be downloaded from cal mapping, and new fund launches, all centered on a com-
http://www.Adaptrade.com. munity-driven site.
Wave59 Technologies released Wave59 RT 3.0, an Note: The New Products and Services section is a forum for industry busi-
update of its real-time technical market analysis program. nesses to announce new products and upgrades. Listings are adapted from
Version 3.0 includes the ability to design, backtest, optimize, press releases and are not endorsements or recommendations from the
Active Trader Magazine Group. E-mail press releases to editorial@future-
and automate custom trading systems using Wave59’s QScript
sandoptionstrader.com. Publication is not guaranteed.
TRADE
Note: Initial targets for trades are typically based on things such as the
RESULT
historical performance of a price pattern or trading system signal.
However, individual trades are a function of immediate market behav-
Exit: $74.20 (first trade). ior; initial price targets are flexible and are most often used as points at
which a portion of the trade is liquidated to reduce the position’s open
Profit/loss: -6.675 (8.2 percent). risk. As a result, the initial (pre-trade) reward-risk ratios are conjec-
tural by nature.
TRADE SUMMARY
Initial Initial
Date Contract Entry stop target IRR Exit Date P/L LOP LOL Length
10/14/08 QMZ08 80.875 79.125 82.125 0.71 $74.20 10/15/08 -6.675 (8.2%) +0.10 -6.675 1 day
Legend: IRR — initial reward/risk ratio (initial target amount/initial stop amount); LOP — largest open profit (maximum available profit
during lifetime of trade); LOL — largest open loss (maximum potential loss during life of trade).
RESULT